Latest / Ego and Other Things / Beliefs You Never Chose: What My Parents Taught Me | Worldview Series
Transcript
- William: Dear Heavenly Father, I thank you for the opportunity to do this recording, to continue talking about this world with you. Lord, I pray that you would bless this session. I surrender it into your hand into your hands. I ask that you would speak through me. I ask that my words would connect people who watch this video in the ways that they are meant to be. Lord, I don't know always what to say. I am oftentimes nervous when I'm starting these recordings, but Lord, I know that you who live within me are capable of overcoming that fear. I know that you who live through me have the words to say, even if they aren't the words I expect. And so Lord, I just pray that you would speak through me. I pray that you would take over my thoughts, my ideas, my words, and just express in this video. What is what it is meant to express. Surrender this recording into your hands. And all this I pray in Jesus' name. Amen. All right, this question today's question is what was I taught growing up about God, success, and right and wrong, with the sub-question of who is still carrying beliefs that they never chose? So I guess let's just tackle each of each of these three subjects one by one. the first being what was I taught growing up about God? let's see. I would say that God was pretty absent in my early childhood, really in my throughout my whole childhood. my father was a nominal Catholic in the sense that he, if you asked him if he was a Christian, he would say, Yes, I'm a Catholic, but never actually went to church, never did any any part of the sacraments, didn't really talk to me about God, didn't read the Bible to me, didn't really do anything that you would associate with being a Christian. my mother also considered herself a Christian. I'm not sure. Yeah, she also considered herself a Christian, but she considered herself to be a universalist in the sense I think that what defines that entire school of Christianity is the idea that everybody at some point will get into heaven. And my mother and father actually disagreed so significantly about religion and Christianity in particular that they never got me baptized. I think they argued over whether I should be baptized Catholic or whether I should be baptized universalist, couldn't come to an agreement about it, and so didn't baptize me at all. so I wasn't baptized. My first time being baptized was as an adult a few years ago when I came to faith in Christ. At my own church. So to ask the question, what was I taught about God growing up, I'd say I wasn't taught really anything at all. God was occasionally talked about, but it's not like there were prayers or again any biblical instruction. I didn't go to Sunday school, I didn't go to church growing up, and so I really didn't know anything about God, and certainly nothing really about Christianity. In some ways, the way I was taught about God is at least the way that I experienced was the way I was taught about Santa Claus. Growing up, people tell you about Santa Claus, and they act like he's real, and you believe him because you believe what your parents say. And so, you know, I had this real belief in this magical being called Santa Claus, who would come on Christmas every day, which happened to be Jesus' birthday, and give me presents that I wanted. And I genuinely believed in that, even though I never had any evidence or proof about it, because this is what my parents told me. And So I would say that I had a genuine belief in God as a little kid, based on what my parents told me, but not the Christian God, not Jesus Christ in particular. God was this, I don't know, distant, all powerful creator who had fashioned the universe and created me for some reason, and now I was here. But I never had this, I was never taught to have a relationship with God. And I certainly was never taught about. Christ or who Christ was or what he had done or why it related or why it related or mattered to me. I kind of just believed in it, but the way that God was taught to me was in a way where God never cross crossed paths with me in my life. I lived my life for the most part without thinking about God, just like I lived the most part of my life without thinking about Santa Claus, except for when Christmas came around. And particularly I only the only times I would have ever prayed or even called out to God as a kid growing up with this understanding of God was when I got in trouble. And I was praying to God that that I wouldn't get in trouble or that my dad wouldn't hit me or yell at me or punish me in some way like that. and doing it as a last ish effort, pretty much knowing that I'm going to be hit or yelled at, that I'm gonna get in trouble and Asking God, who is supposedly the all powerful creator, who can do anything, to not allow me to be punished in that way. And certainly I never thought about God in terms of somebody who would give me, give me things or enter into my life in any kind of positive way. Again, God was this distant deity that I barely understood. I barely understood what it meant to be Christian, or or really anything about that. I I again I wasn't really taught about God at all. And when I grew up and I began to, you know, come to the realization that Santa wasn't actually real. even though I had a I had a strong desire to believe that that Santa was real. But I remember that and really not wanting to let go of that for a while. But when I came to the belief that Santa wasn't real, it was probably around the same time that I came to the belief that God wasn't real. That that Santa and God were kind of like fun things that people pretended to believe for for some kind of reason. And, you know, especially as I learned about history and all the different kinds of gods going back thousands hundreds and thousands of years. It was this sense of well, human beings do this thing where they put their belief into these fictional entities that maybe help them to live better lives. Kind of like how me putting my belief in Santa Claus helped me to not do as much bad stuff because I wanted to get presents from Santa Claus and not get coal. And so adults also do this thing where they put their belief in some fictional entity and they call them, in in my family we call it God or Jesus Christ. And that helps them maybe to live better lives. And it's just almost like a fun game that maybe has some benefits to it. that was where the evolution of the idea of God ultimately went for me. And then on top of that, I think later on, when I began to realize that Christianity was oftentimes used as a weapon. God and Jesus were used as a weapon in order to coerce people into believing what they believed, I started to have a much more negative view of God and really religion in general, in the sense that I began to believe that those lies were just used to manipulate people. And yeah, manip essentially manipulate stupid people into giving you stuff or doing stuff for you. But those weren't necessarily things I was taught by by my parents or even the people around me. Those are things I just came to a conclusion, a conclusion to at some point. And then around 13, 14, 15, when my dad or 14, I want to say 13 or 14, where my dad started to get into mysticism, he started to talk to me about a different conception of God as like this center of consciousness within the universe that we were we had been separated from and we're trying to get back to. And that was another I like a different idea of God, not like as this I don't know, old man of the clouds sitting off in the distance who happens to be our creator, but this abstract entity of consciousness that I guess was really powerful, but we had been cut off from something like that. and it was very quickly after that that I I turned away from God and religion altogether and became an atheist. And now being a believer, my conception of God is dramatically different and much more personal than it was certainly growing up. that's really all I have to say. Like I said, I I don't think I got I don't know what I don't think I really got taught anything about God or very little about God. And the things I picked up on my own was this idea that like God was really just kind of this cultural entity that played a role in helping people to form the good life, but was oftentimes used and manipulated and corrupted for the sake of, you know, evil ends, something like that. was I taught growing up about success. This one I think is a little bit more interesting because my I came from a poor background. my dad was I think he was like a manager at a gas station, something like that. Like that was his job. And my mother was out of the picture at that time dealing with her own kinds of struggles. There weren't many There weren't many people around me who just in my broader family who were examples of societal success, you might say. People who had lots of money and enviable jobs and had high levels of education, or were were seen as I don't know, pillars of the community, so to speak. There weren't any of those people in my in my family. my family was composed of a lot of poor people who worked menial or working class jobs who didn't have a lot of influence in the world around them and are often difficult dealing with substance abuse and trauma. Like My family as a whole did not exude social success, you might say. And when my dad would talk to me about success, because again, my mom was out of the picture at this point. So it was really my dad who taught me ideas about success. When he talked about success, he always put it in terms of what I would say process rather than outcome. So an example, the earliest example I can remember is I never really cared all too much about school. And so I would bring report cards home that were C's and D's, and maybe I got the occasional B or A. But for the most part, I brought like I would say low to average report cards home. And when I would bring these to my dad to get him to sign them, you know, his his refrain was often, you know, I don't care whether you get A C or a D or whatever, as long as you really put in the effort to try, right? As long as you put in the effort to work towards getting this grade and you did, you yeah, as long as you put in the effort, I don't care what the grade is. So my dad wasn't focused on me getting Strainers on my report card. He was focused on me putting in my best effort in my life. And I would say this is how success was defined to me early on, meaning that it wasn't so much what you did, but how you did it. My dad had this kind of I want to almost say martyristic view of himself, in the sense that he believed that his lack of social success in the world, his lack of a good job, his lack of having money, his lack of reputation with other people. didn't really come down to the fact that he had chosen wrong or done the wrong thing or made mistakes in his life. but because he did not view being a good person as meaning having success in the world. And more than that, I think he e he would he even stressed at times that being a good person, like being a virtuous person in your life, is actually detrimental to having success in the world. So that If you were a genuinely selfless and virtuous kind of person, you actually would struggle to make money or or have a lot of social acceptance from other people because the world was corrupt in one sense. I think my my father had this very pessimistic view of the world. You might even say a Christian centered view of the world in the sense that people were generally evil and corrupt. The world was generally evil and corrupt, and so if you were a good person, you were likely to be. to to suffer, to to suffer poverty, to suffer hardship, you might say. And so he didn't look at success in himself and didn't look at it in me in terms of whether we achieved anything, but whether or not we lived up to what it meant to be a good person in the world. but really in this moderistic way. I mean he to the point where I think he took evidence of of not achieving success in the world as a badge of honor, if you will. And looked on success in the world with with suspicion. You know, I think of like a a common phrase here today is like, there are no good billionaires. To and you know, the the truth of that statement can can we can go back and forth on that. But it is that sense of like if you achieve phenomenal excess in this world, or even just a a strong level of success in this world, that there's some there might there's something wrong with you, right? You haven't somehow done you've in somehow or in some way gone and done the wrong thing and that's allowed you to achieve success level. And that's the the way that that suc like a success was seen. It wasn't seen in terms of outcome. In fact, it it if if anything, achieving significant success in life meant you had failed in some way. Like that was the implication. Never he never said that in the direct way, but that was kind of the implication of the way he talked about himself and the way he talked about his life and what he taught me. So I learned as a kid that success had to do with process, had to do with trying your best, had to do with being a good person, not with Achieving things in life. It had to do with working hard and trying hard and and being a good person and being willing to take the sacrifices necessary to be a good person. It had much more to do with actually sacrificing success than it had to do with achieving success. And I'm somewhat ambivalent about that lesson because it's it's good on the one hand, it's bad on the other hand. The good the good part of that lesson is to say that I think generally that's true. We don't necessarily have control over the outcomes in our lives. We don't have control oftentimes of whether we are going to be successful monetarily or socially, or we're gonna have the kind of jobs that we want. And I believe very much that a person can be successful and they can be a good person, without having achieved much in the way of like I guess socially expected goals. Because virtue and success are not one and the same thing. And oftentimes, and you can see this in just in historical cases, it is true that to do the right thing means to make sacrifices in one's life, right? Make sacrifices in terms of worldly success. And like this is all throughout the Bible, right? I mean, Jesus is the perfect example of this because he he sacrificed his eternal ground crown of glory in heaven. for the sake of coming down here to to suffer, be ridiculed and abandoned and die for our sakes. So, and that's heroic in that sense, right? But the the dark side of that mindset, the dark side of the process mindset is the victim mentality. It's the martyrdom mentality of the reason I don't have success in my life is because I'm such a good person. Or the reason I, the my society rejects me is because I'm so virtuous. the reason I'm failing at all these different kinds of things is because I'm so good and wonderful and making sacrifices for the sake of what is good. But that's presumptuous. It's a it's the presumptuous bel it's a you might say a post-justification of your own failures. You fail, you feel bad about that failure, you haven't lived up to the success that you want, and so you rationalize that failure by saying, well, it must be because the world is corrupt and I'm a good person. rather than looking at how you have contributed to your to your failures. I think another good lesson from this idea of success is the idea that it's not enough for success to be success. It is not enough for success to be f to be defined socially. Meaning like other people's expectations of success, your culture's expectations of success are not necessarily what success looks like to you. But the downside of that is that you so you you how do I put it, you neglect, I guess, the case for what would be successful, right? You just you you go in the opposite direction of your society because you're so determined that society's notion of success is is not real. It reminds me of Nietzsche's analogy of the camel, the camel, the lion, and the baby, right? He's like these were three modes of psychological development that Nietzsche proposed that people go through. And he said something like 98% of the world or 95% of the world falls into the category of of the camel, which is that they're just kind of defined by the people around them. Their society just loads them up with all this baggage that they have to carry on. And they are they become an object for their society to be used, to become filled up with or loaded with all the values of the society around them. rather than ever striving out on their own to figure out what it is it that they value. The second Animal is the, or the second analogy is a lion. And the lion, the lion just attacks society. So it doesn't take on the burdens of society as a whole, or just piles on the values of society as a whole like the camel does. Rather, it attacks society. It tries to tear down all the different kinds of values. It tries to criticize and annihilate the values of society as a whole. By doing that, it ends up destroying a lot of what is of value in society, what is what there is to treasure in society. And then the third analogy is like the baby. And Nietzsche's description of this is that the baby is new to society. And the baby can pick and choose what they value rather than either taking everything on or discarding everything. And I think when you have this notion that on the one hand, it's important to be able to choose your own values, but if you are taught that that the values of society are just inherently bad, you end up, throwing the baby out with the bathwater, for lack of a better term. And I still very much like take on the the idea of success being a process. I think it's easy for me to slip into outcome orientation and and you don't want to necessarily ignore what kind of outcome that you want, but I think of my writing or these YouTube videos or my reading, what I would love in terms of outcomes is to be a famous philosophical writer who, you know, significantly contributes to the ideas of society. I would love to be able to communicate ideas in videos like this that significantly contribute to the culture and ideas of society and go on to to reshape the world around me, much like other famous philosophers have done. But I have absolutely no control over that kind of outcome. I have no even direct control over my own skills. I have to continually work the process in order to benefit from the kind of skill developer. It's not like I just wake up and decide, yes, I'm gonna be a great writer, or yes, I'm gonna be a great YouTuber. I have to commit to the process of it, allow that process to take over, and essentially take the risk that maybe it's not going to end up where I want to be. But I can't be focused on the outcome. So my standard of success for my life is not so much whether I'm rich or famous or whether everybody respects me as an intellectual or whether I'm I blow up as a YouTuber or blow up as a writer or any of these kinds of outcome-oriented standards of success. My standard of success most days is did I show up and do the things that are necessary for my for the kinds of goals that I would like to see and am I committing enough effort to that? Right. There's a little bit of a downside where your standard is is hard work. Because sometimes hard work is not what's necessary. sometimes it's about being smart in the way that you're working, or really a lot of the times I would say ninety percent of it is consistency rather than hard work. But point is to say, did I show up and did I try? Right. That is that would be my standard of success for my life in terms of, I guess, outcomes. And then you have the second standard of did I do the right thing? Which a lot of times is did I prioritize what is of most important to me today? Right. So if I sit here and spend all my time doing this kind of work, but I neglect my friendships or my relationship with my wife or my relationship with God. then I've failed to live up to my moral obligations, So it's not merely a matter of consistency, but it's also a matter of moral priority. And you're gonna fail at both. You're gonna fail at at the consistency, and it's not going to match your ideal picture of it. And you're gonna fail in terms of prioritizing in terms of your moral priorities. But the question is, did you genuinely try? Right? And I think that's a better standard of success than is whether, your life works out to be a mirror of what we call social success. Lastly, what was well, not lastly, but what was I taught growing up about right and wrong? this is the thing that's what that that actually is still pretty influential at me and it really it really speaks to the power of a parent's words. because my my father was a complete moral hypocrite. He wasn't a he wasn't a good person. Not that any of us are really good person people, but my father was abusive and didn't live up to his own standards of morality, at least the ones that he imposed on me. But very early on, I remember him saying to me, essentially saying that. You should always do the right thing even when it's hard. You should always do the right thing even when everybody else is against you. You should always do the right thing even if it costs you a lot. Meaning basically, you should prioritize what is right above everything else. Prioritize what is right, especially above what is practical or what is easy. and his vision of the world and one of the reasons he had s he he had this self-imposed belief of him being a good person was because he had Done what was right in his eyes, even when it was hard, right? Even when it was difficult, even when it was costly to him or his relationships or his career, whatever. And so this notion of this isn't necessarily about the exact standards of what is right and wrong, but it was the idea that like if you know what is right, you need to do what is right regardless of what it costs you in the world. Which also just set up this picture in myself that doing the right thing was always costly, which I found in my life is not always the case. There are some times where you have to make tough decisions and it's important to do the right thing, but a lot of times the right thing is not something that is really costly. And costliness is not a good signal for what is right, meaning that just because something is difficult to do or just because it's costly doesn't mean it's always right. But that was the mindset that that he gave me about doing the right thing. That was going to be costly. And then I need to sort of be on guard for I guess slipping into prioritizing practicality or ease over what was right. There's I don't know, there's so many things that I was taught about right and wrong. But but I I would say that's the main one. And that's the kind of the one that sticks with me in my head. And I still agree with it in the sense that very often we are willing to do what is easy or practical for the instead of doing what is right. And there are many times in life which doing what is right is going to cost you. Cost you materially, cost you socially, cost you with your relationships, with people who are close around you, like Sometimes sticking to the what is morally true is much more difficult than it might appear. And you have to be willing to take on those costs in order to prioritize what is right. but it's not really as stark as I was taught about it. And And oftentimes the thing that you have to fight with is not other people, but yourself in terms of what is doing doing what is right. Other things that were really emphasized me as emphasized to me as right were there's big big to-do in my and grow in my family growing up about respect and particularly respecting your parents. It was significantly frowned upon, even to the point of being like this is something like my dad would hit me for if I questioned him, or what he would call talking back, right? Which amounted to questioning him, right? So if my dad told me to do something and I had questions about it, and I tried to express those thoughts, concerns, or emotions towards him, that would be considered being disrespectful. And he would threaten to to hit me or to punish me for doing that. So growing up, respect, quote unquote respect, was equated with really uncritical or unconditional obedience. If I didn't do what my father said, I or or and didn't or argued back, argued with him about it, or really just expressed my thoughts and feelings about it, that was considered a sign of. disrespect and that disrespect was punishable by through violence, yelling or or other kind other forms of punishment. so I guess respect was well, see, this is the thing is I don't want to call it respect. Obedience, unquestioning obedience to what your parents tell you to do, to the point where you you're not even able to express what you think back, was highly prized. But it was termed, it was sort of hidden under the guise of this term respect. Like I had to learn about what respect really was later on. And that were that kind of term has even has even been significantly. triggering to me over my life because the r s the word respect was used as a catch all for do what I say and don't don't question me at all, even if those questions and concerns were were perfectly legitimate. we were not really allowed to like like I said, express our thoughts and feelings towards particularly towards my dad. And part of his whole parenting style was to, you know, abuse us. So we do something he doesn't like, he hits us, yells at us, whatever, and then he would lecture you. Like he would spend an hour, hour and a half just talking to you about, you know. what he thinks is right and wrong and why he hit you and yelled at you and explaining all these different kinds of things to you, essentially justifying to himself why he was abusing you and hoping that you would would buy into it. And of course as kids you're impressionable and this is what he would talk to you about. And you would just have to sit there and listen to him. But you couldn't argue with him. You couldn't express your thoughts and feelings about what he did. You certainly couldn't express your emotions about any of those kinds of things. very strongly. If you were if you cried, this was something that was seen as as weak and something else you could get punished for. so he wouldn't hit you and then also expect you to repress any emotions or thoughts or feelings that you had about that. Particularly in language, but even more so in in expressing, really just expressing bodily language. Like you had to it was almost it was so bizarre because He would hit you and then it would be almost like he would expect you to thank him for it or you know, express gratitude and a spy. Like I was supposed to get get up after being hit and said, You know what? Thanks, Dad. Thanks so much for for doing this to me. And I I'm just so happy and glad that that just happened to me. Like it was this really bizarro kind of environment to to grow up in. And what was even more interesting about it and more contradictory about it is that my my dad would emphasize this idea of the importance of authority and the importance of of respecting authority, and unquestioning obedience when it came to your parents, but he was very verbally expressive about I don't know, the tyranny of government and the tyranny of the state. And would talk a lot about how yeah, how evil politicians are, and how he was so proud to be an American because, you know, our founding fathers had revolted against the tyranny of, you know, I don't know, the king and how Americans have this obligation to resist tyranny and force and violence against them and and the violation of their rights, et cetera, et cetera, that people had an obligation to speak the truth, to power. So when it would come to his relationship to the authorities that were over him, the government, he was very much he would very much encourage other people to fight against tyranny, even when they told him not to, right? Like very willing to fight tyranny. but if you tried to fight his tyranny even just through words or even just express displeasure in how he was he was parenting me then or or my siblings or whatnot, then that was seen as like one of the highest violations, which was very also very odd to to be sitting in on because on the one hand he would tell you fight tyranny, but not my tyranny. And again, it was one of those other things that kinda had to to to parse growing up and and and whatnot. I don't know. I was taught a lot of different things about right and wrong as a kid, but th those are those are the major things which stick out to me. I go on and on about different particular lessons, but I feel like this video would go on too long for that. Yeah, we're we're having about 40 minutes now. So I think those are the major strokes about how I was taught about these different kinds of things. And and some of these these bleed in with one another, but to the sub question of who is still carrying beliefs they never chose. I think that's probably the most important question to ask in this video because I believe that everybody is carrying beliefs that they did not choose. When you grow up, your parents, your culture, your society, the schools that you go to, you know, I was in one sense lucky enough to have different competing views in my life that forced me to think through a lot of these different I don't know, moral beliefs or whatnot, right? Like Try to find out the moral picture or try to find out the truth in general, because there are so many conflicting views in my life. But a lot of people grow up in a generally more homogenous kind of environment where everybody around them basically reflects the same beliefs. maybe there's different variations, but they basically reflect the same beliefs. And it's easy to it's easy when everybody around you reflects the same kinds of beliefs, whether morally or otherwise, to assume those beliefs are true and regurgitate them yourself. It's very natural thing to do because children take have children believe that their their parents are or an authority that that they have all this wisdom to pass down and you don't it's very uncomfortable psychologically and cognitively to go against what the people around you, what your social environment Tells you is true. So many people don't ever get to the point of asking very deep questions about that. Democracy is one of those things in our current society that people are just grown up with, to the point where something like democracy is just assumed to be a gift from God or intrinsically good. And many people don't even question that belief their entire lives. And the few people that do are the ones who go to college and get exposed, go to get advanced degrees in colleges and get exposed to a variety of different kinds of ideas. So I would say that every single person, including myself, has beliefs that we've never chosen. And that can be dangerous because those beliefs might be untrue. they might actually be harmful in ways that we just can't really see because they don't necessarily affect us or the people around us individually. But they affect maybe the wild world, the wider world, or people that we just simply don't know or aren't exposed to. But the good news is that philosophy is all about examining those beliefs. Philosophy is all about getting the truth of those beliefs. Because too often what happens is that people recognize that they have these assumptions. And they just automatically go in the the opposite direction. They reject the things that they have been taught, they reject the morality that their parents have given them, they reject what society has told them, and they just run off into the opposite direction because, you know. That must be true if this is what their parents have taught them, right? And the truth is much more subtle. As you can probably tell from watching a little bit of this video and other communities that I've made, there are things that my parents have taught me that, you know, verbally or for their actions, that I completely reject as an adult. But there are also other things that my parents have taught me that, like, success is not necessarily defined by outcomes and it's important to do the right thing. When it's difficult, and you know, different ideas like that, that I still carry with me. Because upon becoming aware of those assumptions that I'd be given and examining them thoroughly, I can say, even coming from my background, you know what, that's true, or that's a valuable insight. and our parents and our society and the people around us and our friends and whatnot, they all have va some degree of valuable insight. They the potentially they have valuable insight. even if, again, my parents were abandoning and abusive, but they still had important things to teach me. And if I just completely rejected everything that they said, then I would never have been able to get to the truth of those kinds of things. I had to be particular. I had to investigate the truth of these things for myself. I had to become aware of the kinds of assumptions that they gave me. And then actually put them to the test. And this is one of the best things that philosophy can do to us, do for us, is to give us the tools to both identify our assumptions and examine them for meaning and truth. But it's not just philosophy that can do this. Psychology has a lot of benefits in these ways, in the sense that you get that self-examination, you get the truth of yourself, you get the truth of your history, not just what everybody's narratives about you is, but your your how you actually experience those things. And And so while I think that everybody is carrying various beliefs that that they haven't chosen, or they maybe if upon examination they they they wouldn't agree with, I believe everybody has the capacity to identify those beliefs and question them, get to the truth, the real truth and meaning of those different beliefs. And that's part of what this whole channel is about. But doing it in that kind of open, messy moment to moment, Process that allows the complexity of all these different kinds of questions to come out to fill in the picture. So If you're a person who's carrying a lot of beliefs you you feel like you haven't chose you haven't chosen, this is a place for you. This is a place where philosophy can step in and help you to identify and examine those beliefs for yourself. Anyway, I think that's where we're gonna think gonna wrap it up, so If you made it to the end of the video, thank you for s so much for watching. If you want more videos like this, please subscribe. And as always, thank you guys for watching and I'll talk to you next time.