Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Handle a Difficult Performance Review
Transcript
- Lucas: We got a question this week from a marketing manager at a mid-size tech company. She's been in her role for about 18 months, consistently hitting her targets, and her last performance review came back as 'needs improvement.' She's frustrated and confused, and she's not sure whether she should push back or just take it. Luna: Oof, that's a tough spot. Especially when you feel like the rating doesn't match your output. Lucas: Yeah, and it's a pretty common situation — the numbers look fine, but there's something else going on. Today I want to walk through a three-step approach for handling a review that feels unfair or overly critical, without damaging your credibility. Luna: I think a lot of people's first instinct is to get defensive or argue. And that almost never ends well. Lucas: Exactly. So step one: don't react in the moment. Even if you're blindsided, your first job is to stay composed. Say something like, 'Thank you for this feedback. I want to take some time to reflect on what you've shared so I can have a more productive follow-up.' That buys you a day or two to process. Luna: And to figure out whether the feedback is actually about performance or about politics or miscommunication. Lucas: Right. Step two is to ask clarifying questions — but not in the meeting itself. In your follow-up, you want to get specific. For example: 'Can you point me to a specific project or decision that led to this rating?' or 'What would success look like in the next quarter?' This shifts the conversation from a subjective label to something actionable. Luna: Yeah, and if you've helped us think through a career move or workplace situation like this one, and you want to keep the show ad-free and listener-supported, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, but it helps us keep doing this. Lucas: Absolutely — we appreciate anyone who chips in. Okay, back to the review. Step three is to create a shared plan. After you understand the gap, propose a 30-day check-in with clear deliverables. That shows you're proactive and that you take the feedback seriously — whether you agree with it or not. Luna: One thing I'd add: don't fall into the trap of saying 'But I hit all my numbers.' It sounds like you're dismissing the feedback, even if you're right. Instead, say 'I understand the focus on, and I want to show improvement there while maintaining my performance on the metrics.' Lucas: That's smart. It acknowledges the critique without conceding that you were wrong. I also recommend documenting the conversation — send a brief email recap after your follow-up meeting: 'Thanks for meeting today. To confirm, my focus areas for the next 30 days are X, Y, and Z, and we'll check in on.' That creates a paper trail. Luna: And if the review is genuinely unfair — like the manager is playing favorites or has a grudge — that documentation becomes your evidence if you need to escalate to HR or find a new job. Lucas: Exactly. One more thing: don't let a single bad review define your trajectory. Research from the Society for Human Resource Management shows that nearly 60% of employees have received at least one piece of negative feedback they felt was unfair. And most of them recovered their standing within two review cycles — if they handled it well. Luna: So the key is to stay professional, stay curious, and stay focused on the future. Don't get stuck in the past. Lucas: Right. And if you have a question about a career challenge you're facing, send it in. We might cover it on a future episode.