Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Disney and OpenAI Make a Deal: The Paradigm Shift in AI Content Licensing & Litigation Risk
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everyone. I'm Randi Bandman. And on behalf
- 0:03of the Entertainment Law section of the Beverly
- 0:05Hills Bar Association, welcome you to today's
- 0:08program, Disney and OpenAI Make a Deal, where
- 0:12Julia Turlow of Birdmarella LLP and David Schrage,
- 0:17the media mediator, will examine the pivotal
- 0:20licensing deal recently announced by Disney and
- 0:23OpenAI, how it reshapes the future of AI -generated
- 0:26content and the potential industry implications
- 0:29as the story unfolds. Julia Cherlov is a partner
- 0:34at Bird Marella and a nationally recognized entertainment
- 0:37trial attorney who represents guilds, talent,
- 0:40and other IP owners and bet the company disputes.
- 0:44Her practice spans cutting edge issues at the
- 0:46intersection of entertainment, technology, and
- 0:49intellectual property, including high profile
- 0:52litigation involving film, television, and digital
- 0:56media. David Shraga is a mediator, specializing
- 1:01in entertainment, media, and intellectual property,
- 1:04drawing on more than 20 years of legal experience
- 1:07in Los Angeles. His background includes work
- 1:09as both an entertainment and IP litigator and
- 1:12a senior in -house executive at Maramax and NBC
- 1:15Universal, where he developed deep expertise
- 1:18across film, television, and streaming. Thank
- 1:21you, Julia and David. Thank you so much, Randi,
- 1:26for that lovely introduction. Julie, it's a pleasure
- 1:28to be here with you. Absolutely. Your credentials
- 1:32are a tough act to follow, but I'm going to try
- 1:33and keep up with you. And I think really, though,
- 1:37what your resume speaks to is the really multifaceted
- 1:40perspective that you bring to this conversation.
- 1:42And I think that's part of what makes your insights
- 1:44so valuable into this conversation we're going
- 1:46to be having today about a really high stakes
- 1:48issue in Hollywood and in the litigation world
- 1:51that involves a spectrum of stakeholders like
- 1:53the folks I think you represent. And so maybe
- 1:57I could set the stage here for our audience today
- 2:00very quickly. Obviously, for the past couple
- 2:04of years, we've been in a world where AI companies
- 2:06like OpenAI, Anthropic, Meta, Google. are in
- 2:11a race against each other to develop these generative
- 2:14AI tools, and they are changing the industry,
- 2:17and they are, of course, changing our world in
- 2:19myriad ways. And as they charge forward, a slew
- 2:23of lawsuits have been filed against these companies
- 2:26involving copyright claims and other legal theories
- 2:30where they're basically being sued for using,
- 2:32in a host of different ways, the IP that's owned
- 2:35by third parties without their permission or
- 2:38payment. This includes suits by authors, by publishers,
- 2:45by our own big Hollywood studios here in town,
- 2:48including Disney, NBCU, Warner Brothers, and
- 2:51others who have brought these claims. And I know
- 2:53we're going to talk more about this in detail
- 2:54as we keep going. And so. On December 11th, 2025,
- 2:59just before the holidays, the story took its
- 3:01latest big turn when Disney and OpenAI announced,
- 3:05in their own words, a landmark agreement to work
- 3:08together and bring Disney's beloved characters
- 3:11to OpenAI's Sora platform. And of course, It
- 3:16seems like there's new announcements virtually
- 3:18on a daily basis in terms of what's happening
- 3:20in the world of AI collaboration in terms of
- 3:23these lawsuits that have been filed and moving
- 3:26through the courts. And obviously, this is a
- 3:28deal that's groundbreaking. It's reverberating
- 3:30through our industry. And we're going to dig
- 3:32into data to what it means for. for the entertainment
- 3:35industry and this ongoing litigation involving
- 3:37AI as well. So I thought that maybe we could
- 3:40start out by saying or talking about what is
- 3:43this deal between Disney and open AI really?
- 3:46I mean, are we talking about a licensing deal
- 3:48for our purposes or seems like maybe there's
- 3:50something more limited and strategic that's going
- 3:52on here. Absolutely, David. And thank you for
- 3:55your kind words and introduction. It's really
- 3:58an honor for me to be able to have this conversation
- 4:01with you, given your decades of experience in
- 4:04the field. And I look forward to a lively conversation
- 4:08about this. So the Disney Open AI Deal. There
- 4:14are still many questions because it has not yet
- 4:17been rolled out and we don't know all the specific
- 4:19nitty -gritty But we do know generally the material
- 4:23deal points that have been agreed to and so to
- 4:27your question Is this a licensing deal for all
- 4:29purposes? Absolutely not. This is it I look at
- 4:34this as Disney. It's kind of sticking its toe
- 4:38into the AI pool while still preserving a lot
- 4:42of control as opposed to just a wholesale grant
- 4:46of use of its, you know, jealously guarded IP.
- 4:49I mean, Disney in particular is known for how
- 4:53carefully It has protected and policed its IP
- 4:57over the years. And so initially, when I heard
- 4:59about the deal, I was a bit surprised that Disney
- 5:02was the first mover. But we'll get into a little
- 5:06bit more of that over the course of our conversation.
- 5:08I think it makes a lot of sense for Disney for
- 5:11a number of reasons to be the first mover in
- 5:15this space. But we can talk maybe through some
- 5:18of the deal points of the deal. First off, the
- 5:22term of the deal. So it's a three -year term.
- 5:26I believe it's scheduled to begin in early 2026.
- 5:32I continue to go on to open AI. And I don't know
- 5:35if you've experimented with this at all, David,
- 5:37to see if anything's available yet. But not quite
- 5:41yet. I'm sure that there are a lot of deal lawyers,
- 5:45transactional lawyers, billing around the clock,
- 5:48analyzing all these terms. Must be a lot of fine
- 5:52points they're still working out, because as
- 5:53you mentioned, they announced the deal in December,
- 5:56but they basically said they're still working
- 5:58on papering this long form effectively, which
- 6:00I think is probably going to be a very nuanced
- 6:02and complicated agreement that's going to have
- 6:04to evolve given the terms that we're talking
- 6:06about. Absolutely. Absolutely. There's so many
- 6:12unknowns. I do not envy those transactional attorneys
- 6:17trying to build for the future to protect this
- 6:20very valuable IP. So the term of the agreement
- 6:25is three years. And what has been licensed to
- 6:30OpenAI is about 200 different characters and
- 6:34creative elements that are Disney, Marvel, Pixar,
- 6:40and Star Wars. elements, and this includes everything
- 6:44from props to costumes, vehicles used within
- 6:49these universes, and even iconic environments.
- 6:53It's really the holy grail of the Disney IP we're
- 6:56talking about in terms of these characters. Absolutely,
- 6:59absolutely. I don't know about you, but I look
- 7:04forward to experimenting with it myself. Absolutely.
- 7:08But so maybe it's interesting to also to highlight
- 7:12what's not involved or included in these deal
- 7:14terms. Well, one thing in particular for former
- 7:19likenesses or voices, those are not included.
- 7:23And for obvious reasons, I think that Disney
- 7:26was trying to create a deal where it didn't have
- 7:30to deal with any issues of. complicated chains
- 7:37of ownership, whereas here it's relatively straightforward,
- 7:42200 characters or creative elements that it owns
- 7:46whole cloth and has the ability to control. Yeah,
- 7:51it's an interesting aspect of the Disney business
- 7:54specifically because so much of it is based upon
- 7:57copyrighted characters and animated works and
- 7:59they typically are created on a work -for -hire
- 8:01basis. performers who are involved in the scripted
- 8:06programming that they do and some of the voice
- 8:07work, but they really sort of have tried to separate
- 8:10that out. And I think that puts to the side,
- 8:12at least for now, dealing with a lot of complicated
- 8:14permission issues like you mentioned, but guild
- 8:16issues as well that come into play when we talk
- 8:19about involving these performers too. Absolutely.
- 8:23Absolutely. And so it seems like What folks will
- 8:27be able to do is create these short user -prompted
- 8:30videos making use of the Disney IP and also create
- 8:35images based on user prompts of the IP. But this
- 8:40is not going to be full -scale commercial exploitation
- 8:44of the IP at all. Yeah, so what's really fascinating
- 8:48about this deal is it takes us into really a
- 8:50whole new world, where the users are able to
- 8:53access this underlying IP and create their own
- 8:56works. And I know there's been discussion by
- 8:58Bob Iger, and it's been announced at CES and
- 9:00some other places along the way that this is
- 9:03going to provide an opportunity for some of this
- 9:05content to be on Disney+. And so maybe it's worth
- 9:10talking about. this new dynamic when it comes
- 9:14to using Disney's IP and sort of regulating this,
- 9:18because obviously with these licensing deals
- 9:20and from the studio perspective, what's so important
- 9:23to these studios is gonna be exercising control
- 9:26and making sure that the licensed content is
- 9:28something that they're comfortable with. How
- 9:30do you think about those issues and how does
- 9:32Disney actually control use of its IP at AI scale?
- 9:37Right. Well, what I think about is there are
- 9:40going to be disputes arising all over the place
- 9:44because this is a very, very hard thing to control.
- 9:48The deal has been announced that Disney will
- 9:51be able to retain control. And how that gets
- 9:55done, again, relates back to what we were talking
- 9:58about earlier as far as the transactional attorneys
- 10:00who are hammering out the deal points. My guess
- 10:03is that OpenAI will be on the hook for regulating
- 10:09exploitation on Sora on the site, and that Disney
- 10:13will then retain the obligation to regulate the
- 10:18exploitation of any content created on Sora that's
- 10:21then used elsewhere. But how they do that, I
- 10:27mean, there are a number of open AI can regulate
- 10:30prompts and have regulations kind of on the front
- 10:35end of what is allowed to be created. But I mean,
- 10:40regulating at this scale where you know, it's
- 10:45very different from regulating in the environment
- 10:47that we have been working in. So it remains to
- 10:52be seen where where we go. Yeah, I mean, historically,
- 10:57when you're when you're licensing your IP, you
- 10:59have approval over the deliverables that are
- 11:02being created and put out there into a dynamic
- 11:06where What are those deliverables going to look
- 11:09like, and who's actually creating them? It's
- 11:11a whole new set of considerations. But I have
- 11:14to believe that the technology that's available
- 11:17internally at these platforms is something that
- 11:18they're talking about so that they can really
- 11:20collaborate to make this something that's effective,
- 11:24but also doesn't sort of overregulate and over
- 11:26control what's being done by the fans. Because
- 11:29fundamentally, they're going to be driving this,
- 11:31and they're the ones who are going to be uplifting
- 11:34all of this content. Absolutely. I think it really
- 11:38is going to require a intelligent and carefully
- 11:42thought through set of ground rules that allow
- 11:45users to create content that stays within the
- 11:50guardrails of what Disney has in mind as far
- 11:52as how it wants its IP to be used. But again,
- 11:55not overly regulating, take the fun out of what
- 11:59users want to do with this opportunity. What's
- 12:05really interesting to me though David on this
- 12:07issue is that who owns the content after it has
- 12:13been created. I know that historically users
- 12:18have owned the content that they created on Sora.
- 12:22Now obviously Disney's going to retain ownership
- 12:25over the underlying IP and I don't think that
- 12:28they have disclosed yet exactly how they're going
- 12:31to formulate their terms of service as far as
- 12:35what rights users do have to the content that
- 12:40they create and whether they can then exploit
- 12:43it downstream. But to a point you said earlier,
- 12:49there have been announcements about potential
- 12:51exploitation of content created by users on Disney
- 12:54+, which I think is interesting. and problematic
- 12:59for a number of reasons. I mean, there's only
- 13:03so much. It's going to be taking the space of
- 13:12content that folks in the guilds that I represent
- 13:16are out there creating and trying to sell. It's
- 13:21taking air time away, which is very concerning
- 13:24for the guilds. How is that even going to work?
- 13:30Are the users who have created these Sora content,
- 13:36are they going to be paid a license fee for exhibition
- 13:40of their work on Disney Plus? Are they going
- 13:46to be able to exhibit their content elsewhere
- 13:50on YouTube? Are there going to be issues then?
- 13:55with exclusivity. It's very interesting. And
- 13:59for us still to learn how these are going to
- 14:04be regulated. I think you hit on a really fascinating
- 14:07issue and an important trend creatively, right?
- 14:11Because if you ask Ted Serendous at Netflix,
- 14:13who his biggest competition is, he says it's
- 14:16YouTube. And so, you know, this world, the influencer
- 14:19economy that we're in, the world of user generated
- 14:22content is exploding. It's a new place for fans
- 14:25and creators to go to interact with each other.
- 14:29And to your point, you know, Disney being a first
- 14:31mover in this area, it's showing that interest
- 14:33in trying to exploit these trends and stay ahead
- 14:36of it in a way. But, you know, from the copyright
- 14:39lawyer perspective, from the creative perspective,
- 14:41the guild perspective, I mean, what happens if
- 14:44one of these users is creating something that's
- 14:46derivative of a Star Wars property, for example,
- 14:49but they create something completely new and
- 14:52out of whole cloth, as we might say, right? A
- 14:54new character, something entirely new. Who owns
- 14:56that? And then how does that get exploited? And
- 14:59are they going to be compensated for that? So
- 15:02and to your point as well, there's always this
- 15:04concern that the more attention is going into
- 15:07these areas, the more money is going into these
- 15:09areas, the less money there is and attention
- 15:10there is for the traditional creator economy
- 15:12that we know here in Hollywood. So important
- 15:15not just creatively right in terms of the actors
- 15:17and writers producers who we work with and love
- 15:19but But the people who work in town and who support
- 15:22these productions from a physical production
- 15:24perspective we get absolutely Absolutely, I live
- 15:28in Burbank and a lot of parents of my kids friends
- 15:32Are very concerned about where things are headed
- 15:35and for exactly the reasons that you just described
- 15:39The question is, why now? And why is Disney doing
- 15:42it now? What has the response been? But I think
- 15:44you've kind of hit on that in terms of why there's
- 15:47such a tension here. And obviously, as we're
- 15:48going into this new season of guild negotiations,
- 15:52the renegotiations of all the guild agreements,
- 15:54I think this is probably something that people
- 15:57are paying very close attention to over within
- 15:59the guild space. Absolutely. Absolutely. To the
- 16:04question, though, of why now? I think that it
- 16:07was strategically really interesting for Disney
- 16:10to take this step and be the first mover. I think
- 16:17there are a lot of reasons why it was a good
- 16:19move for Disney, given that after its launch
- 16:24Sora really has not taken off in the way that
- 16:28I think that Open Eye had hoped it would, at
- 16:30least initially before it shifted into an opt
- 16:35-in type approach as opposed to an opt -out approach
- 16:38for use of IP. And so Disney, as a first mover
- 16:43and given that Sora has been in a somewhat more
- 16:47vulnerable position, had a lot of leverage so
- 16:50that it could extract as good of a deal for itself
- 16:54as possible, including, and this is one of the
- 16:57terms that we didn't cover earlier, only one
- 17:00year of exclusivity with open AI over the three
- 17:04-year term, the other two years, it's a non -exclusive
- 17:06use of the Disney IP. So potentially Disney is
- 17:11thinking about additional deals with other generative
- 17:16AI players. I'm assuming they're probably already
- 17:19in talks about this given that the terms here
- 17:24have already, you know, are allowing for non
- 17:27-exclusivity. And so It really made a lot of
- 17:37sense for Disney. Also, I think that it strengthens
- 17:41its litigation position in connection with its
- 17:45lawsuit against Mid Journey, which you referenced
- 17:48at the start of the podcast. That is a suit where
- 17:53Disney is suing, with a number of other players,
- 17:56NBC Universal, Warner Brothers, for... both use
- 18:01of IP in the training of the AI and also copying
- 18:06in the outputs of the AI. And here, Disney is
- 18:11showing, OK, this is how you do it here. This
- 18:16is how you can actually contractually work with
- 18:20the generative AI company and create guardrails
- 18:24upon use and actually a contract for the use
- 18:30of our IP as opposed to the exact opposite of
- 18:33what Mid Journey did. Right. So you're getting
- 18:37into a really fascinating area within the litigation
- 18:39landscape now, which is this distinction between
- 18:42training and outputs, right? And maybe you could
- 18:46speak to sort of how the deal itself deals with
- 18:49that because it's not covered, right? Sure, absolutely.
- 18:53And I think Disney was very careful in this in
- 18:56order to kind of protect its litigation position,
- 19:00particularly in this mid -journey lawsuit. So
- 19:04it has licensed the use of the IP for outputs
- 19:09for these user -generated videos, but it has
- 19:13absolutely prohibited the use of OpenAI to use
- 19:18the Disney IP to train. the IP and that distinction
- 19:24is critical and it also cabins the impact of
- 19:30this deal on the ongoing copyright disputes.
- 19:35It's not like this deal is now dispositive or
- 19:39defines what is fair use. Those questions are
- 19:42still absolutely churning in the courts. But
- 19:46it does provide a framework and shows that there
- 19:52is a market that exists for IP holders to directly
- 19:59work with the generative AI companies for permissive
- 20:04use of the IP, which really hadn't been done
- 20:07before. a tremendous development in terms of
- 20:13the litigation, and I think what all the parties
- 20:15to these cases are thinking about. And so what
- 20:17I hear you saying is, in the context of these
- 20:20copyright infringement lawsuits that have been
- 20:21filed in Northern California, for example, and
- 20:24all throughout the country, and really throughout
- 20:26the country, there's sort of two theories and
- 20:28two pieces that are going on. One is that the
- 20:30owners of this IP are suing and they're saying,
- 20:33you're training your large language models and
- 20:35ingesting our content without our and consent,
- 20:38and that's a copyright infringement. And of course,
- 20:40the defenses from OpenAI itself and these other
- 20:44platforms is, well, it's a fair use, and it's
- 20:47a transformative use, and there's a lot of analysis
- 20:49that goes into that. But they're basically saying,
- 20:51we have the right to do this under copyright
- 20:53law. We don't need your permission or consent.
- 20:55And then the other part of these suits is they're
- 20:57talking about what the outputs look like, so
- 20:59that if you actually input a Disney character
- 21:02into like Mid -Journey's platform, for example,
- 21:04which is not part of this deal, then you can
- 21:07create a Darth Vader in a different context,
- 21:10right? And you can create output themselves are
- 21:13potentially substantially similar within the
- 21:15language of the statutes and infringing too.
- 21:18So it sounds like what you're saying is Disney
- 21:20has really sort of tried to thread the needle
- 21:21here. And on the one hand say, We're still taking
- 21:24the position that training requires our consent
- 21:27and that these are not fair uses within the context
- 21:30of these cases. But when it comes to the output
- 21:34side, we're going to work with you to potentially
- 21:37license our IP. But the two issues bleed together.
- 21:40There's been this conversation about, is there
- 21:43really a market for these works? And I think
- 21:44what you're talking about is. is the fact that
- 21:47this deal does reflect that there is some market.
- 21:50And hasn't that had some impact on sort of what's
- 21:52happening in the litigation already from your
- 21:54perspective? Absolutely. Well, yes, just recently,
- 21:59there's a suit that's going in the Southern District
- 22:05of New York. The author is killed against open
- 22:08AI. they have actually subpoenaed from OpenAI
- 22:16copies of this particular deal, along with a
- 22:20number of other piece of information, correspondence,
- 22:24drafts, et cetera, for that particular reason
- 22:29to prove that there is a market for these licenses
- 22:33and there is an ability for IP holders to contract
- 22:40directly with the generative I companies. And
- 22:43so this deal is very much at issue and could
- 22:48have a great impact on this ongoing piece of
- 22:52litigation. Yeah, it opens up a whole new can
- 22:55of worms really, right? Absolutely. Absolutely.
- 23:00I mean, in Discovery, they learned that OpenAI
- 23:03has taken different positions on how it internally
- 23:06values this IP versus litigation positions it's
- 23:10taken as far as how it considers its position
- 23:18in connection with fair use of the content. It
- 23:21could really blow up the litigation. Yeah, now,
- 23:25of course, we're dealing with very sophisticated
- 23:26parties with very smart lawyers. And I'm sure
- 23:29they're anticipating a lot of these concerns.
- 23:33And to go back to sort of what the deal looks
- 23:35like itself, One of the things that I'm sure
- 23:40they're going to be talking about that's very
- 23:41different and interesting is that this deal also
- 23:43included an opportunity for Disney to invest
- 23:45a billion dollars into OpenAI. Do we know anything
- 23:50about how the deal is structured in terms of
- 23:52Disney's going to be paid for the use of this
- 23:54IP or what that's going to look like? Because
- 23:57I'm sure all those considerations will affect
- 23:59these fair use arguments that are happening in
- 24:01the courts. Absolutely. Understand it seems that
- 24:09disney will be paid through its participation
- 24:12in its investment in open ai and it. Has this
- 24:18one billion dollar investment as well as warrants
- 24:21to purchase greater interest as open ai. Potentially
- 24:27hopefully in disney's mind continues to increase
- 24:30in value and so. Disney is really linking itself
- 24:35to OpenAI's long -term success through the course
- 24:38of this deal. And so Disney will get paid if
- 24:42OpenAI is able to monetize these tools in the
- 24:47ways that it thinks it will be able to. a licensing
- 24:52standpoint, that makes sense. I was thinking
- 24:55about this earlier today. It would be very difficult
- 24:58to come up with some sort of licensing formula
- 25:00for the use of the characters or if it was in
- 25:04any way tied to the specific use of specific
- 25:08characters given that it will be extremely hard
- 25:12to even know given that users have complete control
- 25:20over that. Yeah, this kind of goes back to the
- 25:23technology issue and what sort of tracking and
- 25:25monitoring and policing is going to be available,
- 25:27and how do you tie it back? And I think that
- 25:30presents one of the really thorny issues in this
- 25:32litigation about training itself, right? And
- 25:36how do you value this underlying IP that's being
- 25:39ingested given what the outputs look like? And
- 25:43they may look like the IP. They may look very
- 25:45different in that sense. it seems like there's
- 25:49a consensus from the creative community at least
- 25:51that there's a value that's being contributed
- 25:52but the real question is going to be how do you
- 25:55how do you quantify that and monetize that um
- 26:00yeah and i i think there's another content consensus
- 26:02among the creative community that um this is
- 26:06not a step forward for anyone i know that there
- 26:10have been statements issued by wga and sag aftra
- 26:15that expressing grave concerns about the impact
- 26:18on the creative economy as we were talking about
- 26:21earlier across the board. Yeah, I mean, I think
- 26:24it highlights one of the big tensions that we're
- 26:26dealing with right now is this technology advances
- 26:28and how is it going to be used? How is it going
- 26:30to be incorporated? There's a quality of incorporating
- 26:33it on the production side to make productions
- 26:35more efficient, but then there's the fundamental
- 26:37challenge to how we create in this modern world.
- 26:40And a lot of talent has spoken on that. Do you
- 26:45think that this deal with Disney is a bellwether
- 26:49or an outlier? I mean, do you think the other
- 26:51studios are going to follow Disney's lead? It
- 26:54seems like the train is leaving the station in
- 26:56some sense, but there's a lot of pushback. That's
- 26:59a great question, David. You know, Disney is
- 27:02uniquely suited for some of the reasons that
- 27:04you mentioned earlier. I mean, these are animated
- 27:08works. They're wholly owned by Disney. And in
- 27:14large part, Disney has complete control over
- 27:20licensing, whereas it may not be so easy for
- 27:25other entertainment conglomerates to enter into
- 27:30a deal like this. For example, let's think of
- 27:33Warner Brothers. I'm sure that there's a huge
- 27:36appetite out there for users to be able to access,
- 27:42for example, the universe of Harry Potter, right?
- 27:46But then you're dealing with, okay, well, what
- 27:49rights to Harry Potter does Warner Brothers have?
- 27:53Well, it has the rights to the film, but I'm
- 27:56sure that... it obviously doesn't have rights
- 28:04to the underlying literary works. And so what
- 28:07can Warner Brothers actually license out to a
- 28:11generative AI company? And that's just one example
- 28:16of many. But it really shows that it's going
- 28:19to be complicated for other studios to enter
- 28:22into similar deals. Yeah, I think that's right.
- 28:26And my point was going to say, what does J .K.
- 28:28Rowling have to say about this? Right. Exactly.
- 28:30And to your point originally, this deal excludes
- 28:35the likenesses and the performances of actors
- 28:38that we know and love, but oftentimes those actors
- 28:41and their voices can become very sort of intimately
- 28:44intertwined with the characters themselves. And
- 28:47you can imagine there's gonna be a lot of cases
- 28:48on the edge that are gonna potentially spawn
- 28:51some disputes and some questions about this as
- 28:54well. Absolutely, I see right of publicity cases
- 28:57coming down the pike. The question will be then,
- 29:02who do you go after, right? And I think that
- 29:08OpenAI and Disney are obviously carefully parsing
- 29:13those issues in connection with drafting the
- 29:17terms of these deals. Yeah, and I think that's
- 29:19going to feed into these guild negotiations as
- 29:21well. You know, the guild say that they're carefully
- 29:23watching this. And we certainly see within the
- 29:26context of the music industry, more collaborations
- 29:28evolving for the use of underlying music compositions
- 29:32by these platforms. And I think the details on
- 29:36how the artists are going to be compensated are
- 29:38still murky, we should say. you know, from the
- 29:42perspective of someone who's a mediator and yet
- 29:44you're a litigator, you know, we often work together
- 29:46to craft solutions that involve a more collaborative
- 29:50approach. And I think that, you know, this partnership
- 29:55between Disney and AI is a good example of what
- 29:59the parties can come up with themselves when
- 30:02they're trying to be cooperative and effectively
- 30:04make the pie bigger and things that they can
- 30:06come up with that you can't get from a judge
- 30:08in court, right? And so, think that these guild
- 30:12negotiations are going to be another opportunity
- 30:14to talk about how can we make the pie bigger?
- 30:17I was at the UCLA conference last summer, I think,
- 30:20and there was a gentleman at OpenAI who was sitting
- 30:22on the stage who was involved in these types
- 30:24of partnerships. And what they're trying to say
- 30:27is that there's a responsible way to collaborate,
- 30:30to exploit this IP, to work with the artists,
- 30:33to support the creative community. And they want
- 30:35to be at the forefront of that dialogue. And
- 30:38this is definitely, I think, an example of of
- 30:40them making that effort. People have different
- 30:42opinions on whether or not. But certainly, it
- 30:46reflects the new reality we're in. Absolutely.
- 30:49I mean, AI is not going anywhere. It's a reality
- 30:52that we all have to grapple with. And as you
- 30:55said, we're going to get some answers from the
- 30:57courts about what is fair use and what's not.
- 31:00But in the meantime, I take some hope in this
- 31:09collaboration between Disney and OpenAI to potentially
- 31:15work together and create something really exciting
- 31:18and new that doesn't trespass on Disney's IP
- 31:23and also doesn't trespass on creators' rights
- 31:28to their content. And this is by no means Just
- 31:33positive the the fight will go on but uh and
- 31:38it will be interesting to see how the rollout
- 31:41actually goes once it happens but uh we shall
- 31:46see. I mean it's as you said earlier on there's
- 31:49often a lot more questions than there are answers
- 31:51when we have these types of conversations and
- 31:54it seems like there's maybe a movement towards
- 31:55the towards a landscape that involves more consent
- 31:59and permissions and compensation in certain respects,
- 32:02at least. But I guess just maybe to close out
- 32:06this conversation, what do you think that non
- 32:09-entertainment lawyers should take away from
- 32:11this deal and where things are headed in this
- 32:16area? Sure. Well, I think that this is not about
- 32:22whether or not AI will exist. It's a first stab.
- 32:25I see as a major IP holder venturing into the
- 32:29space while still trying to retain control and
- 32:33consent over its IP. You know, it's risk allocation
- 32:38given this uncertain environment and it doesn't
- 32:43end the copyright wars, we'll still have those
- 32:45ongoing, but it does show how powerful players
- 32:49like Disney and OpenAI are positioning themselves
- 32:53To continue forward while these wars are still
- 32:55being fought Yeah, and I think it really demonstrates
- 32:58it's it's better to be at the table than not
- 33:00when it comes to having these conversations and
- 33:03obviously being a part of these lawsuits and
- 33:05uh And we'll see how things develop. Well, uh,
- 33:08julia. Thank you so much for a fantastic conversation
- 33:10Do you have any any parting thoughts or predictions
- 33:12or uh again? I give you can I give you the final
- 33:14word in terms? Sure Absolutely. Well, I think
- 33:17we've been alluding to it throughout the proof
- 33:19is in the pudding and um I know that Disney and
- 33:24opening, I have the best intentions to make this
- 33:27work, but I do see many avenues of potential
- 33:31dispute arising as we move forward. Yeah. Yeah.
- 33:35I think there's a lot of stakeholders who are
- 33:37going to be watching very closely, very closely
- 33:39is from the talent community, from the from the
- 33:43technology community and beyond. So thank you
- 33:46very much, Julia Ciarlo, for your contributions
- 33:48today and obviously sharing your expertise and
- 33:50your insight. It's been a pleasure to have the
- 33:52conversation with you, and we'll look forward
- 33:54to maybe we can revisit this topic down the road
- 33:56and see what the landscape looks like then. Absolutely.
- 33:59Thank you, David. This was a pleasure.