Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / How Institutions Trade Vertical Credit Spreads
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever looked at options trading and just thought it was
- 0:05essentially gambling with infinite risk?
- 0:07Oh yeah, I mean, that is probably the most pervasive myth
- 0:11in all of finance. Right, because you hear these
- 0:13wild stories online. People blowing up their entire
- 0:17life savings overnight, literally losing more money than
- 0:20they actually put into their accounts in the first place.
- 0:22Exactly. It completely terrifies people.
- 0:25It really does. It can feel like, I don't know,
- 0:27stepping into a casino where the house not only has the
- 0:30mathematical edge, but they can legally take your car and your
- 0:33house if the roulette wheel lands on the wrong color.
- 0:36Yeah, that's a terrifying image. But the reality of how
- 0:39quantitative analysts and, you know, institutional funds
- 0:42actually trade options is, well, it's so fundamentally different
- 0:46from that reckless gambling perception.
- 0:49Which is exactly what we're getting into.
- 0:50Today. We're doing a deep dive into an
- 0:53exhaustive, highly technical research report on a structural
- 0:57strategy known as the Credit Spreads Option Strategy.
- 1:01And it's a fascinating paper. It really pulls back the curt.
- 1:04It totally does. So our mission today for you the
- 1:06listener, is to decode how the pros actually use these specific
- 1:11structures to generate consistent yield with strictly
- 1:14capped risk. Right, Risk management is
- 1:16everything here. It's about engineering risk, not
- 1:19just rolling the dice. Exactly.
- 1:21And we are going to do it by stripping away all the
- 1:23intimidating jargon. OK, let's unpack this.
- 1:26How do we even begin to construct a trade that caps our
- 1:30downside so completely? So it all starts with
- 1:33understanding the basic architecture of what we call a
- 1:36vertical spread. A vertical spread OK.
- 1:37Yeah, when most people think of options, they think of just
- 1:40buying a call or buying a put, or even worse, just selling one
- 1:46naked. Which is where those horror
- 1:48stories usually come from. Exactly, but a credit spread is
- 1:51a multi legged trade. You are simultaneously selling
- 1:54one option and buying another option of the exact same class.
- 1:57Wait, when you say same class you just mean they have to be
- 1:59both puts or both calls. You know you aren't mixing them
- 2:01up. That's right, both puts or both
- 2:03calls, and they also have to be on the exact same underlying
- 2:06asset, like the same stock or ETF, and they must expire on the
- 2:10exact same day. OK, so everything is identical
- 2:14except for one thing, right? The only difference between the
- 2:17two legs of the trade is the strike price.
- 2:20And the keyword in the name of this strategy is credit.
- 2:23So I'm assuming the entire goal of assembling this multi legged
- 2:28structure is to collect a net credit upfront.
- 2:31Like I want cash deposited into my trading account the very
- 2:34moment I click execute. Yes, exactly.
- 2:37And the mechanics of how you get that credit are really important
- 2:39to understand. Walk me through it.
- 2:41Well, you collect cash because the option you are selling is
- 2:44positioned closer to the current stock price than the option you
- 2:46are buying, right? In the options world, an option
- 2:49that is closer to the money holds more premium.
- 2:51It's simply more expensive, so the cash you bring in from
- 2:55selling that short leg is always going to be mathematically
- 2:58larger than the cash you spend to buy the long protective leg.
- 3:02I was actually trying to wrap my head around this concept earlier
- 3:04and it really reminds me of the insurance business.
- 3:07Oh, that's a great way to look at it.
- 3:08Yeah, think about a retail trader selling a naked option,
- 3:12which again is what gets them into so much catastrophic
- 3:15trouble. That is essentially like writing
- 3:18an insurance policy for a coastal town, but with unlimited
- 3:21payout risk. Right, you're just taking on all
- 3:24the rest yourself. Exactly.
- 3:25If a massive hurricane hits, you are personally on the hook to
- 3:29rebuild the entire town. You're completely ruined.
- 3:32It's a terrifying position to be in.
- 3:33I mean, the tail risk is theoretically infinite if the
- 3:36market moves violently against you.
- 3:39But a credit spread that feels like writing the policy,
- 3:43collecting that hefty premium from the town, but then turning
- 3:46around and immediately using a small piece of that premium to
- 3:50buy reinsurance for yourself. Precisely.
- 3:52You're laying off the catastrophic risk.
- 3:54Right. You're buying a policy from a
- 3:55bigger company that says, OK, if the hurricane hits, we cover
- 3:58everything above a certain dollar amount.
- 4:00So if that catastrophic market crash happens, your losses are
- 4:04strictly capped by what is essentially a high deductible.
- 4:08I really like that framing. It totally shifts the mindset
- 4:12from speculator to risk manager. And structurally, you know you
- 4:17can apply this insurance model in two distinct directions.
- 4:20Depending on which way you think the market is going.
- 4:21Exactly, depending on your bias for the market you can use a
- 4:25bull put spread which is what you deploy when you want the
- 4:28stock to go up or at least just stay flat.
- 4:31And the other side of that. Conversely, there's the bear
- 4:33call spread. You use that when you believe a
- 4:35stock is going to go down, or if you think it's going to hit a
- 4:38strong ceiling of resistance and just stall out.
- 4:40Let's make this incredibly concrete, because the math
- 4:43underlying this is really elegant, but it can get muddy
- 4:47for people without real numbers. Let's walk through an example of
- 4:50a bull put spread. Let's invent A hypothetical
- 4:53stock. We'll call it XYZ.
- 4:56Perfect, let's do it. So let's assume stock XYZ is
- 4:59currently trading at exactly $70 per share.
- 5:02OK, 70 bucks. And you've done your analysis
- 5:05and you hold a moderately bullish assumption.
- 5:07You don't necessarily need it to shoot the moon, you just
- 5:10strongly believe the stock is going to stay above a certain
- 5:12floor over the next few weeks. Right, I just need it to not
- 5:15crash. Exactly.
- 5:17So you execute a bull put spread by selling the $68.50 strike
- 5:22put. OK, so I'm agreeing to buy the
- 5:23stock at 6850 if it drops that low and for taking on that
- 5:27obligation the market pays me. Let's say I collect a premium of
- 5:32$2.00 per share. Right.
- 5:34But we know we aren't stopping there.
- 5:35No way, because selling that put alone leaves you with that
- 5:38hurricane risk. We just.
- 5:39Talked about exactly. I don't want to wake up in a
- 5:42cold sweat. So simultaneously in the exact
- 5:46same order ticket, I buy the $65 strike put.
- 5:50That is my reinsurance, my safety net.
- 5:52Right. And let's say that protective
- 5:54put cost you $0.50. OK, so let's look at the net
- 5:56result here. I brought in $2.00 but I spent
- 5:59$0.50 to cap my risk. So your net credit is $1.50 per
- 6:04share? And since standard U.S.
- 6:06Equity option contracts represent 100 shares.
- 6:09That is $150.00 deposited directly into my account the
- 6:14second the trade goes through. Exactly.
- 6:16And that $150.00 is your absolute maximum theoretical
- 6:20profit. You keep every single penny of
- 6:23it. If stock XYZ simply closes
- 6:26anywhere above 6850 at expiration, the stock could go
- 6:30to 80, or it could just sit at 71.
- 6:33It really doesn't matter. Both options would just expire
- 6:36totally worthless and I walk away with the premium.
- 6:38You got it. That sounds great when it works,
- 6:41but I mean, what if my analysis is dead wrong?
- 6:45What if the CEO resigns unexpectedly, the broader market
- 6:48totally tanks, and XYZ drops like a stone to $62.00?
- 6:53This is where the architecture of the spread saves you.
- 6:56If you had just sold that naked put at 6850 and the stock
- 7:00dropped to 62 you would be losing $6.50 per share so.
- 7:04That's $650 per contract. Right, and the losses could keep
- 7:08piling up if it kept dropping. But with a credit spread, your
- 7:11risk is strictly defined by the width of your spread.
- 7:14Let me make sure I'm doing the math right on that width.
- 7:17My short strike was 6850. My long protective strike was 65
- 7:22S The width between them is $3.50.
- 7:25Exactly $3.50 per share is the absolute maximum the trade can
- 7:30expand to, but remember you already collected $1.50 in
- 7:34credit upfront. Right, so I take the 350 width,
- 7:38subtract the 1:50 I already hold in cash.
- 7:41That leaves me with a maximum loss of exactly $2.00 per share,
- 7:45or $200 total per contract. The bleeding completely stops at
- 7:49your $65 long strike. You risk $200 to make $150.00.
- 7:55OK, so I know exactly what my worst case scenario.
- 7:57Is exactly and your breaking point.
- 7:59The exact price where you make 0 but lose 0 is $67.
- 8:04Even if the company goes bankrupt and the stock goes to
- 8:07absolute zero, you cannot lose a single penny more than that
- 8:10$200. That is the power of defined
- 8:12risk. It actually lets you sleep at
- 8:14night. It really does.
- 8:15But having a safe structure is only step one.
- 8:18Now we need to explore the unseen mathematical forces that
- 8:22actually dictate if this trade wins or loses as time moves
- 8:26forward. If you've ever looked at an
- 8:28options chain, you've probably seen these weird symbols at the
- 8:32top of the columns, the Greeks. Yeah, the Greeks, they can be
- 8:36deeply intimidating because they are quite literally the
- 8:39differential equations that govern option pricing models.
- 8:42Which sounds terrifying. It does.
- 8:44But here's the secret. If you are going to trade credit
- 8:47spreads, you don't need a PhD in calculus.
- 8:50You just need to understand how they react to underlying price
- 8:53changes to time and to volatility.
- 8:56OK, so where do we start? The foundational Greek you have
- 8:58to grasp first is Delta. My understanding of delta has
- 9:01always been that it measures how much an option's price changes
- 9:05for every $1.00 move in the underlying stock.
- 9:08So like a delta of .5 means the option moves $0.50 for every
- 9:12dollar the stock moves. That's the textbook definition,
- 9:15yeah, the. Quantitative traders use it a
- 9:16bit differently, don't they? They use it as a proxy for
- 9:19probability. They do, and it's a vital
- 9:21shortcut. While mathematically delta is
- 9:24not a pure probability metric, standard market practice
- 9:27universally relies on it as an exceptionally robust heuristic
- 9:31for selecting your strikes. So how does that apply to
- 9:34building our spread? Well, the research outlines a
- 9:36major structural sweet spot for selling credit spreads.
- 9:40Quantitative funds systematically target short
- 9:42strikes at the 15 or 16 delta level.
- 9:45And what does the 16 delta actually translate to in the
- 9:48real world for a trader? It statistically translates to
- 9:51roughly an 85% probability of profit. 85%.
- 9:55Yeah, it means the market is pricing in an 85% mathematical
- 9:59probability that the option will expire completely out of the
- 10:03money. That is a wildly high win.
- 10:05Rate it is. It strikes the optimal balance.
- 10:07You get a high historical win rate, but you are still close
- 10:10enough to the money to collect enough premium to outpace your
- 10:13expected occasional losses. So if you go too far out.
- 10:15If you go too far out, you might win 99% of the time, but you
- 10:19collect literal pennies and one single loss wipes out years of
- 10:23gains. Right.
- 10:24OK. So we have a high probability
- 10:26directional bet, but here's where it gets really interesting
- 10:29because with a credit spread, we aren't just betting on
- 10:32direction, we are simultaneously betting on volatility.
- 10:36And this brings us to Vega. Vega is often the hidden driver
- 10:40of profit that retail traders completely miss.
- 10:43How so? Well, credit spreads are
- 10:46inherently net short implied volatility.
- 10:49Because you're short option is closer to the current stock
- 10:51price, it naturally carries a higher Vega than you're further
- 10:55out long option. Meaning my overall position is
- 10:58sensitive to how much fear or uncertainty is in the market.
- 11:01Precisely Implied volatility is just the market's expectation of
- 11:05future turbulence. This means you actively want to
- 11:07execute these trades when market volatility is elevated.
- 11:10Like when everyone is panicking. Exactly.
- 11:12Think about the day right before a major earnings announcement or
- 11:16during a sudden geopolitical crisis.
- 11:19In those moments, option premiums are heavily inflated
- 11:22because everyone is buying insurance.
- 11:24Right. So you want to step in and act
- 11:25as the insurance company when premiums are at their absolute
- 11:28highest. Because you are positioning
- 11:29yourself to profit from what's called a volatility crush.
- 11:32A volatility crush. Yeah.
- 11:34The moment that earnings report drops or the crisis this
- 11:36stabilizes, the uncertainty just vanishes.
- 11:40The expected volatility suddenly drops.
- 11:42When that happens, the extrinsic value of the entire spread
- 11:46collapses. So the price of the options just
- 11:48deflates like a balloon. Yes, you could be sitting on a
- 11:52substantial unrealized profit just days after opening the
- 11:56trade, even if the stock price itself hasn't moved a single
- 11:59inch, simply because the fear left the market and the premiums
- 12:02deflated. That's incredible.
- 12:04You're literally getting paid because people stopped
- 12:06panicking. It's a great feeling.
- 12:09And the other massive wind at our back is Theta, right?
- 12:12Theta represents time decay. Yeah.
- 12:14And time is well, it's like a melting ice cube for options.
- 12:18Every single day that passes, the spread loses extrinsic
- 12:21value, which is perfect when you're the one who sold it.
- 12:24Theta is the steady, relentless engine of a credit spread.
- 12:28The short option you sold decays more rapidly than the further
- 12:31out of the money long option you bought.
- 12:32That differential steadily shrinks the overall value of the
- 12:35spread, and since you want to buy it back later for cheaper
- 12:38than you sold it, that decays exactly what you want.
- 12:41Wait, I have to push back here because if time Theta is always
- 12:44working in my favor, I mean, if every tick of the clock makes me
- 12:47money, why wouldn't I just hold the trade until the absolute
- 12:51last second of expiration date? Why not squeeze out every single
- 12:54penny of that premium I collected?
- 12:55It is the most logical question to ask, and honestly, it is the
- 12:59exact behavioral trap that routinely destroys amateur
- 13:02traders. Really.
- 13:03Yes, the answer is our final Greek gamma.
- 13:07Gamma is the rate of change of delta and as expiration rapidly
- 13:11approaches, especially in the final week, the gamma of near
- 13:14the money options increases exponentially.
- 13:16Whoa, OK, exponentially increasing gamma sounds like a
- 13:20phrase a physics professor uses right before an explosion.
- 13:23Keep it simple for me. Why does the last week of the
- 13:26last day matter so much? What does that actually mean for
- 13:29My Portfolio? It means the math gets violent
- 13:32in the final days of a trade. If the stock price even slightly
- 13:36challenges your short strike, the delta of your position will
- 13:39swing wildly. So the probability jumps around.
- 13:42Right, an option that had a low probability of being in the
- 13:45money can suddenly jump to a high probability with just a
- 13:48tiny fluctuation in the stock price that causes massive
- 13:52terrifying swings in the real time monetary value of your
- 13:55spread. So holding a credit spread to
- 13:57the very last day fundamentally alters the strategy?
- 14:01You're telling me it transitions from a slow mathematical time
- 14:05driven income trade into a highly leveraged coin flip
- 14:09binary bet governed almost entirely by gamma risk?
- 14:12That is exactly what happens. You are risking massive
- 14:14unrealized gains just to squeeze out the last $0.10 of premium.
- 14:18Wow, turning a high probability math equation into a slot
- 14:21machine just for a few extra Dimes?
- 14:23That's a terrible trade off. It really is.
- 14:25And since Gamma makes that expiration week so dangerous,
- 14:28the research points out something fascinating The
- 14:31specific asset you are trading dictates exactly how dangerous
- 14:35it can get. If the math is sound, the real
- 14:38world must have hidden traps, right?
- 14:41Which brings us to the actual market mechanics of settlement.
- 14:43Yeah, settlement is where traders experience the most
- 14:46devastating surprises because not all options settle the same
- 14:49way. You have to understand the
- 14:51fundamental difference between physical settlement, which we
- 14:53see with standard equities and ETFs like the SPY, and cash
- 14:57settlement, which is used for index options like the SPX.
- 15:00OK, let's start with the dangerous one.
- 15:02Physical settlement SPY options which track the S&P 500 are
- 15:06American style. I was on an option just expired
- 15:09on a Friday. But American style means they
- 15:11can actually be exercised at any time, right?
- 15:13And they settle in actual physical shares of the ETF.
- 15:17They do, and this introduces non linear risks that completely
- 15:20bypass your beautifully defined risk parameters.
- 15:23You mean examples? Well, for example, there's the
- 15:25dividend trap. If you have a short call spread
- 15:28on a dividend paying stock or ETF F and an ex dividend date is
- 15:32approaching the person who bought that option from you
- 15:35might choose to exercise it early just to steal the dividend
- 15:38payout. Wait, if they exercise my short
- 15:40leg early, what happens to me? You instantly get assigned a
- 15:44short stock position and worse, you now have an explicit
- 15:47obligation to pay that dividend out of your own pocket to the
- 15:50lender of the shares. Oh wow, it turns a theoretical
- 15:54paper loss into cold hard cash missing from your account.
- 15:58Exactly. But as bad as that is, the
- 16:00absolute nightmare scenario outlined in the research is
- 16:03something called pin risk. Walk me through this.
- 16:06What exactly happens to me if my physically settled SPY trade
- 16:10gets pinned right between my 2 strikes on a Friday afternoon at
- 16:13the closing bell? OK, let's paint the grim
- 16:15picture. It's Friday at 4:00.
- 16:16Tomorrow PM, the closing bell rings.
- 16:19Your ETF closes exactly between your short strike and your long
- 16:22strike. So right in the middle.
- 16:23Yeah, because it's American style and physically settled.
- 16:26Your short leg expires in the money, but your protective long
- 16:30leg, your safety net that we paid for, expires completely
- 16:34worthless. So over the weekend, the
- 16:37clearinghouse automatically assigns you on that short leg.
- 16:40So on Saturday morning I checked my brokerage app.
- 16:43What do I see? You see that you are now holding
- 16:45a massive, totally unhedged physical stock position.
- 16:49Your protective put is gone. It expired.
- 16:52You are just holding raw shares. And if some massive
- 16:55macroeconomic news breaks over the weekend, maybe a central
- 16:59bank unexpectedly hikes rates, or there's a geopolitical
- 17:01conflict and the market gaps down violently at Monday's open.
- 17:05You are fully exposed to the theoretical infinite downside of
- 17:09holding those shares. That gap down happens before you
- 17:11can even hit the sell button on Monday morning.
- 17:14It completely obliterates the defined risk architecture we
- 17:16just spent all this time building.
- 17:17That is absolutely terrifying. You go into the weekend thinking
- 17:21your risk is capped at 200 bucks and you wake up on Monday
- 17:24morning on the hook for 10s of thousands of dollars of stock
- 17:27depreciation. So what is the institutional
- 17:31solution to this? They can't possibly just accept
- 17:33that risk. Oh they don't.
- 17:34The solution is trading cash settled European style index
- 17:38options for the major funds. That's the SPX.
- 17:42For retail traders, it's the XSP, which is the mini SPX that
- 17:45is scaled down to a tenth of the size.
- 17:47Because they are European style, they can only be exercised at
- 17:50expiration, so no early exercise means no dividend traps.
- 17:54Correct, and far more importantly because they are
- 17:57cash settled, no physical shares ever change hands.
- 18:00Wait. Really, none at all.
- 18:02None. If your XSP trade gets pinned
- 18:04between the strikes at expiration on Friday, there is
- 18:07no weekend assignment of shares. The clearinghouse simply
- 18:10calculates the exact mathematical monetary difference
- 18:13between the closing price and your strike.
- 18:16They debit that cash from your account and the position just
- 18:18vanishes. Poof into the ether.
- 18:21Exactly, you hold 0 residual market exposure moving into the
- 18:25next trading session. There is no weekend gap risk
- 18:28whatsoever. These PM settled XSP options
- 18:31establish their final cash value precisely at 4.0 PM Eastern,
- 18:37giving you total clarity and safety.
- 18:39OK, so knowing how to survive the trade by dodging pin risk is
- 18:43half the battle. But to truly trade like a
- 18:45quantitative fund, we need to look under the hood at the
- 18:48regulatory plumbing and the tax codes that give institutions
- 18:51their real edge. How do they actually manage
- 18:54these trades day-to-day? This is where rigorous back
- 18:56testing and systematic management completely replace
- 18:59emotion. The research analyzed massive
- 19:01data sets from algorithmic platforms, simulating millions
- 19:04of credit spread trades to find the optimal management rules.
- 19:07And the data totally destroys the idea of set it and forget
- 19:10it, doesn't it? Completely the highest risk
- 19:12adjusted returns were achieved not by holding to expiration,
- 19:16but by systematically taking profits at 50% of the maximum
- 19:19credit and employing A strict 50% stop loss.
- 19:22Let me put real to that. If I collect $100 in premium
- 19:25upfront, I have a resting order to close the trade the moment
- 19:28I'm up 50 bucks. But I also cut my losses and
- 19:31exit the moment I'm down 50 bucks.
- 19:33Yes, and the sharp ratio on that is incredible. 0.83 By doing
- 19:39this you drastically reduce your time in the market, which
- 19:42inherently lowers your exposure to Black Swan events.
- 19:45Makes sense. You completely eliminate that
- 19:47terrifying gamma tail risk we discussed because you are never
- 19:50holding into the final days and mathematically it deeply smooths
- 19:53out your equity curve. But the regulators are watching
- 19:57how aggressive these strategies are getting, especially with
- 20:00zero data expiration options. I was reading about some major
- 20:042026 amendments to Funeral Rule 4210.
- 20:08And I couldn't believe it. Oh, it's a massive paradigm
- 20:10shift for active traders. Historically, if you Bay trade
- 20:13it, you were flagged as a patterned day trader and forced
- 20:17to hold $25,000 in your account to participate.
- 20:19Right, the old PDT rule. That old rule is fundamentally
- 20:22gone. Replaced by something much
- 20:23stricter. Yes, FI and RAW has implemented
- 20:26A modernized real time intraday margin standard.
- 20:30Brokers must now actively monitor accounts for intraday
- 20:34margin deficits minute by minute.
- 20:36Wow, minute by minute. Yeah, if you are a trader
- 20:39aggressively managing 0 days to expiration credit spreads, you
- 20:43can't over leverage your account and hide between overnight
- 20:46settlement periods anymore. The brokers algorithms will
- 20:49either block the trade in real time or hit you with an
- 20:52immediate margin call before the closing bell.
- 20:54Which brings up a fascinating point about the margin
- 20:56algorithms themselves. The SIBO exchange requires
- 21:00algorithms to group different option legs together to figure
- 21:03out your total margin requirement.
- 21:04It's called combinatorial optimization.
- 21:06It sounds incredibly dense, but it's crucial for capital
- 21:09efficiency. If a fund has hundreds of
- 21:12overlapping option legs, the clearinghouse relies on the
- 21:14broker's algorithm to pair them up into recognized risk defined
- 21:18strategies like credit spreads to calculate how much margin
- 21:21they need to hold. I was trying to visualize this
- 21:23and it feels like packing the trunk of a car for a long road
- 21:26trip. I love this analogy.
- 21:27So older greedy algorithms are like clumsily throwing the first
- 21:31bag. You see it in the truck.
- 21:32Sure, it gets in there and you technically meet the requirement
- 21:35to pack the car, but you waste a ton of space.
- 21:37But the advanced linear programming solvers the
- 21:40institutions use, they Mac out the entire complex geometry of
- 21:44your portfolio. They pack the trunk perfectly,
- 21:47recognizing every single multi leg hedge to absolute millimeter
- 21:51precision. That is a brilliant way to
- 21:53visualize it, and the real world impact of packing that trunk
- 21:57efficiently is staggering. According to the institutional
- 22:00stress tests in the research, optimizing that combinatorial
- 22:03math saves large funds up to $500 million in and required
- 22:08margin. Half a billion dollars.
- 22:10Exactly. That frees up half a billion
- 22:12dollars to deploy elsewhere. That capital efficiency is why
- 22:15institutions dominate, but they amplify that edge even further
- 22:19through the tax code. We have to talk about IRS
- 22:21Section 1256. The Magic 6040 rule If you trade
- 22:25options on a standard ETF like SPY, your profits are typically
- 22:29taxed as short term capital gains at your highest ordinary
- 22:32income tax rate. It's a massive drag on
- 22:34compounding your wealth. Nobody likes it.
- 22:36Right, but if you trade broad based cash settled index options
- 22:41like SPX or XSP, they are statutorily classified as
- 22:44section 1256 contracts. And what does that
- 22:47classification actually do for my tax bill?
- 22:50It means that regardless of how long you hold the trade, even if
- 22:53you open and closed it in 5 minutes, 60% of your gain is
- 22:57automatically taxed at the highly favorable long term
- 22:59capital gains rate. Only 40% is taxed short term.
- 23:03That is wild. Just by changing the ticker
- 23:06symbol from SPY to SPX you get a massive structural tax break.
- 23:10Oh, it gets even better when you consider accounting.
- 23:12Have you ever dealt with the wash sale rule?
- 23:14Oh yeah, that's when you take a loss on a stock, but you buy it
- 23:18back within 30 days and the IRS says Nope, you can't deduct that
- 23:21loss yet. It's an absolute accounting
- 23:23nightmare. Well, section 1256 contracts
- 23:26utilize mark to market accounting at year end.
- 23:28This means the IRS treats your entire portfolio as if you sold
- 23:32everything at the closing price on the very last day of the
- 23:35year. So they just draw a line in the
- 23:36sand. Yes, the slate is mathematically
- 23:39wiped clean because of this. Individual trades throughout the
- 23:42year aren't tracked for wash sales.
- 23:44They are entirely exempt. An aggressive quant can rapidly
- 23:47close and reenter SPX credit spreads dynamically all year
- 23:51long without ever triggering those restrictive tax accounting
- 23:54penalties. That is an insane advantage, so
- 23:57let's look at the big picture of what we've covered today.
- 23:59We started with this scary concept of options being
- 24:01unlimited risk gambling, but we learned how to architect a
- 24:05vertical spread to strictly cap our downside.
- 24:08Using reinsurance, we found the mathematical sweet spot of
- 24:11probability using delta. We learned to use time and
- 24:14volatility to our advantage. We dodged the nightmare weekend
- 24:18PIN risk by using cash settled index options, and we optimized
- 24:21our management rules and our taxes.
- 24:23We truly moved from idea of gambling to engineered
- 24:26structural finance. We really did.
- 24:29But before we go, I want to leave the listener with one
- 24:31final mind bending thought that builds on everything we just
- 24:34discussed. So we know how to cap risk, but
- 24:37is there a way to eliminate market risk entirely?
- 24:40The research points to something called the box spread.
- 24:43How does this work? The box spread.
- 24:46This is where options transcend standard trading and become a
- 24:49literal corporate finance loophole.
- 24:52Imagine combining a bull call spread and a bear put spread at
- 24:55the exact same strike prices. Wait, if I.
- 24:57Have a bullish spread and a bear spread simultaneously?
- 25:01Doesn't one just win and the other lose?
- 25:03Don't think you 0 each other out.
- 25:04By locking those two together, you perfectly offset all
- 25:07directional market risk. It doesn't matter if the stock
- 25:10goes to the moon or goes completely bankrupt, the
- 25:12settlement value at expiration is 100% guaranteed and
- 25:16mathematically predetermined. So why do it if the payout is
- 25:19just flat? Because since the payout is
- 25:21guaranteed, institutions use what's called a short box to
- 25:24synthesize a fixed term loan. They aren't betting on stocks at
- 25:28all. They sell the box spread today
- 25:31to collect a massive influx of cash upfront, and they legally
- 25:35commit to repaying a fixed, slightly larger amount at
- 25:38expiration. Oh my God they are basically
- 25:40securing cash loans straight through the options clearing
- 25:43house. Exactly.
- 25:44They completely bypassed traditional banks, often at
- 25:48interest rates far cheaper than their own brokers margin rates.
- 25:51That is unbelievable. It is the exact same caps risk
- 25:55math of the credit spread, just applied non directionally to
- 25:58manipulate the time value of money itself.
- 26:00So the next time someone tells you that options trading is just
- 26:02reckless gambling, remember the box spread.
- 26:05Remember that the smartest players in the room aren't
- 26:07pulling slot machine levers. They are engineering synthetic
- 26:10loans, legally manipulating the tax code, and capping their
- 26:14risks down to the absolute penny.
- 26:16Well said. The whole different game.
- 26:19Thanks for joining us for this deep dive, and we'll see you
- 26:21next time.