Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringe Mini- We're going to go with follow up;
Transcript
- 0:00OK, Chelsea, I have a choice for you and I'm going to try to keep it as vague as possible.
- 0:05Do we want an AI episode?
- 0:07Do we want a follow up on a previous news article I've gone over?
- 0:12Or do we want?
- 0:14I just seem to see if I saved this one.
- 0:17I did not save it.
- 0:18Do we want AI or do we want a follow up?
- 0:20I want the one not saved. Damn it.
- 0:22I can find it real quick, actually.
- 0:25No, let's do the follow up. Damn it.
- 0:28Fine, just so you know, the one that I didn't save the title is Florida Bill
- 0:32would make it easier to kill bears on crack.
- 0:34But what? OK, no, let's do.
- 0:38No, no, no, that's we got to go this way.
- 0:40No, no, no. Damn it.
- 0:43OK, do you remember that school shooting that we covered was over a year ago now?
- 0:49Wait, school shooting?
- 0:50Yeah, and it was because the parents ended up getting charged with manslaughter
- 0:55associated with it.
- 0:56Vaguely. OK, well, this article will give you a bit of an update on it
- 1:02so that we can all follow along.
- 1:03Oh, wait, yeah, I do remember now.
- 1:05That was a while ago.
- 1:07Yeah, it might be even season one for us.
- 1:09Well, that source I wanted to use just isn't working for me.
- 1:12So we're just going to go with MSN article.
- 1:15This is a story by Nick Logan published on February 12th, 2024.
- 1:21Title, the mother of school shooter was convicted of manslaughter.
- 1:24What does this mean for other cases?
- 1:26A Michigan mother could face up to 60 years in prison
- 1:28after a jury convicted her on Tuesday on four counts of involuntary
- 1:32manslaughter after her teenage son killed four students in a school shooting in 2021.
- 1:37Prosecutors argued Michigan law compelled Jennifer Crumpley
- 1:40to prevent her then 15 year old son, Ethan, from harming others.
- 1:43And the jury in the case agreed.
- 1:45Now 17, Ethan is serving a life sentence after pleading guilty to murder
- 1:49and terrorism charges in October 2022.
- 1:52Jennifer Crumpley's conviction is a first of its kind verdict
- 1:55in the U.S. school shooting case, raising questions about the extent
- 1:58to which a parent can be held responsible for the criminal actions of their child.
- 2:01Legal experts say it could have broader implications
- 2:04for the U.S. criminal justice system.
- 2:06Short-faced criminal lawyer Michael Belotta believes
- 2:09the jury's manslaughter verdict was an overreach, saying he thought
- 2:12that the trial would have ended in a not guilty verdict or a hung jury.
- 2:16I have a problem with the legal concept of parents causing their children
- 2:19to commit crimes, try being bad parents, he said.
- 2:21And that's what I think this case represents.
- 2:23And that's the dangerous part.
- 2:25This isn't the first time in the U.S.
- 2:26that a parent has been charged with gun violence.
- 2:28The mother of a six year old boy in Virginia who took a nine millimeter
- 2:31semi-automatic handgun to school and shot his teacher last year
- 2:34serving a 21 month prison sentence on various felony firearm convictions.
- 2:38And she was sentenced separately in November to two years in prison.
- 2:41There's also the case of a father in Illinois who pleaded guilty last fall
- 2:45to seven counts of misdemeanor felony conduct for signing a state firearm
- 2:49owner identification card for his son, despite concerns about his behavior.
- 2:53His son was underage at the time, but he was legally allowed to possess
- 2:56the firearm three years later when he was accused of killing seven people
- 2:59in a mass shooting at a Fourth of July parade in 2022.
- 3:02In Jennifer Crumbley's case, prosecutors argued that even though she didn't
- 3:05pull the trigger, she stored the gun in ammunition in a negligent manner
- 3:09and should be held criminally responsible for the four deaths.
- 3:12Prosecutors also said her and her husband, New Ethan, was mentally
- 3:15in a downward spiral and posed a danger to others, yet allowed him
- 3:19access to firearms, including the nine millimeter pistol that purchased
- 3:22as his Christmas present, and that was used to kill his classmates.
- 3:26To testify in her own defense, saying her husband was responsible
- 3:28for securely storing firearms in the family home and that while her
- 3:32son had been anxious about getting into college and what he would do with his life,
- 3:36she did not think this problem merited seeing a psychiatrist.
- 3:40I think that's far enough to go.
- 3:41Please go read the article.
- 3:43I think there's a few things that it leaves out so far that we need to remember.
- 3:46The school told them repleted times.
- 3:49They were worried about this child.
- 3:50He needs therapy, which they said, no, fuck off.
- 3:53The day of the school shooting, the principal called and said, your kid
- 3:57can't be in school right now.
- 3:58We think he's a threat to others.
- 4:00They refused to come pick him up and told them that he needs to be in class that day.
- 4:04Right. Yeah.
- 4:05They were the one that bought him the gun.
- 4:07And when they heard there was a school shooting going on at his school,
- 4:11they texted the son, don't do it.
- 4:13Right. Yeah.
- 4:14I remember that now and I think they very clearly knew their son was going to do it.
- 4:20While there's some things that I think are obviously going to be out of your control,
- 4:24these are specifically negligent actions and even supplying a weapon knowing
- 4:33that there could potentially be a problem.
- 4:35Yeah. Knowing there's a problem.
- 4:37Yes. And I think it's important to remember, too.
- 4:40The parents like ran away and went into hiding after the shooting happened.
- 4:44And it took days to actually find them.
- 4:46They were trying to get into Canada to like run away.
- 4:49But we don't have guts in Canada.
- 4:51Well, we do, but not in the way of the United States.
- 4:53Well, they were trying to escape prosecution.
- 4:55But yeah, that's I thought we should do a follow up on that because it's been a long time since we talked about it.
- 5:00I found it very interesting.
- 5:02Sorry, mate. Did I miss it?
- 5:03Did they actually go to course?
- 5:05She has. Yeah.
- 5:06She was found guilty.
- 5:07She hasn't been sent.
- 5:08I'm serving. Oh, OK.
- 5:10So her son and husband both pled guilty.
- 5:13So they're in jail right now.
- 5:15She pled not guilty and was just found guilty.
- 5:18And now they have to do a sentencing.
- 5:19OK. But yeah, in cases where you are very clearly neglectful as a parent to the point where it drives a child to basically do this,
- 5:28you're going to be held responsible.
- 5:29And I think that's a reasonable approach.
- 5:31Yeah, I think especially when it comes to a minor.
- 5:33Yeah. And yeah, some philosophical things to think about in the next 48 hours.
- 5:38We'll see you on Friday.
- 5:40Let's stop. Bye.