Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / When “Not Now” Still Means “Maybe Later” For Private Property and ICBC Hit and Run Requirements
Transcript
- 0:27Michael Mulligan: Well, uh, this is somebody who at least had the opportunity to go to court because the accident itself occurred in 2019 prior to eliminating the ability to do that.
- 0:37Michael Mulligan: Now in the world of ICBC no fault, what you might get would be a function of both what you paid for in terms of insurance, right?
- 0:46Michael Mulligan: Um and uh you're in many cases uh don't have uh the opportunity to challenge what ICBC uh is doing to you in court.
- 0:54Michael Mulligan: But this case is from a time when that was possible, and it is still important to know about, um, because the Insurance Motor Vehicle Act has provisions to deal with um hit and runs.
- 1:06Michael Mulligan: And in this uh case, uh I should say those provisions, however, require uh that where you're making a claim against ICBC for an unknown driver, uh, that is a requirement that the person making the claim show that they had taken all reasonable efforts to ascertain the identity of the unknown driver in a hit and run.
- 1:29Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that can take a variety of forms depending on the factual background, uh, which is important to this decision ultimately over the Court of Appeal.
- 1:39Michael Mulligan: But the fact pattern here involved uh a uh a couple of people driving at four o'clock in the morning.
- 1:45Michael Mulligan: They went through a green light, uh, truck sli went through a stop sign, or sorry, stop sign, right a stop sign, stolen truck, crashed into them, described as smashing into their vehicle, uh, and then a person got out wearing dark clothing with a hoodie on and fled the scene on foot, disappearing into darkness, the driver of the stolen truck.
- 2:06Michael Mulligan: Uh the truck had been reported stolen two days earlier by the owner of it.
- 2:10Michael Mulligan: Uh, there was no basis to sue the owner of the vehicle, nothing they had done uh negligent about that.
- 2:15Michael Mulligan: It was stolen and they reported it to the police.
- 2:18Michael Mulligan: And so, as a result of this serious accident, the police show up, not surprisingly.
- 2:24Michael Mulligan: Um, and given the seriousness of the accident, the fact that the vehicle was stolen, um, after they uh dealing with the uh medical conditions of the uh two people from the car, they're taken away uh to the hospital.
- 2:36Michael Mulligan: Uh the police start conducting an investigation to try to figure out who stole the car and who crashed into it and ran off.
- 2:42Michael Mulligan: And they did a variety of things.
- 2:44Michael Mulligan: They he uh brought out a police dog and they tried to follow the track, and that didn't work.
- 2:49Michael Mulligan: They then canvassed the area for video cameras.
- 2:52Michael Mulligan: That's common, like you know, doorbell cameras, business security cameras, this kind of thing.
- 2:56Michael Mulligan: They didn't find any that could have captured it.
- 2:59Michael Mulligan: Uh they canvassed for witnesses, they did manage to speak to three witnesses who had, like, I guess showed up at the scene.
- 3:05Michael Mulligan: Uh one guy was described as a person who had been playing video games who heard screeching, came out, and then he'd heard the crash but didn't see what happened, the video game player.
- 3:15Michael Mulligan: Um, and then they even went so far as to have a forensic examination done on the stolen truck, including searching it for DNA, fingerprints, or anything else that might help identify the driver.
- 3:26Michael Mulligan: None of that uh provided any useful information, and uh within a couple of days the police closed their investigation.
- 3:33Michael Mulligan: There was just nothing more they could do to try to locate this hooded person uh who ran off into the darkness.
- 3:40Michael Mulligan: There were just no leads to go on.
- 3:42Michael Mulligan: And so the people who had been badly hurt when they got uh I guess T-boned by this stolen truck, um uh, I guess eventually spoke to a lawyer about it, and the advice is advice included advice, no doubt, about this obligation to take all reasonable efforts to try and identify the driver.
- 4:01Michael Mulligan: Now, this was about a year after the fact, and some of the cases involving all reasonable efforts involve uh a person going out and pasting up signs, like looking for witnesses, as one of the things that's been pointed to.
- 4:13Michael Mulligan: And so I guess they decided to do that.
- 4:15Michael Mulligan: They went and pasted up signs asking if anyone witnessed what went on.
- 4:18Michael Mulligan: They they produced one response, that being from the video game player who had already been interviewed by the police, who just heard the screeching and came out and saw the the aftermath.
- 4:27Michael Mulligan: So that not surprisingly didn't go anywhere.
- 4:30Michael Mulligan: And so ICBC refuses to pay uh because their argument is, well, you didn't take all reasonable steps, you took no steps.
- 4:37Michael Mulligan: You were just hospitalized and you didn't do anything for a year.
- 4:41Michael Mulligan: And they said, Well, you can't just uh offload this on the police, you have to take the reasonable steps to try to locate the person.
- 4:47Michael Mulligan: And so they denied the claim.
- 4:49Michael Mulligan: Uh and the thing first of all proceeded to trial where ICBC took that position saying, sorry, you haven't taken all reasonable steps, you just uh sat in your hospital bed uh not try to track this person down, you didn't do anything for a year.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: Uh and the judge, hearing the original trial, uh agreed with ICBC uh and said, Well, it's unfortunate, but uh judge said they're adding to the chorus of other judges who have talked about the unfairness of these provisions, but uh denied the claim.
- 5:18Michael Mulligan: Uh and that then led to an appeal to the Court of Appeal and the decision which just came out.
- 5:23Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal, happily, in in my judgment, given just the unfairness of what was described there, uh concluded that the trial judge had made a mistake in agreeing with ICBC's position that uh these uh people who got uh slammed into hadn't taken all reasonable steps.
- 5:40Michael Mulligan: Uh and what the Court of Appeal focused on uh is that all reasonable steps, and it has to remember all is the language in the uh legislation, right?
- 5:50Michael Mulligan: And so, for example, if you just like spoke to witnesses but didn't put up signs, that's gonna lead to, well, hold on, couldn't you have done one more thing?
- 5:57Michael Mulligan: Signs?
- 5:57Michael Mulligan: How many did you put up?
- 5:58Michael Mulligan: Yeah, the legislation doesn't even say what it is, it just says all reasonable steps.
- 6:03Michael Mulligan: And so, you know, you you would on your own have to be out there canvassing for cameras and maybe trying to get a private dog track, I'm not sure.
- 6:11Michael Mulligan: Uh, but the Court of Appeal pointed out that the trial judge was correct, that you can't merely report the accident to the police and then say, well, I've offloaded my duty to them.
- 6:22Michael Mulligan: Uh and furthermore, it wasn't enough here.
- 6:25Michael Mulligan: The people also promptly reported what happened to ICBC, and ICBC didn't tell them anything about their obligation to do anything.
- 6:33Michael Mulligan: Um that only came up when they eventually, that is to say, ICBC eventually denied their claim.
- 6:39Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the Court of Appeal, the way they approached it is even though that language is all reasonable steps, the Court of Appeal concluded that when assessing what all reasonable steps mean, uh it requires an assessment of like all of the circumstances about what happened, uh, and some assessment as to whether any other steps here would have been anything but obviously futile, right?
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: Um, you know, here, uh did they go and put signs up as soon as they got released from the hospital?
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: Well, no, they didn't.
- 7:08Michael Mulligan: But in fairness, the police had already canvased for witnesses, spoke to three people that heard you, could not locate anyone else.
- 7:15Michael Mulligan: What else would have happened, right?
- 7:18Michael Mulligan: Um and so what else were they to have done?
- 7:20Michael Mulligan: And so they looked at the fact that not only was it reported to the police, but the police did this relatively thorough investigation with dog tracks and gift canvassing for videos and you know, DNA searches and fingerprint examinations.
- 7:33Michael Mulligan: And sort of, well, what else are these people supposed to do?
- 7:36Michael Mulligan: It's sort of like a yes, if you try to come up with a list of things that people have done in other cases, which is sort of how it was approached originally, looking at, well, other people have put up signs.
- 7:45Michael Mulligan: Did you put up signs?
- 7:46Michael Mulligan: Well, no.
- 7:46Michael Mulligan: Well, then I guess it's not all steps, is it?
- 7:48Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 7:48Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 7:49Michael Mulligan: You could have put up signs.
- 7:49Michael Mulligan: The other people put up seven, you only put up six.
- 7:51Michael Mulligan: Surely you could have done more, right?
- 7:53Michael Mulligan: What about the other corner?
- 7:55Michael Mulligan: So the Court of Appeal found that, you know, when assessing what all reasonable steps mean, you do have to take into account all of the circumstances, including, for example, the thoroughness of the police investigation.
- 8:07Michael Mulligan: This wasn't just a case where somebody, you know, phones up ICBC and says, hey, I've got a fender bender in the parking lot, I need a file number.
- 8:14Michael Mulligan: You know, here's a picture of my dented door or something where police are doing, frankly, nothing, right, other than giving you a number and accepting your photograph.
- 8:22Michael Mulligan: This is where they attended.
- 8:23Michael Mulligan: They did a full-throated investigation, they spoke to witnesses, they did all that stuff.
- 8:27Michael Mulligan: And so in that circumstance, uh the failure to take any other steps that one could think of to accomplish all uh didn't invalidate uh their claim.
- 8:37Michael Mulligan: And so the net result from the Court of Appeal is that they've remitted the matter uh back to the BC Supreme Court to assess their damages, which sounds like they're pretty serious.
- 8:46Michael Mulligan: They were hospitalized for some period of time.
- 8:48Michael Mulligan: Now, of course, what you what you may get is going to be subject to what insurance did you buy?
- 8:53Michael Mulligan: Did you buy the uh you know hit and run insurance when you purchased your no fault insurance?
- 8:58Michael Mulligan: If not, you may be out of luck, right?
- 9:01Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh as well when you have decisions, because that's how that now works, is sort of well, did you buy that, did you take off that option and pay for it?
- 9:08Michael Mulligan: No, well, that's that then.
- 9:10Michael Mulligan: Um and and that's why for no fault, you have results like, you know, car thief smashes into you, right?
- 9:16Michael Mulligan: And car thief uh gets uh you know treatment paid for by ACBC, no fault after all.
- 9:22Michael Mulligan: And you might be out of luck, you know, for the uh your car being smashed up or inaccessible for months as it's being fixed because you didn't buy that option.
- 9:30Michael Mulligan: It's kind of up to you to buy your own first party insurance now.
- 9:33Michael Mulligan: And if you didn't do that too bad.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: And if you don't like the decision made, your option is to go to the civil resolution tribunal, which of course are a bunch of people who are on short-term contracts employed by the government, and so best of luck to you there.
- 9:45Michael Mulligan: Um as I ask the latest of the Court of Appeal, and that's why when you're involved in an accident, at least depending on the circumstances, if you can't identify who the driver was, all reasonable efforts are required.
- 9:55Michael Mulligan: So if it's something you could do to try to track the person down, you best do it, or you could get denied uh on that basis as well.
- 10:24Adam Stirling: What's happening there?
- 10:26Michael Mulligan: This is really interesting, and and it also uh connects up with what you've been covering today in terms of like exact comments made by Premier Eve with respect to things like what the exactly is meant.
- 10:39Michael Mulligan: Uh and here's why here I'll give you the basis of this, and then there's some key elements to what people should be aware of.
- 10:45Michael Mulligan: So what what this is, is this was this is in the context of a private landowner that was impacted uh by the decision in Richmond with respect to the couch and tribes decision in terms of what impact it could have on their private property there.
- 11:01Michael Mulligan: Uh and the it's a corporate landowner there, and they they are applying to reopen the trial and to be added as a party uh in order to be able to argue about uh whether the decision as it relates to private property um should be uh further considered.
- 11:18Michael Mulligan: Um and the application was made in terms of uh sort of an extension of time to uh or uh application to to do that at this time, uh, and it's opposed by Cowichan tribes.
- 11:31Michael Mulligan: Now the uh they're opposing the application generally, that is to say, Cowichan Tribes is opposing the application to reopen the trial to allow the private landowner to make submissions.
- 11:42Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh the uh property owner is arguing that uh when they're assessing how long they waited to apply to or reopen things, the only time that should be considered is the date from the date of the decision to the date the application was made.
- 11:58Michael Mulligan: Cowichan Tribes is saying, no, no, no.
- 12:01Michael Mulligan: Uh this is long delayed.
- 12:02Michael Mulligan: If you wanted to do this, you should have done this way back years ago as part of this litigation.
- 12:07Michael Mulligan: Now, the history of that is this.
- 12:10Michael Mulligan: Early on in that Cowichin Tribes litigation, there was an application made back in 2017 uh to another judge of the BC Supreme Court asking uh that there be an order that notice be provided.
- 12:23Michael Mulligan: This is an application by the province, that notice should be provided to all privately uh private landowners so that they can decide whether they wanted to intervene in the case.
- 12:32Michael Mulligan: And that application by the province was denied.
- 12:36Michael Mulligan: Uh and so it meant that there wasn't notice sent out to all the private landowners so they could determine if they wanted to uh participate.
- 12:43Michael Mulligan: Now, here's how it here's why here's where the precise language becomes very important and relates to some of the comments made most recently.
- 12:52Michael Mulligan: On this, this is a this hearing was a hearing about whether the private landowner should have to provide documents to Cowichan tribes uh that Cowichan tribes would want to try to say, well, hey, you knew more about this earlier on, and so you should have applied earlier if you wanted to be a party to all this.
- 13:10Michael Mulligan: In response to that, the private landowner said, Well, hold on a minute.
- 13:13Michael Mulligan: That's an abusive process.
- 13:15Michael Mulligan: You, Cowichan tribes, uh took the positions that private property owners uh would not be impacted by what was being sought.
- 13:24Michael Mulligan: Now, how can you take some different position?
- 13:26Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 13:26Michael Mulligan: Now here's what the judge says about that.
- 13:28Michael Mulligan: I find that the property owner's submission that the plaintiff said the declaration sought in this trial would not impact private property owners misstates the position the plaintiffs mentioned maintained throughout the proceedings.
- 13:44Michael Mulligan: So the judge says that's wrong.
- 13:47Michael Mulligan: That's not the position that Cowichan Tribes took, that this would not impact private property owners.
- 13:52Michael Mulligan: And so what's going on here?
- 13:53Michael Mulligan: And that's why parsing it is so important.
- 13:56Michael Mulligan: What the judge says is that in the hearing before the other judge, the plaintiff asserted they were not seeking a declaration of invalidity or defectiveness with respect to the fee simple interests of private landowners, not claiming that they were entitled to possession of such land as against the private owners, referencing the paragraph.
- 14:17Michael Mulligan: The plaintiff said this application is left for another day, and only if necessary, the consequences of a declaration of aboriginal title on land held by private own by private landowners in paragraph 15.
- 14:29Michael Mulligan: And so Cowichan Tribes did not take the position that uh granting them uh aboriginal title would not invalidate private property ownership.
- 14:40Michael Mulligan: What their position was, according to the judge, is that well, that's just for another day.
- 14:46Michael Mulligan: They are not making that application to invalidate uh pro or invalidate or find private property ownerships to be defective at this trial.
- 14:55Adam Stirling: Yet.
- 14:56Michael Mulligan: What they are saying yet.
- 14:58Michael Mulligan: What they are saying is we just want Aboriginal title, that will be dealt with if necessary, in a future trial.
- 15:04Adam Stirling: Bingo.
- 15:05Michael Mulligan: Uh and at that future trial, they're saying, well, that's when private property owners can come and make submissions about how their private property ownership should not be invalidated.
- 15:15Michael Mulligan: Yes.
- 15:15Michael Mulligan: But that's not these proceedings, that's the next proceedings.
- 15:19Michael Mulligan: And that's why some of the comments that you played uh from the Premier with respect to the the more recent announcement about uh recognition of Aboriginal title in Vancouver, uh the if you listen carefully to what the premier said, he speaks about in this court case and in this decision, yeah, those things are not at stake.
- 15:42Michael Mulligan: That's probably true, but only if you parse that very finely.
- 15:49Michael Mulligan: And so when you hear the language that your private property is not at stake in this decision, and when the judge finds that yes, that is the consistent position that Cowichan tribes took, and that's what the judge finds, they found that Cowichan tribes submissions throughout the whole proceeding was not that private property was not at stake or that it could not be invalidated uh as a result of the decision.
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: It's just that that would be the next case.
- 16:15Michael Mulligan: And so that is the basis upon which the judge who made the Cowichan Tribes decision found that it was not an abusive process now for Cowage and Tribes to resist the private landowner or resist the private landowner's attempt to reopen the trial so they could participate in it, because they had not said that it would not have it would not impact private property.
- 16:38Michael Mulligan: They just said it wouldn't impact private property right now, exactly in this decision.
- 16:42Michael Mulligan: That's for another day.
- 16:43Michael Mulligan: And so as a result of that, the trial judge has ordered the private property owner to provide Cowichan tribes with this long list of documents so that Cowichan tribes could argue that, hey, you know, if uh, for example, they one of the things on the list here is like any other documents that the province sent to the property owner regarding these proceedings over a 10-year period.
- 17:05Michael Mulligan: And so what they want to argue as well, you know, you were told something about this.
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: Uh you should have realized that Cowichan Tribes was not saying private property wasn't impacted.
- 17:13Michael Mulligan: They were just saying it wasn't impacted right now.
- 17:16Michael Mulligan: In this case, that's for another day as necessary.
- 17:18Michael Mulligan: And so on that basis, uh, you should not be allowed to come on now and try to make new submissions about your property, the impact it had.
- 17:27Michael Mulligan: Too bad.
- 17:28Michael Mulligan: Uh we should be assessing the uh delay in applying to do this from back in whenever, rejecting the argument that hey, this is an abusive process because you said clearly this wouldn't impact private property.
- 17:39Michael Mulligan: So that's the really, really fine distinction.
- 17:42Michael Mulligan: And it's important to listen carefully to exactly what Premier EB is saying when he speaks about in this court case and in this decision, uh, because that's exactly what this application is talking about, and that's how uh the judge who made that decision is uh uh approaching it.
- 18:02Michael Mulligan: Not an abusive process, because they never said uh it wouldn't mean that your property rights would be invalidated, just that that would be decided later.
- 18:10Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's the uh latest sort of the BC Supreme Court on that Cowage and Tribes case that's still bubbling away.
- 18:16Michael Mulligan: Um, and uh that is, I think, just very, very important insight from the trial judge uh explaining exactly what it was that Cowitch and Tribes had to say throughout those all those proceedings.
- 18:28Michael Mulligan: Uh and so when you hear sort of generalized comments about we weren't asking for private property, the full subversion of that would be yet.
- 18:38Michael Mulligan: Yeah, but we can in future might exactly correct.
- 18:42Michael Mulligan: That's exactly it.
- 18:43Michael Mulligan: And so the private property owner would want to say, look, you know, maybe we will have another trial about whether you take our property away or whether our property rights have been invalidated or are found to be defective.
- 18:57Michael Mulligan: But, you know, for example, maybe they have other some other submission to make about the broader issue, you know, the uh uh uh Aboriginal title ought to apply at all or in their particular place or the history of their property ownership or whatever it might be.
- 19:13Michael Mulligan: Um, and they didn't have that opportunity during the trial.
- 19:16Michael Mulligan: And so uh because they weren't given notice, because the court concluded that they shouldn't uh there shouldn't be notice to all of these private property owners.
- 19:24Michael Mulligan: And the other interesting thing about it, of course, this is one property owner, right, who's bringing this application has been ordered to turn over all these potential documents to the uh Cowichan tribe so they can resist the application to reopen.
- 19:39Michael Mulligan: But of course, even if it turns out there was something that you know was mailed to them in 2014 that should have alerted them to the fact that yes, you you may be impacted in this in the next hearing, um, what does that say about all the other private property owners?
- 19:54Michael Mulligan: Exactly.
- 19:55Michael Mulligan: Even if this particular property owner got something in the mail or you know had looked something up or had found something out that should have alerted them to, yeah, you could be in jeopardy down the road, this could be very important to you if that's eventually the basis.
- 20:08Michael Mulligan: If the judge says, no, I'm not reopening it because look, you know, you had something about this in a letter that was sent to you in 2015 or something, what about everyone else?
- 20:17Michael Mulligan: What about the other thousands of people?
- 20:19Michael Mulligan: How does that affect them?
- 20:21Michael Mulligan: And so, really, how this thing plays out does bring into sharp relief that decision about should there have been proper former formal notice provided to all those people uh at an earlier date, and it also provides just a really important lens when you're hearing now comments which are probably true in a in a strict sense, like what the premier is saying now about in this context, in this case, and in this decision, and comments being made by Calithan tribes.
- 20:48Michael Mulligan: Uh, you need to just remember what they're saying may be literally precisely true, uh, but it doesn't provide the whole picture.
- 20:57Michael Mulligan: Uh and that's why this decision is so important because it lays bare exactly what was said and why this was approached in the way it was, uh, right from the uh trial judge herself.
- 21:06Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, thank you so much as always for the benefit of your knowledge and insight in these and other matters.
- 21:10Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour, every Thursday, it's been a pleasure.
- 21:15Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 21:16Adam Stirling: It's always great to be here.
- 21:17Adam Stirling: All right, we'll talk to you next time.
- 21:18Adam Stirling: It's Michael Mulligan.
- 21:18Adam Stirling: We'll take a quick break.
- 21:19Adam Stirling: Who is next?