Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Jobs, Inflation and the Economy
Transcript
- 0:02♪ ♪
- 0:11GOOD EVENING WELCOME TO KENTUCKY
- 0:12TONIGHT I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:13THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR JOINING
- 0:14US.
- 0:15OUR TOPIC, JOBS, INFLATION AND
- 0:17THE ECONOMY.
- 0:18AMERICA IS STILL DEALING WITH
- 0:21INFLATION THOUGH IT'S NOT AS BAD
- 0:22AS IT WAS IN THE SUMMER OF 2022
- 0:23WHEN IT TOPPED 9%.
- 0:25IT WAS DOWN TO 4 BEHRS IN MAY--
- 0:284% IN MAY.
- 0:29THAT MEANS YOU ARE PAYING 4%
- 0:30MORE ON AVERAGE FOR GOODS AND
- 0:32SERVICES THAN YOU DID A YEAR
- 0:35AGO.
- 0:35THE FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD DID
- 0:36NOT RAISE THE KEY INTEREST RATE
- 0:38TWO WEEKS AGO BUT SIGNALED IT
- 0:40COULD RIZ RATES IN THE FUTURE
- 0:41AND THERE IS STILL CONCERN ABOUT
- 0:42THE POSSIBILITY OF A RECESSION.
- 0:45SO TO DISCUSS ALL THIS AND MORE,
- 0:46WE ARE JOINED IN LEXINGTON BY
- 0:48ASHLI WATTS OF THE KENTUCKY
- 0:49CHAMBER OF COMMERCE, THE
- 0:50PRESIDENT AND C.E.O., JASON
- 0:53BAILEY, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
- 0:54THE KENTUCKY CENTER FOR ECONOMIC
- 0:55POLICY, JOHN GAREN, AN ECONOMICS
- 0:58PROFESSOR AT THE UNIVERSITY OF
- 1:00KENTUCKY GATTON COLLEGE OF
- 1:01BUSINESS AND ECONOMICS AND CHRIS
- 1:03PHILLIPS, AN ECONOMICS PROFESSOR
- 1:05WITH SOMERSET COMMUNITY COLLEGE.
- 1:06WELCOME TO ALL OF OUR GUESTS.
- 1:08THIS AFTERNOON, WE ARE TAPING
- 1:10EARLY, WE ADMIT THAT RIGHT AT
- 1:11THE FRONT, THAT WE ARE TAPING
- 1:12THIS PROGRAM ON WEDNESDAY,
- 1:15JUNE 21.
- 1:15AND SO WE WELCOME OUR GUESTS.
- 1:17WE WELCOME YOU THE VIEWERS AT
- 1:18HOME.
- 1:18WE WILL STILL HAVE A ROBUST
- 1:20DISCUSSION AND LET'S GET
- 1:21STARTED.
- 1:21LET'S LOOK AT THE STATE ECONOMIC
- 1:23PICTURE.
- 1:24WE KNOW THAT IN MID JUNE, IT WAS
- 1:25REPORTED THE STATE IS STILL ON
- 1:27TRACK FOR ANOTHER BILLION-DOLLAR
- 1:29SURPLUS BY THE END OF THIS
- 1:30FISCAL YEAR.
- 1:31THAT IS VASTLY APPROACHING
- 1:36JUNE 30.
- 1:36DIRECTOR JOHN HICKS SAID THE
- 1:37INCOME TAX REVENUE FELL BY
- 1:39$148 MILLION BECAUSE OF THE
- 1:40INCOME TAX CUTS THAT WENT INTO
- 1:42EFFECT.
- 1:42SALES TAXES WERE UP BY
- 1:45$40 MILLION.
- 1:46KENTUCKY CHAMBER WAS VERY
- 1:49INVOLVED IN PERSUADING LAWMAKERS
- 1:51TO REDUCE THE STATE INCOME TAX,
- 1:54GRADUALLY PHASING THAT OUT TO 0
- 1:55OVER THE COMING YEARS.
- 1:56WHAT DO YOU TAKE AWAY FROM THESE
- 1:58NUMBERS?
- 1:58DO YOU THINK THAT'S A VERY
- 1:59POSITIVE PICTURE OF WHERE
- 2:00KENTUCKY IS HEADED?
- 2:01>> WE DO.
- 2:02AND I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO
- 2:03REMEMBER THAT WHEN WE PASS THE
- 2:05TAX BILL A COUPLE YEARS AGO,
- 2:06HOUSE BILL 8, IT WAS INTENDED TO
- 2:08PHASE OUT THE INCOME TAX.
- 2:10NO SURPRISE THOSE INCOME TAX
- 2:12REVENUES WILL START DIMINISHING.
- 2:13WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE BUDGET.
- 2:15I THINK THE IMPORTANT THING TO
- 2:16NOTE IS THAT THE MAY RECEIPTS
- 2:19WERE $430 MILLION.
- 2:20THIS IS STILL HIGHER THAN
- 2:23PRE-PANDEMIC, BEFORE THAT BILL
- 2:24WAS PASSED.
- 2:24IF YOU LOOK BACK IN MAY OF 2019,
- 2:27THOSE INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX
- 2:28RECEIPTS WERE ABOUT
- 2:29$300 MILLION.
- 2:30SO EVEN THOUGH THEY HAVE
- 2:31DROPPED, THEY'RE STILL
- 2:33SIGNIFICANTLY MORE THAN WAS
- 2:34PRE-PANDEMIC.
- 2:35AND I THINK LOOKING AT IT NOW,
- 2:36NOW THAT WE ARE MOVING TOWARD A
- 2:384% INCOME TAX WHERE A COUPLE
- 2:39YEARS AGO WE WERE AT 6%, YOU
- 2:41KNOW, THE GOAL OBVIOUSLY UNDER
- 2:44HOUSE BILL 8 IS TO GET TO 0%
- 2:46THROUGH VERY RESPONSIBLE
- 2:47TRIGGERS, TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
- 2:48ARE MEETING OUR GOALS, THAT OUR
- 2:49BUDGET IS GOING TO BE WHOLE.
- 2:51WE ARE GOING TO BE ABLE TO HAVE
- 2:52THE EDUCATION AND THE ROADS AND
- 2:53BRIDGES AND EVERYTHING THAT THE
- 2:54BUDGET, YOU KNOW, NEEDS TO
- 2:56SUPPLY.
- 2:56BUT MAKE SURE WE CAN CONTINUE TO
- 2:58LOWER THE INCOME TAX.
- 2:59SO IT SHOULD REALLY NOT SHOCK
- 3:01NOR SCARE ANYONE THAT THOSE
- 3:02NUMBERS ARE GOING DOWN.
- 3:04WHAT IS ALSO PROMISING IS THOSE
- 3:06SALES RECEIPT TAXES ARE GOING
- 3:07UP.
- 3:08AND SO THAT'S REALLY MOVING
- 3:09TOWARD THAT CONSUMPTION-BASED
- 3:11TAX SYSTEM WHICH IS WHAT THE
- 3:13LEGISLATURES LINED OUT IN HOUSE
- 3:15BILL 8.
- 3:15IT'S REALLY GOING VERY MUCH
- 3:16ACCORDING TO PLAN.
- 3:18>> Renee: SO JASON BAILEY, I
- 3:19KNOW THERE IS A DIFFERENT
- 3:21INTERPRETATION THAT KENTUCKY
- 3:22CENTER FOR POLICY HAS AND HAVE
- 3:25WRITTEN ON YOUR WEB WEBSITE AND
- 3:27TALK ABOUT HOW THE INDIVIDUAL
- 3:28INCOME TAX IS THE LARGEST
- 3:30REVENUE SOURCE FOR KENTUCKY,
- 3:31PAYS FOR OVER 40% OF THE STATE
- 3:33BUDGET.
- 3:33DO YOU THINK THAT THERE ARE DIRE
- 3:35DAYS AHEAD IF KENTUCKY CONTINUES
- 3:37DOWN THIS ROAD IF.
- 3:38>> THIS THEY CONTINUE DOWN THE
- 3:40ROAD EVENTUALLY ELIMINATING THE
- 3:42INCOME TAX, YOU ARE TALKING
- 3:42ABOUT NEARLY HALF OF THE STATE
- 3:44BUDGET THAT PAYS FOR OUR
- 3:45SCHOOLS, OUR HOSPITALS, OUR
- 3:47INFRASTRUCTURE.
- 3:47THE OTHER THINGS THAT EVERY
- 3:48KENTUCKIAN RELIES.
- 3:49YOU CANNOT GET RID OF THE KEY
- 3:54CORNERSTONE SOURCE OF FUNDING
- 3:55AND PAY FOR THE THINGS THAT YOU
- 3:56RELY ON.
- 3:56WE ARE ALREADY SEEING A DROP.
- 3:58WE HAVE ONLY SEEN A HALF POINT
- 4:00CUT IN THE RATE.
- 4:01WE ARE SEEING A BIG DROP IN
- 4:02INCOME TAX RECEIPTS AND THAT'S
- 4:04AT THE SAME TIME THAT THE
- 4:05ECONOMY, THE UNDERLYING ECONOMY,
- 4:07NATIONAL ECONOMY IS VERY HOT.
- 4:09I MEAN UNEMPLOYMENT IS AT A
- 4:11RECORD LOW, INFLATION IS HIGHER
- 4:12THAN IT HAS BEEN IN 40 YEARS.
- 4:14THOSE THINGS PUSH UP RECEIPTS
- 4:15BUT WE ARE SEEING INCOME TAX
- 4:17RECEIPTS DECLINE.
- 4:18SO THAT'S THE FIRST GLIMPSE OF
- 4:20FUTURE TROUBLE.
- 4:20WE ARE GOING TO SEE ANOTHER CUT
- 4:23JANUARY 1 THAT'S BEEN PASSED BY
- 4:25THE LEGISLATURE, HOUSE BILL 1.
- 4:26WE ARE GOING TO HAVE A TOTAL OF
- 4:2920% REDUCTION IN OUR LARGEST
- 4:30REVENUE SOURCE.
- 4:31AND WE WILL FIND OUT IN THE FALL
- 4:33WHETHER THEY WILL CONSIDER
- 4:35ANOTHER CUT THE FOLLOWING YEAR.
- 4:37SO, YOU KNOW, THIS IS, WHAT THE
- 4:39LEGISLATURE HAS DONE IS CREATE A
- 4:41SITUATION WHERE WE HAVE SOME
- 4:43UNIQUE EXTRA REVENUES, I GUESS,
- 4:46BECAUSE OF THE PANDEMIC AID, THE
- 4:47STIMULUS THAT WAS ROYED
- 4:50PROVIDED.
- 4:51EVERY STATE, NEARLY EVERY STATE
- 4:52IS EXPERIENCING THESE LARGE
- 4:54REVENUES BUT THEY'RE TEMPORARY.
- 4:55LEGISLATURE IS USING A TEMPORARY
- 4:57OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE PERMANENT
- 4:59TAX CUTS FOR ALL TIME AND
- 5:02DIMINISHING THE SOURCE THAT'S
- 5:03BEEN WITH US ALMOST 100 YEARS.
- 5:06WITHOUT A PLAN AND WITHOUT ANY
- 5:08VIABLE OPTIONS TO REPLACE THE
- 5:09REVENUE THAT WE LOST.
- 5:10IT'S A VERY DANGEROUS PATH.
- 5:12IT'S ONE NO STATE HAS EVER DONE
- 5:16WITH THE EXCEPTION OF ALASKA AND
- 5:17THEY GOT RID OF THEIR INCOME TAX
- 5:18AFTER THEY STRUCK OIL ON THE
- 5:21BAY.
- 5:21WE HAVE NOT STRUCK OIL IN
- 5:23KENTUCKY AND WON'T BE DOING
- 5:26THAT.
- 5:26SO THERE HAS TO BE A PLAN AND
- 5:28THERE IS NOT.
- 5:30AND SO SORT SHORT OF THAT, WE
- 5:33HAVE TO PROTECT-- I'M HOPING AS
- 5:34EARLY AS THE NEXT SESSION, WE
- 5:36WILL PUT A HALT TO THIS EFFORT.
- 5:38>> Renee: WE KNOW THE REPUBLICAN
- 5:39CONTROLLED LEGISLATURE THAT HAS
- 5:40EXPANDED IN ITS SUPER MAJORITY
- 5:43SINCE HOUSE BILL 8 EVEN WAS
- 5:45FIRST INSTITUTED, WE DON'T THINK
- 5:46THEY WILL REVERSE COURSE.
- 5:47THEY SEEM TO BE PRETTY
- 5:49STEADFAST.
- 5:50>> THEY DID CREATE RULES ABOUT A
- 5:51TRIGGER AND WE DON'T KNOW IF THE
- 5:53TRIGGER WILL BE MET.
- 5:55>> Renee: THAT'S RIGHT.
- 5:56>> THERE ARE TWO PARTS TO THE
- 5:57TRIGGER AND ONE OF THEM MAY NOT
- 5:58BE MET THIS YEAR SO TO THEN CUT
- 6:00ANYWAY, I THINK, WOULD BE THE TO
- 6:03MOVE THE GOAL POST THEY ALREADY
- 6:05SET.
- 6:05>> Renee: I THINK CHAIRMAN PETRI
- 6:07MENTIONED BEFORE AND OTHERS,
- 6:08CHRIS McDANIEL, THAT THE
- 6:10TRIGGERS ARE THERE FOR A REASON,
- 6:12RIGHT?
- 6:12THOSE ECONOMIC CONDITIONS HAVE
- 6:13TO BE MET BEFORE YOU PULL THE
- 6:16TRIGGER.
- 6:17QUOTE UNQUOTE.
- 6:18>> AND WE KNOW THAT UNEMPLOYMENT
- 6:19RATE IS VERY LOW RIGHT NOW BUT
- 6:21THE FEDERAL RESERVE IS
- 6:22PREDICTING A HIGHER UNEMPLOYMENT
- 6:23RATE.
- 6:23THEY'RE PREDICTING UNEMPLOYMENT
- 6:24RATE THAT WOULD MEAN 1.3 MILLION
- 6:26AMERICANS LOSE THEIR JOB IN THE
- 6:27NEXT YEAR OR SO.
- 6:29THAT'S GOING TO HIT OUR ECONOMY
- 6:32AND AT THE SAME TIME THAT WE ARE
- 6:33CUTTING TAXES, WHEN WE ARE
- 6:35CREATING A NEW TWO-YEAR BUDGET,
- 6:36IT'S GOING TO BE A PROBLEM.
- 6:37>> I WOULD ALSO SAY A
- 6:39BILLION-DOLLAR SURPLUS IS HARDLY
- 6:40A CRISIS.
- 6:41IF YOU THINK ABOUT THIS AND
- 6:42JASON WAS TALKING ABOUT THE AID
- 6:44THAT CAME THROUGH DURING THE
- 6:45PANDEMIC.
- 6:46AND YES, EVERY STATE HAS
- 6:47EXPERIENCED THIS.
- 6:47BUT OUR NUMBERS TODAY ARE STILL
- 6:49HIGHER THAN THEY WERE
- 6:51PRE-PANDEMIC BEFORE ANY OF THAT
- 6:52AID CAME IN.
- 6:53AND SO I THINK WE NEED TO LOOK
- 6:55AT THAT AS WELL.
- 6:56AND THAT'S THE BEAUTY ABOUT
- 6:57HOUSE BILL 8 AND TRIGGERS THAT
- 7:00OTHERS LIKE NORTH CAROLINA HAVE
- 7:02USED, WE CAN EVALUATE IT.
- 7:03MAKE SURE OUR BUDGET IS HEALTHY,
- 7:04WE HAVE A HEALTHY RESERVE TRUST
- 7:06FUND BEFORE WE LOWER THE INCOME
- 7:07TAX.
- 7:08I THINK RIGHT NOW A
- 7:08BILLION-DOLLAR SURPLUS IS A
- 7:09PRETTY GOOD THING TO HAVE.
- 7:10SO WE'LL SEE WHAT HAPPENS THE
- 7:12REST OF THE YEAR.
- 7:13BUT I WOULD EXPECT TO HOPEFULLY
- 7:14CONTINUE TO LOWER THE INCOME TAX
- 7:16ANOTHER HALF PERCENT.
- 7:17>> Renee: I WANT TO GO TO YOU
- 7:20PROFESSOR GAREN BECAUSE ONE OF
- 7:22THE THINGS THAT WAS WRITTEN IS
- 7:23THE COST OF THE STATE WILL RISE
- 7:25FROM AN ESTIMATED $292 MILLION
- 7:27THIS FISCAL YEAR TO 1.28 BILLION
- 7:30IN THE YEAR 2025.
- 7:31THAT'S OR MORE THAN KENTUCKY
- 7:33SPENDS ON ALL UNIVERSITIES AND
- 7:35COMMUNITY COLLEGES COMBINED.
- 7:36YOU ARE AT THE UNIVERSITY OF
- 7:37KENTUCKY.
- 7:38I'M JUST CURIOUS.
- 7:39ARE YOU CONCERNED?
- 7:40I KNOW YOU SUPPORT PERHAPS THESE
- 7:42INCOME TAX REDUCTIONS BUT ARE
- 7:43YOU CONCERNED, AS SOMEONE WHO
- 7:45WORKS FOR A PUBLICLY FUNDED
- 7:47INSTITUTION, THAT IT COULD BE IN
- 7:48JEOPARDY DOWN THE ROAD BEYOND
- 7:502025?
- 7:51>> WELL, I'M RETIRED NOW.
- 7:52SO...
- 7:53[LAUGHTER]
- 7:55>> Renee: SO NO WORRIES, RIGHT?
- 7:57>> BUT TO ANSWER THE QUESTION IN
- 7:58A MORE SERIOUS WAY, I THINK THE
- 8:00KEY IS THE REVENUE TRILLINGERS,
- 8:03RIGHT-- TRIGGERS?
- 8:04I THINK THE GOAL IS TO HAVE
- 8:06REVENUE INCREASES WITHOUT, YOU
- 8:08KNOW, THIS REDUCED INCOME TAX.
- 8:10AND ONCE YOU HAVE ATTAINED THAT,
- 8:12I MEAN PROBLEM SOLVED, RIGHT?
- 8:16AS LONG AS YOU MAKE THE TRIGGERS
- 8:18AND IF YOU DON'T, THEN YOU DON'T
- 8:20HAVE TO GO THROUGH WITH THE CUT.
- 8:22SO I DON'T THINK THERE IS-- YOU
- 8:25KNOW, AS LONG AS THE LEGISLATURE
- 8:27WILL HOLD TO THAT, I DON'T SEE
- 8:29THE CONCERN.
- 8:29>> Renee: ARE YOU CONCERNED,
- 8:31Mr. BAILEY THAT THE
- 8:32LEGISLATURE WON'T HOLD TO THE
- 8:33TRIGGERS BUT THAT'S STATUTORY
- 8:35LANGUAGE THOUGH.
- 8:35>> THE TRIGGERS IS BASED ON HOW
- 8:36MUCH REVENUE YOU HAVE IN ONE
- 8:38YEAR AND MAKES A PERMANENT CUT.
- 8:40SO IT'S NOT THAT YOU SUSTAIN THE
- 8:42REVENUE OAF TIME.
- 8:43IT'S JUST THAT IN ONE YEAR YOU
- 8:44HAVE IT.
- 8:44THIS IS A VERY UNIQUE TIME IN
- 8:46OUR HISTORY.
- 8:47TO HAVE UNEMPLOYMENT THIS LOW
- 8:49AND INFLATION THIS HIGH?
- 8:50IT HASN'T BEEN THIS WAY IF 50
- 8:51YEARS.
- 8:52SO IF YOU LOOK BACK, YOU KNOW,
- 8:53DURING THE GREAT RECESSION, THE
- 8:55PERIOD, YOU KNOW, NOT THAT LONG
- 8:57AGO, WHEN UNEMPLOYMENT WAS AT 6,
- 9:007, 8, 10% AND IF WE HAD AN
- 9:02INCOME TAX RATE AT 4%, IT WOULD
- 9:04HAVE BEEN MASSIVE-- WE HAD BIG
- 9:06CUTS ANYWAY.
- 9:06BUT MASSIVE, MASSIVE CUTS.
- 9:08SO THE TRIGGERS ARE NOT-- THERE
- 9:10IS NO WAY TO GET BACK, CLAW BACK
- 9:13THE TAX CUT IF IT TURNS OUT THAT
- 9:15WE GET A RECESSION.
- 9:17AND WE WILL HIT A RECESSION.
- 9:19IT'S A QUESTION OF WHEN, NOT A
- 9:21QUESTION OF IF.
- 9:22>> Renee: I WANT TO GET TO YOUR
- 9:23THOUGHTS ON THIS ABOUT THE STATE
- 9:24ACTIONS, PROFESSOR PHILLIPS.
- 9:26AND DO YOU BELIEVE THAT A
- 9:27RECESSION IS INEVITABLE AND HOW
- 9:29DEEP COULD IT BE?
- 9:30>> IN TERMS OF THE STATE
- 9:31ACTIONS, I'LL AGREE WITH
- 9:33PROFESSOR GAREN THAT THE
- 9:35TRIGGERS ARE WHAT MAKES THE PLAN
- 9:37WORK.
- 9:38AS LONG AS THEY'RE ADHERED TO.
- 9:39AND THEN I THINK BACK PRE-COVID
- 9:42TO KANSAS, I SIGH SIMILARITIES
- 9:44THERE.
- 9:44THEY MADE DRAMATIC STRUCTURAL
- 9:46CHANGES TO THEIR FISCAL HOUSE,
- 9:48NOT EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED TO
- 9:49KENTUCKY BUT SIMILAR.
- 9:50HAD TO GO BACK AND RESTRUCTURE
- 9:52THOSE BECAUSE OF THOSE BIG, BIG
- 9:54SHORTFALLS.
- 9:54AND THE STATE, IF THERE WERE
- 9:55GOING TO BE BIG SHORTFALLS WOULD
- 9:57HAVE TO REVISIT IT, GO BACK,
- 9:58RESTRUCTURE THINGS COMPLETELY.
- 9:59NOW IT REALLY JUST DEPENDS ON
- 10:01HOW IT WORKS OUT.
- 10:03>> Renee: AND KANSAS DID HAVE
- 10:04THE TRIGGERS THE FIRST GO
- 10:06AROUND.
- 10:06>> THEY HAD TO STEP BACK AND DO
- 10:07IT ON THEIR OWN BECAUSE THEY
- 10:08WERE FORCED TO.
- 10:09BUT THE TRIGGERS IS WHAT MAKES
- 10:10THE PLAN WORK AS LONG AS THEY'LL
- 10:13ADHERE TO THOSE.
- 10:14NOW NO TERMS OF A RECESSION, WE
- 10:15HAVE BEEN HEARING FOR WHAT, 18
- 10:18MONTHS, RECESSION, RECESSION.
- 10:20I THINK ECONOMISTS WIDELY AGREE,
- 10:21WE DON'T KNOW IF A RECESSION IS
- 10:23GOING TO OCCUR.
- 10:25IT'S GOING TO OCCUR EVENTUALLY.
- 10:27WE DON'T KNOW WHEN IT IS GOING
- 10:28OCCUR.
- 10:29IF YOU LOOK AT SOMETHING LIKE
- 10:30THE YIELD CURVE, WHICH HAS
- 10:32MATURITY RATES FOR SHORT-TERM
- 10:33BILLS BEING LOWER THAN LONGER
- 10:35TERM BILLS, IT HAS BEEN INVERTED
- 10:37THE PAST FEW MONTHS.
- 10:38THAT'S ABOUT ALWAYS BEEN A
- 10:40SIGNAL OF A RECESSION.
- 10:41IT SEEMS LIKE THOSE SIGNALS ARE
- 10:43OUT THERE FLASHING.
- 10:44GROWTH HAS BEEN RUNNING ABOUT 2%
- 10:45FOR THE PAST SIX MONTHS.
- 10:46AND THE FORECAST FOR THE NEXT
- 10:48SIX MONTHS IS ABOUT 2%.
- 10:50RECORD LOW UNEMPLOYMENT AS WAS
- 10:52JUST MENTIONED, 3.7%.
- 10:54IT DOESN'T LOOK LIKE A RECESSION
- 10:56IT DOESN'T FEEL LIKE A RECESSION
- 10:58IT FEELS LIKE AN OVERHEATED
- 11:00ECONOMY IF WE SEE THE
- 11:01UNEMPLOYMENT RATE REALLY
- 11:04SPIEBING SPIKING UP 5, 6, 7%.
- 11:06IT DOESN'T SEEM LIKE THAT'S
- 11:07ANYTHING THAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN
- 11:09IN THE NEAR FUTURE.
- 11:10>> Renee: WE HAVE HEARD SOME
- 11:11ECONOMISTS SAY YOU WANT
- 11:12UNEMPLOYMENT TO SPIKE UP A
- 11:13LITTLE BIT.
- 11:13>> THIS IS THE FED'S BALANCING
- 11:17ACT.
- 11:17THEY HAVE BEEN RAISING RATES.
- 11:19THEY DIDN'T AT THE BEGINNING A
- 11:20FEW DAYS AGO BUT THEY HAVE BEEN
- 11:22RAISING RATES, RAISING RATES,
- 11:24HOPING TO TAMP DOWN AGGREGATE
- 11:25DEMAND, SLOW THE ECONOMY, SLOW
- 11:27BORROWING AND YES, BRING
- 11:28UNEMPLOYMENT FROM THE 3.7 MAYBE
- 11:31SOMEWHERE IN THE 4.5 TO 5% RANGE
- 11:34AND GET THE INFLATION RANGE BACK
- 11:37TO 2%.
- 11:38>> Renee: THOSE LOOKING FOR A
- 11:39JOB DOESN'T SOUND LIKE A
- 11:40PROMISING TRAJECTORY.
- 11:41>> IT'S ALWAYS A TRADE-OFF F. WE
- 11:43GO BACK TO COVID AND WE LOOK AT
- 11:45THE $3 TRILLION PRESIDENT TRUMP
- 11:47THREW AT COVID, THE $3 TRILLION
- 11:49THAT PRESIDENT BIDEN THREW AT
- 11:51COVID, THAT'S $6 TRILLION AND WE
- 11:52DID THAT BECAUSE WE WERE AFRAID
- 11:54OF THE ONGOING DEEP DEPRESSION,
- 11:55ESSENTIALLY.
- 11:56UNEMPLOYMENT WAS AT 15%.
- 11:57WE WERE AFRAID IT MIGHT GO
- 11:59HIGHER, AND SO THERE IS
- 12:01ESSENTIALLY A TRADE-OFF.
- 12:02WHAT WE HAVE TODAY IS ULTRALOW
- 12:04EMPLOYMENT, THE MOST JOBS IN THE
- 12:05RECORD OF AMERICAN HISTORY,
- 12:08161 MILLION, BUT WE DO HAVE 4%
- 12:10INFLATION WHICH IS HIGHER THAN
- 12:11WE LIKE BUT NOT THE 9% AS YOU
- 12:13MENTIONED WE WERE GOING THROUGH
- 12:14LAST YEAR.
- 12:15>> INFLATION IS COMING DOWN, AS
- 12:16YOU MENTIONED AGAIN, IT WAS 9% A
- 12:19YEAR AGO, DOWN TO 4% NOW.
- 12:22IT'S GOING DOWN WITHOUT THE
- 12:23UNEMPLOYMENT RATE GOING UP AT
- 12:25ALL.
- 12:25SO THE THEORY IS THAT IN RAISING
- 12:27INTEREST RATES, THAT YOU ARE
- 12:28GOING TO WEAKEN THE ECONOMY, LAY
- 12:30PEOPLE OFF AND STOP A POTENTIAL
- 12:34SPIRAL OF INFLATION.
- 12:35BUT WE DON'T HAVE THAT.
- 12:36THIS IS NOT A TRADITIONAL
- 12:40INFLATION SITUATION, THEORY,
- 12:42WHERE THE ECONOMY IS
- 12:44OVERHEATING.
- 12:44WHAT WE HAVE HAD IS THE SHOCK OF
- 12:45A PANDEMIC AND A WAR THAT THEN
- 12:47HAD RIPPLE EFFECTS THROUGHOUT
- 12:49THE ECONOMY, THAT TEMPORARILY
- 12:51INCREASED INFLATION.
- 12:51BUT THAT INFLATION IS COMING
- 12:53DOWN WITHOUT RAISING
- 12:55UNEMPLOYMENT.
- 12:56>> Renee: PEOPLE WILL SAY I'M
- 12:57STILL SPENDING MORE THAN $3 AND
- 12:59SOMETHING ON GAS.
- 13:00MORE THAN DOUBLE FOR MILK AND
- 13:01EGGS.
- 13:02I DON'T SEE WHERE THE INFLATION
- 13:03NUMBERS ARE GOING DOWN.
- 13:04THAT'S WHAT THE AVERAGE CONSUMER
- 13:05IS SAYING.
- 13:06>> REMEMBER WHEN WE PAID $5 FOR
- 13:08GAS A YEAR AGO.
- 13:09SO IT IS COMING DOWN.
- 13:10IT IS COMING DOWN SLOWLY.
- 13:12BUT THE QUESTION IS INFLATION
- 13:15HURTS.
- 13:16BUT IT SORT OF SHIFTS MONEY FROM
- 13:17SOME PEOPLE TO OTHER PEOPLE.
- 13:18IF YOU OWN A MORTGAGE, INFLATION
- 13:21ACTUALLY HELPS, IT MAKES YOUR
- 13:22DEBT SMALLER.
- 13:23IF YOU HAVE A STUDENT LOAN DEBT.
- 13:27UNEMPLOYMENT, A LOT OF
- 13:29UNEMPLOYMENT HURTS EVERYBODY.
- 13:30NOT JUST THE PEOPLE WHO LOSE
- 13:32THEIR JOBS, IT HURTS THE MOST
- 13:33AND THAT'S DISPROPORTIONATELY
- 13:35PEOPLE OF COLOR, LOW INCOME
- 13:37PEOPLE, THOSE WITH LESS
- 13:38EDUCATION.
- 13:39BUT IT HURTS ALL WORKERS IF WE
- 13:40HAVE HIGH EMPLOYMENT BECAUSE
- 13:42WAGES STAGNATE AND THAT'S WHAT
- 13:43HAS HAPPENED FOR MOST OF THE
- 13:45LAST FEW DECADES.
- 13:46UNEMPLOYMENT HAS HAS BEEN
- 13:48ALLOWED TO BE TOO HIGH AND
- 13:49THAT'S THE REASON THAT WAGES
- 13:51HAVE BEEN STUCK FOR SO MANY
- 13:52PEOPLE.
- 13:52>>
- 13:52>> Renee: I WANT TO HAVE A
- 13:53CONVERSATION HERE IN A MINUTE
- 13:55ABOUT WAGE GROWTH OR LACK OF
- 13:56WAGE GROWTH.
- 13:57BUT I WANT TO GO BACK TO WHAT
- 13:58THE STATE HAS BEEN DOING AND YOU
- 13:59MENTIONED, Ms. WATTS AND MAYBE
- 14:03I DID, ABOUT HOW THE SALES TAXES
- 14:05HAVE GONE UP AND WE KNOW THAT
- 14:07PART OF HOUSE BILL 8 AND THE
- 14:10YEAR 2022, CAN I NEVER GET THE
- 14:11YEARS RIGHT.
- 14:12HELP ME OUT IF I MISSPEAK.
- 14:14THEY DID EXPAND THE BREADTH OF
- 14:17THE SERVICES THAT COULD BE
- 14:19TAXED.
- 14:19>> BROADENING THE BASE.
- 14:21>> Renee: BROADENING THE BASE IS
- 14:22WHAT LIKES TO BE SAID, TO
- 14:23PARKING, MOVING COSTS, MARKETING
- 14:25SERVICES WERE A PART OF THAT BUT
- 14:26THEN THEY CLAWED THAT BACK IN
- 14:28THE RECENT GENERAL ASSEMBLY.
- 14:29TAXI CABS, THINGS THAT PEOPLE
- 14:31USE EVERY DAY.
- 14:33AND SO WHAT DOES THE CHAMBER
- 14:36HERE-- AND WE KNOW YOU REPRESENT
- 14:38SMALL AND LARGE BUSINESSES BUT
- 14:39THEY'RE ALSO CONSUMERS.
- 14:40>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 14:41IT'S ONE OF THE THUNKS THAT
- 14:42PROBABLY A THEME FOR TONIGHT
- 14:43COULD BE IT'S COMPLICATED.
- 14:44A THE LOVE THESE THINGS ARE
- 14:47COMPLICATED.
- 14:47VERY UNUSUAL SITUATION.
- 14:49JASON MENTIONED WAGE GROWTH BUT
- 14:50HERE IN KENTUCKY WAGES HAVE
- 14:52RISEN 6% YEAR OVER YEAR.
- 14:55THERE IS WAGE GROWTH IN KENTUCKY
- 14:57BUT THE TWEAKS MADE WITH TAX
- 14:58REFORM, TAX REFORM IS
- 15:00COMPLICATED.
- 15:00I HAVE BEEN WORKING IN AND
- 15:02AROUND FRANKFORT FOR 20 YEARS.
- 15:03WE HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT IT
- 15:05FOR 20 YEARS.
- 15:05EVERYONE IS FOR TAX REFORM BUT
- 15:09EVERYBODY'S VERSION IS
- 15:10DIFFERENT.
- 15:11JASON'S IS DIFFERENT THAN MINE
- 15:12I'M SURE.
- 15:13EVERY TIME WE TAKE A BITE OF THE
- 15:15APPLE, THINGS HAVE TO BE TWEAKED
- 15:16AND THAT'S WHAT HAPPENS WITH THE
- 15:19LEGISLATE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS
- 15:20THEN HOUSE BILL 8 WAS PASSED AND
- 15:21HOUSE BILL 1 THAT LOWERED THE
- 15:23INCOME TAX AND TOWARD THE END OF
- 15:25SESSION, SOME THINGS WERE
- 15:26CORRECTED WHERE THERE WAS SOME
- 15:27EXPANSION OF TAXES ON SOME
- 15:28SERVICES.
- 15:29SOME OF THOSE WERE ROLLED BACK
- 15:30AND I REALLY THINK THIS IS JUST
- 15:31GOING TO BECOME WHAT WE ARE
- 15:33GOING TO BE DOING WITH TAX
- 15:35REFORM IS ALWAYS KEEPING OUR
- 15:36FINGER, YOU KNOW, ON THE PULSE
- 15:37OF IT TO MAKE SURE WE CAN MANAGE
- 15:39IT APPROPRIATELY.
- 15:46LOOKING AT BROADENING THE BASE,
- 15:48WE ARE A MUCH MORE SERVICE BASED
- 15:50ECONOMY THAN WE WERE DECADES AGO
- 15:52WHEN TAX SYSTEM WAS CREATED SO
- 15:54WE DO THINGS NOW THAT WE DIDN'T
- 15:56DO BACK THEN AND MANY STATES, WE
- 15:57LOOK AT TENNESSEE, THEY TAX
- 15:59THINGS EVEN LIKE GROCERIES THAT
- 16:00WE DON'T DO HERE IN KENTUCKY.
- 16:02EVERYONE'S TAX SYSTEM IS
- 16:03DIFFERENT.
- 16:03BUT FROM A COMPETITIVE
- 16:04STANDPOINT, I DO THINK WE HAVE
- 16:06TO BE VERY, VERY CAREFUL TAXING
- 16:08THOSE SMALL AND BUSINESSES AND
- 16:09THOSE SERVICE-BASED BUSINESSES,
- 16:12THINGS LIKE TECH, ET CETERA,
- 16:13LIKE YOU SAID.
- 16:14WHEN WE LOOK AT WHAT THE TAX
- 16:16FOUNDATION, NON-PARTISAN GROUP
- 16:17IN D.C. LOOKS AT, ONE OF THE
- 16:19THINGS THEY LOOK AT IS HOW ARE
- 16:21WE TAXING THESE BUSINESSES?
- 16:23KENTUCKY RIGHT NOW IS 18, WHICH
- 16:24IS PRETTY GOOD.
- 16:25WE HAVE RISEN FROM ABOUT, I
- 16:27THINK 36 A COUPLE YEARS AGO.
- 16:29BUT IF WE CAN CONTINUE TO KIND
- 16:30OF MAKE SURE THAT THAT TAX CODE
- 16:32IS COMPETITIVE, WE'LL CONTINUE
- 16:33TO DROP DOWN AND I THINK ONE
- 16:34IMPORTANT THING TO LOOK AT, TOO,
- 16:36IS I KNOW WE ALL TALK ABOUT THE
- 16:37GOAL BEING ZERO.
- 16:38THAT WAS LAID OUT IN HOUSE BILL
- 16:408.
- 16:40WE CAN STILL BE A REALLY
- 16:42COMPETITIVE STATE TAX WISE
- 16:44WITHOUT GETTING TO ZERO BY DOING
- 16:46THINGS LIKE ROLLING BACK SOME OF
- 16:48THE TAXES ON BUSINESSES, THE
- 16:49LEGISLATURE DID THIS YEAR.
- 16:51YOU KNOW, PRODUCING ABOUT 2%
- 16:53OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS
- 16:54FROM 6 TO 4 IS A HUGE INCREASE
- 16:56FOR OUR COMPETITIVENESS HERE IN
- 16:58KENTUCKY.
- 16:59SO KNOCKING ON THE DOOR OF A 3%
- 17:01INCOME TAX, NOT RAISING OUR
- 17:03SALES TAX ABOVE 6%, REDUCING
- 17:05SOME OF THE TAXES ON BUSINESSES.
- 17:08THAT PACKAGED TOGETHER IS GOING
- 17:09TO BE REALLY COMPETITIVE.
- 17:11>> Renee: AND LOOK WHAT HAPPENED
- 17:12WITH THE BOURBON INDUSTRY, BIG
- 17:13TAX CUT FOR THE BOURBON
- 17:15INDUSTRY.
- 17:15I'M CURIOUS PROFESSOR, WHY ARE
- 17:17WE SINGLING OUT CERTAIN
- 17:18INDUSTRIES TO GIVE THEM A TAX
- 17:20BREAK WHEN THEY'RE ALREADY
- 17:21BOOMING AND DON'T SEEM TO SHOW
- 17:23EVIDENCE OF NEEDING IT?
- 17:24>> RIGHT.
- 17:25I THINK THE BROAD PICTURE OF TAX
- 17:28REFORM IS WHAT YOU WERE SAYING
- 17:30HERE, IS BROADENING THE BASE AND
- 17:32LOWERING THE RATES.
- 17:32AND SO SOMETIMES THAT DOESN'T
- 17:35HAPPEN ALL AT ONCE.
- 17:36YOU HAVE YOU KNOW, LITTLE BY
- 17:38LITTLE, YOU BROADEN THE BASE AND
- 17:41YOU KNOW, ELIMINATING TAXES ON
- 17:43STUFF THAT DON'T REALLY FIT INTO
- 17:44THE BASE.
- 17:45SO IT'S HARD TO GET THIS
- 17:48SWEEPING TAX REFORM ALL AT ONCE
- 17:49AND SO SOMETIMES LITTLE BY
- 17:50LITTLE IS THE WAY IT GOES.
- 17:53WHICH IS KIND OF UNCOMFORTABLE
- 17:55FOR THOSE OF US WHO ARE NOT IN
- 17:57THE MIDDLE OF THE POLITICAL
- 17:58PROCESS AND NOT USED TO OR
- 17:59DEALING WITH THAT.
- 18:00BUT THAT'S KIND OF THE WAY IT
- 18:02GOES.
- 18:03>> Renee: DO YOU THINK
- 18:04CONSUMPTION-BASED TAX SYSTEM IS
- 18:05THE WAY TO GO.
- 18:06>> YEAH, GENERALLY I THINK IT
- 18:08IS.
- 18:09THERE ARE SOME ISSUES THERE, AND
- 18:11I GUESS THE BIGGEST ISSUE IS HOW
- 18:14IT MAY HIT THE POOR FOLKS.
- 18:16BUT THERE ARE WAYS TO DEAL WITH
- 18:18THAT WITHIN THAT CONCEPTION
- 18:22BASED TAX SYSTEM.
- 18:24>> Renee: IS KENTUCKY EVALUATING
- 18:26HOW THIS MOVE TO
- 18:27CONSUMPTION-BASED TAX SYSTEM
- 18:29MIGHT IMPACT THOSE WHO ARE LOWER
- 18:30ON THE...
- 18:30>> I'M NOT SURE.
- 18:32>> ONE THING TO CLEAR UP, THE
- 18:34LEGISLATURE HAS NOT BEEN DOING
- 18:36TAX REFORM IN TERMS OF SHIFT
- 18:37FROM ONE TAX TO ANOTHER.
- 18:39THE NEW SALES TAX ON SERVICES
- 18:40ARE PENNIES.
- 18:42THE REDUCTION IN THE INCOME TAX
- 18:44RATE IS DOLLARS.
- 18:45SO WHAT THEY'RE DOING IS BLOWING
- 18:47A HUGE HOLE IN THE BUDGET THAT'S
- 18:49NOT VISIBLE NOW BECAUSE WE HAVE
- 18:52ALL THIS SURPLUS REVENUE BECAUSE
- 18:53AGAIN, THE HISTORICALLY LOW
- 18:55UNEMPLOYMENT RATE, THE
- 18:57HISTORICALLY HIGH INFLATION, THE
- 18:58PANDEMIC STIMULUS THAT'S GOING
- 18:59TO GO AWAY AND WE ARE GOING TO
- 19:01HAVE DIFFERENT ECONOMIC
- 19:01CONDITIONS IN THE FUTURE THAN WE
- 19:03HAVE NOW.
- 19:06SO THE INCOME TAX IS THE MOST
- 19:08PRODUCTIVE SOURCE THAT WE HAVE
- 19:09IN TERMS OF TRYING TO GENERATE
- 19:11MONEY.
- 19:11WHY IS THAT?
- 19:12BECAUSE IT ASKS MORE OF THOSE
- 19:14WHO HAVE MORE AT THE TOP WHOSE
- 19:16INCOMES HAVE BEEN GROWING
- 19:18DRAMATICALLY, THE WEALTHY.
- 19:19SO WHEN YOU SHIFT TO A SALES
- 19:21TAX, YOU ARE RELYING MORE ON THE
- 19:23POCKETBOOKS OF EVERYDAY PEOPLE,
- 19:25OF LOW INCOME, OF WORKING
- 19:27FAMILIES,-OF-THE-ELDERLY ON
- 19:30FIXED INCOMES AND IT JUST
- 19:31DOESN'T GENERATE ENOUGH.
- 19:32TO REPLACE, YOU KNOW, WAS WE'VE
- 19:37-- A 1 POINT CUT IN THE
- 19:41INCOME TAX, HAVE YOU TO HAVE THE
- 19:42SALES TAX GO UP FROM 6 TO 7.4%.
- 19:48THAT'S THE HIGHEST SALES TAX IN
- 19:49THE COUNTRY.
- 19:50I DON'T THINK THE LEGISLATURE IS
- 19:51GOING TO DO THAT AT THE SAME
- 19:52TIME THEY'RE CUTTING THE INCOME
- 19:54TAX.
- 19:54TO SAY OOPS, WE CUT TOO MUCH AND
- 19:56WE ARE GOING RAISE TAXES ON
- 19:57EVERYDAY PEOPLE'S POCKETBOOKSES.
- 19:59I DON'T THINK THEY SHOULD DO
- 20:00THAT.
- 20:01THAT'S JUST A SHIFT FROM THE
- 20:02WEALTHY TO EVERYBODY ELSE.
- 20:05>> Renee: PROFESSOR.
- 20:06>> I WAS GOING TO SAY SOMETHING
- 20:06ELSE ABOUT INFLATION.
- 20:08WHEN COVID HIT, WE KNOW WE HAD
- 20:11THESE SUPPLY CHAIN PROBLEMS.
- 20:12MOST OF THOSE HAVE BEEN RESOLVED
- 20:14BY AND LARGE.
- 20:15WE HAD THE BIG STIMULUS THAT
- 20:16CAME IN.
- 20:17WE HAD THE PRESSURES PUSHING
- 20:18PRICES UP.
- 20:19YOU MENTIONED WAGES AND WE KIND
- 20:21OF HAVE THIS WAGE PRICE SPIRAL
- 20:24CONCEPT THAT WE BELIEVE IS
- 20:25PUSHING PRICES UP.
- 20:26BUT IN THE LAST YEAR OR SO, AT
- 20:2914, 12 MONTHS, THERE HAS BEEN A
- 20:30LOT OF RESEARCH OUT THERE ON
- 20:32SOMETHING THAT INITIALLY KIND OF
- 20:36IGNORED, DIDN'T THINK MUCH
- 20:37ABOUT.
- 20:38BUT PROFIT-LED INFLATION.
- 20:40AND NOW A LOT...
- 20:41>> Renee: WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
- 20:43>> LOOKING AT THE IDEA THAT
- 20:44BUSINESSES ARE GETTING HIT WITH
- 20:45COST AND WAGE INCREASES, MAYBE
- 20:47TO THE TUNE OF 2, 3 OR 4% BUT
- 20:50THEY'RE RAISING THEIR PRICES 8
- 20:51TO SO%.
- 20:52IT'S JUST THE IDEA THAT
- 20:53BUSINESSES, CORPORATIONS ACROSS
- 20:55THE BOARD, EVEN MOM AND POP
- 20:57CORPORATIONS ARE SAYING, GOSH
- 20:58PRICES ARE GOING UP.
- 21:00HOW MUCH CAN WE REALLY RAISE
- 21:02PRICES THOUGH TO MAKE MORE AND
- 21:03MORE MONEY?
- 21:04IT'S A DIFFICULT THING TO KNOW
- 21:05BECAUSE IT'S DIFFICULT TO
- 21:06RESEARCH.
- 21:07IT'S DIFFICULT-- IT'S SOMETIMES
- 21:09GONE BY AGREED-FLATION.
- 21:13THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
- 21:14RATIONAL SELF INTEREST AND
- 21:16AGREED.
- 21:17THE KANSAS CITY FED OUT OUT IN
- 21:21JANUARY, 60% OF THE INCREASE IN
- 21:22INFLATION HAS BEEN DUE TO THE
- 21:23PROFIT-LED INFLATION.
- 21:25SO IF THAT GOES AWAY, THEN
- 21:27PRICES WILL COME DOWN QUICKLY.
- 21:28BUT IT'S A DIFFICULT THING TO
- 21:29KIND OF ASCERTAIN, TO KNOW, TO
- 21:31WHAT DEGREE OR ARE BUSINESSES
- 21:34RAISING PRICES BAUGH BECAUSE
- 21:35THEY NEED TO AND WHAT DEGREE ARE
- 21:37THEY THINKING I NEED A NEW BOAT.
- 21:38I NEED SOMETHING ELSE?
- 21:39I NEED MORE MONEY?
- 21:42>> Renee: THE REASON DOESN'T
- 21:43MATTER WHAT IS HAPPENING, RIGHT?
- 21:44>> HOW DO YOU SORT THOSE THINGS
- 21:47OUT?
- 21:47>> THAT'S AN IMPORTANT PART.
- 21:48>> THE CENTRAL AUTHORITIES DON'T
- 21:50HAVE THE INFORMATION TO SORT
- 21:51THESE THINGS OUT.
- 21:52THESE ARE KNOWLEDGE SPECIFIC OF
- 21:54EVERY BUSINESS AND EVERY
- 21:55ENTREPRENEUR AND EVERY SMALL
- 21:56BUSINESS AND COMPANY.
- 21:57AND I THINK ULTIMATELY THE
- 21:59ANSWER IS, WE NEED COMPETITION.
- 22:01AND IF THERE IS ENOUGH
- 22:02COMPETITION, THAT EVENTUALLY
- 22:04WILL SQUEEZE OUT PROFITS AND
- 22:06EXCESS PROFITS, I GUESS.
- 22:10SO THERE IS NO NEED TO HAVE THIS
- 22:17AND I JUST DON'T THINK THAT'S
- 22:19PRACTICAL.
- 22:20AND IT HAS BEEN TRIED BEFORE
- 22:22WHERE WE HAVE THESE INCOME
- 22:24POLICIES TO TO LIMIT PRICES IN
- 22:26DIFFERENT SECTORS, BUT IT JUST
- 22:30DOESN'T WORK.
- 22:33>> LAST TIME WE HAD INFLATION,
- 22:35THE SOURCE OF THIS INFLATION
- 22:37AGAIN WAS THE SHOCKS OF THE
- 22:39PANDEMIC AND A WAR.
- 22:40AND THE RIPPLE EFFECTS OF THAT,
- 22:42AND ONE OF THOSE IS THAT EXACTLY
- 22:44WHAT CHRIS IS SAYING, COMPANIES
- 22:45WERE ABLE TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF
- 22:47PRICES ARE GOING UP ANYWAY,
- 22:49RAISING MORE THAN WE HAVE TO.
- 22:51AND PROFITS HAVE BEEN INITIALLY
- 22:53THEY WERE HALF OF THE PRICE
- 22:54INCREASE.
- 22:55NOW THEY'RE ABOUT A THIRD OF THE
- 22:56PRICE INCREASE.
- 22:57SO THE IMPORTANT THING THAT
- 22:58MEANS FOR US NOW IS IT GOES
- 23:01AGAINST THE THEORY THAT WE HAVE
- 23:02A WAGE PRICE SPIRAL.
- 23:03BECAUSE WAGES ARE NOT DRIVING
- 23:05THIS INFLATION.
- 23:06IN FACT, WAGES, THEY WENT UP IN
- 23:102021 BECAUSE A BUNCH OF PEOPLE
- 23:12GOT LAID OFF AND THEN WHEN THEY
- 23:13WENT BACK TO FIND A NEW JOB,
- 23:15THEY WERE ABLE TO BAGGER--
- 23:18BARGAIN MORE WITH THEIR
- 23:19EMPLOYER.
- 23:20THEY JUMPED UP THEN BUT SINCE
- 23:22THEN WAGE GROWTH HAS DECELERATED
- 23:24AND IS NOT WHAT IS DRIVING
- 23:27INFLATION.
- 23:28IT IS THESE CORPORATE PROFITS SO
- 23:32IF THE FEDERAL RESERVE RAISES
- 23:33INTEREST RATES, ALL THAT--
- 23:34CONTINUES TO RAISE INTEREST
- 23:35RATES AND THROWS US INTO A
- 23:37RECESSION, IT'S JUST GOING TO
- 23:38HURT WORKERS WHEN WE DON'T HAVE
- 23:39THE RECIPE FOR THE TRADITIONAL
- 23:41CONCERN ABOUT INFLATION THAT YOU
- 23:43ARE NOT ABLE TO GET RID OF.
- 23:45WE HAVE INFLATION COMING DOWN,
- 23:47AGAIN OVER LAST YEAR SLOWLY.
- 23:49BUT IT'S COMING DOWN AND WE NEED
- 23:51TO TAKE A WAIT AND SEE APPROACH
- 23:52AS THEE THESE THINGS WORK
- 23:55THEMSELVES OUT.
- 23:55>> HAVE I TO CHIME IN HERE.
- 23:57WAGE GROWTH HAS GROWN.
- 23:58LAST MONTH WE KNOW IT HAS GROWN
- 24:006% OVER LAST YEAR AND SO THERE
- 24:02HAS BEEN SIGNIFICANT WAGE GROWTH
- 24:03THAT WE HAVE SEEN.
- 24:04>> Renee: ARE THERE CERTAIN
- 24:05SECTORS WHERE YOU ARE SEEING
- 24:06THAT.
- 24:06>> PRETTY MUCH ALL SECTORS
- 24:08ACROSS THE BOARD THERE HAS BEEN
- 24:09WAGE GROWTH AND A LOT OF THAT IS
- 24:10BECAUSE OF OUR WORKFORCE
- 24:11SHORTAGE AND I THINK WE WILL
- 24:13TALK ABOUT THAT AS WELL.
- 24:14RIGHT NOW WE HAVE TWO OPEN JOBS
- 24:16FOR EVERY ONE PERSON LOOKING.
- 24:18I DO THINK I WOULD TAKE-- I
- 24:22WOULD DISAGREE WITH JASON ON THE
- 24:23WAGE GROWTH ISSUE.
- 24:24EVERYTHING IS GETTING MORE
- 24:26EXPENSIVE.
- 24:27LOGISTICS, BACKLOG FOR GOODS AND
- 24:29SERVICES WE ALL KNOW WHAT THE
- 24:30PANDEMIC HAS CREATED IN TERMS OF
- 24:31BACKLOGS TO BUSINESSES AND
- 24:33COUPLED WITH THAT WORKFORCE
- 24:35ISSUE RIGHT THERE.
- 24:36THE WAGES HAVE BEEN PRETTY
- 24:37STEADILY INCREASING.
- 24:38AND I MEAN IT'S JUST RIGHT HERE,
- 24:396% SINCE LAST YEAR IS THE
- 24:41AVERAGE WAGE GROWTH.
- 24:42>> Renee: I THINK SOME PEOPLE
- 24:43WOULD SAY IT'S NOT ENOUGH TO
- 24:44KEEP UP WITH THE RISE IN
- 24:47INFLATION.
- 24:47>> THE PROFITS ARE THE BIGGER--
- 24:49>> YOU KNOW, I MEAN THIS IS, I
- 24:52GUESS SHOWS YOU WHAT RECENT
- 24:53EXPERIENCE OVER THE LAST YEAR
- 24:55AND A HALF HAS SHOWN THAT REALLY
- 24:57MUCH OF THE INFLATION IS
- 24:59MONETARY POLICY DRIVEN.
- 25:00BECAUSE WHAT WE HAD IN 2022,
- 25:04BEGINNING IN LATE 21 IS THE FED
- 25:09MONETIZED ALL THIS BIG SPENDING
- 25:10THAT CHRIS, YOU WERE TALKING
- 25:12ABOUT, BY BASICALLY PURCHASING
- 25:16THE SECURITIES WITH PRINTED
- 25:17MONEY.
- 25:18AND SO WE HAD A BIG RAMP UP OF
- 25:20INFLATION.
- 25:20NOW IT'S REELING THAT BACK IN BY
- 25:23RAISING THE SHORT-TERM INTEREST
- 25:24RATES.
- 25:25AND WHAT WE ARE SEEING IS
- 25:26INFLATION IS RESPONDING. IS
- 25:29RESPONDING TO THAT SLOWLY.
- 25:32MONETARY POLICY IS A KEY THING
- 25:35HERE THAT'S DRIVEN THE
- 25:35INFLATION.
- 25:36NOW REGARDING WAGES, THE
- 25:39IMPORTANT THING TO LOOK AT THERE
- 25:41IS WHAT ECONOMISTS SOMETIMES
- 25:42CALL REAL WAGES, MEANING
- 25:44INFLATION ADJUSTED WAGES.
- 25:45AND THERE HAVE BEEN SOME SECTORS
- 25:47WHERE THEY'VE GONE UP.
- 25:48BUT IF YOU LOOK AT THE DATA FOR
- 25:50THIS OVER THE LAST, OVER A YEAR,
- 25:54WAGES HAVE BEEN GOING UP BUT
- 25:55THEY HAVEN'T BEEN KEEPING UP
- 25:56WITH INFLATION.
- 25:58ON AVERAGE.
- 25:58NOW THE OTHER THING, ANOTHER
- 26:00THING THAT'S GOING ON IS THAT
- 26:03PRODUCTIVITY BE HAS BEEN GOING
- 26:05DOWN.
- 26:05AND I THINK THIS IS PARTLY
- 26:08BECAUSE I COUPLE OF THINGS.
- 26:09ONE IS ENERGY PRICES HAVE GONE
- 26:10UP A LOT, MUCH NEWSCAST-- MUCH
- 26:14FASTER THAN INFLATION.
- 26:16EVEN NOW THEY'VE GONE DOWN SINCE
- 26:172022.
- 26:18BUT THERE IS STILL SOMETHING
- 26:19LIKE 30% HIGHER THAN THEY WERE
- 26:21IN THE BEGINNING OF 2021.
- 26:23BUT THE OTHER THING IS, WE'VE
- 26:26HAD SIGNIFICANT AMOUNTS OF
- 26:30REREGULATION COME IN AS WELL.
- 26:34SO THIS HAS CAUSED PRODUCTIVITY
- 26:35TO GO DOWN.
- 26:36WHAT HAPPENS FOR FIRMS IS THAT
- 26:38WHEN PRODUCTIVITY ENABLES FIRMS
- 26:41TO GIVE RAISES, AND THAT HAS
- 26:43BEEN GOING DOWN.
- 26:44NOW INFLATION ENABLES FIRMS TO
- 26:45GIVE RAISES IN DOLLAR TERMS, BUT
- 26:48YOU KNOW, IF THE RAISES ARE NOT
- 26:51AS HIGH AS INFLATION, THEN YOU
- 26:53ARE NOT KEEPING UP IN REAL
- 26:57TERMS.
- 26:57SO IT'S A LITTLE BIT PARADOXICAL
- 27:00I THINK THAT INFLATION HAS BEEN
- 27:05REELED IN TO SOME EXTENT.
- 27:06WAS VERY HIGH, BUT THE FACT THAT
- 27:10WAGES HAVE NOT KEPT UP HAS
- 27:13ENABLED COMPANIES TO RETAIN
- 27:16THEIR LABOR FORCE AND NOT LAY
- 27:17OFF A WHOLE BUNCH OF PEOPLE.
- 27:23>> Renee: MANY COMPANIES ARE
- 27:24STILL LOOKING FOR PEOPLE.
- 27:25THEY'RE STILL TRYING TO RECRUIT
- 27:29PEOPLE.
- 27:30WAGES HAVE NOT KEPT UP WITH
- 27:31INFLATION.
- 27:33SO THEY'RE ABLE TO, YOU KNOW,
- 27:34AFFORD TO HIRE MORE AND MORE
- 27:35PEOPLE AND NOT LAY PEOPLE OFF.
- 27:39SO NOW IF PRODUCTIVITY CONTINUES
- 27:41TO FALL, THAT IS GOING TO STOP
- 27:43AND SO THAT'S A PROBLEM WE ARE
- 27:46HAVING NOW THAT G.D.P. GROWTH
- 27:48HAS BEEN KIND OF SKETCHY HERE
- 27:50THE LAST YEAR AND PRODUCTIVITY
- 27:53KEEPS GOING DOWN AND THAT MEANS
- 27:59WAGES ARE GOING TO GO DOWN EVEN
- 28:04FURTHER.
- 28:04AND THE PRODUCTIVITY SIDE HAS TO
- 28:05DO WITH A LOT OF THE REGULATION
- 28:06AND INFLATION ITSELF IS A DRAG
- 28:08ON PRODUCTIVITY BECAUSE IT TAKES
- 28:10A LOT OF TIME AND EFFORT FOR
- 28:12FIRMS AND INDIVIDUALS TO PLAN
- 28:15FOR INFLATION AND THAT PULLS
- 28:16PEOPLE OUT OF PRODUCING GOODS
- 28:17AND SERVICES.
- 28:18>> Renee: WHY DO WE HEAR THAT 2%
- 28:20IS THE OPTIMAL RATE OF
- 28:22INFLATION?
- 28:22WHY THAT NUMBER?
- 28:23>> WELL, I THINK THAT'S JUST TO
- 28:26GIVE THE FED LIKES TO SAY THAT
- 28:27SO THEY CAN HAVE SOME ROOM TO GO
- 28:30DOWN, RIGHT, IN TERMS OF THEIR
- 28:33INTEREST RATES SO THEY CAN DROP
- 28:35THE INTEREST RATES AND IF THEY
- 28:37NEED TO.
- 28:37>> Renee: SO WOULD YOU SAY THAT
- 28:39THE INTEREST RATE HIKES THAT WE
- 28:40HAD BEEN EXPERIENCING, EXCEPT
- 28:41FOR THE LAST TIME WHEN THEY
- 28:43CHOSE TO PUT A PAUSE ON THAT,
- 28:44DID DO WHAT IT WAS SUPPOSED TO
- 28:46DO?
- 28:46>> OH YEAH, THE M2 IS ONE OF THE
- 28:50MEASURES OF MONITORING THE MONEY
- 28:53SUPPLY.
- 28:53IT HAS BEEN DROPPING FOR THE
- 28:54LAST SEVERAL MONTHS.
- 28:57THAT'S KIND OF WHAT ULTIMATELY--
- 28:59I MEAN THERE ARE SOME OTHER
- 29:01FACTORS, BUT ULTIMATELY THAT'S
- 29:02THE BIGGEST CAUSE OF INFLATION
- 29:04OR DISINFLATION.
- 29:06AND WE SOMETIMES FORGET SINCE
- 29:08THE GREAT RECESSION 09,
- 29:10INFLATION RAN ABOUT 1% OR LESS
- 29:12FOR ABOUT 10 YEARS.
- 29:13SO HISTORICALLY LOW, LOW
- 29:15BORDERING ON 0 OR EVEN
- 29:18DISINFLATION IN 09 AND A COUPLE
- 29:20MONTHS IN 2015.
- 29:22AND SOME THEORIES WE HAD PENT UP
- 29:24INFLATION WHERE WE HAD LOW
- 29:27INFLATION FOR SO LONG, PEOPLE
- 29:28DIDN'T SIT BACK AND SAY GOSH,
- 29:32I'M SO HAPPY PRICES ARE SO LOW
- 29:34BUT WE JUST LIVED OUR LIVES AND
- 29:36THEN WE HAD THE PANDEMIC AND
- 29:37PRICES SHOT UP AS A RESPONSE.
- 29:40>> Renee: THE FEDERAL
- 29:40CHAIRPERSON HAS SAID WE PAUSE ON
- 29:41IT RIGHT NOW BUT BY THE END OF
- 29:43THE YEAR, WE WILL HAVE A COUPLE
- 29:45MORE...
- 29:45>> I THINK WHAT HE WAS SAYING
- 29:47EARLIER TODAY IS THAT THERE IS
- 29:48NO NEED TO DO EVERY MEETING
- 29:50RAISES.
- 29:51IT SOUNDED LIKE THEY'RE GOING TO
- 29:52RAISE RATES MAYBE EVERY OTHER
- 29:54MEETING FOR A TIME AND THEN
- 29:55WATCH THE DATA AND SEE WHAT
- 29:56HAPPENS.
- 29:57>> Renee: RIGHT.
- 29:58>> AND THERE ARE PROBLEMS WITH
- 29:59RAISING INTEREST RATES BEYOND
- 30:00WHAT WE HAVE ALREADY TALKED
- 30:01ABOUT, PEOPLE WILL LOSE THEIR
- 30:02JOBS.
- 30:02WE HAVE HAD SOME BANKING CRISIS
- 30:04THIS YEAR THAT HAVE TO DO WITH
- 30:05HOW QUICKLY INTEREST RATES HAVE
- 30:06GONE UP.
- 30:07IT'S A FRAGILE SYSTEM THAT THERE
- 30:10IS RISK OF MOVING TOO FAST AND
- 30:14BREAKING.
- 30:14I WANT TO RESPOND TO THE IDEA
- 30:15THAT THESE INFLATION CAME FROM
- 30:17THE STIMULUS.
- 30:21THE INFLATION IS WORLDWIDE.
- 30:22IT IS HAPPENING IN COMPANIES
- 30:24THAT PROVIDED A-- IN COUNTRIES
- 30:26THAT PROVIDED A LOT OF PANDEMIC
- 30:27AID AND HAPPENING IN COUNTRIES
- 30:28THAT DID NOT PROVIDE PANDEMIC
- 30:30AID.
- 30:30THE SOURCE OF THE INFLATION WAS
- 30:32THE PANDEMIC ITSELF.
- 30:33AND THEN FOLLOWED UP BY THE WAR
- 30:36IN UKRAINE.
- 30:37THE SHOCKS AND RIPPLES APPROACH,
- 30:40I GUESS, DRIVER OF THIS VERSION
- 30:43OF INFLATION.
- 30:44WHAT WE DID WITH THE PANDEMIC
- 30:46AID IS WE KEPT IT FROM TURNING
- 30:48INTO A DEPRESSION AND WE MADE
- 30:51PEOPLE WHOLE WHILE THEY WENT
- 30:53THROUGH A PERIOD OF EXTENDED
- 30:55JOBLESSNESS, PREVENTED MASS
- 30:58DESPERATION, YOU KNOW, WE CUT
- 30:59THE CHILD POVERTY RATE IN HALF
- 31:01FOR A YEAR.
- 31:01AND SO IT DID SAY LOT OF GOOD.
- 31:03AND IT DID ACTUALLY, FOR A VERY
- 31:05TEMPORARY PERIOD, HELP WAGES GO
- 31:07UP FOR ABOUT A YEAR, BECAUSE
- 31:09PEOPLE HAD A LITTLE BIT MORE IN
- 31:11THEIR BANK ACCOUNT WHEN THEY
- 31:12WENT BACK TO LOOK FOR THAT WORK,
- 31:14THEY HAD BEEN LAID OFF FROM THE
- 31:15RESTAURANT JOB AND WENT BACK TO
- 31:17LOOK FOR ANOTHER RESTAURANT JOB
- 31:18AND MAYBE THEY HAD A FEW HUNDRED
- 31:20DOLLARS MORE IN THE BANK THAT
- 31:22ALLOWED THEM TO MAYBE BARGAIN
- 31:23FOR A LITTLE MORE.
- 31:24AND THAT WAS GREAT BUT THAT WAS
- 31:26ONE TIME AND IT WAS TEMPORARY.
- 31:27AND THERE IS NOT EVIDENCE THAT
- 31:29WORKERS HAVE THE BARGAINING
- 31:31POWER.
- 31:31IN FACT, THEY JUST DON'T, TO
- 31:33CONTINUE THOSE WAGES INCREASES
- 31:36OR CREATE A WAGE PRICE SPIRAL.
- 31:38THE LAST TIME WE HAD REALLY BIG
- 31:40INFLATION IN THE COUNTRY, A
- 31:41QUARTER OF THE WORKERS WERE IN
- 31:43THE UNION AND THE UNIONS HAVE
- 31:44COST OF LIVING ADJUSTMENTS EVERY
- 31:46YEAR.
- 31:46NOW IT'S ABOUT 6%.
- 31:48SO WORKERS JUST AREN'T ABLE TO
- 31:49CONTINUE BEYOND THAT ONE-TIME
- 31:51MOMENT TO SORT OF PUSH UP WAGES.
- 31:53AND WE HAVE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE AT
- 31:553.7% AND WE ARE SEEING WAGE
- 31:57GROWTH DECLINE.
- 31:58AND THAT'S IN THE NUMBERS.
- 32:00WAGE GROWTH IS ABOUT 4% NOW.
- 32:01IT'S GOING DOWN.
- 32:02IT WAS HIGHER A COUPLE YEARS
- 32:04AGO.
- 32:04SO THERE IS A LOT OF CONCERN
- 32:06THAT WE ARE USING THESE
- 32:0850-YEAR-OLD MODELS ABOUT
- 32:09INFLATION THAT DON'T FIT AN
- 32:11ECONOMY WHERE THE BOUNCE OF
- 32:13INFLATION WE ARE LIKELY TO HAVE
- 32:15NOW AND IN THE FUTURE ARE MORE
- 32:17LIKELY TO BE DRIVEN BY THESE
- 32:20CRISES, CLIMATE CRISES, THE
- 32:22DISRUPTION OF SUPPLY CHAINS IN
- 32:25THIS CASE WHICH HAPPENED WHEN
- 32:26THE PORTS CLOSED, WHEN, YOU
- 32:29KNOW, THERE IS FLOODS, FIRES,
- 32:32DROUGHTS IN DIFFERENT COUNTRIES
- 32:33THAT CUT OFF SUPPLY FOR A KEY,
- 32:35YOU KNOW, INPUTS FOR VARIOUS
- 32:38PRODUCTS.
- 32:38THOSE THUNKS PUSH UP INFLATION.
- 32:40AND THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED
- 32:41IN THIS CASE.
- 32:43SO WE ARE GOING TO HAVE TO HAVE
- 32:44A DIFFERENT SET OF TOOLS THAN
- 32:46JUST JACKING UP INTEREST RATES
- 32:47WHICH IS A VERY BLUNT AND
- 32:49INDIRECT MEASURE AND AGAIN VERY
- 32:51PAINFUL FOR THE ENTIRE ECONOMY.
- 32:54>> Renee: Dr. GARREN TALKED
- 32:55ABOUT REGULATION DRIVING UP
- 32:57INFLATION.
- 32:57PERHAPS HE CAN GIVE US MORE,
- 32:59EXPAND ON WHAT YOU MEAN ON
- 33:01REGULATION AND WHAT SPECIFIC
- 33:02TYPE OF REGULATION CAN YOU
- 33:03PINPOINT THAT CAUSES AN
- 33:05INFLATIONARY SPIKE.
- 33:06>> A LOT OF IT IS WITH THE
- 33:07ENERGY SECTOR AND ALSO THERE IS
- 33:09A LOT OF DEBATE THESE DAYS ABOUT
- 33:11ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION AND HOW
- 33:13EFFECTIVE IT HAS BEEN IS IT
- 33:19RISING COSTS AND NOT BENEFIT.
- 33:22THE SUPREME COURT HAS CHIMED IN
- 33:25ON THE CONSTITUTIONALITY OF IT.
- 33:27YES, IN FACT, CASEY MULLIGAN,
- 33:30WHO IS NOW A PROFESSOR OF
- 33:33ECONOMICS AT UNIVERSITY OF
- 33:34CHICAGO, HE DID A STUDY BACK I
- 33:36THINK WHEN HE WAS ON THE COUNCIL
- 33:38OF ECONOMIC ADVISERS ABOUT
- 33:39REGULATION AND COSTS, YOU KNOW,
- 33:41COST OF BUSINESS.
- 33:43AND IT WAS KIND OF DRIVING KIND
- 33:45OF ONE OF THE DRIVERS BEHIND
- 33:48SOME OF THE DEREGULATORY MOVES
- 33:49IN THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION.
- 33:52BUT I THINK IF YOU JUST LOOK AT
- 33:54THE NUMBERS OF SPENDING, IT'S
- 33:55GONE WAY UP, OF COURSE.
- 33:56WE KNOW THAT.
- 33:57BUT IF YOU LOOK AT THE MONEY
- 33:59SUPPLY, THAT'S GONE WAY UP.
- 34:00AND THESE ARE, I DON'T KNOW,
- 34:02MAYBE MORE THAN A 50-YEAR-OLD
- 34:04THEORY.
- 34:05THE MONETARY THEORY OF INFLATION
- 34:07HAS BEEN AROUND FOR A LONG TIME.
- 34:09AND IT WORKS.
- 34:12AND I THINK TO DISMISS THAT, I
- 34:15THINK, I DISAGREE WITH JASON ON
- 34:17THAT.
- 34:18I THINK THAT'S PRETTY KEY.
- 34:21AND AGAIN, IF YOU JUST LOOK--
- 34:23EXCUSE ME, AT WHAT HAPPENED IN
- 34:252022, THE MONEY SUPPLY, AND
- 34:30BEFORE 2022, AND THEN DURING
- 34:322022, IT'S GONE WAY UP AND
- 34:33STARTING TO COME DOWN.
- 34:34SO THAT TRACKS INFLATION PRETTY
- 34:37WELL.
- 34:38>> YOU KNOW, I MEAN IT'S HARD TO
- 34:42POINT TO AN EXAMPLE OF
- 34:44REGULATORY POLICY DURING THE
- 34:46TRUMP ADMINISTRATION, WHICH IS
- 34:46WHERE THIS ORIGINATED, THAT
- 34:48WOULD HAVE CAUSED INFLATION.
- 34:49THAT WAS NOT ON THE AGENDA AT
- 34:52THAT TIME.
- 34:52ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATIONS WERE
- 34:53NOT ON THE AGENDA.
- 34:54WHAT DID HAPPEN IS WE WERE HIT
- 34:56WITH A WORLDWIDE PANDEMIC THAT,
- 34:58I MEAN FOLKS NEED TO REMEMBER
- 35:00WHAT HAPPENED AND HOW IT CHANGED
- 35:03PEOPLE, BOTH DEMAND AND SUPPLY.
- 35:06PEOPLE QUIT BUYING FACE-TO-FACE
- 35:08SERVICES AND THEY BOUGHT GOODS
- 35:09INSTEAD.
- 35:10SO INSTEAD OF, YOU CANCEL YOUR
- 35:13GYM MEMBERSHIP AND YOU BUY AN
- 35:15EXERCISE MACHINE INSTEAD.
- 35:16THOSE THINGS VASTLY INCREASED
- 35:18DEMAND FOR GOODS THAT DIDN'T
- 35:19HAVE THE SUPPLY CHAINS IN PLACE
- 35:21TO DO THAT.
- 35:22AT THE SAME TIME COVID ITSELF
- 35:23SHUT DOWN THOSE SUPPLY CHAINS
- 35:25AND WE HAD PORTS THAT CLOSED, WE
- 35:27HAD, YOU KNOW, SUPPLY THAT
- 35:30COULDN'T BE DELIVERED.
- 35:31PEOPLE ALSO BOUGHT MORE HOUSING
- 35:33BECAUSE THEY WERE WORKING AT
- 35:34HOME.
- 35:35AND THEY FIGURED OUT, I NEED A
- 35:36BIGGER HOUSE IF I'M GOING TO BE
- 35:37WORKING FROM HOME, OR, YOU KNOW,
- 35:39YOU ARE A KID LIVING WITH YOUR
- 35:41PARENTS AND YOU ARE LIKE NOW
- 35:42THAT I'M HERE WITH THEM EVERY
- 35:43SINGLE DAY, I THINK I'LL GET MY
- 35:44OWN APARTMENT.
- 35:45THAT INCREASED DEMAND ON HOUSING
- 35:47AND THE PRICE OF HOUSING WENT
- 35:50UP.
- 35:50HOUSING IS ABOUT 40% OF CORE
- 35:52INFLATION.
- 35:53SO IT IS A BIG FACTOR IN PUSHING
- 35:56IT.
- 35:56AND IT HAD TO DO WITH CHANGES IN
- 35:59PEOPLE'S DEMAND DURING THE
- 36:01PANDEMIC THAT THE SUPPLY CHAIN
- 36:02WAS NOT PREPARED FOR.
- 36:05SO THOSE ARE THE UNIQUE
- 36:07DISRUPTIONS THAT THIS CRISIS
- 36:08CREATED THAT THEN SPURRED
- 36:11INFLATION.
- 36:11AND AS WAS ALREADY SAID, SOME OF
- 36:12THE COMPANIES, AND SOME OF THOSE
- 36:14SECTORS TOOK ADVANTAGE OF THAT
- 36:15OPPORTUNITY WHERE PEOPLE SAW THE
- 36:16PRICES WERE GOING UP AND THEY
- 36:18JUST PUSHED THEM UP EVEN MORE TO
- 36:20INCREASE THEIR PROFIT MARGINS
- 36:21AND INCREASE THEIR MARGINS.
- 36:24AND ALL THOSE THINGS SORT OF
- 36:25ADDED TO A SITUATION.
- 36:27NOW IT'S COMING DOWN.
- 36:29AND IT'S COMING DOWN BECAUSE THE
- 36:32SUPPLY CHAIN SNARLS HAVE WORKED
- 36:33THEMSELVES OUT.
- 36:34THE PORTS HAVE REOPENED.
- 36:35THERE HAVE BEEN DIFFERENT SUPPLY
- 36:37THAT HAS BEEN BUILT AND
- 36:38DEVELOPED FOR SOME OF THOSE
- 36:41SEMICONDUCTORS, FOR EXAMPLE, YOU
- 36:42KNOW, WE HAD A FIRE AT A
- 36:44SEMICONDUCTOR PLANT IN JAPAN
- 36:46THAT HELPED CONTRIBUTE TO THAT,
- 36:48AND THAT WAS THE BIG THING THAT
- 36:49KEPT US FROM BUILDING NEW CARS
- 36:51FOR A WHILE.
- 36:51SO THEN YOU SAW THE PRICE OF
- 36:53USED CARS GO UP, RIGHT?
- 36:54AND THAT'S WORKING ITSELF OUT
- 36:56OVER TIME.
- 36:57SO THIS IS NOT-- THE TRADITIONAL
- 37:00MODEL OF WHAT CAUSES INFLATION
- 37:02DOESN'T FIT WHAT ACTUALLY
- 37:05HAPPENED WITH A GLOBAL PANDEMIC
- 37:06AND SO THE TOOLS ARE NOT THE
- 37:09BEST TOOLS.
- 37:09>> YOU KNOW, ONE THING THAT
- 37:11ECONOMISTS LIKE TO SAY IS THAT
- 37:13INFLATION COMES FROM MORE MONEY
- 37:16CHASING THE SAME NUMBER OF
- 37:17GOODS.
- 37:18BUT YOU KNOW, YOU CAN HAVE THE
- 37:19OTHER THING GOING ON WHERE THE
- 37:20NUMBER OF GOODS FALLS AND THE
- 37:23SAME AMOUNT OF MONEY.
- 37:24NOW DURING THE PANDEMIC, YEAH,
- 37:25THERE WAS A SHUTDOWN, OF COURSE,
- 37:27OF LOTS AND LOTS OF BUSINESSES
- 37:28AND SO THERE WERE FEWER GOODS
- 37:30AND SERVICES PRODUCED.
- 37:32SO DURING THAT TIME PERIOD, AND
- 37:33AFTER THAT TIME PERIOD, WE HAD A
- 37:36REDUCTION IN THE AMOUNT OF GOODS
- 37:37AND SERVICES PRODUCED, AND AN
- 37:40INCREASE IN THE AMOUNT OF MONEY.
- 37:41SO WE HAD MORE MONEY CHASING
- 37:43FEWER GOODS.
- 37:44THAT DIDN'T SHOW UP RIGHT AWAY.
- 37:45AND, IN FACT DIDN'T REALLY SHOW
- 37:46UP UNTIL THE ECONOMY MOSTLY
- 37:51RECOVERED.
- 37:51AND THAT WAS LATE 2021.
- 37:52SO THE MONEY KEPT GETTING PUMPED
- 37:55INTO THE ECONOMY.
- 37:56SO WE HAD MOSTLY BACK TO THE
- 38:00SAME NUMBER OF GOODS AS EARLY
- 38:032020, BUT MORE AND MORE MONEY.
- 38:05>> THE MONEY IS COMING OUT OF
- 38:06THE ECONOMY.
- 38:07THE STIMULUS IS ENDING.
- 38:08MOST OF IT HAS ALREADY ENDED SO
- 38:11IT'S DISINFLATIONARY NOW.
- 38:12>> THAT'S THE POINT.
- 38:13>> BUT IT'S GOING... GOING AWAY
- 38:16ON ITS OWN.
- 38:16>> IT WAS DESIGNED TO BE
- 38:18TEMPORARY AND HELP PEOPLE GET
- 38:19THROUGH THE PERIOD AND IT'S
- 38:20GOING AWAY.
- 38:21SO IT'S NOT CONTRIBUTING-- IT'S
- 38:23NOT CONTINUING TO CONTRIBUTE--
- 38:24>> WE ARE TALKING ABOUT TWO
- 38:25DIFFERENT THINGS HERE.
- 38:26ONE IS GOVERNMENT SPENDING AND
- 38:27YOU CAN HAVE INCREASES IN
- 38:28GOVERNMENT SPENDING WITHOUT
- 38:30INFLATION THAT, IF THE FED
- 38:32DOESN'T IMPRINT MORE MONEY,
- 38:34THERE IS GOING DONE MORE MONEY
- 38:36RAISED THROUGH BOPPED SALES OR
- 38:37TAXES, AND GOVERNMENT DECIDES
- 38:40HOW MUCH WHERE IT GETS SPENT.
- 38:41SO YOU CAN HAVE MORE GOVERNMENT
- 38:42SPENDING WITHOUT MONETARY SURGE.
- 38:46SO, AND BUT OFTEN TIMES
- 38:48GOVERNMENT SPENDING COMES WITH A
- 38:50MONETARY SURGE WHERE THE FED,
- 38:51EVEN THOUGH IT SAYS IT DOESN'T
- 38:52WANT TO DO THIS, THE FED HELPS
- 38:54IT ALONG BY MONETIZING THE DEBT.
- 38:57AND THAT'S WHAT WE HAD IN 2021,
- 39:05AND-- 2020 AND 2021 AND THAT
- 39:06SHOWED UP BIG TIME IN 2022.
- 39:09>> Renee: SO THE ECONOMY FOR ALL
- 39:10OF THOSE YOUNG GRADUATES WHO
- 39:12GRADUATES, YOU KNOW, MAYBE THEY
- 39:14HAVE AN ASSOCIATE'S DEGREE FROM
- 39:16SOMERSET AND WENT TO U.K. AND
- 39:18FINISHED UP AND NOW THEY'RE IN
- 39:19THE WORKFORCE.
- 39:20I MEAN IS THIS THE IDEAL ECONOMY
- 39:22FOR AN UPSTART, A YOUNG START?
- 39:23>> THERE ARE JOBS OUT THERE.
- 39:25THE QUESTION IS LOTS OF JOBS, IS
- 39:27THERE THE JOB?
- 39:28AND I THINK A LOT OF YOUNG
- 39:29PEOPLE, WHETHER THEY WANT TO OR
- 39:31NOT, HAVE YOU TO SOMETIMES START
- 39:33AT THE BOTTOM.
- 39:35INSTEAD.
- 39:35MIDDLE OR THE STOP AND WORK YOUR
- 39:37WAY UP AND SHOW HARD WORK AND
- 39:38SHOW UP AND PRODUCE AND BE
- 39:40PRODUCTIVE AND SHOW YOU HAVE
- 39:41GOOD IDEAS.
- 39:43AND SOME FOLKS CAN DO THAT AND
- 39:45SOME FOLKS MAY NOT.
- 39:46SO I THINK IT'S A GOOD WORK
- 39:48ENVIRONMENT JUST BECAUSE THERE
- 39:49IS PLENTY OF JOBS.
- 39:50WHETHER YOU ARE GOING TO GET THE
- 39:51SALARY YOU WANT, AND LIVE THE
- 39:53LIFE YOU WANT AT 22, PROBABLY
- 39:56NOT.
- 39:56BUT YOU GOT TO WORK FOR THAT.
- 39:58YOU GO TO THE WORK FOR THAT UP
- 40:01THE CHAIN.
- 40:01>> I HAVE SAID THAT OFTEN.
- 40:03COLLEGE GRADUATES RIGHT NOW,
- 40:04SOMEONE WITH A BACHELOR'S DEGREE
- 40:06STARTING OFF, THERE ARE TWO OPEN
- 40:08JOBS FOR EVERY PERSON LOOKING
- 40:09HERE IN KENTUCKY.
- 40:10AND IT'S NOT JUST ENTRY LEVEL
- 40:12JOBS OR HOSPITALITY.
- 40:14IT'S LITERALLY EVERY SINGLE
- 40:16SECTORS.
- 40:17I TALK TO EMPLOYERS EVERY SINGLE
- 40:18DAY FROM ALL OVER THE STATE,
- 40:20WHETHER IT'S IN HEALTHCARE,
- 40:22EDUCATION, MANUFACTURING,
- 40:23THEY'RE LOOKING FOR ALL SORTS OF
- 40:25EMPLOYEES.
- 40:25AND SO RIGHT NOW I DO THINK IT
- 40:28VERY MUCH IS THAT JOB SEEKERS'
- 40:31MARKET WHERE EMPLOYERS ARE
- 40:32REALLY, YOU KNOW, FRANKLY
- 40:33DESPERATE FOR EMPLOYEES.
- 40:34>> Renee: AND WILLING TO PAY
- 40:35MORE.
- 40:35>> AND WILLING TO PAW MORE AND
- 40:37THAT NATURAL COMPETITION HAS
- 40:39DRIVEN UP THE WAGES.
- 40:40AND I DO THINK HAVING SOME
- 40:42SKILLS OR SOME TRAINING OR SOME
- 40:43EDUCATION, YOU ARE IN A REALLY
- 40:44GOOD SPOT RIGHT NOW TO LAND, YOU
- 40:46KNOW, A GOOD JOB HERE IN
- 40:48KENTUCKY.
- 40:49>> MOTIVATED.
- 40:49BE MOTIVATED.
- 40:50>> Renee: BUT IF YOU ARE MIDDLE
- 40:52AGED PERHAPS, HOW IS THAT
- 40:53WORKING FOR YOU?
- 40:53>> I SAID IT'S KIND OF ONE OF
- 40:55THOSE THINGS RIGHT NOW WHERE
- 40:56IT'S ALL HANDS ON DECK.
- 40:58I THINK WE AS THE CHAMBER HAVE
- 41:00BEEN VERY CREATIVE IN HELPING
- 41:02EMPLOYERS LOOK FOR EMPLOYEES.
- 41:04WE LOOK AT PEOPLE WHO MAYBE HAVE
- 41:05NOT BEEN IN THE WORKFORCE FOR A
- 41:06PERIOD OF TIME, WHETHER THEY'RE
- 41:07IN RETIREMENT.
- 41:08WE ARE LOOKING AT-- TODAY I HAD
- 41:09A MEETING WITH DIFFERENT
- 41:10BRANCHES OF THE MILITARY TALKING
- 41:12ABOUT HOW VETERANS CAN
- 41:13TRANSITION INTO THE WORKFORCE
- 41:14ONCE THEY RETIRE FROM THE
- 41:15MILITARY.
- 41:17WE DO A LOT OF WORK, AS YOU
- 41:19KNOW, AROUND SECOND CHANCE
- 41:20HIRING.
- 41:21AND SO IT'S REALLY THIS ALL
- 41:22HANDS ON DECK APPROACH BECAUSE
- 41:24WE SIMPLY NEED EVERYONE THAT CAN
- 41:25WORK TO WORK.
- 41:27>> WE HAVE HAD-- IF YOU LOOK AT
- 41:29THE WAY THE ECONOMY HAS CHANGED
- 41:31IN KENTUCKY AND THE COUNTRY THE
- 41:32PAST FEW DECADES A LOT OF THE
- 41:34JOBS, INCLUDING THE FAST GROWING
- 41:36JOBS ARE LOW WAGE SERVICE
- 41:38SECTORS JOBS.
- 41:38IF YOU LOOK AT THE FASTEST
- 41:40GROWING JOBS, IT'S IN ELDERCARE,
- 41:42IT'S IN FAST FOOD, IT'S IN HOTEL
- 41:46ACCOMMODATIONS AND RETAIL
- 41:48RELATED JOBS THAT, YOU KNOW,ARE
- 41:51NOT TYPICALLY UNIONIZED.
- 41:52THEY DON'T PAY VERY MUCH.
- 41:53WE HAVE ABOUT 20% OF JO BUSINESS
- 41:55THAT PAY LESS THAN $15 AN HOUR.
- 41:59THERE HAS BEEN SOME WAGE
- 42:03INCREASES AGAIN AT THE BEGINNING
- 42:04OF THE PANDEMIC ONE TIME BUT
- 42:05THEY HAVEN'T, AIS WE SAID MULT
- 42:09MULTIPLE TIMES, THISY HAVE NOT
- 42:10KEPT UP WITH INFLATION WHICH HAS
- 42:11BEEN VERY HIGH.
- 42:12THERE IS A JOB QUALITY PROBLEM
- 42:13THAT MANY PEOPLE FACE AND THAT'S
- 42:15WHY SO MANY YOU KNOW, SO MANY
- 42:18KENTUCKIANS THAT ARE EMPLOYED
- 42:20ARE STILL STRUGGLING TO MAKE
- 42:21ENDS MEET, ESPECIALLY WITH THE
- 42:22COST OF HOUSING GOING UP IN MANY
- 42:24PARTS OF THE STATE AND THE
- 42:26SCARCITY OF HOUSING, ESPECIALLY
- 42:28IN THE URBAN AREAS AND THE OTHER
- 42:30SORT OF COST OF LIVING
- 42:31CHALLENGES THAT FOLKS MAKE.
- 42:33SO WE HAVE A LOT OF JOBS AT THE
- 42:35MOMENT, WE DON'T HAVE A LOT OF
- 42:36JOBS OR ENOUGH JOBS TO PAY A
- 42:38LIVING WAGE.
- 42:39WE DON'T HAVE ENOUGH JOBS THAT
- 42:40ARE-- YOU EVEN SEE THAT, FOR
- 42:43EXAMPLE, RIGHT NOW, THERE IS A
- 42:45MAJOR RENEGOTIATION HAPPENING
- 42:45OVER KENTUCKY'S LARGEST
- 42:48EMPLOYER.
- 42:48UPS, WHICH IS A UNIONIZED
- 42:51EMPLOYER, PAYS GOOD WAGES FOR
- 42:53FULL-TIME WORKERS, BUT THEY'VE
- 42:54ALSO, LIKE MANY EMPLOYERS,
- 42:56THEY'VE CREATED THE COMPANY HAS
- 42:59CREATED TIERS FOR NEWER WORKERS
- 43:00WHERE THEY MAKE LESS THAN
- 43:02SOMEBODY WHO HAS BEEN ON THERE
- 43:03FOR A LONG TIME.
- 43:04AND THERE ARE JOB QUALITY ISSUES
- 43:11. ACCESS TO AIR
- 43:12CONDITIONING.
- 43:13MANY WORKERS ARE FACING
- 43:14SURVEILLANCE ON THE JOB MORE AND
- 43:16MORE.
- 43:16SO THOSE ARE THE THINGS THAT
- 43:17PEOPLE ARE LOOKING FOR, TOO.
- 43:19NOT ONLY IS IT PROVIDING A
- 43:21LIVING WAGE BUT IS IT PROVIDING
- 43:23THE WORKING CONDITIONS THAT MAKE
- 43:24A PERSON HEALTHY AND LIVE A GOOD
- 43:27LIFE.
- 43:28>> I WOULD SAY COMMENTING ON
- 43:30WHAT JASON SAID, RIGHT NOW THE
- 43:31MAIN HOURLY WAGE IN KENTUCKY IS
- 43:33$25 AN HOUR.
- 43:35AND SO THERE REALLY ARE JOBS,
- 43:36FROM ALL ENDS OF THE SPECTRUM
- 43:38WHETHER YOU ARE JUST STARTING IN
- 43:39THE JOB MARKET OR YOU ARE A
- 43:40YOUNG WORKER, ALL THE WAY IF YOU
- 43:41HAVE A PROFESSIONAL DEGREE, IT
- 43:43REALLY, WE ARE SEEING THIS
- 43:44WORKFORCE ISSUE IN EVERY SINGLE
- 43:46SECTOR AND EVERY SINGLE LEVEL.
- 43:47>> ONE THING THE COUNTRY
- 43:49STRUGGLES WITH, WE HAVE ABOUT
- 43:52100 MILLION INDIVIDUALS THAT ARE
- 43:53NOT IN THE LABOR FORCE.
- 43:54ABOUT HALF THOSE ARE RETIREES.
- 43:56WE DON'T EXPECT THOSE TO WORK.
- 43:58SO AS MANY AS 40 TO 50 MILLION
- 44:00WORKING AGE ADULTS ARE OUT THERE
- 44:02, NOT IN THE LABOR FORCE.
- 44:05THEY'RE DOING SOMETHING TO GET
- 44:07BY, BUT THEY COULD COME BACK IN
- 44:09AND TAKE SOME OF THESE JOBS.
- 44:13THAT'S A DIFFICULTY WE FACE.
- 44:15WHY THEY DROPPED OUT, THE LATEST
- 44:20NUMBER--
- 44:22>> 57% RIGHT NOW KENTUCKIANS
- 44:24THAT COULD WORK ARE WORKING.
- 44:26THAT'S OUR WORKFORCE
- 44:27PARTICIPATION RATE.
- 44:29>> Renee: WHERE DO WE RANK
- 44:30NATIONALLY.
- 44:30>> BOTTOM 10.
- 44:31I THINK RIGHT NOW WE ARE AT 42
- 44:35OR 43.
- 44:36IT CHANGES EVERY MONTH BUT THE
- 44:37NATIONAL AVERAGE IS 62.6%.
- 44:40WE ARE SEVERAL PERCENTAGE POINTS
- 44:41DOWN ON WORKFORCE PARTICIPATION
- 44:42WHICH IS THE PEOPLE IN THAT
- 44:43WORKING AGE POPULATION THAT
- 44:44COULD WORK, THAT ARE WORKING.
- 44:46AND WE CONSISTENTLY RANK IN THE
- 44:48BOTTOM 10.
- 44:49DURING THE PANDEMIC WE WERE AT
- 44:50THE VERY BOTTOM.
- 44:51WE HAVE RISEN UP A COUPLE
- 44:53NOTCHES IN THE LAST COUPLE OF
- 44:54YEARS, BUT WE REALLY CANNOT
- 44:55CRACK OUT OF THAT BOTTOM 10.
- 44:57>> Renee: AND WE TALKED ABOUT
- 44:58CHILD CARE BEING ONE OF THE
- 44:59MAJOR BARRIERS, PARTICULARLY FOR
- 45:00WOMEN, WHO ARE THE PRIMARY
- 45:03CAREGIVERS IN THEIR HOME TRYING
- 45:04TO FIND AFFORDABLE HIGH QUALITY
- 45:06CHILD CARE.
- 45:06SO UNTIL THAT'S ADDRESSED,
- 45:09PERHAPS THAT WILL BE A DRIVER
- 45:10FOR MORE WORKFORCE PARTICIPATION
- 45:12WHEN MORE PRIMARILY WOMEN CAN GO
- 45:14BACK TO WORK AND NOT PAY THEIR
- 45:15WHOLE PAYCHECK TO DAYCARE.
- 45:17>> YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT.
- 45:19THE WORKFORCE CRISIS ISSUE, A
- 45:21MYRIAD OF REASONS.
- 45:21THERE IS NOT ONE SIMPLE
- 45:23SOLUTION.
- 45:23I WISH THERE WAS.
- 45:24IT'S A LOT OF THINGS, CHILD CARE
- 45:25IS OBVIOUSLY SOMETHING THE
- 45:27CHAMBER HAS CARED ABOUT THE LAST
- 45:28SEVERAL YEARS AND WE HAVE HELPED
- 45:30PASS LEGISLATION AROUND THAT AND
- 45:31SPEAKING OF WOMEN IN THE
- 45:32WORKFORCE, I LOOK AT A LOT OF
- 45:33DATA AROUND THAT AND YOU KNOW,
- 45:34WOMEN WERE MORE NEGATIVELY
- 45:36AFFECTED WITH THE PANDEMIC IN
- 45:37TERMS OF BEING UNEMPLOYED OR
- 45:39HAVING TO STAY HOME.
- 45:40UNFORTUNATELY A LOT OF THAT
- 45:41BURDEN OF HOME SCHOOLING YOUR
- 45:43CHILDREN AND DOING THE VIRTUAL
- 45:44SCHOOLING FELL TO WOMEN.
- 45:45A LOT OF THE HOSPITALITY WORKERS
- 45:47WHERE THEY WERE CLOSED DOWN,
- 45:48WHETHER YOU WERE IN RESTAURANTS
- 45:50OR HOTELS, FALL TO WOMEN AS
- 45:52WELL.
- 45:52THE GOOD NEWS IS THAT WOMEN, OUR
- 45:54NUMBERS IN KENTUCKY, WOMEN HAVE
- 45:56GOTTEN BACK INTO THE WORKFORCE.
- 45:57THE BAD PART IS THAT WE ARE NOT
- 45:59SEEING THAT SAME KIND OF WAGE
- 46:02GROWTH AS IN TERMS OF MEN OR
- 46:03UPWARD MOBILITY.
- 46:05AND SO IT'S TAKING WOMEN A
- 46:06LITTLE LONGER TO GET BACK INTO
- 46:07THE WORKFORCE THAN IT DID MEN
- 46:09POST PANDEMIC.
- 46:10>> I WANT TO...
- 46:11>> THAT STATISTIC IS THROWN
- 46:14AROUND A LOT.
- 46:15>> Renee: WHICH STATISTIC.
- 46:17>> 57% OF WORKING AGE PEOPLE IN
- 46:18THE WORKFORCE MUCH THAT'S NOT
- 46:19TRUE.
- 46:20THAT'S PEOPLE 16 AND OLDER.
- 46:21SO YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT 98 YEAR
- 46:23OLDS, YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT 84
- 46:24YEAR OLDS.
- 46:25IF YOU LOOK AT THE WORKING AGE
- 46:27POPULATION, WHAT IS CALLED THE
- 46:29PRIME WORKING POPULATION BETWEEN
- 46:30THE AGES OF 25-54, 79% OF THE
- 46:34PEOPLE IN KENTUCKY IN THAT AGE
- 46:35GROUP ARE IN THE WORKFORCE.
- 46:3879%.
- 46:38IN THE NATION IT'S 82.
- 46:39SO WE ARE A LITTLE BEHIND.
- 46:41BUT NOT MUCH.
- 46:43THE REMAINDER OF THOSE PEOPLE--
- 46:45SO ROUGHLY 20% OF PEOPLE NOT IN
- 46:47THE WORKFORCE, THEY'RE
- 46:49CAREGIVERS, THEY HAVE A
- 46:51DISABILITY, OR THEY'RE IN
- 46:52SCHOOL.
- 46:53THE VAST MAJORITY OF THEM.
- 46:54THERE IS ONLY A SMALL PERCENTAGE
- 46:55THAT WE CAN'T PUT IN ONE OF
- 46:56THOSE CATEGORIES.
- 46:58SO, YOU KNOW, GENERALLY PEOPLE
- 47:00ARE WORKING.
- 47:01THERE IS NOT THESE HIDDEN POTS
- 47:03OF MONEY YOU CAN GO AND RELY ON
- 47:05UNLESS YOU COME FROM A WEALTHY
- 47:07FAMILY.
- 47:07AND NOT BE IN THE WORKFORCE HERE
- 47:08IN KENTUCKY.
- 47:09PEOPLE ARE WORKING, THEY'RE
- 47:10STRUGGLING TO MAKE ENDS MEET.
- 47:14SO I WANT THAT STATISTIC TO BE
- 47:16CLARIFIED BECAUSE IT'S ALWAYS
- 47:17STATED AND IT'S ALWAYS STATED
- 47:19INCORRECTLY.
- 47:20NEARLY HALF OF THE PEOPLE NOT
- 47:21WORKING IS JUST-- THAT'S JUST
- 47:23FALSE.
- 47:24NOW, FOR THOSE PEOPLE WHO DO
- 47:26HAVE BARRIERS, AND YOU LISTED A
- 47:28GREAT ONE, LIKE THE CAREGIVERS
- 47:30WHO WOULD LIKE TO HAVE
- 47:33EMPLOYMENT BUT JUST CAN'T AFFORD
- 47:34CHILD CARE, WE SHOULD REMOVE
- 47:36THEM.
- 47:36AND I WILL POINT TO CHILD CARE
- 47:38SPECIFICALLY BECAUSE IT'S VERY
- 47:39IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND THAT THE
- 47:41CHILD CARE INDUSTRY HAS BEEN
- 47:42PROPPED UP BY FEDERAL PANDEMIC
- 47:44AID THE LAST FEW YEARS, ABOUT
- 47:47$300 MILLION A YEAR IN FEDERAL
- 47:48PANDEMIC AID.
- 47:50IT'S INCREASED THE WAGES OF
- 47:51THESE LOW PAID CHILD CARE
- 47:52WORKERS.
- 47:53IT'S INCREASED, MADE IT MORE
- 47:55AFFORDABLE FOR PEOPLE TO GO.
- 47:56IT'S HELPED UPGRADE THE
- 47:59FACILITIES.
- 47:59AND IT RUNS OUT VERY, VERY SOON.
- 48:02SO WITH ALREADY HALF OF
- 48:05KENTUCKIANS LIVING IN A CHILD
- 48:06CARE DESERT, THIS IS A VERY BIG
- 48:08ISSUE FOR THE 24 LEGISLATIVE
- 48:09SESSION, IS IN THIS, ALL THIS
- 48:12SURPLUS MONEY IN THE RAINY DAY
- 48:13FUND SET ASIDE RIGHT NOW, IS THE
- 48:15LEGISLATURE GOING TO TAKE SOME
- 48:17OF THAT STATE MONEY AND PREVENT
- 48:20THERE FROM BEING A CLIFF THAT
- 48:21THESE CHILD CARE CENTERS FACE?
- 48:23I THINK THAT'S A HUGE ISSUE.
- 48:25>> CAN I CHIME IN AND JUST DIVE
- 48:26A LITTLE DEEPER TO WHAT JASON
- 48:28SAID ABOUT THE PRIME AGE
- 48:29WORKFORCE PARTICIPATION.
- 48:30HE IS RIGHT.
- 48:3279% RIGHT NOW IS OUR PRIME AGE
- 48:34WORKFORCE PARTICIPATION RATE BUT
- 48:35IT'S LOWER THAN IN 2019.
- 48:36WE WERE AT 79.5.
- 48:38IT IS LOWER BE THE NATIONAL
- 48:39AVERAGE OF 82.4 BUT THE MOST
- 48:42IMPORTANT THING I THINK TO
- 48:42REMEMBER IS THAT THOSE NUMBERS
- 48:44ARE OBVIOUSLY HIGHER THAN THAT
- 48:46WORKFORCE PARTICIPATION RATE OF
- 48:4857%, I THINK IS WHAT I SAID.
- 48:49BUT WE ARE STILL IN THE BOTTOM
- 48:5110 IN TERMS OF PRIME AGE
- 48:52WORKING.
- 48:53SO WE ARE STILL IN THE BOTTOM
- 48:5510, MORE THAN 40 STATES ARE
- 48:57STILL DOING BETTER IN THAT
- 48:58STATISTIC THAN WE ARE AS WELL.
- 49:00SO THOSE NUMBERS ARE CORRECT,
- 49:01BUT WE ARE IN THE BOTTOM 10 AS
- 49:03WELL.
- 49:04>> I WOULD LIKE TO COMMENT ON
- 49:06SEVERAL THINGS THAT HAVE COME UP
- 49:07HERE.
- 49:08I THINK YOU GO PRE-PANDEMIC,
- 49:10THAT WE HAD A SITUATION WHERE A
- 49:12LOW WAGE WORKERS WERE
- 49:16EXPERIENCING QUITE SUBSTANTIAL
- 49:17WAGE GAINS AND OUTSTRIPPED
- 49:20INFLATION.
- 49:21THIS IS SEVERAL YEARS PRIOR TO
- 49:21THE PANDEMIC.
- 49:23AND INFLATION WAS VERY LOW, OF
- 49:25COURSE, LIKE 1 OR 2%.
- 49:27BUT REAL WAGES WERE GOING UP.
- 49:29INFLATION ADJUSTED WAGES WERE
- 49:31GOING UP FOR ALL WAGE BIG
- 49:34CATEGORIES.
- 49:35BUT ESPECIALLY AT THE LOW END.
- 49:37AND THE REASON FOR THAT IS WE
- 49:39HAD SOME SUBSTANTIAL ECONOMIC
- 49:41GROWTH AND PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH
- 49:43WAS GROWING UP.
- 49:43BUT I THINK THAT THIS WAS A TIME
- 49:46WHEN, IF YOU RECALL SOME OF THE
- 49:48NEWS STORIES AND THERE IS
- 49:49PROBABLY DATA ON THIS AS WELL,
- 49:51WHERE EMPLOYERS ARE REALLY
- 49:52TRYING TO FIND, LIKE THE SECOND
- 49:54CHANCE WORKERS, OR TRYING TO
- 49:56FIND PEOPLE WHO HAVE MAYBE HAVE
- 49:59BEEN MARGINALLY CONNECTED TO THE
- 50:01LABOR FORCE, MAYBE NEEDED CHILD
- 50:02CARE ASSISTANCE, LET'S GET YOU
- 50:04IN.
- 50:04WE GOT A JOB FOR YOU.
- 50:06NOW THE BEAUTY OF THAT IS
- 50:07BECAUSE THAT WAS DUE TO
- 50:10PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH.
- 50:11SOME OF IT, OF COURSE THE STABLE
- 50:14MONETARY POLICY.
- 50:14REDUCTIONS IN TAXES, FRAMEWORK
- 50:17WHERE THERE WAS SOME
- 50:19DEREGULATION GOING ON.
- 50:20THAT SPURRED PRODUCTIVITY
- 50:22GROWTH, WHICH AFFECTS WAGES OF
- 50:24EVEN THE LOW INCOME WORKERS.
- 50:26SO HERE WE HAVE A SITUATION,
- 50:28KIND OF LIKE THE BEST POVERTY
- 50:31PROGRAM IMAGINABLE BECAUSE IT
- 50:32DOESN'T COME OUT OF ANYBODY'S
- 50:33POCKET.
- 50:33THIS COMES OUT OF JUST RAISING
- 50:36PRODUCTIVITY.
- 50:37NOW SOME OF THE JOBS LOW INCOME
- 50:40JOBS ARE NOT THAT GREAT OF JOBS.
- 50:42I MEAN WE HAVE ALL BEEN THERE,
- 50:43RIGHT?
- 50:44IT'S NOT ALWAYS THAT GREAT.
- 50:46BUT FOR SOMEONE YOUNG, YOU KNOW,
- 50:47THAT'S WHERE YOU START.
- 50:48AND IF YOU'VE GOT AN EMPLOYER,
- 50:50WHO IS READY TO HIRE YOU, WANTS
- 50:52TO TRAIN YOU AND WILL WORK WITH
- 50:54YOU, MAN, THAT'S THE TICKET.
- 50:55THAT'S THE KIND OF ECONOMIC
- 50:58GROWTH THAT WORKS FOR LOW INCOME
- 51:00AS WELL AS OTHER FOLKS.
- 51:01>> AND MAYBE IT'S NOT ALWAYS THE
- 51:03MONETARY BENEFIT.
- 51:05MAYBE IT'S THE ABILITY TO SAY
- 51:06YOU CAN WORK FROM HOME THREE
- 51:07DAYS A WEEK.
- 51:09REDEFINING WHAT THE WORK
- 51:10ENVIRONMENT LOOKS LIKE.
- 51:10>> THAT'S WHAT I WAS GOING TO
- 51:11CHIME IN.
- 51:12WE WERE TALKING ABOUT WAGES AND
- 51:13I THINK ABIMPORTANT PART OF THE
- 51:15EMPLOYMENT CONVERSATION IS THE
- 51:16CREATIVITY THAT EMPLOYERS HAVE
- 51:17HAD THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS.
- 51:18WE WORK MUCH DIFFERENTLY THAN WE
- 51:20WORKED A COUPLE YEARS AGO.
- 51:22IT'S FLEXIBILITY.
- 51:23HELPING TO PAY FOR CHILD CARE,
- 51:25TUITION ASSISTANCE.
- 51:25I KNOW SOME EMPLOYERS OFFER PET
- 51:28INSURANCE.
- 51:28IT'S ALL OF THESE THINGS THAT
- 51:30EMPLOYERS ARE DOING TO REALLY
- 51:31GET CREATIVE TO COMPETE IN THIS
- 51:33JOB MARKET.
- 51:34>> Renee: DO THEY MONETIZE THAT
- 51:35TOTAL COMPENSATION PACKAGE AND
- 51:36SAY WELL YEAH, YOUR BASE SALARY
- 51:39MIGHT BE $35K BUT WHEN WE GIVE
- 51:41IT TO YOU, IT'S WORTH WHATEVER
- 51:43IT'S WORTH.
- 51:44>> I WAS GOING SAY SOMETHING
- 51:45ABOUT PERCEPTIONS WHAT IS GOING
- 51:46ON IN THE ECONOMY.
- 51:47WE CAN LOOK AT THESE NUMBERS AND
- 51:49WE CAN AGREE MOSTLY ON THE
- 51:50NUMBERS.
- 51:50BUT THE ECONOMY SEEMS TO BE
- 51:52DOING PRETTY WELL OVERALL.
- 51:53WE KNOW THE INFLATION, WE BATTED
- 51:55BACK AND FORTH.
- 51:56BUT BECAUSE OUR POLITICAL
- 51:58ECONOMIC DIVIDE IS SO VAST TODAY
- 51:59, IT REALLY DEPENDS UPON
- 52:01YOUR POLITICAL PERSUASION, HOW
- 52:03YOU EVEN VIEW THE ECONOMY.
- 52:04IF YOU LOOK AT THE POLLING IN
- 52:05THAT.
- 52:06IF YOU GO BACK AND LOOK AT 2020
- 52:08DURING THE ELECTION, I PULLED UP
- 52:10THOSE NUMBERS.
- 52:12JIB WAN 525 COUNTIES AND
- 52:15PRESIDENT TRUMP WON 2500
- 52:16COUNTIES.
- 52:17ALMOST 2600.
- 52:17BUT ABOUT 70% OF THE G.D.P.
- 52:19COMES OUT OF THOSE 500 COUNTIES
- 52:24THAT JOE BIDEN WON.
- 52:25SO IF YOU LOOK AT ECONOMIC
- 52:26GROWTH AND WHERE IT IS CENTERED,
- 52:28IT IS REALLY CENTERED IN THE
- 52:30METROPOLITAN HUBS AROUND THE
- 52:32COUNTRY, LIKE FAYETTE COUNTY,
- 52:35JEFFERSON COUNTY, AND THAT'S
- 52:37WHERE MOST OF THE ECONOMIC
- 52:38GROWTH HAS TAKEN PLACE.
- 52:39AND IF YOU LOOK OUT IN THOSE
- 52:41RURAL COUNTIES, THE RED
- 52:42COUNTIES, IT SEEMS LIKE THAT
- 52:43FOLKS ARE A LITTLE BIT MORE
- 52:47PESSIMISTIC ABOUT THE FUTURE
- 52:48BECAUSE THEY RELY MORE ON TRAVEL
- 52:50AND GASOLINE AND WE KNOW ENERGY
- 52:51PRICES HAVE GONE UP.
- 52:52MAYBE THEY RELY MORE ON, YOU
- 52:55KNOW, STAPLE FOOD ITEMS AND WE
- 52:56KNOW GROCERIES HAVE GONE UP AND
- 53:00IN THE INTERURBAN AREA, MAYBE
- 53:01YOU DON'T RELY ON YOUR CAR SO
- 53:03MUCH OR ON, YOU KNOW ERIK WOO--
- 53:05OR WEEKLY GROCERY BILLS.
- 53:07A LOT OF IT COMES BACK TO EVEN
- 53:10OUR POLITICS DETERMINES OUR VIEW
- 53:12OF THE ECONOMY.
- 53:13AND IT'S SORT OF STRANGE THAT IT
- 53:15WORKS OUT THAT WAY.
- 53:15>> Renee: THAT'S A GOOD POINT.
- 53:16>> I WANT TO CONNECT A COUPLE OF
- 53:18THINGS THAT WERE SAID BECAUSE
- 53:19THERE IS A VERY URBAN-RURAL
- 53:21ELEMENT TO OUR LABOR FORCE
- 53:24PARTICIPATION RATE.
- 53:25WE ARE IN THE BOTTOM 10 IN THAT
- 53:27STATISTIC.
- 53:27WE ARE IN THE BOTTOM 10 IN EVERY
- 53:29STATISTIC.
- 53:30BUT IF YOU LOOK AT IT
- 53:32GEOGRAPHICALLY, WHERE WE ARE IN
- 53:33LEXINGTON AND THE GOLDEN
- 53:34TRIANGLE IN BOWLING GREEN, THE
- 53:36URBAN PARTS OF THE STATE, YOU
- 53:38KNOW, OUR LABOR FORCE
- 53:39PARTICIPATION RATE IS VERY GOOD.
- 53:40IT'S ABOVE AVERAGE.
- 53:41BUT THE STATEWIDE RATE GETS
- 53:44PULLED DOWN BECAUSE PARTICULARLY
- 53:46IN THE RURAL AREAS, AND THE MORE
- 53:48REMOTE AREAS IN EASTERN KENTUCKY
- 53:49WHERE SO MANY JOBS HAVE BEEN
- 53:50LOST, THE LABOR FORCE
- 53:53PARTICIPATION RATE IS MUCH
- 53:54LOWER, HIGHER LEVELS OF
- 53:55DISABILITY, MORE PEOPLE WILL
- 53:56HAVE BLACK LUNG DISEASE, ALL
- 53:58KINDS OF BARRIERS AND THERE ARE
- 54:00FAR FEWER JOBS.
- 54:01I MEAN WE HAVE A 3.8%
- 54:04UNEMPLOYMENT RATE STATEWIDE IN
- 54:05KENTUCKY.
- 54:05IT'S HIGHER THAN THAT IN MARTIN
- 54:07COUNTY AND THOSE AREAS HAVE BEEN
- 54:08HIT BY FLOODING, MOST RECENTLY,
- 54:12AND THERE JUST AREN'T TWO JOB
- 54:15OPENINGS FOR EVERY JOB IN THOSE
- 54:16COUNTIES.
- 54:17THERE ARE NOT A LOT OF JOBS.
- 54:18THE SCHOOL SYSTEM IS THE LARGEST
- 54:20EMPLOYER.
- 54:22THE HOSPITAL IS AN IMPORTANT
- 54:23EMPLOYER, BOTH OF WHICH, BY THE
- 54:24WAY, DEPEND ON STATE REVENUES
- 54:26FROM THE INCOME TAX.
- 54:28BUT THERE ARE NOT A LOT OF JOBS,
- 54:29AND THERE ARE MORE PEOPLE
- 54:31WORKING FAR MORE PEOPLE WORKING
- 54:33AT DOLLAR GENERAL THAN THERE ARE
- 54:35COAL MINERS SO YOU USED TO HAVE
- 54:37THESE UNION JOBS THAT PAID GOOD
- 54:38WAGES.
- 54:38>> MULTIPLE JOBS.
- 54:39>> THEY DON'T EXIST ANYMORE.
- 54:41AND PEOPLE WORKING AT DOLLAR
- 54:43GENERAL, THEY'RE NOT 22 YEAR
- 54:44OLDS ON THEIR WAY UP THE CAREER
- 54:46LADDER.
- 54:46MANY OF THEM ARE ADULTS, OLDER
- 54:48PEOPLE.
- 54:49THEY HAVE WORKED THESE JOBS
- 54:50THEIR ON WHOLE LIFE AND
- 54:51STRUGGLED THEIR WHOLE LIVES AT
- 54:53IT.
- 54:53IT'S BECOME AN ECONOMIC REALITY
- 54:55FOR MANY PEOPLE AND I THINK WE
- 54:57NEED TO BE DOING MORE TO CREATE
- 54:59JOBS IN THE PLACES WHERE PEOPLE
- 55:00LIVE AND ULTIMATELY THAT'S GOING
- 55:02TO REQUIRE, I THINK, MORE PUBLIC
- 55:04INVESTMENT BECAUSE THE EFFORTS
- 55:05TO ATTRACT A LOT OF, YOU KNOW,
- 55:09MANUFACTURERS THERE HAVE NOT
- 55:10BEEN SUCCESSFUL.
- 55:11>> Renee: SO QUICKLY TO YOU MISS
- 55:13WATTS ABOUT CHILD CARE.
- 55:14WILL WE SEE THE KENTUCKY CHAMBER
- 55:16PUSH FOR FURTHER LEGISLATION TO
- 55:17HELP PARTICULARLY PERHAPS EVEN
- 55:20WOMEN WHO WERE DISPLACED OUT OF
- 55:21THE WORKFORCE, TO GET BACK IN?
- 55:23AND WHAT KIND OF INCENTIVES ARES
- 55:26ARE YOU THINKING ABOUT.
- 55:27>> WE ARE GOING TO CONTINUE TO
- 55:28ADVOCATE FOR CHILD CARE
- 55:29LEGISLATION.
- 55:29YOU KNOW, WE HELPED PASS THE
- 55:31BILL A COUPLE YEARS AGO THAT SET
- 55:32UP THAT CHILD CARE ASSISTANCE
- 55:33PROGRAM WHERE AN EMPLOYER CAN
- 55:35PUT MONEY INTO SOMEONE WHO NEED
- 55:37CHILD CARE ASSISTANCE AND THE
- 55:38STATE MATCHES IT 100%.
- 55:40THAT IS LIVE RIGHT NOW.
- 55:41SO EVERY EMPLOYER SHOULD GO AND
- 55:42CHECK THAT OUT.
- 55:43SO RIGHT NOW WE ARE LOOKING AT
- 55:44KIND OF THE REGULATORY
- 55:47ENVIRONMENT.
- 55:47HOW IS IT EASIER TO PROVIDE
- 55:49CHILD CARE, ALL OF THAT, I THINK
- 55:50EVERYTHING RIGHT NOW IS ON THE
- 55:51TABLE BECAUSE I THINK TO JASON'S
- 55:54POINT, THAT FEDERAL SUBSIDY,
- 55:56THAT ASSISTANCE CANS IS GOING TO
- 55:57RUN OUT IN THE NEXT COUPLE OF
- 55:59MONTHS.
- 55:59WE KNOW CHILD CARE LOCATIONS
- 56:00CLOSING THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
- 56:02THERE ARE AREAS IN THE STATE
- 56:04WHERE THERE ARE CHILD CARE
- 56:04DESERTS SO IT'S A REALLY BIG
- 56:06ISSUE.
- 56:06JASON, WE AGREE ON THIS ONE
- 56:08HOPEFULLY WE CAN WORK TOGETHER
- 56:09THIS NEXT SESSION AND GET
- 56:10SOMETHING DONE ON CHILD CARE.
- 56:11>> Renee: WE'LL HAVE THAT AS A
- 56:13TOP TICK I'M SURE.
- 56:16WE THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
- 56:16JOINING US TONIGHT MAKE SURE YOU
- 56:18JOIN US EACH NIGHT 6:30 EASTERN
- 56:225:30 CENTRAL AND BILL BRYANT
- 56:23WILL BE HERE WITH A TEAM OF
- 56:24WORKING JOURNALISTS TO DISCUSS
- 56:26THE NEWS OF THE WEEK ON COMMENT
- 56:29ON KENTUCKY FRIDAY.
- 56:30I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 56:31THANK YOU FOR WATCHING AND HAVE
- 56:32A GREAT NIGHT.