Latest / The Team House / Israel/Hamas Conflict & Ukraine War Update w/ CIA Officer | Marc Polymeropoulos | Ep. 250
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, folks, I just want to take a minute to ask you to
- 0:03go in rate this podcast. Let the Team House know how you think we're
- 0:07doing. Go and rate us on whatever platform you're listening to this on,
- 0:11whether it's iTunes or Spotify or whatever else. Those ratings really help us out
- 0:16and we really appreciate the feedback to let us know what you like and what
- 0:19you don't like. And if you do like the Team House and you'd like
- 0:23to support us, go check out our Patreon page and you can actually support
- 0:27the stream and well as get access to our bonus segments and bonus episodes.
- 0:32Yeah, if you're going to give us a great review, please do.
- 0:35And if you're going to give us ant secret view, why don't you just
- 0:37send us an email and we'll talk about special operations. Cobert ask me and
- 0:49the team House with your hopes. Jack Burphy and David Park everybody, Welcome
- 1:03to the Team House. I'm Dave Park. Jack can't be here tonight.
- 1:07Welcome our many time guests, Mark poly Monopolis. Mark is a retired CIA
- 1:15s I s correct uh you know, a big shot with a vast knowledge
- 1:22of UH international affairs with the intelligence community and particularly on the topic we're going
- 1:27to talk about tonight, which will cover the situation Israel, will also talk
- 1:33about Ukraine. Uh be welcome, Mark, Thanks for joining us. Awesome,
- 1:38great to be here. I think this is number five. I believe
- 1:41this time I've been on. I don't know, I don't know what the
- 1:42record is. But I'm but I'm a little I'm a little insulted. Jack
- 1:46is not here again. I think he's avoiding me. So we're gonna have
- 1:48to address this somehow. I can't come to the Christmas party. That's it.
- 1:52Oh yeah, well he's playing hard to get. He's like, yea,
- 1:56if he's not here, maybe you'll come to the Christmas party. Uh,
- 1:59you know, Okay, touche, let's go. We want to give
- 2:01a quick shout out to our first sponsor of the evening, Barbel Apparel dot
- 2:07com. Barbel Apparel makes amazing clothes. Guys. Uh, these jeans are
- 2:12a Barbel Apparel. They stretch, they stretch. My ass has never looked
- 2:15better. I mean, you will love their clothes. Check them out Barbel
- 2:20Apparel dot Stand up again hold on spin for us. I mean that's a
- 2:27great looking ass. Yeah yeah, I I I think that I was walking
- 2:34down the street and somebody called me a fot. There you go, so
- 2:38plus one. Yeah, so the genes are definitely working. But uh yeah,
- 2:44so check out Barbel Apparel. Great, great clothes. Honestly, I'll
- 2:47never wear another pair of jeans. I mean, I'll wear other pairs of
- 2:51genius, but to always be Barbel Apparel. I love them to death.
- 2:54Anyway, Mark, Uh, let's kind of get into it. Oh,
- 3:00Barbell Apparel dot com slash Teamhouse get a free Stealth hoodie with any purchase over
- 3:05nine and nine dollars. So Mark, back to you, the star of
- 3:10the show. For people who may you know, be new to the show
- 3:15or haven't seen you before, can you give us the brief intro into your
- 3:19background? Sure of course. I worked for twenty six years at CIA,
- 3:24start off in nineteen ninety three. You know, the first two desks I
- 3:32was sitting on was the Afghan desk, and then then went and did some
- 3:37stuff on the Palestinians and then went to CTC on the Hamas desk. So
- 3:39talk about stuff that's relevant. I mean, nothing frickin' changes. It's unbelievable,
- 3:44same players, But we can talk about that a little later. I
- 3:46served twenty six years, did seven tours overseas, most of the time in
- 3:50the Middle East, lots of time in Iraq, in Afghanistan, and then
- 3:55the last two years of my career after I unfortunately got promoted. You were
- 3:59very kind. I'm certainly was not a big wig. I just think hung
- 4:00around a lot. So if you hang around there, you're gonna get promoted
- 4:03to the kind of general officer cadre. But I was the deputy in the
- 4:08acting operations chief over what's called the Europe and Eurasia Mission Center. So that
- 4:13really had to do with Russia, you know, Ukraine places. What you
- 4:16know, we thought was kind of calm and quiet, not really, but
- 4:18really it was. It was an amazing It was a unique career and uh,
- 4:24and you know, I kind of look back and I think about all
- 4:26the highs and lows. I'm very humble. I'm really proud of a lot
- 4:30of the stuff we did, and then some terrible things happened to when we've
- 4:32lost friends, uh, in the line of duty. And so you kind
- 4:35of sit back and you come on great shows like this. That's why I
- 4:39love coming on here. You know. Someone asked me, why do you
- 4:41love coming on the Teamhouse. All they do is kind of drink and hang
- 4:43out and chat, and I'm like, that's what I fucking do all that
- 4:45time. That's my life now. I mean I usually do it at a
- 4:47dive bar in Northern Virginia called the Vienna End. But I love this show
- 4:50and because you know, you guys are my peeps and so it's a very
- 4:54very comfortable place. But it's awesome to be on again. Thank you very
- 4:56much. We appreciate it. Do you want to I don't know if you
- 5:00want to start with the with Hamas and the Israel Hamas question, or if
- 5:04you want to start with any updates on Russia Ukraine, because that's really fallen
- 5:09off in the news since uh, you know, since October seventh. So
- 5:14do you have a preference, Yeah, let's do Let's do uh Israel stuff
- 5:18first, okay, uh, just because it's as fresh in my mind,
- 5:21I think some of the listeners will be interested because I had the opportunity I'll
- 5:26talk about in a sect to go to the Israel Embassy the other day and
- 5:29view the raw footage of October seventh, which was fucking horrendous. But actually
- 5:32I they allowed me to take notes. They're allowed members of the media,
- 5:38and somehow I've qualified as that. I kind of talked my way in and
- 5:42I took a couple of pages of notes and they're gruesome and so I'll share
- 5:45that. But first I just have to say hi to D producer, because
- 5:47you know, a fellow ethnically uh uh Greek, ethnic Greek. I'm having
- 5:54some uza here you go. D. That's great, Thank you, Mark.
- 5:57I appreciate the respect we got. As you know, the Greek mafia
- 6:00of course runs the CIA. Everybody knows that I've been saying it. Nobody
- 6:03said, nobody wants to believe me. Well it's true. You know,
- 6:06we went we went to a family restaurant, one of one of D's family
- 6:12restaurants last night, and I'm pretty sure that there were some KG individuals hanging
- 6:16out in the shadows. Yeah, a couple of people on parole for sure.
- 6:20Well, then they'd fit right in the intelligence community. No, So,
- 6:25you know, the the you know Israel uh Hamas you know war,
- 6:30you know, it was fast and let me just kind of go, you
- 6:32know, I'll start from October seventh, and so you know, I think
- 6:38you know, you know Dave and D you certainly know I'm a contributor for
- 6:41MSNBC. That's one of my kind of post retirement gigs, and I'm on
- 6:46TV a lot, and so you know, they used me as their national
- 6:47security analysts because of my background in the intelligence community. I think they also
- 6:50like having someone who is very much in the center because I don't always kind
- 6:55of tow the line of a lot of what uh is set on air there,
- 6:59And that's good you want to have just like you know, you need
- 7:00some folks in the center on Fox, you need some folks in the center
- 7:03on MSNBC. But I got a I got a call. I actually I
- 7:08woke up. I was in Harrisonburg of Virginia. It was October seventh at
- 7:11seven am, and I had fifty five text messages and it was MSNBC saying
- 7:15you got to get on the air in five minutes, you know, Andrew
- 7:17Mitchell's waiting, and I was like why. They said, literally the text
- 7:20was Hamas just in a Hamas army just invaded Israel. And I looked over
- 7:26my wife and I think, I said, I think I got on TV
- 7:29now, like I got to get my computer up, and she said,
- 7:30what happened? I said, I looked at I told her, and I
- 7:32said, did we drink too much last night? Like, was there too
- 7:34much wine that we had? Because that's insane. It wasn't. It wasn't.
- 7:38Hamas and Israel were going at it again. It was literally a Hamas
- 7:42army had invaded. And as you kind of unpack it, you know it
- 7:45it was relatively true. Is you know, three thousand man army, complete
- 7:49with you know, Hamas's kind of shock troops, there's special operations capabilities and
- 7:54over kind of twenty different locations in Israel, you know, launched this surprise
- 7:58attack which ended up killing twelve hundred Israelis and certainly changed you know, changed
- 8:05the region in the near and medium term, and then of course became a
- 8:09huge problem for the United States government. But but you know, just in
- 8:13terms of kind of this this shock, I then I you know, immediately
- 8:16thought back to, well, that was one of the first operational desks that
- 8:18CTC in nineteen ninety six where there was a Hamas desk, and guess what,
- 8:22it's not there anymore. And so then you start thinking about, you
- 8:24know, how did this happen? And it was pretty clear I want to
- 8:26I take no credit for this, I said it on air at seven o'clock
- 8:30in the morning on October seventh. But I said, hey, this is
- 8:31Israel's nine to eleven, and it's certainly when everyone you know, this is
- 8:35not really an original thought. But ultimately this was this you know, kind
- 8:41of incredible intelligence failure in which the vaunted you know shin Bet, the Israeli
- 8:46Internal Service, Israeli military intelligence, you know, Masad is externally focused.
- 8:50So they're looking up at Lebanon and looking at Ran. This is not on
- 8:52Masad, but shin Bet and Idi what happened? And it turns out they,
- 8:56you know, they focused so much on kind of you know, signals
- 8:58and tell leigence intercepts or el electronics, intelligence sensors or you know, they
- 9:05built its huge wall that even went underground. They had drones in the air,
- 9:07but they missed the human intelligence piece. They didn't have a human source,
- 9:11which is incredible that could tell them that three three thousand man army was
- 9:16about to invade. And it's one of the you know, there'll be a
- 9:18blood letting on this. There'll be an official inquiry in Israel. There always
- 9:20is. They did it after the nineteen seventy three kind of Yam Kapor War
- 9:24where they were surprised it'll happen again. But you know, for a for
- 9:28a country which has this vaunted intelligence capability, that was a that was a
- 9:31shock. So, you know, I've read and I think one of the
- 9:37challenging things right now is, especially with social media, is parsing out what
- 9:41is misinformation, uh, and not just misinformation from people who are on you
- 9:46know, Israeli misinformation or Hamas misinformation, but you know people saying something like
- 9:54a Hamas operative saying something as in Israeli and then being able and then being
- 9:58able to to debunk that and say, oh, look it was debunked,
- 10:01you know what I mean, sort of that putting false stuff out there,
- 10:05Like it's very hard to tell. But I read a couple of reports that
- 10:09said that a lot of like there was reporting that was going up, but
- 10:15that some mid level officers were like, that's fanciful. I'm not going to
- 10:18report on it. So so what it turns out what happened. I've and
- 10:22you know, I mean again this is this is my opinion based you know,
- 10:24I think it's based on good sources. I have a lot of friends,
- 10:28you know, who are former Israeli military, former Israeli intelligence, former
- 10:31members of the Israeli Diplomatic Corps. So I do reach back into Israel.
- 10:35What I don't do, by the way, is talk to my old friends
- 10:37at the agency. I've been really, really kind of true to that.
- 10:39I don't want to call back in. I don't want to ever get crossed
- 10:43up with someone accidentally giving me classified information. But I have enough of a
- 10:46kind of a knowledge base in this and I'll just you know, one thing
- 10:50I forgot to mention, you know, I was I worked with the Israeli
- 10:52Intelligence Service very closely the Palestinian Service. I've been to their headquarters in Ramala.
- 10:58I've tried, you know, I've been to every city in the West
- 11:00Bank. I worked with the Jordanians and the Egyptians, and so I really
- 11:03have a good sense of kind of the region. But Dave, you bring
- 11:05up, you know, a great point about and so some of these these
- 11:09reports are true in the sense that so first of all, Israel had the
- 11:11war planned. If there was a forty page plan that they presumably it's with
- 11:16signals intelligence. The last one they obtained was about a year old, but
- 11:20it was the plan. But again, what they didn't have was a human
- 11:24source to give it context. Because as this plan then filtered up through the
- 11:26Israeli analytics, you know side of the house, it was dismissed. It
- 11:30was too fanciful, it was aspirational. And you know, again the inquiry
- 11:33is going to be just brutal because there's going to be people named who are
- 11:37going to have said some things which turned out to be kind of catastrophically wrong.
- 11:41Because if you think about it, you know that this was the attack
- 11:43occurred on a holiday. It was also a time in which the IDF,
- 11:48the Israeli Defense Forces had redeployed a lot of their gaza units to the West
- 11:52Bank because the settlers were causing all sorts of trouble there and so they you
- 11:58know, they really were kind of left kid. Uh. But ultimately there,
- 12:01you know, there was there was warnings, not specific ones. I
- 12:05mean, you know it's gonna be uh more than you know, the famous
- 12:09presidential daily brief that said, you know, uh Alkaito wants to tack the
- 12:13homeland with no details. In this case, Israel had the details. They
- 12:16didn't have the timing. But uh, but ultimately, you know, and
- 12:22let me just say one thing about accountability. Israelis to accountability way more,
- 12:26way better than we do. So running Bars, the head of shinbat He
- 12:28already came out and said this is on me. You know, he will
- 12:31resign when this war is over. Same thing with the head of military intelligence
- 12:35said the same thing. This is you know, I take full responsibility prem
- 12:37Minister net Ya, who's has not done any of that. And that's a
- 12:41whole kind of separate issue. Uh. But but the Israeli uh, you
- 12:45know, uh security establishment is gonna it's gonna have a lot of explaining to
- 12:48do. And you know, the the one piece on that that I'll say
- 12:50is, having having been involved and made some decisions that were wrong in my
- 12:56career that led to think really bad things have there's no one who's going to
- 13:01feel worse than the leadership in these intelligence services. And you know, one
- 13:05of the things I've been talking a lot about is you know that the Israelis
- 13:07are going to have to pull themselves up by their bootstraps and get back at
- 13:09it and lean into it. There's no other choice the countries at war.
- 13:13And I think they have and I think there and we can speak you know
- 13:16maybe later that I think they've performed very well. But there's no one who's
- 13:20going to kind of look back, you know, in their retirement with more
- 13:24regret than these individuals who who kind of stood watch at an intelligence failure,
- 13:28which is one for the ages. And you know, I just I think
- 13:33it's going to be that the inquiry is going to be pretty nasty, and
- 13:35the Israelis do this very very well. There will there will be accountability.
- 13:39Yeah, you mentioned, you know, a three thousand man element of Hamas
- 13:43with you know, different different units and their their sort of shock troops.
- 13:48We saw at the Nova Festival. We saw how they paraglided in. Where
- 13:54where did Hamas? Where did they get the training? Where did they get
- 13:58the parachutes? Right? They get all this military great equipment. Well,
- 14:01you're looking at an issue that we still don't know how to kind of wrap
- 14:05our hands around. Is that that you know, certainly the Iranians have funded
- 14:09and helped train Hamas for years. You know, there is a question now
- 14:13in the intelligence community, and I'm a little skeptical of this because I think
- 14:16they've bent over backwards to say that, you know, the Iranians were not
- 14:20aware of the exact plans, And of course the administration is saying this as
- 14:24these are the Israelis because ultimately, if Iran was culpable, you know,
- 14:30that means they have to be dealt with immediately. But but I think that
- 14:33uh clearly, you know, the so much of the training, the funding,
- 14:35the weapons, the equipment comes from Iran. One of the things though,
- 14:39as you as you look back, is that they were conducting even conducting
- 14:43some of this training in Gaza. You know, the paraglider you know,
- 14:46with the issue the paragliders at the rave and there's been a lot on social
- 14:50media you see them coming in. That actually is not new. That an
- 14:52old Palestinian terrorist group called the PFLP GC or I think maybe is the PFLP.
- 14:58There was, there was a it was kind of a two secular kind
- 15:00of Marxist terrorst groups if you can imagine, They had some spectacular kind of
- 15:05hang glidder attacks in the past as well. So it's it's a it's a
- 15:07technique that is not new, but it was. It was pretty wild to
- 15:11see that. But you know, the the to train a three thousand person
- 15:16army, it probably took place, my guess would be both in Gaza but
- 15:20also in Elebanon, UH and UH and I think that the Israelis almost certainly
- 15:26have a exquisite uh, you know, idea of what happened. You know,
- 15:31they've caught they've captured a great many Hamas operatives, and so you know,
- 15:35obviously they're doing these debriefs, and so I think they have a pretty
- 15:37good idea of of exactly what happened that will come out in the in the
- 15:41future. But you know, it just goes to show that, you know,
- 15:43the Iran issue, which we've never been able to tackle, you know,
- 15:46our government, the Israeli government, you know, the notion that we
- 15:48can have some kind of nuclear deal now I think is in the toilet because
- 15:52of certainly Iranian backing for this, for this is you know, it's in
- 15:56essence of mass murder and now a regional war. Uh And and of course,
- 16:00and Dave, you and I talked about it kind of offline. The
- 16:03Iranians are also busy attacking via their proxies US forces in Iraq and Syria.
- 16:07The Iranians that you know, via the Huthis, they're they're surrogate in Yemen.
- 16:11If essentially shut down you know, kind of a major international you know,
- 16:15waterway, and so you know, I think the US has this fear
- 16:19of escalation, but we still haven't figured out what to do about around I
- 16:23will say I can't imagine us going back to any kind of negotiations with the
- 16:27Iranians now. And this is in everyone's back, certainly in the back of
- 16:30the Israeli's mind, but in US policymaker circles too, is you know,
- 16:34how do we deal with uh in Iran that we thought we could have a
- 16:37new you know, a new nuclear deal with but that ain't happening. Well,
- 16:42you know, with you see a lot more than idea that you were
- 16:47behind the scenes for a long time. The leadership in Iran hasn't changed for
- 16:52you know, decades. Why why did we think that Iran was any more
- 16:56willing to play ball than they were ten or twenty years ago. You know,
- 17:00I think that you know, there's a lot of wishful thinking on the
- 17:03part of successive US administrations, But you know, I think one thing that
- 17:07was inspiring to a lot of people, there's you know, obviously there's a
- 17:10difference between the Iranian government, which is you know, which kind of supports
- 17:14terrorist groups around the world. Really is thorn in the side of the United
- 17:18States. But then there's the Iranian people. And we saw for you know,
- 17:21for months, if not you know, a year plus of these incredible
- 17:23demonstrations on the streets that the Iranians wanted more. They you know, they
- 17:27certainly wanted to be free of this kind of terrible, you know, autocratic
- 17:32rule with you know, religious zeal and. So I think we may have
- 17:36been fooled by that that, you know, while the Iranian people have you
- 17:38know, you know, do want freedom, and I don't think they hate
- 17:41the United States at all, but the Iranian government hasn't changed, and you
- 17:47know, the the notion that somehow we can kind of deal with them as
- 17:52a partner that we could maybe trust but verify, I think that's that's certainly
- 17:57at the at the door now. But you know, we'll see. You
- 18:00know. The other thing, it depends on the next US administration. Clearly,
- 18:03the Democrats are much more willing to entertain We're not getting into politics,
- 18:07I promise, but the Democrats just in general are more willing to entertain negotiations
- 18:11with the Iranians and the Republicans, and so I think the next election,
- 18:15you know, matters a lot. Yeah, Now, can you give this
- 18:19sort of because you worked in Israel, you work, you've worked with the
- 18:25Palestinian intelligence. Can you give us sort of the situation in terms of the
- 18:33you know, you had Era Fat, you had the PLO. You know
- 18:37you have the PLA Hamas. What took over in two thousand and seven,
- 18:40is that right? They were elected elections in two thousand and six and Gaza
- 18:42six and Gaza, So can you kind of give us the background of Hamas,
- 18:48I mean, because the PLO isn't really I mean, once Sara Fat
- 18:52was gone, didn't the PLO kind of the successors of the palace and the
- 18:55authority now right in essence? Right? And so I mean, you know,
- 18:57two thousand and six was kind of this seminal moment again the mistake I
- 19:00think in the United States part where we certainly advocated for elections in Gaza and
- 19:04Hamas won. It's the famous it's what a lot of you of these Islamic
- 19:07fundamentalist groups do. It's you know, it's one vote, one time,
- 19:11thank you very much. This is no democracy and there's never been an election
- 19:15since then. So Hamas controls Gaza in the West Bank. You have the
- 19:18Palestinian Authority with kind of nominal control it's it's you know, that is that
- 19:22that was to be kind of the representative of the Palestinian people, but it
- 19:26ended up being a very old and corrupt organization, really hated by the Palestinians.
- 19:30And then the Israelis didn't make matters any better because over the last couple
- 19:34of years there's been the explosion of settlements and so you know, the Israeli
- 19:38settlement settlers, I think have doubled in size, and so there's there's huge
- 19:41tensions there. But but in essence, this goes down, It goes back
- 19:45to you know, what is going to happen between the two sides. And
- 19:48for a long time, the United States and sometimes with an Israeli partner,
- 19:51pushed the idea of a two state solution, meaning that you know, the
- 19:53Palestinians would have some form of their own state with the palestin Authority as that
- 19:57representative. But then Prime Minister Netnya, who is fundamentally against that, and
- 20:03what he did, which is you know, one of the most cynical,
- 20:07you know moves that has come back. And I think that's why, you
- 20:08know, his popularity is essentially at zero now is he promoted, actively promoted
- 20:12a policy of strengthening Hamas in Gaza. Hamas As an Islamic terrorist group dedicated
- 20:18to the destruction of Israel, but he did so in order to discredit the
- 20:22Palistin authority in the West Bank, to ensure there was never any unity between
- 20:26the two entities, the West Bank and Gaza, and openly talked about this.
- 20:30This was the policy, and he thought, as did some of the
- 20:34Israeli security establishment, that they could deal with Hamas. And Hamas pulled one
- 20:40of the great intelligence tricks of all time. You know. First of all,
- 20:42the Israelis led in nineteen thousand Palestinian workers from Gaza into Israel. Well,
- 20:48it turns out a lot of them were actually spying. They were casing
- 20:51for this attack, but it was the notion that Israel would kind of ease
- 20:56some of the economic burdens. And then comes this deal with a cuttery who
- 21:00were pumping in one hundreds of millions of dollars into into Gaza again at the
- 21:06request and the agreement of not only Israelis the United States knew all about this
- 21:10as well, but ultimately, which is kind of keep the peace, you
- 21:14know, they thought they could, you know, in some way a piece
- 21:15Hamas and the Hamas leadership absolutely tricked the Israelis. Meanwhile, this you know,
- 21:21in operation of the size they have three thousand man army training that took
- 21:26you know, months, if not a year plus. I mean this thing
- 21:27has been planned for, you know, for a year plus. And so
- 21:30you know, the feeling of betrayal in the part of the Israelis. Now
- 21:33it sounds a little ridiculous because Hamas is a terrorist group, but boy,
- 21:37did Hamas pull pull a fast one over Israel. And it turns out they
- 21:41have been planning this for for extraordinary amount of time. Again, Uh,
- 21:48under the guise of hey, there's gonna be kind of this this you know
- 21:52this uh, this you know, semi piece between the two sides. It
- 21:56certainly wasn't It wasn't that way at all. Now with you know, you
- 22:00mentioned that net and Yahoo was attempting a strengthen Hamas in order to create that
- 22:03divide with the US and and cutter. Uh was that was that money like
- 22:08all the money that's gone to Palestine one hundred million obviously that gets funneled off
- 22:15by Hamas and it you know, keeps but it's was it supposed to?
- 22:18Was it intended for Palestinian development or was it for appeasement? No, no,
- 22:25it was this was and this is you know, it was intended to
- 22:26help you know, Gaza operate as a as an entity. So it's you
- 22:32know, it's it's how it's good governance, it's hospitals, it's schools,
- 22:36it's infrastructure, and Hamas stole most of it. You know, you know,
- 22:40there's there's a lot of really good reporting on you know, the tunnel
- 22:42system, the three hundred kilometers or whatever it is. I think the Israelis
- 22:45will tell us at the end of the day. But this massive tunnel system
- 22:48underneath Gaza, well that was kind of funded by all this and so you
- 22:52know, they skimmed so much off and you know, the there's two point
- 22:56two million and you know people in Palestinians in Gaza living in you know,
- 23:00some pretty bad conditions. This is even pre war. Yet, Yeah,
- 23:03you know, Hamas is an entity with hundreds of millions of dollars. I
- 23:07mean that's one of the you know, one of the things that you kind
- 23:10of scratch your head. Some of the Hamas leadership living in five star hotels
- 23:12and cutter you know, fly flying around on private jets. But again This
- 23:17was a this was a policy that was okayed by you know, certainly approved
- 23:19by or supported by the Israelis. You know, Cutter was the intermarry intermediary.
- 23:25But the US was fine with this, you know. And so you
- 23:27know, I think it's worth talking a little bit about the US role.
- 23:30And you know, you have to is if you kind of look at at
- 23:33you know, just like where you can criticize what happened in Afghanistan and the
- 23:37withdrawal you know, for a long time under the Abraham Accords, which was
- 23:41this kind of peace treaty or I wouldn't even say it a peace but normalization
- 23:47between Israel and several uh you know, golf Arab states. It was done
- 23:51with the specific intension of leaving the Palestinians out, never solving the Palestinian issue.
- 23:56And and and the US was kind of was was fine with this,
- 23:57and so you know, ultimately that didn't help either because you know, obviously
- 24:02the frustrations of the Palestinians are growing, and then you know, when it
- 24:06comes to just this appeasement of Hamas, the US is right there. I
- 24:07mean, we you know, Cutter is a huge ally. There's a massive
- 24:11US air base there but Cutter also plays this kind of strange role of middleman
- 24:17with awful groups such as the Taliban and and and Hamas. And I think
- 24:22that, you know, there should be some kind of policy discussion now afterwards,
- 24:26I mean, one of the things. And maybe it's it's a good
- 24:27time to talk about it now, you know. I was on I was
- 24:30on Morning Joe on the MSNBC this morning because I wrote a piece in the
- 24:33Messenger, you know, basically saying, you know, over thirty Americans died
- 24:37on October seventh. Where's the outrage, right, So thirty two Americans are
- 24:41dead, and you know, and this so this is not a war just
- 24:44in Israel. There's also eight Americans hostage, you know, held hostage,
- 24:48and and you know sometimes you know, there's this notion, you know,
- 24:51uh, you know, so these were dual citizens. Well that's a little
- 24:53kind of that's kind of bullshit because so many I actually did some research.
- 24:57I looked into This is one guy's name, are Ya Zering, Israeli kid.
- 25:06He was serving the idea, but he also spent every summer in Maine.
- 25:08It was a big Red Sox fan. He just was here, ran
- 25:11the San Francisco Marathon, he has a blue passport. These are American citizens
- 25:15who are dead. And Dave, you know this from serving in the US
- 25:18government. You know, if you have that big, beautiful blue passport and
- 25:22something happens to you, like we're coming to the rescue, that's it.
- 25:26That's the agreement with the government, right, that's the agreement that your government
- 25:30is coming, is going to help you. And so whether that's the FBI
- 25:36trying to bring Hamas members to justice, which will never happen, or the
- 25:40US military working with the Israelis to put you know, you know, a
- 25:42lot of lead on foreheads in Gaza, or the intelligence community using our own
- 25:48unique authorities to remove people from the battlefield. You know, this is a
- 25:52really big deal. There are more Americans killed on October seventh, and the
- 25:55embassy bombings in dhar Darcelaon and Nairobi in nineteen ninety eight by he And so
- 26:00why isn't anyone pissed off? Right? I mean, I think it comes
- 26:03back to just this notion of kind of this, you know, under under
- 26:06current of anti Semitism. I mean, somehow I don't I mean, and
- 26:08and these Israelis who are dual citizens. You know, guess what they speak
- 26:12American, like if you're from I don't know, Baltimore or Philadelphia or or
- 26:18Chicago. So you know, you you remember this, you know, you
- 26:21know that's that's our mantra. Yeah, and you know, if something happens,
- 26:25you know, we are going to uh you know, when I say
- 26:27avenge them, that's the wrong word, but we're going to bring those perpetrators
- 26:32to justice legally or remove them from the battlefield. And I can't you know,
- 26:37I would imagine the counter Terrorism Center is is hard at work on this,
- 26:40helping the Israelies. I'm sure you know Massad and shinnbt and id I
- 26:42have that, you know, I think back to I put it in the
- 26:45in the messenger piece. I think back to the There was a poster that
- 26:48came that was made right after nine to eleven and hung in CTC for a
- 26:52while, and it said every day is September twelfth, And I fucking love
- 26:56that. You know, if you don't have a step, you know,
- 26:57you know, in your in your you know, and you're walking coming in
- 27:00every day or a what a skipping your step? I don't know what I'm
- 27:03saying, but you know, if you're not pumped walking in with that,
- 27:06and so for these Raelies it would be, you know, same type of
- 27:07thing. Every day is October eighth, and so you know there's there's work
- 27:11to do. And I think that clearly the US and the Israeli intelligence services
- 27:15are working very well together. They always have. It's a very close ally.
- 27:19I've worked with them very closely. They have a different view of collateral
- 27:23damage than we do, and that was always the case, I remember.
- 27:27So I'll tell you a quick story. Sorry, I'm rounding here. I
- 27:30go two things. One is a good buddy of mine, he's listening now.
- 27:33Uh. He'd we had we'd served together in the in the Middle East.
- 27:37And I called him right after this and he he had served in Israel,
- 27:40work with the Israelies, also work with the Palestinians in the past,
- 27:41and he said, you know it's gonna happen, Mark, you know they're
- 27:44going to go in and kill everybody. And then I remember listening to Zohar
- 27:48Palti, who was the former chief of counter terrorism from Asade. He was
- 27:49on a podcast the Washington Institute and he said, and I remember Zohar and
- 27:53I worked with him, and he said, you know, we are not
- 27:56going to be nice so you know, their view of of of how they
- 28:00have to kind of reconstitute that aura of fear and invincibility is going to cause
- 28:03them to do some things that maybe we're uncomfortable with. But you know what,
- 28:07nobody should be surprised. Like, you know that big embrace that President
- 28:10Biden gave to these raellities when he did that, and I said, oh
- 28:12shit, we're owning this and they're gonna go fucking crazy. Yeah. And
- 28:18and I remember having conversations with these railies about collateral and they would look at
- 28:21me like at a you know, a giant, you know, something grown
- 28:23out of my forehead, right. Uh, And they just don't think that
- 28:26way. And and like you got to understand that that's the partner we have.
- 28:32So I'm not surprised. That's kind of the level of lethality that they
- 28:33have unleashed. Yeah, real quick, I need to give a shout out
- 28:37to our second sponsor for the night, and then, uh, we have
- 28:41a lot to cover. Thank you to Hello Fresh. With Hello Fresh,
- 28:45you get farm fresh, pre portioned ingredients and seasonal rest please delivered right to
- 28:51your doorstep. Skip trips to the grocery store and count on Hello Fresh.
- 28:55To make home cooking easy, fun and affordable. That's why it's America's number
- 29:00one meal kit. Say hello to a stress less holiday season. With the
- 29:03help of Hello Fresh, skip the grocery store and save time. Look,
- 29:07Hello Fresh is a great solution if you cook, if you don't cook,
- 29:11Hello Fresh is a great way to learn how to cook. I love Hello
- 29:14Fresh because I enjoy cooking, and it sends me the portions I need.
- 29:18I don't have to go to the store firm. It gives you recipe ideas
- 29:21that I never thought of. When you order a Hello Fresh meal kit,
- 29:23you get the recipe, you get all the ingredients you need, and it's
- 29:27just up to you. Up to you to cook them. So check out
- 29:30HelloFresh. Go to HelloFresh dot com slash Teamhouse free. That's HelloFresh dot com
- 29:40slash Teamhouse free and use code teamhouse free for free breakfast for life one breakfast
- 29:47item per box while subscription is active. That's free breakfast for life at HelloFresh
- 29:52dot com slash Teamhouse free with code Teamhouse free. So going back to this
- 30:02because you know that is you know one of the things we talked about off
- 30:06the air is there is collateral damage going on. But at the same time
- 30:10israel Is they are trying to evacuate people that are trying to use the knockers
- 30:17to let people know that they're going to bomb an area. Where where is
- 30:21Israel falling on that balance because it's again it's one of those things that's getting
- 30:26confused in the media. I think I think that you know, so this
- 30:29is a great, great point of discussion, and let me I just want
- 30:32to preface that. We'll get to that in one second. But you know,
- 30:34after, after you know, my comments over the last half hour,
- 30:37you know, some people might say, well, you know, here goes
- 30:38Mark. He's kind of this, you know, crazy pro Israel guy who
- 30:41just wants the Israelis to kill everybody. But that's actually not true. I
- 30:44mean, I'm you know, I spent a lot of time in the Palestinian
- 30:47areas. You know, I spent every every city in the West Bank.
- 30:49You know, I was traveling through there back in nineteen ninety six for for
- 30:52several months. I've been to Gaza back in ninety six as well. And
- 30:56I have enormous sympathy for the Palestinans. I actually, you know, and
- 30:59one of those kind of proponents of a two state solution. I think the
- 31:02Palestinians should have their state, and they have been you know, victims of
- 31:06obviously being under kind of Hamas rules. So I just kind of want to
- 31:08throw that out there. And and that last point, you know, if
- 31:11if you really want to analyze this, this conflict, now, you have
- 31:15to look at the civilian damage that's happened. I mean, it is a
- 31:18catastrophe, you know, that has occurred. And so while I certainly sympathize
- 31:22with the Israelies, and I'll go over a second, you know about the
- 31:25video that I saw on October seventh, you can't not look at what's happening
- 31:30inside Gaza as well, if you know, you're not human, if you
- 31:33you know, if if you don't, and so when it comes, you
- 31:37know, I think, you know, there's two bins in terms of US,
- 31:40uh, these US Israeli dynamic now and the first bin is kind of
- 31:42in the near term, and that's we need the Israelis to do a little
- 31:45bit better on targeting. You know, there's there is you know, there
- 31:48was an article in the paper today about the use of of you know,
- 31:51dumb bombs, and I think that's a lot of people don't have any idea
- 31:53what they're talking about here. But but ultimately kind of this you know,
- 31:56which is more kind of heavy handed airstrikes, which is killing a lot of
- 32:00innocent civilians. So we're telling them, hey, you know, you know,
- 32:02change your tactics a little bit, and they're listening in some sense,
- 32:06I think they are. And also it's the notion of letting humanitarian aid in
- 32:09which they're doing as well. And so this is all designed for the US
- 32:13to give Israel some more diplomatic runway to keep going, right, I think
- 32:16we want them to kind of wind down that this kind of heavy handed campaign.
- 32:21I think it's actually going to organically happen for a couple of reasons.
- 32:23One is Israel's made a lot of progress, you know, up in the
- 32:27north and now moving to the south. I don't think they're going to need
- 32:29that kind of heavy handed tactics. But the other part of it, too,
- 32:31Dave, I think a lot of people don't understand is that, you
- 32:34know, Israel can't go on and do it. You know, with three
- 32:37hundred thousand forces mobilized, the economy is going to fall apart, right,
- 32:40and they've never you know, the mobilization right now is this has extended,
- 32:45you know, two months, and so I think they're going to go to
- 32:47much more targeted strikes, use of special operations forces, use of you know,
- 32:52drones, and more surgical capability. And I think that'll naturally happen.
- 32:54But clearly the US has put some pressure because of the collateral, because it's
- 32:58awful. And again I mean I, you know, I I I I've
- 33:01certainly tilted towards Israel in my commentary. I think as a former counter counter
- 33:07terrorism official, it's almost impossible not to after what occurred on October seventh.
- 33:10But but you know, if we can somehow get you know, some if
- 33:15we can somehow mix you know, some magic out of this at the end
- 33:17of the day, with some kind of settlement in which you know, the
- 33:22Palestinian authority is replaced or strengthened or changed in some fashion, and that there's
- 33:25a move to a two state solution. I don't think the Israelis are ready
- 33:29for that now. Even the most leftist Israeli friends I have are like,
- 33:31you know, it's too soon. We gotcha, but too soon. But
- 33:35but we got to get to that, just because you know, I've spent
- 33:37a lot of time. The Palestinians are wonderful people. They don't deserve this.
- 33:40And then last point, Dave, and I think that you know this
- 33:44based on your background too in conflict zones is you know, everyone thinks war
- 33:47is a fucking video game, right. You know, there's ten thousand civilians
- 33:51that were killed in mosl in twenty seventeen, right, and no one gave
- 33:53a shit back then either, right, And so you know, And and
- 33:57I know from being in a rock in Afghanistan that you know, and I'm
- 34:02proud of my service there. We killed a lot of civilians, just we
- 34:07just did. And and that's it, you know. And so you know,
- 34:09when it comes to conflict, when it comes to war, these things
- 34:12happen. You certainly try to minimize it. I'm not excusing anything, but
- 34:15bad shit happens. Like, if you don't want bad shit to happen,
- 34:19don't go to war, right, because you know bad stuff will happen,
- 34:22and your people are going to do some bad things too, Right, It's
- 34:24just that's just the nature of conf I don't know if you agree with you
- 34:27or not, but I think about this a lot. I mean, I'm
- 34:30I am of the mind like I agree with you that you know that,
- 34:35yes, Israel needs to do the best they can to protect the civilian populace.
- 34:40But at the same time, we are not seeing we are not seeing
- 34:45protests on you know, the one ten or the I ten or whatever in
- 34:47California, or on the Brooklyn Bridge for the victims in Sudan in this conflict,
- 34:52Like people are very specific about which civilian invests are protesting right now.
- 34:58If someone told me the other day that I don't know if this is five
- 35:00hundred thousand people in Sudan have died in the last several months, is that
- 35:05true. I don't know what the numbers. It was a staggering number,
- 35:08and maybe that's it was. Something else too, is that you know,
- 35:12several hundred thousand Ukrainian kids have been kidnapped and taken to Russia. Like there's
- 35:16there's terrible barberism and depravity all over the world. It is interesting that selectively
- 35:22that you know, the Israelis are picked on, and again I think it
- 35:24goes back to that issue of anti Semitism. I'm sorry, because you know
- 35:29why college kids are protesting this against all the other kind of ills of the
- 35:31world. Right, you know, you certainly can can question that. I
- 35:37think, well, I mean, we saw it here in the US as
- 35:40early as October eighth, student groups mobilizing and calling hamas freedom fighters and revolutionaries.
- 35:49And it's like, you did not watch the footage. You did not
- 35:52see the footage. When people are joyful about beheading, when they are joyful
- 35:59about killings millions, that's there. There's nothing. There's no freedom in that,
- 36:05right. So okay, so there's a good time for me. I'm
- 36:07gonna get my glasses on because I'm getting older. Yeah, so so on.
- 36:10You know, three days ago, I went to the Israeli embassy for
- 36:15this kind of exclusive viewing screening of the footage, and they they're not putting
- 36:19this out to the general public out of respect for the families. That's how
- 36:22bad this is. So I went there with some other members the medias and
- 36:25think tanks. Again, I kind of talked my way in there and used
- 36:29my old old agency background, and they kind of they let me in and
- 36:31probably get in trouble because I was saying I was with msn you know,
- 36:35I worked for MSNBC as a contributor. But anyhow, it was important that
- 36:37I was there, and especially as I told the Israeli pressed uh spokes there's
- 36:45uh two ladies there for from the Israeli pressure up. I'm like, hey,
- 36:47you know, you got to let me in because I'm going to talk
- 36:50about this on air like Fox and News, Mac Max. You got those
- 36:53guys or gals like MSNBC crowd you know is the one who has to hear
- 36:58this. And they kind of acknowledged, you know, the talking in an
- 37:00echo chamber, it doesn't make sense. But so they allowed me to take
- 37:02notes. And again, the it's a forty six minute video. The footage
- 37:07is from Hamas operative, the GoPro cameras that these Raelies recovered. It was
- 37:12also from live streaming that Hamas did. It was from Israeli first responders afterwards,
- 37:17it was from Israeli cell phones that were recovered. And it's just this
- 37:21kind of this incredible forty six minutes of total, absolute carnage and brutality.
- 37:27And again, you know, you know I've both been in conflict zones.
- 37:29We've seen a lot of bad stuff. This was this was extraordinary. So
- 37:34let me just kind of give you a quick snitch. I think the listeners
- 37:37will like this in terms of of of what I saw obviously constant chance by
- 37:43Hamas if bablah wakbar that's God is great in Arabic. That's not that big
- 37:45a deal. But then they start saying kill the dogs. There was confident
- 37:50that they were referring to the Israelies as dogs the whole time. That's in
- 37:52the Arab world. That's you know, that's something that is certainly not a
- 37:57positive. I wrote a massacre, you know, bodies piled everywhere. They're
- 38:00executing the injured. Hamas members feel joy. They're screaming yes, yes,
- 38:06kill kill as they mow down civilians. They're shooting cars like it was a
- 38:09video game. Then one of the thoughts I wrote down Hamas or cowards,
- 38:13they won't fight the IDF this way. They were shooting pets, just executing
- 38:17dogs. That kind of pissed me off. I don't know. It was
- 38:19a little weird. Groans of victims slowly dying, beating to death on the
- 38:23head, civilians with a shovel just beating them, bashing their head in this
- 38:30one was particularly bad. Hamas terrorist comes in, throws a grenade, kills
- 38:35a father. There's two young boys who are who are in the in the
- 38:38house in the kibbutz. He's slumped over, he's dead. One of the
- 38:42boy's eyes is blown out. He's screaming and his brother is trying to comfort
- 38:45him. He's screaming, you know, where's where's mommy. The Hamas guy
- 38:50sits the kids, two kids down, then goes opens the fridge and he
- 38:52takes out a bottle of coke and he drinks it like a fucking Franco Harris
- 38:55commercial, remember that Olds commercials. Yeah, it just stunning. Yeah,
- 39:00no, I mean nothing, and then just walks off. Uh. You
- 39:05know, Hamas communications that the Israelis kind of put out there, you know,
- 39:07the internal calm, saying that cot we cut off their heads. My
- 39:10first kill, kill the Jew, desecrating bodies, the blood soak bodies.
- 39:15The hostages were taken, some of them alive into Gaza and they were just
- 39:20beaten along the way, spit on by Palestinians on the street. I mean,
- 39:22this is video of watching this. A Hamas member calls his family and
- 39:27these screams. He's talking to his father. He says, Dad, I
- 39:30killed ten, I killed ten. His father screams back, alu wakbar God
- 39:32is great, brags to his mom, I killed ten. Jews. Uh,
- 39:37the attack on the kibbutz was I'm sorry. The attack on the on
- 39:42the rave a mass casualty event. It's horrible. Yeah, bodies stacked up
- 39:46everywhere. And the joy in the celebrating, that's the thing, just you
- 39:50know, absolutely joyous. And then I think one piece that's worth mentioning.
- 39:52And you know, we've all at the intelligence community, we've seen this.
- 39:57There's a dead Israeli soldier and Hamas operative comes are just just cuts his head
- 40:00off. He just saws it off in about ten seconds and picks it up
- 40:05and just parades it around like a trophy. The Hamas members taking selfies and
- 40:09so kind of the the takeaway on this was the joy of Hamas and doing
- 40:15this. But why this matters is is because the Israelis know this, and
- 40:19in talking to Israeli officials afterwards, and they say very clearly, you know,
- 40:23we cannot allow Hamas not to be an exiit, but to have any
- 40:29you know, any kind of role next door. In essence, you know,
- 40:31I live in Washington, DC. That's that's right down the road here
- 40:35in Vienna, northern Virginia. That can't happen, right, And so you
- 40:38know when we say they want to eradicate Hamas. I mean, nobody really
- 40:42means that. You basically have to degrade Hamas, so it's not a threat
- 40:44anymore. But they said that's not negotiable. So when you hear someone say
- 40:47ceasefire, I mean, for fox sake, Bernie Sanders doesn't even support a
- 40:51ceesfire now. But when you hear ceasefire or cessation of hostilities, like the
- 40:53UN Secretary General the Israelis, you know, look at that person, they
- 40:58say, are you crazy? Right? And so all these these powerful kind
- 41:02of words that I just read that what I saw. You know, as
- 41:06an intelligence officer, you always have to put yourself in other people's shoes.
- 41:08So you know, what did the Palestinians think? We what do the Israelis
- 41:10think? And that's what they're thinking that right. And then there was a
- 41:15poll that came out two days ago by a very reputable pollster in Gaza,
- 41:21I'm sorry, in Gaza, in the West Bank, in the Palestinian territories,
- 41:24both of them, and seventy percent of Palestinians approve of October seventh.
- 41:29Now you can understand that perhaps because of kind of the humanitarian disaster that's unfolded
- 41:35in Gaza. But Israeli's point to that poll and say, what the fuck
- 41:38right are you kidding me? Our neighbors are an existential threat? Come on,
- 41:44yeah, you know. And let me just say one other point that
- 41:46I think is missed. There is a big peace camp in Israel, and
- 41:52so many of those Israelis were killed along the border were actually members of kibbutzz
- 41:58that were letting the Palestinians in that they wanted them to work on their farms
- 42:01or in the kibbutz. They actually were very much pro peace, and and
- 42:06look what happened. Yeah, and you know, in any discussion about you
- 42:09know, the Hamas warriors, you know they have the video of them beheading
- 42:15the tie worker, uh right, Like he's not he's not in the Jewish
- 42:20military, Like why are you beheading a tie worker? Like there is so
- 42:23much out there that is just viled depravity. If anybody can watch, if
- 42:28anybody can watch that and say the Hamas is nothing but a death cult,
- 42:31it was unbelievable. I mean I was shocked, and you know, I
- 42:35was embarrassed. So I look over with the Israelise press spokes lady and you
- 42:39know she's she has tears in her eyes. I'm like, you know,
- 42:43she's seen this six times and I got you know, I think that what
- 42:45got me the most was the two kids screaming for their mom and the one
- 42:47kid is eyes gone. Uh but you know I have I had tears in
- 42:52my eyes too. I mean it was it was I've seen a lot of
- 42:54bad shit. This was really really uh appalling. And you know, again,
- 43:00you walk out of there and you say, Okay, I get it.
- 43:02I understand why the Israelies have this sense of resolve now. They ain't
- 43:06stopping until Hamas is again. You can't say eradicated. Nobody says that.
- 43:10We didn't say that about al Qaeda. You say degraded to the point it's
- 43:13not a threat anymore. By the way, That's what we did. And
- 43:15so these rallies are two months into this. It took us ten years to
- 43:19find and kill m Laden but you know, and I'm proud of what we
- 43:22did at the agency, you know. So it's you know, it's it's
- 43:23a combination of you know, empowering our Afghan allies, our surrogate forces,
- 43:28but also kind of relentless drone strikes where we did both, you know,
- 43:30signature strikes, which is killing the foot soldiers. But then of course a
- 43:35high value target stunt strikes, you know, cutting the head off the snake,
- 43:38and these rallies get that, you know, they're going to go after
- 43:39their their two high value targets. It's the I sn War is HVT one
- 43:45and Muhammad Daif is HVT two. And they're in the conmunis in the south,
- 43:47and then they're going to try to kill as many Hamas members as possible.
- 43:51And their estimate is about seven they've killed about seven thousand of the thirty
- 43:53thousand, and so you know, when I talk to my my friends in
- 43:57Israel, you know, they think that the idea of they're doing well now
- 44:00they understand there's this time constraint in the US is putting some pressure on them
- 44:05and there's much more to do. But uh, going back to that video,
- 44:08I mean, I understand the Israeli psyche now, I really do,
- 44:13because it was the joy I think that's what was shocking, right. I
- 44:15mean, by the way, this is three thousand people. It's not one
- 44:17cell of al Qaeda. I mean, fuck al Qaeda. You know when
- 44:21we went and we killed most of them, right, and and but it
- 44:23wasn't a cell, you know, one one or two cells of of people
- 44:27who jumped on a plane and crashed it into the World Trade Center. That's
- 44:30horrible. These are people who kind of up close and personal, you know.
- 44:34And the other thing is the amount of sexual abuse was staggering, you
- 44:37know that the systematic use of rape and torture. You know, again,
- 44:40the video had you know, you could see you know, uh, female
- 44:45you know, with kind of blood soaked in their private areas or naked with
- 44:49their privates exposed, bound and gagged, the beheadings, the kind of the
- 44:54defiling of victims, that's I mean, I don't know that that that to
- 44:58me, El Qaeda was a was a was a brutal terrorist organization. This
- 45:01was I think much more like like Isis was just a screw loose of depravity.
- 45:06Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's uh, you know, it's fascinating
- 45:09that, you know how me too was such a culture you know, such
- 45:14a cultural thing at one point here and now so many people are like,
- 45:17oh, well, there's no proof of this. It's like, well,
- 45:20Israel is actually trying to you know, they're they're they're not releasing a lot
- 45:23of this stuff out of sentiment for the families involved, right, right,
- 45:29But but somehow, well, they're losing the information work, Dave. And
- 45:32so yeah, that's I told that the Israeli embassy as well. I said,
- 45:36you guys are losing yeah. Uh and obviously sensitivities. They can't release
- 45:39this, but they can't tell this story, uh, because they're so worried.
- 45:45But but and I don't, I don't. I mean, if I
- 45:46was a family member and I saw, you know something, one of my
- 45:49loved ones, you know, getting their brains beaten in, I don't know
- 45:52if i'd want that either. But they're they're losing the information war, and
- 45:54you're right, and you know, one of the amazing things is how did
- 45:58the United Nations not for two months, you know, condemned sexual abuse right
- 46:02against the Israeli women. And then and the same thing. And again we're
- 46:05not getting political. But and I've said it on this this show a million
- 46:08times, I'm right smack in the center. So everyone's mad at me all
- 46:10the time about everything. That's good. Uh. But but you know,
- 46:14the you know, the idea of you know, some of these progressive left,
- 46:17you know groups ofthing the left in the United States, you know,
- 46:21marching and support of not the palst I don't care if you march and support
- 46:23the Palestinians, that's fine, But basically they're supporting Hamas you know, go
- 46:29live there. Yeah, you know, how's it going to go for you?
- 46:31Yeah? I mean, you know, it's the same thing with the
- 46:32notion of kind of the progressive left is going to abandon Biden because of his
- 46:37support for for for Israel. Well, you know, I mean, it's
- 46:42again not getting political. But if Trump wins, do you think that you
- 46:45and the progressive left are going to have an easy time? I mean,
- 46:46it's just that there's no thought process here. And so I think that a
- 46:52lot of progressives, a lot of I'm sorry, a lot of American Jews
- 46:55feel abandoned. Look, the Jewish community was integral in the Civil rights movement,
- 47:00and and I think a lot of American Jews feel abandoned by the left.
- 47:05All of a sudden they realize that they're not with them and that they're
- 47:07supporting their enemy. I mean, one of one of my really good friends
- 47:09personally, like you know, he was very pro Blum. He was very
- 47:14pro like he marched and everything like that, and now he's like, now
- 47:16he feels betrayed, he feels completely BLM in Chicago put a put a poster
- 47:22oute the fucking Kamas guy in a hang glider. Yeah, yeah, are
- 47:25you kidding me? Yeah? And I guarantee you there was there was tons
- 47:29of you know, progressive American Jews were marching and support of BLM, which
- 47:31is fine, right, but but you know, but ultimately I think they
- 47:36there's there'll be a feeling of there is a feeling of betrayal. I mean,
- 47:38one of my couple of my friends who are definitely from the left,
- 47:42they've been watching Fox News all the time. I thought that was kind of
- 47:44funny. Yeah, that's I mean, you know, I don't know,
- 47:46that's your experiences matter. Now what what's happening. You know that you've that
- 47:53you get a censor from what you've heard in the administration because we saw like
- 47:57a number of staffers, like White House staffers were calling for ceasefire today when
- 48:01they're actually going against their bosses. It is is this creating problem? Do
- 48:07you think this could lead you intelligence issues in the future? Well, look,
- 48:13I mean, you know at the that kind of I said it actually
- 48:15on air today this morning on MSNBC. I said I found it ridiculous that
- 48:20you have White House junior White House staffiers calling for a ceasefire when thirty plus
- 48:23Americans are dead. You know, what does a ceasefire mean? A ceasefire
- 48:27means, you know, again, nobody knows what the fuck they're talking about
- 48:29all the time. A human pause for humanitarian aid is different. A ceasefire
- 48:32usually is weeks or months of a cessation of hostilities. Right, But calling
- 48:37for that means that we're letting the mask get away with what they did to
- 48:39thirty plus Americans. So that you know that. But but I think you
- 48:43bring up a really interesting point. So you know, we worked in the
- 48:45executive branch. Uh. If you don't like something that your boss is doing,
- 48:51you can fucking quit. Uh. You know, there's no democracy.
- 48:54I don't get a chance to set Afghan or a Rocky or Syrian policy.
- 48:58I was there, you know with the US CAR when when we fucked up
- 49:00serious six Ways to Sunday, you know, when we didn't enforce a red
- 49:05line where all of our Seerian allies in essence were abandoned. Uh. But
- 49:08you know, you know that's the policy. Decisions good or bad are made
- 49:14by your kind of political masters, and you're in the executive branch, and
- 49:16you're, you know, in our case, you know, you're kind of
- 49:19the tip of the spear. You know, you're you're a sharp sword for
- 49:21the US government. But if you don't like it, you can quit,
- 49:24and you can and you should, and you can speak out. And I
- 49:28have no problem with that. But the idea that people are protesting who work
- 49:30in the White House white House policy, I find utterly ludicrous. Now,
- 49:36you know, I guess that that's maybe I don't understand generation c uh.
- 49:40You know again, same thing that you know with a lot of people in
- 49:42the State Department AID are upset about this. That's fine, you know,
- 49:45there's a descend channel use that. But you see some people go on social
- 49:50social media. Again, not the right thing to do. And because you
- 49:53know, you didn't join the military, you don't have a contract, feel
- 49:57free to quit and to go to the Washington Post and your Times or anyone
- 50:00else. And amazingly and so so one of the things that that I what
- 50:04I what angers me a little bit is you hear all this dissent. One
- 50:07person has quit in the entire US government, an official from the State Department.
- 50:13I admire him. You did the right and he spoke out, Okay,
- 50:15got it, that's what you should do. But the idea that you
- 50:17know, you're protesting outside the White House, I found that unbelievable. And
- 50:21you know, you know, I will tell you that I've talked to so
- 50:24many of my friends. Uh. First of all, it's not happening in
- 50:28the intelligence community or in d O D. You know, for the most
- 50:30part, I think there was one senior agency analyst who puts something on Facebook.
- 50:34But you know, uh, but for the most part, you don't
- 50:37see it interestingly enough in in d O D or the IC. We do
- 50:40our fucking job, right, Dave. You know when when you I mean
- 50:45in your career, I'm sure there's plenty of things you're kind of scratching your
- 50:47head thinking, Hey, this isn't really the right thing to do, right,
- 50:51or I don't agree with it. Yeah, I don't agree with it,
- 50:53right. Yeah? So what do you think is is you know,
- 51:00and the other thing you mentioned, I just want to go back to this
- 51:02real quick. You say ceasefire, but every but but Hamas is constantly launching
- 51:07rockets into Israel. It's like you can call for a ceasefire. It doesn't
- 51:10matter what Israel does. Hamas is going to keep on. They're going to
- 51:14keep on attacking regardless. Well, I mean, I think that in some
- 51:17I mean, I'm not giving Hamas a break on this, but I think
- 51:21that you know that the ceasefire would definitely aid Hamas more because they can regroup,
- 51:25they can move people throughout the tunnels, they can resupply and rest.
- 51:29They're getting their asses kicked these The IDEF does not want to cease fire period
- 51:34and so so think back to the success that we had in the conflict zones,
- 51:37and I remember this clearly. You know, ordinarily we think that intelligence
- 51:40drives operations, but in fact operations can drive intelligence. What does that mean?
- 51:45And your listeners are going to understand. So, so instead of instead
- 51:47of shinback giving these the idea of targets, IDEF is gonna is gonna is
- 51:52gonna, you know, move throughout the guys of Strip. They're gonna find
- 51:54what, They're gonna find a weapons cash, They're gonna find a Hamas safehouse.
- 51:58They'll do s SE sensitive exploitation, They'll they'll capture Hamas operators and do
- 52:04battlefield interrogations. That's driving the intelligence picture. So In fact, the more
- 52:08that the Israelis you know, you know, move in the Gaza strip,
- 52:12the more intel they gain and they can kind of and stopping that, that
- 52:15all comes to a halt, and then they become you know, more blind.
- 52:20And in fact, the last you know, again it was called a
- 52:22ceasefire, the last pause of a couple of days for the hostage release.
- 52:24One of the things I was surprised the Israelis agreed on is is they stopped
- 52:28flying drones over Gaza. Hamas insisted on that. But again that's you know,
- 52:32maybe you can offset. I mean, who you know, I know
- 52:35that I know we have an m Q nine there assisting in hostage you know,
- 52:38recovery. Uh. And with an m Q nine, I knew you
- 52:40could. You don't have to be over Gaza. You can offset a little
- 52:43bit. But I'm not sure that there's Israeli's capability. But ultimately, uh,
- 52:47you know, uh, you know, the cessation of fighting in any
- 52:50way does not aid uh, the israllies. That's why they want to keep
- 52:53going. I think, let me just throw one thing out there. I
- 52:55know we're kind of moving fast and furious, but you know, something happened
- 52:59today and I'm interested in your take on this too, and it's tragic is
- 53:02that the idea of killed three Israeli hostages, yeah, who actually had escaped
- 53:08and just in the fog of war and at a time where Hamas was sending
- 53:12out suicide bombers, three civilians came out and the idea of killed them.
- 53:15And there's a couple of things on that. One is there's no one who's
- 53:19going to feel worse than those soldiers right on what happened. And you know,
- 53:22there's all this bullshit on social media about this, but ultimately what I
- 53:25think is going to happen. And already the Massat chief David Barnia has said
- 53:30that he's going to go back and actually meet the cutteries again because the hostage
- 53:35issue is so emotional in Israel. And let me just kind of say one
- 53:37thing on that is that one thing that's that I find admirable is that the
- 53:42Israelis, you know, uh, and we do to some extent, not
- 53:44as much, but we do have this is that the in terms of hostages,
- 53:47but the Israelis, you know, they have a pact with their government
- 53:50that if you're taken, the Israelis are going to get you back and they
- 53:52have traded. You know, the I sin War was released from Israeli jail
- 53:55in a hostage and sorry, in a prisoner exchange where one Israeli soldier was
- 54:00released for a thousand Hamas operators, including Ya sn War, the head of
- 54:06the head of Hamas. So the Israelis will kind of push this and it
- 54:08becomes extremely emotional, and so there's gonna be a lot of pressure from the
- 54:12families now that three hostages were killed. So I think that you might see
- 54:16these negotiations start again. The problem with this is and the reason why the
- 54:22last round fell apart is it was it was abundantly clear, and I had
- 54:25kind of sources tell me this as well, is that you know, the
- 54:28sexual abuse of the hostages is something that hasn't been reported now it hasn't been
- 54:31reported again at the request of the families, right. And also I was
- 54:37told that Hamas Hamas members had had threatened the hostages who were released that if
- 54:42you talk about this, other people are going to be at risk. But
- 54:45ultimately, if if Hamas was to release more of these hostages, the stories
- 54:52of sexual abuse are going to be horrific. And so in some sense,
- 54:57Hamas does not have an incentive either. That's why the negotiation broke down last
- 55:00time. And so it'll be interesting to see, you know, who's on
- 55:02the and then if there was to be any kind of exchange, because I
- 55:06think, what what is what has happened to some of these people is is
- 55:08going to be pretty barbaric. Uh yeah, one hundre percent. I mean
- 55:13just the reports from witnesses, uh, from Nova, we're talking about some
- 55:16of that depravity, right, and you know some of the discussions that Hamas
- 55:22members had on on tape talking about the women, like take this one,
- 55:27take this one. You know, it was very clear what their intentions were.
- 55:31No, you know what you have though, So I thought about this
- 55:34a lot, and I just talked to a journalist who is really close to
- 55:36the situation too. He's you know, he's going back and forth Israel,
- 55:39and he's studied this forever. And you know, there's a there's a difference
- 55:45between if you're living in the Gaza strip under under you know, and you're
- 55:49a member of Hamas, which is an Islamic fundamentalist movement in which you know,
- 55:52if you look at a woman you know before marriage, you know,
- 55:55you know, or if if the woman looks at another man, you know,
- 55:58they're condemned, and then all of a sudden, you look right across
- 56:00the way, literally the lights over in uh in Israel, there's a rave
- 56:06where there's gorgeous women scantily clad, and so you know, I think they're
- 56:10you know, this is this is just my kind of my view of kind
- 56:13of the the what happens in these kind of Islamic fundamentalist terrorist movements. I
- 56:17mean, there's you know, there's sexual repression there. I know we're getting
- 56:21deep here, but the sexual repression is an issue. And I think these,
- 56:23you know, the the while the Hamas, we know from the debriefs
- 56:27that you know, the Hamas leadership or some kind of religious edict was came
- 56:30down that they were they were permitted to kind of go rape and pillage and
- 56:34do all the things. But I think there's some you know, I think
- 56:36they went crazy there because all of a sudden you're seeing these you know,
- 56:38these beautiful Israeli women. They've been repressed their whole life, they've been told
- 56:43what they can't do yet, and they've just been given the dispensation to to
- 56:46to kind of uh go down a road that I mean, nobody does.
- 56:51Yeah, uh, and so I don't know, there's there's certainly some psychology
- 56:54behind this. Well, but it's not it's not out of it's not out
- 56:58of pocket for for that for that demographic, because we saw it with Isis
- 57:04too. We saw the sex slaves. Yeah, the sex slaves, right,
- 57:07Yeah, I think it was the Azidi's mostly right, but but you
- 57:10know that they would keep and and trade and whatnot. So so how does
- 57:19you know? I mean, it's it's crazy when you talk about how much
- 57:21money Cutter gave Palestine, because there are two million people in Palestine roughly,
- 57:24right, two to five million gods in Gaza, right, correct, in
- 57:28Gaza. And if if Cutter gave them, gave Gaza one hundred million,
- 57:36I mean that divides up pretty well if that's what you were going to do
- 57:42and gets everybody a fairly decent quality of life or right, I mean yeah,
- 57:45or built substantial infrastructure. Hamas stole it all, yeah and built this
- 57:51tunnel system. So so talking about Hamas leadership and you know, just like
- 57:55Arafat didn't live in you know, in God, he didn't want to Palestine,
- 58:00right, we have these other Hamas leaders who live in luxury in other
- 58:06parts of the world. Who are you know, going on Mary or whatever
- 58:09and making these statements, you know, about how Israel should die and whatnot?
- 58:15What what should happen to them? And why isn't it I guess,
- 58:21I guess that's a loaded question leadership? Yeah yeah, So so okay,
- 58:24there's there's two parts of this. So one is, you know, you
- 58:28wonder if the Palestinian public is going to seize the hypocrisy and kind of it's
- 58:32grotesque to see how you know, the leadership living in luxury hotels in Doha
- 58:37or some are in you know, Bairut somewhere in Algiers. You know,
- 58:40they certainly are not are suffering with the rest of them. But but it
- 58:44comes down to I think that you know, we're going to see you know,
- 58:45you can call it whatever you want to call it a munich too,
- 58:49and so you know, uh, the shin Bet chief, Ronan Bar already
- 58:52kind of announced that it's kind of funny because shin Bett I didn't think it
- 58:53would have a role, but he basically said that, hey, these really
- 58:57cabinet met and we've been given the task of of of tracking all the mass
- 59:00leadership down everywhere. You know, not only inside Gaza, but externally.
- 59:04You know, these guys are are kind of are are dead man walking clearly
- 59:07that is it's going to be in Masads, you know, uh number one
- 59:10in their their task and order, and they're good at this. Uh and
- 59:15and so uh, I think it's I think they're it's important for a couple
- 59:19of reasons. One is they have to hold these individuals responsible. By the
- 59:22way, US official yesterday it was unnamed, too bad. I don't like
- 59:25that when people are obviously, but but you know they said, you know,
- 59:29yeah, y sin War is us blood in his hands and he's he's
- 59:31he's a dead man. Well, I mean that's that's the US advocating for,
- 59:35you know, Israel conducting this kind of extra judicial killing and assassinations.
- 59:39By the way, I totally support this. Yeah, so you know,
- 59:44but but uh, I think the Israelis are going to go to the ends
- 59:46of the earth to track these people down, and it's it will last days,
- 59:50weeks, months or years. There's no statue of limitations in the minds
- 59:53of of Masad. And you know, perhaps shin Bet has a role too,
- 59:58uh or Israel military intelligence. But this is going to be you know,
- 1:00:00what my old friends and Massade certainly are are going to do. And
- 1:00:05you know, let me tell you. I'll tell you a funny story.
- 1:00:07I was in you know, when I was serving in Damascus. Uh.
- 1:00:12I went to this was just crazy. This was two thousand and six or
- 1:00:14seven, I can't remember. I was there five to seven and it was
- 1:00:16Libyan National Day. And what does that mean? If you're a US official?
- 1:00:21You got to go to national days? But hey, Libyan National this
- 1:00:22is when we actually had kind of resumed diplomatic contacts with Libya. We had
- 1:00:28opened up a kind of a pseudo embassy and and I actually was, you
- 1:00:31know, was on the ground there in five helping open up our office.
- 1:00:37There whole other story on that. But so I go to Libyan National Day
- 1:00:40because I thought it would be kind of amusing to talk to the Libyan ambassador
- 1:00:43about this. Uh, And nobody else from the US embassy wanted to go.
- 1:00:46So I was this, you know, schmuck, who was going to
- 1:00:49go? And I go there and who is at Libyan National Day in Damascus
- 1:00:52area? It was Ahma Jabriel, who was the infamous head of the PFLPGC,
- 1:00:59a notorious terror group with a lot of American blood in his hands,
- 1:01:01and Kalin Mitchel, one of the leaders of Hamas, and I was I,
- 1:01:06you know, and and the rest of the diplomatic community was, you
- 1:01:08know, normally amused by the fact that I was there, but everyone there,
- 1:01:13including the Libyan and Bastor. I never, of course met either of
- 1:01:15these individuals, because I would I couldn't have done that. But they all
- 1:01:19said, well, Mark, I'm glad you're here because there won't be an
- 1:01:21Israeli Israeli airstrike because they know that a US official is here. And you
- 1:01:27know what Masad lost on October seventh with the Israeli security establishment lost was that
- 1:01:31that aura, that fear. And I don't give a shit who you you
- 1:01:36know, how tough you think you are, as a as a you know,
- 1:01:38Palestinian terrorist or you know Hisbola Lebani, a Lebanese terrorists. They are
- 1:01:43scared of the reach of Israeli intelligence services. But that aura was shattered.
- 1:01:47And so what Israel needs to do for you know, first of all,
- 1:01:51they want to avenge the deaths of twelve hundred their citizens, but they need
- 1:01:53to restore that and so kind of that long arm of the Israeli intelligence going
- 1:01:58off and you know mythic, you know, killing folks overseas like they did
- 1:02:02it after Munich, right, and they've done in other occasions too. They've
- 1:02:06done it in Syria, They've done it Iran. I think that's really important
- 1:02:09for them to do. I actually have no doubt they're going to do this
- 1:02:13again. If if you know, there's nothing more satisfying than being in a
- 1:02:17position right now of a Masado officer who is who is the task is to
- 1:02:22find, fix, and help finish some of these individuals who are responsible for
- 1:02:27for the brutality of October seventh, and I who knows, you know,
- 1:02:30what's happening kind of our joint efforts. Obviously it takes a presidential finding.
- 1:02:35I don't know if we have that when it comes to this. If if
- 1:02:37the US, the US certainly is helping and targeting and Gaza, I don't
- 1:02:40know about targeting overseas. But there also were reports by the way that some
- 1:02:44of the Hamas leadership and cutter has fled. I'm not sure if that's confirmed
- 1:02:46or not, but yeah, because the Israelis told the cutteries were and the
- 1:02:51same thing with the Turks were coming at you. Yeah, we don't give
- 1:02:53a shit, and a lot of protests from Cutter and Turkey, but I
- 1:02:57think that there was some some reports that the some of the leadership and Cutter
- 1:03:00I think they might have fled to Al Jerry or and I don't know if
- 1:03:02that's true, but not a surprise, and the Israelies will just keep tracking
- 1:03:07them. Yeah. Well, it's interesting because you mentioned his Belah and it
- 1:03:12seemed to me by the rhetoric coming from Hamas shortly after October seventh, that
- 1:03:17they thought that his Belah was going to join in this fight, and then
- 1:03:21all of a sudden, his Bela is like like, you guys got this,
- 1:03:24You're doing great, you got you got it. Go team. Dude.
- 1:03:30Do you think do you think that there do you think that there was
- 1:03:32like an agreement for participation at one point and then his ballad is backed off
- 1:03:37or do you think that Hamas just kind of made that assumption. Well,
- 1:03:40you know, they run these joint operation centers where Hamas and his Blah are
- 1:03:45co located in Beirut. But none of this matters without their their their their
- 1:03:51mama, their papa, which is Ran right, so the Irani and so
- 1:03:53so ultimate. You know, his Bola is the ultimate Iranian proxy in the
- 1:03:57region. You know, they you know, are have a stake in the
- 1:04:00Lebanese government. They're entrenched there. And for his Bulla to join the war,
- 1:04:05I think Iran does not want that because the Israelis have no appetite for
- 1:04:10this now. And so there's a and this is a really great point,
- 1:04:14Dave, that you that you raise now, because the risk of escalation is
- 1:04:16not in Gaza. The risk of escalation is is all eyes are north,
- 1:04:21all intelligence assets are pointing north, whether it's human intelligence, signals intelligence,
- 1:04:26you know, certainly imagery because his Bolla has what one hundred and fifty thousand
- 1:04:33missiles, not rockets, missiles aimed at at you know, at Tel Aviv,
- 1:04:38at Israel, and the Israelies frankly, are itching to kind of level
- 1:04:42Beirut. And they've said very publicly, if you want to have happen,
- 1:04:45you know, in Beirut like what happened in Gaza, you know, go
- 1:04:48for it. And so I think there's there's two There are a couple of
- 1:04:51things going on in Israel. Well, first of all, you have so
- 1:04:55US wants nothing of this, They do not want this to occur, which
- 1:04:58is why we park two carrier battle groups that's sixteen aircraft squadrons and then a
- 1:05:02US you know, nuclear sub with one hundred and fifty Tomahawks and so so
- 1:05:06ultimately that's the that's the show to Iran. Hey, don't don't let his
- 1:05:11balla on leash on Israel because we're gonna you know, our targets are dialed
- 1:05:14in in Lebanon and Beirut. And that seems to have held. The problem
- 1:05:17is that Israel and his Balla have this escalation ladder and it's really interesting and
- 1:05:23the Washington Institute has done a lot of good kind of research on this,
- 1:05:26and so it's where you strike you know, five mile or five miles or
- 1:05:30ten miles or fifteen miles across the borders and so and there's a gradual ladder
- 1:05:33and that's going up now. And one of the things that there's two things
- 1:05:36that can happen that that one is that the Israelis say, fuck it,
- 1:05:41we're not doing another ten to seven. We are going to preempt and there
- 1:05:45is and that and the IDEF has been pushing for this. They you know,
- 1:05:48the Israeli defense ministers like, yes, we need to take care of
- 1:05:51this. We can't have another surprise. I don't necessarily blame them for that
- 1:05:56feeling. And the other part is miscalculation. So you know, in this
- 1:06:00changes and his bullet and Israel are fighting every day and people are dying.
- 1:06:03But I'm not as worried about you know, these rallies can kind of whack
- 1:06:06a whole bunch of his ball of folks, because the Iranians really don't want
- 1:06:10this. If if if his bully gets a lucky shot and kills you know,
- 1:06:13thirty Israelies, it's game on. Yeah, And so that is really
- 1:06:17the trigger point for what could be a really a wider regional war, which
- 1:06:21you know, people ask, you know, ask me all the time.
- 1:06:24You know, where's the US intervened? If it's if it's full on,
- 1:06:28you know, Iron Dome is getting overwhelmed, you know, tens of thousands
- 1:06:31of missiles raining down you know, our our our our jets are taken off,
- 1:06:35yeah, from from those carriers and uh and we have we have communicated
- 1:06:40that directly to the Iranians and to the Lebanese. You there's been National Security
- 1:06:44Council officials traveling back and forth to Beirut constantly. But again, you know,
- 1:06:48that's this is the this is kind of the the point of of events
- 1:06:51on the ground can kind of drive things. So so I mean, is
- 1:06:56is the US just trying to keep a pot on the kettle because we also
- 1:06:59have not taken It's like for the Houthis and we can I want if you
- 1:07:02don't mind, not like you to Houthis. Yeah, for people who aren't
- 1:07:06familiar with that situation, it's almost like we sent them a strongly worded letter.
- 1:07:15This is killing me and I don't get it. So, you know,
- 1:07:16it's one of the things about the administration is you know, we do
- 1:07:18things that they do things fairly well. I mean, I think that the
- 1:07:21support for Israel has been the right policy, and then sometimes we're too cautious
- 1:07:27and we'll get to Ukraine in a second. But in this case, you
- 1:07:29know, the Houthis are are are conducting repeated attacks almost daily on on kind
- 1:07:34of international shipping. I think that Central Command is itching to do something about
- 1:07:40it, but I think the White House is holding them back because of worry
- 1:07:43of escalation. Again once again, it's that it's that fear of things spiraling
- 1:07:46out of control. Now, I don't think it would take much for the
- 1:07:49United States Navy or or US Air Force assets located in the region to hit
- 1:07:56hoothy targets. Uh, you know, as you know, and I'm gonna
- 1:07:59I'm going out my kind of you know, comfort zone here. You know,
- 1:08:02every kind of who's who the launch is, A is a point of
- 1:08:05origins, there's a there's a there's a point of origin, right, uh,
- 1:08:10delineated where this this attack was emanated from. Very easily picked up by
- 1:08:15US technical means we could put missiles, aircraft, anything on that probably within
- 1:08:20minutes, right, Am I wrong? Fast? I mean time a flight
- 1:08:26like it? Like yeah, I mean basically I think the ship systems could
- 1:08:30lock onto the origin point almost immediately after the launch. So I don't know
- 1:08:36why we haven't done that. Now I understand that that that Sencom you know,
- 1:08:40uh, is very frustrated that they're not able to to respond and you
- 1:08:45know, and so what does this get to? This gets the notion of
- 1:08:46deterrence. Deterrence is not working. Uh, we have because I haven't really
- 1:08:51seen much. No, and same thing with the Iranian you know, proxies
- 1:08:56in I Rock and Seria. Now we have hit back a little bit stronger.
- 1:08:59I mean, there is kind of that. I'm sorry, this is
- 1:09:01this is just one of the things that that I enjoy, that kind of
- 1:09:05joyous uh AC one thirty strike of about ten days ago, where where you
- 1:09:12know, local commanders, you know, or you know, local uh uh
- 1:09:15US military were able to kind of see kind of port of origin of of
- 1:09:20of strikes. I can't remember as a Rock or Syria, but whatever,
- 1:09:23there's an AC one thirty in the area and they kind of blasted these guys
- 1:09:26and and that was you know that that didn't need any kind of you know,
- 1:09:29authorities from anywhere above, which is good. Uh But ultimately, you
- 1:09:32know, we're not deterring the Iranian proxies, whether it's the Houthis or the
- 1:09:36proxies in I Rock and Syria. And that's a problem. And so why
- 1:09:40is it a problem? You know, it's a problem because you know,
- 1:09:43and you remember this from time in conflict zones, you get shot at,
- 1:09:46you got to shoot back, right, I mean, it's it's pretty simple.
- 1:09:49And Leon Panetta, god bless them, at the Reagan Defense uh at
- 1:09:54the Reagan Institute of two weeks ago, just it says as clear as anything
- 1:09:58that I believe you said, it's if someone shoots at an American. Someone
- 1:10:01shoots an American. Uh uh, you know with a missile, we got
- 1:10:04to kill that person. Right, doesn't get any clearer than that. Right,
- 1:10:08And we're not doing that, and so and and and so there is
- 1:10:11no with the might of the US military, which is extraordinary. Right,
- 1:10:15it's the fucking hoothies, are you kidding me? Right? And and so,
- 1:10:18and we're not doing anything to me. That's exceedingly frustrating. And what
- 1:10:21does that mean? And so if you translate that, which gets me really
- 1:10:25upset? Is okay? So what what in essence the administration is saying is
- 1:10:30until an American dies, we're not going to do anything. Well, that's
- 1:10:32totally immoral in my view. And I remember when I was a base chief
- 1:10:36in Afghanistan. We're shot at every day, you know, from you know,
- 1:10:41across the border in Pakistan. You know, I was authorized to return
- 1:10:44fire always, and we had some wild cross border engagements. And at one
- 1:10:48point, and this is you know, there's a little too much inside baseball.
- 1:10:50People are getting uncomfortable this And I remember, you know, a certain
- 1:10:54I'm not going to say it was of a certain you know, agency leader
- 1:10:57was like, hey, Mark, you know, you need to call back
- 1:10:59and ask us permi to return fire. And I said, send me home,
- 1:11:00close the base. Yeah, can't do that, you know. In
- 1:11:03fact, I'm going to tell you after the entire engagement's done. And I
- 1:11:08remember, I, you know, my the you know, the paramilitary officers
- 1:11:11from ground bears there. I was really fighting for them, and they really
- 1:11:13appreciated that because they said, you know, this is not sustainable when you
- 1:11:15when we're fired upon, we have to fire back. We have to kill
- 1:11:18the enemy who's trying to kill us. We'll tell everybody at hire later,
- 1:11:23you know, sure, yeah, no problem with that, but it's long
- 1:11:26done by the time, you know, we're we're calling up and writing a
- 1:11:29report, and I'm not getting on the horns screaming, oh my god,
- 1:11:30we're under attack. You know, we'll take care of it on the ground.
- 1:11:34And so in essence, you know, we're certainly not doing that,
- 1:11:38and uh in these places, and I fear it's going to take the loss
- 1:11:41of US lives and that's not fair to the American military, right, you
- 1:11:45know, I'll tell you that one one two stories. One is I just
- 1:11:47you know, I've been giving college lectures all over the place, so I
- 1:11:49was. I've been at the Naval Academy a lot, and I was the
- 1:11:53last time was the Naval Academy when I was talking to the midshipman and I
- 1:11:56was like, hey, I just realized, like, you guys are all
- 1:11:58you know in your in your last year, like you know everybody? Do
- 1:12:00you know people you know out in the deployed right now in the sencon Ao
- 1:12:04And they're like, yeah, we talked to them all the time. And
- 1:12:06I was, so I'm thinking, like, these these men and women who
- 1:12:10I'm talking to are going to be on a ship, you know it conceivably
- 1:12:15it's it's you know what is December? Now they graduate in May, they
- 1:12:19could be on one of those ships. It's not fair to put them at
- 1:12:23risk, right And that pisses me off because we don't have to. We
- 1:12:26can change that policy. Last piece is with the houthis I'll never forget.
- 1:12:30I was the last trip I made to Sannah before we closed up shopd When
- 1:12:33was that? It might have been I might have been there in two thousand
- 1:12:36and fourteen, thirteen fourteen, but I remember the case officers coming back and
- 1:12:42they're like, there's a really fucked up group on the streets. You know,
- 1:12:45it's not it's not aquap ill kite. It in the Arabian Peninsula is
- 1:12:47what we were battling. And there was a there was a major kind of
- 1:12:51you know, under the table war between the us IC and military and AHAP
- 1:12:57for years. They said, but this is a group, you know,
- 1:12:59they start handing death to America. And here's what they brought me back a
- 1:13:01poster one time. I was just visiting from headquarters and they said, but
- 1:13:04you know, they're a little kind of fucked up. There was the Hoothies.
- 1:13:09Yeah, but you know, we're letting this kind of ragtag group,
- 1:13:12you know, control the sea lanes. And it's it's ridiculous and and and
- 1:13:15that's what I was gonna, you know, say, because it's not just
- 1:13:18that they have actually fired on us ships and because we have the you know,
- 1:13:23because we have the ability to like to stop it. It's like,
- 1:13:26okay, no harm, no foul ha ha, like like a kid brother.
- 1:13:29But they've they've taken over major ships, they've shut down a shipping lane.
- 1:13:33May marisk An International shipper just came out and said incredible, shocking,
- 1:13:41but good for them, good for Maris. Like they said, hey,
- 1:13:43everyone fucking do something. Yeah, I mean, I mean, you know
- 1:13:45this is I mean, you know, this is our special operations capability.
- 1:13:49Navy seals are are you know, this is their thingy, this is old
- 1:13:53Captain Phillips ship. Yeah, so you know, come on, yeah,
- 1:13:56but we're not we're not allowing you know, we're not employing any of these
- 1:13:59these resources. I I don't get it. I just want to I want
- 1:14:02to go over our notes from our talk real quick to make sure we haven't
- 1:14:05missed anything as we go. One one quick thing I wanted to, uh
- 1:14:13to kind of raise was kind of the US role in this and I,
- 1:14:17you know, in terms of uh uh, the U S intelligence community and
- 1:14:21and and you know this is and I wrote something and I was quoting the
- 1:14:25Wall Street Journal, and I got a rash of ship for this. But
- 1:14:28you know, so this is considered the October seventh was considered a US sorry
- 1:14:30inn Israeli intelligence failure. But but I think you have to kind of unpack
- 1:14:34it a little bit too. And so the US has a little bit of
- 1:14:36you know, uh, responsibility is the wrong word. But let me just
- 1:14:40kind of walk you through my thinking on this. And I and I and
- 1:14:45I said we're you know, we have a little bit there's a little bit
- 1:14:46of blame on us. And you know, Warren Strobel, who's a great
- 1:14:50journalist for UH Photo Wall Street Journal, said that he got you know that
- 1:14:54that agency folks really pushed back on what I said. But ultimately it's that,
- 1:14:57you know, UH decisions are made in terms of recent allocation. And
- 1:15:00so I sat in nineteen ninety six and the Hamas branch, that branch doesn't
- 1:15:03exist anymore. Well why is that? Well, you know, Hamas we
- 1:15:06didn't think had an external operations capability. Interesting a whole bunch of arrests recently
- 1:15:11in Europe in Geramy, Yeah, yeah, Germany, Netherlands, Denmark,
- 1:15:15I think it was. But but because we had bigger fish to fry,
- 1:15:18which was what obviously Al Qaida and so is. You know, so we
- 1:15:23shift resources. But we did that. There's something called the NIPPEFF, the
- 1:15:27National Intelligence Priorities Framework. This is the weird geeky shit that you know,
- 1:15:30if you know, you did my job in the past, and that means,
- 1:15:32where are we going to put our money in our resources? And we
- 1:15:34said, okay, we're gonna We're gonna shift it all to al Qaeda.
- 1:15:38But but ultimately, you know, we still have to have coverage of Mosca,
- 1:15:41but we're gonna give it to the Israelis. We're going to seed all
- 1:15:43collection to the Israelis. You know where this is going now because we did
- 1:15:47so, there's no more American human capability, there's no more sigent. We're
- 1:15:50really going to say, Israel, you got this right. And and once
- 1:15:55again, thirty plus Americans were killed on October seventh, eight Americans still held
- 1:15:58hostage. And so you kind of look back and you say, we understand
- 1:16:00why the US made those decisions. I get it. There's no there's no
- 1:16:04no one's going to get disciplined for this. But we made decisions that were
- 1:16:08actually turned out to be maybe the wrong one. And maybe in the future
- 1:16:12when we say, you know, we can't cover this target, maybe don't
- 1:16:15go, you know, one hundred percent, give it to a liaison service.
- 1:16:19Maybe keep a little bit of residual what we call unilateral collection. And
- 1:16:23I'm not sure we did that. This is just I'm just surmising this.
- 1:16:26You know, I wasn't there for these decisions. But but then what happens,
- 1:16:30so then you know, so and and I would I would also say
- 1:16:32that, you know, what's the role of the American intelligence community, Well,
- 1:16:36we want to prevent strategic surprise. I can't imagine, you know,
- 1:16:41Bill Burns, the CI, director of Real Haynes, the head of the
- 1:16:43DN. I going in to see the President Biden when he says, what
- 1:16:45the fuck happened on October seventh? Well, the three thousand man army invaded
- 1:16:49Israel? Did we not know? And the answer is no. Like,
- 1:16:54that's not good, right If I was ahead of the US, I see,
- 1:16:57I'm like, that's not a good day. And so okay, So
- 1:17:00so I just kind of throw that out there. But no one ever wants
- 1:17:02to criticize anything, and so I got a lot of a lot of pushback.
- 1:17:05But so but but I think the CIA, and I say, the
- 1:17:09US. I see, certainly the US military has rebounded, And so what
- 1:17:11do you have? You have an m Q nine and flying hostage recovery,
- 1:17:14you have, you have you know, obviously an intelligence fusion celle at the
- 1:17:16embassy. Uh you have and this has kind of been reported. I think
- 1:17:20you guys have talked about it. You know, you know, different soft
- 1:17:23units involved in hostage's recovery, whether they're you know, in Israel or hanging
- 1:17:27out in Cypress, wherever the hell I'm going to cut in here. Jack
- 1:17:30wrote an article about what's going on, like jsuck spun up in Cypress,
- 1:17:34yep, and is ready to go for any kind of hostage rescue and stuff
- 1:17:39like. Yeah. So so we have responded, you know, you know,
- 1:17:43uh, really well. And of course the intelligence support, you know,
- 1:17:45we're we're kind of pumping intel in there. And so I think the
- 1:17:47US has has certainly recovered and again, you know, and and there was
- 1:17:51an article I think the Wall Street Journal is saying US singant we're actually now
- 1:17:54conducting unilateral singant u missions back there, so you know, we can turn
- 1:17:59on a dime. It's an area we know very well. Uh. And
- 1:18:01I think that, you know, the relationship between the US and the Israeli
- 1:18:05intelligence communities has always been very good. Some strains here and there sometimes,
- 1:18:10but it's probably going full boor now. But look, we we weren't covering
- 1:18:14this on October sixth, and you just got to you got to admit that,
- 1:18:18yeah, out of curiosity, you know it we're in Gaza. Is
- 1:18:23this kind of weird area, especially the relationship to you know, Israel and
- 1:18:27what's going on right now? Because if it were Somalia or Yemen or you
- 1:18:32know, uh, the Philippines and ten Americans were killed in eight were hostage,
- 1:18:39what what in your experience, what would be our intelligence and military response
- 1:18:43to that at this point in time? Right? I mean yeah, I
- 1:18:46mean, you know that's that's a mass casualty terrorist event. A task force
- 1:18:50is set up, you know, there's you know, embassies are mobilized.
- 1:18:56You know, CTC goes on war footing. You know, you know the
- 1:19:00beach in brag you know, are twenty four to seven people start moving right
- 1:19:05away, and and you know, and so I mean there's there's a an
- 1:19:10enormous industry in in response to this. Uh. And so you know again
- 1:19:16you know, when when when Americans are you know, in harm or or
- 1:19:20killed or captured, you know, that's that's our thing. There's nothing that
- 1:19:25kind of gets you going every day, like you'll work twenty four hours a
- 1:19:28day weeks on end. And so you know, I imagine that's what's that's
- 1:19:32what's happening now. And I think that I would hope that there would be
- 1:19:40some questions asked though about about you know, uh, events before this,
- 1:19:44because you know, okay, so let's you know again, it's it's the
- 1:19:46idea of of you know, can we have global coverage as the intelligence community.
- 1:19:54Well, I think that we should. We certainly, we can certainly
- 1:19:56try. But to have kind of seeded all this to the Israelis in Gaza
- 1:20:00ultimately was a mistake. I'm going to ask you to put on your sort
- 1:20:05of imagination camp because anything can happen. But how do you think this winds
- 1:20:14down or ends? Because obviously Israel can't stay at it forever. They cannot
- 1:20:19get every member of Hamas, you know, no no matter how hard they
- 1:20:25try. But Hamas is still going to live right next door, and they're
- 1:20:29going to build up again, and they're gonna plan the next operation to do
- 1:20:32this because Hamas's goal is to bring hate and pain onto the Palestinians, right
- 1:20:38like, that's to to eradicate Israel and and you know, and create martyrs
- 1:20:48like the what Israel what is going on in or in Gaza right now?
- 1:20:55Hamas planned for? Oh so there's what a great point you made, Dave
- 1:21:00so in there. I mean, it's you can make the same argument.
- 1:21:04But Issama bin Laden in September eleventh, you know, they plan for a
- 1:21:09massive response, and so you know, so right now, Hamas thinks they've
- 1:21:14won. So that's why I cease fire. I think is so damaging if
- 1:21:17Hamas they've gotten their asses kicked after this. But Israel is now in you
- 1:21:23know, in many circles, in international pariah because of the collateral damage,
- 1:21:27the civilian casualties. So Hamas thinks they've won, and so they're happy to
- 1:21:32kind of call it a day. I mean you they're actually their spokesmen are
- 1:21:35saying this right now, Yeah, we want, we want to cease fire.
- 1:21:38We're good, yeah, and these realities are saying hell no. But
- 1:21:42your your question is, is is really important? Because I'm really good at
- 1:21:46doing what we've done in the last hour and twenty two minutes talking about the
- 1:21:51kind of the tactics and counter terrorism. But when you say, you know,
- 1:21:55how does this end? I think the smartest thing for an intelligence officer
- 1:21:57or former intelligence officers say like, I don't really know, because there's so
- 1:22:00many different variables. And ironically, I think the biggest variable in this is
- 1:22:04Israeli politics. And let me tell you why, because ultimately Prime mister net
- 1:22:11Nyah, who who is enormously unpopular probably has about a five percent you know,
- 1:22:16you know, popularity rating there would lose in the next election. There
- 1:22:20is no incentive for him to to have this war wind down because the second
- 1:22:25it does, there's gonna be elections and he will be out of power.
- 1:22:28And any politician, particularly someone as kind of cynical as net Yaho, wants
- 1:22:30to remain in power. The other part, too, is that you know
- 1:22:34he very much, you know, the notion of how this could conceivably end,
- 1:22:40which is some type of two state entity where there's some kind of good
- 1:22:44governance, Palestinian something, you know, Palestinian authority two point zero. All
- 1:22:49this is he is fundamentally against. He does not want a Palestinian state ever.
- 1:22:55And so you know, I think this goes where the Israeli electric sends
- 1:23:00it. So you know, you know, a new Israeli government is absolutely
- 1:23:02critical. Right. The Arab states have said, you know, the Amiradis,
- 1:23:08the Saudis, who have you know, gazillion dollars, have said,
- 1:23:10hey, we're gonna come in and rebuild, but only if there's a two
- 1:23:13state solution and it kind of a viable palset and an entity not amas.
- 1:23:16Right, let me so so I think that, you know, but but
- 1:23:19so much it depends on the Israeli electric Excuse me, this is a d's
- 1:23:25making me drink all this uza, so it's your fault. Let me throw
- 1:23:29one other thing uh out there to discuss. And this is in relation to
- 1:23:32this, because I think it's really important. There's the notion of the Arab
- 1:23:38Street. You know, what does that mean? So you know, American
- 1:23:40embassy officials are sending in cables saying the US has lost the Arab Street for
- 1:23:44generations. And my response to that is that doesn't fucking matter because so much
- 1:23:48of this is kind of generated by Arab governments who want to give their miserable
- 1:23:53populations some kind of you know, valve to vent. I'm sorry, you
- 1:23:58know, there's you know, and and when I say miserable populations, that's
- 1:24:00not being that's not being fair. But but so what really matters in terms
- 1:24:04of of you know, the Arab world, and that has to do with
- 1:24:06the Arab intelligence services. And so what I've been I've been I've been asking
- 1:24:12people if someone write this story. I can't. I don't have the sources.
- 1:24:14But uh uh, the whole thing goes to shit if security cooperation breaks
- 1:24:19down between Israel and Jordan, or Israel and Egypt, or Israel and Cutter,
- 1:24:25or Israel in Saudi Arabia. Israel actually actually is the security blanket for
- 1:24:30Jordan's So you see the Jordanian Foreign Minister, Jordanian king howling protests all over
- 1:24:34the place. The last I heard from kind of sources I had in g
- 1:24:39I d they were telling Israel keep going, I'm being dead serious, Dave.
- 1:24:42Yeah, and so you know, you know, so so and why
- 1:24:45does that matter even in the context of what we're talking about. Is so
- 1:24:48okay. So everyone's saying that Israel has to has to kind of do the
- 1:24:51best they can and remove Hamas as a threat. But then when it comes
- 1:24:57to rebuilding, you know, the Arab States will come in, but you
- 1:25:00got to have a different Israeli government in power. But the thing is,
- 1:25:02though, also I think, I mean in addition to that, because I
- 1:25:08agree with you, and in in addition to that, anytime a two states
- 1:25:12solution has been brought to the table or anything else like that, whoever was
- 1:25:15running, whoever was making money off Palestine, whether it was Arafat or you
- 1:25:20know, or or I mean not not Arafat, but you know, whoever
- 1:25:25was making money because Gaza and Palestine is basically it's a money making scheme for
- 1:25:32you know, whomever runs you know, like runs Gaza. So so actually
- 1:25:40getting them to the table and agreeing to it, well, then's you know
- 1:25:44who Gaza is a problem because you know who's going to come in after that.
- 1:25:47I mean, you know, you know, the Hamasa has kind of
- 1:25:49run the entire infrastructure there. But but I think you bring up an interesting
- 1:25:54point that that at the times where we thought that a settlement was closest you
- 1:25:57know, Arafat ended up rejecting it, and that is kind of the tragedy
- 1:26:00behind this as well, you know for sure, but you know so but
- 1:26:04but you know it's okay. As a former intelligence officers, intelligence officers,
- 1:26:08how does this end? You say, I don't know. Yeah, I
- 1:26:11mean, because there's so many variables. But I really do look to the
- 1:26:13Israeli elections, like that's going to be key to getting net New out of
- 1:26:15Yahoo, out of power. Yeah, and that is the only path forward
- 1:26:20to this kind of having any kind of resolution that means something. Yeah,
- 1:26:26it's tough for me because you know, having you know, studied Arabic and
- 1:26:29had a lot of Arabic teachers and talking to them about you know, the
- 1:26:31region and their impressions, uh, you know, and as citizens like they
- 1:26:36were none of more government officials, but from my Egyptian instructor, Jordanian Lebani,
- 1:26:45they were all the opinion that Palestine is not going anywhere because Palestine is
- 1:26:49a great foil to Israel. So nobody's ordering or nobody's opening their borders to
- 1:26:58Palestinians. Nobody's like the Egyptians are not. I mean, it's unbelievable.
- 1:27:01I mean Jordan, Jordan killed them. They're terrified of this. They don't
- 1:27:04want refugee. Yeah, kind of nobody's going to open their borders. And
- 1:27:10and the thing is is that as long as uh, you know, there's
- 1:27:17the Israel Palestinian conflict, Israel's there's always a foil against Israel to claim about,
- 1:27:26you know, to claim that Israel is abusing Arabs. And you know,
- 1:27:31so it's that it's that Palestine operate or palerce increase an opportunity for them
- 1:27:40to complain about Israel. Let me, let me, let me thought.
- 1:27:45I just thought of one other great story, you know, one of the
- 1:27:46fun things about coming on the show. Here is that this I can say
- 1:27:49things that I can't stay in a thirty second you know TV SoundBite. I
- 1:27:55think I put that out on social media today when I said I was excited
- 1:27:58coming on. But you know, and this goes to you know, so
- 1:28:00obviously you know people gonna walk away and saying, holy shit, Mark,
- 1:28:02is this like crazy pro Israel? You know, kill them all, not
- 1:28:05back? But actually no, And let me tell you a story, because
- 1:28:09I really do sympathize with the plate of the Palestinians and in these and so
- 1:28:13this is going to be kind of the opposite end is that, you know,
- 1:28:15anyone who wants to have an idea about the conflicts got a visit.
- 1:28:18And I was going into Ramala back in twenty sixteen, and I hadn't been
- 1:28:23to Israel for since two thousand and ten or eleven is when I left Jordan,
- 1:28:27so when I was at the A sign there, and so twenty sixteen,
- 1:28:30we're going in. I'm with our you know, our kind of the
- 1:28:33head of our liaison to the Palestinian intelligence Service. We're going to see the
- 1:28:36head of the Palestinian Service in Ramala. And as we're going in I'm like,
- 1:28:43holy shit, there's you know, they've built a whole lot of walls
- 1:28:45here like that, you know, the the kind of the it was very
- 1:28:47imposing, and we're going in and of course what people don't understand is often
- 1:28:54as the US official, you're not treated all that well by even the Israeli
- 1:28:57border guards. You know, they can be totally obnoxious assholes. Frankly,
- 1:29:00they don't give a shit if I have a black passport because I'm going into
- 1:29:04the Palestinian authority areas. So clearly I'm doing something that's you know, not
- 1:29:09going to be you know, in their mind, something positive. And so
- 1:29:12but I'm going in there. And my my colleague again, who's listening right
- 1:29:15now, he's texting me wildly because of being a pro Israel nutbag. He
- 1:29:19said, tell the story. And so we're going in there. And he
- 1:29:23looked him and he said, welcome to the zoo. And it was shocking
- 1:29:26to me. And that was the notion that the Palestinians are caged in there,
- 1:29:30and so so you know, it goes kind of the fundamental notion is
- 1:29:33that you know, this is not sustainable. You know, the way the
- 1:29:36Palestinians are treated is not sustainable, and you got to go see it.
- 1:29:41If you're I remember, you know, we're this is going to sound horrible,
- 1:29:44like we're having a drink. It's somewhere, you know, at a
- 1:29:45bar in Jerusalem overlooking watching the you know, the Palestinians in the Old City
- 1:29:51battling with the Israeli with the idf Uh. You know, it's just you
- 1:29:55know, there there, it's not sustainable because the Palestinians certainly are not treated
- 1:29:58well, both certainly in the West Bank and Gaza is not ruled by Israel.
- 1:30:02Uh. But there's got to be a better way, and you know,
- 1:30:04you can't help. And that's why that you know, there was there
- 1:30:08was a you know, so I go and I go to the Israeli embassy.
- 1:30:12I watched this footage for forty six minutes. I'm outraged. But then
- 1:30:15yesterday, you know, a really good reporter, Clarissa Award of CNN,
- 1:30:19I mean, she's a great war reporter, and she went in with uh
- 1:30:25kind of snuck into Gaza and went to visit the Emoradi Hospital there a field
- 1:30:28hospital, and the report was kind of heartbreaking at the civilian casualties, at
- 1:30:32the kind of humanity and humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza. And I sit back after
- 1:30:35that, I'm like, all right, like you know, what am I
- 1:30:38feeling? What am I doing? And it's you know, it reminds me
- 1:30:41of conflict zones where there is you know, there's so many kind of different
- 1:30:44moral challenges all the time. I mean, I'm you know, I remember
- 1:30:46this is a terrible story. Get in trouble for this. I remember when
- 1:30:50in Iraq and we had some assets were giving us, you know, targeting
- 1:30:55data, and I and I sent some coordinates and was re laid up to
- 1:30:58a marine F eighteen, and you know, he came around and he was
- 1:31:01trying to hit a target. He missed, and he hit a building,
- 1:31:04a fucking apartment building. And I was like, what the fuck just happened?
- 1:31:08That's my fault. And that happens constantly, and and you know,
- 1:31:12some innocent people probably died that day. Maybe not, maybe they were evacuated.
- 1:31:15I have no idea, one hundred percent possible that no one was there,
- 1:31:19but you know, bad stuff happens like that, and innocent people get
- 1:31:23hurt, and so you know, there's all these kind of moral ambiguities in
- 1:31:27war, and I don't know, I go back to again, one of
- 1:31:29the great victories of the war against ISIS was mostly twenty seventeen, ten thousand
- 1:31:32civilians died, and that's considered a great US success. I don't know,
- 1:31:38No, it is challenging. You know, you and I have talked about
- 1:31:45this. The footage is like, it goes outside of war. The footage
- 1:31:50goes outside of what the normal humanitarian crisis that happens in a war. The
- 1:32:00footage even one of those guys, if if he had done that in the
- 1:32:04United States, it would be on all the news channels as a barbaric act.
- 1:32:10Yeah, you know, well they let me. Let me say something.
- 1:32:12So if the equivalent twelve hundred, if forty thousand Americans right had died
- 1:32:18and a third of them had been beheaded, beaten to death and raped,
- 1:32:25whatever country did that wouldn't have a capital I'm sorry, Like so Americans don't
- 1:32:29understand this, and you know we would have leveled you know that we were
- 1:32:32talking about that, you know, I mean Joe Scarborough on Morning Joe said
- 1:32:35this, you know, and a former you know, kind of conservative congressman,
- 1:32:41he said, you know, if Mexico had done this to us,
- 1:32:43he just kind of threw this out there. He goes Mexico City would be
- 1:32:45and someone said, would we have tanks outside Mexico City? He said,
- 1:32:47no, it wouldn't exist. Forty thousand Americans, you know, raped and
- 1:32:53dismembered and defiled, and so I don't know. We kind of understand the
- 1:32:58Israeli thinking. We went to Warford, we went to war for three thousand,
- 1:33:01World Trade Center, we went to war for what three four thousand?
- 1:33:05Pearl Harbor like like Pearl Harbor was two thousand. I think it was even
- 1:33:10small. I mean, I get the numbers. Actually, there's a great
- 1:33:13Netflix documentary out in World War Two. Have you seen that? No,
- 1:33:15not yet, it's really had, the one that's colorized. Yeah, I
- 1:33:19haven't seen it, but I think that the casualty numbers in Pearl Harbor tragic,
- 1:33:24terrible. Yeah, we're not as high as I as I as I
- 1:33:27for whatever reason, I thought, so yeah, yeah, and we yes,
- 1:33:30we went to war. We went we went to war like world like,
- 1:33:32we went to war, so equivalent of forty thousand. So I think,
- 1:33:36like I tend to agree with you that I think that America should be
- 1:33:41very embarrassed because our anti Semitism is really showing right now in the sense that
- 1:33:45on the right, you know, when you talk about racist and anti Sumites
- 1:33:49on the right, like you always knew they were there. They weren't shy
- 1:33:55about it, you know. They they've done little dumb little costumes and do
- 1:34:00alleys and stuff like that. On the left, it was hidden until now
- 1:34:04it's there. Yeah, I mean it's not hidden anymore. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:34:10right, it's right. I mean, you know, I member,
- 1:34:13they could be marching, Yeah, they could be marching alongside clan members and
- 1:34:15it'd be like, you know what I mean, and be like, which
- 1:34:18which I think is? You know, actually I'm surprised at that, you
- 1:34:20know, I you know, I you know, I love this country,
- 1:34:23you know dearly, but I was I'm disappointed with, uh, with a
- 1:34:29lot of what I've what I've seen, you know, especially on college campuses.
- 1:34:30Now. You know, it's funny because I go around, I talk
- 1:34:32to colleges. I probably do one lecture every every week around the country.
- 1:34:36I love doing this and I haven't seen this. But I'm trying to think,
- 1:34:41like, Okay, why am I not seeing this anywhere? And because
- 1:34:44I'm going to talk to the class that's you know, of national security studies
- 1:34:47or intelligence studies that you know, whoever's taking that class is not going to
- 1:34:51have the propensity to kind of you know, have those have those feelings and
- 1:34:56so but you know, I was just but U I was at at I
- 1:35:01think I addressed. I did a keynote at GW University's Naval r OTC kind
- 1:35:06of their annual conference, and and GW has had some problems and so you
- 1:35:11know, some of the students were telling me about that too. But it's
- 1:35:13it's it's it's really unfortunate because you know, a lot of these a lot
- 1:35:17of kind of Jewish students are are feeling incredibly unsafe, and it's a it's
- 1:35:23a I just I thought better of America. And you know what, you
- 1:35:27can be upset what's happening. If you know, if if you sympathize with
- 1:35:30the Palestaians, that's fine. But the idea of of you know, glorifying
- 1:35:33Hamas and and let's not forget you know this, that insanity of last week
- 1:35:39or the week before where this kind of this went viral on TikTok about the
- 1:35:43bin Laden letter. You remember that day, yes, yes, I do,
- 1:35:45But all of a sudden, bin Laden is the new sa Goe era,
- 1:35:47right, right, I mean, are you what the f happened?
- 1:35:51I mean, I mean I went crazy with both of them hated homosexuals,
- 1:35:55so why not right, like like both of them executed. Yeah, So
- 1:35:59it's like, but this is the new the new starling of the left,
- 1:36:02like uh and and and to me, that was something that was really unfortunate.
- 1:36:08Just again it's but but you know, you know, as I as
- 1:36:11I do a lot of media stuff, I've met you know, or you
- 1:36:13know, you certainly run across a lot of kind of senior kind of you
- 1:36:18know, Jewish leaders you know, uh uh and and and you know they
- 1:36:25will tell you that anti Semitism was this anti semitism was always there. But
- 1:36:29to me, it's I'm I'm certainly disappointed. I mean, you know,
- 1:36:31when I went to college, you know, you study everything and there's you
- 1:36:35know, you have to you have to be able to talk about everything.
- 1:36:38And it certainly is that there's a notion of of of free speech. But
- 1:36:43you never let any kind of group feel unsafe, right, And that's what
- 1:36:46we've seen, and that to me was really awful. I uh want to
- 1:36:54move on if unless there's anything else you want to go, they were good
- 1:36:57about all. We covered everything. So you know, the Russia Ukraine war
- 1:37:01was hot in the news for a minute, and then you know, obviously
- 1:37:06the situation in Israel has taken over and there aren't too many reports. Have
- 1:37:12you been following that closely big time? And so you know, to me,
- 1:37:16this is this is something that's near and dear to my heart. And
- 1:37:18I will tell you why. The last job I had again from sixteen to
- 1:37:24nineteen when I retired or maybe early seven, late sixteen, early seventeen,
- 1:37:28being the Deputy Ops Chief and then the acting Ops chief for all of Europe
- 1:37:31and eur Asia. So that's fifty countries, two thousand, you know,
- 1:37:35agency officers. But ultimately a lot of it had to do with what I
- 1:37:40call putting in the plumbing in a kind of our counter kind of Russia program,
- 1:37:45and that had to do with supporting the Ukrainians. This was the most
- 1:37:48kind of non sexy deployment of all time, where we had folks going out
- 1:37:54there kind of working, building those personal relationships, training assistance. You knows,
- 1:38:00were fighting the good fight in the East. But it wasn't Iraq,
- 1:38:02it wasn't al Qaeda, it wasn't Afghanistan, it wasn't kind of the stuff
- 1:38:05that's on the news all the time, and then it was. And and
- 1:38:10one of the one of the things that that is that is so great about
- 1:38:13you know, the intelligence community being a CIO officers, that's you know,
- 1:38:16we build these relationships and we do them at a time where you don't know,
- 1:38:20it's go if it's gonna be an advantage later on, but in this
- 1:38:23case, it one hundred percent was. And so you know, the day
- 1:38:26of the Russian invasion in Ukraine, it's not like Zelensky called up Langley and
- 1:38:30said, who are you. It's more of, hey, you know the
- 1:38:33guys and gals down the street who've been here for years helping us build capacity,
- 1:38:39training and and and you know, one of the things that happens in
- 1:38:44our old world is that you know, you know, you have this kind
- 1:38:46of cycle. There's a rotation cycle where people go back to the same area
- 1:38:49time and again and again and again. So our people knew, you know,
- 1:38:54the the the the members of you know, Ukrainian military intelligence for example,
- 1:38:59because they've been going there for years. And so you build on those
- 1:39:00relationships and then what happens and so you look right now there was this is
- 1:39:05incredible. Two days ago the US I see declassified an assessment of Russian losses
- 1:39:13and Dave, I don't know if you saw this, but it blew my
- 1:39:15mind because I knew it was bad. Eighty seven percent of the Russian standing
- 1:39:19army anywhere on the day of the Russian invasion has been killed or wounded three
- 1:39:26hundred and fifteen thousand. That's a staggering number if you think about our assistance
- 1:39:30programs globally anywhere in history, never anything like this. But but what does
- 1:39:34that mean? Also, not a single US booting on the ground. There's
- 1:39:39no US military on the ground, there is no US loss of life and
- 1:39:45so, and it's about five percent of our of our defense budget. And
- 1:39:49even the assistance program that we're trying to push through Congress now sixty billion dollars.
- 1:39:54That's an accounting error, you know, rounding error in DD and so.
- 1:39:58So. US has done incredible things for the Ukrainians. And I'm really
- 1:40:01proud of that because it goes back to kind of the that that notion of
- 1:40:04building relationships that we do over time. You know, I've written articles on
- 1:40:10this before. I firmly believe in the in kind of the concept of defending
- 1:40:14forward. Now, does that mean US military deployed all over the world,
- 1:40:16No, but it does mean US intelligence deployed all over the world. It
- 1:40:20means our case officers, our paramilitary officers selectively, our analysts, certainly CIA
- 1:40:27stations where we're kind of you know, building that capacity, building those those
- 1:40:31relationships that if they need to be called on, can be And that's certainly
- 1:40:34what happened in Ukraine. And so I think that, uh, you know
- 1:40:40that that ultimately this is going to be one of the great success stories.
- 1:40:43Now I wish we had done more. And what drives me crazy about this
- 1:40:46administration is you can make the argument that the administration saved Ukraine, and they
- 1:40:50did, but they didn't allow Ukraine to win, right, and that means
- 1:40:55giving them kind of advanced weapons. You know, there's always this again,
- 1:41:00what does this go back to, Dave? It's the fear of escalation,
- 1:41:01Like this is like kind of you know, traumatize this administration on every count.
- 1:41:06Some some would say that's being smart and wise. I would say we're
- 1:41:10being too risk averse. But ultimately, you know, you want to give
- 1:41:13the other side the ability to win, and so you know, we're we're
- 1:41:16at a point right now in which, you know, the European governments actually
- 1:41:20this is a really good thing. This is a good The messaging is all
- 1:41:24wrong, you know, in terms of how this fight in Congress. This
- 1:41:27is not a never ending war. You know, we actually have a never
- 1:41:30ending ally in Ukraine. But the never ending war is we need to get
- 1:41:32Ukraine through the next year. But Germany just pledged eight billion dollars and the
- 1:41:36European nations actually are are have pledged even more in in military as systems.
- 1:41:43So this sixty billion will get get the Ukrainians through twenty four and we've really
- 1:41:47gotten Europe on board. I think the Estonians said that zero point two five
- 1:41:53percent of their entire budget is going to be is going to be dedicated to
- 1:41:57Ukraine. That's pretty impressive. And so I think it's I think it's a
- 1:42:00success story. Certainly, it's a massive intelligence success story. I mean something
- 1:42:04that we you know that myself, as a as a former agency officer,
- 1:42:09is incredibly proud of UH and UH and and we just have to kind of
- 1:42:14keep resolute. I think that ultimately, maybe I'm being an optimist, I
- 1:42:17think that they're going to come to some agreement that Democrats will give on some
- 1:42:19border stuff. We'll get this sixty billion dollar package forward and again. But
- 1:42:26but it's but it's not it's not a never ending war, right, it's
- 1:42:30a never ending ally. But the Europeans are stepping up and that's a good
- 1:42:31thing. Right. Has there been any major shifts in the battle lines there?
- 1:42:39Or has it been mostly static? I mean has been you know,
- 1:42:42this this vaunted offensive didn't work. Now why didn't it work? My you
- 1:42:45know, I think that we didn't give them the means to do it.
- 1:42:48There's a lot of arguments between the Pentagon and the Ukrainians on strategy. I'm
- 1:42:53not a military strategist, so I don't know. But ultimately I think that
- 1:42:57if you don't have air power, you know, how are you going to
- 1:42:59make any kind of gains? And F sixteens are coming online, but they're
- 1:43:02coming online late. Right. The attack of missiles, these long range missiles,
- 1:43:06that these attack of missiles drove the Russian black sea fleet out of Sevestipol.
- 1:43:12Right, But there's no many. There's you know, we gave them
- 1:43:15like twenty there's there's no more left. I mean, it's maddening to me.
- 1:43:18Right. And again it's because of this indecision and this trepidation and fear
- 1:43:23of escalation in the NSC that drives me nuts. It's the same thing we
- 1:43:26talked about before about, you know, the worries of escalation in the Middle
- 1:43:29East. I think that, you know, the US could have a much
- 1:43:32more aggressive foreign policy. By the way, this is also not a Democrat
- 1:43:36versus Republican thing. I don't know if a president you know, Haley or
- 1:43:41you know, or or Dysantis or or Trump would would have a different view
- 1:43:45of this, But I certainly think that we should. We can, we
- 1:43:47can be much more aggressive, and we have this tremendous military power. We
- 1:43:50should use it be smart about it. But now, but again, not
- 1:43:55all is lost in Ukraine. I think that, uh, the key thing
- 1:43:59over you know, we have it's twenty twenty four. Now Ukraine is running
- 1:44:01out of ammunition and they're running out of air defense and Europeans is not going
- 1:44:06to come online. So we've got to get them what they need over the
- 1:44:11next year. I wish that the administration would make that argument. I think
- 1:44:14the GOP would would respond to that because they're concerned about a never ending confract.
- 1:44:19My point is it won't be Europeans are going to step up. They
- 1:44:23have pledged this, but just you know this as a as a as you
- 1:44:26know, it's former military, like the whole could of capacity and production.
- 1:44:30It just it just takes a while to ramp up. We'll get there,
- 1:44:34but we got to get them through this next. And you know, if
- 1:44:36you say, hey, we're going to give the sixty billion and then Europe's
- 1:44:40got to take over, that's fine, and I think the Ukrainians would would
- 1:44:42accept that, But I think the messaging has been all screwed up on this.
- 1:44:46I don't I don't blame like the GOP's view for like you know,
- 1:44:51or whoever in the GOP, because you know, I think that they are
- 1:44:54there are these were these hawks basically are these Russia hawks that it doesn't matter
- 1:44:59if they're left for right, they're just Russia hawks, you know who through
- 1:45:02last through these administrations, and their goal has been to bleed Russia. Like
- 1:45:08they didn't want Ukraine to win a decisive victory in no time flat because that
- 1:45:14doesn't serve the goal of economically and militarily harming Russia to that, you know,
- 1:45:18to a massive degree. So you know, when you talk about when
- 1:45:23we talk about just money, because you mentioned the attackers and talk about six
- 1:45:27seams. When we talk about money, it's like, well, if you
- 1:45:29give me ten dollars worth of aid in bbs or ten dollars worth of aid
- 1:45:34in shotgun shells, it makes a significant difference in my ability to, you
- 1:45:39know, to defend my home. And I think that some people see as
- 1:45:45US have as US as have been giving Ukraine bbs, and we're just going
- 1:45:51to keep giving bbs even though it's a meat grinder for them, it's also
- 1:45:57a meat grinder for Russia, and that's the long term goal of some of
- 1:46:00these people deep in the administration. I think that you know, there's there's
- 1:46:03a I you have a different view of this if you've been on the ground,
- 1:46:09working with local forces, with indigenous forces, and so, you know,
- 1:46:12I always think about things I did in the past with the Kurds,
- 1:46:15for example, other Iraqis, Syrians, Afghans for sure, And you know,
- 1:46:23the US makes a lot of promises and you know, and and very
- 1:46:26often we don't kind of uphold those. And so if I wasn't retired,
- 1:46:30I would hope I certainly would have volunteered maybe I was too senior, but
- 1:46:33fuck it, I take it to motion like I'd want to be in the
- 1:46:35Ukraine. AO. You know, I can't say anything more, but i'd
- 1:46:40want to be around that area. So if you're looking at someone you know,
- 1:46:44and it would probably be someone from Ukrainian military intelligence who were working with
- 1:46:48and uh and and and you're saying, you know, we're gonna we're gonna
- 1:46:51help you win. By the way, I also know that you know your
- 1:46:56sister and your brother were killed at your home. Is is no longer h
- 1:47:01and and so you know you are under absolute threat from the Russians. But
- 1:47:05we're going to do everything possible. But then then your government, in this
- 1:47:09case, the US government doesn't do enough. These are really hard. That
- 1:47:13was the hardest part of my job before is dealing with that. And I
- 1:47:16remember in the Syria program where where literally senior US officials would say, we're
- 1:47:21just going to give the Syrian opposition enough to get to the negotiating table.
- 1:47:25And I said, that's fine if you're an armchair quarterback in DC at the
- 1:47:28NSC, But if you're on the front lines every day living with the Syrian
- 1:47:30opposition, how the fuck do you say that? And so the same thing
- 1:47:34with the Ukrainians where they say, we know you have attack'ms. The same
- 1:47:39thing with you know, the Abrams then the tanks were late f sixteens were
- 1:47:42way late. Why can't you give them to us? Like my family's dying,
- 1:47:46right, and so maybe that's the that's the age old kind of.
- 1:47:51I had this conversation with a lot of people here in DC because this is
- 1:47:55the way I think of things, and they're always like, well, you
- 1:47:57know, Mark, you don't understand the greater strategic good and black blah blah
- 1:48:00blah blah. I'm like, well, I look at it from being on
- 1:48:01the tip of the spear, and my job was to look at my indigenous
- 1:48:04kind of you know Campadre, who, by the way, it's impossible for
- 1:48:09me not to fall in love with I'm sorry, you know, I'm living
- 1:48:12with them. It's the same thing with you know, with the ctpts in
- 1:48:15Afghanistan, right in my base in Afghanistan, like ever, you know,
- 1:48:18we lived with them, we ate with them. Such different experiences. When
- 1:48:24the regular US military everyone was armed together, there was never a green on
- 1:48:28blue ever, and in fact, they saved our lives constantly. I'm not
- 1:48:30here today there's ten Americans or twenty Americans. Is a thousand endage, right,
- 1:48:35and so you know you have an affinity for them, and you know
- 1:48:39these are your brothers in arms or sisters in arms. And so ultimately,
- 1:48:44I think that where I get upset about the Ukraine issues that we just didn't
- 1:48:47do enough. And I would have hated to be on the front lines or
- 1:48:51not in the front lines, but but you know, in the trenches somewhere
- 1:48:55with the Ukrainian you know, partners, and trying to explain why we didn't
- 1:49:00give attackers where I have sixteens or late and for God's sake, political dysfunction
- 1:49:04in the US. I mean again, look at that that that declassified intel
- 1:49:09report. I mean, we have at TRIDD eighty seven percent of the Russian
- 1:49:14military that's an adversary of ours. Like, right, this is a wild
- 1:49:16success, Like okay, why are we not doing more of this? I
- 1:49:20just you know, it's a an and and and one other last piece too.
- 1:49:23I know I talked about it last time I came on about Ukraine.
- 1:49:26And this is being very simplistic, but it is a I think one of
- 1:49:30the reasons why Ukraine has been appealing to members of the intelligence and special operations
- 1:49:36in military communities. Is that it is much more of a good versus evil
- 1:49:40story, you know, you know Iraq was very fuzzy. Yeah, I
- 1:49:44mean, for Fox's sake, we have we have we have put in place
- 1:49:47a sort of an Iranian surrogate, right rock. Yeah, I mean,
- 1:49:51I don't know, I could. Could you say that Iraq was a win
- 1:49:54for the US? I'm not sure? No, no, right, no.
- 1:49:58Uh. Ukraine is a little more clear cut in my view, and
- 1:50:01I think there's that, there's that I'm sorry, I'm just a middle class
- 1:50:03kid from New Jersey, but you know that's the appeal that I have.
- 1:50:06That stuff tugs at me. Yeah. Yeah. Russia invaded and we're helping
- 1:50:13a country room free from invasion. That's it. It's kind of good.
- 1:50:15I mean, I like that we knew by all the protests against Russia that
- 1:50:18they invaded everywhere. Amazing, Yeah, all over campuses. I can't have
- 1:50:25me. I don't know. I mean, I'm gonna go down to d
- 1:50:26C. Yeah, or in London or everywhere else. I mean, yeah,
- 1:50:29no, I didn't see that. Was there anything else? Is there
- 1:50:35anything else that you want to talk about? Even if it's not about these
- 1:50:39two topics anything else going on for you. That one of the coolest things
- 1:50:44that I will this This is a positive note because I mentioned before that I
- 1:50:48go around kind of talking to UH to to college students all over the country.
- 1:50:54I mean, I spend I don't get paid anything for this, like
- 1:50:57they'll pay my expenses, so it's not I'm not making any money. But
- 1:51:00I love going and talking to to college students who are interested in national security.
- 1:51:04So these are either RTC programs or you know, intelligent study programs,
- 1:51:09national security programs, anything like that. And it's the idea of passing the
- 1:51:12torch to the next generation. And to me, that's so important. And
- 1:51:15and aside from my kind of being horrified that some of generations d who are
- 1:51:19protesting UH out in the streets, but but in general, I think we're
- 1:51:24okay. And and you know, and and the the individuals who are you
- 1:51:28know, who are interested in national security, you know, are are patriotic,
- 1:51:32you know, they want to serve UH UH. And And as I
- 1:51:36go and talk to schools all over the country, and it's it's across the
- 1:51:40board everywhere. It's really exciting because I think that you know, you know,
- 1:51:45the most important thing is that you know, as we all kind of
- 1:51:46get grand in the tooth or lose our hair. Sorry, you and I
- 1:51:49are in the same spot. We got to go back to the first episode
- 1:51:54I came out. I definitely had more fucking hair, There's no doubt about
- 1:51:58that. But but ultimately we're passing the tour the next generation and that's a
- 1:52:00good thing. And you know, when you I don't believe everything the agency
- 1:52:03tells me when I ask him about kind of you know, recruitment and retention.
- 1:52:06I think there's an issue on retention, but I think on recruitment,
- 1:52:10I mean, I think they're doing pretty well. And so there are people
- 1:52:13who want to come into the national security community. They want to serve.
- 1:52:15And it's not it's not the post nine to eleven surge where everyone wanted to
- 1:52:18go kind of kick ass. But it's the idea of you know, what
- 1:52:21is what does an intelligence officer mean? Well, it's you know, it's
- 1:52:25a it's a you know, it's an intellectual exercise too. You know,
- 1:52:28I was always say, you know, you got to go and be interested.
- 1:52:30You know, Dave, you talked about you know, in your in
- 1:52:31your military you know your career learning Arabic and so you got to learn about
- 1:52:35learn different languages and what does that mean, Well, you got to learn
- 1:52:38about different cultures. You got to learn about religion, you know, uh,
- 1:52:42you know, you got to learn about Islam if you want to go
- 1:52:43in in the Arabic world. It's funny people and funny food and immersing yourself
- 1:52:47in a culture and becoming that expert. And you know, I always I
- 1:52:50tell these students a story. It's really I've done a lot of things in
- 1:52:54my career, and you and I have talked so much about this. I've
- 1:52:57had some great moments. I've had some awful moments. My me, my
- 1:52:59my record is mixed, and I'm very humble. But one of the one
- 1:53:01of the cool things that happened. And I'm gonna I'm gonna name a US
- 1:53:06politician and have the audience. Maybe more of it here will go crazy,
- 1:53:09but it doesn't matter, because you know, she was Speaker of the House.
- 1:53:12So Nancy Pelosi came out to Damascus when I was there, and she
- 1:53:15went to the charge at a fair. There was no ambassadors, the number
- 1:53:17two, but she said, I want to talk to the smartest person on
- 1:53:20Syria in the embassy, and he said, go talk to Mark and and
- 1:53:25I was, I was. I was flattered first of all that a senior
- 1:53:28State Department person said this, But that's because I spoke Arabic. I knew
- 1:53:31this the town cold, I knew everything. I knew everybody in the town.
- 1:53:34There's nothing in that place that and so and I spent four hours talking
- 1:53:38to her just about internal Syrian dynamics and politics. That is what you want
- 1:53:43to do as an intelligence officer. This goes back to the old days of
- 1:53:46Lawrence of Arabia, right, or or the book I read by I love,
- 1:53:49you know James Mitchener books. But you know there's a book he wrote,
- 1:53:53Caravans, about a young foreign service officer in Afghanistan, that to me
- 1:53:57is so inspiring. I want to be that substant expert. I remember there
- 1:54:00was an ABC News journalist also, Anthony Corterisman. I don't know if you
- 1:54:04remember that name. He worked for ABC for a long time. He came
- 1:54:08to Damascus and he went to the Syrian He told me he went to the
- 1:54:10Syrian Palace and he said, who's this Who's the smartest person at the embassy?
- 1:54:14And they said the CIA guy Mark. Now that's not good. I
- 1:54:16was like, well, well, fuck my covers fucked up right now.
- 1:54:20But that's what you want to be, that are to be that expert.
- 1:54:25Yes, And so that's what I tell these college students is that you immerse
- 1:54:28yourself. Like, Hey, if you don't want to do kind of funny
- 1:54:30food, religion, people, ethnic stuff, go join the FBI. God
- 1:54:33bless love my bureau colleagues work in America. Go to you know, Des
- 1:54:38Moines, which I actually might be going to. So I got to go
- 1:54:41go do a speech in Des Moines. I've never been to Des Moines.
- 1:54:43I'm actually excited about it. I love you know, We've been all over
- 1:54:46the fucking world and I haven't seen half of America. So I'm excited to
- 1:54:49see men America. But but ultimately, you know, that's what you want
- 1:54:53to be. You want to you want to be that person who has that
- 1:54:55incredible kind of you know, cultural and linguistic and historical knowledge and and and
- 1:55:00what I tell this to college students, they really respond to that. And
- 1:55:02so I do have faith that we're gonna be okay, not always, but
- 1:55:06but but just kind of inherently when I go and talk to these folks,
- 1:55:10and and then and then, you know, particularly when I go talk to
- 1:55:13RTC programs, I was not in the military. Just gonna kind of throw
- 1:55:15that out. But you know, I go talk to the service academies.
- 1:55:18I've been going to the Citadel quite a bit to talk to them. I'm
- 1:55:20gonna go to vm I for their kind of leadership program. And so I
- 1:55:24think we're gonna be all right, and that that to me is something that
- 1:55:27that that matters if we if we can pass the torch the next generation.
- 1:55:32You know, no one gives a ship, Dave, what you and I
- 1:55:33did in our past. Now, I mean, I don't know you might
- 1:55:36have this. You know, we got to have you guys come to Northern
- 1:55:39Virginia teamhouse. I'll come to the you can come to my basement. Everyone
- 1:55:45has their I Love Me wall. Everyone fucking has it. I'm sorry.
- 1:55:47You know you have it. And it's all that the hero ship that I've
- 1:55:50done. But none of that matters. No one gives a ship except me
- 1:55:53my kids. What matters is passing the torch. Yeah, absolutely absolutely,
- 1:56:01Dee, what were you saying, I say, no, people will remember
- 1:56:04what you got, are interested in what you guys. I don't think so
- 1:56:08like, yeah, you sleepy eyed when I like short a lot of stories.
- 1:56:15You should do a teamhouse at the Vienna. In a team house,
- 1:56:17that's you gotta you gotta come to the greatest dive bar on the planet where
- 1:56:21actually I spend way too much time. We're down a special show chili cheese
- 1:56:28dogs that you know. The Vienna is quote actually, so here's Oh there's
- 1:56:30what there's I'll tell you three stories from the Vienna. One is there's a
- 1:56:34hat I wore in Afghanistan for your ine skin that's in a glass case right
- 1:56:39by the men's room there. I think that's pretty cool. I came back
- 1:56:42and it was a vienna and had dirty and nasty and smells, but we
- 1:56:45put in a glass case and Marty, the owner put it up there.
- 1:56:47Uh. Number two is uh uh they sell my book there. I I
- 1:56:55you know, I wrote a book on leadership, and so I signed copies
- 1:56:58and and people come in and buy it, which I still find shocking.
- 1:57:00The last point. And I haven't told you guys this. So I was
- 1:57:03the technical consultant on Equalizer three, the Denzel movie. How was that for
- 1:57:09you? Matt? It was? It was It was fun and but here's
- 1:57:12the great Vienna end story. So you know, as I'm going through and
- 1:57:15and I'm kind of reviewing the script, and if you go back and you
- 1:57:17see the movie, there's so much kind of CIA nomenclature in there. So
- 1:57:23it's Denzel's script and Dakota Fanning and all the things they say, it really
- 1:57:27is kind of this story is not a CIA story, but everything to say
- 1:57:30about the agency had kind of rings true, whether it's you know, I
- 1:57:33think Dakota Fanning works at CTC Pheno Financial Operations Group. That's a real group.
- 1:57:38There was there's a you know, there's a there's a team that's coming
- 1:57:41in and doing something, and it was paged the Physical Access Group. I
- 1:57:44mean, none of this is classified, so I or or if it is,
- 1:57:46I'm in trouble. But but but the best part about it is there's
- 1:57:50a there's a character in there who plays the chief of station in Rome in
- 1:57:55the movie, and they they made it exactly looking like kind of me,
- 1:57:59like a little goatee, uh all the time, wearing jeans and kind of
- 1:58:03an untucked button down shirt, which is all I wore ever anywhere, including
- 1:58:09at headquarters and then and then but I remember, So I went to the
- 1:58:13Vinn one day and I'm like, hey, I got to get a hat
- 1:58:15out to the set out in Italy, and so we fedexed a Vinn baseball
- 1:58:18hat. And in the movie, the chief of station room is wearing this
- 1:58:21Vienna in baseball hat for you know, five different scenes. And so it
- 1:58:28was awesome. And so there's a picture, there's there's kind of a picture
- 1:58:30up. There's a spread at the Vinn about it. They're really excited about
- 1:58:32it. But what happened is so I went in there the other day and
- 1:58:35they're like, we've had to order, like we're getting calls from all over
- 1:58:39the world for these baseball hats, the vin hat, and so they've had
- 1:58:43to make multiple orders over and over and over again because it's now there's kind
- 1:58:46of cult following. Is like the Vienna n So it's it's pretty and it's
- 1:58:49it's an old CI hangout too, so uh but you know, but and
- 1:58:55I go in there every once in a while, I'm always saying, like,
- 1:58:56didn't you guys give me like free chicken wings? Right, you know?
- 1:58:59Billye? Occasionally they do, but not enough. Well, I mean,
- 1:59:02either that or some of those sweet sweet hat profits totally. But it's
- 1:59:06a great place. And so you know, I mean the Vien End is
- 1:59:09like this. We sit around and just fuck around and bullshit and here and
- 1:59:14and that's why that place is is uh, I mean it is. I
- 1:59:16think if if that place closes, I'm moving. Yeah, that's it.
- 1:59:21So Mark's book is Clarity and Crisis. You can get it on from any
- 1:59:26of your booksellers. It's down on links, it's down in the description.
- 1:59:30And we've talked about the book on a previous show, and Mark's been on
- 1:59:33like I think five times now, maybe six, I'm not sure. But
- 1:59:36go back and check out everything from talking about the fantas syndrome right to uh
- 1:59:44yeah to I mean every show has been Every show has been great. We're
- 1:59:46also fun. But people always come up to me and tell me to talk
- 1:59:48to me. They love they remember these shows. That's great. Yeah,
- 1:59:54So I guess that's a cult following. It's good. I guess we get
- 1:59:56around in the Intel community every and now and then you do, oh yeah,
- 2:00:00this is fun. Maybe I should have shown my ass earlier by the
- 2:00:04way you started off the show. Yeah, I don't know if people turn
- 2:00:10I don't know if people turned on, turned it on and like you know,
- 2:00:14all of a sudden it went viral or people like, oh they got
- 2:00:15to turn it off. You know, you can see you guys have your
- 2:00:20metrics on this. You'll see how many people end up doing this. I
- 2:00:24got some jelly in my role. What can I say? I think it's
- 2:00:28positive. Okay, I think so where goes let's go by the way.
- 2:00:33I just want to say to all the listeners, you know this is you
- 2:00:36know every obviously there's a there's a great following for the show, but you
- 2:00:41all are quality humans. And I will say that when I last time I
- 2:00:44was in New York, we all went at the lunch at a Greek restaurant
- 2:00:47I think chosen by d right downtown and it was awesome. It was just
- 2:00:53great seeing you guys. It's so much fun kind of hanging out. And
- 2:00:56basically I think when we sat around for lunch for two hours we did this
- 2:01:00just wasn't taped. Yeah, just shout around around shot ship. Yeah yeah,
- 2:01:04where else can people find you? Mark? So, fortunately or unfortunately,
- 2:01:09I'm on Twitter at m polymer it is unfiltered and uh, you know,
- 2:01:15one of my one of my friends from from the Intel community is also
- 2:01:17in the media. I won't say his name, but he said, he
- 2:01:19goes, you know, you are like the the the dart with no feathers.
- 2:01:24You don't just you don't give a ship what you say, which is
- 2:01:26probably hurts me sometimes. But yeah. So I'm on Twitter and certainly I'm
- 2:01:30on MSNBC is the National Security Contributor. I'm on probably a couple of times
- 2:01:32a week. Uh, and I you know, you know, I I
- 2:01:38have a kind of unique uh place there and that you know, look,
- 2:01:43you know, my job is to comment on the intelligence world and the national
- 2:01:45security world, and so I've I've had some fun doing that, but it's
- 2:01:48it's uh. And then the last piece too is that you know, one
- 2:01:51of the things I do, if anyone here is in the corporate world or
- 2:01:55the sports world, I do a lot of leadership talks around the country.
- 2:01:59I've done tons of it for sports teams. I mean, I was pretty
- 2:02:01Vanderbilt University baseball, any baseball fans or college baseball they reached out to talk
- 2:02:06to me, and I was thrilled. But I've gone around the country talking
- 2:02:09a lot about leadership in the athletics world, and then obviously corporate stuff which
- 2:02:14makes me some money, which is which can be fun too. One of
- 2:02:16the cool things about the book is, you know the principles and we've we've
- 2:02:19already done our book episode, but I've had some wild groups kind of come
- 2:02:25to me to do leadership talks that you would not even imagine, and so
- 2:02:29it's it's been a lot of fun too. D. I gotta tell you,
- 2:02:32Can I tell you a story? One last thing for D Yeah,
- 2:02:34yeah, this is all Rush. I went out to Chicago about in October
- 2:02:42and I did the leadership convention for the Greek Orthodox Church of America, Oh
- 2:02:46God, three hundred and fifty to eighty Greek priests, three hundred and fifty
- 2:02:51members, and they wanted to hear about leadership and it was. It was
- 2:02:56incredibly fun. It was wild. Was the FBI surveilling, No, No,
- 2:03:00but it was pretty close to the Greek And so my father calls me
- 2:03:03and said, when's the last time you were at church? I was like
- 2:03:05never. He's like, you're a fraud. I to call them up and
- 2:03:09say, look, hey, like you know, I'm not very religious on
- 2:03:12this. They didn't care, and it was it was actually really fun.
- 2:03:15And the Greek Church has the same problems as any company or corporation as anywhere
- 2:03:18else in terms of you know, you know, micromanagement or not being on
- 2:03:23the same page. God, I'm not going to say that, but ultimately
- 2:03:30I've done some really fun stuff with this. And so that was a that
- 2:03:32was a wild one out in Chicago, Illinois. The Greek Orthodox Patriot of
- 2:03:38North America came to see me. What the hell? It was great?
- 2:03:42I think he can He probably condemned me, you know. So here's a
- 2:03:45really interesting point on that. Sorry, this is this is great because we
- 2:03:48can kind of do freeform stuff. Is I told a story about having some
- 2:03:53regret about some of the things I've done in war zones, and they were
- 2:03:55really upset about that. I guess, you know, in terms of religiously.
- 2:03:59They said, you know, you you can't feel like you have to
- 2:04:00forget. I had to do with forgiveness. Oh and I haven't forgiven myself
- 2:04:03for some of the things that I've done. Yeah, And they said,
- 2:04:06you have to get They were really serious about that, and they took me
- 2:04:09aside and they're like, we need to talk to you about this. And
- 2:04:12I said, and you know, forgiveness is something that's really you know,
- 2:04:15it's got to be kind of your personal journey. And I said, well,
- 2:04:16well I don't. I really screwed up and some people got hurt and
- 2:04:20they said, well this is something for you to work on. So I
- 2:04:23thought that was fascinating. Yeah, and it's also interesting. I think,
- 2:04:26you know, it's always easier to look at somebody else and forgive them,
- 2:04:30especially if you understand then it is to forgive yourself, Like you were talking
- 2:04:33about the three hostages Israeli hostages killed, right, you know, in that
- 2:04:39thing. And it's like anybody who's been sort of in that situation in fog
- 2:04:43of war, and especially if you have maneuver elements or you have people with
- 2:04:46with with suicide bombs that you can't really identify, that that can clack off
- 2:04:51when they get within five, you know, five feet of you or whatever.
- 2:04:56Right, it's it's a term tragic thing. And the people who did
- 2:05:04that, you know, I don't know what unit it was, but they
- 2:05:09were not They probably were not a premier counter terrorist. Oh, it definitely
- 2:05:12was not. It was not you know what they are probably regular soldiers who
- 2:05:15are not No, I would say, I'd say they were probably reservists.
- 2:05:17Yeah, who were not trained to that level, and they were put in
- 2:05:21a in a stressful situation and and uh made a bad shoot. They're like,
- 2:05:30they're there. The hostages. Families I would, I would imagine will
- 2:05:33probably forgive them long before they forgive themselves. I will say that this is
- 2:05:38going to get a little too personal, that some of the things that I've
- 2:05:40done that have gone wrong, that that there are people who have said to
- 2:05:43me, I forgive you for that, Yeah, but I don't forgive myself.
- 2:05:45Yeah, So you know that's that's that's a that's a really good point.
- 2:05:48Yeah, on that. And I don't know my my wife, you
- 2:05:53know, so I'm Greek, but you know, my wife's Catholic and and
- 2:05:57our kids were raised Catholic. She's always trying to get me to to get
- 2:06:00a little more deep and religious. I'm not there yet, but I don't
- 2:06:03know. We'll see. But you know that on a serious note, I've
- 2:06:08told you before about kind of my some of my health struggles and stuff like
- 2:06:11that in the past. But the the one individual who's the most helpful for
- 2:06:15me in terms of kind of mental health care at Walter Reid was a Marine
- 2:06:18Corps chaplain. You know, Chappie and he told me about forgiveness, and
- 2:06:21so it was it was definitely like, you know, because I was really
- 2:06:25pissed at that at the agency for screwing me on healthcare. Yeah, and
- 2:06:29certain individuals, and he's like, you've got to forgive them, and I
- 2:06:30said I can't. He goes, you just gotta, you gotta just you
- 2:06:32gotta drop it, like the hate, the anger and the hate. It's
- 2:06:35not good for you. And so in that sense that that that that idea
- 2:06:40of forgiveness for me looking outward at something else I can do that me looking
- 2:06:46at myself for some of the mistakes I made. You know, that's a
- 2:06:48that's a different story. And and I will say that Walter Reid also said
- 2:06:51that as as I was there with you know, myself and a couple of
- 2:06:55members of of you know, Naval Special Warfare and then Air Force uh A
- 2:06:59Special racist command, they basically said, you know, we could probably spend
- 2:07:03a year with you all son on mental mental health Catholic. That's true.
- 2:07:08Yeah, yeah, anyhow, no shame in that at all. That's something
- 2:07:13that I certainly needed and still do. Yeah. No, it's important,
- 2:07:16and it's it's uh, you know, it's an important facet that you know,
- 2:07:21We've talked with you about it. We try to talk with other veterans
- 2:07:24and and uh, intelligence professionals about it if they've gone through that journey,
- 2:07:29because it's something that needs to be normalized. I mean, it doesn't help
- 2:07:33when medical records are getting turned over to cops. Like it makes people like,
- 2:07:39you know, like this big thing that's like it. It definitely like
- 2:07:43it makes it harder for veterans to trust that that they can speak in confidence
- 2:07:47with anybody without all all of a sudden getting red flagged or whatever else,
- 2:07:51right right, but that you know, so it can't be a stigma.
- 2:07:55It can't. Yeah, yeah, so yeah, all right, last last
- 2:08:00thing I want to I want to say, I'm gonna ask you guys,
- 2:08:01what's your favorite show on TV right now? I'm watching right now. You
- 2:08:09said Fargo. Yeah, that's pretty good. That's what I'm watching, Dave.
- 2:08:16I mean, I don't know. I mean SEVENS was fantastic, waiting
- 2:08:18for the next season of that, and then h Mythic Quest. I don't
- 2:08:22know. There there's so much there's a good lot of good stuff and or
- 2:08:24was phenomenal. I'm gonna throw up Bosh Legacy, Box Legacy, Bosh Bosh
- 2:08:30Legacy. Yeah, Bosch the police series is the Cop and so Bosch Legacy
- 2:08:37is when his daughter becomes a cop too and he becomes a private investigator.
- 2:08:41It's awesome. Is where can people find that? Amazon? Amazon? I
- 2:08:46think was on Amazon. I'm pretty sure the second Amazon Privately. It's interesting
- 2:08:50because you know, I do a lot of leadership one last piece, a
- 2:08:52lot of leadership consulting with the Philadelphia Police Department. So I'm shuttling back and
- 2:08:58forth to Philly a lot because of the cops, especially cops on the street
- 2:09:01certainly need that. And so I've kind of been become fascinated with the policing
- 2:09:07profession. And so Bosh Legacy was was pretty cool. But I you know,
- 2:09:11my wife thinks I'm crazy because I come back and I was like,
- 2:09:13yeah, I'm going on these ride alongs at night with the Philly cops and
- 2:09:16having a blast and it's an adrenaline rush. And She's like, come on,
- 2:09:20man, you're fifty five years old. What do you doing. Yeah,
- 2:09:26And actually I took my son there. My son's in college, so
- 2:09:28I took a picture of he's wearing his vest and he's going out in the
- 2:09:31streets with the Philly cops and she's like, you're crazy, And of course
- 2:09:33now he totally he's totally into this. Mark, I got a question.
- 2:09:37I've got it. We got a question. Did you check Petrona or do
- 2:09:41you want me to? Can you do it? Yeah? I'm gonna ask
- 2:09:43Mark a question right now too. Okay, okay, So let's say you
- 2:09:48know, you were the deputy chief of ops right in Eurasia and Europe when
- 2:09:52you're tired cut, you know, and you were what you were young,
- 2:09:56relatively young, you were like in your fifty I mean, if you didn't
- 2:10:01retire, and let's say like the you know, you didn't get hit with
- 2:10:05the microwave weapon and all that went down, you're probably in line for like
- 2:10:09that being director. No, you got to be on a short list.
- 2:10:13No, that's all based on luck. I have no idea. I mean
- 2:10:16I think I think that you know, ultimately, well, there's a couple
- 2:10:20of things on that that's total luck. I have no idea. I would
- 2:10:22never be so presumptuous to think I'd be chosen for that. But let me
- 2:10:24also say, like, you know, the second you get promoted up to
- 2:10:28those ranks. Your life is miserable. You don't run operations anymore. It's
- 2:10:31all about people and resources and problems. I hated the job, I really
- 2:10:35did. And you know, my time as a street case officer was so
- 2:10:41far in my past, so I don't know. I don't think I was
- 2:10:46terribly ambitious to do those things. But what was interesting is, you know,
- 2:10:48you get promoted to the Senior Intelligence Service, it's a big deal.
- 2:10:52That's that's the similar to be a one star. And then I retired as
- 2:10:54an SIS four, so that's the equivalent of a three or four star,
- 2:10:58but it doesn't mean anything. And ultimately it was just kind of a lot
- 2:11:01of headaches. And I remember when I got promoted to S. I asked
- 2:11:05one of my friends, said, well, you know, we're in the
- 2:11:07same class, and they said, you know, now we're going to get
- 2:11:09the secrets to the Kingdom, the keys to the Kingdom, And there was
- 2:11:11nothing there. You know, it's a thousand personnel problems, resource problems,
- 2:11:18and you know, if someone comes to me with an operational decision, something's
- 2:11:22gone really wrong because there's a billion people under me who should make those decisions.
- 2:11:26Now, sometimes that happened, but you want to let you know the
- 2:11:28leadership kind of model you should follow is like, you know, no one
- 2:11:35I should not be making these decisions and all brief me on what happened after
- 2:11:37the fact, for God's sakes, but not coming up there. So I
- 2:11:41don't know, you know, there's no glory in senior leadership. Sorry,
- 2:11:46my nice fancy title, but that's about it. I mean, obviously I'm
- 2:11:50being hypocritical because I certainly would use this since you know, in my public
- 2:11:54persona now. But my favorite times was as a street case officers at GS
- 2:11:58eleven or twelve, you know, on the streets of the Third world somewhere.
- 2:12:01That was really fun. I you know, I have nothing else except
- 2:12:05me and the agent I'm handling in a hostile counterintelligence service and you know,
- 2:12:09foreign intelligence information. To gather that stuff was was really fun. No other
- 2:12:15responsibilities. I want to be a kid again, That's what I'm saying.
- 2:12:18Yeah, yeah, well, I mean in about thirty years we will be
- 2:12:22so from Patreon from in, please let Mark that we're concerned for his health
- 2:12:31and hope he is well. That's very nice, that's very good. People
- 2:12:33have been so nice about kind of my health journey and so you know,
- 2:12:37I talked to Walter Read the other day, and you know, I was
- 2:12:41I was diagnosed with a traumatic brain injury obviously, you know, and it
- 2:12:46was based on some events that happened in Moscow in twenty seventeen. But when
- 2:12:50I talked to the docs at Walter Read and you know, this is the
- 2:12:52this is the leading TBI center on the planet, and I said, you
- 2:12:56know, it's it's six years later. I'm finally feeling better. And they
- 2:12:58said, yeah, TBI takes about five or six years. And I was
- 2:13:01like, you didn't fucking tell me that, and you know, and they
- 2:13:05said, we can't. Yeah, so if we tell you that, you
- 2:13:07know, and this is really serious, like people might you know, if
- 2:13:11you say you have a five year recovery, there's gonna be some bad stuff
- 2:13:15that happens with people are really suffering. And so I'm like, I'm really
- 2:13:18feeling better, thank you for all you did. And they said, well,
- 2:13:20you know that's that's you know, this is this is the kind of
- 2:13:22the timeline, the trajectory, and so I was I was both happy that
- 2:13:26I'm on the right path, but also I was like, holy crap.
- 2:13:28I mean, if you had told me you know in twenty eighteen or nineteen
- 2:13:33twenty nineteen, especially or eighteen when I was really struggling. You know,
- 2:13:35that's when you have some some serious kind of that's that's a danger zone right
- 2:13:41there. If you say, hey, don't worry about it three years,
- 2:13:41you'll feel better, Right, My head's gonna fucking explode every day, right
- 2:13:46And and you know, and you know, whatever happened to me doesn't matter
- 2:13:52as much as the notion that it was a TBI. And so like all
- 2:13:56everything, I experienced all the symptoms, you know, and when and I
- 2:14:00ultimately got a settlement from the from the agency. It was because uh,
- 2:14:05Walter reed, you know, did the following They said, yes, market
- 2:14:07a traumatic brain injury line of duty. Imaging shows it not a pre existing
- 2:14:11condition. This is what happened. I mean, they were so meticulous in
- 2:14:16documenting this, and so uh I got I got a lot of love for
- 2:14:20that place. I must say, those people save my life, no doubt.
- 2:14:24Yeah, Isaac, I've seen some of the footage from the festival massacre,
- 2:14:31and I'm aware of the terrible things that Hamas has done. But how
- 2:14:33is it even possible for all of that awfulness to be getting lost in all
- 2:14:39the noise, right, and so you know, that's that's the problem.
- 2:14:41That's the that's the age that we're in where you know, footage like that
- 2:14:46is talked about, comes out a little bit, but then people refute it,
- 2:14:48say it didn't happen. Right. You know, social media has been
- 2:14:52you know, social media is a great avenue to kind of disseminate you know,
- 2:14:56things to the masses in the world, but it's also so rife with
- 2:15:00disinformation and you have you know, you know, you know, hundreds thousands
- 2:15:05of people who actually don't believe that ten to seven happened, or actually say,
- 2:15:09you know, Hamas did not perpetrate those atrocities, and right, and
- 2:15:13and you know you can have this you know notion, you know, and
- 2:15:16I'm not saying positive or negative. Kind of the Elon Musk view of this
- 2:15:20is the kind of the what does he call it, the like the public
- 2:15:24square? The public Yeah, the public square, that's right, the public
- 2:15:28square. But the problem is there's no filter, right, and of course
- 2:15:31what can be a filter? Who says what's wet or what's wrong? But
- 2:15:33ultimately, you know, it is I think, you know, the the
- 2:15:39idea of pushing this out that kind of information out is is a good thing.
- 2:15:43Obviously the families made object to this. But yeah, so the disinformation,
- 2:15:48so I mean, this is a whole to a whole other show on
- 2:15:50this and you know, how does disinformation kind of play into everything we do?
- 2:15:54But you know, some people, I don't know if I'm ever going
- 2:15:58to be able to if you'd ever show that that that footage of ten seven
- 2:16:01to someone who's a Hama sympathizer, they won't believe it, right, I
- 2:16:05don't know. I mean, just you lost, They'll they'll they'll say it's
- 2:16:07all like deep fake. I mean, I don't know. And the thing
- 2:16:11is is that you know what what the counter agents do is they do create
- 2:16:16the deep fakes. They put them out there, and then they then they
- 2:16:22debunked them, and then they say, see the whole thing was fake.
- 2:16:26So that people discard everything that goes along with that. Yeah, it's it's
- 2:16:31it's crazy. So so one of the one of the things that was really
- 2:16:35interesting and my last job, we talked about Russian disinformation and information operations and
- 2:16:39and so so how the Russians would would put and and so the way to
- 2:16:43battle this just and this is not I'm not picking on Russia now, but
- 2:16:46you know, the truth is always the right thing to do, and so
- 2:16:50if you can you know, it's not you can't battle propaganda with propaganda.
- 2:16:56What you have to do is is if you see something thing is you know,
- 2:17:01is a deep fake, or it's kind of a Russian disinformation operation,
- 2:17:05or if it's the Chinese. The Chinese are endemic in this. The Chinese
- 2:17:09are kicking our butt at stuff like this. You know, if if we
- 2:17:11can kind of catch that in time and counter it with the truth. Uh,
- 2:17:16you know, and I remember when we would kind of brief members of
- 2:17:20Congress on our efforts on this, and they would say, well, we
- 2:17:22can't make up stuff about our adversary. Well we're not, which is if
- 2:17:26we tell the truth, if we expose what the other side is doing,
- 2:17:31that's going to be really effective. And so uh but but you know,
- 2:17:35when it comes to that kind of the Hamas Israel Hamas stuff, I mean,
- 2:17:37Israel is losing the information war, which is h which is unfortunate.
- 2:17:43M. Corbin, thank you very much. I wonder if the response we
- 2:17:46saw from the US public was partly from the algorithmic content grooming. An example
- 2:17:52of this is a present presenting content that is likely to be negative to keep
- 2:17:56the user engagement gone. I don't even know what that means, you know,
- 2:18:03just just like creating negative comment or content because the algorithm promotes uh posts
- 2:18:15and and content that is that has a lot of engagement. Oh that's right,
- 2:18:18Yeah, that's so. So if you create negative posts or I'm sorry,
- 2:18:22sorry, I apologize that that that that actually makes a lot of sense.
- 2:18:26I think I'm not smart enough on this, you know, in terms
- 2:18:28of the algorithms of of some of these whether it's whether it's you know,
- 2:18:31Twitter or Facebook or things like that. But it's clear, and so so
- 2:18:35I apologize to that because the to the to the person who wrote that in
- 2:18:37actually makes a lot of sense. So one of the things you look at
- 2:18:41is the algorithms for that. I've heard people talking about the algorithms for for
- 2:18:48TikTok, and so you know it's so kind of wildly biased, uh you
- 2:18:52know, kind of uh in a certain way. I mean it was god,
- 2:18:58I don't know what what entity put out. You know that there was
- 2:19:00kind of this kind of pro hamas pro Palestinian content was like eighty seven percent
- 2:19:05of the algorithm you know, with something like that. So I again,
- 2:19:07this is this is you know, how do you how do you regulate social
- 2:19:11media platforms? I don't know. This is getting into areas where there's issues
- 2:19:15of free speech and it's it's super complicated. And you know, the weird
- 2:19:18thing is that you know, there's all sorts of different political kind of this
- 2:19:22is this is across the political divide, or or you have weird bedfellows on
- 2:19:26this with kind of the hard left and the hard right sometimes agreeing on this.
- 2:19:31I don't know, tough one do you for the people that you know
- 2:19:35in Israel? Is Israel right now looking at these because we're seeing this a
- 2:19:41lot out of IVY leagues, right We're seeing a lot of these protests out
- 2:19:45of IVY leagues, and IVY leagues lead to a lot a lot of times
- 2:19:48to government positions to you know, they had that pipeline. Does Israel see
- 2:19:54sort of the this current trend in America colleges as a threat to their future
- 2:20:00in fifty and fifty years or twenty years, you know, I mean,
- 2:20:05I think that it's just been a lot of surprise at some of these elite
- 2:20:07universities. I mean, you know, one of the things that you know,
- 2:20:09the everyone wants their kids to go to kind of the best schools.
- 2:20:13All of a sudden, some of these best schools are not a place where
- 2:20:16it kind of, you know, American Jews can feel comfortable. I think
- 2:20:18that's you know, my friends, you know, kind of the Jewish community
- 2:20:22or sending their kids the IVY leagues are horrified. That's what I But that's
- 2:20:26where you want to send your kids in terms of kind of making it in
- 2:20:30America. But I think that, you know, the Again, when I
- 2:20:33talk to the Israeli embassy officials the other day, I said to them,
- 2:20:37I said, take this video to the IVY League campuses. And they said,
- 2:20:39we're thinking about it. And I said, that's the right thing to
- 2:20:43do. Again understanding the sensitivities of the families. But you know, you
- 2:20:48got to kind and I wouldn't blame it only on the IVY leagues. I
- 2:20:50think it's endemic all over college camps and maybe not the SEC. I don't
- 2:20:54know, maybe not down south. But but again, a buddy of mine
- 2:20:58was at the Olabama game and there was you know, students running around with
- 2:21:01kind of free Palestine flags down and so. But but I think that it's
- 2:21:07just a matter of kind of pushing this message out. And look there,
- 2:21:11what's the old something to get this totally wrong? It's the use of talking
- 2:21:15in the old statement by Churchill. If you're not you know, if you're
- 2:21:16not a liberal when you're young, you have no heart, and if you're
- 2:21:20not a conservative when you're old, you have no brain. Like you know,
- 2:21:22college kids, like young people can be stupid. That's okay, Like
- 2:21:26you know, youngsters are going to be dumb. I was, Uh,
- 2:21:30But ultimately I think that, you know, we do have to kind of
- 2:21:33put the truth out as best as possible, and and uh, there is
- 2:21:37there is a lot to be said for uh that that testimony of the university
- 2:21:43presidents the other day from m I t from Penn and from Harvard, because
- 2:21:46I think that is indicative of kind of some of the things that have gone
- 2:21:48wrong in American academia. When I went to college, you know, I
- 2:21:52I you know, so I truth be told. I got to admit it
- 2:21:56here I get vilified by I went to Cornallis and Ivy League School. But
- 2:22:00you know, there were there I had professors who were very conservative and a
- 2:22:03professors who were liberal, and there really was more of a notion of free
- 2:22:05speech. And my friends there from Cornell, some of them who are listening
- 2:22:11here, you know, my Jewish friends, uh who some of those their
- 2:22:15kids actually go to Cornell are horrified and what's happened and they can't believe it.
- 2:22:20And you know, I think, you know, there's there's certainly people
- 2:22:22who want to pull their you know, donations or you know, fun fundraising
- 2:22:26for the schools. But that's not the right answer. It's more of you
- 2:22:28know what is So I actually blame this dave on the professors. I don't
- 2:22:33know what's happened, you know. So so you know, when when when
- 2:22:37colleges hire professors, they got to hire both from the left of the right,
- 2:22:39they really do. I love that. I had an extremely conservative professor
- 2:22:43at Cornell, Jeremy Rapkin, famous kind of strict constitutionalists. I loved his
- 2:22:48class. I didn't agree with a lot of this stuff, but you got
- 2:22:52to learn both sides. I want to I want to read Karl Marx and
- 2:22:54I want to read Ann Rand and let's talk about it. But but I
- 2:23:00think that that American academia somehow has drifted so far to the left, and
- 2:23:03you know, I'm a centrist, so you know, I'm not. I
- 2:23:05come at this from a kind of a very moderate angle, but I think
- 2:23:09that that when it comes down to it, it's the it's it's you know,
- 2:23:13professors are going to influence the students, simple as that. Sorry,
- 2:23:18we uh. Our church upstairs seems to be going out a pattern and starting
- 2:23:24up on a Friday night. So if you hear that, yeah, I've
- 2:23:26already sent them a text mentioned them out already. I just want to say,
- 2:23:30yeah, what are they doing? Bro? They fucking rock, dude.
- 2:23:33It's like they play on their drums, they have their speakers on the
- 2:23:37floor and they like it's like like shaking. It's like being in a club
- 2:23:43a church. Yeah to Ethiopian Evangelical church. No, I hate it.
- 2:23:48I hate it. Like you go do it somewhere else. We're not Friday
- 2:23:52night above us almost. Thank you very much for the donation. We appreciate
- 2:23:56it. And Corbyn, thank you very much. You good and Mark that's
- 2:24:01it, man, thanks so much for joining us tonight. That was great.
- 2:24:05I love coming on. You guys are awesome. I hope the listeners
- 2:24:07enjoyed kind of a grand tour of the Middle East and Russia and their usual
- 2:24:13kind of banter. But love coming on here and give jack shit. He's
- 2:24:16avoiding me. He is avoiding me. I am now officially suspicious again.
- 2:24:22Like I said, he's playing hard to get to get you to our Christmas
- 2:24:24party. Right, I'll be in the Bahamas. I'm perfect. Perfect,
- 2:24:30Thanks guys, Thanks Mark,