Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / Why Your First Idea Is Rarely Your Best Idea at Work
Transcript
- Lucas: You know that moment in a meeting where someone pitches an idea, and it lands kind of flat, and then ten minutes later someone says basically the same thing and everyone acts like it's genius? Luna: Oh, that happens to me at least once a month. And it's infuriating because you want to say, hey, I just said that. Lucas: Right, and sometimes you genuinely did say it. But here's the thing — it might not just be the idea itself. It might be when you said it. There's a well-studied cognitive bias called the serial position effect, and it's been showing up in workplace settings in ways most people don't realize. Luna: The serial position effect — that's the one about how you remember the first and last items in a list better than the middle, right? Lucas: That's the classic version from memory experiments — the primacy effect and the recency effect. But there's a newer twist researchers have been looking at: how the order of ideas in a meeting affects not just memory, but perceived quality and credibility. A 2024 study out of Carnegie Mellon looked at this specifically in brainstorming contexts. Luna: What did they find? Lucas: They ran a series of experiments where groups generated ideas for a real business problem — cutting costs in a manufacturing process. Ideas were presented one at a time in random order, but the researchers controlled the sequence. What they found was that ideas presented first in the sequence were rated significantly lower on a scale of creativity and feasibility than identical ideas presented third or fourth. Luna: Wait — identical ideas? So the exact same idea was penalized just for being first? Lucas: Exactly. Because when an idea comes first, the listeners haven't established a context yet. They don't have a baseline to compare against. So the first idea feels tentative, maybe obvious. But by the time the third idea rolls around, people have a framework, and that same idea feels like a refinement or a clever synthesis. Luna: So the order is essentially creating an anchoring effect, but in reverse — the first idea gets anchored as the baseline, which makes it seem less impressive, while later ideas look like improvements. Lucas: Yes. And the researchers called this the 'serial position penalty for novelty.' They also found that the effect was stronger when the ideas were more complex — so if you're pitching something genuinely new, going first is almost the worst possible play. Luna: That's pretty counterintuitive because most of us are taught to speak up early in meetings to show initiative and get credit. Lucas: And there is some value in being seen as engaged. But if your primary goal is to get your idea adopted, the data says you should hold back. Let one or two other people throw out something — even if it's close to your idea — and then you come in and build on it or reframe it. Suddenly you're the person who moved the conversation forward, not the person who started it. Luna: But what if someone else says your exact idea and takes all the credit? Then you've lost. Lucas: That's the risk. So the strategy isn't to stay silent forever — it's to be deliberate about your slot. If you can, volunteer to go third or fourth in a round-robin. And if you're forced to go first, you can mitigate the penalty by framing your idea as a starting point, not a finished proposal. Something like, 'Here's a rough direction — I'm curious what others would add.' That way you invite the refinement that usually boosts later ideas. Luna: I've seen this play out in practice. At a previous job, a product manager suggested a pricing change in the first five minutes of a meeting and got completely ignored. Three weeks later, a consultant suggested the exact same change and everyone thought it was brilliant. The PM was livid. Lucas: And the consultant probably didn't even know they were benefiting from the serial position effect. They just happened to be in a later slot. I've got a case from a SaaS company — I won't name them — where a product team was trying to decide on a new feature prioritization framework. The first proposal was a simple weighted scoring model. It got polite nods and then silence. The second proposal was more complex, but people pushed back on the complexity. Then a third person proposed what was essentially the same weighted scoring model, but framed as a hybrid that combined the simplicity of the first idea with some elements of the second. That third proposal got adopted unanimously. Luna: So the third person basically repackaged the first idea with a small twist and got all the credit. Lucas: Exactly. And the first person probably walked away thinking their idea was weak. But it wasn't. It was just early. Luna: Honestly, if this episode was worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's how we keep the show ad-free and independent. Lucas: Yeah, listener support really does make a difference. Even a single coffee helps us keep diving into these research-backed strategies. Luna: And it means a lot that you're willing to chip in. So thank you. Lucas: Alright, back to the serial position effect. One interesting nuance from the Carnegie Mellon study: the penalty for going first was even stronger when the group had a dominant personality who spoke first. People unconsciously deferred to that person's framing, so any idea that came later but was similar got a boost because it seemed like a refinement of the dominant person's thought. Luna: That's a perverse incentive — if you're in a meeting with a loud boss, your best move might be to let them speak first and then echo them back with a small tweak. Lucas: It sounds cynical, but it works. The key is that the tweak has to be genuine. If you just parrot them, people will see through it. But if you listen, find a gap in their thinking, and then offer something that builds on it, you're seen as adding value. Luna: Does the effect hold in written contexts? Like if you're submitting ideas asynchronously on a shared doc? Lucas: That's a great question. The research suggests the effect is weaker in writing because people can scroll back and compare. But there's still a recency effect — the last idea in a written list often gets more attention because it's fresh. So if you're contributing to a doc, being toward the end might help, especially if you summarize and synthesize earlier points. Luna: So the practical takeaway for me is: in verbal meetings, don't rush to be first unless you have a strong reason. Aim for slot three or four. And if you're stuck going first, frame it as a rough draft. Lucas: Exactly. And one more thing — the study also found that ideas presented with a concrete example or analogy outperformed abstract ideas at any position. So even if you're in a good slot, make your idea vivid. Luna: That reminds me of a story about a designer who wanted to pitch a new onboarding flow. Instead of just describing it, she showed a quick sketch and said 'like Airbnb's but for our data.' That tiny analogy made it stick. Lucas: And she probably didn't go first. She let the product manager and engineer share their thoughts, then she dropped that analogy. Classic move. Luna: I think the deeper lesson here is that office politics isn't just about who you know — it's about when you speak. Lucas: Absolutely. Timing is a form of strategy. And the serial position effect gives us a research-backed way to think about that timing. Next time you're in a meeting, try holding back just one turn and see what happens. Luna: I'm going to try it. And I'll let you know if I get credit for someone else's idea.