Latest / Quantum Potential / Law Professor Lauren Sudeall on Building a “Person-Centered” Judicial System
Transcript
- 0:00If I think about these papers or a lot of the work that I do, you could think about some of it as addressing these blind There are these areas that we're just not focused on, and probably why I've been drawn to a lot of the work I've a lawyer, but also as an academic.
- 0:13People are thinking about eviction, but they're not it in ... in these places, right?
- 0:17They're thinking about civil legal needs, but they're it with respect to this population.
- 0:23And I think not only is it important, but I think real lesson here for thinking about people just feeling ignored or being left out of a narrative and what happens, right?
- 0:32And part of what happens, at least in the legal system, is respect, right, and trust in the courts.
- 0:39Today I'm so excited to introduce Lauren Sudeall, who joined Vanderbilt Law in 2023 and who directs our Access to Justice Initiative.
- 0:47Lauren's research focuses on how lower-income individuals system—with or without a lawyer—and her work has been like the Columbia and Harvard law reviews.
- 1:09Welcome to Quantum Potential, a podcast dedicated to My name is Cybele Raver, and I serve as the provost of As a leader in higher education and as a social scientist, that we can transform higher education for the 21st century.
- 1:25At my core, I am wildly curious about other people's in science, the social sciences, the humanities or the arts.
- 1:34This podcast gives us the opportunity to break open new discovery and creative expression.
- 1:47Before joining academia, Lauren clerked for Judge on the 9th Circuit and Justice John She also worked at the Southern Center for Human Rights, indigent clients facing capital charges, and advocating to counsel in Alabama and Georgia.
- 2:04Lauren is a member of the American Law Institute an associate reporter on high-volume civil adjudication.
- 2:10With degrees from Yale and Harvard Law School of the Harvard Law Review, Lauren brings deep expertise and insight to Vanderbilt.
- 2:18We are so lucky to have her with us today.
- 2:20Thank you so much for having me.
- 2:21It's great to have you, Lauren.
- 2:23Really exciting.
- 2:24I was really captivated by your work, specifically addressing the needs of everyday people.
- 2:29This idea that there are so many people in this country don't have access to legal representation.
- 2:38You have a great paper called"Creating a People-First Court where you really set out to reframe and reorient legal understanding for analyzing cases and shifting that to understanding people's law by looking at court data in a fundamentally different way.
- 2:56I'm fascinated by that, the idea that if we took a approach, that we would see people's experiences across of court proceedings, different encounters with the legal Can you tell us a little bit more about that?
- 3:11Sure. Courts are meant to serve people, ultimately, and so in ways, I don't think this should be a particularly radical They're meant to help people resolve disputes, things that come up in everyday lives: things relating to your housing, to your family, to your job.
- 3:26And yet the way in which courts are designed are, for the most by lawyers and for lawyers.
- 3:32And the reality is that most people in navigating the legal system today don't have a lawyer, so not only might they be frustrated by some of what they and what they encounter is probably very different from but it actually makes it difficult, if not impossible, them to resolve these issues.
- 3:48One piece of that that we tried to address in this paper was thinking about what courts are tracking or how they're tracking fact that they track cases makes sense, that's sort of how they view the world, right: How many cases are they moving through their system?
- 4:01How fast can they get through them?
- 4:03But the problem is the way in which they see the world doesn't to see what that experience is like from the individual's So my colleague, Charlotte Alexander, and I set out to try conceive of the system differently.
- 4:16That required a lot of restructuring of court data, which took us about a year— which should maybe show you how difficult it is to actually reconfigure the data in this way.
- 4:25But what we hoped that would allow us to do was to think courts and the court process ...
- 4:29not through the lens of the courts and but instead through the person, right?
- 4:34A person may have multiple different touchpoints with over a long period of time, and we wanted points and get a really broad picture of what their experience It made me, as you were speaking, immediately think you know, this university.
- 4:49What if I, in my role as provost, only focused on classes and I never asked what was a student's experience moving from Or what was the student's experience of And that idea of seeing the system from of service or from the institutional perspective way in which individuals are navigating those systems ...
- 5:16But to do that, you did this amazing thing methodologically, You actually basically completely took and I just thought it would be really helpful if you tell us a about what you did in terms of finding this random set of a out of tens of thousands of cases in I think one thing to point out is that we were how we had to approach this because of So we did most of this through data scraping, and one of the challenges was, was we had to figure out where We couldn't just sort of get this whole universe of cases.
- 5:54We had to have a more targeted beginning.
- 5:55So we started, for a few different reasons, by who had criminal cases.
- 6:01Part of why we did that is because criminal court data information about demographics— things like race and gender—and we wanted to have that Yet civil cases often don't have that information.
- 6:12So we knew one benefit of starting with that data set is we would have that information.
- 6:17The downside of that is that it does mean that the data set we limited to people who had some engagement with the, with the We weren't able to capture people who had no engagement that part of the system at all.
- 6:28But essentially we went through a process of identifying a group and then ... using those people, ran systems to try to get all of the cases affiliated with those This was a complicated process, in part because we also had to disambiguate people who had similar names and trying to cases truly were of the same person.
- 6:49So we went through a very long, complex process to do that, and in the end also had to get rid of some cases where we be sure that we were actually dealing with the same person.
- 6:58But what we were ultimately left with was this data set of ...
- 7:02all of the cases that sprung from the through this criminal case data set.
- 7:09Amazing.
- 7:10And when you did that, if you could just give us a sense or a feeling of, uh, what level of, not only that you were confident that you found but the sense that people did in fact have multiple touchpoints with different courts?
- 7:23I think the findings, um, that were yielded from that paper surprising from my perspective.
- 7:30So you get a sense, right, not only of how many cases each average, but things like what are the what is the sequence of those cases?
- 7:39What is the average amount of time that Um, I mean, there's so much more.
- 7:44This is in a way is really just the beginning.
- 7:46It's sort of, we, we framed this as that it would be so difficult to do.
- 7:51But our hope is really to demonstrate the kinds of things find, more so than the entire universe of what you might find.
- 7:58Um, but to give sort of one more concrete example: So if you think about how different case of the things that we saw was we looked Um, so we looked at people who'd experienced one eviction, and we were able to see that people who'd experienced a 30% of those people had another case follow in the same year.
- 8:21For people who had experienced serial evictions, so multiple evictions with the same landlord, those people had a 56% chance of having And for people who had experienced eviction with landlords, the number went up to 80%.
- 8:35So ... we were careful to not make claims about causation but I think that might suggest a relationship, for example, between housing instability and future legal engagement.
- 8:45The fact the more, sort of, intensely you're experiencing that might sort of ... have ripple effects and I think, to me, that's a really important finding.
- 8:56Absolutely.
- 8:56I ... I'm so glad you went to that point causal claims from those data, but instead pointing out that misfortune begets more misfortune somehow, that, um, families are experiencing multiple challenges and that they cascade in a way that, um, certainly aligns with experience poverty-related stressors: That housing instability and food insufficiency and job loss, can sometimes co-occur in ways that are profoundly, uh, to families.
- 9:29But I think that way in which you saw really poignant, but also really telling.
- 9:36And that you were very careful to steer out of where I think we often get stuck, honestly, which is um, "Well, so is that really a problem of proneness to be evicted on the individual side?
- 9:49Or proneness of the court to, uh, generate problem that it, uh, leads to a family to be more unstably Right— this idea that having a writ against you leads you to a ... more difficult time getting a lease in your next So that idea that you're avoiding those causal claims, but you do have this really great way of damage or collateral consequences.
- 10:17Can you talk a little bit about that construct?
- 10:20Sure.
- 10:20One point that I just wanted to make, I think, that touches on a things that you've said is ...
- 10:23the, the your analogy to the university context, I think is an it's, it's broken into these silos, and it sort of neatly packages things and labels them.
- 10:35Whether it's civil, criminal, right? History, English, law— but yet the reality for people's lives of different issues, and often there's a lot of overlap between Not only might one issue lead to another, but one incident can touch many of these different contexts, right?
- 10:55So, um, I think domestic violence is a good example of Somebody ... one incident of violence could It might require that somebody else get an order of protection, which is a civil matter.
- 11:06It may involve needing to relocate in terms of housing.
- 11:10It may involve a lot of family law issues—divorce, custody— and yet these issues are placed in all different parts of the when the reality is a person is dealing with this one issue and has all of these things that need to be ... need to be So I think the way in which we've constructed the system is mapped well onto, onto people's lives, which means it's not very, it's not efficient for the courts and really work well for courts because they certainly doesn't work well for the people Yeah, I mean, I think that was so well put regardless of cause uh, causal effects, uh, and which, uh, issues are driving issues that, uh, really complicate families' lives or courts and this, the nonprofit organizations that are providing services to families, still have to manage and or have, um, approaches to meeting individuals' needs.
- 12:08And this way in which a problem-focused court, whether court or family court, takes on those additional subsequent or preceding instances, at least it tries to, immediately I thought about the ways in which your students must have had a phenomenally clearer understanding of that— having done this people-centered effort to code the data, um, rather than a, a centered, uh, coding of the data.
- 12:37And I wondered how much your students, um, are interested in that more holistic approach, or whether they view it as, um, sort of Well, it is...
- 12:48it is a massive challenge.
- 12:49I don't think any one person or any one court can address all of but I think the reason that data is so important is because it gives us some sense of what the landscape even looks like.
- 12:58Part of why we wanted to do this project is because by not or making data available in this way, it really masks this entire different way of seeing the system.
- 13:08Which... you're right that it makes the problem seem maybe even larger in some sense, but I think it's a good starting point— not just for courts to think about how they should create problem solving or can deal with multiple different issues.
- 13:25But it also, as you sort of alluded to, helps legal service about how to structure their services.
- 13:31There are already a lot of examples of this with public offices that do use social workers or public defender offices working with legal aid offices sort of address various different problems that someone But I think, as you were saying, it's understand that when they're representing clients, they're In law school, we're guilty of the same siloing.
- 13:52I'm one of the very few people, I think, that I know in the really, who thinks about both of these different contexts.
- 13:58And I feel really fortunate to have practiced on the criminal but yet a lot of my research relates to the civil side.
- 14:03So I often find myself as sort of the civil access to justice, who has a lot And similarly, I find myself in conversations with criminal and scholars who aren't really thinking about the civil system.
- 14:18And I think for students it also is creative thinking about, right, how to I have a paper that I know we're not talking about today, but it's called"Delegalization," and the idea is taking ideas behind decriminalization and about whether any of those ideas could apply to the civil And I think it's straddling those two worlds that allows me to think about how concepts might translate from one sphere In your papers, um, I was really impressed quantitative data and qualitative data.
- 15:11And that you interviewed, you know, legal aid staff members, you interviewed court clerks, you interviewed judges, you interviewed public defenders— that way in which you were collecting the perspectives of stakeholders or participants in that, sort of, universe of Can you tell me a little bit about what ... how did they see What was it like driving around?
- 15:32You know, when I think about another of your papers that I talk about where you're in suburban and rural counties in was their view of you as a Harvard Law, you know, recently trained, uh, faculty member who's now at And how did it all work in terms of your own experience?
- 15:50It's a good question.
- 15:51Um, and you know, part of what I have been able to do in the last several years where not only do I get to learn about these issues in the field, but learn from colleagues.
- 16:03And also bringing law students and graduate students into that, to learn from each other and from...
- 16:07[Absolutely] people in different disciplines.
- 16:09So, and you know, to your point about mixed-method research ...
- 16:13to me, I almost find it hard to think about doing research, at regard to these issues, in any other way.
- 16:19Because the quantitative data gives you have a human element to ... to it and doesn't really explain why all the So part of what I really loved about that project was not only of what was happening in these courts, but, as you mentioned, talking to the people involved.
- 16:34And we felt like it was really important to get the perspective of a number of different people, so the judges, clerks and court personnel who in these courts thinking about state and local courts—play a really outsized Talking to tenants, talking to landlords, talking to law enforcement who are, you know, serving things on So that was really important.
- 16:56And as to, right, my role in it— it is sort of an irony.
- 17:00I'm someone who's spent a lot of time in major cities.
- 17:03I'm from the Northeast, so I'm not of a lot of time practicing in the South in And I was really struck when doing that I would be in on a day-to-day basis ...
- 17:17and how different they were from what but even what I would've had have conceived of as what a court was or should be.
- 17:24Um, so that, to me, being immersed as an academic and thinking about these issues, it, it struck me that a lot of the research similarly was big urban courts and maybe leaving this other piece of the You know, there you are clerking in a, in a Supreme Court and then you're in very small counties— uh, in very small rural counties in the U.S. South.
- 17:46To me, that must have just been a tremendous contrast, but perhaps, uh, maybe you saw similarities across both.
- 17:52I was just fascinated to think about your CV on the one hand, uh, you know, what I knew about you from, um, all your and then you as a data collector, as a person out in um, and how different or similar your experiences must have been.
- 18:08Well, we spend so much time, or even in I teach we don't necessarily do this— but we spend so much time focusing on such a small part of The number of cases that actually make it to the Supreme They're incredibly important, but they're also incredibly We're talking about, right, dozens of Yet state courts, the percentage of that are in state court day to day are, right, nearing 98, if We're talking about a lot of cases, and this is where most people spend their time.
- 18:41So to me it's sort of shocking that we don't spend more time and thinking about these courts.
- 18:46And, and think to your, to your other question, being a lawyer doing this work is sort of interesting because, and on one hand I think it other disciplines don't always have.
- 18:59I think at least I found from doing work with sociologists and they were amazed at the level of access I was able to get, I think, because there was sort of this sense from judges of you know, you're one of us and we can But at times there was also, I think, some skepticism or almost I was there with another agenda or to sue them for violations I was, I was going to find.
- 19:21You were in the know, but at I assuaged them, I convinced them that as a lawyer seeking to file a lawsuit.
- 19:27So there was that tension.
- 19:28But more so, I think it gave this level of access, which again is, I think, another real is that you have someone who has sort and maybe has that access but doesn't have knowledge around right quantitative methods.
- 19:42Um, and so I think bringing those things together gives you really good, more detailed picture of what's going on in Absolutely rich reading and very detailed, but also theoretically really fascinating.
- 19:53I love that you raise in your eviction paper, this idea of multiple axes of justice.
- 19:59The praxis and paradox of tenants' and, and landlords' going to court and working through the different ways in state eviction laws are applied.
- 20:09One of the things that was very moving to me was that the way were applied could look completely different in depending on the rurality of the court, depending on how many cases came through that particular court— and the way in which, um, you're really addressing what people come to court hoping for.
- 20:29I don't know if you would like to read what the metrics of, uh, justice are.
- 20:41In assessing the data resulting from this study, we found it to consider multiple axes of justice against which case and outcomes may be assessed.
- 20:49One obvious set of metrics relates to substantive outcomes: Who won and who lost?
- 20:54Was a monetary judgment awarded?
- 20:55And if so, how much?
- 20:57Was a writ of possession issued?
- 20:58And was the tenant ultimately evicted?
- 21:00Another set of metrics we considered in assessing the quantitative and qualitative data were Was the process by which the outcome was reached perceived as Was one party unfairly disadvantaged?
- 21:15I think that notion of "was it perceived as fair versus did I um, and that idea that people might have come out of court feeling that they were fairly treated, even though they lost— it speaks to such a, again, a dual lens on what the court is And in that paper you describe the way in which judges—perhaps surprisingly, perhaps not—were open to giving people their day their ... their opportunity to be heard, even if it meant that most of the time those people in court uh, postpone or have reduced their amount of rent owed, for um, they might not win on that front.
- 22:02But they, they, they might at least feel heard.
- 22:04Can you say a little bit more about that?
- 22:06One of the most surprising things and interesting things, I that emerged from the study was this contrast between um, justice and substantive outcomes.
- 22:17So there's this really deep literature on procedural justice importance of people feeling like they were heard and or perceiving the process as fair— in part because it affects people's view of the courts and they view the system as legitimate.
- 22:29And I think what was interesting ...
- 22:31and this relates to, I think, a, a broader what you already pointed out, the very you have the state law applying across all these different outcomes can be wildly different.
- 22:45I wrote another paper, that we're not gonna talk about at how eviction prevention measures that were promulgated government and by state courts actually played out in state And what you see is they played out in wildly different ways depending on the state, depending on the court.
- 23:02Um, so that's, that's another conversation.
- 23:05So you have these courts that are, that are operating very and there's a narrative, I think, around eviction court— and I think a lot of larger urban courts—that they're this mass processing of cases, so cases are flipped through one by one after another, and in these courts you get very little procedural justice.
- 23:22And so part of what was interesting is what we saw was counter to that narrative, right?
- 23:26In one case, we, you had a court that actually called people to make sure that the time of the hearing would work for them— set aside, dedicated time for people to hear their—which is unheard of in a appeal.
- 23:36Well, no, of course,'cause I grew up in New York City, the idea that the court check to see if you were coming, right?
- 23:41Right.
- 23:41Or just, right, or setting aside, right, specific assigned hearing times. And there was a real for the, for both sides, right— particularly the tenant—to tell their story.
- 23:52We talked to judges who really expressed this priority that have their day in court and that people be able to tell their But that didn't at all map onto better substantive outcomes.
- 24:04And part of why that is, is because you can give someone the opportunity to tell their story, but if they have no idea how or whether that story is relevant in the context of the law, not only might it not make a difference, but it might So one example is a tenant says in response to an eviction notice: "I owe rent, but I pay it because I lost my job.
- 24:25I was in the hospital.
- 24:26I had to pay a hospital bill." These are things that people, sort of, at a natural level sort of social realities, right— that's how they respond.
- 24:34"You hear me.
- 24:34You see me, you understand the, the challenge or the plight that Right?
- 24:38And the court says, "Sure, you know, tell us your story." They write it down.
- 24:41And then when it gets processed through the court, the court"That is a legally insufficient answer" because that's not a defense under the even having a hearing in court sometimes.
- 24:52So there's this real disconnect...
- 24:53And in fact, they've admitted to nonpayment, right?
- 24:55Right.
- 24:56There's a real disconnect between, right, it may on some level seem to be procedural justice.
- 25:01But it's only sort of this half-hearted version of justice because you're really not giving people any information as to how they're supposed to use that opportunity when they are being Yeah.
- 25:09And that conclusion, um, I have to say going into the paper was not what I expected, right?
- 25:16It was a surprising set of findings and conclusions.
- 25:19That in airing one's grievances or getting a hearing, it doesn't always work out for the tenant and could lead to a worse And that this idea that informal procedures for procedural not a substitute for substantive justice.
- 25:34That's such an incredibly powerful position to I think a lot about the, an additional paper that we had the read, that talks about individuals who've had previous civil court engagement around things like, um, where they weren't given any guidance or support in thinking or even knowing about, um, what kind of legal, uh, have had in those previous instances.
- 26:06So that that sense of trusting a system is impossible if you even know that that system exists.
- 26:13Just phenomenal in terms of thinking about all the space there is to develop for people's access to justice.
- 26:20Can you tell us a little bit more about that?
- 26:22Sure.
- 26:22When I think in a lot of ways, or if I think about these papers or a lot of the work that I do, I think you could think about some of it There are these areas that we're just not focused on.
- 26:32And I think it's probably why I've been drawn to a lot of the work I've done, both as a lawyer, but also as an academic, People are thinking about eviction, but they're not it in ... in these places.
- 26:42They're thinking about civil legal needs, but they're not it with respect to this population.
- 26:47And I think not only is it important—and I don't wanna bring in politics, but for, right, thinking about people just a narrative and what happens, right?
- 27:01And part of what happens, at least in respect and trust in the courts.
- 27:06Yeah.
- 27:06Um, so take what you will for that in, you know, in our But I think, you know, looking at these blind spots is ...
- 27:13not only to sort of shine a light on what's happening— because the people there are just as but I think they give us these unique opportunities to learn may be playing out in a different context.
- 27:24Which maybe you can't generalize that to make a conclusion about the whole system, but it can teach you something really Right.
- 27:30You know, the, the article we were talking about before: We're looking at these smaller courts when we're used to about these bigger courts, right?
- 27:37We learned something from that about the relationship between justice and substantive outcomes, where if you just looked at the larger courts, you might think two are correlated or make assumptions about why that's And I think we tell these narratives, right?
- 27:50Just one small example is ...
- 27:50we talk about ...
- 27:56talk about how there's this asymmetry as to who gets a So in a lot of these bigger courts, you have 90% of represented, but just 10% of tenants.
- 28:04And that's this common narrative that Well in these smaller courts, right, you've ... tenants almost never have representation.
- 28:12I think in the article we talk about the fact that most judges on one hand during their time on the seen a tenant with an attorney.
- 28:20But the landlords also don't have an attorney.
- 28:23The judge is often not an attorney.
- 28:26So you have this world where, right, issues are being resolved the legal system, and there's nary an attorney in the picture.
- 28:32Is that a good thing?
- 28:33Is that a bad thing?
- 28:34I actually don't know.
- 28:35And I think I'm not willing to make assumptions without, right, researching it more.
- 28:39But it certainly gives us a very different Um, with the article that you were sort of referencing in the there's been not enough research done, research done on civil legal needs.
- 28:53But often people who are incarcerated are left out of And that's for, I think, a number of different reasons.
- 28:58I think some of it has to do with the siloing of the system, also siloing of academics, right?
- 29:03Academics typically focus on one or the other, so you don't often get people thinking about the civil legal needs that people who are incarcerated may not as related to their criminal conviction, not related to collateral consequences, but just everyday civil legal needs that Um, and I think it also may be for other reasons.
- 29:21So for example, the Legal Services Corporation, which legal aid offices across the country, they don't allow those work with people who are incarcerated.
- 29:30So there is this sort of practical or But I think you can learn a lot of really interesting things or, and also think about really interesting points of when you're talking about a population that is in a very How is that working in terms of the way in which you're leading Vanderbilt, both with students and in terms of, uh, what you're to do either locally or regionally or nationally in up that issue of access to justice?
- 30:17Is that a message that is heard at the local level? Is it heard at the national level?
- 30:22How does that play out?
- 30:23So I, well, I think again, here, I often end up playing this role of the ... the blind spot identifier.
- 30:30And I, there's a lot of irony in the who's well known for speaking about rural courts when I've lived in a rural place in my life.
- 30:37I'm from Boston, I've lived in major cities across the country.
- 30:40But again, I think it's more just this inherent need to the bigger picture and seeing how this is playing out I think there's a real tension in the to come up with solutions that can be But as you were saying, which which is really real, is that every court is different, every jurisdiction is different.
- 31:01And so both trying to come up, right, sort but also knowing that they're going to context and for particular courts.
- 31:11So I think that's been a challenge, for example, with the project that I'm working on through the American Law Institute on high-volume civil adjudication, where we're trying to come up with procedures and suggestions courts operating in the context of thinking about how those courts really need to operate to actually serve the goals of fairness and accuracy and And trying to come up with solutions that can be thought sort of national broad solutions, knowing at the same time that ultimately every court is going these things for the realities of the Yeah, and it seems to me just even the forms that people had to fill out, led to different ... or led different paths of disclosure, right?
- 31:59That perhaps forms shouldn't give people, you know, a legally insufficient prompt for an answer that they would then be tempted to give, but doesn't...
- 32:08isn't gonna help them in any way, right?
- 32:10Right.
- 32:10Or the, I mean, one of the crazier things that we thought at least that we saw was in one of the smaller courts, um, and we talk about this in the article, they're basically given three options: I admit the claims. I deny the claims. And I request a payment What's so strange about that...
- 32:25that doesn't sound like something you would say in a where what's at issue is litigating, sort of, the nature But I think it is a reflection of how eviction actually works in practice.
- 32:37Right.
- 32:37There's another judge I think that we, that we quote that we through the legal aid attorneys we interviewed who said, "All I is that you pay the rent. We're not here to litigate your case." think people went to court thinking that And yet, the reality is a lot of these courts do function— and I'm not laying the blame purely on them, right, it's a function also of the law and of a lot of other things— but they do function essentially as rent collection agencies.
- 33:04And so this ... the fact that the form which in itself is sort of an admission, right?
- 33:10Seems problematic to me if what we're thinking about is what the court's role and why people are in court to resolve It makes complete sense in hindsight, or now that we crack it open and look at it, right?
- 33:24But probably wasn't really in the minds of the person writing Right.
- 33:29I think that they probably just had a In that same court, you know, people would come to court, and there was one—it was a fairly rural county— there was one apartment, I think, built and, by the way, this court was held in a ... in a essentially a building that also housed the local jail, I think, sort, of shifting our ideas of or how it might feel.
- 33:51But the, the people from that apartment complex would just up, and they, they would just sort of resolve their issues one There was no sort of legal process or You know, I mean, these issues have to get resolved, but I think there maybe is something problematic about process that we attach certain ideals to— and then somehow having it play out in that way.
- 34:13Yeah.
- 34:13And it made me think a lot about this to figure out the system or the plan that would, um, somehow the number of people in that line, right?
- 34:25You know, you also highlighted the way handed in, uh, whose side they take by, uh, for example, limiting the amount of, uh, additional landlords could charge for late rent.
- 34:40And I could just imagine that, you know, a judge might have every time that charge is levied against less likely to be able to pay their rent on time in future That it's just placing that person at greater jeopardy of in that judge's court down the line.
- 35:00And that sense that access to justice might help somebody with earlier upstream from what might, uh, snowball into a, a more costly challenge down the line.
- 35:15How do your students respond to or engage I would imagine it really may appeal to students who want to open that idea of expanding a notion of both procedural um, sort of who wins versus who loses.
- 35:33So I teach...
- 35:34I teach a few different classes at the Law School in this vein, and I think students have found all of them to be pretty I teach one class called Access to Justice, appropriately and the main purpose of the class is to really get students to understand what it feels like and as someone who has very little to no variety of challenges and obstacles that talked about in these articles as well.
- 36:01So I think part of it is getting their complicated statutes and processes, you know, how those appear to someone in that position.
- 36:12But then they're also challenged to think more creatively and affirmatively about solutions.
- 36:17In law school, we spend a lot of time critiquing.
- 36:19It's very easy to pick apart, it's a lot harder to actually come up with solutions.
- 36:22And so part of what they do is also think about things like literacy and the use of technology.
- 36:28And they're, they're tasked with coming up with a discrete not these sort of big, lofty policy goals, you know, like suggesting the whole system is underfunded.
- 36:37But instead, "What's something that you could create that a court could implement next week?
- 36:40Or a legal aid organization?" They craft these things, and they actually but I bring external folks in and representatives from these judges to actually give them feedback.
- 36:51And I've taught this class for many years, But in some situations, the organization actually said, "You This is a great idea, and we're gonna use this.
- 36:58We're gonna implement it." [Far out.] And to me that's a huge win.
- 37:01Yeah.
- 37:01Not only did the student learn, but they actually did something that's gonna benefit.
- 37:05Right.
- 37:06And, and in law school, we spend a lot of time ... clinical education is largely important.
- 37:10But I think it's also really important for them to not just to understand how it translates through a relationship, but that lawyers can have We, um, I implemented this semester with, along with our Dean for Public Interest Beth Cruz, a court-watching practicum where students just observe court.
- 37:28Because what we, what I'd heard, and work, was that students just really found watching court because it's so different from what they talk about.
- 37:36It's not televised versions of...
- 37:38No!... court drama, but really watching court.
- 37:41It's not "Judge Judy," but it's really quite fascinating stuff.
- 37:43And I, and, and we have practitioners who work in these sort of give the students, you know, some But there's no substitute for actually just going to court and seeing, again, because so much of what we talk about in schools is highly formalized, right?
- 37:59We spend a lot of time on Supreme Court cases.
- 38:01We spend a lot of time on federal court— and that is extremely important, and some of our students will practice in that in area— but as I said before, that's not most of and so I think students kind of have to Um, and the, the last class I'll mention, which is new, has been really interesting.
- 38:18It's an Access to Justice class that's focused on legal education and empowerment.
- 38:22And I have the students ...
- 38:22crafting an Access to Justice but they are then bringing it to students And they're essentially facilitating a discussion about substantive justice, procedural justice, what does it mean to have access to justice—with women who are in a very different position, right?
- 38:41They have some, perhaps, overlaps in experience, but in a lot of ways have a very different perspective on this, given their own position.
- 38:47And I think it's really fascinating to have these conversations—not just in the law school Or not just with you, which is really fun today.
- 38:55But with people who've really been through this ...
- 38:57Right.
- 38:57...with a very, um, concrete cost.
- 39:00Yeah, absolutely.
- 39:01And are those students' experiences sometimes Do they end up finding that things that they thought were I mean, I love the counterfactual in I'll tell you that I had one student ...
- 39:15But it's kind of cool in student experience, too, right?
- 39:17We left class ... when we left the prison stopped taking notes at one point 'cause Which, to me, that's, that's a huge win.
- 39:27Yeah.
- 39:27Right.
- 39:27And those students, you know, when I used to teach Capital in Georgia, um—I've taught it here, but I haven't been able to I would take students to Death Row, right?
- 39:36And so you're not just learning about ...
- 39:38we spend a lot of time talking about the cases, right: Here's what the Eighth Amendment means, and here's how it plays And here all the Supreme Court cases that are really important to know because these are the bases for claims that people But it's also important for you to know, whether you're gonna defense attorney or a prosecutor, what happens after the case?
- 39:54Where is this person spending the rest of their life?
- 39:57And so I think really making things concrete for students, much in the way that I try to bring this, this empirical data into these discussions, I think that's really important.
- 40:06That's super important.
- 40:07I love that you balance that with very, uh, very distal that has some major implications.
- 40:15You talk a little bit about what does it and creating data sets that have such You know, when we think about a predictive analytic framework for disease progression, the assumption is that we're gonna prevent or at least the progression of that disease.
- 40:37Um, if it's about predicting who might commit a crime or who be found legally liable in a civil case, it's super costly to And, um, it might be deeply, deeply unjust to make that basis of whether it's social address or a personnel in a under-resourced school with That there are ways in which avoiding the concrete or the concrete could be quite concerning, if not, uh, Um, and I didn't know if you wanted to talk a little bit On one hand, you were advocating beautifully for this opportunity to have better data, and on the other, you were also really weighing the challenges um, thinking about de-identifying those data and that don't put people in jeopardy.
- 41:30I think, we were really aware of that in, in doing this, and we tried to frame it as, the concerns that you might see coming from that, as being twofold.
- 41:38One backward-looking, right?
- 41:40So if you sort of tie this per all these person's touchpoints that could give people a really good sense of their whole past people might not want that revealed for It could hurt them in looking for a you may just not want people to know, right, all these things.
- 41:55And yes, it's possible to get that information individually, but if you make it easier, it's easier for someone to access it.
- 42:01Um, but I also think we had fears, as using this in a predictive way, right, in the same way that predictive policing has been used—and might be made, not just about certain people, but about And you know, I think part of how we making data available about people is And I think there are some ways from an empirical perspective that you can work around this— either by only making aggregate data available, by restricting of the data in different ways, by adding in ... using techniques, some of which are far beyond my pay grade, but like differential privacy, which sort at individual, you know, pieces of data.
- 42:41So I think that there are ways around that.
- 42:43I think the key is just being really aware of those concerns So when you are thinking about how to it, how you're storing it, right, how you're going to allow for creating an identifier—just those things into the process.
- 42:56I don't think those fears should all, that should prevent us from going down this road.
- 43:00I think just thinking about those things upfront.
- 43:02Yeah, the solvable problems, but ones Right?
- 43:06Yeah.
- 43:07Yeah.
- 43:08And just to close, um, Lauren, I'd love to do next or where you're, you're headed.
- 43:14Obviously, you have incredibly amazing track record of academic leadership effort, uh, both in training students and in terms thinking and, and legal, uh, thinking.
- 43:27But where, where would you like to take this work going forward?
- 43:30So I guess I'll, you know, I'd like to do all the things all But if I had to talk about two pieces of it, I would say with initiative that you mentioned that I'm starting here at Part of what I'd like to do with that legal education more broadly, and much in the way that this I'm teaching this semester is doing, right?
- 43:48So thinking about how to create really clear modules about aspects of access to justice that could be used not just in schools—undergraduate institutions, right, community things that would make ...
- 44:00basic information about how the law works available more broadly— so sort of this broadened sense of civic education, but with respect to the legal system.
- 44:11And I think in doing that, not just generating and making that information available, but actually generating it with the input and help of people who been directly impacted by the system, I think that's really important.
- 44:22The other thing that I hope to do, um, in that I think pulls a lot of this together.
- 44:31Um, I think broadly just to demonstrate as we've been how courts in our existing system have been designed by and And yet most people using it don't have a lawyer, will never lawyer, and that really creates a big gap between theory and So I think really showing the public that gap in a sense, um, and the fact that we've created a system that's nearly impossible to understand or use— and yet that's a system that we either force or have people rely on to resolve these really major problems in their lives.
- 45:00Um, so I think taking this idea of a not just it would, what it would mean What would it mean for legal services providers and what it mean for legal education?
- 45:12Thanks to our listeners for tuning in.
- 45:15Remember to stay curious and keep exploring new ideas.
- 45:17We'll be back next time with another guest Until then, I'm Cybele Raver and this is Quantum Potential.
- 45:33The Quantum Potential podcast comes from Vanderbilt Your host is C. Cybele Raver.
- 45:41Thank you to our guest, Lauren Sudeall.
- 45:44Production by Matriarch Digital Media.
- 45:47For more information about Quantum Potential, go to vanderbilt.edu/quantumpotential.
- 45:57Stay curious.