Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / The Hidden Cost of Your Internal Job Title
Transcript
- Lucas: Let’s talk about the silent killer of mid-career earnings: the internal lateral move. You see it all the time in tech and professional services. An employee stays at their company for three years, gets promoted from Senior Manager to Director, or maybe just shifts titles internally to stay fresh. The title looks better on LinkedIn, sure. But the paycheck? It barely budges. Luna: Right, because the company thinks they’ve already paid you what you’re worth by keeping you there. They don’t have to offer a market-rate jump if you’re already inside the building. Lucas: Exactly. And here is the brutal math. If you leave that same role externally, you might get a twenty percent bump just for switching vendors. But internally, you’re often capped by your existing salary band. I looked at some data from a large financial services firm this week. A VP moving to a different department saw a four percent increase. That’s it. Four percent. In a year where inflation has been sticky, that is effectively a pay cut in real terms. Luna: That feels like a betrayal of loyalty. You stay, you learn the systems, you build relationships, and then you get rewarded with a slightly fancier email signature. Lucas: It is a structural trap. Most companies have a rule: internal promotions cannot exceed a certain percentage, usually fifteen or twenty percent, regardless of market demand. So when the market jumps thirty percent, your internal raise is still stuck at fifteen. You are slowly being diluted. By year five, you could be making forty percent less than someone hired externally for the exact same role. Luna: So the incentive structure is literally telling people to leave if they want to grow. Why do companies allow this? Lucas: Because it’s cheaper for them. Retention is a metric they love. They’d rather keep you at a lower cost than lose you to a competitor who pays market rate. It’s a short-term balance sheet win that creates long-term talent drain. But here is the thing: you can break this if you know how to frame the conversation. Luna: I assume the standard 'I deserve more' pitch doesn't work when HR has a policy document saying otherwise. Lucas: It never does. You have to bypass the policy document and go straight to the value argument. The key is to treat the internal move as a new hire negotiation. You need to explicitly state that you are evaluating your total compensation against the current external market, not your historical internal salary. Luna: That sounds risky though. If you tell your boss you’re comparing yourself to external offers, aren’t you threatening to quit? Lucas: Not necessarily. You are signaling awareness. You say something like, 'I’m excited to take on this new scope. However, my research shows that roles with this level of responsibility in the current market command a base of one hundred and eighty thousand. My current band tops out at one hundred and sixty-five thousand.' You are presenting a fact, not a threat. Luna: So you’re forcing them to either match the market or admit they are underpaying you. That puts the ball in their court. Lucas: Precisely. And often, managers will push back and say, 'We can’t do that right now, but we’ll review it in six months.' That is the classic deflection. If they give you that answer, you need to ask for a written exception or a clear path to adjustment. Otherwise, you are walking into a two-year wait for a two percent raise. Luna: Writing it down is smart. It creates accountability. But what if the manager says, 'We just don’t have the budget'? Is that a hard no? Lucas: Budget is always soft. Budget is a choice. If they truly don’t have the budget, then you have to ask yourself: am I staying for the title, or am I staying for the money? Because those are rarely aligned anymore. If the title is enough, fine. But don’t let them trick you into thinking the title has monetary value it doesn’t actually hold. Luna: That’s a tough pill to swallow. We spend so much of our identity tied to our job titles. Lucas: And that’s the other side of the coin. Title inflation. Companies promote people to 'Senior Vice President' or 'Head of Strategy' to make them feel valued without spending a dime. I see it constantly. A 'Head of' title that used to manage ten people now manages zero direct reports. It’s just a badge. Luna: So you end up with a resume full of impressive titles but a bank account that hasn’t moved forward. That’s dangerous for future negotiations too. Lucas: It is. Because when you eventually do leave, the external recruiter sees 'Director' and assumes you are expensive. But if your salary history is flat, they might lowball you even harder, thinking you were stagnant. You have to be careful about what you put on your CV. Sometimes less title is more valuable if the compensation trajectory is steep. Luna: So prioritize the comp over the prestige? Even if the title sounds boring? Lucas: Absolutely. A 'Manager' role with high equity or a clear path to higher base pay is infinitely better than a 'Vice President' role with a frozen salary. The market respects the latter far more than the former. Luna: This makes me think about the rise of contract work. People leaving corporate jobs entirely to avoid these traps. Lucas: Yes, and that is a valid exit strategy. But it requires a different skill set. You become your own HR department. You negotiate every single engagement. There is no annual review cycle. Every quarter is a new negotiation. It’s freedom, but it’s also anxiety. Luna: Freedom with a price tag. I guess nobody gets off scot-free. Lucas: Nobody does. But understanding the game lets you play it better. If you stay, negotiate hard on the first internal move. Set the precedent. If you can’t, plan your exit strategically. Don’t wait until you’re forty-five and realize your title is worth more than your wallet. Luna: Or, as we said earlier, just leave. Sometimes the best way to get a raise is to walk out the door. Lucas: Always an option. And a powerful one. But only if you know your worth before you knock. Luna: Before we wrap up, I want to pause for a second and talk about how we keep this show running. We’ve helped you think through a lot of career moves and decisions lately, and honestly, the support from listeners like you is what keeps these episodes coming out daily. Lucas: It really is. A couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going. If you’ve gotten something out of the show, check out buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps cover the costs and keeps the ads off. Luna: No pressure at all, just a thank you if you can spare it. Anyway, back to the topic. Lucas: One final thought on the negotiation point. If you do decide to stay after that initial conversation, make sure you get the adjustment in writing. Not a vague promise. A written agreement on when and how your salary will align with the market. If they won’t write it down, they won’t pay it. Luna: Written agreements are the only things that matter in corporate law. Verbal promises evaporate when budgets get tight. Lucas: Exactly. So, next time you’re considering an internal move, ask yourself: am I buying a title, or am I investing in my income? The answer should dictate your next step. Luna: Smart question. And hopefully, one that leads to a bigger paycheck, not just a bigger business card. Lucas: Ideally both. But if you have to choose, pick the money. The title will follow eventually, but the compound interest on your savings starts now. Luna: There you go. Money talks, titles just shout. Lucas: Well said. Thanks for tuning in to Office Hours. Let us know which internal battles you’ve won or lost in the comments.