Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Are Paid Below Market Rate
Transcript
- Lucas: So, Luna, we've been getting a lot of questions about raises lately, but this one from a listener named Priya really stood out. She's been in her role for about two years, and she just found out from a former coworker that she's making at least fifteen percent below what the market pays for her position. Luna: Fifteen percent is significant. That's not just a rounding error. Lucas: Exactly. And her question is, how do I bring this up without sounding greedy or like I'm threatening to leave? And honestly, that's the right question to ask, because the way you frame this conversation matters as much as the numbers you bring. Luna: So where does she even start? I imagine it's not just walking into her manager's office and saying 'I'm underpaid.' Lucas: Right, that would be a disaster. The first thing she needs to do is gather solid evidence. Not just one data point from a former coworker, but multiple sources. Things like salary surveys from professional associations, job postings for similar roles with salary ranges, maybe even a conversation with a recruiter who works in her field. Luna: But isn't there a risk that the data is all over the place? Like, what counts as 'market rate' can be pretty fuzzy. Lucas: It can be, and that's why she needs to triangulate. For example, let's say she's a marketing manager in Chicago. She could look at the latest marketing salary survey from a group like the American Marketing Association, cross-check that with a couple of job postings on LinkedIn or Glassdoor that list ranges, and then maybe talk to a local recruiter who places marketing roles. If three different sources all point to a similar range, she can be pretty confident. Luna: So once she has that evidence, what's the next step? Does she just schedule a meeting? Lucas: Yes, but timing matters. She should look for a natural checkpoint. Maybe quarterly business reviews, or right after she's completed a major project. You don't want to catch your manager in the middle of a fire drill. And she should request a dedicated meeting, not try to squeeze it into a casual chat. Luna: And what should she actually say in that meeting? I imagine she needs to walk a fine line. Lucas: She needs to lead with her contributions, not the market data. Start by talking about the value she's delivered—the project she led, the revenue she helped generate, the efficiency gains. Then she can transition to the market research and say something like, 'I've been doing some research on comparable roles, and I've found that the market range for someone with my experience and in my region is X to Y. I'm currently below that range, and I'd like to discuss how we can bring my compensation more in line with that.' Luna: That's a nice script. But what if her manager pushes back and says, 'Well, we don't always pay market rate, we rely on annual reviews'? Lucas: That's where she needs to be prepared to have a negotiation conversation, not just a request. She can acknowledge the annual review process, but then ask, 'Would it be possible to have an off-cycle review given this data? Or could we at least agree on a plan to bring me to market rate by the next review cycle?' Luna: So she's asking for a plan, not just a check. That feels more collaborative. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a good segue to something we talk about a lot on this show. You know, if you find these conversations helpful, and you want to support the work we do here, you can help keep this podcast ad-free by buying us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small gesture that goes a long way in helping us keep producing the kind of practical advice we love to share. Luna: Yeah, and even a one-time coffee helps. But back to Priya—what if her manager still says no? What's her fallback? Lucas: That's when she needs to think about her alternatives. If the company is truly unwilling to address a fifteen percent gap, she has to decide whether that's a dealbreaker. And that's okay. Sometimes the answer is to start looking externally. But she should be careful not to use the threat of leaving as a negotiation tactic unless she's actually prepared to leave. That can backfire. Luna: So she should have a plan B in her back pocket, but not necessarily pull it out right away. Lucas: Right. And if she does get an external offer, she can come back to her manager and say, 'I've received an offer for X, and I'd love to stay, but I need to be at that level to justify staying.' That's a much stronger negotiating position. Luna: But is that risky? I mean, doesn't it sometimes poison the well? Lucas: It can, but only if she's not genuine. If she's bluffing, it's a huge risk. But if she's truly willing to leave, then it's a legitimate part of the conversation. And in many cases, it's the only way to get a significant adjustment. Companies often have more flexibility to match an external offer than to proactively fix an internal inequity. Luna: That's a sad reality, but I think it's true. Lucas: Yeah, it's an unfortunate truth. And it ties into a broader point about salary transparency. In some states, employers are required to post salary ranges now, which helps employees know where they stand. But in others, it's still very opaque, and that's why doing your own research is so important. Luna: So, for someone listening who might be in a similar situation, what's the one key takeaway? Lucas: I'd say, don't wait for your annual review to find out you're underpaid. Be proactive. Do the research, build your case, and frame it as a conversation about fairness and your value to the company. And remember, you're not asking for a favor—you're asking to be compensated fairly for the work you do. Luna: That's a great note to end on. Thanks for tuning in, and we'll catch you next time on Office Hours.