Latest / Deep Dive / Why Influencer Wealth Was Never What It Seemed
Transcript
- 0:00You know, if you really stop to think about it, we've spent the
- 0:04better part of the last decade watching something that is just,
- 0:08well, historically speaking, it's completely unprecedented.
- 0:11Oh, absolutely. Like, think about your own
- 0:14habits for a second. We've all been sitting on our
- 0:16couches, you know, endlessly scrolling through our phones and
- 0:19just watching these 20 somethings get absolutely,
- 0:22unfathomably rich. Right, just making 32nd videos.
- 0:25Exactly. Making short videos in the
- 0:27sprawling Los Angeles mansions, we've watched them unbox luxury
- 0:31cars, casually take private jets to music festivals, and I mean,
- 0:37drop 10s of thousands of dollars on a random Tuesday afternoon
- 0:41shopping spree. Yeah, it really felt like this
- 0:43endless fountain of digital money.
- 0:45It really did, but lately you pay close attention to your
- 0:49feed. You might have noticed a severe
- 0:51shift. The digital gold rush seems to
- 0:54be hitting a massive, unyielding brick wall.
- 0:56He's hitting it hard, yeah. So today we're going on a deep
- 0:59dive into the collapse of the influencer economy.
- 1:02We're looking at why these mega creators are suddenly going flat
- 1:05broke, the hidden tax bombs that are just destroying their
- 1:09finances, and the bizarre, almost dystopian psychological
- 1:14reality of living your entire life as a performance for an
- 1:18invisible audience. It's a fascinating and frankly
- 1:21kind of alarming shift, and I think it's crucial to understand
- 1:24right from the start that what we were really looking at here,
- 1:27it isn't just a story about social media apps or Internet
- 1:30drama. Right, it's bigger than.
- 1:31That much bigger? This is a modern economic fable.
- 1:34We're watching a real time case study in extreme lifestyle
- 1:37inflation, the intricate construction of the illusion of
- 1:40wealth, and, well, the inevitable fallout of building
- 1:43an entire industry on a foundation as fragile as a tech
- 1:46company's algorithm. OK, let's unpack this, because
- 1:49the facade of riches is really where this story begins.
- 1:52The entire influencer lifestyle, especially during its absolute
- 1:55peak over the last three to four years, it was essentially built
- 1:58on the performance of wealth. Performing being the keyword
- 2:01there. Right, it's the old fake it till
- 2:03you make it adage but pumped with digital steroids.
- 2:07There are some unbelievable lengths people went to just to
- 2:10project this image. Like, think about the private
- 2:12jets. Oh, the jet sets.
- 2:14Yes, people weren't actually chartering Gulf Streams.
- 2:17There were literal fake private jet sets.
- 2:20Just a meticulously Zion fuselage sitting inside a
- 2:23warehouse where creators would pay by the hour to take photos.
- 2:28It's wild to think. About it would bring like 3
- 2:30different outfits, take hundreds of pictures and then slowly post
- 2:33them on Instagram over a few months so their followers would
- 2:36assume they were constantly flying private.
- 2:37It's the sheer commodification of aspiration.
- 2:41You know, the aesthetic of wealth became the actual
- 2:43currency of the Internet. You had young creators taking on
- 2:47massive, crippling debt just to project an image of a premium
- 2:50lifestyle. Because they had to look the
- 2:52part. Exactly because they believed
- 2:54that projecting that lifestyle was the only way to attract the
- 2:56brand deals that would eventually pay for it.
- 2:59There is a documented case of a creator who openly admitted to
- 3:03taking out $10,000 in credit card debt back in the mid twenty
- 3:0610s. Wait. $10,000. 10,000 And why?
- 3:11Just to mimic the carefree, constantly busy influencer
- 3:14lifestyle she saw on her own feed.
- 3:16She was flying to Austin for weekends, shopping at trendy
- 3:19boutique stores, dining at the most photogenic, expensive
- 3:22restaurants in town, and she couldn't actually afford any of
- 3:25it. But wait, I mean, $10,000 on a
- 3:28credit card for a young person with no real income, the
- 3:33interest on that alone is going to snowball incredibly fast.
- 3:36Yeah. How does someone rationalize
- 3:37that? Well, they rationalize it as a
- 3:39business expense, a sunk cost for marketing.
- 3:41Wow. Yeah.
- 3:42She felt she had to put up this facade of having a highly
- 3:44curated premium life to gain traction with the algorithm.
- 3:48The logic is like if I look like I already have brand deals,
- 3:51actual brands will want to work with me.
- 3:53It's a massive financial gamble based entirely on the assumption
- 3:57that virality is a meritocracy and the scale of this faking is
- 4:01just mind blowing. We're not just talking about
- 4:03buying a Gucci belt on a high interest credit card to look
- 4:05cool. No, it went way beyond that.
- 4:07Creators were moving to Los Angeles and signing leases on
- 4:11literal mansions for 30,000 to $40,000 a month.
- 4:16But here's the crazy part. They weren't even really living
- 4:19in them in a traditional sense. Right, they were just sets.
- 4:22Yeah, they were renting these massive estates for the sole
- 4:26purpose of throwing parties and having a glamorous backdrop for
- 4:29their content. But if you look closely at the
- 4:31videos from that era, a lot of these massive houses were
- 4:34completely empty. Exactly because to properly
- 4:38furnish a multi $1,000,000 Los Angeles mega mansion you're
- 4:42looking at a quarter to half $1,000,000 easily just in
- 4:45furniture and and rugs and art. Which they didn't have.
- 4:48Right, so they would pool their money to rent these cavernous
- 4:51estates to project wealth, but they quite literally couldn't
- 4:54afford a sofa. You'd watch these Get Ready With
- 4:57Me videos And the creator is sitting on the floor, their
- 5:00voice echoing off the bare walls of an empty 10,000 square foot
- 5:04house. The house wasn't a home, it was
- 5:07a stage set. The stage set with no running
- 5:09water in some cases. Oh yeah, that story.
- 5:11There's this hilarious but deeply sad anecdote about a
- 5:15group of creators going to the Coachella music festival.
- 5:19They rented this massive, gorgeous house to pretend they
- 5:22were living this wildly prosperous festival life, and in
- 5:26one of the raw video clips, you can literally hear one of them
- 5:29whispering off camera. Make sure you don't show them
- 5:33the house doesn't have water because you couldn't afford that
- 5:35part. Oh.
- 5:35Man. They were prioritizing the
- 5:37visual aesthetic of wealth over the ability to flush a toilet.
- 5:41Which perfectly illustrates the psychological trap of lifestyle
- 5:45inflation. When you start performing wealth
- 5:47at that level and then actual money, it does start rolling.
- 5:50Which it did for a time in massive ungodly amounts.
- 5:54These creators assumed it would last forever.
- 5:57They fundamentally misunderstood the nature of a windfall versus
- 6:00a steady salary. Wait, can you explain that
- 6:02distinction? Because to someone making, you
- 6:04know, 50 grand a year at a normal job, money, It's just
- 6:07money. It's a vital distinction though.
- 6:09A salary is relatively predictable, right?
- 6:12You can build a 30 year mortgage around it.
- 6:14A windfall is a sudden, often unrepeatable spike in income.
- 6:18When an influencer income goes from zero to $50,000 a month
- 6:22because they hit a viral trend on TikTok, the human brain tends
- 6:26to project that success infinitely into the future.
- 6:30They don't view it as a lucky lottery ticket.
- 6:32They view it as their new permanent.
- 6:34Baseline. And when you project that income
- 6:37infinitely, you spend infinitely.
- 6:39I mean, the story of Tara Lim is the perfect tragic example of
- 6:42this exact phenomenon. It really is.
- 6:44She rode the wave of the 2020 social media boom, pivoted her
- 6:48audience and ended up making a reported $300,000 a month on
- 6:52only fans. Which is an astronomical sum of
- 6:55money for anyone, let alone someone in their early 20s.
- 6:58Exactly, and because she was making 300 grand a month, she
- 7:01bought a three and a half million dollar mansion in
- 7:04Hollywood. She put down $1,000,000 in cash,
- 7:06got approved for a massive loan and ended up with a minimum
- 7:10monthly mortgage payment of $25,000.
- 7:13Unbelievable. Plus she started doing massive
- 7:16renovations on top of that. But then, you know, the
- 7:18algorithm changed, people's interests shifted, the economy
- 7:21tightened, and her subscriber count plummeted.
- 7:24Yeah, the bubble burst. Suddenly she's on TikTok crying
- 7:28publicly, begging for help because she has absolutely no
- 7:32idea how she is going to pay a $25,000 mortgage next month.
- 7:37But this raises an important question about the systemic side
- 7:40of this collapse. How does a 20 something with no
- 7:43long term financial history get approved for a multimillion
- 7:47dollar mortgage based on a few months of app revenue?
- 7:50Right, I was thinking the exact same thing.
- 7:52Isn't the banking system somewhat complicit here?
- 7:54If I'm 22 in a major financial institution tells me I can
- 7:58afford a $3,000,000 house, I'm going to assume the adults in
- 8:02the room did the math. There is certainly an argument
- 8:04to be made there. The underwriting standards for
- 8:07gig economy workers and creators have been wild.
- 8:10Lenders were looking got a six month window of massive cash
- 8:14flow and treating it like a tenured position at a
- 8:16university. Which is insane it.
- 8:18IS, but the creators themselves were also engaging in everyday
- 8:21capital bleed. It's not just the big ticket
- 8:24items like mansions that bankrupt you, it's the Uber ego.
- 8:26Oh the Uber ego. I love this concept.
- 8:29It happens when a creator hits say 200,000 followers.
- 8:33Suddenly they refuse to use Uber X.
- 8:36They convince themselves they have to order Uber Black for
- 8:40safety and privacy. Oh, of course, for their safety.
- 8:42Right. They completely stop cooking at
- 8:44home. They start hiring private chefs.
- 8:46They rent supercars for $500 a day just to drive around Beverly
- 8:51Hills and look successful. They rapidly acclimate to a
- 8:55standard of living that requires an incredibly high and more
- 8:58importantly, incredibly stable income to maintain.
- 9:01But the income is the exact opposite of stable.
- 9:04And this brings us to the tax bomb.
- 9:06Honestly, this part of the research made my jaw physically
- 9:09drop. It's brutal.
- 9:11We've all seen those videos of influencers opening literal
- 9:14mountains of PR packages, right? The #gifted halls where luxury
- 9:18brands send them everything from designer makeup vaults to actual
- 9:21sports cars. Yes, the unboxing video Videos
- 9:23are a staple of the genre. It's designed to make the viewer
- 9:26intensely jealous. But what most viewers, and
- 9:30apparently a shocking number of influencers themselves, don't
- 9:33realize is that the IRS does not view those items as birthday
- 9:36presents. They view them as taxable
- 9:39compensation. Exactly.
- 9:41Wow. Imagine you're opening a box of
- 9:42free designer clothes. You think it's just a fun perk
- 9:45of the job, but if a brand sends you a $2000 handbag in the hopes
- 9:49that you'll feature it in a video, that is a business
- 9:52transaction. There is a staggering story of a
- 9:55creator who received a 1099 tax form in the mail for $63,000.
- 10:0163,000. But she hadn't been paid 63
- 10:04grand in cash. That was the taxable market
- 10:07value of all the free physical products she had been gifted by
- 10:10brands over the year. The brand writes it off as a
- 10:13marketing expense, which means the IRS comes looking for the
- 10:16person who received that value. And this is where the financial
- 10:19illiteracy becomes catastrophic because she didn't even make
- 10:22half of that 62,000 in actual liquid cash income from social
- 10:26media that year, but now she owes real hard cash to the
- 10:30federal government for physical items she can't easily
- 10:33liquidate. I mean you can't exactly pay
- 10:35your taxes and half use look sticks and PR boxes.
- 10:39It forces them into massive immediate.
- 10:42They are legally on the hook for the tax on items they might not
- 10:45have even explicitly asked for, but accepted and opened on
- 10:49camera. It highlights a profound
- 10:51structural lack of basic financial education across the
- 10:55entire industry. It really feels like these
- 10:57creators are lottery winners who somehow convinced themselves
- 11:01that the jackpot pays out every single month rather than just
- 11:04once. That's exactly it.
- 11:06If we connect this to the bigger picture, your lottery analogy
- 11:09explains how you can have a scenario where an individual is
- 11:12making $100,000 a month, an amount most people would
- 11:16consider life changing wealth, and still end up completely
- 11:18bankrupt in a year. Which is just hard to wrap your
- 11:21head around. There's a documented case of a
- 11:23creator who flat out said he was making 100 grand a month on
- 11:26Snapchat and thought, you know, that's not a lot of money.
- 11:28Are you kidding? No, he bought a house without
- 11:31even negotiating the asking price, lived like a billionaire,
- 11:35and then got banned from the platform for violating terms of
- 11:38service. His income went to zero
- 11:40overnight and he instantly found himself in a massive financial
- 11:44hole. If you're spending $150,000 a
- 11:47month, making $100,000 a month still leaves you 50 grand in the
- 11:50red, right? It's basic math, but the
- 11:54illusion of infinite digital wealth obscures that math until
- 11:58it's too late. It's wild, but you know, while
- 12:01the technology is total new, we're talking about tick tock
- 12:03algorithms and Snapchat revenue. The financial trajectory we were
- 12:06talking about really isn't new at all.
- 12:08There is a direct and compelling historical precedent here.
- 12:12Professional athletes. The parallels are incredibly
- 12:14striking. Financial expert Dave Ramsey,
- 12:16who does a lot of consulting work with NFL rookie camps,
- 12:18points out a very sobering reality check.
- 12:21He notes that the average NFL career is just 3.8 years.
- 12:24Not even four years. Exactly.
- 12:27The acronym NFL, he jokes with the rookies, stands for a Not
- 12:30for long. Yet you have these young
- 12:32athletes coming into millions of dollars at 21 years old, and a
- 12:36staggering 78% of them face severe financial distress or
- 12:39bankruptcy shortly after retiring. 78% Think about that.
- 12:44You are handed millions of dollars and almost 8 out of 10
- 12:47times you end up broke. How is the failure rate that
- 12:51high? Because they buy into the exact
- 12:53same hype as the digital influencers.
- 12:55They've been told their entire lives that they are special,
- 12:58that they are physically gifted, that they are untouchable.
- 13:01They get drafted, they get surrounded by yes men and an
- 13:04entourage that relies on them for money, and they start spend
- 13:07like the initial contract is a permanent fixture of their
- 13:10lives. A great example to look at is
- 13:13the NBA contract of Lamello Ball, which perfectly
- 13:16illustrates how easily reality becomes completely distorted for
- 13:20a young person. Oh the the breakdown of that
- 13:22contract math is mind boggling. When you look at Lamello Balls
- 13:26fully guaranteed contract, it means that every single month he
- 13:31earns enough money to provide clean bottled water for most of
- 13:34Flint, MI. Incredible.
- 13:37Every single week, he makes more than 11 years of the average
- 13:41American's income. Every single day of his life, he
- 13:44earns enough to pay for a full year of tuition at Harvard
- 13:48University. Think about that for a second.
- 13:50It's hard to even process that level of wealth.
- 13:53Right. If you are a 20 something
- 13:56business making Harvard tuition money every single day, of
- 13:58course you're going to think you're invincible.
- 14:00Of course you're going to think the normal rules of gravity and
- 14:02economics don't apply to you. And Ramsey talks about how he
- 14:05sees these young athletes buy 6 luxury cars in their first
- 14:08month. They buy cards for their high
- 14:09school friends. They put their mother on an
- 14:11allowance, giving her $10,000 on the 1st of the month and then
- 14:15another 10,000 on the 15th. Just casually dropping 20 grand.
- 14:18Yeah, and then a knee injury happens, or they simply age out
- 14:22of the league after their three-year Rickle deal and the
- 14:25money completely stops. The underlying issue is
- 14:28identical for the pro athlete as it is for the TikTok star.
- 14:32They haven't learned how to manage wealth.
- 14:33They've only learned how to spend a windfall.
- 14:35Wait I get the NFL comparison but isn't there a fundamental
- 14:38difference here? Professional athletes have
- 14:41agents, players, unions, and financial advisors heavily
- 14:45pushed on them by the league. That's true.
- 14:46These TikTok kids are negotiating multi million dollar
- 14:50brand deals from their childhood bedrooms with 0 institutional
- 14:54support. Doesn't that make the influencer
- 14:56economy even more precarious? It absolutely does, which makes
- 15:00it even more dangerous. The athletes have institutional
- 15:03guardrails that they frequently ignore.
- 15:05The influencers have no guardrails whatsoever.
- 15:08And this brings us to another fascinating parallel, the
- 15:10entertainment industry itself, specifically the child actor
- 15:14pipeline. We are seeing former child stars
- 15:17suffering the exact same fate as the current crop of influencers
- 15:20for the exact same reasons. It's the exact same ecosystem.
- 15:24You achieve massive fame at a young age, the money flows in,
- 15:28the adulation from fans is intoxicating, and then you age
- 15:32out of the demographic. The Disney show gets cancelled
- 15:35and the real world hits you like a freight train.
- 15:37Yeah, the transition is brutal. There's the story of Zeke, one
- 15:40of the actors for the massive Disney Channel hit Wizards of
- 15:43Waverly Place. He publicly stated that the
- 15:46residuals from that globally syndicated show paid next to
- 15:49nothing. He ended up in a position where
- 15:52he literally couldn't afford medicated dog food for his pet,
- 15:56and he ultimately pivoted to the adult entertainment industry
- 16:00just to survive and pay his rent.
- 16:02And in the child actor space, the financial ruin isn't just
- 16:05from their own overspending, it's frequently from outright
- 16:08exploitation by the adults who were illegally supposed to
- 16:11protect. Them oh the stage, parents and
- 16:13managers. Exactly.
- 16:14Take the story of RJ Mill, who played Walter Junior on Breaking
- 16:17Bad, one of the bittest television shows of the century.
- 16:20He revealed that he ultimately paid more in taxes than he
- 16:23actually made from the entire run of the show because he hired
- 16:25A corrupt business manager. That is sickening.
- 16:28The manager would take the money RJ set aside for taxes.
- 16:31Send RJ a fake IRS filing document to make it look like it
- 16:34was paid and just pocket the cash.
- 16:36Just brutal. And there's Allison Stoner from
- 16:39Camp Rock, who found out that her business team had been
- 16:42quietly siphoning money from her account since she was a small
- 16:45child. She checked her balance as a
- 16:47young adult and found she had $0.00 in an account that should
- 16:50have had over half a million. It is a completely unregulated
- 16:54Wild West. But it's not all tragedy.
- 16:56There are people who saw the writing on the wall and escaped
- 16:59gracefully. Ethan Wacker, who was on the
- 17:02Disney show Bizarre Dvark alongside Jake Paul, realized
- 17:05how incredibly toxic the celebrity culture was behind the
- 17:08scenes. He essentially said, you know,
- 17:10I'm out, quit acting, went to college and is now working a
- 17:14normal, highly lucrative job on Wall Street.
- 17:16Those who survive seem to be the ones who recognize the fleeting,
- 17:19ephemeral nature of the platform and choose to pivot before the
- 17:22platform pivots on them. But the psychological damage for
- 17:25those who stay and try to ride the dying wave is profound.
- 17:29It really makes me wonder, is this whole influencer collapse
- 17:32just gifted kid syndrome on a massive societal scale?
- 17:37You know the concept, right? The children who are placed on
- 17:40honors classes in elementary school and told they are
- 17:43exceptional. Exactly.
- 17:45The kids who are told they're geniuses at age 7, everything
- 17:48comes incredibly easy to them. They never have to study for a
- 17:51spelling test. They never have to struggle with
- 17:53math homework because everything is easy.
- 17:56They never build what psychologists call a
- 17:58perseverance muscle. When everything comes
- 18:01effortlessly in your formative years, you naturally associate
- 18:04success with your own inherent talent rather than with
- 18:07sustained difficult effort. Right.
- 18:10And then they hit a rigorous college, or they enter the real
- 18:12workforce, and suddenly things are actually hard.
- 18:15They can't just coast on being smart, but because they haven't
- 18:18built that resilience, they literally don't know how to
- 18:21struggle. They don't have the tools.
- 18:22They don't know how to fail and try again.
- 18:25They feel bitter. They feel like the world reneged
- 18:28on a promise that life was going to be a golden, easy path.
- 18:30Yeah, it seems like these influencers who hit viral fame
- 18:33at 19 just by lip syncing to a trending audio in their
- 18:37bedrooms, they expect the world to just keep handing them
- 18:40adulation and $100,000 brand deals forever, right when the
- 18:45algorithm turns against them. They lack the resilience, the
- 18:48actual real world skills to survive the downturn.
- 18:52They don't want to learn a new skill, they just feel owed.
- 18:54They absolutely feel owed that. Deep seated entitlement is the
- 18:58central theme here. They feel that because they were
- 19:00celebrated once in one very specific, highly curated arena,
- 19:05the rest of life should be handed to them on a silver
- 19:07platter. And when the real world refuses
- 19:09to comply with that expectation, their reaction isn't to adapt or
- 19:12work harder. The reaction is bitter
- 19:14resentment. Which perfectly transitions us
- 19:16to where this gets really interesting.
- 19:18Because this entitlement doesn't just manifest as financial
- 19:21irresponsibility buying houses you can't afford.
- 19:23It manifests as a total, staggering disconnect from
- 19:27reality. A deep vocal contempt for
- 19:30anything normal. The absurdity reaches an
- 19:33absolute peak when you observe how some of these mega creators
- 19:36interact with the everyday world.
- 19:38They begin to view themselves as a higher species and the rest of
- 19:41us, the people with actual jobs, mortgages and responsibilities,
- 19:45as just background, non playable characters in their content.
- 19:48Yes, the MPC complex. There is this viral video that
- 19:52is just honestly, it's hard to watch.
- 19:54It's an influencer named Katie Ebb and the premise is that she
- 19:57walks into a normal small town grocery store, not a high end
- 20:00Erawan in Los Angeles where a smoothie cost $20.
- 20:03Just a regular everyday grocery store.
- 20:06And she acts completely genuinely traumatized by the
- 20:09experience. She treats a fully functional,
- 20:11well stocked grocery store like she has just walked into a
- 20:14haunted house. Yes, she's wandering the aisles,
- 20:18literally laughing at the fresh produce.
- 20:22She repeatedly calls the store a simulation.
- 20:25She looks into the camera and says she feels like she's on a
- 20:27different planet, that the fluorescent lights are making
- 20:30her nauseous and anxious, and that she genuinely rather starve
- 20:34than buy the food there. It's.
- 20:35Just so performative. She refuses to buy any of the
- 20:39fresh vegetables and says she only trusts the prepackaged
- 20:42processed items. She even acts visibly grossed
- 20:45out that there are workers walking around stocking the
- 20:47shelves. What's truly revealing here
- 20:49isn't just the abhorrent behavior itself, but the entire
- 20:52production process behind it. The fact that she filmed this
- 20:55meltdown, edited it, watched it back on her phone, and thought
- 20:58to herself, yes, this makes me look relatable and funny.
- 21:01I should broadcast this to the world.
- 21:02That's the craziest part. It shows a complete hermetic
- 21:06insulation from how the vast majority of Americans live their
- 21:09lives. She is walking through a place
- 21:11where parents are painstakingly trying to stretch $40 to feed
- 21:15their kids for a week, and she is mocking the very existence of
- 21:19the building. For millions of followers, the
- 21:21contempt for the working class is palpable.
- 21:24And that audacity, that complete lack of empathy, isn't an
- 21:28isolated incident. The Internet is absolutely
- 21:31littered with these examples. Take the story of James Charles,
- 21:34one of the biggest beauty influencers on the planet.
- 21:36Oh, this story. A few years ago, during a wave
- 21:39of corporate bankruptcies, a woman who had just been laid off
- 21:42from her job as a flight attendant at Spirit Airlines
- 21:45reached out to him via direct message on Twitter.
- 21:48She politely asked if he could share her GoFundMe link to help
- 21:52her pay rent while she looked for a new job.
- 21:54And his response was not just a polite decline or even just
- 21:57ignoring the message, which would have been perfectly normal
- 22:00and acceptable. No, he blasted her to his entire
- 22:03audience of millions of followers.
- 22:06He recorded a video explicitly calling her a lazy piece of
- 22:09shit, calling her an entitled prick, and essentially saying
- 22:13that because she had the audacity to ask a wealthy person
- 22:16for a retweet to help her survive a layoff, she was what
- 22:19was wrong with modern society. It's hard to even fathom.
- 22:23Let that sink in. A multimillionaire who makes his
- 22:26living filming himself applying makeup is screaming at an
- 22:29unemployed flight attendant, calling her lazy.
- 22:32It perfectly illustrates the total inversion of reality that
- 22:35happens in this bubble. The person whose primary output
- 22:38is aesthetic vanity views. The person who performs
- 22:41grueling, on your feet customer service labor as the lazy one.
- 22:44There's another story that perfectly captures this brain
- 22:47rot. An influencer was throwing an
- 22:49absolute temper tantrum on TikTok because a follower didn't
- 22:52mail her a free halter top to borrow for a New Year's Eve
- 22:55party. The influencer went on a rant
- 22:57accusing this follower of ghosting her maliciously, trying
- 23:00to ruin her night, and being a terrible person.
- 23:03But the reality, which eventually came out in the
- 23:04comments, was that the follower was an emergency room nurse.
- 23:08Exactly. She hadn't maliciously ghosted
- 23:10the influencer to ruin her party.
- 23:13She had been forced to work a grueling 20 hour double shift in
- 23:17the ER on New Year's Eve. While the influencer is having a
- 23:21literal meltdown into her ring light because she thinks she
- 23:23looks like a fridge without of this specific borrowed top.
- 23:27The nurse is literally saving human lives in a hospital for 20
- 23:30straight hours, and the influencer felt completely
- 23:34justified in weaponizing her millions of followers to bully
- 23:37this nurse over a piece of fabric.
- 23:40This raises A profound psychological question about
- 23:42what happens to human development when your entire
- 23:45existence becomes a closed feedback loop of your own image.
- 23:49If your job is making lifestyle content, but your life consists
- 23:52entirely of the act of making that content, you become an
- 23:55infinite mirror reflecting nothing but yourself.
- 23:58Oh, the infinite mirror analogy. I love this.
- 24:00Let's explore that. It's like they have no actual
- 24:02substance or lived experiences outside of the performance
- 24:05itself. They aren't going out,
- 24:07experiencing the richness of the world and then coming back to
- 24:10share it. The performance of a life is the
- 24:12only experience they have, and because of that you end up with
- 24:15creators becoming bizarre parodies of themselves.
- 24:19You have someone unboxing 2 identical $5000 leopard print
- 24:22bags on camera crying because they couldn't decide which one
- 24:26they liked better on the website so they just bought both.
- 24:29So disconnected. And they're flaunting this to an
- 24:32audience where the average person is putting a $7.00
- 24:35cheesecake back on the shelf because grocery prices have gone
- 24:38up. It's completely grotesque.
- 24:40And eventually, that level of grotesque display, combined with
- 24:43the crushing economic pressure as the average person is facing
- 24:46in the real world, generates a massive cultural backlash.
- 24:50People simply run out of patience.
- 24:52The social contract breaks. Which brings us to the Great
- 24:54Nantucket culture War. This was the specific catalyst
- 24:58for the current mainstream public backlash against the
- 25:01influencer class, and it all started with a piece of paper in
- 25:04a window. A very small sign in a very
- 25:07small historic town. Exactly.
- 25:10A family owned craft shop in Nantucket called Four Winds
- 25:13Craft Guild. They've been open since 1948
- 25:16selling woven baskets and local art, and the owner put up a
- 25:19simple printed paper sign in the front window that read in plain
- 25:23text. No influencers.
- 25:25The intent, according to the shop owner, was relatively
- 25:28straightforward and practical. Nantucket has recently become a
- 25:32highly aestheticized, highly desirable backdrop for social
- 25:35media content. The owner was exhausted by
- 25:38people coming into his small, historic shop not to appreciate
- 25:42or purchase the local crafts, but simply to use his commercial
- 25:45space as a free film set. These creators bring in massive
- 25:48ring lights, they set up tripods in the aisles, they take up
- 25:51physical space, and they completely disrupt the
- 25:53experience for actual paying customers.
- 25:55Which is incredibly rude. He later clarified to the press
- 25:58that the sign was meant to be somewhat tongue in cheek, a push
- 26:00back against the sheer lack of respect for the physical space.
- 26:04But the Internet, as we know, does not do nuance.
- 26:07They did not take it as a tongue in cheek comment about tripping
- 26:10over ring lights. It sparked an absolute Internet
- 26:13war. And this is where we have to
- 26:15objectively breakdown the arguments on both sides, because
- 26:18the rhetoric gets incredibly intense.
- 26:21Let's start with the perspective of the creators who felt
- 26:23targeted by the sign. The primary argument was
- 26:26presented by Paige Lorenz, a major lifestyle and fashion
- 26:29influencer who had actually recently opened her own brands
- 26:32physical pop up store in Nantucket.
- 26:34Right, and Pages argument is fundamentally rooted in a
- 26:37feminist defense of the entire creator economy.
- 26:41Her stance is that the influencer industry is a $250
- 26:44billion global economy, and it is largely led by and populated
- 26:49by young women. Her argument is essentially that
- 26:51putting up a no influencer sign is inherently misogynistic.
- 26:55She argues that it delegitimizes the space where women have found
- 26:58massive financial freedom, entrepreneurial success and
- 27:01career flexibility entirely outside the traditional male
- 27:04dominated structures of corporate America.
- 27:06OK, I see where she's coming from.
- 27:08The premise is that society is always quick to dismiss business
- 27:11led by women, specifically young women creating lifestyle content
- 27:14as frivolous, vain, or not a real job, and that this sign is
- 27:19a physical manifestation of that deep seated prejudice.
- 27:22She even posed the question on her platform.
- 27:25If you call yourself a feminist but proudly put up a no
- 27:28influencer sign, it's worth asking who you are attempting to
- 27:31delegitimize and why. OK, so that is the defense, that
- 27:35attacking influencers is just a proxy for attacking female
- 27:38entrepreneurs. But the counter argument, which
- 27:41is heavily championed by cultural commentators like Betty
- 27:44Unfiltered, is fiercely critical of that specific framing.
- 27:47Betty points out that in the rush to defend themselves, some
- 27:50creators didn't just call the sign sexist, they actually
- 27:53equated the no influencer sign to Jim Crow era segregation
- 27:56signs. Yes, comparing a store policy
- 27:59against filming to no blacks allowed signs from the Jim Crow
- 28:02South. Which the counter argument finds
- 28:04absolutely important. The critique here is that
- 28:06equating a small stores policy against filming equipment to
- 28:09historic, systemic, violent racial oppression is deeply out
- 28:13of touch. Very out of touch.
- 28:14Betty Unfiltered argues that influencing is a luxury career
- 28:18choice. It is a highly privileged way to
- 28:20make a living. It is a job title, not a
- 28:23marginalized, protected demographic identity.
- 28:26You are not born an influencer. A store owner cannot look at you
- 28:30walking down the street and know you are an influencer unless you
- 28:33walk through their door wielding a camera, speaking to your phone
- 28:36and demanding free things. The critics of the feminist
- 28:40defense point out a major scaling issue in the rhetoric.
- 28:43They stress that the store owner wasn't banning a demographic, he
- 28:47was banning a specific disruptive behavior.
- 28:50And the critique further notes that attempting to weaponize the
- 28:53heavy language of the civil rights movement or
- 28:56intersectional feminism to defend the right to film a
- 28:59TikTok outfit check in a private business actually belittles and
- 29:03damages those very real social justice movements.
- 29:06I'm curious what you think about the PR strategy here.
- 29:08Does utilizing that kind of academic civil rights language
- 29:11to defend filming in a craft store actually backfire?
- 29:15It feels like it alienates the exact working class demographics
- 29:18they were trying to appeal to. From a sociological standpoint,
- 29:21it absolutely alienates the everyday public.
- 29:24The Internet has developed a tendency to weaponize highly
- 29:27academic social justice language for minor everyday
- 29:31inconveniences. Yeah, we see that all the time.
- 29:34When a highly privileged, wealthy creator adopts the
- 29:37language of the historically oppressed simply because a small
- 29:39business asked them to put their phone away, the average working
- 29:42person who faces actual systemic hurdles to pay rent or afford
- 29:46healthcare feels nothing but exhaustion and resentment
- 29:48towards that creator. It shatters any remaining
- 29:51illusion of relatability. It becomes APR crisis.
- 29:54And while this cultural backlash is happening loudly, on the
- 29:57surface belief it all, the actual economic engine of the
- 30:00industry is quietly seizing up. We are hitting the algorithmic
- 30:04brick wall. This is where the story shifts
- 30:07from a cultural critique of bad behavior to a systemic economic
- 30:11collapse. The well of Internet money is
- 30:13quite literally drying up. There is a great quote from Emma
- 30:15Chamberlain, who is basically royalty in the YouTube and
- 30:19creator space. She's been doing this at the
- 30:21highest level for years. She predicted this current
- 30:25crash, saying the industry feels like a train going towards a
- 30:28brick wall. That's powerful image.
- 30:30She noted that the audience is becoming too keen to the inner
- 30:33workings of the industry. They know exactly when they are
- 30:36being sold to, they know what a brand integration looks like and
- 30:39they just don't want it anymore. And the hard financial data
- 30:42supports her feeling completely. The middle class influencer is
- 30:45being completely wiped out. While the top 1%, the Emma
- 30:49Chamberlain's, the Mr. Beasts might still be securing massive
- 30:53multi $1,000,000 brand deals, the reality for everyone else is
- 30:57grim. Just grim.
- 30:58Only 13% of creators actually make over $100,000 a year.
- 31:03Meanwhile, nearly 50% of people trying to be full time creators
- 31:07make less than $15,000 annually. That is not a living wage in any
- 31:11major city in America. There are creators currently
- 31:14going viral for breaking down their plunging monthly incomes.
- 31:18One creator who has over 400,000 followers and averages a solid
- 31:23100,000. Views of video revealed she made
- 31:26only $58,000 last year. Another showed her monthly
- 31:31income dropping from a comfortable, livable wage to
- 31:33just over $2400. That shatters the myth that a
- 31:38big follower account automatically equals a massive
- 31:41bank account. And the reason for this economic
- 31:43collapse is the death of the follower.
- 31:45As a reliable metric, we have to look at the mechanics of the
- 31:48modern algorithm. In the early days of YouTube or
- 31:51Instagram, you operated on what is called a social graph.
- 31:55OK, a social graph. If you gain a subscriber, that
- 31:58person was highly likely to see your next video on their
- 32:01chronological feed. You were building a compounding
- 32:03audience. Every new follower was an asset
- 32:06in the bank. But now everything has changed,
- 32:08largely driven by the TikTok boom.
- 32:11Followers no longer guarantee views.
- 32:13We've shifted from a social graph to an interest graph.
- 32:16Precisely. The algorithm now prioritizes
- 32:18highly engaging individual pieces of content over the
- 32:22creator's historical follower count.
- 32:25The 4U page only cares about keeping the user's eyes on the
- 32:28platform. Right now, it will serve a user
- 32:31a video from an account with 10 followers if the engagement
- 32:33metrics are high, and it will bury a video from an account
- 32:36with 2 million followers if the first 100 people swipe past it.
- 32:40Exactly. You are no longer building a
- 32:42reliable, predictable community. You're fighting for your
- 32:45absolute life on the 4U page every single day.
- 32:49The platforms, not your audience, decide how many people
- 32:52you reach on a given day. It's terrifying for them.
- 32:55One creator stated, you know, I don't have 4 million followers.
- 32:58I probably have an average of 20,000 followers because that's
- 33:01all the platform will reliably push her content to on an
- 33:04average day. Think about what that does to
- 33:06your mental health. It's like having a boss who
- 33:08fires you every single night and every single morning you have to
- 33:11wake up, put on a suit and re interview for your exact same
- 33:14job just to get a paycheck for that day.
- 33:17You can never rest on your laurels.
- 33:19And that dynamic is creating massive systemic burnout.
- 33:23Creators are terrified to take a weekend off, let alone a
- 33:25vacation, because they fear the algorithm will punish them for
- 33:28inconsistency. They are tying their financial
- 33:30safety, their ability to pay rent and their emotional
- 33:33well-being to a black box algorithm managed by engineers
- 33:37in another country, which they do not control and cannot
- 33:40predict. Which is wild.
- 33:42And the payouts are plummeting. There are creators who are
- 33:44making thousands of dollars a month on creator funds who
- 33:47suddenly dropped to making literally $100 a month for the
- 33:51exact same amount of views simply because the platform
- 33:54quietly changed its back end payout structure.
- 33:57It's a completely unpredictable, hostile working environment,
- 34:01which leads to this incredible ironic twist we are seeing now
- 34:05the 9 to 5 Renaissance. It is deeply, deliciously
- 34:09ironic. For years, the entire influencer
- 34:11brand was built on aggressively mocking the nine to five job.
- 34:15The rhetoric was always escape the Matrix, be your own boss,
- 34:18don't be a corporate slave. Why are you working for someone
- 34:21else's dream? But now we are seeing a flood of
- 34:24videos from these exact same influencers celebrating their
- 34:28return to normal, traditional corporate jobs.
- 34:31Because they are exhausted by the instability, they are
- 34:33realizing that there is immense tangible value in a predictable
- 34:37paycheck that hits your direct deposit every two weeks,
- 34:40regardless of whether a video went viral or flopped.
- 34:43They crave employer sponsored healthcare benefits.
- 34:46They crave a 401K match. They crave not having a panic
- 34:50attack. 1 Earning for brand will take 90 days to pay an invoice
- 34:53when rent is due tomorrow. The reality of being your own
- 34:56boss in the creator economy is that you are also your own HR
- 35:00department, your own accounting department, your own legal team,
- 35:03and your own crisis management PR firm, all while entirely at
- 35:07the mercy of a changing algorithm.
- 35:09The fantasy is completely shattered.
- 35:11But as we look at the wreckage of this economic model, we have
- 35:13to look at what this entire era has done to our collective
- 35:16psyche. We're looking at a philosophical
- 35:18void. What does it mean to live
- 35:20entirely for the camera? This is perhaps the most
- 35:22lingering and disturbing aspect of the entire phenomenon.
- 35:26Long after the money dries up, the psychological rewiring
- 35:29remains. So what does this all mean for
- 35:32you, the person listening to this?
- 35:34Think about this viral video that perfectly encapsulates the
- 35:37mindset a creator was asked a hypothetical question by an
- 35:41interviewer. If you could go on an all
- 35:44expenses paid absolute luxury vacation to anywhere in the
- 35:48world, but the catch is you can take a single picture or video
- 35:51to post on social media, would you go?
- 35:53And her answer, without hesitation, was a definitive no.
- 35:57She explicitly stated she would refuse a free luxury vacation if
- 36:01she couldn't post it. She argued that because her
- 36:04entire life is dedicated to growing her social media, if she
- 36:07can't gain followers and engagement from the experience,
- 36:10she doesn't even want to be there.
- 36:11The experience is worthless to her.
- 36:13It's a stunning admission of defeat.
- 36:15It means the experience itself has 0 inherent value to her.
- 36:18The beauty of the sunset, the taste of the food, the immersion
- 36:21in a new culture, the physical relaxation of being on a beach,
- 36:25none of it matters internally. It's all just content.
- 36:27Right, it only gains value when it is transmuted into digital
- 36:31content, uploaded to a server and validated by the likes and
- 36:35comments of total strangers. There's a really profound
- 36:38philosophical point to be made here.
- 36:40It argues that many of these influencers no longer want to
- 36:43live a life. They want to perform one on a
- 36:46stage. They want to view their own
- 36:48existence like a satisfied audience member watching
- 36:51episodes of a TV show starring themselves.
- 36:54That's a great way to put it. They're painstakingly curating a
- 36:57Museum of their life, but they aren't actually living inside
- 37:00it. It's the ultimate alien nation
- 37:02from the self. You are completely detached from
- 37:05the present moment because you are viewing the present moment
- 37:07entirely through the lens of how it will be perceived, judged,
- 37:11and consumed by strangers in the future.
- 37:13You are never truly there. Contrast that tragic mindset
- 37:17with the story shared by one of the cultural commentators we
- 37:19looked at. He told a story about being on a
- 37:22cross country road trip with a friend.
- 37:24They were driving through the Nevada desert, got tired, and
- 37:27pulled over to sleep in their car for the night.
- 37:29When they woke up, they were trapped in a terrifying,
- 37:32beautiful, completely unexpected Blizzard.
- 37:35They were stranded in the snow for hours, totally isolated.
- 37:39But he notes that it was one of the most thrilling, hilarious,
- 37:42deeply memorable experiences of his entire life.
- 37:45And he took absolutely 0 photos. The experience belonged entirely
- 37:50to him and his friend in that exact moment.
- 37:52It wasn't optimized for a feed. It wasn't monetized.
- 37:55Because a human experience doesn't need to be documented to
- 37:58be real or to hold immense value.
- 38:01But if your entire self worth and your financial survival is
- 38:04tied to engagement metrics, a silent, undocumented joy feels
- 38:09like a wasted opportunity. It feels like a loss of revenue.
- 38:12And if the goal is purely A flawless aesthetic performance
- 38:16to sell products, if the humanity, the flaw laws, and the
- 38:18actual lived experience are no longer required by the audience
- 38:21or the brand, then we arrive at the terrifying final evolution
- 38:25of this trend. AI influencers.
- 38:27If human influencers have turned themselves into walking
- 38:29billboards, technology is simply stepping in to do the job more
- 38:32efficiently. Enter Ava Deloney.
- 38:35Yes, if you don't know who this is, Ava Deloney is a creator
- 38:39with almost a million followers. She is a singer, a dancer, a
- 38:42visual artist. She posts about her complex back
- 38:45story, her Japanese and Nigerian heritage, overcoming a difficult
- 38:49childhood where her father left her struggles with anxiety, and
- 38:52she does not exist now. She is entirely generated by
- 38:55artificial intelligence. Every pixel, every tear, every
- 38:58story, a supercomputer. It's insane, if you look at the
- 39:02comments on her videos, people are praising her, defending her
- 39:05from haters, calling her an inspiration, totally unaware
- 39:09that they are interacting with lines of code.
- 39:10It's dystopian. But from a corporate bland's
- 39:12perspective, this makes perfect sense.
- 39:14If you just need a beautiful, flawless avatar to hold up a
- 39:17bottle of shampoo or wear a fast fashion designer dress, why on
- 39:22earth would you hire a human? Are people really falling for it
- 39:25though? Or is it just a novelty?
- 39:26A huge portion of the audience truly believes she is real, but
- 39:30even for those who know she's AI, they don't seem to care as
- 39:33long as the aesthetic is pleasing.
- 39:35And for the brands, a human is messy.
- 39:38A human demands a $10,000 a day rate.
- 39:41A human gets burnt out, has mental breakdowns on TikTok,
- 39:43live ages out of the demographic, or gets caught in a
- 39:46massive PR scandal for screaming at an airline worker.
- 39:50An AI influencer is perfectly brand safe, infinitely scalable,
- 39:54doesn't need to sleep, and requires no backstage pampering
- 39:57or craft services. If the creator economy has
- 39:59already reduced human life to a sanitized performance designed
- 40:03to sell products, AI is simply a more efficient, cost effective
- 40:06performer. It's incredibly bleak, but it
- 40:09speaks to the underlying fear driving so much of this frantic
- 40:12human influencer behavior. The absolute terror of failure.
- 40:17There's a fascinating historical pushback regarding this fear of
- 40:19failure. If you look at the greatest
- 40:21artists and creators in history, the failure rate is
- 40:24astronomical. Oh.
- 40:25Absolutely. Pablo Picasso created roughly
- 40:27150,000 pieces of art in his lifetime, but he is known for
- 40:31about 1170 hits. That is a .7% success rate.
- 40:36Right. Babe Ruth struck out constantly.
- 40:39Frank Sinatra recorded thousands of songs, but only a fraction
- 40:43became massive in during hits. The point is that true enduring
- 40:47success requires a massive volume of failure.
- 40:50It requires immense patience, decades of dedication to a
- 40:53craft, and the willingness to try, fail quietly, and try
- 40:57again, over and over. But these influencers, they are
- 41:00terrified of failing quietly because everything they do is
- 41:02public. Every single failure is public.
- 41:04They want a 100% success rate right out of the gate.
- 41:07They want the shortcut. They want the $1,000,000, the
- 41:10mansion and the adulation immediately, at age 19, without
- 41:14the decades of patient, unseen labor required to build actual
- 41:18enduring art or a sustainable business.
- 41:20They want the reward without the risk.
- 41:21And when the algorithmic system stops delivering that immediate,
- 41:24unearned reward, they crumble. They want the aesthetic of
- 41:27success without the foundation of mastery, and as the
- 41:31algorithmic foundation inevitably crumbles beneath
- 41:33them, the aesthetic alone cannot sustain them.
- 41:37So let's wrap this up. We've journeyed from the
- 41:39absolute peak of the influencer bubble.
- 41:41The fake private jets, the empty mega mansions, the crushing
- 41:45$25,000 mortgages built on fleeting Internet money.
- 41:49We've explored the historical echoes of child stars and pro
- 41:53athletes, seeing how sudden wealth, when paired without
- 41:56financial literacy or emotional resilience, almost inevitably
- 41:59ends in disaster. We watched the sheer absurdity
- 42:02of the bubble bursting in real time, from the Nantucket culture
- 42:06war over a window sign to out of touch influencers melting down
- 42:10in normal grocery stores. And finally, we hit the
- 42:13unforgiving algorithmic reset where the middle class of
- 42:16creators is being entirely wiped out, forcing a desperate and
- 42:19often celebrated return to the stability of the nine to five
- 42:23job. It is a complete recalibration
- 42:25of what the Internet values, what it is willing to pay for,
- 42:28and what we as a society are willing to tolerate.
- 42:30Exactly, And to leave you with one final thought to Mull over
- 42:34something to really think about the next time you open your
- 42:36phone. We've spent the better part of
- 42:38the last decade treating visibility and attention as the
- 42:41ultimate luxury goods. The belief was that the more
- 42:45people looking at you, the higher your status.
- 42:48But as this influencer bubble violently bursts and living a
- 42:51highly publicized life becomes synonymous with severe anxiety,
- 42:55burnout, brutal public scrutiny, and financial ruin, what if the
- 42:59ultimate status symbol of the next decade flips completely?
- 43:02What if the highest form of modern luxury is absolute,
- 43:06untraceable privacy? To have a life so rich, so
- 43:09secure and so fulfilling that you never, ever feel the need to
- 43:12prove it to a stranger on the Internet.
- 43:14It's a fascinating thought. Thank you so much for joining us
- 43:17on this deep dive. Keep your eyes open, stay
- 43:19curious, and always keep questioning the feeds you scroll
- 43:22through every single day. See you next time.