Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Spiel des Jahres Special-Interview with Brett J Gilbert and Matthew Dunstan on Guild of Merchant Explorers
Transcript
- 0:00Freshly doug from the cold face of the board game world. We bring you
- 0:06five games for Doomsday News. So I'm delighted to have on the end of
- 0:14the line from the northern bastion of Cambridgeshire and new Castle, Australia, Brett
- 0:20J. Gilbert and Matthew Dunstan, designers of the award nominated Guild of Merchant
- 0:25Explorers. Gentlemen, Welcome to my SDJ previews. Thank you, Thank you
- 0:31very much. Be nice to be so to begin, you've been working together
- 0:36a long time, like a decade or so on games with each other.
- 0:41Can you finish in on how did you get together, how did you start
- 0:44working together, and why the relationship works so well? Brett, let's start
- 0:48with you, crikey, I mean it all happened ten years is more than
- 0:52just slightly over ten years, I think, now, isn't it. We
- 0:55first met at Essen because but that was just at the beginning of my game
- 1:00design publishing journey. My game Devinari had been published the year before, I
- 1:04think, and I'd only gone to Essen for the first time of the year
- 1:08before, and Matt had come to Cambridge, and we didn't meet originally in
- 1:17Cambridge. He just had spotted me online. I must have talked about Cambridge
- 1:21and we met at Essen that year, but that was only the second time
- 1:23I'd ever been to Essen, so like the whole thing was still new to
- 1:27me. I was still meeting people in the UK in terms of other designers,
- 1:30So it was very very early in my own kind of successful well successful
- 1:37came to ZN career and Matt, what made you think that Brett might be
- 1:41someone good to work with? Well, I think Brett's sort of undersold it
- 1:45a little bit. I mean I always say I kind of stalked Brett online
- 1:49because he used to write an excellent blog. This is in twenty eleven,
- 1:53and I think he had been writing it for maybe a year or two before
- 1:56that, with some really excellent articles, which you know, I keep prodding
- 2:00Brett to somehow put them back on the internet somewhere, because I think they
- 2:05would actually stand up really well today anyway, I mean, and in a
- 2:08way, there wasn't as much being written about, you know, game design
- 2:12even at that time. So back in Australia, I'd only started designing a
- 2:15year before, and I hadn't you know, I hadn't had anything, you
- 2:19know, even finished a game really and I read these things, and yes,
- 2:23I found out I was moving to Cambridge. I knew Brett was there
- 2:25somehow, and I think it was just that case. I mean a lot
- 2:30of the case when people start in game design, it's you know, you
- 2:34look, you seek out a bit of a mentor or at least somebody to
- 2:37work not work with. But play tests were to bounce off and we were
- 2:40lucky to be able to do that. And we started just meeting once a
- 2:43week in a pub in Cambridge and it sort of became a playtest group,
- 2:46which is actually still going in Cambridge. It's you know, been going for
- 2:51you know, thirteen years. O. Now I'm not a part of it
- 2:53anymore, or I mean, whenever i'm there, I try to attend,
- 2:58but I think it, yeah, it became a really strong sort of community.
- 3:01Actually, so yeah, let's let's talk a bit about that then.
- 3:07Because I've spoken to a number of people, Trevor Benjamin, David Thompson,
- 3:10it seems that the Cambridge Playtest Group has, pound for pound, been one
- 3:15of the most successful sort of playtest groups in the UK. Did you did
- 3:20you start it, Brett or was it some sort of just a morphous group
- 3:24of people that came together and you formalize something. Well, no, it
- 3:28was just me and Matt. That was the beginning. After we returned from
- 3:31Esen. The time that we met, Matt proposed that we get together and
- 3:35playtest each other's games, and it literally was just the two of us in
- 3:38a pub in Cambridge. I had, I think at that time I'd already
- 3:42met Rob Harris, who set up the Playtest UK kind of network, but
- 3:45even that was really recent. That was the year before, I think,
- 3:49and it took us a while before we actually placed put our the two of
- 3:53us meeting onto the internet so that anybody else could find us. Initially we
- 3:58met with Andrew Sheeran, who's another game designer you may remember the game War
- 4:03on Terror, and his collaborator, his illustrator, Tom Walkin Jones. They
- 4:08were based in Cambridge. I knew that I found them on Twitter. So
- 4:12for a while it was just the four of us with meet in the pub
- 4:14to meet to play test each other's games, and it was I don't know
- 4:17how long it took before we put it onto the meetup to become part of
- 4:20the Playtest UK sort of network, but once it did, then it pulled
- 4:26in all sorts of people, including Trevor and Dave Neil and David Thompson,
- 4:30and a huge number of other people, actually all of them, you know,
- 4:33and it's still getting strong. It obviously had a pause during the pandemic,
- 4:38but we're now back to twice monthly, and two weeks ago, three
- 4:43weeks ago, there were like twelve thirteen people there. It was fantastic.
- 4:46So I need to ask you this, Brett, because I've spoken to Matt
- 4:49about this. I sported to Trevor about this, sorting to David about this,
- 4:53and apparently your critique style when playing someone else's prototype is quite legendary.
- 4:59Apparently you don't hold back. Well, how true is this or are people
- 5:04exaggerating? I'm not sure they're exaggerating, But Matt's just as bad, like
- 5:09I think often, Matt and I were very much on the same page when
- 5:11we were revealing stuff. I think I've certainly gained a reputation. I'm not
- 5:15denying it, but I think we realized, I mean, we were running,
- 5:17you know, we kept meeting every week, we saw lots of games
- 5:20like we realized you had to be at least challenging to a design for it
- 5:25to move ahead. I don't. I'd like to think that I wasn't ever
- 5:30I was constructive, and I think that's true, and I have maybe moderated
- 5:35my style slightly because the risk is you you go into hard too early,
- 5:40and that is, you know, that crushes the kind of the spirit,
- 5:45perhaps, which is never the point. The point is to try and be
- 5:46constructive, but to be helpful and to push a design forward. And if
- 5:51you're going to bring it to a playtest session, then I think the whole
- 5:58point is to really kick it, you know, tires and see what people
- 6:00think and listen and receive feedback. And that is a tough skill to learn
- 6:05itself. And it's still hard sometimes to do that myself because people have lots
- 6:11of designers have lots of opinions. When you played us with designers, you
- 6:15get a lot of opinions and you have to filter that through. I mean,
- 6:19hopefully I was doing people as service. Hopefully I was helping them with
- 6:24their game. I suppose you'd have to ask them. So, Matt,
- 6:28you brought to work together for a long time. So firstly, what are
- 6:30some of the games you've designed together? And secondly, how have you managed
- 6:34to maintain a designing relationship over a decade. Well, I mean to the
- 6:40games. I mean games like Elysium, which was also nomin known for the
- 6:43Kinnishpiel, you know, like eight years or nine years ago now, actually
- 6:48Costa Rica with Brett chime In. If I just tried to remember good,
- 6:54good examples, I'm looking at a vill Israel. But Israels is a more
- 7:00recent one with Osprey, which is funny walk on a smaller box game.
- 7:05There's a game called Smike Spy Connection with Pegasis Shpila which Oh, and we
- 7:09have Tree Society coming out with Sorry, we have Tree Society coming out with
- 7:13playing at gen Con, which only yesterday received. Oh you've got them yesterday.
- 7:20Oh, very exciting. No, it's I mean Lovely Mention, Lovely
- 7:25Box, Lovely Bits. So that's coming out very since. That's the most
- 7:28recent. But that is also one of the longest. I mean that the
- 7:31very first it's finally being published in twenty twenty four The very first email in
- 7:36the very long email chain that exists on my computer between me and Matt about
- 7:41that was in twenty fourteen. Wow, So that game has had a whole
- 7:46decade, has that one game has spanned most of that period, as it
- 7:49happens, and speaking to why, I think we've been out to work together
- 7:54for so I mean, it's like I imagine any sort of creative collaboration or
- 7:58even professional, you know, working relationship, you have to it is a
- 8:03bit about fit, you know, It's something a little bit indescribable because I've
- 8:09liked, I think both of us enjoyed, have enjoyed working with a lot
- 8:11of different designers, and we have done so in published games. But our
- 8:16collaboration still, I think is the most has been the most fruitful for both
- 8:20of us. And it's still it slowed down a little bit because I'm on
- 8:22the other side of the world, but you know, I'm hoping we'll keep
- 8:26making games together. And I think it's just that when you just have a
- 8:33very good fitting of styles and you have to overlap, it's like you have
- 8:37to have the right amount of overlap, but the right amount of difference,
- 8:41because if you're just exactly the same, then there's no point working together.
- 8:43You're not really adding anything to each other's designs or sensibilities or preferences. If
- 8:50you're too far apart, then you can't find any compromise. And the games
- 8:52don't move anywhere because you can't even agree on a common direction, so you
- 8:56sort of have to be in that kind of goldilock zone. And then you
- 8:58also having complementary skills just helps, I think, just finish a lot of
- 9:03things. You know, I think part of the you know, part of
- 9:07the being kind of a professional game designer, so to speak. Sure,
- 9:11there's an amount that you know, you have to kind of be good at
- 9:15the craft, but a lot of it is just there is such a broad
- 9:18range of skills that it needed to actually finish a game and actually pitt it
- 9:22to a publisher. And the more games you get to that point that you
- 9:26pitch, well, you've just got more chances of them being actually published.
- 9:28And I think Brett and I compliment well each other. I'm very good at
- 9:31coming up with new ideas and sort of making the first prototype of an idea.
- 9:35Brett's very good at editing and rule book riding, a much underrated skill,
- 9:41and also sort of graphical designer layout and kind of iconography and things like
- 9:45this. So I think we you know, that's a good package that you
- 9:48know leads to making a lot of games. And I think, yeah,
- 9:54it's been a no, and it's enjoyable. I think we still get along
- 9:58after all this time, which is also useful. I guess, yeah,
- 10:01you have to enjoy the process. But Matt alluded to the bit after that
- 10:05comes after actually making a game is the work of pitching it and going to
- 10:11meetings and going to Essen and just turning up. And that would be exhausting
- 10:16on your own. I mean we went to sen year after year for like
- 10:18six or seven years and had twenty plus meetings over two or three days,
- 10:24and it's just that is hard work and having on your own it would be
- 10:31impossible. I think. So having two people in the room when you do
- 10:33that means you can, you know, you can ebb and flow a little
- 10:35bit, and you can build relationships with the publishers in I don't know,
- 10:41in a slightly easier way because it's a little bit more. It's not just
- 10:45you. You're not under the spotlight, so you can I said, like
- 10:48the very first time we went to Essen with a game, which was the
- 10:50year after we met something Matt brook is doing something weird, we had one
- 10:58game essentially that we're has worked on. We had thirteen pitches I think,
- 11:01and we got really good at pitching that game because we had to do it
- 11:07back and we hadn't practiced. But by the end of it, it was
- 11:09it was really on point. Like I would I would talk it, I
- 11:13would have a little patter, and Matt would know when to bring the bits
- 11:16out of the bag and how to arrange stuff like it was a real dance.
- 11:20I didn't get signed, by the way, but we did do a
- 11:22really good job of pitching it, and I think that, yeah, that's
- 11:26just that was the beginning of just that. The benefit of having two people
- 11:31in the room like that was huge. So Matt tell us about Guild Emotions
- 11:35Explorers. Then what was the origin of the game and how is the development
- 11:39process of it. It's funny I was trying to prepare for this interview and
- 11:43it has somewhat eluded me. The kind of core, the kind of spark
- 11:50of the idea I think I and tell me if I'm wrong, but I
- 11:54think I had probably the initial idea batting. I think I was sort of
- 11:58a test with exploration games, you know, and you know, things like
- 12:03Kingdom. People make comparisons to games like Kingdom Builder. I think I've been
- 12:07always interesting games where you you know, your influence kind of spreads over a
- 12:11map, and I think I was also quite obsessed with maps. I hadn't
- 12:13really done like a map game, and I think it was that kind of
- 12:18almost thematic urge to do something. And I think around that time is twenty
- 12:24nineteen, you know, role and rights, it sort of all happened,
- 12:28and I think that kind of mechanism of you know what we now call flip
- 12:31and phil or whatever, flip and exit, And it was probably just I
- 12:37mean, it's a lot of a lot of game design for me. When
- 12:41I sort of think back to it, it's just the happy fortune of sort
- 12:46of a few different ideas coexisting in my head at the same time and sort
- 12:48of coalescing into a project. It's not like that for every game, but
- 12:54for something like this, it was, Yeah, I was taking a bit
- 12:56from here, a bit from there, and really from the start, but
- 13:00we had that flip and fill idea that kind of reveal a card and everybody
- 13:03does things at the same time. We had that map putting cubes on a
- 13:07map, and that that really core thing of that connectedness like starting for a
- 13:11point of moving out. So actually it was kind of close at the start,
- 13:18which was which was quite exciting. It doesn't always happen that way.
- 13:22Of course, it took a long time, and I was actually looking back
- 13:24through the prototypes. We didn't one of the mechanical things that a lot of
- 13:28people alid on it that we enjoy a lot too, is this idea of
- 13:31getting new powerful cards each round, and that wasn't in the game originally.
- 13:35There was an idea. I think it almost like a deck building idea originally,
- 13:39but we didn't kind of nail the system as it is until you know,
- 13:43I don't know, I let of them. I think it was prototype
- 13:45J or something so that. But that whole process, it wasn't that long.
- 13:50Actually, I think it was sort of three to four months something like
- 13:54that, which is which is pretty quick really, And I have a very
- 13:56clear memory of playtesting the game increasable, which probably helps me remembering it.
- 14:01I'm just really enjoying it. I'm not saying that I hate all my games
- 14:05or something, but I think when you work on something, it doesn't you
- 14:11know, like it's hard to disengage the kind of game design to fix it
- 14:13brain. But I remember playing it and going like, actually, I'm really
- 14:16enjoying this. Even in that process where the game isn't kind of done.
- 14:20I think that was probably a good sign that it was, you know,
- 14:22like there was something kind of special aut And I even played the game barely
- 14:26two weeks ago actually, no before the nomination, we didn't know, and
- 14:31I was just like, wow, I really enjoyed that. You know,
- 14:33it's not always this case that you have that kind of raw enjoyment of your
- 14:35own designs, which sounds a bit wrong maybe, but I don't know anyway,
- 14:39So that was it. We pitched a Desson in twenty nineteen and AG
- 14:43signed it very quickly actually, and we had the pleasure of working with Josh
- 14:48Wood from Age, who was the developer on the game, and he's designed
- 14:52games like Cat Lady and Chappette. What's the Japan game, Let's go to
- 15:01Japan? Yes, just look, And he'sent in Santa Monica, which I
- 15:05think is an underrated gem. I would if you haven't played Santa Monica,
- 15:07I really recommended anyway. He's fantastic, and I think he he poured so
- 15:13many so much time and expertise into developing the game, really developing the maps,
- 15:18which is kind of you know, we had a few that were already
- 15:20kind of there, but we didn't have six and he really helped with that
- 15:24and a lot of the kind of production and you know, graphic design and
- 15:28and sort of guiding all that. So actually it was a very it was
- 15:33a collaborative process. We felt part of it, certainly, but it was
- 15:37you know, again, it was a really good fit. And and we
- 15:39had another person in Josh, bringing a new skill set and just really just
- 15:43just playing it a bunch, you know, which is really handy as well
- 15:46to kind of iron out all those you know, thirty six cards to different
- 15:50powers, making sure they're all interesting. And I think he did an amazing
- 15:52job because you hear people say consistently when they finished the game, they feel
- 15:56like, oh, I had these three cards, they are amazing that like,
- 15:58how how could this be balanced? And they look over at someone else's
- 16:02cards like that also saves really good So it's sort of to manage that I
- 16:07think speaks to his dedication in work in developing the game. So on that,
- 16:11then I guess we should talk a little bit about what the game is,
- 16:15So Brett, can you give us a sort of a pracie of what
- 16:18Guild Emerged Explorers is there? I mean, it is a sort of flipping
- 16:22right made flesh, and you start with an empty map and it's played over
- 16:26for eras, and in each era you get to explore a little bit,
- 16:32and the first era is shorter, and it gets longer and longer, and
- 16:34you get more and more abilities. Essentially each there's one moment in each round
- 16:37where you get a fresh new card, and it they're big cards which then
- 16:42get activated then and in later rounds, and as you grow you get to
- 16:47spider your way out. But at the end of each era, all of
- 16:51your explorers come home, so you know you're going to have to start again.
- 16:55But there is an opportunity within the system to build all the villages,
- 16:57which gives you little jumping off points later on, so you can begin to
- 17:02explore, and the corners of the map feel a long way away at the
- 17:04beginning, but in the last round often you can spend the entire map,
- 17:08and all the while you're gaining coins and you're kind of you're doing You're competing
- 17:11little missions to get points, lots of little victories all the way along the
- 17:15way. But the biggest difference between that and the more traditional different right is
- 17:21this history of the idea that there is something something can remain on the map
- 17:23when it's wiped clean and give you another jumping off point, and that that
- 17:30kind of cycle. New players get to see it really quickly because the first
- 17:33round is really short, and as soon as you get given one of these
- 17:37cards, you're like, oh wow, you know, suddenly the world has
- 17:38opened up to me. And it's it's all in that growth and that acceleration
- 17:44that's having what people really love about it. And so it's been out in
- 17:49English for a while now, a couple of years. What was the initial
- 17:56reaction to the game on its initial printing and were you about month? Yeah?
- 18:03I think actually the reaction was really good. I think it came out
- 18:07sort of like twenty twenty two tailor twenty two or may it started twenty three.
- 18:11It was a bit in that kind of kind of COVID post COVID sort
- 18:15of dell uge of games. I think it got lost a little bit in
- 18:18that shuffle, But the reaction initially was really good. I remember a lot
- 18:22of reviewers, you know, I can't remember many negative things about about the
- 18:26game play actually, and I know it. I think it sold out reasonably
- 18:30quickly. I think there was a period where it wasn't available in the US
- 18:33for quite some time, which in some ways might have kind of hurt its
- 18:37kind of longevity because you know, once you know, if the hype is
- 18:41there, but you can't And I mean it's not Age's fault. It's a
- 18:45perennial problem for publishers to try and solve how to meet demand in a timely
- 18:48fashion, and like post COVID, which is kind of crazy, like the
- 18:53logistics. So I think actually the reaction was really good, and you see
- 18:57that now, you know, when people hear that it's been nominated, you
- 19:02know, people sort of come out of the the cob, you know,
- 19:06the from the shadows and sort of go like, yeah, it's a bit
- 19:11of a hidden gem for them. You know, they really feel like they're
- 19:12glad that it's getting kind of this second chance that people sort of know about
- 19:17it, because yeah, maybe it kind of not that it was not well
- 19:21received, but maybe a bit of a victim to just you know, there's
- 19:23just a lot of games these days. I'd so Brett tell us about your
- 19:29Spielder's Yarrus announcement morning. So, first, did you expect did you expect
- 19:36the Guild Emotional Explorers would be nominated. And secondly, were you there with
- 19:41baited breath waiting for the announcement or are you too cool to care about it?
- 19:45No, I'm not too cool for that. I did actually watch the
- 19:48live stream of them of the announcement, which is quite a long drawn out
- 19:52of fair. I mean, they wanted to make me in a bit,
- 19:55and they had lots of talk about mostly in German, of course, and
- 19:57I didn't expect Guild. Actually it was the first one that came up out
- 20:03for the Kennish building another game of Ours Prey another day by audition Shieldvisor.
- 20:07I think we both secretly harbored maybe a hope that you know, that could
- 20:11get a Field a spiel nod rather than a Kenish bill nod. I'm really
- 20:15annoyed because I've been saying for a year, indeed, that is a guaranteed
- 20:18nomination for the Shielders. It was on the long list. You were already
- 20:23there. You should have spoke louder for longer. And so when the first
- 20:27game that came up was not that was in Guild, it was like,
- 20:30oh, okay, well that's I mean, maybe you were going to get
- 20:33two nominations, you know what I mean. But it was No, it
- 20:37was exciting, of course, because it's fantastic to get that recognition, Absolutely
- 20:41amazing, and it's it was it was a surprise. It was a surprise.
- 20:48So to be surprised like that, I'm not too cool for that.
- 20:52It was fun. And Matt, you were obviously in Australia when the announcement
- 20:56was made. Were you awake or I did actually in the morning to text
- 21:00messages. I'm not that cool. I did actually watch the live stream as
- 21:04well. It was like, I don't know what the time was, maybe
- 21:07midnight or something like that here or one am. I mean, I have
- 21:11a five month three year old daughter at the moment, so sleep is you
- 21:15know, like it's not necessarily that it's interrupting my sleep. And yeah,
- 21:21I mean it's very exactly what Brett was saying that, Yeah, we had
- 21:26really thought pray another day, and I should say this is not you know,
- 21:29not just as a kind people like yourself and even the publisher. I
- 21:32think, like you know, of course knowing that you know, you've never
- 21:34predicted, but that sort of seen that I think I had had a very
- 21:38small inkling because I saw Harold Sharper's maybe I putched this last name Apologies had
- 21:47put a review, I think on the website sometime late last year, and
- 21:52seeing that he liked it through the translate, so I was like, Okay,
- 21:56at least it seems to be on the at least it was on the
- 21:57radar. But even so, like it is a bit of a surprise for
- 22:03a game that yeah, I think, yeah, as described it, Well,
- 22:06it's just a very weird because I think we were really I was really
- 22:10disappointed about Pray because I think that I think we knew that first, or
- 22:12at least we knew it wasn't on the long list, so it was like,
- 22:17oh, you know, it's that weird sense of like, oh,
- 22:18you know, another year, I thought we had a chance, but you
- 22:21know, and then just like in the wake of that, getting the nomination,
- 22:25so it was sort of this really weird and I walked in and took
- 22:27to my wife, who was also up, and I led I sort of
- 22:33suffered our you know, Pray Another Day didn't get nominated, and she was
- 22:36like, oh, okay, well you know that's how it is. I
- 22:37was like, oh, but we got nominated for Guild and Virtual Explorers,
- 22:41so yeah, it's a it's a funny. It was yeah, it was
- 22:45a funny like I mean, it's a sort of a what is it like?
- 22:49I can't argue with good fortune to you know sort of you know,
- 22:53have these expectations and somehow be filled even even when you sort of missed the
- 22:57mark the first guest, Uh, yeah, there was. It was a
- 23:00really nice It was a really nice time. We even texted each other I
- 23:03think around the time in with the time zoning. Yeah, it was.
- 23:07It was nice, nice moment. So, Bratt, I assume you've spoken
- 23:10with a G post the nomination. What what effect does the nomination had on
- 23:17the game? Has it revitalized it, has it had a second life?
- 23:21I think that's yet to be proven. It is too soon, I think,
- 23:22And I mean with that, I think until the award is actually announced,
- 23:26and if we were to win, of course, that would be a
- 23:30very different situation. I mean, without being too a pessimistic, the Kennish
- 23:37Bild and the Spiel nominations do not have the same weight as each other.
- 23:42And a Spiel nomination obviously is you know, is fantastic, and a Spiel
- 23:47went would be incredible because that's what every publisher is chasing. The Kennish field
- 23:52is definitely like second fiddle to the field, and a nomination of the spield
- 23:56of the Kennish build isn't probably an enough because for example, Elysium was nominated
- 24:02for the Kennish Bill and had it one, I think that would have pushed
- 24:03it forward and it would have, you know, still had its life today,
- 24:07but or perhaps have had a longer life for sure, But I don't
- 24:11it's it's I don't think it's enough, unfortunately, just to be nominated.
- 24:15Of course, it's fantastic, and it gives it a longer life than it
- 24:18would have had and puts in people's kind of minds, and maybe it means
- 24:22later it can have it can have a rebirth. You know, there can
- 24:25be a moment later when this game, one of those games can can rearrive
- 24:29I suppose and have a second wind. But I'm not without taking anything away
- 24:33from the Kennish Field Field jury, It's like, I don't think that nomination
- 24:37on its own is enough. So as yet to be proven, I guess,
- 24:40so fingers crossed, we shall see. The only thing I would say
- 24:44to Canada slightly is I think you know it's a bit different when you know
- 24:48age is obviously not a non German publisher, a North American publisher. I
- 24:52think for Scaleague, who is the German publisher of the Gildmest Explorers, like,
- 24:59I think that I think there will be an impact for them. I
- 25:00think they announced story that they they've ordered a reprint. I'm not sure whether
- 25:06they had sort of I don't know exactly the timing of, but it might
- 25:10give it a bit more legs in Germany. I mean, yeah, it
- 25:11might not translate to to over the you know, in kind of the English
- 25:15speaking world. And also I think the game being older kind of affects that
- 25:19a little bit as well. But definitely the next station last year, you
- 25:22know, you know, you see it in the sales figures like it.
- 25:26It's still a nomination has a big impact even if you don't win. But
- 25:30yeah, I think you just we sound a bit sort of what is it,
- 25:33jaded old and jaded, but it's it's a really different. It's just
- 25:38it's it's tough to get a game to survive or to you know, and
- 25:41especially to have a game sort of fall off and then come back is even
- 25:45less sort of likely. So I think we're you know, obviously really appreciative
- 25:49of the like the recognition is amazing, but I you know, we're yeah,
- 25:53cautious whether we think it'll will translate into huge sets. So I was
- 26:03with you, Matt last year at the Schield's RAS Awards ceremony, and I
- 26:04was I was surprised at the grace that you showed in not winning. I'd
- 26:11have I'd have smashed the room up probably. I mean, you're not going
- 26:17to get any more if you smash through. This is true. I would
- 26:21have plaid to see that. So, so what are your expectations for the
- 26:26award do you expect to win? I mean, you're up against You're up
- 26:30against Matt Leecock, who is you know, a bit a big, a
- 26:37big name in games. I mean, what are your expectations? Sure?
- 26:41So, uh, it's funny you mentioned that I'm going to wait until I
- 26:47kind of get there. I remember last year sort of being a bit like,
- 26:52oh, who knows, maybe there's a chance, And the moment I
- 26:53got there, it was just obvious Doorformatic would win, for instance, because
- 26:56you kind of get the sense of what's going on in the German world.
- 27:02And I'm not sure if the same will happen this time, where you'll get
- 27:06a very quick sort of re orientation as to because that it still is a
- 27:11German award and it's still is kind of reflective of what you know. I'm
- 27:14sure then you're you're much more plugged into that tonight. And it's interesting this
- 27:18year. I mean interesting that certainly a Matthew will definitely win the Kennish Bill
- 27:21at least, which is as But it's a funny year because it's the games
- 27:30I think are so different for the Kennish Bill, like they kind of fit
- 27:33into different things you might want to recognize. I think our game is Other
- 27:37people said, I agree. I think it's a bit like the Safe Choice
- 27:40in that it's probably the closest to what a traditional Kennish Bill would be,
- 27:45I guess, And it's not going to be, you know, so out
- 27:48of the realm of introducing it to you know, German families in that realm.
- 27:52But you know, it's not maybe not as daring as some of the
- 27:56other games. Obviously Ticket to Right Legacy, as it is such an accomplishment,
- 28:00and obviously then there's a downside to that because you know, it's a
- 28:03bigger and more expensive game. Maybe it's a bit more to ask of people.
- 28:06And then you have Daybreak or Emission, which I think is an incredible
- 28:10achievement for just being able to combine, you know, mechanisms, Like it's
- 28:15really like the power of games to kind of deliver a message, if you
- 28:19will, like it puts you in really in the thing and to kind of
- 28:23feel it in regards to climate change. And we both know Matteo who's at
- 28:29the co designer of Daybreak, and I think just the kind of achievement of
- 28:33being able to like make that game and to make it fun and enjoyable,
- 28:37you know, like that's that's part of that. So it's sort of like
- 28:41depending I think this is kind of interesting because I think it's sort of it's
- 28:45not like a I don't think it's a comparative choice. I don't think you
- 28:49sort of go like it's this game versus this game, and I have this
- 28:52game tips, you know, pips this one. It's what do you want
- 28:56to recognize? I guess, like what do you want the AWA to kind
- 29:00of represent? And I think for each of the games, I think there's
- 29:02a strong argument. And and actually at that point I'm not I'm probably not
- 29:07that confident, but I think I'll be happy with whatever they choose because you
- 29:11know, there's I don't think there's any choice. You would go like,
- 29:12oh, that's ridiculous, or you know, i'd hope that. Yeah.
- 29:17I think I think the juries, I think actually they've made a good job
- 29:18of like the three nomination is a good set. I mean, I'll say
- 29:21that because I'm obviously part of it. But I think it's a good you
- 29:23know, like a good sort of like set of games to recognize. I
- 29:27think. And so Brett Matthew is going to the award ceremony. He's he's
- 29:34traveling to Europe from Australia. You're you're currently sat in Cambridge, which is
- 29:41which is comparatively Its a long way, isn't it? This is true?
- 29:45So why have you decided not to attend the ceremony? Well, I I
- 29:52mean at some part of me doesn't want to. I suppose not because I
- 29:55don't I'm not thankful for denomination. It's just I don't know. It's it's
- 30:00a it's a tricky thing to be part of, I mean, because part
- 30:03of it is putting yourself out there and you're kind of you're arright, And
- 30:06matt has more experience of this now than I do. But and you're geared
- 30:10up for either the accolade or the disappointment, and both of those would be
- 30:15I mean, they're both challenging. I guess I don't know. I think
- 30:17I'm very happy. I am quite a home body, just fundamentally, I
- 30:21am my own body. So it's I'm very happy. I will be very
- 30:25happy if the game wins. I'll be very happy. I'd be very I
- 30:26won't be particularly surprised if it doesn't. I think, I mean, there
- 30:30are matters articulates are really well, actually better than I would have done a
- 30:33good job. But I think it is a really interesting set of three games.
- 30:36Sometimes people look at the lists and they go, what are they on?
- 30:38What are they on this year? But I think they are different,
- 30:41and it's not an apples for apples thing. It's very much, well,
- 30:45you have to there's a sort of yeah, you can having a really strong
- 30:48opinion about which game should win, and they're all right kind of thing,
- 30:53and all of them will be perfectly strong choices. And but fundamentally games like
- 31:00culture and art is political, I mean, as they should be their political
- 31:03objects. And there is there is an aspect to the to the climate change
- 31:07game, which I think is really strong, and if it wins, if
- 31:11it only won for that reason, that would still be a good enough reason,
- 31:14because I think it's an important I think it is important that it exists.
- 31:18And games aren't just about fun, not necessarily, you know, they
- 31:22have other purposes and they can represent other points of view, and that's all
- 31:27good. So I would be unsurprised if we lost. But I don't know.
- 31:34And maybe, I mean, I was surprised there was nominated, so
- 31:38maybe it will surprised us again. I mean, and going back to the
- 31:41earlier point, I was actually signific I was genuinely surprised by how well received
- 31:45it was online. I mean, we always set out to make a good
- 31:48game, of course, and you want to make a game that you enjoy,
- 31:52and you want to put into it stuff that you like and make a
- 31:56good product. But you can never tell. It is a very crowded market,
- 32:01very fickle audience. And it's done. It seems to have been received
- 32:06much better than that I would have anticipated. In terms of like pinning a
- 32:09number like a BGD rating onto it, I would not have chosen seven points,
- 32:13and he's at seven point seven at the moment. It wasn't ten point
- 32:15eight. To me, that's a really that's a pretty creditable achievement actually for
- 32:19a game in its class. So it clearly does have something in it,
- 32:22more than perhaps I could have seen when it was you know, beforehand.
- 32:25So who knows, maybe the Germans will embrace it. So just to wrap
- 32:30up, then you've you've given over your time to me quite charitably. So
- 32:35here is the part of the interview where you get to shamelessly plug what you
- 32:37got coming up. So we'll start with Matthew, then go to Brett.
- 32:40What can we expect from you in the future. Well, I think firstly
- 32:44you should expect I'll take a large cardboard cutout of Breath to the ceremony so
- 32:47that you know he's still present, and said, I'll have the official photograph
- 32:52up on the stage with our certificate lists exactly. Well as we said,
- 32:59Teresa's already we already plugged ourselves. Like you see what we did? You
- 33:02didn't, I mean, marketing is is life. So here we are,
- 33:08okay, So yeah, True Society will be out at gen Con. The
- 33:13I'll have some copies or at essen. And for me, actually, I
- 33:20had this company, Postmark Games. We do print at home games and very
- 33:22soon we're going to have a kickstart of a new Phil Walker harding game from
- 33:29Joey Games, which is going to be about be about rescuing Koala's. So
- 33:34stay tuned in July on kickstart of August. Sorry, sorry July for that.
- 33:39I think that's I've probably got other things, but did prepare for the
- 33:44same shameless but plugging. I'm afraid you go, Brett Craikey. I mean
- 33:52there's a there are no I know better what this is the problem exactly.
- 33:57Being a marketer is a very different skill from being a game designer. I
- 34:01mean a game that I was really pleased with that came out a couple of
- 34:05years ago was the team addition of Labyrinth, which I was asked by Robinsburger
- 34:08to work on over the Pandemic, which was a kind of great pandemic project
- 34:15because I'd work in it on my own sat, you know, on my
- 34:19carpet, because it couldn't go out. And beyond that, there's going to
- 34:23be there was another a Labyrinth property, let's say, another game within the
- 34:28Labyrinth space, which was a game I pitched Robinsburger many years ago actually,
- 34:31which sat on there to do the shelf I think, and they've plucked it
- 34:36off that shelf. I'm not entirely sure it's going to be cool, but
- 34:37it will be under the Labyrinth brand. There's going to be a smaller box,
- 34:40like a speed kind of game, and I'm actually really excited about that
- 34:44because it's it's it sounds like they're going to do another beautiful job with the
- 34:47production. It's going to have really blovely dice and like little tiles and you
- 34:52place them onto a board to try and connect things. I mean, it's
- 34:54very simple, but I am a very simple person and I like fast thing.
- 35:02I like fast things. I like shiny objects, so it's nice to
- 35:06have. I don't know, I think those kind of games are ones.
- 35:08I will you know when I see that. I was really pleased when that
- 35:12Brth send up. I think they did such a good job with it.
- 35:15And Tree Society is a good example of a game that has spanned our entire
- 35:19kind of design career. And it is hard to be excited about a game
- 35:22after ten years, partly because you're a different person, you know what I
- 35:27mean, You're a different person. So it's nice to see new things or
- 35:30pressure things come through. And I think I have changed as a designer,
- 35:34Like the kind of things, the kind of games that I'm excited about has
- 35:37changed, of course, I mean, of course it has, so it's
- 35:40always the next one. Anyway. It is a when you're good or when
- 35:45you're productive and you've put the hours in and you do have lots of games
- 35:49published. Of course that's fantastic, but it is hard to be excited about
- 35:52the games after they're done. It's much more exciting to work on the new
- 35:57stuff. The process is what makes being a design another fun part. I
- 36:00think waiting for a box to turn up it's fantastic and I should be more
- 36:05excited about it, but it's it has lost its edge slightly. The next
- 36:12thing is always the thing you work, you know, the new thing is
- 36:14always the thinking most excited about. This feels like the kind of Academy award
- 36:19for a lifetime achievement or something. Brett excellent, Well, Brett Gilbert,
- 36:27Matthew Dunstan, thank you very much for your time. Thank you, Ben,
- 36:30thank you for having us. You can support the show by going to
- 36:34Patreon, dot com, Forward slash five. G Ford, thank you for listening.