Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Movies with Accurate DSM Disorders (2019 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. Today, I'm going to talk about the most accurately
- 0:03portrayed DSM disorders in characters in movies. This was actually suggested as a top
- 0:11eleven list by Patron Malika during our eleventh anniversary show earlier this year. We
- 0:20asked for a bunch of people to submit different top eleven lists that they wanted
- 0:23us to do, and this is one of them. And there were so
- 0:27many good ones that some of them got left on the cutting room floor,
- 0:30and so I just thought I would do some of those. Now, these
- 0:35movies are in no particular order, and I actually couldn't come up with eleven.
- 0:38I could only come up with I don't know, eight or nine or
- 0:40something, because there's so few movies and TV shows that depict mental illness.
- 0:48So there's two things I'm looking for. One do they portray it accurately?
- 0:52And two do they give us enough detail that actually tells us that the character
- 1:00actually has that disorder? Because like in Iron Man three, for example,
- 1:06we have Tony Stark who exhibits some PTSD symptoms, but the movie, probably
- 1:12for a good reason, doesn't really go into detail about his symptoms because that's
- 1:17you know, it's trying to Iron Man three is a superhero movie. It's
- 1:22supposed to be PG. Thirteen and light and fun, but you know,
- 1:26with a twist of psychological issues that the character has, so you know,
- 1:34it makes sense that they wouldn't go into detail. So I'm looking for is
- 1:37it accurate and is there enough information so that we can be like, yep,
- 1:40this person actually does have this disorder. So in no particular order,
- 1:46I'll start with There Will Be Blood. This is perhaps one of the only
- 1:51movies that depicts narcisstic personality disorder accurately. I did actually a whole episode on
- 1:57this, and if you want to, you know, listen to that.
- 1:59You can listen to that where I broke down all the different movies that claim
- 2:04to be good depictions of narcissism. And There Will Be Blood is perhaps the
- 2:08only movie I can think of, aside from my next movie, which is
- 2:12The Talented Mister Ripley. These two movies in conjunction show two different sides or
- 2:19two different types main types of narcisistic personality disorder. The Talented Mister Ripley,
- 2:23you could say there's a touch of borderline. Narcissism and borderline are actually very
- 2:28similar according to my conceptualization of it. But the problem with these movies,
- 2:35as with a lot of these movies that I'm going to talk about, they
- 2:38have to have some kind of storyline, some kind of plot. And one
- 2:42of the most favorite tropes of movies and TV show plot writers is to have
- 2:47murder and death and there will be blood, and the talent of mister Ripley
- 2:53have murder in it. These main characters who you know could be diagnosed with
- 2:59narcisstic personality disorder are murderous. So that's something that also is a problem.
- 3:07Because the vast, vast majority of people with narcisistic personality disorder and borderline don't
- 3:13kill anyone. I would venture to say that the rates of killing among those
- 3:16who have those kinds of personality disorders are probably similar to people who don't have
- 3:22personality disorders. And because of this portrayal, this trope that is used in
- 3:29movies and TV, there are people in our society, a good number of
- 3:32them, who associate narcissistic personality disorder with murder with killing. I think I
- 3:39just got an email from someone today or yesterday, last night. Maybe they
- 3:44were saying, I can't remember what the question was, but basically it was
- 3:49implying that they believed that narcissistic personality disorder people, you know, why do
- 3:55they kill? You know? Sort of a question like that. I can't
- 3:59remember anyway. My first response to that person was, you realize, narcissistic
- 4:02personality disordered people are not murderers anymore so than anyone else. As a clinician
- 4:09who treats people with personality soorders, I'm here to tell you they don't want
- 4:14to kill anyone, just like other people don't want to kill anyone. So
- 4:18these movies there would be blood talented, mister Ripley, although they give us
- 4:23enough information so that we can because they're very focused on their characters. They
- 4:29give us enough information to be able to diagnose them, and they seem to
- 4:32be fairly accurate. Now are they quintessential? No? And also they kill
- 4:38people, which isn't very common. The next movie that I want to talk
- 4:42about is To the Bone, which is a Netflix movie that came out a
- 4:44couple of years ago, I think, and it portrays anarexia and the main
- 4:47character. It's mostly accurate. A lot of movies have tried to depict eating
- 4:54disorders, but To the Bone really goes for it, because that's the whole
- 4:59point of it. It's someone who is suffering from anorexia and is slowly sort
- 5:05of descending into symptoms. It's getting worse and worse and worse. She goes
- 5:11into treatment. She goes into a group home for treatment. There are other
- 5:15people with eating disorders in group therapy, so you see the different sorts of
- 5:19people who might have an eating disorder. The other problem with movies is that
- 5:26you have to cram everything into a short amount of time. To really understand
- 5:31anorexia, you'd have to live with someone or treat someone for a long time.
- 5:35That's something that I learned actually when I went to graduate school and learned
- 5:40about anorexia along with all of my fellow grad students. I learned about the
- 5:45symptoms, I read some vignettes, I saw some videos, and then the
- 5:49next week we just moved on to a different disorder. And when I started
- 5:54treating people with eaning disorders, I felt like I kind of understood it.
- 5:58But then more and more I learned about and the more I started treating people
- 6:01with it, the more I realized, Wow, this is way more complicated
- 6:04than one could possibly encapsulate in a course or in the DSM, eating disorders
- 6:12are extremely complex. There are certain DSM diagnoses that are pretty straightforward, panic
- 6:18disorder, generalized anxiety, major depression. These are pretty easy to understand.
- 6:24Anorexia and certainly personality disorders are very complicated. But to the bone, I
- 6:30think they did a pretty good job, and I have experts in eating disorders
- 6:35colleagues of mine who also appreciated it. There are problems, of course,
- 6:42but like I said, you know, as far as things go, it's
- 6:46pretty good. And this movie doesn't have things like and then her anorexia caused
- 6:51her to murder a bunch of people, Like, there's nothing like that.
- 6:54It's just a story about someone as they become more and more symptomatic and how
- 7:00they are trying to find themselves in that process. The next movie is Flight,
- 7:05with Denzel Washington playing someone with substance use disorder or alcoholism as is generally
- 7:12called in this movie Flight, which I found to be just a gem of
- 7:17a movie. Not only is it interesting because it has that whole flight scene
- 7:21of that's really famous where he turns the plane upside down, but the rest
- 7:26of the movie is pretty much about him and his alcoholism and you really get
- 7:31a sense in this movie how powerless people are over their addictions. There's this
- 7:39point in the movie where you think, like, okay, he finally realized
- 7:43he's hit bottom so many different times. He's trying to be clean and sober.
- 7:47He realizes, you know, his trial is the next day. He
- 7:51realizes he needs to be sober, and you know, he's doing all these
- 7:56different things to make sure he doesn't drink, and then he you know this,
- 8:01you're just seeing this. It's all nonverbal, it's all this. It's
- 8:05this scene that's shot in a hotel room, and just when you think,
- 8:09okay, he overcame the temptation, boom he gives into it, and boom
- 8:13he's drunk all night long, and boom he ends up going to the trial
- 8:16intoxicated, and then boom he starts talking about it. He's in the hearing
- 8:20and he's like, and by the way, I'm drunk right now. And
- 8:24it's this powerful just you know, cringing. I mean, that's what it's
- 8:31like to live with an addiction. Is it's so hard to control. And
- 8:35this notion that you know, if you just have willpower, you'll be able
- 8:39to overcome it. And it also portrays alcoholism in this really accurate way,
- 8:46and that his life isn't completely going down the tubes. Most people who suffer,
- 8:50the vast majority of people who suffer from addictions, their lives are pretty
- 8:54much functional. I treated heroin addicts for a while and found that there were
- 9:01some whose lives were a little bit on the rocks, but most of my
- 9:05clients in Seattle. Heroin is kind of a problem in Seattle. And but
- 9:09Seattle also has this you know, booming economy, all these different, you
- 9:13know, internety kind of things that I don't understand, and a lot of
- 9:18these young people have these jobs, yet they're using heroin or there are other
- 9:22opiates opioids, and they have they're you know, they're doing good. They're
- 9:26still talking to their parents, they they might have a spouse, they might
- 9:31have kids. Everything's functioning, and yet they're they're powerless over their addictions.
- 9:37And it's just, you know, heartbreaking to see people, you know,
- 9:46continue to use in the face of just consequence after consequence after consequence. Now,
- 9:50I'm not saying that people who use heroin in the long term are always
- 9:56functional. That's not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that this move
- 10:00Flight shows that tension between you know, holding onto one's sort of regular life
- 10:09and then also just struggling in isolation and in shame and behind closed doors with
- 10:16something that's just really awful. The next movie is Shine. This came out
- 10:22a while ago, and I saw it when it came out in the theater.
- 10:26I think I might have seen it with my dad actually, and when
- 10:28I was in my twenties. I think it's a movie presumably about schizo effective
- 10:35disorder. I don't remember it that well, but from my memory it was
- 10:39a good depiction of what that disorder is like. I don't know if it
- 10:41gives enough information to really show what the disorder is like, but I remember
- 10:46certain scenes that pop out in my head when he starts, you know,
- 10:48when he first starts to break from reality, and how it might feel to
- 10:54be in someone's shoes like that. The next two movies are about schizophrenia,
- 11:00A Beautiful Mind in The Soloist A Beautiful Mind. So again the Soloists and
- 11:03The Beautiful Mind. These are movies that are trying to tell a story about
- 11:09a person. They're not trying to tell a story about schizophrenia. They're not
- 11:11trying to educate the audience about schizophrenia, and so a lot of details are
- 11:16left out, and they they don't fully explain. It's not like you can
- 11:20watch A Beautiful Mind and go, oh, I understand what schizophrenia is now,
- 11:22because it's a lot more complicated than that. There's a lot of different
- 11:26presentations blah blah blah. But from my memory, both these movies, particularly
- 11:30A Beautiful Mind, from my memory, they're not bad depictions of what schizophrenia
- 11:35actually is. Like they take shortcuts, like, you know, in order
- 11:39to tell a story of hallucinations, it's it's you kind of have that's you
- 11:46know, it's it would be impossible to depict what hallucinations actually feel like in
- 11:54movies. They tend to just you know, like in Beautiful Mind, Russell
- 12:00Crowe's character John Nash, I think this is the real guy's name. He
- 12:05hallucinates this guy, he just hallucinates a friend. Like his friends, he's
- 12:11having conversations with his friend. And although that's in the direction of what schizophrenic
- 12:16people will describe, it's not exactly accurate. So, you know, it's
- 12:20a movie you're trying to make an entertainment sort of thing. But A Beautiful
- 12:26mind in the Soloist, I remember being like, okay, you know,
- 12:28they gave us enough information and I could see something like this happening. The
- 12:33next movie is The Aviator with Leonardo DiCaprio depicting obsessive compulsive disorder. This movie
- 12:41really shows you how horrible the disorder is. Maybe it's because it's about a
- 12:46real person that they kept it honest or something, but you really get the
- 12:52sense of how compulsive the disorder is and how you slowly descend in to isolation
- 13:01and a lot of odd ideas. Now, they didn't give us a lot
- 13:05of background into what was going through Howard Hughes's mind at the time. They
- 13:09just showed us. The style of the movie was they showed us OCD what
- 13:16it looked like, kind of from the outside, so you wouldn't walk away
- 13:20from the avier saying like I understand what OCD is. But in terms of
- 13:24a lot of the depictions of OCD, the Aviator is is, you know,
- 13:28one of the better ones. A lot of movies will show OCD TV
- 13:33shows as well, like Monk, and there are a lot of corners that
- 13:39they cut and inaccuracies that they sprinkle in because they're again they're trying to make
- 13:43something entertaining, like as Good as It Gets with Jack Nicholson. Presumably people
- 13:50talk about that or people talk about this is like, oh, it's a
- 13:52great movie about OCD. There are problems with that movie. If you actually
- 13:56have OCD, or you actually treat OCD as I do at times, and
- 14:01you watch As Good As It Gets, you're just like, wait, what
- 14:03like one of the things about as Good as It Gets is I think that's
- 14:07the name of the movie with Jack Nilson and Helen Hunt. Helen Hunt.
- 14:11I'm trying to do this off the top my head. But anyway, JACKI
- 14:13Nicholson presumably has OCD, and they start off the movie kind of showing it,
- 14:18but they also equate OCD with just being kind of like a grumpy old
- 14:22man, which is not the same thing. Now, you could argue it's
- 14:26just like, well, we were trying to portray a grumpy old man with
- 14:28that who has OCD. It's like, okay, fine, but in the
- 14:31end, what ends up quote unquote, he's going to therapy, he's getting
- 14:35medication, nothing's really helping, And in the end what helps him is he
- 14:39falls in love with this young, very young woman. By the way who
- 14:43you know will look over We'll overlook that for a second. But anyway,
- 14:46he falls in love and he allows her into his life, and that's what
- 14:52cures him of his OCD. Is essentially what the movie is about, which
- 14:56is fucking ridiculous. The next movie is still Alice with God what's her name?
- 15:03Do you? Anyway? It portrays Alzheimer's dementia and memory loss. This
- 15:11movie, that's the whole point of this movie is showing how this middle aged
- 15:16woman has early onset Alzheimer's and how she slowly starts to forget things, She
- 15:24slowly becomes less functional in life, her the grief she experiences in that process,
- 15:31the way her family reacts to it, the way you would sort of
- 15:39emotionally deal with it at the beginning of the discovery for yourself, it's like,
- 15:43whoa really, i have early onset Alzheimer's and in five years I'm not
- 15:48gonna I'm not going to know who my own children are, and in seven
- 15:52years I'll be dead, you know, Like, oh my god. It's
- 15:56It's something that is very familiar to a lot of people, particularly people who
- 16:02are with their elderly parents or grandparents or a relative of something or a loved
- 16:07one, and the rest of the world completely ignores this. It's something that
- 16:12is very much a part of our you know, human experience, particularly today
- 16:18as we have technologies that allow people to live a lot longer than they used
- 16:22to, and yet hardly any movies about it still. Alice is just a
- 16:29wonderful depicture of that. Are there problems, yes, but I think overall
- 16:33it's a good movie. So yeah, as I said, I couldn't come
- 16:37up with any other movies that now. I'm sure they're out there, but
- 16:41I looked online different lists that people made, and there's a lot of lists
- 16:45of movies, and I've seen a lot of movies. I haven't obviously seen
- 16:48them all, but I can tell you that as a therapist, I've been
- 16:53you know, in the field for almost twenty five years or twenty five years,
- 16:59and whenever I see anything mental health related, counseling related in movies,
- 17:04I always take note of it. I'm always evaluating it as a professional,
- 17:08and I would remember if I saw a movie that actually was an accurate depiction.
- 17:15There are movies that are listed on the internet that are often cited as
- 17:18these excellent examples of disorders in the DSM, but in my opinion, they're
- 17:25not like Girl Interrupted. This is supposed to be a wonderful depiction of borderline
- 17:30personality disorder. It's been a while since I seen the movie, but I
- 17:33remember thinking, no, no, no, this is not borderline. This
- 17:38is someone who is suffering quite a bit and feels quite isolated. But it
- 17:44doesn't look like borderline at all to me. So yeah, Girl Interrupted,
- 17:48from my memory, wasn't accurate. The Sopranos TV show tries to portray a
- 17:53number of things. One of Tony's mistresses apparently has borderline. She was the
- 18:00one who was the Mercedes dealership saleswoman. It's not a terrible depiction of borderline,
- 18:07but it's very brief. There's not a lot of detail, and it's
- 18:10a little sensational. So I wouldn't point people to that as a good example
- 18:14of borderline. I actually can't think of any movie that portrays borderline well.
- 18:18Honestly, Silver Lining's playbook, Jennifer Lawrence is supposed to have borderline in that.
- 18:23Bradley Cooper is supposed to have bipolar in that. And although there's a
- 18:27scene with Bradley Cooper in the beginning of the movie where it looks like a
- 18:32manic episode and it's you're like, oh, is that what mania looks like?
- 18:37And you're like, yeah, it can look like that. Again,
- 18:40silver Lining's Playbook is trying to be an entertaining movie. It's not trying to
- 18:44educate people about borderline and bipolar, and they don't really show us the full
- 18:49breadth of the symptoms, which again makes sense because it's not an educational movie.
- 18:55It's an entertainment movie. And the problem with this movie is so the
- 19:00you know, someone with borderline falls in someone with bipolar and Bradley Cooper and
- 19:04Jayla and by the end of the movie they're in this dance scene together.
- 19:07I enjoyed the movie for sure, but at the end of the movie,
- 19:11I was like, wait a second, So we're just supposed to believe that
- 19:14these two people just right off in the sunset happily ever after, that's not
- 19:19how this usually plays out. If you have someone who legit has borderline and
- 19:23someone who legit has bipolar, there's gonna be a lot of bumps in the
- 19:26road after that. And they just made it seem like if someone with borderline
- 19:32and someone with bipolar, if they just really believe in love and they just
- 19:36try to do this dance together and you know, and and they try to
- 19:41capture the goodness of life, then that'll just solve all their problems. Again,
- 19:45they're not explicitly saying that, but it just as a clinician watching it,
- 19:51I just thought, well, that's not accurate. Like, if that's
- 19:56all I mean, believe me, as someone who treats P I specialize in
- 20:00borderline. If it was just that simple, you know, like, hey,
- 20:06go find a dance partner or fall in love and you know, really
- 20:10try to capture life and do you know, look on the bright side and
- 20:14done it. If that's all it took, Like come on, there's a
- 20:18lot of movies online where they talk about like, oh, you know,
- 20:21if you really want to see what mental illness is, like you got to
- 20:25watch Psycho or American Psycho or Silence of the Lambs or Fatal Attraction. And
- 20:30although one could argue that these movies depict psychopathy or any social or sadism or
- 20:34something, it's like, okay, fine, but these if we're going to
- 20:38look to those movies as like examples of how to teach the public or clinicians
- 20:45about mental illnesses, then my god, you know, we're just furthering that
- 20:51connection, that false connection, that false association between mental illness and murdering people.
- 20:56So and it's actually kind of a trope of screenwriters is to make your
- 21:03villain have a mental illness which isn't helping. So it Yeah, there's Again,
- 21:11there's a lot of other movies that people identify. And if you want
- 21:14to let me know about any particular movie that you think depicts mental illnesses or
- 21:21disorders in the DSM, then let me know. My guess is that if
- 21:23it's a popular one. So if there's any popular movies out there where you're
- 21:27like, well, Shirley Kirk has seen this movie or he's heard of it,
- 21:30why isn't he talking about that, it's probably because one it wasn't accurate.
- 21:37Two, it didn't give enough information to really portray the disorder well enough
- 21:41so that I, as a watcher would go Okay, yeah, I could
- 21:45see how that person has that disorder. Or Three it does it doesn't stigmatize
- 21:49the disorder in a really inaccurate way. So those are the those are the
- 21:52three criteria I'm looking for, I guess, So think about that before you
- 22:02identify a movie I mean, you might have a movie like, Oh,
- 22:03this movie I think really depicts this really well, or this movie was shown
- 22:07to me in my graduate school courses. It's a good example of this.
- 22:11Again, I think is it really accurate too? Does it really give you
- 22:15enough information? And three does it stigmatize the disorder in an unnecessary way?
- 22:22Because these other movies there will be blood talented mister Ripley, they stigmatize so
- 22:29well, but I think they're an example of what it's like to live either
- 22:33next to someone with narcissism or be in the shoes of someone with narcissism.
- 22:38To the bone, Flight, Shine, a Beautiful Mind, The Soloist,
- 22:41The Aviator, and Still Alice. These movies, in my book, don't
- 22:47really stigmatize disorders. They give enough information and it's mostly accurate. But the
- 22:55thing to remember is that if you're a lay person, watching these movies will
- 23:00not teach you what these disorders are. It'd be like watching a movie about
- 23:06cancer and you know how to diagnose it and how to treat it or something.
- 23:12You wouldn't claim after watching a movie about cancer and cancer treatment that you
- 23:17could identify cancer and treat it right. Well, it's the same when it
- 23:21comes to these complicated disorders such as anorexia or particularly personality sorderschizo effective, schizophrenia
- 23:29for the most part, even OCD, these are things that you have to
- 23:33be a clinician who specializes in that. For example, for me, I
- 23:38have very rarely treated someone with psychosis people. I don't think I've ever had
- 23:45someone with schizo effective. I've had a few people with schizophrenia, and I
- 23:49had very brief experiences with them. I've never worked in an impatient psychiatric ward.
- 23:56I've never, you know, worked with seri quote unquote seriously to ill
- 24:00people. And so for me, even though I've been working in the field
- 24:03for twenty five years and I have a doctorate and two masters, and I
- 24:07teach people about psychopathology and I supervise people, and technically I can diagnose someone
- 24:14with schizophrenia. If I came across someone who I thought had schizophrenia, I
- 24:18would consult with an expert who knew about schizophrenia because I recognize myself, I
- 24:22don't know that much about it. I specialize in personality disorders, and I
- 24:29for a time specialized in eating disorders. I don't anymore because I found that
- 24:34treating uni disorders required. It depends, but in my opinion, to be
- 24:41a really effective eating disorder clinician, you have to kind of be on call,
- 24:48maybe not twenty four to seven, but you have to treat clients.
- 24:52You have to have safety plans between sessions. And although I did that for
- 24:56a while, once I became a professor full time time, I just didn't
- 25:00have the time for that and I felt like I was being irresponsible, so
- 25:03I stopped specializing in eating disorders. But anyway, there are many clinicians out
- 25:08there who don't specialize in personality disorders, who don't specialize in eating disorders,
- 25:14and they also do not understand those disorders. So even other clinicians don't really
- 25:21understand some sections, if not many sections in the DSM. And that's fine,
- 25:26that's normal. So for lay people to think that they would just understand
- 25:30something, Now, if you have the disorder, or you had a brother
- 25:34or a spouse with the disorder, then you probably have a good beat that
- 25:38on that particular disorder, or at least that particular presentation of that disorder.
- 25:42So I just want to point that out that I'm not trying to beat people
- 25:45up, but I'm just trying to make sure that people understand the landscape,
- 25:49because the internet seems to think that if you watch a couple of YouTube videos
- 25:53and maybe you read, you know, the Mayo Clinic website, suddenly you
- 25:56understand a certain disorder, and the fact is you probably don't. One of
- 26:02the things that I often hear from students, and I actually went through this
- 26:06kind of myself. It's sort of a cliche is that graduate students in mental
- 26:10health when they take psychopathology, suddenly they start diagnosing themselves with everything in the
- 26:14DSM. It's a joke. It's sort of an inside joke that graduate students
- 26:18will make and teachers will make about graduate students sometimes. And part of the
- 26:22reason why that is is because a little bit of information is dangerous because you
- 26:30learn a little bit and you're like, whoa, You feel like you understand
- 26:33it, and you start applying it all over the place, when in fact
- 26:36you actually don't understand it. Well, taking psych I mean, just give
- 26:38you a clue, just give you an idea. And I've talked about this
- 26:41before. Most people who graduate with a doctorate in clinical psychology or a master's
- 26:48in some clinical mental health discipline. Marriage of family therapy counseling, social work.
- 26:55They will have taken maybe two classes on side pathology, maybe more,
- 27:02but probably not. And now psychologists tend to take more in assessment and whatnot,
- 27:07so they get a little bit better education on psychopathology depending on who they're
- 27:10supervising and who they're taught, But in general, a lot of people have
- 27:15only taken one to three classes on average. And when you try to cram
- 27:21and so just give you an idea how the students in my program are taught.
- 27:26We it's a master's program there. They have two courses. We're on
- 27:30quarter systems, so they get six months of education on psychopathology. For the
- 27:33first three months, every week they're taught about a different chapter in the DSM
- 27:40essentially, so one week they learned about all the anxiety disorders, another week
- 27:45they learn about all the mood disorders. In the next week they learn about
- 27:47all the psychotic disorders. The next week it's all the you know, sexual
- 27:51disorders, and you know and so so in the week that you have to
- 27:56learn all the eating disorders, you probably spend three hours reading stuff about eating
- 28:03disorders, anorexia just being one of them, and then you hear a lecture
- 28:07for a couple hours about eating disorders and then you're done, and then the
- 28:11next three months you spend time thinking about how to treat how to write treatment
- 28:15plans for those disorders. And that's that sort of assumes you already understand the
- 28:22disorder and doesn't really it furthers it a little bit because it's you know,
- 28:26it's like, okay, now that you can assess someone, how do you
- 28:29how do you exactly treat it? And how do you write up the treatment
- 28:30plan? That's it. So for a lot of people when they graduate and
- 28:37they they're working with people or even at internship, before they graduate, they
- 28:41will have had a total of probably like two hours, you know, just
- 28:45for anorexia alone. They will have probably had a total of one to three
- 28:49hours of reading and lecture and thinking time about anorexia in and of itself on
- 28:56a good day. And that's because anorexia is actually focused on there are whole
- 29:00sections of the DSM that are usually ignored in these classes, and that is
- 29:06not enough time. And the person's a clinician. So the key is is
- 29:10that you have to have supervisors that help you. You have to in the
- 29:14first ten twenty years of your career you have to have experts whom you consult
- 29:18with. For me learning about borderline, for example, that's how I learned.
- 29:23I had that one week on all the personality disorders and I learned a
- 29:29little bit about borderline. Really had no idea how to identify it. I
- 29:34just remember just being like, I still don't get this stuff, because how
- 29:37could you. It's too complicated. Then at my internship, our early career,
- 29:45I had someone who had borderline personality disorder. The client didn't know she
- 29:48had borderline. I slowly started to realize as I got to know her.
- 29:56Over months, I was like, maybe this is what border line is.
- 30:00And I would consult with experts and blah blah blah, and they were like,
- 30:03well, look into this, think about this. What's your counter transference?
- 30:06How does it feel? And then eventually I was like, oh,
- 30:08I think I finally understand what borderline is. Now I understood what it was
- 30:14just for that one person. I can't know it for everyone, but I
- 30:17knew what it was for that one person. It wasn't. It wasn't until
- 30:21I don't know a couple of years after I graduated, maybe earlier than that.
- 30:25But it took a long time. Many hours of actual contact with someone
- 30:27with borderline, many hours of actually treating them before I finally got oh,
- 30:33I think I understand borderline now twenty years later, when I look back at
- 30:37myself in my early career, I will say I barely understood borderline. I
- 30:42understood it well enough to treat it. But my experience with borderline since then
- 30:48has been enormous, and many hours treating it, and many hours thinking about
- 30:55myself in relation to borderline in terms of we all have the potential to be
- 30:59borderline on the inside of us. We all have we're all on the spectrum
- 31:03on you know, to some extent. We can all become mildly borderline under
- 31:07stress and then experiencing that and people in my personal life, I now understand
- 31:11borderline forwards and backwards. So so my point is is that when you think
- 31:18about watching a movie and you're like, I now understand this disorder, it's
- 31:23probably more complicated than that. All right, let's take a break, and
- 31:26when we get back, I will answer a Patreon email. All right,
- 31:37we're back from the break. If you haven't become a patron, do so.
- 31:41Now go to patreon dot com. All of our best episodes are only
- 31:44available for patrons. Sorry about that, non patrons, but there's a easy
- 31:48solution to that, just become a patron. Also, I just want to
- 31:52remind everyone that when you become a patron, a certain amount of your money
- 31:55goes towards various philanthropic efforts that we do on the podcast. We've given a
- 32:00way over ten thousand dollars to various different charities that we support. We've given
- 32:05I don't know, four to five thousand dollars in scholarships directly to students who
- 32:09are making the world a better place, LGBTQ charities, animal charities, homelessness
- 32:17charities, and so know that when you give to the podcast, ye're giving
- 32:23to the community as well. And not to put a sort of grandiose point
- 32:29on it, but I would like to think that this podcast also puts forth
- 32:35a lot of ideas that I think need to be presented on the Internet.
- 32:39I'm not the only one, of course, but there's a lot of ideas
- 32:43on the Internet that are underrepresented. Just one hearkening back to what I was
- 32:49talking about earlier, hearkening of borderline, the idea or narcissism, or any
- 32:54personality sort of for that matter, It is normal for people on the internet
- 32:59to believe that people with borderline or raving lunatics and people with narcissism or murderous
- 33:04psychopaths, and these are destructive notions because if we're going to help all the
- 33:09people with personality disorders, we have to think about the way that we communicate
- 33:15to the public. And if people are walking around thinking these false notions,
- 33:20then it's going to be hard for them to get help for it, you
- 33:22know. Like along those lines, sometimes people ask me, so, if
- 33:29you have a client with borderline, do you tell them that they have borderline?
- 33:31And what I say is, well, maybe, but what I tell
- 33:36them is do not google it, because everything on the internet is false.
- 33:39So let me tell you what borderline really is. When you're relationally traumatized,
- 33:44you're traumatized, and when that trauma is triggered, you're going to have tremendous
- 33:49anxiety, and that is going to result in you being the most scared person
- 33:54on the planet. And when you get really when anyone gets really scared,
- 33:59then they they get desperate and they're going to do a lot of different things
- 34:01to try to alleviate that fear. They might isolate, they might want to
- 34:07kill themselves. They might drink a lot, they might have you know,
- 34:10they might reach out sexually to other people, to hold on to other people
- 34:15and their attachments. They might get angry. They might even stalk there,
- 34:22you know, they're they might be danging someone, they get someone dumps them,
- 34:28and they're very, very hurt. All that trauma is triggered, and
- 34:30they might stalk their their former partner. And that's not because they're evil.
- 34:35It's because they're desperate. They're terrified, and they don't have anywhere to land.
- 34:38And so so that's how I you know, I describe it in more
- 34:43lengthier terms than that obviously to clients, but that's not the way to subscribing
- 34:46the internet. The way subscribing the Internet is they're they're manipulative, they're into
- 34:52themselves. They have no empathy, and it's just like my god, like
- 34:57and some clinicians are even saying shit like that. It's like, you obviously
- 35:00have no idea what you're talking about. It's sort of be like to me,
- 35:05while I'm on this soapbox, it'd be like saying, it's you describe
- 35:10someone with depression with major depressive disorder, it'd be like describing them as they're
- 35:15manipulative, they're lazy. They just want everything brought to them on a silver
- 35:22platter. And it's like, well, maybe that's how it feels like to
- 35:28you because you lived with someone with depression. But certainly they're not doing it
- 35:32on purpose, and certainly there's a reason why they look lazy to you.
- 35:39It's because of you know this and this and that. But for some reason
- 35:45when it comes to personality disorders, because they're just so misunderstood. And I
- 35:49also think some disorders somehow tap into some I don't know, some common things
- 35:57that we like to beat people up about, beat other peop people love about.
- 36:00Anyway, Also join us on Facebook and Instagram, mainly Facebook are We
- 36:06have two pages on Facebook mainly we got our main page and we also have
- 36:09the fan group. On the fan group, you can post anything you want
- 36:13on the on our Facebook page. That's where I do most of my most
- 36:16of my announcements. And so if you want to learn about what we're doing
- 36:22on the podcast, like sometimes we do special things and blah blah blah.
- 36:25Anyway, go to Facebook. If you want to talk to me, only
- 36:31contact me through the US on the website. So go to psychology and Seattle
- 36:36dot com go to the contact us page. Contact me through there. Also,
- 36:40if you don't know, we are on YouTube live often me and and
- 36:45Verdo or just me Thursdays two pm Seattle time. So join us on YouTube
- 36:50where I we just you know. We got the webcams set up and the
- 36:54microphones, and we we chat with you and as listeners you or watchers,
- 36:59you ask questions of us. I don't know, I don't know the talk,
- 37:01I don't know how things these things work. But anyway, if we've
- 37:06made almost a thousand episodes and we're going to do our thousand, we're going
- 37:09to do our thousandth episode celebration I think in December of twenty nineteen. And
- 37:16if so, we on your phone. If you listen to the podcast on
- 37:21your phone, you probably only have access to the last one to three hundred
- 37:24episodes. We've made a lot of great episodes prior to you know, three
- 37:28hundred episodes ago, so if you want to access those, go to our
- 37:31archive on the website. The website is the only place that has all the
- 37:36archive at this point. In the future, we want to change that,
- 37:37but the technology doesn't really exist yet. The other thing that I'll say is
- 37:45that I'm starting to do. If you haven't noticed reruns on Sundays, so
- 37:49I'm kind of picking good episodes from the past anyway and sort of recycling them
- 37:52into the feed. Yeah. Okay, so that's all that. Let's your
- 37:58email. Anonymous patron or patron Marie writes, I am a psychology undergrad students.
- 38:07I am loving my courses in psychology, and my degree requires me to
- 38:10do certain compulsory units, so I chose to take a course on the history
- 38:15and philosophy of science. As a student, I've always been self conscious about
- 38:21whether I'm smart or not, and I'm still working on feeling like an impostor
- 38:24at my university. I have a tendency when learning to think that things are
- 38:30more complicated than they actually are, and then completely must understanding the tasks,
- 38:35especially when I have a teacher that makes me feel uneasy and anxious. I
- 38:39get I see, there's this class that has a tutor that seems to be
- 38:45really nice. I think tutor is like a teaching assistant or something. However,
- 38:51every time I put my hand up to contribute something, she tells me
- 38:54that I am wrong. This made me feel weird because the teacher I've had
- 39:00in other classes are more subtle and encouraging when we missed the mark on something.
- 39:05She also kept going on about how to write our papers, which is
- 39:08helpful, but she also kept saying things like I've read so many bad papers,
- 39:14blah blah blah, and I feel like she focuses on how people are
- 39:17getting things wrong so much more than telling us what a good example is.
- 39:22I felt like there was something off about her, and so I googled her
- 39:25and I found her Twitter account, and I found that she was tweeting about
- 39:30how she couldn't believe we got a simple concept wrong and we didn't even bother
- 39:35to google the concept. I actually did that exercise that she was referring to,
- 39:39and she gave me a zero on it, and I did try hard
- 39:43on it. I felt quite bad reading that tweet of hers. What was
- 39:46she What was the reaction she was expecting from people on Twitter? That she
- 39:51think people would agree with her that we were all stupid people. It's her
- 39:54job to guide us so we don't make mistakes like that. Right later or
- 40:00my friend asked her if she knew who Jordan Peterson was because he really likes
- 40:05him. By the way, I'm not a particular fan of Jordan Peterson,
- 40:08but she said that she didn't like him, and she gave some reasons.
- 40:12Then later after class, she tweeted about how he asked her about Jordan Peterson
- 40:19and how she couldn't hide her negative opinion of him. It just seems off.
- 40:23It seems like it wasn't coming from a good place. I just thought,
- 40:27is it necessary to tweet things like that, to tweet about what goes
- 40:30on in your class like that? I know, Kirk, you talk about
- 40:35stuff that goes on in your class on the podcast, but I can tell
- 40:37it comes from a place of compassion. The thing I like about you the
- 40:43most is that you're never afraid to admit your faults, and I think that's
- 40:46a great quality and a leader. End of email. Well, thank you
- 40:52Petroon Marie. That's nice of you to say. I think teachers should be
- 40:57that way. I don't think there's anything special about me. I'm just gonna
- 41:00say, I hate this person. I hate this teacher you're referring to.
- 41:04I don't know her, I don't know this story. I haven't seen the
- 41:07tweets myself, but I have a lot of feelings about people like this.
- 41:13So I don't know if what I'm about to say applies to your teacher,
- 41:15but if it's any if this teacher is who I think she is, I've
- 41:22seen the sort of person before, and I hate people like this. People
- 41:24like this should be fired immediately. When I was a program director, if
- 41:30I saw a tweet like this, I would immediately fire them, no questions
- 41:34asked. I'd be like, you're done, because publicly ridiculing your students for
- 41:40not knowing things, it's your responsibility as a teacher to teach things. So
- 41:45if your students don't know things, it's your fault. And that's how I
- 41:49always see it when my student when I especially if it's a if I see
- 41:53in a lot of students. Last quarter, I taught a brand new class
- 41:58on couple therapy. Never taught it before, and so I was still working
- 42:02out some of the some of the kinks, and I got all the you
- 42:07know, it's all papers, it's no tests, so at my university.
- 42:09So halfway through the quarter I got everyone wrote a paper. I get,
- 42:13you know, fifteen papers, and I'm reading them and I start seeing these
- 42:16consistent mistakes that I don't know about half the students were making maybe a third
- 42:22my concludion. Now in the moment, I'm like, ugh, like it's
- 42:24frustrating. As a teacher, I get that frustration where you're just like,
- 42:28oh, like, these students, they didn't learn this thing that I wanted
- 42:34them to learn. And it taps into this deep insecurity that all teachers have.
- 42:38Believe me, I can tell you about that, and I know it's
- 42:42universal. Every every instructor I talked to has deep insecurities, even you know,
- 42:47people like me who have been teaching for twenty years. It's like,
- 42:52if a client thinks I'm a terrible therapist, that hurts my feelings. But
- 42:57if a student thinks I'm a terrible instructor, that destroys me. Because I
- 43:01don't know why, it just it just is. It's so I think school,
- 43:07you know, we start school at the age of like four or something,
- 43:10so I think we just regress to this early place. There's so much
- 43:15at stake in terms of our personality and self worth with school. But anyway,
- 43:19so I get it. You know, you're looking at your papers and
- 43:22you're like, oh man, you know these people didn't get it. But
- 43:25I immediately say, okay, well, I have a there's a why in
- 43:29the road. I can blame the students and be like, what a bunch
- 43:31of dumbshits, Or I could assume that these are smart, able, enthusiastic
- 43:37people and I just didn't teach it well enough. Now I don't have to
- 43:42beat myself up about it. I don't have to cry myself to sleep at
- 43:45night. But I could say, huh, that must be a that must
- 43:49be a topic that I didn't give enough time in class. So I'm going
- 43:53to make that a point the next time we meet. I'm going to make
- 43:57sure that I lecture about this for another half an hour and really make sure
- 44:00that those who didn't get it the first time I talked about it, they're
- 44:04given an opportunity to get it the second time. And that usually works.
- 44:10People are trying to do well. Students, they're trying, and so if
- 44:17there's especially as you know, the example that this patron Marie talks about,
- 44:23where many of the students are getting it wrong, then the only answer is
- 44:30it's the teacher's fault. Again, you don't have to cry yourself to sleep,
- 44:34but you do have to say, huh, the way I taught this
- 44:36obviously was not effective. So that's just supportingt Now, if you're teaching a
- 44:43bunch of thirteen year olds who hate being in school, then it's not so
- 44:47much on your head. But in my position where I'm teaching graduate students who
- 44:52are adults, average age is I don't know, thirty five, and they're
- 44:57all paying thousands of dollars just to take my class. I think to take
- 45:00just my class as something like two or three thousand dollars, I don't know,
- 45:05And they're trying. Now, undergraduate students are also probably trying pretty hard.
- 45:10You might have some who aren't trying very hard. That's fine too,
- 45:14But I also blame instructors for that too. Good instructors can motivate even unmotivated
- 45:21people to learn. You put it in an undergraduate class, you get half
- 45:27the students are enthusiastic and the other half aren't. A good instructor can motivate
- 45:31many of those unmotivated students. It's a matter of making the material compelling.
- 45:38It's a matter of having enthusiasm. It's a matter of having compassion. It's
- 45:42a matter of being creative. It's a matter of constantly innovating your teaching style.
- 45:47I've been teaching this one class called family of origin for twenty years,
- 45:53twenty plus years. The first time I taught it was in ninety seven.
- 45:55Yes, so it's twenty two years time might teach this class. I'm changing
- 46:00it. I've been teaching. I don't know how many times I've taught the
- 46:04class. I've taught it, you know, dozens of times, and I'm
- 46:07still changing it. And years ago, I said to myself, why am
- 46:10I continuing to change this class when students love the class as it is?
- 46:17You know, the first or probably the third time I taught the class,
- 46:22students were like, this is the best class I ever took, or you
- 46:25know whatever nice things people say to their instructors on their you know, anonymous
- 46:30evaluations. And I was like, huh, okay, I've nailed it.
- 46:34I don't I've figured out the curriculum, I've figured out my approach. Don't
- 46:37change it or else you might mess it up. Well, I'm constantly changing
- 46:43it because it's important to innovate. And once you kind of get in this
- 46:47rut, I think things go downhill, and so you're so I'm always so
- 46:52I'm making work for myself because I just think it's important to stay fresh.
- 46:58I also kind of get bored doing the same thing over and over and over
- 47:00again. Also, you know, things change over time. You know,
- 47:06different ideas come into our field. You got to incorporate that. Anyway,
- 47:09My point is is that I hate this person that you're talking about. I
- 47:15hate people like this. I think they should be fired. If I saw
- 47:17a tweet like this and I was program director, I would fire someone like
- 47:22that. Ridiculing your students. You know, I hate it when people do
- 47:28this in private conversations. So there's two situations that are run into you professionally
- 47:32where this happens. One is among PRIs fellow professor professors. Well, there'll
- 47:37be some people who woul have this kind of attitude toward their students. I
- 47:42luckily don't work with a lot of instructors like this, but I have in
- 47:45the past. The other venue is I'll be in a room full of therapists
- 47:50and they'll start talking about their clients in a very negative way. And even
- 47:55in those situations where the clients and the students can't hear what's happening, it
- 48:00bothers me there too. But to tweet about it, I mean, my
- 48:07god, you know what's wrong with it? Does she not think that some
- 48:13of her students aren't going to come across that, like it's just deplorable.
- 48:19Now again, I get where it comes from. Like I said, we're
- 48:21all deeply insecure. She sounds particularly insecure, so she bullies others to make
- 48:24herself feel better. I get it, and I feel bad for her,
- 48:28and I hope she gets the help that she needs. But I would still
- 48:30fire her, And there's probably a university policy about this, and I would
- 48:36look into that. Patron Marie. I would look into is this instructor breaking
- 48:40some sort of policy because you might want to report her. This is an
- 48:45absolutely reportable offense, and I guarantee you her boss would like to know about
- 48:50this bullshit. It's also possible that it's a FURPA violation, so you don't
- 48:54know what. Essentially, students have confidentiality in the same way that clients do,
- 49:00and for a instructor to tweet about particular conversations they're having in their classrooms,
- 49:07it's probably not strictly a FURP violation because it doesn't identify any particular student.
- 49:10But I don't know. I'm just guessing that the university has some sort
- 49:15of policy about that. And like I said, I've always been against this
- 49:20sort of attitude. I see it among therapists sometimes talking about their clients behind
- 49:25their backs. Again, I get it. Being a teacher is stressful,
- 49:30Being a therapist is stressful. Some clients even attack us, some students attack
- 49:35us. It's rare, but it happens. But to me, if you
- 49:38can't take it to the point where you're tweeting about it, then you need
- 49:43to get out of the profession. You need to be removed, or you
- 49:45need to quit. Go do some job where it doesn't matter. You know,
- 49:50go work at Microsoft, and maybe you have a bunch of customers,
- 49:55vendors, or co workers that you hate. You know, feel free to
- 49:59tweet about that. That's fine. Therapists have a moral obligation to find compassion
- 50:07and understanding, and so do professors. Professors and therapists particularly, you know,
- 50:13in certain fields, you have a moral obligation to find compassion and understanding.
- 50:20And to not have that to the point where you're actually, on purpose
- 50:24tweeting to the entire world that you believe your students or your clients are stupid
- 50:31or something indicates that you do not have that value of returning to compassion and
- 50:38understanding. You know, I tell my students this and I've talked about this
- 50:42in the podcast before, but I guess I should talk about it in this
- 50:45context. Is I tell students, look, before you decided to become a
- 50:50therapist, you could be a regular human. You decided to become a therapist,
- 50:54you can now not be a normal human. If you want to be
- 51:00a normal human, then then get out of the profession now. And what
- 51:02I mean by that is you need to have compassion for everyone. Doesn't mean
- 51:07you need to like everyone, or hang out with everyone, or forgive everyone,
- 51:13but you have to have compassion and understanding for literally every human being on
- 51:16the planet. Sometimes people say like, well, I'm supposed to be of
- 51:21compassion for Hitler or pole pot or something, and it's like, okay,
- 51:23fine, if you happen to run across a polepot or a Hitler, then
- 51:29you know, feel free to disregard this statement. But certainly, when you
- 51:34have students who are making mistakes, you need to have understanding compassion for those
- 51:37people. Certainly, when you have a client who is a Republican and voted
- 51:43for Trump and you hate Trump, you need to have compassion understanding for that
- 51:46person in the same way you'd have compassion for anyone else. Before you were
- 51:52a therapist, you could hate your political rivals. Before you were a professor
- 51:57in psychology, in particular, you could you could refuse to understand other people
- 52:02and refuse to have compassion for your fellow human being. Now that you're a
- 52:07therapist, now that your professor, those days are over. You chose this
- 52:13field. You chose to be a helper of humans. You chose to be
- 52:17in a field where you are in contact with human beings that depend on you
- 52:22to have compassion understanding. There are other professions. Most professions do not require
- 52:28you to have compassion understanding for all human beings. So go do that,
- 52:32no problem. Physicians, teachers, religious ministers, social workers. I would
- 52:39even argue politicians, all of which you could have done anything. If you're
- 52:45that privilege that you can become a teacher, a doctor, a minister,
- 52:46a social worker, politician, a therapist, professor. You're a privileged individual
- 52:52to begin with. With that privilege, you could have done a lot of
- 52:57things. And if you're going to point that privilege at one of the helping
- 53:01professions, then you can't be a regular human anymore. You have to be
- 53:06a compassionate, understanding person. Now you're gonna lose your compassion. Sometimes you're
- 53:09gonna lose your understanding. Sometimes I have, we all do. But you
- 53:13got to return to it. You certainly have to return to it before you
- 53:15start fucking tweeting again. I get it. I have kind of transference to
- 53:22I get angry and frustrated too with students and clients. But after I vent
- 53:28a little bit or think about it for three seconds, I return to compassion
- 53:31and love because otherwise I'm going to harm society and or I'm going to burn
- 53:37out of this profession, which isn't good for me or them. Plus,
- 53:42I just want to say, and I've talked about this before, compassion and
- 53:45love and understanding that position is much more of a peaceful place to live.
- 53:54It's honest, it's real, it's authentic, it's I don't know other other
- 53:59words to say, roots like I'm in contact with realness. When I see
- 54:05Donald Trump's narcissism, which is motivated by his deep sadness that he never shows,
- 54:10but I can see it, I feel like I'm connecting with Donald Trump
- 54:15on a fundamental human level instead of this other level. And again, if
- 54:22I wasn't a therapist, I could hate Donald Trump. I don't like his
- 54:24politics. I don't like the way he presents himself. I know some of
- 54:29you voted for Donald Trump, and you know it's fine. You probably hate
- 54:32you know, many Democratic people, politicians. I don't know. It's just
- 54:38the bias of the political landscape we're in, but or objective truth, depending
- 54:44on how you look at it. But anyway, when I see him,
- 54:49I see someone who is hurting. Let's just do Bill Clinton. He's far
- 54:52enough in the past. Bill Clinton has problems and in the ME two movement
- 55:00he would have been shredded, I would assume, and he was very problematic
- 55:12and did very horrible things. But I can see the damage that he must
- 55:21have incurred growing up, and I can see his pain, and I can
- 55:25see his I can see it's like he's a lost little boy to me.
- 55:31Now, I separate that from how I vote. I'm not I'm not going
- 55:35to vote for people just because I have compassion for the human being. I'm
- 55:37going to vote based on how I feel like they're going to legislate. So
- 55:45so there are two different things. Just because I can have compassion for a
- 55:46politician doesn't mean I'm gonna vote for them. So anyway. It it's so,
- 55:53it's so much of it's so. I feel so much more at peace
- 55:57when I can understand people. Forget about policy, just think about people in
- 56:00your own life. Just that person who cuts you off from the freeway and
- 56:05flips you off, that coworker who never says anything nice to you, that
- 56:10child of yours who never gives you appreciation, that parent of yours who never
- 56:16shows that they're proud of you, that sibling of yours who criticizes everything you
- 56:22do. I can see that in the typical way, which is to say,
- 56:27oh, you know, they're an asshole, blah blah blah. But
- 56:30when I can see through the surf, the veil of hostility that they have
- 56:36and see the pain behind that, I have compassion for them, and I
- 56:45feel like I'm connecting to the universe in this fundamental way, like I'm grounded
- 56:49in a way, and it, you know, is so much more optimistic.
- 56:54When I see the love that everyone is giving each other all the time
- 57:00today, which is what I see, I feel good about the future.
- 57:06I feel good about today. I just feel a lot better. I have
- 57:12compassion for this instructor who tweeted, you know, denigrating things about you and
- 57:16your classmates. I understand her, I think I understand people like her I
- 57:22think in general, but I'd still fire her. All right. Well,
- 57:27that does it for that episode of psychology and Saala, thanks for joining me
- 57:29out there. Please take care of yourself because you deserve it, you really
- 57:31really really do. And take care of other people, please,