Latest / Newcomer Pod / Defogging Our 2021 Amnesia
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome. What I did was I went on to
- 0:14technium a few minutes for we started recording and I looked
- 0:17at the top, couple news stories on the 1st and the 15th of the
- 0:21month so I figured I could get like, whatever the biggest story
- 0:24was beginning in the middle and then kind of scroll down to see
- 0:27the long tail because usually they'll be like a big story and
- 0:29then it Much of follow-ons. So that that was my process.
- 0:33Okay, and I should disclose the top.
- 0:37I this process is not very scientific and I missed a bunch
- 0:40of things in it. That probably would be
- 0:41considered the biggest stories of the year, which to me were,
- 0:45but what I will not bring up our the meme stalk, AMC, GameStop
- 0:50that whole thing which happened this year.
- 0:52And if you even remember that, that was a thing.
- 0:54At the beginning of the year, I didn't get the capital riot.
- 1:00Or Facebooks non role role in the organizing of that AT&T
- 1:05spinning off were media and merging it with Discovery and
- 1:09then Facebook name change to Metta.
- 1:12We're all things that I just remembered having happened this
- 1:15year but did not pick up in the technium, okay?
- 1:18So just want me to go through the list and we can just Riff
- 1:20on, whatever, whatever I come up with.
- 1:22Yeah, this is great. I mean, wow, this is most
- 1:24productive 15 minutes. Yeah, right, well, I'll tell you
- 1:27what, I was not doing the thing that I get paid.
- 1:30For okay. So so the thing that so, its
- 1:37first of the year, biggest story cyber hack sources,
- 1:41investigators are checking, if solarwinds was hacked via its
- 1:43offices, in check, Geo, Poland and Belarus where the company
- 1:48moved, much of its engineering. So basic there was this giant
- 1:51hacked. You remember this?
- 1:52The solarwinds hack maybe Katie you do because that might have.
- 1:54I do remember this? Yeah amazing.
- 1:58Yeah, but if you would ask me what year, I And I don't know
- 2:01that I would have said this year.
- 2:02Yeah, it was a long time ago. Long ago.
- 2:05Right? It was a huge hack though.
- 2:07And I think Microsoft was like compromised.
- 2:09Our does it. Yeah, I think Russia was
- 2:12obviously involved. And so there was like, a lot of
- 2:14hard talk between the incoming Biden Administration and Russia.
- 2:19Anyway, no one really remembers it now, but that was the biggest
- 2:22story in January January. Well, one of the reasons it was
- 2:26a big deal is because solarwinds was a subcontractor.
- 2:30Basically two big tech companies.
- 2:32So by hacking solarwinds it was like the hackers were able to
- 2:36get into lots of different companies and it reminded the
- 2:39federal government. A lot of other people that we
- 2:42should be paying attention, not just to Microsoft and Google,
- 2:45but all of the companies that they use to keep our data
- 2:48secure, especially when the clients or people like federal
- 2:52government agencies, right? Who are who were hacked by a
- 2:56solar ones, right? And it's what I feel.
- 2:58Like we've reached a point where there are so many Things to be
- 3:00worried about when it comes to the safety of our shit.
- 3:04That I don't feel like my major hacks get a ton of play anymore.
- 3:07Yeah, because they happen so often sort of like, oh, what's
- 3:10the big deal? But the thing is, is that, I
- 3:13mean, yes, they happen all the time.
- 3:15I can totally understand why people are having a hard time
- 3:17like getting it getting interested in yet another hack.
- 3:21But what they show is that big tech companies are now part of
- 3:25the National Security apparatus. So if you think about our
- 3:29national Abilities. Yes a vulnerability.
- 3:32Like yes flying a plane into a large building is still a
- 3:37vulnerability that we're working hard to make sure it never
- 3:40happens again and yes, other sorts of attacks are
- 3:43vulnerabilities that we want to never happen.
- 3:45Here attacks on the subway etcetera, plate, things we've
- 3:47seen in other countries, but hacks of major corporations and
- 3:51of our critical infrastructure, our banking system are now also
- 3:55National Security issues, but they're so sprawling.
- 3:58Like the To surface is so huge. It's literally every person who
- 4:03uses the internet who works for a major corporation that there's
- 4:07no way the government can plug the risk in the way they can
- 4:11with say planes flying into a big building.
- 4:14And so now it is literally up to Corporate America to take care
- 4:18of our national security. Okay, so January fit, I don't
- 4:22know why this one caught my eye but Cameo hired like 10
- 4:24different, Executives to work. There Cameo huge, pandemic.
- 4:28Winner was raised. Raising, you know, hundreds of
- 4:31millions this year. I think.
- 4:33Anyway, that was a thing, right? So it's like Cameo clubhouse,
- 4:37right? Well, guess the clubhouse
- 4:38because that's funny. So February 1st, Robin Hood
- 4:42raises 2.4 billion from shareholders.
- 4:44Just have to raise, a Robin Hood raises, a shitload of money.
- 4:47They're obviously one of the big stories this year as we move
- 4:49into the mean stocks thing and they also go public later in the
- 4:53year. So that was a big thing
- 4:54beginning of February. So yeah.
- 4:56So I had line from Ben Thompson in strata Curry.
- 5:00Clubhouse which centralizes creation and consumption into a
- 5:02feedback loop will do for audio. What Twitter stories and
- 5:05Tick-Tock did for text images and video?
- 5:08Yeah. Sorry.
- 5:08Ben didn't happen II? Do like, I mean, that already,
- 5:14it's like clubhouses the story for the year.
- 5:16I want to dig into that. I mean because it is quite it
- 5:20has sort of the It's not quite a meme stock, but there were a lot
- 5:24of influencers or rushing on their thinking, oh, I can sort
- 5:27of, have a land grab, we had sort of Andreessen Horowitz,
- 5:31trying to make it happen, it right.
- 5:33It fit with the pandemic in that, we were all excited about
- 5:37it because we were bored at home and we totally forgotten what
- 5:41real life Joy was like. And so happy to have sort of
- 5:45this simulacrum of it with these.
- 5:47We're all weird. Audio chat rooms.
- 5:51I do think Clubhouse is a pretty, I mean, was it all time
- 5:56in the pandemic? I mean, was it mostly this year,
- 5:58like, the, the the rise of Clubhouse, it launched before II
- 6:03think it was in. Yeah, I think it was basically,
- 6:06the short of this winter or like just before the springtime,
- 6:11right? When people started talking
- 6:12about the fact that Clubhouse wasn't going to make it because
- 6:16the minute we could get out of our homes and do something else
- 6:19we would. And so, you saw people being
- 6:21like, That's ridiculous. Like, this is the most
- 6:23compelling audio, but then by April, it was sort of less
- 6:30exciting to be on clubhouse. I think I deleted the app.
- 6:33So this was the fall of Clubhouse.
- 6:35The rise of Clubhouse was 2020. Exactly.
- 6:39I think it's a very it was the Omicron of trends like I think
- 6:43it Rose and crashed fairly soon after right now.
- 6:47Like it did. I remember when things were
- 6:49getting real? Hot was like when What's his
- 6:52name? Shriram and his wife were
- 6:54hosting a weekly room in the evenings and that was when suck
- 6:57showed up. And I think right?
- 6:59Ilan showed up and when was that I want to say beginning of this
- 7:03year or something like Elon Musk, or right?
- 7:06So he would show up in member. There was a little fight from
- 7:08the journalist that were like Marc Andreessen banza, Elon Musk
- 7:12bus Clubhouse. Limit fan stream to YouTube was
- 7:15February 20, 21. This is a this year story, I
- 7:17write winner this year. We were going ballistic over.
- 7:21We saw it Peak like in february/march.
- 7:24Yeah, but basically by May when people were about starting to
- 7:28get vaccinated and they were let out of their homes, people had
- 7:31stopped using it and then by June.
- 7:33Remember the month, June, when the pandemic ended and we were
- 7:37all happy. Nobody was on clubhouse in this
- 7:40year. And that was kind of the end
- 7:41Clubhouse. This is the your Clubhouse.
- 7:44That's the most compelling so far.
- 7:45All right, keep going. Yeah, okay, back to that.
- 7:47Sure, as story about Lyme raising money, Honey, I'm going
- 7:52to skip that slime scooter company.
- 7:54This scooter is good skier. I mean it's hard.
- 7:56It's not a good story the year because it feels very like
- 7:59pandemic asterisk, like they were falling.
- 8:02But then right, who knows? It's fine.
- 8:04They're still around, which is more than I think, a lot of
- 8:06people were expecting. I took one yesterday.
- 8:10This is now getting into March. Every Apple Store in the u.s. is
- 8:13open for the first time, since March 2012, he starred in offer
- 8:16in store shopping. Well, yeah.
- 8:18Okay, March. Yeah.
- 8:22Stripe raises 600 million from Sequoia and others that
- 8:24evaluation of 95 billion dollars becoming the most valuable
- 8:27private company. In Silicon Valley, stripe is
- 8:30going to go public, what next year.
- 8:32Eric, that's the plan I ever. I mean, it's one of these
- 8:35companies. People always say next year, but
- 8:37I do think that's likely. I mean, Chris sacca told me an
- 8:40interview. He was getting offers on
- 8:41secondary for, like, 200 billion.
- 8:44I mean, I think the story, You could say that it 2021 was not
- 8:53the year of stripe because that's what stripe wanted.
- 8:56I mean they get some news coverage with like Fast grants,
- 8:59they're doing more charity stuff, but in some due to some
- 9:02degree I think stripe is enormous company stripe is
- 9:06enormous company for how little it gets covered.
- 9:10Like I mean I would write well that's because think about what
- 9:12they do. I mean that is not a compelling.
- 9:15It's a Selling company. And that it makes a lot of
- 9:17money, but in terms of finding a narrative, right?
- 9:20I mean, I'm one of the people who should be writing about it
- 9:23more, I think it's a big company but it is sort of like what's,
- 9:27what's the exciting story to write about striae sky's the
- 9:30limit on valuation. They're disrupting VC, they've
- 9:33got celebrity, you know, CEOs, right?
- 9:36They do. Oh, that's right.
- 9:37This film has a really nice. Yeah.
- 9:40I like them or anyone, you know? I mean they're, you know,
- 9:44they're Charming. Irish Brothers.
- 9:45They Are they very much are lovely?
- 9:49Yeah there was a mini. There was a mini stripe.
- 9:52It's funny that the stripe takedown occurred.
- 9:54I think I just like Hacker News. Someone complaining was they got
- 9:58there was one, they got offered a job basically by a recruiter
- 10:03and then it got rescinded and their accusations that stripe
- 10:06handled sort of, you know, had poor treatment of recruiters
- 10:11some Outlet. Like I think I might've been
- 10:13protocol stood up some of the accusations ins and one of the
- 10:16Collison's went on Hacker News to respond but to I just think
- 10:21it's an interesting case study because it's almost engineer's
- 10:24have such strong opinions and like true hardcore, Silicon
- 10:27Valley people. What was the what was the take
- 10:30down? What happened to them?
- 10:32Yeah, I miss that but they don't treat recruiters very well.
- 10:34Well, this guy said got recruited by stripe and then
- 10:38they didn't give him the job like he was sort of ghosted and
- 10:40it was just a poor experience. And then in the comments section
- 10:44of that, News Post. There were accusations that
- 10:48stripe. Also like said they were going
- 10:50to acquire companies and then didn't and it was just generally
- 10:55an argument that stripe has this very glowing reputation but
- 10:58actually the founders are sort of Ruthless that was but I don't
- 11:04know the truth of it but it was an interesting just like stripe
- 11:07is a YC company and then Hacker News, which is owned by YC was
- 11:12sort of the most aggressive anti stripe.
- 11:15Unity. I've never heard of anybody
- 11:18running at enormous company and making it successful, who wasn't
- 11:23to some degree ruthless like which of the seat, like, right?
- 11:27Anyway. Yeah, it's also there like a
- 11:29giant backbone. Payment infrastructure, provider
- 11:31for the internet? Like you got to be kind of
- 11:33Ruthless, you know? It's anyone.
- 11:35Okay, Amazon April 1st says it expects.
- 11:38Some employees are coming back to the office as early as this
- 11:40summer and most of its half will be back in the office.
- 11:42This fall, very funny. There should be some analysis of
- 11:45the Of management just based on how wrong and their predictions
- 11:48of returned to the office were like some of these companies.
- 11:52The fact that they're like, telling people they're going to
- 11:55return to the office when anyone looking at.
- 11:58It would know they're not coming back on the dates.
- 12:00They were setting. Like it's just like the best
- 12:02proof point of who's like, a totally incompetent manager.
- 12:07I mean, April 1st, they were rolling out.
- 12:08The vax has at large, you know, it was, you know, this is
- 12:13Amazon. No, I'm not saying specific to a
- 12:15Azana. We're just saying like all
- 12:17these, all these places that were like, oh yeah, we're
- 12:20definitely going to be back on X date and then it would get so
- 12:24close and then they'd wait like a week away and they'd be like,
- 12:27yeah we're not we're not running back then.
- 12:29It's like what how do you make all your other decisions?
- 12:32I will say it felt very strange as a reporter reporting on it
- 12:35because you know, you want to make everything about like.
- 12:37Oh here's what the big company is making its employees do and
- 12:40really like their we're all subject.
- 12:42We're all reading. The same news were subject to
- 12:44the same whims of the Chris, as anyone else.
- 12:47So it, they were strange stories to write generally, because
- 12:50there would always be tons of grumbling.
- 12:52Like I wrote a lot about boober and they're and they're back to
- 12:54office plans and it was like oh why is Uber forcing people to go
- 12:57back three days a week? And they had to change it to be
- 13:01more flexible and in the end all of its just been thrown up in
- 13:03the air right but it does seem like anyone that I mean you know
- 13:08God God willing. This thing does wind down, I
- 13:11don't know if the like extremists on coming back to the
- 13:13office will ever win. I Really think it's a lost
- 13:17battle April 15th us sanctions Russia for 2020 election
- 13:22interference and the solarwinds hack blacklisting 10 tech
- 13:27companies. Okay, we talked about that.
- 13:31Okay, for some reason I jumped all the way to June 1st just as
- 13:34an aside. I feel like you could do this
- 13:35whole thing and you it could have been 2020 and I would have
- 13:39no, I'd like be okay. That was a sheer, I have no
- 13:41sense of time. I just wrote a bunch of holiday
- 13:44cards, you could Like we could do the whole episode.
- 13:47It's like, oh shit. I was this was 2020 90.
- 13:50Now my oh, wow, okay sure. I just want to throw it all
- 13:53these holiday cards. I wrote saying here's to a great
- 13:562020 was right. Yeah.
- 13:58Right. It's like first of all it was
- 14:01bullshit garbage as a hall like it happen bitch.
- 14:04I know side to throw all of them away it was just totally
- 14:07forgotten. Yeah I know I think we will look
- 14:09back at 2021 as a completely forgotten year like thank well
- 14:132022. Well yeah because it you know
- 14:15like this Slight bit of hello all the memories we made in
- 14:172021, that were so good. Yeah, well, there was that month
- 14:20member will least 2020 was unique, right?
- 14:23It was like the early, I hope, everyone had a good June.
- 14:26Yeah, I was, I that was when I had my vacation I could see like
- 14:30the waves slowly you know, in the distance and the Horizon
- 14:34like making its way towards my life.
- 14:37But for that moment it was fine, I jumped to June for some
- 14:39reason. When I did this a lot of the
- 14:41world skipped over the spring went right to the.
- 14:42Yeah, I don't even as we were getting the vax.
- 14:47Antonio Garcia Martina said he did quote not part ways with
- 14:50apple was fired in a snap decision.
- 14:52And apple statement on his exit is defamatory and false.
- 14:55You guys remember that whole thing?
- 14:57Yeah. Well, that's another.
- 14:59Yeah, I got cancelled culture. Another, they've got like much
- 15:02like Clubhouse. It felt like it was going to be
- 15:04the biggest thing, and I was like, who gives a fuck that gets
- 15:06us back Clubhouse, Wolk. Wolk - and Clubhouse are very
- 15:09interrelated, like both, why reporters don't like it.
- 15:13Why people don't go it. Sure member that was We need to,
- 15:16we need to moderate Clubhouse and Taylor Lorenz, like got all
- 15:20the injuries and partners pissed at her because she missed
- 15:23misquote Edition Horowitz. Oh my God.
- 15:25Yeah. Oh, that's right.
- 15:27A lard. Yeah, that was like the worst
- 15:30truly. I'm sorry.
- 15:32I just like, when I think about the things that are destroying I
- 15:35just like, oh, can't like I'm just glad that.
- 15:38We don't hear a lot about Clubhouse.
- 15:40Cancel culture, and the teller Lorenz Andreessen Feud anymore.
- 15:46And like frankly if you told me those things happened in 2020, I
- 15:50would have been like sure 2019 whatever.
- 15:52Yeah. It's a long time ago.
- 15:54Yeah this one definitely feels like a million years ago and I
- 15:58thought just to editorialize for a second here.
- 16:00Really stupid move by Apple like like this was people complaining
- 16:04about a line that he had written in a book like six years ago.
- 16:07Oh, you're something that people liked in wrote positively about.
- 16:11I mean, I know some of the reviews mentioned the sexism but
- 16:14it was he being a kid. Used of being sexist himself or
- 16:17just being dutifully being a scribe.
- 16:20And he describes his girlfriend in a sexist way as girlfriend in
- 16:25a book that he wrote like seven years ago.
- 16:27Well so long you know like I'm not that's not that's not
- 16:31something is going to keep me up at night.
- 16:32I'm so sorry. Yeah.
- 16:34Well you just got you just got kicked out of the slack Apple
- 16:38Community because that's where all this went down and then they
- 16:40all leaked it to The Verge. Slack is a slab, slack is a
- 16:43monstrous company. That's what we learned.
- 16:46In 2020, whatever the frick this year is whatever this year is we
- 16:49learned slack is terrible. Slack is bad for people.
- 16:52It's bad for companies. The only person slack is good
- 16:55for is maxed Annie the right, the media's the media reporter
- 17:01at The Daily Beast. You dogged slack reporter.
- 17:04Yes slack slack Sleek to him so he can help help, cancel people,
- 17:08independent of whatever Max's particular view.
- 17:11It was a fantastic reporter and I think we I think Should hire
- 17:15him. I think we should hire Max
- 17:18Danny. I've been on record saying that
- 17:19so many times if only so you can cover some other companies other
- 17:23than the New York Times. Yeah, I mean, the New York Times
- 17:24dominates the media be like, I mean, it's a headache.
- 17:27Probably, you guys should just have all the top one, many hired
- 17:31Ben Smith. I mean, it's not that was
- 17:33helpful true. Yeah, we're taking them out one
- 17:35by one. Now, that I work at a place
- 17:37where people leak the slacks from, I find it to be a strange
- 17:41posture. It's like, oh, it's probably
- 17:43getting out there. I just Imagine how mad I could
- 17:46be at somebody. Yeah.
- 17:47Like I would never be so mad that I'd be like, you know what?
- 17:50Fucker, I'm gonna screenshot your slack, the chaos monkeys
- 17:54guy. I mean, the other thing, and
- 17:56this has been said, but the chaos monkeys guy, you know, is
- 18:00probably has more reach. Now, he has a sub stack.
- 18:03He's totally in the opinion game or as if he was at Apple, he
- 18:07would have not been out there with like the views.
- 18:10These people hate like, it's sort of the, you know, reaction
- 18:14Is equal and opposite reaction. Are he?
- 18:17Are he and the girlfriend still together?
- 18:19I don't think they were together at the time.
- 18:21Probably not. I don't think, I don't think so.
- 18:23Yeah. Okay.
- 18:24So and have you ever ever, ever before heard of a sexist,
- 18:28mandating. A woman has ever happened
- 18:30before. I hope not.
- 18:32Oh my God. I mean, obviously, I know
- 18:35nothing about the actual concert.
- 18:37How else do they get girlfriend? That's part of negging.
- 18:40You gotta commit. I know nothing about the actual
- 18:43controversy, so somebody's Gonna be like, well, Katie actually,
- 18:46it wasn't about the fact that he was saying sexist things about
- 18:48his girlfriend. It's about the fact that he was,
- 18:50you know, he was burying bodies in his backyard and then I will
- 18:53feel bad because that my friends that is illegal.
- 18:56But if I think the idea. Yeah, well, look, if our
- 19:01listeners have a problem with that, this is Katie's fault.
- 19:03She could be the one canceled on it.
- 19:05She, I am waiting about Tom's description.
- 19:09Katie is like, oh, I'm I'm right if someone gets cancelled.
- 19:13When really, the reason they're getting Canceled his for, not
- 19:16the thing that's being said public, right?
- 19:18That's the position. You and you alone, subscribe to
- 19:21you're like you're like real politic of cancellation.
- 19:25Like it doesn't matter. I just have no idea.
- 19:28What was? I don't know.
- 19:29It's a publicly. I think that Tom's description
- 19:32of what was said Papa. Yeah, sounds very silly to me
- 19:35because I, I guess like he just, if he were the only sexist
- 19:39person to ever get a girlfriend and then describe her, like an
- 19:42asshole. Wow, right.
- 19:45Wow. And yeah next you can tell I've
- 19:47also covered finest. Yeah.
- 19:49LinkedIn data shows Austin. As a top beneficiary of
- 19:52tech-related migration in the past 12 months, followed by
- 19:54Nashville. Miami was number 11 by net
- 19:57migration rate. Given I am still The Story of
- 19:59the Year, definitely not Austin. Well, Miami began at the end of
- 20:02last year. This I remember well, that that
- 20:05the whole Miami as the siphon of Silicon Valley Talent was like a
- 20:09December 2020, thing it continued on through this year.
- 20:12I think maybe he's still going on.
- 20:13I unfollowed all of Really done Miami so funny.
- 20:18Yeah, yeah. So yeah, I mean like the San
- 20:21Francisco, the Silicon Valley dispersion, you know, San
- 20:25Francisco supposed downfall as the capital of tech that is that
- 20:29that has been a big story this year.
- 20:31The Miami Herald. Emailed me to ask me for my take
- 20:34on Miami. Oh my goodness.
- 20:36You are being asked for your takes now.
- 20:38Yeah, I'm a pundit silent. I said, Miami definitely
- 20:42captured the Silicon Valley Zeitgeist this year.
- 20:44Even if There's two. I don't want to read myself.
- 20:46I can't. Well don't don't scoop yourself
- 20:48error. Yeah, I don't know if they're
- 20:50ever going to run it. They probably they probably
- 20:52emailed you because you were bitching about public trans.
- 20:54Yeah, definitely. Yeah.
- 20:56I just I replied like instantaneously like, you know,
- 20:59you know that's that's how you become agile of quote folks.
- 21:02As soon as someone asks you just fire off, you don't look for
- 21:05data. You don't think about it, you
- 21:06just write an email right away. I love those people, right?
- 21:11I depend on. You can tell the reporters were
- 21:13working hard there. The girl talk about fucking
- 21:15anything right? Yeah you should have some
- 21:17completely wrong headed like completely.
- 21:19Just have no knowledge of Miami infrastructure and be like I
- 21:22think it should be more tunnels in Miami more and deeper
- 21:26tunnels. It seems it seems a major
- 21:30oversight by the Miami Chamber of Commerce to not invest in
- 21:33hyper Loops everywhere, okay? So that was, that was a big
- 21:36story and not Austin, Austin not.
- 21:39He's cares about the data. It's it's whoever's loudest on
- 21:43Twitter shaping the narrative. This is about like the
- 21:45narratives of 2021 and definitely the Miami people own.
- 21:49The awesome people eat, which makes it more pathetic for the
- 21:52Austin people if they actually had data on their side.
- 21:55So I need to be better about their propaganda.
- 21:58I really, I think New York is going to come out the best of
- 22:01this, but I live in New York that was it, that was a thing
- 22:03to. There were people that were
- 22:04moving to New York, that talked a lot about that and as the
- 22:07reasonable alternative to Silicon Valley, I have no
- 22:11thoughts so oig and I got some good.
- 22:16Interviews with around 200 people show.
- 22:18How am this was a New York Times investigation, 200 people at
- 22:21Amazon's Warehouse employment system, under strain before the
- 22:23pandemic burn through workers and created a huge confusion.
- 22:27There were a couple of great stories that the times put out
- 22:29around then about the treatment of Amazon warehouse workers in.
- 22:33I think, New Jersey and now is before the tornado and people
- 22:36died. Yeah.
- 22:37Right is mean, Amazon is such a huge employer.
- 22:40I do not to give them any defense on this, but there is a
- 22:43degree to, which Just the scale at which they're employing
- 22:48people creates so much. You know, so much bureaucracy,
- 22:52and problems and negative stories.
- 22:55Well, I think the, I mean, we're still, I don't know what the
- 22:57latest polling shows. I assume public sentiment is
- 23:00still strongly in favor of Amazon, but it must have turned
- 23:05a bit this year, like the numbers have to be sinking.
- 23:07I mean, but the thing is Amazon also drives up wages and a lot
- 23:11of places that it enters, you know, there is definitely a
- 23:14case. That regular American both for
- 23:17the products and for the jobs in some cases likes Amazon.
- 23:21I mean, the flip side is Amazon, seems to turn through a lot of
- 23:24people, so maybe I don't know. Yeah, we need data, but they say
- 23:27she wants to test positive for you look.
- 23:29Depressed, Amazon was a huge story, Amazon's working
- 23:34condition, I mean, Amazon's working conditions.
- 23:36Right? That's not going to go away.
- 23:38Did Jeff Bezos change? Yeah, that happened this year.
- 23:41So I know that one, too. That he stepped down or now,
- 23:44instead of stepping down, Down. That's huge.
- 23:45He's it though. I mean, it's I mean, obviously,
- 23:47like Andy jassy, he'll get a couple profiles written about
- 23:50them and people are starting to Source up and figure out how to
- 23:54characterize him as a tech personality but is amazing.
- 23:58People don't seem to have like I have no idea what that Andy
- 24:02jassy narrative is I mean they've been interesting pieces
- 24:06written. You know, ruthless nice-ish guy
- 24:09is the Via, but I typically get. But yeah, it's I mean, as long
- 24:14as Bezos, Sitting there as the executive chairman, it'll be
- 24:18hard for it to be his company and I think in the Public's just
- 24:23because Bezos is the second richest person in the world.
- 24:27I think people like any random person, you ask me, like, who's
- 24:29the head of Amazon? They'll say Jeff Bezos.
- 24:31You got to really be in the know, right?
- 24:34And even if you are then the clever take, could still be Jeff
- 24:38except so yeah. Disney was similar for a while
- 24:42with tigers chairman and You know, no one really has thoughts
- 24:46about Bob check back anyway. So this was mid-june also
- 24:51Andreessen, Horowitz launches future immediate property that
- 24:53will focus on informational and editorial consecrated by
- 24:56full-time staff and outside contributors.
- 24:58So that was a whole thing for like a week or so, like the
- 25:02creation of the Andresen media site and the fact that it was
- 25:05going to disintermediated us. Well, yeah, it was one of my
- 25:09biggest stories of the Year talking about and it was my
- 25:12biggest story. So what happened to it?
- 25:13Does anyone read this thing? No, I just I mean you know
- 25:16sometimes I'll you know if you put a URL into Twitter you can
- 25:20sort of see what the engagement is.
- 25:21It doesn't feel like it's definitely not penetrating my
- 25:26conversations and I don't see that it sort of typical piece
- 25:30getting a ton of Engagement. I mean I I do think just like
- 25:35the Mandate writing about the future limits.
- 25:37You know people are very interested in the present and
- 25:41there is a reason that the media investigates thing.
- 25:44Things and asked how things are going, not just sort of opines
- 25:48about the future. So I mean, I think they're still
- 25:51figuring out how their editorial voice connects with an audience.
- 25:56Do you think it needs to be widely, read for it to be
- 25:58successful? I mean, I guess my one take on
- 26:01it at this point or my one perspective on it is that the
- 26:04media overreacted to what they were trying to do that.
- 26:07There was this idea that there was going to be a war.
- 26:09No, but I do think they want like they set themselves up for
- 26:13being good at this. I mean, they are I really do
- 26:15think like Margot was shifting her Focus to editorial like when
- 26:20that's all true. They want to take it very
- 26:22personally. So I think they want to succeed,
- 26:26right? Certainly by the standards of a
- 26:29venture firm. They're good at what they do.
- 26:30I mean I love their blog posts about their companies like
- 26:34people listen to their podcast. I don't.
- 26:37Right. Right.
- 26:40Okay. So that that was a thing in June
- 26:43and then moving to July Why Robin Hood files for
- 26:46long-awaited IPO says, it will set aside 35 percent of shares
- 26:49for retail investors. We've kind of talked a bit about
- 26:52Robin Hood already. Yeah, Robin Hood.
- 26:54I mean, that gets, I think that's up there with Clubhouse
- 26:57and I mean in story of the year because it captures the meme
- 27:00stock, sort of high pi po that sort of took a dive.
- 27:06It's dabbling in crypto. It does a lot of Dogecoin you
- 27:10know, big regulatory questions with the slow SEC.
- 27:14All right. Let's keep moving through.
- 27:16So we talked about Robin Hood while you were out Katie, that's
- 27:18fine. Good kid.
- 27:20The Robin Hood. That's a big story 2021.
- 27:22Yeah, I'm looking for a story that like, grabs a bunch of the
- 27:25themes at once. Okay.
- 27:26Well, here's here's an interesting one on that because
- 27:29it's from August 1st. Many viewers are experienced the
- 27:31Olympics primarily through Tech talk with some of the most
- 27:34watched videos, not coming from NBC, but from the athletes
- 27:36themselves, do they Olympics happen this year?
- 27:38Yeah. So that's part of it.
- 27:39Like I didn't remember that at all.
- 27:43I didn't watch it which one? 20/20 it was like the Olympics
- 27:46with no audience because Japan was dealing with Summer
- 27:49Olympics. Yeah, that was this summer.
- 27:52Yeah, because they postponed it for you to post this and people
- 27:56are going to be like none of those things you talked about
- 27:57happened. Is she like I do and some of it
- 28:00really sincerely not just as a put on like a sliding.
- 28:04You guys are hard to believe that it happened this year.
- 28:07This is serious. I'm turning to the internet
- 28:10right now. There was an Olympics in Japan
- 28:12this summer while I was in Maine.
- 28:14There was a This in Japan. There is skateboarding in it.
- 28:17Michael Phelps. Did not participate.
- 28:20What else happened in this Olympics with this year's 2021?
- 28:23Yeah, because they postponed it from 2020 because we were all in
- 28:25clear, right? Oh my God.
- 28:28Yeah there, but there were like, just family in the audience.
- 28:31It was, it was Haunting. It was a nightmare.
- 28:33They did it, but Japan was dealing with.
- 28:36It's worth. O is so weird.
- 28:37Yeah, I mean what, that's a perfect one to Gaslight us with
- 28:41also because it's their Spurs to be in 2020, but then their
- 28:45postponed. Yes.
- 28:46The date is still the 2020 Olympics.
- 28:49To when you look at it online is the Japan 2020 Olympics.
- 28:52Right? Well, that's funny one.
- 28:53Yeah, maybe that's just really jamming your system.
- 28:56Just like telling you over and over again, welcome to 2021
- 29:00showing of the 2020 Olympics live.
- 29:04Now that's a glitch in the simulation.
- 29:06I was like yeah 57 gonna go clean.
- 29:08So I'm going to go ahead and edit that know.
- 29:10There are probably a percentage of people that had like Strokes
- 29:12every time that logo came up. We call this the tiny 20 bucks.
- 29:18I don't remember anything from it.
- 29:19I didn't know you sure. This Olympics totally fell
- 29:21apart. Like okay, the fact that we all
- 29:23got the like, you know, Matrix glitching Olympics is one thing
- 29:27but also that it was experience your Tick Tock which, you know,
- 29:31the rise of tick-tock and how it's infected both of.
- 29:34You not me has been a huge story.
- 29:36It is here. Oh, yeah, it's destroyed me.
- 29:40It's huge in music. It's huge music and culture.
- 29:43Well, yeah, but it almost It feels I mean it hasn't brought
- 29:46down the government yet. But like, you know, like Rosa
- 29:49recently a talk assimilated to our culture, much better, it
- 29:52wasn't like but the tick tock meme as a threat became a big
- 29:55story in 2021. I just know this via, I mean,
- 29:58it's definitely a threat to our mental well-being, right?
- 30:01No, but also there's now the store.
- 30:02You know the stories will come out about like oh this Tick Tock
- 30:05meme is, you know, this school had to shut down.
- 30:07So the last week there was a story about Tick Tock meme p.m.
- 30:10like you know, national school shooter day or something.
- 30:14Which I don't believe turned out to be true.
- 30:17Not that there weren't School shooters but that there was like
- 30:19a trending Tick Tock meme with that.
- 30:22But there was another story similar to that a few months
- 30:26earlier which was like national slap at teacher day which was
- 30:32there again, it was apocryphal but their YouTube had these
- 30:35things before. I mean Tide Pods no none of its
- 30:38new. I'm not saying it's Unique to
- 30:40Tech talk. I'm just saying that as a
- 30:41company and as a piece of technology.
- 30:44In a medium it now crossed into the this thing that your kids
- 30:48are on isn't just a distraction and annoying.
- 30:50It's a threat and it's a place where they're going to organize.
- 30:52And it happens with every social media platform and happened with
- 30:55Snapchat to, as I go bullying is taking place on Snapchat.
- 30:58So, so that it seems like 2020 was the year that Tick Tock kind
- 31:02of became it entered that phase of its life.
- 31:05Trent 2021 was, yeah, 2020 became huge right because we
- 31:09were, you know, my first year we're traps, we're watching
- 31:12people, dance to Megan this Talia.
- 31:13And then next next, Here for tick tock is it gets more
- 31:17criticism? It's big.
- 31:18It's like we obviously the Wall Street journal's already
- 31:21investigating and but right well next year will be like the I
- 31:24don't know, Tick Tock midterms or something, I don't know.
- 31:26God, I disagree. That Tick Tock would be the
- 31:30story of 2021 because I feel like it mostly is the same thing
- 31:35as like teens. You crazy thing, and Tick-Tock
- 31:38itself isn't really doing that much to amplify it, it's just
- 31:42very good at Discovery and makes it easier.
- 31:44To like, come to this stuff, but I don't see it as like a game
- 31:49change and that's that's that's stuck in general.
- 31:52Yeah, and I see Tick-Tock generally as being pretty Pro
- 31:57moderation and wanting to keep right a glossy image.
- 32:00So maybe they fuck up a few things.
- 32:03I've been talking to your friends at Sequoia.
- 32:09No, I mean, seriously, I don't get on that.
- 32:13I wish the Chinese I don't talk to the Chinese Sequoia people,
- 32:16very much and the pretty distinct firms.
- 32:21So that was Tick-Tock so September 15th.
- 32:23Here's the first Facebook piece here.
- 32:25Internal documents Facebook's own research.
- 32:26Found that a 20-18 change to encourage positive interactions
- 32:29have the opposite effect Zuckerberg resisted, any fixes.
- 32:32So that's the one, you know, Facebook Paper story that I
- 32:35pulled from this obviously that's one of the biggest
- 32:37stories of the year. We've talked about it too much
- 32:39on the show. We're having deep on ya for our
- 32:43next episode. Okay?
- 32:44I want to talk. Talk about it went deeper than
- 32:45one more time. You don't want to hear, what
- 32:47Eric and I and you have to say about is what you're saying.
- 32:49We're going to solve this Facebook issue, we're going to
- 32:52really first of all, she's gonna tell us why this stuff all
- 32:57mattered when we've become Facebook nihilus at this point,
- 33:01and I don't know, save it, save it.
- 33:04I only have so much left of me on Facebook.
- 33:07After being sued by the state of California Activision.
- 33:09Blizzard is sued by a group of representing employees.
- 33:11LED you to try to prevent them from organizing.
- 33:13I mean, that story is not really about Out the thing that the
- 33:15Activision Blizzard story became which was the you know, apparent
- 33:21sexual assaults, that happened at that company and Bobby codex.
- 33:24Knowledge of it is Bobby kotick. Lucio that company?
- 33:27Yeah. Yeah, he's not been pushed out
- 33:29yet amazing. Amazing.
- 33:30People were basically saying it was like sure thing.
- 33:33You lose his job over that. I mean, that's about as close.
- 33:36Yeah, I don't get it. It doesn't make sense to me, but
- 33:38and a good exam we talked about this a bit last week with with
- 33:41Richard, but like if Activision was in a different sector that
- 33:45the broader public cared more about this would be a way Huger
- 33:48story, right? The CEO of the company was aware
- 33:51of like rapes that happened on company time.
- 33:55Allegedly. Yeah.
- 33:56And I was like, you better fact, check that like, allegedly, this
- 33:59is what other people are reporting.
- 34:01So that was that Activision 1, October, Senators, grilled
- 34:05Facebook exact Antigone Davis about Instagrams impact on teen.
- 34:08So, that's more of that, you know, Facebook Paper story
- 34:11October 15th, which downplays last week's hack said I had
- 34:14minimal. Twitch had a huge fucking hack
- 34:16this year. That no one's talking about
- 34:19anymore, but it was the worst hack in the company's history
- 34:21and that's another example of a social network, whatever you
- 34:24want to call it. That doesn't get nearly the
- 34:26level of coverage. It deserves considering how
- 34:28Central it is to so many people's lives and I don't know
- 34:33what the outcome of it is. Yeah, it's huge didn't like the
- 34:36like core technology guy hacked to though?
- 34:38Yeah, the level. Somebody could have copied the
- 34:41whole thing. Yeah, I don't remember the Affix
- 34:45of it, I'm numb Dax you know like yeah I I don't know what
- 34:50even to I mean the most hat caring person on the podcast
- 34:54right now is on a phone call. So we've already talked about
- 34:58hacks November 1st. This is from our Mark Germann
- 35:03chip shortage hits Apple at the worst possible time, out of the
- 35:05holidays and met an apple are set to be.
- 35:07So that's the story of the year, not being able to get
- 35:09PlayStation 5. I don't know how we can open
- 35:11that up. The fact that I these
- 35:13next-generation system, The route.
- 35:15I can't even buy one of them with my hard-earned money and
- 35:18then inflation's probably gonna end up dry.
- 35:21Yeah, that's the story the year right there.
- 35:23Right. Right.
- 35:24What our capitalist system is failing, the consumerism that
- 35:28this whole thing was built on and our moment of need, when
- 35:31we're having to go back into the pandemic that I am playing
- 35:34mobile games, is just write a big problem.
- 35:37Now, my PS4, I'm tired of it. I wanted a PS5, I'm not even
- 35:41looking anymore to see when it's an option to get.
- 35:44Oh yeah, I've Get up and and all all all these stories about like
- 35:47that one reporter who's made his whole career now just like
- 35:51helping people find the council consoles.
- 35:54He's like the biggest reporter of the year, you know how I
- 35:57missed this who's that? He's been profiled and like the
- 35:59New York Times and BuzzFeed celebrities like, DM this guy
- 36:03asking him like how they can get their hands on a PlayStation
- 36:07five like that's pretty. This is the guy, you know, like
- 36:10I mean it hasn't been like you don't when it we like Meet the
- 36:15chattering class is obviously don't like, sit around talking
- 36:18about it too much, if they really wanted one, they have the
- 36:20money. Maybe to pay for it.
- 36:24You'd have to pay like double. I don't know.
- 36:26I mean, just double. That's surprisingly small, but
- 36:29yeah, I refused on principle even, I feel like, even if I had
- 36:31unlimited money, I mean, if I had on limit but like I'd have
- 36:35to be pretty rich to just pay double the price.
- 36:38Something's worth at what should be a findable?
- 36:42I don't know. I'm disconnected from the person
- 36:44whose Willing just be like, whatever I'll buy it.
- 36:48Yeah, I'm not that guy but yeah our are the capitalist supply
- 36:52chain hit a snag this year and that to me the reason the story
- 36:58was good, not the port and the ship.
- 36:59You know what about the ship is that on your list?
- 37:02It's not on there but that's getting our entry point into it.
- 37:05Yeah, well that wasn't a come-on tech meme.
- 37:07I mean, I don't know if the tech angle is there, right?
- 37:09I know, but I do think that's another way that like not being
- 37:12able to get our consoles fits in The generals supply chain
- 37:16breakdown. I mean, that shit was just too
- 37:18fat for what our infrastructure allows for.
- 37:21It was like a gust, you know, is the I don't think it was the
- 37:24captain's fault. It was sort of like weather
- 37:26condition, it wasn't and the moon I think, is the Moon's
- 37:30fault. But but no, I mean, look, the
- 37:32supply chain that became a thing that people were talking about
- 37:35this year which is not a good sign ever for capitalism when
- 37:38people are starting to think about like the sausage parts.
- 37:41And yeah I mean we had Ryan. What's his name from Flex Port,
- 37:45Peterson Peterson becoming a mini celebrity because he took a
- 37:50tour of the Port of Long Beach and was like the why don't we
- 37:52stack the shipping containers on top of each other and he got
- 37:56like 20 million retweets and the mayor of Long Beach was like
- 37:58yeah let's do that. I've always wanted to with that
- 38:02story, I like Ryan so I don't want to I don't want to knock
- 38:05him for it at all and, you know, he's just he's just a man out
- 38:08there, you know, throwing out ideas but like I would be
- 38:11interested in better coverage of that particular episode.
- 38:14Because I would bet there are people in the supply chain world
- 38:17that are just like to that had nothing to do with it.
- 38:20Like, like first of all, that wouldn't have had any normal
- 38:23effect on the supply chain in the way that it would have
- 38:25changed. All the problems that we have
- 38:27and like this is just very I would like to know factually.
- 38:30I mean, I'm yeah the see if it's just seemed like a delet on kind
- 38:33of let's card, not to cheer for Ryan.
- 38:35I mean, he's the right Summits are just like do it, make it
- 38:39happen but there is yeah, I mean, I think we both yeah, the
- 38:43world's often Not that simple. Like usually there aren't sort
- 38:47of easy solutions that can change things right.
- 38:50There are lots of people who spend their entire careers
- 38:55working on these particular things and try to make, you
- 38:57know, like Grease the gears of capitalism in the supply chain
- 39:02that, I just think it just strikes me that often in tech
- 39:05people think like, oh, an outsider's perspective is really
- 39:07going to shake things up and it's like no there's a lot more
- 39:10to it than that on the flip side.
- 39:11I mean, I don't, I actually I'm on, I'm on the text.
- 39:14To this. I mean at the end of the day,
- 39:16Elon Musk is running a very successful like Space Program.
- 39:20I mean, the most impressive Logistics comes from Amazon, you
- 39:24know, at the end of the day, the sort of we can fix it sort of
- 39:28private sector, mentality is better than the government and
- 39:32and I mean, yeah. So now I believe in Ryan more
- 39:35than okay. My intuitions about though, I'm
- 39:39not, I'm not going to be anti Ryan.
- 39:40I just think that episode could have been more investigated
- 39:43rather than just, Tweeting him another.
- 39:46This is a good topic but it should be its own episode.
- 39:48I like the topic. Yeah, November 15th, I look at
- 39:52Constitution Dao or Dow, which is in 3 million Constitution
- 39:56die, which is taking in three million crypto and bit of, for
- 39:59the US Constitution printed in 1787.
- 40:02And that's part of the headline. But I don't think, I mean, that
- 40:05was good because the finance guy, that was a fun story.
- 40:09The Citadel guy, beat them out and it seemed I saw a story that
- 40:13said Is Like, Son, texted him, Dad, you got like, we just saw
- 40:16the headline. It's classic like, big money
- 40:18beats, you know, the little guy old school Finance versus it's
- 40:26Ken Griffin. It's a tall old school Finance
- 40:28beats. You know the nft world.
- 40:31That's it's not political. Yeah, I like that one.
- 40:34Yeah. Look, the specifics around
- 40:36constitutional doubt. Like that was afford a story.
- 40:39It was kind of fun. I don't know what the larger
- 40:41meaning of it was, right? I don't know.
- 40:44The Constitution down, I like it, just because, yeah, I know,
- 40:48I know, I just liked it, because what?
- 40:49Will clearly become a theme. Next year, is the widening of
- 40:54stances of the pro and against Webb, three crypto, whatever you
- 40:59want to call it. That like people are more and
- 41:01more entrenched or getting more and more entrenched in their
- 41:04perspective on whether or not this is real or this is a scam
- 41:06or a Ponzi or whatever. And I think you really saw it
- 41:10coming to the mainstream in a way it hadn't in 2021.
- 41:14That's why I liked it on there. Yeah, I know.
- 41:16I mean, that's a great. I'm trying to think of a better
- 41:18nft Sort of want. And I mean, the problem is some
- 41:23of the stuff is just like, oh the prices soared but like,
- 41:26crypto Punk's are all, you know, they've been around for a couple
- 41:29years. I mean it's there any number of
- 41:32stories there was no one single one that I think like rocked you
- 41:37know the markets are people individually but that will
- 41:41probably come. But this was that I mean this
- 41:43was just like a fun couple the episode that's a good one and
- 41:46then December 1st, we got Kevin ruse and is calm.
- 41:49At the at the times that I liked Jack, Dorsey joins other Tech
- 41:52leaders who seemed to have grown tired of management or platforms
- 41:55mean increasing political controversy and hard to fix
- 41:57problems. So that's the, you know the
- 41:58Dorsey stepping down from Twitter thing and generally like
- 42:02Tech leaders retreating into you know, the metaverse or other
- 42:07kind of future projects that are further remove, you know, it's
- 42:12dr. Manhattan.
- 42:12Going off to the Moon. Yeah, so did Jeff Bezos
- 42:17announced last year and The step know he announced this shit.
- 42:21I think it'll happen this year. Okay so we've got Jeff Bezos.
- 42:25We've got Mark Zuckerberg, renaming the company and Jack
- 42:28Dorsey leaving Twitter, right? Yeah, I do think that's a good
- 42:33candidate sort of the sort of reimagining restructuring of the
- 42:38biggest tech companies with. So that these these guys can
- 42:43think about sort of more fun stuff and not, right?
- 42:47Social media moderation And yeah, and whatever cloud
- 42:52services? Yeah, I mean, it's yeah, for
- 42:55Bezos, I can get it because Amazon is an increasingly
- 42:59political animal. I mean, it's like, it's a
- 43:01punching bag now and that's going to be less fun for him.
- 43:03He doesn't want to have to be called in front of.
- 43:05There's also just bad for the company because he's a Target,
- 43:08you know? And I'm right.
- 43:09Yeah, he's a celebrity, if you can personify it it's much.
- 43:13It's much more powerful. Yeah, and my bet is that there
- 43:16is a probably a gulf between the way people feel about Jeff
- 43:18Bezos. The way they feel about Amazon
- 43:20like they like it in their packages delivered in two days
- 43:25they like the one in maybe some of the shows on Amazon Prime,
- 43:27but they think Bezos is bad for the generalized reason they
- 43:30don't like billionaires and so yeah, that isn't Fun for him.
- 43:34But yeah, I think like the tech backlash, whatever you want to
- 43:37call it. Hit a point this year that I
- 43:39think it really did start affecting the CEOs and they made
- 43:44changes to deal with that sort of saw like the online Of course
- 43:50becoming reality that's near the end.
- 43:53I mean the last thing I have here is leaked memo Google tells
- 43:57employees. They must comply with vaccine
- 43:59policies by Jan 18th or lose pay, and eventually be fired.
- 44:03I don't know. I just sort of included that one
- 44:05because no one knows, I really like vaccine minutes or yeah.
- 44:09Well, the vaccine mandate is its own thing.
- 44:11I don't think it'll be that much of a problem in Tech but but
- 44:15just the fact that we end this year completely unclear as to
- 44:19whether And life will return to anything close to normal.
- 44:22Everyone's living in a panic vaccine works, the vaccine
- 44:25works. I mean I feel fine or probe acts
- 44:29here not just Pro undersells. It like, I mean, is there any
- 44:33ambiguity to that? Like, I don't know.
- 44:35I mean, did you see Trump by the way, say that he got a booster,
- 44:38he was being interviewed by Bill O'Reilly, got a booster and then
- 44:41people started booing. I mean like there's no real
- 44:44controlling that crowd at this point, you know?
- 44:47It's like lettuce isn't that supposed to be?
- 44:49His specialty like how he lost because he's afraid of them.
- 44:52He like they're terrified of these people at a certain level,
- 44:55you know. It's like it's one that you can
- 44:57whip people up into a frenzy to get elected.
- 44:58But, you know, that's a certain level of.
- 45:01I do things like the case against Constitution, dour and
- 45:04ft stuff. Being the biggest story of the
- 45:07year is just, it doesn't have like a political component which
- 45:10would broaden it. I do think the Robin Hood.
- 45:15The meme stocks. There's such a political they're
- 45:18still like the regular guy and sort of the don't trust
- 45:23Authority. We can I don't know that that
- 45:27has that strain. I do I Clubhouse obviously most
- 45:31Americans. I most Americans have no idea
- 45:33clubhouses. So in a, in a sort of broad
- 45:37sense, it is in no way the story of the year, but as a framing
- 45:41device, Four people in Silicon Valley for what happened this
- 45:47year. I think it's interesting, also,
- 45:49because there's a strong promise that it won't be a story of
- 45:542022. So it does make 2021 feel sort
- 45:58of stand on its own. I don't know what you're
- 46:01thinking at the clubhouse, specifically.
- 46:02I mean, just Clubhouse is a narrative.
- 46:05I mean, clubhouses, like represent.
- 46:06I mean, they could have sold to Twitter, right?
- 46:08I mean, that was, there was a point in time where they could
- 46:10have offloaded this thing, but not as a business I mean as a
- 46:13business. Yeah.
- 46:14I mean even if it's sold for 4 billion dollars like who cares
- 46:17about that? I think just the idea that like
- 46:20for a moment, it felt like it was almost like pre-med a verse
- 46:24or was like how do we all live online together right?
- 46:28In the lockdown? I can I can follow that logic.
- 46:30If we're going to view clubhouse as a metaphor for this
- 46:34increasing reality that we need to connect, we're going to be
- 46:37connecting virtually as a matter of safety and habit, I don't
- 46:42know if Clubhouse it Elf is the best version of that, but
- 46:47there's clearly a bet on the, you know, from from the top down
- 46:49in Tech that the future is going to be some sort of virtual
- 46:53interaction with people, and that's normal.
- 46:56And although, like we've talked about on the show, I don't think
- 46:59we're not there yet, and there's a huge amount of drawbacks that
- 47:03should we ever return to normal? I just don't think is going to
- 47:06be as big as people expect it to be, at least, unless it gets way
- 47:09cooler, which it clearly isn't yet, but But yeah, I it came in
- 47:15to a point where it's being widely discussed and there's a
- 47:18huge amount of money put into it.
- 47:20I'm not that psyched for it. I saw like there's some analysts
- 47:24report over the weekend that said that like apples a our
- 47:27device is going to come out as soon as next year and people are
- 47:30getting hyped about that. I'm first of all, I'd be
- 47:33surprised if it does come out next year and I be fully
- 47:35prepared for it to suck to me. I mean the metaverse is just a
- 47:40matter of timing, I mean I don't know that will be in there.
- 47:43Made the argument my strong position that I have not wavered
- 47:45from is just the metaverse just has to be better than work where
- 47:50I do think we're going to be mostly remote at work.
- 47:52People are going to need a place to collaborate.
- 47:54It's better than just like going from browser to browser that
- 47:58that will happen. That will be the metaverse.
- 48:01And people already spent hours a day on gaming will instead of
- 48:04operating systems, we have sort of a connecting Universe between
- 48:08games, I think very likely and then framing it as a debate
- 48:12between Her outside is a total mistake.
- 48:15Given we already spend tons of time in front of screens and the
- 48:18metaverse just needs to replace a subsection of that time.
- 48:23And the quality, the question is just when a single company or
- 48:26entity can sort of build that how it works out,
- 48:29technologically, and whether the graphics and then obviously the
- 48:32interface. So, there are lots of questions.
- 48:34Thank God, you saved us from this.
- 48:35I'm like, oh, tiger Global is the story.
- 48:39I mean, Amy was we can, you know, you can have cake Clark on
- 48:41here. You guys can battle it out.
- 48:43Listen 2020. Wait 2020 is you know the year
- 48:47of SoftBank in 2021 was the year of tiger Global and that's how
- 48:51every American clearly organizes the world from Unity, right?
- 48:56No I can't wait to go see my parents in a couple days and
- 48:58talk about tiger with them and whether you know, do should they
- 49:02be investing alongside SoftBank, everything, you know?
- 49:05Yeah. You know, it's like she can they
- 49:08really do series. A what what happens if like if
- 49:12tiger is not Willing to sort of Steward.
- 49:14These companies is like a sort of a board member then are they
- 49:18just relying on their early investors to supervise them.
- 49:22Are they only getting in the, you know, the B and C to your
- 49:25company's because the a to your company.
- 49:27So you know we you know what's sad is that we're probably more
- 49:29qualified to talk about that than we are about the metaverse.
- 49:33Oh yeah. That's my real job.
- 49:35Yeah. I mean not really mine but right
- 49:38but definitely not the met over so I have no business spouting
- 49:42off on it. But I guess we sort of end the
- 49:44year in a place arguably worse off than we were at the start.
- 49:48We have back now. You know, I take that back we
- 49:50have vaccines we're just looking at the news and seeing a line
- 49:53going vertical and it gets in and gets a scared.
- 49:56And the thing, we thought wasn't going to happen or we hoped was
- 49:59going to happen garak, got covid.
- 50:09Looking at a 20 22 CES. Looks like it's happening, but
- 50:13no one will attend. So it'll just be like the best
- 50:15CES ever. Write a theoretical CES.
- 50:19Just, I don't know. That's, that's going to be
- 50:21haunting, but I'm trying to think like of the stuff that
- 50:25happened. This Lear, what we could even
- 50:29begin to predict will be the case in 22?
- 50:33I don't know. Eric, where are you?
- 50:34Like it sub? Stacking to pull more writers
- 50:36away from from there. Are there Media Company homes?
- 50:39Is that on its way up still, or has it and pass it?
- 50:42Maxed out and it's now just going to be why I think the, the
- 50:45sort of angler like building bigger media companies is an
- 50:50interesting theme. I mean, I assume Iglesias.
- 50:53Medical ACS will keep sort of expanding his Empire?
- 50:58I just don't think I mean sure it's a media story but I think
- 51:01it's a small small Story. I mean the broadening would be
- 51:05sort of I mean I do think you know more visibility into how
- 51:10many likes solo entrepreneurs there are in the economy overall
- 51:13and how that's affected the workplace.
- 51:16I mean that's that's a huge theme.
- 51:18I mean, to me, I guess my first question would just be like How
- 51:24big I mean we're in exponential growth right now of the
- 51:26pandemic, like if this holds, you know, all of a sudden like
- 51:31the insta carts that everybody, you know, is getting a second
- 51:34wind and like the airbnb's were happy for people to travel get
- 51:37hurt. So I do think there's like, is
- 51:39this a whole nother sort of pandemic period if that were the
- 51:44case? You know, that would have big
- 51:46effects. I'm sort of skeptical, right?
- 51:48I think we're going to go back to normal pretty quickly.
- 51:53Second half of January or whatever, as a total nany,
- 51:56peace, just knowing people's willingness to, like, do this.
- 52:01So, in that case, I don't know. I think to me, my bullish
- 52:04prediction is still like crypto crypto bull, you know, just like
- 52:10crazy crazy excitement there. There's just so the funds
- 52:14getting raised are so big that there's money, that's going to
- 52:17keep that show going. Even if the prices fall, I think
- 52:20there's just a ton. I think it'll A crypto year.
- 52:24Yeah. And I guess the ongoing battle
- 52:27or maybe fake battles kayfabe between web to and web 3 will
- 52:32kick into a higher gear or something.
- 52:34I don't know. It doesn't really seem, they're
- 52:35really sides in any of this. I don't want to spend too much
- 52:39time on that, but it's like, yeah, these just feel like
- 52:41ancient grudges that are being dredged up via the topic of
- 52:44crypto that they're all friends, girlfriends.
- 52:47I mean, obviously, there's some year will be the year of
- 52:50implosion, right? Like, I mean, We are seeing like
- 52:53these big Executives sell off a lot of their Holdings if we had
- 52:58a big correction. Thanks to you know Keith or boy
- 53:02was saying, you know, I think we're at a top.
- 53:04I mean if interest rates go up and that really hurts you know,
- 53:08the economy and the stock market fell, then it could be the year
- 53:12of, you know, the rivi insertive Tesla Reckoning which would be a
- 53:17huge story, right? If we saw the enthusiasm come
- 53:20out of some of the electric car maker, Jurors and self-driving
- 53:24cars and all, and we haven't really felt like the true Pains
- 53:29of, like, ice pack implosion. I keep saying in the newsletter
- 53:33that I'm bullish now, because most of the time, the economy
- 53:36goes up. So, it's a bad prediction game
- 53:40to say, oh, next year will be the Reckoning, but obviously,
- 53:44whatever your, the Reckoning comes will be a big story.
- 53:48I think of the electric auto makers whenever that happens.
- 53:53I generally just like predictions that said, I think
- 53:57that before we can have that kind of Reckoning, we almost
- 54:00need more exuberance which we didn't get in 2010.
- 54:04Not just not just because everybody was clinically
- 54:06depressed, sorry, this should be more fun.
- 54:08Like if this is the peak, why isn't it like wildly awesome
- 54:12yet? Like and I don't mean like, I
- 54:14mean irrational exuberance in the in in the way that like an
- 54:17economist would use it and FTS aren't doing that for you but
- 54:21that's but so I remember in the mortgage market and 2006 right
- 54:27and seven people were like, this is crazy, but it really took a
- 54:32year of absolute Insanity like beyond what people could have
- 54:36imagined so much. So that it's silenced doubters
- 54:40because it was so insane. That's the kind of exuberance
- 54:43I'm talking about talking about like Robert Shiller level
- 54:46irrational, exuberance in the market fine crypto Punk's for
- 54:50millions of dollars but those are things that Are still not
- 54:53part of the, those things that part of the broader economy,
- 54:56right? So, what irrational, exuberance,
- 54:58if you're an economist irrational, exuberance is when
- 55:00it isn't just a niche of professional speculators.
- 55:03But when everybody becomes a professionals, regulator right,
- 55:06right? It's like, it's like a
- 55:07load-bearing beam collapses. Not just like, you know, you're
- 55:11weird a dealer. So, that's why we have it, for
- 55:13example, seeing the impact of a stock explosion, because Mom and
- 55:19Pop aren't Instax really. So, when it's just the
- 55:22professional, Best in Class is getting her rights.
- 55:25The beauty of wealth inequality. That there's just so much money
- 55:28that, like, without destroying the economy, they can just
- 55:31wildly speculative lose money, say that the prediction would be
- 55:35that we need, sort of it sort of twinned with this.
- 55:38I think what we will learn to live with the pandemic, even if
- 55:41it's living on Happily with it, that doesn't mean we'll be
- 55:43happy. We will learn to live with the
- 55:45pandemic in some way and that out of that I think there's
- 55:48going to be like an amount of escapism.
- 55:51That is really Tense and that will impact market.
- 55:54So impact behavior in a lot of ways.
- 55:56And that's when we're going to get that irrational, exuberance,
- 55:58mmm, because you need the irrational, exuberance mm4,
- 56:01collapse to impact people. Broadly so 2022 is the real fun
- 56:05year for 2023 beans. Sort of, I'm not gonna put it,
- 56:09I'm not going to put months on it, I'm just saying that.
- 56:11I don't think we had the irrational exuberance level yet
- 56:13because not enough people are involved in speculative economy.
- 56:16Right now. It's always why I've been sort
- 56:18of unexcited by the predictions of a bubble bursting because I
- 56:22just don't I think there's enough of the structure of the
- 56:26economy that really makes for, you know, like the bus to happen
- 56:30to be there yet for me to see like, oh, this Fallout is going
- 56:33to be huge rather than a littl little implosions that happen
- 56:37across the landscape. My prediction.
- 56:41I guess this is just going to come from like where I spend a
- 56:43lot of my time reporting. I think there will be more
- 56:47interesting things happening on the labor front, within a lot of
- 56:50these big companies than we have.
- 56:52I've expected in a while and I know I've been down on.
- 56:55Wow, yeah, that's total reverse. I don't think it's going to come
- 56:58from the ground up. I genuinely think there is not
- 57:01enough Co Collective action and organization on the part of
- 57:06drivers to do anything but I think all the stuff that's
- 57:09happening in Europe with the forcing of protections and some
- 57:14form of like, Proto unions on the part of these big companies
- 57:18that it's going to like, infiltrate the US political
- 57:21scene. And you're going to see a Of
- 57:23politicians pushing for this on like a federal or national level
- 57:27and that wouldn't surprise me if you start seeing like the B
- 57:30Administration and the lead up to like a midterm be in like
- 57:33let's fuck some stuff up and like force you know like through
- 57:36executive action Union like protections within a lot of
- 57:40these big companies. Oh yeah that's a good
- 57:42prediction. Just to the regulatory regime
- 57:44finally really fires up. I mean part of it on antitrust
- 57:47were seen what Europe didn't Europe come down on giphy with
- 57:51Facebook. Yeah right there.
- 57:52Yeah, they're nervous about all of that but so to expand that
- 57:56just like labor, like you're having this driver's seat
- 58:00position around sort of tech regulation and then sort of the
- 58:05bind Administration looking for but specifically around unions
- 58:08to and and like we've seen when it comes to Tech that Europe is
- 58:11usually out ahead of the curve when it comes to like, you know,
- 58:14privacy for example like they set more rigorous, You could
- 58:18argue good or not good standards on it.
- 58:20And I just think like when you've seen Successful labor,
- 58:24movements happening this last year with like, the Kellogg
- 58:26strike, with the John Deere strike.
- 58:29I'm not saying that there is a real wave happening here, but I
- 58:31do think that politicians view it as a winning issue and that
- 58:36it wouldn't surprise me. I would actually no, let me go
- 58:38further. I think it would be more likely
- 58:40than not to happen that you see someone within the bite of
- 58:42ministration or on a you know, National political level
- 58:45champion this cause and suddenly the you know these get companies
- 58:49have to deal with it again. Okay.
- 58:51Interesting too. Because if there is some sort
- 58:52Out of downturn, the kind of downturn that Eric talking
- 58:56about, I'm not predicting, I agree with you.
- 58:57I to be clear, you're and I would take my cues from you
- 59:01before myself about the natural rhythms of the economy, but no,
- 59:04but, but someday it will come, but the exuberance does lead to
- 59:08a downturn that impacts a lot of people.
- 59:11And so, if this sort of Labor movement is not in place.
- 59:15If there is nothing, for the people who will be negatively
- 59:20impacted, you don't have a ginormous Worcester.
- 59:22Capital to make it nothing but a mere inconvenience, you know?
- 59:27It will have really interesting ramifications politically,
- 59:31right? Right.
- 59:32I guess that's it but within that is we think 2022 will still
- 59:36be a boomer wasn't if we're not all at zero bond with the
- 59:41incoming mayor, like then then the irrational exuberance
- 59:45doesn't happen. I know, I can't believe I didn't
- 59:48vote. I had so many places.
- 59:49I could have voted for Eric Adams.
- 59:51You had so many chances. I didn't vote.
- 59:52Them at all. And now I'm like the biggest
- 59:54booster. I'm like, this is gonna be the
- 59:56best. I'm like, yeah, that's right.
- 59:58That's it. So, you know, unless all of
- 1:00:01lower Manhattan looks like Studio 54, yeah. 2022 is the
- 1:00:05year of fun mayor's. We've got a fun mayor in San
- 1:00:08Francisco. To she's like, going to
- 1:00:09concerts, she's like taking her mask off.
- 1:00:12She's like there was a reunions of Bell.
- 1:00:15Biv DeVoe or someone like that. It's a fight.
- 1:00:17It's the year of fun mayor. Why I do think there is a degree
- 1:00:21to, which it's like People have also sort of like, they're not
- 1:00:24afraid of like the alleged cancel culture to the extending
- 1:00:28existed. I do think there's a degree to
- 1:00:29which politicians have now been like, it's not that powerful,
- 1:00:33you know, when Governor Northern wasn't taken out by the
- 1:00:37blackface incident, I think that was set the he set this.
- 1:00:40Mold, that was an early. That was the canary in the coal.
- 1:00:43Mine for cancel culture. It's like you know what?
- 1:00:45So is this a hard year for Barry Weiss then if like cancel
- 1:00:49cultures losing, you know, stop, she's building a university.
- 1:00:53That's true. That's her.
- 1:00:55She'll teach a course on us. Speak out to my mean, the show.
- 1:01:01All right, this is good. All right.
- 1:01:02Yeah anyway. Thank you guys.
- 1:01:04We should end in some like, salutatory way.
- 1:01:06But anyway, it was this was also 2021 was the year that we
- 1:01:09started dead cat, and our lives will forever be changed.
- 1:01:14I've been so grateful to get to spend.
- 1:01:15So much time with you guys on this podcast.
- 1:01:18Something that I hadn't had a chance to do since you all moved
- 1:01:21away from San Francisco. So it's It's true sincerity
- 1:01:24feels very off-brand to me, I don't know.
- 1:01:26I'm sorry, sorry, we can cut that.
- 1:01:29We've argued, we've argued more on this podcast, we ever did in
- 1:01:34real life, which is hilarious. Well, that's the new.
- 1:01:37That's the metaverse baby. It's not real life.
- 1:01:39It's just like a simulacrum but angrier to a great 2022.
- 1:01:44So you guys all they're nice having you here.