Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: CNOOC production, Scottish nukes, and Piper Alpha book
Transcript
- 0:01Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:08the UK energy market. Seenox, dwindling output,
- 0:12nuclear in Scotland and a book all on Piper Alpha.
- 0:16That's a lot to talk about if you're just me.
- 0:18Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, but thankfully I'm joined
- 0:21by my crack team of Co hosts. Erica Asklyn, News editor How
- 0:26are you doing this week? Great.
- 0:28I love being in the studio. I think, you know, the more we
- 0:31get to hang out together and record this together, the
- 0:33better. Do you know that's a good point?
- 0:35If you're listening to this on your podcast platform of choice,
- 0:38which is completely valid, you can be watching this on video if
- 0:42you want. We are in our studio in Aberdeen
- 0:45where you can also see the lovely face of news reporter
- 0:49Matt Perry. How are you doing this week?
- 0:51Well, I'm just really in need of a haircut.
- 0:52So I'm a bit disappointed that we're on a video this week.
- 0:55But I'm also happy to be back up in Aberdeen because I was down
- 0:58South during this this heat wave.
- 1:00And I will give the English and the Welsh credit.
- 1:04A lot of people in Australia make fun of the British when
- 1:06they talk about a heat wave and we say oh, heat wave, we deal
- 1:08with that weather for three months.
- 1:10The key factor is we deal with it with a lot of air
- 1:12conditioning though. So I am quite happy to be back
- 1:15up in Aberdeen where a heat wave is 1920°.
- 1:19I. Think it's about the threshold
- 1:21for evidence in. Heat scorchio at 15° here in
- 1:24Aberdeen. Positively tropical, you know
- 1:26that that makes me build upon appointment.
- 1:29We're recording this on the day that E Forward hosted an event
- 1:32in our offices in Aberdeen, hence why you're up here.
- 1:35Ed Reed, E Forward editor, spoke about, you know, is is it time
- 1:39that government stops focusing on data centres and more on on
- 1:43air conditioning? Do you think that's a valid
- 1:45point? Well, yeah, absolutely.
- 1:47I I'm very pro air conditioner. So yes, please get them
- 1:50everywhere. Fair enough, fair enough.
- 1:53But to get onto the actual topic of today, I didn't have a smooth
- 1:56Segway for that. It's just, you know, 'cause I
- 1:58said maybe, let's see, let's hope we're going.
- 2:00To talk about the weather sometime, right?
- 2:03Let's hope the let's hope the the weather, the temperature
- 2:07here in Scotland and the wider UK comes crashing down a bit
- 2:11like the production figures. It's been Speaking of weather
- 2:15drops. Yeah, no, Seanock put out their
- 2:18accounts. Well, Seanock's North Sea
- 2:20subsidiary put out their accounts for 2025 up to 31st of
- 2:24December this week and it wasn't great.
- 2:26Reading friend of the podcast Ashley Kelty from Pan Willabarum
- 2:30described it as gloomy. Basically the the headline is
- 2:34that it's 90% their their profits in the North Sea are
- 2:38down production largely from a fall in production.
- 2:42I think there's about 25% across the North Sea assets, which is
- 2:46Buzzard, Golden Eagle and the Scott area.
- 2:49I think the Scott actually saw a little bit of a bump in
- 2:51production, but Buzzard, which is the largest producing oil and
- 2:55gas field in the the UKCS was down 40% I believe roughly.
- 2:59So you know, I tried to get in touch with seen up to our
- 3:02similar what's going on there. They weren't really forthcoming
- 3:05with with imagine. That let's.
- 3:06Just say they're pretty crap actually with explaining what's
- 3:09going on and telling people what's going on and being, you
- 3:13know, kind of transparent. We have to rely on historic data
- 3:18like those in accounts filed a company's house.
- 3:21Thank you for the UK's financial transparency regulations on that
- 3:26one. But I guess it does, because
- 3:28obviously one of the big stories last year involving Scenic and
- 3:32Buzzard was that they confirmed that they won't be going ahead
- 3:34with electrification on the platform.
- 3:37And I guess looking at these accounts, you can probably see
- 3:40why if reduction is down 40%, you know where what's the
- 3:45incentive to spend billions of pounds on on electrifying this
- 3:48asset? Are you just going to kind of
- 3:50keep it humming along while the while the resources dwindle?
- 3:53But you know, Kelty kind of said that not looking great in terms
- 3:59of kind of their portfolio because alongside foreign
- 4:01productions is arising their their D com costs by about I
- 4:05think a rough 15%. I don't have the exact figures
- 4:07to hand, but also the parent company, the holding company for
- 4:11the North Sea wing increase in lodging impairment.
- 4:15So they kind of not rosy reading for for Scenic.
- 4:21But I guess Kelty made the point that, you know, unlike maybe
- 4:26some of the other operators, because Scenic is state owned,
- 4:29that there's potentially, you know, still geopolitical reasons
- 4:31for them to be in the UK. This, we're having a foothold
- 4:34print here, you know, access to to UK policy makers,
- 4:38politicians, that sort of thing is maybe enough of an incentive
- 4:41for CNOP to, to keep its investments going in the UK.
- 4:43But certainly you'd think that, you know, given what the wider
- 4:47industry is talking about in terms of the, the, the EPL,
- 4:51yeah. Did they say anything about APL
- 4:54in the accounts? As well.
- 4:56Nothing in there. No, it was really just a
- 4:57straight down the line kind of numbers on their their earnings.
- 5:00But it's, yeah, you'd think that if it was a rosier picture in
- 5:06terms of the fiscal regulatory environment that they might be
- 5:09looking to. Yeah, we've seen from the likes
- 5:12of, I remember a few years ago a presentation from Mitch Flegg,
- 5:18formerly of Sarika, who kind of displayed that just because an
- 5:23asset is, is dwindling, you can't, there's things you can do
- 5:26to to increase production. You can hum it along like, but
- 5:29obviously CNOC is either not able to or not willing to make
- 5:33those sorts of investments into Buzzards production at the
- 5:37moment at least. Who knows, it could be could
- 5:39come back in 2026 and everything's turned around.
- 5:40It might have been down to maintenance outages.
- 5:42They they weren't really willing to say, but it's yeah, not not.
- 5:47I guess, I guess, you know, maybe to try and be the
- 5:50optimist, which who feels like an uncomfortable position for me
- 5:53to be in of all things is, is there is this maybe, you know,
- 5:58an opportunity for them in the sense that we we look at the
- 6:02direction of travel for oil and gas in the UK and you know,
- 6:06you're speaking about increasing production in Cerica is the the
- 6:09poster child of that be it, You know, they've quickly gone from
- 6:12being sort of one of the smaller players to one of the bigger
- 6:14players in the North Sea. And you could argue that's
- 6:16because all the big guys have taken their ball and gone home.
- 6:19But at the end of the day, they have managed to sort of deliver
- 6:23increased production and with the way the UK is going, that's
- 6:28the only way that we're going to increase, we're going to get any
- 6:31sort of gains in oil and gas is through tie backs and ensuring
- 6:34that existing assets bump up their production levels.
- 6:37Do we see that as a potential gain for them?
- 6:40Do we see maybe Buzzard and and Co maybe sort of go reassessing?
- 6:45Or is this a case of maybe we see yet another sale on the
- 6:49cards? Well, I mean, yeah, I hate to
- 6:52kind of just keep repeating what what Kelty's thoughts, but he is
- 6:55a man who knows what he's talking about.
- 6:57He and he said that he was, in his opinion, he's sure that
- 6:59Seenup would love to sell their assets, but who's buying an
- 7:02ageing portfolio really and in this current environment?
- 7:05And I think it's one of those things where if the EPL was
- 7:09reformed in the way that the industry has been calling for,
- 7:11if some other kind of certainty was given around tiebacks and
- 7:15you know, Rosebank and Jackdaw got the go ahead and there is a
- 7:18bit more optimism and enthusiasm, investor confidence
- 7:22as as the industry loves to talk about then then sure.
- 7:25I'm sure with a huge asset like that, Buzzard and Golden Eagle,
- 7:29I'm sure there are opportunities that they've identified, but I
- 7:33mean don't necessarily really see it happening in the current
- 7:35kind of state. The important thing here though,
- 7:38to note in particular is that if they were maybe making a little
- 7:43bit more money, as you say, had a bit fairer wind under their
- 7:47wings, then you know, they could have pressed ahead or wouldn't
- 7:51have hesitated to press ahead. With electrification.
- 7:54Which we know is probably one of the key requirements that the
- 8:00people who are developing Greenville, the UK's flagship
- 8:05floating offshore wind scheme, that everyone needs to have
- 8:09happen in order for this industry to get up off the
- 8:13ground. It would be a lot clearer if
- 8:16Canuck were performing a lot better, but this is a problem.
- 8:19Yeah. I mean, yeah, we've got to
- 8:20remember the Green Vault one, it's it's leased through the the
- 8:24in TOG process, you know, predominantly the TOG process,
- 8:29the target oil and gas and they don't have an oil and gas asset
- 8:32target anymore. But you know, they have got CFDS
- 8:36for you know, bringing power to shore to, to hook up to the
- 8:39grid. So I mean there is a bit of
- 8:41uncertainty around that. But then at the same time, let's
- 8:44face it, the, the Scottish Government have plowed so much,
- 8:48you know, into, into Greenville in terms of, you know, sort of
- 8:52in terms of showing their their direction of travel with the,
- 8:56with the offshore wind. I feel like that projects
- 8:58probably not going to be allowed to fail.
- 9:00Maybe. But where's, where's it going to
- 9:03go? I mean, like, how is it going
- 9:05to, you know, where's it going to export its energy too?
- 9:09And who's going to pay for it? I mean, maybe it doesn't matter.
- 9:12I think that's I think it's, I think it will probably probably
- 9:14be secure looking to secure more CFDS to to cover its power going
- 9:18to shore rather than for an asset.
- 9:20But then what we've also got to remember is electrification is a
- 9:23long and expensive process. It's a lot of retrofitting.
- 9:27It's a lot of yeah, it's it's, yeah, it costs a lot of money.
- 9:31And that's something that, you know, the, the NSTACEO Stuart
- 9:34Payne has been all for as electrification.
- 9:37But, you know, developers in the North Sea, you know, have been
- 9:40saying for for years now that this is not, this is not
- 9:45something that's cheap or easy to deliver.
- 9:47So I don't know, it's not just the NSTA.
- 9:49They've, you know, the industry committed to this as part of the
- 9:51North Sea transition deal. So, you know, they've, they've
- 9:54made commitments back in 2021 and I know that we live in a
- 9:56very different world to how many?
- 9:58Prime ministers ago was that that was before it.
- 10:00Was Johnson. Deal.
- 10:01Wasn't it? How many energy crises has?
- 10:03Been since then. But but those commitments were
- 10:05made and I guess it will be not a great look for an industry
- 10:09that's trying to secure, you know, political backing across
- 10:12wider society. You know, there is this ongoing
- 10:16debate if they start to back away from the electrification
- 10:20commitments on mass, you know, there's a lot to be said about
- 10:24maintaining that social license to operate.
- 10:26And I think electrification is one of those key things that
- 10:29they've committed to alongside methane reduction that will be
- 10:32something to keep an eye on in terms of how the industry
- 10:34performs and kind of demonstrates to wider society
- 10:39that they, they should be able to keep operating.
- 10:41Because see that a lot of people in Aberdeen, you know, firmly of
- 10:45the opinion that the industry should be going, but they're not
- 10:48the only people that vote in the UK.
- 10:49I'm sure UK energy policy would be very different if the people
- 10:52in Aberdeen with anyone's allowed to vote.
- 10:54That's true. We have.
- 10:55Different in the the Aberdeen S elections and how that really
- 10:58did sort of show maybe support probably guess in the same, but
- 11:02that's not to be a you know, that's to be expected.
- 11:04Sorry, but I think that does wrap up this segment.
- 11:07But please do stick around because there wasn't a in future
- 11:11weeks. We will probably be coming back
- 11:12to this I'm sure, but stick around because after the break
- 11:15we're speaking about nukes in Scotland.
- 11:19Hey guys, guess what? What is it, Erica?
- 11:22Energy Voice is on WhatsApp. Well, is that what's been making
- 11:25my phone buzz all? Day it really is.
- 11:27I mean, I can't stop buzzing about this.
- 11:30It's a great way to get the latest updates from Energy Voice
- 11:34because anytime the latest story hits a site, it's out on
- 11:39WhatsApp and then you get to find out what's going on.
- 11:42And that that makes a lot of sense because I mean, let's face
- 11:44it, that's how everyone shares their newses and you text it to
- 11:46your pals, you WhatsApp it to your pals.
- 11:48So your pals at Energy Policy are making sure that they're
- 11:50whatsapping you with the latest headlines.
- 11:57You know, we ended the last segment speaking about political
- 12:00consensus in Scotland and the the idea that, yeah, the
- 12:03Aberdeen S election, the Tories are saying that that's mandate
- 12:07for for more oil and gas based on how how the the people of
- 12:11Aberdeen S voted. However, something that we're
- 12:13still yet to get political consensus on in Scotland is
- 12:17nuclear. We've we've seen in the past
- 12:19that, you know, SN people or is there, you know, maybe open to
- 12:22the idea, but the SNP aren't the last nuclear power station in
- 12:27Scotland. Hunterston is looking to to wrap
- 12:29things up by the end of the decade.
- 12:31Erica, you've been looking at a Scottish, Sorry, a UK.
- 12:35Government. Yeah, Yeah.
- 12:36No, it's Torness. Torness.
- 12:38Lies. Yeah, that's OK, that's OK.
- 12:41I've I've got the notes here right on my thigh, so it's all
- 12:43good but so here's what's going on though.
- 12:48So yes, you're right. SNP are dead set against
- 12:51nuclear, new nuclear in Scotland, although, you know, in
- 12:54the rest of the UK, you know, the UK government, Ed Miliband
- 13:00has called for a nuclear golden era in England.
- 13:05You know, they're pressing ahead with Sizewell C in Suffolk and
- 13:10then of course they're also planning to install a bunch of
- 13:13small modular reactors in Wilfa in Wales.
- 13:17And then of course for that, you're seeing a huge jobs boom,
- 13:22you know, lots kind of investment going in because as
- 13:25we know, nuclear is really eye wateringly expensive.
- 13:29And that's a good way for, you know, kind of contractors to get
- 13:32certainty because they have certainty that these are kind of
- 13:36up and running in the next 1020, thirty years.
- 13:38Who knows, they'll take a long time to build too.
- 13:41But for the current status, the Scotland ain't going to have
- 13:46none. And as you said, Torness is
- 13:49going to be mothballed come 20-30 and that would be the last
- 13:55nuclear production facility going in Scotland.
- 13:57But then comes Ed Miliband, you know, he's up here at Peterhead
- 14:02saying Oh no, no, no, no, you know what, you Scots, you need
- 14:05some nuclear. And So what he did is he
- 14:07commissioned GB Energy nuclear, the division to do a report
- 14:11saying which would be the good sites in Scotland to establish
- 14:15new nuclear. So where do you think they are?
- 14:17Where do? I think, well, you mentioned
- 14:19Peterhead, so I'm going to say Peterhead.
- 14:20Well, see. But then surely you know, yeah,
- 14:23I mentioned, I wrongfully mentioned understand, but also
- 14:26Tornas surely if we're going to decommission, you know, I've
- 14:29heard, I've heard EDF or previously makes signals that
- 14:34they would be open to the idea of an SMR there.
- 14:37Of course they would. However, here's, here's a
- 14:40question for you. I'm going to put, I'm going to
- 14:41answer your question with a question is SMR or SMR is the
- 14:45really the, the, the right approach, you know, because
- 14:47let's face it, economies of scale are so important,
- 14:50especially when it's something that's expensive.
- 14:52And I was, I was in Germany just a few weeks ago and I was
- 14:55speaking to some folks over there about nuclear and an
- 14:58interesting point was raised about no nuclear projects ever
- 15:02been delivered without masses of government investment.
- 15:06Is it right to be going for SMRS?
- 15:07So maybe maybe we should be looking at you talked about.
- 15:10Economies of scale, that's pretty much the, the main
- 15:13argument about SMRS is that if you can, you know, modularize
- 15:16them and create a factory, you know, production line approach
- 15:19to building them, that that will bring costs down.
- 15:21Obviously, no one's actually really done that yet.
- 15:24And the key kind of fact of that is that you can't just commit to
- 15:27building 1 SMR. You've got to have a suite of them 678, so
- 15:33they can get that certainty and they can get that production
- 15:36line going. That's the theory is that it
- 15:39will bring down costs in that way and it will just, you know,
- 15:41rinse, repeat. Because one of the main things
- 15:43that drives up costs is that, you know, the UK will take a
- 15:46tried and tested design from EDF in France and make 3000 planning
- 15:50changes to it. And that, you know, in the same
- 15:53way as high speed HSR 2 and then all the high speed rail bumps
- 15:57the costs up. But yeah, that's kind of the
- 15:58argument behind SMRS is that. No, I get that.
- 16:01But you know, at the end of the day, if we're going to, if we're
- 16:03going to scale up the production of nuclear, why keep on the
- 16:06small side rather than the large side is kind of the the argument
- 16:10against, right? Yeah.
- 16:11Well, I think it's just, you know, it's very difficult to
- 16:13build it in a factory. If you're looking to build a one
- 16:16GW reactor, you kind of just have to build that on site,
- 16:19whereas you can build those smaller modules in the same way,
- 16:22you know, and just truck at the site and.
- 16:25Build it. But we did derail you.
- 16:27Sorry. I I suggest that I suggest that
- 16:30a handful of sites in. Scotland.
- 16:31Where are they? Where is where is Dan McGrail?
- 16:35'S drum roll please. Drum roll please, I've only got
- 16:37one hand, I can be one side. There we go.
- 16:41Lovely. Thank you.
- 16:41You should. Probably have not done that out
- 16:43of frame for the guys watching that might.
- 16:46Have looked it would probably be terrible for sound.
- 16:48But anyway, anyway, so as you can almost expect, I mean like
- 16:52it would have made no sense not to consider these sites which
- 16:56are Torness in East Lothian, June Ray, you know, up in Cape
- 17:02Ness, of course, you know, that's where you know there.
- 17:05The nuclear facility there has long been decommissioned, but I
- 17:08think they're moving fuel out. Of it, is it there also some pH
- 17:12there and by that I mean pumps the rich hydro isn't doing Ray
- 17:14also the site for for some of that?
- 17:16No, am I talking I'm talking I'm talking pH.
- 17:21See that joke? There we go.
- 17:22Another one is Hunterston. You were out there not too long
- 17:25ago in Air Shore. You did a feature on the history
- 17:28of that. It was was being yes, but so
- 17:32these are the obvious ones for where you want to go.
- 17:35I went. For the easy ones.
- 17:36See, but then other sites which they kind of just hinted at that
- 17:41they think might be useful for it.
- 17:43So hang on for this. So this is Firth of 4th estuary
- 17:48on the five site, right Sterling, so we can get some
- 17:53nukes in a kind of maybe right next to the Wallace monument.
- 17:55I think that would go really well.
- 17:56Oh, I'm sure I'm. Sure, I'm sure the the the
- 18:00nature nature folks will be all. For them, well, see, here's the
- 18:03thing about wanting SMRS in your backyard.
- 18:06No one wants them yet as far as we can tell.
- 18:08And then of course, they think that maybe we should get some in
- 18:13Angus and the Aberdeenshire coast because of course, they're
- 18:17saying, well, you know, there's a lot of like oil and gas
- 18:20workers there. You know, if they work with
- 18:21energy, they could probably, you know, handle this kind of stuff.
- 18:24But, you know, I think there's still a lot of people would go,
- 18:28excuse me, we're going to build nuclear where?
- 18:31So I mean, but this is still the thing.
- 18:33This is like the one the report that Ed Miliband commissioned
- 18:38and you know, which they said it's a very technical thing.
- 18:41These are just like technical points.
- 18:43But of course, you know, kind of like the SNP is still about no,
- 18:48absolutely not. And it's too expensive.
- 18:50You say you don't like is technical points, but you know,
- 18:52Michael Shanks, who's an energy minister within Desna is that
- 18:56you know, is Scott is Scottish based.
- 18:58I think around Glasgow is where his his constituency is.
- 19:01He's all he he came out with some slightly more punchy words,
- 19:05right. He was he was sort of saying
- 19:06that that was it there. There's no reason not to was
- 19:09that was that what you said? I can't remember there was a
- 19:11quote in your headline from, from Michael Shanks that was a
- 19:15bit a bit punchy on on exactly that.
- 19:18Now don't quote me on the no reason not to.
- 19:20I will go and look that up while you're, yeah.
- 19:22Yeah, yeah, I know. I don't know.
- 19:23What you know there, there is kind of.
- 19:25That there is there. Is that growing divide?
- 19:27Between. North and South isn't there that
- 19:29yeah, Ed Miliband and Co are all for it and maybe the the SNP
- 19:33are. Not well.
- 19:34And the Lib Dems in Scotland have actually said that they
- 19:37would probably think a little bit about it, you know, and I
- 19:40don't know what that policy then fits them with the kind of like
- 19:43UK Lib Dems. But you know, there seems to be
- 19:46greater consensus building across nuclear in Scotland.
- 19:50I know, right? Who knew?
- 19:52But that said, could it be Matt that maybe some of these SMRS?
- 20:00That may or may not be built in Scotland, be built by Poland's
- 20:04richest man. Potentially, yes.
- 20:06So you're talking before Ryan about whether it should be, with
- 20:08so much government expenditure reliant on nuclear.
- 20:12We've actually heard this morning that a Warsaw based firm
- 20:16called SGE, which is owned and founded by Poland's richest man,
- 20:21who, forgive me if I get the pronunciation wrong, Australians
- 20:23have a terrible track record of butchering Polish surnames.
- 20:26But Mikhail Sollivov, I believe he has submitted plans under the
- 20:31UK's advanced nuclear framework to build a 4.2 GW fleet of GE
- 20:36van Nova Hitachi small modular reactors.
- 20:39And they reckon that'll cost in total about 35, £5 billion and
- 20:44about two to 3 billion of that roughly at the moment.
- 20:46It has to be CapEx expenditure. And essentially kind of what
- 20:51they want to do is take 3 or so sites across the UK, start with
- 20:56six at the first one and then, you know, they want to build
- 21:00these all across. They wouldn't say where exactly.
- 21:02They just said that two of them are privately owned sites, one
- 21:05that they're negotiating with the government on and they see a
- 21:09role for sort of contracts for different styles, scheme and
- 21:13involvement of the national wealth fund.
- 21:15So I asked him, you know, when you say contracts for different
- 21:17national wealth fund, what does that mean?
- 21:19They said that's all still to be determined.
- 21:21It could look like an equity stake.
- 21:22And you know, kind of lots of discussions going along there
- 21:24with the national wealth fund. We've seen those sorts of
- 21:26investments happen already. But yeah, really interesting
- 21:31company that is looking to do similar things all across
- 21:35Central Eastern Europe. They've got, you know, plans.
- 21:37They've partnered with All In, which is Poland state owned oil
- 21:40and gas operator. Look at building Smis across
- 21:42Poland. They've got similar ambitions
- 21:45across the likes of Hungary, Bulgaria, Lithuania and now the
- 21:49UK and they said they're pretty keen.
- 21:50They see the UK as being the, you know, they've got the best
- 21:53nuclear workforce in Europe and good solid policy environment
- 21:58and backing so well. It sounds like they think that
- 22:02the UK's nuclear policies makes it pretty bankable, or else they
- 22:08wouldn't have. Been and they described it as a
- 22:09privately financed, commercially LED investment.
- 22:11So, you know, that's, I guess we're seeing particularly with
- 22:14this boom in electricity demand from data centers, you know,
- 22:17we've seen the likes of Microsoft and Google and Amazon,
- 22:20Facebook, you know, looking at investing in fusion companies
- 22:23and other kind of AMR and SMR startups.
- 22:26And so there's, I believe that, you know, I've sort of did a bit
- 22:30of Googling on on Solovov because I've not heard of him
- 22:31before. I don't keep tracks on Polish
- 22:33Poland's rich list, but he's been quite outspoken recently.
- 22:37He owns a few, you know, chemical industry firms.
- 22:40Maybe he's kind of like the Ineos, Sir.
- 22:47Jim Ratcliffe. Jim Ratcliffe How could yes, and
- 22:49how can we? Forget.
- 22:50Collins, Sir Jim Ratcliffe is, he's got a lot of, you know,
- 22:53industrial companies that he owned and he's complaining
- 22:55about, you know, industry being destroyed by high energy prices.
- 22:58So obviously he sees SMRS as a solution.
- 23:01It's interesting that he's gone with, I believe SGE is going to
- 23:05have been an investor development partner with GE
- 23:07Hitachi because they were involved in the UK's SMR
- 23:12competition, which Rolls Royce SMR ended up winning.
- 23:15They're the ones that won, you know, the three government
- 23:18backed. Ones in into the UK.
- 23:20Yeah, so this is I guess the, I don't know if we could describe
- 23:24it as a consolation prize. 14 of them seems like a pretty big,
- 23:27big, big prize to be had. But yeah, so it's it's not as if
- 23:31these companies have packed up their bags as well.
- 23:33If you if we didn't win, we don't want you anymore.
- 23:35They still see the UK. They may not have won the prize
- 23:38of the government backed 3 reactors as Rolls Royce did, but
- 23:43they still see the UK and Europe as somewhere they want to
- 23:46deploy. So I guess this chat about SMRS
- 23:49and who wants to have them in their backyard certainly is not
- 23:51going to be going away. Because I mean we've also seen
- 23:53the likes of Centrica and X Energy they want.
- 23:56They've got their sights set on Hartlepool.
- 23:59So it's certainly looking like it's not just the government,
- 24:04it's the, you know, private, private investors are interested
- 24:07in this as well. So again, a lot of questions
- 24:10over, as you said, Ryan, the kind of economics of small
- 24:14modular reactors. Do they make sense?
- 24:16No one really knows because it hasn't been done.
- 24:18There's also questions that our colleague Jess has been been
- 24:21parking into around the nuclear waste because there's a lots of
- 24:25sort of early evidence that shows that they are, they
- 24:27produce more waste than conventional reactors.
- 24:29So lots of environmental questions there, but it's it's a
- 24:33topic that won't be going away. I'm sure certainly not, but
- 24:35there is obviously high potential to use Michael
- 24:38Shanks's words, not, no reason not to, but pretty much the same
- 24:42thing. There's a high potential for a
- 24:44nuclear in Scotland and the conversation will keep on going.
- 24:47But that is all the time we've got for this, this segment.
- 24:51But stick around because we are looking at offshore.
- 24:54What's next for the Energy Transition?
- 24:57Joined PINS and Masons and E Forward on July 7th for Inside
- 25:00the Energy Transition, exploring insights from nearly 1000
- 25:04investors and technology developers worldwide.
- 25:07Yeah. Expert views on investment
- 25:09trends, evolving energy markets, and the path to net zero.
- 25:13Find all the details on the Energy, Voice and E Forward
- 25:16LinkedIn page. So, yeah, we're this week we're
- 25:19going to be looking at the, the Piper Alpha anniversary.
- 25:23It's 38 years since the, the, the North Sea and the oil and
- 25:26gas industry's largest disaster. Obviously we all know the story.
- 25:30167 men lost their lives, you know, went out there and never
- 25:34came home. And that that took place
- 25:38throughout the night of the 6th of July into the 7th.
- 25:41And I've been speaking to Shane Gorman, who's involved with the
- 25:45pain for paper trust, but he's, he's got a, he's got a very
- 25:49close personal connection to, to the disaster as he lost his
- 25:54father that night. And a really, really sort of the
- 26:00interesting thing for him from a, from an outside perspective,
- 26:03he'd, he just went to, to join the army.
- 26:07He just went to the to do basic training And he, he sorry, ended
- 26:13up being rushed back, back home to Edinburgh When, when he, you
- 26:17know, was told that there was a disaster.
- 26:19It was an incident on the, on the, the platform.
- 26:22But he's written a book, sorry about his, his personal
- 26:27connection to the disaster. And he's now sort of dedicated
- 26:30his life to safety in the North Sea, much like his dad did.
- 26:33Actually, we'll get into that in a little bit too.
- 26:35But he, yeah, he's, he's been quite outspoken throughout his
- 26:39career about safety in the North Sea and he's sort of committed
- 26:42his thoughts to the page, about 150 pages.
- 26:44He tried to keep it super accessible and super snappy for
- 26:48anyone across the industry or further afield that would be
- 26:51interested. But Erica, yeah, you.
- 26:54Well, you know, it's, we had come to this somber universe,
- 26:57somber anniversary, you know, every year.
- 27:01And we are moving ahead to the memorial surface at Head coming
- 27:08up on Monday. And yeah, I mean, it, you've
- 27:13been there a number of times. And I I have also attended the
- 27:17surface and it, it, it is a lovely memorial.
- 27:21And I'm, you know, the garden that, you know, has been
- 27:24designed specifically to host, you know, this beautiful statue
- 27:28that, you know, memorializes, you know, the people that lost
- 27:33offshore in the disaster, You know, it's just quite touching.
- 27:39So, yeah, you know, it's an important thing, I think, for
- 27:42the industry and the people of the Northeast.
- 27:45Yeah, So if you if you're listening to this on the Friday
- 27:47that it goes out that this episode goes out the the
- 27:50following Monday on the 6th at 1:00 PM in Hazlehead Park at the
- 27:54North Sea Memorial Gardens. That's when the the reading of
- 27:57the 167 names and the the service will take place.
- 28:01And it'll be the first time that a new, a new chaplain is a new
- 28:05oil and gas chaplain will, will look, look after that service.
- 28:09Michael Mayer has done it in the past couple of years.
- 28:11We've got a new interim chaplain coming in for the oil and gas
- 28:15chaplain see just now. And so, yeah, it's, it's, it's
- 28:19always a touching moment. It's always a moment for the
- 28:22industry to get together. And this is the first time in a
- 28:24couple of years that it's being held on a weekday.
- 28:27It'll be interesting to see sort of how that impacts attendance
- 28:30numbers. And obviously it's not, it's not
- 28:34quote, UN quote big anniversary like sort of 35 years, 40 years
- 28:37and a couple of times. Or whatever reason A5 or zero
- 28:40makes things more. Important.
- 28:41But on the other hand, it's still important.
- 28:43But you know, you ask Piper Alpha survivor and pound for
- 28:47Piper boss Steve Ray about it. Well, you know, he, he speaks
- 28:51about how it doesn't matter what the attendance numbers is, It
- 28:54doesn't matter what the anniversary is.
- 28:55It's important for the industry to remember and to give the give
- 28:59a space for those people who lost loved ones or those people
- 29:02who were, who were out there or, you know, have spent time
- 29:06offshore to, to remember those that we've lost.
- 29:08And I. Think it's really commendable
- 29:09that people like Steve Ray and others involved in that memorial
- 29:14service do keep that conversation going because we
- 29:16know it led to a sort of a fundamental shift in how the oil
- 29:20and gas sector operates in the real culture of safety.
- 29:22But it's also, you know, we get constant reminders covering
- 29:25energy sector like we do that it is still can be a dangerous
- 29:28industry to work. And we just saw, you know, that
- 29:30the helicopter crash in Saudi Arabia, there's been a few
- 29:33incidents we've been covering on on Belarus rigs of of people
- 29:36getting hurt. And so it is, you know, that's
- 29:39something that sort of, I guess it's commendable that people do
- 29:42keep that conversation about safety and the the impact it has
- 29:45on on families and lives, because it's not just about
- 29:48operations and and it's, it's the people that work on and the
- 29:51industry needs to keep making sure that they are as safe as
- 29:54they possibly can be. And that's what Shane is
- 29:56speaking about in his book. You know, that's, you know, the
- 30:00through the flames is the, the name of the book that's coming
- 30:03out. I'm going to the launch event
- 30:04tonight on Thursday. So by the time this, this
- 30:06episode goes out, you will be able to get your hands on a
- 30:09physical copy. You can already get it on Kindle
- 30:11if you if you so please. And it's, you know, he, he
- 30:15speaks about his dad's role in the industry, David Gorman and
- 30:19about how he was he was a safety officer on the Piper Alpha.
- 30:24And he spoke about how his dad had this, this, this philosophy
- 30:29around safety, about how he used to always wear this particular
- 30:33sticker on the back of his hard hat that said speak to other
- 30:36side. And he spoke about how how
- 30:40throughout his career, he's worn that exact same sticker on the
- 30:44back of his hat. Ever since he pivoted careers,
- 30:47he's, he's went from being in the Army.
- 30:49As I said, you know, he was doing basic training and he
- 30:53discovered that that, yeah, he'd heard that there was a safety
- 30:56incident and he was told you should go back up to Edinburgh
- 31:00and find out what, you know, you know, find out what's going on.
- 31:03And so he, he said that the first time he found out that,
- 31:08you know, what the accident was, he was said, he said, you know,
- 31:11there's he always heard his dad speaking about incidents.
- 31:14But you know, the first time he found out what had happened was
- 31:17he was waiting in the train station and saw on the front
- 31:20page of all the the papers what had happened.
- 31:22But he's, he's kind of he's. Did his dad survive?
- 31:26No, his dad, he lost his dad in that incident.
- 31:29And that's, that's why today is such a big day, the, the 2nd of
- 31:34July, because that was the, that's the anniversary of the
- 31:36last day he saw his dad before he went to, to off to the Army
- 31:41for training. But he's kind of tried to
- 31:43continue that philosophy of the speak to other side.
- 31:47You know, throughout his career, he's pivoted from finance in
- 31:50Edinburgh off to, you know, sort of being, being a labourer
- 31:54offshore. And then sort of now he's a
- 31:55safety officer, like his dad before him.
- 31:57And, you know, he's, he's speaking with Step Change and
- 32:00Safety, the trade body that focuses on safety and the North
- 32:03Sea and globally in the oil and gas sector, about sort of using
- 32:08that phrase as is a means to sort of drive safety.
- 32:12Because his dad was around that time when, you know, he said
- 32:17that it was quite commonplace for folks to say to the safety
- 32:20officer on a platform, hey, why don't you head off to your
- 32:22office because what we're doing, it's a bit dodgy.
- 32:25We don't, you know, but we need to get, we need to get it done.
- 32:29And his dad was a big, a big advocate for saying, well, hold
- 32:32on a minute. If you need to do this, if
- 32:34you're being told this is a task that needs to be done, why don't
- 32:36we have a conversation rather than just telling me bugger off
- 32:39to your office So you don't need to see this.
- 32:41We can have a conversation about it and make sure it's done in
- 32:43the safest manner. That's something that he's been
- 32:46continuing. That's something that the book
- 32:47was trying to to focus on. Well, as I think Matt touched
- 32:52on, testimony is really important.
- 32:56And of course, you know Steve Ray really well.
- 32:58And, you know, I've heard him speak a number of times.
- 33:02And every time you see someone like Steve talk about their
- 33:07experience, how it all went down, you know, what happened
- 33:11really, you know, important things.
- 33:14It almost feels like the room becomes, you know, electric.
- 33:18Everyone, you know, starts being emotionally affected by just,
- 33:24you know, the, you know, vast necessity to kind of think about
- 33:30actually what's important here. And, you know, that's the safety
- 33:33of people. The people that are out there
- 33:35come back safely. So, yeah.
- 33:37And you know, that testimony is so instructive, it makes it
- 33:41brings it home. No, exactly.
- 33:43And you know, it's not just it's not just Steve Joe Medan also
- 33:45survived the the disaster and he also does a talk.
- 33:48I'm I'm yet to actually hear that one.
- 33:50I've heard Joe's and I've heard Stevens even and there's always
- 33:54this, there's this moment and that really every time it really
- 33:58hits me and I don't know why is this moment in particular, you
- 34:01know, because he goes through in in Steve's talk.
- 34:04He starts at, you know, landing on the platform for the last
- 34:08time to, you know, being back at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
- 34:12But there's this one moment in the talk that not to ruin
- 34:15Steve's talk, and I do, I do encourage anyone who's not heard
- 34:19it to make sure they get to it because it is, it is very
- 34:22poignant. But there's this moment in it
- 34:23where Steve speaks about how, you know, he's he's, you know,
- 34:29been on this vessel that he was sort of picked up from after
- 34:31jumping from, from the platform. He's been collected.
- 34:36And, you know, there's helicopters going back and forth
- 34:38from from the North Sea to Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, and
- 34:43they're sort of triaging because there's, you know, as many
- 34:46people coming back. And so essentially he says that
- 34:50there's this nurse that goes, you're walking wounded, so
- 34:52you're fine. You need to step to the side
- 34:54because there's so many more coming.
- 34:56And Steve had to tell the nurse, no, there's not.
- 34:59You know, I'm the last helicopter back.
- 35:02I think that really shows the vastness of the, of the, of the,
- 35:08the incident. Obviously, we, we remember 167
- 35:12men lost their lives and they're all their names are engraved at
- 35:14that statue at the Hazelhed Park at the North Sea Memorial
- 35:18Gardens that you, you mentioned at the top of this segment,
- 35:20Erica. But, you know, I don't know why
- 35:23that moment always kind of sticks in my throat a little
- 35:26bit. I always get, you know, it's,
- 35:28it's it's always a point that you kind of realize that at the
- 35:32time they, they didn't, you know, at the time, they didn't
- 35:34remember it as Piper Alpha. It was, you know, it was
- 35:37something that was so, so fresh. And it's something that still is
- 35:41very fresh for so many people. So, you know, it's something
- 35:45we'll remember going forward. It's something that the industry
- 35:48needs to remember going forward. And it's something that not to
- 35:51turn this into an ad for Shane's book, but genuinely, I will be
- 35:54picking up a copy and I will be reading it.
- 35:56I think it's, it's important to do so and you know, it's
- 36:00important to remember this. And I really hope that I see
- 36:03people that have listened to this podcast at the at the
- 36:07memorial service on Monday, because I'll be going for the
- 36:09the 5th year on the bands and we'll be we'll be covering on
- 36:13energy voice too. But I think that that does it.
- 36:16It's a bit of a sombre way to end the end the episode.
- 36:19But yeah, thank you, Erica and Matt, for for joining me this
- 36:22week and thank you very much for listening.
- 36:24If you'd like to stay up to date with all things energy, well,
- 36:27there's only one place to be and that's energyvoice.com.
- 36:29And we'll see you same time, same place next week.