Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Jodi Arias - (Chapter 5)
Transcript
- 0:00All right, Berto chapter five in our deep dive on the psychology of Jodi
- 0:04Arias, Let's get into it. What do you say, Let's do it.
- 0:07This is the Psychology and Shadow Podcast. I'm your host, doctor Karkanda.
- 0:11I'm a therapist and a professor. My name is m I watched trains
- 0:16and judge them, all right, So this first part of the episode,
- 0:20Chapter five will be for everyone, and then at some point we'll transition into
- 0:25the patron zone because I want to reward the patrons for giving me money so
- 0:30that I don't have to work at the university full time, so that I
- 0:32can actually spend the time on episodes like this. I've been nerding out on
- 0:36this for weeks, just sixteen hours a day, you know, several days
- 0:41watching all this kind of stuff. Very fascinating case. Okay, so chapter
- 0:44four was the last chapter, and we went into detail about the murder itself,
- 0:49right, the events that we can definitely point to as factual, and
- 0:54then there's a lot of things that we can speculate as to what happened.
- 0:59Very brutal murder, lots of blood, lots of just horrible details. Pictures
- 1:06that were accidentally taken while the murder was happening, and then she tries to
- 1:11cover up. She tries to get an alibi, She tries to act like
- 1:15everything's fine. She meets up with her boyfriend, and this is on June
- 1:21fourth, when he died. And at this point he was supposed to go
- 1:26on a conference call that evening for work, and he wasn't on that conference
- 1:30call, and people started to become concerned. So June fifth, I know,
- 1:34last chapter I was talking about how the evening of the murder she drove
- 1:38to Ryan Burn's house. But lower in my notes it looks like it was
- 1:42the next day that she drove to Ryan Burn's house. So maybe she slept
- 1:46in her car. I don't know, But all that that we talked about
- 1:49Ryan Burns and all likelihood seemed to have happened the next day. There are
- 1:55reports that he noticed she had a bunch of cuts on her hands, presumably
- 2:00stabbing Travis, and she told him. She told Ryan She's like, oh
- 2:06my god, you have all these cuts, and he would say that she
- 2:09told him that she cut her hands on broken glass while working at a restaurant
- 2:14called Margaritaville, and a detective testified in court that no restaurant by that name
- 2:20had ever existed in the Eureka area. So she's even lying about where she
- 2:25worked. She could have said a lot of things, like I cut my
- 2:28hands on broken glass at home, but she because she's a pathological liar,
- 2:31she or at least she lies a lot, or she's an amode of lying.
- 2:35She you know, said that it was at a restaurant called Margaritaville at
- 2:38the time, Jody was actually working at a restaurant called Casa Ramos. Am
- 2:44I saying that, right, yeah, Casa Ramos. So that's a very
- 2:46interesting one. She could have just said that, right. She could have
- 2:49said, oh, yeah, a whole bunch of glass broke. I was
- 2:52trying to pick it up stupidly at the restaurant where I work, period,
- 2:55or at the restaurant where I work, Cassa Ramos, even yeah, because
- 2:59is this person gonna call Casa Ramos? Hey did this person cut their hands?
- 3:02Like, No, that's not gonna happen. I like, how you
- 3:05say, I said it right, and then you proceed to say it more
- 3:07right. So Jody would later testify and sort of rebuttal of all this that
- 3:17after she cut her finger, she had a billion. She had quote unquote
- 3:22a basilion margaritas to make at Casa Ramos. So she's like, I didn't
- 3:28say, he said, because I told him that I had a bazilion margaritas.
- 3:35You know. It's just interesting, which, by the way, could
- 3:37be true, but they'd be given all the other lies. It's like,
- 3:39yeah. June six, she left Salt Lake City away from her her new
- 3:45boyfriend drove west to California. She called Travis several times and left several more
- 3:50voice messages for him voicemail messages. She also accessed his cell phone voicemail system
- 3:55at this point, and there's records of that from her phone call, you
- 3:59know, because you can tell what phone is calling the voicemail. She doesn't
- 4:02she doesn't know that or didn't think it would matter. So June seventh,
- 4:05she returned the car, and you know, they write down how many miles
- 4:10that you drove, because they charge you by the mile, right, and
- 4:13a little more than utah, right, so twenty one hundred miles. That
- 4:16detail would be used against her to show her that she did that, to
- 4:19show the jury that she did in fact drive to Arizona. But then she
- 4:23claims she got lost something like that well, I got lost in the desert,
- 4:27but it doesn't make any sense. Yeah. The rental clerk testified that
- 4:30the car was missing floor mats and had red stains on its front and rear
- 4:35seats. However, it could not be verified that the car had floor mats
- 4:41when Arius actually picked up the car, and the red stains could not be
- 4:45analyzed as the car was cleaned before the peace could examine it. So we
- 4:47just have the testimony of the worker. Hydron, you know, I'm sorry.
- 4:51It should just be a law that rental car rental companies if they see
- 4:58blood, they need to rep to the police. Yeah, I don't know.
- 5:02I can't imagine anyone in that scenario following it or caring because there's probably
- 5:09a lot of signs of blood or something, and I imagine the police would
- 5:14say, no, no, no, don't make that a law, because
- 5:16every cut that happens, we're gonna have all right. June nine, so
- 5:20this is five days after the murder. Having been unable to reach Travis,
- 5:25a concerned group of friends went to us home, including Mimi after and actually
- 5:30four days later this is this is five days later June nine, and he
- 5:34was supposed to have flown already out of town to the conference, and he
- 5:40wasn't at the conference, and so they find a key to his room and
- 5:45they enter his room. And by the way, this is a point of
- 5:48confusion as well, how can how did no one smell this if their roommates?
- 5:55So how did his roommates not smell this? Right, because once you
- 5:59enter the room, it's, you know, pretty obvious that something's going on.
- 6:03Well, so what the I think? It's two guys that lived with
- 6:08him, and you know, these are thirty ish thirty, you know,
- 6:12late twenties, early thirties, single guys, And what they would say is
- 6:16we either didn't smell it, or we did smell it but confused it for
- 6:20something else. And what they would say is, you know, in our
- 6:24house, we drink beer. We don't necessarily take out the garbage all the
- 6:28time. And to a lot of people when they hear that, they're like,
- 6:30maybe, to you, that's absurd. But I've lived with a lot
- 6:34of roommates in my early twenties and I can tell you that there's a lot
- 6:38of disgusting smells that just happen. Plus personally, I've never smelled a decaying
- 6:44body before. Yeah, I don't even know if I've smelled acay a decaying
- 6:49corpse of like an animal, so I can't. I from what I hear,
- 6:55it's a very distinctive smell. But if I smelled it, what I
- 6:58know it was a dead corpse. I hear you of all the data here,
- 7:03everything to me always added up about this except for that, just from
- 7:08the perspective of I've had roommates. I had roommates for so many years,
- 7:12and the thought that you know, four or five days would go by and
- 7:16I wouldn't hear or see them, I wouldn't get curious at all or anything,
- 7:21and I wouldn't smell anything like that just seems so unbelievable to me.
- 7:26I think that the roommates weren't exactly like best friends. I think they were
- 7:30roommates and they would all have periods of time where they wouldn't see each other.
- 7:35He had his own bathroom, his own bedroom, maybe his own TV,
- 7:39that kind of thing. He worked a lot, he traveled a lot.
- 7:42So you remember, like you know Dean. You know, I lived
- 7:44with my friend Dean, and he had his own entrance downstairs. He could
- 7:47if he wanted to, he could go in and out without me noticing,
- 7:50right, But there's no way. But you also spent a lot of time
- 7:55downstairs and right outside his bedroom. So you know, well, what's the
- 8:01what's the speculation that they did know there was a dead body? Well that
- 8:03if there were, which is interesting that this wasn't even they didn't try to
- 8:07go this direction. If there was ever gonna be anyone else involved in this
- 8:11day, it would have been the two people that didn't notice or smell anything,
- 8:15right, But of course no, it's again all comes Razor would be
- 8:18like, no, they just literally didn't notice. Yeah, it's just so
- 8:22to me, it just seems crazy. Yeah, we don't know how bad
- 8:26the smells. We don't know the seal on the bedroom door, we don't
- 8:31know if the bathroom door was closed. It's just it doesn't seem out of
- 8:35the ordinary for me. Okay, so they break you know, they get
- 8:39into his room, they find blood everywhere in the hallway, they just immediately
- 8:45see blood. They're like, oh no. They enter the bathroom and they
- 8:48see his stuffed body and the shower. In the nine one one call,
- 8:52which I listened to, yeah I did too, the dispatcher asked whether Travis
- 8:58had been suicidal or if anyone was in gree enough to hurt him, and
- 9:01his friends immediately mentioned Jody Arius by name as a possible suspect. They said
- 9:07that Travis had told him that she had been stalking him, accessing his Facebook
- 9:11account, and slashing his car's tires, so immediately or pretty quickly, they
- 9:18start to investigate her and the crime scene, which, by the way,
- 9:22this also paintens a picture of what a mythical world she was living in her
- 9:26head, and you know, like all of this in her mind somehow she
- 9:31must have had an inkling that she might be able to get away with it.
- 9:35But just disregarding all the reality of like, well, all these people
- 9:39know I've been stalking him. She doesn't see it that way. She doesn't
- 9:43think all these people think I've been stalking him, that all these people know
- 9:46I slashed his tires, and all these people know I showed up unexpected,
- 9:48blah blah blah. She doesn't see any of that. She's like, uh,
- 9:52well, there wasn't any direct evidence that she had done any of those
- 9:56things. She was standing outside the door when they were discussed seeing her at
- 10:00one time. Yeah, but the slashing of the tires and the stocking,
- 10:05she could conceivably believe that if push came to shove, there wasn't any evidence
- 10:09that implicated her. Plus, she wasn't someone like, hey, you know
- 10:15what, I'm going to devise a scheme that will get me money. How
- 10:20do I do that? Okay, what's the logical? This was a crime
- 10:22of passion that she tried to implement with some self preservation. You know,
- 10:28she wasn't what multiday planning. I mean, I'm not saying it was.
- 10:33It was all well thought out. I'm just saying it wasn't like in the
- 10:37moment she finally snapped it no, no, no. But she she made
- 10:39a decision seemingly a week or even a month or two prior to kill him.
- 10:46But my point is is that the emotionality around I must kill him was
- 10:52very tremendous for her, and so the push to do it. It wasn't
- 10:56like the reason why I bring up the counterexam ample of someone saying, you
- 11:01know what, how do I kill someone to take their money? There's not
- 11:03a desperation there, right, It's not like I she in all likelihood emotionally
- 11:11had to kill him. Not that she had to, but yeah, in
- 11:13her mind, she felt that she was left with no other option. Yeah,
- 11:16I must destroy him, maybe, even as you were pointing out in
- 11:20the last chapter before he goes on this Mexico trip and displays to everyone that
- 11:26he truly is over me totally. It's just, you know, some of
- 11:28these annihilators in the last ten, fifteen, twenty years, they'll go in
- 11:33expecting probably to get shot by the cops or maybe kill themselves. You know
- 11:39when I'm talking about his shooters. You know they'll go in, they'll kill
- 11:41a whole bunch of people and then shoot themselves, or like, okay,
- 11:43here's the cops. I'll just go out in a blazical or just shoot me
- 11:46whatever. And you can imagine that there was not a huge fantasy in their
- 11:50head where like, I know how to get away with this, right right,
- 11:54And you're right that I think that the point wasn't necessarily to quote get
- 11:56away with it, because this wasn't trying to get money. At the same
- 12:01time, I still find it fascinating in a horrific way that it's like that
- 12:05she even thought she had a chance given all the evidence that she was leaving
- 12:09behind. Well, let's look at it so I can imagine, let's say
- 12:13that I'm this I'm the ghost of Travis, and I show up to Jody,
- 12:18and after I yell at her and chastiser, I say, how do
- 12:22you possibly think you're going to get away with this? And you know I
- 12:24could see her. I don't. I haven't thought about this. So let
- 12:28me kind of step into her mind at this point, given her point of
- 12:31view and what she has available to her in terms of knowledge, because you
- 12:35know, she's not a criminal mastermind at the age of twenty eight or how
- 12:39old she was. At the same she could have said something like, well,
- 12:45no one saw me at your house, and there's no record of me
- 12:48even being in Arizona, and I have an alibi. I have friends and
- 12:52so so cal. I have Ryan Burns in Utah, so that's why all
- 12:58that happened. If people ask me why I rented the car, I'll just
- 13:01say that my car wasn't working and they don't have any record of me at
- 13:05a gas station. So there's that. Now, she doesn't know or contemplate
- 13:11that when police investigate, they're going to look into a lot of things,
- 13:15including records of her buying a gas can. Now, she could argue,
- 13:18well, if they go into that, I'll just say I needed a just
- 13:20a backup, or I was buying it for a lawnmower at home, and
- 13:26they're like, well, there's also this burglar you're happening. So well,
- 13:28there's no evidence that that I did that right, but it right, and
- 13:33I totally get it from that perspective. But that adds to my point of
- 13:35how like her, her worldview is so distorted because she doesn't consider things like
- 13:41that his friends probably hate me. The first person they'll probably point to is
- 13:45me. That doesn't even probably enter in her brain. And that's interesting.
- 13:50Well, yeah, so this is what I'll get into later when I provide
- 13:54what I believe to be the diagnosis. I can't know, of course,
- 13:58because I haven't evaluated her, but based on a fair amount of data and
- 14:01also the psychological testing that was done, it's possible that she has narcissistic features.
- 14:09And with people like Ted Bundy and others, there's a and if you've
- 14:13ever had someone in your life who was on the narcissistic personality spectrum, they
- 14:18are so self centered and so grandiose that they believe with all of their heart
- 14:24that the things that they believe are the truth, because they're so in love
- 14:30with their own thoughts and they're so cut off from outside influence that they will
- 14:33believe, well, I figured it out. I'm better than the costs.
- 14:37Yeah, I know how to do these definite air of course, you're right,
- 14:41right, And when she was in court, which we'll get into later,
- 14:46she had this air. This stupid prosecutor, I'm so much smart,
- 14:50I'm gonna get away with this. No, you're right. It's just you
- 14:52know, I think about, like, if I was having this public argument,
- 14:56like with some neighbor or something, let's say, some big yelling match
- 14:58like you let your rodents in my lawn or whatever people argue about, right,
- 15:03and then later you let your rodents in my lawn, and then later
- 15:09tragically this this neighbor is murdered. Right, dude, I am immediately getting
- 15:13a lawyer showing up at the cops's doorstep, being like, my client has
- 15:18this story to tell. He admits freely that they had an argument. But
- 15:20here's all the alibis, here's all the proof, here's all the thing.
- 15:24Just because I'd be like, yeah, people are gonna say, yeah,
- 15:26well I saw him yelling at that. Dude, Well you've been obsessed with
- 15:30crime stories and murder TV. Well, also, you pay attention and you've
- 15:39seen a lot of things. Yeah. I mean there's a lot of people
- 15:41watching or listening to us right now who can say who have actively thought about
- 15:46if they had to kill someone, how would they cover up? Because of
- 15:50all the procedurals that they've watched. Yeah, because of all the documentaries they
- 15:54watch. It's like, okay, well, yeah, you know there are
- 15:56people out there that are experts on how to premeditate murder and clean up afterwards
- 16:00and get away with it because they've basically taken a graduate level set of courses
- 16:06on that by watching all the all the law and order and the um what's
- 16:11the one the no, but the documentary where every episode is a different murder.
- 16:15What's it called documentary? Yeah, every episode is an actual it's not
- 16:19a documentary, but it's an actual non fiction show with what's his face from?
- 16:25It's from the nineties, aiming every everyone else knows what that sort that
- 16:27that shows forensic files forensic files never watched. Yeah, so let's get into
- 16:33the investigation of so there's blood everywhere, when the when the police arrive and
- 16:40they take pictures and whatnot. There's blood on the floor, the walls,
- 16:45the ceiling, in the bedroom, in the bathroom, all over the place.
- 16:48They investigate the body, they confirm it actually is Travis, and because
- 16:53his face is unrecognizable after five days of decomposing, and they count twenty seven
- 17:00plus knife wounds and very deep knife wounds in his body. And they also
- 17:04eventually they discovered that he was shot in the head. Yeah, it was
- 17:08just interesting that it's so bad, like the head's so bad that you can't
- 17:11just like see that that's the case. Well, and also the evidence seemed
- 17:15to indicate that his heart had stopped when he was shot with such a small
- 17:19calib caliber blood. Yeah, it was a small entry wound, and I
- 17:26believe the bullet was still in his head. And so it took a while
- 17:32to discover that compared to all the huge knife wounds in his body. And
- 17:37the police and the investigators during the trial would say that this fit a profile
- 17:42of a revenge killing, because what were the elements of this that would indicate
- 17:48revenge killing? Broum So I guess that there were multiple murders, and like
- 17:55he wasn't killed once he was killed, stabbed to the heart. That would
- 17:57have killed him, it would have taken a while, would have killed them,
- 18:00the cut, slice through the through the neck that would have killed them,
- 18:04and then the gunshot to the head that would have killed them. Right
- 18:07at least, you know, any one of these had a very very high
- 18:10likelihood of killing him. Probably the slice through the neck was worse. Right.
- 18:14The it's overkill literally one of the qualities and also the rage that someone
- 18:21is that it's hands on. For example, if it's self defense, then
- 18:29you're going to see a different set of of wounds, like for example,
- 18:33maybe just one knife or one gun shot, because in self defense, you're
- 18:38just trying to stop it. Yeah, usually you're just trying to end it.
- 18:41And if you shoot someone and the threat ends and you run away,
- 18:45or if you're doing it because of a different reason, maybe it's manslaughter,
- 18:51you're just trying to hurt him. You're just trying to like I hate you
- 18:53in the moment, then you might stab him once or twice and then you'll
- 18:57stop because your purpose isn't too just completely I don't know what the word is,
- 19:04but raise them from existence. Yeah, you're so angry at the person
- 19:10that you want to kill them ten times over essentially, Yeah, yeah,
- 19:12I don't know how to describe it. But okay, So other things that
- 19:15they find are the sheets weren't on the bed and they're in the washing machine,
- 19:21haven't been cleaned. They find brown hairs clumped in blood, and they
- 19:26later will test the blood and the hair and it's his blood, her blood,
- 19:32her hair. They also find a pom print with her fingerprints or at
- 19:38someplace her fingerprints show up. I don't know if it's that pom print,
- 19:41and they you know, again, the handprint has DNA of both her and
- 19:47Travis. By the way, because the other thing is this isn't nineteen ninety
- 19:51one, this is two thousand and eight. So it's another thing where I'm
- 19:53you're right. Maybe it's because I watched too many movies or TV or O.
- 19:56J. Simpson trials, but I'd be like, if there's even one
- 20:00drop of my blood, I'm done. It's over. Yeah. It appears
- 20:03that because she had all the time in the world to clean up. I
- 20:06mean, presumably she had five days. Now she was trying to skidaddle,
- 20:10so she couldn't have an alibi, but she at least had another hour or
- 20:14two to finish, and I think she was in a rush. I think
- 20:18she thought at any point someone could come and come in. They might have
- 20:22heard the screams, because he's got to have screamed right, like hard to
- 20:26know. He might not have. He might not he might have not had
- 20:29the energy, or who knows. But so they also find footprints, bloody
- 20:33footprints. They're a match for her, her shoes, and like I said,
- 20:40they find at least one fingerprint of hers. There's a digital camera and
- 20:42the Washington machine, as we talked about, and she thought that she had
- 20:45deleted the photographs and or that the washing machine would destroy the memory, and
- 20:51they actually retrieved the pictures and the cups must have been like wow. They
- 20:56talk about handing me, yeah, the pig. And also they ask friends
- 21:04and family, and all of them will attest to lots of stories about Jody
- 21:08stocking him extensively, that she was jealous, that he was trying to get
- 21:12away from her. So all right, well let's take a break there,
- 21:15Berto, And then the next thing I want to talk about is the interrogation,
- 21:19which we've alluded to, but I want to kind of go over what
- 21:22you and I have seen, because you and I've watched hours and hours of
- 21:26her being interrogated because it's very fascinating. And then also I want to go
- 21:29into how she might have gotten away with it. A bit of a morbid
- 21:34discussion, but I think it. I don't know why it's interesting to talk
- 21:40about, but I want to explore that with you. And then we'll also
- 21:42get into the trial and all those kinds of things. But the rest of
- 21:45the podcast will just be for patrons of the podcast, because I want to
- 21:48thank all the patrons for actually giving me the ability to spend all the time
- 21:53to look into this. So if you want to hear the whole episode,
- 21:56become a patron. Otherwise, take care of yourself, because to serve it