Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Tucker Carlson, Putin, Biden & More | The World According to Irina Tsukerman (Ep 10)
Transcript
- 0:19Welcome to the 10th episode of The World According to Irena
- 0:23Sukerman, our very special series on the global politics on
- 0:27the KJ Master class Live. Irena Sukerman is AUS based,
- 0:31national security and human rights lawyer as well as a
- 0:34renowned geopolitical analyst. Her writings and commentary have
- 0:38appeared in diverse US and international media, and I have
- 0:41been translated to over a dozen languages every fortnight in the
- 0:45world, according to Irena Sukerman.
- 0:47We traverse the geopolitical landscape and delve into
- 0:51pressing international issues and gain insight from Irena's
- 0:54expert perspective. Welcome to the show once again,
- 0:58Irena. Thank you so much, I'm very
- 1:00happy to be here. You are welcome to the show,
- 1:03Irena. Welcome to the to India once
- 1:05again. And I'm sure this in this world
- 1:08of geopolitics, where politics is business and businesses
- 1:11politics, your perspective will help both the economics and the
- 1:15business part of politics, part of every country, every leader.
- 1:19So we will be touching a lot of big stories today.
- 1:22The first big story let's look at is Tucker Carlson's interview
- 1:27with hotel. What are the key takeaways?
- 1:30What did Putin achieve what he wanted to?
- 1:32How does the world look at it? You are very clued into it.
- 1:36Help us understand this part. Well, I think Putin really very,
- 1:42very much achieved what he wanted.
- 1:44I think Tucker Carlson, on the other hand, did not.
- 1:47I think, I think Tucker's goal here was to portray Putin as
- 1:52more sympathetic and as this misunderstood character who
- 1:56never got the chance to really explain himself.
- 1:59But he's not as bad as the media and portrayed and his critics
- 2:05portray him. And that's why he repeatedly
- 2:08throughout the show was, you know, trying to push Putin into
- 2:12saying this sort of things that would humanize him in front of
- 2:15American audiences. Because counsel comes from APR
- 2:20background. He's actually part of a major PR
- 2:23firm. And he obviously was doing from
- 2:25that perspective what he thought was best to introduce the
- 2:29subject to the American audiences.
- 2:31But Putin's goal was different. Putin's messaging was mostly
- 2:36geared at domestic Russian audiences.
- 2:38That's why he went into this long foray into history.
- 2:42That doesn't mean much to an average American viewer, but was
- 2:47the sort of from diatribe that would be very familiar after
- 2:52years of that similar messaging in the Russian media,
- 2:56educational system and so forth. And he also actually wanted to
- 3:03show that he was in the control of the conversation, that he did
- 3:07not care about the opinion of American audiences and that he
- 3:10also that for him, Tucker was someone to be manipulated, even
- 3:16though Tucker was trying to help him.
- 3:19You know, he put his goal was to to embarrass him actually which
- 3:24he did. He also there was another issue.
- 3:27There were several times that Tucker gave him an opportunity
- 3:31to address the issue. But Christianity, Because at one
- 3:35point Putin tried to gain sympathy in conservative Western
- 3:39circles, but claiming that he's a protector of Christians around
- 3:42the world. But he, in this interview, he
- 3:46actually completely geared away from that line, from that
- 3:51narrative and actually said, oh, well, God has nothing to do with
- 3:54what I'm with what is happening. And I think the reason for that
- 3:59was, you know, and it was very subtle, but I think the reason
- 4:04for that was 8. To show that he no longer cares
- 4:07about trying to appeal with that sort of messaging, that it was
- 4:12just a narrative, a useful narrative, to gain support all
- 4:16along. And two, that the people who
- 4:18who've come to support him will continue to support him
- 4:21regardless of the details of what he said.
- 4:24And that is actually true. I don't see that you know that
- 4:28anyone who who was on his side before this interview suddenly
- 4:33moved away and said will because he said all these things, we're
- 4:37not going to, you know, make make these claims.
- 4:41Actually, you know, the claims became more brazen after the
- 4:44interview. Takakasans went to UAE where he
- 4:48started attacking not just the Ukraine but Israel this time and
- 4:53the US support for Israel. And that was very much along the
- 4:56same lines that Russia is currently supporting.
- 5:00So he became much more open. Previously Takasan was less open
- 5:04about that. He said that, well, I prefer
- 5:06previously he would say that he preferred Israel over Hamas and
- 5:10so forth. So, So we are seeing that
- 5:13actually the, you know, Russia's becoming much more open about
- 5:17the type of messaging that it's going for and much less
- 5:22interested in trying to win over independent voters who are, you
- 5:27know, kind of in the middle or you know or critics, you know,
- 5:32this is more about solidifying support, becoming much more
- 5:36direct. So we're seeing that this
- 5:38interview was in fact a change, you know, sort of a turning
- 5:42point in some, in some respect. Right, right.
- 5:46So Arena, if Putin was a bit successful in in whatever he
- 5:51wanted to achieve, then will the world look at him differently?
- 5:57Which part of the world will look differently, look
- 5:59differently at him? Because there seems to be a lot
- 6:02of, you know, understanding between different parts of the
- 6:08world with Russia getting much more closer to the Middle East
- 6:12there in terms of their countries coming into it, with
- 6:16lots of, you know, Middle East countries coming into the bricks
- 6:19form format and so many things you know, happening.
- 6:23So I want to understand now where this whole interview will
- 6:28change the outlook of the world. Will it be also in the US with
- 6:32the US going into elections with both the candidates, you know,
- 6:37top, top guys in terms of, you know, very prospective guys for
- 6:42the next presidential elections they are also embroiled in on in
- 6:46their own sort of controversies. How will this whole
- 6:51understanding of Putin that he wanted to go, you know, portray
- 6:55for the world looks like to you? Because U South is not America,
- 7:00but there is a lot of world outside the US.
- 7:02So I want to understand from all this perspective, apart from the
- 7:08home games, what did Putin expect and what did he gain
- 7:11actually, in terms of his of his image worldwide?
- 7:15Well, it's not clear exactly how many people actually that
- 7:18watched that entire interview because it was very long.
- 7:21And I think most of the Russian history bits will be lost on
- 7:25everyone outside, you know, Eastern Europe who are more or
- 7:28less familiar with that period in time.
- 7:30But in general and then broader strokes, I think this interview
- 7:34should not be seen in isolation. I should be seen as part of the
- 7:38general messaging. And I think that messaging has
- 7:40been consistent and I'll point out and it's been consistent not
- 7:45in terms of trying to change the minds of critics, but
- 7:47solidifying the base of support and kind of bringing together
- 7:54this point, these narratives into a more cohesive world view
- 7:58that is becoming more clear. And I think to that effect, we
- 8:02should be also looking at several other incidents that
- 8:05took place at around the same time, namely Donald Trump's
- 8:09comments at various events, namely some of the narratives
- 8:14being pushed to these Margaret speakers like Tucker Carlson in
- 8:18UE and Candice own speaking about the alleged church
- 8:23closures in Ukraine. And we should be in and Elon
- 8:31Musk's defense of all these characters and the defense of
- 8:36Tucker and and so forth. So we are seeing that all these
- 8:40main influencers that were kind of didn't making comments
- 8:44supportive of Russia's general efforts, they have been kind of
- 8:52made very have been coming out more and more openly and more
- 8:57and more cohesively supporting different things.
- 9:00And also some of these narratives have been coming
- 9:03together. That Ukraine narrative, the
- 9:06Christianity narrative or you know, the Russian victimhood
- 9:10narrative and also the anti Israel narrative, that's the
- 9:14reason for that is very, very strategic from Russia's
- 9:17perspective. It's not that they particularly
- 9:20care about the outcome in the conflict, although they're you
- 9:25know, the intelligence structures that have never been
- 9:30you know, Philo, Semitic or pro Israel.
- 9:33But the real reason is that it's trying to move closer to the
- 9:37Arab world, to the Muslim world and specifically especially to
- 9:41the anti Israel groups within that Arab world.
- 9:45So it has been playing up the narratives that resonate in the
- 9:51median. There was actually Al Jazeera
- 9:54picking up on many of the points related to Tucker and some of
- 9:58these other characters. So there's without a question, a
- 10:01coordination with the Middle Eastern media and an effort to
- 10:04kind of bring all these people together into a cohesive front.
- 10:11I don't think up until now people saw Tucker, Elon Musk,
- 10:15Donald Trump and and all those others as part of the same, you
- 10:20know, they saw them as basically agents of change.
- 10:24It's different from the typical establishment figures.
- 10:28They never necessarily saw them as soldiers of the same cause
- 10:33because they're just different spheres.
- 10:35Musk as a businessman, Tucker is a media personality.
- 10:39Trump used to be all of these things plus also a politician.
- 10:44But now we are seeing that all these people are reading work in
- 10:50a more coordinated way from the same script and repeating the
- 10:53same narratives. And all of that is being echoed
- 10:58throughout the world and not just in the US.
- 11:00We are very much seeing it being targeted to to other countries.
- 11:05Right, right. Irina, if I understand, I read
- 11:08one of the international political newsletters written by
- 11:12some very eminent guys and in that they mentioned two things
- 11:15that Tucker Carlson should have, you know, asked but missed or
- 11:20did not asked was one is the high casualties of American, of
- 11:25Russian soldiers in the Russia, Ukraine war.
- 11:28And secondly, in terms of the political, the the way there is
- 11:33no opposition coming up and the way, you know, opposition
- 11:35leaders are being, you know, not so handled as as they should by
- 11:42any administration. So that political part did not
- 11:45come up as well as the war part did not come up in that.
- 11:48What would your would your reaction be to this?
- 11:52Well, obviously he did not want to embarrass Putin and his goal
- 11:56was not, you know, his goal. This was APR interview.
- 12:00This was not a tough interview. I mean, when he asked questions
- 12:04about Evan Goshkovitz, the American was the Journal
- 12:09reporter who is awaiting trial in Russia.
- 12:13This was not out of goodness of his heart.
- 12:15This was yet another opportunity for Putin to redeem himself in
- 12:19the public view and to portray himself as a reasonable man.
- 12:23But of course, Putin did not take that opportunity and did
- 12:26not, you know, really say, Oh well, I'm going to give you this
- 12:31goodwill gesture and let you take him away and be a hero.
- 12:34So Putin very much retained that leverage, bargaining leverage
- 12:38that he's using that reporter for.
- 12:42And and and Tucker on the other hand completely deflated in the
- 12:47eyes of many even. You know, the image of Putin did
- 12:51not change, but the image of Tucker did because he looked,
- 12:56you know, based confused and not in control of the interview as a
- 12:59journalist. And he also was you know,
- 13:02running the softball questions and was very obvious that he was
- 13:05trying to play up to his audience and also to the mother
- 13:08crowd that he thought would welcome the sort of coordinated
- 13:13approach. But he ended up being used and
- 13:16tossed away. And this is.
- 13:19But interestingly enough even after that experience he he
- 13:24continued talking the same line once he went to UAE.
- 13:28So it's curious that even after being embarrassed, he did not,
- 13:32you know, kind of say to yourself, well, I mean I'm, I'm
- 13:36clearly being used here and I'm being played for fool and I'm
- 13:40being embarrassed and people can take me seriously as a
- 13:43journalist if I can't ask challenging questions.
- 13:47So why should I continue to play along?
- 13:49But nevertheless, he did. Right, right.
- 13:53To be fair to Carlson, you know, it was an important interview
- 13:57for him, big interview. Nobody else had been given that
- 14:00chance and he got it. So he has to work within the
- 14:03confines of, you know, conditions that laid down many a
- 14:07times. Sometimes the name becomes
- 14:09important. The questions come later on.
- 14:12Be that as it may now I understand you know that he
- 14:16there in one of the places I read that you know Zalenski now
- 14:19has been also you know there has been in right about an interview
- 14:24with Tucker Carlson. What do you think of this Will
- 14:27Jalinski be tempted to accept that invitation or would he let
- 14:31let it go because there is so much of an honest plate right
- 14:34now with the with with the funding from the US you know
- 14:38that bill that has been passed by the Senate so yet to pass in
- 14:42the house and secondly in terms of the can change in generals
- 14:46there. So do you think going forward,
- 14:48how does this look like to be going with this interview
- 14:51politics happening? You know, I think presidents,
- 14:56heads of state, leaders of any kind should be taking
- 14:59challenging and even hostile interviews.
- 15:02And they should not be hiding from the media the, you know and
- 15:07and quite frankly there's you know a lot of questions about
- 15:11Ukraine's strategy that they think, you know journalists have
- 15:14a right to ask. The issue with Tucker is that
- 15:17he's absolutely not acting in good faith and his questions are
- 15:21not just going to be tough questions.
- 15:23You know, they're going to be biased.
- 15:24And I'm not entirely sure that the this interview is not going
- 15:27to be would not be manipulated in a way to not not let lanski
- 15:33answer the questions correctly. If Tucker can guarantee that the
- 15:40interview would be aired in its entirety and not maliciously
- 15:45edited to serve a propaganda point, then I don't see why not.
- 15:52But if this is not something, but if there is a concern about
- 15:55it, if there's a good likelihood the TARPA will use it not to,
- 16:00you know, demand answers to tough questions because it's
- 16:04honestly would answer them once and for all.
- 16:06Although they have many of these questions are fairly predictable
- 16:10night. I'd wager that both Zolensky and
- 16:14his supporters in the West have already answered them many times
- 16:17over. But I think that's not the goal
- 16:19of the interview. I'm not entirely sure that
- 16:21Tucker is not trying to use that as an opportunity.
- 16:25So I would condition that interview for resilience to on
- 16:29ensuring that the good faith standards over over the
- 16:33interview I met. Otherwise, you know, I would not
- 16:35take it without those guarantees.
- 16:39Right, right. Now, Irena, let's move on from
- 16:42Putin interview to the US What is happening with the special
- 16:47investigators report on Biden A lot of, you know, dust flowing
- 16:53in there with this Biden probe. What help us understand what a
- 16:57common person in this part of the world, how should they
- 17:01understand all these, you know, controversies about documents,
- 17:05you know, being here in his role as a vice president and now this
- 17:09is coming back to him during such a crucial time as the
- 17:12presidential elections? So there's been a long record of
- 17:16high level U.S. officials being careless with the classified
- 17:20documents taking them out of secure locations and placing
- 17:25them in in places where they can be easily targeted by anybody
- 17:30really in both Trump and Biden did did that in in the you know,
- 17:37I leave the Trump case aside because it's a separate story.
- 17:40And this, you know, I think we can discuss it more when the
- 17:44when the trials for that come up.
- 17:46I'm sure there'll be a lot to discuss.
- 17:48But in Biden's case, the devastating part of it is that
- 17:52the report basically admits that he violated the law.
- 17:55In general, the top level officials are not likely to be
- 17:58held responsible for the for breaking such a law, even though
- 18:02lower ranking officials and military personnel would go to
- 18:06prison for this type of national security violations.
- 18:09But in Biden's case, what's interesting is that the report
- 18:13essentially said that he's incapacitated, that he's not in
- 18:17the mental state to be found responsible for his actions.
- 18:21And that's just as worrying as if he had deliberately violated
- 18:25a serious national security provision and was trying to
- 18:29avoid responsibility. And of course, Biden denied
- 18:31that. But the fact that this issue has
- 18:34become so obvious is a is a is a concerning side sign for what
- 18:40what's to come. And it makes Biden
- 18:43unpredictable. It makes him controllable, easy
- 18:45to manipulate and it's a very dangerous, creates a very
- 18:49dangerous situation. Right, right.
- 18:52And and Biden went on to clarify that he is in very good shape.
- 18:57And then that in that whole conference where there is
- 19:00confusion between Mexico and Egypt.
- 19:03So that that did not turn out as well as it as it wanted,
- 19:08especially, you know, in the backdrop of also about his
- 19:11standing as a, as a president presidential candidate, the
- 19:15Israel thing, he had shown a lot of support toward Israel, but
- 19:20then he wanted Israel to look at things differently and that is
- 19:23not happening. And all these things are coming
- 19:25out in the public, you know, and and Biden is not looking good at
- 19:29least from this part of the world the way this whole, you
- 19:33know, Gaza thing is happening. How do you look at all these
- 19:37things? Why is Netanyahu not looking,
- 19:40you know, not listening to Biden when Biden was supporting him so
- 19:44much? Well, look, I think, I think
- 19:47Biden support is very much appreciated by Israel and but
- 19:50Netanyahu. But at the end of the day,
- 19:52Israel is in facing an existential threat and no amount
- 19:57and and US is facing an election year.
- 19:59And those are two things that are incompatible.
- 20:03US has to deal with the pressure from various segments of its
- 20:06population, including those who are concerned, more concerned
- 20:10about the humanitarian crisis or human losses in Gaza.
- 20:14And some of them are outright, you know, Hamas supporters and
- 20:18there are such people and they're being funded to in, you
- 20:21know, and it's very concerning. But Israel has to its primary
- 20:26goal is to protect its citizens, as any country would be in this
- 20:30situation. You know, when US was facing a
- 20:33task over dealing with Afghanistan after 911, nobody
- 20:38was telling me the US what to do.
- 20:39And yes, you can say that the standards are different from for
- 20:43big countries rather than small countries that Israel is
- 20:46dependent on the US supporting. the US has leverage to put that
- 20:51sort of pressure. But you all know that had it not
- 20:54been the election year and had it not been for this publicity,
- 20:59I think the calculus would have been very, very different.
- 21:01And that's it has to be managed. But at the end of the day, if
- 21:05Israel and Israel has tried to be accommodating to the point
- 21:09that it actually damaged its effectiveness in the field, and
- 21:13it does actually part of the problem because Israel was
- 21:16trying to be foxy low and accommodate multiple goals both
- 21:20over tone and burdens, it has, you know, it was actually
- 21:25prolonged the situation that should have been, you know,
- 21:30because it now has to go door to door and it's trying to minimize
- 21:36human casualties. But that means placing its own
- 21:39troops in danger and it gives. And there's been causes that
- 21:42gave Hamas, you know, a time to return to in parts of the parts
- 21:48of parts of Gaza that the Israeli military has moved away
- 21:53from. So, So yes, advice has not been
- 21:57all that effective operationally.
- 21:59At the end of the day, US still wants Israel to Vanquish Hamas.
- 22:04And there are multiple goals that in my opinion are
- 22:06contradictory because Hamas is a terrorist organization.
- 22:10It's willing to use hostages as leverage.
- 22:13It's willing to sacrifice as many people is it that it's fit
- 22:17and doesn't abide by any international code of law.
- 22:21So you know, trying to both give the time and rescue the hostages
- 22:26and also finish the war and and the command and control
- 22:30structure of Hamas may be contradictory goals and people
- 22:34don't really want to admit to that because it's a horrifying
- 22:36thought. But at the end of the day is you
- 22:38might have to make a horrible choice and US is trying to play
- 22:43kind of all sides and that's just not something that's that
- 22:47is possible in current circumstances because Hamas is
- 22:50not a state actor. State actors usually come to
- 22:54sort of some sort of a reasonable compromise.
- 22:56Egypt and Israel after long many wars have come to compromise.
- 23:01Jordan and Israel you know made a peace deal.
- 23:04But Hamas is a state dedicated to, is a non state actor
- 23:09dedicated to results, instruction, destruction.
- 23:12It follows Iran's line. It's dependent on Iran and not
- 23:16just on the United States. It has.
- 23:18It had infinite resources to towards that goal and it's
- 23:22playing the propaganda game very well and has no incentive to to
- 23:26reach a compromise. Its incentive is to preserve its
- 23:29existence by avoiding any sort of compromise, by avoiding and
- 23:33releasing the hostages, because then there would be nothing
- 23:37stopping Israel from finishing off all of its leadership.
- 23:41So that's that's the situation. Right, right.
- 23:45Arena, amidst all these things, there is this fresh round of,
- 23:49you know, possibilities of peace talks and moving forward between
- 23:54Israel and Hamas. How do you look at that?
- 23:57Secondly, in this backdrop of this security conference, even
- 24:02Israeli Prime Minister, President and Palestinian Prime
- 24:05Minister, they are both there. So how do you see, do you think
- 24:09they will talk? I don't know if they have talked
- 24:11till now, you would be knowing better.
- 24:13So what are the possibilities looking out in in in in this
- 24:17whole new peace talk atmosphere getting a bit of a boost.
- 24:22How does that look like? Help us understand.
- 24:24Do you think this is possible It's going to because Netanyahu
- 24:28has his own you know way of looking at things and and and
- 24:32the world is looking at in a much more different manner
- 24:35amidst all these things $95.3 billion Ukraine, Israel and in
- 24:41fact Taiwan aid package has been approved by Senate.
- 24:44So how what will they do with this all this money amidst all
- 24:48these peace talks going on. Help us understand in this whole
- 24:51perspective the world is watching with bated breath.
- 24:54It involves about, you know, not only present about Ukraine,
- 24:57Russia, Israel, Hamas, also about the future preparation for
- 25:01Taiwan, looking at the Chinese, you know, threat over there,
- 25:05that region. Well, the peace talks right now,
- 25:08not really peace talks. They're more like attempt to,
- 25:12you know, arrive at that temporary ceasefire and to
- 25:16release the hostages. But, you know, you know, the
- 25:20only pressure that anyone can exercise is over Israel because
- 25:23Hamas is not inclined to listen. And Qatar has come out and said
- 25:27that they don't have any leverage to make it happen.
- 25:30And now they just failed again. They were supposed to deliver
- 25:33medical aid to the hostages and they apparently failed to do the
- 25:37to do that. So essentially this is A1 sided
- 25:41situation where Israel is expected to give infinite, you
- 25:46know, compromises and sacrifices and accommodations to a
- 25:49terrorist organization and there's no pressure from us to
- 25:52completely to give up, to stop, you know, firing missiles and to
- 25:57release the hostages immediately.
- 26:00There's nothing. Normally if you were dealing
- 26:02with the state actor who in that position, a state actor that was
- 26:06losing in the field of law and losing fighters, they would have
- 26:10to capitulate on some aspect of their operations.
- 26:13They would be told this is what is going to happen and this is,
- 26:17you know, and these are limitations and you have to
- 26:23abide with this framework. But Hamas doesn't feel it has it
- 26:27needs to do that because it it gets assistance and it seems to
- 26:31have infinite supplies and more help from where it comes from.
- 26:35And Iranian officials just met with Qatari leadership in Doha
- 26:40and this no one seems to you know question that you know this
- 26:46individual school from abroad are monitoring these operations
- 26:51are free to meet with the founders of the school scheme in
- 26:55a country that is supposed to be a major non-us airline and
- 26:59immediately in this conflict. But it's mind boggling.
- 27:02But you know, I I think these negotiations are complete farce
- 27:07given that there's absolutely no pressure on any of their actors
- 27:12who are actually responsible for this conflict.
- 27:16You know, the Doha leadership, Iran and so forth to take, you
- 27:20know, to take any measures to actually resolve it.
- 27:24And so long as you know, the pressure remains on the initial,
- 27:28nothing is going to happen as far as funding is concerned.
- 27:32For the time being, that bill from Senate is not going
- 27:35anywhere because it needs, you know, it needs to be coordinated
- 27:40with the House and Speaker Johnson announced immediately
- 27:45that it was going to block this bill.
- 27:49The reasons are entirely political.
- 27:51They have have to do with the fact that the the House actually
- 27:57hollowed out the immigration portion of the bill, the border
- 28:00security, which they're now using as an excuse to block this
- 28:05measure. But the reality is Trump
- 28:08essentially told the House of Republicans not to move forward
- 28:12with any bipartisan measures that would give Biden any credit
- 28:18for border security and to block it until because he's planning
- 28:22to campaign and one in the general election on that
- 28:25particular issue. So the result is stagnation and
- 28:29the way to move forward is for together in other enough woods
- 28:34to override Johnson's block or else to oust him, which may not
- 28:39be easy. But on the other hand, Johnson
- 28:41has a very slim majority. So and right now the Republicans
- 28:46just lost another seat after a special election regarding
- 28:52George Santos replacing George Santa.
- 28:55So you know, I I think it's very likely that Democrats may be
- 29:04able to exert some sort of political pressure and kind of
- 29:09overcome the situation, but I don't think it's going to be
- 29:11very quick. I think it's going to take some
- 29:14time. Right, right.
- 29:17And Amit all this the Munich. Munich Security Conference,
- 29:20Russia not invited, Iran not invited, other players invited.
- 29:25What does it mean for for the rest of the world?
- 29:29What has happened there? Any highlights that we should be
- 29:32aware of that can help us our understanding of that part of
- 29:35the world? Well I I I think I think it's
- 29:38not surprising that Russian Iran are not invited because they're
- 29:42deemed to be responsible for the two major two of the major
- 29:46conflicts we we're going on. Again how can they possibly be
- 29:50you know the straight face appear at the major security
- 29:53conference and then essentially you know as aggressors basically
- 29:58make make make these claims and demands and manipulate public
- 30:04opinion. I I don't think it would be a
- 30:06serious conference if they allowed them to do that.
- 30:09That's it. I'm not entirely sure that
- 30:12having the Israelis and Palestinians is going to change
- 30:15the calculus there, because I don't think a boss has any
- 30:19control over what's happening in Gaza at all.
- 30:22And I think even after the conflict is over, he will have
- 30:25trouble enough dealing with what's in the West Bank, much
- 30:30less in Gaza. And now Hamas is actually
- 30:33encroaching even into West Bank. Iran is flagging West Bank with
- 30:38weapons. I think Abbas's power is very
- 30:43tenuous and I don't think he has anything creative to contribute
- 30:48to the current scenario. And I think the Israelis should
- 30:52be appealing to the international communion,
- 30:55presenting the fact that Hamas and its founders a global
- 30:58threat. And moreover, it's not just as
- 31:01Iran that's and it's proxy network that they're responsible
- 31:06for funding and supporting commerce.
- 31:09Not even just Qatar in Turkey who've also contributed
- 31:12significantly, but all these European NGOs that have
- 31:16continued to poor support without any sort of structure to
- 31:21ensure that aid is getting to civilians and not to a terrorist
- 31:26organization. And and they've known for years
- 31:28that all of these funds we're being Co opted by unre to unre
- 31:32and to other efforts. And unless this issue is being
- 31:36is addressed at Munich right now, at and unless all of these
- 31:41European state actors who have been very much creating this
- 31:45contributing to a destabilized situation in Gaza, take hold
- 31:49themselves accountable for examining European role in all
- 31:53of this and putting an end to their own contributions, I think
- 31:58this conflict will go on indefinitely.
- 32:01Right, right. Now let's look at this whole,
- 32:04you know new way of India engaging with the world
- 32:09especially in the with the Middle East and with Middle
- 32:12East, more Middle East countries are expected to you know look at
- 32:16joining rigs. How do you look at this whole
- 32:19Indian approach with Prime Minister or Prime Minister is
- 32:23right now in that part of the world, You know he's just wasted
- 32:26UAE moving on to the to Qatar. And so how do you look at that
- 32:31with more engagement, independent engagement with the
- 32:35Middle East countries, with Middle East countries coming
- 32:38into breaks with China being there, Russia already being
- 32:42there. How do you see this whole thing
- 32:44of India's engagement in the backdrop of breaks, you know,
- 32:48with China and? So I I, I, I mean I think
- 32:52obviously he's trying to both compete for influence with with
- 32:56China and also to cooperate on economic issues where it makes
- 33:00sense and to have a broad broader scope of relationships.
- 33:05But I think you know well you know I think I think it's
- 33:08premature to look at the multilateral alliances and
- 33:12blocks and their success. I think we're at a very early
- 33:15stage and while there is definitely growing cooperation
- 33:19in economic areas, in technology areas and research, I think all
- 33:24of these are very rudimentary and there's a lot to be worked
- 33:28out before we can really call these issues a success.
- 33:31And now Russia and China particularly focused on creating
- 33:35alternative financial systems. There's a lot to be said about
- 33:38currency. I don't think a lot of it is
- 33:41going particularly well with that exception of sanctions
- 33:45busting mechanisms. But in terms of positive
- 33:48achievements, I think it's worth looking at bilateral relations
- 33:53and despite various global crisis challenging multilateral
- 33:57alliances, the bilateral relationship building I think is
- 34:01going very well. I think the UAE, UAE, India
- 34:06alliance is actually quite promising.
- 34:08There's been a lot of recent talks over mass investments into
- 34:13India by UAE leadership. Now with with Prime Minister
- 34:17Modi visiting you, I think we are going to see even more
- 34:23flourishing of economic and energy cooperation.
- 34:28They and that also brings us into the India Energy Energy
- 34:33Week. It's becoming a major player on
- 34:35some of the top issues that are of interest to the GCC
- 34:39countries. We will also see now a level of
- 34:42diplomatic success in on other fronts with the India being able
- 34:47to secure eight of its citizens who've been charged with
- 34:52espionage and sentence initially to execution and then to life in
- 34:56prison in Qatar. So that's also no matter.
- 34:59Yeah, you know, if you're really cynical, you can ask what has
- 35:02Qatar gotten out of it politically?
- 35:05But regardless, you know, on the surface it appears to be a major
- 35:10diplomatic success and and it's it should be celebrated.
- 35:17Absolutely, absolutely strong diplomatic understanding with
- 35:20the with Qatar on the on the free freedom for the Indian Navy
- 35:25men and they are many of them are back home.
- 35:28So that's a great thing And in terms of security, energy
- 35:31security, a lot of India seems to be the destination of the
- 35:35world in terms of investments especially, you know, India had
- 35:38just let's say energy India Energy Week just a few days back
- 35:43and that is going to be you know, very, very prominent when
- 35:46it happens next, next, next year in New Delhi.
- 35:50So how, how do you see this energy thing with regards to
- 35:54India and the world engaging with India in terms of
- 35:58investment, especially for the Middle East?
- 36:00Who wants to, you know, look at the new options for at looking
- 36:04at energy needs of the world including II is a big place
- 36:08where you know there will be a good demand for for energy from
- 36:12all different ways as India tries to, you know, develop with
- 36:16a strong force with all the investment from the world that
- 36:19is anticipated. Well, I think in terms of
- 36:22investments, things are moving fairly quickly.
- 36:25I think India usually takes its time to examine opportunities,
- 36:29but once it does commit to particular line, I think you
- 36:33know there's been a lot of success in Indian companies
- 36:37taking portion of the market in London and elsewhere.
- 36:41I think with the Middle East, it's likely to flourish as well.
- 36:46Now the question of the practical cooperation on the
- 36:49research development of these products and creation of various
- 36:55things, whether they are hydrocarbons or nuclear or any
- 37:00of the myriad of other opportunities, that's going to
- 37:02take more time. But I think there's the timing
- 37:06is right for for various developments.
- 37:09And I think the key to note is that not one of those things is
- 37:12a perfect solution to any anything in particular, but each
- 37:15country will work out the combination of investments into
- 37:19particular areas that will give them the optimal position in the
- 37:24global market and in terms of its own domestic needs as well.
- 37:27And I think India is looking at a whole range of major
- 37:32opportunities and major factors ranging from hydrocarbons to
- 37:39various other types of energy to shipping industries in the rare
- 37:44earth minerals and the response of cooperation and management
- 37:49and professional skills. So I think, I think as long as
- 37:53these major annual events have followed through by consistent
- 37:57workshops and investments into kind of the process along the
- 38:03way in each of these areas beyond these occasions, I think
- 38:10I think it's very clear that India is going to be a very,
- 38:14very serious player in the near future.
- 38:17It is already, but it's going to be even more fun.
- 38:21Right, right. Indeed, indeed.
- 38:22And that's the way you know economics is ruling everywhere.
- 38:26China is facing its own difficulties, challenges in
- 38:30terms of its own economic economy there with with
- 38:36evergrand and all those things happening then the silk route
- 38:39and all those routes thing happening and giving its own
- 38:42challenges. The world is looking at India in
- 38:46a very, very different manner. Be that as it may, let's look at
- 38:49the political part of it. Elections happening a lot across
- 38:53this world. This is the year of elections of
- 38:55almost half of humanity is going into elections.
- 38:58You know India is going into elections.
- 39:00US is getting into elections. Already that strong mood is
- 39:04already there. Several elections have happened
- 39:07and let's look at their outcomes in Pakistan.
- 39:10It is unclear even after, I don't know, the army is happy or
- 39:14sad there with Nawaz Sharif coming as the candidate with
- 39:18Imran Khan's party not getting not getting much support in the
- 39:22way a political party should get.
- 39:24But the elections have come, results have been very different
- 39:27again in El Salvador. There it Senegal.
- 39:31Help us understand these outcomes of elections all across
- 39:34the world. All these things are good for
- 39:36democracy, bad for democracy. How do we look at it from a from
- 39:41from a very neutral perspective? Well, let's say that El Salvador
- 39:45case is very easy because the support there for President
- 39:49Buchelli's reelection was overwhelming and no one could
- 39:53argue that it was actually a real, real support.
- 39:56It was a fully democratic election and he gained vast
- 39:59popularity by both his economic policies.
- 40:03Introducing cryptocurrency while balancing it is more
- 40:07traditional. Avenues of financing, but also
- 40:12with his crackdown on crime, which has been a bane of El
- 40:16Salvador's existence for decades.
- 40:19I think tourism is up, the economy is doing well and it's
- 40:22becoming a very safe place to live and people are happy.
- 40:26So despite all the controversy and attacks on him, I mean he is
- 40:30following. He's following the law of people
- 40:34support his rule and you know I think I think it's all good.
- 40:40You know senator on the other hand the the indefinite
- 40:44postponed of elections at least as as at least till December of
- 40:49this year if not past that is very concerning.
- 40:53There's been a team of eco boss countries sending delegation to
- 40:58try to resolve the situation. It doesn't sound like that will
- 41:04be resolved anytime soon and there's already political
- 41:09troubles with Nigeria. So we we don't know what's going
- 41:12to happen. I hope another conflict can be
- 41:15avoided because there are conflicts popping up between
- 41:18various African countries all over the place and it could
- 41:21really destabilize the continent.
- 41:24In terms of Pakistan, that's a complete disaster.
- 41:27I mean the reason Imran Khan was sentenced for lengthy Trump's
- 41:32was probably at least partly political to try to keep his
- 41:36party out of government. There's been inter factional
- 41:43fight in in Pakistan. I believe his party very
- 41:47populist party was seen as excessively open about its
- 41:51closeness to Russia and China alienating the United States and
- 41:56being just controversial in many ways that the military found
- 42:02destabilizing. But I think, I think, you know,
- 42:06the military itself is also highly factionalized.
- 42:09That has different, you know, it's not like 1 entity.
- 42:13There are many political factions.
- 42:15So I'm not entirely sure how they're going to play this one
- 42:19out. But Imran Khan remains in
- 42:21prison. And until and so unless his
- 42:25party chooses another Prime Minister who can then maybe
- 42:28pardon him and and figure out the rest afterwards and maybe
- 42:33step down and, you know, they don't really have a way of
- 42:37accessing power. And so far, you know, there's
- 42:39been protests, demonstrations. It's becoming quite messy.
- 42:43And meanwhile, there's also an Indonesian election taking place
- 42:47with the concern from the West that the candidates from the
- 42:51previous government may end the democracy there all together and
- 42:56turn into a very nationalistic, very, very entrenched and
- 43:02authoritarian way. And then, you know, it's
- 43:05Indonesia is one of the largest democracies in the world.
- 43:09So it would be quite a quite a significant set back if that
- 43:13were to happen. Absolutely, Absolutely. 11.
- 43:18Last thing about, you know, about the startling access to,
- 43:23you know, to Russia. I want to understand a lot of
- 43:27these talks going on this, all these reports coming in, a lot
- 43:31of corporates, they said, you know, that support Ukraine.
- 43:34And now now this talk about, you know, Elon Musk apparently talk,
- 43:40let's talk about giving access to Russia on Starling.
- 43:43So how do you look at that if it is true?
- 43:46I don't know, you will be able to tell us if it is true, does
- 43:49that mean that the whole corporate world will get a cue
- 43:52to engage again with Russia? What does it show?
- 43:56Help us understand all about this particular report.
- 44:00Well, mosque has denied given access to Russian maybe that
- 44:05Russia has been deliberately, you know, deceiving and creating
- 44:11this deception to to cause a problem.
- 44:13It's not clear yet. But if you had done that, that
- 44:16that essentially actually creates opportunities because it
- 44:23means that the the block that Russia has been imposing has
- 44:27been broken through and that's an opportunity for Ukraine.
- 44:33From its perspective, Moscow has has strong himself to be not
- 44:37particularly concerned about the ethics of the issues with just
- 44:41the opportunities to make money. He, for instance, held up the
- 44:44civilian use of Stalin until the US military negotiated with him
- 44:50a separate contract for the application.
- 44:52So clearly it's not necessarily the ideology at play here as
- 44:55much as opportunism. He may, for whatever reason,
- 44:59feel that Russia's growing geopolitical hold is an
- 45:05opportunity for him. And so he's actually willing to
- 45:08expedite that by putting the resources at his disposal, such
- 45:12as X, in order to facilitate the goal.
- 45:16Because it brings him followers, it brings him attention, it
- 45:19brings him money from unusual sources and brings him political
- 45:23power, quite frankly, whether that can be rained in, should it
- 45:28be rained in, given that he's a private businessman at the end
- 45:32of the day, but his actions conflict with the US interests.
- 45:36But then again, the US has not fully really cracked down on
- 45:41Russian, has sent very mixed signals in that regard.
- 45:44That is, that is a complicated question.
- 45:46I think. I think everyone will agree that
- 45:50these tools, they're abused and if he's deliberately boosting,
- 45:55you know, Russian foreign operations, that would the US
- 46:00government. the US government does have leverage at the very
- 46:03least to examine sources of his funding and investments and to
- 46:06go after assets that are seen as in non compliance with the
- 46:10current US Wilson, I didn't think Musk wants that to happen.
- 46:15So he has to maintain a balance at the very least, even if his
- 46:19rhetoric cannot be managed can stop him from using his freedom
- 46:23of speech in even in an extremely damaged way.
- 46:27In terms of how he uses his money and assets that's a
- 46:31different story and you may yet see that it's some of his access
- 46:36could back backfire to him and I think he's being he's very much
- 46:41hedging and and and knows where to draw the line if he does not
- 46:47all of that can can really backfire at him at the end of
- 46:50the day and quite frankly you should also remember that Russia
- 46:53is not a friendly actor. It has you know some of its
- 46:58supporters of Putin much less enemies ended up being dead.
- 47:04It has put a number of well known personalities on the
- 47:07terrorism and ban less these days.
- 47:12While it's unlikely to gain access to many of these people,
- 47:16it can make their lives quite difficult with political battle.
- 47:20So Musk, you know if you're operating the mafia states, you
- 47:25can end up being beholden to them in a way that makes you
- 47:29unfree. At the end of the day, Musk
- 47:31should think about that even more so than their precautions
- 47:34from the US and and what it could also cost him in terms of
- 47:38business. Right, right.
- 47:41Maybe another way to look at it. Maybe Musk is, you know, very
- 47:44worried about money lost because of his company's incorporation
- 47:49in Delaware. So he's wanting to shift to
- 47:51another state. I guess he has already shifted,
- 47:53but maybe he's looking at Russia also in the long term, maybe to
- 47:57get some concessions there and very.
- 48:00Likely, very likely because we have seen that his business with
- 48:04Tesla in China has for sure affected his pasture towards
- 48:09China. So I don't really see and
- 48:11beautiful cutter in some of the factions in Saudi Arabia that
- 48:15he's taking money from. So all of these things colored
- 48:18who he deals with, who he doesn't use within drives his
- 48:23business. But I think at the end of the
- 48:25day all of these, all of these regimes may end up being, may
- 48:33end up losing more than they gain once once US and other
- 48:39countries start acting a little bit more intelligent and think
- 48:42it's only it is a matter of time.
- 48:44Eventually. And you know I think the malign
- 48:49influences will find a pushback from from somewhere in mosque
- 48:53may make a lot of money in the short term.
- 48:56But let's not forget what happened to a lot of Western
- 48:59businesses in Russia in the 90s. They went bust.
- 49:03They were essentially nationalized and robbed.
- 49:06And the same thing is happening in China today as we speak.
- 49:10So I think it's I think war Musk may think that he is protected
- 49:14because of his good relations and loneliness to accommodate.
- 49:18And so the land that has never stopped the regime, desperate
- 49:21for money, from going after their former friends and allies.
- 49:26Right, right. Be that as it may, a lot of
- 49:28things keep on happening in the world.
- 49:30They will continue to happen and as they happen every, every
- 49:34biweekly we will be bringing you, you know the the world
- 49:38according to Irena Superman to make sense it of all with this,
- 49:42it's a wrap on this very special episode of the world according
- 49:46to Irena Superman on the KJ Master class life.
- 49:49Thank you once again. Thank you so much.