Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP287: How Noble Panacea Successfully Launched Ecommerce in China, with Global Digital Director Will Lockie
Transcript
- 0:00It's like having the biggest FAQ in the world right, about your
- 0:02products. You've got to be able to provide
- 0:04that. And also remember during the
- 0:06live stream, you can get those questions in real time from
- 0:09consumers as well. So you've got to be able to arm
- 0:12the teams running the live streams with the with the
- 0:15capability answer those questions.
- 0:22You listen to Insidecommerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:24and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:28and re platform specialist James Geddick Paul Rogers.
- 0:30Get insights into ECOM strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:32industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:35practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:40This episode is sponsored by Shop Fight.
- 0:42Another really interesting and topical episode.
- 0:45Today we are talking about how the e-commerce brands expanded
- 0:48to China and with all of the geopolitical chaos that's going
- 0:52on in the world. All right, the Chinese market's
- 0:54been important for many years, but actually some of these
- 0:56markets in Asia are coming back into the fore given some of the
- 0:58challenges in other markets with tariffs.
- 1:02So I've got a highly experienced digital leader as my guest today
- 1:05who I've had the joy of working with personally on a project
- 1:08for. So warm welcome to Awlaki.
- 1:10He's global digital director and I see it.
- 1:12Hey Will, how are you? Good.
- 1:14Thanks James, what a pleasure to be here.
- 1:17I'm an avid listener of the podcast and super looking
- 1:20forward to. Today, I love it.
- 1:22There we go, shameless plug about why everyone else should
- 1:24be avidly listening all the time to the podcast.
- 1:27But before we get into the questions about China, and I
- 1:29mean, we've had to be really focused because let's face it,
- 1:31launching China's a massive topic.
- 1:33So we're going to, we're going to try and be laser focused
- 1:34today. But do you want to give people a
- 1:36little bit of an intro to who you are, what you do that you're
- 1:38kind of like your background and and what brought you to where
- 1:41you are now? Yeah, of course.
- 1:43And what I thought would be fun is a quick whistle stop tour
- 1:47around the world following the international flavour of your
- 1:50podcast and a little bit of tech because I know the listeners
- 1:53like me love to hear about what platforms people are on
- 1:57etcetera. Really briefly, I mean, I
- 1:59started my career in retail. I was in marketing in the music
- 2:03industry. Then along came a company called
- 2:06Apple and they had this thing called iTunes and iPod.
- 2:09And at that point I realised maybe digital's the future.
- 2:13So decided to leave the world with music marketing, got myself
- 2:17trained digital marketing agency and ended up Holland side at AUK
- 2:23multi brand SME called Evans cycles.
- 2:26And that was really where I kind of cut my teeth on all things
- 2:29retail econ builds, Omni channel projects and the tech back in
- 2:34those days. Those were the on Prem days.
- 2:37So it's free SAR think Hassi smyg see hybris think I've been
- 2:43on website. Oh, those days anyway, So a cup
- 2:45of tea for there quickly realised having done the UKI
- 2:49wanted sort of global experience.
- 2:52I've always wanted to like work abroad by that sort of
- 2:55fascinating. Along came George Jensen, like a
- 2:58global luxury mono brand, a design house, very famed US in
- 3:02Denmark. So I went over to George Jensen
- 3:04in Copenhagen, headed up to the digital team there in leading
- 3:09teams across Mia. Funny enough, the brand's really
- 3:12big in APAC. So obviously speaking the
- 3:15Nordics, Denmark, Sweden, Norway, etcetera, but really big
- 3:19in Taiwan, Australia, so good. So that was my first
- 3:23introduction really to sort of, if you like, managing teams in
- 3:26completely different parts of the world, completely different
- 3:28cultures. So really super interesting the
- 3:32tech in those days. This was my sort of SAS demand
- 3:35era. Everybody was on Salesforce
- 3:37Commerce Cloud at that time, totally dominating the market
- 3:42after George Jensen Kobe came along.
- 3:43So I wanted to come back to UK, ended up at the Rug Company
- 3:47where we met James on one of our projects.
- 3:50So again, luxury business, luxury interiors, super high
- 3:54average, all the value. Interestingly that one most of
- 3:57the business in the US and actually B to B, you know, so
- 4:01it's saying to interior designs as you well know.
- 4:04And that was really I guess in terms of the take of the start
- 4:07of working with you know Saslak ones that we kind of know today,
- 4:10Bigcomb, Shopify, etcetera moved on from the rod company and did
- 4:15where I'm now at Noble Panacea. So luxury skin care again super
- 4:21high Aboriginal value, welfare skin care is about 500 USD.
- 4:25And interestingly, this business, most of the business
- 4:28in the US and China which we're going to talk about today, these
- 4:31are our key markets for growth. And of course we are still in
- 4:35the Shopify BC era. Plus a bit of AII will add.
- 4:40Excellent, I love that it's like Phileas Fogg around the world
- 4:44tour of of E Gorgeous those days of on Prem.
- 4:49I remember working for AE Comm agency in implementing those and
- 4:53just the amount of fun it was with support and maintenance.
- 4:59But yes, how the world's changed.
- 5:00But today, yeah. So today let's we're, we're
- 5:03talking about China and I mean, launching in China's a massive
- 5:06topic. And I for a lot of people who
- 5:09have forays into it, this will be really interesting to hear
- 5:12how you have managed it for a new launch.
- 5:16But those who might be considering looking at other
- 5:18markets will be fascinated into I guess the structure and the
- 5:22approach and like the advice of what what works and, and
- 5:24learnings along the way. So why don't we start with
- 5:28Warriors China? Such a fascinating market for
- 5:30e-commerce. Yeah, let's start there.
- 5:32I mean, I'll start by sort of say this is what I've learned.
- 5:35And I think that's the funnest, the funnest kind of talks and
- 5:37the funniest podcast are always, always when you can actually
- 5:41just hear what people have learned.
- 5:42So I'll just try and take you through our journey a little
- 5:44bit. One quote this brings to mind, I
- 5:47was talking to something in my network recently.
- 5:50I was talking about China and they said to me, yeah, you know
- 5:53what it is about China? It teaches you how to accelerate
- 5:57and lean into digital on a seismic scale.
- 6:00And I thought that was a really nice way to sum up because the
- 6:02words like seismic, the scale is just staggering.
- 6:06The thing that I find so fascinating about this market
- 6:10for e-commerce is because it's so unlike what you've been
- 6:14trained for here in the West. So our world of platforms, SIS,
- 6:18vendors, tech, you know, all the things that we we do with day
- 6:21and day out, it just doesn't exist.
- 6:24So you've got to sort of retrain your brain.
- 6:27It's turned on its head. It's still completely different.
- 6:30Probably the the easiest way to sum it up, why it's so
- 6:33fascinating is that the customer journey sort of completely
- 6:39contained end to end in the app peak assistant, right?
- 6:43So you, you know, you start on one app and social and that go
- 6:46end to end through to payment. Rather here over in the West
- 6:50you've got all these disparate systems, platforms, CRM, PIM, E
- 6:54com, etcetera, blah, blah, blah that you're, you know,
- 6:57connecting together in China. It's just all one seamless in
- 7:01out journey. And if that one's sort of on the
- 7:03sort of techie side of things, then bigger picture is probably
- 7:07around, well, you know, everything there is kind of
- 7:10quicker, faster, bigger. The logistics is staggering.
- 7:14You know, the size of the market is just staggering.
- 7:18And I think the other thing I've learned really about the
- 7:20consumer is, is sort of the Chinese consumer is almost in a
- 7:24way sort of suited from us. Like they, they want pretty
- 7:28detail. They want, they do a ton of
- 7:30research, a way to compare, they want convenience.
- 7:34So all of these things that like E com and digital is super
- 7:37suited for matches. It can consume my mindset in a
- 7:40way. Plus also there's like just a
- 7:43ton of shopping festivals and moments, Double 11, double 12,
- 7:47there's a ton of them. So your trading calendar is
- 7:51well, and there's always something to do.
- 7:55I have interest. Which of your preconceptions
- 7:58from having worked, you know, in the UK and other markets, did
- 8:01you find the hardest to like reprogram the mind on?
- 8:04Was it about the not having agencies and platforms, or was
- 8:07it something else that you found the hardest to adjust to?
- 8:11That's a really good question, James.
- 8:13I think that's part of it. I think he is part of the.
- 8:15It's just quite simply how to do business like you are used to
- 8:20having a team doing certain things in certain roles, running
- 8:23certain systems. That one kind of goes away in
- 8:25China because you know, it's one, you've got a one stop shop
- 8:28really in your TP or your agency.
- 8:31It's kind of I guess the equivalent of the Sr. but
- 8:33they're going to do everything end to end, right?
- 8:35So they'll do all of your performance marketing, they'll
- 8:37do all of your fulfilment, they will load up products and store
- 8:40etcetera. So that kind of goes away.
- 8:44So actually really what what you are left with at its core is,
- 8:49you know, being the internal brand sign team is planning and
- 8:53managing your calendar and your marketing activity and really
- 8:58honing in on that. Because success, you know,
- 9:03almost wholly depends on how much awareness can you build in
- 9:06the market, how much content can you put per hand in the market,
- 9:09how many live streamers if you got on the go, how many KO rolls
- 9:12cases, all of that, you know, you're creating demand and then
- 9:16people come on the platforms and buying and obviously take care
- 9:19of the hygiene there. But I think it is that adapting
- 9:21your mindset more to focus on which platforms I'm going to
- 9:26focus on. Is it just T-Mobile Red Book and
- 9:30really honing in on that as opposed to, you know, over here
- 9:34in the restaurant, right? OK, I've got to run now Google
- 9:37Meta and I'm going to make sure my site is well merchandised.
- 9:41That kind of. It's just less of a focus
- 9:43because it really is about. What do Mattel, Victoria,
- 9:50Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier all have in common?
- 9:55They power their businesses with Shopify.
- 9:59Shopify is the most innovative and scaled commerce platform on
- 10:03the planet. It also happens to have the best
- 10:06converting check out on the planet Shopify powering the
- 10:11future of enterprise commerce. Find out more at
- 10:14shopify.com/enterprise. Excellent.
- 10:18And we're going to come back onto resourcing like a a Chinese
- 10:21operation later. But let's start, let's start
- 10:23with you said to me when we're talking about this podcast with
- 10:27the skin care's the top selling category for beauty in China.
- 10:31So obviously the market demand is there, but what made you and
- 10:34the business side that now is the right time for for market
- 10:37entry? Yeah.
- 10:38I think, I mean it's kind of coupled.
- 10:40So what I said is simply the the size and the scale of the
- 10:44opportunity there. And it's really where our target
- 10:46audience is given the category that we're in.
- 10:50So luxury skin care, the interesting thing, which I
- 10:53didn't know actually about China and sort of East versus West is
- 10:59within beauty sort of in the West, traditionally it's makeup
- 11:05first, fragrance, then skin care, skin care.
- 11:09So like you go E that's reversed.
- 11:11So it's, it's a skin care first market, then like fragrance and
- 11:15makeup. So, so the consumer mindset,
- 11:18complexion of the skin and so on.
- 11:20The consumer mindset is all around skin care, skin health
- 11:24and all of the things associated with and after your skin.
- 11:29So it's like it's just completely natural for us as a
- 11:32brand being technology LED, science LED.
- 11:37There's a nice match there in, you know, the consumers looking
- 11:40for technical details, solutions and just, yeah, the size of the
- 11:46prize, if you will. And how did, how did you, how
- 11:49did you approach this and build a go to market plan because
- 11:52there's so many things to look at in terms of the market,
- 11:54competitors, sales opportunities, channels,
- 11:58compliance, etcetera. So what advice can you share
- 12:00with other E Comm leaders or E Comm teams about how would you
- 12:03approach this in a systematic and controlled way?
- 12:07Yeah. I think, I think my first
- 12:10comment on that, is it actually applicable to trading in any
- 12:15market or doing business in any market?
- 12:17It's actually just the number one thing.
- 12:19It sounds really simple, but is go and spend time in the market.
- 12:23Go and talk to people who've worked in the market, have been
- 12:28in the market. Go and explore different models,
- 12:31Go and network in the market because I think you know, you,
- 12:37there's a ton of experts out there, but there is absolutely
- 12:40no substitute. Sounds like basically there's
- 12:42just no substitute for spending time on the ground to get a feel
- 12:46for what works, what doesn't work.
- 12:50And in China even more so, you know, because it is so different
- 12:53because of some of the reasons I've just said, yeah, go and
- 12:57spend time in the market. Being a bit more specific, I
- 13:01think, you know, you can go there, there's, there are many
- 13:05good agencies out there that will help you enter the market,
- 13:07that will help you build your go to market plan.
- 13:10They will already know, you know what the competitors done like
- 13:16for your competitors, they will know.
- 13:18It's actually it's super interesting because I mean, all
- 13:20of the, all of the sales data out of the platforms is
- 13:24available, right? So they can pull it all and
- 13:26instantly tell you versus your competitors set, how are people
- 13:30trading? Like do you go down the West?
- 13:33Nope. So if that's really, and that
- 13:36again is gives you a real sense of the scale and and the volume,
- 13:41then that kind of insight is just readily available.
- 13:44I think the other things, the other interesting thing that I
- 13:48learned a bit related to spending time in the market is
- 13:53you keep finding things out. The more people you talk to is
- 13:56like, oh, oh, that works. Oh, that doesn't work.
- 13:59Oh, we can do that or we can do that.
- 14:01So I think, yeah, keeping an open mind and having those
- 14:05conversations with people, just the.
- 14:09Number one thing. And how about for a product
- 14:10point of view? Because I find this really
- 14:11interesting. I've worked with a lot of
- 14:13different brands in different verticals going into different
- 14:17markets, mainly in Europe, some in the US, etcetera.
- 14:20And product strategy I find fascinating about how divergent
- 14:24it might need to be to hit the local market and what you have
- 14:26to do to make your products compliant.
- 14:28So can you talk to like how, how did you approach that?
- 14:31Is it just same products packaged differently or is it
- 14:34completely different ranges? I mean basically, well, and then
- 14:39this is quite specific to skin care.
- 14:42The the formulations and the ingredients all have to be
- 14:46illegally compliant in the market.
- 14:47So it's a little bit different than selling in your pair of
- 14:50shawls. So in that regard, you need to
- 14:53get everything passed, summoned off and compliant.
- 14:58So and that is effort. You need to take all the legal
- 15:03advice. It's very different.
- 15:05And because once you know the equivalent, once you are trading
- 15:09as a local entity, once you're selling domestically and and in
- 15:15effect the equivalent of a, a manufacturer in the given market
- 15:20is very different. And in order to be able to trade
- 15:22as such in that market, you need to have all of the appropriate
- 15:27licences, stamps, certificates. You think there's quite a lot
- 15:32involved and getting tests. One example would be, for
- 15:38example, it's going to go well, you know, sort of your, your
- 15:42claims of efficacy test results and so on.
- 15:46They'd like super important. They're, they're a core of, of
- 15:50any marketing to show the consumer, well, you know, this,
- 15:53this, this problem actually works and we've tested it and we
- 15:56can prove it on that piece of content in China.
- 16:01There will be, you know, a huge chunk of text proving that this
- 16:07was being validated has been passed and is in compliant.
- 16:12So that's very different for us. We were kind of lucky on, on a
- 16:17bit more on the products. I was thinking we were kind of
- 16:18lucky in that we have a couple of hero products specifically
- 16:23related to sleep, which is a huge topic in China.
- 16:26Actually, we found out on our last trip, you know, sleep,
- 16:29sleep deprivation, green addiction, these are all huge
- 16:32topics at the moment, not just in China, everywhere that we do
- 16:37have a couple of products that are specifically related to when
- 16:41you're asleep and that fits well with kind of.
- 16:47Interesting. And a link to link to this is
- 16:50like China is often associated with like red tape, bureaucracy
- 16:54and very specific ways of working.
- 16:56So what was your experience like?
- 16:57What were the key challenges you had to overcome?
- 17:00How long did it actually take to get through those compliance
- 17:03checks and certifications? I mean, allow yourself a bare
- 17:09minimum 12 months, you know, like it's a long process.
- 17:13It's complex to set up an entity and you just need a good lawyer
- 17:18insure and to set it all up correctly.
- 17:22He knows how to do it and there's, there's plenty of them
- 17:24out there and there's plenty of businesses that can advise you
- 17:26on that both here in the UK and, and and in the market.
- 17:31So, yeah, and I, I think I'll sorry, revert back to what I
- 17:35said previously is that you talking to people in the market
- 17:39will often allow you to find out the quickest route around that
- 17:43because you might there might be one piece of advice.
- 17:45But actually so and so did it like this.
- 17:47I mean, we can, maybe we can do that and that's a good
- 17:50registration. Yeah, and you so you bet, you
- 17:53said. Obviously you, you work with
- 17:55local advisors. How do you do, I guess probably
- 17:58on listening because it, it can sometimes feel quite daunting of
- 18:02finding an advisor because you think where, who, how, how do I
- 18:06know there's? So how did you go about that?
- 18:08Who have you worked with and what were the key value?
- 18:11I guess what's the key value proposition?
- 18:12What do they bring that you can do yourselves?
- 18:14Yeah, for sure. Like you, absolutely.
- 18:16I mean, if if you are completely new to the market and let's say
- 18:20you know, your team has no experience of engineering China,
- 18:23don't, don't go off and try and do it yourself.
- 18:25Obviously, I mean, there are many partners in the UK, like an
- 18:30example, hot pot China, you know, they are a business that
- 18:33they know the market so well and they can take a UK brand or a
- 18:39western brand and give you a good go to market strategy.
- 18:43So you know, Jonathan and Adam true China experts, they're in
- 18:48the market all the time. So a blend of sort of outside
- 18:52partners and advisors and agencies on the ground and
- 18:56employees on the ground. I mean, now the other thing is,
- 19:00you know, there is absolutely no substitute for hiring talent on
- 19:05the ground that has a network in Shanghai or Beijing that can be
- 19:11lent on do you know, make things work, get stuff done and make
- 19:17things happen basically and and crucially works with your TP and
- 19:22sort of at a one level. And you'd coming back to that
- 19:26point you made earlier about it critical to spend time in
- 19:28market, which I fully agree with, because you having a
- 19:31cultural understanding is really important when you're trying to
- 19:33understand how business is done. But how did how did you start
- 19:37that? What was your first did you go
- 19:39through? Did you find your local advisor
- 19:411st and then use them to help set up connections?
- 19:46Or did you just go to like events?
- 19:48How did you put your how did you get put your feet on the ground
- 19:51and do things? All at the same time, yeah, I
- 19:57mean Qualcomm and approach really is yeah, higher in the
- 20:00market, find a legal adviser in the market, higher in the
- 20:03market, open an office in the market as well as having
- 20:06advisors like I mentioned Hopfart and others.
- 20:09So a blend really you know and and finding leaders in the
- 20:14market to represent your brand is probably like the number one
- 20:17thing. So having AGM in the market, a
- 20:20general manager in the market who has a good network.
- 20:23And we'll get, we'll get you far basically because that's, yeah,
- 20:27what we have found is just absolutely essential.
- 20:31Sound advice. Let's come back to that thing
- 20:34about losing the preconceptions. How ecommerce is, is executed is
- 20:38very different. So the online store experience
- 20:41as you touched on is very different.
- 20:42Most sellers done via the big marketplaces and you launched,
- 20:45if I'm going to write you launched from Tmall Global
- 20:47first. So what was it?
- 20:49Why there? Why start there?
- 20:51Well, TT Tim, War Global's open, right?
- 20:54So any brand can can sell on Team War Global, but the mindful
- 21:00that the price is going to be higher because you're subject to
- 21:03import duty, right? So it's an easy way to sort of
- 21:05test the market and everybody will tell you Team War Global or
- 21:08TMG is a great starting point, which is fine, but you're,
- 21:14you're never going to achieve like sort of volume through it.
- 21:19So our route was far less, of course, you know, get the brand
- 21:22known and start, just start building some awareness.
- 21:25To me, probably the number one learning we have in the market
- 21:28is as early as possible start building awareness.
- 21:33And if that's listing on Tingle Global and doing content of a
- 21:37little red book, great. But our journey was essentially
- 21:44open up the local entity list and then once you've done that,
- 21:49then you can sell domestically on Timo Classic or TMC and
- 21:54that's where you know you, you have local prices basically.
- 21:58And that's where that's where the consumer effectively.
- 22:02So that was the easiest route drafts.
- 22:04There are other platforms of course, you mentioned, we
- 22:06mentioned a few, but Timo for us is starting close up the volume.
- 22:13They always have the luxury pavilions.
- 22:14That's something maybe to work towards in the future.
- 22:17So yeah, and given our passport, it's an actual thing.
- 22:21And the next question I'm really interested in is WeChat, because
- 22:28WeChat is huge. We'll see in China, WeChat has
- 22:31its own payments. I'd love to hear about how
- 22:34you're seeing the role of WeChat in the purchase journey and also
- 22:39how that ecosystem works for like post purchase.
- 22:43Because as you said that over here, we're so used to you go to
- 22:46a website, potentially you buy, there's data pushed into a ACRM
- 22:53or into an ESP and there's follow up marketing and there's
- 22:56retargeting in the social. But you have these combined
- 23:00ecosystems. So I'd love to hear how you've
- 23:02seen what, what was it like? What's the user's journey like
- 23:04and what's the opportunities for you as a brand?
- 23:08It's super interesting. I'm glad you asked about that
- 23:10one because that, that was one of the things when I first
- 23:12bought something, I was like, had this mobile.
- 23:14Oh, that's how quick it is. And I'll explain a little bit
- 23:19more. So obviously, you know, WeChat,
- 23:22it's got payments embedded. So you know, if I'm buying
- 23:26something in store at the counter, I'll rock up, get the
- 23:32item and in one scan I have paid for said item.
- 23:38I am on the brand's WeChat mini program, AKACRM, to your point.
- 23:44So there's no, there's no e-mail, there's nothing else.
- 23:46Just straight into like a one to one chat with the sales
- 23:50assistant and any simple terms. That's going to be it.
- 23:53There's an opt to prove it. But just that sort of example of
- 23:58a sort of condensed or shortened customer journey kind of sums it
- 24:02up a lot because it's like it's so quick basically completely
- 24:07contained within the app ecosystem a little bit more
- 24:11because it's quite interesting. So in within WeChat, they have
- 24:17something called a mini program. So effectively that is a brand's
- 24:23mini CRM program. It's like a mini pram zone.
- 24:28So when I was scanned, when my WeChat ID was scanned and then
- 24:33add it in to that brand's mini program and then I'm getting
- 24:39messages, for example, from McLaren's or I hosted all the
- 24:41future brand when they have offers, when have things
- 24:44happening in store or when happening online.
- 24:48So it's like super rich and it skips all of that and stuff that
- 24:52you mentioned, you know, there's no e-mail, there's no say
- 24:55nothing else going on. You're straight into that
- 24:58conversation and you also completely skipping the card
- 25:04ecosystem that we're so used to over here.
- 25:06And then that becomes again, like just another super rich
- 25:12data point because they know. So the back end of WeChat know
- 25:16exactly where you were, how much you spent, what you bought.
- 25:20And that's sort of like the the secret part that all of us in
- 25:23the West, in the West wish we knew about our customers like
- 25:26you. Like tapping into home in
- 25:29details is complicated, as we all know.
- 25:31So because they've skipped cards and you're straight into wallet
- 25:36payments, it's super rich. One example actually I really
- 25:42like, I was in one of the malls and the Clarins had like a
- 25:47sample vending machine. So you're in the mall, you walk
- 25:51up to the vending machine, you scan the QR with your WeChat,
- 25:56you get a skin care sample and straight away you're into their
- 25:59CRM programme within a few minutes.
- 26:01So again, a really nice example of a condensed kind of a journey
- 26:06and straight straight into the database.
- 26:09Basically. And is that free samples?
- 26:11Then you paid for it. Yeah, that is, I'm giving you
- 26:14effectively I'm signing up to a programme.
- 26:17Yeah, the equivalent of your. Give me your e-mail address and
- 26:20I'll give you. Yeah, amazing though, isn't it?
- 26:22I've just done through through basically a payment app that
- 26:27then has all your data to. Yeah, really interested
- 26:30actually. Which for me, for somebody who
- 26:33like me, I mean, I, I totally get it on the consumer level.
- 26:36For somebody like me who outside of work, doesn't want to look at
- 26:39his phone up and check rugby scores, it terrifies me.
- 26:43But think about that, that is, it is that that in that in
- 26:48China, they perfectly, you know, you know, the, they've skipped
- 26:52bigger screens, everything's mobile 1st and that has pros and
- 26:57cons. But you know that that whole
- 26:58being contained really in the app ecosystem just brings so
- 27:02much opportunities for brands and they're like super rich.
- 27:07It it does. I remember looking at this a
- 27:10good few years back when the, the comparisons are being made
- 27:13between China and and the West about our evolution because of,
- 27:18because of the nature of our, our, our, our countries have
- 27:20suddenly tailed cities and so much more infrastructure.
- 27:24From a desktop point of view, the, the, the complexities that
- 27:28then brings into like use user experience, user journeys versus
- 27:32missing out that entire desktop and going straight into mobile.
- 27:35It definitely has some succinct voltages from a data and CRM
- 27:38point of view. Yeah, and the and the
- 27:40infrastructure there is to back it up like you know, like I mean
- 27:445G everywhere you go is faster than most towns and cities are
- 27:49there in the UK. Yes, yeah, well, I haven't
- 27:53regularly suffered on any train journey in this country to get
- 27:57any decent signal even for a phone call.
- 28:00Yeah, we have a long way to go in terms of connectivity.
- 28:02The other bit I really will chat about and it's it's an area that
- 28:04I really wish Western countries like the UK had embraced a bit
- 28:08more. And every year I'm still waiting
- 28:10for it to be the year of live shopping.
- 28:12But Coltry, we're just not so in tune with it live, you know,
- 28:16live video streams in social massive actual live shopping out
- 28:20of some of the the big channels and maybe a few brands doesn't
- 28:23really taken off so much, but it's massive in China.
- 28:28So do you want to talk us through like what what does live
- 28:30shopping mean to no panacea, how we use it?
- 28:33What's a strategy? Yeah, lately, I mean this, it's
- 28:38kind of linked, right, this. So if you think about think
- 28:41about it in the context of live shopping plus KOL or live
- 28:46shopping plus influencer, influencer plus live shopping is
- 28:48that is that blend of having celebrities or consumers, you
- 28:55know, literally talking through your product, how to use it, all
- 28:59the details and so on. And I think how we've used it
- 29:05is, well, what we learned is, is just like it is critical.
- 29:08So and especially in a super noisy category like skin care in
- 29:14this market and you need to do it because it quite simply is
- 29:18just is, is how consumers shop. The benefit that it gives the
- 29:25consumer is you get an absolute ton of detail before you make up
- 29:30your mind purchase that you just don't sort of get from reading
- 29:35through PDP for example. So you know, live streamers will
- 29:39talk for 30 minutes about one product, the ingredients, how to
- 29:44use it, efficacy, you know, good, all of the packaging, you
- 29:48know, in sort of minute detail. They have these things for hand
- 29:53cards, right? So you give them the hand cards
- 29:54and it has just all the detail that they use within the live
- 29:58stream. So yeah, like you can't avoid
- 30:03it. It's super, super important to
- 30:06have celebrities K Wells doing the nice dreams.
- 30:10We run ours on the red book because that's the an actual
- 30:14play to where where our audience are.
- 30:18And in the beauty and skin care category, it's the red book.
- 30:22It's important. The thing, the thing needs to
- 30:24kind of watch out for, right? So it can be very deal LED.
- 30:29So you know, you have to adjust your mindset a little bit.
- 30:34Let's say you know, you're sort of super premium, high luxury
- 30:38band. You have to adjust your mindset
- 30:40a little bit in the sense that you're going to have to offer a
- 30:44gift repurchase, for example. You're going to have to offer
- 30:46some things that perhaps you may not necessarily used to in the
- 30:51West. So that you know, the consumer
- 30:54mindset is very sort of Pavy orientated.
- 30:57The other thing we learn about the about the market in general
- 31:01and and particularly in the live streaming is returns rate like
- 31:05can be really high. It really can be high because
- 31:10sort of impulse purchases and then regret afterwards.
- 31:15You know, AT they should defend is not unhedal and you look in
- 31:20some of the key shopping periods, but, you know, bringing
- 31:25it down to, you know, having a conversation like, oh, a returns
- 31:28rate of 30%. Well, that's good.
- 31:30Like most of us would be like, whoa.
- 31:33Plus, you know, so that's that's what that's the equivalent of
- 31:35fashion in the in the West 1. So those sorts of things,
- 31:42learnings and, and understanding what is OK, what is good
- 31:46performance and what isn't is interesting.
- 31:49And the other thing, if I was just saying who is doing your
- 31:54live streaming and your live shopping is also super important
- 31:58because who is endorsing it? Who you've got talking through
- 32:02your product in certain categories.
- 32:06There's just, you know, there's a few celebrities that dominate,
- 32:09you know, Alibaba, I've got Austin Lee.
- 32:12This guy is like, you know, the scales are absolutely
- 32:14staggering. Everything he touches cells and
- 32:19in the beauty there's others like that also.
- 32:21So you know, finding arrangements for these people is
- 32:24important. The other, the other really
- 32:27interesting thing I think about the live streaming that we learn
- 32:30is putting a GMV on everything is another way to say it in the
- 32:35sense that whoever you start working with and whether they're
- 32:39Kola consumer or a sales opinion leader and all of them will have
- 32:46effectively revenue protection in in working with those that
- 32:51you can almost guarantee return with is just a little bit of a
- 32:54different mindset as well. So you know are commercial.
- 32:58Yeah, I find this fascinating and and I guess a related
- 33:02question for me is you spend up to 30 minutes on one product, it
- 33:06feels really counter intuitive to the fast-paced world we live
- 33:09in, in digital where attention spans are shrinking and
- 33:12everything's micro moments. So how do you approach that from
- 33:15a content point of view? Because 30 minutes I, I, you
- 33:18know, I run a podcast and I know how much time and effort it
- 33:22takes to prepare and make sure we, we've got tangible things to
- 33:26talk about rather than just, you know, hoping that we've got 30
- 33:30minutes content. So, yeah, how would you go from
- 33:33APDP to 30 minutes of audio? Because the number of words you
- 33:36can get out in 30 minutes and audio is quite extensive.
- 33:40With the AUD, you need to provide the detail.
- 33:42But and and again, again, a bit going back to what I said at the
- 33:45beginning, consumer mindset, they want to consume a lot of
- 33:49detail about product. They want to say where it's from
- 33:51and what it's made of efficacy. All of these, all of these
- 33:55things that go into making a decision to purchase and we need
- 33:59to provide it all. So you need to provide evidence
- 34:02and we will. The other learning for us is to
- 34:05be banner at that, quite frankly is that you will get an absolute
- 34:10ton. It's like having the biggest FAQ
- 34:13in the world right about your product.
- 34:14You've got to be able to provide that.
- 34:18And also remember during the live stream, you're going to get
- 34:20those questions in real tough from consumers as well.
- 34:25So you've got to be able to arm the teams and running a live
- 34:29streams with the with the capability to answer those
- 34:32questions. So yeah, it's like having the
- 34:35detail doing your hand right, Really pretty straightforward.
- 34:39Yeah, I would, I, I guess, I guess also the the benefit of
- 34:42that is it forces you to properly scrutinise and
- 34:44understand your product, your messaging, your hierarchy and
- 34:49ensure that you, I mean if you, as you said, you have to go
- 34:51through all these compliance checks anyway.
- 34:53So you have to have all of that legal and compliance data behind
- 34:56it before you can start selling. 100%, yes.
- 34:59No, really good point. Because because of that level of
- 35:02scrutiny, it will reveal things about your business and brand
- 35:07that you probably thought, ah, OK, maybe we can use that
- 35:09elsewhere because that level of detail or a particular point
- 35:13that might be assumer for either elsewhere and.
- 35:20Well, maybe this is for anyone, Listen, maybe this is the way
- 35:22that you solve your product data and attribute issues where you
- 35:25can't get the business to buy in, just get everyone to launch
- 35:27in China, then you have to do it anyway.
- 35:29And then you can just take that discipline back to your other
- 35:31countries. You know, it's only 12 months
- 35:35and quite a lot of money, but don't worry.
- 35:39So the next thing I got a question about it and you
- 35:43touched about it earlier about the fact that like paid media in
- 35:46especially like UK, Europe, this is massive, but so much happens
- 35:50through the apps in China. How is what, what is a
- 35:56performance marketed in a social strategy in a Chinese market?
- 35:59What, what does it look like? What, what are you doing?
- 36:01How are you execute it? Yeah, yeah, there's similarities
- 36:06and differences. The similarities I think I
- 36:09mentioned earlier, right. So, you know, really focusing on
- 36:12building awareness first. Fine, that's no no news to
- 36:15anyone. Start doing that in social.
- 36:18We've got it. Yeah, we all know that.
- 36:20So start seeding, start doing that work early on.
- 36:23That's a given before you start doing performance marketing, OK.
- 36:28But the big difference here is that you're going to be working
- 36:31probably in a couple of platforms, right?
- 36:33And you're going to be selecting a couple of, you know, a
- 36:36selection of Kols to do that seeding work.
- 36:41And that that approach isn't that different to the West.
- 36:46The platforms will help you do that.
- 36:49And I think the other thing is there is almost everywhere you
- 36:53go to Shanghai, there's an influencer, right?
- 36:55So there's a lot of people doing it.
- 36:57So coming through is interesting there.
- 37:01I think the thing that we found, which was actually sort of it's
- 37:06quite nicely really because and once you start looking at force
- 37:12functions, so that's what you've done, your awareness.
- 37:14You know, you've you've I'm working with some Kols, you've
- 37:18tons of product seeding, you've got a level of content out
- 37:21there. And by the way, counting the
- 37:25pieces of content that you're putting out is pretty much going
- 37:29to be your measure of awareness. So any TP, for example, James,
- 37:32you go over there and you say, well, I'm going to start
- 37:33multiple brand. Well, how many pages of content
- 37:36have you put out there? How many, how many videos?
- 37:41If you know that, how much content is that there?
- 37:42What's the volume out there? Because it's that there is the
- 37:45sort of most simple measure of how well your brands can perform
- 37:49that then should you know if if everything's going OK, translate
- 37:55into people searching for your brand in a factory.
- 38:00How many people are then searching for a brand on Tmall
- 38:03because they've seen content outside of the platforms,
- 38:07They're now in the platform, hopefully on the buying journey.
- 38:10But the thing that we learned actually sort of behind the
- 38:15scenes under the hood, for example, some of the ad tech, so
- 38:22some of the things that you, a lot of the listeners would be
- 38:25used to over here in the West. So some of the tools around, I
- 38:30don't know. So it's like audience building
- 38:31and meta. It's actually just not
- 38:33sophisticated over there. And actually what we've really
- 38:37posed is that a lot of it is sort of under the hood, behind
- 38:43the scenes, manual range of data.
- 38:50I'm not saying it's, it's unsophisticated, but what I'm
- 38:52just hinting at is, is that you realise why there's enemies of
- 38:58people just running your campaigns, because there's a lot
- 39:01of manual work involved in setting up a retargeting,
- 39:07setting up a posting schedule on your Red Book.
- 39:10It's actually some, you know, it's some some level of it's not
- 39:13just like here, your head of social on Instagram and you put
- 39:19up a post on Instagram. That's what it's not quite the
- 39:23same in China. So that was a bit of an iron for
- 39:26us is how much work is involved and how many people are behind
- 39:32the scenes, whether it be at the TP or at the platform to get the
- 39:38work done. Interestingly, when we to visit
- 39:42Little Red Book, and this made us realize this.
- 39:45When we went to visit Little Red Book, I think we queued for
- 39:49about half an hour to get into an elevator.
- 39:52There wasn't that many people, literally hundreds all going up
- 39:56to sit at their desks. And it really made us realize
- 40:00this. And once we start talking and
- 40:01saying, OK, can we do this? Can we do this?
- 40:04What's that? That that netter that little
- 40:08they're beginning to understand. And I think that again, is sort
- 40:12of a learning to take away from spending time talking to them.
- 40:18Yes, they are of talking to people and never to be
- 40:22underestimated. I've got a final question for
- 40:25you, which is around resourcing and team structure, because I'd
- 40:29love to hear how you've got about it because you've also
- 40:30talked about having local advisors and external partners.
- 40:35But how have you resourced internally?
- 40:37Like how have you, did you have a separate team?
- 40:39Do you just deliver it with the existing team?
- 40:43And what role do externals play versus what you take ownership?
- 40:47Yeah, Yeah. I think we're, we're like super
- 40:50lean. We're, you know, we're not a
- 40:51huge team size. So we have a small team on the
- 40:56ground. I think I mentioned earlier, you
- 40:58know, hiring in some of those silly roles like having GM on
- 41:01the ground, super important. So they are taking care
- 41:05effectively of planning, making sure that the campaigns are
- 41:10being set up correctly. They will effectively follow the
- 41:14global plan, make sure stop these on the ground and make
- 41:19sure assets are in place to launch set campaign at any given
- 41:24time. That's all fairly fairly
- 41:26straightforward. They are managing the TP, right.
- 41:30So they are managing closely the TP to execute said campaign to
- 41:34fulfill do the marketing and so on.
- 41:38That's one model though. I mean there are, there are
- 41:40different models. We talked you mentioned Team
- 41:44Global earlier like you could just go into the market there
- 41:48some on Team Global and and probably get achieve a good
- 41:52amount of sales there and and just employ ATP not have anybody
- 41:56on the ground. There are brands like Rafa that
- 41:59have done that super, super well and have sold very well in the
- 42:03market as a result. Our approach though was you know
- 42:08beyond the ground in the market given size of the opportunity,
- 42:13we would like to own it more and own how our brand represented
- 42:18the other. The other parts of that
- 42:21literally around physical representation is that we opened
- 42:25a cop up store in Plaza 66 in Shanghai.
- 42:29Obviously to open up a physical store it's it's very different
- 42:32to selling online. So and obviously we need team on
- 42:35the ground to do that tends to sell associate managers
- 42:39etcetera. We've also just opened in Hunger
- 42:42Tower, which is another big city outside of the Shanghai.
- 42:48So to have the full model, you know, to have this call the
- 42:53online retail, you have to house people on the ground basically.
- 42:57And yeah, it's worked super well.
- 43:00The other thing that we really learned was having that having
- 43:03that team supported by, you know, the global team on my team
- 43:08in London also is super important.
- 43:11Like to make sure that the team on the ground is supported.
- 43:14And I don't know, getting assets or helping them plan budgets,
- 43:19forecast trade plans, whatever it is, we can help do that.
- 43:25And that that team, you know, have also enjoyed spending time
- 43:29in the market and learning, building relationships.
- 43:32And that's when you know, things really start to work well.
- 43:35Like you have a local team on the ground, you have a global
- 43:38team sat wherever, working together well, communicating,
- 43:42and then you get results. Amazing, That's really
- 43:45interesting. Thank you for sharing that
- 43:47because I think often the the question on everyone's lips
- 43:51around expansion is how do I structure this?
- 43:53What how does my team need to diverge from where it is now?
- 43:56Or can I do it with that existing 1.
- 43:58So that's really, really interesting.
- 43:59And will thanks so much for joining us.
- 44:01I know everyone listening. We've got a load of value out of
- 44:03this. And if anyone wants to connect
- 44:06with him, I highly recommend that he's always, always good
- 44:08value to chapter around all things e-commerce and generally
- 44:11in life. His contact details are on the
- 44:13landing page. But yeah, Will, thanks so much
- 44:16for joining us. I really enjoyed that.
- 44:18It was an absolute pleasure and lovely to chat to you as always.
- 44:21Yeah, well, good luck with the expansion plans and for growth
- 44:24in China and I look forward to catching up with you soon.
- 44:27You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast hosted by
- 44:30experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 44:33Inside Commerce is your fast tracked additional knowledge
- 44:35featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 44:38industry thought leads and the C-Suite, key tech companies to
- 44:41explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 44:43and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 44:46really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 44:49to help fine tune your E com strategy and taste.
- 44:52Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 44:55like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 44:57We hope you enjoy the latest episode.