Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Halfway Home, Charging Standard Light Speed, Costco’s Cheers and Jeers w/ Todd Caputo
Transcript
- 0:00[gentle music] All right, it is the last day of the month, a Friday close. Half of the year is gonna be closed. We're heading into a long weekend. Well, some people have a long weekend.
- 0:10So we're gonna talk about these charging standard wars and Costco. Everywhere I go. Seems like a rare combination- People wanna know... for a Friday, but it'll all make sense. Who I is and where they can cop this.
- 0:17We have special guest, Todd Caputo, in the studio, or his studio today. Todd, good morning. Watch for me, tip my hat to the side. Morning, Paul. Good to see you, my friend. How are you? It's good to see you, too.
- 0:25Good to see you, too. Yeah. You got some new lighting on that picture behind you. Yeah. Uh, you recommended it, so I did what you told me to do. [laughs] Well, you know, I wasn't trying to get a compliment there.
- 0:34You know, your, your store, um, you know, your store, it was so cool. Like, you...
- 0:39So Todd crafted this used car store experience that had all this vintage, like, these vintage photos, and it, it just had such an energy to it. You just always had a good, good taste for that.
- 0:50And you're, you're one of the guys in the car industry that's an actual car guy. I love cars. Right, like an enthusiast, not just a car guy- Yeah... but, like, a car guy.
- 1:00I might love cars more than I like people, but I'm not sure. [laughs] You, you might, I think you might l- like, love cars more than you like people, but I think you still- Yeah... love people more than you love cars.
- 1:10I know I don't. We don't get these. We don't get these. [laughs] All right. But, yeah, I do, I do have a passion for cars, you know that. We have an all-out comment war going on.
- 1:17I'm just gonna pivot through these, because now it's a thing where everyone tries to get the first comment on the show.
- 1:22If you're, if you're listening to the podcast, there's also a live stream in the morning, and LinkedIn seems to be where it's all going down. Uh, it's good to see you, Jordan, Russell, Adrian, uh, Brian.
- 1:31Man, everybody's just showing up for some fun. Uh, we're gonna give you a nice quick show today. We wanna make sure that you know, though, that ASOTU CON is coming in hot.
- 1:39Today is the very, very last day to get the cheapest ASOTU CON ticket. Prices go up, and then they're gonna ratchet up as we get closer. You can go to asotucon.com and get the cheapest ticket you can get.
- 1:52Today is the last day. Prices go up on the 1st, which is tomorrow, and we're about to release, uh, probably a list of about 20 speakers, 25 speakers that are confirmed, and we're talking about publicly traded groups.
- 2:03We're talking about people that you see on TV that you wanna see in person. We got Jesse Cole, the owner of the Savannah Bananas, is gonna be our main keynote.
- 2:10So, uh, first round of speaker announcements coming next week. So, you know. I can't wait. I, I mean- You, you're one of them...
- 2:17you know, like, when you talk about there's a lot of conferences, there's tons of them, and you can get conferenced to death if you want to in this business. Easy, easy.
- 2:25But, you know, that event you put on last year, um, in Philly was just, it was really cool. It was different.
- 2:31Um, a- a- and the social aspect of it and the group of people that come is amazing, that you're able to get together.
- 2:36So I'm looking forward to, to, to Baltimore this year, uh, for sure, and I think anybody that, uh, wants to spend a little bit of time and meet some great people and just not go to a typical conference should definitely consider going, 'cause I think it's gonna be awesome.
- 2:48I'm glad you mentioned the city. Baltimore, uh, it's only about five minutes from the airport. We wanted to keep it convenient so you don't have that, like, terrible one-hour commute in a big city somewhere.
- 2:57Land at the airport, five minutes later you're in the venue. Uh, September 26th and 27th, so put that on your calendar. All right, let's talk about some news. So, uh, we're gonna follow up on a few things.
- 3:07I think you're the perfect guest host for today because we're gonna talk about the charging standard, and, uh, you own a Tesla EV, or a couple of them. So here's the story.
- 3:15As the mass adoption of Tesla's NACS, which is North American Charging Standard, uh, has been dominating the news, the transition might not be just as simple as we think.
- 3:24So, um, yesterday a couple more people added to the list.
- 3:27Polestar adopted the standard and, uh, the first only EV motorcycle manufacturer, Verge Motorcycles, which are real cool, by the way, uh, they announced their shift to the Tesla standard.
- 3:37And then Electrify America, which is a, a majori- Volkswagen owns a majority of this company. It was basically kind of their, their penance from Dieselgate. They, they put [laughs] this big charging network up.
- 3:48They announced that they're gonna now include the NACS standard o- all of their Superchargers, which is about 3,500 currently. They're gonna i- change all those over to Superchargers by 2025.
- 3:59Still gonna have the, the current CCS, uh, uh, standard available as well. Now, here are the challenges.
- 4:05So there's your great automo- automotive news article today talking about the things maybe we w- aren't thinking of that make it a little more complex than just like, "Okay, we'll just put the adapter on the end.
- 4:14It's not like a cell phone." So, um, challenges: software development on the vehicle.
- 4:19They need to be able to talk to one another, because if you've never been to a ch- Tesla Supercharger, they don't have a screen or an interface.
- 4:25It just automatically connects with the hand- the car and the handshake when you plug it in, and your app, so you gotta be able to pay for it and know what's charging.
- 4:33Um, all Tesla charging ports in all their vehicles are in the left rear of the vehicle. They're designed that way for uniformity so when the, you back into a Tesla Supercharger, everyone can back in in a line.
- 4:45Well, as you may know, that's not the case. Some chargers are in the front grill.
- 4:48Um, they could be on the opposite side of the vehicle across other manufacturers, leading to, like, some at the current rate would have to take up two spaces in order to charge, which is gonna obviously cause some problems, maybe even some fights.
- 5:00Um, you know, the pins are different in the plug, so even though the adapter might look the same, um, you know, the pins are a little bit different.
- 5:07And, you know, thinking of all those considerations, that leads to manufacturing changes potentially with all these cars to route ports to the different side, to stamp parts a different way.
- 5:18So, um, you know, a lot of different problems. Tesla released a statement and then, Todd, I wanna get your opinion.
- 5:23Tesla's statement said, "It's always been our ambition to open the Supercharger network to non-Tesla EVs, and by doing so, encourage more drivers to go electric.
- 5:31More customers using the Supercharger network enables faster expansion.
- 5:34Our goal is to learn and iterate quickly while continually and aggressively expanding the network so we eventually welcome both Tesla and non-Tesla drivers to Superchargers worldwide."
- 5:45Todd, did you think about these questions when, you know, when Ford announced they were gonna be able to charge and then, you know, like, on and on and on? Here's what, you know, I think about.
- 5:55It's not about the plug, and it's not about where it is. It's about how long it takes to actually charge a car. Yeah. Uh, and in order for these things to be adopted en masse-They gotta charge really, really fast.
- 6:09Like, they need to charge as fast as, uh, it takes to go to the gas station and pump your own gas. You can pump your own gas in a very short period of time- Mm-hmm... I don't know, three minutes, four minutes. Yep.
- 6:18You think people are gonna line up and wait f- 20 minutes, a half an hour, and there's gonna be lines and lines of people? It's not gonna happen. It just, it just won't happen. That's number one.
- 6:28I think number two, you know, I've been reading some stuff that Steve Greenfield has been publishing recently about, um, you know, the technology changes.
- 6:36Every year the technology's gonna get better and better with these EVs, and you're gonna have cars that have longer range, that probably charge faster- Mm-hmm...
- 6:43right, and operate just more efficiently and have better features. The, th- these used EVs may depreciate a lot faster if they don't have updated technology, because they're almost gonna be obsolete.
- 6:55Does that make sense? Wow. It does. I mean, I mean, any car, like, it, it does- You can, you can take and drive a 30 or 40 or 50 or 80-year-old car, right? I do. I got old cars.
- 7:04I can just go to the gas station and pump it up and leave, right? Um, and pump up with gas.
- 7:08But if you've got a, a car that won't charge necessarily as fast, um, as a late-model one, um, I don't think it's gonna be worth as much. Oh, sure. Yeah.
- 7:17So it's the speed of what it takes to actually charge these EVs which I think is the key. Can they build charging stations all over? Yes.
- 7:26Can they make a longer cord if the, if the port's in the front or in the grill or in the left front fender, whatever? Yeah. I mean, that's- Practical... the easy part. Can they figure out the software?
- 7:34Of course they can figure out the software so it interacts with Tesla's network. That's not a problem. But I, I think the key to mass adoption with these things is they gotta be able to charge faster.
- 7:42They're not gonna be... They're, they, they won't be mass consumption until then. Yeah. You know, it, I think it did mention something about that in the article, about the, the...
- 7:51There are some vehicles that, that take power faster than a Tesla. Like, I think the Polestars will take power faster, and the Supercharger will actually limit the actual capability of the vehicle.
- 8:01So that's, that's a great point to make.
- 8:03And yeah, like think of the, the issue the used car market's gonna be facing in three or four years from now when they start to figure this stuff out and they change the standard, and all of a sudden everything that's the new standard- Mm-hmm...
- 8:15won't go as fast as the old standard. It's gonna... Yeah, it'll create a thing. Well, look, look at, look at what NADA said the other day about the day's supply of new EVs in the market.
- 8:23I would, I'm gonna say 90 days, I think it was. Yeah. They said it's like above ice. And, and it's- Yeah...
- 8:27and, and if you look at the day supply of used EVs, especially Teslas in most markets, um, it's, it's creeping up there, right?
- 8:35Uh, people are getting their taste, and I, I think at the end of the day, most people, uh, des- depending on where they live, are gonna have range anxiety. Mm. And, um, there needs to be a lot more of these chargers.
- 8:47And then in a... think about what, what about the grid, right? Just think about- Oh, I've been thinking about that... the grid and the EV. I brought that up on the show yesterday.
- 8:53It's like, "We can't put the air conditioners on right now because it's too hot." Yeah. So it's- Yeah... got a long way to go, and I don't think that these gas-powered cars are gonna go away anytime soon. I just don't.
- 9:03Ah, there you go. Well, speaking of, uh, I don't know. I don't know. We're gonna go back to your comment about range anxiety. Speaking of anxiety. Stop. Need a Segway or something. Segway time.
- 9:13[upbeat music] [laughs] Okay, so Costco has identi- intensified its enforcement of its membership policy with employees now asking to see shoppers' membership IDs with their photo on it at the self-checkout lanes, drawing both cheers and jeers.
- 9:28So basically, when the company opened their self-checkout lines in the stores, um, they noticed an increase in card sharing, and it's like Net- Netflix password sharing basically.
- 9:38You give a friend a card, they go in and get all the benefits of a membership.
- 9:41Um, so what you may not know about Costco's, uh, business model is they sell their products so, uh, on such a thin margin, the only profit they actually make as a company is from membership fees.
- 9:51Chief Financial Officer Richard Galanti, uh, said during Costco's May 25th earnings call that, "At some point we'll raise rates on the membership, um, but inflation is a reason that we're waiting."
- 10:01He said, "Our view right now is we have enough levers out there to drive business, and we feel it's incumbent upon us to be a beacon of light to our members in terms of holding the membership fees down for now."
- 10:11Um, and so what one of those levers is obviously they're gonna enforce the membership requirement a little bit tighter. One shopper says, "I'll pay extra to shop somewhere to get good prices." Um,
- 10:22and she said, "It's not fair to have multiple people using one membership card," because if you know Costco, like, they do sell out of items.
- 10:29She's like, "And now these non-members that aren't paying are getting the item that I wanted to buy."
- 10:34Um, you know, some other people said, "You know, it, it causes anxiety now that I feel like I'm getting kind of policed at the checkout lane." And so, um, Co- Todd, I know you have a Costco membership.
- 10:43I don't know how often you go. I've noticed, um, I don't mind because I, I like, I, I'm a, I like following that rule because that's how they make their system work.
- 10:50But what's your think- what's your, what's your thought on, like, is it worth hassling your members to enforce, you know, the non-members? I, I mean, I don't know. First of all, I hate shopping, right?
- 11:01[laughs] I hate going to stores. [laughs] It's, ugh, I dread it. Amy goes, my wife, she, she, she goes to Costco and, and, um,
- 11:09I, I just, you know, at the end of the day, they can say that they only make money on membership fees, but I don't necessarily believe that. Um, I, I find that very hard to believe, number one.
- 11:18No, it's, it's their profit. Their profit. They, they run on, like, a one, a one to 2% margin. And when you look at their membership count, it's billions and billions on the membership fee.
- 11:28That's just how they've structured the business. Well, from- That, that is, like, kind of business case study...
- 11:31from, from a membership, so from a membership standpoint, I feel like if you have to be a member to shop there, then you should just pay for it, right?
- 11:38I think it's dishonest to use somebody else's card, uh, to get in there and shop. So I guess I can understand why people that are members, um, you know, feel that way.
- 11:47And, um, what does it cost for a membership for a year? I don't even know. 60 bucks a year. I mean, come on. 60 bucks a year? Yeah. I mean, people should just pay.
- 11:54I mean- And actually, if you get the Costco credit card, you make way more than that back in, like, the refunds they give you.
- 12:00You know, one of the things Costco has been so known for is their return policy, which is one of the reasons they need the extra, the extra margin, and they allocate, like, their, their sales margins toward that.
- 12:10Because you can return anything at any time for any reason. They will literally take it back. I, I saw- Yeah... I saw plants, I saw, like, a stack of trees that was returned. They were never taken out of the pot.
- 12:21Somebody probably just left them out and didn't water them, and they were returned. They'll take that back. Two years later something breaks, they'll take that back. And so, you know, I'm a, I'm a big fan of Costco.
- 12:30Uh, my family shops there a lot. And, like, hey, systems don't work when you, when you don't follow the rules, which is why Netflix- Well-... cracked down too on password sharing. Sorta.
- 12:38I think people still found ways to- [laughs]... you know, they're like, "Oh." I mean, I don't have Netflix anymore. I just find- You know- I find my way other ways... yeah, I, I, I think that, uh,
- 12:48you know, follow the rules, right? I mean, it's s- it's 60 bucks. I mean, 60 bucks is a lot of money, don't get me wrong.
- 12:53But if in the grand scheme is if you can afford to shop at Costco on a weekly basis, you can afford the 60 bucks. John Roper comments, "Needed this!" Exclamation point.
- 13:01"I'll stop letting the non-members [laughs] use my card." No, John, you don't need to do that. You just need to get them a disguise so they look like the picture on the membership card when they go through.
- 13:10Well, that's the show for today. We're about to head into the All Things Used Car with David Long Clubhouse room. Go to Clubhouse, search it up. We'll be over there jamming on used cars.
- 13:19Until then, have a great weekend and welcome to July tomorrow. [upbeat music]