Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / False Accusation, Social Media Self-Harm, Attachment Parenting, and Nocebo
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deser own listeners. I thought I would answer patron emails, so
- 0:03let's get to it. As emails from patron Matt from Minneapolis, he says,
- 0:07Hey, Kirk, I just finished listening to your Duty to Warn deep
- 0:11dive and found it fascinating and very informative. I was wondering if duty to
- 0:16warn and protect standards could be applied if a patient uttered and showed serious intent
- 0:21to falsely accuse, falsely accused their partner of a crime physical or sexual abuse,
- 0:27for example, that they didn't commit. Do you think this hypothetical would
- 0:31beat the standards? End of email? Yeah, So for your listeners,
- 0:35if you want to listen to my ethical deep dives on duty to warn to
- 0:40protect, I would listen to those episodes. Pretty complicated depends on the jurisdiction
- 0:44and on case law, and there's a lot of uncertainty because these things aren't
- 0:49clearly delineated for us as clinicians. But to contemplate your question by first reaction
- 0:56is no, if I had a client tell me that they had a plan
- 1:00to accuse their you say it's a husband and he plans on falsely, he
- 1:07knows that he's going to lie to the authorities and say that his wife physically
- 1:11abused him, he's going to call the police, like they're going through a
- 1:14divorce, that's a custody case or something like that, and he's planning on
- 1:18doing that. Would I consider that to be a duty to protect issue.
- 1:22No, because it doesn't alert me to some seriously bought, serious bodily harm.
- 1:27Right, it's a serious issue, and of course I would talk with
- 1:32the client a lot about how they shouldn't be doing that. I mean,
- 1:36even if the client isn't necessarily asking me for that kind of feedback, that's
- 1:41just a moral issue that as a human being, you know, never mind
- 1:45that I'm a therapist in that moment. As a human being, I'm not
- 1:48going to just stand by and watch someone do that. Now, let's say
- 1:51you have a scenario where the husband has convincingly told me, maybe even I
- 1:56have corroborating evidence and reports stating that the wife is massively abusive to the kids
- 2:04but has gotten off scott free, and so the husband has to lie to
- 2:09get custody of the kids or something. You know, I don't know.
- 2:12It's I don't run into those situations ever so or at least to my memory,
- 2:17So I don't know what I do, but could I wonder about my
- 2:22duty to protect in this situation? And sure, this is such a rare
- 2:27circumstance that I would absolutely call my attorney and ask her what she thought about
- 2:35it. And you know, if you have a good attorney who knows what
- 2:38they're doing in the area of clinical malpractice, then they will just walk through
- 2:44all the different laws and case precedent and ethical codes and considerations, and you,
- 2:52of course document all that, and maybe in the end the lawyer and
- 2:55I would conclude that this was nestsary for me to report. You know,
- 3:01I, for example, if that did come up, I guess the justification
- 3:06and I would tell the client this. I would say, look, you
- 3:07told me last session that you were going to falsely accuse your wife of sexually
- 3:12abusing your kids, or physically abusing you or the kids or something. And
- 3:16I thought about it, I asked my attorney. I consulted, and under
- 3:22normal circumstances, I would uphold confidentiality, of course, because that is a
- 3:25value and an ethical code. But in this circumstance, I believe that I
- 3:31have a duty based on course, court precedent and ethical codes, and also
- 3:37just morally speaking, to do what I can to stop you from doing that.
- 3:43Now, if you can convince me that you're not going to do it,
- 3:46then I won't have to take action like this. But if you continue
- 3:50to go down this road of planning on making this false allegation and you refuse
- 3:54to refrain from doing it, I will have to call the Who would I
- 4:01call? I guess i'd call the partner, because you can't. You can't
- 4:04call the police on someone for well, I guess you could if if it
- 4:08was a police report that my client was making, for example, I guess
- 4:11I would call the police and say, by the way, my client made
- 4:14this false allegation. I know it's false because the client told me that they
- 4:18were going to make a false allegation. And the reason why I am compelled
- 4:23to do this not only for moral grounds, but also because I have a
- 4:27duty to protect And if you made this allegation, there's a chance that this
- 4:32an individual because of a false allegation, could go to prison for a long
- 4:36time and be physically harmed. And so I'm interpreting the case precedent of duty
- 4:43to protect it that way. So end of role play, what I does
- 4:47that sound right? To me, no, Might I still do that anyway
- 4:50and not actually invoke the duty to protect? Might I just say, look,
- 4:55I just can't stand by and have you do this. And I suppose
- 5:00if you want to sue me because I broke confidentiality, then I guess I'll
- 5:06cross that bridge when we get to it. But I can't stand by and
- 5:10watch you make this false allegation. You know, I don't know. I've
- 5:15been in similar situations, like I'll have a client that's cheating on their spouse,
- 5:18for example, and I am inside feeling morally torn because I don't want
- 5:29that harm to happen to their partner. And so I mean what I always
- 5:33will say, and I'll say this to the client. It's like, you
- 5:36either in order to be in order to have integrity, I might depends on
- 5:42what word they use, But if, for example, the client tends the
- 5:46word tends to use the word integrity, I would say, in order to
- 5:48uphold your own integrity, in your own vision of yourself as a good human
- 5:53being, you either have to tell your partner that you're doing this, or
- 5:58you have to worse your partner, or you have to break up with the
- 6:02cheating person. You have to stop cheating and start repairing your relationship. But
- 6:08you can't just continue in this zone where you're married and tricking your partner and
- 6:14cheating and just staying in that limbo. That's you're causing tremendous harm for everyone,
- 6:20including yourself. It's just not a good system. Maybe polyamory is an
- 6:25answer. I don't know, but you can't stay in this zone. So
- 6:29I have had that conversation. I don't know if i'd say you can't stay,
- 6:33but I would, I would be pretty pointed, and I have.
- 6:36I've had I don't know how many other therapists do this. I have a
- 6:41suspicion anecdotally anyway, that I'm a bit of a rare person in this way.
- 6:46But I don't just stand by and watch people do things that are destructive
- 6:49to other people. I'm not going to reject the client. I'm not going
- 6:55to chastise the client. You could argue, I guess I'm kind of judging
- 6:59that, But I'm not judging their personality. I'm I'm judging their behavior.
- 7:02I'm calling their behavior what it is. It's harmful, it's immoral, it's
- 7:05wrong to knowingly harm another human being. It's just it's just wrong, and
- 7:09cheating is knowingly doing something that is harming another human being. It depends,
- 7:14right if the cheating person, the cheating partner, is being abused by their
- 7:18partner. You know, there are circumstances where I wouldn't consider it as much
- 7:24of a moral problem or even a moral problem at all. But you know,
- 7:28in the classic cheating scenario, it's it's immoral, it's wrong. It'd
- 7:30be the same as if a client told me that they were stealing from their
- 7:34partner, or pushing their partner down the stairs, or neglecting their kids on
- 7:39purpose or something. You know, there's just things that I'm I'm going to
- 7:43say because it's just I just can't stand by and watch bad things. If
- 7:47a client says something racist or sexist, you know, I'll just call it
- 7:51out. And if that sacrifices their relationship and they don't want to talk with
- 7:56me again, then that's fine. But that's not usually I've never had that
- 7:59happen. I would gauge the relationship strength. I would choose my words carefully,
- 8:03I'd choose my tone carefully, and in my experience, it deepens the
- 8:07relationship because they know that I'm being honest with them. They know that I'm
- 8:11authentic and I'm real, and I'm trying to make them a better person.
- 8:16I'm trying to make them live a life that is more in line with their
- 8:20values, with integrity and love and compassion and health. But anyway, getting
- 8:26back to your question, I don't think duty to protect applies there, but
- 8:30you know you could make an argument that it does, all right. Sex
- 8:31question is from Patron Calvin. He writes, how have social media communities like
- 8:39Tumbler influence self harm among adolescents? End of question? Well, I don't
- 8:46know the research. I'm sure there is research on this, but I do
- 8:50know that non suicidal, non suicidal self injury or self harm is influenced by
- 8:56peers. It can be can be influenced by societal norms. For people who
- 9:03are susceptible to this coping technique or behavior acting out behavior, they if they
- 9:09see it in other people, they're more likely, according to science, to
- 9:15do it themselves. And also, on the opposite side of the coin,
- 9:18if no one around them is doing it and they're doing it, they're more
- 9:22likely to try to stop so. But there are many more factors that are
- 9:26at play when people engage in non suicidal self injury that have nothing to do
- 9:30with influence from the outside or social media. Usually people use non suicidal self
- 9:35injury because they are suffering greatly emotionally and they've tried a lot of different things
- 9:41to reduce that emotional pain. And it's real pain. The emotional pain is
- 9:46the same center in the brain that is involved in physical pain. So you
- 9:50know, it's it's very, very painful emotional pain, and it's ongoing,
- 9:54and it's it's plaguing, and you know, they try all sorts of things.
- 9:58They I don't know, deep breathing, they try therapy, they try
- 10:03maybe even medication. They try relaxation or something. Nothing seems to work,
- 10:07hanging out with their friends, dressing more. You know, they might think,
- 10:11well, if I have more acceptance from my peers, maybe I'll feel
- 10:15better about myself. That doesn't work, and then they hear about it,
- 10:18or they just stumble upon it that cutting or other kinds of self injury will
- 10:22temporarily change the brain chemistry, or at least it'll distract them from their pain
- 10:30or relieve their pain temporarily. It's not something that they're in love with.
- 10:33They're not like, yeay, I want to do this. It's out of
- 10:35desperation. So when these individuals get the treatment that they deserve, then they
- 10:41no longer need non suicidal self injury. Now it can become addicting, and
- 10:46that's an issue. And I've treated many people with an SSI and successfully help
- 10:50them to kick the habit and get the trauma treatment that they need. It
- 10:54can take years and years, of course, And there are also a very
- 10:58small set of people who engage in this who are doing it because other people
- 11:03are doing it. They think that it's cool or whatever. That's a very
- 11:07very small percentage. A lot of people think that's the majority of people,
- 11:11but it's not according to science. I don't know the exact percentage, but
- 11:13you know, you're talking in the order of like three percent or some pretty
- 11:16pretty low amount of people who engage in NSSI are doing it because they're trying
- 11:22to fit in. And in my experience, the people that are doing it
- 11:24for that reason, they are doing it very briefly and superficially because they don't
- 11:31really have a need for it. And there's a lot of consequences to doing
- 11:33it. You know, there's pain, there's blood, there's possible infection.
- 11:37You know, scarring, so they're not willing to have those consequences just to
- 11:43fit in, you know, so they might engage in some mild scratching or
- 11:48something and it will just last for maybe a few months. It's just a
- 11:50phase they're going through typically, So could tumble or influence people in both those
- 11:58ways. Yeah, I could see that absolutely happening. I don't know the
- 12:01data on it off the top of my head, though, and I could
- 12:03see it going one of two ways. On social media places like tumbler in
- 12:07that people might be legit suffering and as a part of their therapy or a
- 12:13part of their raising awareness about something that they might talk about an SSI non
- 12:18suicidal self injury as an educational tool or just as a vlog or you know,
- 12:24it's just part of their life that they're talking about among all the other
- 12:28things they're talking about in their life, and that could influence. But there's
- 12:33also social media accounts where people purposely will create accounts to talk about the sort
- 12:39of stuff that's their whole reason for being on social media is not only talking
- 12:43about this one thing an SSI, but also potentially glorifying it. I see
- 12:48this as a product of raising awareness as we raise awareness of an SSI,
- 12:54and that's a good thing that we're raising awareness and educating people and helping people
- 12:58get help. Then you're going to see these anomalous societal effects. And it's
- 13:05sort of like as we raise awareness for abuse and gaslighting the word, or
- 13:11just abuse in general, or psychology in general, which is a good thing,
- 13:15right, raising awareness education about psychology and relationships and abuse and victimization.
- 13:20Then as a side effect of that, an unfortunate side effect, but one
- 13:26that you just can't get rid of, is that people on the Internet,
- 13:31people in society are going to bastardize the terms thereof i e. Gaslighting.
- 13:35The fact that anyone even knows what gaslighting is to begin with, even just
- 13:39as a word, is astonishing to me because I've been using this term and
- 13:46other terms and the field of intimate partner violence for over twenty five years and
- 13:50the public didn't seem to care at all about any of the stuff. Suddenly
- 13:54the Internet knows a lot about the source of stuff, which is good,
- 13:58and we're raising a lot awareness and a lot of people are to get recovered,
- 14:01a lot of people are helping get out of relationships like this. We're
- 14:03also helping perpetrators to not do this sort of thing. This is all good,
- 14:05but as an unfortunate side effect, you have a lot of people online
- 14:09completely bastardizing the term gas lighting because they learned the basics of it, and
- 14:13then it just became a meme through society and anyway. So with non suicidal
- 14:20self injury, we're raising awareness, we're getting people to help, and as
- 14:22an unfortunate side effect, you have some people that are using NSSI as a
- 14:26marketing tool. They are doing it or acting like they're doing it, and
- 14:31trying to get other people to agree that it's not a bad thing. Right,
- 14:37there's a justification for it. They will glorify it. They'll say like,
- 14:41don't listen to the doctors. They you know, we love this and
- 14:45obviously that's not great, and we need to do what we can to protect
- 14:50children and really everyone from this information. And these social media platforms probably have
- 14:56a responsibility around that sort of thing. I would say they have responsibility around,
- 15:01you know, deleting or getting that sort of content off of their platforms.
- 15:07I don't know what to do about that, but so yeah, that's
- 15:11what I say about that, all right, So combing through the document with
- 15:16all the emails looking for questions I haven't answered recently. We have an email
- 15:22from anonymous patron in Italy. He says, Hi, doctor Hannah. Whenever
- 15:26I get into a relationship, I become kind of dependent on the other person's
- 15:31presence in my life, especially their warmth. My girlfriend is a doctor and
- 15:33works up to thirteen hours per day, and when she gets stressed by working
- 15:37so much, she gets in She goes into an autopilot version of herself,
- 15:41and she gets distant and cold with me. I know she loves me,
- 15:43and our relationship is not in danger, but the lack of warmth from her
- 15:48puts me in such distress and sorrow that sometimes I reach the point of contemplating
- 15:52suicide. I have never attempted, though I feel empty, lonely, and
- 15:56I lose interest in everything. I check my phone every minute for her messages,
- 16:00and I feel like a black hole in my chest that absorbs everything and
- 16:04strangles me. All this, all of this drops as soon as she says
- 16:08something nice to me, for example, that she misses me, or when
- 16:11she apologizes for being so distant. Where can I find inside myself the warmth
- 16:17she can't give me in those moments if that's what I need and of email.
- 16:21Yeah, that's a great question, and I think a lot of people
- 16:23listening right now could relate at least to a part of this. And this
- 16:30is a very important question. You have a lot of self awareness, a
- 16:33lot of differentiation. Instead of blaming her, which would be the undifferentiated response,
- 16:38like you're such a called person, you're like, well, she's a
- 16:44doctor and she works a lot, and it's normal for her to get kind
- 16:47of stressed out and go into autopilot. And yet I am suffering because I'm
- 16:53alone with my thoughts and I have a lot of emotional issues with this.
- 17:00So it's good that you have that self awareness. But the question that you
- 17:03have is a very common question, but the question is misguided. Your question
- 17:08is how do you find inside yourself the warmth? You can't. None of
- 17:12us can find attachment security alone. So the answer is corrective experiences around making
- 17:26you know that people are there for you. I'm guessing you went through a
- 17:30lot of abandonment or trauma growing up that made you feel as though known was
- 17:33there for you, and so you don't have that inner resource because you never
- 17:38experienced it externally. The things we have on the inside of us. The
- 17:41resources we have on the inside of us, according to me anyway, are
- 17:47largely dependent on experiences that we went through. We aren't just like for me,
- 17:52for example, I'm just I'm not naturally confident. I wasn't born with
- 17:56the ability to soothe myself when I'm lonely. These are things that I internalized
- 18:02from the outside because people attune to me and made me feel safe. I
- 18:07over time eventually internalize that and now just have an inner resource to soothe myself
- 18:12when I feel danger. So you have to experience, you can't find it
- 18:18on the inside. Could you maybe do a little bit along those lines to
- 18:22reassure yourself why they are cognitions you can participate in. Yeah, but if
- 18:26you're really going to cure yourself, the answer is long term therapy with a
- 18:32therapist that understands corrective experiences, that understands how to help you with this internalization.
- 18:38And that's the answer. And I know that isn't a great answer,
- 18:42because it wouldn't it be nice if I could just give you this little tip.
- 18:45You know, the internet is full of that kind of crap, like,
- 18:48well, just read a book or watch a movie or have a nice
- 18:55meal, or call a friend, or write a song or something. Psych
- 18:59Okay, maybe, but not in my experience. Those things might help a
- 19:03little bit. But the thing that will really help is if you have,
- 19:07say five to ten year intense relationship with the therapist who really helps you to
- 19:15recover from the traumas that you went through. Having said that, anyone in
- 19:19this situation would be hurt. Maybe not to the extent that you are where
- 19:25you're contemplating suicide, but you know, I go through this with my wife.
- 19:29Sometimes she will get stressed out. And you know, Bob talks about
- 19:33this as well with his wife, that when Stacy or Calleen Bob's wife,
- 19:40when they get stressed out, they kind of shut down, and that it
- 19:45feels distant and cold. And I've learned that about my wife and know that
- 19:51it's not I don't take it personally. You know, for a long time
- 19:55I thought, is she actually does? She actually not like me? But
- 20:00we talked about it, and I differentiated as best I could, and we
- 20:07tried to understand each other as best we could. And over time I've learned,
- 20:10oh this she shuts down. She actually that's not the only thing she
- 20:15does when she's stressed out. But that is one of the things, and
- 20:18so I do my best to interpret it differently, and for the most part,
- 20:22I succeed at that, but it doesn't take away the loneliness. But
- 20:26I have other things that I can do right well. One, I have
- 20:29my parents that attune to me a lot that I can turn to. On
- 20:33the inside, I don't have that black hole inside of me because my parents
- 20:37fulfilled my attachment needs throughout my lifetime. But also I will turn to other
- 20:44people, other attachments. If it was really bad, I suppose I would
- 20:48go back to therapy, you know. So I know to lean into other
- 20:53people. And that's the impulse I have when I have those moments where I
- 20:57feel neglected and I don't have an avenue to re engage with Stacy, I
- 21:04e gauge in other attachments Bob Mbarto, other people in my life, my
- 21:08parents. I turn to those relationships to soothe me and to make me feel
- 21:14secure, to make me feel grounded, to make me feel accepted and loved
- 21:18in having that warmth in my life. So there's a possibility that you have
- 21:22a lot of eggs in that one basket, which is your partner, which
- 21:26is probably going to cause a cyclical problem like this because one, there's just
- 21:33a natural ebb and flow to a relationship even in best of times. But
- 21:37also since she's a doctor and works up to thirteen hours a day, I
- 21:41mean, you know, she's not going to have the capacity, and depending
- 21:45on where she is at in her training, it could literally be five ten
- 21:49years of this into the future, maybe even the rest of her career.
- 21:52I mean, some physicians are absolute workaholics along these lines, and there's a
- 21:56lot of culture of that in the medical profession. So you know, therapy
- 22:02and other attachments is the answer. There's probably not an answer to the question
- 22:07what where can I find in myself to soothe myself? Because you have to
- 22:11internalize it from the outside. And even for me, even though I was
- 22:18raised pretty well, there's no way I could only rely on myself for attachment,
- 22:22security and an affection and warmth. There's no amount of inner resources that
- 22:27would make it so that I could just be completely emotionally neglected for an extended
- 22:32period of time and feel good about it. All right, it stick a
- 22:34break, We'll get back more emails. All right, we're back from the
- 22:41break. Anonymous patron from Bend, Oregon. She wrote in and says,
- 22:47can you be parentified by your mother at the age of thirty two? End
- 22:51of the question, And the answer is yeah. Absolutely. One could be
- 22:56parentified off and on throughout one's life and then have an intensive period of prentification
- 23:02at age thirty two. Or you could have never been preentified throughout your life
- 23:07and then suddenly be prentified. It's easier to prentify a child, and it's
- 23:14more common but apparent. For example, could be struggling with something relational chaos
- 23:19or a medical problem or self esteem issues and really rely on a thirty two
- 23:27year old adult child to pick up the pieces to overfunction for their underfunctioning and
- 23:33pressure the thirty two year old adult child to do so. And then the
- 23:37thirty two year old child would feel all the negative effects of the prentification,
- 23:41the resentment, the anger that trapped, feeling that being pushed into a position
- 23:47of over responsibility, and a lot of self blame. Prentified kids will self
- 23:52blame a lot. So yeah, absolutely, It's not common for prentification to
- 23:56come out of nowhere like that, but it happens for sure. A right
- 24:02sixth email is from anonymous patron from Germany. She says, Dear doctor Kirk,
- 24:07my husband, who is American, is avoiding, attached, and I
- 24:12am preoccupied. We can always talk about my feelings. He attends to my
- 24:18needs and has provided a corrective experience for me. However, he can't access
- 24:22his emotions his own emotions. If you ask him how he's doing, he'll
- 24:26always say that he is just good. His father was diagnosed with terminal cancer.
- 24:32He doesn't talk about it. He barely tries to figure out what his
- 24:34father is doing, even though he often sees his parents. I try to
- 24:38talk with him about his feelings about his father's diagnosis, as his family doesn't
- 24:44seem to really talk with him about it, but he won't talk. I
- 24:47have kind of given up and just told him that I'm always there for him,
- 24:51but that I don't want to bother him anymore. This lack of communication
- 24:55makes me insecure and starts to make me preoccupied about our relationship bad talking about
- 25:00my own feelings while he is going through this. How can I help him
- 25:03to talk about his feelings or grief with him? Also, he does not
- 25:07want to go to therapy PS. He got my premium subscription last year to
- 25:12the podcast for Christmas, which was a great and thoughtful gift. I love
- 25:17the podcast, learned so much about me in my relationship. Thank you and
- 25:21an email. Yeah, tough situation. You know, you can lead a
- 25:23horse to water, you can't make him drink. You can suggest someone go
- 25:29to therapy, but you can't make him go. You can suggest they talk
- 25:33about their feelings, but you can't make him talk. And the first thing
- 25:37though, that I'll say is that you're very differentiated. You have a lot
- 25:40of self awareness and a lot of compassion. That's good. You can use
- 25:44that to your advantage. And you recognize that he is, in all likelihood
- 25:49having a lot of grief feelings, a lot of worry, a lot of
- 25:52pain or something, and that he doesn't talk about it. He doesn't talk
- 25:56about his family, he doesn't talk about it with himself and talk about a
- 26:00therapist. He doesn't talk about with you. He doesn't express his emotions,
- 26:03and you're worried about him. So that's good. You feel compassion. You're
- 26:07worry that he's going to bust at the seams, which is the worry,
- 26:11right. Alcoholism can develop from that all sorts of things, physical ailments.
- 26:18The other thing that you're experiencing. Is that, due to your preoccupied attachment,
- 26:22you are distorting this scenario as evidence that he's going to leave you.
- 26:30That's why your preoccupation is becoming triggered. Right, you're saying that it's making
- 26:36you wonder, See where did you say it makes you preoccupied about the relationship.
- 26:41It starts to make you worry that the relationship is going to come to
- 26:45an end. That is a distortion that's based on your preoccupation. It's based
- 26:48on your relational traumas you're transferring onto your displacing. You're projecting, you're seeing
- 26:53something based on your description. I can't know obviously in this week talk,
- 26:57but based on your description, that's what you're describing. You're describing that you're
- 27:02you're distorting him shutting down from the pain and the lack of repertoire or lack
- 27:11of habit, lack of know how, lack of safety, I mean avoiding
- 27:17people. They don't avoid feelings just because they feel like it. They avoid
- 27:19it because they're terrified. They avoid their feelings because they don't feel safe feeling
- 27:25their feelings. When they were young, when they were twelve months old,
- 27:27eighteen months old, they had all the normal feelings, but due to lack
- 27:32of attunement, they were just left on their own to have their feelings and
- 27:36it felt very unsafe and it felt very lonely to them, and so emotions
- 27:41to them are terrifying at an avenue to get more rejection. You know,
- 27:45it's one thing to be rejected, it's another thing to reach out and then
- 27:49get rejected. Right Like, if you are at the dance at the high
- 27:55school dance and you have low self esteem and you think no one to dance
- 28:00with you, that's one thing. But if you actually walk across the room
- 28:03and ask someone to dance with you and they shut you down and everyone laughs
- 28:07at you, that's ten times worse. Right, Well, that's the avoidant
- 28:11person. They just sit on the sidelines, so they don't ask because they're
- 28:15they're pretty sure they're going to get rejected, So why ask, and why
- 28:18even go to the dance to begin with? I'll just stay home. That's
- 28:22what avoidant people do. They're sad and lonely and scared of being rejected in
- 28:27the same way that preoccupied people are, but they just express it in a
- 28:30different way. Right, it's avoidant. It's a you know, attachment insecurity.
- 28:34They're insecure about attachment, and so for these people it's you know,
- 28:38it's it's hard, and it's not an indication that he's going to leave you
- 28:42though, right that is your preoccupied voice telling you that it is. Now
- 28:48what do you do? Well, like I said, you can lead a
- 28:52horse to water, you can't make a drink, So you can't make him
- 28:56be different. And I understand the impulse. I have that impulse too.
- 29:00I see people that are close to me in my life where I'm just like,
- 29:03there's a better way to do this, and I might try to influence
- 29:07them, but at the end of the day, they have to make a
- 29:11choice, and you can do everything you can to convince them within reason,
- 29:14but if they don't take the bait, then that's just the breaks. That's
- 29:18that's their life. It's their choice. It's there. You know, they
- 29:21can dig their own graves, so to speak. I suppose I don't want
- 29:22to be that dark, but you know, they have their own path that
- 29:26they're on and you just have to accept it, have to differentiate from that.
- 29:29It's like, well, their problem is their problem, and I've done
- 29:32everything I can to help them. But if they don't want that help.
- 29:36Then they don't want that. The other thing that I tell myself is,
- 29:40well, what do I know? Maybe this is for the best, and
- 29:42I might ask you. I might tell yourself that same thing. Anonymous patron
- 29:47in Germany is just say, maybe maybe this is best for him. Maybe
- 29:52for him the best path given his personality is to avoid it, and then
- 29:59maybe he'll revisit it in five years. I don't know. Maybe that's or
- 30:02maybe he is visiting it in his mind, in his way, and he
- 30:04just doesn't want to share it with me. I don't know how would I
- 30:08possibly know what's best for him. I know what I would be doing if
- 30:11I were in issues, but I can't really know what's best for him.
- 30:15I have my suspicions, but I can't really know the answer. So you
- 30:18want to be careful about drawing firm conclusions. I'm a therapist. I'm pretty
- 30:23pompous about my point of view, and yet when I'm at my best,
- 30:27I will say that to myself with clients or people in my life or even
- 30:32myself. I'm just like, well, I can't really know what's best here.
- 30:36I just have a guess. The other thing is to maybe do what
- 30:40you've done already and continue to do it, but do it in a way
- 30:45that feels good to you and is non pressuring. Is to tell him how
- 30:51you feel. You know, You're like, it feels weird for me to
- 30:53tell him how I feel, even though I'm trying to make him talk about
- 30:57how he feels. And because this is what I'm this way, I'm a
- 31:02level I like to level with people. I don't It doesn't always work.
- 31:07I always think it's going to work, but it doesn't always work. But
- 31:11I try to level with people, and so I might every when it seems
- 31:15like it's bubbling up inside of you and it seems like you have the space
- 31:18to talk about it, you just turned to him, you just like,
- 31:22Hey, you know, I just want to tell you that I don't want
- 31:25to pressure you. I don't want to tell you what to do. I
- 31:26don't know what's best for you. I can only take guesses to what's best
- 31:32for you. But I don't know. But I do know for myself that
- 31:36as I'm watching you and your dad, your dad is he has terminal cancer.
- 31:41He's going to die, and he's my father in law. So I
- 31:47have a lot of feelings about that and I have a lot of sadness and
- 31:51worry and grief and sorrow about losing him and about him his suffering, and
- 32:00it just it just causes all those feelings. And I have those feelings all
- 32:05the time. And I also am suspicious that or I imagine that you have
- 32:12those feelings times one hundred, because this is your dad, and I worry
- 32:15about your dad because he is dying, and that is got to be an
- 32:22emotional roller coaster. And so that's my observation. That's what I imagine.
- 32:30But what I see is you and your dad. You don't even talk about
- 32:34it seemingly, and I don't know, but I just would imagine that all
- 32:39those feelings are just being bottled up and it's going to cause a problem.
- 32:43You know. It could cause you to suffer unnecessarily. It could cause you
- 32:46to miss an opportunity to communicate about something that you always wanted to communicate before
- 32:52he died. It could cause you to have physical ailments or sleep problems,
- 32:55and you know, I don't know. I don't want to presume that about
- 32:58you, but I love you, and I worry about you. I love
- 33:00your dad. I worry about him, and I'm just throwing it out there,
- 33:04but I you know, you know me, I'm preoccupied. I worry
- 33:07all the time. And sometimes when you do this, and I know this
- 33:14isn't rational, it feels kind of like you're gonna leave me, because if
- 33:19you're gonna shut down those feelings, it makes me worry that you're going to
- 33:22shut down all your feelings, including your love for me. And I know
- 33:24that's not rational, but I sometimes feel that way sometimes, and so that's
- 33:30why I will get a little moody around you sometimes when I see you doing
- 33:35this, so you can respond to what I'm saying. Now, you can
- 33:42respond. Later you could not respond. I'm not requiring anything of you,
- 33:45and it just it feels good for me to get this off my chest.
- 33:50But what do you think? And then let's say he just says, I
- 33:52don't know, I'm just trying to get to work, or I'm just you
- 33:55know, I just I don't like to talk about the kind of stuff.
- 33:58And then you then you say, okay, you know totally, that's you're
- 34:01on your path. You know, I'm just going to throw it out there
- 34:05that therapy could help, or talking about your feelings could help, or bonding
- 34:08with your dad in a deeper way, an emotional way, or whatever way
- 34:14the two of you communicate these kinds of things. I don't know, it's
- 34:16just a good opportunity to do that since he'll be gone soon in all likelihood,
- 34:22which is horrible to think about. I just I love you and I
- 34:27don't want bad things to happen to you emotionally, and you know, I
- 34:31just and you might start crying or whatever, and so end of role play
- 34:36in that you're you're getting it off your chest. You might be modeling how
- 34:40to emote to him. You might be leading him to water and helping him
- 34:46to see that that health lies in him actively grieving in his way. And
- 34:53the other possibility, you know, when I talk about the science of grief,
- 34:58is that we understand actually studying human beings that they will fascinate between two
- 35:04modes. One is grieving and one is rebuilding. And the rebuilding phase is
- 35:07to not think about the loss and to not feel the feelings and not reminisce
- 35:12to not talk about it. And there's a possibility that in his way,
- 35:16he is going to be in a rebuilding phase for a while, and that
- 35:22the grieving phase will start at some point or will emerge in a little short
- 35:27burst or something. So it's hard to know where he's at with that.
- 35:30You know, there's this One of the things that I would see in my
- 35:35early career when I used to treat kids was parents would drop their kid off
- 35:39and they would say, this kid went through a huge loss recently, you
- 35:45know, Grandma died or dad died, or a divorce happened, and this
- 35:50kid refuses to grieve, and so I need you, therapist to make this
- 35:53kid grieve. They wouldn't phrase it that way, but that's basically what they
- 35:57were saying. And I had a lot of cases like that, and I
- 36:02understand the worry, you know, that a parent would have about a kid.
- 36:07You know, say dad dies and mom is with kids, and mom
- 36:13notices that little Johnny is not grieving and thinks, well, that can't be
- 36:19right, that there's got to be something wrong there, and well, I'll
- 36:22take him to therapy and a therapist will make him grieve. It will help
- 36:25him to grieve. And in those situations, I would eventually come to realize
- 36:31that it's not a good idea to force a kid to grieve right now.
- 36:37I might lead them to water, and I might create an environment where grieving
- 36:42might be possible, but people have different needs at different times, and so
- 36:46you know, for example, it's not uncommon if you're a kid to say,
- 36:52if you're one of your parents died, it's not uncommon to not really
- 36:55begin grieving in in earnest so you're twenty five, thirty five years old or
- 37:01something. Maybe when you actually reach the age of your parent when they died,
- 37:06that's when the grief really kicks in. So there's that. Also,
- 37:09it's not uncommon for kids, when they're given enough of a venue to fully
- 37:15grieve, just like anyone else in the moment, right to cry and to
- 37:17create and to talk about and reminisce and to obsess and to feel the pain.
- 37:22You know, that's that's another thing that kids will do. I'm not
- 37:25going to generalize, but anyway, my point is is that you just don't
- 37:30really know what's best for him. In your email, it sounds like you
- 37:34you know what's best rum Now, I would agree with you and your speculation
- 37:37that your idea of what's good for him is probably true, but you just
- 37:42can't really know as the point, and you want to have that bound or
- 37:46you want to give him that space because he deserves it, but also because
- 37:52that might actually help him, because a classic preoccupied avoidant dynamic is the preoccupied
- 37:58person will feel all the feeling for the system, and the avoidant doesn't have
- 38:01any room to few feelings because the preoccupied person is taking up all that all
- 38:07that job responsibility, and the avoidant person will sometimes feel like, well,
- 38:13someone has to be strong, someone has to be rational, so that'll be
- 38:17me. So you don't want to do that. You don't want to have
- 38:22your feelings take over his feelings, his opportunity. Now he is responsible for
- 38:29his own feelings and his own reactivity. But until he gets treatment, you
- 38:34have to kind of work with what you got. So I don't know.
- 38:37That's my response to that. All right, let stick a break, a
- 38:43right back from the break, let's do an opp These people became patrons all
- 38:47the way back in twenty twenty and of state patrons through thick and thin.
- 38:52We have Charlie and Antonin and Dina and Michelle and Liz and a Lease and
- 39:00Cindy and Carl and Snow and Brandy and Caitlin from god knows where. We
- 39:07have Nilla from Great Britain. We have Vicky from Canada, Quebec. We
- 39:14have Sash from Black Lick, Ohio. Black Lick, Ohio. We have
- 39:20Madeline from Seattle. Do I know you, Madeline. We have Ilulrica from
- 39:25Stockholm, Sweden. We have Lizard Queen from Philadelphia, PA. We had
- 39:31Advocat from San Diego. We have Rus from Belmont, Massachusetts. We have
- 39:37Marlina from Minnesota, Richmond, Minnesota, annual patron Marline. We have Sara
- 39:40from Helsinki in Finland. We have Dan from Norfolk, Norfolk, Virginia.
- 39:46If Leslie from Handsville, Washington, Good Old Handsville, Washington. We have
- 39:51Janny from Denmark. We have Willow from We have Uppertier patron Willow from Texas.
- 39:57We have Uppertier patren cat from Rogue River, Ohio or sorry Oregon,
- 40:02Rogue River, Oregon. I mean that is just a Netflix drama TV show
- 40:08waiting to happen, right, you just got to have a TV show called
- 40:12Rogue River. And we also have Lee from Columbia, South Carolina. Thank
- 40:19y'all for being a patron through thick and thin all right. Sext email is
- 40:22from Kaylee patron Kayley from Cleveland. She says, how can I explain to
- 40:28my older family members? That I want to create a secure attachment with my
- 40:32child without sounding judgmental of their parenting style. Whenever my six year old cries,
- 40:37I either pick him up or do whatever I need to do in order
- 40:40to calm him down. I believe I am creating a secure attachment with him,
- 40:45but my older relatives often criticize me, saying that I spoil him or
- 40:49he needs to figure it out by himself to become independent. In the past,
- 40:53I've just told them I don't believe in crying it out and left it
- 40:57at that, because I don't feel I can eloquently plain attachment theory in a
- 41:00few words without seeming resentful of the way I was raised or that I'm criticizing
- 41:05them. How should I explain this to them or is it even worth explaining?
- 41:08Hope to hear from you. Thank you, doctor Honda. End of
- 41:12email. Yeah, this is a great question. I think this happens a
- 41:15lot. But I applaud your efforts, kay Lee, to raise your kid
- 41:21right and even in the face of judgment and criticism, direct criticism from other
- 41:25people in your family. And yeah, this is a pretty common issue.
- 41:31I don't know what to do, obviously, that is a strategy worth considering
- 41:36of just like I'm just not going to get into it with them. I'm
- 41:38going to parent my kid the way that I want to, and if they're
- 41:42going to criticize me, I don't know, fuck them whatever. But another
- 41:47so, the middle road isn't a very good road either, which is I
- 41:51think what most people take, which is that they will very briefly try to
- 41:54explain to people, you know, like I don't believe in cry it out.
- 41:58That's not going to get at across it. If it's possible to attain
- 42:02this, I would consider the following, which is the end of the road.
- 42:07What we're trying to get to is where they understand what attachment theory is.
- 42:14They understand what good parenting is not only just for their own edvocation,
- 42:19but maybe even for their own kids, right, maybe even for their own
- 42:22relational trauma awareness. Right. So it's a tall order, but you know
- 42:28it could happen. Stranger things have happened in the world, and you would
- 42:31want them to do that so they'd stop criticizing you. The other thing is
- 42:35is in all likelihood you're going to have to rely on them to help you
- 42:38with parenting. Right now, once the kid gets past a certain age,
- 42:44it becomes less of an issue. But I don't know it could help,
- 42:49right, It takes a village. At the same time, you don't want
- 42:52to alienate your parents because if you talk about proper parenting, your parents might
- 42:59reflect on their own style of parenting you and they could be hurt by that
- 43:04or threatened and maybe get defensive or feel ashamed or something. And sounds like
- 43:07you don't want that either, So how do you get there? Well,
- 43:12it sounds ridiculous, but why not, right, It just depends on what
- 43:15you're willing to, what sort of campaign you're willing to go on. And
- 43:20one of the things you can do is actually have them listen to the attachment
- 43:25Deep Dive or have I actually have an episode on attachment parenting actually that they
- 43:31might be able to listen to. Or you get a book or something,
- 43:34or maybe there's some YouTube videos that are short and sweet and you can show
- 43:37them that, or just sit them down to say, hey, I'm not
- 43:40a professional, but I do know enough about attachment theory an attachment parenting to
- 43:47tell you the following. I'm not going to be super eloquent, but I
- 43:51just want you to listen to me. Talk for about fifteen minutes while I
- 43:54tell you what I've learned and what I'd like to do, And then as
- 43:58you're talking about the principles of it, maybe you jot down a couple of
- 44:01bullet points or something and you say, the reason why I want you to
- 44:05know this is because I want you to be involved in parenting and taking care
- 44:08of my kid. I also don't want you to criticize me anymore. At
- 44:12the very sad I don't want you to look at me and judge me as
- 44:15being a terrible parent, because it's actually a misnomer in our society that to
- 44:21create an independent child you need to start making them independent at six months,
- 44:25which I just have to say, I mean, come on, people,
- 44:28six month old baby, you're going to turn into an independent creature? I
- 44:32mean, what the fuck? And yeah, you might actually do that by
- 44:37emotionally neglecting a child, you might make them pathologically independent, but they will
- 44:43be like that other person's husband who literally never talks about their emotions and never
- 44:46reaches out and shuts down at every opportunity. So obviously that's not good right
- 44:52anyway. But the other thing that you might want to say or have to
- 44:54say feel compelled to say is you say, And I just want to say
- 45:00that overall you raised me really well, and I think because of the way
- 45:06you were raised by parents that caused too much independence too early, you also
- 45:12raised me in that way, and overall you raised me great. But if
- 45:15I had one asterisk to your parenting style, it was that you raised me
- 45:22and my siblings to be too independent too early. And I know that was
- 45:28the prevailing wisdom. Almost all parents in the United States parented that way.
- 45:32And I'm not like permanently damage or anything, but I do walk around with
- 45:37a fair amount of what I believe to be results because of that. I
- 45:42walk around with a fair amount of anxiety. I walk around with the fair
- 45:45amount of low self esteem. And I believe and research shows this, according
- 45:50to the experts, that when you properly and fully attune and help a kid
- 45:55up until the age of say two or three years old, then they feel
- 46:00fulfilled. And when you give them that reassurance and that soothing, then they're
- 46:06able to soothe themselves after and actually become more independent. If you want to
- 46:10create an independent child, then you want to attend it to their dependence enough
- 46:16when they're very young such that they don't need you around all the time when
- 46:22they start growing up. That's the idea. Kids who are very clingy and
- 46:27overly dependent on their parents are kids, according to research, that actually experience
- 46:35a lot of inconsistent parenting. So it's not true that tending to a child's
- 46:39needs will make them clingy and dependent. What will make a kid clingy and
- 46:45dependent, which what we call preoccupied attachment or anxious attachment, is when you
- 46:51occasionally attend to their needs and then pull it away and deny them soothing,
- 46:55deny them attunement. That inconsistency seem to result in overly dependent, overly clingy
- 47:02people. But if you provide consistent love and attention and soothing, then research
- 47:09shows that person develops what they called secure attachment, which means that they have
- 47:14a healthy balance between dependence and independence. And that's what I'm trying to achieve.
- 47:19And I know it looks a little weird to you, but it's what
- 47:22the science has said. End of role play, you could say something like
- 47:25that, I don't know if it would work, but if you went on
- 47:29a campaign then maybe it would. And I feel like people give their family
- 47:34members, older family members a short shrift, that they're incapable of adjusting like
- 47:40this, that they're incapable of learning. I've sat down my parents, I've
- 47:45sat down people in my family and had talks along these lines. I've talked
- 47:51with older people about LGBTQ issues, about what it means to be non binary,
- 47:57this kind of thing. And I have seen people changed in my family.
- 48:01I've seen people understand more. And now I'm a teacher and I am
- 48:07a yammerer. So maybe I have that strength going for me, and I
- 48:10think I have that role in my family as well. I think that I
- 48:15tend to I don't know, people in my family tend to accept the fact
- 48:21that I'm a yammer and so they'll they'll indulge me. So I have that
- 48:25benefit and maybe you don't have that. But you know, people can change
- 48:29if you give them a chance. At the same time, they might not,
- 48:32you know, like you can lead the title of to day's episode as
- 48:37you can lead a horse to water, but you can't make them be healthy,
- 48:39all right. This thanks email is from Patron Gabriel from Europe. He
- 48:44says, doctor Kirk, are you no sebowing? You're deserving listeners just chiming
- 48:49in here, so you have no cebo and you have placebo. So placebo
- 48:53is when you believe something will work, and thus it has a greater benefit,
- 49:00greater treatment benefit. Like if you are given a Pacebo pill, a
- 49:06sugar pill that is told you that it's going to cure your anxiety, there
- 49:12is a signal and a well known phenomenon where just taking a Pacebo will help
- 49:16people with their anxiety on average. Right, So, like the way it
- 49:21goes is like they give people, they'll have three groups. They'll be testing
- 49:23out a anti anxiety medication, and one is an actual anti anxiety medication that
- 49:30has been shown to work, another one is a Pacebo pill, and then
- 49:34the control group is people with anxiety but you don't give them any medication.
- 49:37And what they find is that the greatest benefit is found in the people that
- 49:43actually took the any anxiety medication. But there's a difference between the pacebo group
- 49:46and the control group. The Pacebo group on average has a greater reduction in
- 49:52anxiety symptoms in the control group, which shows that if you just tell people
- 49:55that something's going to work, then it has an effect on some people.
- 50:00It can have a large effect on some people. For a lot of people
- 50:02has no effect. And research shows that even when you tell people it's a
- 50:07pacebo, it's still on average shows an effect there not for everyone, but
- 50:12on average. So even when you tell someone this is not a real medication,
- 50:16but this is a pacebo that's supposed to help you with your depression,
- 50:21for example, and they find that not every study finds this, but many
- 50:24studies do. So with a no sebo, it is when it's the opposite,
- 50:29you couldn't give someone. So you take different groups of people. You
- 50:32take a control group and everyone has anxiety that comes in, and you put
- 50:37some people in the control group, and you put some people in a group
- 50:40where you give them a medication and you don't say anything about the medication.
- 50:45And then another group and you give them any anxiety medication, but you tell
- 50:49them that this medication probably won't work. And what they find is that the
- 50:53greatest benefit, to the greatest change, the greatest symptom reduction and anxiety are
- 50:59those people that were just given the medication. The next group are the people
- 51:01that were given the end anxiety medication, but you told them that it wasn't
- 51:05going to work. And then the least amount of benefit happens to the people
- 51:09who didn't get the medication at all. And so that's what no sea bow
- 51:14means, right, So Gabriel is saying, doctor Kirk, are you no
- 51:17sea bowing? You're deserving listeners. One thing that I often hear you mention,
- 51:22though, it's the resistance to treatment of certain attachment injuries. I would
- 51:27never put into discussion your knowledge and experience, But as a normy sometimes I
- 51:31find that these kinds of statements trigger my learned helplessness. Learned helplessness. I
- 51:36have complex PTSD. So just jamming in here, Yeah, well the reason
- 51:42why, Well, see what did you say? You often hear me mention
- 51:45that it's the resistance to treatment of certain attachment injuries. I wouldn't phrase it
- 51:51that way, at least I hope that I didn't say, because it's not
- 51:53what I believe. My position, my belief, my experience is that there
- 51:59are certain issues in life that we term his psychological issues that take a long
- 52:06time to recover from, and in all likelihood you're never gonna fully recover from
- 52:13it. At best, you're gonna recover like fifty percent. I mean,
- 52:15just look at Bob for example, he was abused growing up and has disorganized
- 52:20attachment according to him, and he has a lot of syndromes of being an
- 52:23abused child. He's in his mid fifties, heading into his late fifties.
- 52:29He's been in therapy for forty some odd years. He's a therapist himself.
- 52:35He knows all about this kind of stuff. And yet he would say that
- 52:39he's not very far down the road to recovery. So is everyone like that?
- 52:45No, but it's a pretty common story. Doesn't make it worthless to
- 52:50try, No, of course not. He's benefited, according to him,
- 52:53a lot from the work that he has done. So the reason why I
- 52:58will point things like that out is because I need people to understand the scope
- 53:02at which they are faced with. That they can't just read an article online,
- 53:07or they can't just change their diet, or they can't just take a
- 53:10CBT ten week course and fix the problem the way that a lot of people
- 53:15in our society seem to believe. I need people to understand what's really happening.
- 53:21You know. It'd be like if someone had diabetes or something and you're
- 53:24just like, well, all you gotta do is exercise, and it's that
- 53:29could literally cause people to die and when it comes to this sort of thing,
- 53:34as a responsible clinician, I need people to understand the prognosis. I
- 53:37obviously can't know in every case, but I want to give people the information.
- 53:44Plus I'm guessing a lot of people benefit when I say that, because
- 53:49they might have been in and out of therapy with the impression that somehow they're
- 53:52a bad client because they haven't recovered fully yet and they've tried really hard,
- 53:55and they've been to three different therapists, and they might have even been blamed
- 54:00by a therapist or two. And so for me to say, it's not
- 54:04your fault, it's just the nature of the problem. It takes a long
- 54:07time and you have to find the right therapist, and even then you're not
- 54:10going to fully recover from an ongoing horrendous abuse growing up. So a lot
- 54:16of people feel liberated by that, like, oh thanks, you know,
- 54:20it's not great to know that, but at least it aligns with my experience,
- 54:23and I can no longer blame myself. I can just say like,
- 54:27well, this is what everyone goes through when they have this degree of relational
- 54:31traumas and childhood. So that's my position. I think that's what you're referring
- 54:37to. But you say that it triggers your learned helplessness, And I get
- 54:40that, And what's the alternative that I tell everyone that it's easily fixed.
- 54:49It's it's a fucking bummer. It's fucking depressing to think about, you know.
- 54:54If i'll just personalize it to Bob. He's a wonderful human being,
- 55:00y'all know that, and he was massively abused growing up and he deserves so
- 55:05much better in life. And he's suffering almost all the time. He doesn't
- 55:08talk about it a lot on the podcast, but I mean he does talk
- 55:13about it, but it's no joke. He's suffering a lot on a daily
- 55:16basis, on an hour by hour basis. It's not a walk in the
- 55:22park for him. It's you know, it's a lot of pain. It's
- 55:23a lot of anxiety, it's a lot of uncertainty, it's a lot of
- 55:27triggering, it's a lot of conflict. It's not an easy life for him,
- 55:30and it's just so unfair. It's just so unfair. Why did I
- 55:37get the parents that I got and he got the parents that he got.
- 55:40Why he's arguably a better person than I am. Why did he get treated
- 55:45so badly. Why is this his fate. It's depressing, it doesn't make
- 55:50any sense. It's unfair, it's aggravating, and that's real. And so
- 55:55the grief around that is also real. So you know it triggers your learned
- 56:00helplessness. But I don't know what you're going through. But it's possible that
- 56:05what you're feeling is just that demoralization that is I think just a rational response
- 56:10is at the end of the line. No, it's the same when we
- 56:15realize we're all going to die. It's depressing to know that we're all gonna
- 56:21die. One day. Everything ends, and it's sad. And when we
- 56:25deal with that sadness and face it and then we break through the other side,
- 56:30there's there's another side to it of acknowledging the reality of this, acknowledging
- 56:34the the shit, the suffering, and the reality of human life. And
- 56:42so that's my philosophy. You know, other people obviously can have their own
- 56:46philosophy, but that's mine. And if my philosophy harms you, then you
- 56:52know, I wouldn't listen to the podcast. I guess I don't know.
- 56:54Obviously, I talk with your therapist about going on from learning about sports science.
- 57:00I know about the importance of the placebo and no sebo effect on us
- 57:04people so much so that certain finding suggests it's actually harmful to call certain physical
- 57:09exercise is harmful when the evidence doesn't support that. Right, So the research
- 57:16shows that if you are work and I don't this isn't my field, but
- 57:22in physical therapy or in training, if you have a coach or a physician
- 57:28that is like, don't quote me on this, but say you have like
- 57:32a knee injury, and there's if you have a physician that says working out
- 57:43or running or heavy activity with your leg with your knee is actually going to
- 57:47cause the need to get worse. And then they take another group and you
- 57:52tell those people with the same knee injury, random randomly assigned control to treatment
- 57:59group, and you tell those people that actually working out will improve their knee.
- 58:05And then they all work out, and the people that you told the
- 58:07working out with the knee, their knee actually physically gets better. You can
- 58:12actually measure the markers of health and of improvement in their knee physically. It's
- 58:20not just psychological. You can actually measure certain things, you know, repair
- 58:24of the knee signs of repair. And it's different in the person that believed
- 58:29that exercise was going to help their knee when compared to the group of people
- 58:34on average, when compared to the group of people that where you said,
- 58:37go ahead and exercise, but it's going to harm your knee. And don't
- 58:43quote me on that, because obviously this is not my area. So I
- 58:45don't know if that's a specific study, but that's essentially the idea that Gabriel
- 58:50is getting at. He goes on. A study from this year on microdocing
- 58:54psychedelics suggests that the claimed benefits could be a tribe to a placebo almost in
- 59:00their entirety. Just chiming in here. Yeah, I've seen a lot of
- 59:05research on that as well. Going on, and it depends on what they're
- 59:08looking at. But going on here, I am not an expert. I
- 59:13hope this question is not offensive to you. Just chiming in here. It's
- 59:15great that Gabriel knows how thin my skin is and is having all these caveats.
- 59:21I'm not an expert, and I hope this question is not offensive to
- 59:23you. It isn't, But could it be possible that often reminding people how
- 59:28hard certain conditions are to treat, makes us even more resistant to treatment,
- 59:34preventing us from harnessing the pacebo effect or even potentially no sea billing us listeners.
- 59:39I don't think it's ethical to lie, of course, but it would
- 59:43be really interesting to hear your perspective. Thanks for all your work. You
- 59:45change my life for the better in more ways than I can list here and
- 59:50of email. Yeah, and I've thought about that. I do contemplate that,
- 59:53not only with y'all as listeners and patrons, but also just own clients,
- 1:00:00my students. I think about that sometimes, but I just can't do
- 1:00:05it. I can't lie, I can't deceive. It's just not It's so
- 1:00:08hard for me to do that. And I would rather tell people the truth
- 1:00:15and take it from there than to obscure what I know to be true and
- 1:00:22try to remember that I lied or I don't know. Like, it's just
- 1:00:27never a question for me to do anything like that. I have faith in
- 1:00:31people that they will be able to navigate it. And like I said,
- 1:00:37it might be a matter of going through an existential crisis when you really figure
- 1:00:44it out, or accepting radically accepting the suffering that everyone has in the world
- 1:00:51radically accepting the fact that you're never going to fully recover or something. I
- 1:00:53don't know. The other thing is is, in my experience, this radical
- 1:01:00acceptance and this disclosure to people has not caused harm for them. Like I
- 1:01:06said, there's a lot of liberation in it, and there's a solidarity.
- 1:01:10When we can all collectively agree that life fucking sucks a lot of the times,
- 1:01:16and it particularly sucks for some people, then we can talk about it.
- 1:01:21We can acknowledge it, we can look at it, we can share
- 1:01:23in it, we can support each other in it. We can be it.
- 1:01:27We can let it be, we can let it exist. The suffering
- 1:01:30is there, and we can be with the suffering end for me and people
- 1:01:37around me. Bob included. When we do this, he improves. You
- 1:01:42know when on the podcast sometimes after we stop recording, I'll ask him,
- 1:01:45I'll be like, are you doing okay? Like how you're feeling? And
- 1:01:47yeah, I guess he could be lying. I don't think he is.
- 1:01:51He'll say, huh, well, actually I feel better. Even though the
- 1:01:57conversation led him to a lot of pain, we went in a direction that
- 1:02:00caused him to recall and to identify with and to feel a lot of pain
- 1:02:06to move past the veil of his regular cruising speed. Psychologically, he goes
- 1:02:12into it and it hurts, and it's Some of our conversations can be pretty
- 1:02:16depressing, pretty demoralizing, right things along these lines. It was just like,
- 1:02:21geez, fuck, I'm doomed. I'm going to always have this problem.
- 1:02:24I'm going to always have this reactivity. I'm going to always have this
- 1:02:29attachment style least to stomach scent throughout the rest of my life. I've been
- 1:02:32always have to cope with it. And it can be demoralized, it could
- 1:02:37be depressing, it can be a learned helplessness feeling. I'll ask Bob,
- 1:02:40how do you feel at the end of that, and he'll say that number
- 1:02:45One, he feels better because he talked about it and he lived in it,
- 1:02:47and he was taken care of by me as I'm doing it, and
- 1:02:50he feels closer to me, he feels he feels more inside of his own
- 1:02:53body, he feels more like he's actually being real and authentic. And although
- 1:02:59it sucks to recognize how much life sucks, it's better to recognize how much
- 1:03:05life sucks and live in our own bodies and live in reality and express it
- 1:03:09and talk about it than to skip along on the surface acting like none of
- 1:03:15this is happening, and it's a philosophy, it's case by case, but
- 1:03:21that's the principle that I follow. And I can't recall ever running into a
- 1:03:25situation where that went wrong. But it is a worthy question. And I'm
- 1:03:30not there with you as listeners regarding this. If you find that the material
- 1:03:37that we talk about is depressing to you, or is triggering to you,
- 1:03:42or is demoralizing to you in a way that isn't helpful, or you don't
- 1:03:46have any guidance to move through that demoralization, then yeah, I wouldn't listen
- 1:03:51and or I would definitely talk with a therapist about this, because you know,
- 1:03:53these are important questions that you deserve to explore. And I'm not there
- 1:04:00to monitor it. I am there to monitor Bob. I'm there to monitor
- 1:04:02monitor Bob. I don't monitor my friend, but you know I'm there to
- 1:04:06ask questions and to listen. I'm there with my clients, obviously, I'm
- 1:04:11there with my students. I'm there with people in my personal life, so
- 1:04:15I can react, maybe pull back a little bit on the demoralization talk,
- 1:04:19right, or maybe hug them and and actually you know, with you the
- 1:04:25listeners, if you're left in demoralization, I'm not there to hug you.
- 1:04:30I'm not there to take care of you. I'm not there to be with
- 1:04:32you. I'm not there to cry with you. And that could be bad.
- 1:04:38I could. I have read many emails from people saying that even though
- 1:04:42we're not there with you, me and Bob or whoever, that you feel
- 1:04:45our presence, you know, emotionally speaking. So it is kind of like
- 1:04:48a podcast hug or something. But you know, but you have to monitor
- 1:04:55that for yourself, and I suppose I should occasionally remind people about that.
- 1:05:00Your email Gabriel reminds me pot that I probably should do that more often.
- 1:05:03I suppose, you know, let me know if this is an issue for
- 1:05:06you, because obviously this is of a high priority for me, that if
- 1:05:10the podcast is affecting you negatively somehow in this way, I would really want
- 1:05:16to know that so that I could change what I'm doing to account for that
- 1:05:20somehow, or advise people to do this or that. So you know,
- 1:05:25let me know email email in please, and let's have one big podcast,
- 1:05:30Hug consensual podcast Hug Consensual for those who wants one in a consensual, don
- 1:05:36creepy way. That's just so funny how we's had we have to have all
- 1:05:41these caveats now, but you know it's good modeling. Consensual podcast. Hug
- 1:05:45my arms are out. Reach out your arms even if you're on the bus
- 1:05:49or if someone, if you have your earbuds in your partners or hug them,
- 1:05:54or your kid or your dog. Let's all just hug it out.
- 1:05:59I can yel your energy as you hug your dog and your kid, and
- 1:06:03you're hugging the air just like me. And take care of yourself because you
- 1:06:06deserve it, You really really do.