Latest / My Sister's A Therapist- Mental Health, Wellness, and Healing with Humor / Fatphobia
Transcript
- 0:01My sister's a therapist and I tell jokes.
- 0:05We both want to help all kinds of folks.
- 0:09Hello and welcome to my Sister's a Therapist.
- 0:11My name is Virginia Jones. I'm a stand up comedian but my
- 0:14sister's a therapist. Hi, I'm Laura Ryan, I am a
- 0:17licensed marriage and family therapist and sister to modern
- 0:20day jester Virginia Jones. Modern day jester telling truth
- 0:24to power. The philosopher clown.
- 0:28Wearing bells on her hat. That's right, the Shakespearean
- 0:32ideal of modern fool. I think that I fulfilled out
- 0:36pretty pretty well. I had some real life feedback
- 0:39from a listener yesterday. She had just listened to the
- 0:43white culture episode and she said, well, thanks for making me
- 0:46feel bad about being white. I got some feedback from an
- 0:51Irish listener because the episode was white culture.
- 0:54Laura swiftly realized you cannot say white culture on
- 0:58TikTok. They ban you immediately.
- 1:00Tick Tock get very angry because they assume that you're a white
- 1:03supremacist and I guess why? Well.
- 1:05And I even spelled it the way they like to spell it on TikTok
- 1:09Wyt and that still wasn't good enough.
- 1:12Not good enough. So Laura decided to call it Mayo
- 1:14culture and I thought that was a lot funnier, one of our
- 1:17listeners from Ireland said. Well, you know, Mayo culture.
- 1:20Every other place. County Mayo, like, like that is
- 1:24a real place. I'm like, yeah, we weren't
- 1:25thinking about that, but. Let's be real though, let's be
- 1:28100%. County Mayo is about as wide as
- 1:31you get. Yeah, it doesn't get any wider.
- 1:33So it still tracks, it still works.
- 1:35According to ancestry.com, my DNA test County Mayo is where
- 1:40most of our family is from so. Well, it's also where my
- 1:44boyfriend Karen Newton is from. He's delicious.
- 1:47He. Certainly is.
- 1:48And he has a lot to say about County Mayo men.
- 1:51He has a lot. To say about Irish flirtation,
- 1:54which I find hilarious because it's very similar to English
- 1:57flirtation in my experience. You're not the worst looking
- 2:00woman in the world. You look like you got a strong
- 2:03back. Thanks a lot.
- 2:08Speaking of men and women, our topic this week is fat phobia.
- 2:12This is a classic. This is a classic.
- 2:14This is something I think we've talked about between the two of
- 2:17us at least once a week for our whole adult lives.
- 2:21Yes, you know that this week I had an experience with fat
- 2:24phobia on. TikTok That's true.
- 2:28Laura got her comment not in response to a video she had
- 2:31made, but in response to a comment she made on someone
- 2:35else's account. Right.
- 2:36So there was a guy who was making fun of Americans, which
- 2:39I'm always game for, and he was saying this is what Americans
- 2:43think British people are doing all the time.
- 2:44And one of the things he was doing is basically every 10
- 2:46minutes he was, he was pouring himself a cup of tea.
- 2:50And I said the tea part is true, though.
- 2:53They think you wear knickerbockers and you you wear
- 2:56bowler hat and you're, you're always riding the train.
- 3:00You're on double Decker buses every 10 minutes.
- 3:03You're you have a handlebar mustache.
- 3:06I said the tea part is true though.
- 3:08And then I got a helpful comment for a man named Horror.
- 3:13Hello. Horror.
- 3:14Horror Horror used a photo of Kanye West made to look obese,
- 3:20which was interesting. So Horror said I can't look at
- 3:25it without laughing. Go on a diet you S lard of he's
- 3:30thinking I might get a T-shirt that just says S lard of fat.
- 3:35Well, I appreciate. That horror has battled through
- 3:40the challenges of not speaking English to let you know you are
- 3:46apos Sack of lard. I was.
- 3:49Wondering to myself what what even is an S lard of fat?
- 3:54An SE lard of fat? What's funny is item 1.
- 3:59You really went out there by saying the British drink tea.
- 4:01I can see why that's like a really fiery opinion.
- 4:04It's a it's a hot topic and it could be, it could be really
- 4:07offensive to a lot of people. So I get it.
- 4:10He wasn't responding to your avatar, which does not show your
- 4:13body. He saw your comment, became
- 4:17incensed that you said that British people drink tea, went
- 4:20to your page, watched a video and came back to say you were an
- 4:24S lard of fat. I mean, it was a lot of effort.
- 4:26We frequently start with definitions.
- 4:28The definition of fat phobia is the irrational fear of aversion
- 4:31to, or discrimination against obesity or people with obesity.
- 4:36Now, homophobia is not really fear.
- 4:39I think it sometimes is. It's rooted in fear, but it
- 4:42comes across as dislike, right? Disdain.
- 4:45Disdain. Social stigma.
- 4:47But people really hate and fear being fat.
- 4:49So much so that there was a study in 2006 at Yale that found
- 4:53that 46% of people studied would rather give up a year of their
- 4:57life rather than be obese. I mean, that tracks.
- 5:00And that 15% of people 1/5 were willing to shave 10 years off of
- 5:06their life, so dying at 60 if they could die thin.
- 5:09That's not surprising to me at all, just based on everything I
- 5:12know about my personal and professional life.
- 5:15Not going to tell tales out of school.
- 5:17Laura and I have been fat for most of the time.
- 5:20I've always felt like I was fat. I don't know if I was the
- 5:22definition of fat. I don't think I haven't felt
- 5:24thin as a child, I just felt like a person.
- 5:25I have not felt an acceptable weight since I was probably
- 5:2912-13, something like that. I.
- 5:31Have yo yoed quite a bit in my life and one of the real good
- 5:34features is that when when you lose a bunch of weight, your
- 5:39friends and family will talk about how gross you were before.
- 5:45It's not a bug, it's a feature. After the second or third time
- 5:50that I lost a bunch of weight, I had to tell people, please don't
- 5:54talk about that fat girl because.
- 5:58She was me then, She's still me. I'm still her.
- 6:02And also. She's going to.
- 6:04Be back. This is a reprieve, but she's
- 6:06coming back. That's how this works.
- 6:08Yeah, she's coming back better than ever before, really.
- 6:11I mean, she'll probably be fatter than ever before.
- 6:14That's usually how that works. When I lose an extreme amount of
- 6:17weight and then bring some back, it's always more than than what
- 6:21I have. More than what you put down in
- 6:23the 1st place. I have a joke about fat phobia
- 6:26in my act that I have been telling and right now it's in a
- 6:30shape where I really, really like it.
- 6:31It's about the absurdity that the person who is most unhappy
- 6:36about my fatness is my mother. When she.
- 6:38Herself is a fat and had a baby with another fat.
- 6:43With another fat. Exactly.
- 6:45And their parents were also fats.
- 6:47It's not a coincidence, it's a causal effect.
- 6:51Again, it's not a bug, it's. Feature but the end of the joke.
- 6:56I have started saying I try to like myself no matter what
- 7:00weight I am, but it's hard because I know that other people
- 7:04don't. And then the room goes.
- 7:06Quiet, absolutely silent. Pin drop silence.
- 7:10I mean, this is the truth. You guys are not laughing
- 7:13because it's true, but how absurd that it's.
- 7:15True, because this person's body formation doesn't fit a standard
- 7:19that we made-up. I have to dislike them.
- 7:21Of course, the obvious thing is romantic relationships.
- 7:24Oh, fat people can never be in love.
- 7:26No one can ever love a fat. I've been single for 45 minutes
- 7:29my entire life, so I don't particularly worry about that.
- 7:31But what you don't think about is the disdain of friends, of
- 7:35coworkers, of people on the street, of randos.
- 7:39Well, yeah, the last time I had a big weight drop, I ran into a
- 7:44woman that I knew extremely casually.
- 7:46Like I would see her at events or whatever but we weren't
- 7:49friends by any stretch. This is going to shock you.
- 7:52I was walking through the Target parking lot.
- 7:55Moms go to Target. Well, this mom goes a whole
- 7:59bunch again. If Target wants to give us a
- 8:00sponsorship, I'm down because I hope my child and my money go to
- 8:05Target. She pulls over, rolls down her
- 8:08window and yells wow you have lost a lot of weight.
- 8:13Thanks man. It's knowing that someone who
- 8:16you don't really have a relationship with is carrying
- 8:19around a picture of you in their mind and concerning themselves
- 8:23with it. You have enough concern about my
- 8:26body that you're going to park your car and roll down the
- 8:30window in the middle of a Target parking lot to tell me that
- 8:33thank God I'm not so fat anymore.
- 8:35I have. The other side of that story, a
- 8:37couple years ago, I had just come out of a second audition,
- 8:40which is known as a callback in the business.
- 8:43The callback had gone really well.
- 8:46The guy in the room really liked what I was doing.
- 8:49The casting director really liked what I was doing.
- 8:51I had good vibe with my partner. So I walked out feeling really
- 8:55good and booked that role. But me and the guy that I was in
- 9:00the audition with walked out on the street smiling and talking
- 9:04about how it went. I stepped into a crosswalk and a
- 9:09lady I guess didn't want me to and she screamed out the window
- 9:12at me. F you you fat bee.
- 9:15Not only on my own, but got to enjoy being called that in front
- 9:19of a guy that I just did a scene with.
- 9:22I think I love slurs when they're in front of people that
- 9:26maybe I'm trying to impress or something.
- 9:28Like not even that, just a witness to my misery.
- 9:30And he was also a fat. And so we just had this moment
- 9:33of misery together. He.
- 9:35Knew, but we do see that overweight people marry less
- 9:41often, have fewer career opportunities.
- 9:44Fatness will affect your ability to earn money, which is bizarre
- 9:48because it's looked at as a moral failing.
- 9:51So if I'm a morally inferior then I don't deserve more money.
- 9:56We think of fat people as lacking willpower, being lazy,
- 10:00being gluttonous, being stupid. Someone in our family was very
- 10:04surprised to know that a fat person was, in fact, really
- 10:08smart. We won't talk about who it was.
- 10:12He knows a lot of things. He's really smart.
- 10:15When there's bad feelings about minorities, when people have
- 10:18opinions and stereotypes about minorities, they are minorities.
- 10:21They are a small segment of the population, but overweight and
- 10:24obese people are 2/3 of the population.
- 10:26Right, but that phobia is entrenched in racism.
- 10:31I had a very sad interaction with a pharmacist recently who
- 10:36was filling a prescription for me and remarked that the
- 10:39medication that I'm on frequently leads people to lose
- 10:43weight. And so he was asking me about
- 10:45it. And I said, yes, I have been
- 10:46experiencing that as part of this depression Med.
- 10:50He said, well, like, does it help a lot?
- 10:51I'm like, it's definitely an element with everything else.
- 10:54And he said, yeah, I just have to get more willpower.
- 10:57And it broke my heart. It wasn't appropriate for the
- 11:00time for me to lean over the table and say there's no such
- 11:02thing as willpower. This is literally what I say in
- 11:05my office once an hour. What I say is willpower is not
- 11:09something I can put in a bucket or a bowl.
- 11:11It doesn't exist. It's made-up.
- 11:14And basically what you're saying is the way that your body works,
- 11:18you have sugar and fat cravings more than a naturally thin
- 11:22person does. That's what you're saying to me.
- 11:25When people become TikTok influencers or Instagram
- 11:29influencers, it tends to be because they're small people and
- 11:32they know that they're not experiencing fat cravings.
- 11:36I have cravings. They don't have these compulsive
- 11:38cravings. They're like, well the solution
- 11:40is just work on not having those.
- 11:43You know, I do the same thing when I see someone in a
- 11:45wheelchair. I go.
- 11:46I can walk. Have you tried just walking?
- 11:49You considered the possibility of just hopping out of that
- 11:52chair and walking a few blocks. Let's talk about that a little
- 11:55bit. The advice that you get, because
- 11:58on the Internet, off the Internet, wherever I am, many
- 12:01people have told me what's just calories in calories.
- 12:04I used to try to do a joke about that.
- 12:05I'm like, I'm like, Oh my God, you don't just think I'm fat,
- 12:07you think I'm bad at math. Well, circling back to our mom,
- 12:11she has this incredible ability to add up really high numbers
- 12:16because she's been counting her calories since she was 5.
- 12:19If that were the only thing in play, no one would be fat.
- 12:23This would not be an issue. And also, if bullying people
- 12:26kept them from being fat, no one would be.
- 12:28Fat. Literally no one would be fat
- 12:30because every person who's fat is bullied.
- 12:33The first part of my career, 85 to 90% of my clientele were
- 12:38women trying to lose weight. It's brutal.
- 12:41And I think the worst part is the external bullying is part of
- 12:44it. It's the internal, you know,
- 12:45it's the way that these women talk to themselves.
- 12:47It's really painful. As we have both experienced,
- 12:50people who are hardest on you for being fat are fat people.
- 12:55Or former fats. I haven't really been harassed
- 12:58by women too much about being fat of course, apart from my
- 13:01mother. But I'm just thinking.
- 13:03It's not even shaming what I have felt most of my life when
- 13:06it comes to dating and even just being out in clubs around men,
- 13:10things like that, like bars and stuff.
- 13:11I'm just invisible. No one's actively rude to me, I
- 13:14just don't exist. You are just not perceived, you
- 13:17are not interacted with. I find that the the form that
- 13:21women interacting with me usually takes is a faux
- 13:24helpfulness. I had lost a bit of weight and I
- 13:26was walking around the reservoir, Silver Lake Reservoir
- 13:29in LA every day. A man I did not know pulled his
- 13:32car over and rolled his window down and said, hey, I noticed
- 13:36you've lost a lot of weight. What?
- 13:38A man I had never spoken to in my life.
- 13:41Stalker much? And this is a change in me
- 13:45because 20 years ago I would have said thank you, but I said
- 13:48please don't talk to me about my body.
- 13:51You're a stranger. Why are you talking to another
- 13:54stranger about her body? I used to take a spin class with
- 13:57a friend. I really enjoy a spin class
- 13:59because it's one of the exercise classes that actually teaches
- 14:02you a skill. You're learning how to ride a
- 14:04bike. She and I went every Saturday.
- 14:06She got familiar with the same faces all the time.
- 14:09And a woman came up to us, the two of us after class and said,
- 14:12I just want to let you guys know I was where you are.
- 14:15Keep coming back going to be, you know you're going to do
- 14:18great. I'm so proud of you guys.
- 14:20And at the time I still took that as a compliment.
- 14:22And my friend was like, no, she's telling us that there's
- 14:26non fat rainbow at the end of this yellow brick road.
- 14:31I wouldn't possibly just be taking a spin class so I can
- 14:35have cardiovascular health and also the word healthy.
- 14:38I really hate that. Oh, yeah, I'm so triggered by
- 14:41that word. Yeah, we're eating healthy.
- 14:43Oh, you mean you're eating low carbohydrate, high protein food?
- 14:46OK, got it. But the conversations that I've
- 14:49had in offices, oh, I got this salad.
- 14:52I thought it was going to be healthy, but it has all this
- 14:55dressing on it. They wouldn't make me half a
- 14:58sandwich. Will someone eat the other half
- 15:00of this extremely normal sized sandwich?
- 15:03You mean the normal portion of food you have in front of you?
- 15:06You can only eat half of it. And only half of it is an adult
- 15:09woman having a full day. There's no way you could eat the
- 15:13other half of the sandwich, I guess ever because I I've worked
- 15:17in fashion most of my life. I have been in extremely fat
- 15:20phobic environments. Surrounded by women with eating
- 15:22disorders. I remember I had a client in the
- 15:25past who had a Co worker and every single day she ate a can
- 15:30of Heinz tomato soup for lunch and she didn't eat breakfast.
- 15:35That was her day. A friend of mine told me once
- 15:39when I hadn't lived in LA very long, Everyone here has an
- 15:42eating disorder and a really good justification for that
- 15:46eating disorder. Absolutely.
- 15:48And a lot of people are saying, oh, I used to have an eating
- 15:50disorder, OK, but tell your arms that.
- 15:53It's interesting. You're talking about plus size
- 15:55models and stuff. I have a tough time with plus
- 15:58size models because when I'm really fat, I'm like, but I
- 16:00don't look like that chick. And I found out recently that
- 16:03they're stuffing these women. They're taking a woman who's
- 16:06like a size 10 and just putting extra stuffing in her boobs and
- 16:10bottom and they're just saying that's what that is.
- 16:13My chin doesn't look like why'd? She have such a thin face.
- 16:17It's because she's not that size.
- 16:18And then Emily told me she was dating a man who was a
- 16:22photographer for Vogue, and he was saying it's very difficult
- 16:27because all of fashion is built around basically the male body.
- 16:32What a young gay man would be interested in looking at.
- 16:35No curves, broad shoulders, tall, thin.
- 16:39So that's what women have been eating, disordering their way to
- 16:43create. Another way fat phobia showed up
- 16:46at work is we would have stuff photographed on a plus size
- 16:50model and there would be notes like can we Photoshop out these
- 16:54folds? And we had to explain to the
- 16:56design department, this is what fat people look like.
- 16:59You're not just solid like a Barbie doll, but bigger.
- 17:03You are softer. Even a very beautiful, very fit
- 17:07plus size model is just more soft.
- 17:10And this is what clothes look like on that model.
- 17:12That is what literal fat looks like.
- 17:15Right, We had a piece of clothing not do very well that
- 17:17we thought was going to do very well, one of my designers who I
- 17:20love very much said. And we photographed it on X
- 17:23models name. It would have looked better on
- 17:26the straight size model. Now different companies are
- 17:29using plus size models. I'll be looking at clothes and
- 17:32like, I would rather pretend that I have a much smaller body
- 17:35and when I buy this sweatshirt, it's going to look like that.
- 17:38The relationship between women and the fashion industry is also
- 17:43super toxic. We are used to looking at these
- 17:47extremely tiny, extremely young models, and part of us likes to
- 17:51fantasize that's what it's going to look like on me, even though
- 17:53we had the experience 100 times, right?
- 17:57But that's. Not being in this body.
- 18:00In the 90s, which was, you know, maybe one of their more fat
- 18:04phobic times we've ever. Survived.
- 18:06Absolutely. It was the rise.
- 18:08The rise of Kate Moss and the low rise gene.
- 18:11God bless us all. In the 90s, there was a push to
- 18:15have more plus size models, especially on magazine covers,
- 18:18when magazines were still a thing that people bought and
- 18:21paid attention. It was documentable, verifiable,
- 18:24that when you put a beautiful plus size model on the front of
- 18:27a magazine, that issue would tank because fat women didn't
- 18:31want to buy it. We didn't want to think of
- 18:33ourselves. That way, absolutely not.
- 18:35But also reflecting back on the 2000s fashion, I'm just going to
- 18:38shock you. I saw TikTok and this woman went
- 18:41she went home to her parents house and they still had
- 18:44basically a capsule collection of her 2000s clothes.
- 18:48And she pulled out this pair of jeans and she said, do you see
- 18:50that? There's like a one inch from the
- 18:52top of this zipper to the bottom?
- 18:54No wonder my whole butt was hanging out of all of my pants,
- 18:57right? Well, and it's funny because
- 18:59when things like that get trendy, super low rise jeans,
- 19:03super crop tops, shirts get longer, there will be layers of
- 19:07shirts. Right, that was the Disney move.
- 19:09You wear a tank top and a long sleeve shirt and a sweater.
- 19:13I have a friend who's very fashion conscious and she was
- 19:16telling me the new thing right now is crop top and butt cut for
- 19:20your hair and socks that are pulled all the way up.
- 19:24And I was like, Can you imagine what I would look like you would
- 19:28look like? Someone who had escaped from a
- 19:30special. School.
- 19:31Somebody's on the loose. She found that in a random
- 19:35person's backyard. Those are not her clothes.
- 19:39Although you did rock the butt cut for many years.
- 19:41With pride at this point, No, no thank you.
- 19:45So you mentioned television and performers who fearfully admit
- 19:51that they used to have eating disorders, but they look like
- 19:53people with eating disorders, right?
- 19:55Exactly. Media in general over represents
- 19:58underweight individuals and under represents overweight
- 20:01individuals. 1/3 of actresses in television are classified as
- 20:05underweight, while only 5% of the general pop is underweight.
- 20:08So here we have the phenomenon of the teeny tiny wife and the
- 20:12great big fat funny husband and everybody being teeny tiny.
- 20:16A teeny tiny doctor. A teeny tiny nurse.
- 20:19A teeny tiny psychic, a teeny tiny crime fighter, everybody.
- 20:23And a challenge of being overweight in Hollywood is that
- 20:27previously, if you're overweight, there has to be a
- 20:29reason in the story for that. I watched a whole show about it
- 20:32where a woman died and came back as a fat person she couldn't
- 20:36hack kiss. The study of over 1000 TV
- 20:39characters in 2003 identified 14% of female characters and 24
- 20:44percent of male characters as overweight, despite the fact
- 20:46that in the real world it would be 75%.
- 20:49And when you do have overweight people on television, they're
- 20:51often doing best friend roles, bad guy roles, many times
- 20:55stereotyped to be unintelligent, lazy and evil.
- 20:58Bad TV characters are more commonly seen eating and are
- 21:01less likely to be involved in romantic relationship compared
- 21:04to average weight television characters.
- 21:06In Bridgerton, the beautiful Penelope Featherington has
- 21:10gotten Colin Bridgerton and people are losing their minds.
- 21:14It is disgusting because this woman is gorgeous.
- 21:19Yeah, and anywhere else in the world, people would be dying to
- 21:22date her. And even a lot of historians
- 21:24have pointed out, hey, guess what?
- 21:26Her body is the ideal of that time, as it has been through a
- 21:31great deal of European history. Right.
- 21:34The actress who plays Penelope Featherington, the very
- 21:37beautiful Nicola Coughlin, did an interview that was very funny
- 21:41where basically the interviewer was telling her that she was so,
- 21:44so brave for being partially nude on television, just so, so
- 21:48brave. And she said, yes, I represent a
- 21:51type of body type that is not frequently on television, which
- 21:54is the body type of women with perfect breasts, right?
- 21:57And she said, and I'm willing to expose them to share this with
- 22:01the world. And she was so right.
- 22:02She does have perfect breasts. But yes, just the idea that even
- 22:07though we see fat people in real life having relationships,
- 22:11having kids, to see them on television.
- 22:14No way. So there was a show called Drop
- 22:16Dead Diva. Did you ever watch that?
- 22:18No. OK, so the plot line is a vapid
- 22:20aspiring model is killed in a car crash and gets brought back
- 22:23to life in an intelligent overweight lawyer hoping to find
- 22:27the meaning of inner beauty. And the other thing that's
- 22:31hilarious to me is this overweight lawyer is the
- 22:35beautiful, just drop dead gorgeous Brooke Elliott playing
- 22:39Jane Bingham. But the whole show is her as
- 22:42basically this ghost of a a dumb model trying to get through life
- 22:46as a fat woman. And she's kind of shocked
- 22:49because she's like, well, why aren't people doing things for
- 22:51me? You know, Why is every man that
- 22:53I'm interested in not wanting to date me?
- 22:55Why is my life changed so much? And because she's in a fat body
- 22:59and hilarity ensues and she never gets a boyfriend.
- 23:02Another analysis in 2007 135 scenes featuring overweight
- 23:07individuals found that it was anti fat humor.
- 23:11So either the person was doing something physical that was
- 23:16hilarious because they were. Fat, out of breath.
- 23:18She's sweating. Or someone was saying something
- 23:21fat phobic to them. It's hard.
- 23:23Melissa McCarthy is incredibly funny and incredibly beautiful,
- 23:26but has made her career on the physical humor of the fat woman
- 23:30and how funny it is the absurdity of a fat woman acting
- 23:34in a sexy way talking to men. Hilarious.
- 23:38It's so funny. Can you imagine a fat woman
- 23:41thinking she's pretty like she often does in television and
- 23:45film on Bridgerton? I'm a fan.
- 23:47So I've watched three seasons and there was a woman who was
- 23:51doing an analysis of how many love scenes they were in seasons
- 23:551 and 2 compared to season 3. And basically the Colin and
- 24:00Penelope Featherington story gets like 1/8 of the time of
- 24:04every other season where it's great size folks banging
- 24:08everywhere they can. So in the midst of all this fat
- 24:10phobia and we are seeing more diverse actors on television,
- 24:14but fat phobia is actually getting worse.
- 24:16Shocker, self reported incidents of weight based discrimination
- 24:20have increased every year since 1995.
- 24:23It also effects different groups to greater extents that 80% of
- 24:27black women are considered overweight or obese compared to
- 24:315565% of white women. And so we can definitely say
- 24:35that part of what is unacceptable about fatness.
- 24:37Is blackness. Yeah.
- 24:39And Sabrina Strings talks about that in the book Fearing the
- 24:42Black Body. The racial origins of fat
- 24:44phobia. And I think it also has to do
- 24:46with religion. So here's a quote from the book.
- 24:48The legacy of Protestant moralism and race science as it
- 24:51related to fat and thin persons loomed large.
- 24:54Indeed, many early to mid 20th century physicians relied on
- 24:58moral and racial logics to rail against persons deemed too fat
- 25:02or too thin. But overtime, a growing number
- 25:04did so specifically and exclusively to condemn fatness.
- 25:08We were talking about different cultures and especially
- 25:11different times appreciating around her body.
- 25:14For 400 years between 1500 and 1900, bigger bodies for both men
- 25:20and women had a strong appeal. And you can see this in
- 25:23painting, you can see it in sculpture.
- 25:25Well, it's a bunch of naked fat ladies and.
- 25:27There's been times when I've been in an Art Museum looking at
- 25:30a sculpture that is exactly my body type and saying someone
- 25:34likes. Us, the Reubens did.
- 25:36For 400 years, the fat body was the desirable body between 1500
- 25:41and 1900. It wasn't until the the 1920s
- 25:44really, but thinness became equated more with wealth.
- 25:48We had post industrial revolution and rich people found
- 25:52that they did not have to do any labor outside the home, any
- 25:55physical labor. You didn't have to go outside.
- 25:57And so being pale and thin started to be a good thing.
- 26:01And also finding that because they had moved from being
- 26:05exclusively out in the fields to indoors after the Industrial
- 26:09Revolution, poor people weren't tan anymore.
- 26:11So it became fashionable to not just be very thin, but to be
- 26:14very tan. It became associated with
- 26:17travel, right? Travel, outdoor sports, tennis,
- 26:20the realm of every rich person. And so suddenly, what was
- 26:24attractive had to turn on a dime.
- 26:26We've got corsets that made a body very curvaceous, very busty
- 26:31and tiny waist and big hips. And then in the flap era we were
- 26:34dealing with that stick, straight body, that teenage boy.
- 26:37Body fatness is also a racial problem.
- 26:41The black body has always been bigger, and the distaste for
- 26:47that is racially motivated. 80% of black women are considered
- 26:51obese on a BMI chart, so distaste for fatness is also a
- 26:56distaste for people of color. I have a quote with that again
- 26:59from Sabrina String. Stoutness, Corpulence, and
- 27:03Surplus flesh are never desirable except among African
- 27:10savages. This raises several questions.
- 27:13First, what led some well to do Americans to believe that
- 27:16slenderness, especially among women, was both aesthetically
- 27:19preferable and a sign of national identity?
- 27:21How did fatness become a sign of immorality?
- 27:23How did fatness become linked with blackness and Africanity?
- 27:27I do think that the choreographer Georges Balanchine
- 27:31was responsible for the Super thin beauty ideal.
- 27:36He was born in 1904 in Saint Petersburg.
- 27:40So he was operating in the early 20th century in America.
- 27:44And before the 20th century, ballet dancers were round women.
- 27:48Dancers were round women because women were round women.
- 27:51But Balanchine was the first choreographer and ballet
- 27:54director who really thought that the Reed Finn tiny tiny tiny
- 27:58ballerina was the ideal. And then?
- 28:00Did he ever explain why? He just liked it better.
- 28:03Just like The Shape better. Yeah, the idea of a fat
- 28:06ballerina. That's comedy, right?
- 28:08Can you imagine a fat woman who's also a ballerina?
- 28:11I have Mexican beer. Laura's referring to a project I
- 28:16was booked for by the cinematographer Chivo, where
- 28:20they were talking about absurdities, things that didn't
- 28:22go together. So I was a fat ballerina and I
- 28:24got paid $1000. Nice.
- 28:26Fat ballerinas, or at least round ballerinas used to be the
- 28:30norm. And this one man's eye and
- 28:33aesthetic took over at the same time as fatness was increasingly
- 28:38associated with poverty and not with wealth.
- 28:41And then ballerinas have had eating disorders, many of them
- 28:44ever since. So Speaking of poverty and
- 28:46fatness, this is another quote from Fearing.
- 28:49The black racial discourse was deployed by elite Europeans and
- 28:52white Americans to create social distinctions between themselves
- 28:56and fat racial others. Black people, as well as
- 28:59so-called degraded or hybrid whites, EG Celtic, Irish,
- 29:03Southern Italian, and Russians, were primary targets of these
- 29:07arguments. How does that feel?
- 29:09Hybrid whites? How does it feel to be two kinds
- 29:12of hybrid white? Amazing.
- 29:14So let's talk about the medical fields a little bit.
- 29:17We've been told over and over again that we are in an obesity
- 29:20epidemic, that obesity is the second biggest killer of
- 29:24Americans after alcohol. But in fact, being mildly obese,
- 29:28being a little bit higher on the BMI actually makes you less
- 29:31likely to die than being very thin.
- 29:34Being an older, chubby woman is better for your heart and body
- 29:37than being thin. And unfortunately, the thing
- 29:39that's very worse for your heart and body is yo yoing between two
- 29:43extremes, which in an environment of fat phobia we all
- 29:46do because everybody is trying to achieve and maintain this
- 29:50ideal. Exhibit A Mama Cass.
- 29:52I mean, that's why she died. Because her body had been so
- 29:56destroyed by extreme dieting and yo yoing and all those things,
- 30:00Amy Winehouse died. It's purported to be alcoholism,
- 30:03but anorexia and nervosia and bulimia were definitely a
- 30:06factor. What doctors were saying is if
- 30:08she hadn't had an eating disorder, she would have
- 30:10survived. She could have handled it, but
- 30:12her body just couldn't process alcohol very well anymore
- 30:15because of the Ed. So despite the fact that obesity
- 30:18itself, that you can be a healthy overweight person,
- 30:21whether or not you exercise is much more a factor in whether
- 30:23you're healthy healthy than how big your body is.
- 30:26But doctors are some of the most fat phobic people in the world
- 30:30and every fat woman has stories. We see all these stories on
- 30:33TikTok of women coming in with broken legs and cancer and being
- 30:38told, well, the first thing you should try to do is lose some
- 30:41weight. I literally saw a TikTok just
- 30:43this morning where a woman was talking about how she is
- 30:46permanently disabled now she cannot feel her foot because she
- 30:49went to six different doctors who all told her it's not the
- 30:53fact that you have. Compressed things in your spine.
- 30:56It's just that you're fat. Primary care physicians
- 30:59overstate the effects of being overweight on all 'cause
- 31:02mortality so if painted with a broad brush the effects of being
- 31:06overweight on health describing being overweight is much more
- 31:09detrimental than clinical guidelines actually indicate.
- 31:12A national survey of the United States found that individuals
- 31:14who are overweight reported three times higher likelihood to
- 31:17be denied medical care and UK, where Healthcare is free, 25 out
- 31:23of 90 one primary care trusts have bans for the treatment of
- 31:27obese individuals. We're not going to waste our
- 31:30money on treating you if you're not going to take care of your
- 31:34fat problem. Well, it's because being fat is
- 31:37a moral choice. Yes, people would rather be dead
- 31:41than fat, which ties in nicely to eating disorders because you
- 31:45really could die trying to get the body that is going to get
- 31:49you treated better inside. And you often do.
- 31:52Yeah, let's talk about fat dating a little bit.
- 31:54Dating while fat. One, there's a study that 89% of
- 31:59fat people have been bullied by romantic partners, so almost
- 32:02everyone. Well, I remember when I was much
- 32:06less fat than I am today. A friend was wanting to date me
- 32:09and I found out much later that he had written a song with
- 32:14another friend who was also my friend and the song was called
- 32:17Chunky Attractive Girl and it was about me but.
- 32:21They said you were attractive. Well, you have to say that
- 32:23because if she's chunky, she can't be attractive.
- 32:26So we have to just, like, battle it out.
- 32:28Yeah, I definitely. Have experiences where the
- 32:31attitude was if I'm fat and trying to date, I'm there to
- 32:35have sex with. I went on a date with a guy who
- 32:38I thought was very cute, not the smartest guy.
- 32:40You can't have everything and at the end of the day, he said you
- 32:43should come home with me because I love effing fat girls.
- 32:47Wow, that's quite a compliment. I mean, thank you.
- 32:51Well, the thing that I noticed as my weight.
- 32:54Excelled as your weight became even more of what it was before.
- 32:59As my weight became more robust, I found that men that I used to
- 33:04be cohort with, people who I definitely would have dated in
- 33:07my twins, were just not even swiping on me at all.
- 33:12A lot of people who were freshly out of prison or about to go to
- 33:17prison. Ruthless and toothless, 95 years
- 33:20old. I mean I was getting hits.
- 33:21Super hot super. Hot.
- 33:24They were not hot, but I was getting attention, but it was
- 33:27mostly from men that I would never in my wildest imaginings
- 33:30even consider for a relationship ever.
- 33:33And when I would find a guy who was evenly matched with me,
- 33:35similarly attractive, similar age, similar education level,
- 33:39etcetera, they were just trying to have casual sex.
- 33:42With me, so that's fun. After my weight loss, I was
- 33:45like, oh, OK, now all the guys that I used to be able to get,
- 33:49they're coming back around. Where have you guys been for the
- 33:51last five years? When I've experienced that,
- 33:54seeing my stock rise dramatically after losing
- 33:57weight, I regard it with disgust.
- 34:00I'm Yeah. Because I think, well, I don't
- 34:01want to date you now. If I wasn't good enough 20 lbs
- 34:04ago, you're not good enough now. It has made me really look at a
- 34:08lot of men with disdain, just totally grossed out by all of
- 34:11it. So I read this on anti fat bias.
- 34:14There was a study trying to figure out how to resolve anti
- 34:18fat bias. When told an individual was
- 34:20obese because of overeating and lack of exercise.
- 34:23A higher implicit bias was found among study participants than
- 34:27those not provided with context. So when you were told
- 34:29specifically this person is fat because they've been mistreating
- 34:32their body, people thought lesser of them.
- 34:34When the group was told that genetics was to blame, they did
- 34:37not exhibit a lowered implicit bias.
- 34:40So when people were told this person is fat because they have
- 34:43a disease, or this person is fat because they were born to be
- 34:46fat, it doesn't matter why you're fat.
- 34:48Because again, it is a moral failing.
- 34:50Thanks to Protestants. So it's about being plain
- 34:54simple, not eating too much, not having sex, not being interested
- 34:59in any of the seven deadly sins. If you're not following those
- 35:03guidelines, then you are a morally inferior person.
- 35:07The last thing I'll leave us with is in a world where we are
- 35:12seeing more people of color, more people across gender
- 35:16stereotypes in film and television, and you think, oh,
- 35:20maybe bias is getting better. Fatness is maybe the last
- 35:24frontier where you can really really dislike a group for
- 35:27something that they cannot necessarily control.
- 35:29And that anti fat bias has been on the rise every year since
- 35:331995, so it's just getting better and better.
- 35:35Did you ever see that Jack Black movie?
- 35:37The movie where he's attracted to a woman because he thinks
- 35:41she's thin? Dude, you're fat.
- 35:43What are you doing here? You would only date this woman
- 35:45because you think she looks like an eating disorder?
- 35:48Gwyneth Paltrow. Yeah.
- 35:49Shallow how? I mean, the whole thing is like,
- 35:50oh, he's so shallow, but we're not acting like that's that bad.
- 35:54And the whole joke is he sees her as being this thin person,
- 35:58but her real body is. Breaking things, she can barely
- 36:02fit into clothes and he's talking to her father about how
- 36:06beautiful she is and he's like, oh, thanks for lying.
- 36:09It's. Horrible.
- 36:11And that's your boyfriend. So Laura, after this super
- 36:14cheerful episode on a topic that we've thought and talked a lot
- 36:17about, what are your final thoughts about fat phobia and
- 36:20American fatness? I have mixed feelings about all
- 36:24of it, really. Obviously I've been living it
- 36:26for most of my life, but what I've tried to do with my life is
- 36:29not get super obsessive about my body.
- 36:32I don't know if you know my mother.
- 36:33She used to have these AIDS, candies, dieting.
- 36:37Dieting aids. Yeah, it was eight.
- 36:39What was it? Ayds.
- 36:40Ayds. Famously a brand that stopped
- 36:43existing after the AIDS Health. Is epidemic.
- 36:47Somehow they fell out of favor, but she used to eat these little
- 36:49caramels that would, I guess they were appetite suppressants
- 36:53and just spent most of her life destroying herself trying to be
- 36:58thin and she wasn't even fat. That's the dumb part.
- 37:01I guess for me, my goal was just to bulk against that and try to
- 37:05do everything I could to not be in that category.
- 37:09It still sucks. I am at my most fat at this
- 37:12moment. Congratulations.
- 37:16I did get an award. They had to deliver it to me,
- 37:19but I did receive it. It's on my mantle.
- 37:22But it's starting to be to the point where I'm having a hard
- 37:25time fitting in furniture and fitting into the world anymore.
- 37:29And I just think to myself, I'm pretty chubbed out, but I'm not
- 37:32more chubbed out than 60 to 70% of the American population.
- 37:36Why is it like this? And it's like this because the
- 37:39people who are designing airplanes, couches, even
- 37:45automobiles and other transportation, they're not
- 37:47thinking about you. They're not thinking badly.
- 37:49About you. They're thinking about a white,
- 37:51thin ideal that really isn't much of the American population
- 37:55anymore. It doesn't actually reflect.
- 37:57US So Virginia, in closing, what are your final thoughts on this
- 38:00topic? It's a charge topic and I read a
- 38:03thing where 90% of American women say they're trying to lose
- 38:06some weight, 90%. That makes me so sad.
- 38:09It's incredibly sad. I think it's an incredibly dumb
- 38:11thing to spend your time and energy on.
- 38:13You get to the end of your life, what have you achieved?
- 38:16Well, I managed to eat under 1200 calories every day, every
- 38:20day in adulthood. It does make me very sad.
- 38:23So what's the solve? I think the solve is truly
- 38:26working on liking yourself, every single one of us.
- 38:28If you truly like yourself and accept your body and love your
- 38:31body and find great things about your body and great things you
- 38:35can do, that's how we get out of it.
- 38:36I listen to a podcast with Aubrey Gordon called Maintenance
- 38:40Phase, and what she talks about is getting to a place where it's
- 38:44neutral or you just feel neutral.
- 38:45I have a lot of thoughts about my fatness and my body and what
- 38:48do other people think, yada yada.
- 38:50They don't have a charge anymore so they're just rolling through
- 38:52my head, but I don't. Feel them.
- 38:54There's not a, there's not a value judgement on it.
- 38:56Right. It's just like, oh, I'm fat,
- 38:58yes, just like I'm short or I have green eyes or I am a hybrid
- 39:03Italian slash Irish person. My friend Jenny Zagrino has a
- 39:09great joke that mirrors my thoughts a lot.
- 39:12You're not allowed to call yourself fat.
- 39:14If you say I'm fat, people say Oh no, no, you're beautiful.
- 39:18And she's like. That's not an insult.
- 39:20It is it just a descriptive adjective?
- 39:22Yes, but in her. Joke she goes well you know I'm
- 39:24fat and people go no you're not fat you're beautiful she's like
- 39:27I never said I wasn't beautiful I.
- 39:29Just happened to be fat as well. So Virginia, if people want to
- 39:33find you on the Internet, how do they do it?
- 39:35If you want to find my fat butt on the Internet, you can check
- 39:40out Whoa Whoa badinia.com or My Tick Tock at Badinia and my
- 39:45Instagram at Badinia. I did want to give a shout out.
- 39:49We had an episode about stalking and someone I mentioned in the
- 39:53episode wrote me that they liked it.
- 39:55Within a couple days later, they didn't like it anymore.
- 39:57OK, you're going to find that that often happens, but
- 40:00hopefully they'll change their mind again.
- 40:03Laura, where can people find you on the Internet?
- 40:05Well, if you want to find me on TikTok, write me and say go on a
- 40:08diet USUSC Laura Ryan on TikTok. You can also find my website,
- 40:17lauraryan.org. And if you want to reach out to
- 40:20the show, you can e-mail us at hello at my sisters at
- 40:23therapist.com. You can also get on our
- 40:25Instagram, my sisters at therapist.com or our website,
- 40:28mysistertherapist.com. There's a lot of there's
- 40:30Virginias everywhere. There's my sisters at therapist
- 40:33dot com everywhere if you want to hire us for your bar mitzvah,
- 40:38your target opening, pool party, anything related to target if
- 40:44you want. An arity event.
- 40:45You have a Target related charity event, please e-mail us
- 40:49at Hire Us at My Sisters at therapist.com.
- 40:52Laura, this is the part of the show where sometimes you will
- 40:54read a review that someone has sent us.
- 40:57Do you have one to share this week?
- 40:58Yeah, I actually do. We have a five star review.
- 41:03Thank you. Also if you guys want to write
- 41:05your five star reviews I will read them and then you'll be
- 41:08famous just like yours truly Gen.
- 41:11X and yours truly. Gen.
- 41:13X said best cure for the Monday Blues.
- 41:16My sister's a therapist is required listening for my weekly
- 41:19work commute. Virginia and Laura's witty
- 41:22banter is the perfect antidote for the Monday Blues.
- 41:25The topics are always interesting, but what keeps me
- 41:28coming back week after week are the laugh out loud, knee
- 41:31slapping zingers. These two drop each episode.
- 41:35The people in the car next to me want to know what I'm listening
- 41:37to. Thank you yours truly Gen.
- 41:40XI, really appreciate that. From 2 Gen.
- 41:41Xers to another, big thumbs up. Two big thumbs, big big thumbs,
- 41:47big big foam thumbs, and in. Closing, we would like to remind
- 41:50all of our listeners that the immortal words of Billy Ray
- 41:53Valentine Capricorn when he said we could make it baby.
- 41:57Me and you. Bye.