Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Beryl Disrupts Dealers, Personalized Pricing Woes, Target Ditches Paper Checks
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning, it is, what's the today? Tuesday, July 9th. And it's a special day because it's July 9th. I don't know why that is.
- 0:08But today we're talking about the hurricane remnants, personalized pricing, and Target ditching. [rap music] I'm not even gonna tell you what the last story is. Just do it. I don't wanna reveal it yet.
- 0:17It's a happy story. Unless it's in the title when you're watching the live stream- Oh... and then we're in trouble anyway. Yeah. [laughs] You know. They already saw it.
- 0:24I feel like saying good morning to the retail auto industry today. Good- Doesn't it feel good? I, I like that. It does feel just like a good morning. I don't know, the energy yesterday, I had
- 0:36three chats with three different dealers, and the detail at which- [laughs]... they're looking at their operations is- Intense... kind of staggering. Like, it is,
- 0:50it is this, like, meticulous look at every element is what I'm not- Mm-hmm... noticing. Um, and, and that's really cool 'cause you don't typically get that in, in a July. And I know it's anecdotal- Mm-hmm...
- 1:04but that's like, for, for me, for that to be a July and, uh, like, typically summer is just wide open, anything goes, and then you kinda refactor- Yeah... in the fall. Yeah, that's- And- That, you're right... you know?
- 1:19That is not the temperature out there right now. No, no. It is meticulous defining of- I also think there's, like-... like, what do you do?... another word, another word that goes with meticulous, is sophisticated. Hm.
- 1:30I think over the last three years our look at the industry and the business has gotten so much more sophisticated. Some of that is technology.
- 1:37A lot of that is what happened during COVID where we really started to get meticulous and sophisticated- Yep... about all the little things. And if we're gonna keep profits going, right, I think that switched, right?
- 1:48The COVID mindset shift happened, and everyone was like, "We can make how much?" [laughs] Right? Yep. And then no one likes- Right... to go back.
- 1:54So it's like it, it breeds invention, which is super fun to watch and be a part of. It really, really is. Right. Yep. And it's, this is gonna be the, the, the ones who are doing that are separating from the pack, man.
- 2:06Did I say- Absolutely... just say Pac-Man? Did I say those two words together? You said Pac-Man. [laughs] There it is. Uh, we released a new Auto Collabs episode yesterday. It's another podcast that we have longer form.
- 2:15Kyle and I get together with Michael Cirillo and we interview, uh, some of, some really cool people in the industry, and we talk a little bit of personal history, uh, we talk a little bit of, like, real time data analytics.
- 2:25This one was with Keisha Batts of Upstart, where we were talking about AI financing and, and how, like, these companies, speaking of sophisticated, are leveraging AI in the finance world.
- 2:35Gives us a little peek into what we think AI finance is gonna look like in three to five years from now. So super relevant to everyone who, you know, sells something that's financed, so couple of people in the audience.
- 2:45That's a couple, two, three people. [laughs] Yep. Uh, we're, we're traveling next week. We're, we're on the road a little bit. We're traveling a little deeper.
- 2:51We're, they've got the, we got the annual charity event we love. Obviously, we've done the More Than Cars with, uh, the store, with Mr. Beaver and Patrick, uh, Abad there, and the whole team, so we're excited about that.
- 3:03We're also excited about, if, if you got our daily email today, we're gonna be, uh, judging the Automotive Amplifiers contest, uh, with Reynolds in August.
- 3:12And submission, the submission deadline is, I think, the end of this month for what you're doing in your store, uh, that we get to judge whether or not it has that, like, More Than Cars m- mentality around it. Yes.
- 3:25So, uh, if you don't get the- Bonus points for More Than Cars mentality... you know, jump in there and, uh, yeah. Oh, absolutely And, and if, and, and people may say, like, "Well, why do I wanna do this?"
- 3:32Number one, obviously open-handed wins in this industry, so there's an opportunity for you to- Yeah... to be open-handed about some of the things you're doing, sharing with the other people.
- 3:40Also, you get an all expense paid trip. Your flight- Oh... hotel, golf. Uh, Reynolds is gonna donate $5,000 to the charity of your choice if you win.
- 3:50So I think they, I think they did it right as far as, like, this is another little incentive.
- 3:54It's, like, you're not winning a cash prize, but as an industry, $5,000 goes to something you're passionate about, maybe in your local community or your home. So I mean- I'm all in now... it's a pretty good RI.
- 4:04And we'll hang out. Yeah. We'll, we'll hang out. You'll come and we'll hang out. We get to hang out. [laughs] Yeah. Right. Uh, all right, let's talk about some news. Uh, definitely some struggle going on right now.
- 4:13Uh, Hurricane Beryl's arrival as a category one storm brought a lot of severe weather throughout southeast Texas yesterday, um, but specifically the Houston area, affecting a number of local dealerships.
- 4:24They caused temporary closures for, get this, seven CarMax stores and one of CarMax's vehicle auctions. CarMax spokesperson says, you know, "We temporarily closed everything to ensure everyone's safety."
- 4:37Ben Keating, owner of Keating Auto Group, says, "Problems are the mother of invention," as he expressed some- Hey...
- 4:42optimism despite the disruptions his stores experienced, including, um, one of his buildings got damaged, a number of his cars were damaged, but, uh, you know what? We love that, that More Than Cars mindset.
- 4:53And he's like, "Hey" Yeah. "Problem's coming in" Hey, it's an opportunity.
- 4:56Uh, Penske also has pretty large presence in southeast Texas, however, uh, they're, they don't have stores in Houston, but some of their other stores a little bit further south remained open, so, you know, still, still selling, servicing out there.
- 5:09High winds, torrential rains, you know the whole deal. As of last night, there were still 2 million people without... Two million, no, 2 million homes and businesses. That's more than 2 million people. That's wild. Yep.
- 5:21Yeah. I mean, l- uh, one, I feel it for the, the southeast Texas. It's, like- Exactly... ever since, I don't know, 2014 or whatever, they've just continually kinda been pegged, um, across the Gulf there.
- 5:35Uh, also, h- I mean, Beryl, like 78-year-old grandma, is definitely- Never heard that name in my life... bearing down your neck as a category- [laughs] Never heard that in my life... category one storm.
- 5:46Uh, yeah, thankfully it was a category one.
- 5:48Obviously never fun to be in a storm, but nothing like, uh, some of the historical, you know, windfall and, and, and flooding that they've had in that area, so- But the power, man- I mean- It's hot...
- 5:58we, it's, it's tough, uh, being without power, you know? Yep. A- and, you know, you got some CDK dealers that, just coming back online- Oh, my gosh... just to go offline again. Whoop. Didn't think about that.
- 6:08BuddyAnd think about that. Hey, but for- Elites is not as of yesterday, by the way Hey. Forgot to talk about that. I, I... Dude, it is amazing how quickly that story just drops off the face of the planet.
- 6:20That echo just, whoop, gonezo. You're like, "It's back up. All right." [laughs] But- Selling cars... but any dealer- Don't worry about it... any dealer who's in the middle of that, like, we text them back and forth.
- 6:27They're like, "Man, I gotta, I gotta go." [laughs] Like, "I can't text" They're still in it... "I gotta catch up."
- 6:31And so, uh, you know, our thoughts and prayers out to those in Houston, especially anybody being significantly affected, affected.
- 6:37If you are a store and you are open and you do have air conditioning, you have an opportunity to serve the community. So, I think this is where, this is where dealers can, can shine pretty bright.
- 6:47And, uh, if you need any help, if you have anything you want, uh, everyone else to know, news, something like that, just let us know. We'll get it out there. Crew, C-R-E-W, @asotu.com. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 6:58All right, this next story is not technically... Usually, the last story's usually the non-automotive story. It's a retail story. But we have two of those today. I saw this story this morning.
- 7:07I was like, "We have to talk about this." Here it is. It's personalized pricing, a doorway to a place nobody wants to go. Mm.
- 7:14So, personalized pricing driven by AI is becoming more prevalent, allowing retailers to set prices based on individual characteristics and behaviors, AKA- Yeah... how much money can I get out of you for this?
- 7:27Personalized pricing sounds so friendly. Not so much. So, retailers are using AI to exploit personal data, adjusting prices basis, based on factors like age, mood- Wow... even battery life of your phone.
- 7:39Nicholas Guggenberger, assistant professor at, uh, University of Houston Law Center, back, back to Houston, argues that personalized pricing can lead to significant biases and inflation, often targeting the most vulnerable.
- 7:52Um, and said, he said algorithmic price discrimination can basically automate usury. It's a practice that is legal in the US as long as it doesn't, um, discriminate based on protected characteristics.
- 8:04Uh, companies like Amazon and Uber have been accusing, accused of using tactics like this. For example, Uber allegedly adjusts ride prices based on a user's phone battery level.
- 8:16Basically, if your phone battery's low, they know you're more likely to pay whatever it takes to get that car there fast so you don't risk being stranded. Uh- Wow...
- 8:25since the proof is kind of siloed in our pockets, like, on our screens, it's very hard to track, because it's like, the price it shows me could be a different price than what it's showing to you two people down the line there waiting for the Uber ride at the airport.
- 8:40Man, the, the, the, the tr- the, like, insight of I'm willing to pay anything to get where I wanna go- Gosh... fast, and j- It's not even fast... I don't know.
- 8:50It's, but they were talking about, like, airline upgrade seats. They were talking about, like, you know, saying even- I mean-... like, Amazon adjust prices two and a half million times a day, right? Yeah.
- 9:00So how much of that is, like- Well, they do... surge pricing? How much of that is, like, based on what they know I've paid? They were saying, like, 'cause all the data, you know what it's like.
- 9:09People know what I've paid for items elsewhere. Exactly. Cross-app tracking. Oh, man. Yep. I- I mean, I- Auto industry could never get away with this. Let me just say that right now.
- 9:18If someone found out dealers were doing this, there would be a congre- congressional hearing. But, okay. But that happens already, right? As a negotiation. As a negotiation. Right, but there's the ability to negotiate.
- 9:36There's, there's like, right, like, there's, there's like this thing. And, and I've, I've really wrestled with this one. Like, as I read the article, I'm like, I was like, well, free market capitalism, right?
- 9:46Like, something's worth what someone's willing to pay. Exactly. So- That's what I think. And, and so it's like, I don't feel, it just doesn't feel good. It doesn't feel good.
- 9:55Like, if I know- But did it feel good before you knew about it? You were fine with it. Dude, that's all of life. Nobody got mad about it. [laughs] That's all of life. I was happy with my muscles till I saw that guy's.
- 10:05[laughs] I don't know. I think, I think it's, I think it's pretty neat, and I think it's an opportunity for profitability, and I think it's, uh, you know, as long as...
- 10:15The, uh, I think the scary point, part for me is how deeply it goes into personal data- Mm-hmm... shopping behaviors, things like mood, battery life, all that type of stuff.
- 10:23Um, but, but adjusting pricing basing on shopping behavior, right? Yeah. I, I think that that is completely reasonable and, uh, you know, it, it allows for market demand and it's a benefit of e-com.
- 10:36I mean, I, like, o- one thing I know is that a ton of marketing automation out there when it comes to e-com, like, uh, drip emails and things like that- Mm-hmm...
- 10:46there are people studying retention as, uh, an opportunity to either hire, uh, raise or lower prices based on a t- a, a person's retention timeline, right?
- 10:58So it, it, it's all, uh, you know, it, it's all up for grabs in my opinion. It's so- We'll see. It's so gray. So gray. It's, it's so gray because, like, sometimes I'm like, "Yeah, that seems fair."
- 11:08Sometimes I'm like, "Ah, that feels terrible." I think one of the, the biggest challenges, like, what they would do to, you know, an example, they, they cited in the article, right?
- 11:17Typically, how they would keep groups of people from being exploited, for instance, uh, your low income areas, grocery stores.
- 11:24You could go see what things cost here and what s- things cost four miles away and be like, "Oh, are you exploiting the fact that there's lack of transportation to get to that one?" Sure, sure.
- 11:34So, but that was easy to track. This is a little bit different.
- 11:37And I was thinking, like, I, my mind kept, like, processing through, like, what if I go to the grocery store and I'm ordering on the app, and all of a sudden my milk is 5.25 a gallon and the other guy's is 3.80 a gallon?
- 11:49That's such, such a small dollar amount, but it's like, should my grocery bill be 20% higher because, like, I'm willing to pay it and I'm not going to, like... It's like, ah.I mean, it's tough.
- 12:01Like, I- yo, I was at Lowe's two weekends ago buying a power tool, and that thing was $50 more in store than online. I pull up my app, I'm like, "Why is this $50 more or- Yep... less on the app?"
- 12:14They're like, "We don't really know, but we actually can't discount it here in store."
- 12:18And I said, "So what you're telling me is if I go right here, click buy, and pick up in store, I can take this one right here- [laughs]... because you can scan it?" And they were like, "Absolutely."
- 12:27[laughs] I hit the, I hit the buy. Done. They scanned it. They said, "Great, you picked it up", and I walked out with the one that I could have scanned and been out three minutes earlier, so. Yeah.
- 12:35Man, retail has opportunities everywhere. It's not just auto. There are definitely opportunities everywhere. Oh, I need a segue for this one. Speaking of retail opportunities.
- 12:44[upbeat music] Or I, I guess- It's about time... opportunities to grow in your patience. [laughs] Target is now eliminating what we're calling a character- [laughs]...
- 12:52a character-building moment in many of us, as we've had to endure, uh, uh, something that nobody ever wants to endure.
- 12:59[laughs] Target has now ac- uh, said that they will no longer accept personal checks starting July 15th, 2024. So you're not gonna get stuck behind a check writer. [laughs] Uh, they cited low usage- This took so long...
- 13:13as the primary reason for discontinuing it, with only 3% of purchases made this way in 2023. Um, obviously they've, they have said, like, "Look, there's a bunch of other ways you can pay.
- 13:24If you're used to paying with checks, you just gotta get used to the cash or the credit card or the digital wallet".
- 13:29Um, and, uh, the decision aligns with the broader trend of declining check usage noted by the Federal Reserve. Mm-hmm. Um, interestingly enough, personal checks are more prone to fraud and errors.
- 13:43Uh, so that 3%- That makes sense, too... potentially has fraud. You know, you get written errors. Maybe someone- I still catch them if you can... miswrites something. Yeah. Yeah. No. [laughs] Yeah. Yeah,
- 13:53no, checks and- checks are, are really kind of this, this strange enigma to Gen Z, right? Oh. Uh, let me ask you this question. How many, how many paper checks have you written in the last year? One. Case in point. Yeah.
- 14:08Case in point. Yeah. I get so annoyed when someone hands me a check. And I had to fight to find those jokers. Right, right. [laughs] It's...
- 14:13And so, like, if, for, for those of you in Gen Z, like, you used to go to the shop- [laughs]... and you would, like, size up the person at the front of the grocery line. We're back to the grocery store today. Right.
- 14:23And we're like, "Who looks like they're about to pull a check?" And if, you know, old Aunt Beryl, right, is up there in the front [laughs] she pulls out- Old Aunt Beryl...
- 14:31that checkbook, puts it out, and you're like, "No". Now- No, don't do it... my kids act the same way if someone pulls out cash. They're like, "Ah, God." Oh, that's the worst. It's like, "We got a cash payer".
- 14:40[laughs] I almost can't even... You know, you get someone that needs a chip card, you know. Yeah. It's like, "Ah, they didn't have tap today" Get my phone out. I can't even... I gotta get my wallet out and go old school.
- 14:49No, I mean, this, I can't believe it took so long to do this. This is obviously gonna start a little, a little train, I think, of people saying, "It's okay.
- 14:56The grocery store will probably be the last place to go", right? They'll be the last paper check thing to go. I'm like- For sure... what do they even do with that?
- 15:02Just think of the processing involved, and, like, you had the cashier take a piece of paper check, and they have to do something with it, pass it to somebody, and someone has to process that, and then they have to deposit it, and they have to make sure the money gets in the account.
- 15:13Like, what a mess. Yep. What a mess. You know, this is interesting actually, uh, you know, uh, as it comes to dealers. [laughs] Dealers still obviously- Right?
- 15:21A lot of paper checks, and dealers are probably benchmarks one of the highest industries for using paper checks But here's what's interesting is, like, uh, you know, if a dealer has a Stripe account and has bank, you know, because the biggest thing with checks is, like, you don't have to worry about, uh, the cost of the dep- you know- Yeah, 3%...
- 15:40of the actual card every month or the 3%. Um, but if you use a Stripe account require only ACH or bank, someone can actually connect their bank account through their Stripe account or ins- in- initiate a direct wire.
- 15:51Um, and so you basically pay, like, less than 1%- There you go... or 1% on that charge. So that's an opportunity to just reduce fraud and increase the speed of cash in account. There you go. So, good point there.
- 16:02Did you know that banks, banks used to charge for depositing cash? Yeah. You know? Like, that's, I don't know. So, I mean, we have credit card fees now. What you just said is probably the cheapest way to take money.
- 16:14Cashier's check. That's true. Cheapest way to take it, probably. It's free- There you go... to take, not free to get. I don't know. [upbeat music] There you go.
- 16:21We hope we got you thinking about being meticulous and precise about your business. It's a good season to be in. Look, we're making all the little changes, serving the people. Get out there, serve some people.
- 16:32We'll see you here tomorrow. [upbeat music]