Latest / The Vault: The Epstein Files / Virginia Robert's Repsonds To Ghislaine Maxwell's "Undisputed Facts" (Part 3) (5/30/26)

Transcript

Virginia Robert's Repsonds To Ghislaine Maxwell's "Undisputed Facts" (Part 3) (5/30/26) · The Vault: The Epstein Files

• 0:00
  Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
• 0:03
  In this episode, we're diving right back in to Virginia
• 0:06
  Roberts response to Glainne Maxwell's declaration of facts defendants Purported
• 0:13
  facts number twenty. The email to media members read to
• 0:17
  whom it may concern, Please find an attached quotable statement
• 0:21
  on behalf of Miss Maxwell. No further communication will be
• 0:24
  provided by her on this matter. Thank you for your understanding,
• 0:28
  Best Ross, Ross Gal Jane do three is Virginia Roberts,
• 0:32
  so not a new individual. The allegations made by Victoria
• 0:36
  Roberts against Glainne Maxwell are untrue. The original allegations are
• 0:40
  not new and have been fully responded to and shown
• 0:43
  to be untrue. Each time the story is retold, it
• 0:47
  changes with new solacious details about public figures and world leaders.
• 0:52
  And now it is alleged by Miss Roberts that Alan
• 0:55
  Dershowitz is involved in having sexual relations with her, which
• 0:59
  he denies. Miss roberts claims are obvious lies and should
• 1:03
  be treated as such and not publicized as news as
• 1:06
  they are defamatory claim. Maxwell's original response to the lies
• 1:10
  and defamatory claims remains the same. Maxwell strongly denies allegations
• 1:16
  of any unsavory nature which have appeared in the British
• 1:19
  press and elsewhere, and reserves her right to seek redress
• 1:22
  at the repetition of such old defamatory claims. Miss Robert's
• 1:27
  statement controverting the defendants facts. While the defendant cropped the
• 1:31
  body of the text of the email that was sent
• 1:33
  to the news media representatives, she completely omitted the headings
• 1:37
  and metadata. Miss Roberts has put an image of the
• 1:40
  email below in Miss Roberts's paragraph See GM zero zero
• 1:45
  zero six' Eight Defendants Purported facts twenty. One Mister, barton
• 1:50
  who prepared The january twenty fifteen, statement did not intend
• 1:54
  it as a traditional press release solely to disseminate information
• 1:58
  to the, media so he intentionally did not pass it
• 2:01
  through a public relations firm such as Mister gales's Firm Acuity.
• 2:06
  Reputation Miss robert's statement Controverting defendant's. Facts defendant states Mister,
• 2:11
  barden who prepared the, statement did not intend it as
• 2:14
  a traditional press release solely to disseminate information to the.
• 2:18
  Media Miss roberts contests that this statement and all statements
• 2:22
  regarding Mister barden's beliefs and purposes and the. Like, further
• 2:27
  as stated in detail In Miss roberts's opposition To defendant's
• 2:30
  motion for some re, judgment this court should not even
• 2:34
  consider The barden. Declaration, additionally there is absolutely no record
• 2:38
  evidence Of barden's intent and the court should not consider.
• 2:42
  It the next sentence, states so he intentionally did not
• 2:45
  pass it the press release through a public relations firm
• 2:49
  such as Mister gales's Firm Acuity. Reputation, again there is
• 2:53
  zero record evidence to support any assertion Of barden's. Intent
• 2:57
  to the extent that the sentence claims That carden did
• 3:00
  not give the statement To, Gal Miss roberts does not dispute.
• 3:04
  It as described, Above defendant gave the statement To gal
• 3:07
  with instructions to publish it see McCauley, Declaration exhibit forty.
• 3:12
  Eight to the extent that this sentence claims that the
• 3:15
  statement did not pass through a public relations firm such
• 3:19
  as Mister gal's Firm Acuity, Reputation Miss roberts disputes that. Statement,
• 3:24
  record documentary, evidence and testimony established that this statement was
• 3:28
  disseminated through a public relations, firm Namely Ross Goal's Firm
• 3:33
  acuity Reputation Seamacauley declaration At exhibit six and the defendants
• 3:39
  Reported facts twenty. Two The january twenty fifteen statement served two. Purposes,
• 3:45
  first Mister bardon intended to mitigate the harm To Miss
• 3:48
  maxwell's reputation from the press republication Of Miss roberts's false.
• 3:53
  Allegations he believed these ends could be accomplished by suggesting
• 3:57
  to the media, that among other, things they should Subject
• 4:00
  Miss roberts's allegations to inquiry and. Scrutiny for, example he
• 4:05
  noted in the statement That Miss roberts's allegations changed dramatically over,
• 4:09
  time suggesting that their obvious lies and therefore should not
• 4:13
  be publicized as. News Miss robert's statement Controverting defendant's. Facts
• 4:19
  Miss roberts objects to this paragraph in its. Entirety she
• 4:23
  disputes that The january twenty fifteen statement served two, purposes
• 4:27
  as this statement is wholly unsupported by the, record which
• 4:31
  defendant again neglects the. Site Miss roberts also contests the second,
• 4:35
  sentence in which defendant claims that Mister barden intended that
• 4:39
  it mitigate the harm To Miss maxwell's reputation from the
• 4:42
  press republication Of Miss roberts false. Allegations, First Miss roberts
• 4:47
  disputes any statement Of barden's intent as explained. Above Second
• 4:51
  Miss roberts disputes that there was any republication by the
• 4:55
  press as a matter of, law as explained in her
• 4:58
  memorandum of law opposing summary, judgment as the press did
• 5:02
  not republish the press statement under The New york. Law
• 5:06
  Third Miss roberts disputes that our allegations are false and
• 5:09
  sites to the following non exhaustive sampling of evidence to
• 5:13
  corroborate our allegations against the. DEFENDANT ce McCauley declaration At exhibit.
• 5:18
  Sixteen SCHOBERG cea McCauley declaration At exhibit Four FIGUEROA ce
• 5:24
  McCauley declaration At exhibit, Fourteen RIZZO ce McCauley declaration At exhibit.
• 5:29
  Twelve Lynn miller see McCauley declaration At exhibit. Thirteen Joseph
• 5:34
  RICCARI ce McCauley Declaration exhibit, Fifteen David Rodgers exhibit number
• 5:40
  two Excerpted rogers, DEPOSITION cea McCauley declaration At exhibit. Ten
• 5:46
  Marson COVA ce McCauley declaration At exhibit Eight KELLEN ce
• 5:50
  McCauley declaration at exhibit. One ALESSI ce McCauley declaration at
• 5:55
  exhibit forty. Two photographs Including. Virginia see mcaulay declares at
• 6:01
  exhibit THIRTY Us attorney victim notification letter see McCauley declaration
• 6:06
  at exhibit thirty. Three july two thousand and, One New
• 6:09
  York Presbyterian Hospital records seamaccaulley declaration at exhibit thirty. Eight
• 6:14
  Judith Lightfoot Psychological, records seamccauley declaration at exhibit twenty. Eight
• 6:19
  message pad evidencing defendant arranging to have underage girls and
• 6:24
  young women come To epstein's. HOME cea McAuley declaration at
• 6:28
  exhibit twenty. Nine black book in which defendant and other
• 6:31
  household staff maintained a roster of underage. Girls see McCauley
• 6:36
  declaration at exhibit Forty sex slave Books epstein ordered From
• 6:40
  amazon Dot. Com see mccaulley declaration at exhibit thirty. Two
• 6:44
  the folder defendant scent To thailand With Miss roberts bearing
• 6:48
  the defendant's phone. Number see McAuley declaration at exhibit thirty.
• 6:52
  Nine The Palm beach police report showing That epstein used
• 6:55
  women and girls to collect underage girls for his. Abuse
• 6:59
  see McCaulay de la leration At exhibit forty One epstein's
• 7:02
  flight logs showing that the defendant flew With Miss roberts
• 7:05
  twenty three. Times next to the defendant states He barden
• 7:09
  believed these ends could be accomplished by suggesting to the media,
• 7:13
  that among other, things they should Subject Miss roberts's allegations
• 7:16
  to inquiry and. Scrutiny Miss roberts disputes any statements as
• 7:21
  To bardon's. Belief Supra Miss roberts disputes that the harm
• 7:25
  To defendant's reputation could be mitigated by the media's inquiry
• 7:29
  into and scrutiny Of Miss robert's, allegations because a deeper
• 7:33
  inquiry would only reveal additional evidence Corroborating Miss robert's, allegations
• 7:38
  such as the evidence put forth In Miss robert's opposition
• 7:41
  memorandum of law and detailed in the bulleted. Citations. Supra
• 7:46
  defendant then, states for, example He barden noted in the
• 7:50
  statement That Miss robert's allegations changed dramatically over, time suggesting
• 7:55
  that their obvious lies and therefore should not be publicized as. News,
• 8:00
  First Miss roberts disputes That barton noted anything in that,
• 8:04
  statement as that it is unsubstantiated by the record evidence
• 8:08
  not to do the defendant's work for, her but the
• 8:10
  closest evidence defendant has for such a statement his testimony
• 8:14
  from THE gau, deposition Wherein goal speculates That bardon had
• 8:18
  a hand in drafting the press, statement an opinion which
• 8:21
  may or may not be based on firsthand. Knowledge see
• 8:25
  mccauleay declaration At exhibit SIX Gau deposition, answer AND i say,
• 8:31
  it Thanks, philip Because i'm aware of the fact that
• 8:33
  he had a, hand a considerable hand in. Drafting this
• 8:37
  is wholly insufficient to show who drafted the passages quoted
• 8:41
  by defendant, above regardless of those passages original. Author it
• 8:45
  is ultimately the defendant who noted, anything because it is
• 8:49
  her statement and she directed that it be sent to
• 8:52
  the media and the. Public, Second Miss roberts disputes that
• 8:56
  her allegations have changed over time dramatically or of. Wise,
• 9:00
  Third Miss roberts disputes that the press release suggested that
• 9:04
  our allegations are obvious lies because defendants press release affirmatively
• 9:09
  unambiguously stated that her allegations are obvious. Lies there is no,
• 9:14
  subtlety suggestion or statement of opinion. Here See roberts Versus,
• 9:19
  maxwell one sixty five. Supp dot three d one forty
• 9:23
  seven one fifty TWO sdny twenty. Sixteen these, statements as
• 9:29
  they themselves, allege are capable of being proven true or,
• 9:32
  false and therefore constitute actionable fact and not. Opinion Defendants
• 9:39
  Purported facts twenty. Three, Second Mister bardon intended The january
• 9:43
  twenty fifteen statement to be a shot across the bow
• 9:46
  of the, media which he believed had been unduly eager
• 9:50
  to Publish Miss roberts's allegations without conducting any inquiry of their. Own,
• 9:55
  accordingly in the, statement he repeatedly noted That miss roberts
• 9:58
  allegations were defama in this. Sense the statement was intended
• 10:03
  as a cease and desist letter to the media, recipients
• 10:06
  letting the media recipients understand the seriousness with Which Miss
• 10:10
  maxwell consider the publication Of miss roberts obviously false allegations
• 10:15
  and the legal indefensibility of their own. Conduct Miss robert's
• 10:20
  statement Controverting defendants. Facts this paragraph is another purported statement
• 10:25
  of defendant's council's. Intent defendant states second Mister bardon intended
• 10:30
  The january twenty fifteen statement to be a shot across
• 10:34
  the bow of the, media which he believed had been
• 10:36
  unduly eager to Publish Miss roberts's allegations without conducting any
• 10:41
  inquiry of their. Own not only does the defendant once
• 10:44
  again refer to Mister barton's, intent but she also mischaracterizes
• 10:48
  the statement as a shot across the bow of the.
• 10:51
  Media the press release did not threaten or give warning
• 10:54
  to the media in any way. Whatsoever c McCauley declaration
• 10:58
  At exhibit twenty. Six, Next Miss roberts disputes the sentence,
• 11:03
  accordingly in that the statement he repeatedly noted That miss
• 11:07
  roberts allegations were. Defamatory barden did not note anything in the,
• 11:11
  statement nor does defendant sight to any record evidence that he. Does,
• 11:16
  Furthermore Miss roberts denies that any of her allegations are
• 11:19
  defamatory in the slightest as they are all true and
• 11:23
  substantiated by record. Evidence Miss roberts also disputes the sentence
• 11:29
  in this. Sense the statement was intended as a cease
• 11:31
  and desist letter to the media, recipients letting the media
• 11:35
  recipients understand the seriousness with Which Miss maxwell considers the
• 11:39
  publication Of Miss roberts's obviously false allegations and the legal
• 11:44
  indefensibility of their own. Conduct, First Miss roberts objects to
• 11:48
  any statement Of bardon's intent as articulated. Above, second defendant's
• 11:53
  conventional press release was in no way any type of
• 11:56
  cease and desist. Letter there is no evidence in support
• 11:59
  of the, claim And defendant on surprisingly cites to. None,
• 12:03
  Third Miss roberts disputes that any media recipients would be
• 12:07
  given to understand the seriousness with Which Miss maxwell consider
• 12:10
  the publication Of miss roberts obviously false allegations and the
• 12:15
  legal indefensibility of their own conduct by the defendant self
• 12:19
  serving press, release as that is unsupported by the. Record,
• 12:23
  Finally Miss roberts rejects that our allegations are obviously, false
• 12:27
  a claim which is completely unsupported by record. Evidence all, right,
• 12:31
  Folks we're going to wrap up this episode here and
• 12:34
  in the next episode we'll pick up where we left.
• 12:36
  Off all of the information that goes with this episode
• 12:40
  can be found in the description. Box