Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / How Figurative Language Makes Complex Ideas More Persuasive
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07how figurative language makes complex ideas more
- 0:10persuasive. I'm Alla Policastro, Director of
- 0:13Education and Professional Development at Beverly
- 0:15Hills Bar Association. And today I'm delighted
- 0:18to introduce our speaker, the Honorable Jamie
- 0:21Jacobs May. Judge Jacobs -May is a neutral with
- 0:24Jams, where she resolves complex high stakes
- 0:27disputes through strategic persistence, a thorough
- 0:30analysis of facts and law, and strong interpersonal
- 0:33skills. Before joining Jams, she served 21 years
- 0:37on the Superior Court and Municipal Court of
- 0:39California, County of Santa Clara, where her
- 0:42colleagues elected her presiding judge of both
- 0:45courts. She also served on the Judicial Council
- 0:48of California, chaired the Civil and Small Claims
- 0:51Advisory Committee, and has taught negotiations
- 0:53and mediation nationally and internationally,
- 0:56including at UC Berkeley School of Law. We're
- 0:59so excited to hear what she has to share with
- 1:01us today, so I'm now gonna turn it over to her.
- 1:04Well, thank you so, so much. It's a pleasure
- 1:06to be here, and thank you, our participants,
- 1:09for joining me. This is our first slide. I'm
- 1:15going to try through the course of our time together
- 1:19not to read the slides, and to talk about what
- 1:26they represent to you. I can tell you that I've
- 1:31been to many CLE classes, and I probably have
- 1:35an undiagnosed case of ADD. I have a lot of trouble
- 1:39just listening to a talking head. So I encourage
- 1:42you to ask questions. We'll take questions while
- 1:46the course is going on. You don't have to save
- 1:48them to the end. unless we find ourselves totally
- 1:51running out of time, in which case I'll have
- 1:53to truncate that. You all have received the Daily
- 2:00Journal article that I wrote and you've received
- 2:03an outline of today's slides. I want to start
- 2:08out by telling you what was behind it. And what
- 2:14was behind it is I became aware a long time ago,
- 2:18probably when I was in the attorney general's
- 2:20office, that I was really drawn to figurative
- 2:23language and metaphors. They tickled me. They
- 2:26got my interest. They made me excited. And so
- 2:31for a long time now, I've thought about the effectiveness
- 2:34of metaphors and figurative language. And so
- 2:37today, what we're going to do is this CLE is
- 2:41an outgrowth of that article. Further research
- 2:45that I've done I've learned about the theory
- 2:48of bisociation that I'm going to share with you
- 2:50today, and we're going to sort of get into it.
- 2:54The Daily Journal article that you have a copy
- 2:57of says, I mean, it is a headline, figure of
- 3:02language is a powerful tool and a favorite of
- 3:05the law. And I used a metaphor. And the metaphor
- 3:09I used in the article was a food processor, because
- 3:12I love cooking, have a food processor. I love
- 3:16it. And I use that as a metaphor for that figurative
- 3:20language. And you can read the slide and everything
- 3:23you can do. Here's a teachable moment for you.
- 3:26When you are using a metaphor, make sure you
- 3:29know your audience. For example, some people
- 3:32might not like cooking. They may never have heard
- 3:34of a cuisine knot before. So if you have that
- 3:37person, here's a different metaphor. And the
- 3:40different metaphor is the master key. So for
- 3:47property managers and people who are involved
- 3:49in real estate, you know that the master key
- 3:51opens all kinds of doors. So you can use a master
- 3:55key, a metaphor, figurative language, to explain
- 3:59exactly the same thing. Figurative language opens
- 4:02up doors. So what exactly is figurative language?
- 4:08Figurative language uses words or phrases to
- 4:12convey a meaning. beyond the literal language.
- 4:16So for example, if you say, she was extremely
- 4:19tired after the long shift, that's literal. She
- 4:23was really tired. Or you can say, she was running
- 4:27on fumes after the long shift. And that would
- 4:30be a good example of figurative language. The
- 4:34law is made up of conceptual abstractions. That's
- 4:38what the law is. It's not physical objects. I
- 4:41mean, we have the courthouse. We have the jury
- 4:44box. We have accoutrements of the law, but not
- 4:48the law itself. The law itself is conceptual.
- 4:51And for that reason, we rely heavily on figurative
- 4:55language to give complex legal principles a familiar
- 4:59physical experience. Here's a list of them. Let's
- 5:04just take the first one and just talk about it
- 5:06briefly. We know that a tree grows and it's physical.
- 5:12And we know that if it's tainted, everything
- 5:17that grows from it is tainted as well. So the
- 5:21poisonous tree is, here's a tree. If it's poison,
- 5:25all the fruits of it will be poison too. To explain
- 5:29that when you have a unlawful search and seizure,
- 5:32everything that grows from it is tainted as well
- 5:36and is inadmissible. And you're all familiar
- 5:39with these. These examples are so commonplace
- 5:43that they stop being metaphors, and they actually
- 5:46are. Bright line rule, we know exactly what that
- 5:50means, or an eggshell plaintiff, because they
- 5:53become not just, you have to think about it,
- 5:58they become automatically the information that
- 6:01needs to be conveyed. So I want to talk about
- 6:06something next that is an example of the use
- 6:12of figurative language by the Supreme Court justices
- 6:15that is not in the article. There are a couple
- 6:18that are in the article. This is something new.
- 6:21Biden versus Nebraska is a 2023 case. And in
- 6:26Biden versus Nebraska, the issue being addressed
- 6:30is whether the action of an agency, in this case
- 6:34it was Secretary of Education, was allowable.
- 6:40And what the Secretary of Education did under
- 6:43Biden was forgive a $430 billion, $430 billion
- 6:50in student loan forgiveness, what was done. And
- 6:55there was an appeal. And there is something called
- 6:59the HEROES Act. And the HEROES Act stands for
- 7:02Higher Education and Relief Opportunities for
- 7:05Students Act. And the HEROES Act said the Secretary
- 7:10of Education may waive or modify any statutory
- 7:15or regulatory provision applicable to student
- 7:20loans. And the question before the Supreme Court
- 7:23was, you know, Was this allowed? And the majority
- 7:28said no. And the majority said, look, modify
- 7:32or waive does not permit basic foundational changes
- 7:36in a scheme. You can't use waive or modify to
- 7:41rewrite the statute. So that was the majority.
- 7:47Justice Barrett, in her concurring opinion, wanted
- 7:52to address the major questions doctrine. And
- 7:57the major questions doctrine was a doctrine established
- 8:01in an earlier case where the Supreme Court held
- 8:06that agencies must point to clear congressional
- 8:10authorization when they take action of major
- 8:14political or economic significance. Justice Kagan,
- 8:19in that earlier opinion, said, what? You're kidding
- 8:24me. You know, you, you textualist fellow justices
- 8:30rely on the language of the statute. You don't
- 8:33want to interpret anything. And this is nonsense.
- 8:39And she called it this relying on the major questions
- 8:43doctrine. You don't have to look at the language
- 8:45if there's a major political or economic significance.
- 8:49And what does she call it? She called it a get
- 8:52out of text free card, which is so perfect from
- 8:56our perspective in terms of figurative language.
- 8:59We all are familiar with Monopoly, right? The
- 9:03get out of jail free card. And so she's doing
- 9:05a play on that so we can actually picture the
- 9:08guy, and I think it's a pink card, I know maybe
- 9:13it's the green card, but he's getting out of
- 9:15jail free, and we love those cards, and she's
- 9:17saying that's what this is. This major gifts
- 9:20doctrine, this major questions doctrine is a
- 9:23get -out -of -text -free card. In this opinion,
- 9:27in Biden, Justice Barrett disagreed, and she
- 9:31said, hey look, we're still paying attention
- 9:36to the text, but what we're looking at is trying
- 9:40to interpret the text in terms of its context.
- 9:45And she comes up with this, this is complicated
- 9:50stuff, and it's abstract, and what does the statute
- 9:53say, and what's major questions doctrine, and
- 9:57my head is spinning now, and I don't know, it's
- 10:01abstract. and this is what she says to explain
- 10:05what she means by context. She says, consider
- 10:09a parent who hires a babysitter to watch her
- 10:14young children over the weekend. As she walks
- 10:17out the door, the parent hands the babysitter
- 10:21her credit card and says, make sure the kids
- 10:24have fun. Emboldened, the babysitter takes the
- 10:28kids on a road trip to an amusement park where
- 10:31they spend two days on roller coasters and one
- 10:33night in a hotel. Was the babysitter's trip consistent
- 10:37with the parent's instruction? Maybe in a literal
- 10:41sense, because the instruction was open -ended.
- 10:45But was the trip consistent with a reasonable
- 10:47understanding of the parent's instruction? Highly
- 10:51doubtful. In the normal course, permission to
- 10:55spend money on fun, authorizes a babysitter to
- 11:00take children to a local ice cream parlor or
- 11:03a movie theater, not on a multi -day excursion
- 11:08to an out -of -town amusement park. If a parent
- 11:12were willing to give a green light to a trip
- 11:15that big, we would expect much more clarity than
- 11:19the general instruction, make sure the kids have
- 11:23fun. And so you see she's taking something abstract
- 11:27and kind of tough to grapple with and translates
- 11:31it to an everyday sort of household domestic
- 11:37environment that we all can understand. And to
- 11:42me, that shows the beauty and the effectiveness
- 11:45of figurative language. I want to make sure that
- 11:50you know this. If you have questions while I'm
- 11:53talking, please write them in so I can answer
- 11:55them. When I got into this more, and for this
- 12:03CLE particularly, I started studying and looking
- 12:07into and researching figurative language and
- 12:10came across this theory called bisociation. It
- 12:17was a creation of a person named Arthur Kessler.
- 12:24And what it is, is taking two seemingly unrelated
- 12:30ideas, sometimes they're called ideas, sometimes
- 12:33they're called tracks, sometimes frames of reference,
- 12:36sometimes matrices, but it's taking two different
- 12:40concepts and bringing them together to create
- 12:43a new insight or understanding. I would argue
- 12:47to you that that's exactly what Justice Barrett
- 12:51did, right? She took one frame, you know, abstract,
- 12:57federal spending, is it, you know, what's important,
- 13:01is this important enough to a domestic situation,
- 13:06very, very different, and merge them. In my daily
- 13:12journal article, I give other examples. One was
- 13:16by Justice Ginsburg, who in an oral argument,
- 13:20she was saying that DOMA, that's the, where the
- 13:26federal Congress passed a law saying, marriage,
- 13:32states can do what they want to do, and marriage
- 13:34can be between same -sex people, but not the
- 13:38federal court. Federal court defines marriage
- 13:40as marriage between a man and a woman, which
- 13:43then means over a thousand statutes that apply
- 13:46to marriage would not apply to same -sex couples.
- 13:50And Ginsburg said something like, in an oral
- 13:53argument said, you know, it feels like there's
- 13:56two kinds of marriages, the whole milk version
- 13:58and the skim milk version. Another great way
- 14:03to take one thing, laws about a marriage to something
- 14:08we really understand is, yeah, you're calling
- 14:12it marriage, but you know, you can have whole
- 14:14milk or you can have skim milk. And this is a
- 14:16skim milk version. You're not getting the benefits.
- 14:19So those are good examples of bisociation. Bisociation
- 14:28isn't only about figurative language. It's about
- 14:31inventions, art, music, and humor. And I want
- 14:36to talk about art for one second before I spend
- 14:40a lot more time on three other things. So you
- 14:43can see under the art circle a picture of a bull,
- 14:47and it's a statue. It's a statue, and it was
- 14:52created by Picasso. And it was created by Picasso.
- 14:56The horns are a bicycle handlebar, and the seat
- 15:03is the seat of a bicycle. And he is quoted as
- 15:07saying the following, in 1943, guess how I made
- 15:13the bull's head? One day, in a pile of objects,
- 15:17all jumbled up together, I found an old bicycle
- 15:21seat right next to a rusty set of handlebars.
- 15:25In a flash, they joined together in my head.
- 15:29The idea of the bull's head came to me before
- 15:33I had a chance to think. And that's sort of the
- 15:37essence of this creativity and Arthur Kessler's
- 15:41theory. It's the idea that two separate tracks
- 15:45come together. They're very, very different.
- 15:49And in that collision, something is born, and
- 15:54it's the essence of creativity. We are going
- 15:59to explore three of these things on the chart.
- 16:02We're going to explore inventions, humor, and
- 16:05figurative language in more detail. And when
- 16:10we talk about bisociation in all categories,
- 16:16we can talk about three weighs three categories
- 16:21of talking about that collision between track
- 16:24one and track two. And that collision in terms
- 16:29of comedy is the ha -ha moment. The collision
- 16:34in terms of inventions and discovery is the aha
- 16:38moment. And the collision in terms of insight
- 16:43and deeper meaning and understanding is called
- 16:47the ah moment. So let's do comedy first because
- 16:51I love comedy and and I track one or track a
- 16:57is the setup and Track B is the punchline and
- 17:03Track B is incompatible with track a and the
- 17:07collision is when suddenly oh I get it and That
- 17:11it brings you joy and laughter. It's funny. So
- 17:15let me give you some examples The first is, my
- 17:21grandfather has the heart of a lion. And the
- 17:24heart of a lion is, you know, an expression that
- 17:29means, you know, big hearted, you know, really
- 17:31generous and loving and big hearted. And here's
- 17:38the shift. And a lifetime ban from the local
- 17:43zoo. Different meaning, he actually has the heart
- 17:46of a lion, it came from a lion. creating the
- 17:49humor. Here's the next one. My doctor told me
- 17:53that jogging could add years to my life, meaning
- 17:56if you jog, you will live longer. It is a healthy
- 18:00thing to do. Here's a punchline. My doctor was
- 18:05right. I feel 10 years older already. And you
- 18:09get that. The next one is my therapist says I
- 18:14have a preoccupation with vengeance. Here's a
- 18:18punchline. Well, we'll see about that. And finally,
- 18:25and this is, you know, the classic joke, you
- 18:27know, a priest, a rabbi or whatever walk into
- 18:29a bar, but this is a priest, a pastor and a rabbit
- 18:33walk into a blood bank. The rabbit says, I think
- 18:39I'm a typo. Okay, so those are ha ha examples.
- 18:48Now let's go to a ha. And aha is the eureka moment.
- 18:55So you take two previous unrelated ideas or concepts
- 19:04or things and put them together and you create
- 19:09something new. And Steve Jobs said, look, creativity
- 19:13is just connecting things. It's not inventing
- 19:17new things that never before existed. It's connecting
- 19:21things that already exist. So let's see what
- 19:24he did. One thing he did was the Apple Store.
- 19:30So what did he connect? Well, what do they sell?
- 19:35They sell retail products, usually electronics
- 19:38and technology. It's like Big Buy or any electronics
- 19:49store. That's what they do. His track B was taking
- 19:54that retail store and combining it with concierge
- 20:00and luxury. So what happens when you walk into
- 20:05an Apple store? First of all, it's not like shelves
- 20:08of things, right? It's tables and it looks nice
- 20:12and they all have the same. You don't just walk
- 20:15in, you are greeted at the door by someone with
- 20:19an iPad asking your name, why are you here, escorting
- 20:25you to somebody else so that they can help you.
- 20:29If you have a bigger problem, they'll get you
- 20:33an appointment with the Genius Bar. They are
- 20:36treating you like a VIP. They are taking care
- 20:39of your every need. They are being concierge
- 20:43-like. And that's what makes Apple Store's experience
- 20:48so special. You can call up, you can make an
- 20:52appointment. They'll do service for you. They'll
- 20:58change, you know, you're buying a new phone,
- 21:00they'll transfer it over for you. All the kinds
- 21:03of things you would expect from concierge service.
- 21:06And it's personalized. That's the Apple Store.
- 21:10What about the Apple phone, the iPhone? The iPhone,
- 21:14it's a phone. You know, phones are used to call
- 21:17people. That's what phones are. What did Apple
- 21:22do? Well, they took a phone and they said, well,
- 21:25let's throw in the iPod. Let's make it play music.
- 21:30Oh, and by the way, what about a camera? It's
- 21:33a phone, but surely they can take pictures. And
- 21:36they turned it into an internet communicator
- 21:39with apps and games and everything. And so in
- 21:43one device, you have multiple things that it
- 21:49can do with an interface rather than a physical
- 21:52keyboard and it's a breakthrough invention just
- 21:56by combining things that have already existed.
- 22:01Let's talk about other inventions. So we had
- 22:04Velcro. Velcro was, you know, before Velcro you
- 22:11had fasteners, you had buttons, you had zippers.
- 22:15So you had ways of of joining things. But then
- 22:22in track B, this inventor had a dog and cockle
- 22:28burs are a plant with a hook and a hook system.
- 22:39And so that's what he did. Velcro is a hook and
- 22:45loop mechanism. which completely has transformed
- 22:50into a new fastening system. And that's how we
- 22:53got it from pulling out the cockle burrs from
- 22:56his dog's fur and realizing how they attach to
- 22:59it and then incorporating it into a fastening
- 23:03system. Ballpoint pen is another one. We had
- 23:08ink, we had pens, but we had fountain pens and
- 23:11they leaked and they smudged and they dried out.
- 23:16invented was putting a roller ball into a pen
- 23:22and having the ink write much more smoothly and
- 23:27without leak, you know, not all the time because
- 23:30sometimes they still leak, but not nearly like
- 23:33fountain pens do. So same kind of idea. We had
- 23:38roller balls that did other kinds of things.
- 23:41They transferred things onto mainly leather,
- 23:47but putting it into a pen was a new idea. Okay,
- 23:53so why does a bi -association drive breakthroughs?
- 23:59Well, it breaks habitual patterns, and it creates
- 24:03that aha moment. It's, oh, whoa, yeah, this works.
- 24:08And then it generates possibilities. So it's
- 24:12trying to think about things in a new way from
- 24:15two things that we've already thought about.
- 24:18And now comes an example. And then it's gonna
- 24:22come an exercise that I want everyone to participate
- 24:24in. So if I told you, okay, we have a sneaker
- 24:29and we have a power bank. How can we combine
- 24:32them? What's the connection? What can we come
- 24:35up with? We can think about a sneaker and well,
- 24:39Sneakers do a lot of things. They cover your
- 24:41feet. But we wear them when we want to move,
- 24:43right? We wear them for running. We wear them
- 24:45for walking. It's kind of an exercise shoe. And
- 24:48a power bank stores electricity. So one invention
- 24:53might be a sneaker that converts walking, the
- 24:58walking energy or the running energy, into stored
- 25:01power. So we somehow connect the sneaker into
- 25:05a power bank generating energy and then using
- 25:09that power bank for the things that we use power
- 25:11banks for, which are charging devices and that
- 25:14sort of thing. So that'd be a good example of
- 25:17how to combine a sneaker with a power bank. Now
- 25:21I'm going to give you a challenge. I'm going
- 25:23to give you two sets of words and I want you
- 25:27to, we're going to take, you know, five minutes.
- 25:32or thereabouts. And I want you to use your imagination
- 25:36and come up with an invention that puts together
- 25:43these two words. And here are the two words,
- 25:45two sets of words. And the two words are bicycle
- 25:52and bakery or umbrella and library. I don't want
- 25:58you to go to AI or go to outside sources. I want
- 26:04you to just think about what does a bicycle do?
- 26:08How could I combine it with something that has
- 26:10to do with a bakery and what a bakery does? Ditto
- 26:15for umbrella and library. If you like one more
- 26:18than the other, just do one. If you get stuck,
- 26:21move to the other. But see what you can come
- 26:23up with in terms of a bisociation between these
- 26:28two words, a new invention that is triggered
- 26:31by these two unrelated words. And we'll take
- 26:34five minutes to see what you can come up with.
- 27:39Am I talking? Just to let you know, please put
- 27:43them in the chat. So without attribution, we'll
- 27:47just share your ideas and looking forward to
- 27:51seeing what you come up with. And just to let
- 28:54you know, the way to share your answers is to
- 28:57type them into the Q &A. Thanks. Okay, so hi,
- 32:24everybody. Okay, hi, everybody. We have some
- 32:29great answers that I want to share with you.
- 32:32So one is, and this is the bike one, a bike that
- 32:41upon pedaling generates heat to power an oven
- 32:46to bake the bread. And that's terrific. It's
- 32:50a great way of thinking about it. That's what
- 32:52bikes do. They create energy, and that energy
- 32:55can be used to bake bread, which is the bakery
- 32:58one. For the umbrella library, an outdoor screen
- 33:03use is difficult because of sun glare. Create
- 33:06an umbrella -like portable screen with a projector
- 33:10attached, connected to passive reading content
- 33:13for outdoor reading. Again, great one, so that's
- 33:17terrific. Umbrella is a light, something solar
- 33:25panel, which stores energy to power reading lights
- 33:30used for reading books. Another great one. Here's
- 33:38something very different and very creative. Bike
- 33:44and bakery. Use a rotating system to display
- 33:51different types of bread like like in the sushi
- 33:54bar so that you're in a bakery and this this
- 33:58notion of rotating which comes from the bike
- 34:00is is is um rotating the the uh you know pastries
- 34:08etc we just grab it uh pop up a book with 3d
- 34:13illustrations like umbrella pops open great so
- 34:16very you open up the book and uh and up pops
- 34:21up like an umbrella, other kinds of things. There's
- 34:29a new book somebody wrote in. I love the discussion
- 34:32about creative thinking, a new book called Inspiration
- 34:35by a Dutch neuroscientist. Where do the best
- 34:42ideas come from? The unconscious. He gives examples
- 34:45of Newton, Einstein, Picasso, and Mozart, etc.
- 34:48So thank you for that tip too. I think that's
- 34:52everything here. I'll give you some I came across,
- 34:58one is the idea of, it's akin to the oven, but
- 35:04you can use a bicycle to proof the yeast. It
- 35:12might be one. Another might be you're riding
- 35:15a bicycle and you're commuting and you're trying
- 35:19to drink your coffee and whatever, so you have
- 35:21a a tray and you can put your pastry down on
- 35:24the tray. It has a hole for your coffee. It's
- 35:28aerodynamic. Again, combining those two things.
- 35:33The umbrella one and the library, especially
- 35:37if you live in New York, it can rain anytime.
- 35:42for no reason whatsoever. Not in the forecast,
- 35:45and now it's raining. So it's the idea of you
- 35:49lend the umbrella. You have umbrella stands where
- 35:52you swipe it with your credit card, you pull
- 35:55out the umbrella. If you don't return it, you
- 35:59get charged, so you return it to the next one,
- 36:01that sort of thing. Or even you open the umbrella,
- 36:05and there's a way that this umbrella with high
- 36:11tech connects to your public library, and you
- 36:16get to listen to an audiobook as you're walking
- 36:19connected to the library. So there you have it.
- 36:23You can think of even metaphors that have not
- 36:26even inventions, but metaphors. So the library,
- 36:29the bicycle and bakery one, the thought that
- 36:32occurred to me is, you know, there are times
- 36:34in a mediation, and that's what I do. I'm a mediator
- 36:37now. You know people are rushing through it and
- 36:42they're trying to get get to the end fast and
- 36:45and then they get there And you know, they're
- 36:46not prepared. They don't have everything they
- 36:48need and the bicycle and bakery thing reminded
- 36:50me of that So so bicycles can move fast. They
- 36:54can dodge traffic. They can go down side streets.
- 36:56They can get to a Destination in oftentimes faster
- 37:03than a car if there's a lot of traffic but the
- 37:07thing about a bicycle is once you get to the
- 37:08bakery you can't you can't carry very much. You
- 37:11certainly can't carry the big sheet cake. And
- 37:15so it's the idea that sometimes it may be better
- 37:19not to take the bicycle because when you get
- 37:23there, you need the right equipment, so to speak,
- 37:30to be able to carry whatever it is that you need
- 37:34to. And carry is metaphoric for, do I have an
- 37:39interpreter? Do I have the contract? Do I have
- 37:43all the kinds of things I need to be able to
- 37:46ink this deal and get it done? So you need the
- 37:49right equipment. So that's what occurred to me.
- 37:53Thank you very much, everybody. Big round of
- 37:55applause for you for participating. Really appreciate
- 37:58it. Okay, so now what I want to do is pivot and
- 38:04talk about The ah so we talked about haha comedy
- 38:08we talked about aha the inventions and discovery
- 38:12and now it's the ah the deep insight the the
- 38:16the understanding The breaking through an emotional
- 38:20barrier and this is and I want to do it in the
- 38:23context of mediation So there are certain themes
- 38:27that are recurring in a mediation Anger is one
- 38:30of them sunken causes another relationships and
- 38:36the all -or -nothing mindset. And I want to go
- 38:39one by one and talk about how there can be metaphors
- 38:44and figure of language that helps us deal with
- 38:47these things. So let's do the first one. Let's
- 38:51do the anger. And people come to mediation and
- 38:56they're oftentimes very angry. And the thing
- 39:00about anger is it can be toxic to you. And it
- 39:07carries a high, high personal cost. So let's
- 39:10just do the first one for a second and talk about
- 39:13the backpack. And it's kind of a common one.
- 39:18Hey, you're carrying a backpack. It's heavy.
- 39:22Let's put it down. It's a common metaphor. What
- 39:27I like to do is talk about a story. And the story
- 39:30I like to tell is a story about two monks who
- 39:34are walking along and they come to a crossing,
- 39:38it's a big river, and they have to cross the
- 39:41river. And waiting at the river, side of the
- 39:45river with them, they come upon a woman who has,
- 39:49you know, a lot of luggage and she's carrying
- 39:52a bunch of stuff and you can walk across the
- 39:58river You know, you have to be careful, but you
- 40:00can. And she's like, oh, always me. I can't make
- 40:05it across the river with all my things. Can you
- 40:08carry it for me? And one of the monks picks up
- 40:11all of her stuff. And, you know, it's not easy,
- 40:15but he does it. And he takes it across the river.
- 40:20He puts it down. She goes one way and the two
- 40:23monks go the other way. And five miles down,
- 40:27the monk that had not done the carrying turns
- 40:31to the monk that carried all her stuff for her
- 40:33and says, I am so angry at her. She's able -bodied.
- 40:40She could have done it, yet she turns to you.
- 40:43You're elderly. It's harder for you. We both
- 40:46are. And she's taking advantage, and she's selfish,
- 40:51and she's just disrespectful. I just can't even
- 40:55believe she did this. First monk said, you know,
- 40:59it's interesting. I let her baggage down five
- 41:04miles ago and you're still carrying it. And I
- 41:08think it's a powerful story. It's sort of, you
- 41:11know, sometimes you tell a story as opposed to
- 41:14just, hey, you know, maybe it's time to put down
- 41:15the backpack. Some of these are used a lot. The
- 41:19rent -free one is used a lot. The poison pill
- 41:22is used a lot. The high interest credit card
- 41:25I came across recently and I love it and I think
- 41:29it's brilliant. So it's the idea that holding
- 41:34on to anger is like paying high interest on a
- 41:40credit card balance to fund a business that has
- 41:44already gone under. And it just to me really
- 41:48reached me. It's oh yeah, you know, I'm paying
- 41:52for this. And for what? What I'm so angry about,
- 41:57whether it's a relationship or a contract or
- 41:59a deal, whatever it is that I'm upset about,
- 42:03it's over. Why am I paying it? It's like anger.
- 42:07Why do I keep doing this? It's hurting me. So
- 42:11that a moment where you can get to somebody and
- 42:14say, it's not worth it. You're hurting yourself,
- 42:17not the other person. That's the poison pill
- 42:20thing. So I encourage you to use those kinds
- 42:25of things when dealing with a client, if that's
- 42:28what you're dealing with in a mediation, or even
- 42:31in life. Also, it's the idea that anger, what
- 42:38does it do and what does it need to do? So not
- 42:43just in terms of it's hurting you, it's leading
- 42:48you the wrong way. It's telling you something
- 42:51is wrong, but you should not let the anger choose
- 42:55a destination. It also magnifies the injury,
- 42:59so that's all you see. You don't see anything
- 43:02else. And another metaphor is it's a smoke alarm.
- 43:06You know something's wrong. There's definitely
- 43:08a problem, and so you need to be cognizant of
- 43:11that, but it doesn't tell you how to solve it.
- 43:14So don't use a smoke alarm. You can use it for
- 43:18saying, look, I got a problem. But smoke alarm
- 43:21is not going to put out the fire. So reframing
- 43:25anger that way, I think, is very, very helpful.
- 43:29The next one I want to talk about is sunken costs
- 43:33or sunk costs. So you oftentimes get someone
- 43:38to say, I can't settle now because I've already
- 43:42invested $75 ,000 in attorney's fees and $30
- 43:47,000 in costs. and I need to get that money back,
- 43:52or I put in so much time and so much aggravation,
- 43:56I'm not settling now, all of that will have gone
- 43:59in vain. And you can tell them, and do tell them,
- 44:07look, there's something called the sunk cost
- 44:10fallacy, where you're looking at what happened
- 44:15before, but the right question to ask is, that's
- 44:19gone, look forward and say, you know, what am
- 44:23I willing to risk? Everything should be forward
- 44:26looking. But a good way of talking about that
- 44:30is, wait, hold on a second. I'm gonna tell you
- 44:37a good way of talking about it in a second. This
- 44:42is what I have by way of comments, because I
- 44:44told you I wanted to do that. The first is the
- 44:47metaphor of bike and bakery works well in mediation.
- 44:50Some conversations and analysis is quick, but
- 44:54it takes time to let ideas percolate, slow down,
- 44:57and think about the options. Bread takes time
- 45:01to prepare and bake. The metaphor, fast and slow,
- 45:05it's Kahneman's idea about thinking fast and
- 45:08thinking slow, and that's his book. And that's
- 45:10very, very good, and it's a very, very thoughtful
- 45:13response. The next one is David Hoffman uses
- 45:18the metaphor of parents in the front seat of
- 45:21a car with two kids in the back seat. The rear
- 45:24view mirror is very small compared to the windshield
- 45:27in front of you. Don't spend time looking in
- 45:31the rear view mirror. You can't change what happened
- 45:33in the past, but you have agency to move forward
- 45:37to the future. you control the direction of the
- 45:40future. And that's very, very sound. And that
- 45:44rear view mirror is also a common metaphor that
- 45:47people use. I use it when someone's perseverating
- 45:51over what happened in the past. So they just
- 45:55can't get past it. They'll talk about the harm
- 45:58and the injury and the evil thing that the other
- 46:04side did. and they can't get past it. So it's
- 46:08not very helpful to say, hey, you know, we've
- 46:11gone over that before, let's move on. That's
- 46:13not a kind or gentle thing to say and it won't
- 46:15work. But what you can say is, you know, we're
- 46:19looking in the rear view mirror and I get that.
- 46:23But if we want to get to your next destination,
- 46:26the place that you need to get to, we have to
- 46:29look forward, which is a much kinder and gentler
- 46:32way of saying it. So thank you for that. Okay,
- 46:36so in terms of sunken costs, yeah, it's looking
- 46:39at what I spent before. It's like in Vietnam,
- 46:44we sent in 20 ,000 troops, 20 ,000 troops died
- 46:47in this war. We don't want their death to be
- 46:51in vain. Let's send in 40 ,000 more. So some
- 46:56costs are done. And what you have to do to protect
- 47:02yourself is not look backward but look forward
- 47:05and saying, looking forward, what are my chances?
- 47:14What is my risk analysis? What am I willing to
- 47:17lose? What do I think the gain will be? Not worry
- 47:21about what's already been lost. And a metaphor
- 47:25for that, a bi -association metaphor, is emergency
- 47:29medicine. saying, look, you know, it's like someone,
- 47:34you know, something happened, you have sepsis,
- 47:39you know, your arm is all infected. We can try
- 47:43to save your arm, but we have a large, large
- 47:49risk that you're going to die if we don't amputate
- 47:53it. So we amputate a part what's been lost to
- 47:59save the whole. to be able to move forward and
- 48:02save what's remained. And that's a bi -association
- 48:06metaphor. The next one I want to talk about is
- 48:11relationships. So there are lots of cases that
- 48:16have relationships. It's oftentimes family relationships,
- 48:20sometimes it's other kinds of relationships,
- 48:22business relationships, and that sort of thing.
- 48:25Family's the closest one. So whether we're talking
- 48:28about an estate and dividing assets or family
- 48:33business and the siblings are all fighting with
- 48:35each other. And so one frame is this financial
- 48:39decision that has to be made about dividing assets.
- 48:43But another frame is the legacy, right? Where
- 48:46did this money come from? Where did this family
- 48:49business come from? And it came from your parents.
- 48:53And your parents started the family business
- 48:55and your parents worked really hard to create
- 48:58these assets for you. And what would it be like
- 49:03for them to be here and to see what they hope
- 49:06would be a gift to you being the thing that's
- 49:09destroying their family and try to bring in the
- 49:14parent and what would the parent want. And so
- 49:19that's how I do, you know, family disputes and
- 49:23try to bring in something bigger and more important.
- 49:26It can be the same thing with business or friendships
- 49:30or whatever. And I want to talk about kintsuki.
- 49:36And kintsuki is a Japanese word that reframes
- 49:44the value of something broken. So the art of
- 49:48kintsuki is when something breaks, they put it
- 49:52back together and they dust it with and this
- 49:55gold powder and the cracks are not hidden and
- 49:59they don't disappear but rather they become part
- 50:02of of whatever broke and the Japanese view is
- 50:06it doesn't make it less attractive it makes it
- 50:10more attractive and they embrace those changes
- 50:14and so when someone says it'll never be the same
- 50:17I'll never talk to my siblings the same you can
- 50:19say look that may be the way it feels now and
- 50:22it may not be the same But it doesn't mean that
- 50:26it can't be good and you can't get value from
- 50:29it and talk about this Kintsuki idea. Related
- 50:32to it is wabi -sabi, which is another Japanese
- 50:36sort of spiritual approach, which is to embrace
- 50:41imperfection. Imperfection is beautiful and it's
- 50:48there. It's a worldview. It's finding peace and
- 50:53beauty in imperfection. simplicity and the natural
- 50:56passage of time. The last thing I want to talk
- 51:00to you about is that's my number. I'm not budging
- 51:05and it's a ridiculous number, either ridiculously
- 51:08high or ridiculously low, but it's just clearly
- 51:12not going to do it. You're trying to figure out
- 51:17a way through it. And maybe the way through it
- 51:20is, look, you know, when you stand by a, this
- 51:23is my number, take it or leave it, I'm not moving.
- 51:27And they oftentimes do this early on in the mediation.
- 51:30It's not like after a long -term back and forth,
- 51:33it's early on, that's it, that's what I came
- 51:36with. I'm not coming with anything more or less.
- 51:39You can say, look, what you're doing is building
- 51:41a wall and you're defending that wall. I want
- 51:46you to rethink this and think of this as a suspension
- 51:49bridge. And you're at one side, they're at the
- 51:53other side. There's treacherous water underneath.
- 51:57And the treacherous water is years of litigation,
- 52:04of costs, of aggravation, of mistime, and of
- 52:11potential loss. So I want you to think of this
- 52:15as a bridge where what we need is flexibility
- 52:19and a engineering solution. And that's not weakness.
- 52:28That's flexibility. And let's see what happens.
- 52:33Let's see if we can build that bridge. And that
- 52:36may be a way through it. Sometimes it isn't.
- 52:40None of this stuff is foolproof. I think all
- 52:46of it is an art. And I think the important things
- 52:52are the following. And these are the do's and
- 52:56don'ts. So most important is being sensitive
- 53:00to the needs of the participants. The thing that
- 53:03I said about if your participant doesn't like
- 53:06food, use a different metaphor. Listen, listen
- 53:11closely to what they're saying. Try to jump into
- 53:13their metaphor. Don't use old hackneyed expressions.
- 53:18They're called dead metaphors. Don't use obscure
- 53:22references that three people in the world understand.
- 53:26Don't mix your metaphors. Listen really, really
- 53:32attentively. Use language that you think relates
- 53:38to the words and feelings that the participants
- 53:42have. And I think most importantly, build the
- 53:46foundation. You have to establish trust and rapport
- 53:49and likeability. So it's important just to be
- 53:53aware, and you'll make mistakes, and then you
- 53:56apologize, that's all. It's we all do, and you
- 54:00retrace it. Well, you do whatever you're accused
- 54:03of doing. You say, I'm really sorry that it felt
- 54:07that way. really, really, really sorry. Let's
- 54:10restart this. Because those things are very,
- 54:16very important. I'll answer other questions.
- 54:22Are there any other questions? Let me take a
- 54:26look. One second. This All or Nothing Mindset,
- 54:31an example of Cialdini. Cialdini wrote Weapons
- 54:34of Influence. It's a very good book. commitment
- 54:36and consistency. The lawyer has made a public
- 54:39comment to a position to change that commitment
- 54:42may be embarrassing. The lawyer wants to be consistent
- 54:45with a prior commitment. There are ways to redirect
- 54:48commitments to allow the lawyer to look to back
- 54:51off on the prior commitment. Lots of interesting
- 54:53articles on this topic. Great, great suggestion.
- 54:57Great, great shout out to Chaldini as well. And
- 55:00I highly, it's a really good YouTube video. on
- 55:05his weapons of influence, that's just terrific.
- 55:10So I recommend that to you. Let's see. In my
- 55:15mediation yesterday, and I told the lawyer I
- 55:18would do this, he was really stressed. He had
- 55:20a lot going on. Half the time, he wasn't even
- 55:23there. It was on Zoom. He was like, where is
- 55:26he? He had a lot going on. And he had an arbitration
- 55:32starting, and he's under a lot of pressure. And
- 55:34I said to him, you know, it feels like, you know,
- 55:37you're really stretched to the max here. This
- 55:41case is challenging. You have a lot of pressure.
- 55:45You know, how are you managing? And he answered
- 55:49with some humor and a metaphor. He said, well,
- 55:52just like a kidney stone, this too shall pass.
- 55:56And so I leave you with that. I don't think there
- 56:00are any other questions. So over and out on my
- 56:03part. And thank you so, so much for your participation
- 56:06and your great thoughts. Really appreciate it.
- 56:10Bye now.