Latest / Crafted Clarity: Distilling the Tension Between Success and Significance / Your Title Is Not Your Identity — And You Already Know It | The Label | Crafted Clarity

Transcript

Your Title Is Not Your Identity — And You Already Know It | The Label | Crafted Clarity · Crafted Clarity: Distilling the Tension Between Success and Significance

• 0:02
  Many leaders wear labels the way people wear clothes.
• 0:06
  They change depending on the day, the season, or even the
• 0:10
  room they walk into. Visionary in one setting,
• 0:15
  purpose driven when the conversation turns to business,
• 0:18
  servant leader in another. And most of the time, those
• 0:22
  labels come from a sincere desire to lead well.
• 0:27
  They reflect aspiration, conviction, even a desire to
• 0:31
  align leadership with something deeper.
• 0:35
  But sometimes a label gets ahead of the formation.
• 0:40
  A label has a very specific purpose.
• 0:43
  A label exists to identify what's inside of something.
• 0:47
  The tag inside a jacket tells you the material it's made of.
• 0:51
  The badge on the back of a car tells you what engine is under
• 0:55
  the hood, and the label on a whiskey bottle tells you what's
• 0:59
  inside the bottle, The distillery, the mash bill, The
• 1:03
  age. In every case, the label comes
• 1:07
  after the thing itself has been defined.
• 1:11
  But leadership doesn't work that way.
• 1:14
  In leadership, the label often comes first.
• 1:17
  Sometimes that label is a title that describes the role CEO,
• 1:23
  founder, executive director, senior leader.
• 1:28
  Those titles say something about the responsibility and
• 1:32
  authority. They say nothing about the
• 1:35
  substance of leadership within that role.
• 1:39
  Other times the labels are more personal, perfectionist, detail
• 1:44
  oriented, analytical, process driven.
• 1:49
  Sometimes labels come from others, The fixer, the closer,
• 1:54
  the one who gets things done. And still other times we assign
• 1:59
  labels to ourselves as a way of steadying ourselves, especially
• 2:04
  in those moments where we're still working out if we belong
• 2:07
  in the room that we're standing in.
• 2:10
  So the label becomes something that we lean on and something
• 2:14
  others begin to lean on as well. But when leadership is grounded
• 2:19
  in something deeper, the label becomes less important because
• 2:24
  what's inside becomes clear. Alignment shows up in decisions.
• 2:30
  Consistency shows up in behavior.
• 2:33
  Purpose becomes visible in the way people are LED.
• 2:37
  At that point, the label simply describes what has already been
• 2:41
  formed. The whiskey world understands
• 2:45
  this better than most, because in whiskey, the label isn't
• 2:49
  added first. It's one of the very last things
• 2:53
  that gets added. Over the past decade, something
• 3:00
  interesting has happened in the whiskey world.
• 3:03
  It seems like everyone got in on the whiskey boom.
• 3:07
  Actors, athletes, musicians, celebrities.
• 3:12
  Suddenly it felt like everyone had their own whiskey.
• 3:16
  Beautiful bottles, slick branding, stories told on the
• 3:21
  label. And in many cases, those brands
• 3:25
  were introduced as if the person behind them had suddenly become
• 3:29
  a master distiller. For the record, there's nothing
• 3:33
  inherently wrong with a celebrity whiskey.
• 3:36
  Some of the ones I've tasted are actually pretty good.
• 3:40
  But most of those celebrity brands didn't begin by creating
• 3:44
  whiskey. They began with whiskey that had
• 3:47
  already existed somewhere. A distillery had already done
• 3:53
  the long, hard work of creating it.
• 3:56
  The grain had been milled, the mash had been fermented, the
• 4:00
  spirit has been distilled, and the barrels had been filled and
• 4:05
  left to age. Years of process had already
• 4:09
  shaped what was inside those barrels.
• 4:12
  The bottle was designed, the story was written, and the label
• 4:17
  was printed. Only then did the new brand
• 4:20
  arrive, and then the whiskey was poured into something new again.
• 4:27
  Nothing wrong with that, but it reveals something important.
• 4:31
  The whiskey going into those bottles already had its
• 4:34
  identity. No matter what was printed on
• 4:37
  the label, it was the process that shaped what it would
• 4:40
  become. And that's the thing about
• 4:43
  labels. They don't create identity.
• 4:47
  They simply describe what's already there.
• 4:52
  When someone is really evaluating a whiskey, when they
• 4:55
  pick up a bottle, they're usually not focused on the logo
• 4:59
  or the back story. They're asking where was it
• 5:03
  distilled, how long did it age, What's the mash bill?
• 5:08
  And who actually made this whiskey?
• 5:12
  Because they know the character of the spirit comes from the
• 5:15
  process that shaped it and the people who made it.
• 5:20
  The label simply tells the story.
• 5:23
  And that order matters more than we think.
• 5:28
  In leadership, labels are useful.
• 5:31
  They help people move quickly. They build trust.
• 5:35
  They create clarity in complex environments.
• 5:39
  Over time, those labels can become associated with results.
• 5:45
  The Strategist helps shape direction.
• 5:48
  The operator keeps things moving.
• 5:52
  The one who gets things done becomes someone others rely on.
• 5:57
  Those patterns, that consistency, that's what drives
• 6:01
  success. And because of that, the label
• 6:05
  can start to carry weight. It becomes something others rely
• 6:10
  on, something they come to expect, and over time, we start
• 6:15
  to feel that too. We feel the need to live up to
• 6:19
  it, to keep showing up in the same way.
• 6:22
  Because it worked, It created results, it built momentum, it
• 6:29
  helped build something meaningful.
• 6:33
  And when something works, we tend to go back to it, reinforce
• 6:37
  it, and even build on it. Until eventually it stops being
• 6:43
  something we do and starts becoming something we believe
• 6:47
  about ourselves. And this is where something
• 6:51
  begins to shift. It's almost like taking the
• 6:56
  label on a whiskey bottle and letting it define what's inside
• 7:01
  instead of the other way around. In whiskey, that would never
• 7:05
  work. The spirit is already formed.
• 7:08
  The label is just there to describe it.
• 7:12
  But in leadership, the opposite can happen.
• 7:15
  The label starts shaping how the leader sees themselves and can
• 7:19
  even begin to limit what's possible.
• 7:23
  Instead of asking what next might look like, the leader
• 7:27
  begins to protect that label. In other words, the label starts
• 7:33
  to define identity. And that's where the tension
• 7:38
  really begins to rise. The tension between what we've
• 7:41
  built and what we're built for. What we've built is real.
• 7:47
  Our careers, our reputation, our work.
• 7:52
  But what we're built for that doesn't always fit neatly inside
• 7:57
  the labels that helped get us here.
• 8:00
  And when we let those labels become the way that we define
• 8:03
  ourselves, it could become harder to see ourselves in a
• 8:07
  different light, harder to imagine something different,
• 8:11
  harder to recognize what might be unfolding in our next season.
• 8:19
  I've been having more and more conversation with leaders who
• 8:22
  find themselves in this exact moment.
• 8:25
  I had coffee with a leader not too long ago who is navigating a
• 8:29
  career transition. Their company was restructuring
• 8:33
  and was time for them to move on.
• 8:36
  They had spent decades in the same organization, in the same
• 8:40
  role, building a career over time.
• 8:43
  The labels attached to them were pretty firmly in place.
• 8:48
  So when they started thinking about what the next season might
• 8:51
  look like, their thinking kept circling back to the same place.
• 8:56
  Similar titles, similar functions, the same level of
• 9:00
  responsibility. A place where those labels still
• 9:05
  fit. It became clear just how
• 9:08
  powerful those labels had become.
• 9:12
  They had shifted from describing what they did to defining who
• 9:16
  they believed they were. And when this happens, it can
• 9:22
  detour purpose. Because the same labels that
• 9:26
  help build success can make it harder to see the leader we're
• 9:31
  still becoming. And this is where the whiskey
• 9:36
  metaphor really starts to matter.
• 9:39
  And because in whiskey, identity never comes from the label.
• 9:43
  It always comes from what's been formed through the process.
• 9:48
  The grain that was selected, the mash that was fermented, the
• 9:52
  spirit that was distilled, and the years spent aging inside oak
• 9:58
  barrels. That's what makes the whiskey,
• 10:01
  not the label that gets placed on the bottle.
• 10:06
  The identity of the spirit is formed long before the label
• 10:10
  ever appears. The label is simply something
• 10:16
  that tells the story, and it does so in leadership, too.
• 10:21
  Those labels become part of the story, but identity is formed
• 10:26
  through the process, through decisions and pressure, through
• 10:31
  uncertainty and reflection, through time, and through an
• 10:36
  understanding of our unique talents and gifts.
• 10:41
  And it comes through distillation, where everything
• 10:44
  that doesn't belong gets removed.
• 10:48
  If you and I were a bottle of whiskey carefully crafted by a
• 10:52
  master distiller, we wouldn't need a label to know what we're
• 10:55
  made of or what we're capable of.
• 11:00
  And over time, others would know that too.
• 11:06
  This might be a good place to pause for a second.
• 11:10
  If this conversation has you wondering about the labels
• 11:13
  attached to your leadership, here are a few questions to sit
• 11:16
  with. Honestly.
• 11:19
  What labels have attached themselves to how you lead?
• 11:25
  I'm not just talking about the late date, the titles that you
• 11:27
  hold, but the descriptions that you've come to believe about
• 11:31
  yourself, the ones you rely on, the ones others expect, the ones
• 11:37
  that have followed you from one season into the next.
• 11:43
  And then maybe a second question.
• 11:45
  Where have those labels served you well and where might they be
• 11:50
  limiting what you believe is possible?
• 11:55
  Where have they helped create clarity and where might you be
• 11:59
  protecting them? Because for many leaders, the
• 12:02
  tension isn't in a lack of clarity.
• 12:06
  It's being so closely aligned to what has worked or created
• 12:09
  results that it becomes harder to see what might be unfolding
• 12:14
  next. And it's worth saying that I'm
• 12:20
  not saying that the labels are wrong.
• 12:23
  It just means that they might not tell the whole story of what
• 12:27
  you were built for. They may be overshadowing your
• 12:30
  purpose. The spirit inside your bottle
• 12:36
  identity isn't something that we assigned or something that we're
• 12:40
  given. It's something that's revealed
• 12:44
  and formed. And just like that distillation
• 12:48
  process, it requires removing what doesn't belong.
• 12:52
  So what is true can remain. So maybe one more question to
• 12:59
  sit with this week. If your labels were were
• 13:03
  removed, what would still be true about how you lead?
• 13:09
  Because that answer is much closer to your identity than any
• 13:13
  label could ever be. If you've ever gone to whiskey
• 13:19
  tasting, you write down notes of what you've tasted, things that
• 13:24
  stood out to you, and things that you want to remember.
• 13:28
  Here are my tasting notes from today.
• 13:30
  Yours might be different. And if you like to go a little
• 13:33
  bit deeper, I put together additional tasting notes for
• 13:37
  this episode at craftedclarity.net.
• 13:42
  One. Labels are useful, but they have
• 13:46
  a place in leadership. Labels aren't the problem.
• 13:51
  They help teams move faster. They create clarity in complex
• 13:56
  environments. They even help build trust and
• 13:59
  momentum over time. And many of us have used labels
• 14:03
  to study ourselves, especially in moments where we've
• 14:07
  questioned whether we belong in the room.
• 14:11
  But labels are never meant to carry identity.
• 14:15
  They can describe how we contribute, but they can't
• 14:18
  define who we are. Two labels travel with us, even
• 14:25
  when the seasons change. One of the challenges with
• 14:29
  labels is that they tend to follow us from one season into
• 14:33
  the next. The label that made sense in one
• 14:37
  role can shape how we see what's possible in the next.
• 14:42
  And in seasons of transition, that matters because growth
• 14:47
  often requires movement, and movement becomes harder when
• 14:52
  we're trying to make the next season fit the last one.
• 14:57
  Recognizing labels we're carrying is what allows us to
• 15:01
  move through a season instead of staying anchored to it.
• 15:07
  And the third identity is formed, not assigned.
• 15:13
  In whiskey, the label comes last.
• 15:16
  The identity of the spirit is shaped through process, through
• 15:20
  time, pressure, and refinement. And that's the same for you and
• 15:25
  I. What's true about you as a
• 15:28
  leader has already been forming through the decisions you've
• 15:32
  made and the pressure you've navigated and the seasons that
• 15:36
  you've walked through. The work now isn't to find a
• 15:40
  better label, it's to continue the process and remove what
• 15:45
  doesn't belong anymore. Thanks for joining me today.
• 15:50
  And remember, clarity isn't found, it's crafted.
• 15:58
  Thanks for listening to Crafted Clarity.
• 16:00
  If you're a leader wrestling with the tension between success
• 16:03
  and significance, or if you're trying to align your work with a
• 16:06
  deeper calling, I'd love to connect with you.
• 16:09
  If your organization is facing questions about strategy,
• 16:12
  whether it's alignment, ROI, or building confidence in your
• 16:16
  team, this is the work we do everyday at ibrand.
• 16:19
  And if you walk this journey yourself, or maybe you're right
• 16:23
  in the middle of it, I'd love to hear your story and maybe even
• 16:26
  share it here on the podcast. You can find me at
• 16:29
  craftclarity.net.