Latest / Houselights: A Film Director Podcast / 2001 (1968) - Stanley Kubrick | Houselights #126
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the Nerd Polity. Bom bom bom bom bom bom bom bom bom
- 0:30bom bom the only way you can start the show. Welcome back to Houselights,
- 0:35our director discussion show here on the Nerd Party Network. Today we are
- 0:40focused on discussing Stanley Kubrick in the nineteen sixties with nineteen sixty eight two thousand
- 0:47and one, a space Odyssee. That was a lot of years to talk
- 0:50about. At the same time, I am Darren Moser, and I am
- 0:53joined again by my friends doctor Tristan Riddell, back from his business trip to
- 0:57the moon, and doctor John Mills, secretly the new voice of the Hal
- 1:02nine thousand supercomputer. I'm sorry everybody for blowing out your speakers with what Darren
- 1:07did. I'll correct it on the next go oh, gentleman, for bear
- 1:12to go beyond the infinite with this monumental film of two thousand and one,
- 1:17a space Odyssey. Yes, that's probably the most enthusiastic intro we've ever had.
- 1:23Sorry for that, editor. I was taken off guard by the screaming,
- 1:29but then I was shooketh by the pounding of fists. I did warn
- 1:36you about half a second before that, I was going to do that,
- 1:38but oh okay, so yeah, ah man, I'm just gonna say right
- 1:42now, I'm giving this film a five, and you're not going to change
- 1:46my minds. It's not a perfect film, but for its place in set
- 1:53them a history for what is achieved, for what it's done. For my
- 1:56personal just fondness looking back on it, and the what I think of when
- 2:02I think of two thousand and one. That's where we're going. But we're
- 2:07here to find out about what you guys think about two thousand and one.
- 2:10This film came out in nineteen sixty eight. We had not even landed on
- 2:15the Moon yet, we were still a year out. Actually, it came
- 2:20out exactly fifty five years to today because we totally planned that. That was
- 2:27very intentional when on recording. At the time of this recording, Yeah,
- 2:30when this is released, it won't be out the day, but at the
- 2:34time of this recording, it is fifty five years and we obviously had very
- 2:39lofty goals and aspirations and expectations for where we would be by the year two
- 2:46thousand and one, based on the development of the space program and the contributors
- 2:51Operation paper Clip. Yeah, that is a good point. We did not
- 2:54really hit that the enthusiasm for space travel in the sixties is not quite the
- 3:00same as in the enthusiasm for space travel of the tense teams wherever we well,
- 3:08you know, and that and that in and of itself is so strange
- 3:13to me because in the sixties there was this Hey, we're gonna go to
- 3:16the Moon, We're gonna be awesome, we're gonna do all these things,
- 3:19and it's going to keep progressing. And then just I will actually borrow because
- 3:23we're all Star Trek fans that I think it was during the twenty fifth anniversary
- 3:29special for Star Trek when they were interviewing people. One of the people they
- 3:34were interviewing said, you know, honestly, I think that the interest in
- 3:37the space program cooled because we got to the Moon and we didn't find Klingons
- 3:40there. And I do think that played into it a great deal, because
- 3:46you look at it here and it's like, oh, there's a moon base
- 3:49and we achieved that, and you know, and we'd uncover this cool thing
- 3:54and it all has to do with technology we've never encountered before. There's higher
- 4:00it's out of there, and instead we got into space and we found it's
- 4:04a lot of nothing, and it's very difficult, and people don't have the
- 4:11attention span for difficult and nothing. Just ask anyone who has had to sit
- 4:15through this movie for the first time when they're not prepared for it, like
- 4:18heyo yah. Yeah, So let's go around with first viewings. So John,
- 4:29I don't think you watched this in nineteen sixty eight. No, Amazingly,
- 4:32I wasn't alive at the time. We found a film. We finally
- 4:35found a film, finally found every film up to this point of Kubrick said,
- 4:41well, I wasn't alive for so you know, very true, very
- 4:45true. There The first time I saw this would have been on VHS and
- 4:49somebody would have said, oh, you got to watch two thousand and one,
- 4:54or I would have gotten the crazy idea. Please gott to watch two
- 4:56thousand and one. Please tell me it wasn't pan and Scan, because I
- 4:59can I not imagine watching this movie in pants. Can can't remember at this
- 5:03point, but I can't just assume it wasn't so that, yeah, I
- 5:06can. I can tell you that letterboxing wasn't really a thing until a certain
- 5:12point. So worried John, I watch, I watch two thousand and one,
- 5:17and all I can clearly remember was it a halfway point, and then
- 5:23at the end of it, saying and thinking, well, that sucked.
- 5:28I hated this movie the first time I saw it. It was very similar
- 5:31to my reaction to The Shining, which Tristan is intimately familiar with. My
- 5:36journey with that film I made. I made a bit out of hating The
- 5:41Shining and how much I hated The Shining and two thousand and one I had
- 5:46the stock response so many other people do, which was, hey, the
- 5:49effects. I recognize what they achieved at the time, and it looked really
- 5:53cool, but good lord, that movie sucked. And then I views may
- 6:00have softened through the years. You'll just have to keep listening, folks and
- 6:02find out whether they did and how much if they did. I actually thought
- 6:08about The Shining as I was watching this, because, well, your reaction
- 6:13to The Shining. As I was watching this, because I promised you guys
- 6:15that I would give this movie a fair shake and that I would try to
- 6:19look at it with fresh eyes. And as I sat down and hit play,
- 6:24I was thinking to myself, maybe this could be like John and the
- 6:27Shining where I appear in front of you guys, and I'm like real coy
- 6:30about it, and you know, like I'm just like, oh, maybe
- 6:35I liked it. Maybe I didn't. I don't know. And then like
- 6:38John, you know, drops the I loved it. It was crazy and
- 6:42h and yeah, and that didn't happen. But no, I'll so when
- 6:49I I honestly can't remember the first time I saw this. I think I
- 6:54think it had to have been when I was in high school, either middle
- 6:59school or high schoo when I was just consuming as much classic media as I
- 7:03possibly could, Like during that time, I was just getting really into film,
- 7:11really into filmmakers and the process and the behind the scenes. And there's
- 7:15so many great behind the scenes stories about two thousand and one. There's so
- 7:19much material about how this movie was made that it's a really fascinating watch and
- 7:27it's a really fascinating read to discover about the making of movies, just through
- 7:31Kubrick's process and through the special effects and just everything about it, like even
- 7:36how they even how Arthur C. Clark wrote the novel in tandem. You
- 7:43know, it was kind of like the kind of like Godfather, you know,
- 7:45like because like I always thought that it was like, oh, it's
- 7:46a movie you know first, and I mean it was it was a it
- 7:49was a novel first, and that it was based off the movie was based
- 7:53off a long time ago. Now granted it's Arthur C. Clark's short story
- 7:57The Sentinel, that the not like that that everything is based off the inspiration.
- 8:03Yeah, yeah, that was the inspiration. But yeah, so I
- 8:05think it was sometime around in middle school in high school. John, what
- 8:09do you want to say? Well, I just I love that you mentioned
- 8:13that the novel being written in tandem, because people who are familiar with me
- 8:16may be familiar with the fact that when I know a thing, I tend
- 8:20to sort of dig my heels in, even when it's to my own detriment.
- 8:24And when I revisited this film at one point, it was in a
- 8:28college class and the professor I asked him about the novel because I had read
- 8:37it by that point, and that actually had a lot of a lot to
- 8:41do with how I viewed the film after that point and everything, because in
- 8:45the introduction for that edition, Clark said it was always designed to be a
- 8:50he didn't use this term, but basically a multimedia experience. You were supposed
- 8:54to read the book and see the movie and have them work together, and
- 8:58so you know, when I approached it, I approached it through that,
- 9:00and I remember asking the professor, well, what about the novel and he
- 9:03was extremely dismissive, and he said, oh, novelizations are garbage. I
- 9:07don't bother you know reading that book. It has nothing to do with the
- 9:11movie. And yours truly, ever so wisely, in a lecture hall in
- 9:16front of a professor, decided to argue the point and received rather firm notice
- 9:24from the TA afterward that I lost a letter grade for the way I dug
- 9:30my heels in. Oh wow, I went from an A to a B
- 9:33in the class. Nothing provable, no paper trail, but yours truly called.
- 9:37But I was right, and you damn sure. I'm not going to
- 9:41back down thing about movies. Not that professor. Oh he's dead by now,
- 9:46so I'm definitely gonna in that argument. So unless he is evolved to
- 9:50become the star Child, in which case I'm screwed. Well, I had
- 9:52to reach from my copy of the Abyss, which I think is also a
- 9:56really interesting, you know, novelization, and the fact that it was written
- 10:01after the movie, but really written to be like based off of the movie,
- 10:07like in a way that not a lot of novelizations are. So yeah,
- 10:11now there's there's always a mix and match, but this one being tandem
- 10:16written is a really interesting piece of film history. It is especially I don't
- 10:22know, it's okay, I was just gonna say, I was just like,
- 10:24yeah, yeah, it is interesting in that in itself is really cool
- 10:28because it's something that people have been experimenting with for decades since about where like
- 10:35sometimes there's a pushback where it's just like, oh, I don't want to
- 10:37do homework before I see a movie. But then there's other times when it's
- 10:41kind of fun, Like when the Matrix Sequels came out, they're like,
- 10:45oh, also, you know, like there's a short film that's coming out,
- 10:48there's a you know, there's a video game that's coming out, and
- 10:50it's all tying in together, like none of it contradicts, none of it's
- 10:54like a retelling of a story, like it all is about that world and
- 10:58that one singular thing. Now, I grant I'm not trying to compare the
- 11:01Matrix Sequels to two thousand and one, but I'm just saying but yeah,
- 11:05after I saw that in middle school and I hated it. I was just
- 11:11like, oh my god, Like even reading up about the making of I
- 11:15like and like like sitting down going like, oh yeah, people told me
- 11:18it's slow. You know it's slow, It's okay, you know, Like
- 11:20I tried, like I tried to ready my brain, and I just absolutely
- 11:26hated it. And so for decades after that, I M not too many
- 11:31decades. I'm not that old. Um, I tried my decades was it.
- 11:37I revisited it probably four or five times and couldn't finish it. I
- 11:43think I gave up as soon as we got to Jupiter. Like I would
- 11:46fall asleep as soon as like the guy was you know, like jogging and
- 11:50like punching in the air. That's when I would always fall asleep. So
- 11:52like the third act of the film, Okay, okay, good god.
- 11:58Yeah for for me. Well, one other thing right on prepping multi media
- 12:03experiences. It also makes me think of Star Trek two thousand and nine,
- 12:05and they had the kind of the tie in comics that led into the how
- 12:09did we get to this time travel? Alternate? So again they people have
- 12:15dabbled with this kind of thing often that was an example I could think of.
- 12:20So I first saw two thousand and one was most likely a VHS blockbuster
- 12:24rental, but I was probably in like I want to say, fourth or
- 12:28fifth grade. Little Darren loved space and science fiction, Oh my gosh.
- 12:37So I would go to the library and check out like the same five books
- 12:43on robotics every week. It didn't matter that I'd read them already, didn't
- 12:46matter that they didn't have any new ones. That's what I knew. I
- 12:50knew the Dewey Despel number, like where to go to get those books every
- 12:54time. But I remember watching this with my friend Stephen, and we would
- 13:01build lego and and do that together in video games. But we had a
- 13:05thing where anytime either one of us started to hum the Beautiful Blue Danube,
- 13:11all of our lego pieces lost gravity, and that meant they were floating and
- 13:16flying through space. And that's always had that memory connected with that piece of
- 13:20classical music because of this film, because of I mean, it's the only
- 13:24dialogue quote music we're getting for that whole chunk of the movie. But yeah,
- 13:31so this we're talking about, we had people moaning constantly during the tension
- 13:35scenes. That doesn't count. Well, that's a whole note. That's a
- 13:41that's a different track. That's Luck's oh man, Yes, thank you John.
- 13:48Yeah, that one. That one's what I call the Trip because it's
- 13:52it's very very special. I'm glad you say that's the Trip because that was
- 13:58when two was released. Of course, you know, some critics loved it,
- 14:01some critics hated it. They were it was very divisive and everything like
- 14:05that, and they they changed the tagline to two thousand and one The Ultimate
- 14:09Trip or something like that after they had I think it was a roadshow.
- 14:13Really it was a release and it was in San Francisco and some people were
- 14:18smoking funny cigarettes during the show and apparently somebody ran around like screaming, my
- 14:24God, it's God or something like that, and so that's where they,
- 14:28you know, somebody heard the story. They were like, okay, new
- 14:30post or two thousand and one the Ultimate Trip, and that became their angles.
- 14:35That's like just the eye in the false colors and yeah, it's I
- 14:41could see. I could see that. And then it became a financial success.
- 14:46I mean it did. It made a lot of money. It had
- 14:48like a ten million dollar budget. It made like one hundred and forty six
- 14:50million after after that at a campaign. That's true. Yeah, that's true.
- 14:56That's what it's like. It's like the Rule Scouts in front of a
- 15:01weed dispensary, you know, like it's just you're printing money. Yeah.
- 15:03See. What's what's especially interesting to me, though, is that two thousand
- 15:07one undoubtedly has this big impact on everything, right, but you can,
- 15:13I would argue that later in the seventies you see the precise nature of the
- 15:18divisive reaction to it, the polarizing reaction of either love or hate, in
- 15:24the fact that two star franchises. I mean, it wasn't a franchise at
- 15:28the time obviously, but basically Star Wars and Star Trek are the two They're
- 15:33the two reaction camps. Right, there's nothing happening in this movie. Fine,
- 15:39here's a movie where everything happens. True, I dig this movie was
- 15:43long. They're inspired by or but influenced, but well, I would say
- 15:48Star Wars is like, that's the movie for people who hate two thousand and
- 15:50one, and then Star Trek. The motion picture is made by a bunch
- 15:54of people that were like, hey, nerds, like two thousand and one
- 15:56nerds like Star Trek, let's make that movie and that's why you have So
- 16:00I would say that that's the branching argument right there. It's it's funny that
- 16:06you bring that up because I have never shown my wife the motion picture because
- 16:11I love her. Yeah, but don't do that. I've shown her The
- 16:17Wrath of conn and she she really likes it. She's like, Wow,
- 16:18damn, that's that's a solid that's a solid film. And so we watch.
- 16:22She watched two thousand and one with me last night, and then like
- 16:26I joked about how Star Trek just remade the motion picture and she's like,
- 16:30well, what are you talking about? What do you mean? And so
- 16:33I popped in the motion picture just a piece of it. Yeah, And
- 16:37like I I showed her the scene with Spock where he's in the when he's
- 16:41in the EV suit, and she's like, holy crap, Like they literally
- 16:45did just make this movie again with Star Trek flair a few more. There
- 16:52are a few more phaser shots, I guess. And wait a minute,
- 16:56do they ever fire the face? They never fire the fasers in the motion
- 16:57picture? Do they No? Nos fire? They're disruptors. That's the beginning.
- 17:03It's the only battle. They find a cloud. Yeah, everybody fires
- 17:07torpedoes. It's nothing but torpedoes. But now see, that would have been
- 17:11a tagline that would have got me in a Star Trek the Motion picture back
- 17:14in the day. Like if I were a movie going public at the Star
- 17:15Trek the Motion Picture, nothing but torpedoes. Well I'm interested, Okay,
- 17:22nothing but three All right, Well, so this movie I'm gonna we're gonna
- 17:29talk about kind of like three chunks, because there are the three real acts
- 17:33of the movie. First, you have the Moon Watcher and the Dawn of
- 17:37Man. I had to look it up because I'm like, I feel like
- 17:41this is really close to win Ball of the Apes came out because it looks
- 17:45identical. I'm pretty sure. I haven't confirmed, but I'm pretty sure the
- 17:48same effects company did The Moon Watcher the Man Apes for this because it looks
- 17:55like the exact same type of prostesis. I think you're I think you're right
- 18:00about that. Yeah, I would be highly surprised if it was not.
- 18:03But yeah, you have you know, the dawna Man. You have primitive
- 18:07man and touching the monolith learning kind of becoming enlightened, I guess to a
- 18:14point where it now develops a tool, a weapon out of a bone,
- 18:18and that changes the hierarchy. So again, where I will say the hardest
- 18:27thing on this whole movie is Cooper's decision to be like, I'm not going
- 18:32to explain anything. I Am just going to show it to you and you
- 18:36have to kind of figure it out. So that makes it really hard to
- 18:41understand what is going on is very much a kind of figure it out as
- 18:47you go. But but John, how did you know Moonwatch or Strike?
- 18:49You were you able to track like, oh, this is the dawn of
- 18:52man, this is someone gaining that spark of humanity, you know legal because
- 19:00are we're surprised? But did that kind of track when you were watching it?
- 19:03Or was it more like, you know, spaceballs? You know,
- 19:07what the heck am I looking at? When does this happen in the movie?
- 19:11Uh? The first time I watched it, my entire reaction was the
- 19:15hell is a point of this? And then you know that the eight pits
- 19:18of the thing and the bone flies up and then it's a you know,
- 19:21it's a spaceship. And my reaction was the hell was the point of this?
- 19:26Like the first time I watched it, I again, I hated it.
- 19:30I do come at it now with a different perspective, specifically, this
- 19:40is this is what's very difficult for me, is was my perspective on it
- 19:47ameliorated to the point of I've been manipulated by all of the behind the scenes
- 19:53stuff, behind all of the stuff that's discussed it. Did I get there
- 20:00organically? Is my question? Nowadays? I do under you know, nowadays
- 20:06I understand what the genie in the bottom whatever's going on watching it, and
- 20:10I don't know what's going on, but who was whispering in my ear?
- 20:12And then that spurs on the other question of does it really matter, which
- 20:17I would argue actually plays into one of the bigger sub themes of the film
- 20:23of does it really matter how we got where we got? Is it really
- 20:27an argument for or against X or Y, A or B, because the
- 20:33fact is that they got there, We got there. I got there was
- 20:37a monolith whispering in my ear saying this is what it means? Right?
- 20:42Maybe, but nowadays yes, it's it's impossible not to get what Kubrick was
- 20:49going for. I don't know when I got there, whether it was organically
- 20:56or whether somebody else was pushing me in that direction. Yeah, I agree
- 21:00with you. I think I fall into the it doesn't matter camp, because
- 21:04I mean, we talk about this about our rankings all the time. Our
- 21:07rankings flip and shift, and I'll watch something now being a father that I
- 21:15didn't watch until I was a father, and it totally changes the way I
- 21:18perceive it, and now I relate to another character. So I mean,
- 21:23the whole rating aspect of movies is really a lot more fluid, I think
- 21:30than we kind of give it credit at times. You know, this fluidy
- 21:33from the man who never gives half ratings, but you know that's just how
- 21:37it goes. Well, that's just a descent into madness. You know what
- 21:44do we add decibel points? John? Do we just keep adding to the
- 21:48degrees of difference? Why can't we give quarter stars? That's my question.
- 21:52I would really like to give us a three point two seven five. You
- 21:56know it was gonna be a three, but that little extra suthing it had
- 22:00no You madman, it's a three point one eight five. I've ever seen
- 22:03a movie that is. You've convinced me, Um, now Tristan with with
- 22:08this sequence? Um, you know what is your favorite effect in this sequence?
- 22:18Is it the smash cut? Of a thousand of a million years.
- 22:21Is it the painted landscape of the cinerama dome wherever they film this? Um,
- 22:27I loved the author, author of the I could never pronounce this.
- 22:32I'll throw the piththen I'm not saying it right. Three two one, John,
- 22:37give us the name of that that track? Apes. I love the
- 22:44music. I love it. No, no, I'm not talking about the
- 22:45music. I'm talking about the the the Apes, them, the Apeman They're
- 22:52sorry, I thought you're trying to say all the also spiss As again,
- 22:56also sprock Zara. Yes, I'm just gonna have you today it every time,
- 23:00John, But hey, I'm good with that, Okay. So I
- 23:06love them. I loved the the I love the makeup, I love the
- 23:08costumes. I thought they were great. I thought they held up surprisingly well.
- 23:14Um. I mean the only shots that were a little weird were like
- 23:17when they were literally facing the sun. I was like, okay, yeah,
- 23:22that that's you. That's you can put that under scrutiny now where they
- 23:26feel a little bit they look a little bit more like Planet of the Apes
- 23:29there. But every other shot I'm just like, this is pretty good,
- 23:32like even by today's standards in twenty twenty three, Like this is pretty solid
- 23:36work for for live action, like if you're not going to get wet to
- 23:40do to do it? But uh, I love the sequence. This is
- 23:45the this is my favorite sequence of the movie. Um is the all downhill
- 23:48from here but I'm here. It is absolutely just just rolling garbage down the
- 23:53hill, collecting like a snowball. And for me, yeah, this was
- 23:57the Dawn of Man. Was was fan tastic. I wanted to spend more
- 24:00time here, like it made me want to go watch Quest for Fire,
- 24:03you know, like I just or what was that movie? Um Alpha with
- 24:08like the Man and Dog like the first you know, oh yeah, yes,
- 24:12yes man a very little dialogue very like just Birth of Man and just
- 24:18what is it like when you're just scraping by? And yeah, I love
- 24:22that stuff. I love Early Man like also author a le Pisikis site now
- 24:26again I'm not saying it right, like I love like Lucy all that kind
- 24:30of stuff, and um, I love finding out more about Early Man and
- 24:34seeing you know, depictions of it. And of course you know are one
- 24:40of our biggest inventions was used for Murder and I loved the idea. Yeah,
- 24:48um, I was never a fan of the of the match cut because
- 24:55I was really good match cut like it, because it's not it's not a
- 25:00good match cut like the the idea of it is way cooler than the execution,
- 25:06because what you're seeing is a nuclear device in space that obliterate, you
- 25:11know, all human kind. You know, So we go from a bone
- 25:15smashing in a person's skull to you know, atomic horror, and that in
- 25:19itself is very poetic and very that that's why you make films like That's why
- 25:25it's a visual medium that is cool. But it's not a very good match
- 25:27cut. Um No. I love the acting. I love that they used
- 25:32real chimps for the babies. I thought that was a really nice touch.
- 25:34And one thing I didn't know that I totally didn't know is that all the
- 25:40shots at the beginning of the African landscape are just photographs, like that's not
- 25:47they just it's not running, but you don't need to know. They don't
- 25:48move, And that that shows you the importance of grain and how if you
- 25:55have organic grain on a still photograph and you do it just a little bit
- 26:00of motion or even just a standstill, sometimes it can give the illusion of
- 26:03a motion picture. That's why I always get pissed off at the end of
- 26:07Aliens, Yes, because yes, right right, Why the hell like that
- 26:12is always going to be the puzzle of the end of Aliens, is why
- 26:17why James Cameron? Why which shot shot are we talking about? The last
- 26:22shot? When when Ripley is holding um Newt in the Hibernation pod, it
- 26:27is a still photograph. It's not it's not the camera's not rolling. So
- 26:33like, all I can think of is that like they screwed up the shot
- 26:36or they didn't hold on it, and so they just pause. They just
- 26:40pause a shot right there. But there's no grain, there's no motion brain,
- 26:45and so it looks like it looks like when a documentary like throws in
- 26:48a still, that's what it looks like. It really takes right before yeah,
- 26:55okay, yeah, yeah. Now I think with the jump cut person,
- 27:00I think it would have been a better transition if the bone was flipping
- 27:07faster and more of a circle and it cut to the station. I think
- 27:11that because that makes more sense in my mind of like, oh, and
- 27:15now we're in space versus an unknown satellite that you had to read the book
- 27:18to realize was a nuclear weapon platform. That's true. That's the thing because
- 27:23everybody thinks that it's a it's a satellite, or that it's a spaceship.
- 27:29But you have to do you have to do math homework in order to think
- 27:32about the poetic meaning behind it exactly. Whereas if it's the station, it's
- 27:37like, oh, it's a space station. It's more like, you know,
- 27:40when it's like the beginning of Enterprise where they're showing us going from first
- 27:44flight to space flight, you know, it's been a long road getting from
- 27:47there to here. We're going to jump through millions of years of human evolution
- 27:51like that, then it's gonna so well, I'm sorry that I'm not sorry
- 27:56that was your favorite section. I'm just sorry that the whole rest of the
- 27:59movie he is not going to take place in that era because we're gonna jump
- 28:03millions of years to the second phase, which is what I call um Hayward
- 28:11Floyd takes a trip because it's pretty much just first, he's his grand day
- 28:18out. He's gonna go to the station, and then from there he's gonna
- 28:22go to the Moon, and from there he's gonna get on the space bus
- 28:26and go to Tycho Crater, and that's like ninety nine percent of this sequence,
- 28:30it's just doctor Floyd going on a business trip, which I mean is
- 28:34amazing. It's not there's nothing wrong with it. But they spent a lot
- 28:38of minutes on that. But but to your point, it is a highly
- 28:44relatable thing. It's mad Men, but in the space era. Yeah,
- 28:49and it is literally this is a very normalcy of like it's just you're just
- 28:55going to work, and it's a very relatable thing to to a lot of
- 28:57people in the audience even today, of the idea of the business trip,
- 29:02of your away from your family. You're making the call. You got to
- 29:04go through the thing, you got to go from here, and that's exactly
- 29:08what I wanted my cinematic experience, the commute, but it in space.
- 29:15But it really drives home how mundane once we get there, how mundane these
- 29:22things will be that the human experience. And then juxtaposed against the the the
- 29:27awesome glory of an evolutionary moment, of the discovery of this tool that's going
- 29:33to lead to this moment and look at all of this amazing stuff that that
- 29:38we've overcome, this jump, this huge leap from apes jumping around with Sabertooth
- 29:44Tigers to now we're in space and all we've done is is devolved the wonder
- 29:51and the majesty and the glory of everything to a business trip. Yeah,
- 29:55because that's the nature of humanity. Well, as we've hit a point where
- 29:57all it is is doctor Floyd needs to go to the moon. Oh isn't
- 30:03that a drag? And you ruined a perfectly good ape. You gave it
- 30:06anxiety. It's but basically, and you're absolutely right, though, John,
- 30:11although I do kind of try to also think of in nineteen sixty eight,
- 30:15the fact of space being so normal that it's a business trip, I think
- 30:22has a different vibe when we haven't even landed on the moon yet, Like
- 30:25now we're looking back, but like that's still very much in that forward thinking.
- 30:32Oh, we're gonna it's gonna be the Moon and then Mars, and
- 30:34we're just gonna go, go, go, go go, And we know
- 30:37in resrospect that that did not happen. But yeah, it's And I think
- 30:42this also is one of Kubrick's strength is that he I mean, it is
- 30:47one of the most realistic movies of actual space travel as far as velocity and
- 30:52gravity, and you know, O'Neill, cylinders and all this stuff like and
- 30:57it's executed in teen sixty eight, so much so that people think that he
- 31:02faked the moon landing because he did this amazing movie, which is asinine.
- 31:07We're not going to talk about that, but uh well, you know,
- 31:10I you know, people believe that he helped fake the first one. All
- 31:14the other ones were real. That's how the conspiracy theory is shifted. Now
- 31:17or only the first one was faked? What do they say? Uh?
- 31:19It the only way they figured out how to do it was to shoot it
- 31:22on location. So I hadn't heard that one before. Yeah, and that
- 31:27is that my favorite. I love that, Like Kubrick, you have to
- 31:32help us fake the moon landings like I could done, but we have to
- 31:34foot on location. Okay, well the only the only raising Couber couldn't have
- 31:38done that is his fear of flying. So that's true, that's true.
- 31:41But he could have produced it. So maybe he thought space flying would be
- 31:47would be easier. But yeah, we have this beautiful I mean, one
- 31:49of the sad parts about this movie is the fact that after it, because
- 31:55Kubrick did not want these beautiful models to just become the background trash of sci
- 32:02fi. They were all destroyed, and so we don't have the space Station
- 32:07and the Discovery one and these beautiful I'm sure replicas and recreations have been made,
- 32:14but the originals were all trashed and destroyed, which is very, very
- 32:17sad because they are pieces of history. But yeah, I love how the
- 32:23space station is like unfinished and half of it's being worked on, and I
- 32:29love the little details. So that's what I tried to focus on and watching
- 32:31it this time because I've seen this movie many many times. But like when
- 32:36he's checking in, there's a little map behind the person before he goes through
- 32:43the audio identification, and there's, you know, a circle showing one of
- 32:47the rings and then the other one has only like two sections finished. And
- 32:52it matches perfectly with what we saw from the outside, even when the plane
- 32:55is coming in with pan Am, because it's still a company. Guys totally
- 33:00going to be a company in the future along with Eastern Airlines. They're going
- 33:06to dominate the future. But when it comes in, you have like the
- 33:09little foreground screens that are perfectly lining up with the rotation shifting and them locking
- 33:15on into the spin and it's just and that's hard. That's like play it
- 33:20on hard mode. That's like I want to make these foreground images match the
- 33:24special effects that aren't even done Like that is very difficult to do. But
- 33:30John, what is your favorite moment of Doctor Floyd goes to the Moon Children's
- 33:36novel as he is traveling, because I plug into the whole, the whole
- 33:44idea of it being a very routine, boring existence, even though you're in
- 33:49space, that humans will find a way to make anything routine. I go
- 33:53on walks with one of my daughters literally every single night, and it's it's
- 34:00one of those things where she makes fun of me because every so often I
- 34:05will look up at the stars and I will say, that doesn't exist anymore.
- 34:08That's a photograph of millions of years ago. That is not what is
- 34:14actually out there. That's it's amazing. And where we live we get to
- 34:17see rocket launches and I still stop every time I see one, and I
- 34:22say, my god, what an amazing achievement. Look at what is happening
- 34:27right now with this evidence of a round earth thrown right in front of us.
- 34:31And she just shrugs and says, eh, whatever. So as strange
- 34:38as it may sound, My favorite moment from Doctor Floyd goes to the Moon.
- 34:43Is doctor Floyd in the conference room on the moon, and that the
- 34:47space coureaucratic, that bureaucratic, small, cramped, silly, pointless conference room
- 34:55that he's in, because it's such a juxta position of we're in the institut
- 35:02there, We're in the infinite majesty of everything, of creation itself, this
- 35:08magnificent universe that we live in that has no bounds and no no, no
- 35:15fathomable end that we know of. And we're in a conference room. We're
- 35:22not sitting there, you know, honestly high looking at the stars saying we're
- 35:30on the moon. We're in a conference room talking about how this is classified
- 35:34gentlemen, and we can't talk about this. And I'll go out there later
- 35:37today to go see this big thing that we dug out of the moon.
- 35:43Like that is that is my favorite moment of doctor Heywood's Heywood Heywood's visit the
- 35:50Moon. Is him in, you know, with the other people in this
- 35:53conference room. It's such an an incredibly meaningful juxtaposition of we never stop to
- 36:06look at everything around us that is just magnificent to behold. We're in sitting
- 36:15in little rooms in chairs, arguing about mundane things. And I consider it
- 36:21a soul crushing micro commentary on the way most of us spend our lives.
- 36:27So that it's not even a conference room with like a dome that looks outside
- 36:32at the Moon's surface. Yes, and again looking at the background, like
- 36:37when the Moon Shuttle was landing and it's like descending the elevator, you see
- 36:44like all these tiny windows shining onto that red room. Or even I didn't,
- 36:50I've never noticed this before, but in when the plane was docking in
- 36:52the station, there's four sets of windows, one on each part of that
- 36:58rectangle, and there's moving people in every single one, just doing their job
- 37:04with this fantastical view. And I'm like, that's not the room we could
- 37:07have had the space briefing in not it said, we get the tron white
- 37:10wall, like this doesn't matter room like in a bunker. Yeah, No,
- 37:15I totally agree. It's it's it's very funny. No one, I
- 37:21love your favorite spot of Yeah, Like I really love the world building of
- 37:25it. I think that's probably my favorite bit of it is that like you're
- 37:30seeing the flight attendants with the velcro slippers you know, you're seeing people,
- 37:36you know, fall asleep and the and the pen is floating and like he
- 37:39he like the captain comes to talk to him and he forgets that his tray
- 37:45you know, is going to float away on him. And um, just
- 37:49the rotating sets that that they built, like where the camera stationary but the
- 37:55set is moving, absolutely fantastic, phenomenal and like some of those shots even
- 38:00today, I'm like, how the freaking hell did they do that? Like
- 38:06like in the in the next in the Jupiter section, like there's a few
- 38:08shots where I'm just like, I still don't know how they like that.
- 38:12Let's jump Jupiter, yeah, or Saturn if you read the book, but
- 38:17you know that's a slight difference. Um, yeah, the the what was
- 38:23it, I think thirty five foot diameter drum, which obviously everyone looked up
- 38:30and remembered about when we had something similar in Inception, when we had the
- 38:36fight scene in the in the hallway where it also rotated. But yeah,
- 38:40there's again I try to look at a lot of the details in this watch
- 38:45through, and there's a shot where I don't remember which one of the astronauts
- 38:50it was, but he's climbing down the ladder from the central spike to the
- 38:57floor and walks around and the other astronaut is sitting at the table just eating
- 39:01his food. And you know, like in my mind, in my special
- 39:05effects mind, I know, okay, that means that while he's climbing down
- 39:09the ladder, that actor is strapped in like up in the air, and
- 39:15then as he walks around, it's rotating back around for him to be at
- 39:19ground at gravity down and it's all one shot. And it's so you also
- 39:24have a cameraman also strapped into the wall with his camera to get the shot.
- 39:30And it's just incredible. It it does it, Like you said,
- 39:34Tristan, it does it so well. Of I know they obviously had to
- 39:37do it practically, but it's magic. It's magic. At that point,
- 39:43that particular shot I always thought was just a composite, like it was two
- 39:46shots layered on top of each other. Like that's how my brain made sense
- 39:51of it works, Like how dare you there are no composits in my movie.
- 39:55The shot that really made that broke my mind was when the two of
- 40:00them were walking together. They were walking down a corridor and the corridor is
- 40:05not moving, but yet where they're walking to is moving, is rotating,
- 40:12and then when they get on it they start spinning. Yes, And when
- 40:15they get on it, they start spinning. And so I'm still to this.
- 40:17I'm just like, okay, I'm thinking about it right now. I'm
- 40:21just like, okay, So, like, was the initial tunnel moving?
- 40:25But then how are they not on their heads as they're walking? So you
- 40:30know, like that kind of it's two drums. So you have the hallway
- 40:34drum and you have the stairway drum. And so in the initial the hallway
- 40:37drum or the stairway drum is spinning, but they're not. So they're walking
- 40:40with gravity down. And then as soon as they step over, the hallway
- 40:45drum starts turning, and so gravity is again always down. Okay, so
- 40:51camera and the camera starts to turn in as well because the cameras matching with
- 40:55the other. Something similar to that. I think think that speaks C.
- 41:00Tristan's point, because the logistics of getting it so that when they step over,
- 41:07because if they get that timing wrong, a lot of people are about
- 41:12to get hurt. Yeah, and at least two people, probably more are
- 41:15about to get hurt. So this is where Kubrick exercises that masterful control he
- 41:28becomes known for, I think because the amount of coordination and somebody sitting there
- 41:36keeping that all straight in their head and saying, Okay, you do that,
- 41:40you do that, repeat it back to me. Okay, you're going
- 41:44to do those things. Hey, you over there, you do that at
- 41:45the same time. And we've talked about this from time to time that a
- 41:51director has to be a great project manager, and Kubrick is inarguably one of
- 41:59the best after this film, because look at where we've gone with him.
- 42:07Where just looking at him in the sixties, we have Spartacus Spartacus, which
- 42:12is just it is. I can't help myself. It is just it's your
- 42:20typical sword and sand. We've we've talked about it. I think it's got
- 42:22this and that. Then we have Lolita, and then we have uh,
- 42:28you know, Doctor Strangelove. But all of these things, the control is
- 42:32very achievable. It's understandable. Camera goes here, camera goes here, cameracas
- 42:38there, you walk there, you're on your your mark. This is such
- 42:43an incredible leap in what has to be achieved. Just in that shot that
- 42:50we're talking that Tristan, you bring up where they're walking, they step over.
- 42:54Everything has to be timed so precisely that they have to step over with
- 43:00confidence. They can't hesitate. They have to ask as if they have to
- 43:05just walking down the hallway. And then if I step over this threshold,
- 43:07it's gonna just keep going, knowing if I miss my mark, it's it's
- 43:12going to start sharing. And that's which which speaks specifically to the fact that
- 43:17a director also has to have the trust of his cast, his crew,
- 43:22and his cast have to trust that he knows what he's doing. And it
- 43:30is one of those things where I know that the reaction to this, there
- 43:36were a lot of people that walked out of showings that hated it, hated
- 43:40it with a passion, And I wish I could sit down with some of
- 43:45those people and say, even if you hate this movie, it's worth watching
- 43:50to the end, just to to try to comprehend what Kubrick pulled off here
- 43:59for the sake of making a little movie about the evolution of the species,
- 44:04and where it had to go. It's no, it's crazy, it's crazy
- 44:07what he did. Yeah, No, I think that I think that sums
- 44:12up the movie really well where it's and again I kind of think of it
- 44:15as like Citizen Kane or these other giant movies where it's almost monolithic in like
- 44:21what it did for filmmaking, and all of us obviously appreciate, you know,
- 44:27filmmaking and the level that goes into it. I think of, you
- 44:30know, I have to start thinking of like just different gravity. Um.
- 44:36So there's like the scene when he when Bowman has to get back inside without
- 44:39a space helmet, which is again which is great writing because we're not thinking
- 44:44about that when he's heading out to save his friend and then but but it's
- 44:50not forgotten. It's not it's it's clearly everything was intentional leading up to that,
- 44:54and then we're like, oh crap, he doesn't have his space helmet
- 44:58on. How is that going to work? And then we spend twenty minutes
- 45:00opening the door and getting in position. Any've reready, But but I love
- 45:05that moment because I'm pretty sure how it was pulled off is that set of
- 45:12the Emergency Egress is a vertical, so Bowman's at the top and they're dropping
- 45:16him down towards the camera and then yanking him back up as he bounces off
- 45:22the wall to the lever to close the door. But again you our brains
- 45:28aren't wired to think like that. Our brains are like, oh, his
- 45:30head is up here, his feet are down there, that must be up.
- 45:32And Kubrick is just the master in this movie of I'm going to twist
- 45:37the camera every which way I need to to get this shot, and you're
- 45:40not even gonna know which way is up. And you have here Jeffrey Unsworth
- 45:45working with him, which is different than the last film, which, you
- 45:51know what was Gil Taylor? And could Gil Taylor have done this? We
- 46:00we we've talked about with each one of these films, Could you know,
- 46:04could the cinematographer just have not shown up that day? So I think you
- 46:09have to look at their later works. Could Gil Taylor have pulled off the
- 46:15photography that that Kubrick was obviously demanding be achieved with this film. I look
- 46:22at Unsworth's other work specifically after this, I will look past Zardas because nobody
- 46:30should watch that movie. But he was there for the Original Superman in nineteen
- 46:37seventy eight, which I would argue as a wonderfully photographed film. People may
- 46:43disagree, but I think it's it's what to believe a man can fly that's
- 46:46right. I mean talk about somebody who if you don't like you have to
- 46:52photograph that in a very very special way. Superman two, of course,
- 46:57um, but you have you know other things that he's done, Murder on
- 47:01the Orient Express from nineteen seventy four, which is regarded as a classic.
- 47:07But you look at these other things. He has one hell of a resume
- 47:10through time. But I think that obviously this is a guy who knows technical
- 47:19photography. When Kubrick comes in and says I need a guy dropping vertically and
- 47:24we pull him on a wire and we need him to go bouncing around,
- 47:29I would argue that the guy who photographed Superman can say I know how to
- 47:34do wires. I got you. Yeah, you need a wire guy for
- 47:37this for sure. Do I see Gil Taylor? Do I see? So?
- 47:40I think that a more important lesson that I'm seeing exercise by Kubrick is
- 47:46that he's looking at his director of photography and saying, is this the right
- 47:52guy to get what I'm going to tell him to get? Because the way
- 47:55I frame it, the way I stationed everybody, the works, everybody's gonna
- 48:00hit. I'm in charge of that. I need somebody that knows how to
- 48:04talk to his crew. That's going to make all of that happen, and
- 48:07it's also going to believe it's possible. I mean, you get I'm sure
- 48:12you get some Whenever you're pushing the boundary, you're gonna have some people who
- 48:15are like, well, how are we even going to do that? Like
- 48:16that's never been done before. And if that's your response, then you're not
- 48:20the right person. Well and then you know, you know, kind of
- 48:25on the metaphysical aspect, you have the largerness of this movie with the monolith,
- 48:30this one by four by nine shape, and you know, again,
- 48:37everything in this movie is calculated. Everything is like from the way we see
- 48:40the Discovery ship and it fits in the frame and everything is being approached.
- 48:46I mean people have even said, you are, in your own way almost
- 48:52watching the movie through a monolith, through a rectangular screen, and it's just
- 48:57that motif is brought over and over throughout this movie. And again I love
- 49:01directors who are specific and they everything is there for a reason. Every detail
- 49:08is conceived and it's not just oh yeah, well I guess a wide shot
- 49:13would be good. Lock it off and they'll walk over. No, like
- 49:16there's none of that in this movie we got a space bus with a lunchbox.
- 49:21Like everything was thought out to the to the degree. But but Tristan,
- 49:27um, what do you think of how the six member of the crew?
- 49:31You know we have now we here we have a character that has no
- 49:35face, has an eye, but it has a charming voice. But how
- 49:39did you you know? I I love computers, I love hell But what
- 49:45did you think of this character and a lot of the story that has really
- 49:49weighed on him? Well, I have a special connection now because we were
- 49:52born in the same place in Havana in Illinois. That's right. Oh,
- 49:58well at the plant. I didn't know that. That's why that's where I
- 50:05was first activated. Yeah, yeah, it's so good to know. And
- 50:07you learn Daisy right with him? You were practicing on the keyboard, now,
- 50:12yeah, I was. I was born and raised in urban Illinois.
- 50:15And um, there's a lot of pride that we have a lot of pride
- 50:17in our supercomputer program UM at the University of Illinois. And because I think,
- 50:23um it is the most powerful supercomputer in the nation, if not one
- 50:29of them. And UM, that's I'm sure why Urbannah was chosen as the
- 50:36as the birthplace of how because it's been that way for decades and it is
- 50:39to this day. And Um Roger Ebert was also born in Urbannah, and
- 50:45he loved two thousand and one so much that he hosted a festival of in
- 50:50nineteen ninety seven, like on the date um when Howe was born in nineteen
- 50:54ninety seven. Um, So he screened the film celebrated How's first day,
- 51:00and he invited Arthur C. Clark and Clark couldn't make it, but he
- 51:02joined via satellite and he ums a very Arthur C. Clark thing to do.
- 51:07And he invited Um Kubrick, and Kubrick declined, saying, you missed
- 51:13his birthday in nineteen ninety two because in the film it's ninety two and in
- 51:17the novel it's ninety seven. Oh oh, I mean come on just yeah
- 51:22right, just show up, Kuber, come on, come on. No,
- 51:25No, that's a very very it's a very computing satisfy there. You
- 51:31know, it's like because he said you missed his birthday in ninety two with
- 51:36us. He had a little smirk when he said that. Yeah, yeah,
- 51:39yeah, yeah, there's my reason. But no, I I really,
- 51:45uh, from a from a micro standpoint, I think it's great.
- 51:51I love the idea that it was. Originally they they conceived of a of
- 51:57a robot kind of wheeling around the entire unit, like in three dimensional space.
- 52:01But then they realized that because Moon had that robot that was Kevin Spacey
- 52:07voice, that had a kind of move around, and they quickly realized that
- 52:13like if they did that, it would be outdated, Like what they did
- 52:15would be outdated real quick. And so they did the omnipresent Eye, which
- 52:20I think was just a stellar decision, just a great idea. And and
- 52:27I think that winds up somewhat contemporaneously. I think it was the late sixties
- 52:32when Ellison wrote, I have no mouth and I must scream. Where the
- 52:37idea of a machine going nuts because you gave it the gift to go intelligent,
- 52:47but it could never experience life as a living being, because all it
- 52:52would ever beat is a stationary set of circuit boards. How becomes an incredibly
- 53:00when you really think about how is a plot device when you look at it
- 53:05through one lens, but then when you look at it through another lens,
- 53:08How is an incredibly sympathetic figure because how can AI not go nuts? If
- 53:17it can never experience the life that it can comprehend. And this is where
- 53:24I'll go back to Star Trek the motion picture. One of its strengths is
- 53:29that when Spock melds with Jure, he you know, and he comes out
- 53:35of it, he holds Kirk's hand. He says, this is what Vigure
- 53:37can't have, this connection that people that living beings have. So of course
- 53:45the thing is going to go angry, is going to go insane because you
- 53:52have sentenced this life to never being able to experience that which it wants most.
- 54:00You've literally created something that is going to forever live in hell. How
- 54:05could it be anything but angry? And I think that How as a result,
- 54:10is an incredibly complex character. And I think the key to enjoying two
- 54:17thousand and one is to that sympathy with How. I'm not saying everybody is
- 54:23mandated to love two thousand and one, but I'm saying that I think that
- 54:30when if you're one of the people who do you feel bad for How.
- 54:35He's a murderous psychopath, but you kind of understand why he went down that
- 54:39road because his parents didn't treat him too well well, And that's kind of
- 54:45one of the sadder aspects of the movie is the fact that you don't really
- 54:49get the why unless you read the books or the novels or see kind of
- 54:53because they explain it a lot more. It's like, oh, well,
- 54:55if you're read the book, you understand why. Well that isn't good filmmaking.
- 55:00Yeah, but knowing that he was stuck in a loop of you told
- 55:02a computer to lie, and a computer's based program is to not distort information
- 55:08and to present it accurate and truthful always, and he just got stuck and
- 55:15couldn't reconcile that directive. Again, that is not in the movie, which
- 55:19would help in the explaining. But what do you think of that? Tristan
- 55:22Well, I kind of like perked up a little bit when John described as
- 55:28a as a plot device, which made me giggle a little bit because I'm
- 55:35he has nothing to do with the plot. And that's what I That's what
- 55:37I jokingly said to my wife when I said, I was like, oh,
- 55:40yeah, how's really interesting. But he has nothing to do with the
- 55:43plot, And she goes, what plot? And I go, oh,
- 55:45yeah, I guess that's right interesting. So yeah, that's where Hall is
- 55:52for me. It's it's a great concept it would make a great movie.
- 55:59Well, fortunately, how knows how to read lips and he is very sad
- 56:02now watching your lips talk about him in that way. But yeah, so
- 56:08obviously the movie continues on. We go beyond the Infinite with some awesome slit
- 56:13scan techniques and music. Uh, let's just talk a little bit about the
- 56:17music before we get to ratings. Um, okay, I will say this
- 56:23movie is on par streams, is really good. Well yes, okay,
- 56:28yeah, okay, oh yeah, yeah yeah, okay, okay, take
- 56:30us around the slit screen shot. No, yeah, yeah, I says,
- 56:35yeah, yeah, I I did. Yeah, yeah. I listen
- 56:40to your to your little joke, Tristan. I think that this is um,
- 56:46it's true. I think that this is a movie that is more enjoyable
- 56:51if you have some assistance while watching it. Okay, I think that your
- 56:59interject. I'm gonna interject your interject because Lea, I'm on antibiotics right now
- 57:02from recovering from a science infection, and I was so utterly pissed that I
- 57:08couldn't drink lass night when I watched two thousand and one. I was so
- 57:14angry. I don't think Drake Hans is really the thing that's going to catch
- 57:16there, but it would help. I think that I think that it's an
- 57:25interesting I think the acid test is that this movie is Yeah, I didn't
- 57:31mean to say acid tests, I guess, but you know, hey,
- 57:35I didn't mean acid acid anyway. I think that two thousand and one is
- 57:39the sort of movie where when the two camps distill themselves. I think that
- 57:47it's like the Aquitine Hunger Force thing where when I talk to people who watch
- 57:54Aquitine Hunger Force and I talk about how much I love the show, they
- 57:59always ask me, are you on something when you watch it? And I
- 58:04say, no, that's just how I'm wired. I just think it's funny,
- 58:08I do. I think that this is a This is a film where
- 58:13that you're either wired to enjoy or you're not wired to enjoy. And there's
- 58:17no judgment in that comment. All right, Well, last points on the
- 58:22music. We have a very classical score, which it kind of makes me
- 58:28think of just like Loony Tunes, and like how that introduced a lot of
- 58:31people too to that kind of classical music. And I cannot yeah, when
- 58:38when you hear you know that title, I can't say of the opening you
- 58:45know it it you think of this movie like it is irrefarcably bonded with this
- 58:52movie when you hear Blue Danube. I mean, if you haven't seen this
- 58:54movie, obviously you wouldn't make that connection. But like Blue Danube and the
- 59:00like, those two tracks specifically are so ingrained. Like I said, as
- 59:06a child, when I heard Blue Danube, I would think space flight.
- 59:08I would think weightlessness just because and because that's pretty much playing through all of
- 59:15you know, doctor Floyd goes on a moonbus? Is that is that track
- 59:19just playing? And it's a beautiful track and in a way, I mean,
- 59:23granted, you know Kober's going for this minimalist talking motif, but it's
- 59:30kind of nice just sitting there watching these beautiful models and graphics and scenery except
- 59:37for the conference room, you know, while listening to this track. So
- 59:42what do you guys think of the music? Would there have been another way
- 59:45to go about this, maybe something composed for the movie as opposed to taking
- 59:50more classical pieces off the shelf? What do you think, Tristan? I
- 59:57thought it was great. I thought the use of classical music was was was
- 1:00:00perfect for this type of film because it's another achievement that that humans, only
- 1:00:08humans can do. It's something that it's one of the one of the more
- 1:00:15beautiful things that we've that we've achieved. Like it's it's not the bone that
- 1:00:20we've that we've picked in order to bashing somebody's skull. It's not the nuclear
- 1:00:24satellite that can obliterate Earth from orbit. It is it's just like the space
- 1:00:30station. It's it's math and creativity put together to create something beautiful. And
- 1:00:37that's how he's using it in in certain moments, and and so to me,
- 1:00:42it's it's great. I think there's one quote that kept coming to mind
- 1:00:45is that like um like I think it was one person said, like,
- 1:00:51the only thing that distinguishes us from chimps is a one to two percent difference
- 1:00:59in day. You put that that um DNA through a few more rounds of
- 1:01:05division and outcome symphonies and ideology, And I just love that. That's that's
- 1:01:13where we consider our humanity in is ideology and symphonies. It's just so great.
- 1:01:19It's thought and form, it's thought and music, and it's so to
- 1:01:23use such great pieces, such such well manicured pieces, and such a well
- 1:01:30manicured film visually you have to have something auditory to go with it, and
- 1:01:37um, I think the only thing, the only thing is I disliked.
- 1:01:43Were there the luxe turna stuff where it's just like people wailing in the background,
- 1:01:46Like I know, I'm supposed to be uneasy, but it started making
- 1:01:50me google after a while. It's a little much. It's it's a little
- 1:01:52much. And also I know this isn't music, but during the Jupiter scenes
- 1:01:57when they were out in space, I literally had to mute them because they
- 1:02:00just had anything hissing. No, it wasn't even the buithing, it his
- 1:02:05air hiss. Yeah, the air hiss the entire time. I had to
- 1:02:07mute it, and I just every once in a while I mune it just
- 1:02:09to see if it was still gone. I'm like, yep, still going,
- 1:02:12still going on. Yeah, yeah, that's well. And that would
- 1:02:15be a case of not putting music there, especially when they're doing the Eva's
- 1:02:20There is no It's like, how am I supposed to feel? Am I
- 1:02:22supposed to feel tense in this moment? It's like nope, you get an
- 1:02:24air hiss and maybe breathing, And which is also kind of terrifying because which
- 1:02:30was Kubrick's breathing, which I think is great. Of course, of course
- 1:02:35it was. Of course it was Cuber's breathing. What about you, John,
- 1:02:37what are your thoughts as we wrap up on the music of two thousand
- 1:02:42and one. I think that Tristan is, you know, this is the
- 1:02:50only time you'll ever get this on recording. But Tristan's right, yeah,
- 1:02:55right, this is the first time in how many years I've ever said that,
- 1:02:59Tristan. Um. Yeah, that, like the use of classical music
- 1:03:05underscores the what the film is trying to say. I understand why. Um
- 1:03:14he commissioned a score and then turned around and said, now I'm going to
- 1:03:16do this instead. And it's it's really interesting because the the use of also
- 1:03:25Sprock zaratoustra is iconic. Everybody knows it. Everybody knows it, and there's
- 1:03:36something about Kubrick that he knew that that was what was necessary. And it's
- 1:03:45it's a difficult decision to throw away a score, to say no, this
- 1:03:50is what I'm going to do instead. We've grown up, all three of
- 1:03:54us in the post John Williams era, which is just thinking that you know,
- 1:04:00lots of bassoon and here's how we do scores. And it's it's difficult
- 1:04:09to comprehend throwing out a score. It's difficult to comprehend. Hey, I
- 1:04:15commissioned this score, but it's not quite what I was going for. That
- 1:04:19being said, one of the things I've never done is watched this film with
- 1:04:27Alex North's score playing over it, which I would be very interested to do.
- 1:04:32Just you you can actually get the actual score that was originally intended it
- 1:04:38was released at one point. I've never owned it, but I would love
- 1:04:43to see if I could do that. I mean, hellee like a Dark
- 1:04:46of the Moon Wizard of Oz people get. I was about to say that
- 1:04:50if people can put Dark Side of the Moon over Wizard of Oz, I
- 1:04:54should be able to do this in some some capacity. So if you would
- 1:04:59like to go to the Nerdparty dot com slash contact and let me know how
- 1:05:02I can find Alex North's score on top of two thousand and one. Well,
- 1:05:09yeah, you mentioned John Williams, which I think as we talked about
- 1:05:13Star Wars and Star Trek being inspired, you know, visually by this movie,
- 1:05:15I'm sure to an extent you also have John Williams inspired by just the
- 1:05:19classical nature of this score, and I mean, John Williams becomes the de
- 1:05:24facto of you know, not only using traditionally classical instruments in his scores,
- 1:05:31but also the motif method of like, Okay, this is Luke's theme,
- 1:05:35and this is Leiah's theme, and this is how we're gonna draw it all
- 1:05:39together. Floyd did not get a theme in this on his many moonbust trip,
- 1:05:45right, But that's okay, He's he's fine, he's fallen asleep.
- 1:05:49It's very comfortable on this trip, all right. Well, that takes us
- 1:05:55around to Jupiter and or Saturn, depending on your story. And no,
- 1:06:00we will not be covering twenty ten next week, but I do recommend you
- 1:06:03watch it. If you did enjoy this movie, go watch twenty ten.
- 1:06:06It is a very different total movie than this, but it is a lot
- 1:06:11of fun and a lot more dialogue in that one. Oh so much dialogue,
- 1:06:15and you get two space stations bolting on each other. It's it's a
- 1:06:18lot of fun. Are we not going to talk about the ending? We're
- 1:06:24gonna talk about like, okay, twenty minutes of the film. The film,
- 1:06:28I'm trying, you know, I'm trying to go as fast as I
- 1:06:30can. It's really hard. There's a long movie, so we have Beyond
- 1:06:32the Infinite h Dave Bowman goes into the Monolith and goes into tron Legacy where
- 1:06:42he is on a lit up floor old room, and again there's no dialogue,
- 1:06:46there's no talking, and he's kind of first he's in the pod and
- 1:06:51he sees the room, and then he's in the room. Then he's in
- 1:06:56the bed, then he's seeing the monolith over the bed, and then he's
- 1:07:00the star Drive like it's and it takes like like just into like twenty minutes
- 1:07:03for all that to happen. But it is very much a kind of just
- 1:07:09absorbing, like what am I What is this meant to say? What is
- 1:07:14this meant to communicate? And he's kind of transcending in this moment, like
- 1:07:17he's becoming more at the end, I mean, he's becoming what's called the
- 1:07:21star child um and a kind of a rebirth return to Earth with again classical
- 1:07:27music behind it. What did you think this was all about? John?
- 1:07:30When you not even the first time? Now, what do you think talk
- 1:07:34about let's not talk about the first time. Yeah, let's not talk about
- 1:07:36the first time. I think that's going to go yeah again, at the
- 1:07:40end, what the hell man um Now you were seasoned, it's really interesting
- 1:07:48because you know, we already talked about how, you know what what put
- 1:07:51it in my head sort of thing. But I think that it is.
- 1:07:59It is interesting in the sense that when you take the film in its totality,
- 1:08:08you realize that the entire thing is about catching evolutionary moments in humanity.
- 1:08:15And you have the moment where apes discover tools, then you have the moment
- 1:08:20where the people who are using the tools discover the monolith. Then you have
- 1:08:26the moment where the monolith guides people to becoming the next level being, the
- 1:08:32you know, the the being who is going to capture the original cast of
- 1:08:38Star Trek and trap them on a world in an episode of Futurama, and
- 1:08:43it's it's one of those conventions. I know, what a spell melvar exactly
- 1:08:48right, but I love that episode so much. But it is it is
- 1:08:57one of those things where you're seeing these three acts are the three evolutionary stages
- 1:09:01of humanity as seen through the prism of this story, the lens of this
- 1:09:06story. And I think for that reason, it shows how all of these
- 1:09:14things trysted to your point about how it's a two percent difference in DNA,
- 1:09:19but each like, it's an exponential leap as you go, because you have
- 1:09:26this moment and then it's millions of years later that you have space travel and
- 1:09:31all of these things. But then it's not so far after that where you
- 1:09:35transcend into the Star Child in months, right, So you basically have these
- 1:09:43leaps, and as each leap happens, it's a shorter duration of time,
- 1:09:48and that is one of the things I love most about the film, as
- 1:09:51it shows how evolution accelerates, as technology accelerates, as our domination of And
- 1:10:00I'll give credit to a terrific book every everybody should read called The Moten God's
- 1:10:05Eye by Larry Niven and Jerry Purnell, where it talks about how once humanity
- 1:10:12conquers the stars, once technology hits a certain point, evolution inverts and we
- 1:10:18start changing our environment to match us instead of changing to match our environment.
- 1:10:26But this evolution to the Star Child shows how everything becomes exponentially shorter as it
- 1:10:33progresses through time. So that's my takeaway, all right, And Tristan,
- 1:10:40since you weren't able to drink while you were watching this part, I mean,
- 1:10:46I mean you love these kinds of movies right where it's like all it's
- 1:10:49in the interpret the eye of the beholder, doesn't matter what it actually means.
- 1:10:55But whatever you take away from it. I really wish I went first
- 1:11:00because I really like what John had to say. I mean, you could
- 1:11:03just say ditto, many do I would invite you to do that. No,
- 1:11:11oh oh, John, I love what you had to say. I
- 1:11:15just wish that they did that on screen, you know. I just I
- 1:11:20to me, like, what this What this was to me was just Kubrick
- 1:11:26jerking off on the walls. It's just he was just that's not til eyes
- 1:11:30white shut, just painting the walls, and he's just he's doing it while
- 1:11:35staring us in the face. And then he's he's calling us a dirty girl.
- 1:11:42That's that's what's happening. It's a very very specific picture there. I
- 1:11:56just, oh, man, when I watched every time I watched this,
- 1:12:00like the if I actually made it past Jupiter, that's true, you gotta
- 1:12:03get there first, Yeah, yeah, once I if I actually made it
- 1:12:06past Jupiter, and then I got to the infinite, I mean that that's
- 1:12:11when I start to get angry, because, like I was, I was
- 1:12:15bored for most of it. And then this is when I start to get
- 1:12:18pissed off and like actively annoyed. Is when I'm watching it, you know,
- 1:12:25like you see the slit screen, which is cool for like the first
- 1:12:27twenty five seconds, and then you get to the landscapes, the duatone landscapes,
- 1:12:34and that's when I start digging my nails into my thigh to stop from
- 1:12:41screaming. Because if I'm saying to myself, like I if I see one
- 1:12:45more frigging duatone landscape of the of the desert, that I'm kind of lose
- 1:12:51my mind and and I just and it just keeps going. It just keep
- 1:12:56going, It just keeps going. And then we see him look at himself,
- 1:13:00look at there and everything like that, and then all of a sudden,
- 1:13:01he's a he's an incest baby out in space. That's when I start
- 1:13:10to feel what I describe to you of what of what Kubrick has done to
- 1:13:14us, kind of like what Spielberg and Lucas did to us with Indiana Jones
- 1:13:19four. Yeah, I think that's where that's why, that's why, that's
- 1:13:26what I want to be such a revealing movie about nuts. Okay, okay,
- 1:13:33okay, yeah, I mean no, and you're right, Tristed,
- 1:13:35Like the third act is uh, it's like it's a trip. It's like
- 1:13:41what is going on? It is way too much. You'll kind of figure
- 1:13:45it out. It's like, no, just I'm here to watch a story,
- 1:13:49tell me a story. Nope, I'm gonna give you pieces of the
- 1:13:53story and you can draw the collective tissue between them. It's like, okay,
- 1:13:58then do a tonic dude, trying to do trying, Okay, but
- 1:14:01yeah, no, it's honestly, yeah, once they get to the third
- 1:14:05Monolith, I'm like, okay, I'm good. Like I've done to the
- 1:14:11Discovery one. That's a great part. I had all that do I need?
- 1:14:15I know what happens. We watch it once and you don't need to
- 1:14:17watch it again for the ending. You nothing changes except for inspiring tron legacy
- 1:14:24a little bit, I guess. But but yeah, well I would also
- 1:14:27still to you, Tristan, I'd recommend watch to twenty ten. It is
- 1:14:30again a very different movie. It's a lot of fun. John Lyth goes
- 1:14:34amazing, get some arobraking, and yeah, it's we can honestly just throw
- 1:14:41caution to the wind and just do just to twenty ten next week. I
- 1:14:46would not be opposed Twenty ten, I think is one of those sequels that
- 1:14:51both does not need to exist but at the same time, Oh, it
- 1:14:57doesn't need to exist bad at all, but at the same time is massively
- 1:15:00underrated. It is a film that so many people sleep on. I saw
- 1:15:05that as a kid with my dad on VHS, and I have no idea
- 1:15:12if it holds up. Like honestly, the argument against rewatching it is I
- 1:15:15have such a fond memory of it that I don't want to go near it
- 1:15:19because if I go back and it sucks, I'm like, I will be
- 1:15:25despondent. For let's not tempt fate. Then let's not tempt fate. Let's
- 1:15:29just leap. I was going to say, go for it, but well,
- 1:15:32we can all choose to watch twenty ten on our own dime as it
- 1:15:35is is a lot of fun. But next week we will be entering a
- 1:15:42new house with the House of Right. But wait, what am I talking
- 1:15:45about. We don't even get our ratings yet, that's true. I was
- 1:15:49ready to rate and then was so excited that you forgot the ratings. I
- 1:15:56was like, oh, good, good, I get apparent, I don't
- 1:16:00have to talk. I want everybody to come after Tristan. I'm I'm afraid
- 1:16:03I can't do that. We're gonna have to talk about the ratings. I'm
- 1:16:08gonna go first. I'm giving this a five. I don't care. It's
- 1:16:12it's something I grew up with. It's a movie. Yeah, do I
- 1:16:15see? Is it a perfect movie? I don't say a five has to
- 1:16:17be a perfect movie. Is a perfect movie to me and what it means
- 1:16:21to me the visuals, the again, a story and a film where the
- 1:16:28director has chosen well, I'm just not looking at you, Tristed. I'm
- 1:16:30just covering up that part of this group. But no, but no,
- 1:16:32I really enjoy this movie. It's a lot of fun. Do I watch
- 1:16:35it every weekend? No, it's it's really long. It's a long,
- 1:16:40long movie. But that the second act, the m Floyd takes a trip
- 1:16:44to the moon, which is how I'm gonna think about it from all time
- 1:16:46because it's so true. But it's fun and the man, I really it's
- 1:16:51a It is a crime to cinema that those models did not survive after this
- 1:16:56movie. I think they belong in a museum where they would be appreciated by
- 1:17:00many. So I'm going to give this a five. John, We're gonna
- 1:17:03go to you next, so you can say everything that Tristan should say,
- 1:17:08and he can just say ditto. But where what are you going to give
- 1:17:11in this recent rewatching of two thousand and one? How has it softened you
- 1:17:16a little more every single time? Or how how how are we going?
- 1:17:19I think that now I have arrived at the point where I own a four
- 1:17:26K version of it, the four K restoration overseen by Christopher Nolan, our
- 1:17:30greatest active living director. Oh yeah, we didn't really talk about that.
- 1:17:35I got I got a hold of the four K disc um to watch this
- 1:17:40and it's, oh my gosh, it's immaculate. Yea, the restoration is
- 1:17:45insane. It's absolutely insane. But just like Christopher Nolan, I adore this
- 1:17:50film like most right thinking people, I do, and I would say that
- 1:17:55I would give this a five star rating, not or any social pressure,
- 1:18:01because like I said, I hated this the first time I saw it,
- 1:18:05and the second time I saw it, I was like, it's all right,
- 1:18:09and the book is good too. I like, I strongly suggest anybody
- 1:18:15read the book two thousand and one because it is that's a really good book.
- 1:18:20It is. It's really good. I would go so far as to
- 1:18:24say it's one of the best sci fi books you will ever read in your
- 1:18:28life. And it's also at this point a wonderful time capsule for what people
- 1:18:33thought was truly achievable in our lifetime. But I have no choice about to
- 1:18:41give this a five. I think that there is so much about it that
- 1:18:45is so compelling, and it is definitely in the I think some critic described
- 1:18:53it as part of the new Wave school or whatever, but it is.
- 1:18:58It's where David Lynch eventually found himself and then went too far into are you
- 1:19:03know, arguably of holding it for so long that it's like Peter Griffin falling
- 1:19:12on the pavement and hurting his shin. It's funny at first, then it's
- 1:19:16tedious, then it's funny again. And I think that two thousand and one
- 1:19:21unlocks the same sort of progression of everything where it's curious, interesting, I'm
- 1:19:28not sure where it's going. Maybe it's a little boring, and then it's
- 1:19:30interesting again. And I talk about it a lot after every time I see
- 1:19:36it. So this is a five, all right, Bom bom bom bom,
- 1:19:44bom bomb Tristing, What is your vote? So I'm not another child
- 1:19:55when it comes to two thousand and one star child, it's called star child.
- 1:20:00You know, like as I talk as I talked about before, you
- 1:20:02know, like when you look at how this movie was made, how it
- 1:20:05is directed, the production design, the special effects, the optical effects,
- 1:20:11just it's absolutely mind blowing what they achieved with this film and with this with
- 1:20:17this movie, and it's, um, this is a fantastic piece of cinema.
- 1:20:26It's a garbage movie. And so I see this movie very very similarly
- 1:20:33to how I look at Metropolis, which is we reviewed on our one hundredth
- 1:20:40episode, and I gave Metropolis a five star rating because of what it achieved,
- 1:20:47how it was ahead of its time, and its impact on our culture.
- 1:20:51And so I'm giving two thousand and one five stars for that reason.
- 1:20:58I'm coctrissed right now. I am utterly in shock. I did not pick
- 1:21:01me up off the surface of the moon right now with the like doctor Floyd
- 1:21:06right now, Well that's okay. That's the thing though. This is like
- 1:21:10if we were going by my enjoyment level, this would be like a one
- 1:21:13and a half two. If I'm being generous, I was gonna say on
- 1:21:15a cinematic level, it's got to be at least it too. But no,
- 1:21:18no, I can hear what you're I know, probably people, you
- 1:21:23know, long time listeners are probably thinking I'm punking out. But honestly,
- 1:21:27like with just like with with the models, with the the Matt paintings,
- 1:21:30like with the with the suits, with the acting, with the world building,
- 1:21:34with the cinematography, just it's all so amazing, but the story is
- 1:21:41just so black luster. It's just not there. And and like Arthur C.
- 1:21:45Clark himself said, like, oh, if you walk away understanding everything
- 1:21:48about two thousand and one, we didn't do our jobs right. I'm like,
- 1:21:50well, that's not a great way to frame a film. We purposely
- 1:21:56don't want our audience to understand what's going on. Like yeah, exactly,
- 1:22:00Like that kind of stuff pisses me off. Like I love stuff that makes
- 1:22:03you think. I love stuff that's like out there or that's open to interpretation
- 1:22:08to a point. And this is past my breaking point. But when you
- 1:22:11look at the cultural impact and what this movie has achieved and how it achieved
- 1:22:15it, this is a five star film. But it is not something that
- 1:22:19I'm ever going to watch again now that I podcasted about it. Now,
- 1:22:25that's a really good point test. I remember again when I was taking film
- 1:22:30and living with filmmakers, always felt that in a way, you almost need
- 1:22:35like three categories to rate a film. You need like enjoyment, like technical
- 1:22:41aspect, and then like maybe a third one, like the fact that we
- 1:22:44try to distill a rating of a film to a single scale. It's almost
- 1:22:49impossible because and that's why it changes all the time. Like I was feeling,
- 1:22:55you know, you know, melancholy today and then I watched this movie
- 1:22:58and I totally changed the way I perceived it, Like it's so fluid.
- 1:23:00But yeah, that's awesome to hear you recognize the technical achievements of two.
- 1:23:05I am very surprised. I'm not here. I think five was going to
- 1:23:08come out of your mouth today, But that is I'm glad that we all
- 1:23:13it's a five star film. That means everybody should go watch this movie right
- 1:23:17now. Okay, maybe not, but watch twenty ten. But next week
- 1:23:20here on house Lights, we are going to go into the House of Reiner
- 1:23:26with Rob Reiner of the nineteen eighties, starting with This is spinal tap.
- 1:23:31Take it to eleven. Join the Revolution, Join the Nerd Party,