Latest / The Courtroom Files / April 29, 2026 Court Hearings: Judge O'Donnell Sentences Scammer, Mercer Hears 300-Page Record & McNally Scolds Attorney + More | TCF Podcast #280
Transcript
- 0:02Good morning. Good morning, you faithful and
- 0:04true. Happy Wednesday to me and to all
- 0:06of you too. It's TCF Live where the gavel
- 0:08goes clack. I'm Dan Soul, your guide.
- 0:11Won't you hop on my back? We're off on a quest through
- 0:14Courtlandia Bright, where the courtrooms are bustling from
- 0:17morning till night. For the next hours 3 we'll ride
- 0:21through the land with real cases unfolding just as they were
- 0:24planned. They'll be lots of orange in the
- 0:27jumpsuit. So bold and judges who lecture
- 0:31as stories are told. Some will pay fines, some will
- 0:35plead, some will stall while we watch with our eyes and our
- 0:39hearts and our all. We don't know the city or the
- 0:42judge will meet first, but we'll find out together.
- 0:46Oh what a fine burst. McNally or Simpson or someone
- 0:49brand new with ruling so clever they'll make you say whoo.
- 0:54We'll settle in. Comfy.
- 0:55Grab coffee or tea. We're about to begin.
- 0:58Come journey with me. I'm Dan Soul, your host.
- 1:01With a rhyme and a grin. Let's dive into Cortlandia.
- 1:05Let the fun now begin and. We got out.
- 1:22Good morning to my friend Louis. Good.
- 1:27Best to you your final days. Anyway, yesterday morning, very
- 1:36early after I got up and did all my exercises, I got a text that
- 1:40said the courthouse still had no power and hoped to.
- 1:43Open by 9 and. We got a message that we hoped
- 1:46to open by noon and we got a message that we don't have any
- 1:51power and we didn't have any power until sometime late.
- 1:54Last. Night.
- 1:55There was a jury trial scheduled for this morning in this
- 1:58courtroom with Judge Patterson, because he didn't know whether
- 2:01we'd have power today or not, he cancelled the jury trial.
- 2:08So yesterday as a lost day and there's a lot of things to
- 2:13reschedule. There were a bunch of pre exam
- 2:15conferences. There were six preliminary
- 2:18examinations scheduled for yesterday afternoon, a number of
- 2:21which were in custody and we haven't dealt with any of that
- 2:28yet. So we're just going to do
- 2:31today's. Business so this.
- 2:32Morning. I'll be using this courtroom
- 2:35because there's no jury trial. We have some arraignments.
- 2:38I think Vivian will be joining us shortly.
- 2:41One of our yesterday defendants came in today, which we
- 2:44appreciate will handle her arraignment.
- 2:47Let us have a couple of bench warrants and then I have a
- 2:50sentencing at 11. Then this afternoon we have a
- 2:56trial on a termination of tenancy case.
- 3:00From the mobile home. Park here in Centerville.
- 3:02I blocked out the entire afternoon and I hope that's long
- 3:05enough. Someone is indicating there are
- 3:09still sound issues. Sound in this room is so bad.
- 3:16I thought we'd work that out. Some of it maybe that might.
- 3:22Anyway, the sound issues are bad and we're trying to see if we
- 3:25remedy, so my apologies if it's that terrible.
- 3:29I think we can hear it in here. As you may have seen, last week
- 3:33I had a terrible problem with one of the litigants and
- 3:37landlord tenant case, and I don't know if it was.
- 3:41It wasn't me because I can hear everybody else.
- 3:44I think it was where she was coming from.
- 3:46Then we just had a communication problem.
- 3:49We did not have a song of the day yesterday because we don't
- 3:52have any court today. All you get is down in Jamaica.
- 4:00They got lots of pretty women. Steal your money.
- 4:05Then they break your heart. We'll share that little moment
- 4:10of humanity. All right, I'm going to turn off
- 4:13the chat. Get the business.
- 4:16Miss Jackson is here. Mr. Reed is here.
- 4:21Sorry to Miss Jackson, but I have to pause.
- 4:25Lindsay, thank you for the 1999. Very much appreciate it.
- 4:28I had a lot of fun writing that this morning, so I'm glad you
- 4:30all enjoyed it. And again, hopefully I can do
- 4:33the closing equal justice, but that one's going to have a
- 4:36little less thought, so we're going to do it on the fly.
- 4:38So we'll see how it goes. Anyways, back to Judge.
- 4:46Well, we had. We have the echo.
- 4:52I don't sure that we can fix that because of the size of this
- 4:56room. Anyway, we'll do the best we
- 4:59can. Hopefully you can hear this.
- 5:02We can hear it. Some people are still without
- 5:16power. Couple of employees are not here
- 5:21yet. I'm not sure whether Judge
- 5:22Patterson has power or not, but he is here.
- 5:26All right, this is the time for some arraignments.
- 5:31And let's see who we've got. Mr. Rubio, do you need an
- 5:42interpreter? All right.
- 5:44She should be joining us shortly.
- 5:47I don't know why it's. Always a big.
- 5:49Surprise that we need an interpreter when we have a bunch
- 5:54of people with Hispanic surnames.
- 5:56But let's start with Tyrus Morford.
- 5:59Could you come forward, please, right up to the podium here and
- 6:04let me see the top copy of your advice of rights?
- 6:21Well, when I first came in this morning about 7:15, none of
- 6:25these were in my. Queue.
- 6:28Because we weren't here yesterday.
- 6:31So let's see if they made it. There they are.
- 6:42Thank you, Stephanie. All right, Tyrus Arthur, William
- 7:07Morford from Coldwater. Good morning to you, Sir.
- 7:11You got a ticket for driving with a suspended license.
- 7:14It's a misdemeanor. It's punishable by up to 93 days
- 7:17in jail. Fine of up to $500.
- 7:20They wrote that under Sturgis ordinance.
- 7:24You. Have an impaired driving charge
- 7:27over in Cal Creek and so we have a couple.
- 7:33Of them which has. Caused your license to be SIS
- 7:35Revolt, Mr. Reed. Do you have any?
- 7:41Thought on this. Wasn't on a cell phone.
- 7:46When you got pulled over for it. So, but I would say that we'd
- 7:49offered no ballots 7301. All right, that's a pretty
- 7:54generous offer. You're charged with driving
- 7:56suspended and you're suspended because you have two drunk
- 8:02drivings and A7. May I speak to him just a
- 8:06moment? Yes.
- 8:07OK. Can I come outside for a moment?
- 8:09Yeah. That's.
- 8:18The last information. Would you see if you can tell
- 8:31how Mr. Moore forgot him? We don't for for now, forever or
- 8:42suspension. If.
- 8:47You've mentioned, but your record is pretty, so you're a
- 8:52long way from getting all. Right. 1.
- 9:04More thing to discuss at the security meeting next week.
- 9:09It's up to you. Just know that your your record
- 9:22shows that you're going to be a while getting the license, so it
- 9:25probably won't affect sitting along eventually it's just going
- 9:29to be on the suspension, OK? All right, what you're charged
- 9:52with driving suspended is a misdemeanor.
- 9:55It's punishable by up to 93 days in jail, and a fine of up to
- 9:58$500 requires that your license be suspended.
- 10:03Further, Mr. Reed, the city attorney, has offered to reduce
- 10:07that charge to a charge of driving with no valid operator's
- 10:10license. That is a misdemeanor.
- 10:13It's punishable by up to 90 days in jail and a fine of up to
- 10:17$100. It carries 2 points, but it does
- 10:21not carry a suspension. Do you understand?
- 10:24Yes, Sir. Are you willing to plead to that
- 10:26lesser charge of no valid operator's license?
- 10:31Yes, Sir. All right, Anybody threaten you
- 10:33to get you to plead to that charge?
- 10:35That's it. I promise you anything.
- 10:38That's it. Then you understand you'll be
- 10:40giving up all the rights here on your advice of rights.
- 10:43There won't be a trial if you plead to this.
- 10:46Do you understand? Yes, Sir.
- 10:48Where were you going? I was on my way to work so.
- 10:52Where do you work? Big B in South Sturgis.
- 10:57BP. Big B.
- 10:59What? The coffee shop?
- 11:00Oh, Big B, OK. 10 AM What time does your shift?
- 11:09Start. Well that was on my way out of
- 11:13work. Sorry, what's that?
- 11:14I don't really out of work. My girlfriend, she works at the
- 11:17North Sturgis store so I was driving to her so she could
- 11:20drive us both home. Yeah, you were talking on your
- 11:23phone. Yes.
- 11:25Dumb. All right, How'd you get here
- 11:27today? My friend, he's out in the
- 11:29parking lot at the moment. All right, what kind of car?
- 11:32Is he in a red Toyota Camry? All right, that's the first one
- 11:53of these. You can't drive.
- 11:55You're going to have a hard time getting your license.
- 11:57Back. It's a revolt.
- 11:59Which? Means seven years with no
- 12:01license. Well, excuse me, five years with
- 12:04no license if you get 2 and seven if you're in a sobriety
- 12:08court program, you can get a license with an interlock.
- 12:12But you are a revolt. And that's a tough spot to be in
- 12:16where you're as young as you are and you live in cold water and
- 12:18you work in Sturgis. You can't drive.
- 12:24Plus you had a bunch of other baggage on there.
- 12:28So we used to get that wrapped around your head for $225.
- 12:35Can you pay that by May 31st? Yes, Sir.
- 13:03All right, you can use this. You can pay by credit card.
- 13:07There's instructions inside. You can use it.
- 13:10What? All right, your drivers out
- 13:13there, they confirmed that don't drive anymore, it'll make it
- 13:18worse and you'll go to jail anyway.
- 13:23You can pay by credit card, certified check and money order,
- 13:27or bring in green cash to the window right out there.
- 13:32Otherwise you're free to go. This was reduced to no valid
- 13:35OPS. Which was a.
- 13:36Pretty good deal. I didn't order any jail time.
- 13:39I just ordered the fine. I want you to pay it, then
- 13:42you're good to go. Thank you Sir all.
- 13:47Right. Good morning once again,
- 13:48everybody. It's TCF live.
- 13:49It is Wednesday. It's nice to have all of you
- 13:52here today. I hope we can get everybody off
- 13:56to a good start. Let's go down to Lake County,
- 14:00Ohio, Judge F Word, also known as Judge O'Donnell.
- 14:12OK, we're here once again on Heaven Leak 24/12/22.
- 14:19Another violation of community control, September 18th.
- 14:25Is that right? No.
- 14:31What's the violation You're? Under.
- 14:35The violations on. February. 6th 2020 Sixth.
- 14:37The defendant brought you an example to the.
- 14:41Probation. OK.
- 14:41Do you understand that charge? Yes, Sir.
- 14:46It's Novotny. You're at this time I've.
- 14:51Client would like. To waive the final hearing and
- 14:54submit to the violation is. That what you want to do.
- 15:02Yes, Sir. What's your plea?
- 15:05Guilty. Accept your guilty plea and find
- 15:09you guilty. I guess my confusion was the
- 15:11same thing in September. Not very good at this fake urine
- 15:15stuff are you? No.
- 15:17This is my first time I figure and I I what?
- 15:19I was dirty here and I'm in September, my first time ever.
- 15:23Doing whatever, whatever. Yeah.
- 15:30What's a blizzy? Blizzy.
- 15:33What's a blizzy BLIZZYA? Cigarette.
- 15:38Cigarette. A regular cigarette.
- 15:39That's what we call them, yeah. A regular cigarette.
- 15:42Why don't you call it a cigarette?
- 15:44It's just nicknames we have for things.
- 15:46Who's we? Me and my friends.
- 15:49Where's Nick? Nick ain't here today.
- 15:51No, who's not? Why not?
- 15:53Because he had to work last night late.
- 16:00I should just play the recording of the last hearing.
- 16:05I understand. Because you're a little lower on
- 16:07the totem pole than she. Is I understand.
- 16:10Because you don't give a shit about any of this.
- 16:12I do. No, you don't.
- 16:14I do, your honor. No, you don't.
- 16:20Here, tell me if this sounds familiar.
- 16:25Yo brother, three things. One, let the girls at the club
- 16:30know that me and you will have the bag back in again.
- 16:36Finally, Especially Jade. Does that sound familiar?
- 16:39Yes. What does that mean?
- 16:42We'd usually just buy like buy them drinks and do everything.
- 16:45That bag means the money for me. OK, why don't you save money?
- 16:49That's just a termage we use, Sir.
- 16:52And why don't you use, like, the English language and stuff,
- 16:54like, regularly? Yeah, because we're and #2 thank
- 16:57you for everything you do and have done for me.
- 17:02It means the world to have a real brother.
- 17:05Nick. Nick's your real brother.
- 17:07He's, he's like a brother to me, yes.
- 17:11How long you know, Nick? Known him a long time.
- 17:14How long about? Five years.
- 17:16Does he do drugs with you? No, he doesn't do drugs.
- 17:20No, not at all. No.
- 17:22Do you do drugs? Yes, I do.
- 17:24OK, so why don't you, why don't you take some advice from Nick
- 17:30and not do drugs if he doesn't? Do what I plan.
- 17:32To do because Nick does drugs right?
- 17:35He doesn't do drugs. Three, get your car together and
- 17:40don't spend $300.00 at the club no more.
- 17:44We going to turn up when I'm a get us, right?
- 17:48What does that mean? I'm going to get us together
- 17:50because he was slacking on his car payment, so when I get out I
- 17:53was going to help him get together.
- 17:54Can't even help yourself. I I plan to.
- 17:57But you can't, because you don't.
- 17:59Because you won't. I, I have the, I have the
- 18:02ability to now. No, you don't.
- 18:05When things get hard, just look at this message and remember you
- 18:08got a brother and me and I'm a do whatever I can to get us
- 18:12together financially and to make us comfortable from jail.
- 18:18From jail. Text my dad, tell him you need
- 18:21700 for my rent in May. Rent in quotation marks.
- 18:26We will use that for Detroit and to pay whatever bills we need
- 18:29what's in Detroit. We're going to take a trip to
- 18:32Detroit. To do what?
- 18:34Just go out of state. Is that where you get your pills
- 18:37out of Detroit, where most people around here get them?
- 18:39I don't do pills. You don't do pills.
- 18:41No, you don't do. You don't do.
- 18:43I don't do pills. Right OK so you you're going to
- 18:48scam $700.00 from your dad and have Nick say it's rent.
- 18:53The part of it's going to rent and the rest of it was going to
- 18:55and. That's not what you told Nick,
- 18:57right? You tell him it's for rent and
- 19:00we'll go to Detroit, right? I thought you needed 300 bucks
- 19:04for Nick for his car. That's what I'm saying.
- 19:07We were splitting. We were splitting the money up
- 19:08between his car, rent and Detroit.
- 19:12You. You.
- 19:13You expect me to believe that that's the truth?
- 19:15Yeah. But you expect me to believe
- 19:17that? No, I I don't expect you to
- 19:19believe anything. I'm just telling you that's the
- 19:20truth. OK, you you're not familiar with
- 19:23the truth. No, I guess.
- 19:24Not you haven't. No, you, you guessed right.
- 19:26OK, you you're a little pissed off now.
- 19:29No, I'm not pissed off. Sounds like it.
- 19:31I'm not pissed off at all. Keep your head up bro and stay
- 19:36safe. I would like for you to come to
- 19:39my court date and speak on my behalf.
- 19:45Love you gang and I can't wait to get out to smoke a blizzy
- 19:49with my boy and chase the bag in our future in Florida.
- 19:53What future in Florida? He invited me to move to
- 19:55Florida. He's got a guy who has one of
- 19:59his buddies at the landscaping company down there.
- 20:01And he thought it would be good for me to just get out of the
- 20:03state, get away from everybody that I know and everything that
- 20:05I know and just start somewhere fresh.
- 20:07Which I agree is a pretty good idea.
- 20:10Because I, I'm tired of being in Ohio and being around the people
- 20:12that I'm around. Because it just always ends up
- 20:14in me either doing drugs or being around dumb stuff.
- 20:18And I'm just tired of it. Well, there's dumb stuff in
- 20:22Florida, too. I get it.
- 20:23But, you know, at least I have a chance to start over.
- 20:26And I don't know anybody down there.
- 20:28So I don't plan on really getting to know anybody.
- 20:31I just want to, you know, I can, I can do a lot more things down
- 20:34there then I can't hear. You know, I can go fishing.
- 20:36I can go to the beach. I can, you know, do things like
- 20:39that. I can catch snakes.
- 20:40How about how about going to work and getting sober?
- 20:43I have, I have three jobs lined up as soon as I get out of here
- 20:45if I'm allowed to get out and they're willing to hold my
- 20:50position still. May 10th and I've been talking
- 20:53to them about it. I got offered the third job
- 20:56yesterday. Well, I thought you were going
- 20:58to Florida. Yes, we're going in the end of
- 21:00September. So I have three jobs here lined
- 21:03up until and I can save money until I get to September.
- 21:06And when I get to September, we move out there.
- 21:09I'll have a safety net set up and then I can get everything
- 21:14done and I can have a job out there where I can work all year
- 21:17doing something that I love. You're a scam artist is what you
- 21:27are. So your dad's here today.
- 21:50Yes, Sir. Why is your dad here today?
- 21:54Because he supports me and loves me.
- 21:56What the Why do you continue to denigrate your mother and
- 22:00father? I have issues and I need to work
- 22:08on them but. But you don't.
- 22:11That's why I want to do what I need to do and get out and get
- 22:15be by myself so I don't have to, you know, I want to, I need to
- 22:18do this on my own and I, I don't need to be asking my parents for
- 22:21help. And that's why I've been in jail
- 22:24working to get my job so. How?
- 22:25How is this doing it on your own?
- 22:27Been working out so far. I haven't been on my own, so I
- 22:31it's not been working well because I resort back to using
- 22:34people and, you know, now I have an opportunity where I can go to
- 22:38work, be by my be on my own with, you know, one roommate and
- 22:42we work and we go home and we sleep and we repeat it.
- 22:45Well, besides going to the club and spending.
- 22:48Money on these girls. That's what he did.
- 22:50I'm not. I don't have any intentions of
- 22:51going to the club. Let the girls at the club know
- 22:55that me and you will have the bag back in again finally.
- 22:59Especially Jade. Who's Jade?
- 23:00One of my friends. Is that a?
- 23:02Is that a girl or a guy? It's.
- 23:04A girl, But I I have no intentions of going to the club,
- 23:07Your Honor. You did when you wrote.
- 23:08This I, I did and I don't know, honestly, I, I spent my birthday
- 23:13in here yesterday and I did a lot of thinking over the last 82
- 23:16days and I, I just want to get to work, go home, do what I need
- 23:19to do, stay away from everybody. You know my my main dealer who
- 23:22gives me all my drugs is in jail right now.
- 23:24Who's that? Dante Smith.
- 23:27Dante Smith, well, he was just here last week, wasn't he?
- 23:31Yeah. And that's the only person I
- 23:32trust with anything like that. And I don't, honestly, I'm just.
- 23:36You trust Dante Smith? With my drugs he gave me, you
- 23:39know, and honestly, I'm tired of it.
- 23:41I don't want to be doing this anymore.
- 23:42I'm, I'm, I'm over partying. It's just, I want to just get to
- 23:46work, do what I need to do, go home, sleep and do it all over
- 23:50again. And I want to move to Florida so
- 23:51I can just pursue hobbies that I want to do and end up owning my
- 23:55own business and just work, work hard.
- 23:58I know I can do it because I've done it before.
- 24:01And, you know, spending this last 82 days in jail, I've, I
- 24:04felt better about myself now than I have how.
- 24:06Many days, Cindy, So about your honor, on the PV, no, on the PV
- 24:1183 days here 83. And I'm. 83 valuable days.
- 24:18Yep. And I've gotten to do a lot of
- 24:20thinking. I pray every day and every
- 24:22night. I've been working out every day,
- 24:24you know, I've been taking care of my hygiene and my health, and
- 24:30I'm just kind of ready to move on and start a new chapter in my
- 24:34life. You know, this chapter's been 10
- 24:35years of my life, you know, minus a couple.
- 24:38And, you know, I felt, I feel like I do now, like I felt in
- 24:412021 when I had a lot of success and I wasn't doing stupid things
- 24:46and I was around good people. And then I fell into a hole.
- 24:49I got into a really crappy relationship and started doing
- 24:53drugs that I've never done before.
- 24:54And it led me down a dark path and I'm here.
- 24:58You've been tired, you've been playing around with drugs since
- 25:00you were like, for for 10 years, right?
- 25:03Yeah, 15, that's when I started. And, you know, I, I, I didn't do
- 25:07any, you know, I was doing things and I never thought I
- 25:09would touch cocaine or heroin or anything like that.
- 25:12And those things I ended up doing and I regret it, you know,
- 25:16but I'm at the point in my life where I just spent another
- 25:19birthday locked up and I'm 27 years old and I, I want to have
- 25:22something to show for my life. And you know, that's why I've
- 25:26been working to secure my jobs because I have three of them
- 25:29lined up and I've been securing to keep the place that I have
- 25:33over my head so I'm not homeless and.
- 25:36Well, I'm trying to scam 700 out of your dad.
- 25:39That's what you're trying to do. Not, not not anymore.
- 25:42I'm honestly, I'm just I told him to give it to to Nick and
- 25:45you and you can pay the rent. I'm not I don't need anything
- 25:47else from I'm not going to Detroit.
- 25:49You know, I was. That's before I really started
- 25:51thinking about what I need to do.
- 25:52Well, you can do whatever you want to do.
- 25:57Because. You always do whatever you want
- 25:59to do. You've.
- 26:01Been you've been you've been doing whatever you want to do
- 26:07for 15 years, despite your your parents support, you've been
- 26:15just even using them because that's who you are.
- 26:19You're a user of people. I do not want to be that.
- 26:24Well, then don't do it. That's the plan.
- 26:27That's the plan. You know, the plans are good.
- 26:30Plans are good. You don't, you haven't, you
- 26:33haven't given me a plan. You've given me a rosy outcome
- 26:39of where you're going to be when you when you get to where you
- 26:43are. You don't have a plan.
- 26:44And if you had a plan, your problem is you don't execute any
- 26:48plans if you've ever come up with a plan.
- 26:50When I put my head to something, I can do it your.
- 26:53Plan was to, you know, go to the clubs and.
- 26:55And it's not going to happen to work.
- 26:59Go home. I don't listen.
- 27:00I don't care what you say. It doesn't matter what you say.
- 27:03Because if there's one thing you've consistently done since
- 27:07you've had this case, it's lie. OK, So I don't have any control
- 27:12over that, so I'm not going to listen to it.
- 27:14So I don't care what you say. But here's the plan.
- 27:18You've done 333 days of incarceration on a felony 5.
- 27:23You know how many? You know what the number of days
- 27:25on a felony 5 is? 365. 365 S you wasted almost a
- 27:32year. Yes, Sir, on.
- 27:33This nonsense, I know you and your bro Nick, right?
- 27:46And your good friend Dante Smith.
- 27:49So you are going to be, you're going to be on community
- 27:53control. You're going to serve 115 days
- 27:57in jail with credit for 83. Now, that means there's 32 days
- 28:03left on your jail sentence and all the terms still apply.
- 28:10Now, the good news for you is when you finish your 32 days,
- 28:15that's the most I can do to you. So you'll be off probation.
- 28:19So you've managed to complete your four years of community
- 28:24control 2 1/2 years early because you did all your days in
- 28:31jail. So congratulations on that.
- 28:33And then you're going to get out and you're going to do whatever
- 28:38you damn well please. And my guess is it's going to be
- 28:44more of the same. Now, if it's more of the same
- 28:48and you get caught again in Lake County, guess who automatically
- 28:51gets your case right? Anything else?
- 28:55All right. Quite want to apologize to your
- 29:00father. If you caught that, let me know.
- 29:07Judge on the way out, just set out.
- 29:08You ought to apologize to somebody, but I didn't catch who
- 29:12he said, so if you did, put it in the chat for me.
- 29:15Good morning once again, everybody.
- 29:16TCF live. That was an interesting,
- 29:20interesting start there for Judge O'Donnell.
- 29:23Somehow not surprising though. Let's go to a different kind of
- 29:27grumpy and straightforward. Let's go to Royal Oak and our
- 29:30favorite match is straight. Good morning, we have Emma
- 29:37Silly. This is 26 Hour row 013O1 Mr.
- 29:55Thompson. This ticket was issued on the
- 29:588th of March. Fall back for 11:00 in the
- 30:02morning in the area of Crooks Rd. in Estonia.
- 30:07You were cited for speeding. The ticket was issued at 48 and
- 30:12a 30. You can admit or deny
- 30:14responsibility, or you can admit responsibility with an
- 30:18explanation. Or do you wish to proceed?
- 30:22Good morning, Judge. I I will admit responsibility
- 30:25with, I guess, an explanation, Sir.
- 30:29And what is that please? To be quite honest with you, I
- 30:32drove across from West Bloomfield on the side roads.
- 30:35I was trying to get to a bicycle meet point for a bicycle ride
- 30:39Sunday morning. I was unfamiliar with the with
- 30:42the area and I admit I was speeding once told and I I just
- 30:48I wasn't sure. And I think in my mind I thought
- 30:51it was a 40 area and I was hovering around 40.
- 30:54And I'm really sorry for it. And you know, I'm just looking
- 30:59for some, you know, some way to, you know, to mercy on it.
- 31:06That's all that that that's it. I can't I can't say anything
- 31:09other I I did do it. Is there anything you want to
- 31:12add to this officer? Yes, Judge, I remember Mr.
- 31:18Thomas, Sally. I appreciated his demeanor on
- 31:21the traffic stop. He was very respectful and I'd
- 31:26be willing to make a motion to lower this to impeding.
- 31:28Traffic. Thank you very.
- 31:32Much so, the impeding is not a moving violation, therefore it
- 31:35carries no points. OK.
- 31:38So it does not appear in your record as a moving violation.
- 31:41It does carry a fine of $175. I'm I'm willing to pay the fine.
- 31:47Yeah. Of course that beats the points.
- 31:50Yeah, I, I have two young teenage drivers, you know, I
- 31:53again, I really, I am sorry for it.
- 31:55It's stupid. And I was just, I don't know
- 31:57where my mind was at. I think I was nervous about
- 32:00trying to find the ride location and getting there in time or.
- 32:03There's research that shows the average driver commits a civil
- 32:06infraction every three blocks. We're all making mistakes, and
- 32:11the vast majority of those mistakes have no consequences
- 32:14whatsoever. And sometimes a relatively minor
- 32:18mistake can have tragic consequences.
- 32:21So the good news here is there there was an infraction, nobody
- 32:25got hurt, and there's no points. And the you can pay this online,
- 32:29or you could send in a check or pay it at the courthouse counter
- 32:32if that's more convenient for you.
- 32:34Yeah, I'll pay it today on my way out.
- 32:36Yes, Sir. Thank you.
- 32:38And thank you to the police officer.
- 32:40I'm sorry about wasting your time of.
- 32:43Course, well, they they actually pay him to do that, so they do
- 32:46it. So you are you're good to go.
- 32:52So thank you. OK.
- 32:53Will will it be immediately able to be paid?
- 32:58Yes, OK. Thank you.
- 32:59Very much have a fantastic day. Thank you.
- 33:02You too. Do you have that?
- 33:14Are we all set? Yes.
- 33:29Yeah, Miss Wilson, this is 26 R row 013O3 you sent.
- 33:35In a. Copy of the receipt for the
- 33:40renewal of the plate that was dated March 23rd.
- 33:43When you were stopped, were your plates expired?
- 33:46Yes. And and officer.
- 33:50The plates were renewed on the 23rd of March.
- 33:53Yes, correct. Is there anything you want to
- 33:58add to some sorry, I think the officer?
- 34:01In therapy, though. So.
- 34:04Unfortunately at the time. You know, I'm asking the officer
- 34:07if there's anything that he wants to add to it now.
- 34:09Oh. OK, I'm sorry.
- 34:11If she has her plates renewed, yes, I would be willing to
- 34:14dismiss this ticket. OK, Miss Wilson, the ticket is
- 34:18dismissed thanks to the officer's motion, so you are
- 34:21good to go. Thank you so much.
- 34:22I really appreciate that. Have a good day.
- 34:26OK. You too.
- 34:27OK, bye. Thanks, Officer.
- 34:37Believe that's all I have today. I thanks.
- 34:41So that information from Magistrate Chisholm saying that
- 34:45the average person commits A violation every three blocks.
- 34:49At first that struck me as extreme, but then I thought
- 34:53about it and the trips I've taken out lately, and yeah, it's
- 34:57probably true. Any who, let's head down to
- 35:01Florida. Judge Mercer.
- 35:05Been accused of one kind of possession of cocaine and one
- 35:08kind of lowering or prowling. You also have a no bond warrant
- 35:12out of Orange County, Florida. Mr. Bright there is probable
- 35:15cause for the lowering and prowling.
- 35:17I'm not sure there's probable cause on the second charge.
- 35:20I sent a text to the attorneys this morning because the officer
- 35:24never says how he identifies the substance as cocaine.
- 35:27He never mentions a lab test or a field test of any kind.
- 35:31So Mr. Mitchell, anything from the state on that?
- 35:33Yes, Your Honor, I did get in contact with Captain Bassford
- 35:36over the patrol division. He said that Lieutenant Aurorio
- 35:43field tested the substance that was found and it did test
- 35:46presumptive for cocaine. They said that just wasn't
- 35:49included in the affidavit and complaint.
- 35:52So they're going to send an amended complaint and saying
- 35:54that they field tested it and that it tested presented
- 35:57positive for cocaine all. Right, thank you.
- 36:00So Mr. McDaniel, I can either find no probable cause and and
- 36:05hold him and give them a chance to fix that, or if you wish to
- 36:08go ahead and get him a bond set, I'll be glad to do that.
- 36:10If he wants to weigh that, that yeah, we just want a bond.
- 36:15We just want a bond you honor. OK, someone still ask you to
- 36:17notify them of the of the air and deficiency.
- 36:19Mr. McDaniels not contesting that issue because he wants to
- 36:22get his client a bond set, which is understandable.
- 36:24So, Mr. Bride, I'm going to go ahead and set your bond at $7500
- 36:27on the cocaine and $3500 on the lowering and prowling.
- 36:31But you have no bond out of Orange County.
- 36:33Your bond in Jackson County, it becomes a total of $11,000 with
- 36:37a condition of random urinalysis.
- 36:39And if you post bond, Mr. Bright, you'll be released
- 36:42immediately, but you'll go to, you'll go to Orange County when
- 36:45they pick you up to deal with those charges down there.
- 36:47And as I mentioned, they have given you no bond on that
- 36:50warrant. As far as your court date in
- 36:52Jackson County, your court date should be June the 2nd at 8:30
- 36:57and the Corporal Campbell will give you a notice for that date
- 37:00before you leave the jail. Mr. Bright, do you have any
- 37:03questions, Sir? Yeah, can I get it is.
- 37:26There the possibility I can get a reduced bond.
- 37:28For a lot. Of problems.
- 37:30Based upon your criminal history, which is in front,
- 37:32which is what I'm holding up here, that's the bond I'm
- 37:35setting. Plus you already have charges
- 37:36pending somewhere else. Those are factors I look at Mr.
- 37:39Bryant. OK.
- 37:41All right, so I wish you the best.
- 37:43We have Alfred Jones next. Mr. Jones.
- 37:54Good morning, Mr. Jones. You're here for first
- 37:55appearance. Accused of one kind of loitering
- 37:57or prowling. There is probable cause for the
- 38:00charge. I'm looking at the text I was
- 38:02sent from the jail this morning, because the e-mail that is.
- 38:08Yeah, it was an e-mail sent by Corporal Gross advising me of
- 38:12your criminal history, which consists of over 300 pages.
- 38:17So you have the longest criminal history I've ever seen since
- 38:21I've been on criminal law work, which is 30 years, a little over
- 38:2530 years. Someone set your bond
- 38:27accordingly. Let me see if the attorneys have
- 38:28any additional information before I set that bond.
- 38:30Mr. McDaniel, anything. I just made the court aware just
- 38:34number of pages don't mean number of convictions.
- 38:36It doesn't mean it just means number of pages.
- 38:39Sometimes there's a page in there with one little lot,
- 38:41right? I mean, I'm just, you know, I
- 38:42don't want to set a bond based on how many pages that they
- 38:45print out. But I understand you are.
- 38:47I do understand. What you're saying?
- 38:48You're absolutely right. That's why I went to the
- 38:50Department of Corrections website and looked at his
- 38:52criminal history there, and he's probably got 30 felony
- 38:56convictions. He's been to prison.
- 38:58His last prison sentence was 19 years in the Department of
- 39:01Corrections. So Mr. Mitchell, anything I I
- 39:05didn't interrupt you, Mr. McDaniel, I just wanted to know
- 39:07I did. You're right, you're absolutely
- 39:08right. So I followed up with the next
- 39:09step because a lot of times it was that's a may could be a
- 39:12common name. I want to make sure that was all
- 39:14in fact his history and and it appears that it was.
- 39:19What was I about to say? Oh, yeah, Your honor.
- 39:22And this could also apply to Mr. Bright, I think we didn't touch
- 39:25on it, but we would also request no contact with the facility in
- 39:29question also. Yeah, I didn't even think about
- 39:31that. That's a reasonable request.
- 39:32So Mr. Jones, your bonds going to be $10,000 cash or surety
- 39:36because your criminal history is so horrible.
- 39:38You have a condition to have no contact with that facility.
- 39:41You do have the right to post the bond.
- 39:43Your court date will be misdemeanor court date.
- 39:49June 1st. June 1st at 9:00 AM And the jail
- 39:53will give you that notice. Mr. Jones.
- 39:56After first appearance, you will get to use the phone in a few
- 39:58minutes, Sir, to try to post the bond in just a little while as
- 40:02soon as first appearance is over.
- 40:03And Corporal, please make Mr. Bright aware that he also has a
- 40:06condition to have no contact with the Federal Bureau of
- 40:09Prisons property where he was accused of being owner near last
- 40:13night. Mr. Jones, do you have any
- 40:16questions, Sir? No, Sir.
- 40:18Wish you the best, Sir. What was this?
- 40:19Told Bond again. 10,000 times I have one charge, we have the
- 40:25Rico Pettis. Mr. Pettis, Good morning.
- 40:33Mr. Pettis, you're here in case number.
- 40:36Well, your charge of violation of state probation in case
- 40:3924-522, CF Mr. Pettis. Judge Garcia has signed a no
- 40:43bond warrant in your case. I'm going to go ahead and
- 40:48arraign you this morning, Sir. What that means is I'm going to
- 40:50advise you that you've been accused of violent.
- 40:51In terms of your probation, I'm going to appoint your lawyer if
- 40:54you're asking for one. Mr. Pettis, would you like to
- 40:57have an attorney appointed to represent you?
- 40:59Yes. I'm going to appoint the public
- 41:01Turner's office represent you. Mr. Pettis.
- 41:03Please listen to Mr. Mitchell and we'll listen to Mr.
- 41:06McDaniel. We'll go from there.
- 41:07Mr. McDaniel, I'm going to approve not guilty.
- 41:10Yes, since the June 4th pretrial docket.
- 41:12And I'm advising the attorney that I come speak to him prior
- 41:14to that hearing. All right, thank you.
- 41:19And Mr. Mr. Mitchell, anything? No, Your Honor.
- 41:23So Mr. Pettis, that'll be your court date and your attorney
- 41:26will see you before your court date.
- 41:28Mr. Pettis, do you have any questions?
- 41:31All. Right.
- 41:32Sorry. Wish you the best.
- 41:38Ria Lynn Cobb. Just Cobb.
- 41:42Good morning. You're here for first
- 41:43appearance. You are accused of 1 count of
- 41:46retail theft. There is probable cause for that
- 41:49charge. I also look at your criminal
- 41:51history, which is pretty extensive, but I think you may
- 41:54be entitled to a bond. I'm going to listen to the
- 41:55attorneys before I make that decision.
- 41:58Mr. Mitchell, Mr. McDaniel, anything?
- 42:02Mr. Mitchell? No.
- 42:04State, Your Honor. Miss Cobb, I'm going to set you
- 42:07a normal bond that was set for this charge with someone with
- 42:09some criminal history but not extensive.
- 42:11That bond is $2500 cash or surety.
- 42:14You have a condition to have no contact with any Walmart as a
- 42:17condition of the bond and as soon as you post the bond you'll
- 42:20be released. The jail will let you use the
- 42:22phone in just a few minutes to try to post the bond.
- 42:24They will also give you a notice for your court date which would
- 42:26be June 1st. June 1st at 9:00 AM.
- 42:30Miss Cobb, do you have any questions?
- 42:31No, Sir. Have a good day.
- 42:35Robert Thompson. Mr. Thompson, good morning.
- 42:40You're here because you've been accused of one kind of retail
- 42:42staff. Also there is probable cause.
- 42:44It's a Co defendant case with Miss Cobb.
- 42:47Mr. Mitchell, if you notify the officer, please in these cases,
- 42:51I can't find anywhere in here where it gives the total amount
- 42:54of the property allegedly stolen.
- 42:56So I have to assume it's a lowest degree misdemeanor.
- 43:01So it's it's likely that it'll be included on the offense
- 43:05report when it comes in and it may also have been returned to
- 43:08the store. So they still have to put it in
- 43:10the complaint so that I can determine first degree.
- 43:12It makes a difference for bond sometimes.
- 43:15So, Mr. Thompson, there's probable cause for a second
- 43:18degree misdemeanor. You have several prior charges,
- 43:21not super extensive, but you've got some prior criminal history.
- 43:24I think you're entitled to a bond unless there's something
- 43:26I've I've missed. I'm going to listen to the
- 43:29attorneys and then we're going to make that decision.
- 43:30Mr. McDaniel, anything. There you go, Mr. Mitchell.
- 43:34Nothing at this time, Your Honor.
- 43:35Mr. Thompson, you're going to have a $2500 bond just like your
- 43:38Co defendants cash or surety. You also have a condition no
- 43:41contact with any Walmart while the case is pending.
- 43:44You will get to use the phone in a few minutes, Sir, to try to
- 43:46post the bond. You also have given a notice for
- 43:49your court date, which should be June 1st at 9:00 AM.
- 43:53And Mr. Thompson, do you have any questions?
- 43:57All right, Sir. I wish you the best.
- 44:02We have Charles Dykes. Mr. Dykes, Good morning.
- 44:07You're here First appear. First appearance.
- 44:09Accusing 1 count of breach of the peace.
- 44:12There is probable cause for this charge.
- 44:14I'm familiar with your criminal history.
- 44:16I did take a look at it. Also.
- 44:17I've seen you fairly recently, Mr. Dykes.
- 44:21I think you're entitled to a bond, as far as I can tell.
- 44:24Let me listen to the attorneys and I'll set that bond.
- 44:27Mr. McDaniel. Anything bond, Donna.
- 44:30Mr. Mitchell. Nothing at this time, Your
- 44:34Honor. Mr. Dykes, based upon your
- 44:36criminal history, your bond is going to be $3500 cash or
- 44:39surety. You have a condition, not a
- 44:41possession or consume alcohol. Seems like when I do see you,
- 44:44it's usually alcohol related. If you get caught possessing or
- 44:46consuming alcohol, that will violate your bond.
- 44:49Mr. Dyke. I don't ever see you if there's
- 44:50no alcohol involved. Just you know it.
- 44:52Is what? Yes, Sir, it is what it is.
- 44:54You and my neighbor. Me and my neighbor headed out.
- 44:57We will, Mr. Dyke, they'll give you a notice for your court date
- 45:01which will be June 1st. And just stay away from alcohol
- 45:04until we can get this case worked out, Sir.
- 45:06And. I'm not any questions.
- 45:08Thanks Sir, I I don't wish. The best.
- 45:11Mr. Dyke, we have Angela Trim and Mr. Trim.
- 45:22Good morning. Mr. Trim, you have a warrant out
- 45:24of Holmes County, Florida. I've got a copy of the
- 45:27information from their Sheriff's Department and they say it's a
- 45:29violation of probation warrant with no bond.
- 45:31What that means, Mr. Trim, is you'll be held for them.
- 45:34They'll pick you up next day or two, possibly even today, but
- 45:38probably the next working day or two.
- 45:39You'll go to Holmes County. When you get over there, you'll
- 45:41go to another first appearance in front of a local judge and
- 45:44that local judge will address your bond status.
- 45:47But as of right now, you have no bond lease for the time being.
- 45:51Do you have any questions? All right, wish you the best,
- 45:56ma'am. Thank.
- 45:57You. Yes, ma'am.
- 46:01And I think we have the young man that was in the hospital.
- 46:04All right, Sir, Come on up. And your name, Sir?
- 46:14Jonathan Rains. OK, so Mr. McDaniel, Mr.
- 46:16Mitchell, if y'all remember Mr. Rains was first appeared last
- 46:19week, but he had a medical situation at the jail and see if
- 46:23I can find that case number. 25 Five. 42 OK After his medical
- 46:31situation, Mr. Rains, he was held with no bond because he was
- 46:34accused of violating the terms of his either probation or PTI.
- 46:37PTI. His offer was going to be 10
- 46:40days in jail, but due to his health he was not able to even
- 46:43talk to a lawyer. He was in jail with no bond.
- 46:46Then he got the medical situation got worse.
- 46:49He was admitted to the hospital. I gave him a medical furlough
- 46:53until yesterday, however he had court in Gadsden County
- 46:58yesterday. Thank you for letting me
- 46:59allowing me to go to that. No, no problem.
- 47:02So I he called and said I have court in Gaston County, which
- 47:04Mr. McDaniel had already told us about.
- 47:07So we just, I said and struggled ask Pamela to let tell him to be
- 47:10here this morning so we can figure out where we go from this
- 47:13case. So technically it's the end of a
- 47:14medical furlough. So tell me that your medical
- 47:16situation, obviously you're out of the hospital.
- 47:18When did you get out? As I remember, it was either
- 47:23Saturday, I'm not really sure what day it was because I was
- 47:26looking at my phone. But yeah, I got out not too long
- 47:30ago, about a week ago I think. OK.
- 47:33Judge, he was diagnosed with diabetes and his blood sugar, I
- 47:38think it's been around 800 and they've had to start training
- 47:42him on how to use insulin and other diabetic things.
- 47:47So they're going through a lot of training with him on that
- 47:49right now. But it was.
- 47:52And that was that was a medical issue, was the top one diabetes?
- 47:56OK. And there also was the charge in
- 47:59Gaston County at your court date yesterday.
- 48:01Is that case still pending or? Is it resolved?
- 48:04The court wasn't ready and I had to go back next month on the
- 48:0726th. OK, so unless there's something
- 48:09I don't know, gentlemen, my plan will be to his medical furlough
- 48:12has ended. He'd go back to jail with no
- 48:13bond and see if we can resolve the case.
- 48:16Mr. Mitchell, anything from the state?
- 48:20If the court is willing to, you know, look into it, I would even
- 48:24suggest we just basically give him a time served on this.
- 48:28It looks like according to my notes that Monday the victim
- 48:32actually called our office and was speaking about wanting to
- 48:35get the no contact lifted. Seems like she won't have
- 48:38contact with him now that this has happened.
- 48:40And if I was considered miserable yesterday, my stomach
- 48:45acting up, I can't imagine what Mr. Raines went through.
- 48:48I would say he's probably gone through enough, so if the court
- 48:51is inclined to give him a time served, we might just resolve
- 48:55this case today. He's I was going to.
- 48:57Ask Jake about. He's got four days credit, you
- 49:00know, he's paid off all the fines, your honor, and he's paid
- 49:02off even all the probation costs for the entire time.
- 49:06And this. Was a charge that was, I mean,
- 49:09it's I don't even know if it was a crime that's trying to help
- 49:11him out, trying to help the mother out.
- 49:13And you know, I think the ledge knocked the phone out of her
- 49:17hand or something. If I recall this my recollection
- 49:21and I know the mother don't want to do anything.
- 49:23So I've just asked for maybe they just go ahead and keep
- 49:26successfully terminate this PR on success PR unsuccessfully.
- 49:29It don't matter if the terminate is PTI and just was four days
- 49:33credited. The courts climbed.
- 49:36So I'm looking back at the original charge and the air
- 49:40condition's so loud it's hard to hear anything in here.
- 49:49And you're right, the the allegation was originally that
- 49:52he slapped the phone from Jessica's hand.
- 49:56That was the original charge of battery and Jessica's the
- 49:58mother. Is that you, ma'am?
- 50:00So the charge originally was battery.
- 50:02He had no prior history, I'm assuming because he got APTI.
- 50:06He wouldn't get APTI without what he had a history typically.
- 50:10So he got APTI and that would have been in January and then he
- 50:17he's on PTI until he gets charged in Gadsden County under
- 50:23that new law. Dangerous or aggressive driving?
- 50:28Speeding. Dangerous success with speed in
- 50:31Gaston County. Were you arrested there?
- 50:33No, Sir. So you were charged criminally
- 50:35there in February that violated your PTI or calls to order to
- 50:41show calls to be issued and then you got arrested for violation
- 50:45of your pretrial intervention because of the new charge.
- 50:48The new charge is still pending and I don't think the PTI was on
- 50:51battery. I think the charge was amended.
- 50:54To. Disorderly conduct.
- 50:56OK. So Mr. McDaniel, how much jail
- 51:01time does he have credit for? Four days, two days before the
- 51:06PTI and two days after, Correct. All right, ma'am, and you're the
- 51:14alleged victim. You want to come on up, please
- 51:16so I can ask you a couple of questions.
- 51:22Your name, ma'am. My name is Jessica Raines.
- 51:24Miss Raines, let me get you to raise your right hand.
- 51:26You saw me swear are from the testimony about giving this case
- 51:28be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but truth.
- 51:29Help you God. I do.
- 51:31So you understand he was in jail with no bond.
- 51:33His offer at that time was going to be 10 days in jail because of
- 51:36the all the big picture, the total circumstances.
- 51:39Then he got sick and let him out of jail so he could deal with
- 51:43his medical situation. He still got a charge pending in
- 51:45Gaston County. Have no idea what will happen
- 51:47with that. May be dismissed.
- 51:48Make it a fine, make it probation.
- 51:50May I? I don't know what are you asking
- 51:53us to do with with the charge where you're the victim on the
- 51:56point he was on PTI on. Sorry, I would honestly like for
- 52:00it just to be dropped, call it quits like I never wanted it to
- 52:05go this far. Anyway.
- 52:08But given his current medical condition now that is brand new,
- 52:12I'm extremely worried about his health and I really don't want
- 52:16to see him go back into custody because I worry that he won't
- 52:19get the proper care there. You were the The type 1 diabetic
- 52:23diagnosis is brand new. He has never had any kind of
- 52:27health issues. Before.
- 52:28OK all. Right, Mr. Mitchell, any
- 52:32questions for Miss Rains? Not at this time.
- 52:38Of your honor, Mr. McDaniel just let her know it didn't come out
- 52:41the out of the I could be explained some of the things
- 52:45that were happening prior. I mean, I mean, my guess is
- 52:47because it did just happen overnight.
- 52:49I mean, it didn't. Turn into a top one.
- 52:50Diabetic overnight. So I mean, I probably explained
- 52:52some of the stuff that you talked to me about before prior
- 52:55I. Agree.
- 52:58Mr. Mitchell, it seems like it's, I mean, I'm not going to
- 53:00take any action in the order to show calls if the state's not
- 53:03asking me to considering everything I've heard today,
- 53:05what is your decision on the on the underlying case, which is
- 53:09still kind of in limbo because of the PTI status?
- 53:12He hasn't played to it. We either got to get a plea to
- 53:15time served, which is what you suggested, or Richard Mcdaniel's
- 53:18suggestion was dismissal. So y'all got to figure out what
- 53:20y'all want to do with the case. Given what we've heard today and
- 53:25from Miss Raines also, the state will announce a dismissal in
- 53:29case number 26180 MMM. So in light of everything that
- 53:32you spent time in jail as well as the whole pit, the big
- 53:36picture, Mr. Mr. Mitchell's going to dismiss this case
- 53:40against you. So it's being dismissed.
- 53:41You don't have to go back and and go back to jail and finish
- 53:43the sentence. So I just need the state to
- 53:45follow no information. O20. 5542.
- 53:52I'm talking about another case that I won't you, me and Mr.
- 53:56McDaniel to talk about off record and off Zoom.
- 53:58OK? So yeah, it's 25542.
- 54:01MMM. So this case is dismissed.
- 54:03You're no longer on pretrial intervention, you know.
- 54:06Well, I didn't even ask it. Well, it doesn't matter, really.
- 54:08Did he get court costs and fines paid?
- 54:10You got them paid. You paid them.
- 54:15OK, so the case is dismissed. This has nothing to do with
- 54:18Gaston County. You still got that case over
- 54:21there. You got your court aid over
- 54:22there. Do you have any questions?
- 54:24But. What does this mean?
- 54:26It means the case is dismissed. This is a.
- 54:27I'm not a probation in that, no. More you're not a probation, OK?
- 54:30And a lot of the time you spent in jail.
- 54:32Mr. Mitchell's dismissing the case.
- 54:34Yes, Sir. OK.
- 54:36Any questions? No, Sir.
- 54:37Ma'am, do you have any questions?
- 54:38No, Sir. Thank you.
- 54:39Thank you all for coming. Wish you the best, Mr.
- 54:49McDaniels. Everything I had on my list this
- 54:52morning unless I miss something any.
- 54:54All right, that wraps it up for Judge Mercer.
- 54:56Good morning once again, everybody.
- 54:57TCF live on a Wednesday. Judging from the stats, there's
- 55:00probably some new people out there.
- 55:02Either you're new to the live show or new to the channel
- 55:05completely. If you are, say good morning to
- 55:08us in the chat. This is a friendly group.
- 55:10You have stumbled into one of the best places on Law Tube, so
- 55:13it's good to have you here. Let's go back up to Michigan
- 55:17Judge McNally. To the charge impeding traffic,
- 55:25do you plead responsible or not responsible?
- 55:30Responsible. Are you in school still or are
- 55:34you out? No, Your Honor.
- 55:38I don't know. No.
- 55:39What? No, you're not.
- 55:40No, I'm not in school, Your Honor.
- 55:41Pardon. No, I am not in school, Your
- 55:44Honor. Did you graduate?
- 55:46Yes, I did, your Honor. What are you doing now?
- 55:49Security. Your Honor.
- 55:55Security where in Wyandotte? What that means in Wyandotte,
- 56:01where does that work? Where at?
- 56:03In Wyandotte, at BASR. Listen, I'm going to take your
- 56:08plea. I'm going to dismiss the traffic
- 56:10control device. I'm going to dismiss the
- 56:12violation. Basic speed law.
- 56:15I'll tell you, you got to be more careful here. 195 is your
- 56:20total. Can you pay that today?
- 56:23Yes, your Honor. Please slow down around 4 stop
- 56:26signs in a subdivision. Kids running around there.
- 56:30This was at what time? 141 in the morning.
- 56:37How old are you again, Mr. Barton?
- 56:39You say 19. Yes, your Honor.
- 56:43Nothing good happens at 2:00 in the morning.
- 56:45Thanks, Mr. McDonald. Have a good day.
- 56:47Good luck, Josh. Take care.
- 56:49You're going to pay that today, right, Sir?
- 56:51Yeah, it's your honor. All right, good luck, All right,
- 56:54people, against Agron Brahimi 267842174.
- 56:59How you doing, Miss Gary? And good.
- 57:01Judge. Good to.
- 57:01See you. You too, every what do you what
- 57:03to what do we owe the pleasure of you coming in person?
- 57:06I. Was told to come in person so I
- 57:09follow directions. I don't know why I'm special.
- 57:16Why did they tell you to come in person?
- 57:17I don't know when. I.
- 57:19Even who'd you talk to? The court notice says in person
- 57:23and then I called earlier this week.
- 57:25Heather, do you know anything about that?
- 57:28I do not judge. I'm looking at what case it is.
- 57:31Usually we put in choice and on the defendant's copy, but then
- 57:35if there's Oh no and then these are usually Oh no she's a
- 57:38preformer. I usually send a zoom form with
- 57:41these for the preformals with a retained attorney.
- 57:45Yeah. What happened here?
- 57:48Well, I don't know what. Happened.
- 57:50I'm here and it worked out and it's it's fine.
- 57:54It's always good to see. You too.
- 57:59I don't think you would have talked to my judicial clerk
- 58:01because I don't think she would have insisted that I know she
- 58:04lived in them. Maybe you talked to one of the
- 58:07other staff and they thought you were defendant.
- 58:09I don't know, but at any rate, I'm my apologies.
- 58:12You're going to you're going to plead the impeding or authorized
- 58:14center of that plea, correct On behalf of your client.
- 58:16That's correct. Do that charge responsible or
- 58:19not responsible. Responsible plea is accepted
- 58:22150. I'll give them a week.
- 58:23OK, perfect. Thank you.
- 58:25May 6th have a great day. Take care.
- 58:29Be careful out there. All the water on the road with
- 58:33right, Aaron, Justin Tyree, Karen 26, W 841783 AB and C OK,
- 58:44Mr. Herron, you can come on up here and tell me your name,
- 58:46please. All right, so you met with this,
- 58:50the city attorney, you're going to plead guilty to allowing an
- 58:54unlicensed driver to drive and they are then going to dismiss
- 59:01the drug. See.
- 59:03They don't know. They are then going to move to
- 59:05dismiss the driving on a suspended, no proof of insurance
- 59:10and expired plate. True.
- 59:11All right, girl. And that's what you want to do.
- 59:15And apparently you have another ticket you're going to pay
- 59:18today, right? I'm on a payment plan.
- 59:21I just made a payment for the all right.
- 59:29OK, If you plead guilty to allowing an unlicensed driver to
- 59:32drive, I'm going to dismiss all other charges possible.
- 59:35Penalties are up to 500 fines, 90 days jail cost for all those.
- 59:38Do you understand that? You just sign, read and
- 59:41understand the advice of rights, plead guilty.
- 59:44You'll be giving up all those rights and we're not going to
- 59:47have the trials. Understand that you still have
- 59:50the right to a lawyer if you want one.
- 59:51I'll give you 1. You understand that?
- 59:53Yes. Would you like a?
- 59:56Lawyer. To the charge allowing the
- 1:00:00licensed driver to drive, how do you plead?
- 1:00:02On the 6th of March, I'm sorry, 7th of March of 26th, were you
- 1:00:06in control of the 2011 Ford that was being operated on Western
- 1:00:11Allen and Woodhaven? You allow somebody to drive that
- 1:00:13was unlicensed and that was you, right?
- 1:00:17Are you on probation or parole? Anybody force you to plead
- 1:00:21guilty and you're still suspended, right?
- 1:00:25Please Accepted the suspense, dismissed.
- 1:00:28No insurance and expired later dismissed.
- 1:00:31You got to stop doing this son. Anything you want to say hard
- 1:00:45fines 150 costs 75 victims right, $50 justice assessment.
- 1:00:49I'll go kind of light but 375 or 90 days.
- 1:00:53Do you have all that to pay? 370. 5 or 90 days.
- 1:00:58I can start, I got a payment plan on the 272 for North Beach
- 1:01:03and cents. Can I put them together for a
- 1:01:05payment plan? When are you supposed to pay and
- 1:01:08how much on those I? Just paid today another payment
- 1:01:12but I'm supposed to. Pay 55 a month.
- 1:01:15Yeah, Judge. His payment plan on his other
- 1:01:17tickets is $55 monthly. He did make a payment today on
- 1:01:21that. I'm not a lot later.
- 1:01:25How much do you make there? Maybe 18 bucks.
- 1:01:29If kids. Yes.
- 1:01:31How many? One, but I I'll take care of
- 1:01:34everything in my household. So you can pay in that.
- 1:01:36Can you pay 50 more per month than this one?
- 1:01:40So a hundred a month total. Well, if you're paying 55, yeah,
- 1:01:43that'd be 105. Can you do that?
- 1:01:46I. Can make that all right. 50 per
- 1:01:49month beginning May the 15th. Can you do that?
- 1:01:56Or you want me to give you a little more time?
- 1:01:58How about May 31? End of May.
- 1:02:01May 31. OK, you're all set.
- 1:02:06All right, thanks. Have a good day.
- 1:02:08It'll give you another print out on that.
- 1:02:09Just to just so you know, you have to pay on that particular
- 1:02:16case, so go down the hall, please.
- 1:02:18Austin J Doyle 26 W 8419318 Did you send that other file down
- 1:02:26with John yet, Heather? No, I haven't sitting here.
- 1:02:29He hasn't been down here. OK, Can you OK your name?
- 1:02:34Awesome. You're charged with driving on a
- 1:02:36suspended. I can arraign you, send you to
- 1:02:37the prosecutor, or I can give you a lawyer.
- 1:02:39Can you give me a lawyer, please?
- 1:02:41Sure, I'll. Give you a lawyer.
- 1:02:45And you have a second charge of obstructed vision.
- 1:02:50Heather, can you have somebody run that down, please?
- 1:02:55Yes, Judge, I have someone bringing it down right now.
- 1:02:57Go out there. He's going to set you up with a
- 1:02:59lawyer. You can go right outside in the
- 1:03:02hallway. OK.
- 1:03:03Thank you, John. Thank you.
- 1:03:04Eddie Manson's son's in 267842464.
- 1:03:09That means a lawyer. And this one's done.
- 1:03:16Your name, Sir. And I can't let you appear on
- 1:03:20behalf of a corporation on a misdemeanor.
- 1:03:22I'm sorry. You're going to have to get a
- 1:03:24lawyer. I'm not trying to make money for
- 1:03:25lawyers. But that's just the rule on a
- 1:03:28criminal case. So I can't do what?
- 1:03:30I can give you an adjournment, but you're going to have to hire
- 1:03:33a lawyer. OK.
- 1:03:36It's not my rule. It's the state's rule.
- 1:03:40Courts ruled. Whatever you want to call Mark
- 1:03:42May the 13th. Is that at 830, Heather?
- 1:03:48Yes, we can do 8:30. I'm sorry, it's your first name
- 1:03:52is Eric. Eric.
- 1:03:54And that's TR1BL. EY, right.
- 1:03:57Thank you. You're all set.
- 1:03:59Thanks. OK, friends, I'm going to keep
- 1:04:04an eye on Judge McNally, but let's move along.
- 1:04:08But before we do, there is new people out there.
- 1:04:10My name is Dan, by the way, in case you didn't catch that.
- 1:04:12And it's good to have you all here.
- 1:04:15I said in the opening, we might run across somebody new, and I
- 1:04:18have somebody new for you. I've never seen this judge
- 1:04:20before. This is the 39th district out of
- 1:04:23Roseville, MI. This is Judge Aaliyah Marie
- 1:04:26Hakim. No idea what we're going to see,
- 1:04:29but let's find out. Ahead, counsel.
- 1:04:40Good. Morning honored Not yet Francis
- 1:04:42on behalf of plaintiff defendants.
- 1:04:44Of. Records.
- 1:04:47With his permission. State your name please.
- 1:04:49Max. Park I.
- 1:04:51Have a note from a prosecutor, prosecutor, attorney indicating
- 1:04:54complaining witnesses failed to appear.
- 1:04:56They are unable to proceed. Do you have a motion?
- 1:04:58We would make a motion to. We'll grant your motion.
- 1:05:01These are all set. Thank.
- 1:05:02You. 2516005 People versus dudiment.
- 1:05:11And good morning, Your Honor. For the record, Julie Hileo on
- 1:05:14behalf of Miss and I believe she is also carrying on Zoom.
- 1:05:19State your name, please. Sydney is still the bank.
- 1:05:25Thank you. It's today is the in time set
- 1:05:27for pretrial but it is also my motion requesting to withdraw
- 1:05:31from this file. The student event has expressed
- 1:05:34that she no longer wishes me to be her attorney.
- 1:05:37There is a breakdown so I'm asking to allow her new council.
- 1:05:44All right, Miss Student event. Is that true?
- 1:05:46Yes. All right, I will allow Miss
- 1:05:52Halawa to withdraw. We'll set a new pretrial date
- 1:06:02and have a new attorney appointed.
- 1:06:11Pretrial will be for May 20th, 2026 at 8:30 AM on Zoom.
- 1:06:16That's May 20th, 2026 at 8:30 AM here.
- 1:06:19All set. Thank you. 263312 SM People
- 1:06:29versus bacon. Your Honor, for the record,
- 1:06:34appointed counsel Tom Jacobs, premiap of Miss Bacon, who is in
- 1:06:39custody. We have bacon, Macomb County
- 1:06:43Jail. Can we have bacon, please?
- 1:06:47Yes. Go ahead, Council.
- 1:06:49Your Honor, discuss a proposed resolution and I and I discussed
- 1:06:55it the same with my client who rejects it.
- 1:06:57We she wishes to have this matter set for bench trial and
- 1:07:01also wishes to court to consider a request for a personal bond.
- 1:07:07Right. You want to make a bond motion?
- 1:07:10Let's do that before we set a trial.
- 1:07:11Wait. Yes, Your Honor, I would
- 1:07:13respectfully request that the personal bond be set in behalf
- 1:07:18of Miss Bacon. She's been in custody, I
- 1:07:22believe, 3737 days and she wishes, as she puts it, to get
- 1:07:26her life together and put herself on the right track.
- 1:07:29And she would best be able to to accomplish this if in fact she
- 1:07:32was allowed a personal bond. OK.
- 1:07:37And can I hear from the prosecution on?
- 1:07:40Bond Yeah, Judge, sorry. I talked to the fence and I was
- 1:07:43waiting for him to talk to me again.
- 1:07:46Fred berth on the back of the people judge.
- 1:07:48I'm having Miss Bacon trying to get her life in order but she's
- 1:07:51been arrested 19 times since 2023.
- 1:07:53She already has a personal bond on this case.
- 1:07:55She's not accruing credit. The offer is and has been just
- 1:07:59plea discharged and just be done with this.
- 1:08:01Every time she's put on probation through circuit she's
- 1:08:03unsuccessful and picks up new charges.
- 1:08:05So she has a personal bond already and she's not accruing
- 1:08:08time I. Definitely have a personal bond.
- 1:08:11Hold on, hold on. Yeah, I I show a 15,000 cash
- 1:08:15surety, 10% bond. OK, that's what.
- 1:08:20We. Showed 1000 personal that was
- 1:08:22modified after arraignment. I don't have any modification
- 1:08:27after arraignment. She was arraigned on March 16th,
- 1:08:302026 at the jail. Judge Choco said A 15,000 cash
- 1:08:33surety, 10% bond. She then appeared on April 1st,
- 1:08:402026. That was with Judge Viviano.
- 1:08:44Bond was not addressed and the pre trial was set for April
- 1:08:4829th, 2026, which is today. So I'm showing her how with us
- 1:08:52out of 15,000 cash 3010%. OK.
- 1:08:57Just just so that I just want to make sure we're all on the same
- 1:08:59page, ma'am. Do you think is that what your
- 1:09:01bond is as far as you know? Just because that's what I'm
- 1:09:03showing and sometimes our stuff is wrong.
- 1:09:05I just want to clarify that we're all on the same page.
- 1:09:08I I thought it was a personal before.
- 1:09:09It's been said that it was a personal, but it's keeping me
- 1:09:11from going to rehab, Your Honor, That's why.
- 1:09:14And I wanted an adjournment so I can see the police report and
- 1:09:16everything. Not a do.
- 1:09:19We have other files with you. You have, I believe you have
- 1:09:23another file. I don't know what this one is.
- 1:09:25I thought it was the same one at first, but it's something
- 1:09:27different. So I'm quite confused as what's
- 1:09:30going on. I just know that I was.
- 1:09:32I've been ready for rehab for 47 days, so.
- 1:09:35We're going to look it up right now.
- 1:09:36We might have other files and that might be the disconnect and
- 1:09:39maybe another file has a personal bond.
- 1:09:41I just want to get to the right thing.
- 1:09:42So who's releasing you to rehab? Community corrections and it was
- 1:09:48you, your Honor, that made a referral to committee
- 1:09:49corrections for I thought this case, but maybe the other case.
- 1:09:53Has to be another case because I haven't touched this file yet
- 1:09:58because it's gone through Judge Choco and George Viviano and I'm
- 1:10:01is the first day that I'm touching this file specifically
- 1:10:04OK so yeah that I. Would give you another.
- 1:10:07Case, let's let's look that up and let's just get them all
- 1:10:11corresponded together. OK, Gianna, thank you.
- 1:10:18Give us one second. I believe I have a May.
- 1:10:30The next Wednesday is a case. It's OK.
- 1:10:34Hold on, ma'am. We're we're looking it all up
- 1:10:36right now. OK, I'm sorry, I thought it
- 1:10:38would just help if you guys had a date for it.
- 1:10:41I appreciate it. He has a.
- 1:10:56Key trial on A2513456 case next Wednesday at 8:30.
- 1:11:03We need to pull that file today. These should be together.
- 1:11:08That is likely the file she has the personal bond on.
- 1:11:11But I want to see that file. You know, we're going to pass
- 1:11:13this for a minute. We're going to pull that file.
- 1:11:16They're pre trials. They should be being heard on
- 1:11:18the same date. I'm not separated.
- 1:11:20Give me one second Council, Miss Bacon, stay there.
- 1:11:22I'm going to call another case while waiting for that file to
- 1:11:23be brought into the courtroom and then we're going to bring
- 1:11:25everything together. Very.
- 1:11:27Funny. OK, I do have another.
- 1:11:28Date. Like I said, the.
- 1:11:29Next Wednesday, if we could do them on that day.
- 1:11:32Because I haven't seen. The report for this one.
- 1:11:34OK. Thank you.
- 1:11:35I I got it. Don't worry.
- 1:11:37All right, 254346 SM and 19237 OSM people versus Hall.
- 1:11:44Good morning, Your honor. For the record, James Patrick
- 1:11:46Brennan, representing Miss Hall, Miss.
- 1:11:48Hall, can you? Unmute and state your name for
- 1:11:51the record, you have to unmute first, Miss Hall.
- 1:11:57There you go. Kimberly Hall.
- 1:12:00Your Honor, today was the date and time set for a pretrial on
- 1:12:05Case 2543646. The allegation here was for a
- 1:12:11defrauding an innkeeper. The prosecuting attorney on
- 1:12:16April 1st off with a plea bargain of attempt.
- 1:12:20I've explained this to my client.
- 1:12:21She wishes to avail herself to that offer.
- 1:12:26The second case, Your Honor, the 192370 is a show cause case for
- 1:12:33failure to pay. I was hoping we could do the
- 1:12:37current criminal because I'm going to try to bring both of
- 1:12:42these together. We will do then Council, let's
- 1:12:45start with this. 1254346 SM Miss Hall, how do you plead to the
- 1:12:50added count 2 of attempt defrauding an innkeeper?
- 1:12:53Guilty or not guilty? Guilty.
- 1:12:57Do you read, write and understand the English language?
- 1:13:00Yes, I do. You gone over your rights with
- 1:13:02your attorney. Yes.
- 1:13:05Do you understand all of those rights?
- 1:13:07Yes, I do. Is anybody forcing you to plead
- 1:13:10guilty? No, Your Honor.
- 1:13:13Has anybody promised you leniency from this court to get
- 1:13:15you to plead guilty other than the plea agreement itself?
- 1:13:18No, Your Honor. Currently on probation or
- 1:13:21parole. I'm on it.
- 1:13:23I just started probation for Clinton Township all.
- 1:13:28Right. And do you understand that if
- 1:13:29this violates that I have no effect over the consequences?
- 1:13:32Yes, your Honor. If you're not a citizen of the
- 1:13:35United States, we're here, But I advise that a conviction of the
- 1:13:37offense you're pleading guilty too, may have consequences such
- 1:13:40as deprecation, exclusion from admission to the United States
- 1:13:44with the denial of naturalization pursuant to the
- 1:13:46laws of the United States. Do you understand that?
- 1:13:48Yes, your Honor. I know that you've been advised
- 1:13:51of. Do you still wish to plead
- 1:13:52guilty here today? I'm.
- 1:13:54Sorry, what was that? I know that you've been advised
- 1:13:57of do you still wish to think guilty here today?
- 1:13:59Yes, your Honor. How do you plead to the added
- 1:14:02count 2 of attempt defrauding an innkeeper?
- 1:14:05Guilty or not guilty? Guilty.
- 1:14:09And Council, can you bar Deer for a factual basis?
- 1:14:12We're an offense. Date of April 3rd, 2025 in the
- 1:14:15City of Roseville. Miss Hall on April 3rd, 2025 in
- 1:14:22the city of Roseville. Were you at the Rebel Hair
- 1:14:25Studio? Yes, yes, I was.
- 1:14:28And did you leave without paying after receiving services?
- 1:14:33Yes, I did. Your Honor, is the court
- 1:14:35satisfied? I'm satisfied.
- 1:14:38I'll accept the guilty plea for the added count 2.
- 1:14:42I'll dismiss count 1. The fine on count 2 is going to
- 1:14:45be $200. Mandatory state cost of $125.00.
- 1:14:48There's a restitution due in the amount of $250.
- 1:14:51Are you able to pay that today? No, I was hoping to have some
- 1:14:55time just being that I have other courts I'm also paying on
- 1:15:01so if I could. Have I believe 250 is what about
- 1:15:04the 250 just for the restitution as my understanding was that
- 1:15:10that was due at the time of the plea?
- 1:15:13Yes, I could pay that. OK.
- 1:15:16So I'm going to order that you pay the 2:50 today.
- 1:15:19OK. With regard to the remaining
- 1:15:22fines and costs, now we'll address the show cause file as
- 1:15:25well. On the show cause file, it looks
- 1:15:28like you still owe this court $670.
- 1:15:31And then that is in conjunction with the 200 and the 125.
- 1:15:35Let me add those up for you. Your honor, if I may, my client
- 1:15:40was incarcerated in Macomb County Jail for 39 days.
- 1:15:44She lost her job as a babysitter.
- 1:15:46She's trying to obtain employment again.
- 1:15:51She's a single mother with three minor children that are in
- 1:15:55Intermediate School or junior high, both the 19 case and what
- 1:16:02we're talking about now with the 25 case or financial matters.
- 1:16:06And we would ask this court if one that would consider the jail
- 1:16:11time that she actually incurred, or two, if it could waive such
- 1:16:17costs as attorney fees and minimize any other fines and
- 1:16:20costs. All right.
- 1:16:25I don't assess attorney fees on any file on the 19 file.
- 1:16:30What I am going to do is I'm going to close that one out.
- 1:16:34I'm going to give you how many days till she spent in jail.
- 1:16:40I have it down as 39, Your Honor.
- 1:16:45On the old file I'm going to give you 30 days jail.
- 1:16:49Thank you your. Honor waive the fine costs and
- 1:16:56fees and close the file. That's $670.
- 1:17:03I am though to put you on a payment plan for the 325 on the
- 1:17:07new file. I think it's more manageable.
- 1:17:11I'm going to refer you to our financial officer to set up a
- 1:17:14payment plan based on your ability to pay.
- 1:17:17So you're going to get an e-mail address.
- 1:17:18You do need to pay the 250 in restitution today.
- 1:17:20That was part of the plate. OK.
- 1:17:23Thank you, Your Honor. And you can work out a payment
- 1:17:26plan based on your with our financial officer, OK.
- 1:17:29Thank you. Your Honor, you don't want to.
- 1:17:31Have the e-mail. I'm sorry, Mr. Brennan.
- 1:17:34I'm sorry, your Honor, one last detail.
- 1:17:36The court has an improper phone number for my client.
- 1:17:39Do you wish me to give it now or do you wish me to text it?
- 1:17:45What we're going to do is in the chat feature, she's going to get
- 1:17:48an e-mail address to the financial officer.
- 1:17:50She needs to send an e-mail requesting a payment plan.
- 1:17:53In that e-mail, she can update her phone number.
- 1:17:56Thank you, Your honor. We just don't want to broadcast
- 1:17:59your phone number live to YouTube right now.
- 1:18:02And thank you. Fair.
- 1:18:05But in the e-mail you can update it.
- 1:18:07You have to send an e-mail to get the payment plan.
- 1:18:09So we're going to send you an e-mail address, you're going to
- 1:18:11e-mail the financial officer asking for a payment plan.
- 1:18:14He will get back to you in that time.
- 1:18:16He you can have him update your phone number for the file.
- 1:18:18OK. OK.
- 1:18:19Thank you so much for everything you're.
- 1:18:22Welcome you have. You have a great day, Judge.
- 1:18:25Thank you. Thank you, Macomb County Jail.
- 1:18:28Can I have bacon back? While we wait for bacon, do
- 1:18:37check out the bacon pole. Should Bacon ever be charged
- 1:18:39with a crime? Options are no.
- 1:18:42Your options are no, hell no, or conspiracy to cause heart
- 1:18:45attacks. So please, please give us your
- 1:18:47answer. 9 SM It is also a retail fraud, second degree.
- 1:18:52On that file. She does have a $1000 personal
- 1:18:55bond, so that's where the disconnect was.
- 1:18:57The $1000 personal bond is correct.
- 1:18:59It's just we have two files and they were on separate dates and
- 1:19:02I see where that and they're the same charge.
- 1:19:04So I see where the confusion was.
- 1:19:06You are on personal bond on that and you are telling me that the
- 1:19:10jail is trying to release you into treatment but they cannot
- 1:19:13at this time due to the $15,000 bond on the other file, Correct
- 1:19:16Miss Bacon. Yes, you're on.
- 1:19:19Which is common, which is common.
- 1:19:21And what will happen is if I don't do this right now, the
- 1:19:24jail will send me a letter saying we're trying to send her
- 1:19:26to treatment. Here's an order.
- 1:19:28Please reduce her bond to personal.
- 1:19:30So I have reviewed the file and while it is correct, you do have
- 1:19:38extensive contacts in your criminal history, what I am
- 1:19:41going to note is most of them are driving related offenses.
- 1:19:46You do have some retail frauds, but I do think that a lot of
- 1:19:51this stems from a need for treatment.
- 1:19:54A lot of what your history is showing me are offenses that
- 1:19:58stem from underlying treatment issues that aren't being
- 1:20:03addressed in the 1st place. And so to me, then the most
- 1:20:06important thing we do is get you in that treatment because we
- 1:20:08can't address the issues if we're not addressing what's
- 1:20:10causing that. So I am going to reduce your
- 1:20:13bond. That's personal as well because
- 1:20:19if we don't get you into treatment, we don't solve
- 1:20:21anything in the 1st place. I do need you to be committed to
- 1:20:24that treatment. It's not an easy Rd. but this is
- 1:20:27just for you, for your future. In the meantime, your bond is
- 1:20:30reduced here. You'll be able to really reduce
- 1:20:32the bad and get your needs met and be able to take from that.
- 1:20:36In the meantime, we'll set a bench trial date council.
- 1:20:39You can have May 13th or May 20th or May 27th.
- 1:20:49What would you like? Let's see, how about May May
- 1:20:5320th, Your honor? We'll set it for May 20th.
- 1:20:57We'll set it for 8:30 AM. Would you like that on Zoomer in
- 1:20:59person? So, so let me see this.
- 1:21:06This is what I'm going to place on the record on May 20th.
- 1:21:11She may be in treatment. That is the goal.
- 1:21:14That is why we reduced the bond today.
- 1:21:17If she's in treatment, it will be difficult for her to come
- 1:21:19here in person because she won't be able to leave the facility.
- 1:21:23They will be able to Zoom her over.
- 1:21:25That being said, if she's on Zoom and we needed to proceed to
- 1:21:31trial, we would then have to set a new date.
- 1:21:34So it could be a soft trial date to see what you guys want to do
- 1:21:38and how things are going to work out.
- 1:21:40Or if it is going to proceed to trial, we would need a full in
- 1:21:44person date. And I'm just being aware of the
- 1:21:46fact that if she's in treatment, we set it in person that we
- 1:21:49might not get her here on the 20th.
- 1:21:51So I'm going to let the attorneys decide if they want it
- 1:21:55on Zoomer in person, but I'm going to place what I think the
- 1:21:57logistical factors are on the record.
- 1:21:59And that's what I wanted you to consider as you make that
- 1:22:01decision. Is that 830, Your Honor?
- 1:22:048:30 AM. Yes, we set trials at 8:30.
- 1:22:09OK. All right.
- 1:22:11Thank you. And Miss Bacon, give me a call.
- 1:22:15Let me know what your status is when you have an opportunity.
- 1:22:18What is your phone number? Do you want it?
- 1:22:20Do you want it set on zoomer in person for now?
- 1:22:23So. Well, I'll be there in person,
- 1:22:27let's just put it that way so I don't.
- 1:22:29Know all right, I will set it in person.
- 1:22:33What I am going to do is no definite may be in treatment.
- 1:22:39OK. OK.
- 1:22:44That's what we'll do, ma'am. What we'll do is council, if you
- 1:22:48can send your cell phone number or your office number, whatever
- 1:22:51number you want to give out in the chat feature, Miss Bacon,
- 1:22:55Miss Reyes will put it on your disposition sheet.
- 1:22:58Ask for that when they're releasing you from the jail into
- 1:23:00treatment, and we'll put it on there.
- 1:23:02We're just not going to broadcast it live right now.
- 1:23:03You don't have anywhere to write it down and we're live to
- 1:23:06YouTube, OK? OK.
- 1:23:08Thank you so much. We'll thank you.
- 1:23:11We'll put the number on your disposition sheet for you, OK.
- 1:23:15Thank you. Thanks, Kerr.
- 1:23:16Thank you. You're all set.
- 1:23:18Well, hopefully the bacon will be able to be brought home soon.
- 1:23:21That's all I can say about that. Good morning once again
- 1:23:23everybody, hour 2 of TCF Live. We'll end our poll now with its
- 1:23:29split. 33% of you say no bacon should not be charged. 33% and
- 1:23:34say hell no bacon should not be charged and 33% of you believe
- 1:23:38bacon should be charged with conspiracy to cause heart attack
- 1:23:43already taxes Judge Stevens. You need a quick up to speed on
- 1:23:50this one Judge. I did ask for discovery.
- 1:23:52Got discovery from Miss Gasper. She sent me an e-mail back
- 1:23:57saying that Mister Padgett was going to be hired on on the case
- 1:24:01that I got. When she responded to me, I
- 1:24:04contacted Mr. Padgett. And as of right now, Mr. Elam
- 1:24:09hasn't paid Mr. Tablet for that burglary case.
- 1:24:13And I think he's going. To hire Mr. Pat.
- 1:24:15You know what you told me He. We need to sell that to the
- 1:24:17judge. So he'll know.
- 1:24:18Yes, Sir. When are you going to do that?
- 1:24:20This year, 10 years, next year? We we move forward.
- 1:24:25I mean, we're not going to wait on you for your finances.
- 1:24:27We're moving forward here. Good.
- 1:24:31We now hold on. So just all of.
- 1:24:40This aspect is the I know you're not here's this, here's the
- 1:24:49file, here's the file, but I am I am appointed on the murder of
- 1:24:58the habitation, which is this space but.
- 1:25:00That's the one that. OK.
- 1:25:03All right, today's case is a burglary of a habitation.
- 1:25:08Right. But yes.
- 1:25:09A. Few cases on the docket, they're
- 1:25:11just not listed together because Mr. Padgett is on the other
- 1:25:13right. But.
- 1:25:16He has a burglary. Of a habitation and accept of a
- 1:25:18firearm. I did speak.
- 1:25:21With him yesterday, Judge, and like I say, to my understanding,
- 1:25:24he hasn't paid, you know, for the burglary case.
- 1:25:26Well, it's nonetheless. He.
- 1:25:30Announced he's a lawyer in the case.
- 1:25:33I mean that's kind of an ethical importance.
- 1:25:35I mean that's what we live on like if a a lawyer's word, a
- 1:25:39lawyer's come up and says he's representative and it's on the
- 1:25:42record. So the finances are another
- 1:25:45thing that's between you and him.
- 1:25:47That's not, I don't get, that's y'all's deal.
- 1:25:50It's right now. The deal I have is that he's the
- 1:25:53lawyer of record. He should be here right now.
- 1:25:55Please call. Him there is not a.
- 1:25:57Letter of representation in the burglary of the habitation.
- 1:26:00He is representing him on the record.
- 1:26:02In the theft of. Fire.
- 1:26:04That's when I rely on for documents.
- 1:26:08I know I'm saying 251056 is is a case on that man's name and the
- 1:26:17last thing you buy in his life. We're going to keep them
- 1:26:20together. We're not going to in the
- 1:26:21installments. You've got the burglary and
- 1:26:27that's that. But the other case is set for an
- 1:26:38announcement. And if the pageant is the family
- 1:26:50of reference, so period, he needs to be there, you know,
- 1:26:54yeah, I'm in my staff to get him up here.
- 1:27:00I mean, that's just the way his police calls is actually
- 1:27:03changing. Pageant's office goes Thanks and
- 1:27:05tell him. You need him up here.
- 1:27:06On Mr. Elam's case and where are you?
- 1:27:09Going to do. With mine Judge, since Patrick
- 1:27:12hasn't been officially hired, I'm just going to represent him
- 1:27:15so on then when Mr. Patrick gets on the pace till I get off as of
- 1:27:19right now I'm. Going to put.
- 1:27:20Her all the so as far as mine all.
- 1:27:24Time. Today, this is our personal
- 1:27:25appearance together. I just want to.
- 1:27:29To finish. The I'll be ready to know, but
- 1:27:32I'm with him, so I'm not going to perform his birthday
- 1:27:35application and I have. The link from Missus.
- 1:27:38Gas, but she didn't provide me the Discover name access.
- 1:27:43I did get that. Problem.
- 1:27:44But like I said, when she emailed me, she was anticipating
- 1:27:47that Patrick would be here today as it's going.
- 1:27:52But yeah, I'm ready. To go to this.
- 1:27:53I'll be fishing and. What do we want to.
- 1:27:56What's your announcement today? Just to put it on one more one.
- 1:27:59Awesome. Because I think that'd be the
- 1:28:004th 1. You know that.
- 1:28:02Yeah. Well, what I can do is if you
- 1:28:04want me to just stay with him on a child packet, that's cool.
- 1:28:07I can do that. Because is that what we're going
- 1:28:09to do? No, I.
- 1:28:09Didn't want to. I didn't.
- 1:28:11Want to because I know Patrick is going to be if.
- 1:28:14I brought down with y'all. And decide I don't want to do I
- 1:28:16don't put it on another. That's what I want to ask.
- 1:28:19One-on-one everything. I don't want any 3.
- 1:28:20Judge, this case is relatively newer than the other case.
- 1:28:26This offense happened in December of last year.
- 1:28:29OK, so for what this one this one time, I mean we just we just
- 1:28:36don't, we just don't say well, no, we got several months or
- 1:28:41years so. Yeah, it's just.
- 1:28:43It's up and it's ready to move. We've got things to move
- 1:28:47forward. Yes, Judge, I understand.
- 1:28:50I just. Anticipated that, Mister.
- 1:28:52Patrick was going to be on the years.
- 1:28:53I mean it's. Just they don't say this.
- 1:28:56This is the fourth setting on on one of those and then on 1056 3.
- 1:29:18This is the fourth setting on that one as well.
- 1:29:21And that's a lot of resettings. We move forward.
- 1:29:23I mean, Fisher cut away, we make the decisions.
- 1:29:26It's yeah, everybody gets a year or two or five to figure it out.
- 1:29:35I'm not, you know, that's just not the way it is.
- 1:29:37So same trial time. Thank.
- 1:29:40You all. And it was tell Mister Padgett
- 1:29:43that they settle the trial doc. Y'all get ready.
- 1:29:47It's simple on this. Thank you, Joe.
- 1:29:50Yeah. So let's just settle that reset
- 1:30:01again. Yeah, I do. 2 / 5 you know what?
- 1:30:06Two over. Five The host, Barbara, is
- 1:30:09probably still on trial in Orange County.
- 1:30:12Is it reset or or This is Edwin is Lapaul.
- 1:30:17John Edwin. Paul Jones, is that you?
- 1:30:19Come on. Have you talked to your lawyer
- 1:30:24lately? I haven't.
- 1:30:25Talked. To him ever.
- 1:30:28Yeah, yeah, yeah. Don't hear me.
- 1:30:30Yeah, don't tell me that. This is This is.
- 1:30:34Recently. I'm talking to you recently.
- 1:30:36Yeah. OK, we're going to give you a
- 1:30:37resetting on this, OK? OK.
- 1:30:44Mr. Franklin, your defendant is here.
- 1:30:52Yes, Sir. What's his name again?
- 1:30:55What? No.
- 1:30:56What's his full name? I will let him tell.
- 1:30:58You. No, no, you.
- 1:30:59You're the lawyer. I'm going to Indian.
- 1:31:02Pakistani. Indian.
- 1:31:04Indian. Oh, yeah.
- 1:31:05I like. Thank you.
- 1:31:09Thank you. Let's see.
- 1:31:15Yeah, Let's see when I you know how many letters Lakshmana the
- 1:31:27last name is. And.
- 1:31:29Many letters I haven't counted Judge 16 you're right.
- 1:31:34That's exactly right 16 let's see it's beautiful language and
- 1:31:40long letters and really pretty language anyway, what are we
- 1:31:46going to do on this John we this was a joint investigation
- 1:31:50departments. I didn't have anything to do
- 1:31:52with that and we're just we discussed.
- 1:31:55Before and again. Some outstanding discovery
- 1:31:59issues and the state I. Believe was going.
- 1:32:01To reach out to Baytown, double check on some discovery that
- 1:32:07probably exists. And so we're trying to resolve
- 1:32:09that discovery issue that things are happening in in Baytown or.
- 1:32:15Baytown was involved in this investigation.
- 1:32:17Was that Harris County I? Think so, yeah.
- 1:32:20It was here. It was here in Jefferson.
- 1:32:22The often occurred. In it.
- 1:32:25They were cooperating with the Department of Public Safety
- 1:32:27Safety on this investigation. OK, would.
- 1:32:31Does he have cases in Baytown? No.
- 1:32:35So what do we care about? I.
- 1:32:38Mean this is his case. Material, There is a material
- 1:32:40witness who is a detective in Baytown, OK and part of the
- 1:32:46investigation, yes. Yes, So what?
- 1:32:49About it. We just need to contact the
- 1:32:51agency and. Make sure that they have.
- 1:32:52Given us everything on their end.
- 1:32:56Good. It's been over four months since
- 1:32:59the same as indicted. It's what we're going to do
- 1:33:03about getting them, contacting them do you're going to do them.
- 1:33:06Yes. Immediately.
- 1:33:08OK. Yes. 5.
- 1:33:15Weeks. I've done time.
- 1:33:18You have time for me. Four weeks.
- 1:33:25Yeah. Fours.
- 1:33:27Understood. Your assistant.
- 1:33:34Thank you, Pedro Lira. You're asking for a release from
- 1:33:52firstly one of our successful ways to move.
- 1:34:05OK. The defendant was on a ended up
- 1:34:10disposing in this case about a year ago for a Class B
- 1:34:14misdemeanor. He was originally prosecuted.
- 1:34:17With an. Indictment of a third degree
- 1:34:19felony and it was reduced to a Class B was demeanor and he's
- 1:34:25put some two years deferred on adjudicated probation scripture
- 1:34:28and that was as of May 14th of last year.
- 1:34:34I see there's a motion for early termination.
- 1:34:36That's why you there, Paul. Much longer.
- 1:35:07Than that the probation on that that's what I think got this.
- 1:35:22It's I asked probation because I received something back in March
- 1:35:27that was all very good for his response to probation.
- 1:35:37It's what have you learned? Don't ever make mistakes again.
- 1:35:43Well, you're going to make mistakes.
- 1:35:45We all do. But there's you know, but it's
- 1:35:47how you deal with your mistakes that's the test is for
- 1:35:50character, how you respond to them and and how you avoid
- 1:35:56committing the same mistake twice.
- 1:35:59So repeating what what state say on this about probation on an
- 1:36:04objection, John? No.
- 1:36:06Thanks, Jeff. Lead us in the e-file, Sir.
- 1:36:09I believe an order's been transmitted via e-file.
- 1:36:13Some. Probably been yes, I'm.
- 1:36:17Doing that one, let's see if we haven't left.
- 1:36:27Here, this is. Here, this is one that we'll
- 1:36:29see. That's what I am.
- 1:36:31That's the one. That's the.
- 1:36:32One OK second. 102829 Thirtieth I look at I
- 1:36:55don't know, I was swift so 29 champagne and ribs last night
- 1:37:03and I don't know what day it is. Yeah.
- 1:37:07So I hope you've done a million people.
- 1:37:09Here thinking in the city say well lady puts on does great
- 1:37:22things and it's coming up folks support her Regina Rogers very
- 1:37:30sweet lady and great asset to this community Anderson OK so on
- 1:37:38this day cases dismissed do well and send no more OK thank judge
- 1:37:50Houston safe appreciate it OK Calixon Benoit Benoit where are
- 1:38:00you Your lawyer is not here yet right.
- 1:38:03He's outside he's where is he he's staying right now outside.
- 1:38:08Oh is he shy. He's just a few minutes Girks
- 1:38:17has never been shy before. I don't know why he just had a
- 1:38:21character change all of a sudden that.
- 1:38:23Thank you again. That's OK.
- 1:38:26We'll get back to you when he gets back in Felton Carrier.
- 1:38:31Yes, Sir. Please Judge.
- 1:38:34OK. Come on.
- 1:38:36Now. What's this von Dutch?
- 1:38:43Or are you Dutch? That's what.
- 1:38:47What's the clothing line? I've never heard of overpriced
- 1:38:51apparel. Well, I know what you You're in
- 1:38:55line in the Salvation Army. I get my stuff out.
- 1:38:58Of the. Time.
- 1:39:04No, I don't. That's why I'm laughing.
- 1:39:08Where? Where do you?
- 1:39:09Where do you buy that from? Can you buy it?
- 1:39:13Devon, Dutch. Devon, Dutch.
- 1:39:16Well, online. It's an online because I don't
- 1:39:19understand. Yeah.
- 1:39:23My wife is kind of a fashion if they'll never be prepared to
- 1:39:34sing 24 CR 6 two is called the state of Texas versus Felton
- 1:39:39fault carrier. You were here with Mr. Kendler,
- 1:39:41your attorney and the state's attorney.
- 1:39:42Does the defendant wave a formal reading of this indictment and
- 1:39:45arraignment. Can we proceed in summary so
- 1:39:47where are you in summary this indictment alleges that on or
- 1:39:51about July 24th 2022. Five.
- 1:39:54Let's sing this old. It was subsequently to this
- 1:39:58offense subsequently placed on probations on probation now.
- 1:40:02So this is going to be drink exactly for probation.
- 1:40:05It took a long time to. Probably the lab.
- 1:40:08Your own experience on it they have.
- 1:40:09To check for delta 9 PHC. And it alleges that in Jefferson
- 1:40:14County, Texas, you've committed the state jail felony, the legal
- 1:40:18possession of marijuana of more than 4 oz.
- 1:40:23Do you understand what you're charged with?
- 1:40:25Yes, Sir. If convicted, you face
- 1:40:26confinement in a state jail for any term of not less than 180
- 1:40:29days or more than two years. In addition, a fine may be
- 1:40:32assessed not to exceed $10,000. You understand?
- 1:40:36Yes, Sir. If it's been reached in your
- 1:40:38case that you would be pleading guilty and so please sentenced
- 1:40:43to two years in state jail, then that would be suspended.
- 1:40:47You were placed on regular probation for five.
- 1:40:51You want me to circle years? It's five years, OK.
- 1:40:54No, I can do this. I can do it.
- 1:40:56Five years. There is no fine here.
- 1:40:59Is this your understanding of the agreement?
- 1:41:02There will be terms and conditions of probation which
- 1:41:04are normal and customary for this type of office if I follow
- 1:41:08this agreement. So you have no right of appeal
- 1:41:11of your case. Do you understand?
- 1:41:13How do you plead to this indictment?
- 1:41:15Guilty or not guilty? Yes.
- 1:41:17Are you pleading guilty of voluntarily?
- 1:41:20That is on your own free will. And because you are guilty.
- 1:41:30Nobody's forcing me to do this. I'll show you what's Mark the
- 1:41:34State did it. Did you sign?
- 1:41:36That document voluntarily Understand it, Discuss it with
- 1:41:39your attorney. Are the contents true and
- 1:41:40correct? State's exhibit without
- 1:41:44objection, just thank you, Sir. This states that you are
- 1:41:49mentally confident to enter your guilty plea.
- 1:41:51It's freely, involuntarily. Nate, you know what you've been
- 1:41:53charged with the indictments been directed to you.
- 1:41:55You've read it. You were guilty of the kind of
- 1:41:57challenge and that you've less included offenses.
- 1:41:59Mr. Gerges, would you please call Holden Neft?
- 1:42:02I'll call that a judge. It was actually a baby that was
- 1:42:10but Ryan is right in the line of so I just this plea.
- 1:42:21This voluntarily and freely made you understand what you're
- 1:42:26charged with. You were guilty of the crime
- 1:42:28charged and in any lesser including offenses you are
- 1:42:30giving up your rights to a jury trial and the rights to the
- 1:42:32appearance confrontation cross examination of witnesses totally
- 1:42:35satisfied with the representation provided by your
- 1:42:38lawyer. All of this says is true so
- 1:42:40healthy though states exhibit one part of the record for all
- 1:42:43purposes. Presenters report is here by
- 1:42:45Wayne slower. I will follow this agreement.
- 1:42:49I'm going to find, Sir, you are mentally competent into your
- 1:42:52guilty key. It is freely voluntarily made.
- 1:42:54There is sufficient evidence to pull your guilty plea to find
- 1:42:57you guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
- 1:42:58I now find you guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of the state
- 1:43:02jail felony of illegal possession of marijuana.
- 1:43:06Going to amount. More than 4 oz but less than 5
- 1:43:08sounds that's a state jail felony.
- 1:43:10I'm following this agreement. You're hereby sentenced to some
- 1:43:13time to stay jail for two years that can find it is suspended
- 1:43:18based on regular probation for five years.
- 1:43:20You do well, it will be shortened.
- 1:43:23Well, that's the rule for that one too.
- 1:43:33What was it? There will be terms and
- 1:43:37conditions of probation here which are normal and customary
- 1:43:42for this type of offense. Make sure you follow them to be
- 1:43:50failed. Your probation could be revoked
- 1:43:53and you could be sentenced up to two years in the state jail.
- 1:43:57And that's state jail time is almost day for day.
- 1:44:06We'll get a lot of going below under that program.
- 1:44:13All right, pickling all this mess.
- 1:44:16Yes, Sir, good for. You, it's not just probation,
- 1:44:23it's just you have a lot of working and stuff, OK.
- 1:44:25You have a family. Yes, Sir.
- 1:44:26OK. We have children too.
- 1:44:29Children. You have children?
- 1:44:31Yes, Sir. You're the role model.
- 1:44:34So you got to act responsible because the children, they'll do
- 1:44:38just what you do. If you make mistakes, they're
- 1:44:42going to say, well, Dad did it, I'll do it.
- 1:44:44And I I. Think I can?
- 1:44:45Tell you better than that. If you're not, see, you
- 1:44:48shouldn't be here. You have a better character.
- 1:44:52Fix it and move on. Yes, OK.
- 1:44:54Yes, alright, no, there's. I'll say this friends, we've got
- 1:45:00quite the chat going this morning with all the bacon talk
- 1:45:04now. So if I'm hearing you right, it
- 1:45:06sounds like you want me to do some kind of a TCF cooking
- 1:45:13offshoot channel, but have it centered around bacon.
- 1:45:20It's very nichy. It might actually work in
- 1:45:22today's YouTube. I'll have to consider it.
- 1:45:25Let's go back up to Michigan. We'll spend a few minutes with
- 1:45:30few minutes. Let's try that again.
- 1:45:33Let's go back up to Michigan. We'll spend a few minutes with
- 1:45:37Jacquelina. Others.
- 1:45:51Need to choose the language. Where?
- 1:45:57We. Need to learn this is.
- 1:46:24This is done at 23934 FC people in the state of Michigan versus
- 1:46:31Jacob Montalvo. Council.
- 1:46:34Your appearance for the record. Thank you, Sarah.
- 1:46:35Hold on. We have the people.
- 1:46:37Good afternoon. Morning, Your honor.
- 1:46:38Assistant Public Defender Steven Flaglestone on behalf of Jacobo
- 1:46:43Montalvo, standing to my right. Thank you, Sir.
- 1:46:45Jacob by Jacobo or Jacob, I have a note.
- 1:46:48Jacob. Jacob, Your honor.
- 1:46:49That's what I have, OK. Thank you.
- 1:46:50Thank you. Now is that your loveling,
- 1:46:52Jacob, that. Is wrong or?
- 1:46:54It's it's in Spanish and in Spanish the O is it's hagolo and
- 1:46:58and it's pronounced in English and O aside.
- 1:47:02OK, OK, so we have the spelling right, just.
- 1:47:05Yeah, it's it's spelled in Spanish, but it's pronounced
- 1:47:08with the O assignment. And that's what my notes said.
- 1:47:12But thank you for clearing that up.
- 1:47:14All right, please raise your right hand.
- 1:47:16Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to
- 1:47:19provide to be the truthful truth and nothing but the truth under
- 1:47:22penalty of perjury? Yes, ma'am.
- 1:47:24Your Honor, thank. You put your hand down, you have
- 1:47:26a nice deep voice, you don't have to keep leaning forward.
- 1:47:28We got the microphone there, so we're good.
- 1:47:30Have you taken any medication yesterday or today?
- 1:47:33Nope. Well, for heartburn and for
- 1:47:36diabetic. OK.
- 1:47:37So is it anything that would interfere in your ability to
- 1:47:39understand the court or your attorney?
- 1:47:42No, you're not. And Sir, is there a medication
- 1:47:45that you're supposed to be on that you are not on?
- 1:47:48No, you're on. And any sign of fever, COVID or
- 1:47:53other illness? No.
- 1:47:54You've had an opportunity to speak with your attorney and you
- 1:47:57understand this is a final criminal pretrial, meaning you
- 1:48:01have to make a decision as to whether you want to accept any
- 1:48:05plea offer. If there was one, I, I don't
- 1:48:07know if there was one. And if not, we simply set this
- 1:48:12for trial. I don't allow, as a general
- 1:48:16rule, once in a while there's exceptions for odd reasons, but
- 1:48:20I don't allow on the day of trial because then somebody else
- 1:48:26is denying that day and week for trial.
- 1:48:28So I'd like to keep those dates. So do you understand this is the
- 1:48:32deadline? I understand, and I believe
- 1:48:34we're ready, Your Honor. OK, so you've had enough time to
- 1:48:37speak with both of your attorneys?
- 1:48:40Yes. Ma'am, OK, very good.
- 1:48:41On behalf of the people, was there an offer?
- 1:48:43There's no offer. Your Honor, thank you.
- 1:48:45All right. Are we ready then to go to
- 1:48:47trial? There'll be no plea.
- 1:48:49That's correct. Yes.
- 1:48:50Your Honor. Thank you.
- 1:48:52And Sir, that's correct. You want to go to trial.
- 1:48:55Yes, yes, you. Are all right, and did anyone
- 1:49:00force, threaten, or coerce you to make this?
- 1:49:02Decision no your. Honor, did anyone promise you
- 1:49:04anything request you make this? Decision.
- 1:49:07And you are working with both of your attorneys toward trial and
- 1:49:11you're satisfied with their representation I.
- 1:49:14Believe so. OK.
- 1:49:16And we have a trial date. Yes, your honor, it's May 29th.
- 1:49:24And do we know will this be a one week or two week?
- 1:49:26I would expect that it would go into two weeks.
- 1:49:29OK. Thank you.
- 1:49:32Council agrees with that. Yes, Sir, Yeah.
- 1:49:34Sure. Is there anything that you are
- 1:49:36still awaiting that you need for trial?
- 1:49:38Are there any motions? We have not.
- 1:49:40I know spouse rather than I know we've had motions and other
- 1:49:43things in the past. Is there anything we need to
- 1:49:45address prior to trial so we are ready to?
- 1:49:47Go. Since I believe there are no
- 1:49:49additional motions and I believe we have all the discovery
- 1:49:51necessary to proceed the trial on the Twitter, I'm not.
- 1:49:54Ready to proceed? Thank you and you will all work
- 1:49:57together then for jury instructions.
- 1:50:00Of course, Your Honor. And then make the court aware of
- 1:50:03whether or not you want the jury to ask questions.
- 1:50:07And then we'll deal with sequestration motions and other
- 1:50:09issues at that time. All right.
- 1:50:12Is there anything else we need to?
- 1:50:14Address. No, thank you.
- 1:50:19Do you have family members who can bring you civilian clothes?
- 1:50:23You can't be in trial in those. OK.
- 1:50:25The prosecutor does have access to clothes.
- 1:50:27So, public defender. I'm.
- 1:50:30Sorry, the public defender has access to clothes, so we're
- 1:50:32going to. You'll need to work with them
- 1:50:34and get some updates for every day of trial.
- 1:50:37We've worked with him and we have his clothing size.
- 1:50:40We'll make sure he has whether we have a whole closet of the
- 1:50:43board. OK.
- 1:50:45I I appreciate it. You're good with that?
- 1:50:47OK. Anything else we need to?
- 1:50:49Address. No, Judge, I think we're
- 1:50:50satisfied that it's been laid on the.
- 1:50:51Record. I will see you May 29th for
- 1:50:53trial. Thank you.
- 1:50:54Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:50:55You're on. So Tim, thank you for the gifted
- 1:50:59membership and an immediate hit and a win there.
- 1:51:03Punky 83 a new new friend to us this morning gets the membership
- 1:51:08so that's cool Punky you get a whole bunch of things so go to
- 1:51:11the membership page. One of them you get is the pre
- 1:51:13show. The pre show is on hiatus this
- 1:51:15week and next week, but after that it'll be back and that
- 1:51:19starts 1/2 an hour before this show and we have a lot of fun
- 1:51:21there so check that out. Let's looks like new contestant.
- 1:51:27Maybe let's just continue here for a minute.
- 1:51:29It's. At 9:00.
- 1:51:52This is docket 253909 FH People say Michigan versus Theodore
- 1:51:58David Krupp, Council, your appearance for the record.
- 1:52:00Good morning, your honor. EP we're boxing on.
- 1:52:02We have people say Michigan. Good morning, Your honor.
- 1:52:04Alexander Rusk, on behalf of Mr. Crook, who's standing to my
- 1:52:07right, thank. You, Sir, please raise your
- 1:52:09right hand. Do you swear or affirm the
- 1:52:11testimony? You're about to provide me the
- 1:52:13truth, full truth and nothing but the truth under penalty of
- 1:52:15perjury. Thank you.
- 1:52:17And put your hand down, Sir. Have you taken any medication
- 1:52:21using the alcohol, marijuana, over the counter prescription
- 1:52:23meds yesterday or today? Is there anything you.
- 1:52:27I'm sorry. No, you're not.
- 1:52:28Is there anything you're supposed to be on that you're
- 1:52:30not on? No.
- 1:52:30You're any sign of fever code or other illness?
- 1:52:33No. You're not.
- 1:52:35And you had no time to talk with your attorney?
- 1:52:38I have. And I understand there's going
- 1:52:40to be a plea today. So you're waiving your right to
- 1:52:42a jury trial, correct? And Sir, do I have the address?
- 1:52:46Correct. I have you in chest.
- 1:52:48Name on Pearl. Is that correct?
- 1:52:50Correct. And who do you live with?
- 1:52:53Myself. And are you employed?
- 1:52:56Are you retired? No, you're not.
- 1:52:59How do you support? Yourself.
- 1:53:01Say it. OK.
- 1:53:02And you're able to do that. Yes, your Honor.
- 1:53:06OK. At the time of the offense
- 1:53:12you're pleading to, were you on probation, parole, or binding
- 1:53:14conditions on another file? No, Your Honor.
- 1:53:21Are you AUS citizen? Yes, you are.
- 1:53:24And you have no time to talk to your attorney about all matters.
- 1:53:26Yes. What is the plea agreement?
- 1:53:29Yes, your honor, the defendant be pleading to an added count 2
- 1:53:33of operating while intoxicated second offense notice which is a
- 1:53:36one year misdemeanor POD successful plea and sentencing
- 1:53:40Count 1 OWI third will be dismissed.
- 1:53:43There was also an agreement between the parties for the
- 1:53:45defendant to serve at least 24 months of probation with no
- 1:53:49earned early release. 24 months probation.
- 1:53:57So without it being cut in half you mean?
- 1:54:00So OK, so just just kind of an odd way to say it because it'd
- 1:54:05be discharged now. No, no, no problem.
- 1:54:08Just want to make sure I've got it clear that it's it's
- 1:54:11probation. Not yet OK.
- 1:54:16Is there any conversation for Sprite porn?
- 1:54:20Yes, Your Honor, I can address that.
- 1:54:23As Mr. Croft lives in Chesney. We've had some serious issues
- 1:54:27for sobriety court. So he was approved for 55th
- 1:54:31qualified, but the travel about an hour and a half, multiple
- 1:54:35times a week potentially. They ruled him that that just
- 1:54:38wouldn't be workable. Does Chesney have a sobriety
- 1:54:41court that he could have bailed himself out that we could work
- 1:54:43with or no? No Saginaw has a sobriety court
- 1:54:47and a mental health court. They have been.
- 1:54:49Full or not accepting transfers. Saying it's true in Shylawassee
- 1:54:52County as well. That's fine.
- 1:54:54Fine. We definitely wanted to get into
- 1:54:55one of those programs. That's how we reached our
- 1:54:58resolution here. And your Honor, that's why we
- 1:55:00did the 24 months probation. OK, so let me just say in the
- 1:55:06future when? We have this kind of deal.
- 1:55:11I want him to have the plea in District Court, in 55th District
- 1:55:15Court can be or whatever District Court and be monitored
- 1:55:19by the District Court probation, which is much more hands on, has
- 1:55:23the resources and also can refer to some of the resources that
- 1:55:27spread court has. I don't want to waste anybody's
- 1:55:30time. So we're going to do it this
- 1:55:32way, but in the future, that's the way to go.
- 1:55:36Not this way. Thank you I.
- 1:55:38Understand, your Honor. Council, is that full, fair,
- 1:55:46accurate and complete? It is, your Honor.
- 1:55:48Full, fair, accurate and complete, Sir?
- 1:55:50Yes, Your Honor. All right, Thank you.
- 1:55:52And Council, you're waving count 1.
- 1:55:56Correct. S to count 2.
- 1:55:58Yes, Your Honor, people in the State of Michigan versus
- 1:56:00Theodore David Krupp, State of Michigan, County of Ingham.
- 1:56:03In the name of the people in the State of Michigan, the
- 1:56:06prosecuting Attorney for this county appears before the court
- 1:56:10and informs the court that on the date at the location
- 1:56:12described below, the defendant and added count to operate While
- 1:56:17Intoxicated. Second Offense notice did
- 1:56:20operate on or about March 1st, 2025 at East Holt Road and
- 1:56:26Zimmer Rd. Williamson, Michigan 48895,
- 1:56:30Ingham County, State of Michigan.
- 1:56:33The defendant did operate a vehicle in, at or near the 1400
- 1:56:38block of East Holt Rd. a place open to the general public or
- 1:56:42generally accessible to motor vehicles, while having alcohol
- 1:56:45content of 0.8g or more per 100 milliliters of blood.
- 1:56:50Contrary to statute restitution, this offense may result in
- 1:56:56damage to another individual's property or physical injury or
- 1:56:58death to another individual. Second offense Notice.
- 1:57:03Take notice that the defendant was previously convicted of
- 1:57:07operating impaired on or about May 17th, 2007, at the 66th
- 1:57:14District Court and operating impaired on or about February
- 1:57:1924th, 2023, in the 70th District Court.
- 1:57:24Therefore, upon conviction, the defendant will be subject to the
- 1:57:28enhanced sentence under MCL 257.6259 or MCL 257.62511.
- 1:57:36In vehicle forfeiture under MCL 257.625 N, this is a misdemeanor
- 1:57:45that's punished by up to a maximum of 200 to $1000 and five
- 1:57:50days to one year in jail or 30 to 90 days community service or
- 1:57:55both. Rehabilitative programs per
- 1:57:58statute. Toss the prosecution.
- 1:58:00Reimburse government for emergency response and expenses
- 1:58:03for prosecuting defendant. See statute.
- 1:58:06Vehicle immobilization mandatory.
- 1:58:08See statute. Unless the vehicle is ordered
- 1:58:12forfeited under MCL 257.625, NA term imprisonment imposed must
- 1:58:18not, must not be suspended unless the defendant agrees to
- 1:58:22participate in a speciality court program and successfully
- 1:58:24completes the program and against the peace identity of
- 1:58:29the state of Michigan. Did this one.
- 1:58:31Is this one with the 60 day card suspension or no?
- 1:58:37Does it stay in there? It does not, Your Honor, but
- 1:58:40because this would be two within seven years, it would be the the
- 1:58:44automatic revocation. OK.
- 1:58:47Thank you, Sir. Do you understand what it's just
- 1:58:51read? I do.
- 1:58:53So you understand that this is but operating well.
- 1:58:58Tax is second is a one year misdemeanor and for 201,000.
- 1:59:041000. License cost.
- 1:59:05I don't know if there's any requests for cost recovery for
- 1:59:10any ambulance or police, etcetera.
- 1:59:13We'll give you that at the end. And there's five days jail up to
- 1:59:20the one year and then 30 to 9 days of community service and
- 1:59:24vehicle for mature mobilization. So you understand about them.
- 1:59:28Thank you. What's the status of your
- 1:59:30vehicle? You were driving on that, yeah.
- 1:59:37What is it? Do you still have it?
- 1:59:39Is it been immobilized? I guess you could say that I
- 1:59:42still own it. There's been a problem with the
- 1:59:45mechanics out of the engine, and it's.
- 1:59:47So it's immobilized by virtue of none not being able to be used.
- 1:59:52That's correct. OK.
- 1:59:59And Sir, it looks like you signed the Advice and rights
- 2:00:01form. Did you read it before you
- 2:00:03signed it? Yes.
- 2:00:04Did you understand what you read?
- 2:00:06Yes, I did. And if you had any questions,
- 2:00:09you're trying to be able to answer those.
- 2:00:11He was. Yeah, it looks like you signed
- 2:00:14the Advice and Rights form. Did you read or you signed it?
- 2:00:16I did. Did you understand what you
- 2:00:18read? I did.
- 2:00:20And again, your attorney was able to answer any questions you
- 2:00:22might have had. He was.
- 2:00:24Do you have any questions about your rights of this court?
- 2:00:27I did not. And you also understand that
- 2:00:31you're giving up your automatic right of appeal if you choose to
- 2:00:33appeal as permission of the Court of Appeals to appeal.
- 2:00:37And it becomes their choice. They think your issues are
- 2:00:39important whether or not they take out their case.
- 2:00:41You understand that, Sir, as to count to operating while
- 2:00:48intoxicated, second defense, heavy plea.
- 2:00:56And Sir, has anyone told you what I will do at the time
- 2:01:03sentencing other than the statute?
- 2:01:06And. That's because I don't know.
- 2:01:09I will make up my mind at the time sentencing.
- 2:01:10Do you understand that? I.
- 2:01:13Do all right. And Sir, at this time I'm going
- 2:01:21to ask you some questions and Council may jump in and ask some
- 2:01:24questions as well. As to count 2, did this defense
- 2:01:38occur on or about March 1st, 2025 in the Township of
- 2:01:44Wheatfield County, Maine, State of Michigan?
- 2:01:47You came in contact with law enforcement at a specific
- 2:01:50location known as E Fold Road and Zimmer Road.
- 2:01:55And did they stop you because of your driving?
- 2:01:59And it's fair to say that prior to getting into that vehicle,
- 2:02:04you consumed alcohol, Yes. Do you remember what you
- 2:02:07consumed? Roughly 7.
- 2:02:09Drinks like hard liquor, Beer what?
- 2:02:13One hard liquor and rest beer. OK.
- 2:02:16And what was the time period that you drank that over?
- 2:02:20Do you remember? I do not recall.
- 2:02:22OK. And it's fair to say you would
- 2:02:24have driven better without the alcohol.
- 2:02:26Yes. And the officers pulled you
- 2:02:29over. You pulled over and then did
- 2:02:30they give you a breathalyzer? Yes.
- 2:02:35You recall the reading event? .17 I believe.
- 2:02:41And did you also do the field sobriety test?
- 2:02:48Did they have you do the walk and turn and then they took you
- 2:02:54into custody determining that you were intoxicated?
- 2:02:59And you're not disputing the .17, is that correct, Council?
- 2:03:04Correct. And you would be, Sir.
- 2:03:06That is over twice the legal limit.
- 2:03:11Yes, Governor. And you have operated your
- 2:03:17loaded vehicle while intoxicated on roads that were open to the
- 2:03:22general public. Yes, Governor.
- 2:03:29And did you end up having an accident or getting someone or
- 2:03:35something? No, Your Honor.
- 2:03:37All right. Thank you.
- 2:03:43And we have good people. I'll ask to this I'll ask about
- 2:03:47the prior offense, but as to this, any anything for?
- 2:03:50And without the prior offense, I believe we're satisfied, John.
- 2:03:53Council. I agree, all right.
- 2:03:55And Sir, you previously were convicted of Aubrey Long paired
- 2:03:58on or about May 17th, 2007 and 66 District.
- 2:04:03Court. Yeah.
- 2:04:05Sure. All right.
- 2:04:05And for purposes of it, the seven years, there's also one in
- 2:04:09February 24th, 2023, in the 70th.
- 2:04:13District Court. Correct.
- 2:04:15All right. Any additional questions that we
- 2:04:19have for the people? People are satisfied in regard
- 2:04:21to the notice, Your Honor. No, Your Honor.
- 2:04:23Thank you. Any understanding this is a
- 2:04:24second defense, a first offense is a 93 day, but we have that
- 2:04:28enhancement to the one day because your prior offense, you
- 2:04:30understand that, yes, All right, Our council aware of promises,
- 2:04:35threats or inducions other than those already placed on the
- 2:04:38record. No, Your Honor.
- 2:04:39No, Your Honor. As for comply with portable.
- 2:04:41You have your honor. It has your honor.
- 2:04:42I. Find Venice please been free
- 2:04:44voluntarily no lien understanding we made without
- 2:04:47undue of close threats, coercion, promises and lean.
- 2:04:50You can also find there's grounds to accept and this week.
- 2:04:53Therefore, Count 2 will enter. Count 1 in its entirety is
- 2:04:57hereby dismissed. Any outstanding warrants, if
- 2:05:01any, are hereby or called and dismissed.
- 2:05:04The vehicle will be immobilized within the next 7 days and
- 2:05:09you'll show approve of that. You can talk to your attorney
- 2:05:12about how to do that. It can stay in your garage if
- 2:05:14it's truly immobilized and not fixable, or you can have it
- 2:05:19carried off somewhere, but we need it to be immobilized for
- 2:05:21the statutory. Period.
- 2:05:24And. During the sentencing date,
- 2:05:33June. 23rd at 9:30. Does that be with your schedule?
- 2:05:41It does, Your Honor. We're also prepared to go into
- 2:05:43median sentencing at the court's minimum.
- 2:05:47Sure, there's no, there's no damage, so there's no reason.
- 2:05:52For that he he was out in the middle of field, Your Honor.
- 2:05:54So I would agree with that. There's no, there's no
- 2:05:57restitution in regards to that. I do believe there is
- 2:06:01restitution that yes, correct, your honor, for the request for
- 2:06:07restitution from the Sheriff's Department.
- 2:06:11I have a total of. Is that Ingham County or that?
- 2:06:15Would be Ingham or it would be, yes.
- 2:06:18Ingham County Sheriff's Office Your Honor, I have a lodging
- 2:06:24cost of $25. I have.
- 2:06:45I apologize, I did not write. This very clearly.
- 2:06:49Average monthly vehicle cost is $1834.30.
- 2:06:55What did, I'm sorry, 1034 dollars?
- 2:06:57834. Dollars $834. $0.30.
- 2:07:02For for vehicle. For yes, for the for the
- 2:07:05vehicle. For the vehicle, including
- 2:07:07maintenance, gas, insurance for the vehicles that were used by
- 2:07:11officers. Average monthly mileage for the
- 2:07:14vehicles. Your Honor, I think I would need
- 2:07:22a chance review if we're talking about $2000 in cost recovery.
- 2:07:27And I I would have no issue with.
- 2:07:30Yeah, it's usually not that high and there was no accidents.
- 2:07:32So I really just don't know. So what we're going to do is
- 2:07:34have a cost recovery. We'll keep it open.
- 2:07:39If you all agree that's fine. And if not, I will leave the
- 2:07:42determination at a hearing. So we do it that way.
- 2:07:47Yes, Sharon. OK, great.
- 2:07:49All right, I'm gonna have the people.
- 2:07:50What would you like me to know? Yes, Your Honor, as you are
- 2:07:55aware we typically don't do these types of agreements for an
- 2:07:59OWI. Third, I had did have a chance
- 2:08:02to run this by the elected. So there is an approval on this
- 2:08:06type of agreement. But with that being said, that
- 2:08:10was with 24 months of probation. Mr. Krubb obviously has a
- 2:08:16drinking problem with his 2000 and with with two prior OW IS1
- 2:08:22being in 2023. And your honor, as you had heard
- 2:08:27the PBT was .17. However, when they did the blood
- 2:08:31alcohol content, it did come back, Your Honor, at a .215.
- 2:08:38So I believe Mr. Krug has a very serious drinking issue that
- 2:08:41needs to be addressed immediately, Your Honor.
- 2:08:44So I would ask that you follow the agreement of the 24 months
- 2:08:48of probation with whatever mandatory requirements under the
- 2:08:55statute, else you need to give him thank you.
- 2:08:57Thank. You.
- 2:08:59Thank you, Your Honor. I think that Mister Buxton
- 2:09:02covered some of our concerns there.
- 2:09:05His background, though, about Mr. Krupp, he is born, raised in
- 2:09:09Michigan, originally from Owosso.
- 2:09:11He's divorced, but he still has interactions with his children.
- 2:09:14Of course, he's a graduate from New Lamproff High School, and he
- 2:09:17also has his associate's degree from Baker College.
- 2:09:21As the. Court can see this case has been
- 2:09:24pending for a little bit of time here.
- 2:09:27Mr. Krupp from basically the first time that we talked, I
- 2:09:31believe that would have been back in March 2025.
- 2:09:35He has been willing to engage in any specialty court court
- 2:09:38program and he's been assessed for multiple of those programs.
- 2:09:43We've been able to address both sobriety as well as mental
- 2:09:47health. Issues in the.
- 2:09:48Interim, fortunately, without those mental health courts not
- 2:09:52being available. But Mr. Krupp has made
- 2:09:54significant strides from where he was a year ago.
- 2:09:57Your honor, he's not violated bond.
- 2:10:00He's not failed to appear. He's been in constant contact
- 2:10:03with myself and this is the first time that he has been
- 2:10:06charged with a felony. In addition, Mr. Kruff also has
- 2:10:10provable sobriety for the court here today.
- 2:10:13He's been on a SCRAM tether for about a year at this point and
- 2:10:17then no issues. I've not seen any alerts as far
- 2:10:19as even a battery dying and certainly no positive tests
- 2:10:23there as he's been complying with the rest of his pre release
- 2:10:27conditions. Your Honor, I ask that the court
- 2:10:29sentence him to the 24 months. Allow him to.
- 2:10:32Complete. The.
- 2:10:34Community service in place of any jail time.
- 2:10:37Mr. Krupp, he doesn't need an impact weekend or anything like
- 2:10:40that. Your Honor, he's had his life
- 2:10:42really turned upside down since this case and some other issues
- 2:10:47arose last year concerning mental health.
- 2:10:49Fortunately, he is in a much better spot.
- 2:10:52He's taken steps to address those issues and I don't think
- 2:10:56that he's going to be a person that you're going to see again
- 2:10:59during this probation period. I've got no indication that
- 2:11:02he'll do anything but be compliant.
- 2:11:05And as I mentioned, if we could have gotten to a sobriety court,
- 2:11:08that would have been just a great opportunity.
- 2:11:11As we know, in this case, he's not going to have his license
- 2:11:14back before petitioning Secretary of State.
- 2:11:17That can take quite a while. It's certainly not the phase
- 2:11:20one, Phase 2 of sobriety court where you can get that
- 2:11:22restricted license. So I do appreciate the people
- 2:11:26who've been able. To work with.
- 2:11:27Us this was unfortunately a situation where especially
- 2:11:32courts could be of a great assistance and just personally I
- 2:11:35think we need to keep expanding them but unfortunately that's
- 2:11:38where we are today. But Mr. Crooks taking
- 2:11:40responsibility, your honor, he's addressed his alcohol use
- 2:11:43issues. He also has been diagnosed as an
- 2:11:47early remission as far as that alcohol use disorder.
- 2:11:52He was assessed by Doctor Smith at Wallace Inks.
- 2:11:55That was provided to the people and it addresses, I think, the
- 2:11:59concerns of the people. Had.
- 2:12:01Which is, of course, alcohol use Going forward here, the court
- 2:12:04has sufficient resources to make sure that Mister Krupp complies.
- 2:12:08I don't think that you're going to have to use any of those
- 2:12:10additional resources. Your Honor.
- 2:12:13Again, no real concerns about Mr. Krupp being able to complete
- 2:12:16probation in this case, really get things back in line and, you
- 2:12:20know, get back to his life in a new, better form of himself at
- 2:12:23the end of the day. Thank you.
- 2:12:25Thank. You, Sir, what would you like me
- 2:12:27to know? Fairly accurate what Mr.
- 2:12:32Russell? Just.
- 2:12:33Just. Just told you.
- 2:12:35Went through some pretty traumatizing times in my.
- 2:12:38Life. And unfortunately just ended up
- 2:12:41here. You're not going to see me back.
- 2:12:44So are you in counseling currently?
- 2:12:47Where are you? What did you, what did you do to
- 2:12:49get what have you done in the last year and in terms of
- 2:12:54addressing the substance abuse and the underlying factors?
- 2:12:59I've been. Through.
- 2:12:59Multiple a, a classes and meetings and.
- 2:13:03Are. You still going?
- 2:13:05Currently I'm not because of the license issue, if there's
- 2:13:09something online or something. That I could get involved in.
- 2:13:12I'm not opposed to that. Not being able to drive shit a
- 2:13:15lot of. Time and mental health because
- 2:13:18of the situation of a divorce is much.
- 2:13:21More. In line with what the general
- 2:13:23public would expect and. So are you currently in therapy
- 2:13:30with someone in regard to those that trauma of the divorce and
- 2:13:35whatever related issues? Currently I have not.
- 2:13:38Did you completed? You completed it?
- 2:13:40Yeah. Did you have a substance abuse
- 2:13:45assessment? Yes, you.
- 2:13:49Are and you followed the recommendations?
- 2:13:51Yes, you are. Mr. Krub also conclude the
- 2:13:54highway safety. Sewer as well You are Sir.
- 2:14:01It's never OK to drink that much.
- 2:14:04You certainly have a problem. It's also not an answer to drink
- 2:14:08away your problems. Asking for help is a sign of
- 2:14:11growth. It's a sign of strength.
- 2:14:14It's a good sign all the way around.
- 2:14:17Finding answers in the bottle gets you nowhere except in front
- 2:14:20of a judge or a body bag. So I hope you've learned that.
- 2:14:25Lesson. What else have you learned?
- 2:14:35Grief in Toronto. Around.
- 2:14:38Pretty hard to deal. With and should.
- 2:14:39Have reached out for help previous to trying to solve
- 2:14:42situations on my own. Can you do that now?
- 2:14:46I can, your honor. Do you have a support system in
- 2:14:49place? Yes, I have a.
- 2:14:53Pretty good sized family that's supporting me and yes I do have
- 2:14:57things in place. And how did you get here today?
- 2:15:01My brother. Sir, I'll put you in that 24
- 2:15:10months probation. You've been in a scram tether
- 2:15:14for what, a year? I'm going to remove that.
- 2:15:20How do you feel about that? That would be.
- 2:15:23Appreciated one because of the discomfort.
- 2:15:25Of it 2 because of the cost and three you.
- 2:15:29Won't. Have a problem with it?
- 2:15:31Well, Sir, you will have to submit any testing that
- 2:15:35probation wants. You'll not adulterate any test.
- 2:15:39If you are positive, then we will do a secondary test to see
- 2:15:44if it was a false positive or a positive positive.
- 2:15:46OK, You need to keep us surprised of all medications.
- 2:15:50And you know, sometimes there's alcohol and certain cough serves
- 2:15:55or other things to make sure doctors know that you have a
- 2:15:57problem with alcohol. If you end up having a
- 2:16:00prescription, you have 24 hours to tell us what you're taking so
- 2:16:04that if it shows up on the test, we know that it's awful.
- 2:16:07It's up to you to not eat or drink things with alcohol.
- 2:16:11So you go to someone's house, you don't know what's in the
- 2:16:13fruit crunch. You don't drink it or you find
- 2:16:16out, OK, you are not to be in the presence of any alcohol.
- 2:16:22You'll not be at any bar. You can go to restaurants like
- 2:16:28Red Lobster has a bar in it. You won't be sitting in that
- 2:16:31bar. You can sit in the restaurant.
- 2:16:32So where the primary business is alcohol, you cannot go.
- 2:16:36You can't go to a liquor store. Would you go to Meyer's and they
- 2:16:38sell alcohol? Yes, but you can't buy any.
- 2:16:40Does that make sense to you it? Does Your Honor?
- 2:16:48The cost for carvery is held in a vans pending agreement or
- 2:16:51hearing. You will pay a $50 state cost in
- 2:16:55a $75 crime victims. Those are not waivable.
- 2:17:00You can arrange a payment plan if needed.
- 2:17:02You are not working, so I'm going to waive probation
- 2:17:05oversight fees. You will not violate any
- 2:17:09criminal law, any unit of government in this state or any
- 2:17:12other. You'll not leave the state
- 2:17:13without permission of this court.
- 2:17:16You will make a truthful report to probation each contact.
- 2:17:19And because of the distance, this can be transferred to
- 2:17:24chestning or you can't simply meet with probation over Zoom,
- 2:17:29but you first have to meet with probation here.
- 2:17:32And then they would contact probation chest name.
- 2:17:36And then you could do it that way or they could meet with you.
- 2:17:40But testing doesn't know anything about you right now.
- 2:17:42So you first have to come here, then we work with them.
- 2:17:46Does that make sense? So, and I don't know if there's
- 2:17:48probation chest name or static or you just prefer to do it
- 2:17:51here, but you work all that out with probation.
- 2:17:54OK, OK. You'll not use, possess,
- 2:18:00purchase or be in the presence of any firearm, ammunition or on
- 2:18:03the dangerous weapon. Your vehicle, as we discussed,
- 2:18:06must be immobilized for the requisite period.
- 2:18:10I suspect you're already received and if you haven't,
- 2:18:13Secretary of State will be revoking or suspending your
- 2:18:15license for the requisite time period.
- 2:18:17Do you understand that as well? I.
- 2:18:19Do. You'll take the highway safety
- 2:18:21class and you've already done that, so I'm giving you credit
- 2:18:23for that. You were already submitted to
- 2:18:34counseling, so I'm only going to order counseling.
- 2:18:38If you end up with a positive, then you will be back in intense
- 2:18:43therapy, possibly residential AANARCA.
- 2:18:49You will go at least one time per week and you'll find a
- 2:18:52sponsor who you get along with and can call if you have the
- 2:18:57urge to drink or something's going on.
- 2:18:59And I want that sponsor to have worked a program and that's so
- 2:19:03we're through that program and have five years under their belt
- 2:19:07of sobriety. They'll have a sponsor within
- 2:19:09six months. Tell me about employment.
- 2:19:13Are you planning on retiring? You just didn't get employment
- 2:19:16because you drive a license or what it.
- 2:19:19Was due to. The license correct?
- 2:19:21Yeah. I was employed it.
- 2:19:22Just like. What's your line of business?
- 2:19:26I was in machining, manufacturing and yeah.
- 2:19:30That's a good job. You can't take an Uber and get
- 2:19:32rides from friends. Here's the thing, Sir, I don't
- 2:19:38know if you're near retirement or what.
- 2:19:39I don't know what your financials are.
- 2:19:42I don't need to know what I do know.
- 2:19:45I used to be the sobriety court judge and you have to go to
- 2:19:47District Court, and I've seen a lot of it since then.
- 2:19:49I'm like 22 years on the bench. And I do know, especially for
- 2:19:54men, especially for someone who's always had a job and the
- 2:19:58breadwinner, all those things that work is a good thing.
- 2:20:02Now I don't know if you have a hobby, if you go bowling every
- 2:20:04day or you go for long walks or what you do, but sitting around.
- 2:20:10Is not going to be good for your mental health.
- 2:20:14Now if you are retired and you want to play with grandkids or
- 2:20:17do whatever, that's fine. But if you're used to working
- 2:20:20and you need a purpose to get out of bed and not feel sorry
- 2:20:23for yourself and have a group of friends and all of those things
- 2:20:26that come with work, then you need to get back to work.
- 2:20:32So I leave that up to you and probation.
- 2:20:35But I'd like to see you figure out a way to go back to work.
- 2:20:38I bet there are friends who would pick you up to drive here
- 2:20:40or take an Uber. Certainly with the kind of job
- 2:20:44you had, you could afford Uber's or to pay a college kid or high
- 2:20:49school. To drive you to work.
- 2:20:51And pick you up. They'd probably love to do that.
- 2:20:54So you decide what you're going to do.
- 2:20:56But I want to know that you are filling your time being
- 2:21:00productive. Understood.
- 2:21:04I think that goes hand in hand with your mental health.
- 2:21:06I'm not a therapist. I'm not your therapist, but idle
- 2:21:10hands have a way of lizzing, depression, anxiety, other
- 2:21:15things, withdrawal and all of that leads to drugging, drinking
- 2:21:20and their bad habits. I.
- 2:21:24Want something that uplifts you? Maybe it's meditation and yoga.
- 2:21:29I really don't know. Because you worked it out with
- 2:21:31probation. I'd like to see a plan for your
- 2:21:34continued sobriety and healing. I think it should include work.
- 2:21:40You don't look old enough to retire to me.
- 2:21:42Maybe you've already earned your millions.
- 2:21:44I don't know. But work's a good thing no
- 2:21:47matter what your income is. So figure it out Sir, once
- 2:21:54you're employed or in whatever program or hobby or whatever it
- 2:21:58is you decide to fill your time with, you will steadily do that
- 2:22:02and need permission to change that road map.
- 2:22:07It'll work with probation or trained therapist to figure out
- 2:22:10where you go from here. Sounds like you don't really
- 2:22:15have a plan. Maybe you have some ideas, but
- 2:22:17let's get on a lifelong plan. You have a lot more life to live
- 2:22:20and let's make sure it's productive.
- 2:22:22Whatever you do is your choice. I want a plan and I want to get
- 2:22:28executed. We'll be watching you for two
- 2:22:31years. You will not abuse any
- 2:22:34prescription or non prescription medication.
- 2:22:37You'll not use any illegal substances or have any drug
- 2:22:40paraphernalia you have. In terms of prescriptions, we've
- 2:22:45talked about that. You will have 48 hours to show
- 2:22:48all prescriptions to probation. You will submit to pay for all
- 2:22:53testing and treatment. And as to community service
- 2:22:59work, Sir, is there something near your home or something
- 2:23:05you'd like to do? Nothing.
- 2:23:09Right on the top of my head, Your honor, I'm sure.
- 2:23:11I could come up. With something if that's what
- 2:23:13I've been tasked to do. Well, that's what the law says,
- 2:23:1630 to 60 hours. And so I'm going to give you the
- 2:23:1830 hours of community service, but I or day 30 days, however
- 2:23:23you work that out with probation.
- 2:23:25I'm sure there's a library or something that you could
- 2:23:28volunteer at or maybe working with kids or other people in
- 2:23:34substance abuse treatment. I don't know.
- 2:23:38You'll work it out with probation.
- 2:23:41How many days jail did you spend when you got arrested?
- 2:23:48I believe it was like shy 2. So 2 days.
- 2:23:52Yes, Your Honor, 2 calendar days.
- 2:23:54OK. So the statute is 25 days.
- 2:23:57Is that what this says under one year?
- 2:24:00It's five days to one year or 30 to 90 days of community service.
- 2:24:05So I'm going to give you 365 days jail credit for two days
- 2:24:12the balance is held. We do those 30 days or 30 hours
- 2:24:17community service if you decide not to do those for.
- 2:24:22You hours or days, Your honor. What does it say and?
- 2:24:25It says 30 to 90 days of community service. 30 days.
- 2:24:28OK. Is there anything else that I
- 2:25:07have missed that the people are requesting?
- 2:25:11Only other thing, your honor, is that a substance abuse?
- 2:25:15It sounds as if he had taken a substance abuse assessment.
- 2:25:17I would ask that that be given to probation so probation knows
- 2:25:20exactly what they're working with all.
- 2:25:23Right. So it sounds like you've already
- 2:25:25completed all the requirements, correct?
- 2:25:27Correct. All right, so just provide all
- 2:25:29of that or in lieu of that assessment, a letter from your
- 2:25:34provider saying what the recommendations are.
- 2:25:36So because you're required to follow those recommendations.
- 2:25:39So if you're done and everything's good, that's fine.
- 2:25:42Makes sense? It does.
- 2:25:44I'll provide it to the probation promptly, Your Honor.
- 2:25:46All right and then prove the highway safety correct.
- 2:25:51You have 42 days to appeal to request appellate council.
- 2:25:59Can you please hand miss appellate rights?
- 2:26:01They're right, thanks to. Through balance receiving your
- 2:26:10appellate rights. Thank you All right thank you
- 2:26:12Sir. So before you leave today just
- 2:26:14to make it easy for downstairs to make and keep that
- 2:26:16appointment probation and then if you'd like to transfer to
- 2:26:18Justin at all of that these three.
- 2:26:21Terms since. All right.
- 2:26:27Good luck too, Sir. Thank you.
- 2:26:29Thank you, Your honor. Okie, dokie friends, TCF live.
- 2:26:35What about 35 or so minutes more to go?
- 2:26:37We're solidly an hour 3 now. Just a three hour show today,
- 2:26:39not four. I am feverishly working on the
- 2:26:43closing. I did the opening in the style
- 2:26:45of Doctor Seuss. I promised you I'd do the
- 2:26:47closing as well, so I'm writing that as we watch.
- 2:26:50Let's go down to Louisiana. Check in on the Parole Board.
- 2:26:59OK, so we'll start off. We are at Catahoula
- 2:27:02Correctional. Mr. Geding, state your name and
- 2:27:07DLC number. 1st for geding 538992.
- 2:27:12OK. Would staff and headquarters
- 2:27:15introduce yourself? Sure.
- 2:27:17I'll. OK.
- 2:27:19And there's is there anybody in there with you, Mr. Geding?
- 2:27:22No, Sir. OK.
- 2:27:24All right. Mr. Geding, do you have your
- 2:27:26parole questionnaire with you? Yes, Sir.
- 2:27:30OK. You realize you're not eligible
- 2:27:31for appointed counsel. If you want to counsel, you
- 2:27:33would have to retain it. Yes, Sir.
- 2:27:36Or to proceed. Today without appointed counsel.
- 2:27:38Yes, Sir. OK.
- 2:27:40Your case has been assigned to Miss Stapleton.
- 2:27:43So Miss Stapleton, take it good. Morning, Sir.
- 2:27:47I'm going to go over your rule violations.
- 2:27:49You're going. To plead, you're going to plead
- 2:27:52guilty, not or not guilty with a statement, OK.
- 2:27:56Yes, ma'am. OK.
- 2:27:58At your revocation hearing on 1/13/2020, six in lieu of
- 2:28:02revocation, the Board ordered you to complete a work release
- 2:28:05program. You failed to comply with the
- 2:28:08orders of the Parole Board in that you did not satisfactorily
- 2:28:12complete work release due to rule violations #1 contraband
- 2:28:17scale and then #14 intoxication. How do you?
- 2:28:21Play. Ma'am, I plead guilty to the
- 2:28:24intoxication and not guilty to the contraband because it was a
- 2:28:29poor. It was a poor and and
- 2:28:31disrespectful way to honor my dad died and I used it as a poor
- 2:28:37excuse to to to get high. OK, well, I'm.
- 2:28:44I'm all I can do is read what they said.
- 2:28:48This was your disciplinary report, OK.
- 2:28:50And I'm very sorry about your dad.
- 2:28:52Very sorry. Thank.
- 2:28:53You Christopher Keating, stumbling as he walked down the
- 2:28:57highway and passed by me to get to his dorm.
- 2:29:01Offender geating is housed in blah blah blah.
- 2:29:05Observing some steady movement, I approached Keating, who had
- 2:29:09just laid down in his bunk and instructed him to stand up.
- 2:29:11As he attempted to get up, I observed that his motor function
- 2:29:15and coordination was impaired. Due to his intoxicated
- 2:29:20condition, which you just plead guilty to, it was unsafe to to
- 2:29:24handcuff him at the time. I assisted offender geeding
- 2:29:30upright and escorted him to the rear of the CEO office where he
- 2:29:34was past searched, secured and handcuffed and seated.
- 2:29:39Due to his erratic gestures and failing to properly communicate,
- 2:29:44EMS was dispatched and after oh gosh I'm OK and after the
- 2:29:49assessment of offender, Geeding was cleared to be transported to
- 2:29:53West Baton Rouge Detention Center.
- 2:29:56Offender Geeding's bunk was searched and clothes were packed
- 2:30:01before he was escorted to West Baton Rouge and the offender's
- 2:30:05bunk, a small piece of off white wax light paper.
- 2:30:09Bordered with blue lines. Photo.
- 2:30:12Photos and videos were taken and submitted to my superior
- 2:30:15officer. This offender is in violation of
- 2:30:18DOC and West Baton Rouge Transitional Work Program rules
- 2:30:23and regular regulations. There is nothing further to
- 2:30:26report at this. Time.
- 2:30:28So. Do you?
- 2:30:30How do you still plead not guilty or guilty?
- 2:30:33I still I still feel guilty to intoxication but there I don't
- 2:30:36know what he found on my rack, but there wasn't nothing on my
- 2:30:39rack. This was the one and only time
- 2:30:41that that that I did anything on, so whatever they found on my
- 2:30:45rack I know wasn't wasn't anything.
- 2:30:48OK, well I'm going to ask my other board members if they have
- 2:30:51questions. We have no questions.
- 2:30:52I have no questions. I'm sorry, no questions.
- 2:30:56Ready to vote? OK, Mr. Keating, based upon the
- 2:30:59fact that you did plead guilty to in such intoxication, you are
- 2:31:03in violation of rule #14 and and so you have been revoked today.
- 2:31:14Miss Ledoux, my vote is to revoke.
- 2:31:18OK. I mean, we tried to send you
- 2:31:20there, Mr. Geeting, I'm. Sorry about your father.
- 2:31:22But you didn't make the program, so we have no alternative to to
- 2:31:26revoke you today. So good luck to you.
- 2:31:30Can I ask you a question? No, you may not.
- 2:31:39All righty, that was a quick one.
- 2:31:41Let's go back up to Ohio, Judge O'Donnell.
- 2:31:47We're here in the case of State of Ohio versus Michael Logar,
- 2:31:50case number 26. CR 252 then is present in the
- 2:31:54courtroom and represented by defense counsel.
- 2:31:56We're here today for a pretrial or change of plea in the matter.
- 2:32:01Sorry, quick pause before they get into it because I keep
- 2:32:03forgetting. Tim, thank you for gifting
- 2:32:05another membership. And Barbara, thank you for
- 2:32:08gifting a membership. I meant to say that like 2 cases
- 2:32:10ago and I forgot. I'm so sorry, but very much
- 2:32:13appreciated. All right, let's continue.
- 2:32:14Understanding that the. Defendant wishes to change his
- 2:32:17plea to guilty to the two counts of theft in the indictment.
- 2:32:23All right, Mr. Waymack. Is my understanding you're on
- 2:32:26it. All right, Mr. Logar, how old
- 2:32:31are you, 50? 7.
- 2:32:33How far did you go through school?
- 2:32:3411th grade. You gotta speak up a little bit.
- 2:32:39Got my GED and 80. 9. Are you AUS citizen?
- 2:32:43Yes. Are you able to read, write,
- 2:32:45understand the English language? Yes, prior to coming according
- 2:32:50to taking any drugs or alcohol or any prescription medication
- 2:32:53within the last 48 hours. Just what I'm prescribed.
- 2:32:57I I can't, you got to speak up. Just what I'm prescribed.
- 2:33:00What do you prescribed? Depakote and eviscerol.
- 2:33:06When did you last take either of those?
- 2:33:10Last night? Does it affect your ability to
- 2:33:13understand what's going on? No emotional emotional
- 2:33:19stabilizer ends from my high cholesterol.
- 2:33:38Did you get a copy of this indictment?
- 2:33:41Yes. And you're pleading guilty to
- 2:33:43both of those charges, is that correct?
- 2:33:45Yes. And before I accept your guilty
- 2:33:48plea, I need to determine that you know and understand the
- 2:33:50constitutional rights you'll be waiving, the consequences of
- 2:33:54your guilty plea and the maximum penalty I could give you.
- 2:33:56And it needs to be satisfied that you're guilty pleas being
- 2:33:59made freely, knowingly and voluntarily.
- 2:34:01I'm going to ask you questions. If you don't understand a
- 2:34:03question, stop me. If you want to talk to Mr. Lang
- 2:34:06Max some more, let me know and I'll give you more time.
- 2:34:08You understand that? Yes.
- 2:34:10You have a constitutional right to have a trial.
- 2:34:12Give it to me or to a jury of 12 Lake County citizens.
- 2:34:16Do you understand that right? Yes.
- 2:34:18Are you waving that right? Yes.
- 2:34:20If you go to a jury trial, all 12 members must agree to a
- 2:34:23guilty verdict before you can be found guilty.
- 2:34:25Do you understand that right? Yes.
- 2:34:27Are you waving that right? If you go to trial, the
- 2:34:32prosecutor will call witnesses to testify against you.
- 2:34:34Do you understand the prosecutor must prove you guilty beyond a
- 2:34:38reasonable doubt at a trial, after the witnesses are done
- 2:34:42testifying for the prosecutor, you have the constitutional
- 2:34:44right to have your lawyer cross examine the witnesses.
- 2:34:46Do you understand that right? Are you waiving that right?
- 2:34:50If you go to trial, you have the right to have witnesses come
- 2:34:53here and testify for you. Do you understand that right?
- 2:34:56Are you waiving that right? If those witnesses refuse to
- 2:35:00come to court, I'll issue an order called the subpoena to
- 2:35:02make them testify. Do you understand that right?
- 2:35:04Are you waiving that right? You have the right to testify a
- 2:35:08trial if you want to. Do you understand that right?
- 2:35:11Are you waiving that right? You have the constitutional
- 2:35:14right to not testify a trial if you do not want to.
- 2:35:16Do you understand that right? Are you waiving that right If
- 2:35:20you decide not to testify a trial?
- 2:35:22Nobody is permitted to comment on that decision.
- 2:35:24Do you understand that? Yes.
- 2:35:26If you go to trial and you're found guilty of the right to
- 2:35:28appeal the guilty finding, do you understand that right?
- 2:35:31Yes. Are you waiving that right?
- 2:35:33Yes. If you file an appeal, you have
- 2:35:34a constitutional right to have a lawyer represent you in the
- 2:35:37appeal. Do you understand that right?
- 2:35:38Yes. Are you waiving that right?
- 2:35:40Yes. If you could not afford to hire
- 2:35:42a lawyer, one would be provided at no cost to you.
- 2:35:44Do you understand that? Yes, if you file an appeal,
- 2:35:47you're entitled to have a transcript of all the hearings
- 2:35:49in this case. Do you understand that Right?
- 2:35:51Yes. Are you waiving that right?
- 2:35:53Yes, if you could not afford a copy of those transcripts to be
- 2:35:56given to you at no cost, you understand that?
- 2:35:58Yes, if you plead guilty today, you will not have a right to
- 2:36:01appeal the guilty finding. Do you understand that?
- 2:36:04Yes. Do you have any questions about
- 2:36:05any of these rights? No.
- 2:36:07Do you still want to plead guilty to these charges?
- 2:36:10Yes. Do you understand by pleading
- 2:36:12guilty you're fully admitting you're guilt to the charges?
- 2:36:16Do you? Understand by pleading guilty to
- 2:36:18these felonies or to this felony or volunteer, they're giving up
- 2:36:21your freedom for whatever period of time I could sent to the
- 2:36:23prison, to jail or to community control.
- 2:36:28And count 1 theft is a felony of the 5th degree.
- 2:36:30It carries a 12 month maximum prison sentence and a $2500
- 2:36:34maximum fine. Do you understand that?
- 2:36:36Yes. Count 2 theft is a misdemeanor
- 2:36:38one. It carries a maximum 180 days in
- 2:36:41jail and a maximum $1000 fine. Do you understand that?
- 2:36:44Yes. If I gave you a consecutive
- 2:36:47sentence, then the maximum prison sentence you face is 12
- 2:36:51months and the maximum fine $3500.
- 2:36:53Do you understand that? Are you on post release control
- 2:36:56to the Parole Authority? No.
- 2:36:59Do you understand if a prison term is imposed in this case,
- 2:37:02you might have to serve a period of post release control as part
- 2:37:04of your sentence for up to two years under the parole
- 2:37:06authority? Yeah.
- 2:37:08If you are placed on post release control and violating
- 2:37:10conditions of parole authority could return it to prison for up
- 2:37:13to nine months for each violation up to 1/2 of my
- 2:37:16sentence. Do you understand that?
- 2:37:17Do you understand if your violation of post release
- 2:37:20control is a new felony, you could get an additional
- 2:37:23consecutive prison sentence for that violation, do you
- 2:37:26understand that? And if that were to happen, the
- 2:37:28maximum prison term for the violation would be the greater
- 2:37:31of 12 months or the time left under post release control.
- 2:37:34Do you understand that? Do you understand that if a
- 2:37:38prison term is imposed, you are eligible for judicial release?
- 2:37:41Yes. Yes.
- 2:37:44I could place you on community control for up to five years,
- 2:37:47but if you violate, I can send you to prison for 12 months.
- 2:37:49You understand that? Yes.
- 2:37:51Has anybody promised you I would be lenient on you just because
- 2:37:54you're pleading guilty today? No.
- 2:37:56Has anybody promised you what I will sent you to in this case?
- 2:37:59No. Do you understand I do not have
- 2:38:01to follow the sentencing recommendation of either the
- 2:38:03prosecutor or your lawyer? Yes.
- 2:38:05Have you had enough time to talk to Mr. Lang Mack before pleading
- 2:38:08guilty today? Yes.
- 2:38:11Has he discussed everything about your case and answered all
- 2:38:13of your questions to? The best of his ability, yes.
- 2:38:16Are you satisfied with the advice he has given you?
- 2:38:19Right. Have you been threatened or
- 2:38:21coerced in any way to plead guilty today?
- 2:38:23No. Are you freely, knowingly and
- 2:38:25voluntarily entering your guilty plea?
- 2:38:27Yes, I am do. You have any questions at this
- 2:38:29point? Nothing, Your Honor.
- 2:38:32So Gretzky in this case went to trial, the evidence show.
- 2:38:36You have an answered show that on January 24th of 2026 and will
- 2:38:41be Lake County, Ohio. The defendant did take
- 2:38:44merchandise from Lowe's Home Improvement without paying for
- 2:38:47it. The amount of merchandise was
- 2:38:49over $1000. He then, in the same city, took
- 2:38:53merchandise from Target without paying for it.
- 2:38:56Mr. Lane, I can even add to those facts.
- 2:38:59Nothing bad, John. Mr. Logar, did you hear what Mr.
- 2:39:01Gretzky said, that the facts would show if the case went to
- 2:39:04trial? Yes, I did.
- 2:39:06Are those facts true? Yes, they are.
- 2:39:08Yeah. What is your plea to count 1
- 2:39:10Theft a felony 5. Guilty.
- 2:39:13What is your plea to count 2. Theft a misdemeanor 1.
- 2:39:15Guilty. Like it could reflect that prior
- 2:39:30to this hearing, I did have an opportunity to go over these
- 2:39:32documents and the issues contained therein.
- 2:39:34And Mr. Logan does have now it's an understanding of them.
- 2:40:22And in the court back the written.
- 2:40:29So, Logar, is this your signature on the written plea of
- 2:40:32guilty? Yes, it is your.
- 2:40:34Honor, did you sign it voluntarily?
- 2:40:36Yes. Do you want me to accept your
- 2:40:38written plea of guilty? Yes, please.
- 2:40:41I'll accept the written plea. Guilty.
- 2:40:42The penalist President, Mr. Lamac advised all of his rights
- 2:40:45been annoying. Intelligent, voluntary waiver.
- 2:40:48He understands the nature of the charge.
- 2:40:49The consequence of his guilty plea in the maximum penalty.
- 2:40:53Find it to be knowing, intelligent and voluntary.
- 2:40:55I will accept his plea of guilty and find him guilty of count 1
- 2:41:00theft a felony 5 and count 2 theft to misdemeanor one.
- 2:41:05Refer this for a pre sentence report.
- 2:41:09Sentencing will be May 26 at 2:30 and the bond remains
- 2:41:15revoked. Anything else?
- 2:41:16Mr. Lane Mac? Mr. Gretzky?
- 2:41:22All right, we're adjourned. All right.
- 2:41:39All righty, friends, let's go back up to Michigan.
- 2:41:42Judge McNally. We'll hang for him for a while
- 2:41:45while I keep writing because I'm really trying to make this outro
- 2:41:50good for you guys today because you all paid for it yesterday.
- 2:41:53And doggone it, you ought to get for the, you ought to get value
- 2:41:56for the money you gave me. Also, Barbara, thank you for
- 2:41:58gifting another membership. Very much appreciate it.
- 2:42:05I want you up here. Your appearance P76343.
- 2:42:10Sorry, just very few seconds. Well, I called it because I got
- 2:42:14this stipulated order adjoining bench trial correct.
- 2:42:20I had told you last time I was not going to adjourn the trial.
- 2:42:24I understand. Why in the world would you do
- 2:42:28that and submit that with the hopes it's going to get by a
- 2:42:31judge. Either that or you thought I was
- 2:42:34kidding. I don't get in here.
- 2:42:37I have a very good sense of humor outside of here.
- 2:42:41But I told you I wasn't going to adjourn this.
- 2:42:44And then I get a stipulated order.
- 2:42:46Like I sign 150 to 200 orders a week, probably in judgments.
- 2:42:51Why would you submit an order, a stipulated order adjourning a
- 2:42:55bench trial, And I just got done telling you I wasn't going to
- 2:42:58adjourn it. I hope you don't do that in
- 2:43:00other courts, Judge. Just listen to what I'm telling
- 2:43:04you, counsel. I am not happy about this.
- 2:43:08I don't fool around in here. I'm not kidding.
- 2:43:11You guys had multiple pretrials and now all of a sudden there's
- 2:43:15this urgency to adjourn because your client is going to start a
- 2:43:18job. If there if you had a pretrial
- 2:43:21on February the 5th, 19th, 16th of April, I mean February 5th
- 2:43:30and 19th and March 19th and April 16th.
- 2:43:35And now you're telling my clerk your clients not showing up and
- 2:43:37you want to know when you can walk them and listen to me very
- 2:43:40carefully. If he dares plays games with me,
- 2:43:44like he better have a lot of me. And don't think if you walk in
- 2:43:50here on Monday or Tuesday or Friday that that I'm going to
- 2:43:53just say, oh, let's let bygones be bygones.
- 2:43:58He will be sitting in that lock up unless he's married to a
- 2:44:01physician for the longest time. But more important, I'm
- 2:44:07disappointed in you when I tell you I'm not going to adjourn
- 2:44:11something. You don't submit a skip in order
- 2:44:14to adjourn behind my back with the hopes I'll forget about it.
- 2:44:17And signing. I'm serious, it's a heart
- 2:44:20attack. Why would you do such a thing?
- 2:44:28Mr. Borgia asked me if I could do whatever I could to get it.
- 2:44:32You brought it up. I said no.
- 2:44:36Why would you do such a thing? I don't care what your client
- 2:44:40asks you to do. Does he finally got it before he
- 2:44:45has two weeks where he came. This is an animal violation
- 2:44:48case. It's a dog bite.
- 2:44:50It's a domestic violence. And they're going.
- 2:44:59Through a custody issue so that's why he was trying to get
- 2:45:01it so the custody issue would not affect his you mean to tell
- 2:45:05me if he starts one day later he can't get a job at Ford Motor
- 2:45:09Company judge they the. E-mail said that.
- 2:45:12He has to be there for two weeks straight otherwise he will be
- 2:45:16terminated from the job. There's no exceptions, no.
- 2:45:18Excuses. Lee I.
- 2:45:22When is he supposed to start? He started on one of the judge,
- 2:45:25so I think he's going to miss work tomorrow and have to be
- 2:45:29applied between four. Listen, I thought it was an
- 2:45:38animal violation, but it doesn't matter.
- 2:45:41Now did you? Well, why?
- 2:45:42Why? Why so many?
- 2:45:43This is a domestic violence case, That's fine.
- 2:45:46Why so many pre trials? If you guys needed to to push
- 2:45:49this through, I'd have given you a trial date six weeks ago.
- 2:45:53The judge, we didn't want to. Push us through.
- 2:45:55We wanted to work with the. Family.
- 2:45:58Law to get their custody issues set up at the same time as this
- 2:46:01was being resolved and they were supposed to have a custody
- 2:46:05hearing last week and it's not a contentious issue.
- 2:46:09So and he wants to be able to support his two children with
- 2:46:12this with the victim. And he wasn't a former police
- 2:46:15officer. I don't care who he was.
- 2:46:17And he lost his job and now he's been working as a plumber.
- 2:46:20But he finally he's like, I finally have a job to get on a
- 2:46:22Ford. I can't be my kids and move some
- 2:46:26other. I know, but.
- 2:46:27He. If if he told you that judge, I
- 2:46:33begged him to set, I said can. You start 2 weeks.
- 2:46:35Later listen to me if he told you that and me I they remember
- 2:46:43you doing something about starting a job, maybe you
- 2:46:45brought this up. I don't believe I did trust.
- 2:46:47Because I didn't know. He said he.
- 2:46:49Was looking for a check, he was waiting.
- 2:46:50I supported it back to you but. I don't know if I.
- 2:46:51Brought that up. I did bring up the custody.
- 2:46:54I just tried sneezing by the I just no, but you can't you can't
- 2:46:58do this. I was really surprised.
- 2:47:01I didn't think you were would do something like this.
- 2:47:05I mean, I just, well, you could have filed an emergency motion
- 2:47:09and it been explanatory. It said this that the other.
- 2:47:12All I've heard is adjourn, adjourn, adjourn, adjourn,
- 2:47:15adjourn. On this case.
- 2:47:17I don't want to cost anybody a job.
- 2:47:20Heather, I may forget that Mister Nyenhaus handled this
- 2:47:26inappropriately. Hang on, I'm going to adjourn
- 2:47:30this. You called Mr. Kaylee's office.
- 2:47:33I'm. They already submitted A stip
- 2:47:35and order. I'm going to adjourn this two
- 2:47:36more weeks. Is that going to do it?
- 2:47:40May 14th? Yes, Judge.
- 2:47:43You sure? Yes, Judge, because you said he
- 2:47:46started this last week and he needs to be there for two weeks,
- 2:47:48right? He told.
- 2:47:49Me it was 2 weeks. He can't.
- 2:47:50I was like. All right, all right, OK, sure.
- 2:47:53In For some reason I thought this was an animal violation.
- 2:47:58No judge this. Was a we're going to adjourn
- 2:47:59this to or is it May the 13th? Heather No.
- 2:48:02May the 14th. It'll be May 14th.
- 2:48:04Judge, do you want to? Do it.
- 2:48:05At 11:00. Yes, you are.
- 2:48:09What time are we going to do this?
- 2:48:11Do you want to do 11? Are we doing it as a trial that
- 2:48:14day? Yes.
- 2:48:15So you want to do 11:00? What?
- 2:48:18I was going to say I have a do you want at 8:30.
- 2:48:19In the morning. So if I could just have it after
- 2:48:21during 30 or 10, I'll make it 11 May 14th at 11:00.
- 2:48:25I'm going to forget this happened, by the way.
- 2:48:28Next time file a motion, emergency motion.
- 2:48:31I'll accommodate you with an emergency motion, but I felt
- 2:48:33like you were trying to get one by on me and I, I don't like
- 2:48:36that. As soon as I got.
- 2:48:37Information from Mr. Bogia. I reached out to Mr. May 14th.
- 2:48:42That's what we'll be. All.
- 2:48:45Right, good enough. No sense groveling any further.
- 2:48:49But I was disappointed in you. That's all I'm going to tell
- 2:48:51you. It's forgotten be put against
- 2:48:53Buddy or Bradley Brianna Mae Bradley 268841845 A&B Now what
- 2:49:03is the situation with this man Come on up here and state your
- 2:49:06name please. Bradley.
- 2:49:11So he the prosecutors just dismissing.
- 2:49:15Is there a reason for it? Yes.
- 2:49:18Judge. The we found out later on there
- 2:49:22were Co. Defendants after I filed my.
- 2:49:23Appearances because they just got 2 separate tickets the.
- 2:49:26Co defense taking full. Responsibility for us and Miss
- 2:49:29Bradley was based on the video evidence was trying to break up
- 2:49:32the incident. OK so for purposes of ring that
- 2:49:34she stands mute W from the reading dismissed motion of the
- 2:49:38prosecutor. So he's saying that he's going
- 2:49:41to go ahead and just because the Co defendant, Mr. Mr. Bradley is
- 2:49:46going to take responsibility, right.
- 2:49:48Yes. OK, good enough.
- 2:49:50Case dismissed. Now the press motion of the
- 2:49:52prosecutor, ma'am, he is dismissing without prejudice.
- 2:49:57I'm not saying he's he can't refile, but he's not likely to.
- 2:50:03So I'm dismissing the case. You're all set.
- 2:50:05Have a good day. Thank you people against
- 2:50:08Christopher Bradley. Christopher Brian Bradley Junior
- 2:50:12268841844 A&B Make sure you call Mr. Kaylee so he can call off
- 2:50:18his witnesses on that case tomorrow, will you please,
- 2:50:20Heather? OK.
- 2:50:22Not land. You can call them too.
- 2:50:25That's fine. All right, your appearance.
- 2:50:28Heck with my house. P76343 Judge sure your name?
- 2:50:33Christopher Bradley. All right, so we haven't
- 2:50:35disturbed the peace in an A&B. And is I, does he stand mutant
- 2:50:40wave formal reading? Yes, he does.
- 2:50:41And so now I, I, he's going to plead guilty to both of these,
- 2:50:45both the A&B and the disorderly under Section 771.1.
- 2:50:54I got a call in the prosecutor real quick.
- 2:50:59Mr. Urich, please, I can't do a 771 for 18 months.
- 2:51:07It has to be disposed of within 12 months.
- 2:51:10Friday you can 769, you can 7411, you can any of these other
- 2:51:16statutes, but you can't do it on a 771.
- 2:51:19So he's just going to have to change it or do something else.
- 2:51:24But I can't do 18 months probation on them.
- 2:51:29That's all right. I know sometimes you can waive.
- 2:51:31That. That's all right.
- 2:51:33Well, I don't. Yeah, No, I OK.
- 2:51:39So, Sir, do you understand? So first of all, he stands me up
- 2:51:43ways for more reason, right? And now he's going to plead
- 2:51:45guilty to these two children, disturb the peace and A&B, and
- 2:51:49then there's going to be a plead of Eric your name.
- 2:51:56Good. Morning, Your Honor.
- 2:51:57William York on manhunt the city.
- 2:51:58I can't do 771.1 for more than 12 months.
- 2:52:04Is that right? Judge, Yeah, I apologize.
- 2:52:09There's nothing to apologize about.
- 2:52:11You want to just redo it to 12 months or you want to do
- 2:52:13something else with Mr. Nyeans? Do it 12 months up the court,
- 2:52:17please. All right, good enough.
- 2:52:19So it's going to be 12 months and you're that's still
- 2:52:21agreeable, obviously with your client, right.
- 2:52:25So if you plead guilty to that, Sir, I want you to understand
- 2:52:28that each of these are punishable by up to 500 fines,
- 2:52:3198 jail costs are all those. I'll take them under section
- 2:52:34771.1. The conviction will enter now.
- 2:52:38I'll send you for a pre sentence report and if you're complying
- 2:52:42at the end of the year the case will be dismissed.
- 2:52:44You understand that? Did you sign, read and
- 2:52:46understand the advice of rights. If you plead guilty, you'll be
- 2:52:50giving up all those rights and there will be no hearing or
- 2:52:52trials. You understand that?
- 2:52:54OK. Do you have any questions on any
- 2:52:56of your rights to the charge? Disturb the peace?
- 2:53:00How do you plead to the charge of salt and battery?
- 2:53:04How do you plead on March 15 at 26 at 1:44 PM.
- 2:53:08Where you at? 22900 Allen Rd. near Weston Wood
- 2:53:11Ape. Yeah.
- 2:53:14And. And what is that?
- 2:53:16A business establishment. It is Josh.
- 2:53:19What is it? What business is that?
- 2:53:22It's. Outside of Christophe's.
- 2:53:23You're right. OK.
- 2:53:25And what happened that makes you guilty of those two offenses?
- 2:53:28Disturb the peace and assault and back.
- 2:53:31Mutual. Combat.
- 2:53:32You're right, no. Well, see, let me.
- 2:53:34No, I mean, can I? No, let me ask.
- 2:53:36Let me ask the questions. Did you come into contact with
- 2:53:40Joseph Clinton? Yes, you're right.
- 2:53:42Did you know Joseph Clinton prior to that?
- 2:53:45Did you just meet him that day? That was our first meeting.
- 2:53:49You're right. OK.
- 2:53:51And what happened? Did you, did you, Did you strike
- 2:53:54him in any way? I did strike him.
- 2:53:57Yesterday with what? My hand.
- 2:54:00This OK? How?
- 2:54:02Where'd you strike him? At space, Your Honor.
- 2:54:05How many times? Unknown amount, Your Honor.
- 2:54:09Pardon. Unknown amount, Your Honor.
- 2:54:12So you punched him in the face multiple times.
- 2:54:14Is that fair? Yes, Your Honor.
- 2:54:16And were were you disturbing the peace in some other way?
- 2:54:18Were you yelling? Screaming.
- 2:54:19Swearing there are other people got out of their cars and it
- 2:54:25caused a disturbance. Yes, you're right.
- 2:54:26OK, So what happened? Why did you punch him?
- 2:54:30He almost T boned me and my children.
- 2:54:32All right, so he was backing out of a car, out of a parking lot,
- 2:54:36or? Was that the intersection you're
- 2:54:38on? OK, so you got angry with waves
- 2:54:41driving, is that fair? And then you start and you
- 2:54:46accosted him or it came up to him and started yelling at him.
- 2:54:49Is that fair? Yes.
- 2:54:51And then what happened? Did he ever punch you or swing
- 2:54:54at you or take a strike at you before you punched him?
- 2:54:58Before. No, you're on.
- 2:54:59Not before. Before.
- 2:55:01No, you're on. So you were the aggressor first.
- 2:55:03Is that fair to say? Yes, Sir.
- 2:55:04And that you weren't acting in self-defense?
- 2:55:07Are you on probation or parole right now?
- 2:55:09No, you're on. Anybody force you to plead
- 2:55:13guilty? No, you're on.
- 2:55:18You're satisfied, right? Yes.
- 2:55:19Thank you very much. Appreciate that.
- 2:55:20I'll accept the plea. I'll take it under and under
- 2:55:24771, both of them. And I'll make them 12 months and
- 2:55:28we'll set it under. I'll take it under 771.1
- 2:55:32commencing on the date of the sentence.
- 2:55:33I am going to order. You were not.
- 2:55:35He wasn't under the outfit influence of anything, was he?
- 2:55:39You don't you agree this wasn't the right way to handle this,
- 2:55:41right? OK, fair enough.
- 2:55:44Told you we're going to take responsibility.
- 2:55:46I got it, Mr. Nienhaus. I'm not going to give him pre
- 2:55:53sentence report. If you want, maybe I can even do
- 2:56:01it the same day as your other case.
- 2:56:03We set it for May 14th, right, Heather?
- 2:56:06Yes. Well, let's set this one for
- 2:56:1010:45. How's that?
- 2:56:13And then I'll set some then and get back to the other.
- 2:56:17Mr. Nanos. Maybe it was just maybe it was
- 2:56:19just a month misunderstanding. I'm going to give I'm going to
- 2:56:22give you the benefit of the doubt.
- 2:56:24And I was just upset when I got a stiff in order to adjourn when
- 2:56:28I'd said I had. And next time, I just encourage
- 2:56:30you to file a motion and explain it and I'll be reasonable with
- 2:56:33you. OK.
- 2:56:36All right. So you're going to go down.
- 2:56:37No problem. You're going to go down the hall
- 2:56:40and just to not carry on here, I've always liked you and I, So
- 2:56:44you're going to go down the hall, get your notice and then
- 2:56:46you're going over to probation where you'll be interviewed, OK.
- 2:56:50George, I do have a question. Can we do it that day or are we
- 2:56:53going to notify the victim on this or no?
- 2:56:55We have to notify the victim. So does.
- 2:56:57It have to be on a Woodhaven day or no if we have to notify the
- 2:57:01victim. Yeah, it should be.
- 2:57:04That's Woodhaven though, right? Not on the other day as his
- 2:57:07other case, because that's a Thursday.
- 2:57:10Because that's a Flat Rock case. Oh.
- 2:57:12Jeez. We would.
- 2:57:13Have to do it on the 13th. My my mistake, Judge 19.
- 2:57:20Yeah. And Judge, are both of these
- 2:57:22being taken under 7711? Both of them will.
- 2:57:25Yes, OK. Thank you.
- 2:57:27So we'll, we'll make it May the 13th then.
- 2:57:30Are you good at 8:30 or make? It a little later so I don't.
- 2:57:33I don't have a problem, I'll make it 10:30.
- 2:57:35How's that? OK, I got to set bond
- 2:57:41conditions, though I neglected to do that.
- 2:57:45Your client doesn't have any warrants out, does he?
- 2:57:47No, judge. He was never fingerprinted on
- 2:57:50this though, was he? No, he was not judged.
- 2:57:53So, Sir, listen, I have to order you to go over there and get
- 2:57:58prints, OK? So here are your bond
- 2:58:04conditions. I'm going to give you a, I'm
- 2:58:07going to give you $1000 personal bond.
- 2:58:10OK, $1000 personal bond on these.
- 2:58:16We'll give you a copy of the bond sheet.
- 2:58:18You cannot leave the state without the consent of the court
- 2:58:21or violate any law or ordinance. You must appear in Florida as
- 2:58:24directed. OK.
- 2:58:26And I'm going to go ahead and order that you go over the
- 2:58:28Woodhaven Police Department to be fingerprinted and
- 2:58:31photographed by 1:00 PM today. That you not purchase,
- 2:58:39possessor, consume, purchase or possess firearms or other
- 2:58:42dangerous weapons. That you not enter the property
- 2:58:46address at 22900 Allen Rd., That's the Kristoff's.
- 2:58:53And also that you not have any contact with the victim, Joseph
- 2:58:57Clinton. OK.
- 2:58:59So you cannot have any contact with him.
- 2:59:01You cannot have anybody write him, phone him, see him, text
- 2:59:03him, e-mail him. You cannot do any of those
- 2:59:06things for you on your behalf. You have anybody else do any of
- 2:59:10those things for you on your behalf.
- 2:59:11Do you understand that? Yes, Sir.
- 2:59:12And we're going to, I'm going to fill out an order for Prince
- 2:59:15which they're going to send over there.
- 2:59:16So you have to go over to Woodhaven today and we will go
- 2:59:20from there. Anything else counsel appearance
- 2:59:23you'll split for probation. And then?
- 2:59:26We should be done by one speaking.
- 2:59:27Absolutely. Thanks a lot.
- 2:59:29Have a good day. Thank you.
- 2:59:34Well, we've travelled Courtlandia all morning long
- 2:59:38with gavel slams, rulings and stories gone wrong from judges
- 2:59:43who swear to defendants who stall.
- 2:59:45We've seen it all, folks. We've had quite a ball.
- 2:59:48There was O'Donnell with language so bold, calling out
- 2:59:51scammers and stories retold fake urine in court.
- 2:59:55Oh, the drama was thick. You don't give a shit, said the
- 2:59:58judge mighty quick. Then Mercer viewed rap sheet
- 3:00:01that went on and on. The worst that he'd witnessed.
- 3:00:04Oh man, what went wrong, $10,000 bond for the man with the pat
- 3:00:09With that past. Well, another poor fellow got
- 3:00:12charges dropped fast. Type 1 diabetic blood sugar so
- 3:00:16high his mom begged to drop it, and the state said goodbye New
- 3:00:22Judge Hakeem brought a moment so sweet when Bacon appeared in the
- 3:00:26chat Had to eat Can we have bacon?
- 3:00:29She called with a grin and we laughed and said We think that
- 3:00:32Bacon should win. Judge Aquilina gave wisdom so
- 3:00:36true. Stay busy my man.
- 3:00:38Here's what you should do for men who drink.
- 3:00:41Heavy work keeps the mind right. A message that landed with power
- 3:00:45and light. In Louisiana, an inmate stood
- 3:00:48tall. Dad passed away, but violations
- 3:00:50did fall. Work released ended.
- 3:00:53The judgement came down. Another hard lesson in
- 3:00:56Cortlandia town. And oh what a crowd.
- 3:00:58So many new faces, first timers and regulars filling our spaces
- 3:01:03from coast to coast, courts all over the land.
- 3:01:06We laughed and we learned with this wonderful band, new friends
- 3:01:10we found as the hours flew by. Thank you for riding through
- 3:01:13Courtlandia High. We'll do it again when the
- 3:01:16morning bells toll. Same time, same place.
- 3:01:20Come on, lawn nerds, let's roll.