Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [13F] Berkshire Hathaway: Warren Buffett Bought Alphabet!
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep dive. Today we are tackling what is
- 0:03arguably the most defining company of this entire AI era,
- 0:06Alphabet Inc, Gogl. And for you know, for almost a
- 0:10decade, when you think Alphabet, you think growth.
- 0:12An unstoppable machine that just dominates search and ads.
- 0:16A tech behemoth. Exactly.
- 0:18But our mission today, and this is based entirely on the
- 0:21fascinating stack of sources you, our listener shared with
- 0:24us, is to try and frame this colossal multitrillion dollar
- 0:28company as a potential deep value investment.
- 0:31And that is the ultimate paradox, isn't it?
- 0:33I mean, how do you even begin to apply those strict historical
- 0:36rules of deep value, you know, low PE, massive margin of
- 0:40safety, minimal capital spending, capital light, or to a
- 0:43company that is guiding for an astronomical 91 to $93 billion
- 0:47in capital expenditure for 2025 alone?
- 0:51That number is just. It's hard to wrap your head
- 0:53around. It's almost the entire GDP of a
- 0:55medium sized country. It is.
- 0:57And management didn't even try to soften the blow.
- 1:00They came right out and promised a, and I'm quoting here, a
- 1:02significant increase for 2026. So, you know, traditional value
- 1:08investors, someone like David Einhorn, they look at that kind
- 1:11of spending and they immediately warn of a tremendous amount of
- 1:13capital destruction. And that $91 billion figure,
- 1:17that is the central conflict we absolutely have to resolve
- 1:20today. Because if that spending is
- 1:22reckless, if it's a treadmill like Einhorn says, then this
- 1:25isn't value, it's a bubble. But the timing for this deep
- 1:29dive, it couldn't be better because we have this phenomenal,
- 1:32highly visible signal from, well, the ultimate purveyor of
- 1:36quality investing, Berkshire Hathaway.
- 1:39Yes, the new 13 F filing. It just came out for Q32025 and
- 1:43the headline was just crystal clear.
- 1:45They initiated a massive $4.34 billion stake in Alphabets Class
- 1:50A shares. Which immediately makes Gogl
- 1:53their 10th largest holding just like that.
- 1:55And that move just speaks volumes, doesn't it?
- 1:57We're not talking about a hedge fund making a quick trade here.
- 2:00Not at all. This is Berkshire.
- 2:01They're famous for their extreme caution, their focus on proven
- 2:05long term cash flow, and what's even more telling is what they
- 2:08were doing at the same time they were trimming other positions.
- 2:11In mature established holdings. Exactly, including their massive
- 2:15stake in Apple and they were reducing their Bank of America
- 2:18position. So this isn't just new cash
- 2:20going to work, this is a strategic rotation of capital
- 2:23within that quality tech and financial space.
- 2:26So they are actively choosing alphabet over parts of their
- 2:29other core holdings. It signals an extremely high
- 2:32condition that Alphabet, Despite that seemingly expensive price
- 2:36tag and its aggressive CAPEC plan, represents a superior
- 2:39growth adjusted value opportunity.
- 2:41Right now they're looking at the risks and saying they're
- 2:44manageable and the opportunity is asymmetric.
- 2:46OK. So that is our goal today, to
- 2:47unpack all of these sources, the astonishing Q32025 earnings, the
- 2:52quantitative value scorecards and the context of that
- 2:55Berkshire purchase to really assess Alphabet against those
- 2:58strict deep value criteria. Can we resolve the conflict?
- 3:02That's it. Can we resolve the conflict
- 3:04between the need for this massive AI capital spending and
- 3:08the core principles of value investing?
- 3:10Is this genuinely a wonderful company at a fair price, or is
- 3:15it just another expensive growth stock in disguise?
- 3:18We're going to have to dissect the operational health that
- 3:20gives Berkshire that confidence. Then we apply the cold hard math
- 3:25of discounted cash flow analysis and see if the price actually
- 3:28lines up with the the growth story.
- 3:30OK, let's unpack this, starting with the quarter that single
- 3:33handedly justified all the hype and all that confidence, the
- 3:36record-breaking Q32025 results. The first thing that just jumps
- 3:41out from the sources is that Q32025 wasn't just a good
- 3:44quarter for Alphabet, it was an absolute staggering milestone.
- 3:49Financial landmark, it wasn't a recovery or just strong growth.
- 3:52This quarter really cemented their place is probably the
- 3:55single largest engine of cash generation on the planet.
- 3:58So what was the headline number? The revenue figure just tells
- 4:00the story of scale and more importantly, acceleration.
- 4:03Total revenue hit $102.3 billion.
- 4:07Wow, so that's their first ever 100 billion?
- 4:11First ever and just to give you some context, they only hit 80
- 4:14billion and a quarter barely a year before this to achieve a
- 4:1916% year over year growth rate on a base that was already over
- 4:2388 billion is it's just phenomenal.
- 4:27It really shows that the law of large numbers hasn't quite
- 4:30caught up to them yet. Not at all, and it's largely
- 4:32because of this AI growth cycle that's fueling all of this new
- 4:36demand. And what about the
- 4:37profitability? Because revenue is one thing,
- 4:40but for a value thesis you need to see that cash dropping to the
- 4:43bottom line. And the metrics there were
- 4:45equally robust. It suggests that this fantastic
- 4:48operational leverage is really starting to kick in as their
- 4:52different segments mature. Diluted earnings per share, or
- 4:55EPS, it soared to $2.87. Which is a 35% increase year
- 5:01over year. 35% and that EPS acceleration is much, much
- 5:04faster than their top line revenue growth that points
- 5:07directly to margin expansion. And that margin expansion is
- 5:11absolutely crucial for the value thesis we're exploring.
- 5:14It is. The official operating margin
- 5:16was reported at 30.5%, which is already excellent, but that
- 5:19number was actually suppressed. Suppressed.
- 5:22How so? Well, the sources make it really
- 5:24clear that the reported margin included a one time 3 1/2
- 5:29billion dollar charge. It was related to an old
- 5:32European Commission antitrust fine.
- 5:34Ah, so it's nonrecurring, it's just financial noise.
- 5:37Exactly. It has nothing to do with the
- 5:38underlying operational health of the business in that quarter.
- 5:41So if you back out that one time item, what was the real the true
- 5:46operational efficiency of the core business in Q3?
- 5:50If you normalize for that fine, the adjusted operating margin
- 5:53was an extremely impressive 33.9%.
- 5:56Almost 34%. Right.
- 5:58And this isn't just strong, it shows the intrinsic operational
- 6:01leverage of their core searching cloud businesses when they are
- 6:05firing on all cylinders in a strong economy.
- 6:08And the net income reflecting all that soared 33% year over
- 6:12year to nearly $35 billion. That's the cash engine.
- 6:15That's what's funding the $91 billion CapEx.
- 6:18That's it. So let's turn to that core
- 6:20engine itself, Google Services. This is where the money comes
- 6:24from. And it showed immense resilience
- 6:26despite all the macro chatter and, you know, the rising fears
- 6:30about AI competition. Google Services, which covers
- 6:33search, YouTube, Android hardware, all that grew 14% to
- 6:3887.1 billion. This segment is the ballast,
- 6:43it's the foundation, the entire company, and it funds everything
- 6:46from the other bets to that massive AI infrastructure build
- 6:50out. And the most important sub
- 6:51segment in there has to be searched, right?
- 6:53Critically important for any investor.
- 6:55Focused on durability and the performance of search and other
- 6:58ads was fantastic. Grew 15% year over year.
- 7:01That 15% growth in search, that's the data point that I
- 7:04think fundamentally changes the risk profile going forward.
- 7:07Because early on, maybe a year or two ago, the biggest
- 7:10existential threat from Steptex was this idea that generative
- 7:14AI, you know, integrating ChatGPT into Bing or whatever,
- 7:18would just disrupt traditional search.
- 7:20The fear was that query volume and therefore ad clicks would
- 7:23just fall off a Cliff. But the sources and the
- 7:26referencing management commentary here, they suggest
- 7:28the complete opposite is happening.
- 7:30The integration of AI enhancements.
- 7:32Things like the new AI snapshots or AI overviews right within
- 7:35search is actually driving incremental total query growth.
- 7:39So wait, people aren't just getting their answer from the AI
- 7:42and leaving? No, it seems they're using the
- 7:45AI Enhanced Search to launch deeper, more complex
- 7:48investigations. It's a starting point, not an
- 7:51end point. So instead of displacing search,
- 7:53AI is making the product stickier, it's making it more
- 7:56useful, which drives more traffic, and crucially, more of
- 7:59that intent driven ad revenue. Precisely.
- 8:03The fear was replacement. The reality so far is
- 8:06augmentation and monetization. The Moat is clearly getting
- 8:09deeper, not shrinking, especially since Google controls
- 8:12the underlying data and the vast majority of the mobile ecosystem
- 8:15through Android. And then you have the other AD
- 8:18engine YouTube. How did it do?
- 8:19YouTube ads also grew 15% year over year.
- 8:23It hit 10.3 billion for the quarter and you just can't
- 8:26overstate the scale here. That revenue is fueled by an
- 8:29absolutely massive user base. We're talking over 2 1/2 billion
- 8:33monthly login users. It's just its own media empire.
- 8:36It is. YouTube just keeps solidifying
- 8:38its position as a premier video platform.
- 8:41It's drawing in brand advertising budgets that used to
- 8:44go to traditional TV, and it's also getting performance
- 8:47advertising that compliments search.
- 8:50Its sheer reach makes it indispensable to major
- 8:53advertisers. It adds another really durable
- 8:55layer of revenue stability. But if we're looking for the
- 8:59true catalyst, the reason for the huge stock momentum, the
- 9:02massive CapEx and probably the Berkshire purchase, we have to
- 9:06look at Google Cloud. Absolutely.
- 9:08GCP is the high growth engine. Cloud revenue growth was
- 9:11exceptional. It LED all the segments with a
- 9:1334% increase hitting 15.2 billion in Q3.
- 9:17And this acceleration is a direct function of the demand
- 9:20for AI related cloud infrastructure and services.
- 9:24Companies are just flocking to Google to use their custom
- 9:26hardware and their foundation models.
- 9:28And the profitability of cloud, that's the real operational
- 9:31victory here, isn't it? I mean, it only recently turned
- 9:34profitable and now that it's hitting this hyper scale, the
- 9:38leverage must be incredible. The numbers confirm that surge.
- 9:42The operating income for the cloud segment soared an
- 9:45astounding 85% year over year to $3.6 billion. 85%.
- 9:52That rapid growth rate proves this segment is no longer a
- 9:54drain on capital. It's a scale machine that's
- 9:57converting all that massive previous investment into rapidly
- 10:00accelerating high margin profits.
- 10:03This is where that $91 billion CapEx investment is being
- 10:06deployed to capture future returns.
- 10:08OK. Finally, before we move on, we
- 10:10have to acknowledge the sort of quiet strength of the
- 10:13subscription mode. We often think of Alphabet as
- 10:15purely ad driven, but that's really changing and it adds
- 10:18another layer of predictability to their cash flow.
- 10:21The sources really highlight the strategic importance of this
- 10:23shift, the total number of paid subscriptions and this includes
- 10:27things like Google One for cloud storage, YouTube Premium, which
- 10:31gets rid of ads and includes music and the fast growing
- 10:34YouTube TV. It now exceeds 300 million. 300
- 10:39million paid subscribers. That's gigantic.
- 10:41That's on the field of many dedicated streaming and telecom
- 10:44giant. It is.
- 10:45It represents this massive recurring revenue stream that is
- 10:48sticky, it's high margin, and it provides essential
- 10:51diversification and stability against the cyclical nature of
- 10:55the ad market. This subscription base is a real
- 10:59intangible asset that significantly improved their
- 11:01cash flow predictability and strengthens the whole valuation
- 11:04thesis. It's clear the company is
- 11:06evolving far beyond just its ad funded roots.
- 11:10Now let's dig into what structurally underpins that
- 11:12entire evolution, the fortress like business model and the
- 11:15durability of its Moat. When you're trying to define
- 11:18Alphabet, the crucial insight is to see it not just as a search
- 11:21company, but as a technology conglomerate.
- 11:23And it's built around this self reinforcing financial flywheel.
- 11:26And the core mechanism is pretty simple.
- 11:28It's simple but incredibly powerful.
- 11:30You leverage an unparalleled user base and all of their
- 11:33proprietary data to monetize through advertising.
- 11:36Then you relentlessly reinvest those massive profits into new
- 11:41strategic services, cloud, AI infrastructure, and those long
- 11:45term other bets. And the scale required to run
- 11:48that flywheel is just, it's incomprehensible for most
- 11:51businesses. We're talking about a company
- 11:52that has, what, 7 products now with over a billion monthly
- 11:57users? Each at least search Chrome,
- 12:00Gmail, Maps, Android, YouTube, Let's goes on.
- 12:05The analogy I've heard is that owning these platforms is like
- 12:07owning all the digital highways, all the airports, and all the
- 12:10best retail locations at the same time.
- 12:12But a good one. Android has over 3 billion
- 12:14active devices. YouTube has over 2 1/2 billion
- 12:16users. That scale creates the ultimate
- 12:19network effect that a competitor just can't easily bypass.
- 12:21It feeds itself. It really does.
- 12:24Users bring data. That data improves the services
- 12:27like the new AI overviews, which then attracts more users, which
- 12:32in turn attracts the millions of advertisers who want access to
- 12:35that massive, highly segmented audience.
- 12:38Let's breakdown the income streams though, because they
- 12:40really define the risk profile. Even with clouds rapid rise, the
- 12:44engine is still advertising right?
- 12:46Oh absolutely. In 2024, something like 75% of
- 12:50Alphabets revenue still came from advertising in its various
- 12:53forms. The other 25% is split pretty
- 12:56evenly between Google Cloud and their other high margin services
- 12:59like hardware and those subscriptions we just talked
- 13:02about. And the undisputed cash cow is
- 13:04still search and other advertising.
- 13:06The sources show this is roughly 57% of total revenue.
- 13:09It generates about $200 billion a year.
- 13:12The Moat here is just wider than the Grand Canyon.
- 13:14And it's largely due to Google's, what, 90% global
- 13:17market share and search? Something like that.
- 13:19It's in your monopoly. And the durability of that Moat
- 13:22comes from user intent. People use Google search when
- 13:26they are actively looking for something, a product to buy, a
- 13:29solution to a problem information.
- 13:32This intent driven ad spend is the most valuable real estate
- 13:35online. It creates A protective barrier
- 13:38that is extraordinarily difficult for competitors to
- 13:40breach, no matter what the regulatory headwinds are.
- 13:43Then you've got YouTube advertising that makes up about
- 13:4610% of total revenue, generating 10s of billions annually.
- 13:50This isn't just some side business.
- 13:52YouTube is a full blown media giant in the high growth video
- 13:55space. And its continuous double digit
- 13:57growth really proves its success in monetizing that immense user
- 14:01engagement. And Google Cloud is the dynamic
- 14:03future pillar. While search and YouTube
- 14:05maintain the cash flow, Cloud is what's accelerating the whole
- 14:08valuation thesis. It's growing so fast now, up to
- 14:1211 or 12% of revenue. And crucially, as we said, it
- 14:15only recently turned sustainably profitable.
- 14:17It hit an operating margin of 17 1/2% in late 2024.
- 14:21That profitability transition is what unlocks the operational
- 14:24leverage we saw in Q3. It's a game changer for the
- 14:28financial model. Of course, we can't forget the
- 14:30long shot projects, the other bets, you know, Raimo Verily,
- 14:35DeepMind. They are strategically vital for
- 14:37the long term, but they're financially negligible right
- 14:40now. They represent less than 1% of
- 14:43revenue and they consistently operate at a large loss.
- 14:46We're talking about a $1.17 billion operating loss in Q42024
- 14:52alone. A.
- 14:52Traditional value investor would just balk at constant losses of
- 14:56that magnitude. They would, but the key is that
- 14:59these losses are entirely funded by the massive profits from the
- 15:03core Google services. You can tolerate the loss
- 15:06because of the core engine is so strong and because those other
- 15:09bets represent optionality for future disruptive growth.
- 15:12It's a calculated risk. So let's crystallize the
- 15:14durability of this whole thing. What are the four core pillars
- 15:17that make alphabets competitive advantage so so impenetrable?
- 15:21OK, so 1st and most obviously you have the powerful network
- 15:24effects, that self reinforcing loop of search data improving
- 15:28services and the YouTube content creators attractive viewers and
- 15:31vice versa. Google's brand strength is so
- 15:34powerful that to Google is literally a verb.
- 15:38A competitor doesn't just need a better search engine, they need
- 15:41a better verb. That's a great way to put it.
- 15:42OK. So #2 would be the intangible
- 15:44assets, data and technology. And this is the key battleground
- 15:48in the AI race. Alphabet owns an unparalleled
- 15:52proprietary data trove built U over decades.
- 15:54Every search query, every piece of location data from maps.
- 15:58You couple that with their cutting edge AI models like
- 16:00Gemini and their custom hardware, the Tensor Rocessing
- 16:02units or Tus, and you have a massive proprietary
- 16:06technological barrier. #3 high switching costs, the stickiness
- 16:10factor. Exactly.
- 16:12For a consumer trying to move away from the comprehensive
- 16:14Google ecosystem, your Gmail, your maps, your Android phone,
- 16:17it's a massive high friction hassle.
- 16:19They're locked in. You are.
- 16:21And for the enterprise, the lock in via Google Cloud Platform is
- 16:24even stronger. Once a company builds its Core
- 16:27Data infrastructure and runs its proprietary AI models on GCP,
- 16:32the risk and the cost of migrating to a competitor like
- 16:35AWS or Azure are often prohibitive.
- 16:37And finally, the fourth pillar scale advantages, This ties
- 16:41directly back to our big CapEx debate.
- 16:44It does. We're talking about massive
- 16:45global infrastructure, dozens of data centers, deep fiber
- 16:49networks, the sheer amount of index data globally.
- 16:52This scale provides a cost advantage that a new entrant
- 16:55simply cannot replicate without committing to a similar multi
- 16:58decade, $91 billion a year spending plan.
- 17:01So the Moat is wide and durable, but that durability is now
- 17:04inextricably linked to that massive CapEx.
- 17:07Which brings us to the moment of truth.
- 17:09That $91 billion figure. It isn't just a rounding error.
- 17:12It is the price of maintaining that scale and defending that
- 17:15Moat. And it is the primary point of
- 17:17attack for the entire bear case. All right, this section gets to
- 17:19the absolute core conflict of our deep dive.
- 17:23The traditional value thesis states that a good company
- 17:26should be capital light. It should generate high free
- 17:29cash flow without needing constant massive reinvestment.
- 17:32Alphabet violates this premise spectacularly.
- 17:35It does. The primary Baer argument
- 17:37centers squarely on the scale of that investment.
- 17:39Alphabet raise its full year 2025 CapEx forecast to a
- 17:44staggering 91 to $93 billion. And again, they explicitly
- 17:49guided for a significant increase in 2020 26 This is pure
- 17:53infrastructure spending, data centers, fiber, AI, hardware
- 17:56like Tpus and the energy capacity to run it all.
- 17:59And this is where we have to take the bear case seriously.
- 18:01Investors who focus purely on low multiples, they get
- 18:04incredibly nervous. We mentioned David Einhorn.
- 18:06He argues that this AI race spending represents A tremendous
- 18:10amount of capital destruction. He compares it to a value
- 18:12destroying treadmill. Exactly.
- 18:14Massive fixed investments are required just to stay
- 18:17competitive, not necessarily to gain an advantage, and that ends
- 18:21up compressing future returns on capital.
- 18:23From that traditional lens, $91 billion is $91 billion that
- 18:28can't be returned to shareholders.
- 18:30And that is the risk if the spending is speculative.
- 18:33But, and this is a key to the entire bull thesis and almost
- 18:36certainly the primary justification for Berkshire's
- 18:39big bet, the 91 billion is not speculative spending.
- 18:43OK, so how do we know that? We have the critical data point
- 18:46that refutes the treadmill argument.
- 18:48It's a metric called Google Clouds Remaining Performance
- 18:51Obligation, or RPO. Let's slow down and explain
- 18:53exactly what RPO is, because this sounds like the core of the
- 18:56resolution. The RPO is essentially the
- 18:59contractual backlog. It represents revenue that
- 19:02they're already obligated to deliver to customers over the
- 19:05coming years. These are contracts that are
- 19:06already signed, sealed and locked in.
- 19:08And what was that number in Q3? In Q32025, that RPO surged to an
- 19:14incredible 155 billion dollars. Wait. 155 billion with AB.
- 19:20With AB. So just to be clear, the company
- 19:23is building infrastructure to service contracts that have
- 19:26already been signed, verified and locked into multi year
- 19:30commitments. That is a fundamentally
- 19:33different story than speculating on future demand.
- 19:35Precisely this backlog, this RPO, it increased 82% year over
- 19:41year and an astonishing 46% just from the previous quarter. 46%
- 19:45quarter over quarter. That's insane growth.
- 19:48It signals that the demand for their cloud and AI services is
- 19:51exploding faster than they can physically build the capacity to
- 19:55serve it. The $91 billion in CapEx is
- 19:58growth CapEx required to meet the massive high market.
- 20:01Revenue that is already contracted.
- 20:04Management even said they're building reactively in what they
- 20:06called a tight demand supply environment.
- 20:09This completely de risks the spending narrative.
- 20:12But I need to challenge that just a little bit.
- 20:13Even if it's de risked by contracted revenue, that $91
- 20:16billion, it permanently changes the company's financial risk
- 20:20profile. We need to talk about the
- 20:22permanent cost structure shift. That's the nuanced risk the
- 20:25investor has to accept. You're absolutely right that 91
- 20:29billion isn't an immediate operating expense by accounting
- 20:32rules. It's capitalized.
- 20:33It sits on the balance sheet as an asset.
- 20:35Data centers, servers, Tpus and is then gradually expensed over
- 20:40many years as depreciation. And this depreciation is a
- 20:44massive sticky fixed cost. It doesn't go away if revenue
- 20:48dips. Exactly.
- 20:49Management explicitly stated that the growth rate in
- 20:52depreciation is expected to accelerate.
- 20:55Why? Because you're capitalizing 91
- 20:57billion this year and you capitalize maybe 70 billion last
- 21:00year and 50 billion the year before that.
- 21:02And this stuff has a limited lifespan.
- 21:04Right. Servers and network gear are
- 21:06typically depreciated over five to seven years.
- 21:09So as these massive investments hit the balance sheet, the
- 21:11depreciation expense flowing through the income statement
- 21:14becomes a permanently higher and stickier fixed cost base.
- 21:18So this fundamentally increases the operational leverage of the
- 21:21entire company, for better or for worse.
- 21:24Correct. When revenue is booming like it
- 21:27was in Q32025, your revenue grows faster than that sticky
- 21:32higher fixed cost base. This is why cloud operating
- 21:35income exploded by 85%. You're just filling up the
- 21:38factory capacity you just built. Every dollar of marginal revenue
- 21:42drops almost straight to the bottom line because the building
- 21:44costs are already fixed. But the flip side, the true
- 21:47vulnerability is what happens during a severe downturn.
- 21:50In a deep economic recession, if revenue growth slows or even
- 21:54contracts that permanently higher fixed cost base, that
- 21:57massive depreciation number is going to cause operating margins
- 22:01to contract much more sharply than they did historically.
- 22:04It is the textbook definition of a high risk, higher reward
- 22:07operational model. The value investors trading
- 22:10certainty for velocity. Beyond the cost structure, we
- 22:12have to review the long term headwinds that still exist.
- 22:15These temper any bullish sentiment and the number one
- 22:18structural risk is still legal and regulatory action.
- 22:21The sources are absolutely unanimous on this.
- 22:23Regulatory and legal risks are paramount.
- 22:26The global scrutiny is relentless.
- 22:28The massive USDOJ antitrust trial is ongoing, and it's
- 22:33focusing heavily on Google's practice of paying these
- 22:36enormous sums, estimated at over 15 billion a year, just to
- 22:40Apple. Just to be the default search
- 22:42engine. Right.
- 22:42On mobile browsers and operating systems, if that payment
- 22:46structure is deemed illegal or forced to change, that $15
- 22:50billion would immediately be at risk.
- 22:52And the pressure from Europe is even more immediate and it
- 22:54impacts their core data advantage.
- 22:56We saw the direct impact in the Q3 results with that 3 1/2
- 23:00billion dollar fine. And on top of that, the European
- 23:03Union's Digital Markets Act, the DMA, It threatens to
- 23:06fundamentally undermine Google's critical data advantage by
- 23:09forcing changes in how they operate their platforms.
- 23:12You can really reduce their ability to target ads with
- 23:14precision. Which is a structural threat to
- 23:16their core monetization engine. It absolutely is.
- 23:19Then there's the underlying technological disruption risk.
- 23:22We acknowledge that Q3 showed AI augmenting search, not
- 23:26displacing it, but that existential threat hasn't just
- 23:29vanished. No, it has not.
- 23:31If generative AI fully matures to a point where users turn
- 23:34entirely to bespoke chat bots for complex planning and
- 23:38information, and they bypass traditional ad carrying search
- 23:41results altogether, then the core business model is still
- 23:44vulnerable. So the CapEx is an insurance
- 23:46policy? Google's heavy, expensive
- 23:49investment in TP use in the Gemini model is essentially an
- 23:52existential insurance policy against that very threat.
- 23:56They're spending $91 billion to ensure they're the ones building
- 23:59the disruptor, not the ones being disrupted.
- 24:01And finally, the unavoidable reality cyclical ad spending.
- 24:05Alphabet is not recession proof. We saw this vulnerability very
- 24:09clearly in late 2022 and early 2023, when fears of a slowdown
- 24:13LED advertisers to pull back on marketing budgets.
- 24:16While Google has proven to be resilient, the ad market is
- 24:19inherently cyclical and that exposure remains a short term
- 24:22risk you have to account for. Which brings us to the ultimate
- 24:25question of management quality. You can have a great business
- 24:28and still destroy value with poor leadership.
- 24:30So let's move to Section 4 and discuss the people who are
- 24:33actually steering this $91 billion ship.
- 24:35When you are betting on a high growth, high CapEx company like
- 24:39this, you are primarily betting on the capital allocators.
- 24:43You have to look at the stability, the discipline and,
- 24:46crucially, the alignment of the leadership team.
- 24:49And the core management team certainly provides stability.
- 24:51Sundar Pichai has been CEO since 2019 and he's successfully
- 24:56steered the company through this enormous pivot from mobile to
- 24:59AI. The sources seem to indicate he
- 25:01provides that necessary long term focus which is essential
- 25:05when you're planning these decade long multi billion dollar
- 25:08AI investments. And the financial discipline
- 25:10component that's tied directly to the legacy of Ruth Porat.
- 25:13She was the influential CFO from 2015 until late 2023.
- 25:18She was brought in specifically to curb the sprawl and the
- 25:20losses in the other bets and instilled a much needed
- 25:23financial rigor that really culminated in the initiation of
- 25:27these robust capital returns we see today.
- 25:29And her move to chief investment Officer with Annette Ashkenazi
- 25:33stepping in as the new CFO in 2024, that signals a pretty
- 25:37smooth transition. They're maintaining continuity
- 25:40while keeping a firm eye on operational efficiency, which is
- 25:43critical given this acceleration and fixed costs we've been
- 25:46talking about. Now we have to address the most
- 25:49contentious point for value investors, the very thing that
- 25:52makes Alphabet fail so many governance screens.
- 25:56The dual class dilemma. This is a major trade off in the
- 25:58investment thesis, isn't it, because the governance structure
- 26:01limits external shareholder influence almost entirely?
- 26:04That's because the founders, Larry Page and Sergey Brin, they
- 26:08control about 51% of the total voting power.
- 26:11They do this through their Class B shares, which carry 10 votes
- 26:14per share. Even though they only own about
- 26:1612% of the economic equity. Correct.
- 26:18They own a minority of the economics, but they retain
- 26:21majority control over the company's direction.
- 26:24Which means public shareholders, including massive institutions
- 26:27like Berkshire Hathaway, Vanguard, BlackRock, they have
- 26:31virtually no effective vote on management decisions, on
- 26:34strategy, on who gets appointed to the board.
- 26:37The sources confirm this stark reality.
- 26:40We saw a play out during the 2025 proxy votes.
- 26:43There were proposals aimed at improving governance,
- 26:46specifically for equal shareholder voting, the classic
- 26:51one share, one vote measure. And they were defeated by the
- 26:54Founders block. Crushed the proposal, got a
- 26:57significant 3.8 billion votes for, but was defeated by 8.6
- 27:01billion votes against. It just demonstrates the
- 27:03futility of minority influence here.
- 27:05But doesn't Berkshire's high conviction bet ignore the
- 27:08fundamental risk that Paige and Brin, with their absolute
- 27:11control, could make a massive value destroying acquisition?
- 27:15Or they could double down recklessly on an other bet and
- 27:19public shareholders would have 0 power to stop them.
- 27:21That's a huge governance risk. And that is the essential
- 27:24skepticism you must maintain. The counter argument though, and
- 27:27this is the view that Berkshire clearly subscribes to, is that
- 27:30this investment is an explicit bet on the jockeys.
- 27:33For them, the dual class structure isn't viewed as a bug,
- 27:36it's a feature. A feature how?
- 27:38It insulates the company from short term activist
- 27:40interference. So they can't be pushed around
- 27:42by a hedge fund demanding they cut R&D to boost next quarter's
- 27:46earnings. Exactly.
- 27:48They believe that Paige and Bryn's massive economic stake
- 27:51aligns their interests with long term value creation and that
- 27:55this control allows Pichai and the team to execute that multi
- 27:59year $91 billion high CapEx AI strategy without having to
- 28:04constantly worry about quarterly earnings pressure or shareholder
- 28:07revolts over some temporary margin compression.
- 28:10So it's a high condition trust signal in management.
- 28:13It is they are trusting that management's capital allocation
- 28:16skill and their long term vision outweigh the governance risk of
- 28:19concentrated power and the history of alphabets.
- 28:21Capital allocation, especially post porat largely supports this
- 28:25view. Which brings us to shareholder
- 28:27returns. Let's discuss how management has
- 28:30chosen to return that enormous cash flow.
- 28:32Alphabet has shifted dramatically from, you know,
- 28:35hoarding cash to becoming a buyback Titan.
- 28:37This shift is one of the most compelling parts of the
- 28:39investment thesis for quality investors.
- 28:42Before 2015, buybacks were negligible.
- 28:45Today, Alphabet is one of the world's largest repurchasers of
- 28:48its own stock, rivaling companies like Apple and Meta.
- 28:51And the scale is just immense. The board authorized $70 billion
- 28:57in buybacks in 2022-2023 and again in 2024.
- 29:02That is an enormous annual commitment.
- 29:05It shows a clear willingness to use that excess cash flow to
- 29:08aggressively shrink the denominator of the EPS equation.
- 29:11They execute ruthlessly. These buybacks have reduced the
- 29:15overall share count by about 8% over just three years, from 2021
- 29:19to 2024. That reduction is materially
- 29:21boosting their earnings per share growth.
- 29:23And what's wild is that in recent years, they've spent
- 29:25nearly all of their free cash flow on repurchases.
- 29:27Almost 100%. In 2022, for example, they
- 29:30generated 60 billion in free cash flow, and they repurchased
- 29:33$59.3 billion of stock. That signals a clear commitment
- 29:36to shareholder returns, even while they're funding all those
- 29:39other bets. And there was a subtle, but I
- 29:41think philosophically very important shift.
- 29:43In late 2024. They initiated a small but
- 29:47significant 21 cent quarterly dividend.
- 29:50That dividend, which is an annual outlay of about 5 1/2
- 29:53billion dollars, is a crucial signal of maturation.
- 29:57It signals to the market that even with the 91 billion dollar
- 29:59CapEx and the massive buybacks, the company expects to generate
- 30:03more cash than it can efficiently reinvest internally.
- 30:06So it satisfies the need for direct, predictable cash
- 30:09returns. It does, even if buybacks remain
- 30:12the primary mechanism. And it also makes the stock
- 30:14attractive to a broader set of institutional mandates that
- 30:17might require a dividend component.
- 30:19So the management story is one of stable, high quality long
- 30:23term capital allocation funded by astronomical cash generation.
- 30:26And now it's backed by the ultimate vote of confidence from
- 30:29Berkshire Hathaway. But we have to settle the score.
- 30:32Does any of this operational brilliance make it a true value
- 30:34stock? We promised to judge Alphabet
- 30:37against the strict deep value standards from the sources.
- 30:41We're going to use a quantitative analysis, and the
- 30:43results are a study in dichotomy.
- 30:45It's a sharp contrast between valuation and quality.
- 30:48OK, let's start with the things a classic value investor.
- 30:51Someone following Ben Graham or focusing purely on statistical
- 30:54bargains would immediately reject the valuation metrics
- 30:58were Alphabet just fails spectacularly.
- 31:00It fails all the traditional valuation screens.
- 31:03If you look at the price to earnings, the PE ratio, it's
- 31:06currently sitting around 27 to 30.
- 31:09Traditional deep value requires APE of 15 or less.
- 31:12That's a massive fail. Not even close.
- 31:14Not even in the same ballpark. The price to book or PB ratio is
- 31:19around 8.7. It fails the required less than
- 31:221.5 test by a huge margin. And the owner's earnings yield.
- 31:26This is a big one for cash flow investors.
- 31:28It calculates the annual cash flow generated relative to the
- 31:31market cap. It's only 4% demands a 10% yield
- 31:34for that immediate cash return O.
- 31:36The conclusion here is. Unarguable Alphabet is
- 31:38emphatically not a cheap stock, not by any statistical measure.
- 31:43If you are strictly looking for a bargain based on current
- 31:45multiples, you will reject it out of hand and you would be
- 31:48following the rules of statistical value investing
- 31:51perfectly. But then you look at the quality
- 31:53and. Safety metrics and here the
- 31:55picture just reverses completely.
- 31:56Alphabet passes every single quality and safety test with
- 32:01exceptional world class scores. The free cash flow margin is.
- 32:0419.1% It crushes the typical minimum hurdle of 5%.
- 32:10It shows phenomenal cash conversion and return on equity
- 32:13Roe. A measure of shareholder.
- 32:14Value creation is 35.5% on a trailing 12 month basis.
- 32:19That far exceeds the 15% standard and Return on Invested
- 32:24Capital or ROIC, which tells you how efficiently management is
- 32:27using all the capitals at its disposal is 20.3% comfortably
- 32:32over the required 12%. This confirms it is a business
- 32:35with a huge Moat and world class management and the balance sheet
- 32:38removes. All structural liquidity risk
- 32:40absolutely the debt to equity. Ratio is a negligible 0.11 well
- 32:46under the half point safety limit.
- 32:47They have massive cash reserves. The balance sheet is truly a
- 32:51fortress. So the inescapable.
- 32:53Conclusion from the quality metrics is that Alphabet is
- 32:56unquestionably a wonderful company.
- 32:59The entire debate then it boils down purely to whether the price
- 33:02currently being asked for this wonderful company is reasonable.
- 33:05Exactly. Now let's focus on the two
- 33:06metrics that really define this new value thesis, the conflict
- 33:10and its resolution. First, the PEG ratio.
- 33:13The PEG ratio is the growth. Adjusted PE ratio It compares
- 33:16the multiple to the expected earnings growth rate.
- 33:19The standard for a Growth at a reasonable price or GARP stock
- 33:22requires a PEG ratio under 1. If the PEG is 1, you're paying
- 33:26exactly 1 unit of price for one unit of growth and Alphabets PEG
- 33:30ratio comes. In at 0.79 so it passes the GARP
- 33:33test and this is the critical finding.
- 33:35That explains the Berkshire investment.
- 33:37It confirms that the high price that 30 times PE is justified by
- 33:41an even higher expected growth rate.
- 33:44That 35% EPS growth we saw in Q3 fueled by the cloud backlog.
- 33:49Investors are looking at 2026 and 2027 and seeing an
- 33:53acceleration of earnings that makes the current multiple look
- 33:56deceptively high. But the second defining metric.
- 33:59This goes right back to the CapEx debate and provides
- 34:02validation for their case. Depreciation relative to gross
- 34:06profit. This metric measures how much
- 34:08of. The company's gross profit is
- 34:09immediately consumed by the required maintenance and
- 34:12replaced it of its enormous physical infrastructure.
- 34:15The standard value criteria demand this expense be under
- 34:1810%. Alphabets trailing 12 months
- 34:20reading is 19.8%. It fails this metric
- 34:24significantly. So this is the quantitative.
- 34:26Proof of that cost structure shift we discussed, the massive
- 34:29AI CapEx surge is permanently spiking fixed costs relative to
- 34:32profit. A disproportionate amount of the
- 34:34money the company makes is required just to maintain its
- 34:37technological standing and service its contracted RPO.
- 34:40Precisely this. Provides concrete evidence that
- 34:43lends credence to the Einhorn bear case on operational risk.
- 34:47It confirms the business model is becoming more capital
- 34:49intensive, requiring higher gross profit to cover those
- 34:53accelerating depreciation charges.
- 34:55This metric embodies the higher risk, higher reward profile
- 34:58perfectly, so the scoreboard results in this.
- 35:01Clash of the Titans within the value community, you have the
- 35:04quality in Darpaid, Camp Berkshire, Klarman, Ackman,
- 35:08prioritizing the Moat, the growth rate and that D risk
- 35:11CapEx and then you have the traditional cost.
- 35:13Structure purists of the statistical bargain hunters led
- 35:16by David Einhorn, who look at that 19.8% depreciation ratio
- 35:21and the 30 times PE and immediately see competitive
- 35:24value destruction and an unacceptable price to bring this
- 35:26entirely back to reality. Let's run the discounted cash
- 35:29flow reality check using the owner's earnings methodology.
- 35:32This is the ultimate tool for judging intrinsic value against
- 35:35price. We'll use the 8.75% WACC from
- 35:38the sources. We begin with the most
- 35:40conservative baseline, the no growth scenario.
- 35:45We'll assume Alphabet just stops growing its free cash flow today
- 35:48and maintains the current level indefinitely.
- 35:51The intrinsic value generated by.
- 35:52This model is approximately $126 per share.
- 35:56The take away there is clear the.
- 35:58Current market price of around $278 is massively overvalued if
- 36:02you assume growth is dead. The market is pricing in a
- 36:06significant growth narrative, not a static cash cow.
- 36:10This confirms DOGL is not a statistical bargain.
- 36:13OK, next, the Conservative. Growth scenario.
- 36:16Let's assume Alphabet only manages free cash flow growth at
- 36:194.7% annually, which was its slowest year on record recently,
- 36:24and then it tapers quickly to 3% terminal growth.
- 36:27This is a highly pessimistic recessionary view.
- 36:29This model yields an intrinsic. Value of about $245 per share.
- 36:34So at today's price of 270. 8 It's still slightly overvalued
- 36:37even in this pessimistic scenario, but the downside is
- 36:41somewhat contained. It proves the value of the mote
- 36:43and the current cash generation, even in slow growth conditions.
- 36:47It's finally the nominal. OR bull growth scenario.
- 36:51This is the one supported by the Q3 results, the 35% EPS growth
- 36:55and that $155 billion backlog. Here we assume FCF growth
- 37:01maintains its robust historical 10 year average of 19.6% for
- 37:05five years, then tapers to 3%. We are assuming they
- 37:09successfully execute on the RPO. This scenario is arguably.
- 37:13The most realistic, it aligns with the company's current
- 37:16operational performance and the required justification for that
- 37:19$91 billion CapEx and it generates an intrinsic value of
- 37:23approximately $451 per share, 451 dollars.
- 37:27That is a highly significant upside, over 60% from the
- 37:31current price. This DCF valuation is.
- 37:34The key to reconciling the price If Alphabet can execute on that
- 37:37$155 billion backlog and maintain anything close to its
- 37:41recent growth trajectory, the stock is significantly
- 37:44undervalued. And for the value investor, the
- 37:46margin of safety calculation is key.
- 37:48To get a 30% margin of safety on that $451 intrinsic value, you
- 37:53would need to buy the stock below 315 dollars.
- 37:56And since the stock is currently.
- 37:58Trading around 278 and Berkshire's likely enterprise
- 38:01was around 243. The DCF confirms that the stock
- 38:04is trading within the margin of safety of its most realistic
- 38:08growth fueled trajectory. It's not cheap, but it's a
- 38:11wonderful business priced fairly or potentially undervalued for
- 38:15its quality and growth profile. So let's wrap up our deep dive.
- 38:19What are the definitive takeaways for the listener
- 38:22trying to assess Alphabet as an investment today?
- 38:25The primary conclusion is that. Alphabet is a wonderful company
- 38:28at a fair price. Its financial quality, its cash
- 38:31generation, its Moat and his fortress balance sheet are all
- 38:34exceptional. It feels the screams of a
- 38:36traditional cheap value stock but its PEG ratio 0.79 confirms
- 38:41it as a high quality growth at a reasonable price or jar P
- 38:44compounder and the central fear. That astronomical $21 billion
- 38:49annual AI CapEx is analytically de risked by the contracted $155
- 38:55billion Google Cloud RPO backlog.
- 38:59The spending isn't speculative, it's a necessary build out for
- 39:02pre sold high margin long term enterprise revenue.
- 39:06This investment today is a high. Conviction bet on 2 accelerating
- 39:09modes, subscriptions which now exceed 300 million paid users
- 39:13and enterprise AI. And it's important to keep the
- 39:16historical. Context in mind right?
- 39:18The true deep value opportunities where alphabet was
- 39:21statistically cheap trading at low multiples.
- 39:24Those were brief periods during severe crises exactly.
- 39:27Think about late. 2022, when the stock bottomed out around $83
- 39:31per share. That was largely due to panic
- 39:33over interest rates and the initial fears of AI disruption
- 39:35from ChatGPT. Those were the times when the
- 39:38stock traded with a massive traditional margin of safety.
- 39:41The current price is fair. It's based on the assumption of
- 39:44strong future execution and successful monetization of that
- 39:47RPO. It is no longer a cheap stock,
- 39:50but the DCF analysis confirms it's certainly not prohibitively
- 39:53expensive for a compounder of the scale and quality.
- 39:55Which brings us to our final provocative.
- 39:57Thought the AI race has permanently transformed
- 40:00Alphabets financial DNA, it has exploded its fixed cost base
- 40:05through these massive accelerating depreciation
- 40:07expenses. We've seen the incredible
- 40:09operational upside of this in a boom market.
- 40:12The cloud profits soaring 85% in Q3.
- 40:15But we have to ponder the structural risk this creates.
- 40:18What does this permanently higher, stickier fixed cost
- 40:21structure mean for Alphabets, operating margins and downside
- 40:24protection during the next deep cyclical economic recession?
- 40:27That is the structural risk that defines the new, more leveraged
- 40:31alphabet model moving forward.