Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Eavesdropping, Consent, and the Law: What Every Attorney Needs to Know About Penal Code §632 with Arash Hashemi
Transcript
- 0:02Hello everyone, and welcome to Eve's Dropping,
- 0:06Consent and the Law, What Every Attorney Needs
- 0:09to Know about Penal Code Section 632. I'm Alapoli
- 0:13Castro, CLE advisor for the Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:15Association, and today I am delighted to introduce
- 0:18our speaker, Arash Hashemi. Arash is the founder
- 0:22of the law offices of Arash Hashemi. Arash handles
- 0:26a wide variety of criminal cases from petty theft
- 0:29to complex felonies, including murder, with a
- 0:32particular focus on self -defense cases. He represents
- 0:35thousands of Californians accused of violating
- 0:38paration or parole, including before the California
- 0:41of Appeals. Arash is a frequent volunteer at
- 0:44the Massero Free Legal Clinic in South Los Angeles,
- 0:47and recent past president of the Criminal Courts
- 0:50Bar Association. And now let's get started. Evening,
- 0:53everyone. How are you? As you heard, my name
- 0:55is Arash Hashemi. So I do have some slides up.
- 0:59I'm sure you've all gotten these. I'm going to
- 1:01jump around a little bit. I'm going to try to
- 1:03stick with the slides, but I'm going to jump
- 1:04around. So let's talk about Penal Code 36. 632.
- 1:09The first thing I want to do is talk about the
- 1:13learning objectives. So we're going to talk about
- 1:15the penal code itself. But before we go into
- 1:18these learning objectives, let's read the penal
- 1:21code. So in practice, criminal defense at least,
- 1:25as a young lawyer I was taught, whenever your
- 1:27client is charged with a certain penal code,
- 1:29first thing you should do is read the penal code
- 1:31because you're going to get the elements of the
- 1:34crimes that are being accused. So let's read
- 1:36this penal code. California Penal Code 632. A,
- 1:41a person who intentionally and without consent
- 1:44of all parties to a confidential communication,
- 1:48who uses an electronic amplifying or recording
- 1:51device to eavesdrop upon the record, the confidential
- 1:58communication, whether the confidential is carried.
- 2:01on among the parties in the presence of another
- 2:03or by means of a telegraph telephone or any other
- 2:06device except a radio shall be punished. There's
- 2:11more to it but let's talk about that. The reason
- 2:13I wanted to read that is sorry I was reading
- 2:18the I thought there was a question so California
- 2:21is a two -party consent rule. We have to understand
- 2:27the California's two -party consent rule. Now,
- 2:29if you remember in law school, law school was
- 2:33a long time ago for me, but they were talking
- 2:35about two -party consent and one -party consent
- 2:38when it came to certain laws. California is a
- 2:41two -party consent rule, meaning that both parties
- 2:44in the conversation have to give consent for
- 2:47the conversation to be recorded. This actually,
- 2:50the penal code was put into place in 1967. They
- 2:56were worried about advancing technology back
- 3:00then advancing technology back then was the personal
- 3:03tape recorder so they were worried about privacy
- 3:06so they enacted this penal code so you are found
- 3:12guilty of a crime if you violate these key elements
- 3:19one is intentional it has to be intentional you
- 3:22intentionally record the conversation two you
- 3:25use an electronic device to eavesdrop or record.
- 3:30Now, what does eavesdrop or record mean? You
- 3:32don't necessarily have to record the conversation.
- 3:35You can eavesdrop on it. So if you've seen in
- 3:38some of those movies where there's the PI sitting
- 3:42across the street and he has this amplified thing
- 3:44where he can hear conversations across the street
- 3:47really well, he might not be recording, but he's
- 3:50eavesdropping. So Penal Code 6... Three, two
- 3:54applies to them because it's eavesdropping. So
- 3:56it's not just recording, but it's also eavesdropping.
- 3:59And then it has to involve a confidential communication.
- 4:02That is key, confidential communication. We'll
- 4:05get back to that again. And it has to be without
- 4:08consent of all parties. So if one party consents
- 4:11and the other one doesn't, then you're in trouble.
- 4:14Let's go back to the example of the PI. The PI
- 4:17is eavesdropping on someone. It's two people
- 4:19having a conversation. He's eavesdropping on
- 4:21them. He's not involved. So he's not part of
- 4:24the consent. But let's change the example. I'm
- 4:27talking to you and I'm recording you. You're
- 4:31not knowing. So I consented to the recording
- 4:34because I'm the one actually doing it, but you
- 4:36haven't consented to it. You don't know about
- 4:38it. that's where I get into trouble. So the consent
- 4:42part doesn't apply to the eavesdropper because
- 4:46he doesn't need to give consent. He's not part
- 4:48of the two parties to clear it up. So it is a
- 4:52misdemeanor effect. It's punishable by a fine
- 4:56up to $2 ,500 per violation and imprisonment
- 5:01and county jail up to a year. misdemeanor offenses
- 5:05in California, you can only go to county jail
- 5:08for up to a year, no more than that. And the
- 5:11fine maximum could be 10 ,000, and this is 2
- 5:13,500 per incident. And there's also civil liability.
- 5:17The civil liability is defined under penal code
- 5:2036, I'm sorry, 637 .2. We'll get to that as well.
- 5:27So these are our learning objectives. We're gonna
- 5:30talk about the... two -party consent rule, identify
- 5:33what qualifies as confidential communication,
- 5:37distinguish between what's lawful and not lawful,
- 5:41recognize the key exceptions and defenses, navigate
- 5:44evidentiary issues and advise and how you should
- 5:46advise your clients. I do have some more stories
- 5:48I will talk to you about. So again, Penal code,
- 5:52the 632, the overview is prohibits intentional
- 5:56recording of confidential communication. Now,
- 5:59intentional is a key word you have to pay attention
- 6:01to. If I'm talking to you and my cell phone is
- 6:06recording. and I didn't know about it because
- 6:08it was recording from a private conversation
- 6:10or it was recording because, I don't know, my
- 6:14assistant had accidentally touched it or my kids
- 6:17were playing in the background and it was recording.
- 6:20Later on, I find out it was recording. It has
- 6:23to be intentional, OK? At the time, it wasn't
- 6:25intentional. So can you go on and say later if
- 6:29I used it, then it becomes intentional? Maybe.
- 6:31We'll get to that. It applies to phone. and in
- 6:34-person and electronic conversations. So phone
- 6:38conversations, if I'm having a phone conversation
- 6:40with you and I'm recording it, that is one of
- 6:44these intentional recordings that's confidential.
- 6:48If you notice you call some call centers and
- 6:50say, this call may be recorded for operating
- 6:53purposes, they're actually telling you, okay?
- 6:56So you agreeing to... continue with that call
- 6:59is you giving them consent. So later you can't
- 7:02come back and say, oh, you violated my rights
- 7:05and you were recording me. They gave you notice
- 7:08in the beginning and you didn't object to it.
- 7:11So that's consent. Technology is great in my
- 7:14office. Our system has AI taking notes. So if
- 7:19I'm talking to a client, it will say AI is taking
- 7:22notes. Obviously, I tell my clients, hey, I'm
- 7:24going to take notes so I can have this conversation
- 7:26later. It's confidential. It's still going to
- 7:29be confidential. It's going to be in your file.
- 7:31But we give them notice. If some of my clients
- 7:34say, no, I don't want you to take notes. And
- 7:36sometimes I don't want to take notes because
- 7:37I'm talking to them about their case. So we turn
- 7:39that feature off. But If that feature is on and
- 7:43mean not telling them and the feature itself
- 7:45says AI is taking notes and the client doesn't
- 7:48say anything, they've consented. Obviously, the
- 7:51attorney -client privilege still sticks there.
- 7:53I'm just giving that an example. And then the
- 7:56violation could be criminal or civil, meaning
- 7:59that if you don't get charged for it, you could
- 8:03also get sued for it. The other party could sue
- 8:06you for it. We'll get to that part. And then
- 8:09California Penal Code 632A is where the elements
- 8:13we were talking about is. Let me see. OK. I just
- 8:18wanted to make sure that the questions or the
- 8:21chat wasn't for me. OK. So let's talk about the
- 8:24next slide. I don't know if it's working or not.
- 8:28OK. This slide doesn't say. Oh, there we go.
- 8:30OK. So defined in 632C. there has to be a reasonable
- 8:35expectation of privacy. And then the case is
- 8:39Flanagan versus Flanagan. But before I get to
- 8:41that case, let's talk about, we talked about
- 8:46the legislative intent. Let's talk about the
- 8:48reasonable expectation of privacy. But before
- 8:53that, what is the confidential communication?
- 8:55So. The expectation of privacy is what creates
- 8:58the confidential communication. The definition
- 9:02from statute is a communication in which the
- 9:05parties reasonably expect it to be confined to
- 9:08themselves. As lawyers, you know that reasonable
- 9:11reasonably is one of the main keywords in our
- 9:15line of work. And in this penal code and in this
- 9:18scenario, that word comes up again. reasonable.
- 9:21You're going to hear it a lot when you're talking
- 9:23about this. So the legal interpretation of a
- 9:27reasonable confidential communication is in Flanagan,
- 9:30which I cited for you here. If you need the citation,
- 9:33if you don't have the slides, I'll be happy to
- 9:35give them to you. It's a communication, it's
- 9:39confidential, if a party reasonably expects that
- 9:43no one is eavesdropping or overhearing, and then
- 9:46it's a subjective objective test. What does that
- 9:49mean? Let's talk about that. The speaker must
- 9:52have an actual expectation of privacy, and the
- 9:54expectation must be reasonable. So it's subjective,
- 9:57objective. So subjective means I, personally
- 10:01me, have a reasonable expectation of privacy.
- 10:04The objective part comes in, is my expectation
- 10:08of privacy reasonable? Meaning that if anybody
- 10:12else, the majority of the public were in my shoe,
- 10:15would they have that same expectation of privacy?
- 10:18Example of it is, I'm sitting in a coffee shop
- 10:21and I'm talking to you. I think that our private
- 10:25conversation is confidential, right? Is it reasonable?
- 10:30Is my thought reasonable? I would argue no, it's
- 10:32not. Because we're in a crowded coffee shop,
- 10:35even though I have a reasonable expectation of
- 10:37privacy that reasonable expectation wouldn't
- 10:41meet the objective test. It meets the subjective
- 10:44test because I have that reasonable expectation,
- 10:47but my reasonable expectation is not really reasonable
- 10:50when it comes to the objective test. So if the
- 10:54table next to me at the coffee shop is recording
- 10:56my conversation and I don't know, I'm talking
- 10:58business and my rival gets a hold of that conversation,
- 11:02I can't come back and say it's an invasion of
- 11:04privacy under this penal code because I had a
- 11:07reasonable expectation of privacy because it's
- 11:10not an objective reasonable expectation. Excuse
- 11:14me. Some more examples are in -home discussions.
- 11:19Private phone calls personal conversations in
- 11:22a closed office. Those are confidential. Okay,
- 11:25I'm having a confidential Talk with my client,
- 11:30right? Well, the office walls here are thin.
- 11:34So the office next to me is a lawyer as well,
- 11:37but he could hear my my My conversations, right?
- 11:42So in my Expectation reasonable. Yes because
- 11:48I'm in a closed office, so he can't go and talk
- 11:52about what I talked about. A lot of conversation
- 11:56in the crowded restaurant is just like the example
- 11:58I gave you at Starbucks. You're sitting across
- 12:00all that is not reasonable. Objectively is not
- 12:03reasonable. Subjectively, it could be, but it
- 12:06doesn't. It has to meet both criteria. Subjective
- 12:09and then it goes objective. Objective is the
- 12:12most important one in that test, and it has to
- 12:14be reasonable. objectively. So let's talk about
- 12:21Flanagan versus Flanagan. In Flanagan versus
- 12:25Flanagan, the son recorded phone conversations
- 12:28with his parents without their knowledge during
- 12:30a family business dispute. And then the parents
- 12:34sued him under this penal code. The Supreme Court
- 12:38clarified that confidentiality turns on the expectation
- 12:42of privacy. The existence of hostility or litigation
- 12:46does not automatically eliminate confidentiality.
- 12:51So in Flanagan they're having a family business
- 12:55dispute and you know it's hostile and the son
- 12:58recorded him. The court said even though it's
- 13:00a hostile and the hostility exists there, that
- 13:04doesn't mean the expectation of privacy is out
- 13:06the window. And then You can use this argument
- 13:11both in civil and criminal cases. So and then
- 13:16let's go back to This this this case is called
- 13:21Rio versus Superior Court now Flanagan is from
- 13:252002 but Flanagan used Freo versus Superior Court,
- 13:29which is a 1988 case and out of that ruling came
- 13:34what we call the FRIO test. F -R -I -O is the
- 13:37name of the case. So the facts of that case are
- 13:40FRIO is a record producer. He was secretly recording
- 13:44telephone conversations with business associates
- 13:47via his answering machine back in the day. He
- 13:52would later review those notes and create deposition
- 13:57notes that he planned to testify to. So he would
- 14:01record conversations, using his answering machine,
- 14:04listen to those conversations, and then write
- 14:08down notes from those conversations because he
- 14:10was going to plan to testify on them at depositions.
- 14:14The trial court barred his testimony under Penal
- 14:18Code 632, Section D, which exclude evidence obtained
- 14:23as a result of recording a confidential communication
- 14:26in violation of 632. It went to the appellate
- 14:29court, which was reserved. They said that Frio's
- 14:33independent testimony recounting his first -hand
- 14:36conversation even if refreshed by notes from
- 14:39recordings was not evidence obtained as a result
- 14:43of unlawful eavesdropping and therefore admissible.
- 14:46So what did the what did the appeal court say?
- 14:48The appeal court said look Frio is is testifying
- 14:53from his own memory, right? He had the conversation.
- 14:58Me and him were talking. He recorded me on the
- 15:00answering machine. Then he went back and listened
- 15:02to our conversation, took notes, and testified.
- 15:06He's testifying from his memory. He might be
- 15:08using those notes to refresh his memory and testify
- 15:14to it, but he wasn't actually introducing those
- 15:17recordings into evidence. So his testimony is
- 15:21allowed. So the appellate court reversed the
- 15:27lower chord. So what does that mean? Well, that
- 15:31just created a little niche. So you have to actually
- 15:36show that the evidence being used was unlawfully
- 15:40recorded. Now, the unlawful recording that Frio
- 15:44had wasn't actually being introduced in this
- 15:46case. He was using it to refresh his memory,
- 15:49so it was allowed. So the takeaways from that
- 15:53case is Only actual recordings or derivative
- 15:58evidence obtained directly from the recording
- 16:01device are excluded, not firsthand testimony
- 16:05from participants in the conversation. It's exactly
- 16:08what I was telling you. He was using the recordings
- 16:11to refresh his memory, so his testimony was allowed.
- 16:16And then there is participant immunity doctrine,
- 16:18which arrived from Freer v. Superior Court, and
- 16:22I have the citation if you need it. I don't know
- 16:24if I have it in my slides. I noticed this morning
- 16:27it was missing, and it's 203 Cal App 3D 1480.
- 16:33If you need that, I'll be happy to email it to
- 16:36you. Just let me know. So a person who was a
- 16:39party to the conversation retains the right to
- 16:42testify about it, regardless of whether he made
- 16:45a recording, provided the testimonies based on
- 16:48memory, rather than the recording itself, right?
- 16:52So let me give you an example. If you ever handle
- 16:55traffic tickets, traffic tickets actually go
- 16:57into criminal court. You have every single right
- 17:01as any criminal case except the right to a jury
- 17:04trial. You don't have a right to a jury trial.
- 17:06You don't have some other certain rights, but
- 17:08you have all other rights. So the officer...
- 17:11uh is supposed to come when you have a bench
- 17:14trial and if he doesn't come the case gets dismissed
- 17:17why is that because the officer is sort of the
- 17:20witness right he has to testify now one of the
- 17:24things that we do when i say we i mean criminal
- 17:27defense attorneys or people who fight traffic
- 17:29tickets when the officer starts reading from
- 17:31his notes we object right because he is actually
- 17:35supposed to have independent recollection. He's
- 17:38supposed to remember what happened without reading
- 17:42from his notes or reading from his report. Now,
- 17:46he can use his report to refresh his memory.
- 17:49And it's like that in other criminal cases, too.
- 17:52And I'm sure it's like that in civil. You know,
- 17:55someone testifies and they say something that's
- 17:58different. You say, well, remember on this day
- 18:01you took a deposition or remember you wrote this
- 18:03report? uh isn't that what did you say and they
- 18:06go well i don't remember like if you look at
- 18:08your deposition or if you look at your report
- 18:10would that freshen your memory and you approach
- 18:13give it to them they read it so they're not actually
- 18:16introducing their report at that point into evidence
- 18:19they're using their report to refresh your memory
- 18:21and it's the same thing here the recording can
- 18:24be used to refresh your memory and that's acceptable
- 18:27you can't bring the recording in as evidence
- 18:30um The defense that you could use in this, even
- 18:36when the recording exists, you can argue that
- 18:39your client being part of the conversation can
- 18:44lawfully testify based on their own personal
- 18:47recollection, right? So that's the argument that
- 18:54you would bring in, right? if 632 is being used
- 18:58against you. I'm sorry, let me clear that up.
- 18:59If it's being used against you, that's the argument
- 19:01you would use. And then the FRIO test that we
- 19:07were talking about is a two -part analysis. The
- 19:11court established a two -pronged test. And the
- 19:15first one is, was the evidence obtained as a
- 19:18result of an illegal recording? It focuses on
- 19:22whether the evidence directly stems from an unlawful
- 19:25act or recording of a confidential communication
- 19:27without consent. So if the first prong is, no,
- 19:31the evidence wasn't obtained from an illegal
- 19:33recording, well, you don't have a problem there.
- 19:36It's done. It's a legal recording. It could be
- 19:38brought in. But if it was obtained from a legal
- 19:42recording, then you go to prong two, and that's
- 19:45if the evidence can be shown to have an independent
- 19:47source, such as the participant's memory, it
- 19:51is not considered fruit of the illegal recording
- 19:55or fruit of the poisonous tree, it may be admissible.
- 19:59So it's what we were talking about. So that's
- 20:01the two -pronged test. Was it obtained illegally?
- 20:04And if it was obtained illegally, is it something
- 20:08that the person can testify to by memory without
- 20:11having to use or bring in the recording, right?
- 20:16So that's where the FRIO test comes in. Also
- 20:22in FRIO, the court held that although the defendant
- 20:26had illegally recorded a conversation, his own
- 20:29recollection of those conversations were not
- 20:32obtained and obtained as in quotes as a result
- 20:35of the recording, right? So he didn't learn about
- 20:40the recording and testify. He was part of the
- 20:44recording. Let me rephrase that. Okay, so let's
- 20:47use the same example. Rio is having these conversations.
- 20:50He records them on the answering machine. Then
- 20:54Jack gets a hold of those recordings. Jack listens
- 20:58to those recordings. And then Jack takes the
- 21:01stand to testify. Jack's testimony is not gonna
- 21:06be allowed because his own recollection, Jack's
- 21:10recollection was not. was obtained as a result
- 21:15of the recordings, right? He wasn't part of the
- 21:18conversation. He wasn't originally there to talk
- 21:20about, you know, yeah, I talked to Joe, Joe told
- 21:23me this. He wasn't there. He listened to the
- 21:26conversation and his memory of the conversation
- 21:29is from the illegal recording themselves. Whereas
- 21:33in Fria was part of the conversation, his testimony
- 21:37or his memory is from part of the conversation.
- 21:41He used the recording conversation to refresh
- 21:44his memory. Excuse me. So. Again, because his
- 21:50ability, when we say his ability, we're talking
- 21:52about the person testifying, because his ability
- 21:54to testify came from his direct participation,
- 21:58not the recording, that the testimony was not
- 22:00barred, okay? So that's where we go. So this
- 22:04is a crucial test for defense attorneys, at least
- 22:06in criminal cases. It protects clients from blanket
- 22:09suppression when they were a participant in the
- 22:12conversation and can testify from personal memory.
- 22:15And that's if it comes to your benefit, right?
- 22:18You have this evidence. You want to introduce
- 22:22it. Your client wants to testify about it. It's
- 22:25going to help you in your case. The other side
- 22:27is arguing that, no, it's a confidential recording.
- 22:30It was recorded without the consent of the other
- 22:32party. California has a two -party consent jurisdiction,
- 22:37so it can't be brought in. If, as the attorney,
- 22:40you can argue that your client's testimony, a
- 22:44memory of the conversation is obtained not directly
- 22:48from those recordings, those recordings are used
- 22:50to refresh his memory, then you can get that
- 22:52evidence in. It also limits exclusion to only
- 22:58the unlawfully obtained recordings and any evidence
- 23:01directly derived from them. It's a very, very,
- 23:07very fine test when you get to it. So let me
- 23:15go to the next slide. Yeah, Flanagan against
- 23:19Flanagan. We were just talking about it. So and
- 23:22then Criminal and civil exposure. Let's talk
- 23:25about this. So PC 632 is a wobbler a misdemeanor
- 23:29or felony in criminal law We have what we call
- 23:31a wobbler So, you know a wobbler could be a felony
- 23:35could go be be a misdemeanor misdemeanor could
- 23:37be a felony or a Misdemeanor could be infraction
- 23:41infraction could be a misdemeanor. So there are
- 23:43certain crimes that could be wobblers battery
- 23:46could be wobbler, this could be a wobbler, so
- 23:50you could be charged as a misdemeanor or a felony.
- 23:53The civil damages under 637 .2 is $5 ,000 per
- 23:58violation or triple actual damages. What does
- 24:01that mean? That means if you're going to win
- 24:04this case in a civil court, you have to prove
- 24:08damages, okay? You can't just say that... so
- 24:13-and -so recorded my conversation without my
- 24:16consent and invaded my privacy. You might be
- 24:19right, he might have done that, and he invaded
- 24:21your privacy, but were you damaged by it? You
- 24:24need to show damages. Most of you who practice
- 24:27civil law can understand. And then if you prevail
- 24:31in that and you win, you can ask for attorney's
- 24:34fees and costs. There's key exceptions. There's
- 24:37no exception of privacy in public. Again, Starbucks,
- 24:44loud restaurant, law enforcement exception under
- 24:49PC 633, domestic violence threats, and then people
- 24:55versus givens. I'll get to that case. Let's talk
- 24:57about domestic violence threats. I had a case
- 25:00in 2019. The case went through a jury trial.
- 25:03It ended in a jury trial. So the case is over.
- 25:05It actually went through a public court. It's
- 25:07over. That's why I can talk about it. So I had
- 25:10a client who was a war veteran. He had PTSD.
- 25:16He was married. And his wife was always accusing
- 25:26him of cheating on her. Now, she had grounds.
- 25:29I'm not saying she didn't. but she would just
- 25:32you know and he had PTSD so she would just you
- 25:34know poke at him not physically but mentally
- 25:37poke at him so during this instant he's sitting
- 25:39he's lying down in the bedroom minding his own
- 25:42business she comes in she starts you know talking
- 25:47to him or asking him you know about this who
- 25:51is this texting you that this this uh and he
- 25:54gets upset he gets up they're in an argument
- 25:58He punches the wall, puts a hole in the wall.
- 26:01She's standing in his way. He's trying to get
- 26:03out. She won't move. He picks her up, puts her
- 26:07to the side. She actually falls to the ground
- 26:11on her butt. He gets out. He starts packing his
- 26:15clothes. She follows him. She's still going at
- 26:19him. He's packing his clothes. He goes to the
- 26:23bathroom to get his stuff. She's going at him.
- 26:25He... takes all these perfume bottles and he
- 26:28throws them and he breaks them. He goes back.
- 26:32He's a war veteran. He does. He has a firearm.
- 26:36It's not loaded. He takes his firearm to pack
- 26:39it, to take it with him. And he's holding it
- 26:42to his side. He never points it at her. And he
- 26:45says something like, I wish I could shoot you
- 26:49or something like that. I don't remember the
- 26:51exact things. And then he finally leaves, right?
- 26:55During this whole time, she has her phone in
- 26:58her pocket and had started recording what's happening
- 27:02before she stepped into the room. So this whole
- 27:05conversation is on audio. So then after he leaves,
- 27:10she goes, meets up with her sister, they go out,
- 27:13they have like, they go out and then the next
- 27:17day they get up. they go to like brunch or something
- 27:20and during brunch she's telling the sister about
- 27:23this you know what happened last night and going
- 27:26over everything with the sister they talked about
- 27:28last night sister goes you should go to the police
- 27:31she goes to the police like 24 hours later reports
- 27:34it anyway my client gets arrested he gets charged
- 27:37he gets charged they had him for felony domestic
- 27:41violence assault with a firearm they had him
- 27:44for all these charges and they introduce this
- 27:47evidence or they bring this recording and they
- 27:49say look we have this recording obviously they
- 27:51turn it over to us because we have a right to
- 27:53see it so this recording is bad if you listen
- 27:56to the recording you can't actually see anything
- 27:59you can only hear it but you can hear him punching
- 28:01the wall you hear her excuse me you hear her
- 28:05you hear him breaking the perfume bottles so
- 28:07we're like what are we going to do we can't this
- 28:10hearing can't this this recording can't come
- 28:12in to trial. So before trial, we file a motion
- 28:15to eliminate. We bring in the arguments under
- 28:18Flanagan. We bring in the arguments under Frio.
- 28:23We say, look, my client had an expectation of
- 28:27privacy. He's in his own home. He's having a
- 28:30conversation with his wife. He's not expecting
- 28:33to be recorded. She never told him that. He never
- 28:36saw the phone. So it shouldn't be brought in.
- 28:39Well, That's where domestic violence and threats
- 28:42come in. The court ruled that, oh, it could be
- 28:47brought in because there's an exception. If you
- 28:49believe that a felony is impending, that a felony
- 28:54is going to occur, you have a right to record.
- 28:57So that's what the court was saying. We argued
- 28:59that, hey, how is she supposed to know? She doesn't
- 29:06have a sixth sense. How does she know a felony
- 29:09is going to occur, right? The judge wouldn't
- 29:11buy it. The judge ruled against it. So that audio
- 29:16came in. We went to a jury trial. They played
- 29:18that audio. My client got convicted. The gun
- 29:22charge was dismissed. It was acquitted. The jury
- 29:25found that, no, he wasn't actually going to shoot
- 29:28her. He just said it. But he was convicted of
- 29:31the other charges because the audio came in.
- 29:35So that's where the domestic violence threat
- 29:37comes in, right? Even if you have expectation
- 29:40of privacy, even if that expectation is reasonable,
- 29:43even if that recording was obtained illegally,
- 29:47it can still be brought in under domestic violence
- 29:49threats. If you feel, when I say you, I mean
- 29:53the person who's recording illegally feels that
- 29:56a felony is about to occur, it's imminent. So
- 29:59that's where it comes in. That's where it comes
- 30:01in. So people versus gibbons. Let's talk about
- 30:04people versus gibbons. All right, so a police
- 30:10officer recorded a phone call without a warrant
- 30:13during a child abuse investigation. Okay, domestic
- 30:16violence. And for those of you who... who practice
- 30:19family law, domestic violence, the domestic relationship
- 30:23could be anything. You could go on a date with
- 30:25someone once, that's it, you never see them again,
- 30:28and that's a domestic relationship. So later
- 30:30on, if something happens, it's gonna be domestic
- 30:34violence. It could be your brother, it could
- 30:35be your father, it could be anybody you're related
- 30:38to by blood or had any romantic relationship
- 30:41with. So. Let's go back. People versus Gibbons.
- 30:44This is a 1989 case. The police officer recorded
- 30:48a phone call without a warrant during a child
- 30:51abuse investigation. The issue was whether it's
- 30:55632 applies here. And the court held that PC
- 30:59632 applies to all persons, including law enforcement,
- 31:04unless an exception is codified. Without consent
- 31:09or judicial order, officers may still violate
- 31:12632. And the significance of the case was, it
- 31:17reinforces that prosecutors must ensure recording
- 31:21used in evidence are lawfully obtained and defense
- 31:24attorneys can move to exclude such recordings
- 31:27under Gibbons. So what does that say? Gibbons
- 31:30is important because it said, look, this penal
- 31:35code 632, is so sacred when it comes to privacy
- 31:38that it applies to law enforcement. So an officer
- 31:42can't say, oh, I recorded this part of my investigation,
- 31:46right? In this case, it was done as part of a
- 31:49child abuse investigation. Even though it's a
- 31:51horrible thing, he didn't have a right to record
- 31:54it because 632 applies to law enforcement. So
- 31:57that's why Gibbons is very important. There is
- 32:00exceptions. The exceptions have to be codified.
- 32:05And domestic violence, as we go back to the slide,
- 32:09is codified under 633 .5C. So that exception
- 32:14applies here. So giving is very important because
- 32:18it's important in criminal defense, mainly. It's
- 32:22important in other areas as well. But criminal
- 32:24defense, it really goes back to the government
- 32:30can't just do whatever they want. and then use
- 32:34that evidence that they illegally obtain against
- 32:36you and say, oh, we were doing it in the part
- 32:38of an investigation, 632 applies to them too.
- 32:41So if there is evidence that's going to be brought
- 32:44in, let's use the example of the case that I
- 32:47had. In my case, the wife was recording my client
- 32:50illegally. But let's say the police officers
- 32:53were there, right? Police came before anything
- 32:55happened or the police are there and they're
- 32:58recording my client without knowing. and they
- 33:01want to use that recording later, then you can
- 33:04bring in 632. That's a broad, broad example,
- 33:08a general example. As you know now, most law
- 33:12enforcement agencies have body cams. I think
- 33:15the only ones that don't have them yet are CHP,
- 33:19which is surprising because they're the most
- 33:21well -funded law enforcement agency, but they
- 33:24all have body cams and they are required to turn
- 33:26them on When they're talking to you. It's not
- 33:29on all the time Sometimes we get the body cam
- 33:33videos and it's off or even if it's on you see
- 33:37like the officers like eating his lunch or something
- 33:39and then he responds The audio is still not on
- 33:43the video may be but as soon as he has Interaction
- 33:46the audio goes on and you have a right to all
- 33:49those body cam videos so those actually are Allowed
- 33:54and they're you know, if they want to use them
- 33:56against you they're allowed and you can't Well,
- 33:59you could try to bring a six three two violation,
- 34:02but it's not gonna stick Okay, so because everybody
- 34:04knows that they have those bodycams and most
- 34:06of them tell them tell me you're being recorded.
- 34:09So Let's see Evidently current consequences Illegally
- 34:16recorded conversations are inadmissible. They
- 34:19may be admissible in federal court That's a whole
- 34:23different topic we can talk about. Potential
- 34:26suppression and SIPA claims can be brought in.
- 34:30And that's under this code section, penal code
- 34:34section 362D. Let's see what my next slide is.
- 34:40My notes and my slides are a little different,
- 34:41so that's why I'm jumping around. But I want
- 34:43to make sure we talk about everything. So ethical
- 34:46considerations for attorneys. because this talk
- 34:50is designed for attorneys, right? So we need
- 34:52to know this because it will come into practice.
- 34:54And it comes into practice not just for criminal,
- 34:57it comes into practice for families, civil, it
- 35:00comes into all areas because... Privacy is important,
- 35:03actually. And that is why, like I said, it was
- 35:06codified in 1967. They thought back then that
- 35:09technology was going to invade people's privacy.
- 35:14And we're in 2025. So imagine how much technology
- 35:17has advanced. So go back to 67. Imagine what
- 35:21the technology was back then. And they were so
- 35:24concerned about privacy and the technology back
- 35:26then that they codified this penal code. Do not
- 35:30advise your clients to record unlawfully. Do
- 35:32not do it. Do not. Because not only the ethical
- 35:38part, you could get in trouble with the bar,
- 35:40but it's not going to help you. Because if it's
- 35:44unlawful, it's not going to come in. The risk
- 35:48on DV and employment and housing cases. The DV
- 35:53case, the DV parts is a little bit harder because
- 35:57you have that DV. exception. But the arguments
- 36:02you could make is, well, the client recorded
- 36:05it because she thought or he thought that there
- 36:07was an impending felony about to happen. But
- 36:09you would have to prove that, right? In my case,
- 36:13I think the police were called two previous occasions.
- 36:18My clients were having a loud argument. So the
- 36:21judge used that to say, yeah, the victim, the
- 36:25wife, had a reasonable expectation that a felony
- 36:28was going to occur so the recording could come
- 36:30in. And then encourage lawful alternatives, protective
- 36:34orders, witnesses. For those of you who practice
- 36:38family law or those of you who've dealt with
- 36:40domestic violence restraining orders or even
- 36:44civil harassment orders, if an order is granted,
- 36:48even if it's a temporary one until the hearing,
- 36:51Sometimes they say in the temporary ones, and
- 36:54for sure in the permanent ones, you may record
- 36:57this person. That's why the alternative is to
- 37:02get a protective order. Once your client gets
- 37:04that protective order, they have a right to record
- 37:06that person. They don't need to tell them. Next
- 37:08time the person they have the restraining order
- 37:10against calls them, they can just press record.
- 37:13That person comes to the... door, they could
- 37:15just start recording them. They don't even have
- 37:17to use their phone, they could have the cameras
- 37:19recording them. So that's the alternative to
- 37:23getting that thing. So let's talk about some
- 37:26hypotheticals. But before I do that, let's go
- 37:31back to some practice tips. Always get compliance
- 37:35tips, always get written consent for recording,
- 37:38okay? Use consent notifications for recorded
- 37:41Zoom or phone calls. Advise clients against recording
- 37:44private conversations without prior discussion.
- 37:47The first part is basically for you, the attorney.
- 37:50The example I gave, you know how we have AI notes,
- 37:53AI taking notes during our conversations? We
- 37:55tell our clients, AI announces it and our clients
- 37:59sometimes say no, sometimes they say okay. So
- 38:03we record, the AI takes notes. It doesn't record
- 38:06the conversation, it takes notes, right? but
- 38:09I'm sure there's some AIs that record the whole
- 38:12conversation. And you can put them in the file.
- 38:16Remember, even if your client gives you consent
- 38:20to record the conversation or take notes from
- 38:22it, that conversation and notes is still privileged
- 38:26information because of the attorney -client relationship
- 38:29you have. So remember that. Don't think that,
- 38:33oh, okay, they gave me permission to record them.
- 38:36It can be used or someone else can use it. So
- 38:38you have two layers of protection and then your
- 38:41client has two layers of protection. You could
- 38:44actually get in trouble if you use it, not for
- 38:48your attorney client privilege, but for something
- 38:50else, your client could turn around and sue you
- 38:53under this penal code. Okay, and the other one,
- 38:57in criminal cases, for those of you who practice
- 39:00criminal, pretrial motion is to suppress. Like
- 39:04the one I talked about, motion is to eliminate.
- 39:07You could bring it at trial, one of your four
- 39:10or twos, or you could file a separate motion
- 39:12on it. In my case, I filed a completely separate
- 39:15motion before I even went to trial and had my
- 39:19four or twos heard, because I wanted that issue
- 39:22resolved. before going into trial because it
- 39:25would change my strategy, the DA strategy. So
- 39:29I would say if you're going to bring a motion
- 39:31like this in a criminal case, do it before your
- 39:34trial. Don't bring it as part of your 402s right
- 39:37before trial. Have a completely separate suppression
- 39:41motion heard before you go into trial and you
- 39:45have your 402s heard. Leverage 637 .2. which
- 39:52claims to increase settlement value. That's the
- 39:55civil part. Leverage that part. When you're doing
- 39:57civil, use that part. And then the ethical considerations,
- 40:05we talked about them, but again, avoid secretly
- 40:08recording opposing parties or witnesses and know
- 40:11your duties under state bar ethics opinions.
- 40:16I'm not here on a state bar ethics talk, so I'm
- 40:20not going to talk about that, but just remember,
- 40:24you need, as an attorney, not only you have to
- 40:28comply by penal code 632, the prom test and all
- 40:31that, you have to comply with the ethics that's
- 40:34set for us by the state bar. Now, let's talk
- 40:40about some hypothetical, but before I do that,
- 40:43I want to talk about anticipated legal trends,
- 40:45okay? Use of smart devices, Alexa, Siri, and
- 40:49their recordings. As you know, Siri, Alexa, all
- 40:57those people, all those companies say you're
- 40:59not being recorded. And then something came out
- 41:01that actually they are recording you. So can
- 41:04they use those recordings against you? And the
- 41:06answer is no, obviously not. Can they use the
- 41:09data they obtained from the recording, which
- 41:11they've been doing? you know, compiling data
- 41:14of your likes or dislikes. That's why people
- 41:18are, you know, sometimes people are like, I was
- 41:20just talking to Joe about blue shoes and I turned
- 41:26my phone on and there's an ad for blue shoes.
- 41:29How weird is that? My phone is listening to me.
- 41:32Your phone might be listening to you. The argument
- 41:34those companies are going to make is if you bought
- 41:36an Alexa, you should have anticipated that you're
- 41:40going to be recorded. It's a weak argument. But
- 41:43they're going to make those arguments. So as
- 41:45technology advances, as technology expands, and
- 41:49new things come into play, this rule is going
- 41:53to expand itself too. Let's see. Secret recordings
- 42:00in domestic violence, we talked about those.
- 42:03In custody and employment matters. Those are
- 42:07going to be areas that are going to be gray areas,
- 42:12in my opinion. And those are going to be, I think,
- 42:15case by case. So if you have a domestic violence
- 42:20case, bring up these motions. And the reason
- 42:25I pause is I was thinking, I think it was a couple
- 42:28of weeks ago, actually, I got a call from someone
- 42:30who was in a family law case. And they said,
- 42:35my wife recorded me without me knowing. talking
- 42:39bad about, I think the kids, talking bad. He
- 42:43wasn't saying something good. He didn't know
- 42:45he's been recorded. Now they're going through
- 42:47a divorce and the wife is using these recordings
- 42:52and wants to use these recordings in trial. And
- 42:55from what I recall, he said the judge is gonna
- 43:01let the recordings come in, okay? And I told
- 43:06them, well, you need to talk to your lawyer who's
- 43:08representing you in the family law and have your
- 43:11lawyer handle it. So even in the family law case,
- 43:14I think the motion should be brought to exclude
- 43:18those recordings. In any kind of case, you should
- 43:20bring those motions to exclude the recordings.
- 43:25Now, whether they're going to pass new bills
- 43:29or expand on this, I'm not sure. I haven't heard
- 43:33any coming down the pipeline. But let's talk
- 43:36about some hypothetical. So, co -worker threatens
- 43:39you in the hallway. Is it legal to record him,
- 43:43right? What do you think? I say yes, it is, because
- 43:50does it meet the reasonable expectation of privacy,
- 43:55meaning the person who's threatening you, are
- 43:58they reasonably expecting that it's a private
- 44:02conversation between you and him in the hallway?
- 44:04they could be because subjective but objectively
- 44:08is it reasonable and i say no it's not um threatening
- 44:12someone uh in the hallway uh i don't think it's
- 44:16uh it's reasonable because and even if it is
- 44:20i think the the the exception comes in that an
- 44:25impending felony is going to occur uh dv victim
- 44:28dv victim records threats after prior report
- 44:32That's exactly what my case was. And in that
- 44:35case, the judge said, yes, the recording can
- 44:38come in because she thought that a felony was
- 44:42going to occur. And the reason she thought that
- 44:44is because there was prior calls to the police
- 44:47for domestic violence. So she thought that it's
- 44:50going to occur. Landlord records tenant via intercom.
- 44:55That's a good one. So let's go back to the test.
- 45:01the tenant and you are talking on the intercom
- 45:04right do you have a reasonable expectation of
- 45:08privacy you could argue both ways you can say
- 45:12he's out on the street and he's talking on the
- 45:15intercom people could pass by so even though
- 45:19he might have a reasonable expectation of privacy
- 45:21and it's subjective objectively it's not reasonable
- 45:25but let's say it is right Does he think that
- 45:31the landlord is going to record him? No. Okay.
- 45:36Does he have a subjective, reasonable expectation
- 45:40of privacy? Yes. Is his expectation of privacy
- 45:47objectively reasonable? And in this scenario,
- 45:50let's say, yes, it is. Can the landlord then
- 45:52use that intercom against him, that intercom
- 45:56recording? I'm going to go back to and argue
- 46:00on what that intercom is. Is it one that automatically
- 46:06records people? Is it one that, is the recording
- 46:12one that the landlord is holding the phone next
- 46:15to the intercom? Now that clearly is a violation.
- 46:19So you gotta look at the facts. You gotta look
- 46:21at the scenarios because like I said, some of
- 46:24these things fall into gray areas. It could be
- 46:26argued both, both ways, you have to make sure
- 46:29your argument meets the two -pronged test and
- 46:33if it meets that two -pronged test. Now let's
- 46:35go back to this landlord records the tenant via
- 46:37intercom. Let's say it's illegal, the recording
- 46:41can't happen, but the landlord is now going to
- 46:44testify in the UD action and he is going to testify
- 46:49himself. He's using the recording to refresh
- 46:52his memory, but he's not bringing the recording
- 46:55in. Can he do that? And the answer is yes, remember
- 46:57we talked about it. Because he was a party to
- 47:01the conversation. He is using the illegal recording
- 47:05to refresh his memory, but he was a party to
- 47:09the conversation and he can testify as to what
- 47:12he recalls from the conversation. The recording
- 47:14can be brought in, but he can testify and use
- 47:17the recording to refresh his memory. And then
- 47:21we talked about that. Let's see. I think that
- 47:26might be my last slide. Oh, yes, key takeaways.
- 47:33Understand the scope of PC 632 and two -party
- 47:36consent. Remember, California is a two -party
- 47:41consent jurisdiction. Some jurisdictions are
- 47:44one -party consent if one person agrees to be
- 47:48recorded or records the conversation without
- 47:50the other party recording it. It happens off
- 47:53the top of my head. I don't know any jurisdictions
- 47:56like that, but then again, I really don't practice
- 48:00in any other jurisdictions unless it's a federal
- 48:02case. Be aware of criminal and civil exposure.
- 48:06You could be charged criminally and you could
- 48:08be sued civilly for the same set of facts, same
- 48:11scenario. Government could bring criminal charges
- 48:15against you and then you could be sued civilly.
- 48:18You can have two things going on at the same
- 48:21time. Know the expectations I'm sorry they accept
- 48:25exceptions know the expectations as well the
- 48:28expectations of privacy and know the exceptions
- 48:30the exceptions that we talked about And then
- 48:33protect your clients through clear guidance.
- 48:35Like I said, don't tell them to record stuff
- 48:38illegally if If they don't have an order allowing
- 48:43them to record a conversation with another party,
- 48:45don't tell them to record that conversation.
- 48:48If they're going to record that conversation,
- 48:50make sure they have consent of the other party.
- 48:54Make sure that if they're worried about being
- 48:56recorded, they should keep their conversations
- 49:00to somewhere where their reasonable expectation
- 49:03of privacy is objective, not subjective. Subjective
- 49:07is the first prong, objective is the second and
- 49:10most important prong. So those are the key takeaways.
- 49:14That's my contact info if you need anything.
- 49:17We do have about 10 minutes. We can go over some
- 49:23more. I know some of you have lots of questions.
- 49:26Let's see. Okay, this one says. How does this
- 49:34apply to custodial parent recording their minor
- 49:38child when in the custodial parents home parents
- 49:41are divorced? So from my understanding You're
- 49:48asking how does this apply if I'm the custodial
- 49:51parent and I'm recording my minor child So who's
- 49:56gonna argue who's gonna argue that that was a
- 50:00not confidential the other parent right I would
- 50:05argue I don't do family law so but from off the
- 50:13top of my head I would argue that other parents
- 50:15doesn't have standing because the minor child
- 50:19is the one being recorded not the other parent
- 50:21if it's going to be brought in trial and the
- 50:24other parents wants to object to it they can
- 50:28object to it for other reasons even though they
- 50:34don't have standing they could argue the minor
- 50:36doesn't have the ability to give consent so the
- 50:41minor shouldn't have been recorded but then again
- 50:43as a i don't know this i don't practice family
- 50:46law do you have a right to record your own child
- 50:49so i i don't know that answer so that's a good
- 50:55question i haven't come across it so I'm sorry
- 50:59if I don't have a clear -cut answer for you.
- 51:01What about a baby camera video and audio? What
- 51:04would that be considered consent by a party if
- 51:06it's in their house recording a grandparent?
- 51:08So yes, so I have cameras in my house, right?
- 51:11If I have like a babysitter, babysitter knows
- 51:14I have cameras. So is it a reasonable expectation
- 51:18of privacy? She's coming into my home. Does she
- 51:22have an expectation of privacy? She does, but
- 51:24how? much expectation does she have when she
- 51:28sees those cameras? She knows those cameras are
- 51:30there for a purpose, right? I didn't put cameras
- 51:32there to record myself, so I can argue that her
- 51:35expectation of privacy is not reasonable, even
- 51:38subjectively. But let's say subjectively it is,
- 51:42because right? It's subjective. So she believes
- 51:44that, hey, I'm a babysitter, there's cameras
- 51:47here, I don't think you still have a right to
- 51:49record me. Is it objectively reasonable? And
- 51:53I would argue no, because most of us put cameras
- 51:57in our house to record third parties, you know,
- 52:02housekeepers, babysitters, gardeners, things
- 52:04like that. So I would say that that recording
- 52:08would be allowed. Okay, let's talk about may
- 52:14a consumer record if a busy records? That's a
- 52:17great question. I would say you would have to
- 52:25tell them, just like they tell you. They tell
- 52:27you this conversation may be recorded. You tell
- 52:30them the same thing. Tell them, hey, I'm gonna
- 52:32record you and see what they say. And then press
- 52:37the record button. If they say yes, if they say
- 52:40no, then it goes to the courts, right? But again,
- 52:48just like they give you, warning that they're
- 52:50going to record you, I believe you have to give
- 52:52them warning too. So just because they gave you
- 52:55warning doesn't mean you have a right to record
- 52:57it, right? They're telling you they're going
- 52:58to record you. You can object to it. You have
- 53:01to do the same. You have to tell them I'm going
- 53:02to record you and they have to object to it.
- 53:05Even though they are a business, it still falls.
- 53:07Remember, even law enforcement is bound by this
- 53:11law, okay? In a criminal case, isn't the recording
- 53:15admissible regardless of 632 violation under
- 53:19the truth in evidence clause of California Constitution?
- 53:24Well Excuse me, let's go back to the to what
- 53:29we were talking about Remember the the the two
- 53:35-pronged test in video so the appellate court
- 53:39I'm sorry the the lower court said it can't be
- 53:42brought in right because it was illegally obtained
- 53:45the appellate court said no it could be brought
- 53:48in because he's testifying to it as his own memory
- 53:53right so is it admissible under the truth and
- 53:59evidence clause I'm gonna say no it's not Because
- 54:04if that exception applies, then the rule will
- 54:10fall apart. And then everybody could say, oh,
- 54:13under this truth and evidence, it could be brought
- 54:16in. I think it's very specific. I think Frius
- 54:20said the prong test. Flanagan also expanded on
- 54:25it. And it has to go through those process before
- 54:29it could be brought in. You can't just say, well,
- 54:32under truth and evidence clause that could be
- 54:34brought in. That's an argument you can make,
- 54:36but I don't think it's going to win every time.
- 54:38It might win, but not every time, because you
- 54:41still have to go through the process. Penal code
- 54:44632 and everything that applies to it is very
- 54:46specific. And remember, California privacy laws
- 54:51are... California prides itself on privacy laws,
- 54:55right? Believe it or not, they do. And they try
- 54:59to... They try to make sure people's privacies
- 55:03are met. So they're not going to allow a broad
- 55:07exception like that to come in and take away
- 55:09those rights. Remember, they were worried about
- 55:11tape recorders when they enacted this statute.
- 55:15So that's how sacred they believe privacy is
- 55:19in California. What about an employee recording
- 55:22a termination meeting when there was a boss,
- 55:25an HR person, and a terminated employee? Well,
- 55:27if they said, you know, come in, sit down, let's
- 55:31have a talk and you're being recorded, yes. If
- 55:34there's cameras, yes. Like I have cameras in
- 55:37my office. I have a camera right now. It's not
- 55:40recording, but it's set on, you know, after hours
- 55:43it can record if there's a motion. So if I walk
- 55:46in, I'm the employee and I walk in and I know
- 55:48my boss has a camera in that room, that expectation
- 55:51goes away. So if there's HR in that room, I'm
- 55:55sure HR knows the policy and HR would tell them.
- 55:58If you're secretly recording, then you might
- 56:00have a problem. They have to have, remember,
- 56:03it's a two -party consent state, so they both
- 56:06need to be, and their expectation could always
- 56:10be subjective, because it's subjective, but is
- 56:15it objectively reasonable? If I walk into a private
- 56:19office and I don't know I'm being fired, and
- 56:21they fire me, and they recorded me without me
- 56:26knowing Is my expectation of privacy not just
- 56:30subjective, but objective? I would say yes. So
- 56:33I'm going to argue it can be brought in unless
- 56:37that person being recorded had prior knowledge
- 56:40they're being recorded. Let's see. What is the
- 56:45reference to employment and housing about? Just
- 56:49what we talked about, like employment right now.
- 56:52if you're going to fire someone and you're worried
- 56:55they're going to do something and you record
- 56:56them. So if you're worried that they're going
- 56:59to commit a felony, you could record them without
- 57:01their consent. But how are you going to prove
- 57:04that they're going to commit a felony? Well,
- 57:06maybe because they committed a felony before
- 57:09or they committed a crime or something like that.
- 57:11And housing is the same thing. You're recording
- 57:14your tenant because you say that they're doing
- 57:18something and you want to kick them out. That's
- 57:22why it comes up in employment and housing. And
- 57:25the cameras in apartment complexes, things like
- 57:28that. Let's see, what if someone is recording
- 57:32the other without their consent and the other
- 57:34person tries to snatch the cell phone since they
- 57:37don't want to be recorded? Is 632 still applicable?
- 57:42So that scenario will create different things.
- 57:50So if they're recording you and you don't want
- 57:53to be recorded, you got to go back to the test.
- 57:56Is their reasonable expectation of privacy subjectively
- 58:02reasonable? You could say yes, because it's subjective.
- 58:05Is it objectively reasonable? Meaning if you're
- 58:09recording someone in public right in the street
- 58:11and you start recording them, then I would argue
- 58:14their expectation of privacy is unreasonable.
- 58:17And if they tried to snatch the phone, Now they
- 58:19could be charged with a battery, right? They
- 58:21could be charged with theft or whatever it is.
- 58:24So go back to the prong. Go back to the test.
- 58:28When you're not certain about the scenario, go
- 58:30back to the test. Subjective and objective. Is
- 58:34there expectation or reasonable? Is there expectational
- 58:38privacy subjectively reasonable? That's going
- 58:42to be a yes automatically because it's subjective.
- 58:46You might have some. things where it's so, you
- 58:48know, you know what, even subjectively, it's
- 58:50not reasonable. But objectively, is it reasonable?
- 58:54That is the key right there. So if you're recording
- 58:57someone without their consent and they don't
- 59:00want to be recorded and they try to snatch your
- 59:02cell phone, go back. Was your expectation of
- 59:05privacy reasonable objectively or not? OK. Family
- 59:10law case, my client has videos of physical abuse
- 59:13from ex -husband to child and to her. father
- 59:16admits to biting and beating his children it
- 59:19sounds like three six well in that scenario is
- 59:25the husband trying trying to fight those recordings
- 59:28come in um and if they are then you could fight
- 59:33you know with the domestic violence exception
- 59:36you could try to bring it in so i don't know
- 59:40enough about those facts to know uh to give you
- 59:44a clear answer but again Remember, if the husband
- 59:48is not arguing about those recordings being coming
- 59:52into trial, you're good to go. And if they're
- 59:54arguing about it, then go through the two -prong
- 59:57test, right? The person is their home, even if
- 1:00:02they're committing child abuse. Unfortunately,
- 1:00:05it's a sad thing. But even if they're doing that,
- 1:00:08is their expectation of privacy reasonable, subjectively?
- 1:00:12or objectively. And if it meets those, then you
- 1:00:15need an exception. So the domestic violence,
- 1:00:17I would say the domestic violence exception would
- 1:00:19fall into play here. And I would argue that if
- 1:00:22the other side is trying to prevent those recordings
- 1:00:24from coming. How realistic is a criminal prosecution
- 1:00:28for these claims? So it's realistic, but usually
- 1:00:33you don't see a criminal prosecution of just
- 1:00:38discharge. Discharge will go along with other
- 1:00:43other charges, okay? I've rarely seen just one
- 1:00:49count charge on these. They go hand in hand with
- 1:00:52other charges, and they are realistic. I mean,
- 1:00:54that's why it's there. That's why they have the
- 1:00:57penal code. That's why they take it so seriously.
- 1:01:00They do prosecute people for this. They're not
- 1:01:04going to prosecute you for recording your girlfriend
- 1:01:10Without our consent and then sending the recording
- 1:01:14to her mom and she gets in a fight with her mom
- 1:01:16They're not gonna prosecute you for that even
- 1:01:18though it's illegal and you committed a crime
- 1:01:20They're not gonna do it for that, but they are
- 1:01:22gonna prosecute you and they these charges go
- 1:01:24hand -in -hand with other charges If my answering
- 1:01:28service Provides a notice that we record for
- 1:01:33quality and then I am Going over so this will
- 1:01:36be the last one. I believe the other ones we
- 1:01:40can answer through email. If my answering service
- 1:01:43provides notice that we record for quality after
- 1:01:47call is transferred to me, may I automatically
- 1:01:50record without another notice? Yes, you can.
- 1:01:53That's basically every call center, right? You
- 1:01:56call, they go, this call may be recorded, and
- 1:01:58then you get transferred to A, A transfers you
- 1:02:01to B, so the answer is yes. Okay, I'm told that
- 1:02:04I can't go over, or if I go over only a few minutes,
- 1:02:09There is some more questions. I think there's
- 1:02:11a bunch of outstanding questions. I'll be happy
- 1:02:13to answer those through email. Thank you everyone
- 1:02:17and have a good night.