Latest / The Counter Momentum of Spin, with Dr. Franco Musio / Fracturing of the First Amendment
Transcript
- 0:02Good day. Welcome to the Midday Report on
- 0:05the America Out Loud News Talk Radio
- 0:08Network, the counter momentum of spin. I'm your
- 0:11host, Dr. Franco Musio. So to our
- 0:14friends listening in the United States and around
- 0:17the world, I always say this: there is
- 0:19no lack of hard news items to keep
- 0:21our adrenaline going. Our aim, though, is
- 0:25to dissect out the nuances and underlying causes
- 0:28and foundations of the events with which we
- 0:31come into contact now
- 0:33continuously. So today's show, I'm
- 0:37going to pivot a little bit and I'm
- 0:38going to go somewhat away from
- 0:42the hard news item, so to speak. And
- 0:45this is more of a general is kind
- 0:47of a general topic. And but we
- 0:51actually do come into contact with this every
- 0:53single day. But the I'm titling this show,
- 0:56The Fracturing of the First Amendment.
- 1:00So I say this as a very
- 1:03concerned citizen, that the
- 1:06rhetoric, primarily from the progressive
- 1:09left, but actually everywhere, and
- 1:12now
- 1:13the unhinged realities
- 1:17of what's we see pushes uh
- 1:20and pushing for socialism from young candidates
- 1:24who really have no clue as to what
- 1:26they're saying. Young candidates, uh maybe
- 1:30less than middle age, but young adulthood. Um
- 1:34and and again, they don't know what they're
- 1:37saying. And um they're all of
- 1:40this is being more and more cloaked under
- 1:43an umbrella of hate speech,
- 1:46hateful actions, and uh
- 1:49absolutely horrible
- 1:51consequences. I wrote an article last year
- 1:54entitled, uh, have the boundaries of the First
- 1:56Amendment been violated? Well,
- 2:00in my opinion, uh, and that kind of
- 2:03the the title uh really goes
- 2:06into how I feel, uh, but my opinion
- 2:10is that they've been more than violated, uh,
- 2:12and as time goes on, even metaphorically, I'd
- 2:15say raped. So we are going
- 2:18to uh look from a 30,000-foot
- 2:21view first, and then we'll go into
- 2:25some specifics, such as the
- 2:27legitimacy of an amendment, the first
- 2:30amendment, that was passed in 1789 and
- 2:34being applicable to I I'd say the
- 2:37modern-day jungle that we live in, and now
- 2:40invaded by mass media, and uh
- 2:43and as I mentioned to you, the rampant
- 2:46hate hate coming from all directions that
- 2:49was not going on in 1789, I guarantee
- 2:52you. And then we're gonna talk about um
- 2:56implications of AI within this whole
- 2:59topic, that that's a whole nother discussion,
- 3:02and then um, where is common sense?
- 3:06Where is common sense? Clearly, I'm not
- 3:09an attorney, I'm not a lawyer, I'm a
- 3:11doctor, and a lot of times, so often,
- 3:15we need, I remember a colleague of mine
- 3:18said when there was a difficult case, but
- 3:21but there were so many complexities, but then
- 3:26a lot of common sense too. And
- 3:30uh the my colleague said, Well, you know
- 3:32what, in difficult situations, I often ask myself,
- 3:36what would my mother have done? What would
- 3:38my mother have said? And and I I
- 3:41honestly I think this uh this applies to
- 3:45this as well, rather than these very intricate
- 3:48legal uh legalese, legal uh
- 3:52arguments, this, that, and the other. I I
- 3:54I think common sense really, really,
- 3:58really needs to take hold. So, yeah, I
- 4:01I if you go back to last year,
- 4:03the Charlie Kirk murder, um, and
- 4:07and the rhetoric which came about
- 4:10as a result of that murder by many
- 4:13ignorant, in my opinion, and soulless
- 4:15individuals, uh, to really include the assassin
- 4:19himself, it invites us to
- 4:22re-examine this First Amendment of the Constitution of
- 4:25the United States, particularly in the
- 4:28sphere of hate speech and hateful
- 4:31actions. So, going back, this amendment was
- 4:34passed by the first Congress on September
- 4:3725th, 1789, and
- 4:40ratified on December 10th, 1791, as
- 4:44part of the Ten Amendments comprising the Bill
- 4:46of Rights. So the Constitution currently has a
- 4:49total of 27 amendments, but this was the
- 4:52first. So the interpretation of this
- 4:56amendment, my goodness, uh it's been
- 4:59argued by the Supreme Court and many lower
- 5:01courses since their inception, leading to
- 5:05its ultimate standing in our system of justice.
- 5:07James Madison was considered the primary
- 5:10author of the First Amendment, as well as
- 5:13the chief author of the entire Bill of
- 5:16Rights. Uh, although, in regard to historical
- 5:19context, modern society,
- 5:22and I'm gonna make this argument repeatedly, is
- 5:24clearly separated by light years,
- 5:28light years uh from the late
- 5:3118th century. So this
- 5:34requires great contemplation in
- 5:37discussions of the First Amendment and its nuances,
- 5:40uh, that we'll uh we'll elaborate upon a
- 5:43little bit later here. So
- 5:46the First Amendment, it mirrors each of the
- 5:49ten amendments uh of the Bill of Rights
- 5:51in terms of its composition. Listen to
- 5:54this, uh, as a compound sentence, with the
- 5:58others being single or simple or compound
- 6:01sentences also. This is the first
- 6:04amendment. Quote, Congress shall make no
- 6:07law respecting uh an
- 6:10establishment of religion, or
- 6:13prohibiting the free exercise thereof,
- 6:17or abridging the freedom of speech or
- 6:20of the press, or of the right of
- 6:22the people peacefully to assemble, and to
- 6:26petition the government for a redress of
- 6:29grievances. That's the first amendment. You want
- 6:32me to repeat it? Peter, I I will.
- 6:34So, for sake of arguments later, quote,
- 6:37Congress shall make no law respecting an
- 6:41establishment of religion or
- 6:44prohibiting the free exercise thereof,
- 6:47or abridging the freedom of speech
- 6:51or the press, or of the right of
- 6:54the people peacefully to assemble, peacefully,
- 6:57and to petition the government for a redress
- 7:00of grievances. Now, this was written, this is
- 7:02from 1789. So as
- 7:05per decisions uh rendered from
- 7:09a series, series of Supreme Court cases,
- 7:12quote, freedom of speech uh includes the following.
- 7:16They include the following, among others. So
- 7:19they include the freedom not to speak, uh
- 7:22such as, for example, um not saluting the
- 7:25flag. Uh it includes um and
- 7:29I'm quoting here, to use certain offensive words
- 7:32and phrases to convey political
- 7:34messages. And I'm going to argue about that
- 7:37because there's clearly a continuum here into what
- 7:40goes into violence, and three,
- 7:44to contribute money or under circumstances
- 7:47to political campaigns, and next,
- 7:51quote, to engage in symbolic speech,
- 7:54okay, such as burning the American flag in
- 7:57protest. So I have a lot of problems
- 7:59with that, and I know many of you
- 8:01do too. So
- 8:04conversely, conversely, other Supreme
- 8:07Court cases have held that freedom of
- 8:10speech does not include the
- 8:13following, among others. So,
- 8:17quote, to ensue uh incite imminent and
- 8:20lawful action or violence. Oh, lawless action.
- 8:23So again, to incite imminent and lawless action
- 8:26or violence. So, what about
- 8:29what's been spewed by the media? And that
- 8:31kind of is what we're going to be
- 8:33talking about. So, such as remember Maxine Waters?
- 8:36She's the representative of uh the 43rd District
- 8:39of California, as parts of South LA and
- 8:41the South Bay region in LA County. Do
- 8:44you remember what she said a couple years
- 8:46ago, a few years ago? Uh, I urge
- 8:48you to get into the face. She was
- 8:50talking about progressive Democrats, get into the face
- 8:54of these legislators, uh, meaning, of course,
- 8:57uh the Republicans, the conservatives, get into their
- 9:00face and do this and do that. And
- 9:03and she she was bordering on meaning
- 9:07physical violence. That's what she meant. So, anyway,
- 9:10that's how I interpreted that. But also,
- 9:14we mentioned what what uh freedom of speech
- 9:17does not include. So uh, number two, to
- 9:19make or distribute obscene materials. Okay,
- 9:23although most of pornography really is protected. Number
- 9:26three, statements conveying a serious
- 9:29expression of intent to commit an act of
- 9:32unlawful violence against a particular individual or
- 9:36group. Well, that's occurred time
- 9:39and time and time and time again, including
- 9:41today, for example. Next, quote, a false
- 9:44statement about an individual that causes reputational,
- 9:48financial, or other injury. Well,
- 9:51guess what? This is rampant. This is
- 9:54rampant in terms of lying, uh,
- 9:57statements made about individuals, uh, frank lies.
- 10:00And that doesn't cover words that by their
- 10:03very nature are personally abusive and likely to
- 10:06provoke an immediate violent reaction from
- 10:09the person addressed. Okay. Um,
- 10:14you know, uh uh there's a couple of
- 10:16others. Quote: uh conduct that is severe,
- 10:20pervasive, and offensive, creating a hostile environment
- 10:23and often targeting individuals based on protected
- 10:26characteristics. So this is what hate speech, or
- 10:29this is what the First Amendment is not
- 10:33supposed to be um including. Okay?
- 10:36So if this happens, this goes against the
- 10:38First Amendment. So the argument again is that
- 10:41the criminals are often more protected than the
- 10:44victims. Look at all these idiots who are
- 10:47protested against Ice, protested
- 10:50against um the government's
- 10:54perception of the interference with the Somalis in
- 10:57uh and the Somali fraud in Minnesota.
- 11:00Um
- 11:02I'm telling you that all of these uh
- 11:05what they're claiming the First Amendment does not
- 11:08protect has been violated as well,
- 11:11because uh you have people doing this all
- 11:14over the place. And then lastly, speech that
- 11:16is part of a larger criminal act, such
- 11:19as bribery or a conspiracy. All right. So
- 11:23the last of the entities that I mentioned
- 11:25above was protected, protected by the
- 11:29First Amendment. Uh not to speak, okay, such
- 11:32as not saluting the flag, to use certain
- 11:34offensive words and phrases, to convey political messages,
- 11:37uh, to contribute money, and to engage in
- 11:40symbolic speech, such as burning the uh flag.
- 11:43Um so this symbolic speech uh
- 11:47is the very protection
- 11:50that, in my opinion, has been transgressed uh
- 11:53in regard to the meaning and spirit of
- 11:56the First Amendment. Again, the meaning and the
- 11:58spirit of the First Amendment. Um, did did
- 12:02were there people in 1789
- 12:05burning the flag? And no, we had a
- 12:08brand new republic, and we had people who
- 12:10who love the United States, and and of
- 12:12course, further on, this burning of the flag
- 12:15is a relatively new phenomenon. But
- 12:18let me do this, let me chronicle the
- 12:20timeline because it it's really, really important to
- 12:23look at this, and I have to remind
- 12:25myself all the time the timeline of
- 12:28the interpretation by the Supreme Court
- 12:32in supporting my argument for the really shaky
- 12:35grounds uh upon which the
- 12:38Supreme Court's judgments were founded in
- 12:42regard to hate speech. So the bottom line
- 12:44is I'm very, very, very much against hate
- 12:46speech. I said before, there's continuums, of course
- 12:50there are. Uh, but but we've seen
- 12:53recently the rhetoric has gotten way, way, way
- 12:56out of control. And and the Supreme Court
- 13:00knows this. They've known it for years, but
- 13:03I think many of them are too scared
- 13:06to speak up against hate speech. I do,
- 13:09I do. So let me start with this.
- 13:12Uh, activist Gregory Lee Johnson, he burned
- 13:16an American flag. He did, outside the
- 13:19convention center hosting the 1984
- 13:22Republican National Convention as a protest to
- 13:26the polit uh the policies of uh at
- 13:28the time President Ronald Reagan.
- 13:31Johnson was arrested, he was charged and convicted
- 13:34of violating a Texas statute,
- 13:38protecting the uh desecration of venerated
- 13:41objects, including the American flag.
- 13:45So, in other words, rightfully, the American flag
- 13:47is considered as a venerated object, which
- 13:51it is, particularly if such actions were
- 13:54likely to incite anger among other individuals. And
- 13:57and it did. And guess what?
- 14:00Others were also incited and excited uh
- 14:03about burning the flag as well. So
- 14:06Johnson's attorneys appealed the ruling to the Supreme
- 14:10Court. Why not? Of course. And they were
- 14:12arguing that his actions, Johnson's actions, were
- 14:16symbolic speech. Okay, symbolic
- 14:19speech. And it was protected by the First
- 14:21Amendment. So the court ruled by five
- 14:25to four. So so, in other words, there
- 14:27was just one vote that would have swung
- 14:29that a different way. That's why there's nine
- 14:32judges, but five for majority in Texas versus
- 14:35Johnson, 1989. That the burning of the American
- 14:38flag, uh, they said does constitute
- 14:42symbolic speech. Um, yeah, it
- 14:44does, but it does, but it shouldn't be
- 14:48protected. So, which they say was
- 14:50protected, is protected by the First Amendment,
- 14:54notwithstanding its offense and outrage to
- 14:56society. That's what that's what they ruled.
- 15:01So this rule, okay, was
- 15:04invalidated or had this ruling
- 15:06invalidated laws,
- 15:09pre-existent laws, against
- 15:12desecration of the American flag, which were present,
- 15:15already present at that time in 48 out
- 15:17of 50 states at that time. So
- 15:21um the states knew what they were doing.
- 15:24This is absolutely common sense, but
- 15:27the Supreme Court stepped in and
- 15:31with their linguistic uh uh
- 15:34perceptions and and semantics of the
- 15:37if you uh if you will of the
- 15:39first amendment said, well, the letter of the
- 15:42first amendment, they because of that, yeah, it's
- 15:45protected.
- 15:47So as a response to that, to that
- 15:50ruling, the 101st Congress
- 15:53passed the Flag Protection Act
- 15:57of 1980,
- 15:59which actually protected, uh prohibited the
- 16:02mistreatment of the American flag,
- 16:05notwithstanding the messages being imparted by
- 16:09that particular act. So uh at
- 16:12least in 1989, it's clearly not no
- 16:15way as bad as now. Uh there are
- 16:18a bunch of things with Vietnam and such
- 16:20in which that was occurring. But the
- 16:23101st Congress, I think,
- 16:26knew what it was doing in that respect.
- 16:29So um anyway, I uh uh
- 16:33I'm gonna wait until the uh the commercial
- 16:35break and we're gonna go into more of
- 16:37the uh the timeline, because this is really
- 16:39a timeline of what has been involved
- 16:43in terms of protecting or not protecting, not
- 16:45protecting burning of the flag, which uh
- 16:49in my view is completely abominable. Uh, even
- 16:52if you're a a progressive leftist and you
- 16:56you have the right to be a progressive
- 16:57leftist by virtue of living in this country
- 17:00and being a citizen, they could understand that
- 17:03if you don't love this country, get the
- 17:04hell out of here. Anyway, uh on the
- 17:07other side, please hold tight and we're gonna
- 17:10we're gonna go into this more in depth.
- 17:12Feeling off lately? Bloated, brain fog, low energy?
- 17:15It could be parasites, these sound invaders that
- 17:18weaken your gut, immune system, and mental clarity.
- 17:20That's why Dr. Peter McCullough and the doctors
- 17:22at the wellness company formulated ivermectin and mabendazol
- 17:25cleanse, a medical-grade solution designed to help eliminate
- 17:28parasites and restore balance. No gimmicks, just real
- 17:31medicine trusted by top doctors. Go to
- 17:33twc.health forward slash outlout and
- 17:36use code outload for 20% off your first
- 17:39order. Take control of your health today. Have
- 17:41you been looking for a healthy snack from
- 17:44the go? Well, not all energy bars are
- 17:47soft and sugary. Bear bars are a crunchy
- 17:51savory bar made from just six simple
- 17:54natural ingredients. Bear bars are plant-based,
- 17:57organic, gluten-free, contain six grams of protein and
- 18:01are low temperature drain for unique crunch.
- 18:05Most energy bars are based on chocolate litter
- 18:08fruit and are held together with syrups or
- 18:11sweeteners. To learn more, just visit bear bar
- 18:14and
- 18:15command.
- 19:06So um, and we were talking about the
- 19:09101st Congress, they passed the uh
- 19:12Flag Protection Act of 1989,
- 19:15prohibiting the mistreatment of the American flag,
- 19:19notwithstanding the messages being imparted by that
- 19:22act. So, moments after, just
- 19:25moments after this act was implemented, American flags
- 19:29were burned in protest around the
- 19:32country. This was organized by the Vietnam Veterans
- 19:35Against the War, followed by the arrest of
- 19:38demonstrators uh at two of the venues, Washington,
- 19:41D.C., of course, and Seattle, Washington. Why
- 19:44doesn't that surprise me? Next,
- 19:48next, the Supreme Court ruled against, oh
- 19:52my goodness, against the Flag Protection Act in
- 19:55the United States versus Eichmann in 1990.
- 19:58Here we go again by the same five
- 20:00to four majority, including
- 20:03the say exact same justices who voted
- 20:07in the Texas versus Johnson, the way they
- 20:10voted. They voted exactly the same. Again, asserting
- 20:13the burning of the American flag is protected
- 20:15under the First Amendment in its display of
- 20:18quote expressive conduct and
- 20:21quote symbolic speech. All right, I'm
- 20:25gonna take my doctor hat off, my lawyer
- 20:27hat off. I'm pretending I'm a lawyer. That's
- 20:29bullshit. I hate to say that, but this
- 20:32is. So, or that was. So,
- 20:35notwithstanding the fact that listen to this, Junston
- 20:38Anton Scalia, best bless his heart, voted
- 20:42with the majority, the majority, in
- 20:45both Supreme Court decisions, upholding the
- 20:48burning of the American flag by the First
- 20:50Amendment. But listen to this, his personal
- 20:53opinion, as opposed to his
- 20:56interpretation of the Constitution,
- 21:00was quite notable and compelling. This is what
- 21:03he said. If it were up to me,
- 21:06I would put in jail every sandal wearing
- 21:09scruffy beard weirdo who burns the American
- 21:12flag. But I am not king. I'll repeat
- 21:15it if I if it were up to
- 21:16me. I would put in jail every sandal
- 21:19wear, well, I wear sandals, scruffy bearded weirdo.
- 21:22I'm not sometimes I don't say, but I
- 21:25hope I'm not a weirdo, and who burns
- 21:27the American flag. Well, I would never in
- 21:29a million years ever do that, but I
- 21:31am not king. So what he was saying
- 21:33was, um I'm not a ruler, neither is
- 21:36the Supreme Court, and by uh
- 21:38interpreting the wording of the First Amendment,
- 21:42we have to follow that. That's what he
- 21:44says. So uh that's what
- 21:47he said. So, but again, uh implied in
- 21:50all this, at least I would like to
- 21:52imply strongly, uh that
- 21:541789 is not when that
- 21:57ruling came out. In other words, the ruling
- 22:00came out um let's see here,
- 22:021990, uh United States versus
- 22:06Eichmann or Eickman, I think Ek Eichmann
- 22:09is the right word pronunciation. So, anyway,
- 22:12um the First Amendment, so it applies to
- 22:15governmental activities and not private organizations and
- 22:18individuals. That's interesting, too. So, as per the
- 22:21quote, state action doctrine of the 14th
- 22:24Amendment, freedom of speech applies to U.S.
- 22:28government employees, officials, and
- 22:30agencies at all levels, federal, state,
- 22:34local, exclusive of private
- 22:37employers, university, universities, or
- 22:40social media companies, which may institute their own
- 22:43guidelines and rules. So this is uh the
- 22:46amendments and such applies to what I just
- 22:49said. Uh U.S. government,
- 22:52employees, officials, agencies at all
- 22:55levels, federal, state, and local. But the
- 22:58um the private companies, private employers,
- 23:02universities, social media companies, they're um
- 23:05exempt from from these terrible rulings. So
- 23:09what do they do? Well, normally they go
- 23:11along with what the government says, um, normally,
- 23:14typically, like all of this uh you know
- 23:18pride stuff during the Biden administration, and and
- 23:21then notice that there's a a sharp decline
- 23:23of that now with the um
- 23:26uh with the Trump administration. So
- 23:30let's go into uh that's another commentary, the
- 23:33the truth behind hate speech. Let's talk
- 23:36about the truth uh behind hate
- 23:39speech. So uh there's no legal
- 23:42definition of hate speech, and although there's
- 23:46a common reference, and and that of Kenneth
- 23:49Ward, as published in the University of
- 23:52Miami Law Review in 1998. So
- 23:55this is interesting. Quote: Hate speech is any
- 23:58form of expression through which speakers
- 24:02intend to vilify, humiliate, or
- 24:05incite hatred against a group or class
- 24:08of persons on the basis of race, religion,
- 24:12skin color, sexual identity, gender identity,
- 24:15ethnicity, disability, or national origin.
- 24:19So this is really, really good. So let
- 24:22me say it again. Hate speech, quote, is
- 24:24a form of expression through which speakers intend
- 24:26to vilify, humiliate, or incite hatred against a
- 24:30group or class of persons on the basis
- 24:32of race, religion, skin color, sexual
- 24:36identity, gender identity, ethnicity, disability,
- 24:39or national origin.
- 24:42Um, there were other parts of that statement,
- 24:45but also to include um politics
- 24:49and uh ideology as well. So
- 24:52this definition, it can be elaborated
- 24:55to include speech, in my opinion, that's vile,
- 24:59iniquitous, immoral,
- 25:01engendering kind of
- 25:04visceral disgust, as noted by
- 25:07the glorification of the assassination of Charlie Kirk
- 25:11by some individuals and groups. You could even
- 25:13state assassination or killings or murders of other
- 25:16people, no matter the political spectrum,
- 25:20no matter people are people. And in point
- 25:24of fact, many democratic nations,
- 25:27uh not democratic party, democratic
- 25:30nations, democracies, like in Europe, for
- 25:33example, um, or in Japan, they have
- 25:36statutes protecting freedom of speech,
- 25:40although with tighter restrictions than in the
- 25:43United States, such as the uh
- 25:46exclusion of hate speech. So countries like Germany,
- 25:50France, Ireland, Denmark, Australia,
- 25:53among others, uh, UK, UK is a big
- 25:56one, uh, they criminalize hate speech. And
- 26:00I want to tell you that there could
- 26:02be fine lines. I understand that. There could
- 26:05be fine lines, but hate speech is hate
- 26:06speech. I mean, it doesn't take uh it
- 26:09doesn't take a constitutional scholar to
- 26:13define hate speech. Hate speech is hate speech.
- 26:16It's there. You know it, you see it,
- 26:18like when someone's pregnant. You know when some
- 26:20well, that's not a good analogy, you don't
- 26:22know that all the time. But but you
- 26:24know what it is. You know what hate
- 26:26is. We as human beings know what hate
- 26:28is. So Justice uh Lewis Brandeis,
- 26:32he kind of opened the legal door for
- 26:34debate surrounding the protection of hate speech.
- 26:37Um, this was referred he referred it uh
- 26:40to his evil counsels at the time. Evil
- 26:44counsels uh in the majority 9-0 decision in
- 26:47Whitney versus California. That was back in
- 26:501927.
- 26:52That was a case involving a woman convicted
- 26:54under California law for activities with the Communist
- 26:57Party. All right, that was in 27.
- 27:00So in his discussion of the
- 27:04intent of the framers of the Bill of
- 27:06Rights, Justice Brandeis
- 27:09stated this quote Freedom to
- 27:12think as you will and speak as you
- 27:14think are means indispensable to the
- 27:17discovery and spread of political truth.
- 27:21That without free speech and assembly, discussion would
- 27:24be futile. Discussion affords ordinary
- 27:27adequate protection against the dissemination of
- 27:30noxious doctrine. And this should be a
- 27:34fundamental principle of American government.
- 27:37So um again, discussion,
- 27:41quote, discussion affords ordinary
- 27:44adequate protection against the dissemination of
- 27:47noxious doctrine. So
- 27:50Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., he expounded upon the
- 27:54protection of hate speech in his historic dissent
- 27:57uh of a 6-3 decision in the United
- 28:00States versus Schwimmer in also 1929,
- 28:04which denied U.S. citizenship to a Hungarian
- 28:07pacifist who refused to agree to the
- 28:10uh take up arms in defense of the
- 28:12United States. That's interesting. So
- 28:16um what they said is, or that
- 28:19the um argument in 6-3 decision is quote,
- 28:22if there is any principle of the Constitution
- 28:26that more uh imperatively calls for
- 28:29attachment than any other, it is the
- 28:32principle of free thought. Not free
- 28:35thought for those who agree with us, but
- 28:38freedom for the thought that we hate. Okay,
- 28:41freedom for the thought that we hate. So
- 28:45what can I say that that is is
- 28:48interesting. Now, 1929 still is
- 28:51very far away, was from
- 28:541789. Okay, I would argue
- 28:58even there the the timing w i i
- 29:01is something that can be argued and this
- 29:04freedom of speech uh needed to be
- 29:08re-investigated or or or more in
- 29:11depthly indeptly analyzed. So uh
- 29:15the most recent uh interpretation by
- 29:18the Supreme Court of the First Amendment uh
- 29:22regarding hate speech, it involved a case Snyder
- 29:25versus Phelps in 2011.
- 29:28Mr. Fred Phelps and his followers, if you
- 29:31remember this, this was very, very highly publicized
- 29:35at Westboro Baptist Church in Topeka, Kansas,
- 29:38believed that God punishes the United States for
- 29:41its tolerance of homosexuality, particularly in
- 29:45the military at that time. So,
- 29:48as a result, Phelps and others from his
- 29:51church would openly picket military
- 29:54funerals. Okay.
- 29:57The son of Mr. Albert Snyder, Lance
- 30:00Corporal Matthew Snyder, was killed during his
- 30:03tour of duty in Iraq in 2006. Um,
- 30:07although he was not gay, Mr. Phelps,
- 30:10along with many of his followers, picketed Lance
- 30:13Corporal's funeral at St. John's Catholic Church in
- 30:16Westminster, Maryland, on um
- 30:20March 10, 2006. That's not very far away
- 30:22from Baltimore, with signs and slogans stating, quote,
- 30:25God hates the United States, thank God for
- 30:279-11, end of quote. Uh quote, thank God
- 30:30for dead soldiers, and quote, don't pray for
- 30:33the United States. Now,
- 30:35the Supreme Court upheld the protesters' right
- 30:38to hate speech in an 8-1 ruling. And
- 30:41Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the majority.
- 30:44This is what he said.
- 30:47Speech is powerful, it can stir people to
- 30:50action, move them to tears or both joy
- 30:52and sorrow, and as it did here,
- 30:56inflict great pain. On the
- 30:59facts before us, we cannot react to that
- 31:01pain by punishing the speaker. As a nation,
- 31:05we have chosen a different course to protect
- 31:07even hurtful speech on public issues, to ensure
- 31:11that we don't do not stifle public debate.
- 31:15I want to tell you, uh yeah, I
- 31:18don't agree with that at all. I don't
- 31:20agree. And in fact, there were um what
- 31:22the ruling the ruling was eight one. Uh
- 31:25isn't that incredible? The ruling was eight one
- 31:27eight to one. So um, yeah, that
- 31:31that uh and again I'm not an
- 31:34attorney, I'm not an attorney, but that in
- 31:37and of itself is disgusting. So
- 31:42ramifications, I I use this as an example,
- 31:45the Charlie Kirk um murder. I use it
- 31:48as a uh as yes, an example. So
- 31:51notwithstanding
- 31:53overwhelming sorrow after the murder of Kirk,
- 31:56Charlie Kirk, there remains a good number of
- 31:58individuals celebrate still, of course, celebrating his death.
- 32:02And we saw this week, this past week,
- 32:04that uh there are hearings every single day,
- 32:06and it's gonna become what another
- 32:09celebrated trial. But uh the
- 32:12the celebration of his death was uh punctuated
- 32:16with reprehensible slurs, slanders, and insults.
- 32:19So the emotional repercussions led to Vice President
- 32:22uh J.D. Vance, who is hosting the first
- 32:26of Charlie Kirk's podcast after his death. He
- 32:29encouraged listeners with the following quote, when you
- 32:32see someone celebrating Charlie, uh Charlie's murder, call
- 32:35them out, and hell, call their employer, and
- 32:38end of quote. So Attorney General of the
- 32:41U.S. Pam Bondi at the time initially stated
- 32:44that there is, quote, there is free speech,
- 32:47and then there is hate speech, which should
- 32:49be shut down, end of quote. And quote,
- 32:52the administration will go after you if you
- 32:54are targeting anyone with hate speech, end of
- 32:57end of quote. That's what she said. And
- 32:59of course, this this was an emotional outburst,
- 33:02and I have to emotionally agree with her
- 33:03under 100%. So these comments were later
- 33:06revised through other media, that quote, hate
- 33:10speech that crosses the line into threats of
- 33:13violence is not protected. Free
- 33:16speech protects ideas, debate, even dissent,
- 33:19but it does not and will never protect
- 33:22violence. End of quote. So
- 33:25you can see how interpretations kind of
- 33:28have very thin lines and uh or
- 33:31blurred lines, I should say. They do. So
- 33:35Kirk's assassination, boy, it's led to
- 33:38vociferous debate leading to further, further
- 33:42polarization in the last year of our nation
- 33:44on the subject of free speech and hate
- 33:47speech. So as a result of these
- 33:50repugnant, I call them repugnant
- 33:53vocalizations, the writings and actions
- 33:56against Charlie Kirk, um well,
- 33:59after his death, um, there have been recent
- 34:02firings. And they still go on, they were
- 34:04mainly last year, but from universities, school districts,
- 34:08state uh education agencies throughout the
- 34:11country, with many even still
- 34:14ongoing investigations. So, moreover,
- 34:17firefighters, military members, and U.S. Secret Service
- 34:21personnel, they've also been fired and dishonorably
- 34:24discharged due to social media posts that they
- 34:27they've placed. So international
- 34:30effects, they've been they've been seen as individuals
- 34:33from all walks of life have been fired
- 34:36in different countries. Um and
- 34:39as we speak, they're currently under investigation.
- 34:43Um or
- 34:45I'm happy about this, they've had performances canceled
- 34:49uh due to vile comments and from countries
- 34:52such as Australia and Brazil, Canada, Mexico,
- 34:56the Netherlands, and and even the UK.
- 34:59So
- 35:01the topic of hate speech that directed
- 35:05towards the assassination of Charlie Kirk has been
- 35:08metamorphosed. You know, that's that's the long word
- 35:11of morphed. Instead of saying morphed,
- 35:14the scientific word is metamorphosed, uh,
- 35:18into many other realms for discussion,
- 35:21such as you know, the vile speech aimed
- 35:24at our current president right now and ongoing
- 35:27in his administration, and with comparison
- 35:30still to Adolf Hitler and fascism,
- 35:32respectively. So the timely,
- 35:36I'm gonna tell you this, the timely opinion
- 35:39piece by Susan D. Harris in the Washington
- 35:42Times. She wrote an article last year, quote,
- 35:45leftists have become the monsters they decry.
- 35:49End of quote. And this was written several
- 35:51days, believe it or not, several days prior
- 35:54to the murder of Charlie Kirk on September
- 35:5610, 2025. And it was published six
- 35:59days afterwards. So this is what she said:
- 36:02quote, Mr. Trump is derided as a racist,
- 36:05rapist, pathological liar, psychopath, felon,
- 36:08murderer, and thief. Today's propaganda
- 36:11spreads instantly via social media, intensifying its
- 36:15reach and impact.
- 36:17Hashtags such as hashtag Trump Dead,
- 36:21uh trend fueled by trolls and
- 36:24amplified by mainstream voices, create a toxic
- 36:27environment where dehumanization thrives.
- 36:31The American left's relentless vilification of
- 36:34perceived enemies is transforming them into the very
- 36:37monsters they decry. End of quote.
- 36:40So yeah, yeah, it is pretty heavy. And
- 36:44I'm gonna go into uh, well, my commentary.
- 36:47Uh a lot of this is my commentary,
- 36:50but I'm gonna go into it on the
- 36:51other side and then speak about common sense.
- 36:54So say tight, hold tight, I should say.
- 36:57Oral hygiene hasn't changed in 50 years, but
- 37:00our diet and the way we eat has,
- 37:02creating an environment in your mouth for bacteria
- 37:05to wreck havoc on your teeth and gums.
- 37:07For better oral health, get spermide dental defense,
- 37:11an oral care line designed to combat acid-creating
- 37:14bacteria. The toothpaste, mouthwash, mints, and
- 37:17gum all contains lylatol, a natural ingredient
- 37:21shown to dramatically improve oral health. Spermi can
- 37:24be found online and at all fine natural
- 37:26retailers. Are you tired of struggling with low
- 37:29energy? We get it. That's why we created
- 37:32organic energy juice. You'll have clean natural
- 37:35energy all day and never struggle with low
- 37:38energy again. In just two minutes, you can
- 37:40restore your energy without those toxic
- 37:43chemicals and stimulants that make it crash. You
- 37:47shouldn't have to struggle with low energy, and
- 37:49with organic energy juice, you won't. If you're
- 37:52struggling with low energy, then buying organic energy
- 37:55juice is the right decision. Go to
- 37:57chemicalfreebody.com forward slash
- 38:00MtLMOT and save 20% on your first order.
- 38:03In a world of rising prices, you can
- 38:05still grow abundance. I'm Doug Evans, author of
- 38:08the national bestseller, the Sprout Book. Sprouts grow
- 38:12in three to five days without soil, sunshine,
- 38:15or fertilizer on your kitchen countertop for
- 38:18under a dollar a serving. Take control of
- 38:20your food and your future. Visit
- 38:22thesproutingcompany.com slash out
- 38:26loud and use the code out loud for
- 38:28an exclusive offer. Grow food, not fear.
- 38:51And uh this kind of uh absolutely
- 38:55this uh and it doesn't apply only to
- 38:57Trump but others. So there have been two
- 39:00Supreme Court cases. They determined the right of
- 39:03quote-unquote expressive conduct and
- 39:06symbolic speech and the burning of the
- 39:10American flag that we talked about, Texas versus
- 39:12Johnson in 1989, United States versus Heichman
- 39:16in 1990, as we talked. So
- 39:20now I mentioned the five-four slim
- 39:23majority in these cases with with the same
- 39:26voting by the same justices. It's
- 39:29evidence, I think, of the precarious nature
- 39:33of the vote. That is just one more
- 39:35vote, one more no vote, would have shifted
- 39:38the ruling and made burning of our flag
- 39:41a crime. So think about that. Think
- 39:44about those implications. So, on the other hand,
- 39:48the overwhelming rule in favor of the First
- 39:50Amendment, uh the legality of hate speech in
- 39:53Snyder versus Phelps, 2011, by an 8-1 margin,
- 39:57that's a little different. And it leads to
- 39:59a much higher burden of proof threshold
- 40:03in the matter of hate speech. I said,
- 40:05hate speech is hate speech. It's pretty clear.
- 40:08Of course, yes, there can be a continuum,
- 40:12as there is with almost everything. But but
- 40:15that continuum, it's been breached to the far
- 40:18ends. Um, you know, uh, you could say,
- 40:22yeah, this makes me sick, or that person
- 40:24makes me sick, and uh, and I hate
- 40:26that person. No, but when it goes to
- 40:28the point of, you know, not only do
- 40:30I hate the person, everybody should hate the
- 40:31person, and and you know, we should bear
- 40:33arms. They go into all these different things,
- 40:36and and this person being alive is horrible,
- 40:39and let's take care of that. Um, anyway,
- 40:42that that that goes beyond the pale. So,
- 40:46in my opinion, common sense and
- 40:49the appropriate context should be the major
- 40:52driver in the interpretation of the First Amendment,
- 40:56particularly allowing for speech which is
- 40:59vile, uh putrid, and
- 41:02outrageously offensive. I say it
- 41:06again, such as the celebration uh uh
- 41:09of the assassination of Charlie Kirk, or or
- 41:12the death of any individual living a
- 41:15life, I would say reflective of God's image
- 41:18and serving his kingdom on earth, notwithstanding the
- 41:22politics or any other qualification
- 41:25or categorization. You saw when uh during the
- 41:28uh correspondence dinner, by the way, Trump said
- 41:31that he wanted to do it within a
- 41:32month, and there was so much going on
- 41:36in his plate. There's no way that that
- 41:38could have happened. But nonetheless, that there was
- 41:41an individual who wanted to assassinate him, and
- 41:44and of course, of course, you have so
- 41:46so many after that that night, that
- 41:49Saturday night, saying, Oh, we wish that that
- 41:52would have happened, we wish that would have
- 41:54that would have been the best thing in
- 41:55the whole world. Well, if that's not to
- 41:57the fringes of hate speech, what what is?
- 42:00What is so
- 42:03going back, the population of the United States
- 42:06when the Bill of Rights was ratified was
- 42:083.9 million per the U.S.
- 42:12first U.S. census in 1790, um,
- 42:16as opposed to the population just a year
- 42:19ago of approximately 347 million. So
- 42:223.9 million versus
- 42:24347 million. That that's roughly
- 42:28a hundred times, a hundred times. So a
- 42:30hundred, yeah, so a thousand
- 42:34percent, thousand percent, ten thousand, sorry, ten thousand
- 42:37percent, ten thousand percent greater. So,
- 42:40furthermore, the behemoth, and it is mass media
- 42:43in modern society, it's transformed
- 42:46communications to unprecedented levels
- 42:49in comparison to previous periods in our country's
- 42:53history. Uh, it has. And uh, although
- 42:56mass media has in many ways uh
- 42:59helped us and has made life so
- 43:02much easier and wonderful,
- 43:06it's done the antithesis as well. It's done
- 43:08the opposite. So the large number of individuals
- 43:11suffering for example, borderline to frankly
- 43:15deranged mental disorders, you see this
- 43:18everywhere. With psychiatric
- 43:21stigmata, it was formally diagnosed, or formally
- 43:24diagnosed, or not even brought to medical attention.
- 43:26So, in other words, um, many of these
- 43:28people that you see on social media in
- 43:30fights, and you may see them in in
- 43:33real life, and it's all over the place,
- 43:35and it's not made up. It's not like
- 43:37AI is is uh you know fooling us
- 43:40in this, it's not. Uh, it really happens
- 43:43everywhere. They're this out of control, these teens,
- 43:45you know, getting together and going crazy and
- 43:48fighting everybody and each other. Um,
- 43:52there's so many are borderline. I I would
- 43:55argue that many of them were brought up
- 43:58that way, and the cycle goes over and
- 44:00over and over. But nonetheless, uh many
- 44:04of them do have uh do have the
- 44:07the teens, but even older, of course, uh
- 44:10they do have psychiatric stigmata and they do
- 44:13have borderline personality. So they're very, very
- 44:16easily pushed, very easily
- 44:18influenced by hate speech. So even
- 44:21those not non-really clinically ill, they may be
- 44:24influenced by hate speech, and of course, spewed
- 44:27by mass media. So the diatribes
- 44:31against good have, for the most part,
- 44:34no basis in reality, okay? Nor
- 44:37have they undergone or passed the empiric scientific
- 44:40hurdles uh of fact checking peer review,
- 44:43scholarly discussion, etc. So I
- 44:47think without doubt, fomenting speech, described as
- 44:50hateful, uh, has its source uh
- 44:53among a large, large
- 44:55contingency of the progressive left.
- 44:59Uh and although the right,
- 45:02the right is not uh burft, uh they're
- 45:05they're not uh it's not exclusive, put it
- 45:08this way, to the progressive left. It's not
- 45:11as though the right is is they're all
- 45:13angels. Um no, they have their contributors uh
- 45:16for sure. But in some,
- 45:19in some, the founders of the Constitution and
- 45:22the Bill of Rights, uh, they were not
- 45:24working in a society full of and rife
- 45:27with uh easily, easily swayable citizenry
- 45:31that influenced by an unmanageable and largely
- 45:34unregulated mass media, a huge
- 45:37population with multi-diverse culture,
- 45:41soaring levels of crime, although, although
- 45:44it's been more tame recently, um
- 45:48and the quasi-requisite need for arming ourselves.
- 45:52It actually I hate to say it, but
- 45:54but it's not quasi, it's almost requisite here.
- 45:57So all tipping the pendulum to unsavory
- 46:00consequences. So I'll say it again. The founders
- 46:03of the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, and
- 46:05with the First Amendment in 1791, uh
- 46:081789, sorry, when it was written, we're not
- 46:12working in a society
- 46:15uh where
- 46:17the current society, uh, with a very,
- 46:20very easily swayable citizenry.
- 46:23These people who are borderline, who are even
- 46:26not borderline, but just just um
- 46:29uh let's see burden, I would say
- 46:32burdened, but mass media were just enveloped
- 46:36by mass media, uh and and easily,
- 46:39easily influenced. And uh this mass
- 46:42media is largely unregulated. It's a huge population,
- 46:45it has many, many cultures. We're in the
- 46:48middle of soaring crime, we're in the middle
- 46:51of, you know, um, if you look down
- 46:54any major downtown, any major urban uh
- 46:58area, what do you see there? You you
- 47:00see a lot of times rioting, you see
- 47:03a lot of by the way, that uh
- 47:05Derek Chobin, there is um
- 47:08word that he may be released from prison.
- 47:11Expect another uh another uh you know
- 47:14rioting everywhere, expect that. Anyway, so mass
- 47:17media, including entertainment uh industry, that they've soiled
- 47:21our national psyche, my god, they have, uh,
- 47:24with non-stop violence. I I I don't I
- 47:27don't profess to be Rush Limbaugh. I'm not,
- 47:30I'm really not, but I agree with
- 47:34a lot of his bless his soul, a
- 47:36lot of his uh commentary. So uh yeah,
- 47:39our national psyche is nonstop violence. It then
- 47:42begets a conscious, consciousness and
- 47:45subconscious, uh a thirst for additional
- 47:48violence, and uh from a psychological
- 47:51standpoint. Uh and as I said, there there
- 47:54can be a fine line between the uh
- 47:56fanatization of violence and its actual
- 47:59effectuation. So, you know, the fantasy
- 48:03of violence, seeing it, looking at it, and
- 48:06all these we talked about with children, all
- 48:08these videos everywhere. Uh I
- 48:11use the word enveloped, uh, but it's true,
- 48:13envelop their brain. There's a fine line between
- 48:16that, the fantasy, and its actual, actually carrying
- 48:19it out, the effectuation. So freedom of speech,
- 48:23it's a protected privilege. It's guaranteed by the
- 48:25First Amendment, it was talked about, although the
- 48:27safeguarding of hate speech, it necessitates
- 48:31revisitation, reinterpretation, I
- 48:34think very, very strongly through the lens
- 48:38of modern-day society on many levels. So
- 48:42let's talk about this. The categories of
- 48:45unprotected speech. It includes what we talked about
- 48:48before, those utterances that are likely to
- 48:51provoke imminent lawless action or violence. Okay,
- 48:54it includes that. Um or or
- 48:58yeah, the uh of unprotected uh speech. So
- 49:00so it goes against that. But it can
- 49:03be argued, it can be argued that hate
- 49:06speech does not in fact place limits on
- 49:09freedom of speech. Okay, so vile
- 49:12vocalizations, they've been bombarding our public in an
- 49:16overwhelming fashion, again, thanks to yes, mass
- 49:19media, clearly are playing a role and affecting
- 49:23the national procliv proclivity to
- 49:26criminal acts. Now, this would be the
- 49:28antithesis of the intentions of the authors of
- 49:31the Bill of Rights. Absolutely, even
- 49:34well-intentioned media sources. Now, think about this.
- 49:37Umedia
- 49:41sources um and uh displaying
- 49:44nonsense, this case is important what we have
- 49:46to be aware of, contribute to this morass.
- 49:50Um
- 49:52Carl Gustav Jung, if if you uh any
- 49:55people identifying or remembering this person, he was
- 49:58a very well-known Swiss psychiatrist, psychotherapist,
- 50:02and psychologist. He founded the school of analytical
- 50:05psychology.
- 50:07He had many essays, he addressed the evil
- 50:10in the 1930s and 40s, uh just evil,
- 50:13the topic of evil, um, and uh
- 50:18used this as and others as a springboard
- 50:20for elaboration on the import of hate
- 50:23speech in today's world. So
- 50:26I'm gonna quote, I'm gonna quote him, Carl
- 50:28Jung, quote, in the darkest Middle Ages,
- 50:32they spoke of the devil, today we call
- 50:35it an eurosis. The historic events of
- 50:38our time have painted a picture of man's
- 50:41psychic reality in indelible colors of
- 50:44blood and fire, and given him the
- 50:47object lesson uh which he will never be
- 50:50able to forget. And this is the great
- 50:53question. He has today acquired enough consciousness
- 50:56to keep up with the freest place of
- 50:59the devil within him. So that that was
- 51:02in the 1930s to 40s, he he stated
- 51:04this. I want to say the uh early
- 51:0640s. So this
- 51:10quote it invites a religious and
- 51:13biblical perspective uh to the discussion. So the
- 51:16separation of church and state is integral to
- 51:19our republic, as per the establishment clause of
- 51:22the First Amendment. Quote Congress shall make no
- 51:25law respecting an establishment of
- 51:28religion. Okay, so the main purpose
- 51:31of the clause was to prevent the U.S.
- 51:33government from creating a national church or
- 51:36endorsing a particular religion or coercing its
- 51:39citizens to support a religion to which they
- 51:42do not adhere or agree. So, on the
- 51:45other hand, the phrase
- 51:47in God we trust, look at it, look
- 51:50at your wallet. Uh it's imprinted on
- 51:53all paper, money, and coins, respectively, as
- 51:57per a law signed by President
- 52:00Eisenhower in 1955. Um,
- 52:03subsequently, Congress passed a joint resolution in
- 52:061956 declaring uh in God We
- 52:09Trust the national motto, which was
- 52:12formalized by the 84th Congress on July 30th,
- 52:161956. So the phrase is highly
- 52:19appropriate, although courts have argued that it does
- 52:23not espouse religion. Rather, it reflects the U.S.,
- 52:27the U.S. is the United States' religious heritage,
- 52:29quote, religious heritage. So
- 52:32this argument uh it doesn't, to me,
- 52:36doesn't pass the smell test, as many of
- 52:38our founders were frequently invoking God's
- 52:41protection and praying for his guidance.
- 52:44That is extremely true. So um
- 52:48if you look at this, the final sentence
- 52:51of the Declaration of Independence states, quote, for
- 52:54the support of this declaration with a firm
- 52:56reliance on the protection of the divine providence,
- 52:59we m mutually pledge to each other's uh
- 53:02to each other our lives, our fortunes, and
- 53:06our sacred honor. End of quote.
- 53:11Uh his circular to the states in 1783.
- 53:14He stated, quote, I now make it my
- 53:17earnest uh prayer that God would have you
- 53:21and the states over which you preside in
- 53:23his holy protection, that he would
- 53:26include the hearts of the citizens to cultivate
- 53:29a spirit of subordination and obedience to
- 53:32government, to entertain a brotherly
- 53:35affection and love for one another, uh, for
- 53:38their fellow citizens of the United States at
- 53:40large, and particularly by their brethren,
- 53:44who have served in the field, and finally
- 53:47that he would most graciously be pleased to
- 53:50dispose us all to do justice, to love
- 53:53mercy, and to demean ourselves with that
- 53:56charity, humility, and pacific
- 53:59temper of mind, which were characteristics of the
- 54:02divine author of our blessed religion, and without
- 54:06a humble imitation of whose example in these
- 54:09things we can never hope to be a
- 54:11happy nation. I know that's a long quote,
- 54:14sorry. But um yeah, yeah, it
- 54:17it uh
- 54:19my goodness, uh Benjamin Franklin
- 54:23uh he appealed for a prayer at the
- 54:26Constitutional Convention in 1787. This is what he
- 54:29said, quote, in the beginning of the con
- 54:32contest with Great Britain, uh when we
- 54:35were sensible of danger, we had daily prayer
- 54:38in this room for the divine protection. All
- 54:40of us who were engaged in the struggle
- 54:43must have observed instances of a superintendent
- 54:47providence in our favor. And the longer I
- 54:50live, the more convincing proofs I see of
- 54:53this truth, that God governs in the affairs
- 54:56of man. And if a sparrow cannot fall
- 54:59to the ground without his notice, is it
- 55:02probable that an empire can rise
- 55:05without his aid? So
- 55:08that that's pretty interesting. Um
- 55:11we could go into we can go into
- 55:14some oh numerous beautiful verses in the
- 55:17Bible uh instructing us against the use of
- 55:20hate speech. Proverbs 18 21. Quote
- 55:24Death and life are in the power of
- 55:25the tongue, and they that love it shall
- 55:29eat the fruit thereof.
- 55:31Uh John, John 4 20.
- 55:34Quote Whoever claims to love God but
- 55:38hates their brother or sister is a liar.
- 55:41For whoever does not love their brother or
- 55:43sister whom they have seen cannot love God,
- 55:46whom they have not seen. So in conclusion,
- 55:50I I've made arguments. Uh I have a
- 55:52whole lot more to talk about, but we'll
- 55:54have to do this in our next show.
- 55:56I made our arguments for a reinterpretation of
- 55:58the legitimacy of hate speech uh from the
- 56:00prism of modern day society, with the
- 56:04burdensome realities to just horrible realities uh
- 56:07embedded therein. And and it underscores,
- 56:10underscores by our individual and collective
- 56:13spiritual journey, I think. So uh
- 56:17boundaries of the First Amendment and fracturing of
- 56:20the First Amendment, 100%.
- 56:23So thank you all for listening so much.
- 56:26Uh uh I enthusiastically look forward to being
- 56:29with you weekly on the Countermann spin, where
- 56:32we will endeavor to address and work towards
- 56:35solving the problems of the world. Now please
- 56:37note that this show and all the shows
- 56:39on American Laptop Radio go to your favorite
- 56:42podcast network within 24 hours. Apple
- 56:45Podcasts, Spotify, Pandora tune in, Amazon,
- 56:48iHeartRadio, among others. Have a great
- 56:51day, and uh bless you.