Latest / Killer Destinations / 203. THE COUNTRY CLUB MURDERS: Ernest & Charlene Scherer - Pleasanton, CA 2008
Transcript
- 0:00[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Kathy with a K. And I'm Kathy with a C. And this is Killer Destinations.
- 0:09[SPEAKER_01]: Today's destination is Pleasanton, California.
- 0:12[SPEAKER_01]: Incorporated in eighteen ninety four with a current population of almost eighty thousand residents today the city is an upscale suburb of the San Francisco Bay Area.
- 0:23[SPEAKER_01]: The history of Pleasanton was largely shaped by its geographic location along the first transcontinental railroad.
- 0:30[SPEAKER_01]: Ranchers and thoroughbred course breeders were attracted to the favorable climate and abundance of water and were soon followed by dairy farms, hot fields and vineyards.
- 0:39[SPEAKER_01]: Today, Pleasanton enjoys a rich blend of historic turn of the century charm and a high quality of life and economic well-being desired by both residents and businesses.
- 0:49[SPEAKER_01]: It has been named one of the best places to live in California with a very low crime rate, high average income of a hundred and eighty six thousand dollars a year and it's status as a center for commerce and technology.
- 1:02[SPEAKER_01]: But in two thousand eight, two of Pleasanton's affluent residents learned that high end living and a low crime rate can't protect you from a killer.
- 1:17[SPEAKER_00]: It was March of, when the share children, twenty-nine-year-old Ernest III and twenty-four-year-old Katherine, along with family and friends, gathered to say goodbye to their parents, Ernest and Charlene.
- 1:31[SPEAKER_00]: Ernest was only sixty at the time of his death, and while he started out his career as an accountant, he made a lot of money as a real estate investor.
- 1:40[SPEAKER_00]: And he was also involved in politics.
- 1:43[SPEAKER_00]: In the eighties, he was a member of the San Ramone School Board, and San Ramone is the place where he and his wife Charlene originally raised their children, and they had moved to Pleasanton two years before their death.
- 1:57[SPEAKER_00]: Now Charlene was only fifty-seven at the time of her death, and she was a professor.
- 2:01[SPEAKER_00]: She spent thirty-one years, I think it was, as a professor at Cal State East Bay teaching accounting.
- 2:09[SPEAKER_00]: She was also a devout Mormon.
- 2:11[SPEAKER_00]: She worked very hard and tried to instill her values in her children as she was raising them.
- 2:18[SPEAKER_00]: What made this funeral even more tragic was the way Ernest and Charlene had died.
- 2:25[SPEAKER_00]: They were victims of homicide and at the time of their funeral, there were no suspects in the case.
- 2:31[SPEAKER_00]: and no one had any idea why anybody would want these two wonderful people dead.
- 2:38[SPEAKER_00]: The grizzly discovery of Ernest and Charlene took place a week before the funeral.
- 2:46[SPEAKER_00]: The share of parents were in the middle of planning a Hawaii trip and they were inviting each of their children and their grandchildren to join them in Hawaii.
- 2:56[SPEAKER_00]: and Catherine lived in Utah, Ernie lived in Southern California in a town called Braha, and they didn't get to spend as much time with their parents as they all would have liked.
- 3:07[SPEAKER_00]: So as the trip approached, Catherine tried getting in touch with her parents to solidify plans and nail everything down, but no one answered when she called.
- 3:17[SPEAKER_00]: So when this happened a number of times, Katherine got worried.
- 3:20[SPEAKER_00]: And so now we're in mid-March of two thousand eight, Katherine called the Castlewood Country Club where her parents lived.
- 3:27[SPEAKER_00]: They had a home right on the golf course where members of the Country Club and were generally well known in the community.
- 3:34[SPEAKER_00]: Katherine asked one of the employees to go to her parents house and check on them.
- 3:39[SPEAKER_00]: And when he did, he knocked on the door and there was no answer.
- 3:42[SPEAKER_00]: So they started walking the perimeter of the property and looked in a window when they saw Ernest lying face down in a pool of blood.
- 3:53[SPEAKER_00]: Immediately, nine one one was called.
- 4:00[SPEAKER_01]: According to court records, when first responders arrived, the first thing they did when they entered the house was they noticed the smell of decay.
- 4:08[SPEAKER_01]: Both Charlene and Ernest were in their pajamas, and it looked like they had suffered from blunt force trauma to their heads, as well as stab wounds all over their body.
- 4:16[SPEAKER_01]: So the first thing the detective needed to do was figure out when the sheriff parents had died.
- 4:21[SPEAKER_01]: So they said about looking at the newspapers and they looked at their mail and it videos from the entrance and exit gates for the country club and what they found was that on the night of March seventh, this was the very last time they were seen in public.
- 4:35[SPEAKER_01]: They had dinner at the country club and were seen on video surveillance leaving the country club.
- 4:40[SPEAKER_01]: And March seventh was also the last time they picked up their newspaper.
- 4:44[SPEAKER_01]: The medical examiner determined they had been bludgeoned and stabbed in their heads upper bodies and their throats and wrists had been slit as well.
- 4:53[SPEAKER_01]: The forensic pathologist, however, could not tell which of the couple was attacked first, but they did come close to confirming the March seventh date because they said by the time they had a chance to do the autopsy, the shares had been dead for twelve days.
- 5:08[SPEAKER_01]: And they got bodies about a week after they were taken to the morgue.
- 5:12[SPEAKER_01]: Now, Kath, breaking a town, Ernest had six blunt force injuries and six stab wounds.
- 5:20[SPEAKER_01]: Mom Charlene had twenty blunt force injuries and twelve stab wounds.
- 5:26[SPEAKER_00]: Kath, do you know if the coroner was able to determine if they were stabbed first or hit first?
- 5:32[SPEAKER_00]: Not that it was ever reported where I saw, so we don't know if they died from trauma or blood loss.
- 5:36[SPEAKER_01]: And the challenge with it is that sometimes California is the hardest one to get court records on, but there was nothing I saw published by the state or anything else I read or saw in video that they had actually made that determination.
- 5:48[SPEAKER_01]: When the detectives talked to the two share of children, they both said they had no idea as to who would want to kill their parents.
- 5:54[SPEAKER_01]: As Kathy said, they were very involved in the community known by many.
- 5:58[SPEAKER_01]: They had a very close circle of friends and had what was described as a very loving marriage.
- 6:03[SPEAKER_01]: Bloody Footprints were found near the bodies and throughout the house.
- 6:07[SPEAKER_01]: The house actually had been turned upside down and ransacked, but to the train and investigate if I realized that there were a lot of valuables still left in the house.
- 6:16[SPEAKER_01]: And then one of the places the bloody Footprints led was to a linen closet.
- 6:20[SPEAKER_01]: Now unlike the rest of the house that really had been kind of torn apart, the linen closet had been picked through as if somebody might have known something was being hidden there or something like that.
- 6:29[SPEAKER_01]: They didn't have to just pull everything out at once.
- 6:32[SPEAKER_01]: However, they did quickly rule out the possibility that Charlene had been the target of the murder, because she was very well-liked and very well respected at her job at Cal State East Bay, both by colleagues and students alike.
- 6:46[SPEAKER_01]: She also was active in a church, she volunteered at nonprofit organizations, and she loved bird watching.
- 6:52[SPEAKER_01]: Ernest, however, was a different story.
- 6:54[SPEAKER_01]: There were several aspects of his life that stood out to police as being a potential flashpoint for any harm that might come to him.
- 7:02[SPEAKER_01]: Police learned that Ernest Sherer was an avid recreational gambler.
- 7:07[SPEAKER_01]: Love to play poker would go to the casinos as often as he could, had poker games, not at his house because Mormon wife Charlene did not approve.
- 7:15[SPEAKER_01]: She would not allow the gambling nor the drinking in their house, but it also turned out according to Ernest's friends that he liked to brag about how much he was winning and flashed a water cash.
- 7:25[SPEAKER_00]: I think being a poker player would be very difficult.
- 7:28[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, absolutely.
- 7:29[SPEAKER_00]: My son loves poker and he used to be in like a Sunday night poker thing when he lived at his old place, but he's very conservative by nature.
- 7:38[SPEAKER_00]: So once he started losing, he was done.
- 7:40[SPEAKER_01]: Do you remember when we went to the best lake a few years ago?
- 7:42[SPEAKER_01]: We all started playing poker.
- 7:43[SPEAKER_01]: It was leading us all in poker.
- 7:44[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 7:45[SPEAKER_00]: I try to bluff and I'm terrible.
- 7:49[SPEAKER_00]: I could not play poker.
- 7:51[SPEAKER_00]: I could not.
- 7:51[SPEAKER_01]: It's really good at bluffing.
- 7:52[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 7:52[SPEAKER_01]: You can't read his face.
- 7:53[SPEAKER_00]: My brothers are good poker player too.
- 7:55[SPEAKER_00]: My mom loved playing poker.
- 7:58[SPEAKER_00]: Many of my childhood memories involved being awakened late at night by my parents and their friends.
- 8:04[SPEAKER_00]: Ha ha, yuckin it up in the, you know, in the kitchen.
- 8:06[SPEAKER_00]: And then if I had to come in to like get a glass of water, they'd be like,
- 8:12[SPEAKER_00]: Poker chips the next day when I woke up we're all over the table and yeah they totally love playing like penny poker.
- 8:18[SPEAKER_01]: Detectives uncovered that the morning that Ernest died, he had actually won big at a local casino, which, of course, led them to think did somebody see him win was he flash in his cash and causing a scene and did they follow him home and do kind of a home invasion to get this money.
- 8:33[SPEAKER_01]: That was kind of their working theory until they had a chance to go in and look at the bedroom.
- 8:38[SPEAKER_01]: And on the bedroom floor was a pair of men's jeans that had hundred dollar bills sticking out of the pockets.
- 8:45[SPEAKER_01]: And obviously hadn't been taken.
- 8:46[SPEAKER_01]: So if somebody was looking for cash, they missed it.
- 8:48[SPEAKER_00]: They were looking very hard.
- 8:49[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 8:50[SPEAKER_01]: And so crime scene text actually gathered up all the money and it totaled nine thousand dollars.
- 8:55[SPEAKER_01]: And that was the exact amount that Ernest had won in poker that morning.
- 9:00[SPEAKER_01]: But of course, now to detectives is also ruled out the possibility that Ernest and Charlene were the targets of a home invasion.
- 9:06[SPEAKER_00]: So the detectives kept digging into Ernest history.
- 9:10[SPEAKER_00]: And as we said earlier, he was on the San Ramon school board in the nineteen eighties.
- 9:15[SPEAKER_00]: Well, in nineteen ninety now this is eighteen years prior to the murders.
- 9:21[SPEAKER_00]: Ernest and a friend were recalled in an election and it was reported that they were recalled because they refused to negotiate when the teachers union went on strike.
- 9:32[SPEAKER_00]: So Ernest was a fiscal conservative and he did not like how much power the teacher's union had and he was a very outspoken critic.
- 9:43[SPEAKER_00]: He was very critical of the waste and the spending and generally an outspoken adversary of the school board that he once served on.
- 9:53[SPEAKER_00]: And I think he felt he knew so much because he had once been part of it.
- 9:57[SPEAKER_00]: You know, so he had seen behind the veil.
- 9:59[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly, and his biggest complaint was that he believed that some of the things that the school board was done because he believed the power that teachers Union had was over the school board itself.
- 10:07[SPEAKER_01]: So there were some measures that they had put through to get more funding and earnest believed it was a ruse to actually increase teacher salaries without saying that they were increasing teacher salaries.
- 10:18[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 10:18[SPEAKER_00]: And he was scheduled to have a meeting with a friend and a political ally just a few days before he was found beaten to death.
- 10:28[SPEAKER_00]: And what Ernest was alleging was that there was corruption on the school board.
- 10:34[SPEAKER_00]: So the person with whom he was scheduled to meet was a former San Ramon mayor and detectives meet with this guy and he tells them that Ernest had rooms of documents which were designed to prove that numbers had been manipulated regarding a bond measure that had passed four years prior.
- 10:55[SPEAKER_00]: That's the one that Ernest was saying, hey, it was only designed to align people's pockets.
- 10:59[SPEAKER_00]: The numbers are fake and I'm going to blow the lid off this thing.
- 11:03[SPEAKER_00]: So this was not the first time that Ernest had challenged the validity of a ballot measure.
- 11:10[SPEAKER_00]: Specifically by the school board.
- 11:13[SPEAKER_00]: Correct.
- 11:13[SPEAKER_00]: Nor was it the first time that he accused board members of malfeasance.
- 11:17[SPEAKER_00]: However, going through all of the rooms of paper, looking through all of the players and all of this, the detectives could not come up with any realistic suspect whom they believed would have gone so far as to murder Ernest and his wife.
- 11:39[SPEAKER_00]: So with the outside players, his friends and political foes, not panning out, detectives then had to go to the most obvious suspects, his children, because it was estimated at the time of Charlene and Ernest Death that each of their children stood to inherit two million dollars a piece.
- 12:00[SPEAKER_01]: It's just under two million, just under two million.
- 12:02[SPEAKER_01]: There was a point of contention in the newspapers at the time, because somebody had said over two million, and the pleasant and weekly said, it was an over two million.
- 12:10[SPEAKER_01]: It was under two million, and it's like, you know, potato potatoes.
- 12:14[SPEAKER_00]: It's still a lot of trouble.
- 12:15[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, exactly.
- 12:17[SPEAKER_00]: So the police were able to quickly eliminate Catherine.
- 12:20[SPEAKER_00]: As we said, she lived in Utah and she was able to immediately prove that she was home in Utah on the night of the murders.
- 12:28[SPEAKER_00]: They also looked at her cell phone data.
- 12:30[SPEAKER_00]: Nobody suspicious was called.
- 12:32[SPEAKER_00]: There was no indication in any way that she would have hired anybody to do this.
- 12:37[SPEAKER_00]: So this left son Ernie.
- 12:39[SPEAKER_00]: Ernie was married to his wife Robin and the two met at BYU and like many young couples at BYU, they married shortly after graduation from college.
- 12:50[SPEAKER_00]: They had a young son together.
- 12:52[SPEAKER_00]: I want to say he was only like two or three at the time of his grandparents.
- 12:56[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, and so they all live together in Southern California in Braya.
- 13:00[SPEAKER_00]: Although Ernie had a degree in economics, he also followed in his father's footsteps by loving poker.
- 13:08[SPEAKER_00]: But he took it to the next level and he decided, I'm gonna drop everything else and I am going to become a professional poker player.
- 13:16[SPEAKER_00]: So he dedicated all of his time to it and he actually succeeded in becoming a professional poker player and his wife Robin supported that endeavor.
- 13:25[SPEAKER_00]: And it was reported that at the height of his gambling career, he made more than a hundred thousand dollars, and he even played in the World Series Apoker.
- 13:36[SPEAKER_00]: But since his income was hit and miss, as you can imagine, he could not get alone to buy a house.
- 13:43[SPEAKER_00]: So when Robin and Ernie found a home in Braya, I want to say it was over six hundred thousand dollars.
- 13:49[SPEAKER_00]: They put twenty percent down, but the seller carried ten percent and his father had to give him a loan for the rest, which the loan was over six hundred thousand dollars.
- 14:00[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, sixteen.
- 14:01[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 14:02[SPEAKER_00]: And so he paid his father what he otherwise would pay in a mortgage every single month.
- 14:09[SPEAKER_01]: But it was a five-year loan.
- 14:10[SPEAKER_01]: It was not a thirty-year loan.
- 14:12[SPEAKER_00]: I didn't even know that.
- 14:13[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 14:14[SPEAKER_00]: But he was paying over five thousand dollars a month to his death.
- 14:16[SPEAKER_01]: Almost five.
- 14:16[SPEAKER_01]: Not just to his dad.
- 14:17[SPEAKER_01]: He still had the ten percent that he owed to the seller.
- 14:19[SPEAKER_01]: And so there must have been.
- 14:21[SPEAKER_01]: But it was around forty-six hundred dollars.
- 14:22[SPEAKER_01]: So most of it obviously was to his dad.
- 14:24[SPEAKER_00]: There must have been a balloon payment to his dad coming out.
- 14:26[SPEAKER_00]: I'm sure there was.
- 14:28[SPEAKER_00]: But anyway, so when detectives really began focusing in on Ernie, they recalled that after the parents murder, after he was notified that his mom and dad had been killed, and he came to their home, which was the then scene of the crime.
- 14:45[SPEAKER_00]: One of the first things he wanted to do was see their will.
- 14:49[SPEAKER_00]: He insisted on seeing their will.
- 14:53[SPEAKER_00]: That naturalist raised suspicions.
- 14:56[SPEAKER_01]: So, Ernie agreed to be questioned by the police and talked to them about the night's parents were killed.
- 15:01[SPEAKER_01]: He said that he was in Braya asleep.
- 15:03[SPEAKER_01]: His wife and child happened to be on vacation with her family, so they weren't there.
- 15:07[SPEAKER_01]: But said, I'm sure my cell phone can prove that I was there.
- 15:10[SPEAKER_01]: But detectives were kind of pressing him, okay?
- 15:13[SPEAKER_01]: You may not have done it, but did you have anything to do with your parents' deaths?
- 15:17[SPEAKER_01]: And he insisted, no, no, no.
- 15:19[SPEAKER_01]: Why would I want my parents killed?
- 15:21[SPEAKER_01]: My dad was my best friend.
- 15:23[SPEAKER_01]: Why would I ever have something like that happen?
- 15:25[SPEAKER_01]: But just a week after speaking with Ernie, investigators were going through video from the Country Club.
- 15:31[SPEAKER_01]: And in this video, they noticed in the wee hours of the night, a red convertible Camaro that had a black top that looked familiar to them, because it was the exact same car that Ernie Sherrod drove.
- 15:48[SPEAKER_01]: Looking at this video tape, they see that the car entered the Castlewood property at eight twenty-seven pm on the night of the murders.
- 15:56[SPEAKER_01]: and it left four hours later.
- 15:58[SPEAKER_01]: Police reached out to Ernie again, now that they have this information, they want to have another conversation with him, and when they spoke to Ernie's wife Robin, they learned he dipped.
- 16:07[SPEAKER_01]: So detectives talked to his wife Robin, and she told them that when he left, he told her the reason he was leaving was he had to be alone to grieve.
- 16:16[SPEAKER_01]: She said, when he came home, and he said, I'll be in touch.
- 16:19[SPEAKER_00]: And didn't tell her where he was going.
- 16:21[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, exactly.
- 16:22[SPEAKER_01]: Leaving again, a three-year-old son at home.
- 16:25[SPEAKER_01]: When he left home though, he wasn't driving his red Camero.
- 16:29[SPEAKER_01]: He actually was driving one of his dad's cars.
- 16:32[SPEAKER_01]: So the red Camero was in the driveway.
- 16:35[SPEAKER_00]: See, he had flown to Pleasanton when he found out his parents were murdered and it simply took his dad's car home with him.
- 16:43[SPEAKER_01]: Right, because the car was still there detectives use the opportunity to get a search warrant for the car, and they found nothing.
- 16:52[SPEAKER_01]: But then they found a receipt that showed that the day after the murders, Ernie had taken his car to a local car wash and got it detailed inside and out.
- 17:04[SPEAKER_01]: Really, there was nothing there to find.
- 17:06[SPEAKER_01]: So with no trace of evidence in the car, the cops now poured over crime scene photos to see, is there any clue we missed?
- 17:12[SPEAKER_01]: Is there something we need to know?
- 17:13[SPEAKER_01]: And they started with the bloody footprints.
- 17:15[SPEAKER_01]: The ones they found on the carpet from Charlene to Ernest to the linen closet, but one of the places they found them also was on the tile floor of the entryway.
- 17:24[SPEAKER_01]: The interesting thing was, when they saw that footprints on the tile floor, they said that they looked like they'd been staged, because the print itself was perfect.
- 17:34[SPEAKER_01]: It looks like it had been very carefully rolled onto the tile floor to make sure you knew the make and model of the shoe as well as the size.
- 17:43[SPEAKER_01]: And it was at size twelve Nike.
- 17:45[SPEAKER_01]: So investigators really were of the opinion that these footprints were not real.
- 17:50[SPEAKER_01]: It was trying to make them believe that somebody of the size twelve foot had actually killed the share of parents.
- 17:55[SPEAKER_01]: When in fact it was somebody who had a different shoe size than that.
- 17:59[SPEAKER_01]: But then there was another interesting fact that came to their attention.
- 18:03[SPEAKER_01]: Remember, we talked about the footprints that had gone from Charlene to Ernie to the linen closet, and that it looked like somebody had not ransacked the closet, but rather went through it.
- 18:13[SPEAKER_01]: After Ernie dipped, of course, Robin starts going through all these things in her head, the fact that the police were doing a search warrant on the car that he drove.
- 18:21[SPEAKER_01]: She didn't know where he was that night, and she remembered a conversation she had with Ernie at his parents' house right after they found out they had been murdered.
- 18:29[SPEAKER_01]: According to Robin, when the family was finally allowed inside the parent's home, Ernie led her straight to the linen closet.
- 18:36[SPEAKER_01]: And when they got there, he reached in and he pulled out a decorative sword when that he said his father had brought back from Turkey a few years prior.
- 18:44[SPEAKER_01]: But there had been two swords.
- 18:46[SPEAKER_01]: and there was only one in there at that time.
- 18:49[SPEAKER_01]: And so he showed it to her and wanted her to admire it and whatnot.
- 18:53[SPEAKER_01]: But Robin said she remembered as Ernie was putting it back in the closet.
- 18:57[SPEAKER_01]: He muttered something under his breath that sounded like, gee, I wonder where the second sword went.
- 19:03[SPEAKER_01]: When Robin realized what that could have meant, she called the detectives and told them exactly everything she remembered right down to the tone of voice and walking directly there and whatnot.
- 19:13[SPEAKER_01]: Because she was now afraid, her husband was a killer.
- 19:16[SPEAKER_00]: I am sure she was bitter because he left, you know, and he was roaming around and she was hanging out with a three year old not having any idea where he was or what he was doing or what he was coming home.
- 19:26[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 19:27[SPEAKER_00]: Or where was she getting their next dollar front?
- 19:29[SPEAKER_00]: For sure.
- 19:30[SPEAKER_01]: Despite earning now being a main suspect, detectives obviously didn't have enough evidence to arrest him.
- 19:35[SPEAKER_01]: They decided to watch him and hoped he would make a mistake.
- 19:42[SPEAKER_00]: When Ernie decided to make poker playing his profession, his mother Charlene was very critical.
- 19:51[SPEAKER_00]: And being a Mormon, she did not appreciate his chosen profession and believe his would want in ways.
- 19:58[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 19:58[SPEAKER_00]: Believe it would only lead to trouble.
- 20:01[SPEAKER_00]: And of course, she was correct.
- 20:03[SPEAKER_00]: Ernie Sister, Katherine quoted Charlene, because Charlene again was very critical of the poker playing.
- 20:10[SPEAKER_00]: And she said, you can't be a professional gambler.
- 20:13[SPEAKER_00]: That's like saying, I'm a professional nose picker.
- 20:17[SPEAKER_01]: I know a couple kids who could be, oh my god, same.
- 20:22[SPEAKER_00]: Anyway, so detectives kept an eye on Ernie.
- 20:25[SPEAKER_00]: Other ways known as the professional nose picker.
- 20:27[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 20:28[SPEAKER_00]: And as he traveled the country playing poker tournaments, he discovered that he was posting ads on Craigslist, everywhere he went, looking for women.
- 20:40[SPEAKER_00]: So this is one of the ads.
- 20:42[SPEAKER_00]: I am six foot tall, a non-smoker.
- 20:45[SPEAKER_00]: I am really just looking for someone that is intelligent and can hold an interesting conversation over a glass of wine.
- 20:53[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe you are here from out of town for a convention.
- 20:56[SPEAKER_00]: We can get together for drinks and listen to some live music.
- 21:00[SPEAKER_00]: If we hit it off, maybe we can have dinner.
- 21:03[SPEAKER_00]: I know Las Vegas and have lots of great places to go to and things to do.
- 21:09[SPEAKER_00]: If you're a non-smoker, college educated HWP, and between the ages of twenty five and forty, here's my number.
- 21:18[SPEAKER_00]: So Kathy and I had to look up what HWP was.
- 21:21[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 21:22[SPEAKER_01]: That's like single white SWF single white female and what what was it?
- 21:26[SPEAKER_00]: I can't remember.
- 21:26[SPEAKER_01]: It was height weight proportionate immediately.
- 21:30[SPEAKER_01]: No fatties need apply.
- 21:32[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, don't be too skinny.
- 21:33[SPEAKER_00]: Don't be too fat.
- 21:33[SPEAKER_01]: That wasn't even don't be too skinny.
- 21:35[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 21:36[SPEAKER_01]: No, what I read said that's what I mean.
- 21:37[SPEAKER_01]: That's what height weight proportionate means.
- 21:39[SPEAKER_01]: But basically everything I read said don't be overweight don't be too fat like blah blah blah.
- 21:45[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you for your skinny.
- 21:46[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 21:47[SPEAKER_00]: But it's like, when I read this, it's like, oh my God, I don't believe a word that like, when he says, just looking for someone that is intelligent and can hold an interesting conversation over a glass of wine.
- 21:57[SPEAKER_00]: Obviously he was trying to like have women go, oh, what a lovely man.
- 22:01[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my God.
- 22:04[SPEAKER_00]: This totally reminds me I had a well I shouldn't say he was my friend.
- 22:10[SPEAKER_00]: He was my brother's friend and They'd been friends since like back in the day this man was like he was funny to talk to but I'm a hundred percent certain he was a sociopath
- 22:20[SPEAKER_00]: And again, he's entertaining, but he's the kind of guy you have to keep in an arms distance.
- 22:25[SPEAKER_00]: He used to post ads that said, oh my God.
- 22:28[SPEAKER_00]: Widower firemen, looking for woman who loves long walks on the beach and dogs, and I mean, all this crap.
- 22:38[SPEAKER_00]: And he wasn't a fireman.
- 22:40[SPEAKER_00]: He wasn't a widow.
- 22:41[SPEAKER_00]: But oh my God, the people that responded to his ads were ridiculous.
- 22:45[SPEAKER_00]: And he went on a date.
- 22:46[SPEAKER_00]: This is so terrible.
- 22:48[SPEAKER_00]: and yet I'm so freaking amused by it, but he went on a date and he could tell it was not going well.
- 22:56[SPEAKER_00]: So the girl gets up to go to the bathroom and he looks in her purse while she's gone.
- 23:01[SPEAKER_00]: I don't hear this from him.
- 23:02[SPEAKER_00]: I hear this through my brother.
- 23:03[SPEAKER_00]: Oh yeah, sure.
- 23:04[SPEAKER_00]: So she gets back and she's like, okay, well, you know what?
- 23:07[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think this is working out.
- 23:08[SPEAKER_00]: I think I'm gonna go and he goes, well, let's split the check and she goes, I don't have any money and he goes, yes, you do.
- 23:13[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh,
- 23:17[SPEAKER_00]: No.
- 23:18[SPEAKER_00]: Anyway, she stormed out.
- 23:19[SPEAKER_01]: I was going to say did she clock website?
- 23:21[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know.
- 23:21[SPEAKER_00]: I wouldn't like peace out, buddy.
- 23:23[SPEAKER_00]: You can do dishes for my portion of the meal.
- 23:25[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 23:26[SPEAKER_00]: In speaking with some of the women that Ernie met through Craigslist, the detectives learned that he had this fake identity.
- 23:35[SPEAKER_00]: He called himself Bill Franks.
- 23:37[SPEAKER_00]: And detectives actually sought out some of these women.
- 23:42[SPEAKER_00]: And with one of them, she said that he told her that he was writing a novel about a professional poker player whose parents were murdered and therefore this poker player had to go on the lamb.
- 23:57[SPEAKER_00]: And you know a little too close for comfort for the detectives right but this the woman who who he was dating had no idea that he was a poker player right exactly she just thought like oh he's just a douche mo creative man he probably said he was from a condemned he's there for convention exactly exactly this is lousy with him
- 24:14[SPEAKER_00]: And there was another woman they found with whom he had two dates, I believe.
- 24:19[SPEAKER_00]: And so one of the dates was broken.
- 24:23[SPEAKER_00]: And Ernie said, I'm sorry, I can't go out with you tonight.
- 24:27[SPEAKER_00]: My parents' house was broken into and both of them were murdered.
- 24:31[SPEAKER_00]: And when they checked his call logs, it showed that he called this lady before he even called his own wife to tell her that her in-laws had been murdered.
- 24:41[SPEAKER_01]: and the grandparents for her child.
- 24:42[SPEAKER_01]: Correct.
- 24:43[SPEAKER_01]: With this new information about Ernie's extracurricular activities, his Dalian suit.
- 24:47[SPEAKER_01]: There you go.
- 24:48[SPEAKER_01]: I like that word better.
- 24:49[SPEAKER_01]: This creative writing.
- 24:52[SPEAKER_01]: The detectives approached Ernie's wife Robin with details about her husband's secret life that they discovered.
- 24:58[SPEAKER_01]: And this didn't just include the women and his offensive ad that he would put on Craigslist.
- 25:03[SPEAKER_01]: He had a secret stash of credit cards.
- 25:05[SPEAKER_01]: He had secret bank accounts, secret PO boxes, and a number of girlfriends, including one who he had apparently dated for two years.
- 25:15[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, you hear about these stories happening.
- 25:17[SPEAKER_00]: You hear how people have, you know, separate lives, like, a double life.
- 25:21[SPEAKER_00]: And it's typically the man who's doing it.
- 25:23[SPEAKER_00]: And I, I just think to myself, how do you have the energy?
- 25:26[SPEAKER_00]: Like, where's your downtime, man?
- 25:28[SPEAKER_00]: Like, it blows my mind that people can juggle that much emotion, emotion, damage.
- 25:36[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 25:37[SPEAKER_00]: But then again, I mean, maybe it's a kind of thing that if you can do that, there's a little something wrong with you.
- 25:42[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe you don't have that much emotional baggage.
- 25:44[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly, you know?
- 25:44[SPEAKER_01]: You can turn things off to you.
- 25:46[SPEAKER_00]: Like you would weigh heavily on me.
- 25:47[SPEAKER_01]: But also remember as a poker player, he was gone all the time.
- 25:51[SPEAKER_01]: Like he had true.
- 25:52[SPEAKER_01]: And that's, and so his Italians has never took place in Southern California.
- 25:56[SPEAKER_01]: They were all in Vegas, which is where he was most of the time.
- 25:59[SPEAKER_01]: Sometimes he would go to the East Coast.
- 26:01[SPEAKER_01]: Sometimes he would, you know, go up to Reno, or he would just chase the poker tournaments.
- 26:05[SPEAKER_01]: And every time he went there, it was a woman in every port.
- 26:08[SPEAKER_01]: You know, he had all the secret accounts.
- 26:09[SPEAKER_01]: He never thought he'd get caught.
- 26:11[SPEAKER_01]: So he could have these meaningless flings while forgetting about the fact that he actually had a wife and child, which apparently none of these women knew about.
- 26:19[SPEAKER_00]: But I'm surprised how the woman he dated two years.
- 26:21[SPEAKER_00]: She apparently never knew.
- 26:23[SPEAKER_01]: But she doesn't live in Vegas though, but that's not a down there.
- 26:27[SPEAKER_00]: That's a relationship.
- 26:29[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know.
- 26:29[SPEAKER_00]: That's just too much energy.
- 26:30[SPEAKER_01]: But she's never in the same city.
- 26:31[SPEAKER_01]: She lived on the East Coast.
- 26:32[SPEAKER_01]: They would meet in Vegas.
- 26:34[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 26:34[SPEAKER_01]: So he didn't even have to deal with her on a full-time basis.
- 26:36[SPEAKER_01]: I bet he was busy every birthday she had and every Christmas.
- 26:40[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 26:40[SPEAKER_01]: Booker tournament and, you know, you're a bird South America.
- 26:43[SPEAKER_00]: Well, you haven't even said that when Robin had their baby, the husband wasn't there.
- 26:48[SPEAKER_00]: He was not there.
- 26:48[SPEAKER_01]: He was at at poker tournament.
- 26:50[SPEAKER_01]: He came home.
- 26:51[SPEAKER_01]: Brow as busy, saw the baby and quickly left the next day for another pro-creturniment.
- 26:56[SPEAKER_01]: And you know, the hard thing is that she can't tell him not to go because all of their lifestyles dependent on him making cash.
- 27:01[SPEAKER_00]: So that's true.
- 27:03[SPEAKER_00]: Can you imagine like the detectives dropped this information on her and she was like, what the what exactly?
- 27:08[SPEAKER_00]: Broken record.
- 27:09[SPEAKER_01]: Well, and the biggest problem she had had, too, is I guess like he would be gone for such long stretches of time that she'd have bills to pay and they'd have nothing in their bank account.
- 27:18[SPEAKER_01]: So she would text him and be like, hey, I got to pay these bills.
- 27:20[SPEAKER_01]: We need money and the money would always appear.
- 27:23[SPEAKER_01]: Now remember, the murder's happened in March of two thousand eight.
- 27:27[SPEAKER_01]: She had actually texted her husband in February of two thousand eight because again, he was gone.
- 27:31[SPEAKER_01]: She never heard back from him.
- 27:33[SPEAKER_01]: He comes back.
- 27:34[SPEAKER_01]: They spend this little bit of time together after his parents were killed before he dips.
- 27:38[SPEAKER_01]: She's texting him again.
- 27:39[SPEAKER_01]: I got to make a house payment and he never replied and she never paid for the month of March.
- 27:44[SPEAKER_01]: And here's the thing too, and this is what didn't make a lot of sense, is that according to the will, if both parents were deceased at the same time, so if one didn't pre-decease the other, the executor of the will would be one of the ants.
- 27:56[SPEAKER_01]: And I don't know if it was the husband's ant, or the husband's sister, or the wife's sister, different last name than both of them.
- 28:01[SPEAKER_01]: I see what you're saying.
- 28:02[SPEAKER_01]: We're not entitled to any money until they turned thirty.
- 28:06[SPEAKER_00]: So basically what you're saying is like, if the husband died first, the wife's the executive.
- 28:10[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 28:10[SPEAKER_00]: If the wife dies, the husbands, if they both die, it's the aunt.
- 28:13[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 28:14[SPEAKER_00]: Interesting.
- 28:15[SPEAKER_01]: The funny thing was, though, is that Ernie wasn't yet thirty.
- 28:18[SPEAKER_01]: He still had four months until he turned thirty.
- 28:21[SPEAKER_01]: And so he didn't even get the cash in the first place for four months, right?
- 28:25[SPEAKER_01]: So Katherine was in her mid-twenties, you know,
- 28:28[SPEAKER_01]: Nobody's getting any money immediately, or any being the next one in line.
- 28:31[SPEAKER_01]: But again, he's four months off and when you're strapped for cash, that's a long time.
- 28:36[SPEAKER_01]: So according to detectives, when they called and they talked to Robin about what was going on, that's where we started way back when they called to tell her about his secret life, she said, let me help you build your case.
- 28:46[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, she became another detective in the team.
- 28:49[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, a woman's scorn.
- 28:51[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, exactly.
- 28:53[SPEAKER_01]: That is the truth.
- 28:55[SPEAKER_00]: Dudes, we get really creative when we're scoring.
- 28:57[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, exactly.
- 28:59[SPEAKER_01]: To the point that it means is that.
- 29:02[SPEAKER_01]: Now three months into Ernie Sharers grieving cross country trip where he's finding all these extra women, police got a tip that he was in Las Vegas.
- 29:12[SPEAKER_01]: This allowed a detective to put a GPS on his car and keep closer tabs.
- 29:17[SPEAKER_01]: With this tracker, detective did an even deeper dive into Ernie's finances and they learned he really was strap for cash.
- 29:24[SPEAKER_01]: He had at least ninety thousand dollars in gambling debts.
- 29:28[SPEAKER_01]: He had more than forty thousand dollars in credit card debt and of course he had this huge payment that he owed to his parents and also a tiny repayment that he owed to the seller of the house.
- 29:38[SPEAKER_01]: But along with these pressures and anybody who live through it, live through their own day.
- 29:43[SPEAKER_01]: This is when the housing market tanked.
- 29:46[SPEAKER_01]: Every market tank.
- 29:47[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, everything.
- 29:48[SPEAKER_01]: But California, the housing market is normally like it'll go down.
- 29:52[SPEAKER_01]: It doesn't tank and it tanked.
- 29:55[SPEAKER_01]: Apparently Ernest and Charlene Sharer were putting pressure on Ernie to pay back the loan because I think I never saw this technically but I believe they did the five-year loan because they were hoping within five years he'd be able to transfer that into an actual mortgage and then they'd get their money back.
- 30:10[SPEAKER_00]: Oh interesting.
- 30:10[SPEAKER_01]: That was my thought.
- 30:11[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my gosh, that's right because they wanted him to refinance their debt.
- 30:15[SPEAKER_01]: They wanted him to refinance it.
- 30:17[SPEAKER_01]: So they wanted their money back immediately because as we said, remember, Ernest was a real estate investor.
- 30:23[SPEAKER_01]: And if you had the cash, there was no better time to use that money than when everybody's house was tanking and you could afford to give money.
- 30:29[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 30:30[SPEAKER_01]: The other thing that start with this tracker that they have and with phone records, of course, that they're now looking at, they were able to determine that on March seventh, two thousand eight, the day that the share appearance were killed, Ernie cell phone stopped pinging in Prima Nevada.
- 30:45[SPEAKER_01]: This is in Southern Nevada.
- 30:47[SPEAKER_01]: It's on the border of California and Nevada.
- 30:49[SPEAKER_01]: And it's the town you go through if you're heading from Vegas to Southern California.
- 30:53[SPEAKER_01]: On March seventh, two thousand eight, it stopped.
- 31:00[SPEAKER_00]: So they knew he was going from Las Vegas heading into California, but the phone goes off in Prim.
- 31:06[SPEAKER_00]: So it was seventeen hours before his cell phone was turned back on and detectives looked at that and they're like, you know what, in that seventeen hour window, he absolutely could have driven north to Pleasanton and then south back to his home in Orange County, no problem.
- 31:25[SPEAKER_01]: Right, seventeen hours easily.
- 31:27[SPEAKER_00]: There's a lot of time.
- 31:28[SPEAKER_00]: So detectives in Alameda County, which was where the murder took place, through the course of their investigation, they basically tracked it.
- 31:37[SPEAKER_00]: They're like, we're going to do exactly the route that he would have taken because actually it's a fairly clear cut route.
- 31:42[SPEAKER_00]: It is.
- 31:43[SPEAKER_00]: And we're going to see if we can go north to Pleasanton, South to Breia and be home because they know that the phone went on seventeen hours later at his home in Breia.
- 31:53[SPEAKER_00]: And it was almost to the minute detective said that they did their trip pretending to be killers.
- 32:01[SPEAKER_01]: Well, they knew when the red convertible had gone through the gates on the way home.
- 32:05[SPEAKER_01]: So they went to the gates and then at that exact time, that's when they started their drive.
- 32:09[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 32:10[SPEAKER_00]: They knew when it arrived, they knew when it left and that's what they did.
- 32:12[SPEAKER_00]: And so they basically said he had enough time to commit this murder.
- 32:17[SPEAKER_00]: But detectives wanted Ernie to admit that the car in the video surveillance, the red camera was his because the video was too pixelated to specifically identify him.
- 32:31[SPEAKER_01]: or the plate of the car.
- 32:32[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 32:33[SPEAKER_00]: So in comes a woman scorned the wife Robin.
- 32:38[SPEAKER_00]: And she agrees to help detectives.
- 32:41[SPEAKER_00]: So she wants to record a conversation with her husband, Ernie, and try to get him to make incriminating admissions.
- 32:48[SPEAKER_00]: At this point, she has not heard from her husband in weeks.
- 32:53[SPEAKER_00]: And probably in her heart of hearts, she knows that she might not ever see him again.
- 32:57[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 32:57[SPEAKER_00]: You know, so she calls her husband and she says, where are you?
- 33:01[SPEAKER_00]: And he says, I'm in Northern California.
- 33:03[SPEAKER_00]: And then without any prompting, he says, I'm not trying to hide or anything.
- 33:06[SPEAKER_00]: I'm not hiding from the cops.
- 33:07[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I didn't do this.
- 33:09[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, but I know they're trying to collect circumstantial evidence to pin it on me, essentially.
- 33:14[SPEAKER_00]: And then Robin tells him they have you on video surveillance on the night of the murder.
- 33:20[SPEAKER_00]: They have you in the country club in your red convertible.
- 33:24[SPEAKER_00]: And he's stunned.
- 33:26[SPEAKER_00]: It was obviously not true.
- 33:28[SPEAKER_00]: And she was doing it to rattle him.
- 33:30[SPEAKER_00]: And he was rattled.
- 33:32[SPEAKER_00]: And Ernie said, can you really see the driver's face in the video?
- 33:37[SPEAKER_00]: And Robin said, yes.
- 33:39[SPEAKER_00]: And she says, where were you?
- 33:42[SPEAKER_00]: And he's silent.
- 33:44[SPEAKER_00]: He doesn't speak at all.
- 33:46[SPEAKER_00]: So she asks him again, where were you that night?
- 33:49[SPEAKER_00]: And again, silence.
- 33:51[SPEAKER_00]: And then he says, what else can you tell me about the video?
- 33:55[SPEAKER_00]: And so Robin knew at that moment with those long pauses that her husband was a killer.
- 34:03[SPEAKER_00]: And detectives who were listening in on this call knew it as well.
- 34:12[SPEAKER_01]: Nearly one year after the bodies of Ernest and Charlene Sherer were found in their home, their son Ernie was arrested for their murders.
- 34:20[SPEAKER_01]: Ernie was confident he would not be convicted because they had no fingerprints.
- 34:24[SPEAKER_01]: They had no DNA.
- 34:26[SPEAKER_01]: They had no witnesses.
- 34:28[SPEAKER_01]: No evidence was found in the car that they said was there that night.
- 34:32[SPEAKER_01]: I think by now he probably knew that you couldn't see the face.
- 34:35[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 34:36[SPEAKER_00]: In the car.
- 34:36[SPEAKER_00]: I do the driver.
- 34:37[SPEAKER_01]: Right, like we said, you couldn't even see a plate number.
- 34:40[SPEAKER_01]: So they were feeling pretty confident.
- 34:41[SPEAKER_01]: The defense also had talked about having solid forensic evidence at the crime scene.
- 34:46[SPEAKER_01]: They found foreign DNA in earnest blood, but it did not belong to Ernie.
- 34:52[SPEAKER_01]: It belonged to an unknown person, which the defense said was the real killer.
- 34:56[SPEAKER_00]: And of course, the prosecutor said it was probably a first responder.
- 35:00[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 35:00[SPEAKER_00]: So really the only thing the prosecution had was motive.
- 35:05[SPEAKER_00]: And like OJ, he went on the lamp.
- 35:07[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly, but unlike OG, he didn't have a glove.
- 35:10[SPEAKER_01]: So he didn't step ahead, man.
- 35:14[SPEAKER_01]: So year after when he was arrested, so now two years then after his parents murder, the prosecutor discovered something that changed everything.
- 35:23[SPEAKER_01]: In the lead up to trial, the prosecutor was trying to find more evidence.
- 35:26[SPEAKER_01]: He, of course, knew what the defense was going to say.
- 35:27[SPEAKER_01]: And you always have to worry about the jury when they're like, oh, DNA, and it doesn't match.
- 35:31[SPEAKER_01]: We're kind of, you know, DNA horrors at this point.
- 35:34[SPEAKER_01]: We're going to have DNA totally by it at all.
- 35:37[SPEAKER_01]: The prosecutor was looking at the crime scene photos.
- 35:39[SPEAKER_01]: And he noticed in the corner of one of the photos, what looks like a piece of paper.
- 35:44[SPEAKER_01]: So he enlarged the photo and saw that it was a warranty for a child's baseball bat.
- 35:50[SPEAKER_01]: And it was a Nike youth baseball bat.
- 35:52[SPEAKER_00]: But let me just like a side note here, because like looking at the photo, sometimes it's like as an attorney, you see photos for so long.
- 36:01[SPEAKER_00]: And then you look at them like truly like in your heart of hearts, like I am now analyzing every square inch and you see things that you didn't see before.
- 36:10[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm sure that as the prosecution was preparing for trial, they're like, we have nothing connecting him.
- 36:16[SPEAKER_00]: I have to find something.
- 36:18[SPEAKER_00]: And he probably analyzed those photos like within an inch of their lives.
- 36:21[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 36:22[SPEAKER_01]: So, the question of course is, you know, why would the shares need a warranty for a youth baseball bat, right?
- 36:28[SPEAKER_01]: They didn't have kids who live there, the kids were far away.
- 36:30[SPEAKER_01]: Detectives were like, if Ernie is the killer, the last place we know where he was before his parents were killed was Prim Nevada.
- 36:39[SPEAKER_00]: and where his phone went off.
- 36:41[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 36:42[SPEAKER_01]: So let's take a look there and see what we can find.
- 36:44[SPEAKER_01]: They checked his credit card and they found that he had bought some lunch at the McDonald's there.
- 36:49[SPEAKER_01]: He had purchased gas at the Chevron right next door and surprisingly right next door to that was a Nike outlet store.
- 36:57[SPEAKER_01]: Remember we had said the shoe prints found in the entryway were size twelve Nike's.
- 37:02[SPEAKER_01]: Police weren't lucky enough to have a credit card receipt for the Nike store.
- 37:06[SPEAKER_01]: So they went there and they said, great, we need to see all of your receipts from March seventh, two thousand eight.
- 37:11[SPEAKER_01]: And in the midst of this, right around the same exact time that the McDonald's was being purchased and the gas was being purchased, there was a cash receipt for three items.
- 37:22[SPEAKER_01]: A pair of size, twelve Nike's, a youth baseball bat, same-make-and-model, and a pair of youth soccer goalie gloves.
- 37:30[SPEAKER_01]: Those were never explained.
- 37:31[SPEAKER_01]: But with that information, police, of course, now are like, we got him.
- 37:35[SPEAKER_01]: We can connect him to the Nike store purchasing a bat.
- 37:39[SPEAKER_01]: We talked about the warranty, but a bat, the size of a youth baseball bat, was consistent with the blunt force trauma inflicted on Charlene and Ernest.
- 37:48[SPEAKER_01]: They had never actually been able to identify exactly what it was, but this would have fit.
- 37:54[SPEAKER_01]: They also were able to connect Ernie to the size twelve Nike's.
- 37:58[SPEAKER_01]: Remember, shoe prints.
- 37:59[SPEAKER_01]: that looked like they'd almost been made intentionally.
- 38:02[SPEAKER_01]: Size twelve, Tomahawks.
- 38:03[SPEAKER_01]: There's something different about Tomahawks.
- 38:05[SPEAKER_01]: I can't remember what it is.
- 38:06[SPEAKER_01]: But these were Tomahawks that had been purchased with this cash receipt.
- 38:09[SPEAKER_01]: Now granted, they couldn't technically connect him, right?
- 38:12[SPEAKER_01]: It wasn't a credit card slip or whatever.
- 38:13[SPEAKER_00]: A credible circumstantial evidence, so.
- 38:15[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 38:16[SPEAKER_00]: How do you have a bloody receipt for a baseball bat, a warranty on a baseball bat at a crime scene?
- 38:24[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 38:24[SPEAKER_00]: Whatever he was doing there, that receipt came out of the bag.
- 38:27[SPEAKER_00]: Like, I bet you anything he pulled the bag out.
- 38:29[SPEAKER_01]: Or it came off the bat.
- 38:30[SPEAKER_00]: You know, something.
- 38:31[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 38:36[SPEAKER_01]: So trial began in January of twenty eleven this is now almost three years after Ernest and Charlene were killed.
- 38:43[SPEAKER_01]: The prosecution took the jury through all the things that we've mentioned, Ernest's money problems, the surveillance video with the car that may or may not have been him, his duplicitous life dipping.
- 38:54[SPEAKER_01]: That's an important one.
- 38:55[SPEAKER_01]: Robin's phone call and of course the bloody baseball bat warranty card.
- 38:59[SPEAKER_01]: His sister Catherine actually testified as did his now ex-wife Robin and their grandpa who was the original Ernest Sherer because he lived in South Orange County and apparently they would get together and play poker.
- 39:13[SPEAKER_01]: So he testified because he saw them a few days after the parents were killed.
- 39:17[SPEAKER_00]: So the defense of course contended that there was no direct evidence.
- 39:21[SPEAKER_00]: Everything was circumstantial.
- 39:23[SPEAKER_00]: But the reality is circumstantial evidence and direct evidence carry the same weight if the jury believes circumstantial evidence is sufficiently credible.
- 39:33[SPEAKER_00]: The detectives and the prosecutors slowly built their case piece by piece.
- 39:38[SPEAKER_00]: And in a shocking move, Ernie took the stand in his own defense.
- 39:43[SPEAKER_00]: And basically said his father was his best friend.
- 39:46[SPEAKER_00]: They were both into poker.
- 39:47[SPEAKER_00]: They had the same politics, Ernie loved him to bits.
- 39:51[SPEAKER_00]: And he would never ever ever hurt his family.
- 39:54[SPEAKER_00]: Bernie also talked about his seminary training in the Mormon Church and the fact that he had attained Eagle Scout status and Boy Scouts.
- 40:03[SPEAKER_00]: That's pretty cool.
- 40:04[SPEAKER_00]: So, you know, he's painting himself as I'm a good son.
- 40:07[SPEAKER_00]: I'm an upstanding citizen.
- 40:08[SPEAKER_00]: This isn't something that's in my wheelhouse.
- 40:11[SPEAKER_00]: However, on cross examination, he had to answer questions about his relationship with his mother.
- 40:17[SPEAKER_00]: He had to answer questions about the indebtedness to his parents and how he was strapped and had not recently won a poker game and had unpaid bills, etc.
- 40:28[SPEAKER_00]: etc.
- 40:28[SPEAKER_00]: etc.
- 40:29[SPEAKER_00]: And after three months of trial, thirty-two-year-old Ernie Share was convicted on two counts of first-degree murder with special circumstances, which means you're going to have to serve more time for those special circumstances and his special circumstances were multiple murders and killing for a financial gain.
- 40:52[SPEAKER_00]: Ernie was given two consecutive LWP sentences.
- 40:58[SPEAKER_00]: Kathy's favorite.
- 40:59[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, wait, that's really quick start before we get to the end of that.
- 41:02[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, should I just butt in?
- 41:03[SPEAKER_01]: Of course.
- 41:04[SPEAKER_01]: Brian Coberger, which we'll have an update on that, but watching some of the news coverage of it afterwards, there was a prosecutor from California who was opining on one of the shows and he called it Elwop.
- 41:14[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, he got my favorite.
- 41:19[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, he gets two consecutive sentences, which is awesome because they're back to back, you know, and rather than running concurrently, which just doesn't count in my mind.
- 41:27[SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't.
- 41:28[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 41:28[SPEAKER_00]: And his petition to have the California Supreme Court review the case was denied.
- 41:33[SPEAKER_00]: And this was after two appeals had already been rejected.
- 41:36[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 41:37[SPEAKER_01]: So in closing, Katherine said, I think my parents did an amazing job, and I don't think any kid could have asked for better parents.
- 41:46[SPEAKER_01]: She also shared that her mother always pushed them to do the best that they could, one hundred percent of the time.
- 41:54[SPEAKER_01]: And it wasn't that their mom was harsh or critical.
- 41:57[SPEAKER_01]: She just wanted them to achieve their highest potential.
- 42:00[SPEAKER_01]: Then there was an interesting story that we were talking about.
- 42:02[SPEAKER_01]: Katherine had made a comment about how they always went on these big family vacations.
- 42:06[SPEAKER_01]: They went to Big Sur.
- 42:07[SPEAKER_01]: They went to Yessemite.
- 42:09[SPEAKER_01]: They were a big nature family or at least Katherine and her mother were to the extent that I was able to find
- 42:13[SPEAKER_01]: And she said, you know, this was one of her mom's favorite things to do with the family and Catherine would ask her, why do you put in all this effort and tolerate all of us just winding and complaining?
- 42:23[SPEAKER_01]: And which sounds like every family vacation is somewhere.
- 42:27[SPEAKER_01]: Everyone.
- 42:28[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 42:29[SPEAKER_01]: And Charlene share a reply because you don't understand history until you can live in it, until you can see it and touch it and experience it.
- 42:42[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, thanks for listening.
- 42:43[SPEAKER_01]: If you want to support us, hit subscribe.
- 42:45[SPEAKER_01]: And tell your friends.
- 42:47[SPEAKER_01]: I apparently Kathy's done.
- 42:48[SPEAKER_01]: Bye.
- 42:49[SPEAKER_01]: Bye.