Latest / Public Health Review Morning Edition / 1074: From Wastewater to Radiological Readiness: Detecting and Responding to Public Health Threats
Transcript
- 0:01This is Public Health Review MORNING Edition for Monday,
- 0:03February 23rd, 2026. I'm John Sheehan with news from
- 0:07the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.
- 0:10Today, two conversations about very different kinds of
- 0:13preparedness, wastewater surveillance and radiological
- 0:17emergency response. First, Allison Wheeler, manager
- 0:21of the Wastewater Surveillance Unit at the Colorado Department
- 0:24of Public Health and Environment, shares how her team
- 0:26detected measles in wastewater before clinical cases appeared,
- 0:30helping local partners identify an outbreak early and act
- 0:33quickly later. Doctor Ziad Kazi, professor of
- 0:37emergency medicine at Emory University and president of the
- 0:40American College of Medical Toxicology.
- 0:42We'll explain what a radiological emergency really
- 0:45looks like, from accidental exposures to nuclear incidents,
- 0:48and what to think about and prepare for with mass gatherings
- 0:52like, for example, the upcoming FIFA World Cup.
- 0:56But first, here's Allison Wheeler explaining Colorado's
- 0:59approach to wastewater surveillance.
- 1:02So we started a pilot project for measles wastewater testing
- 1:07back in May of 2025. And we always do a pilot project
- 1:13when we bring on new pathogens so that we can evaluate the
- 1:17assay for sensitivity and we can figure out what the data means
- 1:24and so when to report data to our local public health
- 1:27departments and our public stakeholders.
- 1:30So it was in early August where we detected measles genetic
- 1:36material in a wastewater sample from Grand Junction.
- 1:41And 1st we detected a really low level detection and then the
- 1:47sample directly after that. Since wastewater utilities
- 1:51submit 2 samples per week, that was a very high level detection.
- 1:56And so we were pretty sure that this indicated a community
- 2:00transmission of measles in Grand Junction.
- 2:03So we reached out to our Mesa County public health partners
- 2:08and alerted them of these wastewater detections.
- 2:11And their first response was, we don't have any measles cases.
- 2:15And we said, yeah, but we think there might be something going
- 2:19on. And so we would recommend at a
- 2:21minimum reaching out to your healthcare providers to remind
- 2:26them that measles is indeed circulating in Colorado and to
- 2:31remind them of the symptoms and to not hesitate to test patients
- 2:36that presented with those symptoms.
- 2:38And so sure enough, two days later they identified their
- 2:41first case, and then after that they identified and a total of
- 2:4611 cases that were part of that outbreak.
- 2:49That's wild. You absolutely caught it before
- 2:54even cases were coming in. We did, and I think that's the
- 2:57power of wastewater surveillance, especially with
- 3:01these emerging or reemerging pathogens.
- 3:05And what is it about measles that makes it detectable in
- 3:08wastewater? And what other sorts of
- 3:10pathogens do you usually come across?
- 3:13Yeah. So we have a set of defined
- 3:16targets that we test for. So we started with COVID.
- 3:20We test for flu, A&BRSVEV, D68-M, pox, and of course
- 3:29measles. And part of what we do when we
- 3:33are figuring out which pathogens we're going to test for, because
- 3:37we only have so many resources, is we determine if that pathogen
- 3:43is shed in the gut or through urine or another way to get into
- 3:51the wastewater system so we might be able to detect it.
- 3:54And measles virus is in fact shed in urine, feces and
- 3:58respiratory secretions of infected individuals.
- 4:03And so we knew that we could, well, we thought we could detect
- 4:06it in wastewater and we did. And that allows us that that
- 4:10early warning signal to identify us if there is a problem in a
- 4:17certain community. And so we know that measles is
- 4:21shed in urine for four days before rash onset and four days
- 4:25after. And so that's part of the reason
- 4:29that we added this. As you know, we wanted to pilot
- 4:33measles to see if it was beneficial to test for it in
- 4:36wastewater, and we found that it was.
- 4:38Yeah. And then you, you find yourself
- 4:41knowing ahead of the other health agencies that this is
- 4:45coming. What, what do you do?
- 4:48How do you, how do you act on that?
- 4:50And how do you how do you engage your partners to take action?
- 4:55Yeah. You know, I think we, we've
- 4:58learned some lessons for sure. And so I think we, we work very
- 5:04closely with our other groups at CDPHE, including our vaccine
- 5:10preventable disease team. And they're also, they have to
- 5:14be supportive of what we're doing and, and they are.
- 5:16And so we work with them. We work with our EPI response
- 5:20unit who works very closely with our local public health agency.
- 5:25We work with, we worked with Mesa County Public Health.
- 5:29And then of course we loop in our comms teams.
- 5:33And so we then we can figure out together how best to message the
- 5:40wastewater results to folks in the community, whether that's
- 5:43healthcare providers or whether it's the public too.
- 5:47And so we've learned that that consistent, clear language about
- 5:52wastewater surveillance is really needed to help our
- 5:56partners understand the results. And we also have learned that we
- 6:01need to continue our education outreach to our local public
- 6:05health partners to make sure that they understand the
- 6:08benefits of wastewater surveillance data and how to use
- 6:11it, how to act. And so specifically right now,
- 6:15one of our team members is working on an education camp
- 6:18campaign specifically for public information officers at local
- 6:23health departments so that they can feel confident in relaying
- 6:27those results to their communities.
- 6:30Yeah. And in addition to sort of that
- 6:33speedy response and that early detection, are there other
- 6:39benefits to wastewater surveillance either enhancing or
- 6:44complementing traditional disease surveillance?
- 6:48Absolutely. I think a major advantage of
- 6:51wastewater surveillance is the ability, its ability to monitor
- 6:56the health of an entire community in a cost effective
- 6:59and non invasive way. And so we know that with people
- 7:06that are infected with measles can shed the virus in their
- 7:09urine up to four days before the rash onset.
- 7:12And so this allows wastewater surveillance to pick up the
- 7:15virus before the person even knows they're sick.
- 7:18And so this overcomes some of the challenges of traditional
- 7:21case reporting, including the delay between infection and
- 7:25testing. And with a disease as
- 7:29transmissible as measles, we, we don't really need trends.
- 7:33Yes, it's good to have trends to understand what's happening with
- 7:38levels of disease in the community.
- 7:40But with a disease as transmissible as measles, we act
- 7:43on those detections rather than those increasing trends.
- 7:48And so we, we tend to message a little bit differently with
- 7:53these emerging pathogens than we do with say our our traditional
- 8:00targets like COVID or flu or RSV.
- 8:04I see because they're so transmissible, it's more of a
- 8:09red alert situation. Correct.
- 8:11And so it sounds like communication with colleagues
- 8:14across the health system, the public health system, was, was
- 8:17pretty key. What other lessons did you learn
- 8:20in engaging, you know, other parts of the system?
- 8:22Yeah. I think one of the things that
- 8:25that we learned is that we need to involve our vaccine
- 8:33preventable disease team and our health department leadership
- 8:37early on in the process of bringing on a new target to make
- 8:41sure that they support surveillance for, you know, in
- 8:45this case, vaccine preventable diseases and wastewater.
- 8:48If they don't, you know, we we're, we would be collecting
- 8:52this data with no one using it. And, and we don't want to do
- 8:55that. And so the other thing that
- 8:57we've really learned is that we need to teach our internal teams
- 9:03how to use and interpret the data.
- 9:07It it's not very intuitive if you're not familiar with this
- 9:12viral concentration data in wastewater.
- 9:16So we really encourage their participation in calls with our
- 9:21team, our wastewater surveillance team and also with
- 9:23local health departments so that they can explain the clinical
- 9:27relevance of what we're finding in wastewater.
- 9:30And then I would say, I encourage all folks that are
- 9:36even interested, you know, we have teams here at CDPHE that
- 9:39reach out to us that say, hey, we're interested in seeing if we
- 9:43could do wastewater surveillance for X pathogen.
- 9:46Can you do that? And so we talk through it to see
- 9:49if it's even viable, if it fills any surveillance gaps, of
- 9:54course, if if that pathogen is even shed in wastewater, and
- 9:59what value it would bring to their current surveillance
- 10:04system. Yeah.
- 10:04So it sounds like the field itself is still being developed.
- 10:07You're still learning what you can find from wastewater.
- 10:09Absolutely. We are learning every a single
- 10:13day and it's been we've been involved in this for almost 5
- 10:161/2 years now. How much do other public health
- 10:20systems use wastewater surveillance?
- 10:22I mean, is it? Is it widely used?
- 10:25It is, I think now throughout the United States, I think at
- 10:29least every state is involved in wastewater surveillance at
- 10:32different levels. Of course, we were one of the
- 10:35early adopters back in 2020 during the pandemic, but now at
- 10:40least most states are testing for the viral respiratory
- 10:44targets. So COVID, flu and RSV.
- 10:47Other states, especially the the, the six centers of
- 10:51excellence that CDC has designated, they're doing some
- 10:56more advanced work. And so we're doing a pilot
- 11:00project for seeing if we can detect antimicrobial resistant
- 11:05genes in wastewater, so we can determine the prevalence of
- 11:08antimicrobial resistance in communities.
- 11:11We're looking for fungal targets.
- 11:14We're looking for arboviruses like West Nile virus to
- 11:18determine if that can be a supplemental surveillance
- 11:21system. So it really depends state to
- 11:23state, but yes, most states are involved in wastewater
- 11:26surveillance now. It seemed like the expertise in
- 11:29parsing the data was a pretty was a pretty fundamental need
- 11:35for this kind of work. Do you have any other tips or
- 11:39advice for for systems that want to expand their use of
- 11:43wastewater surveillance? Yeah, definitely.
- 11:45You know one of the things that we recognize here at CDPHE on
- 11:49our wastewater surveillance team is that we are not an expert in
- 11:52all of the pathogens for which we monitor.
- 11:56And so we very, we involve our other subject matter experts,
- 12:04you know, that work in vaccine preventable diseases or
- 12:08healthcare acquired infections or our zoonotic team depending
- 12:13on what we're monitoring. We, you know, one thing that I
- 12:17would recommend is, is starting with those partners early on in
- 12:22when you're considering bringing on a target.
- 12:26So you can determine if number one, that target is, is shed in
- 12:31wastewater. If we're going to be able to
- 12:33pick it up, what kind of surveillance gaps that
- 12:37wastewater surveillance may fill by doing surveillance for that
- 12:40target and how that subject matter expert team would use
- 12:44that data. We want to make sure that
- 12:46they're going to use it. I also think it's really
- 12:49important to involve your leadership so that they're under
- 12:56understanding and supportive of wastewater surveillance for
- 13:01whatever target you may do, may understand how to interpret and
- 13:07use the data because often times they're asked by either media or
- 13:13national officials how and what we're doing at the state, right?
- 13:19So it's really important for them to be involved.
- 13:22I think 2, letting it, letting people know that the wastewater
- 13:27surveillance team doesn't have to be the expert in that
- 13:31specific target that you're monitoring is important, right?
- 13:35That can leave a lot of stress for the wastewater surveillance
- 13:39team, and so that's when that subject matter expert team
- 13:43becomes really valuable. Encourage them to join calls
- 13:47with the local health departments so that they can
- 13:50explain the clinical relevance of what you're finding in in
- 13:53wastewater surveillance data. And then I think it's important
- 13:58to make sure that you're teaching your local public
- 14:03health departments, even the public, how to use this
- 14:07wastewater surveillance data so that even public stakeholders
- 14:11can use it to assess their own disease risk.
- 14:15And then I would always encourage other state health
- 14:19departments or local health departments to reach out to
- 14:22either your center of wastewater, center of excellence
- 14:26in your region, or to reach out to the Colorado team.
- 14:29We're always happy to talk to other states involved in this
- 14:35work and share our experience. Allison Wheeler is manager of
- 14:40the Wastewater Surveillance Unit of the Colorado Department of
- 14:43Public Health and Environment. ASTO newsletter subscription
- 14:47options feature updates, analysis, resources and events
- 14:51on pressing issues in state and territorial public health.
- 14:54Subscribe to receive legislative alerts, news releases, Public
- 14:58Health weekly events and Fig connections through the link in
- 15:01our show notes. Now let's hear from Doctor Ziad
- 15:04Qazi, professor of emergency medicine at Emory University and
- 15:08president of the American College of Medical Toxicology.
- 15:12It's important to think about different scenarios where one
- 15:15would encounter radiation. For example, you know, we often
- 15:20think of radiation as an invisible energy that is
- 15:25released for rejected material. But remember, you can also
- 15:28disperse this material without an explosive device.
- 15:31You can disperse this material in the food supply or in in a
- 15:35water supply, drinking supply. You can also release the
- 15:39material in the air, dispersing it manually.
- 15:44That's often referred to as a radiological dispersal device.
- 15:48But there are also scenarios where you don't even disperse
- 15:51the material. Actually, the material is
- 15:52sealed. It's sealed and unshielded,
- 15:56which means any shield surrounding the material is
- 15:59removed and the material is sealed, meaning it's one block
- 16:03of material. It's not indispensable
- 16:06mechanically. And such material could be
- 16:09emitting radiation, exposing people in the environment of
- 16:13this material and the surrounding of this material to
- 16:15radiation. We call that a radiological
- 16:18exposure device. There are other scenarios, more
- 16:22significantly dangerous and impactful scenarios like a
- 16:27nuclear detonation. People often think of radiation
- 16:32in terms of nuclear detonation, and that nuclear detonation, of
- 16:36course, brings a, brings a lot of trauma and burns and, you
- 16:40know, and fires with it. It can also generate the large
- 16:46amount of radioactive debris that can become suspended in air
- 16:51and create a radioactive cloud that contaminates the
- 16:56surrounding environment. So those two scenarios, the
- 17:00nuclear detonation and the improvised nuclear device, which
- 17:04are a bit similar, these are the probably the most significant
- 17:09and dangerous scenarios. And finally, another scenario
- 17:12that people think about is the nuclear power plant emergency,
- 17:16such as what happened in Fukushima as we are approaching
- 17:20March 11th, the day the the anniversary of the Fukushima
- 17:22nuclear power plant emergency that also leads to dispersal of
- 17:27a jet material in the environment.
- 17:29However, these material come from the nuclear power plant
- 17:32itself and they become potentially released outside the
- 17:38nuclear power plant in the environment, contaminating the
- 17:42area as well as food, water, potentially exposing people to
- 17:45radiation. Now of course, these are all
- 17:49very rare scenarios. Some of them have never
- 17:51happened. However, the most common
- 17:55scenario is going to be accidental.
- 17:58We have occasional radiation accidents in the United States
- 18:01and all around the world when a radiation source is misplaced,
- 18:06is lost, occasionally stolen, you know, the car accident, you
- 18:13know, truck carrying a Courier truck carrying rejected material
- 18:16may have an accident spilling the material on the road or
- 18:19inside the truck with the accident rollover, you know,
- 18:23leading to some radiation hazards as well.
- 18:25So that's a brief summary of potential scenarios that we we
- 18:28should think about when we are considering a radiation incident
- 18:32or emergency. Yeah, and you've described sort
- 18:35of a wide range of scenarios from from, you know, relatively
- 18:40small and contained to unbelievably bad.
- 18:44In the case of considering a radiological event in a context
- 18:48of a mass gathering, such as the upcoming World Cup, what do
- 18:52organizers have to think about when trying to protect?
- 18:56People going to see the event. Professionals and organizing
- 18:59these large events, these mass gatherings have a lot of
- 19:03resources and have a lot of expertise in planning these and
- 19:07preparing for any potential emergency.
- 19:09Radiation emergency is only one aspect of this preparation and
- 19:13certainly they have a lot of resources they can use.
- 19:16And one of the things that I always say to people is
- 19:20radiation is one of the easier hazards to detect.
- 19:24Personally, I would, you know, I would really think that if you,
- 19:30if you had given me a choice between a radiation or a
- 19:32chemical emergency, I would definitely prefer to prepare for
- 19:36a radiation emergency because I know I can detect it with
- 19:39radiation detectors. There's also the rejective
- 19:44material speaks to us by emitting limited types of
- 19:49radiation that we can detect in most cases relatively easily.
- 19:55So that's one important thing to consider.
- 19:58The other thing that I would like to just mention is that we
- 20:00should keep it simple. So our response agencies should
- 20:04keep it simple in terms of the preparation and the response.
- 20:08Always try to keep the guidance and their planning easy to
- 20:11understand and and apply. Of course using best evidence
- 20:15available, supportive experts that are available at the state
- 20:20and local level as well as the federal level.
- 20:22And from an operational standpoint, what are the first
- 20:25steps that organizers that emergency response that public
- 20:29health overseeing everything, what are what are the steps that
- 20:32need to happen of? Course, initially it's supposed
- 20:35to recognize that a radiation emergency has occurred because
- 20:38radiation exposures, you know, often do not lead to a rapid
- 20:43onset. Signs and symptoms that are
- 20:45easily detected or you know, discerned by by by responders or
- 20:50by people themselves. Initially it may just be signs
- 20:54and symptoms that are similar to the food poisoning.
- 20:57Of course, if there is a explosion or if there's any, you
- 21:01know, overt, overt incident that's happening, it is part of
- 21:06our protocols to check for rejected material.
- 21:08So that will potentially help us in this situation identify that
- 21:13there's a radiation emergency as well happening.
- 21:18But once we start having an idea about what is the type of
- 21:21scenario that we are dealing with out of the list of
- 21:24scenarios that I gave you at the beginning.
- 21:26And also recognizing that there's a radiation emergency
- 21:29happening or the radiation exposure happening, which I told
- 21:32you is a little bit challenging potentially in some cases
- 21:34because the symptoms are delayed and onset and non specific.
- 21:38But once that's identified, you know, you should not need to
- 21:41start thinking about several, several considerations.
- 21:45First is the of course the rescue of the victims, but while
- 21:51maintaining your responders and 1st receivers at the hospital
- 21:55safe. So in that situation, you must
- 21:58really consider what is the level of personal protective
- 22:01equipment that that you need to use.
- 22:04For example, are you going to use specifically the respirator
- 22:08or not an air purifying respirator?
- 22:10That's the main consideration here because otherwise the skin
- 22:14protection, it's going to be somewhat similar.
- 22:17You know, whether it's a level D or level level C.
- 22:20What's going to vary is the respiratory protection, whether
- 22:23you use a surgical mask, A995 mask, or an air purifying
- 22:26respirator. Assuming you know the only
- 22:29hazard available on the scene is from radiation, you need to also
- 22:34consider wearing those limiters for responders to, to, to, to be
- 22:39able to track their doses, you know, because they may be
- 22:42exposed to some secondary radiation.
- 22:44So having a bozometer on their body is, is important.
- 22:48You need to also look for the radioactive material on the
- 22:51these victims, right? So you need radiation detectors.
- 22:54So that's an operational consideration.
- 22:55You know, you won't be able to do that without these radiation
- 22:57detectors that are available. They're handheld.
- 23:00Some of them are portal monitors where you have people pass
- 23:03through the, the, the, the portal and other, other methods
- 23:07of detection. So these are a few
- 23:11considerations that must be made in the radiation emergency by
- 23:15the responders, by the agencies that are, you know, addressing
- 23:19this this event. Yeah.
- 23:21And what does treatment look like after that?
- 23:23Once it's been established that, oh gosh, there is radiological
- 23:27material, it is, you know, the, the victims have been exposed to
- 23:32it. You know they're being safely
- 23:33removed from the site, Then what?
- 23:36Then decontamination. Then, you know, if people are
- 23:38stable and don't have any life threatening emergencies, then
- 23:43you should look for the material and wash it out.
- 23:47Now, of course, removing the clothing, especially when you're
- 23:50when someone's dressed with clothes that cover most of their
- 23:53body, you know, remember the detective material is like dust
- 23:56or debris, you know, radioactive debris.
- 23:59And I like to think of it as dust or dirt or mud, right?
- 24:03And if you're really wearing a shirt, long pants, you know,
- 24:06that really covers about 85% plus of your body surface area.
- 24:11So simply by removing this closing, get rid of 85% of this
- 24:14radioactive debris, assuming it's uniformly located on your
- 24:18on your body, you're left with your head, your face, your
- 24:20hands, you know, potentially your feet.
- 24:22So in this situation, then you did you look for the material
- 24:26with the detector and then you wash it.
- 24:28You can wash it with water, with soap and water.
- 24:30And then you repeat the radiation survey and see if
- 24:33you've done a good job that you were you able to get rid of that
- 24:35dirt. So it takes time to do this.
- 24:37You know, it takes somebody was trained and using the detector
- 24:40and trained in decontamination while they're weighing the
- 24:43appropriate PPE little bit we mentioned, and then they're
- 24:47decontaminated at that point, you know, they're not
- 24:50contagious, right? So they're, you know, they're
- 24:53going to be evaluated for the potential for illness right from
- 24:58this radiation exposure. Now, remember, there's some
- 25:00cases where there's no contamination.
- 25:02Remember I told you about that ideological exposure device
- 25:04scenario where you you place an unshielded sealed source and
- 25:08that exposes people. People in that environment are
- 25:12not even contaminated because they didn't touch it.
- 25:14They didn't touch it and they were just standing there.
- 25:16But they've experienced this exposure to radiation similar to
- 25:19someone who's getting an X-ray or ACT scan.
- 25:23Remember, these people go to the CT scan department or room, they
- 25:26get scanned and they come back to the emergency department
- 25:29afterwards and they're not considered contaminated.
- 25:31Same in the scenario. So in these cases, you don't
- 25:33need to decontaminate these these victims.
- 25:36And of course, in that case, a Level D personal protective
- 25:38equipment with a simple surgical mask is sufficient.
- 25:42Doctor Ziad Khazi, professor of emergency medicine at Emory
- 25:45University and president of the American College of Medical
- 25:48Toxicology. You can join ASTO and Dr. Kazi
- 25:51for a webinar focused on public health preparedness and response
- 25:55related to the upcoming FIFA World Cup.
- 25:57This session will highlight response operations to a
- 26:00radiological incident during a mass gathering.
- 26:03Doctor Kazi will address key response considerations from a
- 26:06health department and public health lens, including triage,
- 26:09contamination management, radiation safety rules and
- 26:12detection assets, community reception centers, medical
- 26:15countermeasures and more. There will be time for AQ and a
- 26:18session to address questions from attendees.
- 26:21You can find a registration link in the show notes.
- 26:25This has been public health review morning edition.
- 26:28I'm John Sheehan for the Association of State and
- 26:30Territorial Health Officials.