Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The $3 Trillion Market Bitcoin Just Cracked Open
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:29which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for
- 0:40reducing. The role of gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 0:46is a reliable E cash. All righty everyone, welcome
- 0:53back to another episode of Final settlement.
- 0:55Today is Monday, March 9th, 11:36 AM Eastern Standard Time
- 1:00and we've got a big show today. Great show.
- 1:02I'm joined as always by Liam Nelson and we've got a very
- 1:04special guest Mauricio de Bartholomew.
- 1:07Hopefully I'm not uttering your last name knows as best as I
- 1:10could do, but Co founder and CSO of leaden going to be a really
- 1:15interesting conversation. Really excited for this one for
- 1:17a number of reasons, but let in, you know, has been around for a
- 1:21while, which not many Bitcoin lenders can say effectively.
- 1:25You know, the the firm was founded in 2018, I believe, and
- 1:28you were there from the beginning as Co founder.
- 1:31And so you guys have seen multiple cycles and you know,
- 1:35frankly, one of the only lenders to survive sort of the last
- 1:38biggest blow up in 2022. And so that really speaks to to,
- 1:43you know, the firm that you guys have built and we'll get into
- 1:47all of that. We'll get into some of the
- 1:49latest developments on your side in the ABS market, an investment
- 1:53from Tether and we'll get more into your background
- 1:56specifically. But maybe Mauricio, a good place
- 1:58to start. It's sort of just a high level
- 2:01like state of the market. As I mentioned, you know,
- 2:04Bitcoin is gone through multiple cycles where leverage has been a
- 2:07component of that cyclical behavior, to be honest.
- 2:11And so I would like to get your view of kind of where we are in
- 2:14terms of leverage. Are we over leveraged, under
- 2:18leveraged? Was October of last year a major
- 2:21washout moment? Are we still seeing some of that
- 2:24right now? Curious your thoughts on sort of
- 2:26the state of the lending market as as we sit here today?
- 2:30Yeah, thanks for having me. Thank you, Brian.
- 2:32Thank you, Liam and happy to channel things letting all
- 2:36things Bitcoin and all things credit.
- 2:38So to start, I guess to answer your first question on where
- 2:42we're at in the, you know, what's what stage of the
- 2:47evolution are we in for Bitcoin back loans?
- 2:49I would say that when when Bitcoin back loans first
- 2:53started, when we first offered Bitcoin back loans back in 2018,
- 2:56it was Bitcoin back loans for, you know, we're kind of at on
- 3:01par with crypto back loans, right?
- 3:03They were all looked at as these very sort of speculative
- 3:07instruments. But from the very big, from the
- 3:10very beginning, we had let it took a view that Bitcoin was the
- 3:16digital collateral. Everything else was just a
- 3:20gambling token. Frankly that hadn't really
- 3:23proven itself for as collateral. We believe that Bitcoin was
- 3:28different and that's what let it from day one has been a Bitcoin
- 3:31company, right? And a lot of the success that
- 3:36Lenin is having today is having some of those early views that
- 3:40we held back in 2018 validated by the market.
- 3:43Lenin has never pivoted that we've always been Bitcoin back
- 3:46lenders. It's just that right now the
- 3:49world has really sort of woken up to this idea that Bitcoin
- 3:53back lending is a loan and an instrument that you can use to
- 3:58buy a house, to start a business, to fund expenses, grow
- 4:02your family. This isn't this, this isn't the
- 4:06case for most other assets. And I think what you saw from,
- 4:11you know, really in 20/20/25 was a complete bifurcation between
- 4:16Bitcoin back loans and everything else, right?
- 4:19Like, and, and so today what I'm seeing in the market is that
- 4:23Bitcoin back loans are being used very responsibly, right?
- 4:28What I'm what do I mean by that? These products came out to the
- 4:33market in 2018. In the early days, a lot of
- 4:35people had never used a collateralized loan before.
- 4:39They didn't know about margin calls or liquidations or how to
- 4:43protect yourself against a loan, right?
- 4:45They didn't know how to assess risk.
- 4:46They didn't know how to ask for proof of reserves.
- 4:48They didn't know how to look for a for a try to assess where a
- 4:53lender's funding was coming from and understanding how the model
- 4:56works, right. And I think that's come a long
- 5:00way today. If you look at the firms that
- 5:03are offering Bitcoin by globes today, many of them are much
- 5:07more responsible versions of the previous iterations, right?
- 5:10Like if you look at the block price of the world and the
- 5:12Celsius of the world, these are companies that had their own
- 5:14tokens. They were supporting all sorts
- 5:16of things as collateral. They were offering yield on
- 5:19Bitcoin, they were offering yield on all sorts of assets,
- 5:22and that's really where the problems came from, from
- 5:25rehypothecation from taking collateral that had no depth.
- 5:29Why would you want to borrow against basic attention token?
- 5:32Like where's the bid on that? When when the market goes S, but
- 5:35there is no bid. That's what we learned, right.
- 5:38And so what's happening today is just I think what you're what
- 5:42I'm seeing at least is Bitcoin backed loans are understood.
- 5:47OK, when people come into it. No longer there are people
- 5:50asking what is an LTV, right? Like people are saying, OK, I'm
- 5:55starting on my loan. I see that if I take that loan
- 5:57now, I'll have to add more Bitcoin at these levels.
- 6:00What's the speed? What are the timelines to add
- 6:02more big? So the questions are a lot more
- 6:03sophisticated. People understand the product.
- 6:06This is why you're seeing a lot less liquidations and a relative
- 6:09level on down moves like what we're having so far in February,
- 6:14right? I'll give you a very interesting
- 6:16point that was highlighted through the Galaxy Q4 report
- 6:19that came out last week. Since October of last year, the
- 6:24like there was a narrative being built last year.
- 6:27I don't want to say built or pushed.
- 6:28It was just sort of a narrative that was bubbling, which was
- 6:32this idea that D5 worked and C5 didn't and therefore D5 is going
- 6:38to take over the world and C5 is done.
- 6:41And we're seeing now in the Q4 report that is absolutely far
- 6:45from the case, right? Like the October 10th collapses
- 6:48and D5 like basically dismantled the D5 book to the tune of 27%,
- 6:54right? They had never recovered.
- 6:55And now all of a sudden C5 is as big as D5, right?
- 7:00Like back on in the Galaxy report, like again, just this,
- 7:03this is not a, it's probably one of the best reports out there
- 7:05from an industry perspective, but it's still incomplete in
- 7:07that there's people that don't participate in it, right?
- 7:10But what this is showing to me at least, is that D5, as I
- 7:17understand it, has a lot more other stuff in it.
- 7:20Bitcoiners don't use D5 because there's no native way for
- 7:22Bitcoin to use D5. For you to wrap Bitcoin and
- 7:25throw it into one of these protocols, you have to take
- 7:27wrapping risk. You have to take basically
- 7:30custody risk, wrapping risk, smart contrite risk, a myriad of
- 7:33other risks that are not really there if you're doing
- 7:36centralized lending with Bitcoin.
- 7:38So what I would say just, you know, kind of bringing, bringing
- 7:41it back full circle is that I think Bitcoin Back Loans has
- 7:46demonstrated its validity as a product that can be used
- 7:50responsibly both from a user perspective as in people that
- 7:54have using our products since 2018 have done well financially.
- 7:57This is why Leaden is here today because of Bitcoin Back Loans
- 8:00have worked. If our product wasn't helping
- 8:02our clients build wealth or make money, we wouldn't be growing,
- 8:05we would be here, right? And we just had the best year in
- 8:09the history of our business last year.
- 8:10We're off to probably a better one this year so far.
- 8:14The others, and that's on the user side.
- 8:16Now what about the capital side? How's the capital side feeling
- 8:18about this? Well, Lenin just completed the
- 8:21first ABS Bitcoin bond ever 2 times oversubscribed, rated
- 8:28investment grade by S&P. And again, I reemphasize this
- 8:32two times oversubscribed in a down market.
- 8:35OK, So investors love it, consumers love it.
- 8:40And I think that's kind of where we're at for Bitcoin back lows.
- 8:43I think This is why so many people are so excited about this
- 8:45product. Yeah, No, thanks for thanks for
- 8:49walking through that. I think it's a fantastic
- 8:51overview of where we're at. And I love the distinction of,
- 8:54you know, Bitcoin versus everything else.
- 8:56I mean that's something that we talk a lot about on this show.
- 8:58And just in general with clients and prospects.
- 9:01You know, I think it's it, it's slow and it takes time, but I
- 9:04think there is that continued recognition that Bitcoin is just
- 9:08fundamentally different than all these other tokens in crypto
- 9:10assets. And that becomes very apparent
- 9:13in wash out moments like this where you mentioned these low
- 9:18float tokens have absolutely zero bid when things go South.
- 9:23And so I think that's a very important distinction that
- 9:25obviously as a firm you guys have recognized for a long time.
- 9:27So kudos on that. Liam, was there anything else
- 9:30you wanted to pull out from this Galaxy report that we that we
- 9:33pulled up here and that Mauricio mentioned anything worth calling
- 9:37out here? The other thing I did want to
- 9:38talk about that we mentioned was just block fills and the
- 9:44incident there. And if you had any thoughts on
- 9:47the perception of that sort of maybe the realities of what's
- 9:49going on there, is that an isolated incident or are there
- 9:53is that a sign of of more things to come perhaps?
- 9:57Yeah. So great question.
- 9:59And I think that the way I like to think about using
- 10:04collateralized loans in Bitcoin is that there's two major bucket
- 10:10like risks. A bucket number one is
- 10:13counterparty risk and the second one is liquidation risk, right?
- 10:17Those are broadly the two things that can go wrong if you're
- 10:20using a, a, a, a product like this, right?
- 10:24For a while, if you know, in in in the early days, 2018 to 2021,
- 10:30because the industry was basically just being born,
- 10:33people have very little sense of this concept of platform risk.
- 10:39Every platform look really safe. They look great.
- 10:41They had great logos. They were shaking the hands of
- 10:43all these great investors, right.
- 10:45And all of a sudden you realize, you know, in in March 14th or
- 10:51not that was that was the COVID crash.
- 10:53But back when, when Terra Luna collapsed and FDX collapse,
- 10:55collapse thereafter, you had basically Celsius go under block
- 10:59fight, go under Genesis, Voyager, Babel, so on, so forth.
- 11:05And it became very evident that platform risk, if you, if you're
- 11:09working with a platform that is not doing things right, you can
- 11:13lose your Bitcoin, right. And from 2022 to 2025, I would
- 11:20say this was a huge point. And then many people ask letting
- 11:24how did you survive? What did you do differently?
- 11:26And we answered the question in the same way we would today.
- 11:29We don't rehypothecate your Bitcoin.
- 11:31We keep your Bitcoin in custody. That's why it's always there
- 11:35when you repay the loan. And that's what anybody can
- 11:36repay their loans and get their Bitcoin back at any time, right?
- 11:40We don't offer Bitcoin yield, right?
- 11:42There's no risk of loss because we're not lending that Bitcoin
- 11:44unsecured, right? We were the first company to do
- 11:47proof of reserves. None of the firms that went
- 11:49under had proof of reserves, right?
- 11:51So this idea of how to assess counterparty risk was a very big
- 11:56topic of discussion for anybody wanting to take a loan in 2023
- 11:59and 2024 and part of 2025, right?
- 12:03What happened in 2025 was the market reached a new all time
- 12:06high and when people start looking up, all of a sudden all
- 12:10those short memory, like basically you start getting this
- 12:12short memory effect where all of a sudden nobody cares about
- 12:15platform risk anymore. Everybody just wants the best
- 12:18rate. And because companies like
- 12:20Lennon are thriving and growing, you have other companies throw
- 12:24like literally build Bitcoin back loan products overnight and
- 12:28throw them into the market to try to capture market share.
- 12:31And they will try to force feed that product into the market by
- 12:34offering off market rates and terms and an effort to beat out
- 12:40companies like Lenin that have an 8 year track record, proof of
- 12:42reserves, the most competitive rates in the market.
- 12:45The, the, you know, the, the, the, it's really hard really to
- 12:49put out a product that is more compelling than Lenin.
- 12:52But the way they try to do so is by creating artificially low
- 12:55interest rates and building things that are completely, I
- 13:01would argue in many cases misrepresented and say things
- 13:06like auto protection from liquidation.
- 13:08These loans don't get liquidated at these loans have this magic
- 13:11fairy dust that allows us not to have to liquidate you and guess
- 13:15what the paid you don't have to pay us anything for that hedge.
- 13:17It's also included in the price. Those these are ridiculous
- 13:20ideas. And lo and behold, if the terms
- 13:24are too good to be true, they will fail, right.
- 13:27And so we just had a recent example of a firm block fails
- 13:31that did offer some Bitcoin back loans.
- 13:32And I believe they had also a feature where you wouldn't get
- 13:35liquidated because of some hedging that clearly turned out
- 13:39too good to be true. So what I would say is I don't
- 13:43think this will be the last firm.
- 13:45I'm not trying to suggest that there's like massive contagion
- 13:48and that the next firm is, you know, pending lead to go down.
- 13:51I think these are the natural consequences of irresponsible
- 13:57actors competing in a competitive space, right?
- 14:00And that's just why it's so important and so many people
- 14:04choose let in because we've been around for eight years doing
- 14:07right by our clients every single time.
- 14:09And what you're coming to let in, what you see is what you
- 14:12get. We're transparent about our
- 14:13rates. We're transparent about how we
- 14:15like, how we source our funding. We're transparent about where
- 14:17your Bitcoin sits. Lenin is as transparent as you
- 14:20possibly can be in this industry.
- 14:22And I would be very, very skeptical of any offering that
- 14:28seems too good to be true because 99 times out of 100,
- 14:32they have turned out too good to be true.
- 14:34And you're trying to save a penny, but you're losing your
- 14:36Bitcoin. At Lenin, we optimize for you
- 14:40keeping your Bitcoin. That is it.
- 14:43Are there cheaper ways for us to source capital that we could
- 14:46source if we were willing to work with groups that don't
- 14:49share financial statements? Yes, of course we could find
- 14:53cheaper money. But we don't because the groups
- 14:55that we have standards when we interact with anybody and if you
- 15:00cannot meet those standards, we will not work with you.
- 15:03And if that means our rate has to be a little higher than
- 15:05someone else's, that's fine because we're here to give you
- 15:09back your Bitcoin and to ensure that your kids and their kids
- 15:13can hopefully continue using big comeback low as we let it.
- 15:17Yeah, that's a great point. And on the block fills point
- 15:20too. It's worth highlighting too that
- 15:23even if you don't necessarily have a loan out with a platform
- 15:26like this that could be rehypothecating their clients,
- 15:30Bitcoins who actually have loans out, you're even if you're just
- 15:34using them to trade like your Bitcoin could still
- 15:37theoretically be at risk because they have gated withdrawals for
- 15:41all clients at this point. So it's, it's definitely
- 15:44important to highlight that a lot of these businesses and
- 15:50there's short memory in the, you know, Bitcoin and, and broader
- 15:53digital assets industry where there are always net new
- 15:57entrants who are coming into this space, right?
- 15:59If you have a growing industry, you know, that's, that's what
- 16:02you expect and would hope for. And block fills is, is one that
- 16:07I think they were backed by like Susquehanna and and a bunch of
- 16:10other very big players who are grafting on some of their due
- 16:14diligence and processes that apply just to, you know, legacy
- 16:19financial assets, not necessarily Bitcoin itself till
- 16:23which is, you know, global 365 digital bearer asset and just
- 16:29requires a little bit of difference in the way that you
- 16:33both, you know, consider risk as a as a platform as a whole.
- 16:38So while while we've seen a ton of improvements and you know, a
- 16:44lot of this industry growing up, I think that, you know, at the
- 16:47same time, I wish I wasn't as cynical.
- 16:50But it seems like we're going to continue to see a lot of net new
- 16:53players who are backed by existing large financial
- 16:57institution players that are just going to try to graft on
- 16:59their existing risk frameworks and think that, you know, other
- 17:03players who have been in the Bitcoin space for a longer time
- 17:05are being too conservative and they're missing out on extra
- 17:08revenue till. So it was, it was kind of just
- 17:11curious like your thoughts in general of, you know, why
- 17:14Bitcoin is different than some other legacy assets and and why
- 17:17it deserves to be treated differently too.
- 17:20Yeah. And listen, I think we'll get
- 17:22into this when we talk about the ABS.
- 17:24But a big part of what allowed us to do the ABS is the idea
- 17:27that Lenin has uniform collateral.
- 17:29Our book has all the same collateral and and it has size
- 17:34and scale with that uniformity, right?
- 17:36What you have with other players is at times they'll have a part
- 17:39of their book that's backed by ETH and another part that's
- 17:41backed by Sluna and another part that's backed by Doge.
- 17:44And so when you're trying to put a smorks board of undesired
- 17:47assets into a pool, it creates a lot more questions than what
- 17:52hey, do you just take Bitcoin and the to the point you just
- 17:56made Liam, about other products and services offered by these
- 17:59platforms. That is in fact the big point
- 18:02that not everybody got, you know, not everybody I think
- 18:06fully fully distills about the previous collapses of block
- 18:09fight and Celsius and others. So I'd like if these companies
- 18:12have been taking Bitcoin or even ETH and keeping it safely in
- 18:16custody and lending you dollars by back by it and then giving
- 18:20you back that E for that Bitcoin when you repaid those dollars.
- 18:23You could do that pretty responsibly, right?
- 18:25Like that. There's a path and a way of
- 18:27doing So what what what starts messing things up is you do
- 18:32that, but then somebody else comes to you and says, Hey, I
- 18:34want to earn yield on my Bitcoin.
- 18:36Oh, but to generate the yield, not Bitcoin, you have to lend
- 18:38that Bitcoin unsecured to a third party.
- 18:41Well, if those two products are offered by the same legal entity
- 18:45and you wonder wrote the loan and the person you lend the
- 18:48Bitcoin to this went under, then the loan guy is also under and
- 18:52the yield guy is under and the trade guy is under and everyone
- 18:55in the in the boat is under, right.
- 18:57And even back then, companies, banks today don't operate this
- 19:02way. Banks today, if you're dealing
- 19:04with their trading arm, you'll see that the legal agreements
- 19:06say so and so trading comma Inc, you know, legal entity, right.
- 19:09If you're doing the custody, they'll give you your services
- 19:11are being provided by so and so and so and so and so and so that
- 19:14ring fencing, even that ring fencing didn't exist back of
- 19:19Bitcoin. So that's why it was like, if
- 19:21you think about a boat, an analogy of a boat, you can be a
- 19:23massive boat, but if the boat doesn't have compartments
- 19:26underneath, you can just perforate the top of the boat
- 19:29and everyone in the back of the boat is going to sink just as
- 19:32deep as everyone else, right. And so in traditional finance,
- 19:36and again, you know, letting operates in, in a, in a, in a
- 19:41sort of letting operates in a bridge between Bitcoin and
- 19:44traditional finance because we need to source capital from
- 19:47traditional finance and we need to deploy like capital to
- 19:49Bitcoiners. So we need to be able to speak
- 19:50to both, right? And so how do we ensure we're
- 19:54speaking to traditional finance? Well, we're we offer proof of
- 19:57reserves before nobody else did. We actually pioneer prefer
- 20:00reserves for lending business, right?
- 20:02We are stock 2 type 2 compliant. We are a regulated, we have a
- 20:05regulated entity and came out, we have a regulated entity in
- 20:08Spain. We're going through a lending
- 20:09license in the US We have a full compliance team.
- 20:12Everything's KYC. So we've built the business in
- 20:17this way trying to deliver all of the sort of assurances and
- 20:22procedural guarantees that have been learned through hundreds of
- 20:25years in lending and, and and Tratify.
- 20:27This is why we were able to get rated by S&P, right?
- 20:31Where I figure we're, I think we're one of the few companies
- 20:34that could ever even try to do this.
- 20:37But to your point, Liam, it's like so many lessons around risk
- 20:41management have been learned in traditional finance that
- 20:44shouldn't just be discarded and forgotten just because we're
- 20:46trying to build something in the digital world, right?
- 20:48Like our job is to bring those learnings at our transparency
- 20:53and efficiency and make them better.
- 20:55But we're not going to, we're not going to do ourselves any
- 20:58favors if we're just forcing ourselves to relearn the same
- 21:00lessons not everybody learned back in the heyday, right?
- 21:05Yeah, absolutely. I love all of that.
- 21:07And and one thing you noted in there that I think is, is worth
- 21:11calling out is like there is almost this, there's a perverse
- 21:14incentive for other players to come in and basically try to
- 21:19undercut you with a worse product in terms of the rate,
- 21:22right? Because that's very attractive
- 21:23to the average retail participant who's not thinking
- 21:27super critically about, well, what is counterparty risk
- 21:30actually mean? Are they rehypothecating it?
- 21:32You know, they probably haven't even gone down that path of
- 21:34thinking through those those levels of risks.
- 21:37And we see very similar things on the custody side.
- 21:40You know, our our business at on ramp is focused on Bitcoin
- 21:43custody. We do something called multi
- 21:45institution custody, which leverages multi sig and
- 21:47distributes keys across multiple independent institutions.
- 21:50And you know, it's very similar in the sense that, you know, if
- 21:54someone is holding coins on Coinbase, they think they're
- 21:57paying nothing for custody, right?
- 21:59But it's like you're actually paying for that tail risk that
- 22:01something catastrophic goes wrong and you have a single
- 22:04entity failure and your allocation maybe goes to 0.
- 22:07So maybe you're actually paying 100% of your pick coin.
- 22:09And it's very similar dynamic in lending markets where, you know,
- 22:14sort of being too focused on a one or two, one to 3% difference
- 22:20in an interest rate. It's like, well, what's behind
- 22:22that? Why is it a little bit higher?
- 22:24What is the pool of capital that's supporting it?
- 22:26What is the custody setup look like?
- 22:28All those things are super critical to the actual risk of
- 22:31the underlying going to 0, not just the, the, the interest rate
- 22:34you're paying. So I think that that's super
- 22:36important and glad you, you called that out as, as something
- 22:39that I think that's what takes us to a more mature place is
- 22:42people recognizing those things. And, and how we get there is, is
- 22:46folks like yourselves being super transparent about those
- 22:48risks and, and explaining in very clear terms why you're
- 22:52doing the things the way you're doing them, why your rates are
- 22:54what they are, all those types of things.
- 22:59Appreciate it man. It's a no, no.
- 23:01I mean, this is, this is a, you know, it's funny because when we
- 23:05first started this business, taking this approach was
- 23:09perceived by some to be incredibly boring, incredibly
- 23:15conservative, not exciting enough.
- 23:20And it's, it's, it's been fascinating to see that, you
- 23:25know, after a period of time of that view was getting challenged
- 23:28and challenged and challenged. Now all of a sudden it is the
- 23:32view that seems to be able to scale, right, because who's
- 23:37coming in today in size and deploying all these new
- 23:40investments, ironically, not ironically, I think a lot of us
- 23:42expected this, but they are institutions, right?
- 23:45Like you know which, who are the names that we got we got excited
- 23:49about now so and so is the BlackRock CTF and Wisdom Tree
- 23:52CTF and so and so is ETF and Michael's buying a few me a
- 23:55billion more like these are the names and numbers that make this
- 23:58market move now. And the kind of things that
- 24:03these investors value is precisely what we've been
- 24:07building for eight years while being perceived as potentially
- 24:10boring, right. When you took a view back then
- 24:13that no, most of the stuff is speculation.
- 24:16I think this all comes back to Bitcoin eventually, but you're
- 24:19going to lose so much money on the way.
- 24:21How come you're not going to list all these other hundreds of
- 24:24thousands of tokens and you're missing out on all these trading
- 24:26fees? It's like, no, because if you
- 24:28get distracted by those things, you may lose sight of the actual
- 24:31prize, right? Which is exactly what happened
- 24:33to all these other lenders. Like Lenin was under the shadows
- 24:38of these dodgy giants, OK? Like, you know, block fire was
- 24:4210 times bigger than that. And Celsius was five times
- 24:45bigger than Lenin back when they were existed when they existed.
- 24:48Today we're the biggest lending company in the market, right?
- 24:51In the Bitcoin back loans and consumer Bitcoin back loans,
- 24:55that is because we never veered, we never strayed from our path.
- 24:58So many people came asking us, oh, block Fi is Celsius is doing
- 25:031% loan guys. Why can't let him do 1% Bitcoin
- 25:08back loans And we said we because our cost of capital is
- 25:129. Like there's there's no way we
- 25:16can keep your Bitcoin safe and give you this dollar.
- 25:17It's one ask them how they're doing it, but many people didn't
- 25:23ask the question They just no, we could have we could have said
- 25:27Oh no, we have to get into the business of 1% Bitcoin back
- 25:29close. We're going to start
- 25:30rehypothecating and let's re lend the living lights out of
- 25:33the Bitcoin find a cheaper provider.
- 25:35Let's make this happen guys. No, no, that that is not the
- 25:40mission, OK? The mission is to keep your
- 25:42Bitcoin safe and to lend you and to tell you what the money cost
- 25:46and to charge you a small spread on it so that it makes sense for
- 25:49let and I can keep my lights on organically and then the
- 25:51business will scale right? Because if I don't do that if I
- 25:54do anything except for that even if I win, I lost.
- 25:59Does that make sense? Because at best I have a book of
- 26:03speculative loans that nobody wants and they're priced
- 26:05completely bonkers. Like there's, there's no market
- 26:08for these loans. Or I, I had to liquidate a token
- 26:12that didn't have a bid and the business went under.
- 26:15And so to, to us, it was always about, no, there's no, there's
- 26:19no shortcuts to this. We have to basically prove the
- 26:23model is the model and why it is this way and wait to people
- 26:28don't to realize that this is it.
- 26:31Now we, we we don't, we don't have a crystal ball.
- 26:33We didn't know all these guys were going to disintegrate in a
- 26:37sort of nuclear catastrophe one day because Sam, but that's what
- 26:41happened. And we were there to pick up the
- 26:42pieces and we've been there to rebuild the the the sort of
- 26:45market on the foundation that you should use preferred
- 26:49reserves. You should not be re lending
- 26:50collateral. You should be telling people
- 26:52where you get your funding from and how much it costs so that
- 26:55they know that the model is organic.
- 26:58Those things I know you know, are exciting today, but back
- 27:02then everybody was like, Glenn, what are you doing?
- 27:04And today we're very proud to say we're still the same people
- 27:09we were back in 2018. We just have a whole lot more
- 27:13experience under our belt, a lot more now capital and and and the
- 27:17size to start doing a lot more exciting things like going into
- 27:19the ABS market. Yeah, that's awesome.
- 27:23And and we'll get to the ABS stuff, but maybe this is a good
- 27:26spot to zoom out a little bit and go back to 2018 and maybe
- 27:29even before that. In terms of your your specific
- 27:31background. Mauricio, I'm curious how you
- 27:34interested got interested in Bitcoin initially and then maybe
- 27:37it would be good to hear some just early, you know, how the
- 27:41how the firm was created in 2018, what the mission was then.
- 27:44And to your point, like how it's evolved, but sort of, you know,
- 27:47stayed on the same mission, but those learnings over the past
- 27:50eight years, how that's developed and then we'll get to
- 27:52the the ABS stuff and some other news and developments.
- 27:55For sure. So I'm, I was born and raised in
- 27:58Venezuela. And so my family, you know, we
- 28:01all grew up in Venezuela. And I, as Venezuela started
- 28:06falling apart when Chavismo came in.
- 28:09You know, I was 15 when Chavez took office for the first time
- 28:11and saw the country basically fall apart gradually.
- 28:17Then suddenly and I, I witnessed basically expropriations of
- 28:22private property on TV, my dad shutting down his factory, my
- 28:25friends closing down their factories and leaving.
- 28:29I was there at the protests after Chavez died and they stole
- 28:33the election through the Maduro regime.
- 28:35I was, I was throwing rocks at the protests and I know I was
- 28:39there with everyone else. And that day was the first time
- 28:47that I remember hearing real, real shots, real bullets shot at
- 28:52the protesters, which who I was with.
- 28:54And some people, one guy I knew in particular got shot and
- 28:57killed that day. And I went home that night
- 29:01because a lot of us wanted to keep protesting me and my
- 29:03brother. But my mom basically said, my
- 29:07mom and my wife sat me down that night and they said, there's you
- 29:11have nothing to gain and everything to lose by staying
- 29:13here. You've the only, you're the only
- 29:15member of our family that has a semblance of a life outside of
- 29:19this country. You know, we believe it would be
- 29:23a much better use of your skills and time if you went back out
- 29:28and continue building a life out there so that you can pull us
- 29:31out from this mess if this thing falls apart.
- 29:33And I, I went back and that was 2014.
- 29:38And that, that election is what started the sort of mass
- 29:41migration you see in Venezuela today in hyperinflation, because
- 29:44it basically it, it was sort of a done deal that the country had
- 29:47been taken over by these cronies.
- 29:49And hyperinflation, that's where hyperinflation starts.
- 29:52And I'll do a little sidebar to highlight the difference between
- 29:55inflation and hyperinflation, because I think a lot of people
- 29:58consider those two things to be an extension of another.
- 30:01They're completely different phenomenons in my opinion.
- 30:05And an inflation is just a rational response to an increase
- 30:08in the money supply, right? In a, in a fixed state of
- 30:11assets, so you have 10 buildings and $10 million, you print
- 30:15another $10 million, the same 10 buildings, each building goes up
- 30:172X. That's, that's inflation, right?
- 30:19It's rational hyperinflation. There's no math.
- 30:25It's I have to leave. I don't believe anyone's going
- 30:29to, I don't believe these assets are worth anything.
- 30:32I am willing to take anything. I will do a market sell order
- 30:37without looking at the book, right?
- 30:40And I will get filled and whatever I get filled.
- 30:42That is hyperinflation. So you're basically fire selling
- 30:46your currency, you're fire selling your assets, you're fire
- 30:48selling your business. And it, it, it basically all
- 30:53sort of rational goes out the window.
- 30:56You know, you'll be, you'll be offered a cent, two cents on the
- 30:59dollar for something and you'll say, fine, I'll take it.
- 31:02That's hyperinflation. It's it's fear of not ever
- 31:06getting anything back for those assets.
- 31:08And so it's emotional. It's not rational.
- 31:12You're not thinking about price or percentages.
- 31:15You're just, you're getting out. So that's the environment that
- 31:19Venezuela's in, right? And my friends are all fire
- 31:22selling their stuff to get out of the country.
- 31:25In the middle of that, my youngest brother was graduating,
- 31:27my youngest brother Mario, and he didn't want to leave the
- 31:31country. So he pitches my dad on all
- 31:32these entrepreneurial ideas. And my dad says, no, no, no, you
- 31:36got to go. You got to go like your brother.
- 31:37You got to go so you can take us out.
- 31:38And my brother, my, my younger brother's more rebellious than
- 31:41me. And he basically reaches, goes
- 31:44to my dad with an ultimatum. And he says, Dad, I'm going to
- 31:47do this whether you want to or not, you can choose to support
- 31:49me. If you don't support me, I'm
- 31:50leaving the house. My dad sends me the e-mail.
- 31:53He's, he basically says, your brother's serious.
- 31:55What do you think? You went to school for finance?
- 31:57It's the Bitcoin white paper. My brother wanted to start
- 31:59mining Bitcoin in Venezuela with subsidized energy.
- 32:02So that's how my brother starts mining Bitcoin.
- 32:05All of a sudden he found a way of getting Bitcoin in the
- 32:08hyperinflationary country with very cheap energy.
- 32:12So he found a way of basically the only way of making good
- 32:16money in Venezuela that couldn't be taken away from the regime.
- 32:20My my middle brother starts mining, my parents start mining,
- 32:22my uncle start mining, my cousins start mining, my friends
- 32:25start mining, and I start building mines with them.
- 32:28Well, actually, first I approved the sort of project I approved
- 32:32there by reading the white paper.
- 32:33And I said, yeah, that this seems to be like the least
- 32:35insane idea. And so then I fly back to
- 32:39Venezuela six months later and I see this guy has double the
- 32:41machines and he's looking for places to rent.
- 32:44And I asked him to show me what he was doing.
- 32:47He took me into his facility. He sold Bitcoin for Bolivares at
- 32:52the fair market rate, which we can get into.
- 32:55It's a long conversation between what is a fair market rated and
- 32:57a hyperinflationary economy. You know, sneak peek or, or you
- 33:05know, it's not what the government says it is.
- 33:07That's basically the answer. But anyway, he sold it.
- 33:11And when I saw what he did, what Bitcoin did for my brother and
- 33:14what it did for others in Venezuela, I was instantly sold
- 33:17on Bitcoin as a tool. And I started basic trying to
- 33:21figure out what I could do with it.
- 33:22Everybody was mining. Everybody I knew was mining.
- 33:24They were making money off of it.
- 33:26So I start building a mine and I convinced my best friend from
- 33:28university, Adam Reeves, to build a mine in Canada where I
- 33:31was living. We have the same issue in Canada
- 33:34that we were having in every other mine, which is we have
- 33:36Bitcoin revenue, but we have Fiat expenses and selling the
- 33:40Bitcoin to pay for those expenses was the dumbest thing
- 33:42we could possibly do. Every single time it happened,
- 33:44we could never buy back the same amount of Bitcoin.
- 33:46So we went out and looked for a loan.
- 33:49We got laughed out of the room every single time.
- 33:52That's it. Like one of the, one of the
- 33:55favorite answers we got was Bitcoin's not an asset.
- 33:59Bitcoin's not an asset. Who would ever do that?
- 34:02And so we looked at each other after like the 5th or 6th sort
- 34:05of laughing out of the room and and we're like, we should do it.
- 34:09Like we'll do the loan, we'll serve our own problem.
- 34:12And so we put our hats together and we put a plan for letting we
- 34:16raise a little bit of money in 2018 and we set out to build a
- 34:21Bitcoin back loan in the most transparent, quote UN quote
- 34:24boring way you could possibly think of.
- 34:26Show me it's in custody. Show me it's safe.
- 34:29Give me a rate and you know, just give me back my Bitcoin
- 34:34when I pay you the loan. And so we did Canada's first go
- 34:38back Bitcoin back loan November 2nd, 2018 to Francis Puglio and
- 34:42Bill's shout out to Francis and and then the rest is history.
- 34:47It kind of snowballed from there.
- 34:48We we continue helping miners. The beginning was Bitcoin
- 34:52businesses, miners, mostly developers, people that got paid
- 34:54in Bitcoin and and then from there on it just snowballed into
- 35:00today the the sort of consumer product has has become right
- 35:03that our clients today are not just Bitcoin natives, they come
- 35:05from everywhere. I love that that's really
- 35:10appreciate you sharing that. That's a a fantastic story and
- 35:14really appreciate just like how far we've come overall as as an
- 35:19industry and you know, especially your family too.
- 35:22I guess like even it would be super helpful to understand like
- 35:26especially given that background what the recent ABS news really
- 35:30means for letting what it means for the industry as a whole.
- 35:34And just maybe share a little bit more details on what exactly
- 35:38the securitization of some of these loans actually means
- 35:43overall for some of the listeners who may not fully
- 35:46understand. Yeah.
- 35:48So let me kind of paint the picture around why this is such
- 35:52a big deal and, and why I believe it's going to be so
- 35:55transformative for the industry going forward.
- 35:58So if you look at what we do for for a living, like what let and
- 36:02does as a business is we source capital from people that have
- 36:06dollars and we lend that capital to people that have Bitcoin and
- 36:10don't want to sell it, right? So each lending product has two
- 36:13clients. There's the person providing the
- 36:16dollars and then there's a person borrowing the dollars.
- 36:18So any lending product that truly scales has to have a right
- 36:23balance between what's in it for the lender and what's in it for
- 36:27the borrower and protecting both, OK?
- 36:30And most importantly, you have to have a scalable source of
- 36:33those dollars and a scalable way of deploying those dollars,
- 36:36right? What's historically and I think
- 36:40if you ask any Bitcoiner this over the last 5-6 years, most
- 36:45people increasingly so today will tell you I will never sell
- 36:49my Bitcoin. Bitcoin is like, I don't want to
- 36:51sell my Bitcoin. It's a great collateral asset.
- 36:53Bitcoin is collateral, right? So the demand side has been
- 36:57proven check, right, like people don't want to sell the Bitcoin,
- 37:00right? The supply side, if you look at
- 37:02who's been lending dollars to this industry, by and large, it
- 37:07has been up until now, crypto native firms or companies.
- 37:12So these would be groups that have very large balance sheets
- 37:15that are still in the crypto space that want to deploy cash
- 37:18because they understand the risk reward and because they just,
- 37:22you know, want to support the the industry.
- 37:24And I think it's a great risk return, right?
- 37:27So historically, who has been providing this capital is crypto
- 37:31native balance sheets, right? So in the era of Genesis,
- 37:34Genesis was a big liquidity provider today and they are of
- 37:38Tether and other stable coins. You have, you know, a Tether as
- 37:41one of a big institutional lender.
- 37:43You have a lot of these foundations that raise large,
- 37:47large amounts of stable coins, dump them right back into D5
- 37:50pools. And that's really where a lot of
- 37:52the liquidity comes from. This release crypto native
- 37:55balance sheet. If you round all up those
- 37:57balance sheets and add them all up, you get a number that's
- 37:59somewhere in the billions. OK, and that's fine.
- 38:02That's not a small number, but Bitcoin is a roughly $2 trillion
- 38:06asset going on. We believe it's going to get to
- 38:09$5 trillion in the next two to five years, OK.
- 38:12I believe or we believe that the Bitcoin back loan market is
- 38:15going to grow into the trillions, right?
- 38:18So you need to have line of sight into a pool of liquidity
- 38:22that is that that deep that you can source from the ABS market
- 38:29and ABS asset backed securities. So the ABS market in the United
- 38:33States alone is estimated between 2.5 to $3 trillion in
- 38:38size. Now these are ABS bonds,
- 38:43securitized bonds. What these what these products
- 38:47do is they package a lot of credit card loans or auto loans
- 38:53or mortgages and they package them up and sell them to these
- 38:57institutions that want to earn interest, right?
- 39:00And what we have done now is for the first time ever is we have
- 39:05done the same thing that banks and others do with auto loans
- 39:09and credit card loans and other types of mortgages.
- 39:12For the first time ever, we've done this with Bitcoin, right?
- 39:16We've packaged up Bitcoin back loans into an ABS and we've sold
- 39:21that ABS into in the qualified investors in that market.
- 39:25Now importantly, why do investors invest in this type of
- 39:30product? Well, because these products
- 39:32historically are rated and they are rated investment grade.
- 39:37And what does that mean? It means that a company like S&P
- 39:40has gone through the offering, the management, the assumptions,
- 39:45the modeling, the, the operations, the, the, the sort
- 39:49of the, the risk management of those loans and has stress
- 39:52tested all those assumptions. Has gone through all their legal
- 39:54agreement and has basically put those models through every
- 39:58possible scenario they could think of to assume what the
- 40:01potential losses could be. And then based on the
- 40:03expectation of loss, if the expectation of loss is small
- 40:07enough, they can then assign what's called an investment
- 40:09grade rating to that instrument, which means that it now a
- 40:13pension fund or an insurance company.
- 40:17That most of them have mandates that they can only invest in
- 40:20investment grade stuff can now look at the deal and potentially
- 40:24invest in the deal. Why it doesn't?
- 40:26Why is investment grade, the investment category so
- 40:29important? 80% of the ABS market that I
- 40:32just mentioned. So out of those 3 trillion
- 40:35dollars, 80% of it is investment grade.
- 40:39All this to say that the non investment grade section of the
- 40:43ABS market is very small. There is no bid for it because
- 40:46the big bits are in the investment grade category.
- 40:49So it is very important to have an investment grade product if
- 40:55you want that product to scale in the future, right?
- 40:58Because that's where a lot of the demand is.
- 41:00So we for the first time ever work with S&P for them to issue
- 41:05the first ever rating of any Bitcoin ABS product in history.
- 41:10This is the first ever Bitcoin ABS product to exist and as a
- 41:14first time issuer for this product let him receive an
- 41:18investment grade rating from S&P on the first time issuance.
- 41:22This deal was marketed and sold coincidentally, not by design,
- 41:28but coincidentally while the market was crashing from the 80s
- 41:32into the 60s. And the funny part about this is
- 41:36many of these qualified investors that were investing
- 41:38into this product for the first time had the question, well, how
- 41:41will your market hold up in a down market?
- 41:43What if Bitcoin dumps, you know, 40 percent, 30%, what's going to
- 41:47happen then? And the funny part was this was
- 41:50happening as we were pitching the deal and we were pulling out
- 41:53data in real time showing them that our system was working
- 41:57perfectly. So not only did the deal close,
- 42:01not only was there no change to the rating, but the deal was 2
- 42:05times oversubscribed, more than two times oversubscribed.
- 42:08So we have confirmed that there is understanding, growing
- 42:13understanding and demand for this type of product in the
- 42:17institutional ABS investor market.
- 42:22And the other thing that I will highlight as to why I think
- 42:26letting is one of the few, if not the only company that would
- 42:29be able to offer this is because of how important the
- 42:33considerations are to even have even have SAP agree to review
- 42:39your deal right And let alone, you know, get close to an
- 42:42investment grade rating. You need to have three very
- 42:47important things to have a deal like this make be possible.
- 42:52Number one is you need size. Our offering was $200 million,
- 42:58but you need to have multiples of that in available loans to
- 43:02vend into the facility in case some loans get repaid or, or
- 43:06closed, right? And so you need to have a lot of
- 43:09scale because the other thing is you need to have the offering
- 43:12needs to be in the hundreds of millions of dollars for them to,
- 43:15you know, for it to be feasible, then you need to have multiples
- 43:18of that in order to be able to vend into the facility, right?
- 43:21So at Lenin we were you know, our size a nearly a nearly a
- 43:25billion dollars towards the end of last year that that would
- 43:28that allowed us to have enough of a of a ability to sell and
- 43:32inventory to vent back in. The second one is we have an 8
- 43:35year perfect operations track record that we can show.
- 43:40And that is the benefit of having been doing this and only
- 43:42this for eight years because they can now go back eight years
- 43:46in our tape and see that our liquidations work perfectly as
- 43:49they should every time they were needed.
- 43:52Right. And then the third one is
- 43:54Lennon's regulatory posture. Lennon is a fully regulated
- 43:58company, has never had fines, has never had issues and never
- 44:01had run insurance. We've never had our tokens.
- 44:03We've never had any of anything like that.
- 44:06And so that allows them to get comfortable working with
- 44:10somebody like Lennon. I know that was a long rant of
- 44:14pause. That was awesome.
- 44:18That was awesome and, and huge congratulations to you guys
- 44:21because I totally agree this is a, a pretty large milestone
- 44:24because as you referenced, there's, there's historically
- 44:28been a mismatch in terms of we know there's a ton of client
- 44:31demand, you know, Bitcoin holder demand to take out loans against
- 44:34their Bitcoin. What's been less robust or
- 44:39perhaps sustainable is the dollar side, the capital side
- 44:43that needs to support those loans.
- 44:46And I think that's also, you know, frankly why rates
- 44:50historically have been so high to take out a loan.
- 44:51It's because of that mismatch. So I'm curious, given this
- 44:55development, which I agree is a, is a massive milestone from just
- 44:59a signal perspective, but also sort of a, a sign of maturation,
- 45:04what do you think this does going forward in terms of,
- 45:06again, that, you know, adjusting that mismatch?
- 45:09Maybe, you know, more and more capital gets interested.
- 45:12I think part of it too is just a greater recognition of Bitcoin
- 45:17as pristine collateral, you know, just sort of education
- 45:23around Bitcoin, what it is, how it works, why it's not super
- 45:26speculative, why it is this in many ways a risk off asset and
- 45:31really great collateral. What do you think this does
- 45:34going forward in terms of the lending market in general?
- 45:37Check out Early riders.com for all the latest in Bitcoin
- 45:39investment research. Now back to the show.
- 45:43Great question and I'll give you I'll respond with an analogy.
- 45:46I think this will do to Bitcoin back loans exactly what the
- 45:51evolution of financing with solar energy projects went
- 45:56right. And my business partner Adam
- 45:58used to work in renewable energy financing before we got into the
- 46:01Bitcoin. And at the beginning when you
- 46:03were putting out the solar panel projects, a lot of the investors
- 46:07didn't know how long the panels would last.
- 46:09Like how do we, how do I know this panel's in the last 20
- 46:11years? How do I know this panel's not
- 46:12going to break? How do I know it's still going
- 46:13to be as efficient five years out?
- 46:15And so they had a lot of these questions.
- 46:16They didn't understand the asset, they didn't understand
- 46:18the security, the asset backing the cash flows, Right.
- 46:22And as time went on and they were able to demonstrate that,
- 46:26Oh yes, these panels do last 10 years.
- 46:28OK, check. Oh yeah, the efficiency on the
- 46:31intake does maintain as they said it.
- 46:33Well, OK, check for the next deal.
- 46:36I'm willing to take a slightly lower return because I think the
- 46:38risk here is lower. And so, so on the subsequent
- 46:41issuance, the rating was better and the rate was lower and so
- 46:45on, so forth until it basically got to diminishing returns to,
- 46:49to become basically to at the beginning there were a lot of
- 46:52incentives for solar and then the the incentives were taken
- 46:54away and then the rates kind of not just sort of landed at a
- 46:59sort of more, more sane place. I think the same thing will be
- 47:04true for financing Bitcoin back loans.
- 47:07Don't don't forget, yes, you, you know, Brian, Liam, myself,
- 47:11we've been here for a decade, right?
- 47:13So we know Bitcoin, we get it. We've seen the liquidations.
- 47:16I've I've I've had to press Bitcoin sale orders and the
- 47:20darkest hours of March 14th and I've seen them go through and
- 47:23get filled like butter. And when you see it as a risk
- 47:27manager, you say, wow, like this thing really does what people
- 47:33say it would do it. So you start this conviction
- 47:34just grows and grows, right? A lot of these institutions,
- 47:38this is the first ABS they've ever invested into the
- 47:41liquidations that we were showing them.
- 47:44What during the road show was the first time they've ever seen
- 47:46it happen, right? And so as they get more used to,
- 47:52as the dollar side of the equation gets more used to
- 47:55Bitcoin as collateral, that price will come down.
- 47:59And as that price comes down, the very fascinating dynamic
- 48:03with loans is that the, the amount of things I can do with a
- 48:08loan versus the rate. Like basically the usability of
- 48:11a loan versus the cost of a loan has this asymmetric relationship
- 48:15where if you drop the rate over a certain point, the range of
- 48:20things you can now do with the loan go exponentially, right?
- 48:24Because all of a sudden, if it clears your cost of capital, you
- 48:29can do a lot of things, right? Like you can, you can basically
- 48:31do something to start a business, to buy a house, to buy
- 48:33a car, to buy a phone, to go go traveling, to invest in other
- 48:37assets, right? And so as the cost of capital
- 48:40goes from the double digits into the single digits, that's I
- 48:42think going to be the first chasm we're going to cross.
- 48:45It's like Bitcoin back loans are now single digits.
- 48:47Wow. And after you go down to the
- 48:50single digits, then the next one is if you look at the spectrum
- 48:54of of the property loan stack, so there's like first lien
- 48:58mortgage, HELOC, secondly mortgage, you're basically right
- 49:04now Bitcoin back loans are in private mortgage territory.
- 49:08OK, the next stage is it going to come into HELOC territory.
- 49:12Right from there you're going to go into first tier territory
- 49:16eventually. And when you go into HELOC and
- 49:191st tier territory, all of a sudden the sort of amount of
- 49:22things you could do with a loan, you know, is, is it's
- 49:27everything, right? Like I don't sell loans, I sell
- 49:30your new house, I sell that new car, I sell you quitting your
- 49:35job and starting your business. That's what Bitcoin back loans
- 49:39allow you to do, right? And so once those thresholds
- 49:43start coming into like I said, first it will be the sub single
- 49:47digits and then we come into, you know, more comparable to
- 49:51other types of secure lending. Think about it like if I can
- 49:54give. You the same rates of.
- 49:55A Bitcoin back loan than I do with a house and you don't have
- 49:57to get income to qualify. You can take that asset
- 50:00anywhere. It's no longer stuck to where
- 50:03you live, right? You can do any.
- 50:06You can basically you can you can use it in real time from
- 50:10anywhere in the world. It's the same rates.
- 50:12This is the other thing when I talk about these rates, I talk
- 50:15about these rates becoming available to everyone in the
- 50:17world right now. The only person that can access
- 50:20sub 10% private mortgage is America, right?
- 50:25Like no one else can do that and maybe parts of Europe.
- 50:28But I do think that these loans are going to, you're going to
- 50:31see a Cambrian explosion of Bitcoin back loans as these
- 50:36rates come down. I'll do a quick sidebar.
- 50:42Why I think? It's so important.
- 50:44If you look at the asset back underwriting model we have
- 50:47today, it's income based. You can have a 2 million.
- 50:51Dollar house paved. Outright and you have no income
- 50:56and you go to the bank and you say I want a HELOC for 500,000.
- 51:01Dollars of my house that I own. Free and clear.
- 51:04And they'll say, great, what's your income, Liam?
- 51:06And you'll say, oh, I just retired because, you know, I own
- 51:08this house outright. And they'll say, we're sorry,
- 51:11Liam, you don't qualify for a loan even though you own the
- 51:15house outright, you have no debt servicing capacity, Liam.
- 51:20And you'll say, Oh my God, this is this is outrageous, right?
- 51:24With Bitcoin, you can do this, right?
- 51:26And so all I'm trying to say is this income based underwriting
- 51:29model for asset backed loans is disconnected from our real
- 51:33world. Like most of the full time jobs
- 51:37that we have today either don't exist or are overtaxed.
- 51:43And so if you are a young person and you're trying to start your
- 51:46own business and you can't get financing basically anywhere in
- 51:50the real banks and I at Leaden, you can get 50% of the value of
- 51:54your Bitcoin holdings. Are you just?
- 51:58Are you not? Going to get financing or are?
- 51:59You going to get Bitcoin back loan financing.
- 52:01So I, what I'm trying to say is our underwriting model is much
- 52:04more aligned with the future of where the world is headed.
- 52:10And I want to touch on the difference between Bitcoin back
- 52:12loans versus ETFs, but I, I don't want to keep derailing the
- 52:15conversational pause. No, no, I think that's
- 52:18fantastic. I think just.
- 52:20One thing even before going to that there too is we we've at
- 52:25early riders invest in Bitcoin infrastructure as well and
- 52:30specifically very secure products that will essentially
- 52:34allow clients to maintain and not introduce outside risk and
- 52:39and reduce risk as much as possible for all types of
- 52:42clients. And obviously you've you've been
- 52:45in the space building Bitcoin related services and seen a lot
- 52:49of appreciation in bitcoins price itself.
- 52:54It came out, I think you published recently that you just
- 52:57surpassed 100 million in annual recurring revenue have an
- 53:00investment from Tether. Would just love to hear a little
- 53:03bit about how you think about working in the Bitcoin
- 53:06infrastructure space, providing services there and you know why
- 53:11that's been such a an an interesting business for for you
- 53:15and Leadin as a whole. Yeah, definitely so.
- 53:19You know, one of the, you know, as an early Bitcoiner, myself
- 53:25and my family, you know, just through, through life and
- 53:29through managing your own position, you, you kind of get
- 53:31a, a good sense of what you would like to do without Bitcoin
- 53:35or what other investors might want to do without Bitcoin.
- 53:36And frankly also what the sort of limitations are there as an
- 53:41asset. Like what can you do with your
- 53:42Bitcoin? So broadly speaking, you can do
- 53:45three main things to your Bitcoin.
- 53:46You can hold it, you can trade it, and you can borrow against
- 53:49it, right? Like hold it is not holding it.
- 53:51You want to hold that safely and you want to transfer that
- 53:54safely, right? So then you get into multi, sig
- 53:58and multi. Institutional.
- 53:59And you know what is safe, you know, and as you're, as the
- 54:03amount of Bitcoin you're managing change, so does your
- 54:07determination of what is safe and responsible, right?
- 54:10So for everything, right, whether you're holding it,
- 54:12whether you're trading it, whether you're using it as
- 54:14collateral, right? And so I think that Bitcoin as I
- 54:19see it, is a tool that is used by people to protect their
- 54:26wealth, right? And largely what I've realized
- 54:30over time is that the type of person that values the things
- 54:34that Lenin offers is the person that has built wealth over time.
- 54:39They have wealth that they want to protect.
- 54:40And they've also been around long enough to see that if you
- 54:44don't choose the right partners and if you don't have the right
- 54:46set up, all that hard work, all that wealth can just go away,
- 54:50right? And so at Lenin, we focus very
- 54:54much on optimizing for security and transparency and safety.
- 55:00And that is the promise we make to everybody that works with
- 55:05Leaden. And I think the person that ends
- 55:08up that that values this, this type of offering is happens to
- 55:12be a person that, you know, with a lot of sacrifice, build their
- 55:16wealth and they don't want to lose it.
- 55:17And they want to, they want to basically work with the group
- 55:19they think is doing the best thing or the, you know, working
- 55:22the hardest to keep that safe. I think that the amount of the
- 55:28Bitcoiners that value these things is only going to grow
- 55:31over time. If you look at the profile of
- 55:33people that have been getting into Bitcoin recently, outside
- 55:36of the original sort of first adopters, you're having a lot of
- 55:39sophisticated Wall Street investors or companies, company
- 55:43treasuries, governments. And so the people that are
- 55:47entering Bitcoin are not speculators, They are investors
- 55:52looking to protect wealth. And This is why I think
- 55:55companies that are working on services that optimize for
- 56:00protection, that optimize for transparency, for compliance and
- 56:04for security, I think are going to see a a lot of growth.
- 56:09Because I think there's, there's always going to be the person
- 56:12that wants to hold their Bitcoin in self custody with no KYC and
- 56:16have it sort of, you know, completely off grid and, and
- 56:19have it in the sort of, you know, more sovereign individual
- 56:22type of stance. But increasingly I think you're
- 56:26going to see companies and sophisticated investors that are
- 56:29want to going to want to have a big part of their portfolio of
- 56:33Bitcoin and they want to have it with the same assurances and
- 56:36guarantees that Triathi has built over time.
- 56:39And I think that what you guys are building and what Lenin's
- 56:43building and what other sort of qualified custodians and others
- 56:46are building bodes very well for this future because I think that
- 56:52the person that there's only going to be more and more people
- 56:56that value the type of stuff that we've built.
- 56:59And and for that reason, I think we companies that are building
- 57:02in this space stand to do very well 100% that that's very well
- 57:06said. I think it might be a nice place
- 57:09to to wrap because I know we're coming up on an hour.
- 57:12But one thing I did want to reference and we sort of have
- 57:15alluded to this throughout the conversation around this
- 57:19transitional moment in a, in a sense of, you know, what Bitcoin
- 57:23was for the past 17 years is changing.
- 57:26It's becoming an institutional asset.
- 57:29It's becoming much more ingrained in the sort of
- 57:31traditional finance rails. And so one thing I did want to
- 57:34ask you about Mauricio, is like the JP Morgan's, the Morgan
- 57:37Stanley's, the Bank of America's who are now getting into not
- 57:41only the custody game, but probably going to start doing
- 57:44loans as well. I guess first question is like,
- 57:48you know, is that is that scary competition or is that
- 57:51validation for you guys? And then you know what, what
- 57:55does that do? Again, how does that how does
- 57:58that change the market in general of, of moving, you know,
- 58:02a little bit less, less from purely retail, you know,
- 58:06Bitcoiners who've been in it for a long time, they just want to
- 58:08get a loan out to this more institutional playing field.
- 58:12Have you seen that guy? Have you guys seen that shift
- 58:15already occurring in your sort of client mix today and and how
- 58:18are you preparing for the future when it comes to holding Bitcoin
- 58:20securely Peace of Mind? Starts with architecture on
- 58:24ramps multi institution custody. Distributes control across three
- 58:27independent regulated key holders in a two of three
- 58:29quorum. No single point of failure, no
- 58:32pooled or omnibus exposure. Segregated client titled faults.
- 58:37You retain full legal ownership while on ramp.
- 58:39Coordinates security, compliance and operational work flows
- 58:42behind the scenes. It's strength of many delivered
- 58:45through the simplicity of 1 multi institution custody is the
- 58:48foundation for everything. We build sound infrastructure
- 58:51that distributes counterparty risk and provides fault tolerant
- 58:54resilience with clear audits and institutional controls.
- 58:57And now on Ramp is piloting flat predictable pricing, making best
- 59:01in class Bitcoin custody and financial services more
- 59:04accessible now than ever. On Ramp strengthen many
- 59:08simplicity in one. To learn more, check out on
- 59:11rampbitcoin.com. Yeah, great question.
- 59:15So. A couple of things on that
- 59:17point. So the first thing I'll say is
- 59:20definitely banks are looking at the space and increasingly more
- 59:23interested in working or deploying or making moves in the
- 59:27space. So I'll tell you from
- 59:28experience, you know, four years ago we went to banks and said,
- 59:32hey, are you guys interested in, you know, lending
- 59:34institutionally for income bank loans?
- 59:35And they're like, get out of our room, right?
- 59:37Like they're, they're just, they're, they weren't there
- 59:40today. Those same banks are calling us
- 59:43and they're saying, hey guys, you know, we'd love to
- 59:45reconnect. It feels like every other day we
- 59:48get a call from a random bank that that is interested and they
- 59:51heard about the ABS or whatever, right?
- 59:53So definitely banks are interested and they are making
- 59:56moves to come. I do believe there are some
- 59:59structural limitations for banks and that's more so on the sort
- 1:00:02of capital ratios and regulatory side that.
- 1:00:05Doesn't necessarily forbid them from entering, but places quite
- 1:00:08a few restrictions for them sort of entering the space outright.
- 1:00:12I think everybody is sort of assumes that banks are going to
- 1:00:14come in with these like 0% deposits and start lending into
- 1:00:17Bitcoin. But the truth is like those
- 1:00:20deposits compete against real estate loans and student loans
- 1:00:26and other types of loans that are sort of more, I would argue
- 1:00:30have a more of a strategic angle to the United States.
- 1:00:33And so I think, I still think it's TBD on the timeline and the
- 1:00:36format in which banks come in. But they will participate,
- 1:00:39right? Like saying they won't
- 1:00:40participate is, is, is ludicrous.
- 1:00:42We've always believed they're going to come.
- 1:00:44And I think that what this will do is this will elevate the, the
- 1:00:49quality of Bitcoin back loans in the market, right?
- 1:00:51Because it'll force companies like Lenin to become always more
- 1:00:54efficient from a cost perspective, from a distribution
- 1:00:56perspective, but at the same time it'll also force the banks
- 1:01:01to wake up. Why?
- 1:01:04When is Bitcoin most volatile? The.
- 1:01:08Weekends when can you? Not operate in a bank the
- 1:01:13weekends. Yep.
- 1:01:14Right, so. OK, let's say you're taking out
- 1:01:17a Bitcoin back loan. Bitcoin tanks Saturday, 1:00 AM.
- 1:01:21That's the moment you wanted to take out that loan to buy more
- 1:01:23Bitcoin. You're going to wait till your
- 1:01:24bank opens on Monday. You're going to go to Latin,
- 1:01:28right? So.
- 1:01:30Either the bank puts. Up 24/7 service or you're
- 1:01:34probably still Aladdin, right? Like imagine for a second you
- 1:01:37took a loan with Bitcoin was at 70 Bitcoin reached 250 over the
- 1:01:41weekend and you wanted to take profits on a Saturday.
- 1:01:45What are you going to do that? Oh.
- 1:01:47With the bank was offering me 1% less.
- 1:01:51Oh OK. How much does Bitcoin move on
- 1:01:53the weekend? Let's play that game.
- 1:01:57So you're going to see 1% but be locked out after hours for that
- 1:02:001%. Is that worth it?
- 1:02:01Yeah, it's a good point. I think they know.
- 1:02:03They know this. Though they they're, they're all
- 1:02:05they're embracing 24/7. They know they need to get
- 1:02:07there. I think totally.
- 1:02:10Yeah. But imagine.
- 1:02:11Having to run like so how are you going to do this right as a
- 1:02:16bank? So what you're going to stand up
- 1:02:18a new Bitcoin team that's going to be available 24/7 and are
- 1:02:22those guys in the East Coast are those guys in the West Coast?
- 1:02:25How big does your book have to be to manage that service tier
- 1:02:29plethora of questions right? And so I'm not saying we won't
- 1:02:32get there or that we cannot get there.
- 1:02:35I'm saying that both companies like from the from the Bitcoin
- 1:02:39natives, we have to make sure we are the, the name of the game is
- 1:02:44we have to figure out, not figure out, but we have to
- 1:02:46remain competitive from a rates perspective and from a capital
- 1:02:49sourcing perspective, right? We got the distribution, we got
- 1:02:52the service, we built this product for the end user.
- 1:02:54We get them better than the banks, right?
- 1:02:57Like I think nobody can argue that, right?
- 1:02:59The banks may have more money, but if we play our cards right,
- 1:03:02we can tap into the right markets.
- 1:03:03We should be able to take even playing field on that.
- 1:03:07And at that point it'll become a service game.
- 1:03:09So the real bet is, is JP going to serve Bitcoiners better than
- 1:03:13me? Let's go.
- 1:03:16You know, it's, it's a market, it's a free market.
- 1:03:18Let's go. No, I totally, I totally agree
- 1:03:20because we get. We get questions as well on the
- 1:03:24custody side of like, OK, well, this makes sense.
- 1:03:26Multi institution to get it, you know, distributed risk, more
- 1:03:30fault tolerant, robust, all of that.
- 1:03:32But like, you know, why isn't JP Morgan just going to go build
- 1:03:34this? It's like, well, OK, let's,
- 1:03:36let's see them do it because there are a lot of intricacies,
- 1:03:39there's nuances. And so I would totally agree
- 1:03:42with you. There's a ton of advantages to
- 1:03:44the Bitcoin native players with all of this, whether it's the
- 1:03:46lending markets or the custody side of things.
- 1:03:50So yeah, I, I, I totally agree. Well, Mauricio, this has been a
- 1:03:53fantastic conversation. Really appreciate you spending
- 1:03:55some time with us and, and walking through everything
- 1:03:57that's happening at at Leaden and, and the lending market in
- 1:04:00general. Anything else you wanted to
- 1:04:02leave the audience with or where people can find more?
- 1:04:05Find out more about Leaden. Sure, yeah.
- 1:04:08Lenin dot. IO is our.
- 1:04:09Website we are at Hollow with Lenin on XI am at Cryptonomist
- 1:04:15with an A at the end Cryptonomist dot on X DMS are
- 1:04:18always open. Stay tuned.
- 1:04:20Don't don't you know, keep keep turn your notifications on.
- 1:04:23We got some exciting stuff coming this month and hope to do
- 1:04:26this again soon. Awesome.
- 1:04:28Well, really appreciate it, Mauricio.
- 1:04:30And yeah, we'll have to have you back on when the next awesome
- 1:04:33announcement comes out of Out of Lenin.
- 1:04:34So appreciate it. All right, take care.
- 1:04:39Thanks for listening to this. Week's episode of the show.
- 1:04:42If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:04:44episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:04:47app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:04:49today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:04:51Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Rat Media is
- 1:04:54for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:04:57nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:05:00Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:05:02to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact.
- 1:05:06Schedule a consultation with one of our private client advisors.