Latest / Surrounded / 1 Black Conservative vs 20 Black Liberals (ft. Officer Tatum)
Transcript
- 0:00I feel like you wanna be confrontational more than you
- 0:01want to get to the bottom of a conversation,
- 0:04but if you're 25
- 0:05and under,
- 0:06the leading cause of death for you is being murdered by another black person.
- 0:08Thank you fullest.
- 0:11That is the whole thesis of Up from slavery.
- 0:14Did you read the book?
- 0:15I did not read the book.
- 0:16There you go,
- 0:16then you don't know what you're talking about.
- 0:18You are uneducated.
- 0:20To say that Donald Trump is racist is the craziest thing I've heard.
- 0:23Have you,
- 0:23have you?
- 0:25Have you ever,
- 0:26have you ever met Donald Trump?
- 0:27Is systemic racism holding the black community back
- 0:30or has it become an excuse to avoid personal responsibility?
- 0:33Now John was a little too white to handle this topic,
- 0:36so you got me.
- 0:37I'm Paris Rose from Jubilee Media,
- 0:39and this is Surrounded,
- 0:41where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:45Today we're diving into policing.
- 0:46Black communities where the Republicans are
- 0:48better for the black community than Democrats
- 0:50and the debate over systemic racism.
- 0:52I'm here with our featured guests,
- 0:54former police officer and conservative commentator
- 0:56Brandon Tatum.
- 0:57I'm so happy to see you today.
- 0:59How you feeling?
- 0:59I'm,
- 1:00I'm good.
- 1:00I'm blessed.
- 1:01I'm happy.
- 1:01All right,
- 1:01you ready to take everyone on?
- 1:03Oh,
- 1:03we're about to get busy in here.
- 1:05Oh,
- 1:05I love to hear you guys,
- 1:06are you guys ready?
- 1:09They sound ready.
- 1:10All right,
- 1:10let's go.
- 1:11Hi,
- 1:11I'm Officer Tatum,
- 1:12and I'm the host of the Officer Tatum show and I'm surrounded by black liberals.
- 1:19My first surrounding claim is Trump and Republicans
- 1:22are better for the black community than Democrats.
- 1:25If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 1:26get to that chair in 321.
- 1:32Naima,
- 1:32nice to meet you.
- 1:33Naima,
- 1:33nice to meet you as well.
- 1:35Before I do my rebuttal,
- 1:36I would just like to know why you think that.
- 1:38Well,
- 1:38there's a myriad of reasons.
- 1:39I think that
- 1:40conservative policies
- 1:42are more beneficial to the black community,
- 1:44is more beneficial to America,
- 1:46which black people are part of America,
- 1:48and I think that policies like,
- 1:49um,
- 1:50limiting immigration or illegal immigration,
- 1:52getting illegal immigrants out of this country,
- 1:54lowering taxes all benefit black people as a whole,
- 1:57religious freedom,
- 1:58you,
- 1:58you name it,
- 1:59every.
- 1:59Every single policy that I can think about
- 2:01that Republicans
- 2:02have implemented,
- 2:03that they stand for,
- 2:04the values they stand for are all
- 2:07better off for black people than Democrats could ever dream of.
- 2:09How have you quant,
- 2:10OK,
- 2:11first of all,
- 2:12religious freedom is not just a Republican policy.
- 2:14I just want that's far more freedom,
- 2:18believe in the freedom of religion than Democrats could ever dream of.
- 2:20I don't want to harp on that.
- 2:22That's in the Constitution.
- 2:23That's just not true,
- 2:24but every single aspect of life.
- 2:25But I just want to focus on what,
- 2:28which one of Trump's policies specifically
- 2:30has been designed to help the black community.
- 2:33Well,
- 2:34the First Step Act has been designed to reverse the
- 2:37effects of Over policing
- 2:39from the past,
- 2:40that was
- 2:42the First Step Act,
- 2:42yes,
- 2:43it was,
- 2:43to allow for people who were incarcerated with sentencing for drug dealing
- 2:48and less violent crimes for them to have some relief.
- 2:51My uncle got out on the First Step Act,
- 2:53um,
- 2:54urban revitalization,
- 2:56injecting money into these inner-city communities,
- 2:59permanent funding for HBCUs,
- 3:00which Barack Obama never did.
- 3:03Donald Trump implemented.
- 3:04I mean,
- 3:04I can go down a list and I think that lowering taxes and all the other benefits
- 3:08that Americans get
- 3:10is also beneficial to black people.
- 3:11So it's funny because I've watched some of your videos.
- 3:13I've heard these talking points before and I actually looked into all of these,
- 3:15and there's not a ton of quantitative impact on
- 3:18how those have actually affected just the black community.
- 3:20But let's talk about the Republican Party
- 3:22and Trump and his policies as a whole.
- 3:25Do you think that Trump reposting a video
- 3:28in which one of his.
- 3:29Uh,
- 3:30supporters screams white power
- 3:32was beneficial to the black community.
- 3:33I'm not familiar with some video that he posted.
- 3:35Well,
- 3:35I mean,
- 3:36you should let's talk about Democrat policy.
- 3:38Let's talk about Democrat politics.
- 3:40What you're obfuscating.
- 3:42You are the one who has the burden right sorry,
- 3:44I do not want to be interrupted.
- 3:45It says right here that Trump
- 3:48and Republicans are better than the Democrat policy.
- 3:49So the burden of proof is on you.
- 3:52Yes,
- 3:53no,
- 3:53this is how a debate works.
- 3:54You've made a claim that you have.
- 3:56Substantiate and you have yet to do that.
- 3:58I am wrong.
- 4:00So how are you correct in that
- 4:01Democrat policies are better than Republican policies?
- 4:03Well,
- 4:03actually,
- 4:03do you want to know my,
- 4:04my personal belief is that the Democrats are
- 4:07fundamentally kind of apathetic to the needs of black people,
- 4:11while
- 4:12Republicans are openly antagonizing the black community.
- 4:14Give me an example.
- 4:15So,
- 4:15I mean,
- 4:16so an example policy position is negative
- 4:17towards black people that Republicans implement.
- 4:19Trump this year intentionally got rid of the disparate impact.
- 4:23Analysis.
- 4:24So what the disparate impact analysis does is
- 4:26that it analyzes laws that were made neutrally,
- 4:29policies that were intended to be neutral,
- 4:31to make sure that there were not any racial disparities
- 4:35as an effect of that policy,
- 4:37right?
- 4:37Accidentally.
- 4:38So Trump has removed the protection for the disparate impact analysis.
- 4:42So we don't know if the policies that
- 4:44we're enacting are disproportionately hurting the black community
- 4:47or not.
- 4:48That's not,
- 4:48that's not that that doesn't make.
- 4:50Any sense.
- 4:50Any policy,
- 4:52no,
- 4:52what you're saying does not make any
- 4:53sense because the policies that are implemented,
- 4:56the majority of the ones that
- 4:58are in Congress are agreed upon by the House and the Senate,
- 5:02Democrats and Republicans.
- 5:04And so with that being said,
- 5:05there's black people represented,
- 5:06there's all kinds of people represented in creating our laws and policies.
- 5:09So what,
- 5:10what are you saying that they're not considering
- 5:12whether or not it had a,
- 5:13has a desperate effect on on the black community.
- 5:15When you create a.
- 5:16Obviously you're creating it in good faith,
- 5:19but we do not know always how that policy is going to affect the population.
- 5:23Can I finish talking?
- 5:24Give me an example of policy,
- 5:25but I'm trying to,
- 5:26I'm running out of time.
- 5:27So the point of the disparate analysis report
- 5:29is to check to make sure
- 5:31that the laws that we implement in good faith
- 5:35don't end up hurting the black community by accident.
- 5:38Why would you get rid of that?
- 5:40Why do you think he got rid of it?
- 5:42Because he's racist.
- 5:44To say that Donald Trump is racist is the craziest thing I've heard.
- 5:47Have you,
- 5:48have you?
- 5:49Have you ever,
- 5:50have you ever met Donald Trump personally?
- 5:53Have you,
- 5:54have you,
- 5:54you,
- 5:54you don't know him.
- 5:56Why would you say I've met Donald Trump several times.
- 5:58So you're basing his,
- 5:59whether or not he's racist you don't have any evidence,
- 6:01you're saying because he
- 6:03allegedly got rid of some
- 6:05desperate impact analysis that somehow that has something to do
- 6:08with race and it only affects black people is anecdotal.
- 6:10Oh,
- 6:11Trump was nice to me one time,
- 6:12therefore he's not I have no evidence to believe that Trump is a racist.
- 6:17Where's the evidence that It was a racistism.
- 6:19OK,
- 6:19I'll give you more evidence.
- 6:20In 1973,
- 6:22his company was sued for violating the Fair Housing
- 6:24Act by openly discriminating against the black renters.
- 6:27What was the findings of that?
- 6:29He was actually forced to settle.
- 6:31He was forced to settle.
- 6:32He made he was forced to settle.
- 6:33No,
- 6:34there was no finding of fault.
- 6:35Why would someone settle if it finding not guilty.
- 6:39You can make Why would someone settle if he wasn't doing it,
- 6:41was there a determination in court that he was at fault?
- 6:44No,
- 6:44no,
- 6:45no.
- 6:45Was there a determination in court that he was
- 6:46At fault.
- 6:47He settled,
- 6:48so they didn't have a determination in court.
- 6:50He got out of it by settling,
- 6:52which is what you do when you are guilty,
- 6:54but you don't want to go to court.
- 6:55That's not the way that's not the way the system works settling is.
- 6:58Yes,
- 6:58you settle out,
- 6:59yes.
- 6:59He had a dissent decree,
- 7:00which they agreed that he would implement certain things in his organization.
- 7:04There was no fault,
- 7:05uh,
- 7:05granted.
- 7:06They did not prove the things that he had to implement in his,
- 7:08um,
- 7:09company.
- 7:09Recruiting,
- 7:10um,
- 7:11it was a form of it was that I
- 7:13think you're thinking about a different lawsuit against the.
- 7:15No,
- 7:15no,
- 7:16he had to
- 7:17make sure that they have job applications available to minorities.
- 7:20No,
- 7:20this wasn't about jobs.
- 7:21This was about the Trump Corporation,
- 7:22the real estate.
- 7:24Yes,
- 7:24they violated the Fair Housing Act because we're talking about something
- 7:27different because there were 2 times he was sued for racism.
- 7:30I only know of one time.
- 7:31Yeah,
- 7:31we should learn about the other one because I
- 7:34don't think you know what you're talking about.
- 7:36The dissent decree,
- 7:37which was established,
- 7:38there was no findings of Donald Trump being a racist,
- 7:41and his organization has been without fault.
- 7:44You cannot find a court document that says
- 7:47that Donald Trump officially discriminated against anybody.
- 7:52He literally marked?
- 7:52He literally marked black applicants.
- 7:54What's your next one?
- 7:55What's your next uh example of Trump being a racist?
- 7:57Um,
- 7:58when he reposted the Obamas as monkeys.
- 8:00Now,
- 8:01he,
- 8:01he did not,
- 8:02he already said,
- 8:03he already said that he did not post that,
- 8:06it was somebody on his staff,
- 8:07and the post wasn't even about that.
- 8:09That was a real.
- 8:10That was a real,
- 8:12that was a real,
- 8:12and then when it came out,
- 8:14he denounced it.
- 8:15He said it was wrong.
- 8:16It was on his account already.
- 8:18One of his staffers posted it.
- 8:20Why would one of his staffers even have that,
- 8:22even if it wasn't you were making the sound like the post was about that.
- 8:25It was a meme created by somebody else and
- 8:27are you really defending depicting black people as monkeys?
- 8:29Like that's crazy.
- 8:30And,
- 8:31and,
- 8:31and Hillary Clinton and Hillary Clinton was a was a pig,
- 8:35and it was all kinds of people depicting.
- 8:36as animals.
- 8:37It wasn't just about Barack Obama.
- 8:38Did Donald Trump make the video?
- 8:39The other president done that.
- 8:40Did Donald Trump make the video?
- 8:42Has any other president done that?
- 8:43You're blaming him.
- 8:44Did Donald Trump make the video?
- 8:45I don't know if he made a video.
- 8:46No,
- 8:46he did not.
- 8:47It's about what he denounce?
- 8:48Did he denounce what they represented?
- 8:49If I posted something that said kill all of X people,
- 8:53that's what I believe,
- 8:54right?
- 8:54That's not true.
- 8:55Even if I didn't type it out.
- 8:56That's not true.
- 8:57Put it in camera and then post it.
- 8:58If somebody posted what I believe,
- 9:00if somebody posted some offensive on,
- 9:02on,
- 9:02on your.
- 9:02Account and you denounce it,
- 9:04is that a fair statement to say you don't believe in that?
- 9:07No,
- 9:07I don't think that's true.
- 9:09I would like to be held accountable if somebody said
- 9:11he didn't believe if I hired someone to post on my
- 9:14behalf and they posted racist statements and you said that
- 9:17would be and you took it down and you told them
- 9:21and you said to the world you don't believe that to be true,
- 9:23we have to pause here.
- 9:25All right,
- 9:25you have been voted out by the majority.
- 9:27Thank you so much for your time.
- 9:30If you would like to be the next debater,
- 9:32get to the chair in 321.
- 9:38Hey,
- 9:38how are you?
- 9:38Hi.
- 9:40So I'd like to talk about Trump and the Republicans,
- 9:44uh,
- 9:44not specifically on Trump,
- 9:45but focusing upon the history of the Republican Party
- 9:48because he's just the latest iteration of that,
- 9:50OK?
- 9:51So.
- 9:52The Republican Party has a proven track record
- 9:56of giving platforms
- 9:58to sellouts who promote a message that harms black people.
- 10:01Who is that?
- 10:01Who is the sellout that you give me an example.
- 10:03Well,
- 10:03there are actually quite a few,
- 10:04but I'll start with the,
- 10:05let's start with this premise.
- 10:06The first black legislators
- 10:09or the first black
- 10:10people in Congress,
- 10:11House of Representatives,
- 10:12were all Republicans.
- 10:13Right.
- 10:13So let me explain that to you.
- 10:14Is that,
- 10:15is that a fact pattern?
- 10:16Right,
- 10:16yes,
- 10:16so basically,
- 10:17What happened is
- 10:18the last of the radical Republicans,
- 10:20which was a segment
- 10:22of the Republican Party that passed the 14th Amendment,
- 10:25all of the amendments that gave black people the right
- 10:27to vote and ensured that slaves would not be disenfranchised,
- 10:31he died in August 11,
- 10:33no,
- 10:33no,
- 10:33no,
- 10:33black people,
- 10:35I mean Republicans unanimously voted.
- 10:36He died in 1868 when the 14th Amendment was passed,
- 10:41and then guess what?
- 10:43The whole voted unanimously,
- 10:44no,
- 10:44no,
- 10:45no Democrats did not,
- 10:46right,
- 10:46but guess what?
- 10:46After the radical Republican faction
- 10:49left Congress,
- 10:50Republican,
- 10:51yes,
- 10:51that's they are,
- 10:52they were,
- 10:52they were a historic,
- 10:53no,
- 10:54no,
- 10:54no,
- 10:54that's a title.
- 10:55They were a historic was the radical faction.
- 10:57They,
- 10:58they were a segment of the Republican Party that
- 11:01that create Darius Stevens.
- 11:02He's a,
- 11:02he's an example.
- 11:03They,
- 11:04they are the ones who,
- 11:05uh,
- 11:05created the Freedmen's Bureau,
- 11:07which was designed
- 11:08to assimilate.
- 11:09Uh,
- 11:10ex-slaves into
- 11:12the national citizenry.
- 11:14After they left,
- 11:15the Republican Party constructed an oligarchy which we called the Gilded Age,
- 11:19and in which we saw the fate of black people decline,
- 11:22black
- 11:23black homeownership decline,
- 11:25black voting declined,
- 11:27all of that.
- 11:28The Republicans unanimously voted.
- 11:30No,
- 11:30not after that.
- 11:31Let me the Republicans unanimously voted for the 13th,
- 11:3414th,
- 11:34and 15th Amendment under the leadership of the radical.
- 11:37Republicans,
- 11:38and they were progressives unanimously voted for the Civil Rights Act.
- 11:41Yes,
- 11:41and then after the radical Republicans left,
- 11:43they stopped doing that.
- 11:44When did the radical Republicans leave?
- 11:46You're saying the radical 68,
- 11:48the last person.
- 11:48That's not
- 11:50true.
- 11:50It is 100% true.
- 11:51because the Republicans unanimously let me get back to what I was saying.
- 11:54Let me get back to what I was saying.
- 11:56Did Republicans unanimously vote for the Civil Rights Ac.
- 11:58You're bulldozing and you're steamrolling because you don't
- 12:00want to hear what I have to say.
- 12:01No,
- 12:02no,
- 12:02let's quantify the point.
- 12:03Listen,
- 12:04Republicans.
- 12:04Listen to what I have to say.
- 12:06Civil Rights Act.
- 12:07Listen to what I have to say that you can respond to it,
- 12:09OK?
- 12:09I want you to answer that question.
- 12:11Booker T.
- 12:12Washington
- 12:13was feted by the white racist establishment.
- 12:16He had tea at Windsor Windsor Castle
- 12:19by Queen Victoria.
- 12:21He met Susan B.
- 12:21Anthony.
- 12:22He was allowed to create the Tuskegee Institute
- 12:25because he was
- 12:26promoting this myth of personal responsibility which harms black people.
- 12:30The most successful.
- 12:31I
- 12:32documented
- 12:34a black man who
- 12:36lifted so many black people
- 12:38from poverty
- 12:40to success
- 12:41was Booker T.
- 12:42Washington.
- 12:42The
- 12:44Tuskegee Institute
- 12:44Jim Crow incredible Jim Crow in the institutionalization of Jim
- 12:49Crow was a direct result of his false message.
- 12:52What was his false message?
- 12:53His message was that black people were not
- 12:56fit to participate in the political process.
- 12:59Because
- 12:59slavery had set them backwards.
- 13:01And so all of the black congressmen,
- 13:04it's in his book.
- 13:06You said he mentioned that black people were not fit
- 13:07to participate in the whole thesis of Up from slavery.
- 13:12Did you read the book?
- 13:12I did not read the book.
- 13:13There you go,
- 13:14then you don't know what you're talking about.
- 13:16Let me tell you something.
- 13:17I am a history teacher.
- 13:19I teach in the public school system.
- 13:21You are uneducated.
- 13:22Let me finish what I'm saying.
- 13:23You,
- 13:23you don't know what you're talking about.
- 13:26If you're telling me that Republicans did not unanimously vote for the 13th,
- 13:2914th,
- 13:3015th Amendment
- 13:30and the Civil Rights Act,
- 13:33you cannot tell me you're a teacher and you are not,
- 13:35and you do not understand you are lying
- 13:38Republicans can't hear anything either you are saying.
- 13:41He's not allowing me to make a single point because I'm making points.
- 13:43No,
- 13:44because you're afraid
- 13:45of what?
- 13:45Of the truth.
- 13:46I just explained to you,
- 13:48when you just explained to you when you earn a living off of lies,
- 13:51you are afraid of the truth lie that I've told.
- 13:54The idea that Republican policies benefited black people,
- 13:57and that is not true.
- 13:59No,
- 13:59let me,
- 14:00let me give you an example.
- 14:01Give me examples that they've hurt black people.
- 14:02Before,
- 14:03I'll give you an example.
- 14:04During the Hoover administration,
- 14:0643% of the black people who were employed were employed in domestic work,
- 14:11and the reason for that is because they were shut out of truly gainful employment.
- 14:16And the segment who was hurt the most were black men.
- 14:20Black women.
- 14:21Get jobs at maids as maids and things of that sort,
- 14:24but black men,
- 14:25any job that gave them the opportunity for social dignity,
- 14:28value and worth,
- 14:29they were systematically denied,
- 14:31and a lot of it had to do with Booker T.
- 14:33Washington's message.
- 14:34Now,
- 14:35guess what?
- 14:36Booker T.
- 14:36Washington's
- 14:37message has been harmful that I have.
- 14:39You have not read the book portions
- 14:42of his message.
- 14:42read the whole book.
- 14:43I will read the whole book,
- 14:44but you cannot sit here and tell me that Booker T.
- 14:46Washington's message was dis.
- 14:48He had hurt black people.
- 14:49And guess what?
- 14:50Guess what he acknowledges in the in his book.
- 14:53He acknowledges detrimental to guess what he said?
- 14:56Yes,
- 14:57it was,
- 14:57and let me tell you why.
- 14:59He acknowledged
- 15:00that the people in Tuskegee,
- 15:02Alabama,
- 15:02the white community there,
- 15:04only allowed him to create that institute
- 15:06because he assured them
- 15:08he would not be teaching them
- 15:10anything that would lift them out of domestic,
- 15:13uh,
- 15:13status,
- 15:14anything that uh pertained to.
- 15:15Uh,
- 15:16higher
- 15:17education,
- 15:18any knowledge of their history,
- 15:20or just,
- 15:21uh,
- 15:21the humanities,
- 15:23anything that,
- 15:24anything that white people took for granted in normal universities.
- 15:28It was designed to keep black people oppressed.
- 15:30That was the point.
- 15:31Up from slavery.
- 15:33Booker T.
- 15:33Washington
- 15:34had a message of black success and personal accountability and responsibility.
- 15:38He did not depend
- 15:40on the government
- 15:41to do the things.
- 15:42That black people could already do.
- 15:44He did not,
- 15:45he did not make his mission and his plan
- 15:47to say that black people should depend on the government.
- 15:49This is the lie for everybody who is listening to me.
- 15:53The lie is that black people should focus
- 15:55solely upon family and their economic status and ignore agitations for social
- 16:01social equality.
- 16:02No,
- 16:03and he,
- 16:04he actually says in that responsibility that agitations for social.
- 16:08Racial equality are the extremist folly because black people are
- 16:12not prepared to be social equals to white people.
- 16:15He actually says that
- 16:16that has been the program of the Republican Party
- 16:19ever since.
- 16:20First of all,
- 16:20that's a lie.
- 16:21And now guess what else that's a lie.
- 16:22So,
- 16:24uh,
- 16:24after why didn't the Democrats,
- 16:26why did the Democrats have,
- 16:27until Cory Booker recently had the longest filibuster
- 16:30against the Civil Rights Act?
- 16:31Right,
- 16:31I
- 16:31I'll I'll tell you what the longest in history.
- 16:33So basically what happened.
- 16:34Is
- 16:35prior to that act,
- 16:37there were a number of Dixiecrats who were the,
- 16:39the inheritors,
- 16:40the inheritor,
- 16:41I'll tell you,
- 16:42the inheritors of
- 16:44slavery,
- 16:44chattel slavery,
- 16:45and then Jim Crow era that took its place.
- 16:48Guess what?
- 16:49After those acts,
- 16:50the Voting Rights Act and the Civil Rights Act were passed,
- 16:52guess what?
- 16:53Republicans,
- 16:54there was a 20 to 30% shift away from the Democratic Party
- 16:58into the Republican Party
- 17:00and then surprisingly.
- 17:01Sly,
- 17:02Nixon begins his war on drugs,
- 17:04which is a part of his,
- 17:05his,
- 17:05uh,
- 17:06law and order
- 17:07program,
- 17:08and guess what happens?
- 17:09Black people become 6 to 7%,
- 17:116 to 7 times higher to be arrested for drug abuse
- 17:15versus,
- 17:16uh,
- 17:16white people.
- 17:17They are mass incarcerating us and it is a direct,
- 17:20it is directly tied to Republican policies.
- 17:22OK,
- 17:23we have to pause here.
- 17:24We have to pause here.
- 17:25You have been voted out by the majority.
- 17:26Thank you so much.
- 17:29If you would like to be the next debater,
- 17:31get to that chair in 321.
- 17:36Oh
- 17:38Watch out
- 17:39now watch out now
- 17:40pleasure to meet you.
- 17:41How you doing?
- 17:41I'm doing good.
- 17:42So
- 17:43your claim is that Trump and Republicans are
- 17:45better for the black community than Democrats.
- 17:49OK,
- 17:50I think that claim is patently false,
- 17:52and let me explain why.
- 17:54Take the institution of voting,
- 17:56the most sacred thing that the Constitution protects,
- 17:59something that we need for elected officials to represent us.
- 18:04Repeatedly Republicans have used the judiciary to
- 18:08discriminate against black people in voting.
- 18:11We have cases like Louisiana versus Calais,
- 18:13the recent case that in 2026 it's caused
- 18:17all the redistricting crisis that you see right now,
- 18:19and when you
- 18:20see the effects of that for the black community,
- 18:22the Congressional Black Caucus is set to lose 16 to 19% or it's not 1616 to 19 members,
- 18:2830% of its representation.
- 18:31Regardless of anything that
- 18:33you are saying communities should be doing,
- 18:35you have to still elect people to represent
- 18:37you to make those policy decisions and you're,
- 18:40let me finish.
- 18:41I'm gonna finish
- 18:42if you are erasing the ability for people to have that representation.
- 18:46And you're making it even harder to vote like decisions like Shelby v.
- 18:49Holder,
- 18:50which makes it harder to eliminate discriminatory laws,
- 18:53or you have cases like Bernovich v.
- 18:55DNC
- 18:55which are striking case which are striking the ability to
- 18:58challenge laws that we think are discriminatory for mail-in voting.
- 19:01It's not good and it's not reasonable to say that Republicans are
- 19:06representing black people's interests.
- 19:07Let me put this in simplistic terms.
- 19:09Voting is a sacred right,
- 19:11right?
- 19:11And black people were afforded voting rights which we all should fight for.
- 19:15Having voter ID
- 19:17is protecting that sacred right that black people will make
- 19:20sure that black people can actually vote without being.
- 19:23Um,
- 19:23uh,
- 19:24eliminated in their voting power by illegal aliens.
- 19:27This goes beyond,
- 19:27no,
- 19:27no,
- 19:28let me,
- 19:28let me go point by point.
- 19:29Wait,
- 19:29wait,
- 19:29wait,
- 19:30wait,
- 19:30wait,
- 19:30wait,
- 19:30wait,
- 19:30wait,
- 19:31wait,
- 19:31wait,
- 19:31wait,
- 19:31wait,
- 19:31this goes way beyond voter ID.
- 19:33This goes way beyond this goes way beyond voter ID.
- 19:37You simply don't want,
- 19:38they simply don't want people who are black to be elected.
- 19:42How is that possible?
- 19:43Because majority minority districts were created by the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
- 19:48That,
- 19:49that specific.
- 19:50Specific piece of legislation which Republicans have
- 19:52repeatedly targeted through decades has said,
- 19:55hey,
- 19:55there was history done here that harmed people and as a way to
- 19:59make up for it slowly over time we need to designate specific areas,
- 20:04black populous areas to have accurate representation of the folks Supreme Court.
- 20:08The Supreme Court ruled that,
- 20:10hey,
- 20:10actually no,
- 20:11you guys don't need this representation.
- 20:13This is unconstitutional.
- 20:15I certainly you.
- 20:16You cannot,
- 20:17you cannot redistrict cannot you cannot you cannot.
- 20:20You cannot deny black people from having the right to vote and represent themselves
- 20:26because you have white people in Louisiana versus Calake.
- 20:29That's,
- 20:29that's what the case is.
- 20:30OK,
- 20:30let me pause here.
- 20:32Let Officer Tatum speak.
- 20:33OK,
- 20:33this is the problem here.
- 20:34You are assuming that black people can only vote for Democrats.
- 20:38Yes,
- 20:38you are,
- 20:39because the redistricting,
- 20:40where did I say that?
- 20:41Because when did I say I'm saying you insinuated.
- 20:44That because you cannot draw lines of demarcation based on
- 20:48race,
- 20:49that is against the United States Constitution.
- 20:51They ruled that,
- 20:52which is why they had to redraw lines.
- 20:54Black people have a right to vote for anybody that
- 20:56they want that's that acts in the best interest of
- 20:58the black community or the community at large.
- 21:00It doesn't have to always be Democrats.
- 21:02There's a reason why people,
- 21:04there's a reason why black people vote for Democrats
- 21:06and there's a reason why there's only 5 elected,
- 21:08only 5 elected Republicans in.
- 21:11That is the problem in the black community today,
- 21:13the consistency of voting for these Democrats who ain't
- 21:17done nothing for black people and still haven't.
- 21:19We're,
- 21:19we,
- 21:19we're
- 21:20to this day,
- 21:21many people that are sitting around here are still
- 21:23complaining about the plight against the black people,
- 21:25which y'all still vote for Democrats
- 21:27and Democrats have been elected in office for the majority of the time in the last
- 21:30decade.
- 21:34Republicans have done?
- 21:34Republicans Republicans have done way more damaging things
- 21:36even just as of as of recently.
- 21:38Just recently with Doge we had the highest
- 21:40exodus of black women in the federal workforce.
- 21:43I'm not sure if you're not aware of that information,
- 21:45but wait,
- 21:46wait,
- 21:46I'm not sure if you're aware of that information,
- 21:47but black and cutting spending for social services increasing,
- 21:52increasing poverty,
- 21:53increasing crime,
- 21:54increasing death and harming people over and over again who
- 21:56are doing nothing to help the black community and trying
- 21:59to perpetuate a policy platform that insists that black people
- 22:03need to be put down is not going to.
- 22:05That is a lie.
- 22:06You are saying that we're gonna cut government spending,
- 22:09but we should leave all the black people there because they're black.
- 22:11No,
- 22:12we should cutting government spending we should
- 22:13increase government spending by taxing the rich,
- 22:15funding our communities,
- 22:16and putting us in jail instead of putting people in power.
- 22:19Taxing the rich is a foolish statement by you.
- 22:22What do you mean by taxing the rich?
- 22:24We in California have already seen that's why people are leaving California.
- 22:27Oh,
- 22:27wait,
- 22:27wait,
- 22:28wait,
- 22:28wait,
- 22:28wait.
- 22:28That's why business owners are leaving here.
- 22:30Companies are leaving.
- 22:32In California,
- 22:32even in the basic past when we taxed the rich,
- 22:35we were able to fund the University of California systems
- 22:38and what did Ronald Reagan do?
- 22:39Ronald Reagan said,
- 22:40let's slash that because black people need to suffer,
- 22:43communities need to go down,
- 22:44and what do we know now we have budget,
- 22:46no,
- 22:46now we have budget deficits affecting our systems.
- 22:49We have run,
- 22:50we have laws from the 1970s still on the books affecting the rich.
- 22:53Oh wait,
- 22:53wait,
- 22:53let's let's,
- 22:54we can talk about taxes too.
- 22:55Let's go are still selling black folks to this day.
- 22:58Taxing the rich
- 23:00is
- 23:01they're not gonna change the tax code,
- 23:03so taxing the rich is a myth,
- 23:05um,
- 23:06would you benefit more financially
- 23:07if you left California?
- 23:09Depends on how I use my money because I'm a smart person.
- 23:11It doesn't matter about being smart because the taxes are out of control.
- 23:13I think money and how you manage it with your with your as your person,
- 23:17when we talk about personal responsibility you manage money well,
- 23:19you're still gonna be less you have to pause
- 23:22here you've been voted out by the majority.
- 23:23Thank you so much.
- 23:24Pleasure talking with you.
- 23:26If you would like to be the next debater,
- 23:28get to that chair in 321.
- 23:34Hi,
- 23:34nice to meet you.
- 23:35Nice to meet you as well.
- 23:36I wanted to ask
- 23:38just in terms of.
- 23:41Him refusing to sign not only the Affordable Housing Act but also
- 23:47refusing to sign the bipartisan 2024 bill when it comes to
- 23:51putting more money on our borders,
- 23:53right,
- 23:53because you talked about immigration.
- 23:55Why would he refuse
- 23:56these acts if in,
- 23:58in reality if we put more money there
- 24:00we would have more officers and.
- 24:03Less fear and
- 24:04we would be able to actually have legal
- 24:07immigration streamlined more cleanly because the question is not
- 24:12don't have I'm guessing you're not
- 24:13against immigration you're against illegal immigration
- 24:17or
- 24:18for the for the most part I'm against uh
- 24:21illegal immigration but I also believe we need to.
- 24:24Uh,
- 24:24measure
- 24:25how much immigration we're actually allowing in this country when we,
- 24:28when people in America
- 24:29have needs that we need to address here.
- 24:32We allow a million immigrants legally in the
- 24:34United States of America every single year,
- 24:36and we all in here
- 24:38care about
- 24:39the issues that go on in the black community.
- 24:41I would argue.
- 24:42That black people need the financial support
- 24:45that we're giving these,
- 24:46these,
- 24:46these immigrants that are coming over here.
- 24:48I think it's not right illegal immigrants actually don't get federal support.
- 24:51They do get federal support.
- 24:51Illegal immigrants,
- 24:53fact check that illegal immigrants do not have federal support.
- 24:56They,
- 24:57but actually what I will say
- 24:59is that immigrants overall
- 25:01pay taxes immigrants immigrants illegal immigrants do not get federal get access
- 25:06to.
- 25:07Social programs,
- 25:08they get access to Medicare,
- 25:11they get access to all all immigrants,
- 25:13but illegal immigrants do as well.
- 25:14I'm talking about specifically the border bill.
- 25:16Why did he reject that?
- 25:17Because it's because bills are not isolated.
- 25:20It's got a bunch of minutia,
- 25:22a bunch of spending that he doesn't agree with,
- 25:23and the Republicans don't agree with.
- 25:25All of all of those bills have Republicans,
- 25:28it was a bipartisan bill.
- 25:30Well then why you tell me why.
- 25:31He didn't sign it.
- 25:33No,
- 25:33you tell me why he didn't sign it in.
- 25:34I'm asking you.
- 25:35You're saying that he's,
- 25:36that he's doing it because he's racist.
- 25:37I'm not saying I didn't say that.
- 25:39Why are you putting one?
- 25:39I'm,
- 25:40I'm,
- 25:40I genuinely I'm trying to ask you why didn't he?
- 25:42The bill is not just singularly about border patrol,
- 25:46but it's not,
- 25:47we're talking about healthcare.
- 25:48By 2034,
- 25:4910 million Americans are gonna lose their healthcare.
- 25:52I'm so sorry.
- 25:53Thank you both so much.
- 25:55Love the passion though.
- 25:58Time moves fast,
- 25:59but your credit score doesn't have to stay stuck.
- 26:02I remember how overwhelmed I felt trying to fix my credit.
- 26:05It felt like a catch-22,
- 26:07where you need credit to build credit.
- 26:10Then I found Kickoff.
- 26:11Signing up took minutes on my phone with no credit check and no hidden fees.
- 26:15For users with credit under 600,
- 26:17they see an average growth of 86 points.
- 26:20Kickoff helps you score big when it comes to credit.
- 26:22Plans start at just $5 a month with 0% interest.
- 26:25Start building credit with Kickoff today and get
- 26:27your first month for as little as $1.
- 26:29That's 80% off the normal price when you go to getkickoff.com/surrounded today.
- 26:34That's kickoff without the C.
- 26:36Get KIKOFF.com.
- 26:39Slash surrounded.
- 26:40Must sign up via get kickoff.com/surrounded to activate offer.
- 26:41Offer applies to new Kickoff customers first month only,
- 26:43subject to approval.
- 26:43Offer subject to change.
- 26:44Average first year credit score impacted plus
- 26:4586 points between August 224 and August
- 26:462025 for Kickoff credit account users who started with a score below 600,
- 26:48who paid on time and who had no delinquencies or
- 26:49collections added to their credit profile during the period.
- 26:51Late payments may negatively impact your credit score.
- 26:52Individual results may vary.
- 26:53Thank you to Kickoff for sponsoring this episode.
- 26:55Now let's get back to the show.
- 26:57My next surrounding claim is that police officers do
- 26:59more good in the black community than harm.
- 27:02All right,
- 27:02if you would like to be the next debater,
- 27:04get to the chair in +321.
- 27:09I wanna hear
- 27:10why
- 27:11you think that uh police do more good
- 27:14in the black communities than harm.
- 27:15Well,
- 27:16when you look at
- 27:16the functionality of law enforcement,
- 27:18meaning that the people who perpetuate crime in the
- 27:20black community are arrested by law enforcement officers,
- 27:22removing them from the community,
- 27:23removing the,
- 27:24the predators,
- 27:25the drug dealers,
- 27:26and all of that from the community,
- 27:27which is a good thing,
- 27:28and I cannot name
- 27:30other things that are harmful
- 27:32that outweigh all of the good that the police officers do.
- 27:35Um,
- 27:36how did the police first come about?
- 27:41Be more detailed than that.
- 27:42That's that's not true.
- 27:44Police,
- 27:44that's that's two different functionalities,
- 27:46they can fact check it.
- 27:47That's two different functionalities.
- 27:49You're talking about slave patrols and
- 27:50modern day policing is completely different.
- 27:52The origins of policing within the United States
- 27:55of America derived from the slave patrol.
- 27:57They still use the same badges,
- 27:58the same,
- 27:59the stars on the that's fine.
- 28:01The functionality of slave patrols
- 28:04and the jurisdiction.
- 28:05Slave patrol versus the functionality and jurisdiction of law
- 28:08enforcement from the entire premise of slave patrol.
- 28:11That's fine,
- 28:12that's fine.
- 28:12Listen,
- 28:13OK,
- 28:13cool.
- 28:13So
- 28:15you don't think there's an issue with policing in the black community?
- 28:18You don't think there's an issue with stop and frisk?
- 28:20You don't think that there's an issue with like
- 28:23flock cameras and and geo tracking?
- 28:25Got it.
- 28:25OK,
- 28:26cool.
- 28:27Sure.
- 28:27Have you ever heard of the veil of darkness study?
- 28:30No,
- 28:30I have not.
- 28:31OK.
- 28:31The Bell of Darkness study was a study that
- 28:33was completed where 95 million traffic stops were actually checked
- 28:37across the United States of America.
- 28:39Vast pool,
- 28:40right?
- 28:40The methodology accounted for the time of day,
- 28:43for traffic,
- 28:44location,
- 28:45different shifts.
- 28:46Would you like to know
- 28:47what they found in that study?
- 28:50When it came to policing and black people,
- 28:52that black people commit more traffic violations than other people.
- 28:55No,
- 28:56that is that black people were stopped for more traffic violations.
- 28:58Hold on,
- 28:59I got you commit I got you.
- 29:00You don't know the study.
- 29:01How are you gonna answer?
- 29:02I know what other studies and statistical data points show.
- 29:05OK,
- 29:05then give me.
- 29:05That's that's why you think they're just pulling black people over just because
- 29:09they see a black person driving at literally the veil of darkness study,
- 29:12the veil of darkness study that was done by Stanford
- 29:15and backed up by um by the CDC actually showed
- 29:18that what happens is during the day.
- 29:21Police officers use racial bias because they can see people and they pull people,
- 29:26they pull,
- 29:26I'm gonna finish my sentence.
- 29:28I'm literally gonna finish.
- 29:29I'm literally gonna finish.
- 29:31They pull black people over during the day
- 29:33at a disproportionate rate than white people,
- 29:35but at nighttime
- 29:36when you can't see and it's harder to tell someone's actual race
- 29:40than the average drops and it equals out,
- 29:43they actually.
- 29:44found that in the study,
- 29:4595 million traffic violations,
- 29:47that when you can't see someone's race,
- 29:49you focus on the traffic violations versus the day.
- 29:53Let me tell you why your study is flawed.
- 29:55For one reason,
- 29:56I was a police officer many years,
- 29:57I do traffic stops during the day and you cannot always tell
- 29:59the race of a person during the day no matter what.
- 30:01Secondary,
- 30:02they're secondary,
- 30:03when you are patrolling,
- 30:05the majority of the black people that you engage.
- 30:07We live in what?
- 30:07Black communities.
- 30:09So
- 30:10you're gonna make an excuse,
- 30:11we can get to that.
- 30:12You're making an excuse.
- 30:13When you're in a black community,
- 30:14you only have options to pull over black people.
- 30:16Now let me,
- 30:17let me,
- 30:18let me,
- 30:18let me,
- 30:19let me finish.
- 30:20I believe that there's clearly a flaw in what you're saying this study
- 30:24represents
- 30:25because in the black community,
- 30:27in the black community,
- 30:29I,
- 30:30I have
- 30:30plenty of other.
- 30:32You gotta trust me,
- 30:32bros.
- 30:33Touch
- 30:34I did it for a living
- 30:36and you did not.
- 30:38So like I've looked at the information,
- 30:39I'm telling you why the study,
- 30:40I'm telling you why the study is wrong one-off experience is indicative of all,
- 30:44I'm telling you why your study is off.
- 30:47When you're looking at patrolling in black neighborhoods,
- 30:49you cannot,
- 30:50how are you gonna make a fair comparison to how many white people.
- 30:52Pulled over versus black people when there's only
- 30:54black people present in the black neighborhood.
- 30:55The veil of darkness do not,
- 30:57cannot
- 30:58get in the minds of a police officer and determine whether or not the
- 31:00police officer pulled a person over because of their color or the violation.
- 31:03It does not,
- 31:04doesn't get in the mind and prove that a cop was looking at a black man in a
- 31:09racially targeted veil of darkness,
- 31:11it shows not only the reason why they were.
- 31:12Pulled over,
- 31:13but it shows the ones that were thrown out.
- 31:15They were disproportionately pulled over
- 31:17and disproportionately pulled over and there
- 31:20was a disproportion of black violations that were thrown out.
- 31:24It doesn't matter.
- 31:25Why?
- 31:25Disproportionality is not so many black people pulled over and
- 31:28then so many of the violations were thrown out.
- 31:30You gotta look at it like this.
- 31:31If you look,
- 31:32if you're looking at
- 31:33Traffic stops across the country,
- 31:35different jurisdictions have different mandates and they have different
- 31:37standards for what they throw out as traffic violations.
- 31:40So you cannot make a generalization across the entire country.
- 31:44You know across the entire country?
- 31:45White supremacy.
- 31:47White
- 31:47supremacy supremacy have anything to do with a traffic stop.
- 31:50It's it's literally racism.
- 31:53They're literally,
- 31:54they're literally trained to actually go through.
- 31:57Tell me how to train.
- 31:59Have you been through police training?
- 32:00No,
- 32:00I have not.
- 32:07I went through police training and they do not teach discrimination.
- 32:07Why is it that police officers spend more time in black neighborhoods disproport.
- 32:11They're not.
- 32:11Yes.
- 32:12Who commits the most violent crimes in America today?
- 32:17Per capita per capita,
- 32:17period.
- 32:18black people do.
- 32:19No,
- 32:19white people,
- 32:20white men that's a lie.
- 32:21FBI.
- 32:22Fact checking.
- 32:22FBI data shows FBI data shows that white men,
- 32:26white men specifically commit the most violent
- 32:28crime in the United States of America.
- 32:30If you're talking about property crimes,
- 32:31yes,
- 32:31it's black people.
- 32:33Violent crimes,
- 32:34it's white men,
- 32:35including CSA.
- 32:37White men,
- 32:37if you could talk per capita with CSA,
- 32:40you can talk you can talk numbers.
- 32:41White men disproportionately represent CSA
- 32:44and violent crime rate
- 32:46and violent crimes
- 32:47disproportionately represent in 135.
- 32:51Alright,
- 32:51we're gonna have to pause here,
- 32:52so I'm glad you guys took a pause.
- 32:54You have been voted out.
- 32:55Thank you so much.
- 32:56Give me 10 minutes.
- 32:57I'm telling you.
- 33:00She's making up stats.
- 33:01If you would like to be the next debater,
- 33:03get to that chair in 321.
- 33:09All right.
- 33:12Everything I heard,
- 33:13everything I've listened to thus far,
- 33:16I think you're full of shit.
- 33:18Um,
- 33:19you're a police officer.
- 33:20Give me,
- 33:21give me an example of what I said that wasn't true.
- 33:23Let me get to it.
- 33:25I don't think anybody here would disagree
- 33:28that good policing is bad.
- 33:31We're talking about bad policing.
- 33:33We're talking about bullshit policing.
- 33:35We're talking about the kind of policing that puts
- 33:38a gentlemen like you and me
- 33:41in prison for unjust
- 33:43crimes.
- 33:44You like to cite that you're a police officer.
- 33:46Let me cite my professional background.
- 33:48Let me cite my professional background in that profession.
- 33:5110 years writing policy in government at the local
- 33:55and you weren't state of California levels
- 33:58and you weren't,
- 34:00you didn't write policy.
- 34:01I did.
- 34:02I enforced the law.
- 34:03So,
- 34:03OK,
- 34:04I wrote,
- 34:04I write the laws don't enforce but you don't enforce the law.
- 34:07You don't enforce the law appropriately.
- 34:10You'd like to use one-offs,
- 34:11let me use a one-off.
- 34:12You don't need to use one-offs in the city of San Diego.
- 34:15there was a black police officer that sued the San Diego Police Department
- 34:18anecdotal
- 34:19with regard to,
- 34:20I mean,
- 34:21bro,
- 34:21all day you've been coming up with me,
- 34:23me,
- 34:23me,
- 34:23me,
- 34:23me,
- 34:24now points.
- 34:25Where do you want to go like I need you to keep that same energy,
- 34:27bro.
- 34:28I need you to keep saying violent crimes,
- 34:30and that's the problem
- 34:31with black conservatives like yourself.
- 34:33You don't know how to keep the same emotionally.
- 34:35It was me,
- 34:35me,
- 34:35me.
- 34:37Well,
- 34:37I'm trying to get you facts.
- 34:39You,
- 34:39you're supposed to be a police officer.
- 34:41Hold your head,
- 34:41bro.
- 34:42Hold your head.
- 34:43You're interrupting everybody,
- 34:45bro.
- 34:46I,
- 34:47I got to me.
- 34:47I'm not here to listen to you talk in circles.
- 34:49But you're talking like you was a state trooper,
- 34:51you was a Secret Service.
- 34:52I know cops all across the country.
- 34:54I know,
- 34:55I know that.
- 34:56I get to your point.
- 34:57You don't know because you've never written one.
- 34:59We're talking about policing in the black community.
- 35:01We're not talking about I wanna hold you to
- 35:03account because police officers like you don't like accountability.
- 35:07So I want to hold you to account.
- 35:08I'm trying to get my story out and if I can finish my story.
- 35:11This is not story time,
- 35:12man.
- 35:12Get to the point is police do more good.
- 35:15The point was the point was with regard to training,
- 35:19the San Diego Police Department showed a video
- 35:22training officers of that department
- 35:25depicting black people as primary perpetrators
- 35:29of crime.
- 35:30That's not true.
- 35:32My last guy that that was just up here,
- 35:35who who commits the most crimes in America is white people.
- 35:38Name me the last black mass murderer in America.
- 35:43I got shot up schools.
- 35:44It happened in it happened in the hood every
- 35:46day.
- 35:47I didn't,
- 35:47I didn't ask about the hood.
- 35:48Mass shooting,
- 35:50bro.
- 35:50Go to Fort Chicago on the 4th of July definition of a mass shooter shooting.
- 35:54What's the definition of a people shot.
- 35:56It's a mass shooting,
- 35:57according to the FBI.
- 35:58I could tell you to go to any inner city in the United States of America
- 36:02and go just this past weekend and you've
- 36:04seen multiple mass shootings that occurred in that,
- 36:06in that community.
- 36:07I don't know them by name,
- 36:08I can cite you.
- 36:09Columbine,
- 36:10I can cite you.
- 36:11Sandy,
- 36:12you're talking about a shooting isolated at a school.
- 36:14We're talking about violence.
- 36:16We're talking about murder rates.
- 36:18Black people commit
- 36:19over half of all murders in this country.
- 36:21Is that true or not?
- 36:22That's true.
- 36:23That is true.
- 36:24What are you saying?
- 36:25Black people commit black people commit disproportionate amounts in
- 36:28over half of all violent crimes in this country.
- 36:30OK,
- 36:31Officer Tatum,
- 36:31both of you guys,
- 36:32we have to stop here because you have been voted out.
- 36:34Thank you so much for your time.
- 36:37If you would like to be the next debater,
- 36:38get to that hot seat in 321.
- 36:44Alright,
- 36:44what's up,
- 36:44bro?
- 36:45Uh,
- 36:46I would argue that the resources,
- 36:48uh,
- 36:48that the cost of hiring a police officer could be
- 36:52significantly better used in revitalizing the black community rather than
- 36:56affording more cops.
- 36:57As you've seen in the city of New York,
- 36:59when they utilize,
- 37:01when they increased
- 37:02the amount of funding they're putting in schools,
- 37:04when they increased having childcare for people,
- 37:06when they increased training for people to get jobs,
- 37:10they saw,
- 37:11uh,
- 37:11the lowest crime rate that they've seen in years.
- 37:13Right,
- 37:13this is where I think we can agree on.
- 37:15Let's,
- 37:16we,
- 37:16we gotta
- 37:17walk and chew gum at the same time.
- 37:18As we see resources provided and crime go down,
- 37:21then we can begin to,
- 37:22to shrink the availability of law enforcement in that said community.
- 37:26You don't do one before the other.
- 37:27You can't just say,
- 37:28I'm gonna take resources
- 37:30from the law enforcement
- 37:31officers.
- 37:33Crime will go out of control.
- 37:34If you,
- 37:35if I want,
- 37:35was to concede to your point,
- 37:37we need to see
- 37:38these,
- 37:39these crime statistics begin to decrease.
- 37:42Therefore,
- 37:42you can justify decrease in law enforcement.
- 37:44You cannot think
- 37:45that because you build a park,
- 37:47that somebody ain't gonna be shooting and acting a fool in the,
- 37:49in the hood.
- 37:50That is a generational thing that's gonna have to happen.
- 37:53And right now we still got people out today that don't give a F about a park.
- 37:56We've seen plenty of cases that,
- 37:58that people have built
- 37:59incredible schools,
- 38:00they've built parks,
- 38:02roadways,
- 38:03availability to activities for people,
- 38:04and they're still out here cutting up.
- 38:06And
- 38:07a lot of it is the way people are raised,
- 38:09the culture that
- 38:10people are embracing.
- 38:11And I would argue that black people are
- 38:13embracing that wasn't even black culture to start with
- 38:16that that those things need to be addressed and they are the most
- 38:19detrimental to the black community
- 38:21than even funding
- 38:22and defunding police.
- 38:23And I hear you,
- 38:24but I still agree that.
- 38:24All right,
- 38:25we're gonna have to pause here.
- 38:26I'm so sorry you have been voted out by the majority.
- 38:31If you would like to be the next debater,
- 38:33please get to the chair in 321.
- 38:38What's up bro?
- 38:39I just wanna take a second
- 38:40to acknowledge that you're being roasted and you're being very polite about it,
- 38:43so thank you for that.
- 38:44I'm doing what
- 38:45I say you're getting roasted right now,
- 38:46but you're being very polite about it,
- 38:47and I appreciate that.
- 38:48Oh,
- 38:49thank you for your,
- 38:49uh,
- 38:50conceding,
- 38:52um,
- 38:52to my arguments,
- 38:53OK.
- 38:53Mm,
- 38:54I wouldn't say that,
- 38:54but,
- 38:55OK,
- 38:55so
- 38:56you're familiar with broken window policing,
- 38:58right?
- 38:58I'm familiar in part.
- 38:59Yeah,
- 39:00just for people that don't know,
- 39:01it's just a uniform enforcement.
- 39:03Of both
- 39:04significant and insignificant laws,
- 39:05right?
- 39:06And I think we could both agree that there are laws in this country that
- 39:09shouldn't exist,
- 39:10right?
- 39:10Or just give me an example because I can't concede
- 39:12to it if I don't know what you're talking about.
- 39:14Marijuana,
- 39:15right?
- 39:15Like in the state of Texas,
- 39:17if you're caught with marijuana,
- 39:18you can be a felon,
- 39:19right?
- 39:19I think we can both agree that that's.
- 39:21I don't,
- 39:21I don't,
- 39:21I don't agree to that.
- 39:22I mean,
- 39:22people vote on it and they and they'll pass what the
- 39:25majority believe.
- 39:25I don't,
- 39:26I don't agree to that.
- 39:27I think,
- 39:28I think in some cases marijuana should be.
- 39:29Legal.
- 39:30I think medical marijuana should be legal.
- 39:31I mean,
- 39:32obviously.
- 39:32Well,
- 39:32yeah,
- 39:33sure,
- 39:33but I
- 39:35fixed,
- 39:35fixed,
- 39:36um,
- 39:36all marijuana,
- 39:37but,
- 39:37but I think we can both agree that
- 39:39if you have like a felony conviction that stunts
- 39:41your ability to earn and provide for your family,
- 39:44right?
- 39:44Yeah,
- 39:44you knew that before you committed the felony,
- 39:46right?
- 39:47Yeah,
- 39:47but like I think certain laws,
- 39:50well,
- 39:50first of all,
- 39:51you're talking felonies,
- 39:51you're not talking misdemeanor.
- 39:52felonies are very
- 39:54intense things that you do that cause To get a felony.
- 39:57It's not just having weed on you.
- 39:59No,
- 39:59not exactly,
- 40:00not exactly,
- 40:00because if you're caught with a wax pen,
- 40:02right,
- 40:03that can be considered
- 40:04a felony equivalent to if you had like cocaine or
- 40:07something like that depending on what state you're in,
- 40:08but if that's the case,
- 40:09but you know that,
- 40:10you know that before you do it.
- 40:12And so you make the decision,
- 40:13you make the decision,
- 40:14everybody in here makes decisions,
- 40:15they're not gonna do that because you don't want a felony on your record
- 40:17because you want to be successful and be able to get a job.
- 40:19Is that fair?
- 40:20That's personal responsibility.
- 40:21But let's interrogate the central claim,
- 40:22you're saying that
- 40:23Uh,
- 40:24police in black communities do more good than harm,
- 40:26right?
- 40:26So if you're caught smoking a blunt on your porch,
- 40:29and you become a felon for the rest of your life and then you're relegated to like,
- 40:33being like,
- 40:34Like,
- 40:35uh,
- 40:35doing menial labor for the rest of your life,
- 40:37right?
- 40:37When you could have had
- 40:39a lot more prospect,
- 40:40isn't that the police
- 40:41causing more harm to your life?
- 40:42No,
- 40:42no,
- 40:42it's just don't smoke weed and you won't have to worry about the police.
- 40:45So are the laws enforced equally across the races?
- 40:50It is.
- 40:50No,
- 40:50what's your?
- 40:51What's that?
- 40:51So black people
- 40:53in this country,
- 40:54right,
- 40:54are
- 40:55Statistically found to have
- 40:57been given,
- 40:58um,
- 40:59larger sentences for the same crimes compared to their white counterparts.
- 41:02See,
- 41:02let me,
- 41:02let me,
- 41:02let me give you some more information to to give you a better perspective.
- 41:05A lot of it is because people have committed multiple
- 41:08crimes before they get to the final crime sentencing.
- 41:10Yes,
- 41:10yes,
- 41:10it is for first-time offenders.
- 41:12Give me an example.
- 41:13Where do you see,
- 41:14now here's what And everybody should acknowledge this.
- 41:17Where do you see in this country,
- 41:19a judge,
- 41:20this judge gave a white person a different sentence
- 41:23than a black person in that same courtroom.
- 41:24Statistically,
- 41:25you can still see that
- 41:26minority offenders are given harsher sentences for the same crimes compared to the
- 41:30and a lot of times it's because they already have previous charges.
- 41:33I'll give you an example of,
- 41:34of,
- 41:34of people that's in my family.
- 41:36You know,
- 41:37two people that I know,
- 41:37I'm not gonna say what position they're in my family,
- 41:40got 20 years in prison for armed robbery.
- 41:4225
- 41:43years in prison for armed robbery.
- 41:44The reason he got 25 years is because he had
- 41:47already committed a robbery he got 5 years before that.
- 41:49Another one of my cousins got 75 years in prison
- 41:51for shooting 3 people.
- 41:53The reason he got 75 years,
- 41:54and some people didn't get that because he had already been a prohibited possessor,
- 41:57he was already a convicted felon,
- 41:59and he had drugs in the car.
- 42:00Those contributing factors is what lead many
- 42:03black people who already have a criminal record
- 42:05to being sentenced
- 42:06at a higher rate.
- 42:07You cannot find a judge
- 42:09that gave a black person.
- 42:11Uh,
- 42:11uh,
- 42:12a higher,
- 42:13uh,
- 42:13sentencing
- 42:14than they gave a white person.
- 42:15If you find that judge,
- 42:17I think everybody in here
- 42:18will be against that judge,
- 42:19and,
- 42:20and I would,
- 42:20I would march and protest a judge that we can find doing that.
- 42:23You won't find it.
- 42:25Alright,
- 42:25we're gonna have to pause here because you've been voted out by the majority.
- 42:28Thank you so much.
- 42:30If you would like to be the next debater,
- 42:32please get to the chair
- 42:34in 321.
- 42:38What's up?
- 42:39What's up,
- 42:39bro?
- 42:39What's up man?
- 42:40How you doing?
- 42:40Good,
- 42:40good.
- 42:41Um,
- 42:42let's have some fun.
- 42:43I
- 42:45I want to approach this from a place of curiosity,
- 42:48because
- 42:49the thing that troubles me about a lot of
- 42:51the way you structure your arguments is that it seems
- 42:54to suggest to me that you perhaps believe that there's some
- 42:58moral deficit that black people have that inclines us to to commit more crimes.
- 43:02And I guess I,
- 43:03I guess my question is,
- 43:04what do you think that moral lack is?
- 43:05I don't,
- 43:06I don't really think it's a
- 43:08I don't think it's a
- 43:09sweeping
- 43:11generalization that every black person somehow
- 43:14is born inherently evil or inherently a criminal.
- 43:17I think that there's different things that do cause
- 43:19people to fall down a path of committing crimes,
- 43:21which is what their fathers did and what their mothers did
- 43:26I don't think it has,
- 43:27I don't I think it had much to do with racism.
- 43:29I don't think it has,
- 43:30like,
- 43:30like for instance,
- 43:31we can we can isolate criminal activity that happened in the
- 43:33black community that has no hand or involvement from white people.
- 43:36You know,
- 43:36a young man deciding to grab a gun and do a shooting.
- 43:39has nothing to do with white people.
- 43:40A young man
- 43:41having sex with 5 and 6 women,
- 43:43getting them pregnant and not standing up for his
- 43:44responsibilities has nothing to do with white people.
- 43:46See,
- 43:46but when you tell stories like that,
- 43:47it seems to suggest that you're saying that black people
- 43:49are responsible for all of that versus these isolated incidents,
- 43:51these,
- 43:51these mythical isolated incidents that you're bringing up.
- 43:53I'm saying it's personal responsibility.
- 43:55So you're saying there's no there's an epidemic
- 43:57of personal responsibility inside the black community.
- 43:59How do you measure that?
- 44:00By looking at the
- 44:01looking at the effects of it,
- 44:02looking at what black people are doing over time.
- 44:04So,
- 44:04so earlier people have come up come up and
- 44:06given you a vast number of statistics that indicate,
- 44:09uh,
- 44:09systemic racism,
- 44:10inequality,
- 44:11poverty,
- 44:12education's happened over and over again,
- 44:13yet you claim black people have an epidemic of personal responsibility,
- 44:15but you can't give a single statistic that indicates that.
- 44:18How do you have an epidemic of personal responsibility.
- 44:19You see the outcome?
- 44:21That's one indicator.
- 44:25Let the bodies hit the floor.
- 44:26Who wrote that song?
- 44:28Let,
- 44:28let me give you an example of why this is different.
- 44:30Let me give you an example of why this is different.
- 44:32And,
- 44:32and,
- 44:33and I'm gonna tell you how it has a negative effect on black people.
- 44:36White people actually listen to rap music way more than black people do.
- 44:39They purchase it more.
- 44:40But black people are living
- 44:42the stuff that's in the music.
- 44:43White people fantasize of what it may be like to run up
- 44:46on your op and shoot somebody and kill them and go to prison
- 44:49and selling dope in the hood to your own people.
- 44:52Black people are living it,
- 44:53it's a reality and it's reinforced.
- 44:55You cannot tell me that it's a form of brainwashing.
- 44:58I've listened to a lot of rap music.
- 44:59You know what I've never done?
- 45:00Shot up a school.
- 45:02What does a school guy do anything?
- 45:04I think you
- 45:06you try to create the image,
- 45:07this is what I mean by
- 45:08by by you seem to suggest that there's a moral lack,
- 45:11you're saying there's some kind of lack that causes us to be more prone to violence,
- 45:16but you don't acknowledge any of the historical
- 45:18context that you're saying that there's no negative effects
- 45:20of brainwashing yourself
- 45:22about killing your brother and sister and listening to that on a day to day basis,
- 45:25there's no negative effect in that.
- 45:27potent as a uniquely black thing.
- 45:29It's like it's like when you make the argument that like violence,
- 45:31violence has been a part of art all the time.
- 45:33I write for a living.
- 45:33You know who glorifies violence?
- 45:35William Shakespeare.
- 45:36You know who glorifies violence?
- 45:37Quentin Tarantino.
- 45:38But you don't see anyone talking about,
- 45:39oh my God,
- 45:39this is responsible for all the white on white crime,
- 45:40even though there are more white criminals in America than any other race.
- 45:43We're talking about black people.
- 45:45Do you think that black,
- 45:46uh,
- 45:46uh,
- 45:46hip hop music,
- 45:47rap music is detrimental to the black community?
- 45:50You think it has no effect on on on the psyche
- 45:52of a young man who listens to that every day?
- 45:55I,
- 45:56I,
- 45:57I disagree with you on that point.
- 45:58I think here lies the problem.
- 46:00How would,
- 46:00how would you vioidate that?
- 46:01How would you prove that?
- 46:02What can be proved is a correlation between poverty and crime,
- 46:05and that can be traced systemically through history.
- 46:07And this goes back to all the arguments we've made about wealth accumulation,
- 46:10how black people have been prevented from having that.
- 46:12Now,
- 46:12how can you associate that to white supremacy?
- 46:15How can I,
- 46:16uh,
- 46:16associate white supremacy and generational poverty?
- 46:19Do you think wealth is inherited?
- 46:21In part.
- 46:23The majority of people who are successful in this country do not
- 46:26get passed on generational wealth.
- 46:27A lot of people who are very successful came from nothing.
- 46:31I would argue that almost every black person
- 46:33who is successful came from nothing,
- 46:34which is an example of why capitalism works.
- 46:36Yeah,
- 46:36OK,
- 46:36so I went to one of the most conservative,
- 46:39uh,
- 46:39high schools in America.
- 46:41It is a very
- 46:43alluring and deceptive delusion to believe that because you live in
- 46:46circumstances that are different from the rest of black people,
- 46:48that somehow you are special.
- 46:50What do you mean?
- 46:51You're saying that you work in this country this is
- 46:53the way earlier that you that you suggested like,
- 46:55oh,
- 46:55here's my example of someone who escaped poverty and that means that this,
- 46:59everybody has access to that.
- 47:00No,
- 47:00no,
- 47:00I'm not saying every,
- 47:01not every white person has so then you acknowledge that there are forces
- 47:03that operate against black people that are uniquely unique to black people.
- 47:06And where do those come from?
- 47:08I think a lot of it comes from the
- 47:09actions of black people responsibility that you can't indicate.
- 47:13Are you telling me,
- 47:14so are you are you a successful man,
- 47:16like,
- 47:17I'm doing my thing.
- 47:18Yeah.
- 47:19Did you go to school?
- 47:19I got incredibly educated?
- 47:21No,
- 47:21no,
- 47:22are you educated?
- 47:23OK,
- 47:24what decisions did you have to make to get to the point where you're at?
- 47:26OK,
- 47:27if we're gonna to talk about education,
- 47:27we're gonna talk about the difference in funding
- 47:29between schools in black neighborhoods and white neighborhood.
- 47:31No,
- 47:32funding,
- 47:32I went to I went to probably one of the poorest schools in my school district.
- 47:36That didn't that didn't
- 47:37make the difference of whether or not I did my homework or not.
- 47:39Yeah,
- 47:39this is the thing I think you're convinced that you're special.
- 47:41I don't think that inherently because of the color of my skin that somehow
- 47:45I'm I'm I'm behind the curve against white people.
- 47:47Harriet Tubman escaped the plantation,
- 47:50a lot of people didn't.
- 47:51Is it the fault of all those black people that they couldn't escape?
- 47:54I,
- 47:55I,
- 47:55I don't get your point there.
- 47:56The point,
- 47:57the point that I'm making is that people live in dire
- 47:59circumstances and every once in a while someone can break out,
- 48:01and,
- 48:02and that's not an indication of the system itself people
- 48:04don't live in a world where every now and again,
- 48:06the majority of black people live in the middle class.
- 48:08Yes,
- 48:08but a lot more black people live in poverty poverty than any other any other.
- 48:12Disproportionate and a lot of those are because of decision making.
- 48:14When you have children and you're not this is
- 48:16why I'm saying that I think you think that black
- 48:18people have some unique moral deficit because you're saying that
- 48:20there's an epidemic of personal responsibility in black people.
- 48:23But you can't prove that,
- 48:24and yet we can prove that systemic racism exists,
- 48:27but you're what you're doing is you're
- 48:28you're assessing systemic racism in America?
- 48:31When did systemic racism stop in America?
- 48:34I don't think there was real systemic racism.
- 48:37Keep going,
- 48:37please keep going.
- 48:38I would I would love for you to go for the rest of the time on that.
- 48:40I do not believe that there's been systemic racism in America
- 48:44that's been a primary reason why black people cannot succeed.
- 48:46Right,
- 48:46but you can't prove that that there's an epidemic of personal responsibility,
- 48:49but you can prove that there's epidemic.
- 48:51systemic racism.
- 48:52No,
- 48:52no,
- 48:52look,
- 48:52and that's why I'm asking you when did it stop,
- 48:54because theoretically that should be,
- 48:56are you,
- 48:56are you saying that black people are not
- 48:57responsible for the decisions that they make?
- 48:59I'm saying everyone has agency.
- 49:00Everyone commits crime,
- 49:01everyone does everything,
- 49:02but people have had to live in different circumstances.
- 49:04So therefore,
- 49:05if you do the right things like you did,
- 49:07you have an opportunity to be successful,
- 49:08which is equal to just about anybody else no matter what color you are.
- 49:11You think white people are better than you?
- 49:12No,
- 49:12but I worry you do.
- 49:13Why do I,
- 49:14why do you think I do?
- 49:15I'm the one that's saying that black people have
- 49:17an opportunity to be successful in this country.
- 49:19Country
- 49:20just as well as anybody else,
- 49:21you don't believe that.
- 49:22So you think white people are better than you.
- 49:23Your prompt perhaps could have been,
- 49:25we should do more to prevent crime and poverty in black communities,
- 49:28right?
- 49:28That's a way of framing the argument that's about frame or whatever you want.
- 49:32You are focusing on,
- 49:33we're talking about black people on language because words are.
- 49:36We're talking about black people and you're
- 49:37focusing on what white people are doing.
- 49:39So who harmed black people more than other black people?
- 49:40Probably the people who brought us over over here on boats.
- 49:43Gentlemen,
- 49:44gentlemen,
- 49:44the time's up now.
- 49:46Alright,
- 49:46thank you.
- 49:46I appreciate you.
- 49:51Nicotine,
- 49:52the ultimate biohacker's secret weapon,
- 49:54has made a wild comeback.
- 49:56But why is that clean lifestyle still fueled by big tobacco's chemical laden slop?
- 50:00For those who switch out LEDs for incandescence,
- 50:03source raw milk,
- 50:04and read every single label,
- 50:06it's time to stop compromising.
- 50:08Introducing
- 50:09Knick Knack,
- 50:10the nicotine solution that actually complements a clean routine.
- 50:13This family-owned company
- 50:15manufactures a superior nicotine lozenge
- 50:18right here
- 50:19in the USA.
- 50:20Affectionately known as a lip brick,
- 50:22this fully dissolvable option is crafted with just 6 premium ingredients,
- 50:27including real essential oils for authentic flavor.
- 50:30There are no pH adjusters,
- 50:32no plastic pouches,
- 50:33and abs.
- 50:35no waste.
- 50:36Available in 3
- 50:37and 6 mg strengths,
- 50:39this is nicotine perfected.
- 50:41Reject the compromise and raise the standard.
- 50:44Go to knickknack.com/surrounded and use code surrounded for 20% off
- 50:49or use the store locator to find knickknacks near you.
- 50:52Warning,
- 50:53this product contains nicotine.
- 50:54Nicotine is an addictive chemical.
- 50:57My next surrounding claim is that black people
- 50:59hurt black people more than any other group.
- 51:01If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 51:02get to the chair in 321.
- 51:08What's up brother?
- 51:09How you doing?
- 51:10Nice to meet you.
- 51:11OK,
- 51:11I personally think that since we're talking about groups,
- 51:13I think that Republicans,
- 51:14their leadership caused more harm.
- 51:16I think the fact that Louisiana,
- 51:17which has one of the highest murder rates,
- 51:19you're a cop,
- 51:19has one of the highest poverty rates that's run by Republicans,
- 51:23and honestly with the Voting Rights Act,
- 51:25um,
- 51:25they just
- 51:25ask the fact that black people can have a voice.
- 51:28So when we talk about like political harm,
- 51:29Republicans are trying to destroy uh destroy black people
- 51:32when we talk about economic harm,
- 51:34Republicans,
- 51:34I mean with the tariffs with
- 51:36just how we're doing as a country right now Republicans have
- 51:39asked any way that black people can be able to speak,
- 51:41profit.
- 51:42We can go back to racist policies like redlining that,
- 51:44you know,
- 51:45President Trump has participated in twice.
- 51:47I just don't understand how black people are doing more harm there.
- 51:49OK,
- 51:50I disagree with a few things that you've claimed,
- 51:52but what I'm saying is that if you look at,
- 51:54I don't know the ages of everybody in this room,
- 51:56but if you're 25
- 51:57and under,
- 51:58the leading cause of death for you is being murdered by another black person.
- 52:02What do you mean where?
- 52:03Where are victimization of black people higher?
- 52:06In black neighborhoods.
- 52:07Where?
- 52:08In red states.
- 52:09In Mississippi,
- 52:09Missouri.
- 52:10No,
- 52:10no,
- 52:11well,
- 52:11not,
- 52:11not necessarily true.
- 52:12Mississippi as a state obviously has majority white people that live in it.
- 52:17We're talking about
- 52:18cities that are primarily black
- 52:21that are dealing with these issues.
- 52:22So my problem with this is that whenever we talk about black harm,
- 52:25we're only able.
- 52:26To talk about murder rates.
- 52:27No,
- 52:27it's not just murder rates.
- 52:28I,
- 52:29I,
- 52:29I would argue
- 52:30that black people
- 52:31systemically voting for Democrats have been very harmful to the black community.
- 52:35Well,
- 52:35when you look at,
- 52:36let's start from Martin Luther King all the way on,
- 52:38there's plenty of statistical data points
- 52:41where black people have declined in the birth rate.
- 52:43Let me finish.
- 52:44I'm sorry.
- 52:45In
- 52:46black young black people born into single parent homes,
- 52:49um,
- 52:49black people engaging in employment,
- 52:51and mind you,
- 52:52hold on one second,
- 52:53let me,
- 52:53let me get,
- 52:53we get to point by point.
- 52:54And this entire time,
- 52:56black people have been consistently voting for Democrats,
- 52:59which I argue is hurting the black community.
- 53:01You went to employment,
- 53:02you went to employment,
- 53:02right?
- 53:03So let's talk about unemployment.
- 53:04Who had the lowest black unemployment?
- 53:06What do you mean who had what?
- 53:09Well,
- 53:10Joe Biden did.
- 53:11OK,
- 53:11so Joe Biden,
- 53:12the Democrat,
- 53:12right?
- 53:12Let me,
- 53:12let me explain.
- 53:13The first decline that we saw,
- 53:15which was historic,
- 53:16was under President Trump.
- 53:17And then it was historic under Biden,
- 53:19right?
- 53:19After the pandemic,
- 53:21right?
- 53:22It was historically low in 2023 at 5.3% or 5.2% for black unemployment,
- 53:26which
- 53:27beats Trump's 5.5%,
- 53:29which increased to like a 7.9% by the end of this year.
- 53:31Some,
- 53:31some people can argue that Trump's policies residually rolled over into Biden's
- 53:36like a tax cut and jobs,
- 53:37uh,
- 53:37tax cut and jobs at opportunity zones.
- 53:40Help black people,
- 53:40tax cuts.
- 53:41Is that why he didn't bring them back and brought them back for rural areas.
- 53:43Tax cuts do help black people.
- 53:44I don't know if you believe this or not,
- 53:46but black people do have jobs,
- 53:48and they do,
- 53:48they do
- 53:50rely on taxes being cut.
- 53:51That's why Biden had a lower unemployment rate.
- 53:54But when we were talking about tax cuts,
- 53:55Biden had a child tax credit
- 53:56that
- 53:57Trump took away,
- 53:57that the Republicans didn't want to put into his 2023 and 2024 years.
- 54:01So why are the Republicans stopping those tax cuts that you
- 54:03said black people have children that we don't care about.
- 54:06We're getting off track.
- 54:06The premise of what I'm saying is that the ailments that we see in the black community
- 54:10are perpetuated by other black people.
- 54:12Listen,
- 54:12let me,
- 54:13let me say,
- 54:13the,
- 54:15the drugs that are sold in our communities are sold by us.
- 54:18The crimes,
- 54:19the crime that is committed in our
- 54:21communities that's devastating our communities are perpetuated
- 54:24primarily by us.
- 54:27I can give you a solution.
- 54:28You've been voted out by the majority.
- 54:30Thank you so much.
- 54:31Have a great one.
- 54:31Thank you,
- 54:31brother.
- 54:33If you would like to be the next debater,
- 54:34please get to the chair in 321.
- 54:40How are you?
- 54:41Good.
- 54:42I'm Xena.
- 54:42Nice to meet you.
- 54:43Nice to meet you as well.
- 54:44OK,
- 54:44so
- 54:45black people hurt black people more than anyone else hurts black people.
- 54:48My question to you is why?
- 54:51Well,
- 54:51that's a,
- 54:52that's a really good question.
- 54:53I think that it stimulates from a few different facets,
- 54:56and I think a lot of them are responsible and
- 54:59but for the most part by black people.
- 55:01When you,
- 55:02when you are not raised in a loving household
- 55:05and you're not protected,
- 55:06you don't have a father in the household,
- 55:07those things lead to
- 55:08devastating outcomes.
- 55:10Young men
- 55:10doing things they're not supposed to do like,
- 55:12like we see in modern society,
- 55:14these young YNs,
- 55:15all of these things are contributing factors to decisions that we make.
- 55:19OK,
- 55:20cool.
- 55:20So
- 55:21what you're describing is a byproduct of poverty,
- 55:23right?
- 55:24And what we know under a capitalist system is that poverty compounds over time.
- 55:28In history as well as wealth
- 55:30and what has happened systematically as well as systemically
- 55:33in the system is that black people have
- 55:35been pushed away from wealth creating mechanisms.
- 55:38This has happened for
- 55:39generations,
- 55:40even past slavery,
- 55:41even if we were to argue
- 55:42that after slavery
- 55:44nothing else happened.
- 55:45There was no Jim Crow laws,
- 55:46there's no redlining,
- 55:47there was no
- 55:47unequal implementation of.
- 55:49Of the GI Bill,
- 55:50we would still see that like
- 55:52our country has lived under this disenfranchisement of
- 55:55black people longer than it has been free.
- 55:57So
- 55:57my question is,
- 55:59what do you think accounts for like the 4 to
- 56:01$16 trillion that was stolen from black people through slavery?
- 56:05Um,
- 56:05like,
- 56:06where is that
- 56:06equalizing mechanism?
- 56:07I don't,
- 56:08I don't believe that you can say that
- 56:10money was stolen from black people during slavery.
- 56:14Let me,
- 56:14let me explain,
- 56:15because money wasn't stolen,
- 56:17opportunities were not there because black people were slaves.
- 56:19That's not a fair comparison.
- 56:21You got 200 people on a plantation and they're making you
- 56:24millions and millions of dollars,
- 56:26right,
- 56:26a year
- 56:27through their labor,
- 56:28right?
- 56:28So what happens is there's no money to
- 56:30steal because black people weren't granted the humanity
- 56:34to be compensated for the value that they created.
- 56:35Well,
- 56:35let's look at it like this.
- 56:37This is a
- 56:39An environment
- 56:40and a dispensation of time where slavery was
- 56:43a fact and a reality around the world.
- 56:46So let me,
- 56:46let me explain.
- 56:47So it's not like it was somehow uniquely,
- 56:49it's not uniquely in the United States of America.
- 56:53Majority of the slaves were in South America.
- 56:55Let me just give you an example.
- 56:57Majority of the slaves were in South America,
- 56:58you do agree to that.
- 57:00About 400,000.
- 57:01Black people were made slaves over time.
- 57:04Why are we pivoting the conversation?
- 57:05My question was.
- 57:06You got,
- 57:06you,
- 57:07you're jumping around.
- 57:09Let's stick to something that we can you remember
- 57:11the question I asked you around 2 minutes ago?
- 57:13I asked you this.
- 57:14I feel like you want to be confrontational more than
- 57:15you want to get to the bottom of a conversation.
- 57:18You're saying it's unfortunate that
- 57:20that's the way that you feel about how I'm that's not true.
- 57:22We need to stick to a point.
- 57:23Are you equalizing mechanism?
- 57:254 to $16 trillion
- 57:27right,
- 57:27was the revenue that was created through the unpaid labor that came.
- 57:31In my opinion,
- 57:32you cannot judge
- 57:34slavery and act as if black people even had a fair chance in the first place.
- 57:38That's what I'm talking about
- 57:39here.
- 57:39Let me explain.
- 57:40We need to talk in terms of after slavery was abolished,
- 57:44what opportunities were presented to black people do that,
- 57:45we cut out around 2/3 of the story,
- 57:47right?
- 57:48So what I told you before,
- 57:49right,
- 57:49we live under capitalism and if we live under capitalism,
- 57:51what we know is a couple of things
- 57:53wealth comes from capital and capital compounds,
- 57:56right?
- 57:57Value.
- 57:57So what happens is property taxes.
- 58:00That inevitably black people will never have
- 58:02an opportunity to be successful in America.
- 58:04Is that what you're explaining something really,
- 58:05really crucial here that'll help you answer that because I think we'll be
- 58:08on you can't interrupt me when we're not having the same conversation.
- 58:11I'm trying to get to a point where we can have a real discussion.
- 58:14If it is the case that property taxes,
- 58:17right,
- 58:17fund our school systems,
- 58:19build them up,
- 58:19OK,
- 58:20and we see redlining literally labeled
- 58:23neighborhoods where black people were living
- 58:25as
- 58:25inharmonious,
- 58:26full of inharmonious racial groups to the point where they couldn't get the.
- 58:29Mortgage,
- 58:30right?
- 58:30This was what,
- 58:3160 years ago?
- 58:32Grandparents,
- 58:33parents,
- 58:33right,
- 58:34who experienced that inability to have a home.
- 58:362/3 of the middle class
- 58:38gets their generational wealth
- 58:40from properties.
- 58:41Where's this equalizing mechanism?
- 58:43Why do you expect there to be a similar playing field?
- 58:46OK,
- 58:46I,
- 58:47I,
- 58:47I think we're gonna go in circles if we go back in time.
- 58:49What
- 58:50mechanism,
- 58:51I'm saying that we're gonna get to a,
- 58:52a,
- 58:52a standstill.
- 58:53What mechanisms are in place today
- 58:56that prevents you
- 58:57from having the same financial success as.
- 58:59Anybody else in this country.
- 59:00Does inheritance No,
- 59:01no,
- 59:01I'm just,
- 59:02I'm,
- 59:02I'm giving you,
- 59:02I'm I'm asking you to answer this question.
- 59:04What mechanisms in place,
- 59:06what mechanism in place currently
- 59:08prevents you from being financially successful as anybody else in this country?
- 59:11The continuity of private property,
- 59:14right?
- 59:14So I'm not allowed to own property.
- 59:17That's not,
- 59:17that's not the question here.
- 59:18It's who had access to property.
- 59:20No,
- 59:20we know,
- 59:21we know,
- 59:21let's let's put it this way,
- 59:22because we're gonna get into an argument in circles.
- 59:26I don't think you're not answering the question.
- 59:27Here's the thing that we can.
- 59:28Let me say,
- 59:29this is a thing that we can agree on.
- 59:31We can agree that there was discrimination in this country.
- 59:33We can agree that there's some elements of the,
- 59:36let me finish.
- 59:37We can agree that there's elements of things that
- 59:39happen in this country that put black people behind.
- 59:41We can agree to that.
- 59:43But,
- 59:43but what I'm telling you is that we cannot still live
- 59:4860 years ago and act as if we don't have an opportunity today.
- 59:51We,
- 59:51we can break down redlining,
- 59:52we can go through the process of all these different things,
- 59:55because I don't think that we're telling the full story about red.
- 59:57Lonnie,
- 59:58I don't think we're telling the full story about
- 59:59economic opportunity for black people in America today.
- 1:00:02So white families on average
- 1:00:04have a 10 times higher
- 1:00:06median household income than black people,
- 1:00:09and I'm,
- 1:00:09and that's why I want to answer for you.
- 1:00:11It's because,
- 1:00:12no,
- 1:00:12no,
- 1:00:12no,
- 1:00:12no,
- 1:00:12you asked me a question.
- 1:00:13Why are you answering the question that you asked to me for you you just let me,
- 1:00:16let me answer the question for you.
- 1:00:17No,
- 1:00:17no,
- 1:00:17I don't want you to answer it for me because I,
- 1:00:19I want to answer.
- 1:00:19I want to participate in it
- 1:00:20back and forth.
- 1:00:21The reason is because wealth in this country
- 1:00:25is passed down.
- 1:00:26The biggest,
- 1:00:26you know.
- 1:00:27In 2020 they projected that $765 billion right,
- 1:00:31was passed down through gifts and bequests
- 1:00:34to the American population,
- 1:00:35right,
- 1:00:35the middle class,
- 1:00:36and that's just the middle class.
- 1:00:37That is the majority way that wealth funnels down in in this country.
- 1:00:41Are you saying
- 1:00:42that black people
- 1:00:44are not currently able
- 1:00:45to have financial success in this country just like white people?
- 1:00:48I'm saying that we're comparing a tortoise to a hare right now.
- 1:00:51I don't think that's true.
- 1:00:52Are you,
- 1:00:52are you,
- 1:00:52are you alluding to the fact,
- 1:00:53let's let's talk about redlining real quick because I think that it's been.
- 1:00:56Disproportionately represented.
- 1:00:58When you talk about red,
- 1:00:59when you talk about redlining,
- 1:01:01do,
- 1:01:01do you know,
- 1:01:01and I think it's,
- 1:01:02it's good for the crowd to understand this,
- 1:01:04that in the redline districts,
- 1:01:0692%
- 1:01:07of all the people who lived in the redline districts were white.
- 1:01:10Are you aware of that?
- 1:01:11Where is this coming from?
- 1:01:12Redlining
- 1:01:14specifically labeled.
- 1:01:15Do you not know this as a fact,
- 1:01:16how about this?
- 1:01:16The underwritings of the HOLC.
- 1:01:20Specifically said that black
- 1:01:22groups,
- 1:01:22right,
- 1:01:22were seen as inharmonious groups that we should be very wary.
- 1:01:25No,
- 1:01:25no,
- 1:01:25no,
- 1:01:26let's look it up.
- 1:01:27The fact check will be somewhere here or here for you,
- 1:01:29right?
- 1:01:29It said in harmonious groups black people were titled as in
- 1:01:34FHA OK,
- 1:01:35they both work together they both work together.
- 1:01:38No,
- 1:01:38they were different but they worked together,
- 1:01:39you do have to pause.
- 1:01:40You've been voted out.
- 1:01:41Thank you.
- 1:01:43If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:01:45get to that chair in 321.
- 1:01:52Peace,
- 1:01:52brother.
- 1:01:52What's up brother?
- 1:01:53So we're talking about black on black crime.
- 1:01:56Yeah,
- 1:01:56we can,
- 1:01:56we can address that.
- 1:01:58Black on black crime
- 1:01:59is a myth.
- 1:02:00Human beings
- 1:02:02create crime
- 1:02:03based off where they're at.
- 1:02:05In the nineties,
- 1:02:06there was an opioid epidemic,
- 1:02:07specifically
- 1:02:09OxyContin.
- 1:02:10This was white drug dealers
- 1:02:12selling this medicine
- 1:02:14to white fiends.
- 1:02:16Over
- 1:02:1780,000 people in the year 2023,
- 1:02:20according to the CDC,
- 1:02:22overdosed from opioids.
- 1:02:24That same year,
- 1:02:2631,000 people
- 1:02:28overdosed from cocaine.
- 1:02:30Now,
- 1:02:30a portion of those cocaine.
- 1:02:31Abusers were likely
- 1:02:33black people who were on crack.
- 1:02:35However,
- 1:02:36more than twice as many people
- 1:02:38overdosed
- 1:02:39on opioids
- 1:02:40that
- 1:02:40were
- 1:02:41white drug dealers selling to white fiends.
- 1:02:43However,
- 1:02:44in no instance
- 1:02:45did anyone come up,
- 1:02:46a policymaker,
- 1:02:48and say that this opioid crisis was white on white crime.
- 1:02:51However,
- 1:02:52when
- 1:02:52black people engage in crime
- 1:02:54based off where they're at,
- 1:02:55the government uses it as an excuse
- 1:02:58to overcome.
- 1:02:58Criminalize them
- 1:02:59in a way that white communities are not criminalized at all.
- 1:03:02I disagree with you because I don't think that anybody's
- 1:03:04saying black on black crime necessitates a police response.
- 1:03:08People point out that black people disproportionate,
- 1:03:10or,
- 1:03:10I say
- 1:03:11to a higher degree per capita kill each other more than any other group.
- 1:03:15That is 100% accurate.
- 1:03:16That is 100% accurate.
- 1:03:17Anybody can fact check that.
- 1:03:19We kill each other at a higher rate
- 1:03:21per capita than any other group,
- 1:03:23that is a fact.
- 1:03:24Now the reason that people
- 1:03:25point this out
- 1:03:26is because
- 1:03:27others try to claim that the biggest threat to our existence,
- 1:03:30the biggest threat to our young people are white people or systemic racism.
- 1:03:34But the reality is,
- 1:03:35the cause of death,
- 1:03:36the leading cause of death for young people 25 and under,
- 1:03:38from 15 to 25 is being murdered by another black man.
- 1:03:41Then you go on beyond that and the leading cause of death is what?
- 1:03:44Health issues,
- 1:03:45heart disease,
- 1:03:46diabetes,
- 1:03:47and other,
- 1:03:47it has nothing to do with white people.
- 1:03:49OK,
- 1:03:49cool.
- 1:03:50So the biggest threat.
- 1:03:52To black people,
- 1:03:53and the biggest threat
- 1:03:55to the world
- 1:03:56is the system of racism and white supremacy
- 1:03:59that we live in.
- 1:04:00Because the system of racism,
- 1:04:01white supremacy,
- 1:04:02I'll give you,
- 1:04:03I'll give you,
- 1:04:03I'll bring it down.
- 1:04:03The system of racism,
- 1:04:05exactly.
- 1:04:05The,
- 1:04:05the system of racism,
- 1:04:07white supremacy
- 1:04:08affects every faction of interaction.
- 1:04:10We're talking,
- 1:04:11I'll,
- 1:04:11I'll give you an example.
- 1:04:12We're talking economic,
- 1:04:13social,
- 1:04:14and sports.
- 1:04:15So these,
- 1:04:15these,
- 1:04:16yes,
- 1:04:16so these,
- 1:04:17these black.
- 1:04:18Drug dealers that you're mad at.
- 1:04:19For example,
- 1:04:20Freddie Gray.
- 1:04:21Freddie Gray was a petty
- 1:04:23black drug dealer.
- 1:04:24He was selling drugs.
- 1:04:24Yes,
- 1:04:25he was selling drugs.
- 1:04:26He was selling drugs to black people,
- 1:04:27but no petty white drug dealer has ever been thrown in the black,
- 1:04:31in the back of a paddy wagon and ended up dead.
- 1:04:34Only black people are only petty black drug dealers are criminalized
- 1:04:38for selling drugs.
- 1:04:39That's because we live in a system of racism,
- 1:04:41white supremacy that over the.
- 1:04:44criminalizes the actions of black people and overlooks petty white crime.
- 1:04:49Who was the prosecutor and judge
- 1:04:52that allowed those police officers to get off of that crime?
- 1:04:54It was a black judge and a black prosecutor.
- 1:04:55Also,
- 1:04:56in 2018,
- 1:04:57in 2018,
- 1:04:58there were multiple officers
- 1:04:59in Baltimore who were found guilty of planting drugs
- 1:05:03and weapons on black people and arresting them.
- 1:05:05That is an example of racism,
- 1:05:07white supremacy
- 1:05:08being used to.
- 1:05:10To weaponize crime and criminalize black people.
- 1:05:13Have you,
- 1:05:13you've never heard an instance in which petty white drug dealers have had drugs
- 1:05:18and weapons planted on them
- 1:05:20that has led to their arrests.
- 1:05:21Have you ever been a police officer?
- 1:05:23Have you ever arrested,
- 1:05:24have you ever arrested anybody?
- 1:05:25Well,
- 1:05:26let me just,
- 1:05:26let me break this down.
- 1:05:27The things that you're saying are focused
- 1:05:29on what's happening in the black community.
- 1:05:31You don't know what's happening in the white community.
- 1:05:33I just told you,
- 1:05:33I just told you,
- 1:05:34they're fiended out.
- 1:05:34I told you there's.
- 1:05:36There's an opioid,
- 1:05:37there's an opioid crisis.
- 1:05:38White street drug dealers are selling street fentanyl
- 1:05:42and,
- 1:05:42and,
- 1:05:43and OxyContin and opioids to,
- 1:05:45to white fiends,
- 1:05:46but it's cool
- 1:05:47and it's not over-criminalized because
- 1:05:49it's cool to,
- 1:05:51it's cool to the government.
- 1:05:52It's cool to the people
- 1:05:53that,
- 1:05:53it's cool to the people that write the laws.
- 1:05:55The people that write the laws,
- 1:05:56the,
- 1:05:57the government and the politicians are not overcriminalizing this behavior.
- 1:06:01They're not.
- 1:06:02They're not chasing
- 1:06:03the,
- 1:06:04the white dope dealer,
- 1:06:04the white petty drug dealer.
- 1:06:05They're not chasing him around and throwing him into the back of a bag in the back of a,
- 1:06:09in the back of a paddy wagon,
- 1:06:11the same way that Freddie Gray got thrown into the
- 1:06:13back of a paddywagon they're chasing you feel me?
- 1:06:15You feel me,
- 1:06:16Timothy,
- 1:06:17please let Officer Tatum speak
- 1:06:19and address what you're,
- 1:06:20let me,
- 1:06:20let me,
- 1:06:20you,
- 1:06:20you,
- 1:06:20you,
- 1:06:21you said a lot of things.
- 1:06:22If,
- 1:06:22if you're,
- 1:06:22if you're saying that there's no instances where
- 1:06:25white people are getting arrested for criminal activity.
- 1:06:28Or you're saying that they're not thrown in the back of the paddy wagon and dying.
- 1:06:31No,
- 1:06:31that's not true.
- 1:06:32What I'm saying is
- 1:06:33these
- 1:06:34white
- 1:06:35drug dealers are not policed and criminalized and put on
- 1:06:39TV and looked at as criminals and drug dealers in the
- 1:06:42same way that petty black drug dealers like Freddie Gray
- 1:06:45are criminalized and thrown in the back of paddy wagons.
- 1:06:48Let me,
- 1:06:48let me respond to you.
- 1:06:49I think I have to,
- 1:06:50I have to pause it here.
- 1:06:51He's been voted out by the majority.
- 1:06:53Good,
- 1:06:53good.
- 1:06:55If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:06:56please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:07:02Back,
- 1:07:03back,
- 1:07:03back again.
- 1:07:04OK,
- 1:07:04so thank you for clarifying the prompt for us because I was a little
- 1:07:08confused reading it because white people hurt white people around the same rates,
- 1:07:12but I guess my question is like,
- 1:07:15starting when and how are you quantifying harm?
- 1:07:18OK,
- 1:07:18that's a great question.
- 1:07:20I think that we can go all the way back to the beginning if you want to in slavery,
- 1:07:23um,
- 1:07:24when the slave trade was,
- 1:07:26uh,
- 1:07:26proliferated,
- 1:07:28black people enslaved each other
- 1:07:31where
- 1:07:31in Africa.
- 1:07:32Black people enslave other blacks and Africans,
- 1:07:34sold them all over the world.
- 1:07:35That to me
- 1:07:37that's an incredible harm
- 1:07:38of black people inflicted on other blacks and perpetuated across the world.
- 1:07:42Then you have slavery now
- 1:07:44perpetuated in South America.
- 1:07:45You have it in the United States of America.
- 1:07:47That is initial harm.
- 1:07:49I would argue that
- 1:07:50the,
- 1:07:51the point in time of slavery
- 1:07:52in America as we know it.
- 1:07:54I I believe that white people hurt
- 1:07:56black people more than black people did.
- 1:07:58Now we go post-slavery.
- 1:08:00I believe that black people begin to take the torch.
- 1:08:03And destroy themselves or destroy other blacks more than any other group
- 1:08:08in America.
- 1:08:08OK,
- 1:08:09so let's,
- 1:08:09let's start,
- 1:08:09let's start post-slavery.
- 1:08:11I'm gonna ignore the thing about black people selling black people in Africa.
- 1:08:14Well,
- 1:08:15we just,
- 1:08:15do you know how many black people were sold as slaves to each other in Africa?
- 1:08:19Well,
- 1:08:19millions were sold in the slave trade
- 1:08:22around the world.
- 1:08:22Are you talking about the transatlantic slave
- 1:08:24trade or before the transatlantic trade?
- 1:08:25Transatlantic slave trade.
- 1:08:26OK,
- 1:08:26yeah,
- 1:08:26but that was by white people.
- 1:08:28What what do you mean it was by white people?
- 1:08:29I'm saying that black people enslaved other blacks and sold them.
- 1:08:32To white people.
- 1:08:33I think they were primarily kidnapped by the Portuguese.
- 1:08:35There was not primary kidnapping.
- 1:08:36It was the actual legal slave trade
- 1:08:38that existed and millions of transactions between
- 1:08:41the legal slave trade that existed before
- 1:08:43the transatlantic slave trade was mainly based on
- 1:08:46when a tribe conquered another tribe.
- 1:08:48They were prisoners of war,
- 1:08:50which is still enslaved,
- 1:08:51but it's different from the transatlantic slave trade when we're talking about
- 1:08:54black people hurting black people versus white people hurting black people,
- 1:08:57right?
- 1:08:58But I,
- 1:08:58let's,
- 1:08:59let's,
- 1:08:59I wanted to.
- 1:09:00focus on your claim
- 1:09:01about um post slavery,
- 1:09:03post-slavery,
- 1:09:04yes.
- 1:09:04So the primary,
- 1:09:06I guess what,
- 1:09:07what do you think black people were doing post-slavery?
- 1:09:10Well,
- 1:09:10you know,
- 1:09:10there's a,
- 1:09:11I think there's a period of time where there was an explosion of black excellence
- 1:09:15after
- 1:09:16slavery was abolished.
- 1:09:17You know,
- 1:09:18we have black people fighting in the military,
- 1:09:19black people owning their own companies,
- 1:09:21building wealth,
- 1:09:22we have black Wall Street,
- 1:09:23we have,
- 1:09:24you,
- 1:09:24you go on,
- 1:09:25so on and so forth.
- 1:09:26And I I believe.
- 1:09:27That as black people begin
- 1:09:29to support Marxist theology,
- 1:09:31Martin Luther King and others
- 1:09:33put us in a,
- 1:09:34in a path
- 1:09:36where
- 1:09:37we rely on the government
- 1:09:38more than our own
- 1:09:40resilience.
- 1:09:41And you cannot tell me that that's not true.
- 1:09:42So let's,
- 1:09:43let's pause because we just skipped like
- 1:09:46a good 30 years of history.
- 1:09:48We just skipped like I'm giving you a summation from the 30s to the,
- 1:09:51yeah,
- 1:09:51so we,
- 1:09:52we did Reconstruction and Reconstruction was ended.
- 1:09:55Right,
- 1:09:55because the South took back at the time we had
- 1:09:58Northerners in the South who were running the
- 1:10:00South so that the Union could stay together.
- 1:10:02Once the North left the South,
- 1:10:04Reconstruction ends,
- 1:10:05and that's when we see black people start to decline.
- 1:10:08It wasn't Karl Marx.
- 1:10:10Karl Marx didn't come in and I said Marxist theology.
- 1:10:12I didn't say Karl Marx.
- 1:10:14It wasn't Marxist theology.
- 1:10:15I mean,
- 1:10:16we're just ignoring the history of sharecropping.
- 1:10:18That's ignoring the history of Jim Crow,
- 1:10:20right?
- 1:10:21You think that Karl.
- 1:10:22was worse for the black community than Jim Crow segregation.
- 1:10:25Let me,
- 1:10:25let me,
- 1:10:25let me,
- 1:10:25let me argue this point.
- 1:10:27Capitalism
- 1:10:28has rescued
- 1:10:29and
- 1:10:30made successful so many people of
- 1:10:32different
- 1:10:34backgrounds and demographics.
- 1:10:35That's why America is so great.
- 1:10:37What I'm saying is that
- 1:10:38black people being resilient,
- 1:10:40operating through capitalism,
- 1:10:42and believing in themselves and being self-sustainable
- 1:10:45was the best path for blacks,
- 1:10:46and they were successful in that.
- 1:10:47When they begin to rely on the government.
- 1:10:49Begin to rely on handouts,
- 1:10:51begin to listen to foolish things that people like Martin Luther King said,
- 1:10:55it caused us to be more dependent on the government,
- 1:10:58less dependent on ourselves,
- 1:10:59and now you see decline in multifaceted areas.
- 1:11:02Consistent,
- 1:11:03let me say,
- 1:11:04I'm gonna let you speak,
- 1:11:04I'm gonna let you.
- 1:11:05Speak,
- 1:11:05but what I'm saying is that when you look at other groups,
- 1:11:07minority groups,
- 1:11:08they did not fall for that.
- 1:11:10You look at the Jewish population,
- 1:11:11look at immigrants that came over here,
- 1:11:12they were self-sustainable,
- 1:11:14they worked within their community,
- 1:11:15they built wealth,
- 1:11:16generational wealth amongst each other.
- 1:11:18They did not form out.
- 1:11:21Their existence to the government please
- 1:11:23thank you.
- 1:11:24So,
- 1:11:24um,
- 1:11:25the other immigrant groups that you're talking about,
- 1:11:27first of all,
- 1:11:27were not subject to Jim Crow segregation laws,
- 1:11:30but do you,
- 1:11:31I just want you to answer,
- 1:11:32I just Jews were,
- 1:11:33I just want you to answer this question,
- 1:11:35yes or no.
- 1:11:36Do you think that Karl Marx hurt the black
- 1:11:39community and his ideology hurt the black community more than
- 1:11:42Jim Crow segregation?
- 1:11:45I have to think that through.
- 1:11:46Jim Crow segregation,
- 1:11:49no,
- 1:11:49no,
- 1:11:49because you're,
- 1:11:49you're,
- 1:11:49you're,
- 1:11:50you're acting like white,
- 1:11:51so that would still be a white person in the black community.
- 1:11:55But then Martin Luther King embraced his theology,
- 1:11:57which is,
- 1:11:58which is a black man leading the black community off a cliff.
- 1:12:01Now let me just say this,
- 1:12:02I'm saying that every black person was not subject,
- 1:12:05every black person was not subject to Jim Crow laws.
- 1:12:07Every black person did not live in the South.
- 1:12:09There was a lot of success.
- 1:12:10black people during that time period.
- 1:12:12I mean,
- 1:12:12we,
- 1:12:12we,
- 1:12:12I will give you an example.
- 1:12:14I'm gonna say,
- 1:12:14I'm gonna give you an example of black people who were incredibly successful
- 1:12:18through what?
- 1:12:18Capitalism.
- 1:12:19We see Madam CJ Walker,
- 1:12:21the first female millionaire out of any race,
- 1:12:23very successful in the late 1900s,
- 1:12:25early I mean late 1800s,
- 1:12:27early 1900s.
- 1:12:28That's not just one.
- 1:12:29We have,
- 1:12:30we have a tremendous amount of success.
- 1:12:32Uh,
- 1:12:32George Washington Carver,
- 1:12:33we have uh.
- 1:12:35I would like my turn to speak.
- 1:12:36I feel like we're completely
- 1:12:38jumping over history.
- 1:12:40We go from slavery to Martin Luther King,
- 1:12:42then all the way back.
- 1:12:43We ignore the history of sharecropping,
- 1:12:45right?
- 1:12:45We've completely
- 1:12:47glossed over sharecropping.
- 1:12:48We've completely gloss glossed over Jim Crow laws and
- 1:12:51how much wealth was stolen from the black community.
- 1:12:54We've completely glossed over the Tulsa race riots,
- 1:12:56and when black people did succeed under capitalism,
- 1:12:58those communities were destroyed.
- 1:13:00We've completely glossed over eminent domain and how
- 1:13:03much of the black community was taken,
- 1:13:04like literal black.
- 1:13:06Let's talk about what Seneca Village?
- 1:13:08Let's talk about Black Wall Street.
- 1:13:10Let's talk about Black Wall Street.
- 1:13:12Are,
- 1:13:12are we on the same page of what happened in,
- 1:13:14in the Tulsa riots,
- 1:13:15Tulsa race war?
- 1:13:16It depends.
- 1:13:17What do you think happened?
- 1:13:17Well,
- 1:13:18I know what happened.
- 1:13:18There was a conflict between black and white people.
- 1:13:21There was a fight between the two.
- 1:13:23White people got the best of black people in Tulsa.
- 1:13:26Then
- 1:13:26we are not on the same page.
- 1:13:28Well,
- 1:13:28let me finish,
- 1:13:29let me finish and you tell me where I'm wrong.
- 1:13:31In that fight,
- 1:13:32there was a lot of black
- 1:13:33businesses destroyed in Tulsa,
- 1:13:35Oklahoma.
- 1:13:36They rebuilt,
- 1:13:37I don't know,
- 1:13:38maybe 3 or 4 years later.
- 1:13:39And they begin to continue to succeed.
- 1:13:41Is that not factual?
- 1:13:43Uh,
- 1:13:43no.
- 1:13:44What's the truth?
- 1:13:44What happened then?
- 1:13:45I mean,
- 1:13:45the truth is that a community of
- 1:13:47successful black people who were succeeding under capitalism
- 1:13:50were directly targeted because they were not directly targeted.
- 1:13:53It was a conflict.
- 1:13:54It was a conflict between a black man,
- 1:13:56I believe it was a black man.
- 1:13:57It started when a black man was accused of lynching,
- 1:14:00or not lynching,
- 1:14:01he was accused of raping a woman,
- 1:14:03and then because of that,
- 1:14:04there was this anger and a mob inappropriate behavior with a woman.
- 1:14:09There was a,
- 1:14:10there was,
- 1:14:10there was a conflict that occurred.
- 1:14:12The first shots rang out from the black,
- 1:14:14from black people,
- 1:14:14shooting and killing
- 1:14:16several white people.
- 1:14:18And how many people were killed in total?
- 1:14:19Oh,
- 1:14:19I don't know how many black people were killed in total.
- 1:14:20I just know black people fired the first shot.
- 1:14:22300.
- 1:14:24How many white people were killed?
- 1:14:25How many white people were killed?
- 1:14:27Not as many because it was a riot what happened was white people came up
- 1:14:31into Tulsa,
- 1:14:32Oklahoma,
- 1:14:32it became a a a violent confrontation
- 1:14:35and white people over.
- 1:14:36ran the black people in that confrontation
- 1:14:38because it kind of feels like you're defending
- 1:14:41the race rioters.
- 1:14:42I'm not defending any race riots.
- 1:14:43I'm saying it's a conflict that happened.
- 1:14:45You're saying that it's that this is one
- 1:14:46example in which white people hurt black people
- 1:14:48you're saying what you're trying to say is
- 1:14:51that black people are doing their own thing
- 1:14:53and a bunch of white people just came up and
- 1:14:54destroyed all their property just because that wasn't what happened.
- 1:14:57It was a conflict,
- 1:14:58it was a conflict that occurred that caused that to happen.
- 1:15:01But you know the KKK existed,
- 1:15:02right?
- 1:15:03They did.
- 1:15:04supremacy exists and that was in the South.
- 1:15:05Where's Oklahoma?
- 1:15:06I didn't,
- 1:15:07I didn't say that white supremacy don't exist.
- 1:15:09We're we're not arguing the point.
- 1:15:11I'm not arguing that,
- 1:15:12uh,
- 1:15:12the Ku Klux Klan didn't have a negative effect on the black community.
- 1:15:14We're not arguing that.
- 1:15:15But that's what we are arguing.
- 1:15:16The whole point of this prompt is that black
- 1:15:19people hurt the black community more than white people,
- 1:15:21and these are some examples of white people hurting the black community,
- 1:15:24and every time I give you one,
- 1:15:25you say no.
- 1:15:26Let's give,
- 1:15:26let's give an example of some things that are ailments
- 1:15:28in the black community that I think that we can,
- 1:15:30we can agree on.
- 1:15:31The single parent household situation with young black men born out of,
- 1:15:36you know,
- 1:15:36young black men born and women are born to parents who are not married.
- 1:15:39OK guys,
- 1:15:40please don't raise the flags on me.
- 1:15:41I have to make one point and then I'll go,
- 1:15:42OK?
- 1:15:43So,
- 1:15:44to the single parent house,
- 1:15:45I think that's a great example,
- 1:15:46right?
- 1:15:47Because I think we can all agree we want
- 1:15:49black families to stay together.
- 1:15:51What is the leading cause of the separation of black families?
- 1:15:54I think it's a
- 1:15:55a degradation of
- 1:15:57values in the black community.
- 1:15:58Would you say that
- 1:16:00the criminalization of black men disproportionately going to jail more
- 1:16:03has an effect on the separation of the black household?
- 1:16:06I would,
- 1:16:07I would agree to that,
- 1:16:08but I would also say that is because of the
- 1:16:10choices and decisions that these young black men are making.
- 1:16:13Perfect,
- 1:16:13thank you.
- 1:16:14I was hoping you would say that.
- 1:16:15So,
- 1:16:15is that not true?
- 1:16:16You don't go to jail.
- 1:16:17You go to jail for selling drugs.
- 1:16:19OK,
- 1:16:19you go to jail for selling drugs.
- 1:16:20Can I read you a quote
- 1:16:22from Nixon's domestic policy chief,
- 1:16:24John
- 1:16:25Ehrlichman?
- 1:16:26This is at the start of the war on drugs,
- 1:16:27which we know is what led to a lot of mass incarceration of the black community,
- 1:16:31a significant increase in black men
- 1:16:33imprisoned and incarcerated for
- 1:16:36drug possession and selling.
- 1:16:38We knew we couldn't make it illegal to be either against the Vietnam War or black,
- 1:16:43but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana
- 1:16:46and blacks with heroin,
- 1:16:48and then criminalizing both heavily,
- 1:16:50we could disrupt those communities.
- 1:16:54I'm not familiar with that quote.
- 1:16:56Oh,
- 1:16:56really?
- 1:16:57Shocking.
- 1:16:58I can go and read it later,
- 1:17:00but that's still not that's not getting to the point of saying
- 1:17:03that people are incarcerated because decisions that they make to commit crimes.
- 1:17:07Is that not true?
- 1:17:10The reason that none of us,
- 1:17:11the reason that none of us,
- 1:17:12the reason that none of us,
- 1:17:13the reason that none of us are selling dope,
- 1:17:15why?
- 1:17:16Because we don't wanna go to prison,
- 1:17:17we value our lives.
- 1:17:18If if you are gonna sell drugs and you're gonna kill people and you're gonna commit.
- 1:17:22Robbery,
- 1:17:22you're gonna go to jail.
- 1:17:24You can't blame all of that on
- 1:17:26the war,
- 1:17:26the war on crime or whatever the case may be.
- 1:17:28It is nothing wrong,
- 1:17:28it is nothing wrong
- 1:17:34with imposing laws that help our community.
- 1:17:37You act like,
- 1:17:38let me,
- 1:17:38let me explain,
- 1:17:39you act like it's a good thing
- 1:17:41for black people to be selling drugs in our community.
- 1:17:43It is not.
- 1:17:44So when you go to jail for.
- 1:17:46Selling drugs,
- 1:17:47in my opinion,
- 1:17:47and I think the opinion of anybody that's rational,
- 1:17:50that is a benefit to the black community
- 1:17:52by getting
- 1:17:53drug dealers,
- 1:17:54criminals
- 1:17:55off the street,
- 1:17:56and,
- 1:17:57and,
- 1:17:57and our communities to be able to thrive,
- 1:17:59our property value to be able to go up,
- 1:18:01we,
- 1:18:01these people need to go to jail.
- 1:18:02That's not a negative.
- 1:18:03OK,
- 1:18:03I hear you,
- 1:18:04I hear you,
- 1:18:04thank you,
- 1:18:05but literally the domestic policy chief
- 1:18:07is saying
- 1:18:09we could.
- 1:18:09Disrupt those communities.
- 1:18:11He is openly admitting,
- 1:18:12no,
- 1:18:12no,
- 1:18:13no,
- 1:18:13no,
- 1:18:13I let you talk a lot.
- 1:18:14I need you to I need you to clarify this.
- 1:18:15Disrupt his communities in what way?
- 1:18:17What is he saying disrupted communities?
- 1:18:18What is the criminalizing
- 1:18:21to what go to what end?
- 1:18:22To hurt black people it hurt it hurt black people to get criminals off the street.
- 1:18:27No,
- 1:18:27he's intentionally have gone over,
- 1:18:30so thank you both so much.
- 1:18:31Thank you,
- 1:18:32thank you.
- 1:18:34My final surrounding claim
- 1:18:36is that systemic racism is used as an excuse
- 1:18:39to avoid personal responsibility.
- 1:18:41If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:18:42get to the chair in 321.
- 1:18:48Hello,
- 1:18:49how are you?
- 1:18:50Nice to meet you.
- 1:18:51What do you mean by systemic?
- 1:18:52Are you talking
- 1:18:53about
- 1:18:54like
- 1:18:55sociology within our society,
- 1:18:57or do you mean within
- 1:18:59the
- 1:19:00structure of our government?
- 1:19:01I'm,
- 1:19:01I'm thinking that people would argue because I don't
- 1:19:05feel systemic racism a part of my life.
- 1:19:08But I'm thinking that systems or laws
- 1:19:11are in place are put in place or even
- 1:19:14that are implemented or acted upon
- 1:19:18to bring down black is alleged to bring down black people.
- 1:19:21You would say DEI was a hindrance to us,
- 1:19:24because that's a lot of what Republicans like to argue.
- 1:19:28DEI are part of systemic racism.
- 1:19:30Uh-huh.
- 1:19:31That's because that's what a lot of them will believe.
- 1:19:33DEI
- 1:19:34in my opinion,
- 1:19:36Was the overcorrection
- 1:19:37of injustices that has happened to black people,
- 1:19:40which caused,
- 1:19:41I think,
- 1:19:41more harm to black people than good.
- 1:19:43So systematic racism does exist.
- 1:19:46I think in part,
- 1:19:47systematic racism
- 1:19:48and racism in America does exist.
- 1:19:51I don't think,
- 1:19:52but but my point is that I don't think that it,
- 1:19:55it rises to the degree that it affects black people
- 1:19:57where they cannot be successful in America and they cannot
- 1:20:00have the same opportunities as others do in America.
- 1:20:03I don't think that.
- 1:20:04I don't think it's a primary
- 1:20:05causation
- 1:20:07of black people
- 1:20:08and or or the things that that are ailments
- 1:20:10in the black community that cause the numbers of blacks
- 1:20:13and,
- 1:20:14and,
- 1:20:14and
- 1:20:15marker points to go down and be degenerate.
- 1:20:17So I like to think that um when we
- 1:20:21put in red line districting,
- 1:20:22when we put all that stuff in,
- 1:20:25we saw that our schools were greatly affected by that.
- 1:20:28We saw that the systems within the schools
- 1:20:31were.
- 1:20:31Greatly affected in the way that some were more
- 1:20:35white schools and a lot of white districting,
- 1:20:38predominantly white districting,
- 1:20:40were
- 1:20:41way more economically benefited by the community around them
- 1:20:45than the black community who could not afford
- 1:20:48to grow any kind of economic revenue for themselves within the education system.
- 1:20:52We weren't able to get certain soccer fields.
- 1:20:55We weren't able to get
- 1:20:57different auditoriums for acting and stuff.
- 1:20:59That,
- 1:21:00you know,
- 1:21:00when you're not able to have those kind of
- 1:21:03like things in your school,
- 1:21:05how do you expect people to not want to go to the streets?
- 1:21:07How do you expect them
- 1:21:09to not want to,
- 1:21:10how do you expect them to invest in things
- 1:21:12that they cannot afford within their system?
- 1:21:15Well,
- 1:21:15let me,
- 1:21:15let me give you a,
- 1:21:17a perspective here.
- 1:21:18Not all black people are poor,
- 1:21:20right?
- 1:21:20Not all
- 1:21:21I know you're not saying that,
- 1:21:22but I'm saying it's a lot of diversity within,
- 1:21:24so I grew up in a black neighborhood,
- 1:21:26right?
- 1:21:26All black people.
- 1:21:27Within the black neighborhood there are those who
- 1:21:29succeed and those who do not succeed.
- 1:21:31There are those who go on and get a good education,
- 1:21:33even at the same school that I went to.
- 1:21:35There's some that do well and some that do not do well.
- 1:21:38In my opinion,
- 1:21:39that's a perfect example of how I don't think systemic racism
- 1:21:42has much to do with the success of black people.
- 1:21:44It's personal decision making.
- 1:21:46Some of it does have something to do with parents feel like you can do good,
- 1:21:49you can excel,
- 1:21:50you can be great,
- 1:21:51and I really do believe that there is a part of your person,
- 1:21:54you're part of your personality,
- 1:21:55but I'm saying that there is obviously,
- 1:21:59you can see that there.
- 1:22:00There are less black people that are able to graduate
- 1:22:03than white people.
- 1:22:04There are way more white that has anything to do with
- 1:22:06systemic racism.
- 1:22:07No,
- 1:22:07you don't.
- 1:22:07You don't think that
- 1:22:08that has anything.
- 1:22:10You don't think that has anything to do with them
- 1:22:12not being able to afford to continue going to school
- 1:22:15because of the systems that were put in place.
- 1:22:17OK,
- 1:22:17I have to pause here.
- 1:22:18I'm so sorry you have been voted out by the majority.
- 1:22:21Thank you.
- 1:22:22Thank you.
- 1:22:25If you would like to be the next debater to the chair,
- 1:22:28get there in 321.
- 1:22:34What's up.
- 1:22:35Alright,
- 1:22:35uh,
- 1:22:36I just wanna,
- 1:22:37can I lay the foundation of this real quick,
- 1:22:38just,
- 1:22:39just for like two seconds.
- 1:22:40So I,
- 1:22:41what I wanna say is,
- 1:22:42and I want us to be very clear about this,
- 1:22:43and I'm hoping that we all can at least come to a common
- 1:22:46knowledge of this.
- 1:22:47I do not believe that there's no such,
- 1:22:49no such thing as racism in America.
- 1:22:52Uh,
- 1:22:52there's racism in America.
- 1:22:54There's systems
- 1:22:56that
- 1:22:57disproportionately affect black people in a negative way.
- 1:22:59But
- 1:23:00what I'm saying is that I don't even think it's close to a primary
- 1:23:03reason why black people see success or do not see success in America,
- 1:23:07so I think it's a very minor thing that occurs in society.
- 1:23:10Everybody has their own
- 1:23:12um
- 1:23:13engagement with disparity in this country.
- 1:23:16Some believe it's discrimination.
- 1:23:18You have privileges of being better looking,
- 1:23:21you have privileges of being athletic,
- 1:23:22you have privileges of having parents,
- 1:23:24all of those things are contributing factors that everybody engage in.
- 1:23:27Racism does exist in part,
- 1:23:29uh,
- 1:23:29systemic things that cause
- 1:23:31black people to,
- 1:23:32to be behind the curb
- 1:23:33in part does exist,
- 1:23:35but it's not a
- 1:23:36significant reason why black people sedation.
- 1:23:39Uh,
- 1:23:39first and foremost,
- 1:23:41why are you saying.
- 1:23:41Systemic racism instead of just racism.
- 1:23:43Well,
- 1:23:44you got to qualify it.
- 1:23:45I mean,
- 1:23:45I don't,
- 1:23:45I don't,
- 1:23:45systemic means a continuation of,
- 1:23:47of racial practices.
- 1:23:49Um,
- 1:23:50so
- 1:23:50you,
- 1:23:50you,
- 1:23:51you're saying from this point till now,
- 1:23:53that's what you,
- 1:23:54that's why you would say systemic.
- 1:23:55You believe in interpersonal relation interpersonal racism?
- 1:23:58Can black people be racist?
- 1:24:00Really?
- 1:24:01OK,
- 1:24:01alright,
- 1:24:02uh,
- 1:24:02so you're just wrong.
- 1:24:04I got you.
- 1:24:05Don't worry about it.
- 1:24:06The reason why I,
- 1:24:07I asked about like why you
- 1:24:09brought it down to systemic is because it's a whole.
- 1:24:12Racism is a whole,
- 1:24:13it's an entire system,
- 1:24:15right?
- 1:24:15So when you talk about black people being racist,
- 1:24:18you have to understand the ability to actually flip the power structure
- 1:24:21and use the premise of race and racism
- 1:24:24for your benefit.
- 1:24:25Question,
- 1:24:25who created race?
- 1:24:29You know,
- 1:24:29that's a good question.
- 1:24:30I'm not really sure.
- 1:24:31It was a Portuguese man by the name of Gomez Inez de Zarrara in 1452.
- 1:24:36He was actually commissioned by the Catholic Church,
- 1:24:38and they told him
- 1:24:40to go out and document the difference between these people,
- 1:24:43right?
- 1:24:43Do you believe in race?
- 1:24:45Do you believe exists?
- 1:24:46No,
- 1:24:46no,
- 1:24:46you believe that it exists?
- 1:24:48We live in,
- 1:24:48we live in the social construct,
- 1:24:50it's not biological.
- 1:24:51So you're saying this man created it and we perpetuate it.
- 1:24:56Black people also perpetuate it.
- 1:24:57It's documented.
- 1:24:58They published two palables,
- 1:25:00one in 1455 and one in 145,
- 1:25:02so we're we're on the same page.
- 1:25:03The social construct is not really the determinant factor of it being created.
- 1:25:08Well,
- 1:25:08I'm not sure what his purpose was in creating race to justify chattel slavery,
- 1:25:12right?
- 1:25:12I don't,
- 1:25:12I,
- 1:25:12I do not agree with that.
- 1:25:13It documented.
- 1:25:14I don't care if you agree or not.
- 1:25:15I don't I don't care.
- 1:25:16It's literally documented.
- 1:25:17So the point being,
- 1:25:19the point being is that this system was literally created
- 1:25:23to disenfranchise black people,
- 1:25:24specifically,
- 1:25:25it's the structuring,
- 1:25:26maintenance of a hierarchy,
- 1:25:27which continues to actually create a free and cheap labor class,
- 1:25:30chattel slavery.
- 1:25:31Prior to chattel slavery,
- 1:25:33there were slaves,
- 1:25:34but they weren't based off of race.
- 1:25:35After
- 1:25:36the creation of race,
- 1:25:37they engaged in chattel slavery to actually create this free and cheap labor class.
- 1:25:42Now,
- 1:25:42I don't think it was primarily to disenfranchise black people.
- 1:25:46Racism,
- 1:25:47race,
- 1:25:48race has never slavery,
- 1:25:49slavery was never about race.
- 1:25:52It was about cheap available labor.
- 1:25:54Cat slavery was about.
- 1:25:56Slavery as you know it
- 1:25:58was about.
- 1:25:58I'm not saying slavery.
- 1:25:59The perpetuation of race,
- 1:26:01the perpetuation of slavery
- 1:26:02was not instigated by saying slavery instead of chattel slavery.
- 1:26:06Acknowledge the thing that I'm saying.
- 1:26:07Well,
- 1:26:08I I I don't,
- 1:26:08I don't really,
- 1:26:09you know what the difference is between just slavery and chattel slavery?
- 1:26:12I don't
- 1:26:13see that being a major point to the conversation that we're having right now.
- 1:26:16You don't think chattel slavery is a major point
- 1:26:19to the conversation we're having right now.
- 1:26:20I don't think that there needs to be a delineation.
- 1:26:22It literally is.
- 1:26:23Gomez Inez de Javara said,
- 1:26:25I got you.
- 1:26:25I got,
- 1:26:26I got you.
- 1:26:27Gomez Inez dearara said that these people were hypersexual,
- 1:26:30animalistic.
- 1:26:31They were the lower hemisphere,
- 1:26:32and they needed to be civilized,
- 1:26:34and they could civilize them vis a vis chattel slavery.
- 1:26:37Now that rolls forward to where we are today.
- 1:26:39There's a whole bunch.
- 1:26:40The stuff that you missed,
- 1:26:41but I'm going to skip forward.
- 1:26:42What
- 1:26:44I'm getting there right now.
- 1:26:45I'm getting there right now.
- 1:26:46They're getting up right now.
- 1:26:47The systems that black people exist in today that continue to disenfranchise us,
- 1:26:51medical racism,
- 1:26:53educational racism,
- 1:26:54financial racism.
- 1:26:55Quick question,
- 1:26:55I got,
- 1:26:56I got you.
- 1:26:56Do you know,
- 1:26:57I don't agree with you,
- 1:26:58do you know
- 1:26:59the
- 1:26:59black maternal mortality rate in the United States of America?
- 1:27:03I don't know it,
- 1:27:04but I do know this,
- 1:27:05that black people have a disproportionate effect in that area.
- 1:27:09Yeah,
- 1:27:10it's 50.3
- 1:27:11versus the white but that's not,
- 1:27:12but that's not necessarily
- 1:27:14discrimination and disparities are different.
- 1:27:17That's not necessarily meaning that somehow the,
- 1:27:19the medical system is intentionally discriminating racism.
- 1:27:22You gotta let me finish.
- 1:27:24You gotta let me finish.
- 1:27:2414.5 when it comes to the white maternity mortality rate.
- 1:27:29Do you know what the infant mortality rate is?
- 1:27:32I do not know that offhand.
- 1:27:33Yeah,
- 1:27:33the infant mortality rate is 10.8% versus white
- 1:27:374.5%. There was a study that was completed that showed
- 1:27:40that when it comes to white babies,
- 1:27:41no matter who they're treated by,
- 1:27:43whatever race their doctors is,
- 1:27:44whoever they're treated by,
- 1:27:45they have the same possibility to life
- 1:27:48versus anyone else.
- 1:27:50Black babies,
- 1:27:51literally,
- 1:27:52the survival rate for black babies drop.
- 1:27:55Unless it's a black doctor taking care of the baby.
- 1:27:57Everyone else,
- 1:27:58the baby out of the womb,
- 1:28:00the black baby has less of a possibility to life.
- 1:28:03It's literally,
- 1:28:05let me give you a perspective because
- 1:28:06just because there's a statistical data point,
- 1:28:08you gotta,
- 1:28:09you gotta,
- 1:28:10you gotta work through the data points
- 1:28:11because what you're saying is that every
- 1:28:13white doctor is racist against black people.
- 1:28:15That's what you're implicating.
- 1:28:17So you,
- 1:28:17you're saying,
- 1:28:18so are you saying that when you go to the hospital,
- 1:28:20doctors are intentionally being racist.
- 1:28:22I'm saying that doctors are taught through pseudoscience.
- 1:28:25Question for you,
- 1:28:26have you ever heard the myth that black people have thick skin?
- 1:28:29I never heard of that.
- 1:28:30It's literally a medical practice.
- 1:28:32It it's something that's it's something that's derived from chattel slavery.
- 1:28:35It that black people have less nerve endings and thicker skin.
- 1:28:38And what they said
- 1:28:40in medical school,
- 1:28:42literally medical school,
- 1:28:43thick thicker skin.
- 1:28:44I'll give you an example.
- 1:28:47Let me give you a direct example.
- 1:28:48So when you go to the hospital today.
- 1:28:50They're gonna treat you differently because you somehow have thicker skin.
- 1:28:52What medical practice is in place right
- 1:28:54now to treat you differently giving less pain
- 1:28:57medication to black people
- 1:28:58because they think black people lie about their
- 1:29:00pain levels because they have less nerve endings.
- 1:29:03This is literally documented.
- 1:29:04So you're saying every
- 1:29:06doctor
- 1:29:07is
- 1:29:08filled with racism
- 1:29:09and so when a black person go to the hospital,
- 1:29:11they won't treat them fairly.
- 1:29:12They are incapable of treating black people fairly because they're black.
- 1:29:15What I'm telling you is this is something that has been taught.
- 1:29:19No,
- 1:29:19it's not.
- 1:29:19Can I,
- 1:29:20can I give you direct information?
- 1:29:22There's literally studies.
- 1:29:23You think it's a correlation causation,
- 1:29:25but there are studies on this.
- 1:29:26What about comorbidities?
- 1:29:27What about the health of the mother when you're not engaging
- 1:29:31in the premise just because you don't know the information.
- 1:29:35Can I finish my point about the whole medical racism with the nerve endings,
- 1:29:39the thicker skin?
- 1:29:40Sure.
- 1:29:42This was something that is derived from chattel slavery.
- 1:29:45They literally
- 1:29:45use this as an excuse.
- 1:29:47They said you can beat your black slaves because
- 1:29:49they feel less pain and they recover quickly.
- 1:29:51And so they use this as a pseudoscience to say that this still happens today.
- 1:29:56Hold on,
- 1:29:56I'm getting there.
- 1:29:57Are black doctors taught the same thing?
- 1:29:59Are black people or no,
- 1:30:01no,
- 1:30:02we gotta go point by point.
- 1:30:03You're saying the system is taught to anybody in medicine here.
- 1:30:06I have to pause it here.
- 1:30:07You have been voted out by the majority.
- 1:30:10Thank you so much.
- 1:30:10I'm telling you,
- 1:30:11hey.
- 1:30:13I
- 1:30:14can't.
- 1:30:15321.
- 1:30:22All right,
- 1:30:23so
- 1:30:24you're talking about 2026,
- 1:30:26right?
- 1:30:27OK,
- 1:30:27cool.
- 1:30:28You want to say that these systems no longer exist in the way that they have before,
- 1:30:32but kind of going off of some of the other claims,
- 1:30:35there's a resulting effect that comes from the decades
- 1:30:38and decades and generations and generations that have not
- 1:30:41received like
- 1:30:43fairness and equity.
- 1:30:44So
- 1:30:45when you say personal responsibility,
- 1:30:47even what you say like,
- 1:30:48I come from a neighborhood where
- 1:30:50some people make it,
- 1:30:51some people don't,
- 1:30:52it's not,
- 1:30:53it's not that like you have a low floor and a high ceiling,
- 1:30:56right?
- 1:30:57For white people,
- 1:30:58their floor is a little bit higher.
- 1:31:00Because they start off with a little bit more.
- 1:31:02Their families come from a little bit more.
- 1:31:05They might,
- 1:31:06you know,
- 1:31:06they might have better choices as opposed to better outcomes.
- 1:31:10And I think that if you don't apply that sense
- 1:31:12of logic into the decision making of what you're saying,
- 1:31:15it's like you're kind of.
- 1:31:16They're kind of victim shaming people who already have
- 1:31:201 ft kind of like in a
- 1:31:21in a trap,
- 1:31:22and they're trying to run this race,
- 1:31:24but there's like barriers that's holding them
- 1:31:26back that have been there for decades.
- 1:31:28Yeah,
- 1:31:28let me,
- 1:31:28let me explain.
- 1:31:28I,
- 1:31:29I,
- 1:31:29I,
- 1:31:29I love what you said and I think we agree
- 1:31:32on a lot of what you said.
- 1:31:33I'm not saying
- 1:31:35that there
- 1:31:36isn't
- 1:31:37disparity.
- 1:31:39There's clearly disparity.
- 1:31:40You,
- 1:31:40you would have to be a fool
- 1:31:42to say that there's not disparity in law enforcement.
- 1:31:45There's not disparity in
- 1:31:47what we've seen with the effect,
- 1:31:49the negative effects of redlining,
- 1:31:50which we could go into that.
- 1:31:51You,
- 1:31:52you can't,
- 1:31:52it's,
- 1:31:52it's not that there's not disparities.
- 1:31:54What I'm saying is that these disparities that exist,
- 1:31:57I don't believe that they're rooted in systemic racism,
- 1:32:00and I don't think that we can't overcome them
- 1:32:02and become better.
- 1:32:03I,
- 1:32:03I don't believe that because
- 1:32:05like and and and then also some of these disparities,
- 1:32:08we have a lot of responsibility in changing these disparities
- 1:32:12like we talk about a person's credit history,
- 1:32:14like that's a personal responsibility thing we talk about
- 1:32:16our young brothers getting locked up in prison,
- 1:32:18the things that we are doing and how we're teaching our young people.
- 1:32:21Um,
- 1:32:22the,
- 1:32:22the music that we listen to,
- 1:32:23all of those things are contributing factors that keep us
- 1:32:27here when white people are here on average.
- 1:32:30I don't think that there's a system in place
- 1:32:32that's really holding us back beyond what we've done to ourselves.
- 1:32:35That's what,
- 1:32:35that's what my claim is.
- 1:32:37And I can,
- 1:32:37I'm,
- 1:32:38I'm willing to say like,
- 1:32:39you know,
- 1:32:39as somebody who come from a neighborhood that not necessarily a lot of people
- 1:32:43went the college route like I got a master's degree and everything like that,
- 1:32:46I'm,
- 1:32:47I'm reinvesting in my community and helping people out,
- 1:32:49but I,
- 1:32:50but I do think that there's a,
- 1:32:51a piece of that.
- 1:32:52That you,
- 1:32:53you said like all of this blah blah blah blah blah blah blah and then you said but
- 1:32:57and I think when you say that without like a and like it's,
- 1:33:00it,
- 1:33:00it misses the mark of,
- 1:33:01of having humanity for people who might not
- 1:33:04again like choices are choices and if I grew up in a neighborhood where
- 1:33:08I didn't have like books at a,
- 1:33:10at a young age,
- 1:33:10I didn't have after school programs,
- 1:33:12my family couldn't afford a tutor.
- 1:33:14I couldn't,
- 1:33:15I couldn't get
- 1:33:16good lunch,
- 1:33:16so I'm,
- 1:33:17I'm eating the,
- 1:33:18the shit that I,
- 1:33:19I.
- 1:33:21You know what I'm saying,
- 1:33:22so it's like,
- 1:33:22so let,
- 1:33:22let,
- 1:33:22let,
- 1:33:23let's,
- 1:33:23let's,
- 1:33:23let's keep that point.
- 1:33:24I agree with you 100% because,
- 1:33:26you know,
- 1:33:26I wasn't always
- 1:33:28Brandon Tatum,
- 1:33:29you know,
- 1:33:29making the money I'm making and all that other stuff,
- 1:33:31man.
- 1:33:31I,
- 1:33:31I,
- 1:33:32I grew,
- 1:33:33I grew up in a very
- 1:33:34balanced perspective
- 1:33:35and I understand some people don't start from the same place,
- 1:33:38you know,
- 1:33:38when your mama and daddy selling dope,
- 1:33:40your daddy go to prison,
- 1:33:41your mama get killed.
- 1:33:42Your your chances of
- 1:33:44dealing through
- 1:33:45trauma
- 1:33:46is much different than if you had a healthy household.
- 1:33:48I,
- 1:33:48I don't wanna come across as saying I don't understand
- 1:33:52what goes on in the inner city community and this is more about poverty.
- 1:33:55No,
- 1:33:55no,
- 1:33:55what I'm saying is this is more about poverty.
- 1:33:58In race,
- 1:33:58in my opinion,
- 1:34:00when I was a cop patrolling poor white neighborhoods,
- 1:34:02their daddy wasn't there either,
- 1:34:04and
- 1:34:05they were committing most of the crime in these poverty stricken neighborhoods.
- 1:34:08Education was not
- 1:34:09something that was afforded to some of these people,
- 1:34:11so it's not necessarily just a race thing,
- 1:34:14you know,
- 1:34:14and,
- 1:34:14and,
- 1:34:14and I want us to get past the point of using it as an excuse to say
- 1:34:18because we're black,
- 1:34:19we uniquely have these
- 1:34:20these
- 1:34:21things that are holding us back,
- 1:34:22and I don't know if that's true,
- 1:34:23but no,
- 1:34:24so I work with with students with special needs,
- 1:34:25right?
- 1:34:26And a lot of times what we say when we have their diagnosis is,
- 1:34:30it's not
- 1:34:31an excuse as much as it's an explanation.
- 1:34:33And it's like you,
- 1:34:34you have a reason or a rationale behind why something exists.
- 1:34:38And when,
- 1:34:39when you have that,
- 1:34:40it's like you have to let that seep into your thinking and it's like
- 1:34:43you talk about the music or the movies or the TV shows like,
- 1:34:46like it ain't,
- 1:34:47you know,
- 1:34:47Goodfellas and Godfather and Scarface and all these stuff with,
- 1:34:51with people who don't look like us who,
- 1:34:53you know,
- 1:34:53we got power and you know all of that stuff like that cool,
- 1:34:56we got music but.
- 1:34:58Don't act like we ain't seen Tiger King,
- 1:34:59you know,
- 1:35:00or,
- 1:35:01you know what I'm saying?
- 1:35:01And they was out there anyway.
- 1:35:03But what I'm saying is,
- 1:35:04it's like there's,
- 1:35:06there's
- 1:35:07micro microscopic like examples you can give of all of these things,
- 1:35:11but if you just look overall with all of the systems,
- 1:35:14there's never been like an equitable amount.
- 1:35:16Of it that goes towards black folks and I think that for that for that reason
- 1:35:20you have,
- 1:35:21you have to,
- 1:35:21you have to embed that into your thinking and I think again your claim is not
- 1:35:26horribly off,
- 1:35:27but it's also like
- 1:35:29without regard to the reality of the the whole
- 1:35:31holistic situation can we come to an agreement on this
- 1:35:34is that.
- 1:35:36We both acknowledge all of these things happen.
- 1:35:38We both acknowledge that it's not in like in in part of some of the
- 1:35:41things that have happened in the black community is not necessarily just an excuse,
- 1:35:43it's an explanation,
- 1:35:45but we do do we agree
- 1:35:47that it's,
- 1:35:47it does not prevent you
- 1:35:50from becoming successful and doing those things today.
- 1:35:53I,
- 1:35:53I think.
- 1:35:55Yes,
- 1:35:56and,
- 1:35:56and which is,
- 1:35:57which is again,
- 1:35:57the practice that I like to do is a yes and
- 1:35:59because I think that there are going to be people who transcend
- 1:36:02what life is kind of like put in their place.
- 1:36:05But I think for a lot of folks,
- 1:36:06like it's just like
- 1:36:07if I,
- 1:36:07if I have an above average ability like if I'm,
- 1:36:09I'm 6'5,
- 1:36:10so it's like I have a,
- 1:36:11a leg up on somebody who might have also been the same,
- 1:36:14the same level as I am in basketball or,
- 1:36:16or sports or something like that.
- 1:36:18But because Because I have height,
- 1:36:19I have a little bit higher of a chance.
- 1:36:21Like,
- 1:36:21if I'm,
- 1:36:22if I'm somebody who's
- 1:36:24from the same similar neighborhood with,
- 1:36:26with,
- 1:36:26with a similar like IQ and all of that stuff,
- 1:36:28but my parents have access to things that,
- 1:36:31that these other parents don't,
- 1:36:32my outcomes are going to be different.
- 1:36:34And I think that that's like,
- 1:36:35you're saying it like it's an excuse where it's not,
- 1:36:37it's not so much of an excuse as it's like,
- 1:36:39I just,
- 1:36:39I just want us to be able to have like a
- 1:36:42Some people transcend,
- 1:36:43some people go along with the,
- 1:36:45you know,
- 1:36:45like we have a bell curve,
- 1:36:46like you have the,
- 1:36:47the people that's in the,
- 1:36:48the,
- 1:36:48the standard deviations outside of the mean,
- 1:36:50but
- 1:36:51like
- 1:36:51the outcomes over here and the outcomes over here are the ones
- 1:36:54that we tend to focus on when it's like there's a lot
- 1:36:56of people in the middle who really just not getting a fair
- 1:36:58shake at it because these systems are in place that don't benefit us
- 1:37:03properly or effectively.
- 1:37:04I have to pause here.
- 1:37:05It was a great debate,
- 1:37:06but you have been voted out by the majority.
- 1:37:09Well done.
- 1:37:12321.
- 1:37:16Hi again.
- 1:37:18OK.
- 1:37:18I am,
- 1:37:19um,
- 1:37:20so I do wanna isolate this cause you think,
- 1:37:24um,
- 1:37:24of black disenfranchisement
- 1:37:27just over the course of history because
- 1:37:28the thing I keep hearing you say is culture,
- 1:37:31right?
- 1:37:31But in psychology we have this debate between nature and nurture,
- 1:37:34right?
- 1:37:34Every decision,
- 1:37:35the patterns that come from.
- 1:37:37Different populations can be
- 1:37:39caused by either one of two things.
- 1:37:40It's like
- 1:37:41your
- 1:37:42material conditions,
- 1:37:43OK,
- 1:37:43this is the culture you're talking about.
- 1:37:44This is like
- 1:37:45attitudes,
- 1:37:46OK,
- 1:37:46and behavioral patterns,
- 1:37:47or it's like genetically
- 1:37:49in some way you are different from other populations
- 1:37:51like you naturally have less of an inclination towards
- 1:37:54success.
- 1:37:54So for black people I have to ask you which one is it?
- 1:37:57No,
- 1:37:57I,
- 1:37:57I definitely don't think black people have a a
- 1:37:59less inclination towards success because of some DNA makeup.
- 1:38:02Black people do have a DNA,
- 1:38:04um.
- 1:38:05I guess expression that makes them a lot more
- 1:38:08proficient in sports.
- 1:38:09I mean,
- 1:38:09that's an advantage,
- 1:38:10but
- 1:38:10when you,
- 1:38:10when you,
- 1:38:11when you're,
- 1:38:11you're talking about.
- 1:38:13Like,
- 1:38:13so,
- 1:38:14your point is very broad.
- 1:38:16Systemic racism,
- 1:38:18does it affect you today and does it affect your life moving forward?
- 1:38:21I do not believe so.
- 1:38:22If you believe that nurture,
- 1:38:24right,
- 1:38:24is the cause,
- 1:38:25right,
- 1:38:25of black people acting differently,
- 1:38:27it's not something biological here.
- 1:38:28You have to ask,
- 1:38:29OK,
- 1:38:30when it comes to culture,
- 1:38:30it can be,
- 1:38:31it can be in part biological.
- 1:38:33Generational trauma is,
- 1:38:35is could be biological.
- 1:38:37Like again,
- 1:38:38social standards,
- 1:38:39OK?
- 1:38:39Issues that are replicated from the material conditions.
- 1:38:42When I say material conditions,
- 1:38:43I'm talking about what is around you,
- 1:38:44what is the infrastructure of your life,
- 1:38:46OK?
- 1:38:46What systems are you born into?
- 1:38:48OK,
- 1:38:48so if we can if we can recognize that
- 1:38:50that right is,
- 1:38:51is where the cause is lying,
- 1:38:53my question to you is gonna be again,
- 1:38:56where has this equalizer been,
- 1:38:58right?
- 1:38:59In,
- 1:38:59in,
- 1:38:59in the whole status quo between white folks and black folks.
- 1:39:02Put it this way,
- 1:39:02I,
- 1:39:02I don't,
- 1:39:02I don't,
- 1:39:03I'm hoping that we can get to a conclusion of,
- 1:39:06of,
- 1:39:06of understanding because you keep saying black people as if we uniquely
- 1:39:09are the only people who are dealing with certain issues and poverty.
- 1:39:13White people,
- 1:39:13white poor people experience a lot of similar things as black people.
- 1:39:18It's not,
- 1:39:19but when you say redlining,
- 1:39:20when I just told you,
- 1:39:21I just told you when when when you look at the,
- 1:39:23the,
- 1:39:24uh,
- 1:39:24historicity of redlining,
- 1:39:26majority of the people who were in the redlined district were white.
- 1:39:29Disproportionate amount of the check.
- 1:39:3292%.
- 1:39:33I'm gonna tell you right now,
- 1:39:34OK.
- 1:39:3592%,
- 1:39:35listen to me,
- 1:39:36let me,
- 1:39:36let me explain it.
- 1:39:37No,
- 1:39:38it was not explicitly a fact I can't wait for the check,
- 1:39:41I hope they do.
- 1:39:42When,
- 1:39:42when you're talking about the creation of the red line from the HOLO or HOL HOLC
- 1:39:49corporation.
- 1:39:50There's a lot of things in my mind.
- 1:39:52When you look at the,
- 1:39:53the delineation line when they drew the red line,
- 1:39:55that was after discrimination had already existed.
- 1:39:59And what did the red lines?
- 1:40:00The red the red line,
- 1:40:01the red lines were more of a revelation
- 1:40:04of what was happening more so than a demarcation that created it
- 1:40:08because they had already been there had none because you haven't looked it up,
- 1:40:11that's why,
- 1:40:12that's why you haven't looked it up.
- 1:40:14Well,
- 1:40:14you didn't do enough.
- 1:40:15So some of these discriminatory practices
- 1:40:18by lenders.
- 1:40:19Occurred way before there was a red line.
- 1:40:21The negative effects of redlining affected white people and black people,
- 1:40:25disproportionately affecting black people.
- 1:40:27How about this?
- 1:40:27Let's get back to the cause of black individuals' strife in America.
- 1:40:31OK?
- 1:40:32I want you to isolate again for me,
- 1:40:34if it's not biological,
- 1:40:36where is this culture coming from?
- 1:40:38How does it happen?
- 1:40:38It's,
- 1:40:39it's like for instance,
- 1:40:40when you look at the,
- 1:40:41when you look at black
- 1:40:42culture,
- 1:40:4330s,
- 1:40:4440s,
- 1:40:4450s,
- 1:40:46it was it's very different than today.
- 1:40:48There was no gangster hip hop music
- 1:40:51that was talking about killing and thugging and smashing every day
- 1:40:54that didn't exist.
- 1:40:56Black families were intact at a higher rate.
- 1:40:58Black entrepreneurship was up.
- 1:41:00Education was prioritized in the black community.
- 1:41:03We begin to see that degrade over time.
- 1:41:06I,
- 1:41:06so it's,
- 1:41:07it's impossible almost to say slavery caused black people to be here.
- 1:41:11We're not accounting for the,
- 1:41:12the explosion of success here
- 1:41:14in the black community,
- 1:41:15and I'm saying that
- 1:41:17the degrading of culture,
- 1:41:19people
- 1:41:20falling away from God.
- 1:41:22Not marrying the people they have children with,
- 1:41:24all of those contributing factors that are perpetuated by black people
- 1:41:27has caused a lot of the problems that we see.
- 1:41:29When we talk about things like rap music,
- 1:41:31OK,
- 1:41:31when we talk about
- 1:41:32the hip hop and whatever,
- 1:41:34what is being talked about in these songs?
- 1:41:35It's obviously shooting,
- 1:41:37OK,
- 1:41:37shootings,
- 1:41:38OK,
- 1:41:38it's like life experiences are what are being discussed,
- 1:41:42OK?
- 1:41:42And when we look at those life experiences they're much more,
- 1:41:45they're much more so being concentrated.
- 1:41:48In black areas and that was true in the 30s and 40s and 50s.
- 1:41:52Hold on,
- 1:41:52hold on,
- 1:41:53hold on,
- 1:41:53hold on,
- 1:41:53hold on,
- 1:41:53hold on.
- 1:41:54I would love to.
- 1:41:55I would love to see the statistics on Bloods and Crips in the 30s?
- 1:41:59I wanna get like three sentences out.
- 1:42:01That that's important in this debate.
- 1:42:02OK.
- 1:42:03So once again,
- 1:42:0430s,
- 1:42:0540s,
- 1:42:0550s,
- 1:42:06there was segregation.
- 1:42:06Again,
- 1:42:07we,
- 1:42:07we,
- 1:42:07we all know this.
- 1:42:08There was black people still persevered through and
- 1:42:10that wasn't even one sentence I got out.
- 1:42:12You recognize that.
- 1:42:14Yeah,
- 1:42:14we got time going down
- 1:42:15and for us to be on the same page,
- 1:42:17we have to understand the same kind of history.
- 1:42:19So I didn't get any like there was no statistic that or there's
- 1:42:21no kind of facts about the wealth in the 30s or 40s,
- 1:42:2450s that you gave me,
- 1:42:25which well hold on,
- 1:42:26right?
- 1:42:26What I'm trying to tell you,
- 1:42:27right,
- 1:42:28is that
- 1:42:29this disparity has existed even in those times
- 1:42:31you're talking about where there wasn't any,
- 1:42:32you know,
- 1:42:33expressions of culture that had to do with music.
- 1:42:35There was still disenfranchisement,
- 1:42:36there was still a lack of resources.
- 1:42:38HBCUs were still under.
- 1:42:40Funded in those time periods and we saw that black people
- 1:42:43for the most part did not have home equity,
- 1:42:45which is the greatest way that you can essentially create generational wealth.
- 1:42:48That was all true.
- 1:42:49But yes,
- 1:42:49some of what you're saying is true,
- 1:42:51but I don't think it's the,
- 1:42:52it's the end all be all and success of black people today.
- 1:42:54Like for instance,
- 1:42:55all of the things that you're referring to
- 1:42:57hundreds of years ago,
- 1:42:5960 years ago,
- 1:43:00I'm,
- 1:43:00I'm asking you right now,
- 1:43:04do those things that happened then.
- 1:43:07Have a profound
- 1:43:08negative effect on black people in perpetuity.
- 1:43:11Of course,
- 1:43:11and I'll tell you I have to stop here.
- 1:43:13The clock has run out.
- 1:43:15I'm so sorry.
- 1:43:16Thank you guys.
- 1:43:19In the final debate,
- 1:43:20Officer Tatum gets 10 minutes uninterrupted.
- 1:43:24There's been a lot of conversations here today.
- 1:43:26Officer Tatum,
- 1:43:27it's up to you now
- 1:43:29to choose.
- 1:43:30Look around,
- 1:43:30think carefully.
- 1:43:32Who would you like to continue the conversation with?
- 1:43:34God dang it,
- 1:43:35that's a hard one.
- 1:43:36It's,
- 1:43:36it's hard.
- 1:43:36It's hard,
- 1:43:37it's hard to pick.
- 1:43:37I think I had a few that I.
- 1:43:39They all got a lot of energy.
- 1:43:40They all wanna talk.
- 1:43:41I want the gentleman in the green shirt.
- 1:43:43All right,
- 1:43:44do you have a claim?
- 1:43:46Yes I do.
- 1:43:46All right.
- 1:43:47All right,
- 1:43:47good to see you again.
- 1:43:48So Officer Tatum,
- 1:43:49why have you chosen Trevanti?
- 1:43:51Well,
- 1:43:52because I think he's,
- 1:43:52uh,
- 1:43:53acting in good faith.
- 1:43:54He's a seemed like an educated guy.
- 1:43:56We had a spirited debate and I felt like it was fair,
- 1:43:58and so.
- 1:43:59I,
- 1:43:59I had plenty of people I would like to
- 1:44:01finish the conversation with,
- 1:44:02but
- 1:44:03I think this would be the best one.
- 1:44:04My surrounded claim is black people do not support Democrats because of welfare.
- 1:44:09Well,
- 1:44:10hey,
- 1:44:10I think we,
- 1:44:11I think we,
- 1:44:11um.
- 1:44:13Agree on that in part.
- 1:44:14I don't think black people's support of the
- 1:44:16Democratic Party is just because of welfare.
- 1:44:18I think it's because of manipulation.
- 1:44:20You have not seen a single group of people
- 1:44:23disproportionately voting for one
- 1:44:25party
- 1:44:26in almost the history of this country.
- 1:44:28Like black people have,
- 1:44:29which I think is a shame
- 1:44:31and it's the reason why the black community is devastated the way it is
- 1:44:34because when you sell your soul to one party,
- 1:44:37they don't have to do anything for you
- 1:44:39and they haven't done anything for black people.
- 1:44:41And then once you sell to one side,
- 1:44:42the other side don't have a vested interest
- 1:44:44in doing anything to support you because they'll never get your support anyway.
- 1:44:48I would argue,
- 1:44:49and my whole premise with this is that I'm hopeful
- 1:44:51that black people will begin to consider their own self-interests
- 1:44:55when they vote outside of party line.
- 1:44:57So I would like to say it is not a shame it
- 1:45:00actually proves that black people are
- 1:45:02smarter than conservatives give them credit for
- 1:45:05because the fact of the matter is black people,
- 1:45:07well,
- 1:45:07let me ask you this,
- 1:45:08what year
- 1:45:09did blacks begin voting en masse
- 1:45:12for the Democratic Party?
- 1:45:13Do you know?
- 1:45:14It began in the 1930s and 1940s.
- 1:45:15You're right.
- 1:45:16OK,
- 1:45:16so it began in 1930,
- 1:45:19not,
- 1:45:19not as as prolific as it is today,
- 1:45:21but it began there.
- 1:45:22So,
- 1:45:23originally,
- 1:45:23African Americans voted for the Republican Party squarely
- 1:45:27because of the legislative efforts of Abraham Lincoln and the radical Republicans
- 1:45:32in Congress.
- 1:45:33They continued to vote for them
- 1:45:35right up until the New Deal.
- 1:45:37The,
- 1:45:38the reason why things shifted
- 1:45:40is Because
- 1:45:41after the radical Republicans left Congress,
- 1:45:44the Republican Party stepped back and allowed
- 1:45:47the Confederacy to make a comeback in the form of the Ku Klux Klan.
- 1:45:52The Ku Klux Klan was a Democrat military arm of the Democratic Party.
- 1:45:57No,
- 1:45:57no,
- 1:45:57no,
- 1:45:58you got to know very clear,
- 1:45:59no,
- 1:45:59I'll be clear.
- 1:45:59There was the Democrats.
- 1:46:00I will be clear
- 1:46:02against Republicans.
- 1:46:02The federal government allowed
- 1:46:05the Ku Klux Klan to stop black.
- 1:46:07People from voting Democrats
- 1:46:08stopped them from owning homes,
- 1:46:10stopped them from social mobility that was upward,
- 1:46:14I know,
- 1:46:15no,
- 1:46:15no,
- 1:46:15no,
- 1:46:15it was Republicans too.
- 1:46:17There was there was no,
- 1:46:18no,
- 1:46:18listen,
- 1:46:19there was a spate
- 1:46:20of Republican
- 1:46:22presidencies
- 1:46:23after Lincoln was assassinated,
- 1:46:25OK?
- 1:46:26And guess what?
- 1:46:27That was when the Klan became stronger and stronger and stronger.
- 1:46:30And so the thing that they,
- 1:46:31the talking point that they would always repeat is.
- 1:46:33We freed you.
- 1:46:34Now pull yourself up by your bootstraps.
- 1:46:37But what they didn't realize is that you cannot pull
- 1:46:39yourself up by your bootstraps when you are being terrorized
- 1:46:43through racial violence
- 1:46:44by the Ku Klux Klan.
- 1:46:46And so guess what?
- 1:46:47One of the things that you hold on a second,
- 1:46:50one of the things that Martin Luther King advocated for
- 1:46:54was the federal government stepping in,
- 1:46:56and he wrote about this in striving toward Freedom.
- 1:46:58He said that they needed to.
- 1:47:00Intervene in local situations because local governments
- 1:47:04were not protecting blacks from racial violence.
- 1:47:06No.
- 1:47:08Now the Republican Party was established
- 1:47:10to combat
- 1:47:11the Democrat Party
- 1:47:13from their proliferation
- 1:47:14of racism,
- 1:47:16slavery.
- 1:47:17100%,
- 1:47:18yes.
- 1:47:19Slavery,
- 1:47:20yes,
- 1:47:20no,
- 1:47:21but not Later,
- 1:47:22racism and discrimination against blacks.
- 1:47:24The Ku Klux Klan was established as the military.
- 1:47:26Of the Democrat Party,
- 1:47:28Democrats did not unanimously vote
- 1:47:30for the right for blacks to be free,
- 1:47:33to have,
- 1:47:33uh,
- 1:47:34citizenship and to vote.
- 1:47:35The Democrats did not.
- 1:47:37Republicans unanimously voted for that.
- 1:47:38Am I right or am I wrong?
- 1:47:39You,
- 1:47:40you're talking about you're talking about the 1860s
- 1:47:43after that they did the Republican Party.
- 1:47:46They did absolutely nothing.
- 1:47:47Let me give you this.
- 1:47:49So,
- 1:47:50during,
- 1:47:51during,
- 1:47:51why don't you,
- 1:47:52why don't you address that?
- 1:47:53What,
- 1:47:53what part?
- 1:47:54That the Republican Party unanimously voted during
- 1:47:57the 18 and the Republican Party unanimously
- 1:48:00voted for the Civil Rights Act after the Civil Rights Act unanimous by Republicans,
- 1:48:05not Democrats because of the efforts of LLBJ.
- 1:48:09OK,
- 1:48:09we,
- 1:48:09we have 5 minutes.
- 1:48:11What have Democrats done for black people in America?
- 1:48:15Give me policy
- 1:48:16and give me a reason why.
- 1:48:18I will tell you a person like me will vote for
- 1:48:20the Democrats at the current state that they're in now.
- 1:48:23You got to explain.
- 1:48:23We can't do a whole thing.
- 1:48:25I need you to answer that.
- 1:48:26I got 5 minutes,
- 1:48:274 now.
- 1:48:27So number 1 was underneath Roosevelt.
- 1:48:30The number,
- 1:48:31we can't go through this.
- 1:48:32Give me the policy position now that I should go for.
- 1:48:35We're going to do a whole history lesson.
- 1:48:36We run underneath Donald Trump's Donald Trump predicts 3,
- 1:48:40placed 3 Supreme Court justices.
- 1:48:42The Supreme Court
- 1:48:43and they overturned affirmative action in terms of schools.
- 1:48:47That was created because necessary for us to continue in affirmative action.
- 1:48:51It is 100 is not necessary.
- 1:48:53This is what holds black people down.
- 1:48:54We have,
- 1:48:56we have the opportunity
- 1:48:57to work and do things on our own merit.
- 1:49:00We do not need I'm gonna tell you discrimination.
- 1:49:03I'm going to tell you for us to be successful in this country.
- 1:49:05We are starting to discriminate.
- 1:49:07discrimination.
- 1:49:08We're starting to discriminate.
- 1:49:09Then why are there,
- 1:49:10why is there such an enormous wealth disparity if is there a wealth disparity,
- 1:49:15why is there a wealth disparity between Asians and whites?
- 1:49:19White people,
- 1:49:20Asian people make a tremendous amount more money than white people on average.
- 1:49:23Because of the
- 1:49:25the United States.
- 1:49:26And why do black people,
- 1:49:27but why do black people,
- 1:49:28immigrants who come over here,
- 1:49:30are more educated,
- 1:49:32they have less crime.
- 1:49:35All of these statistical data points that immigrants who come over here do better,
- 1:49:38black immigrants than black
- 1:49:40citizens here.
- 1:49:40They don't have the history of oppression in this country that we have.
- 1:49:44What does that tell you?
- 1:49:45That tells you
- 1:49:48that this,
- 1:49:48it tells you that the thing that is most offensive to
- 1:49:51white liberals to white conservatives is the descendants of those slaves,
- 1:49:55foundational black Americans,
- 1:49:56whatever you kind,
- 1:49:57actually experiencing social mobility me explain this to you.
- 1:50:00This is my point being proven.
- 1:50:02It's not about color,
- 1:50:03it's about decisions because a black when it comes to black,
- 1:50:07a black person can come over here from a foreign country
- 1:50:10and be very successful at a rates that are higher than
- 1:50:13black citizens are wildly exaggerated.
- 1:50:15It's not wildly exaggerated,
- 1:50:17it is a fact because there's no policy in place right now
- 1:50:20that will stop you from doing anything that white people can do.
- 1:50:22Name one that systemic racism.
- 1:50:25You're saying there's systems in place or there's a continuation
- 1:50:28of.
- 1:50:29Either systems,
- 1:50:30policies that are in place that are disenfranchiseding black people.
- 1:50:33Name one of them.
- 1:50:34So let me explain,
- 1:50:35name one.
- 1:50:35We gotta make a quick.
- 1:50:36We've already named a number,
- 1:50:37we've named you from being successful.
- 1:50:41I,
- 1:50:41I haven't been stopped from being successful.
- 1:50:43Why?
- 1:50:44Well,
- 1:50:44if you look at the data,
- 1:50:46hold on,
- 1:50:46let me stop you real quick.
- 1:50:47We'll get to that.
- 1:50:48No,
- 1:50:48no,
- 1:50:49I,
- 1:50:49I just want,
- 1:50:49I just want to do a quick poll.
- 1:50:51Raise your hand if there's
- 1:50:53white supremacy has stopped you from being successful in America.
- 1:50:562nd and 3rd
- 1:50:57No,
- 1:50:57no,
- 1:50:57no,
- 1:50:57I'm talking about right now.
- 1:50:59Yes,
- 1:50:59keep it,
- 1:50:59keep it personal.
- 1:51:01Some of you can see,
- 1:51:02others cannot.
- 1:51:02I have a scar on my knee,
- 1:51:04on my leg.
- 1:51:05Uh,
- 1:51:06I was impacted by the healthcare system not supporting black women
- 1:51:10when my leg was broke in two places.
- 1:51:13Um,
- 1:51:14I was on blood thinners.
- 1:51:15I couldn't have Tylenol because I'm allergic to Tylenol,
- 1:51:18couldn't have Advil.
- 1:51:20They wanted to give me opiums
- 1:51:22and.
- 1:51:22I refused.
- 1:51:23I told them I did not want that.
- 1:51:25I told them I struggle with morphine.
- 1:51:28Do you have anything else to please provide me?
- 1:51:30And they refused.
- 1:51:31They only gave me the opiates
- 1:51:34and they told me that I had to just go with whatever,
- 1:51:37only to hear from a black doctor two weeks later
- 1:51:40that I could have just had a muscle relaxer.
- 1:51:42Those doctors actively chose
- 1:51:45not to do their research to find a better way
- 1:51:48for me to.
- 1:51:49Go through less pain.
- 1:51:50They decided they wanted me to experience pain
- 1:51:53from a broken leg.
- 1:51:55You wanted me
- 1:51:56to raw dog all that pain,
- 1:51:58all that pain on nothing,
- 1:52:00on nothing.
- 1:52:01OK,
- 1:52:01so I used to work as an assistant manager at the mall,
- 1:52:04and I had a white manager,
- 1:52:06right?
- 1:52:07There was a huge discrepancy in the count of sales of the hats inside the store,
- 1:52:13and because I was,
- 1:52:15for whatever.
- 1:52:15Reason,
- 1:52:16right,
- 1:52:16the target,
- 1:52:17they hired trained law enforcement
- 1:52:19to come and interrogate me under the pretense
- 1:52:22of first like,
- 1:52:23hey,
- 1:52:24like how are you doing?
- 1:52:25Like how's your,
- 1:52:25how's your money troubles?
- 1:52:27How's this?
- 1:52:27How's that?
- 1:52:28Just to essentially lock me into a story where
- 1:52:31I was committing this retail fraud,
- 1:52:34right?
- 1:52:34They had
- 1:52:35at least 40 hours of store footage of me
- 1:52:39working my shifts where there wasn't a single instance
- 1:52:42of me.
- 1:52:42Stealing anything,
- 1:52:43but
- 1:52:44because I'm the only dark skinned black person working in the store,
- 1:52:47they had someone try to come and
- 1:52:50frame me for a crime,
- 1:52:51essentially.
- 1:52:51I'm currently getting my MBA from Berkeley Haass,
- 1:52:54and as a result of Trump's policies,
- 1:52:57uh,
- 1:52:57removing,
- 1:52:58uh,
- 1:52:58DEI and such,
- 1:52:59my scholarship was removed,
- 1:53:01and this has caused,
- 1:53:01in,
- 1:53:02in addition to his new policies,
- 1:53:03it's caused a cap on the loans.
- 1:53:04I'm currently financially struggling
- 1:53:07because I have to figure out how I'm gonna pay for my next year of school.
- 1:53:09Uh,
- 1:53:10basically when I was younger,
- 1:53:11there was an officer at our school
- 1:53:14who
- 1:53:15would always kind of interrogate me every day.
- 1:53:18I never said anything because unfortunately,
- 1:53:22what can you say when you're black and alone?
- 1:53:24You kind of got to go with it and just
- 1:53:26go about your day.
- 1:53:27And the officer was never disciplined.
- 1:53:30Financial racism.
- 1:53:31I'm a first generation person to go to college out of my family.
- 1:53:34Uh,
- 1:53:35I had to fill out the FAFSSFA.
- 1:53:36I was specifically disproportionately targeted for predatory loans.
- 1:53:40I got into 3 colleges.
- 1:53:42The only college that offered full scholarship.
- 1:53:45To an HBCU,
- 1:53:46the State College,
- 1:53:47University of South Carolina,
- 1:53:49specifically targeted me with multiple loans instead of offering scholarships.
- 1:53:53Later,
- 1:53:53when I started working,
- 1:53:55because I was low income,
- 1:53:56so I had to continue to make money and also go to college,
- 1:53:59I had to take on those predatory loans,
- 1:54:01which then put me behind after I graduated as far as being able to accomplish
- 1:54:05the next level.
- 1:54:06Specifically,
- 1:54:07if you take a look at the
- 1:54:08that they finance the loans inside of
- 1:54:10the United States of America is disproportionately
- 1:54:12black people have these loans where white people
- 1:54:15get specific grants,
- 1:54:17even though
- 1:54:17if you look at the actual transcripts and the scholar,
- 1:54:20I mean the testing,
- 1:54:21they're very,
- 1:54:22very parallel.
- 1:54:23I'd just like to say that
- 1:54:24the idea of us having to explain racism to a black man is absurd.
- 1:54:29It's like,
- 1:54:30OK.
- 1:54:31I have experienced discrimination.
- 1:54:33The reason I responded no to your question was if it held me back.
- 1:54:36No,
- 1:54:36it didn't hold me back because I fought against the discrimination,
- 1:54:39but
- 1:54:39I was discriminated against when I was looking for housing
- 1:54:42when I was trying to get my master's degree.
- 1:54:44One guy even told me it's not because you're black.
- 1:54:46When I saw a bunch of white people,
- 1:54:48he did not want to give me housing.
- 1:54:50Um,
- 1:54:50I was also,
- 1:54:51um,
- 1:54:52targeted by the police on multiple occasions,
- 1:54:54and then
- 1:54:55two weeks after Donald Trump became president.
- 1:54:58I was on my lunch break at my job and a white guy drove past me and yelled white power.
- 1:55:02He was emboldened because of Trump's rhetoric and that I've been called the N-word,
- 1:55:06just walking on the street multiple times by
- 1:55:08white people who feel emboldened by Trump's rhetoric.
- 1:55:11And so
- 1:55:12I have struggled against
- 1:55:14difficult odds,
- 1:55:15but it hasn't stopped me because.
- 1:55:18There's something inside of me that is determined to
- 1:55:20succeed and it's because I want to help people.
- 1:55:22I want to be that person that I did not have.
- 1:55:25And so black people have have striven against
- 1:55:28nearly insurmountable odds.
- 1:55:30That does not mean
- 1:55:31that there is not systemic racism.
- 1:55:33So I actually
- 1:55:35wasn't going to respond at first because of just like he said.
- 1:55:39I don't think that it held me back,
- 1:55:41but I actually had a full EELC claim that I got fired based off of my race,
- 1:55:46and it took me years to get like my back pay and everything like that,
- 1:55:50and
- 1:55:51the basis was is that there was like a discrepancy for like $35 and
- 1:55:56they tried to compare that to somebody at the same job who had did something for like
- 1:56:00$3000 plus and they tried to put us in the same basket when I just took the
- 1:56:03$3500 out of my wallet and tried to be like oh like it was a mistake.
- 1:56:06They fired me for that,
- 1:56:08but then on top of that,
- 1:56:09I came to find out from my from my coworkers that they had said things like,
- 1:56:12you know,
- 1:56:13they needed to staff the the store based off of the demographics of the city
- 1:56:17and that there were too many black people working in
- 1:56:19there that it was like driving down the consumerism.
- 1:56:22So
- 1:56:23at the end of the day it didn't prevent me
- 1:56:25from being great like I was gonna be great regardless,
- 1:56:27you feel me?
- 1:56:28So
- 1:56:28that,
- 1:56:29that wasn't why I wanted to speak up,
- 1:56:30but it,
- 1:56:31it happens,
- 1:56:31bro,
- 1:56:31like you know what I'm saying,
- 1:56:32like it's,
- 1:56:32it's not,
- 1:56:33it's not bad to say.
- 1:56:35I,
- 1:56:35I don't,
- 1:56:36you know,
- 1:56:37I'm,
- 1:56:37I'm gonna just stop because I see bro's tripping,
- 1:56:39so we're good.
- 1:56:41Honest to God truth,
- 1:56:42I have never experienced systemic racism
- 1:56:44or anything
- 1:56:46or racism.
- 1:56:47I've experienced a person say something racist to me,
- 1:56:49but it has no material effect on my life.
- 1:56:51It didn't stop me from doing nothing.
- 1:56:52There a person said,
- 1:56:53called me the N-word while I was a cop,
- 1:56:55and it,
- 1:56:55it,
- 1:56:55I don't think it hurt me for
- 1:56:5735/10 of a second.
- 1:56:59So I have never had anything racist systemically,
- 1:57:03systematically
- 1:57:04that had prevented me from becoming
- 1:57:06as successful as I am today,
- 1:57:07not one thing.
- 1:57:08Now can I respond to what everybody's saying?
- 1:57:10I,
- 1:57:11I think that,
- 1:57:11I think that what,
- 1:57:12what we're,
- 1:57:12when I listen to everybody's statement,
- 1:57:14there is no unequivocal proof
- 1:57:16that what happened to you was specifically because
- 1:57:19of the color of your skin,
- 1:57:20and we are talking about systemic,
- 1:57:22we're not talking about one-offs.
- 1:57:23You guys are giving,
- 1:57:24you guys are giving,
- 1:57:25you guys are giving a scenario,
- 1:57:27no,
- 1:57:27no,
- 1:57:27no,
- 1:57:28what,
- 1:57:28what I'm saying is that the occurrence that you're alluding to
- 1:57:32seems to be a one-off thing.
- 1:57:34It's not.
- 1:57:34Systemic it's not a system in place.
- 1:57:36OK,
- 1:57:37all right,
- 1:57:37Officer Tatum,
- 1:57:38I'm gonna have to stop you all
- 1:57:40Santana.
- 1:57:40I'm gonna have to stop you all here because that's all we have time for.
- 1:57:42We've tried something new,
- 1:57:44all right,
- 1:57:44so but we are out of time now.
- 1:57:46I wanna thank you all.
- 1:57:48You really brought your passion and your energy.
- 1:57:50I really appreciate you guys so much respect.
- 1:57:53Give yourselves a round of applause.
- 1:57:55Thank you guys.
- 1:57:56I appreciate it.
- 1:57:56Really appreciate it.
- 1:57:58All right,
- 1:57:58Officer Tatum,
- 1:57:59I also wanna thank you for listening to everyone and being really graceful.
- 1:58:02I know it's not easy,
- 1:58:03so I really appreciate that.
- 1:58:05Now it's been a great conversation.
- 1:58:07Would you be willing to continue this conversation on our podcast?
- 1:58:10Yes,
- 1:58:11I would love to.
- 1:58:11All right,
- 1:58:12well I thank you so much and I thank you guys in the audience for watching.
- 1:58:15I'm sure you have a lot of opinions after watching this one,
- 1:58:18so please let us know in the comments and I'll see you next time.
- 1:58:25And I,
- 1:58:26I,
- 1:58:26I would argue I don't think anybody that I've posed this question to
- 1:58:29have directly told me that this was
- 1:58:31proven racism
- 1:58:33systemically.
- 1:58:34That caused me to have this negative outcome and that it has a negative outcome
- 1:58:39that affects my success in life.
- 1:58:41A lot of his arguments lacked context,
- 1:58:44like historical context,
- 1:58:46and I think it's clear that he needs to read
- 1:58:49much more.
- 1:58:50I think the debate went well in the sense that all of the speakers were well prepared.
- 1:58:55Prepared
- 1:58:56and points were made that were very salient.
- 1:58:59However,
- 1:59:00I know that we did not change his mind because this is
- 1:59:04his job and any time you bring money into the equation,
- 1:59:07hearts are hardened and opinions become more inflexible.
- 1:59:11And I think kind of the goal of tokenism and the reason why Trump likes him
- 1:59:16is not.
- 1:59:17Because Trump is not racist,
- 1:59:19but because Trump needs a token black person to excuse
- 1:59:23his racism for the people who are out here watching,
- 1:59:26I'm just hoping they take away a different
- 1:59:28perspective from the one they already have.
- 1:59:30So even those who agree with me,
- 1:59:32hopefully they listen to others
- 1:59:34and gain some knowledge from what other people have
- 1:59:36to say and people who disagree with me.
- 1:59:37Um,
- 1:59:38that they listen to some of the things that I have to say
- 1:59:39and just be open minded to consider it that we can be spirited,
- 1:59:43but we can actually sit down and talk to each other
- 1:59:45and come to some commonalities.