Latest / This is Oregon / S3E1: Beyond the Screen Time Debate: Insights on Raising Resilient Kids
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to This Is Oregon, a
- 0:04podcast where we take you inside research happening at the University of Oregon
- 0:08and show you how it applies to your daily life.
- 0:11I'm Sherri Buri McDonald, your host for this episode.
- 0:14We're going to be talking today with Nick Allen, the Ann Swindells
- 0:18Professor of Clinical Psychology at the University of Oregon.
- 0:22He also is the co-founder and CEO of Ksana Health
- 0:25Inc, a spin off from his research.
- 0:28Before we begin, a brief heads up for our listeners.
- 0:31This episode focuses on mental health, and our conversation
- 0:35does touch on the subject of suicide.
- 0:38If you or a loved one are going through a difficult time,
- 0:41please feel free to skip this episode or step away if needed.
- 0:45If you are in crisis, you can always call
- 0:47or text the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline at 988.
- 0:51It is completely free, confidential and available 24/7.
- 0:56Now here is the episode.
- 0:59Welcome, Nick.
- 1:00Would you tell us a bit about yourself and how your research interests
- 1:03came to focus on psychology and adolescence?
- 1:06It's great to be with you, Sherri Thank you.
- 1:08I am originally from Australia.
- 1:10I actually first came to Eugene in the early 1990s to do a postdoc.
- 1:16And so I, and that's where I met my wife, who's American.
- 1:20And so we moved back to Australia for quite a few years.
- 1:22But then I came back when this amazing opportunity presented itself in 2014.
- 1:29And so I've been here since then.
- 1:32In terms of my background in psychology and adolescence,
- 1:36I mean, my my interest in psychology is actually very long lived.
- 1:40I think I told my father he was a social worker,
- 1:43and I said to him that I'd like to do what he did, but with.
- 1:46But I also liked science, and he said, you should be a psychologist.
- 1:50And I had to look up what that was.
- 1:53But I said, okay.
- 1:54And then I went to school the next day
- 1:55and told someone I was going to be a psychologist.
- 1:57And so, so and it happened.
- 1:59It's a you know, it's not that many people who decide that age 13, but
- 2:03so I so it's been a longstanding interest in mental health.
- 2:07And to a certain extent it's sort of family business I guess.
- 2:11So yeah, so I trained in psychology.
- 2:13And the particular issue that I started doing research on
- 2:17was clinical depression.
- 2:19Clinical depression is a very common
- 2:21form of mental health problem, but it can also be extremely serious.
- 2:26And so that was an important issue that I wanted to focus on.
- 2:30And and one of the things that's very remarkable about depression,
- 2:34if you look at some of the figures, is the way it changes over the lifespan.
- 2:39And it's a very dramatic increase in depression that occurs
- 2:43somewhere in early to mid adolescence, you know, across the population.
- 2:47So when you see this dramatic increase then
- 2:50it raises a question why?
- 2:53Why is this particular kind of issue
- 2:56emerging at this stage of life for more people.
- 3:00And so that got me very deeply curious about the
- 3:05developmental processes that were occurring in adolescence.
- 3:08What's changing in adolescence that for some individuals, not for
- 3:11everyone, but for some individuals, is increasing this vulnerability?
- 3:15Sure.
- 3:16And it also provides a very important clinical, opportunity
- 3:22because you've got an opportunity for early intervention and prevention.
- 3:26If you can identify people who are at risk
- 3:30or people who have emerging problems, then you may be able to intervene early.
- 3:34And in general, in health care, we find that when you can intervene
- 3:38early that things are more plastic, they're more able to change.
- 3:41And so therefore you can, you can have a better outcome
- 3:45than if you wait until problems are really well-established.
- 3:49And so that that then drove my interest in adolescence.
- 3:52And I've been focusing on adolescence and young adulthood
- 3:56because of that importance for the onset of mental health problems
- 4:01across people's lifespans.
- 4:02Ever since your work looks at how mobile devices and social media
- 4:06can be used to enhance mental health by helping to detect mental health needs.
- 4:11How does that work?
- 4:12One of the challenges we have at the moment is the way we talk about
- 4:16digital technology in mental health is we talk about it in a very negative frame.
- 4:20And we and that's partly
- 4:22because we often talk about mental health in a very negative frame.
- 4:25You know, mental health and mental illness are not the same thing, just the way
- 4:29physical health and physical illness are not the same thing.
- 4:31So when we talk about mental health, we're talking about both sides of that coin.
- 4:35Things that can be harmful, but things that can promote
- 4:37flourishing and wellness and really good mental health.
- 4:41And so when we look at something like a digital devices
- 4:45or social media, we can ask the same set of questions.
- 4:48We can say, in what ways might they be harmful?
- 4:50Or might that create risk?
- 4:52But we can also say, what are the opportunities that they offer
- 4:55for enhancing mental health, and maybe for solving
- 4:59some of the challenges and limitations that we've been living with
- 5:02for a long time, and how we actually support people's mental health
- 5:05and provide them with with treatment if they need it.
- 5:08The work that we started doing really came out of work.
- 5:11We were doing on sleep,
- 5:14and one of the things that we know is that sleep
- 5:17problems are a strong predictor of mental health problems, and that also
- 5:21there are some very profound changes that occur in sleep during adolescence.
- 5:26And so as a result of that, we were measuring sleep.
- 5:30We were developing treatments for sleep, to improve
- 5:34sleep amongst people who had risk factors for mental health problems.
- 5:39And one of the
- 5:39things you do when you study sleep is you want to measure it.
- 5:42And you can measure sleep by asking people questions about their sleep.
- 5:47Or you can ask or you can collect objective data about their sleep.
- 5:51So, for example,
- 5:52many people of these days have Fitbits and Apple Watches and things like that.
- 5:57They can measure their sleep behavior in those days,
- 6:01that those consumer products weren't available.
- 6:04So we had to buy very expensive research, actigraphs
- 6:08for people to wear on their wrists or bring them into a sleep lab.
- 6:12So we were doing that kind of work
- 6:13as part of our scientific work and as part of our treatment work,
- 6:18and this thing just kind of clicked for me, which is that
- 6:22actually the core thing you have in a Fitbit, it's called an accelerometer.
- 6:28It measures movement.
- 6:30So also in a phone.
- 6:31And in those days, if you were going to ask someone
- 6:33to wear one of these devices, it was kind of a bit of a hassle
- 6:36because that wasn't something that that we used to doing.
- 6:40But you
- 6:40couldn't separate the kid from their phone, right?
- 6:43They wouldn't they wouldn't dare leave home without it.
- 6:45And so my and then and then the other thing is that
- 6:48the phone collects a whole lot of other kind of data objectively.
- 6:53It collects data on people's not only their sleep,
- 6:57but their physical activity, collects data on their, geographic movement.
- 7:02So how they're moving around the world, the kind of places they're spending time.
- 7:06It collects data on their patterns of communication.
- 7:09So who they're connecting with you can collect language.
- 7:12And language is a very rich source of information.
- 7:15You can collect data on the rhythms in their life,
- 7:18how they, you know, when they get up,
- 7:21when they use their phone, when they put it down, that sort of thing.
- 7:25So there's an awful lot of data
- 7:26that you can collect from this thing that people already had in their pocket.
- 7:30And so that was kind of the the spark that made me think, wow.
- 7:35And this and this relates to a very core limitation
- 7:38that we have in the mental health field, which is that we rely
- 7:41almost exclusively on people's self-report.
- 7:45You know, what the how they describe their own mental health
- 7:48and that's important information.
- 7:51So I'm not saying there's anything wrong with that.
- 7:53But the the fact is we know that it never tells the whole story.
- 7:59So to go back to the work we were doing in sleep,
- 8:02if we asked people about their sleep and we measured their sleep
- 8:05objectively, we would find some relationship
- 8:09generally a fairly low one.
- 8:11So what I tell you about my sleep,
- 8:14and what an objective measure says about my sleep, are two different things,
- 8:18or somewhat different things to two different parts of the picture.
- 8:22And you can see that in all sorts of other areas, like in other areas,
- 8:26substance use.
- 8:27If you have an objective measure of substance use, like with a urine screen
- 8:30or something like that, and then you also ask people
- 8:33about their substance use, you get a different story.
- 8:36There's a bunch of examples of this.
- 8:39So it's not to say that one source of data is better than the other,
- 8:42but that if you only have what people can and will tell you,
- 8:46you're actually missing an important part of the picture.
- 8:50So and that's been a real challenge in the mental health field that we haven't
- 8:56had objective measures like you would have to measure blood pressure or to measure
- 9:01cholesterol or other things like that.
- 9:04So this was also an opportunity to start to think about how we might measure
- 9:09behavior directly, objectively, and how that might
- 9:14bring a new perspective to how we can help people.
- 9:17So in your lab, are you able to track some of the things you mentioned
- 9:21in a young person's day and correlate that to their mental health?
- 9:26For sure.
- 9:26We have published a lot of studies about the relationship
- 9:29of these sorts of variables to mental health, a couple of areas
- 9:34that have been quite robust and have found consistent findings is,
- 9:39the language that people type into their phone is often reflective
- 9:43of their mental health, for example, one thing that surprises people is that,
- 9:48using more first person pronouns in your language
- 9:51is often associated with more psychological distress.
- 9:56So you're more likely to talk about yourself,
- 9:59and you're more likely to talk about yourself in a negative way.
- 10:02So and you can pick that up in the way people that just naturalistically
- 10:06typing on their phones,
- 10:07whether it be messages to friends or they what they put into search engines.
- 10:12So that's one example.
- 10:13Another example is just looking at
- 10:16the amount of time people spend at home versus out of home every day.
- 10:20So that's something you can measure with the GPS sensor.
- 10:23And in general,
- 10:25I should point out, there's nothing wrong with spending a lot of time at home
- 10:28or not much time at home.
- 10:29But if you see a change within a person, they change from their usual pattern right
- 10:34then spending more time at home tends to indicate they're not well.
- 10:40I should emphasize none of these data points should be used by themselves.
- 10:43They need to be used with other in context.
- 10:46But they can they can provide important clues,
- 10:50not only to how someone's doing, but also how you might be able to help them.
- 10:55So this is where we get to this question about using it in a positive way.
- 10:59Right. So information is power.
- 11:01And if I have more knowledge about myself
- 11:03and my own patterns in my life, then I can make decisions.
- 11:06So for example, one of our products with the company,
- 11:09Ksana Health, is a product that gives people feedback
- 11:13on their personal patterns
- 11:15and how they relate to their mental health and well-being,
- 11:17and that would relate to both things that they're aware of,
- 11:20but also some things that they probably aren't aware of.
- 11:23Interesting.
- 11:25Well, as
- 11:26students head back to school, what's the research say
- 11:29about why these times of transition tend to be tough on kids?
- 11:33Mental health?
- 11:35Yeah, so often surprises people.
- 11:37Well, maybe it doesn't,
- 11:38but basically kids are much more on average at a population level.
- 11:43Kids are much more mentally healthy when they're on vacation.
- 11:46The end of the the summer vacation in particular, the long summer vacation
- 11:50is often a time of great relief for parents because they have to.
- 11:53They don't have to plan and manage their kids.
- 11:56They can send them off somewhere else to do something valuable, like learn things.
- 12:00But, but what we see is in the data is very clear
- 12:05that at a population level, I use that term repeatedly, because
- 12:11the point of using that term
- 12:12is that not every kids experience is the same.
- 12:16Yes. Right.
- 12:17But at a population level, when school goes back,
- 12:21depression goes up, anxiety
- 12:23goes up, suicide rate goes up.
- 12:26We work with a lot of, pediatric, mental health services.
- 12:30And suddenly, you know, they have a very quiet summer.
- 12:33Suddenly there's a lot of people seeking services at those times.
- 12:36So going back to school on average is a stressful thing.
- 12:40Now, that doesn't mean it's true of every kid.
- 12:42Like I said, some kids are going to be like,
- 12:44just desperate to get back to school.
- 12:46They love school,
- 12:47whether it's because of the academics or the athletics or the social connection
- 12:51or whatever it is. There's something about school that they love,
- 12:53and they can't wait to get back to.
- 12:55And there are some kids who it's probably fine either way.
- 12:58And then there are some kids, and these are the ones that,
- 13:01of course, we are concerned about for whom it's a real challenge.
- 13:04And whether it's the peer environment being more intensive,
- 13:07whether it's the stress of academic pressure, other sorts of,
- 13:11you know, pressures that go with being at school,
- 13:13some of those kids are going to be having a really challenging time.
- 13:16Now, I'm not saying you shouldn't go to school.
- 13:18Obviously they should.
- 13:19There's lots of positive things about going to school, but I think
- 13:22for families, schools, communities, people in health care to understand
- 13:26that this is actually a really challenging time for a lot of kids is important.
- 13:30You know, we saw a similar thing happen during Covid.
- 13:33You know, there are some kids who during Covid
- 13:34and the lockdowns were really like, I hate this.
- 13:37I just can't wait to get back out there and be with my friends.
- 13:41And there were some kids who were like, actually,
- 13:44it's kind of nice, you know, I'm hanging out with my family.
- 13:48I, you know, get to be online a lot, you know,
- 13:50just things that maybe for them, with their personality
- 13:53and their particular context worked well for them.
- 13:57And so for some of those kids,
- 13:59going back to school after the lockdowns was actually very challenging.
- 14:03But it's everyone's different. Right?
- 14:06So for parents who worry about how much time
- 14:09their kids are spending on screens, what's a more useful question to ask
- 14:13than just how much time they're on those devices?
- 14:17This is a big, bugbear of mine is that people spend a lot of time
- 14:21focusing on,
- 14:25screen time, the amount of time kids spend on screens.
- 14:28And I understand why that is.
- 14:31It's because it's the easiest thing as a parent to get
- 14:35some sense of what's going on.
- 14:38But to know what's going on actually on the device is much more challenging,
- 14:43because you need to have a kid who's willing to talk to you about that.
- 14:46Sure.
- 14:47Because
- 14:49even if you think you know, you probably don't know.
- 14:52And that's a very challenging thing for a parent of a teenager, right?
- 14:55Because those teenage years are a period where the kid is going from
- 14:59being very dependent
- 15:01on you as a parent, very
- 15:03open, often with you about all the things that come home
- 15:05and they'll say, guess what happened to school today?
- 15:07I want to tell you all about it.
- 15:08And they go to this kind of monosyllabic, you know,
- 15:12kid who just says, like, what happened at school?
- 15:14And they go stuff.
- 15:17Yeah. It's okay, you know?
- 15:19And so you and although that's very frustrating
- 15:22in some ways sad for a parent because, you know, you want to have that open
- 15:27relationship with the child that you had when they were younger.
- 15:30It's also developmentally important
- 15:32because it's part of them learning to be independent.
- 15:35And part of that
- 15:35learning to be independent is keeping something to themselves.
- 15:38Right. And having their own privacy.
- 15:41If, if you don't do that you can't become an adult.
- 15:45Right. And that's the point of adolescence.
- 15:47But it's not easy for parents.
- 15:48And so when we bring that into the online space the online space is very powerful
- 15:52for kids because it is such a private space.
- 15:55And when we talk to kids about collecting data from their phones,
- 16:00they don't care about Google or Meta or anything knowing
- 16:03what's going on in their phones, but they don't want their parents to know.
- 16:07Right.
- 16:08And so the privacy is very important to them
- 16:11from the parents because that is the developmental challenge.
- 16:14How do I become independent from these people who I've been so dependent on.
- 16:19So that the thing that happens for parents is that they can notice
- 16:22how much time they're on their phone, maybe get a sense of that,
- 16:24but they don't really know what they're doing. Right.
- 16:27But the problem is that what they're doing is what matters.
- 16:30They could be doing really great things online.
- 16:32They could be doing really positive things.
- 16:34They could be doing really awful things.
- 16:36They could be doing a mix.
- 16:37They could be be bullied. They could be going down a rabbit hole.
- 16:40They could be learning about quantum physics.
- 16:42They could be reading the great works of literature.
- 16:44They could be learning about new technology.
- 16:47They could be doing like so many different things.
- 16:49And when we put that all into one category, it's kind of like saying
- 16:52magazines are bad.
- 16:54You know, it doesn't matter if it's a New Yorker or pornography, right?
- 16:56It's no difference. They're just magazines.
- 16:58And that's kind of what we do with the online environment.
- 17:01So I think the advice to parents is actually important but not easy.
- 17:06And what the advice is, you have to develop and maintain
- 17:10as best as you can, a relationship with your child,
- 17:13where they will talk to you about what's going on online
- 17:19and in particular that they will talk to you
- 17:22when something happens that they are concerned about or confused about,
- 17:27because they might not tell you everything, but you really want them to be
- 17:30someone you want to be someone that they will come to
- 17:34when they do have those more concerning or distressing experiences.
- 17:39And that means that you've got to maintain that openness.
- 17:43And to be frank, sometimes you've got to do it one sided.
- 17:47Often, you know, you've just got to hang in there and keep sending that message.
- 17:52I'm here when you need me.
- 17:54I'm not going to be judgmental.
- 17:56I love you, I care about you.
- 17:57I want to know what's going on with you.
- 17:59And you'll get that monosyllabic response and you'll get it again.
- 18:03And you'll get it again.
- 18:05But hopefully, if you've stuck with that message, then the time
- 18:08when they really need to talk to you, that door's open and they know it.
- 18:12Right. Right.
- 18:14So you mentioned sleep earlier,
- 18:17as a risk factor for adolescent depression.
- 18:20What exactly is the connection there?
- 18:22And what should parents watch for when their kids sleep?
- 18:25Routines are disrupted.
- 18:27So there's a there's a fairly typical pattern that occurs for many adolescents,
- 18:32which is often they become somewhat sleep deprived during the school week.
- 18:36And the reason for that is that they have a lot of there's a couple of reasons.
- 18:39They have a lot of activities that keep them up later.
- 18:42Some of them are homework.
- 18:43Sometimes it's athletics, clubs, other things,
- 18:47but also being online and being connected with peers through that method.
- 18:52So you've got
- 18:53interesting things to do in the evening and important things to do in the evening.
- 18:57Secondly, in adolescence, biology is changing
- 19:01so that they're chrono phase shifts.
- 19:03Chrono phase refers to this rhythm of when their body feels like going to sleep,
- 19:08and when it feels like waking up,
- 19:09and for reasons that are largely biological, that shifts forward.
- 19:14So adolescents biologically actually want to go to bed later
- 19:16and they want to sleep in later.
- 19:18And then we have school times. Right.
- 19:20Which say you've got to get up at this time rigidly during the week.
- 19:24So there's a push later in the evening.
- 19:27There's a rigid waking time.
- 19:29And so what happens is a lot of kids get into what's called sleep debt.
- 19:33They're not getting enough sleep.
- 19:34And of course they need sleep developmentally.
- 19:36I mean, they're growing like a weed and all these things.
- 19:39And the brain's changing there’s massive changes and reorganization
- 19:42occurring in the brain.
- 19:43And sleep is one of the things, along with nutrition, exercise,
- 19:45all the other good things that really supports that.
- 19:48So get to the end of the week.
- 19:50You're exhausted. What do you do?
- 19:53Well, on
- 19:54Saturday you're going to sleep in catch up.
- 19:57Right. And that's great.
- 19:59Catch up on your sleep on Saturday.
- 20:01Then maybe Saturday night.
- 20:02You've got a social activity that takes you even later,
- 20:04so you sleep even more on Sunday.
- 20:06It's so good for dealing, getting getting some more sleep.
- 20:09But you've also got this underlying rhythm.
- 20:12And what happens then is on Monday, you've got to reset it.
- 20:15And that's what we call social jetlag,
- 20:18because it's kind of like flying to France.
- 20:21You know, we all know what it's like to sort of have that jetlag feeling
- 20:24where you feel kind of sweaty and weird and you can't think straight
- 20:27because your body wants to be asleep, but it's got to be awake, you know?
- 20:31And kids are often giving themselves a dose of that every week.
- 20:35So on Monday, maybe the first 2 or 3 hours,
- 20:39they're not tuned in because they're redoing this reset.
- 20:42So this pattern that I've just described is a typical pattern.
- 20:45Some kids have it even more extremely, and the kids who have it
- 20:48more extremely are at greater risk for mental health problems.
- 20:52So one of the things that we try to
- 20:56teach kids to, improve
- 20:59their resilience is to develop a regular
- 21:03pattern to their sleep,
- 21:05including on the weekends, which is a really hard one.
- 21:09Right?
- 21:10And so that means during the week, being aware that you might need
- 21:13to go to bed a little bit earlier than maybe
- 21:15you feel like either biologically or socially,
- 21:18to be frank, it's something that parents are often
- 21:20quite happy to see sleep disrupted by homework
- 21:23because they say homework is a very positive activity or something.
- 21:26That's.
- 21:27But sometimes parents have to also be willing to tell the kid
- 21:30that that's enough homework.
- 21:31I mean, as you probably know, there's a whole debate
- 21:33about whether homework's beneficial for learning anyway.
- 21:36It's become a kind of a cultural touchstone.
- 21:38But anyway, so for kids who are vulnerable, it's particularly powerful.
- 21:42So for example,
- 21:45I've done a lot of work, a lot of research
- 21:47and a lot of clinical work with kids who are at high risk for suicide.
- 21:50And amongst this group of kids, disrupted sleep is a very powerful predictor
- 21:55of what we call the ideation to action transition,
- 21:59which is where you go from thinking about it to potentially doing something.
- 22:04So being tired, being exhausted is one of the things that can contribute,
- 22:07along with many other things interpersonal conflict, being intoxicated.
- 22:12There's a whole bunch of things that can trigger that transformation.
- 22:15And, sleep is one that can contribute to that.
- 22:17So it's not a it's not a trivial thing.
- 22:20It's a pretty important thing.
- 22:21What role does family environment play in either buffering or amplifying
- 22:26stress during major transitions, like starting a school year or ending it?
- 22:30One of the cultural stories we have about adolescence is that your family
- 22:35doesn't matter that much anymore, that it's all about the peers.
- 22:38Right.
- 22:39And certainly peers are very important during adolescence.
- 22:43But in fact the research is interesting because it tends to suggest that families
- 22:50are probably more
- 22:51important for mental health even than peer relationships.
- 22:55And that's a bit surprising because.
- 22:57But but it's actually the very fragile and fractious nature
- 23:01of adolescent relationships that probably tells us why.
- 23:05Because that's kind of normal.
- 23:07Adolescence are often breaking up with friends, making new friends,
- 23:10you know there’s a lot of social churn that occurs during adolescence.
- 23:14And that's, that's that's quite normal.
- 23:16And that's true of both peer friendships but also romantic relationships
- 23:20and so forth.
- 23:21So this kind of, stress and churn associated
- 23:24with peer relationships is very salient to adolescence.
- 23:27But it's it's somewhat normative.
- 23:29The question is, do you have that buffering family environment
- 23:32that you can go to when, let's say you've been rejected,
- 23:36in a social relationship and it's really, really stinging.
- 23:40It's really hurting.
- 23:41Can you go home to a family where you can talk to your parents about that,
- 23:45or where you can just feel loved, you know, and valued in that context?
- 23:50Because that often becomes kind of like a home base
- 23:52that can then build up that resilience for you
- 23:55to go back out there and try again and build a new friendship,
- 24:00or maybe repair one that's been, affected.
- 24:03So, so families are really important.
- 24:06That's my first message is, don't figure just because your adolescent doesn't seem
- 24:10that interested in talking to you
- 24:11or seems monosyllabic or whatever it might be, that you're not important.
- 24:15And research tells you that families are really important during adolescence.
- 24:19Even to the extent of affecting how the brain develops.
- 24:22We've published some papers on that topic.
- 24:25So what should families do?
- 24:27Well, I've I've referred to it already.
- 24:29Some of it you have to be aware that some of your adolescence
- 24:33pulling back from the relationship
- 24:35and being a little bit more guarded is actually not a rejection,
- 24:39but an important developmental process that they're going through.
- 24:42And it's important for them to grow and become an independent person.
- 24:46The other thing is that they will be pushing boundaries,
- 24:49and that's kind of their job, you know, to sort of like make mistakes, take risks,
- 24:54do things that perhaps the parents would like them to do because you parent,
- 24:59you just want your child to be safe
- 25:00and, and, and well and all those sorts of things.
- 25:02And that's a very appropriate thing for a parent to want.
- 25:05But but the adolescent is pushing against that
- 25:07because they want to become independent. They want to grow up.
- 25:10And so they want to take risks. They want to make mistakes.
- 25:12They want to try crazy things. They want to break out of the mold.
- 25:15And and that is, once again, not a bad thing.
- 25:18That's important.
- 25:19But as they're doing that, that can create a lot of conflict.
- 25:22And so we have this, you know, metaphor that we talk about
- 25:25with parents being able to scaffold the adolescence experience.
- 25:28We know scaffolding is something
- 25:29you build around a building, and then you can take it away
- 25:32as the building becomes more mature and fully formed.
- 25:36And so this idea that it's it's very different to parent to some things
- 25:39you might say no to, to a 13 year old, maybe you should say yes to a 15 year old.
- 25:45And then more things you might say yes to, to an 18 year old.
- 25:48So this is a dynamic and changing thing.
- 25:50As you do this, then the critical thing is how do you disagree
- 25:54without being disagreeable.
- 25:56Right.
- 25:57So you can have the same goal and presented in a very different context.
- 26:02So let's say you've got an adolescent who's got a messy room.
- 26:04Let's take a very simple example.
- 26:06And a common. One. Yeah. And a common one.
- 26:08So you can come in and you can say, listen, this room is a mess.
- 26:11It's totally disgusting.
- 26:13I don't know how you live with it.
- 26:15And in fact, I don't even know if you can do this like, I've been asking
- 26:19for so long and I have just had it with you, you know, like, really?
- 26:23I think you're a hopeless case, right?
- 26:26So what did I say then?
- 26:27I said, one, I want you to clean your messy room.
- 26:29But I also said a bunch of other things you've tried before and you've failed.
- 26:33In fact, I don't think you can you can succeed in the future.
- 26:36And in fact, I feel really negatively about you as a person.
- 26:41You can
- 26:41deliver exactly the same message, the important one.
- 26:45You can say, hey, your room is really messy
- 26:49and I'm sure it must bug you too.
- 26:53I mean, and you've I remember the other a few months ago
- 26:56where you really cleaned it up a lot and you felt really great about it.
- 26:59And I thought it was amazing. I was really proud of you.
- 27:02And you did that.
- 27:03So, you know, do you think we could find a way to do that again?
- 27:06When? When would be a good time?
- 27:08Anyway, I'm sort of improvising here a bit, but you get you get the idea.
- 27:11Yeah.
- 27:11Both conversations are about the same thing ostensibly:
- 27:15How do you get the kid to clean the room?
- 27:17One conveys you're hopeless.
- 27:19I'm frustrated.
- 27:21I'm giving up on you.
- 27:22The other one conveys I'm optimistic.
- 27:25You're a good person. I know you can do this.
- 27:27And I know that we probably want the same thing here at the end of the day,
- 27:31but there’s just some reasons why it's not happening.
- 27:32Let's work it out.
- 27:34So that's the kind of skill we're talking about.
- 27:36We're not asking parents to give away their,
- 27:39appropriate,
- 27:42management and advice and maybe even, you know,
- 27:45control of what the kids are going through in certain ways.
- 27:48But to do it while also conveying
- 27:52that you're a good person, I love you, I'm optimistic,
- 27:57and I know we can solve this problem.
- 27:59That's the trick.
- 28:00Yeah, that's very helpful. Nick.
- 28:03Through your startup, Ksana Health, you're developing tools
- 28:05meant to intervene exactly when users need them.
- 28:08What does that kind of just in time support actually look like for a teenager?
- 28:14So in the mental health field we have we have this model
- 28:17of how we deliver mental health care.
- 28:19And it basically means that I have an office and someone comes
- 28:23and sees me maybe once a week for 45 minutes,
- 28:2750 minutes, and we talk about what's going on,
- 28:30and then we send them back out into their life.
- 28:32And hopefully that talk has some effect out there.
- 28:37But the fact is, that's probably not the best way
- 28:40of delivering methods to help people change their behavior in positive ways.
- 28:44The metaphor that I sometimes use is, imagine there was a football
- 28:48coach who said to the team,
- 28:50look, I'm not going to come to the game.
- 28:52I'm not going to even come to practice.
- 28:54I'm just going to sit in my office and have each player
- 28:56come and talk to me for an hour a week,
- 28:58and I'll tell them how I think they could play better, and then they'll go out
- 29:02and try to put that into action, but I'm not going to be there.
- 29:05Now obviously had been a football coach and being a therapist
- 29:08are two different things.
- 29:09But there is some important overlap there I think.
- 29:11And so this is where we get to the Just-in-time point is that often
- 29:16when people really need help is not when they're in that appointment.
- 29:19They need help out in their real day to day lives.
- 29:22And the question is, how can you be present for that?
- 29:24Because therapist can't walk around following their clients around all week.
- 29:29Well, as I said before, we've got these
- 29:31very powerful little computers that are in our pockets all the time.
- 29:34Could we use that? Might there be some way?
- 29:38So one use case that we've looked at extensively
- 29:42is the is the, issue of suicide risk.
- 29:47And suicide is very much, a when question.
- 29:51And what I mean by that is
- 29:53that for people who are at risk of taking
- 29:56suicidal actions, often that period when they're going to do
- 29:59that is very short, maybe half an hour might be a little longer.
- 30:04And so if you can get someone through that period,
- 30:07then often they will start to feel a bit differently
- 30:10and see the world a bit differently, and they will become more hopeful.
- 30:12And I'll choose to make a different choice rather than to take that kind of action.
- 30:19So it's a really challenging use case.
- 30:22But if we could in some way predict when people need help,
- 30:27then that's then that that could be really beneficial.
- 30:30Now one way you can get help is you can call a crisis line.
- 30:34And we know that when
- 30:35people call crisis lines, they're much less likely to take action.
- 30:38So that's great.
- 30:40But then you still need that wherewithal to say,
- 30:42I need to call someone and I'm going to do it now.
- 30:45So the possibility with this kind of technology is
- 30:48could it actually push something to you when you need it?
- 30:51Now, I want to be clear that we cannot yet, and maybe never
- 30:55will be able to predict when someone's going to take a suicidal action.
- 30:59That's a very hard problem to solve.
- 31:01But what we can do
- 31:02when we're starting to be able to do
- 31:04is to understand when they might be at generally at higher risk.
- 31:08So I mentioned some things before, like maybe if you're not leaving the house,
- 31:12maybe if there's certain patterns in your language
- 31:14that you're typing into the phone, maybe if you've become less
- 31:17active, less physically active, there's various patterns that we can say
- 31:21that we think might be the beginning of some clues.
- 31:24And then what we do is we we do some work, for example,
- 31:27with people who work in pediatric emergency departments.
- 31:31So when young people come in
- 31:33and they've got suicide risk or they've had an attempt,
- 31:35one of the things they do there is they build what's called a suicide safety plan,
- 31:39which is a set of guidelines
- 31:40of what you're going to do if you're in a crisis in the future.
- 31:44Very often it's on paper, you know, it's stapled
- 31:47to the back of your discharge summary and kind of gets lost.
- 31:50Not always, but, you know, in some many cases.
- 31:52So we have a version of that that sits on the phone.
- 31:55And we also have
- 31:57what we call nudges, which are notifications
- 31:59that come from the phone that remind you to use that plan.
- 32:02And some of them are
- 32:03scheduled to remind you, and some of them are driven by different patterns
- 32:07that we are learning from the phone about your day to day behavior,
- 32:10with the hope that some of those nudges, at least will come when you need them.
- 32:14And that doesn't mean that you're actively suicidal,
- 32:16but it might mean that you're experiencing high levels of distress,
- 32:19and you can learn skills at that moment about how to manage your distress.
- 32:24So that's an example.
- 32:26It's a once again, admittedly, it's a fairly dramatic example,
- 32:30but I focus on it because it's a an example of a problem
- 32:34that will occur mostly, almost always outside of an appointment.
- 32:38In fact, we know that the time of night
- 32:41when it occurs is often, you know, somewhere between 12 a.m.
- 32:46and 3 a.m., even for teenagers, you know,
- 32:49that's when places hospitals aren't even open.
- 32:52You know, like doctors offices, hospitals are.
- 32:54But you know, you know what I mean?
- 32:55So that's the essence of just in time intervention.
- 32:58We also do some work on substance use and addiction, where
- 33:01you can see certain patterns, like for example,
- 33:05if people indicate locations where they might obtain or use drugs,
- 33:10then they can write a message to themselves
- 33:12that they would want to have delivered if they get close to that location,
- 33:15just to remind them of why they might want to make a different decision.
- 33:19And the fact that it's a message from yourself
- 33:21is very important, because the last thing people with addiction challenges want
- 33:25is someone wagging their finger at them and telling them
- 33:27they should do something different.
- 33:29So that's got to come from themselves, right?
- 33:32So they're examples of just in time intervention
- 33:34and what we're talking about there, and basically trying to be there
- 33:38at those critical moments when there's a decision to be made
- 33:42where things could go one way or another, and hopefully just giving someone a nudge
- 33:46in the right direction.
- 33:48Nick, if you could get one piece of research backed advice
- 33:52into the hands of every parent, what would it be?
- 33:55Just one?
- 33:58Yeah, let's focus on one.
- 33:59Okay?
- 34:00I think at the moment, honestly, I think there's a almost a sense
- 34:04of community panic about the effects
- 34:09of digital technology on young people.
- 34:13And I think that this is an area where the community conversation
- 34:18and the research is very divergent, and I don't think most people know that.
- 34:24And so, in fact, the research tends to tell us
- 34:26that most kids are doing just fine,
- 34:30and most kids can even use digital technology
- 34:33quite extensively and have really no harm.
- 34:36And for some, it's very beneficial in many ways.
- 34:40Now, that doesn't mean there isn't some bad things that happen online.
- 34:43There are, and there are some kids who have very bad outcomes.
- 34:45But to go back to our discussion about school,
- 34:48there's some kids that have very bad
- 34:49outcomes going to school too, and we don't suggest we get rid of school.
- 34:53So I think the piece of advice I'd like to tell parents
- 34:55today is that simply using digital technology,
- 35:00even social media, is not in itself harmful,
- 35:05and that our research is getting clearer and clearer about that.
- 35:09Having said that, there are harmful things that can happen online
- 35:13and so really focus on what's happening
- 35:17and what your child's experience is,
- 35:19and not just the fact that they're using it.
- 35:22Because I think when you talk about the fact
- 35:23that they just focusing on their use, then you've got your eye off the ball.
- 35:28The ball is what are they doing
- 35:32and what are their experiences and reactions to that.
- 35:34And that involves a conversation, not just a blanket.
- 35:37Like the phone is evil.
- 35:40Got it.
- 35:41Thanks for your time today, Nick.
- 35:43Thanks for joining us today.
- 35:45If you're interested in learning more,
- 35:47check out the links in the episode description.
- 35:49And don't forget to follow This Is Oregon.
- 35:52For more stories from the University of Oregon.
- 35:54This Is Oregon is produced by the Division of University Communications.
- 35:58For more of the latest University of Oregon research and news,
- 36:02visit news Dot you Oregon Edu or find us
- 36:07on your favorite social media platform using the handle at you Oregon.
- 36:12Thanks for listening and go ducks!