Latest / Systems and Power / Early days at Bain, Teaching at Harvard, Leadership - Dr. Ronald Frank | Systems and Power #3
Transcript
- Moses: Hello everybody. I'm here with a very special guest today. He is a Queen's College alumni of 1968 and a graduate from John Hopkins PhD program in operations research. Prior to that and also beginning his career, he served in the faculty for Harvard Business School and B and Bain Capital and As well as IBM Consulting, please welcome Doctor Ronald Frank. Thank you for joining. Ron Frank: Well thank you for having me. Moses: So in regards to operations research, I did want to ask a few questions on that. How did what made you want to s to get into that field and how did that lecoming a faculty member at Harvard Business School? Ron Frank: So it's a great question. when I was a senior at Queens, I had been a math major. I took a look at the Harvard Business School MBA application. Moses: Mm-hmm. Ron Frank: And on it there was a question, what are the three most important things you've done in your life. And I looked at that question and I said, I worked in a dry cleaning store, I played a lot of schoolyard basketball, and I don't know what these people are asking me, so I never applied. That was number one. that's part of what happens when you're a Queens College kid, first generation college, etcetera. Operations research is basically mathematics and analytics apply to business problems. And given my math background and the fact that I wanted to do something applied, not topology or theoretical math, operations research was a great opportunity. And I wound up having two fellowships coming out of Queens for PhD programs at Johns Hopkins and Northwestern. And how I got to Hopkins Moses: Nice. Ron Frank: and how I got to teach at Harvard Business School is a almost beyond belief story. Which is what you'd expect. So I had these two fellowships and in April of nineteen sixty-eight, President Lyndon Johnson took away graduate school deferments except for medical and dental school. So if you went to grad school, you were probably going to get drafted and go to Vietnam. And I had already written papers on how much I despised the Vietnam War and thought it was just a a bad use of American power. And turned out I was right, but I'm not sure everybody knew that back in nineteen sixty-eight. So as a hedge, I applied for some jobs. I had these two fellowships. I applied to Grumman Aircraft to be a scientific programmer, which was draft deferred. They were a defense contractor out in Route 106 on Long Island. And I got a job there. I started. I was a Fortran programmer. I'd taken some computer courses at Queens. And I hated it. It was I quit after nine weeks. I made more money than my father. And my other hedge was Moses: Mm-hmm. Ron Frank: to teach junior high school math. So I went to teach junior high school math, which was also draft deferred for men, because they were trying so hard to get men to teach in those days. And I had taken one site course, one ed course, and gotten a temporary license. So I showed up in September to teach sixth grade math in a six, seven, eight school. And It was interesting. The first thing that happened is the New York City Teachers Union went on strike. So the schools all tried to stay open, but they basically were babysiting kids 'cause all the teachers went on strike. So I played a lot of touch football. And eventually the strike ended, but while this was going on, I put myself on a list for the Army Reserve. And I came off the list in November. This is all happening in four months, getting out of Queens. Moses: wow. Ron Frank: This was pretty crazy. So I joined the army circle. I Moses: That's definitely one hectic time for a new grad. Ron Frank: joined the army reserve. the strike ended, I went back to teach, and in mid January I called Hopkins and I said actually the beginning of January I called Hopkins and I said, If I paid for second semester, could I have my full fellowship in stipend in the fall? And they said, We don't know. We'll get back to you. January twentieth they got back to me and said a first year student who had dropped out of the PhD program with a full fellowship and money to live on a stipend had quit. And could I be there in ten days with a full fellowship in stipend? And I felt like the song from a chorus line, I can do that, I can do that. So Ten days later, I had an apartment with a grad student and a former grad student who was moving out. I was in the PhD program with a two thousand dollar a year non taxable stipend and all my fellowship tuition, whatever paid. Three and a half years later, one of the guys who'd been in that townhouse got a job teaching at Harvard Business School. He was two years ahead of me. graduating, actually, yeah, I think that's right, two years ahead of me. He got me an interview and I got a job. He was a Hopkins PhD two years ahead of me in operations research. So three and a half years after I can do that, I was a twenty-four-year-old professor at Harvard Business School. You can't make this stuff up. Moses: Wow. So when you were there, were you the youngest professor at Harvard Bus Business School? Ron Frank: so I was the youngest but I wasn't the youngest to start. One of my colleagues, a guy named Bing Sung, was twenty three when he started, but he was in his second year, so he was Moses: wow. Ron Frank: already a very old twenty five. Moses: That's actually really cool. What s what like classes and subjects did you teach when you were at Harvard Business School? Ron Frank: So in those days there was a course called managerial economics, which was basically math and analytics applied to business. So we taught simulation, regression, decision theory, under uncertainty, linear programming, and a bunch of stuff. None of the students really cared about, but it was a required course and they had to take it. Moses: Hmm. What when you were over there as a professor at Harvard Business School, what your the whole student body that I guess was in your classes, what what like backgrounds did they largely come from? Ron Frank: So in those days, coming out of the Vietnam War and disillusionment with business and government. A lot of really talented people didn't apply to business school. There still was a lot of talent Moses: Mm-hmm. Ron Frank: left, but the diversity in each of my two eighty student sections that I taught in first year, there were about six women. There were a couple of diverse men. It doesn't look any you know, today it's fifty percent women, very diverse from all over the world. But back then it wasn't. But just to give you a sense, my first graduating class was class of seventy-four. The class of seventy five had George W. Bush in it, who became the president, Bush forty three, had Mitt Romney. who ran for president. Neither of them were my students. I say with you know interest, I had some very famous and successful students, but not people who ran for president. But the diversity of Moses: Hmm. Ron Frank: interest was all over. I mean, there was an army colonel who wound up becoming General Colin Powell's aide. He became a general himself. there were people who had family owned businesses that they were going to go back to. people who had left consulting firms to go get an MBA for two years to go back, all sorts of people. Moses: Hmm. And after you I get y you served your time in as a professor at Harvard Business School, you ended up going to Bain right after that, correct? Ron Frank: Bainin Company, not Bain Capital. Baining Company Moses: Okay, my my bad. Ron Frank: That's okay. We knew we'd get to it. Bain Company That's Moses: Okay. Sorry for the mis up mix up. Ron Frank: okay. Baining Company was founded in April of 73. Seven consultants led by Bill Bain left the Boston Consulting Group to start Bain Company. They hired one of my first students who had a PhD in computer science. He called me when Bain he was their first summer associate. He called me when Bain was about seven or eight weeks old. And Bain and Company was trying to develop a software product using math programming that I did my PhD in, OR. And they were trying to develop this software. To do higher quality competitive intelligence and analysis. And that guy who founded the Boston Consulting Group, Bruce Henderson, thought this was hogwash. One of their two clients, they took with them, Texas Instruments, that was the most paranoid competitive company that almost ever was, they were paying to develop this software. So that's why they called me. That's how I got involved. I started working with Bain and Company part time when it was ten weeks old. Like I say, you can't make this stuff up. Moses: wow. So you're so you're one of the original employees then at Ba Bane Company? Ron Frank: It was one room one room, one room above a delicatessen at sorry, above a yeah, above a delicatessen at nine Park Street, the second floor. Right off of Boston Common. Moses: wow. I know you you mentioned that Mitt Romney was also during in your time at Ron Frank: B. Moses: at at Harvard Business School. Did he go around there and make and make the jump to Bin Company around the same around the same time? I know he worked at Boston Consulting Group for a little bit before. Ron Frank: So yeah, Mitt graduated. Mitt Mitt did a four year program MD I sorry J D MBA. So he became a lawyer and a MBA. He graduated in seventy six. He went to the Boston Consulting Group. Another guy who Mitt worked for left the Boston Consulting Group to join Bain, and Mitt came over a few months later from BCG to Bain and Company. Moses: Mm. How Ron Frank: So he came over in about seven seventy seven or so. Moses: Hm, how is it like working with with him at ba at Bain and C Bannon Company? Ron Frank: I you know, we never worked on a project together, but I have to say Moses: okay. Ron Frank: and I I saw him at the fiftieth reunion a few years ago in Boston in two thousand three. Mitt Romney is a great guy. He's smart, he's nice, he's funny, he's a really hard worker. He was a bishop for the Mormon church. Just an absolutely wonderful guy. He and Ann had five sons. so they had their own basketball team, so I was always jealous of that. And just Moses: Mm. Ron Frank: an exceptional guy. and we worked together on Baining Company stuff, but just not on clients. We were both about the same level. He became a partner about six, eight months before me. So we were always sort of working in parallel. more than you know, one of us working for the other. Moses: Okay. No, that's that's actually real real really cool seeing I guess the the whole backstory is behind behind what actually went went behind at at the early days of Bane and Company. When I guess now that you made the the point of be becoming part of how was that something that you all that you strive to achieve before you before you joined, or it was it happened somewhere along the way as you progress your time there at at Bain. Ron Frank: So I I took a leave from Harvard. I worked at Bain part-time for a few years. I took a leave in the summer of seventy-five and I worked full time at Bain. They asked me to teach a course while I was working full time because they didn't have it covered. So I did that. Then I took a leave for a second year to Moses: Yeah. Ron Frank: have a full year. You gotta remember I was teaching at Harvard Business School and my only experience working really was in my father's dry cleaning store in Bayside. So you know, I I really needed some business experience if I was gonna stay in teaching long term in business school. And it turned out I ultimately, after two years on leave, resigned, joined Bain full time in seventy seven, and was already a manager and went on to become a partner two years later. got voted in as a part. Moses: In in terms of the process of sorry. Ron Frank: I I was actually I I was actually the twelfth partner at Bain and Company in nineteen seventy nine. Bain probably has fifteen hundred partners now, or some crazy number. Moses: twelve partner. When you ended up leaving Bain and went on to work for a variety of of other firms, what event what was the deciding reason for that, if you don't mind mind me asking? That was one thing I was a bit curious about. Ron Frank: Sure. So it's once again a long story I won't get into, but Baining Company found itself highly leveraged and lost some clients in the late 80s and was in serious financial trouble. and actually downsized by about fifteen percent, a hundred twenty-ish people if I remember. It was pretty significant. I was the most senior of those people after fifteen years with Bain. So the good news is I was a partner. The bad news is we had become a corporation and I was called a partner but I was really an employee at will. Moses: Yeah. Ron Frank: And you know, that stuff happens in life and you pick yourself up, you dust yourself off, and you drive on. And I had a another god forty years in consulting, I left. I still do some today. Moses: Mm. That's okay, thank you thank you so much for tell for telling us that. In from a since you you had a career that spanned over from Bain and then several other firms and then going going on to IBM, I did want to ask like how was the I guess the transition period from like between that time between Bane and IBM, how was that how would you describe that transition period as? Ron Frank: Well, you know, I I had my own company for a while. I was the COO of a very successful financial services company that was on the front end of the MB and Affinity credit card selling and servicing the affinity groups with credit cards. I did a bunch of consulting. I was with a adorable little consulting firm doing internet strategy consulting in the late nineties that IBM acquired. And that's how I wound up at IBM. And I never thought I would stay there that long, but I wound up with an amazing role. And I ran my own business for fifteen plus years and increased the profit margin by six times. took it from ten percent to sixty percent profit margin. have mentees all over the world who were part of that practice and still see some of them on a regular basis. It was pretty cool. Moses: Hmm. That definitely does sound pretty cool. A lot of people would kill to to make sure that they can have like a career that spans especially as as as I I'm trying to find the words for it, but as stacked as that, especially getting like making your own very successful consulting firm and then having it acquired by IBM. That's something that a lot of people can would dream of dream of having. In term and and now that you brought on to the topic of mentees, how would you say as your as throughout your your career, you took the time and you mentored a lot of people and gave back to the community to help others build their own careers as well. What is your thoughts on how the process was like and how you reflect on essentially helping a lot of others build their own careers as as well? Ron Frank: So, you know, Moses, this one is actually pretty simple. Because step back, at the end of the day, I was a teacher. And I was very committed to growing and developing talent as a professor. And that didn't stop when I became a consultant. And in fact, the one of the most important roles of a senior consulting manager and partner is to grow and develop talent. Because you can't do this job by yourself. You need great people working with you, you need great teams to do great consulting. And one of the reasons I love the business, and you're gonna laugh. is my favorite thing growing up was playing schoolyard basketball and getting on the court and trying to win for as many half hours and hours as you could before you got tossed off and somebody beat you. But part of what you had to do Moses: Mm-hmm. Ron Frank: was make everybody else on your team better in five on five and try to stay on the court. Because I kid around when you got when you lost you may as well go home 'cause there were thirty people waiting to play. Well, it turned out team consulting, team strategy consulting is one of the closest things to that experience, I think you could imagine. Because the team has to support each other and everybody has to make everybody else better with their thinking, their analysis, their challenging, they're seeking a better strategic position for their clients. Moses: Hmm. I I actually really, really like that lesson that in order to make to advance you are going to have to be a team player. Success is not just necess necessarily j just just by yourself, but it's gonna take a whole coalition of people joining together and making each other better. I hope I'm putting it in in the in the right words here. Ron Frank: No, y y you are. consulting is a pyramid business. you know, when you you go to Queens College back in my day in nineteen sixty five, they used to say, Look to your right, look to your left, one of you will be gone in a year. And that Moses: Mm-hmm. Ron Frank: happens in consulting. The key is to make sure the right people are still there, the most talented and they're growing and developing and increasing their capacity to contribute. Moses: Hmm. Speaking of also, I guess qu giving giving back especially to Queens College students, I know that you were at one point a well, back when you were an an an undergrad, you were a member of a fraternity, correct? How was the the fraternity scene like back then in Queens College? Because unfortunately now at Queen's College, the fraternity at least like w when I was there when I graduated a couple of years ago, the fraternity scene was not nearly as big a as it used to be, especially after COVID. So if you could take us back to the time back when you were in a fraternity, how was the environment like how is it like making and developing relationships and connections with other like minded brothers at the fraternity in Queens College. Ron Frank: So I hit the jackpot, as did many others. So In the spring of sixty-five, I pledged with thirty-two others, Phi Epsilon Pi, which was one of the best fraternities on campus. EE Pi, Phi Epsilon Pi, Tau Epsilon Pi, ZBT, etc. But Phi Ep was one of the best and they were all good, strong. fraternities. Each of them actually had a fraternity house. They had a house that Moses: wow. Ron Frank: they paid rent for and they could have parties in and people could hang out in. And remember we were all living at home like you guys. So it was extraordinary to have a community and a place for that community to be. So our fraternity house was on god it was just north of Union Turnpike and just west of I think it was just west of either a hundred sixty fourth or Parsons. And it was very close to Queen's College, probably you know, a mile away. And we had a basement we could have parties in. We did have parties. The drinking age was eighteen in those days, not twenty one. so basically everybody everybody Moses: wow. Ron Frank: could drink. and And to this day, I'm still connected to many of those fraternity brothers. In fact, about five years ago, a few of us got together and launched the Phi Epps Lumpy Foundation. By the way, FIEP is not at Queen's College anymore. It got merged into ZBT, and I don't know what the status is of ZBT. I think it's still there. But bunch of us got together and launched a foundation, the Phi Epsilon Pi Scholarship Foundation, and in five plus years we've raised almost a million dollars that funds tuition for a bunch of Queens College students who get picked by the university and have good averages, interesting backgrounds, very diverse. I promise you FIEP was ninety plus percent white and Jewish, and the people we've supported are the opposite. They don't look like us, but in terms of being first generation college and their backgrounds, they're exactly like us. And we've met some extraordinary young people by doing that. So so the fraternity has been a lifelong set of relationships. that still continue as we speak. Moses: Awesome. That was actually one of the questions that I wanted to get get into later about the foundation that you and your fellow fraternity f fraternity brothers spoke about. Is there any I guess certain like st students you would like to give a shout out to or like tell about like how the foundation changed their life and helped them to go out into Queens College Ron Frank: So Moses: and to make make it big? Ron Frank: Yeah, so the answer is yes. if you want to reach out to one of the development team, Chuck Ferrero, I think it's F E R R E R O, Charles Ferrero, Chuck has the names, who the grantees were, in some cases what they're doing now. So about Three years ago we had a get together Moses: Yeah. Ron Frank: in September at Queen's College and we had a few of the grantees there. One of them showed up and spoke. His name was Raul. He was an accounting major. His mom and his sister were there and he basically said this grant helped me support my sister. By not taking family resources so she could go to college. He then, one Saturday morning, a couple of years ago, got on New York One, and you could find this with Bob Jacobs, one of the founders, one of my fraternity brothers, who just passed a couple of weeks ago. And he got on New York One with Bob and told his story. Somebody not in the fraternity watching that on New York One. whose wife had gone to Queen's College, I think he hadn't, donated a half a million dollars to the library in his wife's name because he saw this story and he got motivated to do something great. So You know, these these things have wings. and then he got on New York One a year later and told a story of how he had seen Bob and Raoul and maybe that'll motivate some other people to support kids because perspective we all went to Queens College and paid a registration fee of twenty four dollars a semester. back in the sixties. Tuition was zero. Zero, I repeat. So I wound up going to college for ninety six dollars in tuition, a registration fees, or some such ridiculous number. And then I did a PhD at Hopkins where I got paid money to live on with no tuition. It was a pretty amazing Yeah. That Moses: Free graduation. We love that. Ron Frank: that was pretty amazing. And you know, the thought of giving back if I could leave one message with people if you can't give back, one of the programs we created I wrote an article about a graduation speaker at a small school, four hundred students, who had done quite well. He gave each student a thousand dollars toward their Wardrobe. after they graduated and he gave them Moses: Wow. Ron Frank: five hundred dollars to donate so they'd learn about philanthropy. We actually did that on a small scale at Queens. We gave five hundred dollars to people and work with Macy's to get them a shopper and to get them the best discounts so they could buy great clothes to interview. And we gave them a hundred dollars to actually give to a philanthropic organization so they could begin to understand what it is to give, not just to get. Moses: That's really nice and I it's actually really touching to see the lessons of giving back to the the people who were once in your shoes. And I r I remember that from a w a while ago we had a we had a brief conversation about paying it forward and I really liked what you you said at the time when you were emphasizing it on The importance of paying it forward to those who are once in your position so that way they can continue a chain effect to others and that way it can be in an instance a domino effect to keep on helping improve the lives of others. I was wondering if you could go back on on that topic a little bit more on on the importance of paying it forward to other people who are in our position. Ron Frank: I don't know that I can add a lot to what you said. It Moses: Yeah. Ron Frank: you know, we I remember the first night we were at a Chinese restaurant over by Madison Square Garden, and you know, Bob and I had cooked this up with some help from Jay Newschatz, another one of our fraternity brothers. And we presented this to about 30 guys at Eighth Avenue and thirty sixth or seventh street, a Chinese restaurant. We all got together and talked. And we used to do this regularly, but not on the subject of giving back. And we presented it and we had some rules. Moses: Mm-hmm. Ron Frank: And the rules were only we would solicit the fraternity, we would shut off Queen's College calling people and bothering them. Number two. We would share who contributed, but we would never say how much. Giving a hundred dollars and giving to your point about paying it forward was as important as giving a thousand or a hundred thousand. So we've never shared who gave what. And one of the guys got up and said, How could we not do this? We were given so much. How could we not give back? And that's the night the foundation started to take off. And what's really interesting about it, Moses, is we have a bunch of fraternity brothers, many of whom I never met, and we got lists from years before us, who have contributed significantly to the foundation. And Moses: Mm-hmm. Ron Frank: My own daughter and her husband have contributed significantly in my name to the foundation. So we're a bit like Star Trek the next generation of having some support from people who aren't eighty and are fifty. So we'll see where that goes over time. Moses: Okay, that's that's a really beautiful story. Thank you again for for sharing that. There was a couple of other topics around Ron Frank: Well, so so I'm I I I'm gonna I'm gonna I I'm gonna make you laugh a second. So that night three years ago that Moses: what happened? Ron Frank: night three years ago My wife came, Cheryl, and I met her in the college, Queen's College cafeteria back in sixty eight, right before I graduated. Moses: Mm. Ron Frank: She was a freshman. And we got married eighteen months later. But She called my daughter when we left that night. She was so moved and she said, Jen, you and Michael went to Harvard. They call you all the time for money. Harvard has a huge endowment. They don't need your money. Queen's College needs your money. And from that moment forward, they didn't stop supporting Harvard, where she and her husband met, but they've supported Queen's College every year since then. So it's adorable. Yeah, Moses: We love that. Ron Frank: you gotta love it. I'm sorry, I interrupted. Where were you gonna go? Moses: No that's all good. And for anyone who's watching this who currently thinks that college love is dead, there's still hope out there for you guys. So if Ron Ron Frank can do it, you guys can do it too. one of the things that I've always I've also wanted to to ask about, because as we've seen in the last few few years, especially in the rise of artificial intelligence, it has AI has been impacting the the learning of a lot of students and I wanted to get your opinions on AI and the like how it's gonna impact workforce and school because it is impacting things on a very rapid scale and I and a lot of people are worried about how school and work and the job market and everything is going to be impacted and change alongside it. So I would love to get your your your thoughts on that. Ron Frank: So y th there are a bunch of questions there. The first question is what's my takeaway on AI? And one person's opinion, and I always reserve the right to be wrong, is that Most people when they think of AI, think of the algorithm, so they think of Chad or Gemini or Anthropic or whatever. My instinct is the algorithms are less different than the quality of the data they're searching. And that the quality of the data is gonna matter more to the outcomes. than the algorithms. And interestingly enough, there's no standard that I'm aware of for data quality that the algorithms are searching. All they want to do is use more and more energy to search bigger and bigger databases. Yet if they're searching w when I when I was programming computers in the sixties, we had a saying, garbage in, garbage out. That's true about data and AI. AI is probabilistic. It's giving you the best answer. It says it with great confidence, but it's just giving you probabilistically the best answer it can based on the data it searches. It's a hostage to the data. So that's point number one. In terms of how it's gonna impact, I'm not sure. And I'll I'll tell you why. I've now lived through c computers, PCs. The internet, smartphones. And now we're going to you know metaverse. And now we're going to AI. Each of them has been slower and less impactful than people thought. It's taken longer. I have a sense AI may be more powerful than all those other technologies. So maybe it'll be faster and maybe it'll be more impactful than all those others, going back fifty years, if you will. But I think that and Moses: Mm. Ron Frank: I'm not the only one who's gonna say this and thinks this. I think the people who learn how to use AI well will find roles. I think the people who watch AI and don't try to harness it Maybe displaced and struggle. Moses: Okay, thank you so much for share sharing your opinions on that. I th I found it very insightful. One thing that I also wanted to piggyback off on, because I remember you were you were saying it's basically artificial intelligence, it's what most people think. They think of the the learning language models that we largely use day on a day-to-day basis. But in reality it's the data that it's being presented. And that right now big companies all they naturally just want to do is just get as much data, regardless of whatever quality, just as much of it as possible. Do you think that is something that needs to be regulated or have some sort of guardrails on? Ron Frank: So my instinct is yes, I'm not smart enough to know how or by whom, but I just finished a book last night called Careless People, which is one woman's view of spending years at Facebook. And the whole question of data security. of can the government get at your data? Are the algorithms shareable? When Facebook, she says, tried to get into China? They allowed the Chinese government backdoor access to get at who might be creating dissension in order to be allowed to be in China. If that's true and I don't know, I just read it. That's pretty frightening. Meanwhile Facebook, if she's telling the truth, was misleading the US government as to what it was doing and denying how it was used in elections by people in this country and people outside this country to impact our election system. So yeah, I think AI that way could be a lot scarier than Facebook, and Facebook, as I read Might have been pretty darn scary. Moses: Hmm. That's Ron Frank: Hmm. Moses: actually quite quite alarming now that we you think of it that way. One other you're saying? Ron Frank: No? Go ahead. Moses: Okay, okay, okay. Okay. there was also this other concern I've talked with many other people, especially some fa faculty members at CUNY at CUNY and Queen's College, that artificial intelligence is essentially being outsourced to and replaced critical thinking by many young students nowadays. Do you think that's happening on a large scale on the university level or even the education system as a whole and that AI has a place in the classroom? Ron Frank: So Once again, there's a bunch of questions there. One is is it happening? Is it you know, being used in test taking, is it being used to tilt the table, if you will? And obviously I don't know that. People I talk to say it is, and it's pretty disturbing. Number one. Number two, Is that going to, if people are using it, to replace critical thinking, is that going to hurt their own development of their minds, their thought processes, their judgment? I think the answer is yes. and why do I say that? There's a foundation of communication theory called signal to noise. And the best communication has a very high percentage of signal and a very low percentage of noise. That's how the signal gets through. Be it wired, wireless or whatever. Critical thinking ultimately is about separating the wheat from the chaff, the signal from the noise, seeing what really matters versus what doesn't, and focusing on what really matters and its impact on whatever problem or opportunity you're trying to deal with. If people are using an algorithm to do that rather than their brain, think about the negative impact on ultimately they're developing their own critical thinking and judgment skills. I think it's potentially very dangerous to people's development. Moses: Hmm. Thank you for sharing your your insight on that. I definitely think that people using AI in to replace their own critical thinking is definitely something that is alarming. And if people continue to do that on a scale in the classroom, it's going to be very alarming for the development of talent for the workforce in the future. Ron Frank: Yeah, it's gonna be people are gonna have to start using standardized tests, which hopefully people can't cheat on, to either make up their own or use others to differentiate talent if they can't trust what's going on in the classroom. Moses: This is gonna go back to a topic back to Queens College. Recently Frank Wu did an announce that he's going to be retiring and we're gonna have a new acting interim president soon on August first. I wanted to ask your opinion as someone who is very involved in Queens College and going back from Frank Wu to twenty twenty, the c getting out of the the online era and getting everyone back in in person through the pandemic. How do what's your I guess reflection on Frank Wu's term as president and how do you expect the the new interim acting president for Queen's College and what's your expectations on that? I know what have been Ron Frank: So Moses: couple of too many questions, but we'll just love to get your an your answer on that. Ron Frank: a lot you know what it's a lot of questions it's lot of questions so Moses: Ha ha. Ron Frank: you'll be amused I reached out to Frank Wu Moses: Yeah. Ron Frank: a couple of weeks after his appointment was announced long before he showed up July 1 to take his role five years ago how did I do that I'm analytic I wrote an email to Frank dot Wu at qc.cuni.edu and he answered. I knew he'd already be on the system. So we wound up having a bunch of Zoom calls and spent a bunch of time together talking about Queen's College, backgrounds, issues, whatever. I have a tremendous admiration, respect, and fondness for Frank Wu. I thought he did a lot. for Queens. I think he got the business school going, the undergraduate business program. he got a dean hired to lead it I talked to a few weeks ago for the first time, who seems quite capable to me. He Got the Louis Armstrong Center going. I could go through a list of achievements. They're all written up on his announcement. Let me not go there. Moses: Yeah. Ron Frank: The big challenge facing Queen's College is that enrollment is down well over twenty percent the last five, six years. That means probably less and less funding coming out of the state, which is the major funder of CUNY institutions, not the city. that means enrolment needs to be stabilized if not growing. And you know, Frank and his team they tried a lot of things, but I I think This woman who's gonna be the interim president spent thirty years at Queen's College. She actually was the provost, I think, for Felix, the CUNY Chancellor, if you look at her background, over ten years ago before she left for Media Revers to be the president. And I don't know, maybe she'll have some great ideas. to help turn enrollment around. There's a whole bunch of issues about census in Queens, about people not going to college, about you know, people leaving the city. And, you know, I'm not smart enough to know all the details. But Queens has some real challenges going forward. And we all need to do our best to support it. Moses: n thank you again for giving your insights on that. And is there for I guess the the the final questions is do you have any final answers you would like to give to the audience and how can they re reach out to you for any Queen's College or CUNY students interested? Ron Frank: So I would say first they should reach out to you and you can tee them up to me, has that as a deal and what they want to talk about. All right? I'm gonna make you my I'm gonna make you my intermediary. Moses: That sounds great. That sounds great. I'm honored. Ron Frank: Look, Look, my my My lesson and I've spoken to students at Queens about it, but interestingly enough The alumni they try to bring back at Queens look a lot more like you than they look like me. They think people that are fifty plus years out of college, I mean I'm nineteen sixty-eight, let's do the math. Fifty. eight years out of college. Think about that. They think what I have to say isn't very relevant. Just so you know. I'll be curious whether anybody thinks it is. 'cause I've offered to speak and they go, actually, the students don't really want to talk to people like you anymore. And I'm like, okay, I can deal with that. you know, maybe I've my time has passed. But you know, to me I think Getting multiple viewpoints on issues from all kinds of different people is always a good thing. And you know, maybe this podcast will be helpful to some people. You know, my learnings, and I shared them the last time I was at Queens talking to students, which has to be seven or eight years ago now. My learnings, and think about the story I told you, are As you're in school, coming out of school, you gotta be awake. There's opportunities all around you, and I told you my crazy stories. You gotta be awake, you gotta be aware, and Moses: Mm-hmm. Ron Frank: you gotta be willing to be your own advocate and take action. And keep pushing forward to who you want to be and try to get there and try to push obstacles out of the way. Because trust me, there are a lot of obstacles out there. And it's the people that demonstrate tenacity and grit at dealing with them that are probably gonna find their way better than those who let the rapids define their life. So thank you for the opportunity today and reach out and let me know if anybody wants to talk and we'll discuss how. Moses: Of course. Thank you again so much for taking the time to s to hop on the podcast. I ru I really appreciate it a ton from the bottom of of my heart. Ron Frank: It's always a pleasure, Moses. You take care. Moses: Thank you so much. Ron Frank: Okay, bye now.