Latest / Newcomer Pod / Matt Mahan — "California's Failure Is the Best Ammunition Trump Has Ever Had"
Transcript
- 0:00Don't think we're going to out meme Donald Trump or that we're
- 0:03going to beat him on XI. Think it's going to be
- 0:05ultimately in the in the courts and in delivering better
- 0:09outcomes and getting people to actually vote with their feet
- 0:11and want to come back to blue states.
- 0:13You you sort of tweaked Gavin Newsom, the governor, for being
- 0:16almost like Trump obsessed. Like shouldn't we be?
- 0:19I understand what he's doing. He's holding a mirror up to
- 0:22Donald Trump, who is a threat to our democracy, and I disagree
- 0:27with many of his policies. I also firmly believe that our
- 0:31failure to solve our biggest problems has given the MAGA
- 0:35movement a tremendous amount of ammunition.
- 0:38It's a big part of what's giving oxygen to this movement, and the
- 0:42best resistance is delivering results.
- 0:44So we are now paying more to import dirtier fuel from farther
- 0:49away, and we've lost all the jobs and tax base from that
- 0:52industry in the meantime. I tend to think that there's a
- 0:55there's a difference by an order of magnitude or two between the
- 0:59between waste and fraud and abuse.
- 1:00Fraud and abuse happen and they're very noteworthy and they
- 1:03should never happen and we should always punish them and
- 1:05root them out and try to prevent them.
- 1:07But it's waste and inefficiency that is the the bigger issue.
- 1:10Matt Mahan, mayor of San Jose, and I go back a long time.
- 1:13I think I was at an election party he threw when Trump was
- 1:16first selected, and it was a very sad affair.
- 1:19He's raised money now to run for governor of California from some
- 1:22people I know well, Gary Tan of Y Combinator, Joe Lonsdale, the
- 1:26Palantir Co founder. Mahan and I share a lot of
- 1:29sympathies. We somewhat believe in tech,
- 1:31somewhat believe in what's going on in AII guess both make a lot
- 1:33of our money from the tech set. But on the other hand, our
- 1:36principled Democrats with our own independent ideas.
- 1:40And so he and I had an honest conversation.
- 1:42I think I pushed him on a lot of things.
- 1:44He's competing for governor in a unique primary environment.
- 1:47It's the so-called jungle primary.
- 1:49So he can try and pick up some Republican voters.
- 1:52Obviously that's difficult in a in a world where you have to
- 1:55pick a team man as a a tall hill to climb to win this race.
- 1:59I think he's definitely behind, but a fascinating candidate that
- 2:02says a lot about what's happening in tech and American
- 2:05politics today. I'm Eric newcomer.
- 2:07This is the newcomer podcast. That man, mayor of San Jose,
- 2:18candidate for governor of California.
- 2:20We've known each. It's been, it's been a while,
- 2:23but we met back in your brigade days before your mayor.
- 2:28Not surprised to see you're running for governor, I believe
- 2:31back then, even though it's like that's you saw.
- 2:34Yeah, I was like, believable. So thank you.
- 2:36Thank you for coming on the Newcomer Podcast.
- 2:38Yeah, I'm thrilled to be here. It's good to see you again after
- 2:40all these years. Yeah, so just start with the
- 2:42mission statement of the campaign.
- 2:44It's what? It's a jungle primary.
- 2:46It's gonna be sort of a brawl to get to be one of the top 2
- 2:49candidates. What what is your message for
- 2:52people? Yeah, and I.
- 2:53Jumped in just a few weeks ago. I think it's a a wide open race
- 2:56still. And my, my core argument is that
- 2:59we need to fix California. We need to fix it for the 40
- 3:02million people who live there. Also nationally, what happens in
- 3:05California matters. And frankly, I think that our
- 3:09inability to address housing costs, energy costs,
- 3:13homelessness, crime, addiction issues have given Trump and the
- 3:18MAGA movement the best ammunition imaginable.
- 3:21And so I really, I want to fix our problems for my family, my
- 3:25neighbors, all of our fellow Californians.
- 3:27I also think there's a bigger context here.
- 3:30I'm worried about this rising populism on the right and now on
- 3:34the left. And you, you sort of see folks
- 3:36turning to really easy answers, you know, more authoritarianism
- 3:41or more socialistic socialist policies that ultimately I just
- 3:44don't think we're going to work and practice or really be what
- 3:47America's all about and what actually makes us great.
- 3:49And so I just, I'm worried, you know?
- 3:51Yeah. I mean, how much do you
- 3:53subscribe to the like abundance message?
- 3:56Because there's clearly echoes of that you're saying in a
- 3:58little. Bit yeah, yeah.
- 3:59And I don't think it's a holistic worldview that solves
- 4:03everything. I've spent a lot of time working
- 4:05on homelessness, crime, addiction, untreated mental
- 4:07illness. And is there an abundance
- 4:09message there? Maybe there's also just like,
- 4:12accountability. Sometimes you have to intervene.
- 4:14And there's a whole interesting conversation about civil
- 4:16liberties that's sort of independent of the abundance
- 4:18conversation. But the basic notion that we
- 4:23have made government too slow, too bureaucratic, we create a
- 4:27lot of cost around the things we most want like housing and clean
- 4:32energy, I think is absolutely true.
- 4:34High speed rail being the sort of poster child for everything
- 4:38that's wrong with the progressive governance model
- 4:41today. That's why has California high
- 4:45speed rail failed? Like it's almost, it's so hard
- 4:47to imagine. It's, it's like, let's just
- 4:49throw more money at it and someday it will work.
- 4:51I, you know, I think we're both of the world where we
- 4:54desperately want it to work. We want these beautiful, you
- 4:56know, Japan style trains running around, But why can't America
- 5:00deliver on it? Yeah, it's it's pretty stark
- 5:03when you look at during the 20 years where we've spent $20
- 5:06billion and not delivered a train China's build over 10,000.
- 5:12They may now be at 20,000 miles of high speed rail connecting
- 5:15their entire country. I mean, it's, and that's not an
- 5:17entirely fair comparison. But at the end of the day,
- 5:20people care about outcomes. And I think that's part of why
- 5:22we're seeing this more authoritarian impulse of this
- 5:25turn to a strong man is the people just want stuff to
- 5:28happen. It's it's the, you know,
- 5:30Governor Shapiro, get shit done mind right that we really need.
- 5:34So why? You know, I think it largely
- 5:36comes down to the fact that this project was caught up in years
- 5:40of environmental review and clearance.
- 5:43Years of litigation has taken forever to assemble all of the
- 5:48pieces legally, environmentally, just all of the regulatory
- 5:52compliance takes years. California has made it that.
- 5:55I think the country already suffers from the litigiousness
- 5:58around environmental review, NEPA as well as our California
- 6:02version of that sequa. But we're especially bad in
- 6:05California. You can have housing projects
- 6:08that make so much sense. You have the general plan where
- 6:11the public's already weighed in. You've said this surface parking
- 6:14lot in a downtown next to transit obviously should be high
- 6:18rise residential. And you can still take 18 to 24
- 6:21months to get through the environmental review process and
- 6:23you can still get sued for it. It's crazy.
- 6:26It's. It's amazing, you know, as a
- 6:27millennial to realize that being a progressive in sort of the
- 6:31previous generation was some of this sort of Sierra Club.
- 6:35Like we want green in that we want like a nice park with a
- 6:38sort of limited scope neighborhood.
- 6:40And it's like that. It doesn't match with what I
- 6:43guess progressivism means to my generation.
- 6:46I think that's absolutely right. I think we go through cycles and
- 6:48we have to keep updating the operating system, if you will.
- 6:53I think we went from early progressivism 100 years ago
- 6:56where there was actually a trust in big institutions to solve
- 7:00society's biggest problems. And you ultimately saw the
- 7:03height of that in the New Deal rose like we've we need
- 7:06government to be extremely active and robust.
- 7:10And coming out of that in World War Two, there was a lot of
- 7:12trust in government and expertise and big bureaucracies.
- 7:16And then I think much of kind of leading toward when around the
- 7:20time we were born and, and up till today was the
- 7:23disintegration of that model. And progressives taking a very
- 7:26different approach, largely the environmental movement, but just
- 7:29sort of the rights based, very litigious approach to protecting
- 7:33individuals from big government and big business.
- 7:37But we've we've unintentionally I think hobbled government and
- 7:42we are no longer able to move quickly and efficiently and do
- 7:45big things. And now there's, and I mean,
- 7:48obviously it's being covered by a lot of folks like Ezra Klein
- 7:50and Derek Thompson and others. But I think we're now sort of
- 7:53grappling with what is the next version, what's the next
- 7:56operating system need to look like?
- 7:58Can you achieve, if you're governor of California, will be
- 8:01you be able to achieve great things through government?
- 8:05Or is it about clearing the way for businesses and others to
- 8:08achieve great things? Like is there a way to get the
- 8:11actual humans working for government?
- 8:13I don't know to build things, deliver things more effectively
- 8:16or it's just like government's not always best positioned to
- 8:20solve these big problems. It's a great question.
- 8:22I do think you have to take it case by case.
- 8:25I would not simply rely on the private sector to magically fix
- 8:29education or transportation systems or I mean, there's some
- 8:35big complicated systems that are largely what you might call
- 8:38public goods where government just needs to do better.
- 8:41We need to use technology to deliver better services.
- 8:46Small example of this is in San Jose.
- 8:48We've been using an AI powered tool.
- 8:50There's a startup called Light that has helped us to speed up
- 8:53all of our public bus routes. So buses across the city of San
- 8:56Jose in the last called 18 months have become 20% faster on
- 9:02average through just this very subtle synchronization of
- 9:06lights. And that's a.
- 9:07It's hard not to hear this without the direct sort of
- 9:09mumdani contrast, right? He's promising free buses.
- 9:13You're like, we can make buses 20% faster, which is probably
- 9:17more important in some ways better, right?
- 9:19Yeah. Yeah, people pay for this.
- 9:21But one thing goes viral and the other does.
- 9:22Not no. You're right, the kind of more
- 9:24technical competence based approach is not always the most,
- 9:28the most viral, It doesn't always make the headlines.
- 9:30But I, I do believe, you know, people pay for things that they
- 9:33value. And if you're going to pay
- 9:34$20.00 for an Uber ride, you should be willing to pay 2 or $3
- 9:38for a bus ride. But it can't take five times
- 9:40longer like we, we need to, we need to speed it up and provide
- 9:42a great, a great service. But back to your, your bigger
- 9:45question. I do think there are areas where
- 9:48the answer is to pull back some of the robustness of the public
- 9:53sector. I, I think on housing to some
- 9:56extent energy. I'll give you another example on
- 9:58energy that will probably not win me any friends in the
- 10:01environmental movement. And I consider myself a lifelong
- 10:03environmentalist, very big on open space, love being outdoors
- 10:07and hiking and camping and all that good stuff.
- 10:10We though, have been so single minded about our support for
- 10:15clean energy. And we have so aggressively
- 10:18regulated the oil and gas industry that we have pushed
- 10:21refineries, most of the refineries that are just
- 10:25regulated to be the cleanest, best run refineries in the
- 10:28world. We have pushed them out of
- 10:30California, but we're still using gas.
- 10:32So we are now paying more to import dirtier fuel from farther
- 10:37away. And we've lost all the jobs and
- 10:39tax base that industry in the meantime, but we're still using
- 10:43it, burning it. We've just kind of killed the
- 10:45economics of it. And it's actually producing more
- 10:48emissions. And it's just sort of like good
- 10:50intentions gone awry in an overly regulated state.
- 10:53I think it was, John Arnold, the philanthropist and billionaire
- 10:57said the other day. Like there are a set of states,
- 10:59you know, like Texas, where he lives.
- 11:01They feel like they're competing for people to come and set up
- 11:04businesses. And then there are states like
- 11:06California that feel like we don't need you like with, I
- 11:10mean, the the billionaire tax proposal, I guess being the most
- 11:14prominent. Now, that's obviously not like
- 11:16Gavin Newsom's idea necessarily. Or what is your sense of the
- 11:20political support for this billionaire tax?
- 11:22You've obviously been opposed to it.
- 11:24And what's your read on like the seriousness of it for
- 11:26California? Yeah, it's it's a very real
- 11:28risk. Governor Newsom's opposed to it
- 11:30as well, but most of the Democratic leadership in the
- 11:35state has either supported it or stayed pretty silent on it.
- 11:38I think the governor and I have been two of the only more
- 11:41prominent Democrats in the state to say this is a bad idea.
- 11:44And it's not because we are, you know, worried about protecting
- 11:49billionaires from taxation or don't believe in progressive
- 11:52taxation. I think the wealthiest amongst
- 11:54us should absolutely pay substantially into the public
- 11:58system to continue the the prosperity, the infrastructure,
- 12:03all the things that make that, you know, the platform on which
- 12:07their prosperity was was created.
- 12:09But this is going to backfire if it passes.
- 12:12And I think I think it is backfired.
- 12:13You're right, Google. Govounders are fleeing the
- 12:16state. That's right.
- 12:18We've seen over a trillion dollars of capital flight to
- 12:20your point we there, I just saw a projection the other day there
- 12:24was a debate at Stanford and out of that there there was this
- 12:29analysis that showed that we're likely to lose 25 billion per
- 12:34year. That's recurring revenue.
- 12:35This, remember this proposal supposedly is a one time tax
- 12:40that will generate 100 billion. At this point maybe it would
- 12:42generate 50 because we've already lost so much wealth and
- 12:45that would be one time. It may have cost us 25 billion
- 12:49per year in revenue. Nobody really knows yet.
- 12:52I think it will be defeated. A lot of damage has been done.
- 12:55As you I'm sure know and your listeners know, there are 12
- 12:59European countries that have tried wealth taxes at the
- 13:01national level, not the sub national level and they've
- 13:05mostly all rolled them back. They've seen tax their their tax
- 13:08base shrink. It's just not a smart.
- 13:10And of course, some of the reason the tech industry in
- 13:12particular is going ballistic is sort of the potential for
- 13:15unrealized gains being taxed. And startups are all about
- 13:18having these on paper, highly valued companies that, you know,
- 13:21it's like if you actually had to cash it out, I'll put the money.
- 13:24Right, it's just. Like someday it will maybe be
- 13:27worth that, but I don't have that money today.
- 13:30That's right. You know, on the flip side of
- 13:33this, like, oh, we don't need a larger tax base.
- 13:36You know, California already has so much money.
- 13:38I mean, a lot of that money is going to state health care,
- 13:41right? I think sometimes when I see
- 13:43sort of criticism about the size of government from the left, and
- 13:46you sort of saw this with doge on the federal level, where
- 13:49Elon's Cruz said, oh, we're gonna like save so much money by
- 13:52cutting federal workers, which I think, you know, they did cut a
- 13:55bunch of federal workers, but they didn't balance the budget
- 13:57because so much of the spending is still in healthcare and other
- 14:01things that people love about government.
- 14:03Right. You're absolutely right.
- 14:05And California, the two biggest areas of expenditure by far are
- 14:09healthcare and education. And I think the right approach
- 14:15is to get more value for the dollars we're spending.
- 14:19Now that may involve cutting certain programs or staffing
- 14:22within that larger bucket of healthcare provision or
- 14:25education. We may find that we need to
- 14:27dramatically reallocate how we're spending the dollars.
- 14:31But you're very unlikely to find the political support nor would
- 14:35it necessarily be good for society to reduce the spend with
- 14:38an education and healthcare. I, I think, you know, 50% of
- 14:42healthcare spends in the last five years of life and it's
- 14:44people choosing to want better end of life care.
- 14:48Now, can we do more prevention or reduce chronic illness and
- 14:50all that? Yes.
- 14:52But I think the real focus needs to be on how we get more value
- 14:56for per dollar spent. So it is saving in some of the
- 14:59health spending areas. I think it's saving, but it's
- 15:02really just optimizing the spend.
- 15:03I think in healthcare, for example, I would like to see
- 15:08less of the spend on managing chronic illness and more on
- 15:14upfront prevention. We also spend a lot of our
- 15:18healthcare dollars within a very expensive and inefficient
- 15:21hospital system versus providing more accessible clinics and
- 15:25leveraging the capacity of nurse practitioners who are capable of
- 15:29doing a whole lot more than they are often allowed to do per
- 15:32their for their license or local regulations.
- 15:35So there are ways to actually, we offer more care, higher
- 15:38quality care, more preventative care to more people in more
- 15:41places with the same amount of spending.
- 15:44So it's more about the inefficiency of the spending.
- 15:46When there's this discussion of waste, fraud and abuse, I tend
- 15:50to think that there's a, there's a difference by an order of
- 15:53magnitude or two between the between waste and fraud and
- 15:56abuse. Fraud and abuse happen and
- 15:57they're very noteworthy and they should never happen and we
- 15:59should always punish them and root them out and try to prevent
- 16:02them. But it's waste and inefficiency
- 16:04that is the the bigger issue. We spent a lot of money without
- 16:08knowing if it's actually performing, if it's delivering
- 16:11the outcome that we want. Do you, do you think Doge you
- 16:15have? Was there anything valuable that
- 16:17came out of that? Well, I think it started an
- 16:20important conversation about waste and government and how to
- 16:25do things better. I think where Dodge really went
- 16:28off the rails was in seemingly taking joy in firing public
- 16:34servants, many of whom you know had done, most of whom had done
- 16:38nothing wrong. And we're just very committed,
- 16:40genuinely committed to the mission of the agency where they
- 16:43worked. It seems like some of the best
- 16:45among us, like who developed special specialties over many
- 16:48years. I mean, I get yeah, I just
- 16:51especially sort of the, you know, foreign aid stuff, the the
- 16:54malice about people who are trying to help other people or.
- 16:59The the different roles in different science, you know,
- 17:03scientific fields, doing research, long term research
- 17:06that may be valuable. It just it, it seemed like it
- 17:09was attacking the people, not the problem of innovation
- 17:12spending. Let me try to make this more
- 17:13concrete. In San Jose we have, as with all
- 17:16governments, limited resources for different priorities.
- 17:20One of our priorities is ending homelessness.
- 17:23We spend somewhere between 50 and $100 million a year,
- 17:27depending on revenue. It's a volatile revenue source,
- 17:29but we spend 50 to $100 million a year on tackling homelessness
- 17:33and housing issues. When I came into the mayor's
- 17:36office a little over three years ago, we were spending most of
- 17:39that money building brand new apartments for people.
- 17:42And for those who got those apartments, it was a great
- 17:45solution. They remained off the streets
- 17:46and their outcomes were much better.
- 17:48The problem was the math just didn't show any path to
- 17:52scalability, $1,000,000 a door, six years to build this
- 17:56apartment, we've got thousands of people living outside.
- 17:59So I said we there's a much more optimal way of spending these
- 18:03limited dollars given the magnitude of the problem and the
- 18:06timeline that we have, which is which is like we need to solve
- 18:08this today because. People expect it like.
- 18:11Yeah, people are dying on the streets.
- 18:12A couple 100 people a year die on our streets.
- 18:15So we shifted the dollars toward buying and fixing up old motels,
- 18:20buying prefabricated modular units, and putting these
- 18:22sleeping cabins, if you will, on public land.
- 18:25We brought outreach in house. Reduce the number of people, but
- 18:28improve the quality and actually something to offer people
- 18:30because we had built shelter. We've put money into prevention
- 18:33and slowed the inflow into homelessness.
- 18:36Same amount of money, but we've reduced the number of human
- 18:39beings living outside in tent encampments by about 1/3 in just
- 18:43the last few years. And with the next count, we will
- 18:46for the first time have a majority of people who are
- 18:49homeless in San Jose living indoors, not outdoors, which is
- 18:52qualitatively a completely different type of homelessness
- 18:56than having people literally wallowing in misery in a tent
- 19:00encampment and dying of overdose and, you know, down in the
- 19:03Creek. I mean, it's it's a totally
- 19:05different situation and we didn't have to raise taxes to do
- 19:09it. We just had to think differently
- 19:10and be willing to reprogram our dollars.
- 19:13The tech industry is very enthusiastic about your
- 19:16campaign. I think from, you know, Gary Tan
- 19:19to Joe Lonsdale or back end like what?
- 19:22What do you what do you think is like getting them excited about
- 19:26your candidacy? More than anything, I think it's
- 19:29that being the mayor of the Capitol, Silicon Valley.
- 19:32You got to meet them, you know that?
- 19:34Yeah. I know, I know the tech world
- 19:36well. I've I spent a decade working in
- 19:38IT, in the civic tech space, as you know, with with causes on
- 19:43Facebook and early philanthropy. I was saying, I think perhaps
- 19:46the last time we ran into each other, though I might have been
- 19:49somewhat intoxicated, was when Trump beat Hillary Clinton.
- 19:52I think you guys had a party in San Francisco, 2016.
- 19:56I was sort of like at a wandering day, you know, I wound
- 20:00up at that party was like this saddest set of people that San
- 20:03Francisco, It was a really cultural turning point where
- 20:08you're telling me, I don't know if I can Fact Check this either.
- 20:11You sort of think you saw the Trump thing coming from.
- 20:14So we had a map on on Brigade's website and Brigade, just for
- 20:17your listeners benefit was I would analogize it to a
- 20:21LinkedIn, but for your civic or political identity.
- 20:24We hooked into the voter file. We, we allowed you to claim your
- 20:27voter record and then showed you all of your representatives who
- 20:31else lived in your district or districts, depending on which
- 20:34level of government and allowed you to basically organize with
- 20:37other voters. You could, you could kind of put
- 20:38your votes together around issues you cared about and
- 20:41support candidates. And this was 10 years ago.
- 20:45We had a map and it was much more red than other maps.
- 20:48And I don't think our map was particularly accurate.
- 20:50But what we did see was this crossover behavior of, you know,
- 20:57older, middle-aged and older voters, white voters in the
- 21:01Midwest, lower propensity voters who had voted registered
- 21:06Democratic but told us they were going to vote for Trump or had
- 21:09voted for Obama and told us they were going to vote for Trump.
- 21:12And it was just so interesting to pick up on this trend of
- 21:16people who were telling us that they were all for Trump.
- 21:18But none of the previous data about their behavior or the
- 21:22registration, their status as a voter would have led us to
- 21:25predict that. And so we sort of saw that
- 21:28coming. And on election night, I mean,
- 21:30the New York Times and Wall Street Journal and others
- 21:34literally had reporters call and be like, what did you guys see
- 21:36in your data? Like, what should we did you?
- 21:38What did you guys know that we didn't know?
- 21:40Because we were kind of, you know, dismissed going into that
- 21:43race. It's like, oh, there's that
- 21:44weird app over there that seems to have been taken over by Trump
- 21:46supporters. And we were like, no, not
- 21:48really. Yeah.
- 21:49It was really interesting. Do you from that experience like
- 21:54any validity to election denial claims or what's what's your set
- 21:58like this save act and everything?
- 22:00We we did not get any indication of you're talking about like
- 22:04voter fraud. But whether voter fraud is
- 22:06something, you know, sort? Of well, our.
- 22:07Middle of the road sort of person.
- 22:09Our apartment. Didn't pick up you any of and
- 22:12you don't think? There's like any I don't.
- 22:14Think it is a is a rampant issue.
- 22:16I I do think that building trust in the process is really
- 22:23important. And whether it's whether the
- 22:25claims are legitimate or not or the scale is significant enough
- 22:29to matter. The notion that there should be
- 22:33some identity verification, some sort of voter ID or or some
- 22:38safeguards beyond what we have today, I think it's reasonable
- 22:42because you now have half the country doubting if our
- 22:44elections have the integrity that they need to have.
- 22:47So for better or worse, we're kind of at a point where I do
- 22:50think we need to address this issue.
- 22:52The SAFE Act seems like if that pass, it would be give the
- 22:56federal government under Trump a lot of control over the
- 22:58election. Yeah, that makes me very
- 23:00nervous. There's a conversation in
- 23:02California right now about voter ID, which I think 70 to 80% of
- 23:07people support. The notion that if you've got to
- 23:09use ID to buy alcohol or to buy a car or a gun or any other
- 23:14thing, and you've got to carry your ID with you as a driver and
- 23:17to get into a bar or whatnot, there ought to be some form of
- 23:21identity verification. It's still very, I mean you go
- 23:23on. Everything else, you're like,
- 23:25oh, we need need to be pragmatic and sort of tell people the
- 23:27truth and like, yeah, I just think this voter ID thing,
- 23:30there's just not that much fraud.
- 23:31No, I agree there's not. Too hard to commit the fraud at
- 23:34the level they want. Like you have to go.
- 23:36You say your address like it's just like it's be a lot of but I
- 23:39don't. Think that's the point really,
- 23:41in the sense that you're right, I totally agree with you.
- 23:46And yet the democracy is based on trust.
- 23:49And if half the country is believing that our elections
- 23:53aren't secure and don't have integrity and they shouldn't
- 23:55trust the results if they don't like the outcome, that's a
- 23:58problem for us as Democrats whether we like it or not.
- 24:02And we can, we can do the very academic and classically
- 24:05democratic thing and try to show them a bunch of data and
- 24:08explain, Oh no, don't worry, it's a rounding error.
- 24:11It almost never. It's probably never changed the
- 24:13outcome of an election, although you'd be surprised how many down
- 24:15ballot elections are decided by a few votes.
- 24:17But you can try to explain to people that they're wrong or you
- 24:23can take a common sense action that I mean, I, I just don't buy
- 24:27that it is an impossibility for us to give people 3 or 4
- 24:31different ways to to have an extra layer of protection where
- 24:34they show up and show a driver's license or a passport or
- 24:37something. So.
- 24:37So you right now you represent San Jose, which is tech, you
- 24:43know, Ground Zero, their hometown.
- 24:45Like, what is your view of now that you're campaigning of the
- 24:48average Californians view of like the tech industry right
- 24:52now? Well, there's a lot of
- 24:53skepticism, and I understand that there's the skepticism of
- 24:57high housing costs that I don't think it's fair to completely
- 25:00blame tech for. But the truth is we've created
- 25:03jobs at a much faster rate than we've built housing.
- 25:05I see that as a public policy failure first and foremost.
- 25:09But a lot of people say, well, if it wasn't for all these tech
- 25:11companies and all these high paying jobs, our housing prices
- 25:14wouldn't be as high as they are are.
- 25:16And there's, there's some truth in that.
- 25:17I, I don't think the answer is to get rid of the industry.
- 25:19I think it's to build housing, to be clear.
- 25:21But there's also a lot of fear that AI is going to destroy jobs
- 25:28and massively displace workers. Ironically, it may be those
- 25:33higher paid white collar jobs that start getting automated
- 25:37faster than than. Others double down on that.
- 25:39I mean, it's mystifying right now.
- 25:40You have, you know, Alex Carpet Palantir going around sort of
- 25:43bragging that, you know, the blue collar worker is going to
- 25:47benefit and it's sort of he literally said, you know, it's
- 25:50like the white women who vote Democrat, they're the ones that
- 25:52are going to get screwed. He.
- 25:55He. Specifically said something
- 25:56about women. I, I don't know who are the
- 25:58democratic base, but anyway, we don't need to get in that carp
- 26:01specifically, but there's definitely this sense from, I
- 26:04think it's become sort of a right wing tech talking point
- 26:07that, you know, white collar workers get screwed and the
- 26:09plumber like nothing better to be a plumber.
- 26:11But the, the flip side of that is like nothing better to be the
- 26:14owner of an AI company. Like the person on the top top,
- 26:17maybe, you know, all their coders running around are about
- 26:20to get screwed, but this technology is still gonna be
- 26:22controlled by white collar shape rotator or whatever, you know,
- 26:27but like, not, not the plumber or yeah, I don't know totally.
- 26:30What do you worry about? Sort of the tech industry having
- 26:33more control over what our lives look like if if they have this
- 26:37powerful technology outside of government.
- 26:39So I mean, when I think about AII, think about all of the
- 26:42capability first. I think about the capabilities
- 26:44that we can leverage to make our lives better.
- 26:47And I think about that primarily through the lens of public
- 26:50sector services. We've speed up our buses, we've
- 26:53improved language translation, we're saving it's it's.
- 26:56Amazing language translation. That would have been an insane.
- 27:00Like we would have been like mind boggled.
- 27:01And then we're like, oh, great, yeah, I did that.
- 27:03Actually it's like really easy. It's shocking.
- 27:05We use that just. Just a couple of years ago, we
- 27:08were paying people in our for the the largest languages
- 27:12represented in our city. We're an incredibly diverse
- 27:14city. San Jose is 40% foreign born.
- 27:16Over 50% of people speak a language other than English at
- 27:19home. And we would pay human beings
- 27:21who would not always even show up because they're humans to, to
- 27:25do translation in, in real time in, in Spanish, Vietnamese,
- 27:31sometimes Mandarin. That was about all we could
- 27:34afford and, or find. But people speak dozens of
- 27:37languages in our community. Now with an app, you can scan
- 27:41AQR code and in dozens of languages with really high
- 27:45precision at a very low cost. At all public meetings, you can,
- 27:49you can be on your phone and see true real time language
- 27:53translation. It's incredible.
- 27:55And you can come up and speak in your native language and we can
- 27:58all see on our screens what you're saying in real time.
- 28:02You're, you're ticking through things that sort of AI.
- 28:04Yeah. So when it comes to AI, I mean,
- 28:05you asked a pretty profound question about the the
- 28:08concentration of power and wealth in tech.
- 28:10And what does that mean? I was saying I, I really have
- 28:14focused on how to apply it to public services to make them
- 28:18better. We've also created an AI
- 28:20upskilling course curriculum for our workforce.
- 28:24And we're, our view is that these tools should not be
- 28:28displacing city workers. They should be enhancing their
- 28:30productivity, making their jobs more interesting and allowing
- 28:33these jobs to evolve naturally. But we're not trying to get rid
- 28:36of city workers. We're trying to help them have
- 28:38more satisfying and impactful jobs.
- 28:40And so we've we've taken that mission very seriously in San
- 28:43Jose on, on the bigger, more existential issue.
- 28:47Look, I think tech has to be regulated.
- 28:50I think the big question is exactly how to do that.
- 28:53It's such an evolving space. What is what is model
- 28:55transparency? I mean, this is your world much
- 28:58more than mine. But you know, what levels of
- 29:00transparency? When do you need a human in the
- 29:03loop? I mean, these are big questions
- 29:05and I'm certainly trying to keep up to speed on them and weigh
- 29:08the pros and cons. I don't want to prematurely
- 29:11regulate and push an industry out of California so that others
- 29:15get all of the job growth, high paying jobs, the economic impact
- 29:20and then it happens to us. I'd rather keep tech in
- 29:23California to the extent that we can, where we create the rules
- 29:26of the road and shape it for societal good to the extent that
- 29:30we can on the on the concentration of wealth.
- 29:35It's not just wealth, it's it's sort of power, right?
- 29:37I mean, you, you know, Mark Zuckerberg is, it's not just
- 29:40that he's wealthy, it's that he controls Facebook, which you
- 29:43obviously interacted with with your work.
- 29:45I mean, yeah. And I, you know, sometimes
- 29:47they're good stewards. You know, I've been a champion
- 29:50of some, you know, like Anthropic.
- 29:52I think we're, you know, I'm glad they're taking a principal
- 29:54approach. And that requires a little bit
- 29:56of centrality. So that's part of the American
- 29:58experiment, that companies get to compete with each other and
- 30:01build their sort of mini totalitarian regimes within
- 30:05their company. But yeah, I don't know.
- 30:07It's a tough, tough question. It is and I and I think it
- 30:11depends, you know, where you want to go with this.
- 30:14But if it's if it's there's the wealth piece that that has
- 30:17become very front and center because of the wealth tax in
- 30:20California. I think the answer there is to
- 30:22close a half dozen other tax loopholes at the federal level
- 30:26that are much more impactful, fairer and have fewer unintended
- 30:29consequences on the regulatory environment.
- 30:32We. Support like I feel like if
- 30:33people can get loans based on their wealth, that's.
- 30:36The lowest hanging fruit. It's just insane that's it
- 30:39allows billionaires to be flush. They just get loans.
- 30:43Against unrealized assets, which becomes a, a loophole way of not
- 30:46paying on your capital gains. You're right.
- 30:49There needs to be some sort of trigger where at a certain level
- 30:53of borrowing or time duration, it it's counted as a realized
- 30:57gain and you have to pay the tax on it.
- 30:58And, and if you have to liquidate, so be it because
- 31:02you're borrowing so much that you're effectively realizing the
- 31:04gain. I know that's very well.
- 31:06Federal federal reforms on some of the.
- 31:08I think on the tax code you really need to go to the federal
- 31:10level. California already has the, the
- 31:13second highest overall tax burden, the most progressive tax
- 31:17structure. In any given year, the top 1% of
- 31:21our income earners in the state contribute 40 or 50% of the
- 31:24revenue. So we can try to be a little
- 31:27more progressive, but at some point you are going to kill the
- 31:29golden goose. And I just, I think we're
- 31:31getting close. We're seeing billionaires
- 31:32literally move out of state. And I just, I, I don't think we
- 31:35need to push that anymore. We've increased spending in
- 31:39California at the state level by 75% percent, equivalent to $150
- 31:44billion a year more over six years ago.
- 31:49And if you ask Californians what's gotten better, they'd
- 31:53have a hard time giving you much of a list.
- 31:55And so, and that's not an indictment of anyone in
- 31:57particular. I think it is a systemic
- 31:59problem. I think that we are incredibly
- 32:02bureaucratic and inefficient. We have a system that's hard to
- 32:05reform because they're a highly organized interests, corporate
- 32:08labor and otherwise in Sacramento that just will try to
- 32:13block any meaningful change. And that's that's the
- 32:16environment that has LED us to increase spending massively and
- 32:19not really see much in the way of measurable improvement.
- 32:23I, I know there's a difference between on this question, I'm
- 32:25going to talk, we're going to talk about Trump for a second.
- 32:27And I'm acknowledging that there's sort of a difference
- 32:30between what you want thematically about your campaign
- 32:33and sort of your level of upsetness.
- 32:36And so I guess I want to ask about that, like you, you sort
- 32:39of tweaked Gavin Newsom, the governor, the current governor
- 32:42for, I don't know, being almost like Trump obsessed.
- 32:45Like, shouldn't we be like, isn't it disturbing what he's
- 32:48doing to the country? Like, if you're running for good
- 32:51governance, like on the corporate side, he's picking
- 32:55favourites, you know, helping some, some of your sort of
- 32:58California companies, deciding which ones, you know, can own
- 33:02studios and which ones can't. Like, aren't you sort of deep
- 33:05troubled by some of the stuff he's doing?
- 33:07I'm deeply troubled by a lot of the stuff he's doing, starting
- 33:11with how he's treating our immigrant neighbors.
- 33:13San Jose's incredibly diverse city, and we've got folks who
- 33:19have been living and working and contributing in our city, our
- 33:23community, for decades, who are living in fear, scared to leave
- 33:26their homes. They have children who are U.S.
- 33:29citizens. We are long past the time that
- 33:33we should have come to some, the parties should have come to some
- 33:37bargain here over, yes, a secure border and an orderly lawful
- 33:42immigration, but with a pathway to at least some form of legal
- 33:48status for folks who who are here and are otherwise trying to
- 33:52contribute and play by the rules.
- 33:54So immigration's kind of top of my list, general disregard for
- 33:59rule of law, tariffs, I mean, the list goes on and on.
- 34:02I'm deeply concerned. You know, my disagreements with
- 34:07Governor Newsom over the last few years have have generally
- 34:11been very focused on specific challenges we're facing at the
- 34:17city level. Remember, I'm the mayor of a
- 34:19city in a big state, and my argument has been we need our
- 34:23governor leading the charge locally.
- 34:26And I know he's got his eyes set elsewhere, which you know, is
- 34:30his prerogative. But we need our governor driving
- 34:34change at the local level because we cannot address
- 34:38homelessness, crime, high cost of housing and energy alone at
- 34:41the city level. We are downstream of so many
- 34:44state policies and spending decisions on homelessness and
- 34:47crime. We hold maybe half of the
- 34:49answers, but if the governor and the state legislature don't hold
- 34:52the counties accountable and California counties are
- 34:55extremely powerful, lot of resources, lot of very broad
- 35:00jurisdiction over the criminal justice system, behavioral
- 35:03health, If we don't get our counties aligned around
- 35:06solutions, we get blamed. I mean, like the mayors are
- 35:10accountable. You I go to the grocery store
- 35:12and it takes me two hours to get through the grocery store
- 35:14because people are angry and they want to tell me about all
- 35:18the problems. And you can't be like, well, the
- 35:20county does. I'm like, oh, the counties
- 35:21should do this and the state has this law and if only the
- 35:24legislature would do that. So look, the governor and I have
- 35:27disagreed on a few pretty high profile things.
- 35:31Prop 36, which was a criminal justice reform issue, sober
- 35:34living environments. And I've just, my argument has
- 35:39been, yes, it's, it's I understand what he's doing.
- 35:42He's holding a mirror up to Donald Trump, who is a threat to
- 35:46our democracy, and I disagree with many of his policies.
- 35:50I also firmly believe that our failure to solve our biggest
- 35:55problems in the country's largest and most prominent state
- 35:59has given the MAGA movement a tremendous amount of ammunition.
- 36:04It's a big part of what's giving oxygen to this movement, and the
- 36:08best resistance is delivering results on the issues that
- 36:11matter to people. But.
- 36:12There are norms like, do you say, you know, these CEOs giving
- 36:16you money, like have more of a backbone?
- 36:19You know, it's just, yeah, I just feel.
- 36:22Like, I'm intolation, to be perfectly honest, I don't spend
- 36:25a lot of time with tech CEOs, but I don't, I mean, I used to.
- 36:27They mail you a check and say yeah, 10 our mayor.
- 36:30Well, the, I mean, first of all, most people don't realize this.
- 36:34San Jose is the home of the workforce of tech.
- 36:38We don't have a lot of tech CEO's who live in San Jose.
- 36:40They live up in, you know, the fancy, you know, Palo Alto and
- 36:43Atherton and maybe up in San Francisco.
- 36:46We're a working city. We're people.
- 36:48We're the, you know, the engineers and the designers and
- 36:51the marketing folks and whatnot. They live in San Jose.
- 36:55Those are my neighbors and they're excited about my
- 36:59campaign because they see how much progress we've made in San
- 37:02Jose by bringing this very, to be fair, a, a cultural element
- 37:07of tech. The, the thing that I've done
- 37:09differently in City Hall over the last three plus years is
- 37:14bring a performance management mindset into government.
- 37:17I came in and was like we're, we're the, the failure motors.
- 37:20We're trying to be everything to everyone and it's not working.
- 37:22Let's pick no more than five things.
- 37:25Let's be focused. Let's set actual goals.
- 37:28Let's do the really uncomfortable thing of
- 37:29publishing them on the city website.
- 37:32Let's create some dashboards. Let's track the dollars we're
- 37:35spending, the staff time we're allocating.
- 37:38Let's measure performance. Let's publish our performance
- 37:41every 90 days. Let's look at it and reflect on
- 37:44it and let's start to create a feedback loop and be a little
- 37:47more iterative so that every 90 days to one year, which is every
- 37:5112 months, we do our budget cycle.
- 37:53We can make adjustments and say, well, we're spending money here,
- 37:56but it's not actually leading to any measurable improvement, so
- 37:59maybe we need to change it. That's been the unlock for us.
- 38:02And we've led the state in reducing homelessness, reducing
- 38:05crime, reducing blight, speeding up permitting.
- 38:09We've got thousands of new homes under construction.
- 38:11It's been bringing focus and performance management to City
- 38:15Hall, which is something that I get really excited about.
- 38:18And maybe in San Jose you can, you know, get constituents
- 38:21excited about. And I appreciate that.
- 38:23And I think that is sort of, you've enumerated a lot of the
- 38:27virtues of the tech industry and how they do business.
- 38:30How do you, but how do we get some of the corruption out of
- 38:33government? I mean, it's funny, I feel like
- 38:35it's been the right who's been railing about corruption in
- 38:39government. So I feel right wing saying it.
- 38:41But you know, like some of the crypto stuff, the Trump
- 38:43administration is doing how they want executives to treat them.
- 38:47I mean, it is the biggest public graft of like all time.
- 38:50If we weren't dragged into 500 different issues everyday, this
- 38:54would be a huge 1. And it matters, you know, as a
- 38:57business writer, because I'm trying to hold people, you know,
- 39:01there's, there are norms of business and it's like there are
- 39:03expectations of what you're supposed to do.
- 39:05And if we descend as America into a culture where it's like,
- 39:09I've got to get mine and like, you're a sucker if you don't do
- 39:12XYZ, like that's going to be like the death of America.
- 39:15And so I don't know. Do you have any ideas on what we
- 39:17can do to regain a culture of honest dealing in in business,
- 39:22even as the president sort of begs people to to be dishonest?
- 39:26Yeah, I I think one of the big challenges really flows from the
- 39:32Citizens United notion that your political spending is simply
- 39:38speech and should be unlimited. And the disclosure, the piece
- 39:43is, is important, it's valuable, but it's sort of insufficient,
- 39:48the dynamic. And I'm much more familiar with
- 39:50what happens within California because I've been serving at the
- 39:52city level and thinking about counties and how we interface
- 39:55with our state government. But.
- 39:57These are Californian businesses that I'm worried about.
- 39:59Yeah, that's, that's fair. I'm just saying I, I can give
- 40:02you the, the, I imagine it's the same at the federal level.
- 40:05I'm just not, I don't spend, I don't spend time in Washington,
- 40:08But I mean, I've been maybe twice since I got elected mayor,
- 40:12but I. I can tell you mechanistically
- 40:16that the failure mode and the, the form of corruption, if you
- 40:21will, is not as straightforward as you might think, but it's,
- 40:24it's effectively there's a policy status quo that's in
- 40:28place or, or maybe there's been a recent change.
- 40:32But if it's not optimal for society and someone wants to
- 40:35change it, you have a, an idealistic legislator who wants
- 40:38to change something. I ran into this couple years
- 40:40ago, getting a legislator, A legislator to carry a bill for
- 40:43me. I can give you the example later
- 40:45if you're interested. And we just ran into a buzz saw,
- 40:47special interest power and basically the groups, these
- 40:52outside groups spend so much both lobbying off cycle.
- 40:57They've got a full Time Team up there writing legislation,
- 41:00taking people out to lunch, hanging out, just kind of
- 41:03monitoring and spending a lot of time and meshed within the
- 41:06legislative world. And I mean, they spend so much
- 41:10money around elections that it does.
- 41:12I, I think for many of these legislators, it just becomes a
- 41:15calculus of like, why would I take on changing the status quo
- 41:19if it means that somebody's going to dump $1,000,000 in
- 41:21negative ads against me and I'm going to lose my seat in two
- 41:24years anyway. And that becomes the calculus.
- 41:27And it's not clear enough to the voters why change doesn't
- 41:31happen. And I really believe that's the
- 41:33primary mechanism. There may be other things that
- 41:35happened that I'm not aware of. But I tried to change this
- 41:38construction defect law because it's it's having an impact on
- 41:42our ability to get condos built. And that matters because condos
- 41:45are the most accessible form of home ownership.
- 41:48And basically Sacramento didn't want to touch it because it was
- 41:51kind of like, well, the, you know, the travellers are really
- 41:54powerful and they've sort of already come to an understanding
- 41:58with the building community. And there's just kind of like
- 42:00everybody's happy, Like don't, don't touch it.
- 42:02Yeah. I mean, I'm sympathetic.
- 42:03I mean, what you're saying California's complicated because
- 42:06it's like there are all sorts of unions that have become
- 42:09extremely powerful in a way, sometimes more powerful than
- 42:12through the big business. World by spending the most, but
- 42:15yeah. I mean, I guess I'm, I'm more
- 42:19incensed on the sort of like I'm going to cozy up to Trump
- 42:22specifically and then he's going to use the antitrust authority
- 42:25or whatever. Yeah, let me.
- 42:27Well, OK, so let's talk about that.
- 42:28I mean, I, I think what is really, yeah, I think it's
- 42:32incredibly concerning. I think unfortunately tech
- 42:36didn't engage in politics for so long and which was probably a
- 42:40good thing. And I think the culture for a
- 42:42long time was avoidance. Tech was like, hey, I'm we're
- 42:45out here in California, let us do our thing, leave us alone.
- 42:48There was this very libertarian undercurrent that still I think
- 42:52largely exists in Silicon Valley.
- 42:55And but then as tech became more powerful and government started
- 43:00to engage, suddenly I think they realized how to play the game.
- 43:03And now they've figured it out at a scale and in a way that is
- 43:07that is more powerful than almost any other industry.
- 43:11And it's, it's really, it is concerning.
- 43:15I think the, the question, well, one, I don't think tech's
- 43:19monolithic. I think we have to take it sub
- 43:21industry by sub industry. So like crypto, you make a
- 43:24great, you make a great point, right?
- 43:26There are other elements of technology like, I don't know,
- 43:31solar and batteries, like that's tech, but it's a different kind
- 43:35of tech that I'm less, I'm less worried about.
- 43:37And the startup economy generally, like, I believe in
- 43:39that philosophy. I think that is, yeah, it's
- 43:43great. It's like create new businesses.
- 43:44Now, sometimes they're worried about regulation on stuff like
- 43:47AI because, you know, regulations can protect the big
- 43:50businesses and hurt the small ones.
- 43:52But generally, I think, you know, the startup agenda is good
- 43:55for America by and large. Yeah, I think so.
- 43:58I think our our entrepreneurship is a real strength and all that
- 44:01creativity and dynamism and we we want to be at the fore.
- 44:04What do you make, You know, Congressman Ro Khanna has
- 44:07clearly made the calculation that tech is not is very
- 44:10unpopular. Like, yeah, yeah, you're running
- 44:13for governor, you know, not so friendly.
- 44:16Like, I've learned a lot from tech.
- 44:17And I don't know what do you make of his political calculus
- 44:20here, or this is just true belief, or what do you make of
- 44:23his sort of turn against the hometown industry?
- 44:28Yeah, it's so noteworthy. I I try not to spend a lot of
- 44:30time serving this work. With people as political.
- 44:33Pundit, I mean, I I've openly and publicly disagreed with the
- 44:37Congress member on the on his position on the wealth tax and I
- 44:40already gave you my my main reasons why I really just the
- 44:43unintended consequences of it. I don't know.
- 44:46Just wealth tax, it's like everything.
- 44:48He feels like he's looking for a fight.
- 44:50Yeah, I don't know what else what else lately.
- 44:52I don't know, I'm not following. Up to it.
- 44:56Well, one of the big discussions, and I don't know so
- 44:58that he's weighed in on this, but here's another one where I
- 45:02have concerns. There's this question of when
- 45:04does a human need to be in the loop?
- 45:06And at the at the high level, the idea that a human should be
- 45:09able to review decisions that involve safety, certainly life
- 45:14and death decisions sounds really good.
- 45:16It makes a lot of sense. But the details really matter.
- 45:19There's a push right now to say, well, the the logical extension
- 45:24of that principle is that we should have a human in every
- 45:27autonomous vehicle because you never know, there could be a
- 45:29case where the human needs to override what the vehicle does.
- 45:32Now, the data is already pretty clear from way MO, for example,
- 45:37that the autonomous vehicles on autonomous vehicles on average
- 45:41are much safer than human drivers.
- 45:42And so there's this big tug of war going on where, you know,
- 45:46largely, you know, labour unions who don't want to see job
- 45:49displacement. And they're right to worry about
- 45:51it. I'm worried about job
- 45:52displacement. It's a very legitimate concern,
- 45:55but may lead to a sort of ossification of society, pushing
- 46:00innovation out and say, well, we've got to have a human in
- 46:03every vehicle, which completely defeats the point.
- 46:05Yeah. I'm a radical on this issue for
- 46:07sure. It's like, what are we fighting
- 46:09for? Horse drawn carriages.
- 46:10Still, that's kind of my point. You.
- 46:11Spend time in a way MO it's like this.
- 46:13Is it works? So much better and and as
- 46:15progressives should love them in that like cars kill people and
- 46:19like. Yeah, you can, yeah.
- 46:20They could be central, You could control them more from the
- 46:22government. You could also go here.
- 46:23You can't go this fast. You can't like I'm.
- 46:26The least popular guy on the board of our transit agency,
- 46:29Because I keep talking about autonomy as part of the future
- 46:32of transit because it frankly will allow us to offer a better
- 46:37service to more people more quickly and more efficiently.
- 46:40And we need to plan for it. And if you think of the.
- 46:42Elderly who can't drive, you know, there's so many
- 46:44progressive the disabled. Sorry, I know I'm preaching to
- 46:47the converted here, but. So that's the optimistic side of
- 46:50tech. I mean, I think with tech it's
- 46:52always OK. You get new capabilities that
- 46:55can make life better and you want to maximize the deployment
- 46:58of new tools that make people's lives better while minimizing
- 47:02the whether it's privacy risk or the the loss of agency or the
- 47:08political corruption. To your point, and it's yeah, I
- 47:12just, I don't think there's an easy answer though, to how to
- 47:15how to. I mean, regulation is really the
- 47:17primary answer to curbing the excesses, Do you?
- 47:20Think. But we have to get it right
- 47:23because we could also just push it to other, not just other.
- 47:26States, but other country, I mean at once it's like you're
- 47:29saying I don't know California is one of the top 10.
- 47:34If, if it was, you know, it's own country, it'd be.
- 47:35What number 4 or? 5 Right, exactly.
- 47:38By GDP. By GDP, yeah.
- 47:40So by that argument it's like take some responsibility,
- 47:43regulate, you know, come up with your own regulations.
- 47:46This is a big place with a lot of people.
- 47:48We have our own views and obviously there have been what I
- 47:51think auto regulations, right, with fuel economy.
- 47:54There have been areas where California is, yeah,
- 47:55particularly. On environmental policy, we've
- 47:58often been out in front. So how much do you think
- 48:01California should embrace that when it comes to the tech
- 48:04industry versus taking a posture of these need to be federal
- 48:08because you're going to scare out industry from our state?
- 48:10Yeah, again, this is going to be an unsatisfying answer.
- 48:13I I think it depends on the type of regulation.
- 48:15I I do, I am generally a believer in the notion of
- 48:19decentralization. And you know, we're not France
- 48:21where everything emanates from Paris.
- 48:23We are, we have 50 states. Those states are laboratories I
- 48:27have pushed back against. There was a bill somebody
- 48:30proposed that would have allowed every city in California to
- 48:32regulate autonomous vehicles. And I was very much against that
- 48:35for obvious reasons. But when it comes to this
- 48:40evolving policy landscape, given how close we are to what's
- 48:44changing in California in this area, I think it makes sense for
- 48:48us to be able to regulate. I mean, we, we need to figure
- 48:51out how to protect our children. I think we've, we've made a lot
- 48:54of progress. Now you're seeing cell phones
- 48:55being banned in schools, which I think is a good thing.
- 48:58It's crazy. Isn't a new parent just the
- 49:01idea? It's just like everybody in tech
- 49:04knows about the danger of phones.
- 49:05That's the other irony. It's like, I feel like people in
- 49:07the industry are like, I don't know, don't let my kids on the
- 49:09phone. I think that's right.
- 49:10I think people in tech are less likely to have their kids using
- 49:13devices all day or if at all, right.
- 49:15I mean, we're, we're pretty anti screen in, in our home and
- 49:18really very cognizant of the risks.
- 49:21So I think protecting our children's a no brainer.
- 49:23I would not want to wait for the federal government to figure
- 49:26something out. If a state wants to experiment
- 49:28with basic, you know, privacy safety.
- 49:31We just passed a bunch of changes policies in San Jose
- 49:36that really limit how we use our license plate readers.
- 49:39So on the one hand, automated license plate readers are very
- 49:42powerful law enforcement tool. On the other hand, I, I, you
- 49:45know, we don't want to create a, we don't do facial recognition.
- 49:50We don't want to create a surveillance state, some sort of
- 49:52Big Brother where we've stored all of your movements for all
- 49:56time. And now we can go back and I
- 49:59think it'd be really creepy to kind of know everything about
- 50:01where you've ever gone. So we delete all the data every
- 50:0330 days. So it's really useful in the
- 50:05short run if there's a crime to be able to say, well, we need to
- 50:07respond and figure out who did this and apprehend the person
- 50:10and, and have enough evidence. But on the other hand, we're
- 50:14really limiting what we collect, how we collect it.
- 50:17We're very transparent. We tell people what what we
- 50:20collect and why. And we have very strict data
- 50:23retention policies, meaning we delete the data regularly.
- 50:25So we're, we're regulating tech at the local level, which is it
- 50:30depends on the right, right. Right.
- 50:32And I mean, that's the answer that makes sense that it depends
- 50:34on the issue and you don't want to like give away the total
- 50:36authority, but you know, you sort of have to take a balanced
- 50:38approach and and on AI specifically, like are you using
- 50:44language models? Like how, I mean, you said you
- 50:46were enthusiasts about about autonomous, but the sort of
- 50:49other pieces of what's happening in AI.
- 50:50Are you a big user? And like, what's your view of, I
- 50:54don't know, the rate of progress and how much this is going to be
- 50:56a concern for government, for the next governor?
- 50:59Yeah, I do use models. I, I don't, I wouldn't say I'm a
- 51:03power user, but I, I certainly find that there's a, there's a
- 51:07different and and very meaningful use case over and
- 51:10above search. Obviously, we've created a
- 51:14custom GPT around our budget process where we've uploaded
- 51:18past budget documents and then generated insights in a way that
- 51:23would have taken a lot of manual work.
- 51:25I'm especially excited though, about how city workers are using
- 51:28these tools. We have city employees who have
- 51:30gone through our AI upskilling course, built a custom GPT for
- 51:35whatever their job function is. A couple that come to mind are
- 51:38one woman in our Department of Transportation was applying for
- 51:42a grant, put various documents into a GPT and refined her
- 51:48application. And then when that grant, it was
- 51:51a federal grant that the Trump administration then basically
- 51:54invalidated she because she had this tool and it ingested all of
- 51:59this information. She was able to quickly pivot
- 52:02and apply for a different grant at the state level and she
- 52:04secured dollars, but she never would have made the deadline had
- 52:07she needed to basically like manually start from scratch
- 52:10again. And then we've got a, we've got
- 52:12somebody in our, I think it's in our IT department who took our
- 52:15311 data. And as people are calling in
- 52:18for, you know, potholes and graffiti and, and different
- 52:21service calls, there's our one of the biggest categories, of
- 52:24course, is other where it's not, it's not well classified.
- 52:28He basically built a classifier that saves 500 hours a year of,
- 52:33of what was previously a lot of manual classification.
- 52:35So I think there are a lot of interesting applications of
- 52:39these tools. I generally think, though, that
- 52:41if we invest in people and their training and education and
- 52:44expose them to these tools, particularly at a young age, and
- 52:47give them some guardrails and the confidence to experiment,
- 52:51they'll figure out how to adapt the tools.
- 52:53And you may see tasks automated. But most of the jobs we do
- 52:57inside City Hall at least are complex enough that I don't
- 53:02think they're going to be eliminated.
- 53:03I think they'll be enhanced by. A.
- 53:05Do you think there are any circumstances where, you know,
- 53:10states should embrace what the New Jersey like gasoline
- 53:14attendant model, where it's like we need to protect jobs in this
- 53:18industry because things are being disrupted too fast?
- 53:21Like, are jobs alone a reason to slow the pace of AI development
- 53:26or to sort of make make rules? I'm hesitant because I don't
- 53:31know at that point, as you create that constituency around
- 53:36jobs that otherwise wouldn't exist, how you make the
- 53:39decision, if ever, to eliminate them.
- 53:42And so I think that in the long run, it is better to allow
- 53:49innovation, though we do have to buffer.
- 53:52So, So really the question is we have to buffer people from the
- 53:55impacts of technological change. Technological change generally
- 53:59leads us to a place where there are a number of benefits, but
- 54:01the transition is really hard. So the question is just how to
- 54:05best buffer people. One is you try to freeze things
- 54:09in place and say these jobs have to exist, even if they're no
- 54:12longer necessary or very productive.
- 54:13We're just going to create the jobs because we want people to
- 54:15be working. I feel like that kind of
- 54:17devalues those workers in that work and eventually it may kind
- 54:21of seem like a farce and they may feel like why am I doing
- 54:23this thing that I don't need to do?
- 54:26So I'm a little skeptical of that approach.
- 54:29I think another approach, of course, is a Ubi, although that
- 54:32also doesn't, there's no work involved with that, right?
- 54:35So that's another way of sort of protecting people, but it
- 54:38doesn't particularly value work. And then there's my preference,
- 54:41and I would hope that this would manage most of the transition,
- 54:44even if you need some of the other two categories, is to
- 54:47invest early and often in the training, the skills, the access
- 54:51to tools, and allow people themselves to create new jobs,
- 54:56new companies, evolve their existing jobs and become more
- 54:58productive. Now that's idealistic, but I do
- 55:01see evidence of that happening. We're doing that City Hall.
- 55:02We have 1000 workers going through our AI upskilling course
- 55:06and they're changing in their jobs by applying these tools in
- 55:09new ways. And that that's actually what
- 55:10happened with past information technology people.
- 55:14We started using smartphones before that PCs, you know, the
- 55:19word, the office suite. I mean it's, you know, so you
- 55:23know, we started using Excel spreadsheets.
- 55:25Most of those did not dramatically destroy jobs so
- 55:29much as change the way the jobs were done.
- 55:32Right. I mean, I feel like one of my
- 55:34more AI pilled concerns is just, yeah, I mean, you hear like Sam
- 55:39Altman talk about it and just this access to AI and sort of
- 55:42intelligence is going to be another sort of dividing line in
- 55:46who has sort of. So I'll make a point on that,
- 55:50which it's only a starting point and we have a, we have a lot of
- 55:53work to do here. But last year we launched AI for
- 55:56all and San Jose became the first city in the world to get 3
- 56:00of the leading AI companies. So Google Anthropic and Open AI
- 56:05to collaborate. And that we created a portal
- 56:08through our websites with this this Lander on our website at
- 56:12the through our library where anyone with a library cards,
- 56:14that's 700,000 people in San Jose get access to the tools
- 56:20training, including self-guided tutorials.
- 56:22We're doing some in person trainings and then there are
- 56:26some licenses for unique courses that in some cases would be
- 56:31paid. And so we're trying to get these
- 56:32companies to start opening up more of the tools and training
- 56:36for anyone through our library system.
- 56:39I'm, I'm going back to the Trump thing because honestly, I feel
- 56:43like I agree with you and sort of tonally on a lot of it, but
- 56:48the one I'm concerned about is just if we become more anti
- 56:53democratic on the federal level, like are you what do?
- 56:56You mean more well? It's just like if like we don't
- 56:58have a free, we don't have free election or like not not anti
- 57:02democratic like the Democratic. Party does more like succeed
- 57:04but. We become more authoritarian
- 57:06like California in particular has an important role to play in
- 57:11like standing up for the American like Democratic
- 57:14project. And what makes you feel like
- 57:16you're prepared to take on that mantle?
- 57:19Well, even as mayor, we've sued the Trump administration.
- 57:22I mean, we've, we've joined a number of lawsuits and we've
- 57:25passed local regulations much more limited than what I think
- 57:28we can do at the state level. But there's no doubt California
- 57:32has a critical role to play in offering a a counterpoint, in
- 57:36fact, showing that our values work and practice and are are
- 57:39distinct from and better than what Trump is offering.
- 57:43But also using the power of our legal team.
- 57:46Our attorney general has been, has done a great job of, you
- 57:51know, really prosecuting the case against Trump's overreach
- 57:56and abuse of power, from withholding funds to the
- 58:00birthright citizenship issue to reproductive rights and so
- 58:04forth. And so I, I think continuing to
- 58:06use the law, the bully pulpit and the power of a, a better
- 58:12example, I suppose you could say are, are some of the tools in
- 58:16our, in our toolkit. But I just, I think there are
- 58:19limits to the rhetorical game. It's as important as it is, I
- 58:26don't think we're going to out meme Donald Trump or that we're
- 58:29going to beat him on XI. Think it's going to be
- 58:32ultimately in the in the courts and in delivering better
- 58:36outcomes and getting people to actually vote with their feet
- 58:38and want to come back to blue states.
- 58:40What is your path to being governor like?
- 58:43What can people watching this podcast do to support the
- 58:46campaign? So I'm at Mahan for
- 58:49california.com is the website. You can find me all over, all
- 58:53over social media, as you would expect, I mean.
- 58:57Mom, Donnie, I feel like he won on TikTok or like, have you
- 59:00figured out and you're a guy, you know, like the social media
- 59:03stuff? Yeah.
- 59:04What do you do? You feel like you've found your
- 59:06platform. I think mom Donnie would say
- 59:08that he that he won in a lot of different ways.
- 59:11I think social media was part of it.
- 59:12He he really highlighted the door knocking.
- 59:14I know they do. Not like the video I mean.
- 59:15I think the videos were powerful.
- 59:17Those were good. Don't underestimate.
- 59:18He also spent more on television than Cuomo, so it wasn't just a
- 59:21single all. All campaigns are multi channel
- 59:24and they try to reach people from every angle.
- 59:26And that's not to take anything away from what he did.
- 59:28I mean, I, I think the way that they used short form video is,
- 59:35you know, pretty inspired. I think it's very powerful and
- 59:37we're, we're doing our best to kind of adapt, you know, to
- 59:41those mediums and, and find our own footing there.
- 59:44It won't, you know, my policies are not the same.
- 59:46Obviously I'm much more centrist And so, but we're, we're the,
- 59:50the medium itself, the media are, are quite powerful.
- 59:54So yeah, people can find me on Instagram and TikTok.
- 59:58The election the the primary is June 2nd and in California we
- 1:00:01thankfully we have. An open top two primary, meaning
- 1:00:05whether you're a Democrat, independent or Republican, you
- 1:00:08can still vote for me. If you want to see common sense
- 1:00:12leadership that actually is focused on solving our biggest
- 1:00:15problems in California and providing that that very real
- 1:00:18counterpoint to the Trump administration.
- 1:00:20That's what I'm all about. And we've.
- 1:00:23Yeah, we've had a great start. I only jumped in a few weeks
- 1:00:25ago. I'm starting with low name ID.
- 1:00:29So I was late. Yeah.
- 1:00:30Yeah. Well, I mean late I guess is
- 1:00:33it's very subjective, but I jumped in later than I was the
- 1:00:35last major candidate. Were you still sort of deciding
- 1:00:38or? You know, to be perfectly
- 1:00:39honest, I wasn't planning to do it at least last year.
- 1:00:42I I've love being mayor. I've got a great job and my wife
- 1:00:46loves her day job. We have two little kids.
- 1:00:47They're happy in their schools and on their soccer teams.
- 1:00:50Our plan, if you will, was not to try to go move to Sacramento
- 1:00:54and take on this task. But I was watching the race last
- 1:00:58year, which is when all the other candidates got in.
- 1:01:01And as we got to the beginning of of this year, there just felt
- 1:01:06to me to be a huge void in the race.
- 1:01:08I actually got home early January from a transit board
- 1:01:11meeting and my wife looked, it was probably about 10:30 at
- 1:01:13night and she just looked at me and said, I think you need to
- 1:01:15get in this race, which was my jaw hit the floor because she,
- 1:01:19you know, we both know what that means.
- 1:01:21I mean, I've, I've been on the road almost non-stop.
- 1:01:23It's a big state here. I am with you out of New York.
- 1:01:26Here in New York City all over. The place and we have little
- 1:01:30kids, so it's been hard on our family.
- 1:01:32But you know, Sylvia, my wife, like me, is concerned.
- 1:01:36We're worried about this rising populism on the right, the
- 1:01:40reaction on the left, and this sort of people looking for easy
- 1:01:46answers rather than a real clarity around the the
- 1:01:50limitations we face, the real tradeoffs we face, what's
- 1:01:53realistic, what we should expect from our government.
- 1:01:56We need to rebuild trust in government and I don't think we
- 1:01:59do that by being the loudest, the most sensational, the most
- 1:02:04gratuitous in our politics. We've increased trust in City
- 1:02:08Hall in San Jose and my time as mayor by 40% by delivering
- 1:02:14results for people, by speeding up the buses, filling the
- 1:02:17potholes, reducing homelessness, reducing crime, cleaning up the
- 1:02:21streets, speeding up permitting. You get government start working
- 1:02:24again and you take that oxygen away from anti Democratic again,
- 1:02:30lowercase D Democrat impulses on the right and the left.
- 1:02:35And so that's that's what motivated me to jump in.
- 1:02:37And frankly, if you look at the rest of the field in California
- 1:02:40right now, the two leading Republicans are going as hard
- 1:02:42right as they can, catering to Trump and trying to be the
- 1:02:44standard bearer of the modern movement.
- 1:02:46I don't know. Steve Hilton and Chad Bianco are
- 1:02:48like, you know. Hilton's like ATV sort.
- 1:02:50Of he was a Fox News, Yeah. Not the main one even like yeah,
- 1:02:54but. Yeah, sorry.
- 1:02:55And then and then the other leading Dems, at least up to
- 1:02:59this point, have been basically just trying to be the most anti
- 1:03:03Trump possible, which I understand.
- 1:03:05I mean, I agree with them philosophically and say many of
- 1:03:09the same things. But if that's your whole message
- 1:03:12and you just know what you're against or you I think
- 1:03:15incorrectly try to pretend that Trump is the reason that
- 1:03:19California is struggling, which is just not.
- 1:03:23It's not. It's not Trump and it's, you
- 1:03:25know, frankly, it's not even, I don't even think you can blame
- 1:03:28tech for our problems. I'm not saying that tech has
- 1:03:31been perfect or shouldn't do more.
- 1:03:32Believe me, tech should. And it should be regulated.
- 1:03:34And all those things are true. And Trump is awful and that's
- 1:03:37true. But none of that's like the
- 1:03:39reason that our public schools are underperforming for low
- 1:03:42income students or we've increased spending by 75% and
- 1:03:47homelessness hasn't gone down or that crime is what it like.
- 1:03:51These are just not connected. And it's so much easier to just
- 1:03:55say, oh, it's Trump or it's the billionaires or for the guys on
- 1:03:58the right to say it's these failed Democrats.
- 1:04:00We need to start getting more specific about what are the
- 1:04:03actual policies that are in the way or that need to be changed
- 1:04:06to make our lives better. Mayor Mahan, thank you so much
- 1:04:09for coming on the show. Thanks for having fun, it's good
- 1:04:11to see you. That's the newcomer podcast.
- 1:04:14Thanks so much to Matt Mahan for coming out to New York and
- 1:04:16recording with me. I think he might have been in
- 1:04:18town for The Daily Show, but happy to have him on the
- 1:04:21newcomer podcast. While he was here.
- 1:04:23I had a lot of fun, like comment, subscribe.
- 1:04:26As you know, this is a growing YouTube channel.
- 1:04:28I also have another podcast called this Ruble Valley Show
- 1:04:30with Max Child and James Wilsterman.
- 1:04:32I think it's pretty funny. It's a very different vibe.
- 1:04:34It's, you know, a host show for doing power rankings.
- 1:04:37You know we want to be the ringer if TBPN is Sports Center
- 1:04:41for tech, we want to be the ringer for tech.
- 1:04:43So you know this this is hard hitting interviews.
- 1:04:47That's fun chat show together. You can have you know your
- 1:04:49vegetables and your your cake yeah Anyway, you can find me on
- 1:04:54slep stack at newcomer.co and we'll see you with some great
- 1:04:56episodes coming up. I'm excited at the pipeline and
- 1:04:58guests we have coming and please comment suggest people we should
- 1:05:01have on the show. I'm just getting sassed.
- 1:05:03People are sassing me more in the beginning.
- 1:05:04I haven't improved that much. So give me your feedback and
- 1:05:08thanks. Thanks for following this
- 1:05:09growing channel.