Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Q1] BMI: Badger Meter Software Margins and Valuation Risks
Transcript
- 0:00To access more advanced researches, applications and our
- 0:02latest published personal intelligent multi agent deep
- 0:05value intelligence Welcome to explore and join deep values dot
- 0:09AI community track total market temperature.
- 0:12Welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett indicator from
- 0:15Apple App Store. So imagine a company that
- 0:19basically just makes heavy brass metal parts for city sewers.
- 0:23Right. Like real old school industrial
- 0:25stuff. Exactly.
- 0:26But now imagine that same company somehow boasts like
- 0:29software margins. That would make a Silicon Valley
- 0:31startup completely jealous. It's, yeah, completely defies
- 0:35those traditional industrial stereotypes.
- 0:37You know, like you expect a company bending metal to have
- 0:39slow grinding growth and cyclical layoffs, not cloud
- 0:43subscriptions and massive profit margins.
- 0:45Seriously. So welcome to our deep dive.
- 0:47For you listening, our lens today is entirely focused on
- 0:49Badger Meter ticker symbol BMI. We've got this incredibly
- 0:52detailed Deep Value Intelligence Report published on April 17,
- 0:552026, and our mission is to basically figure out how this
- 0:59100 year old legacy water meter company is attempting to
- 1:01digitize like the entire global water cycle.
- 1:05Yeah. And the central tension in this
- 1:07report is just jarring. I mean, on paper, BMI is this
- 1:11absolute compounding machine. They are generating a 28% return
- 1:16on invested capital, right? And they have nearly a 20%
- 1:19return on equity, plus they carry absolutely zero debt.
- 1:23Zero. That's wild.
- 1:25Yeah, literally 0. Any traditional stock Screener
- 1:28would flag this as a screaming buy immediately, yet the Deep
- 1:32Value AI system actually tagged the stock with a remarkably
- 1:36cautious neutral YCA trading. Oh, interesting.
- 1:39So we have this business that passes like almost every single
- 1:42quality test, but then it entirely fails the pricing test.
- 1:45Exactly. Let's figure out how that
- 1:47happens, starting with the actual mechanisms of the
- 1:49business. Because, you know, if you're
- 1:51listening to this and you're picturing a guy in a utility
- 1:52truck driving around like checking a spinning dial on the
- 1:54side of a house, you are completely missing the
- 1:57transformation here. Oh absolutely.
- 1:58The physical hardware has undergone this massive
- 2:00evolution. So BMI is essentially
- 2:03transitioning cities away from those old mechanical meters to
- 2:06their new E series ultrasonic meters.
- 2:09OK, I read about those and said those ultrasonic meters have
- 2:13zero moving parts. But I mean, how do you even
- 2:17measure the physical flow of a liquid without a wheel or a
- 2:20dial? You know, physically spinning
- 2:22inside the pipe. It basically comes down to sound
- 2:24wave physics. Waves.
- 2:26Yeah, so instead of a physical wheel spinning as the water
- 2:29pushes it, these E series meters actually shoot ultrasonic sound
- 2:32waves across the inside of the pipe, right?
- 2:35And by measuring the microscopic differences in how long the
- 2:39sound takes to travel against the flow of the water versus
- 2:42with it, the internal computer can calculate the exact volume
- 2:46of passing through. That is so cool.
- 2:48So just there's no friction at all.
- 2:49Exactly 0 friction, 0 wear and tear and because of that it
- 2:53never degrades inaccuracy overtime.
- 2:55OK, so that totally solves the measurement problem.
- 2:58But how does that data get from, say, a dark concrete sewer in a
- 3:02random residential neighborhood back to the city's billing
- 3:05department? Yeah, the report says they pair
- 3:08these meters with what they call Orion cellular radio endpoints.
- 3:12But like, why use cellular if a city wants to build a smart grid
- 3:16when they just build their own centralized radio towers?
- 3:19Well, a decade ago that was actually the industry standard
- 3:22and honestly, it was a total nightmare.
- 3:23Really. Why?
- 3:24Because building proprietary radio towers requires massive
- 3:28capital expenditure. I mean you have to buy the land,
- 3:31pour the concrete, build the actual tower and then pay
- 3:34technicians to maintain the whole thing forever.
- 3:37Right, that sounds super expensive for a small city.
- 3:39It is So BMI looked at all that friction and just decided to
- 3:42pivot to a cellular first approach.
- 3:45They basically realized, hey, AT&T and Verizon already have
- 3:49towers everywhere. Why are we reinventing the
- 3:52wheel? OK.
- 3:53I get that, but wait, standard 5G doesn't really penetrate
- 3:56underground right? Like my cell phone barely even
- 3:58works in a parking garage, let alone buried under a cast iron
- 4:01manhole cover. Right, which is exactly why they
- 4:03don't use the standard consumer cellular networks.
- 4:06They piggyback on specific public networks using LTE, M and
- 4:10NB IoT technology. Yeah, narrowband Internet of
- 4:13Things. These are low frequency, low
- 4:16power networks that are specifically designed for
- 4:19connected devices. Because the frequency is so low,
- 4:22it can easily penetrate concrete, dirt, heavy metal
- 4:25lids, all of it. And since it requires so little
- 4:28power to transmit those tiny packets of data, the battery
- 4:32inside the BMI meter can actually last 20 years. 20
- 4:35years? That's insane.
- 4:37So the city gets a full smart grid without having to literally
- 4:40become a telecom operator. Precisely.
- 4:42OK, so they install the ultrasonic meter, they attach
- 4:45this cellular endpoint and then they feed all that continuous
- 4:48data into their cloud based software platform, which they
- 4:51call Beacon. Yep, the beacon.
- 4:52Platform. It sounds like this fantastic
- 4:54software transition, but let me just challenge that narrative
- 4:57for a second. I'm looking at the 2025 full
- 5:00year data from the report, and 65% of BMI's revenue still comes
- 5:04from physical utility hardware. Sure, only 23 percent is
- 5:07actually software and services. So aren't they still just a
- 5:09hardware company hiding in a tech company's trench coat?
- 5:12I totally see the angle there, but you have to look at how that
- 5:15revenue mix dictates their profitability.
- 5:18Like think of the physical hardware as the root system of a
- 5:21tree. It's expensive and really labor
- 5:24intensive to plant those roots in the concrete, right?
- 5:28But once they're in the ground, they feed the high margin
- 5:31software leaves for decades so. It's like a structural shift.
- 5:35Exactly. Yes, the hardware makes up the
- 5:37bulk of the revenue, but the Beacon software is what drives
- 5:40the structural margin expansion. Because of those ongoing
- 5:43software subscriptions, BM is gross margins have climbed to
- 5:4641.7% and their operating margins hit 20% in 2025.
- 5:53South, the hardware basically just gets them in the door and
- 5:55then the software supercharges the profit.
- 5:57That's it. But I mean, selling a 41% margin
- 6:00product in the industrial space usually puts a massive target on
- 6:03your back. Like if I'm a rival tech company
- 6:05or some massive conglomerate, why don't I just build a
- 6:08slightly better dashboard, undercut them on the software
- 6:10price and just steal all their municipal clients?
- 6:13Because you aren't fighting one big national centralized water
- 6:17grid. You are fighting 50,000 tiny,
- 6:20incredibly conservative local water districts and City
- 6:22Council. Oh right, the classic municipal
- 6:25monopoly. It is the ultimate fragmented
- 6:27market. I mean, just imagine the sheer
- 6:29bureaucracy of a small town City Council.
- 6:31How painful, right? Once they finally approve the
- 6:34budget to install thousands of BMI meters, deploy all the
- 6:37cellular endpoints, and fully integrate that beacon software
- 6:40into their highly customized billing and customer service
- 6:43systems, the friction to change vendors becomes immense.
- 6:47Yeah, the report notes. These systems are locked in for
- 6:49the lifespan of the hardware, which you said is what, a 15 to
- 6:5220 year replacement cycle? Exactly 15 to 20 years, the cost
- 6:56and the political headache to basically RIP and replace that
- 6:59entire ecosystem just to switch to a competitor like Xylon.
- 7:02More Itron. It would be in the 10s of
- 7:05millions of dollars. So once BMI wins a contract,
- 7:07they essentially own that utilities data flow for an
- 7:10entire generation. Yep, and they have massive macro
- 7:14tailwinds that are actually forcing these cities to make
- 7:17these upgrades in the 1st place. Like water is rapidly becoming a
- 7:22highly precious, very expensive commodity due to global scarcity
- 7:27and increased droughts. Right.
- 7:28Cities literally can't afford to lose water.
- 7:30Exactly, they simply cannot afford what they call non
- 7:32revenue water. Non revenue water.
- 7:35Yeah, that's the industry term for clean, treated water that
- 7:38leaks out of broken pipes before it ever reaches a home to be
- 7:41built. That makes total sense.
- 7:42Plus I imagine the regulatory pressure is mounting too, right?
- 7:45The EPA's recent lead and copper rule improvements?
- 7:48The LCRI that basically forces municipalities to invest in high
- 7:53precision monitoring just to stay compliant with federal law.
- 7:56Oh absolutely, Cities have to buy this technology now whether
- 7:59they actually want to or not. Wow.
- 8:01And BMI management isn't just relying on organic growth from
- 8:04those regulations either. They are aggressively widening
- 8:07this Moat through highly targeted MNA.
- 8:09Right, they've been buying up companies.
- 8:11Yeah, but they aren't making reckless mega mergers.
- 8:14They are buying niche technology to expand what they call their
- 8:18Blue Edge ecosystem so they can potentially monitor the entire
- 8:21water cycle. The acquisition of Smart Cover
- 8:24in early 2025 is a great example of that.
- 8:26That brought in like $40 million in sales.
- 8:29But what exactly are they monitoring with that?
- 8:30So Smart Cover specializes in stormwater and wastewater.
- 8:34They put these little sensors under manhole covers to detect
- 8:37when sewer evils are rising dangerously high.
- 8:39Go gross, but very necessary. Very It allows a city to
- 8:43dispatch a crew to clear a blockage before raw sewage
- 8:46actually overflows into the city streets.
- 8:48Or, you know, local rivers. And then in April 2026, BMI
- 8:52acquired UD Life over in the UK, which adds even more advanced
- 8:55acoustic sensors for sewer monitoring.
- 8:57OK, so they are shifting from just measuring the clean water
- 8:59going into a house to becoming the, I guess, the central
- 9:03nervous system for a city's entire water infrastructure.
- 9:06That's a great way to put it. Clean water, wastewater,
- 9:09stormwater, it all just feeds right into one BMI gashboard.
- 9:12Yeah. So I have to say, having all
- 9:14that critical civic infrastructure digitized and
- 9:16centralized in the cloud, that sounds like a massive cyber
- 9:20security target. It is a very real vulnerability,
- 9:22and honestly, it's the unmodeled tail risk of this entire digital
- 9:25transition. Like a cyber attack on a city's
- 9:28water grid isn't just a data leak, it's a physical crisis.
- 9:31Yeah, people need water. Exactly.
- 9:33We should definitely explore how that impacts their long term
- 9:35viability. But first, I think we need to
- 9:37look at the financial armor they've built to protect
- 9:39against, you know, traditional market threats.
- 9:42Oh, for sure. Let's get into those 2025
- 9:44numbers because the financial engine here is just staggering.
- 9:47Revenue crossed the $900 million mark, hitting $916.7 million.
- 9:53Free cash flow reached nearly $170 million.
- 9:55Yeah. And their free cash flow margin
- 9:57hit a record 18.5% pure cash generation.
- 10:01But the metric that stands out the most to me is the debt.
- 10:04They have absolutely zero debt and a $226 million cash pile.
- 10:08Is a debt free balance sheet really that big of a competitive
- 10:11advantage or they're just being like overly conservative?
- 10:14Well, in the deep value framework we look for this
- 10:16concept of anti fragility. Anti fragility.
- 10:19Yeah, a fragile company breaks under market stress.
- 10:22A robust company just survives it.
- 10:25But an anti fragile company actually weaponizes that stress
- 10:28against its competitors. I like.
- 10:31That Think about the macroeconomic environment
- 10:32recently. When interest rates spiked up to
- 10:347%, highly leveraged industrial competitors suddenly found their
- 10:39borrowing costs were just crippling their cash flows.
- 10:42Right. They were paralyzed just trying
- 10:44to service their existing loans. Exactly.
- 10:46While those rivals were literally choking on interest
- 10:48payments and cutting their R&D budgets, Badger Meter just
- 10:52reached into its checking account.
- 10:53They can acquire auk startup like UD Live with straight cash.
- 10:57No banks required. Right.
- 10:59They don't have to worry about refinancing debt, maturities or
- 11:02appeasing bondholders. They have total strategic
- 11:05freedom precisely when capital is at its absolute most
- 11:08expensive. And management clearly knows how
- 11:11much excess cash they are generating too.
- 11:12I mean, they just increase their dividend for the 33rd
- 11:15consecutive year. Which is huge.
- 11:17But more importantly, in early 2026, the board authorized a
- 11:21$150 million stock buyback program.
- 11:25Companies authorize buybacks all the time, though.
- 11:27I mean, often it's just to offset the dilution from the
- 11:30stock options they give their own executives.
- 11:32That is usually the case, yeah, but the language in this
- 11:35specific authorization is really crucial.
- 11:37BM is board explicitly designated this for
- 11:40opportunistic repurchases? Opportunistic, meaning they're
- 11:44waiting for a drop. Yes.
- 11:45They aren't just systematically buying a set amount every single
- 11:48month. They have a war chest ready to
- 11:50deploy whenever they believe the broader market misunderstands
- 11:52their stock and drives the price down artificially.
- 11:55Which perfectly contextualizes this major signal from the
- 11:58report. The CEO, Ken Bockhurst, who's
- 12:01basically the architect of this entire digital sauce transition,
- 12:05personally bought 3300 shares of his own company's stock on the
- 12:07open market during a dip in early 2026.
- 12:10Open market insider buying is arguably the strongest signal in
- 12:14all of value investing. I mean the executives will sell
- 12:17their stock for 100 different reasons.
- 12:19Sure, they need to buy a house or pay a massive tax bill.
- 12:23Or just diversify. Exactly, but they only take
- 12:25their own after tax cash and buy stock on the open market for one
- 12:29reason. They genuinely believe the
- 12:31current price is significantly lower than the intrinsic value.
- 12:34Right, and that was over half $1,000,000 of his own money.
- 12:37Yep. So let's pause here and look at
- 12:39the whole picture. For you listening, you hear
- 12:42about a company with 0 debt, a 20 year municipal monopoly,
- 12:46record free cash flow and ACEO dropping half $1,000,000 on his
- 12:50own stock. You are probably wondering why
- 12:53we aren't telling you to just back up the truck and buy this
- 12:55immediately, right? So why on earth did the
- 12:57intelligence system give BMIA cautious?
- 13:01What's the age rating? This is where we hit the classic
- 13:03deep value conflict. It all comes down to the strict
- 13:06separation between a great business and a great investment.
- 13:09OK, unpack that. Well, the price you pay
- 13:11determines your return, regardless of how good the
- 13:13underlying asset actually is. Right, let's lay out the bull
- 13:16versus bear debate. Then the bulls look at those
- 13:1941.7% gross margins and argue that BMI has successfully
- 13:23executed this structural sauce transition.
- 13:25So, you know, it obviously deserves a massive tech company
- 13:28valuation multiple, Sure. But what is the bear argument?
- 13:31Like if the technology is so good, what is the downside?
- 13:34The bears point to the harsh reality of municipal
- 13:37bureaucracy. Just look at Q1 of 2026, BMI's
- 13:41revenue actually dropped 9% year over year.
- 13:43Dropped, but I thought they were growing.
- 13:45They are structurally that drop wasn't because they lost market
- 13:49share to a competitor, it was totally due to the extreme
- 13:52lumpiness of municipal project approvals and physical
- 13:55installation delays. So even if a city really wants
- 13:58the software, the City Council still argues over the budget for
- 14:01like. Months.
- 14:03Exactly. And then, I don't know, a bad
- 14:04winter storm delays the physical crew from actually digging up
- 14:07the streets to install the meters.
- 14:09Precisely. That lumpiness just proves that
- 14:12despite the beautiful Beacon software dashboard, BMI's
- 14:16revenue recognition is still fundamentally tethered to the
- 14:19slow physical deployment of heavy infrastructure.
- 14:22You just can't download a water meter from the App Store.
- 14:25Yeah, that makes sense. And when you run this reality
- 14:28through the strict Graham and Buffett valuation test from the
- 14:30report, the results are super polarizing.
- 14:33Like BMI passes every single business quality and safety
- 14:37test. Oh yeah.
- 14:37Flying colors. Return on equity pass, debt to
- 14:40equity pass, free cash flow consistency pass.
- 14:43But then it's spectacularly fails the valuation tests.
- 14:46Because of the deep value framework is just ruthless on
- 14:49price. Generally a value investor wants
- 14:51a price to earnings ratio under 15.
- 14:54BMI has been trading at APE multiple between 26 and 33.7 and
- 14:58their price to book ratio is over 6.
- 15:01The market is basically already pricing in years of flawless
- 15:04future growth and placing this enormous premium on their
- 15:06software intangibles. Let's dig into the discounted
- 15:09cash flow models, the DCF, because the math really
- 15:12illustrates the lack of a buffer here.
- 15:13Right. Yeah, The report ran multiple
- 15:15DCF scenarios to find the stocks intrinsic value in a nominal
- 15:19scenario, assuming BMI can somehow maintain its historical
- 15:2310.5% growth rate for another entire decade.
- 15:26Which is tough to do. Very tough, but if they do, the
- 15:29intrinsic value sits around $165 per share.
- 15:33But if you use more conservative cash flow models anticipating
- 15:36those municipal slowdowns we talked about, the intrinsic
- 15:39value drops closer to 126 dollars.
- 15:42And the current stock price mentioned in the report is
- 15:44hovering right in that 125 to 161 range.
- 15:47So it's essentially trading exactly at its intrinsic value
- 15:50right now. Exactly, which leaves absolutely
- 15:52zero room for error. Deep value investing strictly
- 15:55demands a margin of safety. Right.
- 15:57You never want to pay 100 cents for a dollar because you know
- 15:59your growth assumptions might be slightly wrong or some huge
- 16:02macro shock and hit. You want to buy a dollar for
- 16:04$0.70? Yes.
- 16:05Exactly. So to get a true 30% margin of
- 16:07safety on BMI, the stock would physically need to drop to
- 16:10around $115 per share. Which is a pretty big drop from
- 16:13here. The report uses a Peter Lynch
- 16:15framework to explain this transition, which I thought
- 16:18provided a great mental model. Yeah, the Lynch categories,
- 16:21yeah. In Lynch's terms, BMI used to be
- 16:23a fast grower. During the initial rollout
- 16:26phases of these smart meters, they were just compounding
- 16:29earnings at 20% a year, right? But as market penetration
- 16:32naturally gets higher, they are shifting into a stalwart.
- 16:36They are highly reliable, incredibly profitable, and
- 16:39totally immune to debt crises, but they're probably going to
- 16:43grow closer to like 10% a year going forward.
- 16:46And the broader market has already recognized that BMI is
- 16:49no longer just bending brass. They're pricing it as an elite
- 16:52infrastructure digital platform. But paying a 30 PE for a 10%
- 16:56grower is, well, it's the definition of a wonderful
- 17:00company at a fair price rather than a fair company at a
- 17:02wonderful price. It is priced for absolute
- 17:05perfection. And when a stock is priced for
- 17:07perfection, any minor hiccup like a delayed AMI deployment in
- 17:11a major city, or a slight miss on quarterly earnings, or even
- 17:15just a broader macroeconomic shift that compresses high tech
- 17:18multiples, that could send the stock price tumbling even if the
- 17:22underlying business remains perfectly healthy.
- 17:24Exactly, which actually brings us back to that cybersecurity
- 17:27tail risk we flagged earlier. Oh, right, let's talk about
- 17:30that. As BMI successfully turns these
- 17:3250,000 fragmented water districts into a centralized
- 17:36cloud connected nervous system, the threat vector changes
- 17:39completely. Yeah, I mean, we've seen
- 17:40ransomware attacks, parallel hospital networks and oil
- 17:43pipelines. If a major municipalities beacon
- 17:46dashboard gets compromised, what actually happens?
- 17:49It's terrifying to model, honestly.
- 17:50A hacker wouldn't just be stealing credit card data.
- 17:52They could potentially manipulate the flow data,
- 17:55tricking the software into ignoring massive main breaks.
- 17:57Oh wow. Or worse, they could target the
- 17:59wastewater systems like Smart Cover, blinding the city to
- 18:02rising sewer levels until raw sewage physically backs up into
- 18:06residential homes. That is horrifying, and that is
- 18:09a vulnerability built directly into the digital.
- 18:13Like the analog meters were super inefficient, sure, but
- 18:16they were unhackable. Now, a single major breach could
- 18:19trigger a catastrophic loss of confidence from those highly
- 18:23conservative city councils. Right, they might pause their
- 18:26tech rollouts entirely, which would just absolutely shatter
- 18:29that high PE multiple. It is a risk that simply it
- 18:32doesn't show up in a spreadsheet or ADCF model today.
- 18:35But as the digital water cycle becomes the standard, securing
- 18:38that data becomes just as vital as securing the physical water
- 18:41itself. 100%. So what does this all mean for
- 18:43you? Listening.
- 18:45How do you categorize Badger Bidder in your own portfolio
- 18:48strategy? If you lean towards strict value
- 18:50investing, BMI goes straight onto your watch list in bold
- 18:53ink. You understand the impenetrable
- 18:5520 year Moat, you respect the weaponized balance sheet, and
- 18:57then you just sit on your hands. UE for a broader market panic, a
- 19:01temporary municipal funding delay, or some overblown
- 19:03earnings miss to drag the price down to that $115.00 margin of
- 19:07safety. Conversely, if you are a growth
- 19:09oriented investor or if your mandate focuses on long term
- 19:12climate resilience and ESG, you have a much tougher decision.
- 19:16You have to evaluate whether their beacon software
- 19:18subscriptions can actually continue growing at 27% year
- 19:21over year, right? If they can maintain that hyper
- 19:23growth in the sauce segment and successfully upsell the storm
- 19:27and sewer monitoring to all their clean water clients, well
- 19:30that premium multiple might actually be justified in the
- 19:33long run it. Really is a brilliant case study
- 19:35of an industrial dinosaur successfully rewriting its own
- 19:38DNA without alienating its core customer base.
- 19:42Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 19:46and may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 19:50All contents from this channel is for educational and research
- 19:53purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 19:56Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 19:59decisions. If you like to access wider
- 20:01topics, including life and investing philosophy, please
- 20:04subscribe to our sister channel Deep Values.
- 20:06Don't forget to like this video. Much appreciated.