Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Cold Hands, Warm Podcast
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking, feels so much more happiness. Truth, Beausian
- 0:32wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and
- 0:39start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Do
- 0:57you ever wonder how Rich feels about all those memes that talk about Christmas coming?
- 1:04You know, she sings the I think the most downloaded or popular Christmas
- 1:11song in the world. Right all I want for Christmas is you, And
- 1:15so it's become a punchline. And I love the memes myself. You know,
- 1:19they talk about defrosting Mariah Carey in the month of I think it's October.
- 1:25There is you know, there's so many of them, and I gotta
- 1:27wonder, like, if it was me, I would think of it as
- 1:30a ball. It'd be sort of the Rick role with Rick Astley that I
- 1:34would think, look at all the free publicity. I get to be the
- 1:38center of this cultural moment. And so I saw another Mariah Carey Christmas meme
- 1:46about how you know here she is for another month of December, and always
- 1:49like, wait not, I wonder how she feels about that. Just a
- 1:53weird random thought to begin this random show. And if you've got something you
- 1:59want to talk about, it doesn't have to be about religion or atheism,
- 2:04politics today, I just let's just whatever. I don't care whatever you want
- 2:08to talk about. I'm releasing just a few extra ones and a few extra
- 2:13streams here in the last part of the year, just because, just because
- 2:19we can. I'm going to see the new Godzilla movie tonight. I asked
- 2:25Natalie, Hey, you want to go? Not really her bag, but
- 2:30I mean, she respects the genre and the franchise, but it's not really
- 2:35her thing. So I, buddy, you might are going to go and
- 2:38catch a showing of Godzilla minus one. Now I own shin Godzilla on Blu
- 2:46Ray and it is one of the greatest things in the known universe. It's
- 2:52weird because it's a Toho production, which is important, but they manage the
- 2:58balance between sci fi cheese and mind blowing knocked you out of your chair amazing
- 3:06special effects, because there's both in it, so you're at first you're like,
- 3:10what in the hell am I looking at? And then it's holy shit,
- 3:15that's amazing. It's true to the classic Godzilla films of the mid twentieth
- 3:20century. It's charming in that way. There's a lot of political subtext to
- 3:24it, you know, about the maneuverings of governments in the wake of a
- 3:29crisis. So I just thought shin Godzilla was amazing, and here is Godzilla
- 3:34minus one with one hundred percent on Rotten Tomatoes. They're like, you must
- 3:38see this film, and I guess they made the whole movie for about sixteen
- 3:42million dollars. Hello Marvel, right, Hello hello Hollywood. In general,
- 3:50it can be done for less, and stop bitching about how much money you're
- 3:55losing on five hundred million dollar films. There's a way. Good storytelling and
- 4:02creativity can make a way. So I'm going to go see Godzilla. Review
- 4:09is forthcoming. Not that I won't watch almost anything, and here's a proof.
- 4:17Last night I watched a Netflix documentary about people in England who chase a
- 4:25piece of cheese down a hill. I'm just saying I did not know this
- 4:32existed. The Cooper's Hill Cheese Rolling and Wake, and I don't know what
- 4:40they mean by wake. It is an annual event held in England at a
- 4:45place called Cooper's Hill, and I guess the hill is really steep, almost
- 4:49a fifty degree down angle. The television doesn't do it justice. I hear
- 4:55that if you stand on the top of the precipice and lean over you'll get
- 4:59vertigo. It's a steep hill. And apparently the origins are disputed, but
- 5:06somebody somewhere decided they were going to take a round piece wrapped cheese and roll
- 5:15it down, roll it down the hill and then people, I think by
- 5:23the hundreds, would fling themselves after the cheese and this would be a sport
- 5:31that would happen once a year. People get jacked up, busted limbs,
- 5:40concussion stitches, the injuries or of people's ankles turned around. It's crazy.
- 5:49You should see them. Part of the strategy that they know they are not
- 5:54going to catch the cheese because the cheese is rolling much much faster than even
- 5:58the falling human can get there. But part of the goal is to be
- 6:04the first down to the bottom. And there's like a white line of chalk
- 6:08line, and you don't just run in order to get there, you must
- 6:13fall. You fall forward, and you tumble and you splat and you slam
- 6:17and you crush and you just it's like you're in a tumble dryer and you're
- 6:24getting the hell banged out of you, and then you manage to pop back
- 6:27up. There's a strategy to how you fall and where you fall so that
- 6:32you go boom boom, boom boom, you jump up and keep running.
- 6:39People practice this. First one down to the bottom of the hill gets to
- 6:45hold up the cheese and claim victory. Who thinks this up? Where did
- 6:53it come from? But I watched a whole documentary on Netflix. It's called
- 6:57We Are the Champions, and they do like everything from Champion Hot pepper eating
- 7:03contests that was insane. Ur In Raw is big into hot foods. He
- 7:10carries a bottle of this super spicy stuff. I don't even know what it
- 7:16is. He's got a it's called the Schofield meter for the intensity of how
- 7:23hot it is. He puts that stuff on everything. We are at a
- 7:27convention we all go out to dinner, and he will order something that's hot
- 7:31anyway. He's got his beer that looks like pens oil, right, super
- 7:34black, dark, thick beer that's probably got a skull on the side,
- 7:40and you know, includes the sacrifice you know, of a virgin and there's
- 7:44virgin blood in it. Hell, I don't know. It's very gothic.
- 7:47And he reaches into his long leather coat and he pulls out his bottle of
- 7:53hot spice squillion on the Scofield meter? Is it Scofield? Am I saying
- 7:58it right? And he will just do is just pour that stuff into his
- 8:01drink, into his beer. He puts in his coffee, puts it everything.
- 8:05What's wrong with people? At some point, do you stop tasting the
- 8:11food. All you taste is hot. All you taste is the heat.
- 8:16There's no actual taste of ingredients. Don't you get to the point where it's
- 8:22pointless. It's too hot, you don't even taste the food. Can you
- 8:26damage your taste buds? The people in this contest who were eating the hot
- 8:33test foods on the planet engineered foods like not even in nature. Somebody went
- 8:37and they cross pollinated different peppers and added a bunch of stuff and jacked up
- 8:43the DNA and then prayed to Satan and got the peppers are evil, that's
- 8:48how hot they are. These professional hot pepper eaters are on stage gushing sweat.
- 8:54Their eyes are red, they're crying, they're huffing, they're puffing.
- 8:58They're forbidden to drink any milk or whatever. I guess milk helps forbidden.
- 9:07Are they damaging their bodies? Can you you can damage? Right? Could
- 9:11you not burn out your taste butts so that then you won't taste anything for
- 9:15the rest of your life. Somebody google it for me. Can hot peppers
- 9:20damage taste butts? I haven't done it. Please do it for me and
- 9:24include the answer in the comments section. Would you anyway? It? On
- 9:28Netflix? We are the champions. But I mean, I'll watch almost any
- 9:33documentary I will. I watched one on a children's group out of Australia that
- 9:39I had never heard of. Now remember that I don't have any kids of
- 9:43my own. But Natalie was all over it because her kids grew up with
- 9:46a group called the Wiggles. I guess the Wiggles is a phenomenon in Australia
- 9:56and it's branched out into the US and around the world. A group of
- 10:00people who wear primary colors, who sing songs targeted to very young children,
- 10:07and it's really sweet, and they seem to they're edgy. It was founded
- 10:13by a group of educators who wanted to go out and just provide stuff for
- 10:16young children, you know, wholesome stuff, and so they do these songs.
- 10:20There's a hot Potato song and drive the car song. I don't know.
- 10:24There's a bunch of children's song. I don't know anything about it.
- 10:26I don't have young children, but it's on. Oh look, there's a
- 10:31documentary. I think it's called Meet the Wiggles, and I watched the whole
- 10:35damn thing and loved it, so now I'm well versed in Wiggles. Natalie
- 10:43and I were in the kitchen lag we were humming the Hot Potato song.
- 10:48I'm just saying we were doing the hot Potato song. I'm reading the comments.
- 10:56Let's see to bast goat sauce in beer is pretty good, especially when
- 11:03you get to the bottom spicy finish. Cashel says, your taste buds renew
- 11:11every two weeks or so. You mean, like shark's teeth. The old
- 11:16ones rotate out and you get new ones. Is that true? Your Batah
- 11:22says you can destroy taste buds. They regrow quickly. If you eat salty
- 11:30food, it damages your taste buds. That's one reason people keep eating more
- 11:35to get the same effect. I'm just reading the comment. Don't take my
- 11:39word for it. Okay, don't take my word for it anyway. I'm
- 11:46setting up twenty twenty four. I know I'm going to be speaking in Canada
- 11:50late summer. I have been asked tentatively to do a debate with a Christian
- 11:56at a university in Virginia. I don't want to get too much into detail
- 12:01until everything is solidified and confirmed. I think they're still going through certain channels.
- 12:07Maybe they have to vet me. I don't know, but I was
- 12:11contacted and they said, would you like to come out and do a debate.
- 12:15My response was, well, I'm not a fan of the format.
- 12:18And what I mean by that is opening statement, opening statement, rebuttal,
- 12:22rebuttal, and then you've got three minutes, and you've got three minutes,
- 12:26and you know that particular format doesn't work for my style. I'm more of
- 12:31a conversationalist. I'm not interested in reading off of a script and then back
- 12:39to you, Bob. But I you know, if we were sitting on
- 12:41the stage together, one on one, in good faith, in a forum
- 12:46that is structured with respect and goodwill, and we were just talking like real
- 12:52people in front of a live audience of college students, that's my back.
- 12:58That would be my thing. I feel like I would have something to bring
- 13:01to the conversation. You know, I have a little bit imposter of imposter
- 13:05syndrome when it comes to debate. I'm not trained in debate, and I
- 13:09know it's a very specific skill. Matt Delahunty does a lot of debate that
- 13:15kind of thing. But talking, you want me to talk about religion specifically.
- 13:22You want me to get into Christianity. Okay, all right, have
- 13:26your people call my people. That's a conversation I have had quite often and
- 13:31would be happy to have again in an auditorium in Virginia. I will let
- 13:37you know if that comes to fruition. I'll be at the American Atheist Convention
- 13:43anyway. All of that's going to come into focus in the next few weeks
- 13:46as twenty twenty four arrives, and you can always monitor the events page to
- 13:52see what's up where and when the Thinkingatheist dot com slash events. Nothing is
- 13:58on that page now, but there will be quite soon. Anyway. I'm
- 14:03honored to be invited. I'm glad they thought of me. They said.
- 14:07One of the reasons that they reached out is because they thought I was a
- 14:09good guy. I don't feel like it was a setup. They said,
- 14:13you know, you seem like a person of goodwill. You seem like you
- 14:16would be a good ambassador for the subject, and we would like to have
- 14:20you out. And I took that as a tremendous compliment, so thank you
- 14:24for that. If it happens, I am going to try to get video
- 14:28of it so that all of you can see what happened. And I'll try
- 14:31not to be an embarrassment to the movement. I just want to go.
- 14:37I just when I go on stage, just tell me I'm pretty and talented.
- 14:41Just validate me. Let's see. Oh look there's some people who want
- 14:46to talk on the switchboard. And again today's no rules. I don't care,
- 14:52you know, just nothing grotesque or you know, not safe for work.
- 14:58You know, I think i'd won the other day. I just edit
- 15:00that edited that call right out. No, I don't know. I'm not
- 15:05here to shock, but you know whatever, if there's something else, something
- 15:07real, let's just chit chat. Seven eight zero. I think it says
- 15:11Peter. Do I have that right? Yes? You do. What do
- 15:16you want to talk about, Peter? What's happening? Brother? I want
- 15:18to know, Like, I listened to you and our in law, and
- 15:22I'm trying to remember the other guys. Matt delahunty, round guy, bald
- 15:30with a kind of a white go tea, and I know you know him.
- 15:35I've seen you on programs together, but I della hunt. Yes,
- 15:41yes, I don't know. He's not very round anymore. But I am
- 15:48going to bring that up at a party. I'm going to bring that up
- 15:50at a party. I'm sorry, I just go ahead, go ahead,
- 15:52Yes, Matt Delaunty. It's OK's odd times I see you guys. Gets
- 16:00like older videos that I haven't discovered until elsively to pop up on my feet
- 16:03on YouTube. Yeah, all you guys, Okay, I got to tell
- 16:08you I'm as dumb as a stump. Okay, all you guys are way
- 16:11smarter than me, way more educated than me, and it shows you have
- 16:18so much command of the Bible and science and reality and stuff. But you
- 16:23know, I was pretty much an atheist by the time I got to junior
- 16:29high school, and I hated church. I always founded a creepy place right
- 16:33from when I was a little young kid, I thought it was a creepy
- 16:37place. I hated going to church, and my dad used to drag us
- 16:41all off. So, and like I said, by junior high school,
- 16:45I was pretty much sure this whole God thing was sort of like Sandy Claus,
- 16:48another old guy with a big, big beard that wasn't true. So
- 16:53how is a smart guy do you justify taking all that time? Well,
- 16:57it's a great question. First of all, I may not be that smart.
- 17:03I'm smooth, I can, you know, talk a pretty good game.
- 17:06But I am not a great thinker, and I'll be the first to
- 17:08admit it. But when we understand the power of indoctrination, programming, cultural
- 17:15reinforcement, threats of hell, we see all the reinforcers that religions use.
- 17:21They bring you up in an alternate normal. So when I was being raised,
- 17:26I thought everything else was abnormal. The same people who taught me to
- 17:30look both ways before I crossed the street never get in a car with strangers
- 17:36that told me don't put your hand on the stove that fed my mouth and
- 17:40put the shelter over my head that I gave absolute trust to for my survival.
- 17:45Those were the same people who told me that the Bible is true and
- 17:48Jesus was real, and I would one day go to heaven if I said
- 17:52the salvation prayer. Once you get a kid early, and churches like to
- 17:56call this the four to fourteen windows. Many of us raised in a devoutly
- 18:02fundamentalist religious backgrounds, we just didn't know the difference. I said it this
- 18:08way in my autobiography. Deconverted parents will install a program onto a child's mental
- 18:17hard drive, and then they make sure that that program runs twenty four to
- 18:21seven. There is an alternate, There is an uninstalled option, but they
- 18:27don't tell you that. They say, no, no, this is the
- 18:30only program that works. And so, you know, many of us grow
- 18:34up and realize much later, or some never find out at all that actually,
- 18:40no, you can uninstall the program, and there are much better programs
- 18:44to do the job in this world. And so I really am convinced that
- 18:51people, young children are victims of often even the best intentions of religious families.
- 18:57But if everything you see and do who says God, Jesus, Bible,
- 19:00Heaven, Hell, you know, it's you're in a cocoon, You're
- 19:04in a bubble, You're in an alternate world, and that's hard to break
- 19:07out of. It doesn't really have anything to do with intelligence. I think
- 19:12some of the most intelligent people in the world can have bad ideas. We've
- 19:17seen examples of that across the spectrum. Right, Yes, yes, indeed,
- 19:21I've long thought that a lot of this religious indoctrination was child abuse.
- 19:26It bothers me deeply. One of the things though, that set me on
- 19:30the path to atheism was in grade four and I went to a Catholic school
- 19:36and we had nuns. Not all the teachers were nuns, but some of
- 19:38the teachers were nuns. And in religion class in grade four, sister Leona
- 19:44was telling us that, you know, well, heaven isn't a place you're
- 19:48not going to see. You'll hang out with your family and you know your
- 19:51dead pets or anything like that. It's just a piece. You're at peace,
- 19:56you have no thoughts or whatever. And that started to sound to me
- 20:00a lot like well, not existing anymore. You cann't. Wait a minute,
- 20:04Wait, you're at peace, but you have no thoughts. Well,
- 20:10I guess that would be peace. I guess that would be laying in a
- 20:14box and holding your breath forever. It's like that Twain quote, I had
- 20:18not existed for billions of years before now and had not suffered the slightest inconvenience
- 20:23from it. I think the same would be after I die. Right,
- 20:27if I don't exist, I guess that's peace, maybe in some context.
- 20:33But you know, cut some slack to those of us who took a long
- 20:36time busting out of the faith. It's people like to say ridiculous things like
- 20:41you need to grow up, or religion is a mental illness, that kind
- 20:45of stuff. Those are horribly wrong, tremendously misguided, and often damaging points
- 20:51of view. You know, a smart people can have and often do have
- 20:53bad ideas. And smart people are very good at out smarting themselves. They
- 20:57know how the two connect that may not even need to be connected. You
- 21:03know, they are too clever sometimes, and so we have to you know,
- 21:07we have to be vigilant regardless of IQ. Okay, yes, well,
- 21:11I often get into discussions with believers and I always get hit with the
- 21:15thing about how it's written here in our books, it must be true.
- 21:19And I always tell them, well, you know, I have a book
- 21:22that said Horton Herd of who, and I'm not sure that's true. And
- 21:26they only have one book really, unless you count the apologetics books that explain
- 21:32the book, and all the books that explain the book disagree, so they
- 21:36have to have other books to explain the books which explain the books. Just
- 21:38bizarre, Peter. But all my best up there in Canada. And I
- 21:42hope the new year is very good to you, my friend, need to
- 21:47I hope I get some cooperation with that, all right, hang in there,
- 21:49brother, bye bye. I had somebody in the chat ask me about
- 21:55talk about a topic switch, ask me about the big how's the bidet?
- 22:00What's the update on the bidet? If you miss this conversation, I'll make
- 22:04it fast. Natalie went to stay with a cousin. Cousin lives near the
- 22:11beach in California, much prettier than where we live, so I'm thinking she's
- 22:18out there having a good time, catching some rays, enjoying the waves,
- 22:21drinking a mytie. I don't know, so i'd get her on the phone
- 22:25because I'm still at the house here. Hey, Annie, how's your trip?
- 22:29What's the best part. What's the best thing you've done? And she
- 22:30said, the best thing I have done is to sit on Shanna's toilet because
- 22:38she has a heated seat and a bidet, and I just I went blank,
- 22:45like what. Before I know it, Natalie is shopping online and she
- 22:49finds this attachment that you attached to the top of your toilet. You take
- 22:56the actual the old seat off the pad seed or whatever, and you put
- 23:02this bidet thing and it is heated, nice and warm. And then when
- 23:10you want the bideta work, you have a remote control and you hit It's
- 23:14got a picture of an ass with water spraying on it on the remote and
- 23:18I Am not kidding. So you hit the ass water button and this little
- 23:23rod comes out and then water sprays up into your rectal area, warm water.
- 23:38And then whenever you think you are clean, there's a dryer. There's
- 23:45a sensation. What do I think? I can't describe the sensation. I
- 23:53feel like this is not something that I'm there should not be that since in
- 24:00that part of the body. Does that make any sense? But I will
- 24:04say I will say that the warm toilet seat is bliss. Three o'clock in
- 24:11the morning, I wake up, you know, I have to go to
- 24:15the bathroom and if I have to sit down and I hit that warm seat.
- 24:19Oh man, that's nice. So I mean, what review can I
- 24:27possibly give it? It's warm and it's comfortable, and it's weird. But
- 24:33day update December twenty twenty three, we continue with our little bonus broadcast here
- 24:41as we kick off the month of December. Your calls and who knows what
- 24:45else coming up next. If you would like to give a Christmas gift or
- 24:57holiday gift to this broadcast, become a patron. It makes a big difference
- 25:04Patreon dot com slash Seth Andrews and you can choose how much and for how
- 25:11long and whatever Patreon dot com slash Seth Andrews. Thanks so much, David
- 25:19at eight zero three, let's chat. What do you want to talk about?
- 25:25Well, since you brought up Godzilla, I thought I would bring a
- 25:27little bit of trivia that I learned from a friend of mine who is a
- 25:32huge Godzilla enthusiast, and even those like Godzilla based artwork. But something that
- 25:37a lot of people may not realize that the early models of Godzilla. What
- 25:41a lot of people think are scales was never scales. The pattern of skin
- 25:45is actually modeled after the burn victims from Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The original Godzilla
- 25:52was a political piece more than it was a monster movie. Yeah, Godzilla
- 25:56was always symbolic. He was always a what's the word I'm looking for.
- 26:02It was always a commentary on the nuclear age, on the recklessness of man,
- 26:07very much so. But I thought that little tibot might be interesting to
- 26:12you and the viewers. So we're talking about the old classics right where he's
- 26:17wearing the rubber suit and running around destroying Tokyo. Those aren't scales you're saying
- 26:22that was. They're emulating the skin burns of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. I'm going
- 26:29to go and after this live stream look up some classic Toho Godzilla and I'm
- 26:33gonna go check out the skin and because now I'm all curious. But that's
- 26:37great trivia. Thanks for sharing. No well, and if I can do
- 26:42a minor little plug for my friend, check out his his site. It's
- 26:47neomonsteriland dot com. Those Godzilla based artwork he's got up there. I think
- 26:52he might have a little bit of that early trivia on there as well.
- 26:56But there's some interesting work on there. If you like God's you might find
- 27:00it of interest. I appreciate you, man, thanks so much for calling.
- 27:03You're welcome. You have a great day. Yeah, see you later.
- 27:07Neomonsteriland dot com. Yeah, send some clicks and maybe some love their
- 27:12way. Yeah. I like to find out more about that hated, hated
- 27:18the film God's Illa Versus Kong. Like, I realize people say, well,
- 27:22it's a dumb monster movie, and so if it does something stupid,
- 27:26you're supposed to just shut your brain off and go with it. Yeah,
- 27:30no, like you got to at least try. God's Illa Versus Kong starts
- 27:37so strongly with the story about Kong and the little girl and the connection that
- 27:41they have, and then they go off into oblivion and talk about what this
- 27:48jungle home hidden under the Earth's crust where Kong lives. What the what?
- 27:56I'm sorry, So if you drill down into the Earth's core you'll find Kongville.
- 28:03Go. I almost I almost left. I was so disappointed. Let's
- 28:11take a look here. Oh, I've got Jeff calling in. He is
- 28:15almost cued on the switchboard. I did like the Gareth Edwards Godzilla film,
- 28:19the first one that they wasted Brian Cranston, but it was actually pretty good
- 28:26movie. And then what was the next one? Was it King of the
- 28:29Monsters? The one with Rodin. I need someone to guide me into the
- 28:36correct films. Jeff from south West Washington? Are you with me? My
- 28:41friend? Yeah? Here? How are you? I'm well, what's on
- 28:44your mind? You know, it's something I wanted to ask you about for
- 28:47a while now, and I really like to get r Ns and Matts and
- 28:51Noah's take on it too. Is when I was still a practicing pagan,
- 28:56I heard some of the horsemen talking about religion, you Dokins and Echins and
- 29:00whatnot, and they always focused on the absurdity of Christianity, the absurdity of
- 29:08Islam. Not a whole lot of people touch on the belief systems that are
- 29:14sort of a part of the neopagan movement. And you know, first of
- 29:17all, the neopagans aren't the ones in power trying to change laws to you
- 29:22know, affect other people, so perhaps they don't need as much attention.
- 29:26And I just wondered if you have any kind of send up for neopaganism at
- 29:30all. I think the reason that the primary focus is on the Big two
- 29:36is because these are the wildfires that require our immediate attention. I mean,
- 29:40even on this show, we've gotten into some other stuff, more of the
- 29:44culty stuff, from time to time. But I think most of the reason
- 29:48you hear Christianity Islam over and over and over is because that's where the main
- 29:52threats are. I myself don't know much about neopaganism, and I would welcome
- 29:59experts to guide me through those conversations and maybe even do an entire broadcast on
- 30:03them. Is this your wheelhouse? Uh? Well, I mean as somebody
- 30:08who practiced for a long time, and as somebody with a degree in psychology,
- 30:12you know, I can kind of break it down a little bit,
- 30:15but I wouldn't call myself an expert. Well, I mean, give me
- 30:18the premer, give me the reader's digest version of neo paganism. Okay,
- 30:23So for me, it's a focus on the cycle of the year in life
- 30:30and death and rebirth. So at October thirty first is the new year.
- 30:33That's what we would call the blood feast in ancient Europe before the Romans came
- 30:37and mucked things up, and what happened during the blood feast is that you
- 30:41would slaughter the animals who weren't expected to make it through the winter. You're
- 30:45bringing the rest of the crops that you were going to store, and then
- 30:48you throw a big party and invite everybody in town and you celebrate the bountiful
- 30:52harvest that you have and that we're you know, we're going to be able
- 30:56to get through these cold, dark times together. And then there's different points
- 31:00throughout the year, the softsses, the equinoxes, they call them quarters and
- 31:03cross quarters. But at different times of the year there are different things to
- 31:07do, such as you know, October is obviously harvest. In February we
- 31:11have mol which is the first of the planting season, right, And to
- 31:18take it to a metaphorical place, you know, I think about harvest the
- 31:22lessons that I've learned throughout the year, and when I'm planting, I'm planting
- 31:27ideas and thoughts and desires and goals I want to see throughout the coming year
- 31:34and hopefully harvest off of again. So in a nutshell, that's kind of
- 31:40a primer. I guess, yeah, what I have liked about and we
- 31:44talk about Pagan traditions as precursors to many of our Christian traditions. I have
- 31:49always liked the gratitude, you know, the connection with the earth, the
- 31:56preparing for the future, and the honoring of the past. Those elements of
- 32:00paganism always kind of struve I always thought they were kind of romantic and actually
- 32:04quite human in that way. I don't know if I'm overreading it or overthinking
- 32:07it. Would you agree, I mean it's sort of an earthy connection,
- 32:10a connection to life, kind of a vibe, right, yeah, and
- 32:15yeah, exactly. And the quote that comes to mind is be noble for
- 32:19you are made of stars, Be humble, for you are made of earth.
- 32:22Right, I'm writing that down. I'm writing that down. That's so
- 32:28good. So my connection with the Earth is important because every molecule that's in
- 32:32my body right now was already here on Earth, and then some chemical reaction
- 32:37came along and stacked it up into me. And so understanding and appreciating the
- 32:42cycles that the Earth goes through and how life evolved here and why we have
- 32:45the practices that we do around you know, finding agriculture and whatnot. I
- 32:51mean, obviously industrial agricultures found ways around you know, like having to leave
- 32:55a field sallow in order to replenish the soil, and you know that kind
- 33:00But you know, I think taking that connection to the earth and then metaphorically
- 33:05transferring it my connection to other human beings. Yeah, you know, it's
- 33:07kind of romantic. So maybe maybe there's not much to send up here.
- 33:13I mean, I'll ask the listeners if they would be interested in a show
- 33:16on paganism, neo paganism, et cetera. But I would have to lean
- 33:21on shoulders much bigger and taller than my own. So yeah, let's let's
- 33:24kind of let me float a trial balloon on that one to do because you're
- 33:29like six' five, right, six one, But you're very kind.
- 33:32Now you want to see somebody tall and looming, just look at ur and
- 33:37Raw. You know, he's he doesn't need lifts like Ron DeSantis does.
- 33:40He just walks and looms and then he pulls out the hot powder. He's
- 33:45such a teddy beer. I just want to sit on his lap and tell
- 33:47him what I want for Halloween. Yeah, that's a whole other party right
- 33:52there. All right, my friend, be safe, Jeff, thanks for
- 33:57calling. Talking to see you later. I think it's romantic to think that,
- 34:02and when I say it, it sounds like a freaking Hallmark movie.
- 34:06But we are all star dust, right. The elements that came from the
- 34:08stars constitute everything that we see around us and constitute too, and what we
- 34:15are. And from stars we came, and to stars we will one day
- 34:21return. I think that's magical. It's a kind of I guess what I
- 34:25call it? Eternal life? As we pass away, right, my day
- 34:30comes and the elements of my body are reconstituted into the earth, and then
- 34:37over the course of time into other things, and then the earth finally goes
- 34:42away and the sun burns up, and I don't know what the universe is
- 34:45going to do, what it's but we continue on in that way. We're
- 34:51not conscious of it, but it is a kind of eternal life. I
- 34:54don't know. I mean, do you see it as romantic in that way?
- 35:00I kind of do, But maybe I'm just a big sap. Paul
- 35:02at six one two, Thanks for your patience. Are you with me?
- 35:07Hey? How you doing, Seth? I'm great, my friend. Let's
- 35:09talk what's on your mind? Well, first of all, I wanted to
- 35:13say quickly, it was really nice to meet you. When you're out in
- 35:15Minneapolis last time. That was a really good talk, really fun time,
- 35:20so I really appreciate that. Thank you. So I was going through some
- 35:22of your old episodes and you talked about really liking Spanish guitar and you always
- 35:29wanted to learn, and you wrote a pretty neat little composition as well.
- 35:31But I thought was pretty cool. Tell me a little bit about that.
- 35:35I'm curious. Flamenco is actually one of my specialities, and I'm curious as
- 35:39to what is it about Spanish guitar that really kind of speaks to you When
- 35:45you say I did an arrangement, I did it on a keyboard with the
- 35:47Spanish guitar kind of a program. So I totally cheated. I am not
- 35:52a great pianist. I play only by ear. I was a nightmare for
- 35:57all my music teachers because as they were trying to teach me scales and all
- 36:01of those clefts and everything else, I just wanted to go play my own
- 36:05thing. But I took guitar lessons for a few months. I just couldn't
- 36:09get my fingers around the fret. I couldn't get them to connect with the
- 36:13strings. I wasn't and I became so frustrated. And everybody I've spoken almost
- 36:16everybody I've spoken to who plays guitar and even teaches guitar, they say,
- 36:22that's normal. You will feel like it is never going to happen, You're
- 36:25going to be terrible, and then suddenly you will connect with the instruments.
- 36:30After three months. I never got there, and I think I put the
- 36:34guitar on eBay and went to go do other things. But do you play,
- 36:38do you teach? What's your story? Yeah? Yeah, so again,
- 36:44I don't know if you remember me so many people, but I'm actually
- 36:46a music professor and I own a little guitar and music school out here,
- 36:51and yeah, I've been teaching for a long time. And one thing I
- 36:52told all my students is I say, you gotta be okay with sounding like
- 36:57shit, and that's normal. You're gonna be fine, right, And I
- 37:00think that kind of allows them to relax a little bit, because a lot
- 37:04of people come into lessons with this idea that, oh my gosh, I
- 37:07gotta sound perfect, I can't make any mistakes. And I tell everyone you've
- 37:09got to make mistakes, you got to you have to suck before you're good.
- 37:14And I find that generally speaking, that kind of puts a lot of
- 37:15people at ease, and it's just fun to see people kind of grow with
- 37:21the instruments, whether they want to be a really great guitar player or they
- 37:25just want to pick up a couple of giant cash tunes. Hey, if
- 37:29they're having a great time and they're picking up the instrument because they love it,
- 37:30that makes me happy as a teacher. Well, I'm not saying it's
- 37:35impossible. It's it's out of the cards that I will let never pick up.
- 37:38I may one day try again. It's probably like anything that you do.
- 37:44You know, if you're going to be a singer or a writer or
- 37:46some sort of painter, you know you're probably going to be horrible for a
- 37:51while until you are not. But you know, are there some people,
- 37:54Paul, that just will never get there? Come on, I know you've
- 37:57had some students and you're like, you need to do something else with your
- 38:00life. Do you ever just write somebody off, Because you'd probably write me
- 38:05off if I showed up in your classroom. Paul. I'm just saying,
- 38:07well, you'll have to show up some time, and then you know,
- 38:10I've the students that I mean, I've never like so much kicked somebody out.
- 38:15But you know, I can usually tell if someone if it's in their
- 38:17heart or not, you know, and they're just like maybe too afraid to
- 38:21say, hey, this just isn't my thing, and I'll just sit them
- 38:24down and just have a nice frank talk with it, and I'll tell them,
- 38:27hey, I tried some instruments too that I thought it like and I
- 38:30and I've didn't, but you gave it a shot and that's perfectly fine,
- 38:32and that's perfectly okay. If you ever want to come back, you're welcome.
- 38:35So I've never you know, I've never sat down and told someone,
- 38:38you know, you can't do this in no way. I work with a
- 38:40lot of kids who are autistic, and usually with those kids is they have
- 38:45sort of an inn. They have a thing that they're really good at,
- 38:47and that can be Like example, I have a student who is really into
- 38:52training, especially injurines, and you can you can tell this kid any year,
- 38:58any year, any date, and he can tell you everything about that
- 39:00steam engine and how it was built and what it takes. So what we
- 39:04do is rewrite songs together that sound like those engines. So I'll say,
- 39:07nineteen forty two, what does the engine sound like? And he'll write a
- 39:10song making sounds with his guitar that sounds like that engine toom And so that's
- 39:15a super gratifying thing to see. And also it's neat to allow him in
- 39:19introduction and experience with music via something he understands. I don't know if that
- 39:22makes sense or not. It does. It's ingenious. What a great way
- 39:25to sort of go into their wheelhouse and make it personal and unique to them.
- 39:30That's fantastic. Well, thanks for the encouragement. And you know,
- 39:35for me, I just love the way it sounds acoustic guitar in general.
- 39:38One of my favorite songs is a song that released I want to say in
- 39:43the late eighties by staying it's called Fragile and it's mostly just him on the
- 39:49acoustic guitar and I could listen to that tune and songs like it all day
- 39:53long. It's funny you mentioned that I was actually just teaching that to a
- 39:57student yesterday. So that's a nice ole coincidence. Powerful message, really really
- 40:00good stuff. Yeah, absolutely, one more thing before I go. And
- 40:05I know you get tons of emails, but a while ago I tried to
- 40:07send you a link to a free copy of my Flamenco album. I don't
- 40:12know if you've got that or not. I would have brought you a copy
- 40:15when you were here in Minneapolis, but I sold out of all my copies,
- 40:17which is a good problem to have. But can I go ahead and
- 40:21read send that to you and give you just a link for a free DOWB
- 40:23Just kind of my way of saying thanks for everything you've given us as a
- 40:28community. Yeah, I'd be honored forgive my inbox it is now. I
- 40:31have not seen it, but I think I've got ten thousand emails in the
- 40:37box. I've read a bunch, but I can't keep up because that plus
- 40:39the Facebook messages, plus all of the comments that are coming on, plus
- 40:45everything else that's in the pipeline. And I'm just one guy. So if
- 40:47I missed it, it is not personal. Send it to me again.
- 40:51Would it be under your name? Well, I see Paul, Yes,
- 40:54Okay, I'll look for Paul. Just send it to me tonight. I'll
- 40:58go take a peek before we call a day. All right, And again,
- 41:00a big thanks for your show, a big thanks for everything you do.
- 41:04You know, I know you've questioned before whether you're making a difference.
- 41:06You are. I just want you to know that and keep doing what you
- 41:09do. And I hope to see you in Minneapolis Saint Paul again. Sometimes
- 41:13all right, all right, my friend, take care of yourself. We'll
- 41:15see you later. Hey, you too. Thanks that. I find myself
- 41:20apologizing a lot for having a difficult time keeping up. But you know,
- 41:25I like being busy. I'd rather have too much than not enough, although
- 41:30occasionally it is a little bit overwhelming. So and I probably and Natalie says,
- 41:37I do it to myself. She's like, you started a second podcast,
- 41:43Yes, honey. She's totally supportive. She's like, with all that,
- 41:49wait, with all that you're doing, you have a set yes?
- 41:52How often does it release? Three times a week? How much research does
- 41:55it require? You do not want to know, but you know people are
- 42:01noticing the true stories with Seth Andrews podcast. If you haven't heard it,
- 42:07I would encourage you to check it out. I should do one for you
- 42:10here, just since we have a second I'll get to Dave on the switchboard
- 42:15in just a moment. This was I think one of the first stories that
- 42:21I released in August. I think of twenty twenty two. If you've heard
- 42:27this one, forgive me. And if I screw up a couple of the
- 42:30details, it's because I'm doing it for memory. I don't have the script
- 42:34in front of me, but this is the kind of thing that I'm doing.
- 42:37On the second show. The year is nineteen fifty three. If I
- 42:45recall man named John, he's a codebreaker for the United States Air Force.
- 42:54This is roughly eight years after the ending of the Second World War, but
- 42:59the Cold War between the superpowers is in full swing, specifically the United States
- 43:05and Soviet Russia with their spies in our midst our spies in their midst John
- 43:12was a codebreaker in the Air Force. His job was to intercept and translate
- 43:17coded Soviet transmissions, and then he would report those messages to his superiors and
- 43:24they would go up the chain of command. And one day there was a
- 43:30lot of traffic, a lot of chatter about Joseph Stalin, the dictator.
- 43:35Now. Stalin had been the totalitarian dictator of Russia since the nineteen thirties,
- 43:43brutal tyrants. In fact, historians would say Stalin was responsible for the deaths
- 43:49of around twenty million of his own citizens. Many by starvation. But what
- 43:54happened to Stalin would affect the balance of power in the rest to the world.
- 44:00And so whenever John was sitting in the codebreaker's chair he heard these messages,
- 44:06he decoded them and they said, Joseph Stalin is in failing health.
- 44:09He is very ill. It doesn't look good. Doctors have been summoned.
- 44:15I mean, this was big news, and this was news that Russia wanted
- 44:17to protect. John caught it and he sent those messages translated up the chain
- 44:23of command until finally the message came in, Joseph Stalin has died. John
- 44:32the codebreaker translated that. He gave it to his superior and immediately it rushed
- 44:37up the chain of command to reach President Dwight Eisenhower. Now what's interesting about
- 44:44this true story is not about Stalin. It's about John. Because John,
- 44:52John, whose message went up to reach the ear of a president's would in
- 44:57his life go on to meet and shake ends with presidents. John in his
- 45:04off hours, was a musician. He wrote songs, played guitar. He
- 45:08was honorably discharged, and he started to pursue music more seriously. Before he
- 45:15knew it, he was writing and recording and performing in front of hundreds,
- 45:17than thousands, and then tens of thousands of people. John would eventually go
- 45:23on to be inducted into both the Rock and Roll and the Country Music Hall
- 45:29of Fame. That same John who sat in the Codebreaker's chair. That was
- 45:37the John who walked the line, who went down to that burning ring of
- 45:45fire and sang the fulsome prison blues, Johnny Cash. And that's the kind
- 45:58of fun stuff I get to release for you three times a week, True
- 46:04Stories with Seth Andrews streaming on all major podcast apps. This is still my
- 46:09first love. That is, it's becoming a close second. We got more
- 46:15to talk about and more calls next. Hard to believe it is the month
- 46:24of December already on Time flies, and I think time flies more quickly as
- 46:31we get older. When we were kids and somebody said, oh, you
- 46:37can do this in a week, we'd be like, I don't want to
- 46:43wait a week. A week is forever. I can't believe it's going to
- 46:46be a whole week. We would whine and moan and carry on because a
- 46:50week was eternity. Now I blink and it's next week, Like all of
- 46:57a sudden, it's December twenty twenty three, The new year reproaches. Twenty
- 47:00twenty four is around the corner. It's weird. Time goes faster as I
- 47:07get older, and I'm kind of freaked out about it when I'm sixty five.
- 47:14What am I just going to like? We'll look around in January turns
- 47:17into August like that. I don't know. I'm I'm just saying, Dave
- 47:24fits seven to one nine. Thanks for waiting on me. What do you
- 47:28want to talk about? Hey, well, thanks for taking my call real
- 47:31quick. I guess in the same vein, I didn't know that story about
- 47:35Johnny Cash. It's really cool, but with the music and the guitar speak
- 47:38and everything like that, it got me thinking for a moment, I really
- 47:42wish that within our education, I really wish there was more of an emphasis
- 47:46putting on the acceptance of failure and trying and not succeeding. But that's okay,
- 47:54because it feels like the way the mark is set, it's either you
- 48:00or you don't, and if you don't, it's bad across the board.
- 48:05And I mean, nobody wakes up able to play guitar. You know,
- 48:10it's something you kind of got to work out a little bit, But I'm
- 48:13sorry, that's a little bit of a tangent. No, I like it.
- 48:15I like the sentiment of it. You know, does it bring you
- 48:17joy, does it fulfill you? Does it feed something in you? Is
- 48:22a hell of a lot more important than are you a master of it?
- 48:28I think that's valid. Sure, sure, I would say that if you
- 48:30had the same passion for playing guitar as you do for your podcast, you'd
- 48:34probably be a rock star. I don't know you if you haven't seen me
- 48:37with a guitar, but you know, I get it. It's like,
- 48:40I'm not a great pianist at all, but it does feel good to go
- 48:45and just kind of peck away at the keys, and who cares if I'm
- 48:46never going to be on stage at Carnegie Hall. It's a great release and
- 48:51it's you know, it's something that feeds something in me. So yeah,
- 48:54that's a great point. I appreciate you making a day. What else.
- 48:58Yeah, it's more important to love than it is to succeed. It's the
- 49:00love for it will help you succeed. But I wanted to talk a little
- 49:06bit about you know, the holidays are coming up for people of us non
- 49:08belief and skeptical persuasion. It can be a difficult time, especially if we
- 49:14have, you know, some ostracization from families and things like that, and
- 49:17going into that. It's a little bit of a struggle for me as I've
- 49:22come into my own here and started breaking away from a lot of the things
- 49:25that I used to think and how I've developed as an adult on account of
- 49:29religion. It's men me realize a lot of the subtle evils that kind of
- 49:32come along with growing up in a faith based institution. You have a lot
- 49:37of people who kind of express those sentiments towards you or I hear a lot
- 49:43from people stressed about the holidays. I myself had a whole conversation about how
- 49:49much do you engage over at the Thanksgiving holiday? Is it worth it?
- 49:54Why do it? What's the cost benefits? What do you want to get
- 49:59out of it? And I understand, you know, it's some people just
- 50:04light up in the months of November and December in the United States, and
- 50:08there are other people who have the opposite feeling. It's hard. They've lost
- 50:13people, maybe the death of a family member becomes much more forefront in their
- 50:17mind. You know, there's an empty chair at the family gathering. Maybe
- 50:22the season causes them to feel depressed as the weather has gotten colder and darker.
- 50:28It's so many factors, and you know, you make a great point
- 50:31that despite the fact that we are surrounded by all of those happy, clappy,
- 50:36nauseatingly cheery, bell filled holiday songs playing on the you know, on
- 50:42the loud speakers at the department stores, it's not really that reality for a
- 50:46great many people. So it's a good point. I've always been really appreciative
- 50:52of the sense of you know, giving and camaraderie with people, and you
- 50:55know, for me, the season is very much so about that, just
- 50:59you know, basic humanity, the people that you don't get to see all
- 51:01the time, and you want to let them know that you're thinking about them,
- 51:05and you want to enjoy those sorts of things with them. But I've
- 51:08suffered with depression for a very long time, and unfortunately, I come from
- 51:15a very religious family, and by that I mean Pentecostal evangelist, So it's
- 51:21a really hard thing for me. Who's somebody who's skeptically minded, who's you
- 51:25know, I want to consider myself a rationalist, But that's one of those
- 51:30things, you know, can't put a title on yourself to be Oh,
- 51:31I'm a rationalist, you know, just like I'm so humble and so caring
- 51:37and giving. But no, well, I don't think that's necessarily egotistical,
- 51:40Dave, to say that. You know, I am a person who is
- 51:44a promoter of rationality, and that's a focus for me. I understand that
- 51:49you don't want to come off as haughty and presumptuous and egotistical. But I
- 51:54you know, if you're a rationalist, you sound like a rationalist to me.
- 51:59So yeah, i'd call you that, Dave. I'd call you that.
- 52:01But it's a difficult thing to call out for help when you have these
- 52:07mental issues that are going on in the background, and I've had to kind
- 52:10of lean on outside sources. Talking with the family members the other day,
- 52:14they actually suggested that I go and see a therapist that Focus on the Family,
- 52:19and I didn't quite know how to tell them no, other than you
- 52:23know, I won't be a part of that evil and it's hard if I
- 52:30may. For those who don't know what Dave's talking about, Focus on the
- 52:32Family is a religious organization that was founded and run by James Dobson, who
- 52:39is a fundamentalist Christian apologist. He's a hardliner, and he's just a freaking
- 52:45human rights nightmare. He's a science nightmare, he's a history nightmare. He's
- 52:51a propaganda nightmare. And so the idea that's focus on the family would be
- 52:55guiding any counseling is terrified because they would likely be rooting it in notions of
- 53:02obedience and disobedience and divine destiny and Jesus is watching you and pray more and
- 53:07all that craziness. So I'm glad you escape that when that would have been
- 53:12a nightmare. Whenever I need to remind myself that I'm a good person,
- 53:15I remember one time I was called to deliver a pizza to their offices,
- 53:21and I resisted the temptation to do anything to it. So I said,
- 53:25yeah, I think I'm a decent person in that respectively. You did your
- 53:30job with honor, Dave, you know, and I appreciate that you didn't
- 53:34bring your own agenda into the pizza delivery, and I appreciate that. I
- 53:38know it's hard for a lot of people. I don't think there's any wrong
- 53:42way to spend the holiday unless you are in denial of yourself, your authentic
- 53:47self. I think that's wrong, But don't beat yourself up too much,
- 53:52you know, I think struggles are part of the human experience, and I'm
- 53:54glad that you are pursuing options. Just know you've got support and family,
- 53:59unconditional support here. And I hope the holiday and I hope the new year
- 54:02brings really good things for you. Okay, indeed, And thank you all
- 54:07very much. The likes of yourself, Matt Dillahunty the round one. As
- 54:13far as I'm concerned going forward, he's not round an. I know he's
- 54:17not. But now that's going to be stuck in my head forever. That's
- 54:21going to get back. But the likes of you, Bennett Docum and the
- 54:24people like that who I got to lose and talk and reassuring me that I
- 54:29was not alone. You are among that, and I thank you very much.
- 54:32I look at you as an uncle that is saying I get to be
- 54:37the same uncle during the holidays. Well, I'll take that seat at the
- 54:40table, and I hope the holidays are good for you. Thanks for calling,
- 54:44Thank you very much. Have a good season. Matt will be the
- 54:46first to tell you that he lost He lost a lot of weight, since
- 54:51the first time we met back in twenty eleven, and so I think there's
- 54:55still a publicity photo or three of him floating around from back then. So
- 55:01when somebody said he's the round one, I think they're either referring to the
- 55:06bald head which makes them think round, but mad. I mean, he's
- 55:09pretty lean these days, so I don't know, but that is going to
- 55:14get back to him. It's just whatever I did, whatever, I'm just
- 55:17going to leave that out there. I appreciate you watching and listening. I
- 55:22appreciate you being a part of my life over the year twenty twenty three and
- 55:28again, there's no wrong way to spend the holidays. I call it Christmas.
- 55:32That's the name of the holiday. You can call it whatever you want.
- 55:36Some people love to do the whole thing, tree, presence, music,
- 55:39everything else. Some people say, screw it, I'm not going to
- 55:43do a damn thing. Absolutely fine. Maybe you want to decorate with your
- 55:47own flavor of Christmas, traditions, your own color, scheme, different foods,
- 55:53different different stuff. The aesthetic I think doesn't have to be any one
- 55:58thing. There's no wrong to do the holiday season. Just make it right,
- 56:02make it yours and enjoy yourself, and that's my hope for you,
- 56:07and I will see you back here next time. Follow the Thinking Atheist on
- 56:12Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs
- 56:16and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources,
- 56:22and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website,
- 56:28The Thinkingatheist dot com.