Latest / Retire and Thrive / Retirement Tax Traps Explained: RMDs, Roth Conversions, and the Widow’s Penalty
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to another edition of Retire and Thrive, where we
- 0:03help you build your life with purpose, wealth, and confidence.
- 0:07Welcome back, Cody. Thank you, glad to be back.
- 0:09Yeah, I know we had talked a little earlier about the the
- 0:14episode around the sports and the tax and everything else.
- 0:17I thought today we would talk maybe a little bit more about
- 0:21your experiences and, and I would say, you know, to the
- 0:24viewers that Cody is our most senior advisor, not a senior's
- 0:30me of course, but Cody spends the majority of time helping
- 0:34people plan for retirement. Very familiar with the software,
- 0:37the analysis, everything from the tax.
- 0:39Like you said, you've got quite a passion for the tax, but I
- 0:42thought it might be kind of fun today to maybe share some
- 0:44stories specifically. And before I dive into that,
- 0:50anything in particular you want to chat about?
- 0:52I'm going to just kind of kind of rapid fire here and maybe
- 0:55give us some some examples that maybe some of the viewers could
- 0:57relate to, you know? I think it's it's unique because
- 1:01again, you mentioned that I like to focus on the taxes.
- 1:05At the end of the day, when we talk with clients, a lot of
- 1:09clients will come in here or prospects or whatever the case
- 1:11may be, we'll come in and be like, hey, I need a financial
- 1:13advisor, can you help me with investments?
- 1:15We can certainly do that. But in my opinion, I think 80%
- 1:19of retirement planning or just financial planning in general is
- 1:23really surrounding the tax conversation.
- 1:26It's how much money can I keep? I've saved a bunch of money, but
- 1:29now how do I make sure I retain the most and I get to enjoy it
- 1:31and spend it the way I can? And so a lot of our
- 1:35conversations and stories, you'll probably hear me talk
- 1:37about, you're gonna hear the word tax a lot because again,
- 1:41nobody likes it. But I enjoy finding ways to
- 1:44ultimately avoid it or minimize it if possible.
- 1:47Within the lines of the IRS guidelines, of course.
- 1:50You know, it's a a very valid comment And, and you're right, a
- 1:54lot of it does tie into taxes. You know, my mindset has always
- 1:57been, you know, we want to do everything we can to make sure
- 2:00these retirees don't run out of money.
- 2:02I mean, that's our number one goal.
- 2:04But taxes play into that so heavily.
- 2:06And you know, we do spend in a majority of our time with people
- 2:11that are approaching retirement or people that are actually
- 2:13retired. And it was kind of interesting.
- 2:15Just yesterday I talked to someone who had reached out to
- 2:17us looking for kind of putting together a retirement plan.
- 2:20And both he and his wife were senior executives at A at a very
- 2:24successful company making very large incomes.
- 2:28And he's 46 and she's 44. And so I mentioned to him, I
- 2:33said, you know, you're still in that accumulation phase.
- 2:36And he says, we don't even know. We're just maxing out our four O
- 2:381 KS and we're put away. And I said, Oh, by the way, are
- 2:40you how much of that are you putting in Roth versus pre tax?
- 2:44And he said, what do you mean? And I said, well, you know, are
- 2:47you putting some into the Roth component?
- 2:49And he, he was like, I don't even know if we can do that.
- 2:53And I said, of course you can do that because you work for a big
- 2:54company. And so it's interesting for me
- 2:57and I just touched on it. I'm not going to go into detail
- 2:59with the conversation, but I just touched on it with him that
- 3:02you might have three 4,000,000 bucks when you're 60 years old.
- 3:06But again, taxes are massive implications on that.
- 3:10So again, I don't want to go down that path, but it does
- 3:13matter. And I told him, I said, you
- 3:15know, you're young enough where we can make adjustments to your
- 3:19contributions to your 4-O1K, your wife's four O 3B and it
- 3:25will make a difference. So you do have some choices in
- 3:27retirement. But today I, I don't want to get
- 3:29too heavy into that accumulators stage.
- 3:32I want to focus kind of more on the retirement side.
- 3:35And so again, I feel like when I look at you and I think a
- 3:38fortress financial, you meet with more new people and yeah,
- 3:42we've got associates that build out the financial plans, but you
- 3:45obviously read review them and go through and everything.
- 3:49And I know you've got tons and tons and tons of stories about
- 3:52success where people have come to us.
- 3:54But is there anything in particular, if you can think of
- 3:57a client, Obviously we're not going to use names here, but
- 4:00people that come to us that maybe had no idea what they were
- 4:02doing and they didn't even know where to begin.
- 4:06Any any stories or any experiences you can share with
- 4:10with the viewers? Well, it's the, the, the list is
- 4:15endless, right? And, and, and it's not a knock
- 4:17on any of the, the clients or any of the people who come to
- 4:19us. It's, it's a complex world out
- 4:22there from financial standpoint. You talk about taxes, that's
- 4:25super complex, but then you throw the different taxability
- 4:27of all these different accounts and how much you can contribute.
- 4:29And if there's phase outs and all these different strategies.
- 4:32And then all of a sudden you get to retirement and say, now I got
- 4:34to take it out. How do I do that?
- 4:37And what's, what's my downfall? What are the good things that
- 4:40can happen and what's the best way to do it?
- 4:41So, yeah, there's a lot of clients that come to mind that
- 4:43says, you know, there's a great success story saying, I had no
- 4:48idea and I'm so glad I found out that I can retire kind of thing.
- 4:52So we, we, we met with these clients a couple of years ago
- 4:55and now clients, they were not at that point in time, but they
- 4:57came in and they worked here in town for a couple different
- 5:00organizations and just worked really hard their entire life
- 5:04and, and stacked money away and put more and more away and made
- 5:06sure they saved and worked really hard for it.
- 5:08And they're getting to the point saying, Hey, we should probably
- 5:11start kicking tires and saying who can help us now make the
- 5:14decision to retire? And they both came in and we
- 5:17spent a lot of time just understanding who they are and
- 5:19what they want retirement to look like first.
- 5:22And then we kind of, we, we unravel some of the numbers and
- 5:25say, well, what do we have to make that dream come true?
- 5:28And so we built them out of financial plan and showed them
- 5:30where they're at right now and what this now may look like long
- 5:32term. And to their surprise, they were
- 5:35far better than what they thought, 'cause really they,
- 5:38they focused on how much do we have in retirement?
- 5:40And that was their their, their, their benchmark saying, can I do
- 5:44it? Can I not?
- 5:45Not to interrupt you, but I think that's a common thing with
- 5:48people is that they look to retirement for the number.
- 5:52Like I've got X amount on set and, and just just touch on that
- 5:57a little bit more because obviously I get involved in that
- 5:59too, but it isn't really the number they're looking for.
- 6:02And so maybe you want to continue on that conversation
- 6:04100. Percent, it's very misleading
- 6:06and and a lot of people will always just fundamentally have
- 6:09that number. I want to be a millionaire.
- 6:10I want to have 5 million bucks in my 4 O 1K, which is fair and,
- 6:14and it's fine to use that as kind of a, a leading indicator,
- 6:18but it's not the answer. It doesn't matter how much you
- 6:21have. It's how much you spend and how
- 6:23much is going to be taxed and how often you take it out.
- 6:26What's your, your, your filing status when it comes to taxes?
- 6:29It does all these different areas.
- 6:30And so it's a very misleading number, although it's a very
- 6:33common benchmark for people. But anyways, this, this couple,
- 6:38they had a fair amount of money in their retirement accounts and
- 6:40they said, I think we're finally to the point we can do it.
- 6:42Well, we aren't, we, we look under the hood and they've got
- 6:45hundreds of thousands of dollars in their bank accounts, which
- 6:49they, they really haven't been utilizing to build the financial
- 6:52plan, but didn't realize was a huge, huge benefit to strategies
- 6:55in unwinding some of this tax deferred money in retirement
- 6:58accounts. And so they came in thinking
- 7:00retirement was for her very short and you know, or around
- 7:04the corner, maybe a couple of months for him, couple years.
- 7:07But we build out this plan and he has a better understanding of
- 7:09how this all kind of piles together and realizes it might
- 7:12make more sense to actually retire earlier from a tax
- 7:15standpoint, the longevity opportunity standpoint.
- 7:18He ends up retiring in in three or four months after we had that
- 7:20conversation. And they've been enjoying
- 7:22retirement ever since. And they come back and and they
- 7:25have all these success stories of where they've gone, the
- 7:28traveling, they've done that, the things they do with family.
- 7:30And so that's the power of it is not just saying how much money
- 7:33do I have, but how does this all work together with Social
- 7:36Security and pensions and so forth.
- 7:37So. So you're saying in this
- 7:39instance you built out a financial plan and he was going
- 7:42to the number he was planning to retire at least in his head in a
- 7:45couple years and you said within a few months he retired?
- 7:47Yep. He came back and said, well,
- 7:49what what happens if I pull it forward a little bit?
- 7:51And so we can maneuver some of the the planning software we
- 7:54have and showcase that in a in a snap of finger.
- 7:57He says, wow, I had no idea. And that's where the light bulb
- 8:00went off. And he said, honey, I think I
- 8:01might go to. Wow, you know, I've, I've had
- 8:05situations that clients have retired sooner than anticipated,
- 8:08but that particular story where it's going from, I don't know
- 8:12what their ages were, but if he's going to retire 62 and now
- 8:14he retires at 60, that's to be like life changing.
- 8:17Seriously. I mean, it's like if you're
- 8:19planning to retire and all sudden you just now retire two
- 8:21years earlier. And you know, my thing is that,
- 8:25you know, life is meant to be lived.
- 8:27And so when you get older, you only have so many years, right.
- 8:33And so for him, he just bought himself two years in retirement.
- 8:37I can't even imagine how you know the feeling.
- 8:39And again, I don't you can touch on that a little bit, but I
- 8:42can't even imagine if he was retiring at two years later and
- 8:45all sudden you put together numbers and he's like, wow, this
- 8:47is unbelievable. And, and it is, it's powerful
- 8:50for us too, because we get to see that, that that light bulb
- 8:52go off and, and quite frankly, tears shed in some of these
- 8:55conversations, which it's, it's huge, it's gratifying, doesn't
- 8:59mean there's not the other side of the coin.
- 9:00Right. I was just going to ask you not,
- 9:02not, not do we have to go gloom and doom here?
- 9:05But obviously there's times where people come in and say,
- 9:08hey, I'm going to retire in three months and you, you have
- 9:10to be deliver the news that maybe not so much.
- 9:12It's very common and again, hats off to them to say, hey, I'm
- 9:16going to come and double check with somebody before I actually
- 9:19do it because a lot of times that can put them in a situation
- 9:22where it says, well, shoot, now I got to go work part time
- 9:25because I didn't realize what my tax bill would be or how long it
- 9:29would last if I spend X amount like I've been doing lately.
- 9:31So not to dive super in depth in any of those scenarios, but
- 9:36we're going to help you understand where you are based
- 9:38on what your goals are and what your spending habits are.
- 9:40If you're on track, we're going to explain and help you
- 9:43understand how to implement it the best way in our opinion, or
- 9:46whatever the case may be will help you down whatever path.
- 9:49But if the numbers don't look great, we're not going to
- 9:53shelter that that that conversation.
- 9:55We're going to say, hey, it might make sense to either work
- 9:58part time or you may have to work a couple more years or you
- 10:01can't draw as much money because of the tax situation.
- 10:05And those aren't usually the most fun conversations, but
- 10:07they're extremely important because you leave an employer,
- 10:10they're likely not going to ask you to come back a month later
- 10:12when you say I made a mistake. That's actually, it's
- 10:15interesting because you, you brought something up that just
- 10:17popped into my head. And obviously once you leave
- 10:20your employer, it is irrevocable.
- 10:22Typically, like you said, you're not going to go back.
- 10:25But what you said was interesting like you don't tell
- 10:27clients no, you can't retire. You're simply saying, here's the
- 10:31alternatives, which I think is a great approach because I think
- 10:34if somebody plans to retire in six months and you come back and
- 10:36say you can retire in six months, but you may not like it
- 10:39based on the budgets and everything else.
- 10:41So I I think the your approach of saying you can retire when
- 10:46you want, however you're going to have to change one of these
- 10:49dials. And retirements, not just a, a
- 10:52subjective conversation, it's such a, or it is very
- 10:55subjective. It's not objective because it's
- 10:57not just a, how much money do I have and will it get me through
- 11:00retirement? It's do I want to retire and
- 11:02when is that appropriate time and when do I draw Social
- 11:05Security? Because a lot of these things
- 11:08overlap each other. And again, a lot of these things
- 11:11are irrevocable as you're talking about.
- 11:12But it's about making sure you have a purpose after you retire.
- 11:16It's not just financially can I retire?
- 11:18It's when can I retire financially and do the things
- 11:21that I want to do. It's not just cut and dry.
- 11:24I'm, I'm going to retire and I'm going to golf every day or I'm
- 11:26going to volunteer every day because quite frankly, everyone
- 11:30we talked to who retires, they don't actually do that every
- 11:32day. And they have to try to find
- 11:34ways to fill their time. And if that's the case, maybe
- 11:37it's not time to retire and and stay with that community at work
- 11:40that you've continued to harvest over the last 30 years.
- 11:42Maybe. So it's not just a easy math
- 11:45problem. It's it's a very deep discussion
- 11:48to have when retirement makes sense.
- 11:50You know, it's interesting when I, I think about myself and you
- 11:54know, I have friends of mine, I mean good, good friends of mine
- 11:58from high school and so forth, that they are retiring and I'm
- 12:01still working because I love it. I absolutely love working and I
- 12:05don't even know if there is a retirement date for me.
- 12:07I mean, the, the people at Fortress are kind of maybe
- 12:10wishing it would be sooner rather than later.
- 12:11But at the end of the day, I love it and I'm going to
- 12:13continue to do it. But you're right.
- 12:16I, I think that, you know, you had mentioned the complexities
- 12:20and you talked about, you know, different strategies and
- 12:22techniques and everything kind of falls in around these taxes
- 12:25at some point. And I know I can recall many,
- 12:29many, many, many instances where we run into these scenarios, we
- 12:34call them tax traps. And it could just be, you know,
- 12:38somebody's like, Oh my gosh, I didn't realize this or that.
- 12:40And so I, I know there's a few out there.
- 12:42And again, I would like you to elaborate because again, you're,
- 12:45you're kind of in, in in the trenches working with these
- 12:47newly retirees. And so you've seen some of these
- 12:50tax traps. And so if you want to just for
- 12:52the viewership, because I think this is, you know, part, part of
- 12:55the whole purpose of this podcast is to provide valuable
- 13:00information for people. So people that are watching
- 13:02today, I think what you're about to say, I think is important
- 13:07because I'm, I'm not even 100% sure what you're going to say,
- 13:09but there are some tax traps that I do want you to touch on.
- 13:12And for you viewers out there, pay attention to this because it
- 13:16can definitely affect you. Know there's two that come to
- 13:19mind when you say that and, and obviously there's an abundance
- 13:22of tax things that you need to focus on, whether it's capital
- 13:25gain harvesting or capital lost harvesting.
- 13:27There's a lot of different strategies there in brokerage
- 13:29accounts. But the main ones that I think
- 13:31of that that come to fruition most often is the required
- 13:35minimum distribution and when you have to take it.
- 13:38But one that I'll mention at the end is, is the widow's penalty
- 13:42that people don't necessarily think about.
- 13:43So if we start with the required minimum distribution, which is
- 13:46essentially any money you've saved in a tax deferred
- 13:49retirement account, you have to take a distribution from that
- 13:53account at 75 years old whether you want to or not.
- 13:56Previously it was 70 1/2, kicked back to 72 to 73, which is what
- 14:01it is right now. And then in 2033 it's going to
- 14:03get kicked back to age 75. So it keeps going further and
- 14:07further down the road, which the average consumer is going to
- 14:10say, well, great, that means I don't have to take the
- 14:12distribution and pay taxes on it if I don't actually need the
- 14:15money yet. It's a common trap because by
- 14:20doing that, what you're doing is letting your account grow higher
- 14:22and higher and higher, and then it's a bigger number in the
- 14:25future that you have to take that distribution off of.
- 14:28And who knows what tax rates are going to be at that point in
- 14:30time. You have no control over any of
- 14:32that. And so unless you're going to
- 14:34donate it to a charity, you're going to have to pay taxes on
- 14:37that money no matter what. And So what we'd like to frame
- 14:39it as is, do you like to pay the least amount of taxes today or
- 14:42the least amount of taxes over your lifetime?
- 14:45And that kind of sets off a little bit of a light bulb.
- 14:47Well then everyone's like, well, I'd rather payless tax long
- 14:49term. Well, sometimes that means
- 14:51biting the bullet and pulling some of these taxes forward and
- 14:54we can showcase what that looks like over a long period of time.
- 14:58And it'll show you literally 10s if not hundreds of thousands of
- 15:01dollars you'll saving, you're saving just in your tax bill
- 15:04over your lifetime, but kind of front loading some of that.
- 15:08So what you're saying is that if I retire at 65 and I built up
- 15:12this nice retirement plan, don't necessarily automatically defer
- 15:17it until the required minimum distribution, like you said,
- 15:19till 73. So you're saying if I retired
- 15:2165, I've got eight years that I could actually reduce that so I
- 15:25don't have to be forced to pull it out at a much higher bracket?
- 15:29And you're you're saying that you can save hundreds of
- 15:31thousands depending on values. Absolutely.
- 15:34And what we'd love to hear is you take that money out and
- 15:36enjoy it if it's within your budget.
- 15:38I love that. But what's more common is you
- 15:42reposition that money, you take it from the IRA and either move
- 15:44it to a Roth account or a brokerage account or your bank
- 15:47account, but you get that tax liability off the table right
- 15:51away and you'll never have to worry about it again.
- 15:53And so it's just proactively saying, gosh, I don't want to,
- 15:55but I'm going to have to pay that tax bill.
- 15:57Let's do it now. We know the tax rates right now.
- 16:01You're probably not prepared for my next question, but that's a
- 16:03great thing of me being kind of flipping here.
- 16:06I get to ask the questions I want to ask.
- 16:07But you talk about Roth conversion.
- 16:09So let's hypothetically say I'm 65 years old, I've got 3 kids.
- 16:15Why would I convert AT65I? I feel like that's more of a
- 16:18young person's game. So when when does that make
- 16:20sense in retirement to convert? It's a great question and it is
- 16:23different for everybody. 65 obviously a very common
- 16:26retirement age, but you got to you got to think about am I
- 16:29taking Social Security? Am I having any other part time
- 16:32job? What other income streams do I
- 16:35have and what is my already allocation with Roth dollars and
- 16:39after tax deferred dollars? It makes sense if you're not
- 16:44drawing Social Security to maybe pull some of those those Roth
- 16:47conversions forward to say, hey, I know I'm going to have to pay
- 16:50tax on in the future. Let's go ahead and do it right
- 16:52now because as I mentioned before, there's a widow's
- 16:55penalty out there. Let's say you know, most people
- 16:58don't think about it and don't want to think about it, but
- 17:01spouses don't typically pass away together.
- 17:04Yeah, let's touch on that. I, I, I kind of went off on you
- 17:06with the wrong and thank you for that.
- 17:07It's OK, but it plays in the. Yeah, let's talk about.
- 17:09Let's talk about that. Widow it plays into the same
- 17:12point because at the end of the day, a required minimum
- 17:14distribution is it has to start when you're 73 or 75, depending
- 17:19on when you were born. But if you pass away, you're
- 17:22probably leaving that money to your spouse, which then in turn
- 17:24will have to do the same thing with the same dollars.
- 17:27But your spouse is now a single tax filer.
- 17:29And the the the tax brackets get cut in half.
- 17:31The standard deduction gets cut in half, but you have to still
- 17:34take the same amount of money out of that IRA, which is going
- 17:37to be taxed exactly the same, if not higher because now you're
- 17:40jumping tax brackets faster. So leading into your previous
- 17:43question, Roth conversions at 65, if both you are healthy and
- 17:47you're in a situation where you're going to lower tax
- 17:49bracket, if you don't need the money, reposition the money, pay
- 17:52the taxes. If you have it available in the
- 17:54bank, pay that out of pocket. Let that money continue to grow
- 17:57and accumulate. Gosh, when you're 75, you might
- 18:00still have a required minimum distribution from your IRA
- 18:03dollars, but it's going to be smaller because you have now
- 18:05more money in your Roth, which you don't have to touch, which
- 18:08is more favorable on the tax standpoint for beneficiaries to
- 18:11inherit as well. Yeah, I never thought about the
- 18:14Roth conversion of being beneficial for a surviving
- 18:17spouse, but you're exactly right.
- 18:19Because if you know one of the spouses passes away and they
- 18:23have to being forced to take the required minimum distribution
- 18:25plus the Social Security and if there's any pensions and like
- 18:28you said, the tax brackets get cut in half.
- 18:30So interesting perspective on the Roth conversion because you
- 18:36are our most senior advisor here at Fortress and you do work with
- 18:40a lot of retirees. I'm going to hold you to one.
- 18:44Give us one thing that you would recommend everybody that is
- 18:50approaching retirement or is in retirement.
- 18:53And I know that we've talked about a lot of things over over
- 18:56this over this episode, but is there one thing that jumps out
- 18:59that you said, you know, what if I were 60 years old approaching
- 19:02retirement, if I'm 65 and I just retired, is there one thing that
- 19:05you would tell the viewers that they should should look into?
- 19:09It's a great question because there's a lot of things, but I
- 19:13would say paint the picture, I mean create that retirement
- 19:17picture that that you really want to do.
- 19:18Don't, don't think about. Do I have enough money to now
- 19:22leave my job? Think about, do I have enough
- 19:25money to go do the things I want to do?
- 19:28And what is that story? What is that picture you want to
- 19:30paint? And I think that's a very
- 19:32important question, not for yourself, but for you and your
- 19:34spouse and your family, whatever the case may be, because that's
- 19:38what's going to drive your ability, your success in
- 19:40retirement. And when you're leading up to
- 19:42retirement, you need to know if you have enough money for that
- 19:44or, or the more common situation is, is the fun one where it's,
- 19:49you need to think bigger because all these people, a lot of them
- 19:52worked really, really hard their entire life.
- 19:54You're probably one of them. And all of a sudden you, you
- 19:57change your lifestyle to now, you used to earn an income and
- 20:01receive a paycheck every day. Now you're your own paycheck.
- 20:04You might get Social Security and a pension, but now you're
- 20:06creating your own income stream. And it's important you do the
- 20:09things you want to do with that money you intentionally deferred
- 20:12for the future. So in my opinion, number one is
- 20:15you're leading up to retirement. The numbers matter.
- 20:18But the intentionality around what you do with the numbers
- 20:20matter much more. And so that's what I would.
- 20:24Say great advice and and I think it goes back and I think it's
- 20:26kind of a corny phrase, but I think it's very relevant to what
- 20:29you just said, which is you want to retire to something, not from
- 20:33something. In other words, you know, I
- 20:35think that the two most common we see is once I get to X amount
- 20:38of dollars, I'm done, done or once I hit a certain age, I'm
- 20:42done, done. And you're saying no, no, no,
- 20:43no. Paint that picture about what
- 20:46retirement looks like. Run the numbers, make sure
- 20:49everything fits financially, but paint that picture so that you
- 20:53can enjoy those those years in retirement.
- 20:55And don't put the paintbrush down and keep adding to it.
- 20:58Great advice. Well, that concludes this
- 21:02episode of Retire and Thrive. Thank you for tuning in and
- 21:05we'll look forward to seeing you next week on another episode.
- 21:08Fortress Financial Group, LLC is a registered investment advisor.
- 21:12Advisory services are only offered to clients or
- 21:14prospective clients where Fortress and its representatives
- 21:17are properly licensed or exempt for licensure.
- 21:19The opinions voiced in this material are for general
- 21:22information only and are not intended to provide specific
- 21:24advice or recommendations for any individual.
- 21:26All indexes are unmanaged and may not be invested into
- 21:29directly. Investing involves risk,
- 21:31including loss of principal.