Latest / Newcomer Pod / Katie Benner on Meritocracy, Race, and American Education Reform
Transcript
- 0:00Today on the podcast, we're joined by an old friend, New
- 0:02York Times correspondent Katie Benner.
- 0:04We look back on our old days covering tech together at The
- 0:07Information, our old podcast Dead Cat, and dive into her new
- 0:10book, Miracle Children, Race, education, and a true story of
- 0:15false promises. And on the ground account of how
- 0:17race and politics shape who America's schools are actually
- 0:20built to serve. That conversation is coming up
- 0:23right now. This is the Newcomer podcast.
- 0:32I'm very excited for today's episode.
- 0:35It's a reunion, not even of sorts.
- 0:37It's a literal reunion. It's it's dead cat.
- 0:39This is what we did during the pandemic.
- 0:42Before literally everybody had a podcast, you know, we were like,
- 0:45oh, we used to have a podcast. It's it's our friend Katie
- 0:49Benner. We were all working at the
- 0:51Information at one point. And in in introing her book.
- 0:56I want to start off with this memory that I just struck me
- 0:59today thinking about this was I actually remember it was like 10
- 1:03PM, 11:00 PM on the West Coast. And I remember getting a message
- 1:07from Katie and I was like, man, it is really late where you are
- 1:11in DC and you were like, I have a story that's coming out in
- 1:14like a couple of hours and I can't sleep.
- 1:17And it's like, I, I want to be awake when it goes live.
- 1:20And I was like, oh, man, what's the story?
- 1:22And it turned out that story was this piece, this investigation
- 1:27about this charter school in Louisiana that kicked off a
- 1:32whole thing that they ended up becoming this book that has just
- 1:34finally come out. Whatever, four years later from
- 1:38from when you wrote the article. Is that right?
- 1:40More because we took two years. We had to hit pause for two
- 1:44years because of the pandemic and January 6th and then all the
- 1:47reporting that happened after that.
- 1:50Yeah, so when did the article come out?
- 1:52So the article actually came out at the end of 2018, I believe.
- 1:57And then we signed on to write the book in 2019 and had just
- 2:01started and we were writing follow-ups about an FBI
- 2:03investigation into this school, which I'll tell you more about
- 2:06in a minute. But and then the pandemic
- 2:10happens and Erica, my writing partner, was covering education.
- 2:14So she had to then cover every single school in the country as
- 2:17they were closing down. I mean, she was hit with a wave
- 2:20of work that was so insane and I thought, well, there's no way
- 2:23she can really dig into more follow up stories and dig into
- 2:28the reporting for this book, you know, so, and we're all.
- 2:31So I thought, I'll there's probably research I can do.
- 2:33And then the Justice Department began to fall apart pretty
- 2:37quickly in that fall leading up to January 6th and all of the
- 2:44insanity after. So then I was also sidelined.
- 2:48So from 2020 through basically the 2022, you know, we, we
- 2:56really picked up again in the summer of 22.
- 2:58So it it's taken us about three years to write the book.
- 3:02So we're, we're, we're talking about miracle children, race,
- 3:05education and a true story of false promises.
- 3:09And I think so we, we started off with the from the scoop at
- 3:13the New York Times to all the things in the world that
- 3:16intervene. But I think what's interesting
- 3:17reading the book, honestly, I mean, the world is sort of
- 3:22served the thesis of the book in, you know, in dark ways.
- 3:27Or it's like, obviously if you have this sort of like super,
- 3:30super relevant topic, which is, you know, the great lengths that
- 3:35people will go to to get into elite education.
- 3:38Now, now our society is being reshaped from the the other end
- 3:42of sort of the I don't know, I don't know, uncharitably the,
- 3:46you know, white supremacist effort to re reclaim the elite,
- 3:51elite education for home grown Americans as we're seeing
- 3:57anyway. So there are lots of big themes
- 3:59in the book, this book, which is what I'm enjoying.
- 4:01But why don't you just tell tell sort of the core story and then
- 4:05that sort of allows us to get into the big, the big topics of
- 4:10the book? Sure, absolutely.
- 4:11So there was a small private school in Louisiana called TM
- 4:14Landry. And it it's it's shtick was that
- 4:18it got black students into the most elite universities in the
- 4:22country, most of the Ivy Leagues, and it had this 100%
- 4:26college acceptance rate. As we all know, any private
- 4:29school that says it has 100% college acceptance rate and they
- 4:32can get students into elite colleges.
- 4:34There are plenty of them in this world.
- 4:36Horace Mann Crossroads in LA, you know, bajillion of them in
- 4:41Washington DC. These are really sought after
- 4:43high schools. This one seemed to be uniquely
- 4:45serving kids who are black in Louisiana who didn't.
- 4:49The feeder school for YEAH under underprivileged people in my in
- 4:54Louisiana. Exactly.
- 4:55But to the Ivy Leagues. And So what ended up and they
- 4:59there were these viral videos of students who when they got in
- 5:02the celebrations that they would have with their peers, they were
- 5:05so, so filled with joy. They were extraordinary.
- 5:08Anyway, we got a tip that in fact, the school was, was was
- 5:13lying and that the students themselves have been trading in
- 5:16racial stereotypes of hardship to get in.
- 5:19That they, you know, while they were most of them were from
- 5:21working class families, very few of them were impoverished.
- 5:24They hadn't grown up with drug addicted parents, they hadn't
- 5:27experienced homelessness and things like that.
- 5:29But these were the kinds of stories that were going into
- 5:31their applications to try to convince predominantly white
- 5:36admissions offices to let them into these spaces and that the
- 5:41school itself, that the founders of the school were really,
- 5:45really emotionally, verbally and in some cases physically violent
- 5:50toward the students to kind of keep them in.
- 5:52Line like criminally right? They've been charged at 1:00.
- 5:55Point well, they've they've been investigated and and one of the
- 5:58founders Mike Landry was charged and then ultimately the charge
- 6:03he plead guilty to lesser charges.
- 6:05So I mean, there is there. There was something going on
- 6:08there. And my colleague Erica Green and
- 6:12I, who was covering education at the time, I was covering the
- 6:15Justice Department, we decided that it was, even though it was
- 6:17a small school, the ideas behind it were so big that we wanted to
- 6:21really better understand how this had happened.
- 6:23And so we read a story about it for The New York Times, which
- 6:27severely impaired the school itself, even though it didn't
- 6:30shut it down. And then we ended up turning it
- 6:33into a book. And the larger story that you're
- 6:37trying to tell here beyond just this school and like the ways it
- 6:42treated its students or like the ways that they kind of game the
- 6:44system emotionally or otherwise, to get their students into
- 6:48school, like what was the bigger story you're trying to tell
- 6:51here? Well, there were a few.
- 6:53You know, One was this historic kind of sweeping history of
- 6:57segregated education and the role that race plays in
- 7:00education and the role education plays an opportunity.
- 7:03So, you know, we go way back in history, but when the Founding
- 7:06Fathers say education is what makes you a citizen, they really
- 7:10meant it. Especially in a democracy, in
- 7:12order to vote, to understand your rights, to fight for your
- 7:15rights, to use the court system, education is so essential.
- 7:19And it's really the difference between having power and not
- 7:22having power in America. No matter what era you're in,
- 7:24what year you're in, it really doesn't matter.
- 7:27That has remained true for the hundreds of years America has
- 7:30existed. And what what for all his
- 7:33faults, Mike Landry, the guy, you know, founds the school,
- 7:35makes the point, you know, he makes a lot of compelling
- 7:37points, I guess, because that's how he won everybody over.
- 7:39But he's sort of like, oh, they, you know, the elites are willing
- 7:42to let, you know, minority children in through sports, but
- 7:45they're not really interested in letting them in through this
- 7:49sort of like the permanent resource, which is, you know,
- 7:51learning to sort of think and, and getting in through your
- 7:54academics. Exactly which has historic
- 7:57analogs right? Like, there was a reason why not
- 8:00just black students, but many other minorities in this
- 8:03country, places like Harvard, places like Yale, spent so much
- 8:07of their history. These are schools that were
- 8:08founded, you know, in Harvard's case, before America was
- 8:11founded. And they spent basically up
- 8:14until 1960 fighting very, very hard to keep out black students,
- 8:20to keep out Jewish students, to keep out, you know, Native
- 8:23American students and Asian students because they had an
- 8:26understanding that they were a gateway to power.
- 8:28And they also had a, you know, eugenics, for example, was
- 8:31really the heart and soul of of the academic and intellectual
- 8:37underpinnings of eugenics grew out of Harvard and Harvard
- 8:39Medical School. So these were institutions that
- 8:42until very recently had a beyond conservative bias towards who
- 8:45should have power. And it was not any of the groups
- 8:47I just mentioned. They they talk about like
- 8:49accepting, I forget it was Harvard or Princeton where
- 8:51you're like the for the alumni standard is like, as long as we
- 8:54think you'll pass like you, we'll let you in.
- 8:57You know, we can get through the school work at all.
- 9:00You know, you can hang out with the other like real meritocrats.
- 9:03You know that we're starting to let in here.
- 9:05And there were so many things that we're startling to
- 9:07understand about not just like I said, one of the themes is a
- 9:11sweep of segregation education and white exists.
- 9:14Another one is kind of the role that Ivy League universities
- 9:16have played in terms of gatekeeping power.
- 9:19And so many of the mechanisms we think of as like neat race blind
- 9:26admissions, holistic admissions, all the things that came after
- 9:29affirmative action and admissions were actually created
- 9:33at the turn of the 20th century to keep power in the very, very
- 9:39cloistered communities of America's elite.
- 9:42So yes, this was a time. It's like the turn of the
- 9:44century before World War One. You, you have lots of Jewish
- 9:48immigrants coming into the country.
- 9:50They believe in education and they want to get ahead.
- 9:54Columbia University is accepting more of them than others.
- 9:56Because somebody immigrated to New York City and you have
- 9:59schools like Yale and Harvard really freaking out.
- 10:02They're like, this is what we don't want.
- 10:03We don't want to be overrun by Jewish students.
- 10:07This will ruin society. So instead of relying on test
- 10:12scores, which, you know, you had a lot of Jewish students really
- 10:15acing these tests, they, they created a holistic look at a
- 10:20student. So what if you're good at, what
- 10:22if you're good at athletics? What if you're just a really
- 10:24good citizen? What if you bring other
- 10:27qualities where you would just get along well with the other
- 10:29boys? What if there were all these
- 10:31things that they could do so that you could take this Jewish
- 10:34student with perfect test scores and not accept him?
- 10:38So you could take a student who had gone to Choate or Phillips
- 10:42Exeter, who'd gotten straight CS, and say, but he will add to
- 10:47this community in ways that are ineffable but important.
- 10:51It's really a story of how people contort themselves to
- 10:53systems. So you have that holistic
- 10:54process. And so then Landry is like, oh,
- 10:58people love this idea of grit. What if we can really make grit
- 11:01something people can understand in terms of, you know, the
- 11:05African American experience and the type of grit that you expect
- 11:09this sort of minority student out of Louisiana to have.
- 11:11And that's where it's like, oh, we will, we will sell you the
- 11:14grit the same way you know, your prep school, you know, kid is,
- 11:18is trying to show it the. Grit, you want to, you know, I
- 11:21don't think he was. He's a really complicated figure
- 11:24because some of the things that he does, you know, when he's
- 11:26accused of hitting children, when he's arrested, these things
- 11:28are I I truly believe you children should not be ruined in
- 11:34that way. However, as one of the students
- 11:36said, Mike is really hard to dismiss out of hand because he
- 11:39diagnosis correctly so many things about society.
- 11:42He has such a a Spidey sense for what people's like desires are
- 11:46underneath what they're saying. So when he encounters Ivy League
- 11:49admissions officials, he's like, OK, these are people who ran
- 11:55extremely socially conservative institutions and in just a
- 11:58matter of 50 years have tried to undo hundreds of years of of
- 12:05this like cloistered ultra elite system.
- 12:09These are the tools they have, right?
- 12:11It's holistic process. These are the things they seem
- 12:14to want. It was not hard for him to
- 12:16figure out ways to give them those things and the students
- 12:20that he had applied to their schools.
- 12:22Yeah, I, I want to take a, a step back to talk about
- 12:26meritocracy or meritocrats because this is like a text
- 12:29show, right? And that's like still one of
- 12:31the, you know, like major currencies in the valley is like
- 12:35this belief in the meritocracy and how that is like the only
- 12:38real way for people of, of, of skill and, and intelligence and
- 12:43capability to like rise up in the world here.
- 12:46What's like, as you were investigating or, or researching
- 12:49for this book, like, can you talk to me about like the
- 12:50history of meritocracy and the role that it played with the Ivs
- 12:54and like creating AI Have my opinions on it.
- 12:57But I'm, I'm curious like what you kind of realized as you were
- 13:00looking into like the role of meritocracy and, and the Ivs
- 13:03'cause it's like a 20th century phenomenon, right?
- 13:05Yeah, this is all the 20th century.
- 13:07This is all pretty recent history.
- 13:08It's there. There's a an extraordinary New
- 13:10Yorker article from the early 60s, nineteen 60s where the
- 13:14writer, forgetting the woman's name, she shadows the Yale
- 13:17admissions department. And these are people who they,
- 13:20they, when they're speaking to her, they are not saying things
- 13:23that they think are controversial or things that
- 13:25should be hidden or things you only say behind closed doors.
- 13:28So they're talking about meritocracy, and they don't
- 13:33believe in meritocracy as a concept in the way we would
- 13:36today. You know, this idea that you
- 13:38take the people with the best grades.
- 13:40The quote from the head of admissions is if we only took
- 13:42people who did well on test scores, we wouldn't.
- 13:44We would lose all these presidents, future presidents.
- 13:47We would lose future heads of industry.
- 13:50We can't just take people because they do well on their
- 13:52tests. We have to take people because
- 13:54they have a certain kind of background.
- 13:58Like this idea of meritocracy was considered somewhat insane
- 14:02because they were like, if we take people who, who get in on
- 14:05merit, we're going to take in just a bajillion Jewish students
- 14:08is basically the fear. And keep in mind this is also
- 14:09when Yale, they measured every, it was all men.
- 14:13Of course, you know, all these schools were all male.
- 14:16They measured every quote. They called them boys.
- 14:17Every boy their freshman year gets measured and it was the
- 14:21year after they started. You know, it was in the years
- 14:24after they started becoming more meritocratic, IE admitting
- 14:28students who weren't necessarily, as they called it,
- 14:31but pale Male and Yale, that the student body as the average
- 14:36height started to go down. And the the head of admissions
- 14:40really bemoans this in the interview and just is so sad
- 14:44that the students are getting shorter because they're not big,
- 14:47tall, kind of waspy white guys 'cause.
- 14:49They're letting in the Jews, they're letting in the like, you
- 14:51know, the, the, the, the Mal, not, not malnourished.
- 14:54It's clear they're. Well, fed Jewish, let's fly,
- 14:56yeah? The Jews are bringing down the
- 14:58hype. It's like all these Wasps are
- 15:00being. Particular facts I feel like our
- 15:02like our biographies need to be flagged to all these very
- 15:07difficult. He's also very two Jews, so we
- 15:09can as are you. This is like a highly Jewish and
- 15:13Jewish inflected podcast. It's interesting.
- 15:16I'm like, I guess I went to Harvard in the the brief
- 15:18meritocratic window. I'm just I'd say all this only
- 15:23to explain that meritocracy has gone through a lot of
- 15:25iterations. No, no, no, I could dig it.
- 15:27The well, what do you I mean to, to get to a core question of the
- 15:32day. It feels like people are
- 15:33mourning sort of the no bless oblige.
- 15:36You know, it's sort of like people in some ways.
- 15:39I mean the Trump people, obviously, it's all sort of
- 15:41incoherent. It's like the Ivy League people
- 15:43don't represent them, but they sort of want to.
- 15:46They miss sort of the white elites, like, I don't know, what
- 15:50do you make of the elements in our society that sort of want to
- 15:54bring that back, even though they don't seem to know, I
- 15:56guess, like which white elites they're really like talking
- 15:59about. There are a lot of people who
- 16:01now like fall under the umbrella of whiteness.
- 16:03So we're seeing that fight play out on the far right.
- 16:05It's like our Jewish people white, you know, there's some
- 16:08people who say yes, some people say no, you know, does this
- 16:11include Catholics? Like, you know, there's the the
- 16:13idea of whiteness is really contested right now.
- 16:16But you're right, there is this belief that if we only go back
- 16:20to this past where we could better predict who would run
- 16:25things and whose ideas would win, and we had a less contested
- 16:29world, things would be better. And so, yes, we rejected
- 16:33meritocracy when it created more diversity.
- 16:37When we got more diversity, then we embraced meritocracy again
- 16:40because we figured it would end diversity.
- 16:42So it's like we hated meritocracy when we thought it
- 16:45would, you know, and elitism. And then we embraced meritocracy
- 16:50when we wanted to end diversity, you know?
- 16:52So the idea of meritocracy is a useful tool that you can bend to
- 16:55almost any ideology. Right.
- 16:58And it's like very woven into, you know, you, you cover DC like
- 17:02the, the the culture there is very much like influenced by
- 17:06meritocracy. And you have presidents like
- 17:08Clinton and Obama who were not of the manner born, but are kind
- 17:14of prime examples of maritocratic achievement.
- 17:17And they sort of get plucked from their you.
- 17:20Know Obama goes to Columbia and Harvard Law School and feels
- 17:24very of those institutions. I mean, you know, he's an
- 17:27outsider when he comes in, but then by the time I'm, you know,
- 17:30going to business feels like he's like typifies sort of the
- 17:34what the Ivy League is, which is, you know, I, I don't know.
- 17:38Right. And it and it ends up upholding
- 17:40the system too, right. I mean, part of the theory
- 17:43behind meritocracy is that you can pluck these people from
- 17:46their, you know, economic obscurity and then train them to
- 17:51be able to support the system that otherwise keeps their
- 17:54brothers and sisters and family down.
- 17:55But they can kind of like be existing within this system and
- 17:59and propagate it or or prop it up.
- 18:01Your true belief? Give us a non arch version.
- 18:04What it was your actual view? Oh, I 100% believe that, yeah.
- 18:07Do you not think that's the case, that that's like a huge
- 18:10component of meritocracy is to sort of take certain people
- 18:13that. Takes the best out of their.
- 18:15Community, I mean, I think it it, it reduces revolution, it
- 18:18reduces radicalism. Like people that otherwise would
- 18:21be angry about their their their lot in life.
- 18:23A. Relief valve A release valve.
- 18:26Yeah, yeah. It's like it's steam control,
- 18:28you know, it's like you have this rest of population of of an
- 18:31underclass, racial or economic. And if you just pick enough of
- 18:34them out of it and put them in these institutions that have for
- 18:37hundreds of years been like keeping in the system in in its
- 18:40current place, it kind of keeps things a little bit more stable.
- 18:43Now I think that's a very controversial way of thinking
- 18:45about things. No, I was going to say there's a
- 18:47lot of scholars out there, including Imani Perry.
- 18:51She was at Princeton, but now she, I think she is at Harvard
- 18:54too. Who who talked about this in
- 18:58terms of American exceptional exceptionalism and then racial
- 19:02exceptionalism, that there is a release valve element.
- 19:06You need some people to succeed, you know, in the world where no
- 19:10one succeeds. And then you get and you then.
- 19:13We've been diagnosed part of our problem as like the bourgeoisie,
- 19:17you know, you need they need to be able to strive and hit sort
- 19:21of their class ambitions. But in some ways the Trump thing
- 19:25is like by letting in, you know, non new people into the striver
- 19:30class, you're denying the existing striver class or
- 19:34meritocratic or however were euphemistically calling this
- 19:37like you're denying them spots. And so it creates resentment
- 19:40from the Stephen Miller's of the world that it's like, I should
- 19:43have been treated as, you know, I'm a genius instead of like
- 19:46laughed at. You know what?
- 19:47I'm not capturing it totally. But yeah, I get that you need to
- 19:51deliver like elites in a society.
- 19:53They're elite function. And if you don't, they get
- 19:56really resentful and they say I should be an elite and like this
- 19:59society isn't doing it. And therefore I'm going to like
- 20:01try and destroy the society. But that's just like, that just
- 20:04seems like human nature. It doesn't seem like that
- 20:05cynical. It's like if people feel like
- 20:07they're not living up to their expectations, they're going to
- 20:10get mad and 'cause you all sorts of trouble.
- 20:12Like any functioning society needs to solve the problem of
- 20:16like delivering people to what they think they can.
- 20:19You know, you know their their natural capacity at the same
- 20:23time while finding you know, new people to bring in into that I
- 20:25don't know. Yeah, we've seen labour
- 20:27uprisings obviously that speak to exactly to that.
- 20:30We've seen, you know, you saw the general strike happen on
- 20:33college campuses across the country in after Kent State, not
- 20:37only protesting the Vietnam War, but being like, you know, like
- 20:41we deserve. There's a if enough people feel
- 20:44they deserve better, they will rise up.
- 20:47Also, I just wanted to say, Tom, I think that it's so interesting
- 20:49you bring up Clinton and Obama. I mean, there's there is a
- 20:53historic argument to be made that they are outliers in terms
- 20:56of the academic acuity of our presidents.
- 20:59And I say like we have the founding fathers and we always
- 21:02remember them. But the people we don't remember
- 21:05other presidents that kind of fall between, you know, Chester
- 21:09Arthur and probably like Calvin Coolidge, you know, you have
- 21:14this like, sort of depressing string of 10 presidents who are
- 21:20not covering themselves in glory, who are letting massive
- 21:23scandals happen underneath their noses, who are supportive of
- 21:26massive scandals, who are rolling back the Reconstruction
- 21:29Era, who are reinstating white supremacy laws, who love Jim
- 21:33Crow, who are embracing the KKK. Like, and they weren't like
- 21:37stellar students. And then even in our modern era,
- 21:39you know, George W Bush, God love, I think.
- 21:43This doubt it was a good student.
- 21:45Right, we all know. It's like.
- 21:48A middling student. And so when you think about that
- 21:49New Yorker article where the head of admissions in the 60s is
- 21:52saying if we were only to let good students in, we would be
- 21:55missing out on future presidents, it's almost like
- 21:57he's talking about George W Bush.
- 22:00It's like he's spawned to the future that George W what's?
- 22:03Your ideal, I mean, yeah, what was the ideal system here?
- 22:08Well, I mean the ideal, This is one of the other things.
- 22:10And I think that this is a way, way to think about systems,
- 22:13because when we think about institutions and systems,
- 22:15they're just people. And so we're only just managing
- 22:18desires and we're, it's always competing desires.
- 22:21So like when we have a system of Jim Crow and you have segregated
- 22:26schools and it's very easy to keep black people out of school,
- 22:28which means it's very easy to keep black people opportunity.
- 22:32Everybody understands how that system works.
- 22:35And for those people who want to educate black children, they
- 22:39find ways, right? They'll either set up special
- 22:42schools for them, but they're working within a system.
- 22:43The system changes after 1954. You have, you know,
- 22:46desegregation of busing and this these fights that last for 20
- 22:50years. Well, in those cases, if you
- 22:53want to keep black children out of, of educational opportunity,
- 22:56you have to be more creative. You have to create new systems.
- 23:01OK, that era passes and then you have a more egalitarian world in
- 23:04some ways. And the Reagan era comes and
- 23:07kind of like undercuts all the funding for these systems.
- 23:10You see what I'm saying? It's like, is there?
- 23:12It's it's not so much as what's the ideal system.
- 23:14I think it's more like saying what is the outcome that we
- 23:17want? What do we think is the outcome
- 23:19we want? Some people will say, especially
- 23:22today in 2026, there are people who will say we think that white
- 23:26people should be on top and we want our systems writ large to
- 23:31advance that agenda. That would include education.
- 23:34Some people would disagree with that.
- 23:36And everybody is kind of always going to be RE organizing or
- 23:42creating systems that are getting to whatever ideal it is
- 23:45they want. And so I will tell you that if
- 23:49my preference, my belief is that it is better to have a world
- 23:54where people, no matter what they look like.
- 23:56Right, exactly. And it's pro meritocracy.
- 23:59I'm just saying Tom seems anti meritocracy.
- 24:01Katie, you're you're pro meritocracy is an aspiration.
- 24:05I get that these things are wielded, that we, that race
- 24:07outcomes and white supremacy loom large behind the scenes.
- 24:11Whatever system you create, believe me when I say will be
- 24:15undermined by people who don't want that.
- 24:18And so the most important thing is for people to understand the
- 24:22goals they want for society and to be nimble enough to
- 24:26understand when a system is no longer really working.
- 24:28Like, you were actually pretty decent arguments to be made that
- 24:31affirmative action kind of stopped.
- 24:33If if what your goal with affirmative action was in the
- 24:3660s and 70s was to create better outcomes writ large for black
- 24:40Americans. I think there's an argument we
- 24:42made that those outcomes stagnate in the 90s.
- 24:44I. Didn't believe that until Trump
- 24:46era. And then you're like, wow,
- 24:46there's a lot of racial resentment that we're fostering
- 24:49with this and. And so it's like, well, you
- 24:52know, would it have been when you read the argument for why
- 24:55affirmative action struck down? I do not agree with those
- 24:58arguments. I will say, though, that if
- 25:02you're looking at the effectiveness of affirmative
- 25:06action, there is a plateau where suddenly black, black America as
- 25:11a whole doesn't continue to make gains, where it does somewhat
- 25:16plateau. And so you say to yourself, OK,
- 25:18maybe affirmative action in terms of what we want as a
- 25:21bigger goal has run its course to some degree.
- 25:23What are some other things we can do?
- 25:25That's not how the left really was thinking after, you know,
- 25:2840-50 years of of having all these big federal level wins.
- 25:33And so now I think people are thinking about this.
- 25:35But like I said, no matter what system you create in order to
- 25:39advance racial equality, trust me when I say there will be
- 25:43powerful systems created to tear it apart.
- 25:45So you have to always be willing to work towards something new.
- 25:50I think that the the meritocracy, especially like in
- 25:54the collegiate level and I don't claim that I have nearly enough
- 25:57knowledge as, you know, someone who went to an Ivy League school
- 25:59or someone who spent years studying how it works.
- 26:01But it seems like it exists to propagate itself and it's how
- 26:05can we keep the system of Ivy League educated students running
- 26:09America? And there's just various ways in
- 26:11which you can kind of rejigger the system in order to make sure
- 26:13it has the right admixture of races and education and and
- 26:17wealth to be able to keep it going.
- 26:19Whether that's the best way to run America, that no matter
- 26:21what, we know that the Ivy League need to be running
- 26:23things. So if we make sure that they're
- 26:25successful, doesn't seem like it's always going to benefit a
- 26:29large number of people. And so you have like these
- 26:31situations like Obama and, and, and Clinton, who I'll be very
- 26:35generous about them and say they nominally care about poor people
- 26:38and thinking about how they grew up and how they can enact.
- 26:41I'm being incredibly generous about it.
- 26:44And then you have someone like JD Vance, who is also a, an
- 26:47example of the meritocracy, right?
- 26:49Super relative, you know, poor, like hardship goes, gets
- 26:52accepted by Yale and basically turns his back on that entire
- 26:56world that he came from and, and, and exists as a member of
- 26:59the system. And that's the meritocracy
- 27:02working very effectively in in in some respects.
- 27:06And I don't a system that can produce ajd Vance and an Obama
- 27:10seems inherently flawed to me if it's about actually.
- 27:14People, I mean, we're I. Guess they're successful.
- 27:17Schools. Schools don't.
- 27:20Schools are not designed to make everybody alike.
- 27:22That's the thing. I mean, I understand that the
- 27:24right and sometimes the left accuses education of like,
- 27:27brainwashing people and making them all the same ultimately,
- 27:30like we are all individuals with different subjectivity.
- 27:33And so yeah, of course, like and.
- 27:35Yeah, the, the student body at any school to me defines itself
- 27:39far more than the academic. The faculty and administrators
- 27:42are able to actually control those students.
- 27:44So it's like the assembling of the students to me is the main
- 27:47thing that they are able to do. And then the students mix it up.
- 27:50I mean, I, I agree with you, Tom, that there's like banks and
- 27:56financial firms that like do very, you know, want to recruit
- 28:00sort of Ivy League students in sort of maintaining class.
- 28:03But in some ways I think they're seen as like the holdover of,
- 28:07yeah, the sort of presidents going to Harvard and Yale and
- 28:09everything era. I mean, if you like a newcomer,
- 28:13right? Like just look at her like
- 28:15nobody working for newcomer right now.
- 28:17I think. When do I leave school?
- 28:18I like recruited. Somebody.
- 28:20Just the guy who started it. Yeah, just started it, but it's
- 28:23and I have a network from it, you know, but like it's people I
- 28:27know, you know what I mean? It's just like I, I think
- 28:29Harvard excels at being like a network of people who all stay
- 28:33in the mix, like want to do stuff.
- 28:35It's like I'd network with people from my high school if
- 28:37they were in the mix, Like they're not, you know what I
- 28:39mean? It's just sort of like, the
- 28:41thing about going to Harvard is just like there's so many people
- 28:43who are just like hustling. They're trying to be at the top
- 28:46of their career, Like and then it's a self reinforcing network
- 28:49because the best way to hire somebody is to sort of have the
- 28:53real dope from somebody. You know, it's like you want
- 28:56somebody to say like, oh, like, is this person like a good
- 28:59worker? What's their deal?
- 29:00Like if you know what they're about South, them being in your
- 29:02network is is super valuable to vetting.
- 29:05Like it's not a conspiracy. It's like how human beings work.
- 29:08You know, you know, I have this theory, my Anna Dolvey theory of
- 29:12the elite. Like the elites are like the
- 29:15easiest to fool. Like they're the easiest people
- 29:17in the world to fool because all you have to do is walk in with
- 29:20somebody who's already a member and then you're accepted.
- 29:23And trust me when I say that's not how it works.
- 29:25And like the blue collar part of the country where I grew up, you
- 29:28can walk in to a party with somebody, but they're still
- 29:31going to want to ask you a lot of questions.
- 29:33You are why you should be there, why they shouldn't kick you out,
- 29:36why they should trust you. Like there's a lot where it's
- 29:38like if you walk in on the arm of the right person and and
- 29:42it's, you know, Anna Delphy, you, you're just accepted with
- 29:47almost with so with with far fewer questions.
- 29:51Sometimes it's a breakdown of the elite or it's like that the
- 29:53elite isn't isn't so rooted and that it's like anyone rich
- 29:57person could make you fantastically wealthy.
- 29:59Then you're like, whatever, I'll gamble a little bit, you know,
- 30:02be positive some here. And so like, because Harvard,
- 30:06Yale, it's just something, you know, MIT, Stanford are such
- 30:09powerful signifiers. People are like, well, if you
- 30:12have that signifier that they've ascribed so much meaning to it,
- 30:17that if you are a con artist it, it takes a real long time to
- 30:20figure it. Out right, Right.
- 30:23But it, it it's so interwoven into like, institutions beyond
- 30:26like, like, OK, you work at the New York Times.
- 30:29Like that is a newsroom that is full of Ivy Leaguers, right?
- 30:33Yeah. It is just that that newsroom is
- 30:35overflowing with Ivy Leaguers. It's crazy.
- 30:39It's totally. Crazy Kitty, you're on the board
- 30:42of Bowden I. But but you know, that's what's
- 30:45so interesting and like, back to your book.
- 30:46Like, Colin's the only one he's got the real like, not top UC
- 30:50chip on his shoulder here, you know?
- 30:51I have no chip, though. Like, we're all in the same
- 30:54place. That's The funny thing, Skip.
- 30:58Oh, yeah, sorry. There are chips.
- 31:00There are chips, but that's not even one I ever cared about
- 31:02because you know what? Because I'm white.
- 31:04There are so many others. Yeah, dude, because I'm white.
- 31:07I was upper middle class and I knew things, and I'm Jewish.
- 31:09I knew things were gonna be fine.
- 31:11They were gonna be fine, right? Right.
- 31:12And handsome. He always leaves that off the
- 31:14list. I really.
- 31:15Yeah. It's well thing about Tom
- 31:18because everybody talks about how handsome he is and I'm like,
- 31:21well, it's funny. He carries himself as somebody
- 31:23who is not, which I think is like, very disarming and
- 31:27interesting, but also exceedingly weird at some point.
- 31:31Like, it's one thing for it to be a charming tick, but it's
- 31:33another when it just feels like dysmorphia, like face.
- 31:36Just. Yeah.
- 31:37Yeah, exactly. Where do we get into it now
- 31:39this? Conversation has taken a
- 31:40horrible turn. We're working on Tom's dating
- 31:43profile right now. This is I can't endorse the
- 31:48progression of this conversation.
- 31:52Katie, you're so well, actually, no, let's go.
- 31:56The the the students that you were writing about here.
- 31:58They, I'm assuming, saw this elite system and it was why,
- 32:03like the promise of TM Landry, Landry was so incredible to
- 32:07them. Because if you're on the
- 32:09outside, everything looks like an, you know, an amazing
- 32:11opportunity. And you know, if this school was
- 32:13just getting these students into LSU, which is a decent enough
- 32:17school, it would have seemed like a failure to to a lot of
- 32:20them. Interesting thing and I think
- 32:22that this is like a moment where you have to think about like
- 32:27what does life look like for a white middle class lens.
- 32:29So for the earliest students of TM Landry, Mike was getting them
- 32:33into places like University of Louisiana, some HBCUS.
- 32:38And these were school that can I tell you, these kids were
- 32:40thrilled to go to, right? But it's interesting the the
- 32:45reception he gets when he gets a student into an Ivy League
- 32:48school, the amount of interest he gets from outside of his
- 32:51community, the amount of interest he gets from parents
- 32:54who, unlike early students, actually know more about college
- 32:58and know more about the ways that elite colleges open doors.
- 33:02That is a money making opportunity that that that Mike
- 33:06really, really takes advantage of.
- 33:10And so that's, you see the growth of TM Landry as he
- 33:12understands that top tier universities convey something
- 33:17that is really important that for some of the families he has
- 33:20to teach them about. Like there are some families who
- 33:22do not believe that going to any college is a failure.
- 33:25And there's some families that don't believe that you failed if
- 33:28you don't go to college. You know what I mean?
- 33:29He almost has to like, indoctrinate them into this
- 33:31world view that unless you've gone to an elite school and have
- 33:35a certain kind of job, your life is not very worthwhile, which is
- 33:38such a specific world view. It is not the world view of the
- 33:42majority of Americans, by the way, but it is one we're
- 33:45familiar with because we work in the media.
- 33:48We covered technology, we covered Wall Street, We cover
- 33:51elite people. We're.
- 33:52I think a core problem with society, like it's just, you
- 33:55know, my grandmother like thought idealized, like the
- 34:00local judge in York County of Pennsylvania.
- 34:02You know, it's like that was like, if I think about who she
- 34:05was building up to me is sort of like the great man that I should
- 34:08aspire to be. It was like sort of a community
- 34:11figure, someone, you know, wise and respectful like locally.
- 34:15And I think over time as I grew up, there was just much more
- 34:20like, oh, you know, and I'm competitive.
- 34:21So maybe I'm not representative, but there is just sort of a, a
- 34:24national like that. You need to aspire on sort of a
- 34:27national level that the, it's not that these schools are that
- 34:31you can't get in, right? It's stories of how you could
- 34:33get in. And so there is a sort of dark
- 34:36side to this. Like Mayor, anybody can go to
- 34:39the top in that. Like it creates such an intense
- 34:41focus on on the very top that it undermines being the best in
- 34:47sort of your community, which again, becomes a subtle argument
- 34:52for not having these schools be meritocratic, not letting people
- 34:57in from all and just sort of saying, oh, well, there it's
- 34:58just the elite self perpetuating.
- 35:00The best you can do is like, you know, win your local community
- 35:03race. That's not the world I'm
- 35:04advocating for, but it is sort of a consequence of, you know,
- 35:08that that evolution. It's interesting Eric and I did
- 35:11an interview with a very fancy, very posh.
- 35:14Erica Green, your co-author. Sorry, I'm Erica.
- 35:17Yeah, she's Erica. It was very, very fancy, posh,
- 35:21very brilliant British podcast person.
- 35:25And when we were talking about the outcomes of some of the
- 35:28students, I mentioned that there was one student who was very,
- 35:30very happy that while he had not ultimately gone to Wall Street,
- 35:37he didn't take a Wall Street internship.
- 35:39And he ended up at home in Louisiana with his daughter.
- 35:44And he started a power washing business with his brother and
- 35:47was very, I mean, he all of them.
- 35:49He's probably in many ways, he has a great sense of self and he
- 35:53he's doing financially well. The man said, wow, So you're
- 35:56really advocating that failure is OK.
- 35:59And I found it fascinating that in his world, being at home,
- 36:05owning a power washing business with the brother you love,
- 36:09taking care of the daughter you love and having a life that you
- 36:12really enjoy is a failure. I thought so that's how far.
- 36:17Like I said, when we think of what successes or what people
- 36:20need to do or have a good life, it's like so they're they're.
- 36:24Telling a terrible story. It's has them because I'm like,
- 36:29wow, that is a huge, huge chasm that that was his reflex.
- 36:33And it also follows, I think Thomas Piketty would say it
- 36:39follows an economic gap that we have seen perpetuated by, you
- 36:47know, a loss of ways to have a middle class life without a
- 36:50college degree. And like, this is where people
- 36:52are going to me and be like, nobody wants to work in a
- 36:55shoelace factory in America. I'm not advocating for that.
- 36:58I'm just saying that we see this scramble for college.
- 37:03We mentioned this in the book. We can't get into it too much.
- 37:06But like, this number of colleges that exist in 2026 is
- 37:09basically the number of colleges that existed in like 1920, OK
- 37:132020, 1920. It's basically the same number
- 37:16of schools who want to go to College in 1920 versus 2020.
- 37:23Very, very different. Because the new schools are
- 37:26provided by like community colleges.
- 37:28But like, yeah, I mean, I. Know it's just.
- 37:30Also probably like the death of like the like the the rural
- 37:33America and like the farm ones that people probably, yeah.
- 37:36If you wanted to be able to afford a car and a house
- 37:40payment, you didn't have to go to college for most of the
- 37:44history of this country. And then starting in the 90s you
- 37:48did because all of the jobs that allow you to have house, a child
- 37:54and a car go away. So now it's like you either
- 37:59there's only one Ave. to house child car job and it is through
- 38:02the same number of doors that have existed forever, or you get
- 38:08caught up in this maw of like part time jobs working in the
- 38:11service industry, financial insecurity, maybe you don't have
- 38:14healthcare, etcetera. How binary is that?
- 38:17Like there's middle ground. And so when you and so we've
- 38:21started to also think of not having a college educated life
- 38:25as failure, in part because the economic consequences have
- 38:28become so dire. But we can't we can't put more
- 38:32people through the college system.
- 38:34Like this is one of the reasons why the middle class has shrunk
- 38:36so much. And so like college has become
- 38:38do or die Hunger Games. Do you wanna be in the middle
- 38:41class or do you wanna be in like the Oh my God, wow, that's.
- 38:46Right, right. And which is why I get so
- 38:47frustrated when you see this argument about, you know, the
- 38:50amount of debt that students have to take in order to go to
- 38:52college now being this like onerous thing that's gonna, you
- 38:55know, burden them for the rest of their life, which is true.
- 38:58I mean, like this is incredibly difficult financially for most
- 39:01of these people. It.
- 39:02Was a long time. It took a long time, 20 years.
- 39:05But like people that's like lucky, like there are people
- 39:07that will probably take longer than that now.
- 39:09And, you know, you're gainfully employed, you know, working
- 39:11among Ivy Leaguers. So like, you made it, but like,
- 39:16you know, the, the, the, the knock is like you're taking on a
- 39:19whole bunch of debt to get like, some degree in like a bullshit
- 39:23liberal arts, you know, degree, like, you know, where Harry
- 39:26Potter studies and and you have nothing left, you know, to offer
- 39:31after all of that. And it's like, yeah, but what
- 39:32alternative do these people have?
- 39:34If you're going to say going to college is a waste of your time
- 39:37and you're going to be stuck in debt for the next decades of
- 39:39your life, you've not provided an alternative of any sort of
- 39:43like respectable middle class life that they can have.
- 39:45And So what do you want these people to do?
- 39:47And it to me, it seems like it also perpetuates the obsession
- 39:50with college, which is something that the elites, you know, I
- 39:53mean, that continues. I mean, you look at someone like
- 39:55Bill Ackman, who seems like his entire political theory is based
- 39:59around the fact that he's really pissed off that his daughter
- 40:01went to, I don't know which Ivy League and like became super
- 40:04woke and and there's like a huge amount of bitterness from people
- 40:07about like the. Social impact of like what
- 40:11colleges do like just like. The more time that gets spent
- 40:14people thinking about college, the more importance it gains and
- 40:17the more like significance it has in our political life.
- 40:20Yeah. And when you say these people,
- 40:22that includes like me and Eric, very much like when I applied to
- 40:25college, I grew up in a blue collar home with very little
- 40:30money. I was a good student.
- 40:34I don't know, I got good grades. But at the same time, the
- 40:36competition to get into College in 1994 and 1995 was night and
- 40:42day versus trying to get into College in 2025.
- 40:45The number of people applying for spots at Bowden is now
- 40:48exponentially more our. 2008 was again we were getting.
- 40:52It was, it was starting to really heat up when Eric was
- 40:55applying, which is what this is also Eric's way of saying he's
- 40:57much smarter than I am. I'm not smarter.
- 40:59I. I did every extracurricular you
- 41:01could do in Macon, GA I was the head of the Obama campaign.
- 41:05And for high school students in Macon, GA, yeah, I can go.
- 41:08Yeah. But it's becoming a much harder
- 41:11go. You know, the idea of an elite
- 41:13school having a double digit acceptance rate, which happened
- 41:16all the time in the 90s, very, very good schools had double
- 41:19digit acceptance rates. Part of the reason is because
- 41:23especially through, you know, it was waning in the 80s and 90s,
- 41:26but there had been a world where you didn't have to go to college
- 41:30to have a middle class life. If I were trying to get into
- 41:33college today, growing up in the same exact circumstances I grew
- 41:36up in, wow. I can't even imagine how much
- 41:39anxiety I would feel looking around at a burn like a a rusted
- 41:45out industrial town saying to myself.
- 41:47But the the real next elite what you know I'm reading my I was
- 41:50reading my 3 month old your book prepping for this interview,
- 41:55getting her education going and I was about to say so.
- 41:57That she can be prepared for an even more rigorous college
- 42:00admissions process. But I think the I'm always
- 42:02saying to my wife, like, you want to be elite.
- 42:05So she doesn't even, I want her to be, you know, a musician.
- 42:07You know, it's like you, you know, it's like you, you raise
- 42:10Gracie Abrams or whatever, you know, that'll.
- 42:11Look good on her preschool application, which you should
- 42:13probably be filling out soon. What?
- 42:15No. I they said that'll look good on
- 42:16her preschool application. She's successful enough that
- 42:18you're escaping some of the credentialism rat race.
- 42:22Like, isn't that the point of being truly successful That
- 42:25you're like, we have the credentials?
- 42:28Like what does she need credentials for?
- 42:29Credentials matter so much more to people who don't have them.
- 42:32So you have this, like, weird world where for folks like the
- 42:36kids in this book and for people all over the country, they're
- 42:38like, I just need that credential and that will give me
- 42:40security. And then there's a swath of
- 42:42people who are like, I already have them but still want it for
- 42:45other reasons. Right?
- 42:46There aren't survival, but they have a lot of social capital on
- 42:50their and then that's when you get Varsity Blues, right?
- 42:54Everyone using what it is they have what they have.
- 42:57Varsity Blues is paying people to get them on fake teams to get
- 43:01recruited. There are people in my life that
- 43:04I wonder if they were Varsity Blues.
- 43:07I, I mean, I know when people are really upset about
- 43:09affirmative action and I, I'm like, OK, fine.
- 43:12But there is a way in which other forms of admissions
- 43:16processes, looking at you legacy admissions.
- 43:20Sometimes athletics really, really does save spots for
- 43:25students who might not have hit that meritocratic bar.
- 43:29Right, right. They fell in between the gap,
- 43:31right? It's like they're still, you
- 43:34know, related to rich people, but they didn't have the exact
- 43:36legacy that would have allowed them to get into this school.
- 43:39And so they don't have like the the the grit story to tell, but
- 43:42they also don't have the legacy thing.
- 43:43And so they're weirdly in the middle and suddenly they, you
- 43:45know, they apply to USC as like a, a kicker or something play.
- 43:49This forward like OK for. The golf team.
- 43:52If JD Vance becomes president and like, succeeds.
- 43:55I mean, The funny thing about the Conservatives is like, they
- 43:58don't know how to, they talk about building, building,
- 43:59building, but they don't know how to build any institutions,
- 44:02right? It's like.
- 44:03University of Austin. University of Austin.
- 44:06Yeah, exactly. Like, yeah, let's see.
- 44:09But so it's like, are they able to reform the elite institutions
- 44:14in America? And then if a Democrat wins,
- 44:17like do we just go back to Obama era sort of aspirational
- 44:22meritocracy or how do you see this playing out depending on,
- 44:26you know, a few thousand American voters and how they how
- 44:30they swing and therefore how we set the cultural and political
- 44:33power of, you know, the next 10 years?
- 44:36And I want to add, add on to Eric's question, like how does
- 44:39like the war that the Trump administration has waged on
- 44:43institutions, you know, you know, elite institutions during,
- 44:47you know, his term, Like how is that affected all of this as
- 44:50well? The first question is really
- 44:52interesting because it the impact it's had.
- 44:55I understand there were free speech on campus issues before
- 44:57Trump became president in 2016, even that there were people who
- 45:01are very worried about a group think around progressive ideas.
- 45:06And, you know, it's just reading Jill Lepore's book.
- 45:08She's professor at Harvard. And she was like, you would be
- 45:10lying if you said that there wasn't a lot of social critique
- 45:14around people who did not hold specific sets of liberal ideas.
- 45:19And the Crimson, you know, I like follow the Crimson over the
- 45:21years and there was definitely a period where I was like
- 45:24terrifyingly like boring and sort of, you know, woke and
- 45:27like, but you just felt like, I just felt like an out of touch
- 45:30alum, like I guess like, oh, the times change and I but then but
- 45:33none of. The kids was lifting up their.
- 45:35Coverage gets much better and it feels like, oh, this is the
- 45:38Viron place, sort of, I remember.
- 45:40So there was that. Period.
- 45:42The Trump administration is brought to bear over how you're
- 45:44allowed to think in higher Ed is that they will put you in jail
- 45:47if you. Could right?
- 45:49Exactly, just letting the woke period play out, which it would
- 45:51have burned off on its own. It was.
- 45:53Burning off on its own. But now it's like we will arrest
- 45:57you and might prosecute you and we're going to use the Title 6
- 46:01process, Title nine, Title 3, all the titles to bring
- 46:04investigations to bear, frustrating investigations.
- 46:07And we'll cut off your federal funding if you stray from a
- 46:11certain set of ideals. So I think that the degree to
- 46:14which we're seeing ideas in the Academy flow or not flow has has
- 46:21certainly the Trump administration has a big impact.
- 46:24And the reason why that's important is because a lot of
- 46:27the ideas that come out of the Academy, even the ones that we
- 46:29think of as the most absurd in their moment, right?
- 46:33Whether that is liberalism, whether that is postmodernism,
- 46:36whether that is certain kinds of gender, you know, gender study
- 46:42in their moment in the 50s, seventies, 80s might seem
- 46:47absurd. They become really important
- 46:50underpinnings for how we think as a society, whether we want
- 46:52them to or not. We always do flow.
- 46:54It's like it's tough in the Devil Word Prada, like I knew.
- 46:57You were going there. I knew you were going there.
- 46:59Yep. It's like a.
- 47:00Sweater that you're wearing was like a decision that was made.
- 47:03By both brilliant. OK, so here I was like which
- 47:05color was it? I was?
- 47:06Going to want we do not want this for our universities
- 47:09because it is it's it is such a compass for where we're going to
- 47:14go. And we have seen historically
- 47:15that you can roll back progress like progressive ideas much
- 47:20faster than people expected. And again, that the
- 47:23Reconstruction period, which is understudied I think in American
- 47:26history you have huge gains made for black people after slavery
- 47:30is abolishing after the Civil War.
- 47:31You have many, many black people elected to federal office, to
- 47:37Congress. You have.
- 47:39The establishment of the public school system came during.
- 47:43Public schools, especially all over the South, you have a push
- 47:46for more equal education, you have a push for desegregation.
- 47:49You have colleges like Oberlin, you know, accepting black
- 47:54students. They're one of the earliest.
- 47:55They're all sorts of things that are flourishing in the wake of
- 47:59the Civil War, right in like the late 1860s.
- 48:03And then from then you have this sort of like golden couple
- 48:06decades. And then you have the rise of
- 48:10Jim Crow, the Ku Klux Klan, militarized white supremacy and
- 48:16a very, very repressive Supreme Court coinciding with an
- 48:20extremely socially conservative Academy that is that believe
- 48:24strongly in things like eugenics.
- 48:27So, you know, these things can move pretty quickly.
- 48:29So that's a long winded way of saying depending on who wins the
- 48:33next election, can we see even forgot the next election just in
- 48:37the next three years? Can we see the way we think of
- 48:40rights for immigrants, black people, gay people, women,
- 48:44insider, outsider? Who is us when we think of who
- 48:47is. Going to.
- 48:48Change. Absolutely.
- 48:49This doesn't. Even include the fact that I
- 48:52think and people used to think that America should be the
- 48:55global meritocratic elite, not the American meritocratic elite.
- 49:00And they were denying, perhaps most importantly, like all the
- 49:04every talented person all over the globe, all to come to
- 49:07America and, you know, yeah, great things here and.
- 49:11What was that forward US or whatever like Mark Zuckerberg
- 49:14once had a pro immigration nonprofit dedicated.
- 49:19Well, we'll see how the midterms go, could come back, or at least
- 49:21the next election. But but a point behind your
- 49:24point is just that they even if they haven't built institutions,
- 49:27you know, we're not getting the next intersectionality or there
- 49:30there's lots of ideas that the Academy could have had that
- 49:33they're probably afraid to have and that could have lasting.
- 49:36Well, I also like wonder what, like what social, how social
- 49:39media fits in all of this too, because like all of these ideas,
- 49:42the, the, the, the, the terminology, like the kookiness
- 49:45of the way people discuss social issues on college campuses.
- 49:48It's existed for decades, right? I mean, like, hey, you went to
- 49:51school in like the mid to late 90s.
- 49:52Like all this political correctness that has been
- 49:55rebranded as woke ISM has been here before.
- 49:58None of it's very new, but social media has allowed it to
- 50:01kind of break containment where you have random people in, you
- 50:04know, maybe never went to college and what whatever parts
- 50:07of the country getting extremely angry about, you know, trans
- 50:12rights or heteronormativity or I mean, pick whatever terminology
- 50:16that like they're pissed off about because Tucker Carlson
- 50:18told him to be mad about it. Like, I think that the fact that
- 50:22it can kind of exist in this very accessible information
- 50:25system, it's kind of allowed the debates that happen on college
- 50:28campuses to become things that people get super fucking mad
- 50:31about, you know? Because they're taken so out of
- 50:34context, right? So like a fierce debate over the
- 50:37way that commerce and feminism work in, you know, a book like
- 50:43Pamela or like Tom Jones, the rise of 18th century novels, as
- 50:50people are debating fiercely some postmodern ideals about
- 50:53Marxism and feminism. They make sense in the context
- 50:57of those academic environments, right?
- 50:59They make sense in the context of that specific classroom where
- 51:04you're are basically just trying almost to train your mind to be
- 51:07agile around difficult concepts and to see a different worldview
- 51:12in a narrow setting in a narrow set of goals.
- 51:15Yes. Does it sound absolutely absurd
- 51:18outside of that context? Yes.
- 51:20And did it have a way to migrate outside of that context before
- 51:23social media? No, it most certainly did not.
- 51:25I went to school in May and trust me when I say the
- 51:27conversations that I had in random lecture halls and not
- 51:30leave not only did. They not I mean.
- 51:32Obviously they didn't move that building.
- 51:35The things we're talking about super important.
- 51:37But like I do, I do wonder like how much smartphones do or do
- 51:41not destroy our brains. The shift to like video, some of
- 51:44the like stuff around how techno technology is changing how
- 51:48people think might end up being the larger force.
- 51:51Like, obviously there's this sort of, I don't know, the
- 51:54social force ebb and flow of, you know, how much racism is
- 51:57accepted, who are the elites? But like, if everybody stops
- 52:01reading like that's going to be, it's going to be a dark force.
- 52:06Well, yeah, I mean, think about someone like Charlie Kirk, like
- 52:08his whole shtick was going onto college campuses and basically
- 52:12exposing old people to the kinds of things that, like young
- 52:16people are talking about on college campus.
- 52:17And it made them so mad. Like there's there's so much
- 52:20salience to like these kinds of conversations.
- 52:22And like, that is the core of definitely the conservative or
- 52:25like reactionary movement is, is like, how can we make people
- 52:29really mad about the things that people were talking about in
- 52:31college? And Charlie Kirk, who's kind of
- 52:33like a young, you know, social media savvy, but also, you know,
- 52:36he's conservative in his, you know, traditional family values.
- 52:39He's a perfect, you know, perfect like vessel for, for all
- 52:43of that. It, it is amazing to me how
- 52:46much, you know, during the pandemic there was sort of like
- 52:50the Peter Thiel's of the world saying the thing.
- 52:52You can't say it's probably true.
- 52:54And it's like people like us were like, what could that be
- 52:57besides racism, right? Like the thing And now we have
- 53:01like Elon must be like apartheid was, you know, terrible for
- 53:05society and you're. Coming after the whites.
- 53:08Right. I mean, literally, yeah.
- 53:10There was another big one where somebody retweeted like, you
- 53:12know, just a list of like Rhodesia.
- 53:14Obviously I'm not I'm not necessarily scholar in all the
- 53:17societies that were once white ruled and then were were no
- 53:21longer but. You're yeah.
- 53:23Now I you have to know him, you know, but not even a dog.
- 53:26But literally today, like Homeland Security in the
- 53:29Department of Labor are tweeting this sort of like, you know,
- 53:32clearly echoing sort of Nazism, like what is the homeland for
- 53:37the United States? Like, I don't, I don't
- 53:38understand what a heritage American is.
- 53:41It's totally incoherent. I don't know.
- 53:42That's, that's a rant. But Katie, take from whatever
- 53:45you can from that. Like what where's this headed?
- 53:48Like, besides that, people feel really emboldened, I guess, at
- 53:51least to be honest with what they must have been feeling
- 53:54before. And I was naive enough to think
- 53:56like, surely racism if not solved.
- 54:01Like I, I understood that people were like, you know, we would
- 54:04fight about like the pipeline problem and say, well, there
- 54:06just aren't enough talented candidates.
- 54:07Like we can't get anybody. Like the the fight I took the
- 54:10fight to be sincerely on those terms rather than no, we just
- 54:16like are sort of, we are pretty much racist or we, you know, we
- 54:20yeah, I, I, I don't know, like what?
- 54:22I guess people harbored much darker views than I, I, I
- 54:25realized growing up. Yeah.
- 54:26I mean, I think it's, it's interesting kind of see the
- 54:29country, the ID of the country kind of take over because again,
- 54:34it's, it's it whether you're talking about this, the
- 54:39institutions, whether you're talking about systems, it is
- 54:42just people. And so we've had a long time
- 54:45where there was a consensus view, whether people liked it or
- 54:48not, but consensus view based on the law, based on legal changes,
- 54:52that there was going to be some sort of racial equality.
- 54:55Once that is dismantled, especially once the legal
- 54:58underpinnings for that are dismantled, Voting Rights Act,
- 55:01Civil Rights Act, that we will see a big fast change.
- 55:08And we're already seeing it. So I think you're making a very
- 55:11correct observation about the world we're entering, even
- 55:16though that sounds very depressing.
- 55:17I will say again, these systems are just people.
- 55:20Our society is just people and people have different opinions,
- 55:24but everybody, it's, it's a mass of people, but only really truly
- 55:30of that mass, a small percentage really want to change things.
- 55:33So we are watching a small percentage of people make big
- 55:35changes. There's going to be a small
- 55:37percentage of people, as there always has been, who are willing
- 55:40to push back against that, right.
- 55:42So we had slavery, you had abolitionists, you had people
- 55:46create the, I don't even know how the Underground Railroad
- 55:48could be created today because people can't keep secrets and
- 55:50they want to put everything on the Internet.
- 55:51But you had a small, all number of people, proportionally who
- 55:56were like, we need to make a serious change.
- 55:59And they fought for it and fought for it and fought for it.
- 56:01Many of them died before they saw their work really changed
- 56:04the world. But it, it did change the world,
- 56:07right? And then we saw it again in the
- 56:09abolition of Jim probe. We've seen it as people have
- 56:11fought for the rights of Native Americans.
- 56:13We have seen it and, you know, like all sorts of venues where
- 56:17there's been this huge regression.
- 56:19So I it's impossible for me to believe that in this vast
- 56:24country, everybody is going to roll over and say, I guess we
- 56:28just do immigrants anymore. And one thing that does make me
- 56:31optimistic, you know, this, Renee, good murder, you know, is
- 56:35obviously terrible and, you know, looms very large in my
- 56:39heart and mind. And I mean, I do think in
- 56:43another world, there would be many, many more of those people
- 56:46before it became so visible. But in a world of video and
- 56:51social media at once, I feel like we're more miserable, are
- 56:56made miserable because we're forced to face reality of
- 56:59terrible situations. But I think one thing that gives
- 57:01me hope is that at least that, you know, it takes one.
- 57:05I mean, and obviously there are other people who've been killed
- 57:07by ice, but it, you know, it doesn't take as many of these
- 57:10horrific things for them to reach mass visibility in the way
- 57:14that, you know, obviously during segregation, as you talk about
- 57:17miracle children, like, you know, you needed Freedom Riders
- 57:19and you need all this concerted effort to really build like make
- 57:23these things visible. Whereas right now, I guess
- 57:25everybody's a social media influencer.
- 57:27So there's almost like an effort.
- 57:28Anything horrible is being surfaced to our society.
- 57:33And I I think that honestly, it makes for depressing living, but
- 57:36I do wonder if it will protect us more than it hurts us.
- 57:41Yeah, I mean, if somebody had told me pre social media that
- 57:48that Gaza would become a a 'cause that young people.
- 57:53A mainstream cause. In the United States would care
- 57:56about, you know, every the Palestinian rights movement has
- 57:59been around robustly since the 70s, like there were.
- 58:03And on college campuses specifically, like it was a
- 58:05product very much of of undergrads mostly kind of like.
- 58:09Absolutely. UCLA, like University of San
- 58:12Francisco, Berkeley. And yet what mainstreamed it was
- 58:16probably to Eric's point. Watching videos of children
- 58:20burning to death, starving people, people being shot at as
- 58:24they try to get food, like those are very, very searing images.
- 58:28Yeah, Can maybe like close this in talking about Silicon Valley
- 58:33again a bit because you spent, how many years were you covering
- 58:36tech when you were in San Francisco like 54?
- 58:38Years. Five I think. 55 maybe no.
- 58:42Five. And then you got like the you
- 58:44got the fuck out of Dodd. You were like done with San
- 58:45Francisco. You're like, I'm out, I'm gone.
- 58:50My formative tech, you know, the early days.
- 58:53Kate, Katie and I worked across from each other at The
- 58:55Information. Then she went to Bloomberg View.
- 58:57I was at Bloomberg. Tom joined us at The
- 59:00Information, so we all covered tech together.
- 59:03You'd been at Fortune writing about business generally before.
- 59:06That was it. It wasn't as pure tech right
- 59:09before. You.
- 59:09No, it was more Wall Street. Right.
- 59:11Yeah. It was like finance, I thought.
- 59:12Yeah. Then you covered Apple for the
- 59:14New York Times and you covered the Justice Department.
- 59:17So now that you know, that listener like you can go back
- 59:19and oh, every the legal dismantling point was very the
- 59:22New York Times Justice Department reporter was worried
- 59:25about this, but anyway. What do you think about like
- 59:28where Silicon Valley sits in the kind of college conversation?
- 59:34And and you know, Eric mentioned Peter Thiel earlier.
- 59:37Obviously the thing that made him famous for a a bit was
- 59:39encouraging people to drop out of college and they're at at a
- 59:44surface level. Is this like anti college
- 59:46mentality here that like the time that you spend in a
- 59:49university reduces your creativity and your ability to
- 59:52create the kind of startups that would actually disrupt the
- 59:54world? I've made my point clear, and I
- 59:56think you guys probably agree that like the elite institutions
- 1:00:00run most of Silicon Valley. There there is not truly a huge
- 1:00:04amount of disruption in that system around here.
- 1:00:07But yeah, I mean, looking at someone who's been in DC, which
- 1:00:10is the ultimate, you know, lanyard elite, you know, part of
- 1:00:14the country, Like, what do you, what do you sort of see looking
- 1:00:17at this industry now and like the way it's dealing with
- 1:00:19college and all of these issues? It was interesting.
- 1:00:22I've always wondered when Peter Tell said that, how much of the
- 1:00:25reason he said that was because he hated the direction that
- 1:00:27higher Ed had taken in terms of social issues.
- 1:00:30He was famously one of the cofounders of Stanford.
- 1:00:33It's more conservative publication.
- 1:00:36He felt like the college prey to vocalism before that term was
- 1:00:41popular. And so, yes, when he was telling
- 1:00:44people not to bother with college, it was certainly
- 1:00:46because he was like, you have a lot of energy and creativity,
- 1:00:48and you can work for 20 hours a day when you're 19.
- 1:00:52But also, there was something about college that I think he
- 1:00:55had always been uncomfortable with.
- 1:00:56And now that there's this bigger crackdown happening, I do wonder
- 1:01:01if he would still see college is not valuable or if he would if
- 1:01:06if he would change his mind on that, I mean.
- 1:01:08He's still doing the Teal Fellows.
- 1:01:09I don't know. I don't think he's about to
- 1:01:10become pro college. There, there.
- 1:01:14But would he be more likely to hire a student who'd gone to
- 1:01:17Yale now? Maybe like if he, that kid
- 1:01:21hadn't, you know, been talking about trans rights.
- 1:01:28I don't know. Tech has changed so much in
- 1:01:30terms of how DC sees it. Under the Obama administration,
- 1:01:33it was seen as this force for good.
- 1:01:35After the 2016 election, it was seen as they.
- 1:01:37All went and worked. All the Obama people went and
- 1:01:39worked. It's like flax for tech
- 1:01:40companies. Yes.
- 1:01:41But what's interesting now is that there's almost like a very
- 1:01:46unvarnished view of the technology industry under this
- 1:01:48administration, which is a very transactional administration.
- 1:01:51Now the tech industry is seen as a source of funds, capital for
- 1:01:57the administration, so for the industry, and we've seen which
- 1:02:01exactly. For the East wing expansion, pay
- 1:02:03for. It's, it's like now it's no
- 1:02:06longer like, are you good or are you evil?
- 1:02:08It's do you financially help this group of people?
- 1:02:12Right. Literally what?
- 1:02:13Mark Zuckerberg? Facebook just appointed a new
- 1:02:15president who is the wife of Republican.
- 1:02:19Dina Powell. She's like a total creature of
- 1:02:22DC. Yeah, yes, she is.
- 1:02:24She was like, was it Dick Army? I forgot which congressman she
- 1:02:28was. She she was like one of his
- 1:02:29admins. I mean, she's been there forever
- 1:02:31and. The conservatives would say
- 1:02:32what, you know, Sheryl Sandberg, you know, very cozy with the
- 1:02:37Democrats. You know, it's like it's one
- 1:02:39thing for the other, you know? And it's one of the differences,
- 1:02:42though, is that while the Democrats or Republicans before
- 1:02:45them may have sought the power, money and influence of an
- 1:02:50industry, they tried not to talk about it so openly.
- 1:02:55You know they did it the old school way.
- 1:02:57You know I. Actually don't know if this is
- 1:02:58better or worse, I won't say that.
- 1:03:00It's definitely worth because it's just like, you know, it
- 1:03:02accelerates it. You know, I, Matt Iglesias, had
- 1:03:04something somebody sent me, which is just like, I haven't
- 1:03:07actually pulled up. This seems to me like a pretty
- 1:03:09profound difference from contemporary society these days.
- 1:03:12I feel like the general vibe even, perhaps especially in
- 1:03:14elite circles, is that the worst thing you can be is a sucker.
- 1:03:18You don't want to break the law or directly steal from or
- 1:03:21physically injure other people, but you are seen as holding some
- 1:03:24kind of obligation to yourself and your family to exploit every
- 1:03:28angle available, not just because you want to gratify
- 1:03:30yourself, but because everyone is doing it.
- 1:03:32And I do. As a member of elite of the
- 1:03:33elite, I think that is one of the most corrosive things
- 1:03:37happening right now. I think most elites still scoff
- 1:03:40at the classless law breaking of the Trump people.
- 1:03:44But I do think there's this pressure of like, man, get yours
- 1:03:48like because it's sort of like it's like, I don't know, crypto
- 1:03:51ad part of it, you know, just who's winning, you know, in
- 1:03:54Silicon Valley, like it's yeah, it's a crazy.
- 1:03:58You don't want to be a sucker. Is is, is.
- 1:04:00And I think that's going to be a corrosive force to the elites.
- 1:04:02And I think as somebody with a microphone, you know, I will,
- 1:04:06I'm going to hold against that. I'm not encouraging our
- 1:04:08listeners to have that view. And I'm not going to embrace
- 1:04:10that view. And, you know, I think there is
- 1:04:13the moral capacity to resist the view, but it's definitely one
- 1:04:17that looms large. And I literally, I think I said
- 1:04:19on one of our team calls that I got the nihilism of 2025 made
- 1:04:23life so hard as a reporter. You know, it's like if your job
- 1:04:28is to call balls and strikes and view some meaning some of the
- 1:04:32time, it's like if everyone's nihilistic, like that's a, it's
- 1:04:35a Dark World to write and opine. But I, I do think honestly, in
- 1:04:39some ways, the Trump administration becoming so
- 1:04:42horrifying is a return to morality.
- 1:04:45These are like, Oh, no, I I believe in things like this is
- 1:04:48terrible. Like, and then if you once
- 1:04:50you're activating sort of that moral like alarm bell, I think
- 1:04:54it's easier to be like, Oh, I'm operating on other things and
- 1:04:56just like winning some, some game.
- 1:04:59So I don't know. My hope is the horribleness of
- 1:05:032026 awakens people to some degree and doesn't allow for
- 1:05:08this sort of slippage and to just you don't want to be a
- 1:05:11sucker, you need to get yours and graft everything.
- 1:05:13Which I guess sort of brings you back to your book, right?
- 1:05:16I mean, that's the ultimate graft, right?
- 1:05:17It's someone who recognized the system as it was, exploited it
- 1:05:20to benefit obviously himself. But he was maybe arguing the
- 1:05:23people that went to his school obviously was abusive in in the
- 1:05:27way he did it. But it's sort of like a proto
- 1:05:29Trumpian or or Trump era mentality of like there is a
- 1:05:34real problem in the way the system works.
- 1:05:36But I could get mine by. Engineering, Denzel Washington
- 1:05:40and Training Day. I will do anything you want me
- 1:05:42to do. Come on.
- 1:05:49Oh, I haven't gotten to that party.
- 1:05:50I'm, you know, not that far. But that's I'm excited to get to
- 1:05:54that line. That's I'm fascinated in what
- 1:06:00way he like gives us. What's he expound on that?
- 1:06:04There are people, the people he heroizes and he loves, the art
- 1:06:08of war. He loves but the art of.
- 1:06:11War isn't. I feel like the people who love
- 1:06:13the art of war didn't read the Art of War.
- 1:06:15The actual art of. War, you know, he, he, he, he
- 1:06:21talks to the students and says you're warriors in a war against
- 1:06:24black people and we're going to fight and win.
- 1:06:25You know, he could see how his messages were somehow compelling
- 1:06:28to people who did feel like were unfair.
- 1:06:30But then he'd be like, you know, he loves Denzel Washington
- 1:06:33Training Day, like he loves the principal in New Jersey.
- 1:06:40Why am I blanking at his name? Oh, stand the stand and deliver,
- 1:06:43guy. Yeah, stand.
- 1:06:44You know who? Who?
- 1:06:45I may ask Joe Harp who? No Joe Clark, who would walk
- 1:06:49around with a baseball bat. You know, like Clark would.
- 1:06:51Not stand in, not the inside user.
- 1:06:53Played by Lean on Me. Lean on Oh, sorry.
- 1:06:56Yeah, OK. Yeah, so it's like he, he, he,
- 1:07:00he heroizes like the principal who walked around the halls of
- 1:07:04his high school with a baseball bat, kicking students out, you
- 1:07:08know? So like, he has a very specific
- 1:07:09vision of power, you know? What I love about these people
- 1:07:12is they never fucking finish the story.
- 1:07:16It's just like Denzel Washington.
- 1:07:18Yeah, Denzel Washington's character dies in training.
- 1:07:21Alfonso Harris is dead. And you know what happened to
- 1:07:24Joe Clark? He ended up getting pushed out,
- 1:07:28and he became a prison guard at a juvenile detention center
- 1:07:32where he was investigated for torturing students.
- 1:07:34It's like. You know who my personal hero
- 1:07:37is, by the way? Icarus, because that guy flew
- 1:07:38really high. That guy was so good at flying
- 1:07:42high. And I'm just like, that's me.
- 1:07:43I want to fly high too. Don't tell me what happens, but
- 1:07:47he's cool. Katie, great to have you on the
- 1:07:50show. I miss the dead cat days.
- 1:07:52This was a lot of fun. And the New York Times needs to
- 1:07:55cut everybody loose. You know, it's a world of
- 1:07:57influencers now, but. I mean, let them do what they
- 1:08:00want, not fire people, right? That's me, yeah.
- 1:08:02Read read yeah, not let them keep their jobs and.
- 1:08:06All freelancers. It's all just yeah.
- 1:08:09Miracle children, race, education and a true story of
- 1:08:12false promises by Katie Benner, who we've been talking to and
- 1:08:15her co-author Erica Green. Also the New York Times
- 1:08:17wonderful book important to read.
- 1:08:19Especially important now is we've all all morals who are the
- 1:08:26elites. How colleges work are up for
- 1:08:28debate. I guess so understand your
- 1:08:30history. And I think, you know, obviously
- 1:08:33this is about once it's, you know, it's school.
- 1:08:36But I think the, you know, the book is clearly about the
- 1:08:39broader story of how American elite education has changed over
- 1:08:43the decades. Thank.
- 1:08:44You. Thank you.
- 1:08:46Thanks. Thank you for tuning into this
- 1:08:48week's episode of the podcast. If you're new here, please like
- 1:08:51and subscribe. It really helps out the channel.
- 1:08:53Listen in for new episodes every week, wherever you get your
- 1:08:55podcasts.