Latest / No Way Out / Guerrilla Intelligence: Bob Gourley on the Real OODA Loop, AI, and Winning the Information War
Transcript
- 0:20Bob Gourley: Okay, well he's got an answer in here.
- 0:21Bob Gourley: And the short version of the answer is it's the same way humans have always controlled our elites.
- 0:27Bob Gourley: We have always and we I shouldn't say always, but for the last 250 years, there was this new idea of governance that arose about a representative democracy where we vote our elites out when we don't like them and we push them out of power.
- 0:43Bob Gourley: Wow.
- 0:44Bob Gourley: He says this is the same kind of idea we need to apply to the various AI.
- 0:49Bob Gourley: And once I started thinking of it in that framing, yeah, there's a lot of ways we can do this.
- 0:55Bob Gourley: All of the AI is already controlled by people.
- 0:58Bob Gourley: And so our issue should be how do we control those people?
- 1:02Bob Gourley: And the uh we can have these AIs compete against each other.
- 1:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you saying the interests within the foundation of our country?
- 1:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The declaration.
- 1:11Bob Gourley: Let's talk about that.
- 1:12Bob Gourley: It doesn't mean that the government needs to control all this stuff, but we humans will control AI and make sure it does stuff our way.
- 1:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's already a roadmap or a blueprint or whatever you want to call it for how to deal with this.
- 1:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what I heard from you is uh David Brynn's work potentially connects back to the founding of our country, right?
- 1:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How we deal with it.
- 1:34Bob Gourley: Yes.
- 1:34Bob Gourley: And that's only one chapter in his book, by the way.
- 1:36Bob Gourley: It's a really good book that gets to a lot of questions that you've already been exploring, like what is reality and what is consciousness?
- 1:45Bob Gourley: Now, how do you boil down all of this study of consciousness that so many people are writing just tomes about into a chapter?
- 1:53Bob Gourley: I think he does a really good job of doing that, but it's a it's a tough challenge.
- 1:57Bob Gourley: What is a mind?
- 1:59Bob Gourley: Other people have been trying to apply scientific study to that also.
- 2:03Bob Gourley: I mean, I have a mind, you have a mind, I know it.
- 2:06Bob Gourley: So does my dog.
- 2:08Bob Gourley: I know it.
- 2:08Bob Gourley: Um so do so many other animal life forms.
- 2:12Bob Gourley: And if you, you know, insects think and are creative.
- 2:15Bob Gourley: And people have been writing about the wisdom of birds.
- 2:18Bob Gourley: They have minds.
- 2:19Bob Gourley: Yep.
- 2:19Bob Gourley: But what about a single-cell animal like a paramecium?
- 2:23Bob Gourley: It certainly wants to eat and wants to move and wants to have sex and reproduce.
- 2:29Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 2:30Bob Gourley: Does it have a mind?
- 2:31Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 2:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 2:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is fantastic.
- 2:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I wasn't expecting to have this conversation today.
- 2:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose is joining us.
- 2:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're actually live recording at the moment.
- 2:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, Bob, we were talking about consciousness, and as as Moose gets back in the uh in the cockpit here, the connection to the Oodaloop.
- 2:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, let me give you this idea.
- 2:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When we started this podcast, I I knew about the connection to consciousness and the conversation about the free principle.
- 2:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And Moose is having technical difficulties.
- 2:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He is a crayon's favorite toy.
- 2:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let's let him get in here.
- 2:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I want to get back to this Oodaloop and its connection to consciousness.
- 3:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Tried avoiding that conversation for years, right?
- 3:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because I just didn't want to go there.
- 3:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But it's very clear to me that if you're looking at what Boyd was looking at years ago, and if you're not using the linear four-step decision-making process, but you're looking at the nonlinear, far from equilibrium approach that tells us how living systems interact with their ever-changing environment, then naturally that observoir decide act loop, Boyd's corpus, should be part of the discussion.
- 3:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we're starting to see that now as people are picking up on the things we're putting down on the podcast.
- 3:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So my question to you is are you okay with that?
- 3:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or where where's that fit in your world?
- 3:39Bob Gourley: Yeah, well, to me, yeah, absolutely okay.
- 3:42Bob Gourley: Because to me, what the OODA loop is, you wouldn't need that except you want something.
- 3:48Bob Gourley: Whether you are an individual or an organization, you want something.
- 3:52Bob Gourley: Want is also, in my opinion, central to the discussion of consciousness.
- 3:57Bob Gourley: No matter, I mean, all these theories, so many of them vary about what consciousness is, but all of them seem to have this common theme of we want something.
- 4:09Bob Gourley: We want to understand, we want to grow, we want to learn, we want to learn what consciousness is and where it is.
- 4:15Bob Gourley: And UDA, I think the whole UTA loop and all of Boyd's writings would not be necessary except we want something.
- 4:26Bob Gourley: We want to compete and win.
- 4:28Bob Gourley: And as a nation, we really need to compete and win.
- 4:32Bob Gourley: And as companies, you don't survive unless you compete and win.
- 4:37Bob Gourley: And as individuals uh concerned with uh your current situation or your career, you want to continue to rise and compete and win.
- 4:47Bob Gourley: So yes, I see the OODA loop as directly relevant to understanding consciousness because consciousness is to me is also about wanting something.
- 4:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, let's do this.
- 4:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, we went supersonic and into another, you know, we went towards them towards Mars in in a matter of five minutes.
- 5:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We talked about the uh declaration of connection to aliens, uh, David Brynn's work, and uh we start getting a consciousness.
- 5:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's throttle back a minute uh because uh I think we're gonna scare the crap out of people by going that fast.
- 5:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose, you up?
- 5:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I can hear you now.
- 5:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you hear me?
- 5:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh yeah, let's go.
- 5:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so uh we've been going for the last five minutes, Moose, and uh just getting you up to speed there.
- 5:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But uh welcome Bob to the show.
- 5:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And Moose, welcome back, man.
- 5:28Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 5:28Mark McGrath: Bob, thanks for coming on.
- 5:29Mark McGrath: I've I've been uh blessed to have been your guest twice.
- 5:33Mark McGrath: Uh or is it three times?
- 5:35Mark McGrath: I forget, I think maybe twice.
- 5:38Bob Gourley: Yeah, at least twice.
- 5:39Mark McGrath: I'm losing track, but it's always a good time to uh chat with you.
- 5:42Bob Gourley: It's always educational for me.
- 5:43Mark McGrath: I learn every time you speak.
- 5:46Mark McGrath: Well, let's make uh we'll make today no exception.
- 5:50Mark McGrath: So, you know, I I was interested in the conversation that you're having around consciousness.
- 5:55Mark McGrath: Um as you pointed out, you know, Ponch and I talk about that quite a bit.
- 5:59Mark McGrath: And we really do believe that Boyd was ultimately talking about that.
- 6:03Mark McGrath: And that I think is one of the benefits of talking about Uda in terms of the sketch, because when you realize that it is, as you hear us argue about all the time, not about with each other, but like argue for, that Boyd was empowering us to deal with complexity and be able to rewrite, destroy and rewrite, and destroy and rewrite our perception of that reality in a complex way, which consciousness to me, it always seems like it fits right in.
- 6:34Mark McGrath: And if you look a lot of the corpus of our work around things that we've talked about that other people won't talk about or other people think we're crazy, whether it's psychedelics or trauma or other things, the more and more that we delve into that, the more and more we realize the synergy between Boyd and that whole category, not at the exclusion of military thought or litigation or business or the other or sports or anything else that he's that he was in.
- 6:59Mark McGrath: But what's been remarkable for us over the last two years, especially here in Manhattan, is when you meet more and more of these practitioners of psychedelics and psychiatry and treating for depression and trauma, it is really fascinating to me.
- 7:13Mark McGrath: It's like they understand and get orientation in Oodaloop's sketch, like, oh my gosh, like I've never heard of this guy, Boyd.
- 7:19Mark McGrath: And what's what's also remarkable is the fact that they end up knowing more about Boyd than they ever realized without knowing anything about Boyd.
- 7:26Mark McGrath: Interesting.
- 7:28Bob Gourley: You know, um, that is fascinating.
- 7:30Bob Gourley: And I've of course I've seen similar things where I, you know, maybe I'll meet a CEO and I'll be uh talking about what they do and um across you know any industry.
- 7:39Bob Gourley: And these guys are good at Boyd type things without ever having heard of him.
- 7:44Bob Gourley: But it's just from, I don't know, survival, uh survival of the fittest, some survival of the best competitor.
- 7:51Bob Gourley: And I tell you, I've never really explored uh psychedelics, probably never will, except by uh vicariously reading what you guys write and watching your videos, talking to folks who've scientifically studied this, and it's really fascinating.
- 8:08Mark McGrath: When you think of it in the destruction and creation sense, I think what and and Ponch jump in on this, what I understand of psychedelics is that it's it's empowering us to rewrite our perception, to just again destroy and create perception.
- 8:22Mark McGrath: So we can let go of things like trauma, we can let go of things like PTSD or postpartum depression or whatever it is that someone's being treated for.
- 8:31Mark McGrath: And then what is also really fascinating about that is that my physical orientation becomes aligned with what's actually going on.
- 8:41Mark McGrath: I have a better sense of what's going on.
- 8:44Mark McGrath: The part that is near and dear to all of us as you know, veteran naval officers is the PTSD angle.
- 8:50Mark McGrath: And that's something that I had never I had never thought of.
- 8:53Mark McGrath: But that the more that you dig into Boyd and the more time that you spend in the archives and you and you really are starting to get a sense of where he was coming from, I have a feeling that if he were here, I don't like to speak for him, but if he were here, I would think that he would be pretty curious and interested, specifically on how it was helping veterans deal with something other than, you know, in a way that was different than the sort of standard fare of you know, pills and suicide.
- 9:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose, I got a thought on this.
- 9:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the idea of going outside the system, you know, there's there's Robin Carhart Harris, he talks about the snow globe when you're talking about psychedelics, right?
- 9:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You shake it up and and you get to look at things in a different light.
- 9:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What you're actually doing, I believe, is you're going outside the system, right?
- 9:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We know that's important.
- 9:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can't determine the character of nature from within.
- 9:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You have to go outside.
- 9:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you know the perspective of what happened, what you experienced, and you get to have a new counterfactual created about that, and that rewrites or updates your orientation.
- 9:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's that's why it's so fan, you know, it's a nice connection to genetics, which we know genetically we're predisposed to carry the trauma of our ancestors.
- 9:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know how far that goes, and that may or may not be true at the genetics.
- 9:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're talking about the orientation side and the culture, you know, you and I grew up in, all of us did, you know, where we all learned that alcohol is a good thing and psychedelics are bad.
- 10:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's the war on drugs, basically.
- 10:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, you go to a package store on base and you can get alcohol, right?
- 10:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's right there.
- 10:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's probably the worst thing you can put in your body, right?
- 10:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But so that culture that we were brought into, and then the experiences, uh, and there's something known as the multiple hit hypothesis, if I get this right, that genetics culture and our experiences determine how we view the world, which is exactly what orientation says or suggests inside of Boyd Doodaloop.
- 10:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So thanks for bringing me on that.
- 10:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just had that thought, going outside the system to look inside.
- 10:34Bob Gourley: You know, so let me try a theory on you guys that may resonate from your military background too.
- 10:40Bob Gourley: And that is so I was a military and Navy intelligence officer, and through the years, my first uh focus was on Navy operations.
- 10:47Bob Gourley: Back then it was the Soviet Navy.
- 10:49Bob Gourley: We would try to assess what's happening really close to their ports because we're supporting U.S.
- 10:54Bob Gourley: ships and subs that would go really close into their ports.
- 10:58Bob Gourley: So a very dynamic situation.
- 11:00Bob Gourley: So part one of the job, what is reality?
- 11:02Bob Gourley: Where is everybody right now, all the Soviets, and what are they doing right now?
- 11:07Bob Gourley: Where are they going to be 30 minutes from now?
- 11:09Bob Gourley: But then the harder part to assess is the intention.
- 11:12Bob Gourley: What are they going to do next?
- 11:14Bob Gourley: And really the only way we had of doing that was talking to the older, seasoned pros who'd seen things before and could make reasonable assessments.
- 11:23Bob Gourley: Now, if you fast forward to the big joint military intelligence centers, you have folks doing that at massive scale over entire battlefields.
- 11:31Bob Gourley: Maybe there should be room for a certain cadre of intelligence professionals who are on the psychedelics and are looking at the same thing, but are coming at it from a different angle.
- 11:43Bob Gourley: We and are able to say, you know, here's what I think now.
- 11:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I wouldn't I wouldn't say so.
- 11:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I would say you don't need to be on psychedelics to do that.
- 11:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um you can have a journey at some point.
- 11:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can meditate, you can have um pre-cognition and I think they call it people breath work, post-cognition.
- 11:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So yeah, bringing all this, what would you call it?
- 12:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh the the the flow states into your body, bring it into the organizations.
- 12:05Mark McGrath: Well, it's funny.
- 12:06Mark McGrath: Psychedelics may be part of that.
- 12:07Mark McGrath: One other thing that Bob mentioned was the you know, the intelligence community.
- 12:11Mark McGrath: I I think the intelligence community is all over psychedelics, you know, right right here in my neighborhood around one bedford, as we learned from Norman Oler on one of his episodes, that the CIA was using psychedelics right here in Grench Village to to to you know, I guess the the intent was mind control, but what they realized was like we're not able to control them, but they're they're writing Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Arts Club band or whatever.
- 12:33Mark McGrath: You know what I mean?
- 12:34Mark McGrath: Like they're becoming more creative and more peaceful.
- 12:36Mark McGrath: So I think that it is interesting to see that intelligence has been all over this stuff for a long time.
- 12:42Bob Gourley: Hey, Paul, I mean I don't think they are really.
- 12:46Bob Gourley: They're not.
- 12:47Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 12:47Bob Gourley: Maybe I mean there were some very there were some failed experiments during the Cold War.
- 12:52Bob Gourley: And now I don't know everything that's going on, but there's I don't think there's any formal investment or investigation into psychedelics in the Intel community today, personally.
- 13:02Mark McGrath: Yeah, that's fine.
- 13:02Mark McGrath: I mean, we're we're just I guess historically, maybe um it's changed.
- 13:06Mark McGrath: That's okay.
- 13:07Mark McGrath: But I mean, I guess I guess the I guess the broader point, the the broader point is that that there is a concerted effort across agencies, industries, domains, where people are trying to get a better understanding of what the hell is actually going on.
- 13:21Mark McGrath: And I think that that's really what Boyd was doing was was the milit military might have been the starting point, but reality was what he was trying to help people thrive in.
- 13:31Mark McGrath: And it's not limited to anybody in the military.
- 13:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, Bob, uh let's go back to your uh point about the what you did in the past.
- 13:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's I think you're familiar with Mike Ansley's work on situational awareness, right?
- 13:41Speaker 2: Yes.
- 13:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's really what we're trying to do is what the hell happened, what's happening, and what could happen.
- 13:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that anticipatory awareness of what could happen next.
- 13:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think they call it sense making.
- 13:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if we go back to that language, it's hard, you know, we got to know what to pay attention to in the environment.
- 13:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's what you do.
- 13:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit more about that when you train intelligence officers or you train people to look at the environment?
- 14:03Bob Gourley: Well, you know, first of all, I feel very fortunate that in my youth, I was in that environment where for, I'd say, teen years, I was doing operational intelligence in very dynamic situations, at first as part of a small team and then leading teams that do that.
- 14:18Bob Gourley: And it took about 14 years before I really felt like I was in the flow and I was mastering this profession, or at least starting to get a hold of my hands around it.
- 14:27Bob Gourley: That's around the time that I discovered Boyd.
- 14:31Bob Gourley: It was uh uh we were connecting our ship.
- 14:35Bob Gourley: I was at the on Seventh Fleet on the USS Blue Ridge, their command ship, and we were connecting it to the global telecommunications networks by phones.
- 14:45Bob Gourley: And I was able to connect a phone to my CompuServe account and from there bounce into this new thing, the internet and all the bulletin boards and teach people how to use email and the web.
- 14:55Bob Gourley: And that's when I met G.I.
- 14:57Bob Gourley: Wilson, one of the acolytes of Void, and he started uh giving me all these new ideas about uh command and control warfare and um and started talking about Boyd.
- 15:07Bob Gourley: And when he first started doing that, and I look back on my career, I'm thinking, why had nobody told me this before?
- 15:14Bob Gourley: It would have accelerated my learning and accelerated my productivity.
- 15:19Bob Gourley: And so that part of my journey sticks with me today.
- 15:22Bob Gourley: You fast forward to today, and I'm uh working a lot with companies that are trying to comprehend what's their cyber threat, who's trying to attack them, what are they going to do next?
- 15:32Bob Gourley: Our little consultancy also works with a lot of corporate boards that want to figure out what do I need to do in this new world of AI?
- 15:41Bob Gourley: What do I, what do we invest in?
- 15:44Bob Gourley: And how do we train our people?
- 15:45Bob Gourley: And what are my competitors doing?
- 15:47Bob Gourley: All those old lessons that came from my time in this dynamic environment are just so relevant today to sense making for corporate organizations.
- 15:58Bob Gourley: So my my big regret is I sure wish I could have learned more earlier about these Boyd ideas.
- 16:07Mark McGrath: It's interesting too, I because I when you say it that way, it really makes me realize because I I learned it in the Marine Corps, and I learned that there were still some firsthand accounts of firsthand people that were still on active duty.
- 16:21Mark McGrath: In fact, when I first heard about the Boyd cycle, it was 1995 as a Razzi midshipman, and and Boyd was actually still alive.
- 16:28Mark McGrath: And to think that, you know, he you know, this is all kind of pre-internet as we know it, and back in 1995, we remember those days, it would have been interesting to at some point it clicked to me that what I had been taught in the Marine Corps was the limited version that they wanted us to know, but the in-depth version of what he was actually working on.
- 16:50Mark McGrath: I had to pull all those threads myself.
- 16:53Mark McGrath: I couldn't, I wasn't going to get that from the Marine Corps.
- 16:55Mark McGrath: That was all uh, you know, in um independent research.
- 16:58Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 16:59Bob Gourley: I was also very fortunate to go to um a Marine Corps command and staff college where uh, and this was '97.
- 17:07Bob Gourley: So by by then, Boyd's ideas had taken the place over, and it was uh a great opportunity to study more.
- 17:16Bob Gourley: Still, of course, very much maneuver warfare focused.
- 17:20Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 17:21Bob Gourley: And another great teacher, I mean, besides you guys, which are both great teachers of this stuff now, is uh Chet Richards, who I I loved because of his taking of these concepts and putting it in a business context where it's just so totally relevant.
- 17:36Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 17:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I would have challenge both of you on something.
- 17:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and I just thought about this.
- 17:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we talk about Boyd's ideas.
- 17:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: A lot of the ideas that Boyd has in his, you know, in his discourse winning and losing are not his ideas.
- 17:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're borrowed from somewhere else.
- 17:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All he did was look at things.
- 17:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He was curious, right?
- 17:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And he was very curious about multiple disciplines, multiple domains.
- 17:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we often talk about ideas from John Boyd.
- 17:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: To me, I think that might be wrong.
- 18:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I want to get your take on that, uh, Moose and Bob.
- 18:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are they his or they're a good question?
- 18:05Bob Gourley: I bet you something tells me Boyd would agree with you.
- 19:07Bob Gourley: Because he pulled from so many disciplines: biology, physics, philosophy, economics.
- 19:13Mark McGrath: History, Eastern philosophy.
- 19:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So maybe we're doing a disservice by talking about his ideas rather than another way to look at it.
- 19:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I just hearing you guys talk about it, let's let's explore that for a minute.
- 19:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose thoughts.
- 19:25Mark McGrath: Well, I mean, I think that that is one of the ways that I really resonated with Boyd because I was brought up in a very, I don't want to say orthodox, but a very definitional sort of classical liberal arts education from being a kid and going through the high school that I went through, um, and then the the you know, the program that I went through through a college of liberal arts.
- 19:48Mark McGrath: So being exposed to so many things from so many perspectives was one of the ways that I probably related and identified with Boyd the most as I started to dig in.
- 19:58Mark McGrath: Because, you know, when people explained UDI and the Marine Corps and the Boyd cycle, it was very the, you know, it was the linear version.
- 20:04Mark McGrath: Get inside somebody's Ouda loop, you know, out-orient, outspeed, outthink, but it wasn't out-orient.
- 20:09Mark McGrath: And that came with, you know, kind of touching on what Bob said.
- 20:12Mark McGrath: That that came when I discovered Chet Richard's work, Franzo Singa's work, John Robb and others.
- 20:17Mark McGrath: And then being on Wall Street and not in the Marine Corps, that really helped too, because it showed me that whatever Boyd was chasing after was not merely limited to the military, that Boyd was in fact a theorist that discovered the way complexity actually works, the way the universe actually works, and how humans can be empowered to thrive in it.
- 20:39Mark McGrath: And, you know, there is the quote unquote danger or risk of creating a theory of everything.
- 20:43Mark McGrath: But on the other hand, there's a great gift that creating a theory of everything.
- 20:46Mark McGrath: Because as Bob said, Boyd pulled from literally everywhere and showed that not only can I understand this logically, philosophically, strategically, but I could also understand this as part of my, of my uh, of my evolutionary biology.
- 21:00Mark McGrath: And then as our clients know, Ponch, you know, when they start interacting with us and they see that we are doing what Boyd told us to do, leave it open and add and develop and and and and and tweak and and build on.
- 21:14Mark McGrath: That's when you start adding things like McLuhan and others that really broaden.
- 21:19Mark McGrath: You know, when I I got this from John Robb.
- 21:22Mark McGrath: When I started looking at McLuhan in tandem with Boyd, it actually made my understanding of Boyd expand significantly.
- 21:29Mark McGrath: But then vice versa, I was able to understand McCluin quicker and better than the sort of stereotype view of communication because I understood Boyd so well, you know.
- 21:40Mark McGrath: And then there's there's other thinkers that the same thing.
- 21:43Mark McGrath: But basically, what we realized is that Boyd wanted us to create snowmobiles ourselves and build on what he left intentionally open and incomplete.
- 21:55Mark McGrath: And the last line of Franzo Singer's science, strategy, and war, but that's it.
- 21:58Mark McGrath: That's the last line.
- 21:59Mark McGrath: He left this incomplete for uh for a reason.
- 22:02Mark McGrath: He used to say, Bob, and you know this.
- 22:04Mark McGrath: If you think that this is doctrine and granite and set in stone, take it out and burn it right now and shoot me, because uh I I I don't know.
- 22:11Mark McGrath: I'm constantly learning, I'm constantly adapting.
- 22:14Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah.
- 22:16Bob Gourley: Well, you know, and I I do think this applies to so many other fields.
- 22:19Bob Gourley: And when you my eyes were opened in thinking this kind of thing, you know, it's well, let me just put it this way it's relevant to science and physics.
- 22:27Bob Gourley: You know, there's uh three major theories in physics now, and they're all incomplete and they're all wrong, but they're all we've got to work with.
- 22:36Bob Gourley: There's the general theory of relativity, which is just so important and a great framing, but it's incomplete.
- 22:41Bob Gourley: There's uh quantum mechanics, but it's the math of quantum mechanics is the most widely understood math in the world, I think, the most widely studied, and it works, but it's incomplete.
- 22:52Bob Gourley: It's totally incomplete and doesn't explain things and doesn't connect the quantum world to gravity.
- 22:57Bob Gourley: And then there's the standard model of all the particles.
- 23:01Bob Gourley: Man, that's a beautiful theory.
- 23:03Bob Gourley: But none of those things are describing reality well enough, and all of them are wrong.
- 23:08Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 23:09Mark McGrath: Um there's a there's a it's you mentioned G.I., you know, who's been a guest on our show, and he's a friend and mentor, in addition to being a brother marine.
- 23:17Mark McGrath: But one of the things that boyed.
- 23:18Mark McGrath: Had told him that stood out that we, I mean, we were going through our transcripts of our podcast.
- 23:23Mark McGrath: I had forgotten that he had he had mentioned this.
- 23:25Mark McGrath: That Boyd told him that math is imprecise.
- 23:28Mark McGrath: And it threw him through a loop, like, you know, what the hell are you talking about?
- 23:34Mark McGrath: Like, no, math is not precise.
- 23:36Mark McGrath: How do we know that?
- 23:37Mark McGrath: Well, Girdle's second uh Girdle's incompleteness theorem, you know, no system can verify, you can't verify calculus with calculus.
- 23:43Mark McGrath: You can't verify algebra with algebra.
- 23:46Mark McGrath: So that math was imprecise.
- 23:48Mark McGrath: And he's like, that kind of thinking and open-mindedness and acceptance of that reality is exactly why you have to destroy and create, exactly why you have to stay on the world of reorientation, because math is imprecise.
- 24:00Mark McGrath: It's like any other model, it's it's or a map.
- 24:03Mark McGrath: You know, it's it's useless, but useful.
- 24:06Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 24:07Bob Gourley: Well, I sure look forward to someone destroying and creating all these theories of physics and coming up with a better understanding of what reality is.
- 24:15Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 24:16Mark McGrath: Well, and and Boyd was on that because you know, he he was not only he was delving into the quantum world late in his life, but the fact that he could show that even Newtonian physics, it did seem to verify things that you know you could pull from that.
- 24:29Mark McGrath: But then as Chuck Spinney points out in his his evolutionary epistemology, is like, well, Newton's not enough.
- 24:36Mark McGrath: Yeah, you got to build on top of Newton, and then and then there was this and there was that and there was that, and it just keeps going.
- 24:41Mark McGrath: That's the that's the conceptual spiral.
- 24:43Mark McGrath: And I think that that's another massive part.
- 24:45Mark McGrath: And G.I.
- 24:46Mark McGrath: himself said this on the show, is like, if if you don't talk about, if you don't understand destruction, creation, conceptual spiral, and the essence of winning and losing, which includes oodaloop sketch, if you don't understand those things as Boyd did and work to understand them as Boyd did, and then build off of those things as Boyd did, then you're not going to get Boyd.
- 25:07Mark McGrath: You know, because patterns of conflict and everything else, it's all along that vein of main thinking from destruction creation to Oodaloop sketch.
- 25:15Mark McGrath: That's the part that people don't realize.
- 25:18Mark McGrath: And I think that that's the part where people leave so much power of Boyd on the table because they think that patterns of conflict is set in stone or organic design for command control is set in stone, and it's not.
- 25:29Mark McGrath: It's those are experimental outputs along the journey of destruction, creation, conceptual spiral, the essence of winning and losing, and then he dies.
- 25:38Mark McGrath: And we know that if he had lived another 10 years, it wouldn't have stopped with this.
- 25:43Mark McGrath: It would have kept, it would have kept going.
- 25:45Mark McGrath: And that's where that's where we're trying to pick up.
- 25:47Mark McGrath: And that's where I think where we have a lot of success with people is getting them to see that.
- 25:51Mark McGrath: That is in fact not formulaic, it's not linear, it's actually trying to channel complexity, you know, the tap into the vibrations and frequencies that that complexity is constantly throwing at us.
- 26:03Mark McGrath: But the only way you can do that is by rewriting that right there, by constantly destroying and rewriting your orientation.
- 26:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, Bob, last week I was at Duke University with Adrian Bajan, and then this uh there's a poster in the background, and this connects to Mandelbrot, uh, what John Boyd was looking at late in his life.
- 26:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it said uh the the world is fractal, or is it constructal?
- 26:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the constructal law is uh it's an extension of the second law of thermodynamics.
- 26:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It basically says it says that uh all living systems are flow systems.
- 26:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's an evolution towards freedom, right?
- 26:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we use that to sort of explain the basics of the Oodaloop that you need an input and output, you need a boundary, uh statistical boundary to understand the system you're looking at, and knowing that that evolution or design is to be optimized to improve the flow of the currency that moves through it.
- 26:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Rather, it could be information, it could be oil, it could be blood, it could be whatever, right?
- 26:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this didn't exist when John Boyd was still alive, right?
- 26:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But he gave us that pathway and said, keep looking down here, look at Mandelbrot and see where that takes us, because I think that's in the conceptual spiral, right?
- 27:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose Mandelbrot is mentioned in there.
- 27:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 27:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So and then we get into bigger and better things, maybe things like ecological dynamics.
- 27:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't think Boyd looked at that, but that's just the perception action loop, which is to us, it's embedded inside the oodle loop.
- 27:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you get into things like active inference and predictive processing, which is gonna be missed if you look at the linear circular OODA loop.
- 27:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's what a lot of AI researchers and AI companies are doing is they go, here's our AI map to the four-step OODA loop.
- 27:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, I don't know if you want to do that.
- 27:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That may not be a good idea.
- 27:39Mark McGrath: From an intelligent profess, you know, from an intelligence professional standpoint, it seems to me that many stop at data aggregation or information and they turn that into knowledge and then they stop there.
- 27:54Mark McGrath: They don't they don't get into the to the hierarchy, which would be understanding next or wisdom beyond that.
- 28:00Mark McGrath: But just to get to the point of understanding, is that well, you know.
- 28:05Bob Gourley: We have a problem in the Intel community as well, and that is the intelligence cycle.
- 28:10Bob Gourley: And you can find this on every Intel agency webpage.
- 28:13Bob Gourley: It's taught in every Intel schoolhouse.
- 28:16Bob Gourley: It's probably taught in every academic institution that has intelligence courses.
- 28:20Bob Gourley: And the intelligence cycle is collect, process, analyze, disseminate.
- 28:27Bob Gourley: And it's a it's a cycle.
- 28:29Bob Gourley: Then some agencies will bend themselves in here, they'll say, We're NSA, we're in the collect group phase, or we're DIA, we're in the analysis group.
- 28:36Bob Gourley: Well, that is a failed model, just like the linear version of the OODA loop.
- 28:42Bob Gourley: You're not just collecting stage one, stop, finish collecting, and then process, finish processing.
- 28:51Bob Gourley: Now, now I'll do my analysis.
- 28:53Bob Gourley: All that stuff occurs all the time in an extremely complex uh environment where your adversary is also making decisions and changing the environment.
- 29:04Bob Gourley: It's very the same kind of problem is set up in our when our schoolhouses teach that there is an intelligence cycle by this continuous ongoing um interaction where you are continuously collecting and continuously analyzing and continuously processing and of course disseminating the results of your intelligence and making decisions and changing the environment where your adversaries are at.
- 29:31Mark McGrath: So where does synthesis fit?
- 29:35Mark McGrath: You know, it's one thing to analyze and disseminate, but if I analyze, synthesize, then disseminate, what would that what would that give me?
- 29:41Bob Gourley: Yeah, and this creating data from knowledge, um uh I'm sorry, I said that backwards.
- 29:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:48Bob Gourley: Taking data in uh sense making and understanding and then creating knowledge is the more important piece of that.
- 29:55Bob Gourley: And then in a continuous environment where you do want access to all the data and you do want to know every historical fact of every adversary, and you also want to be able to run scenarios and figure out what the adversary is constrained by so you can come up with assessments on what we should do.
- 30:14Mark McGrath: See, this is where the this is interesting.
- 30:16Mark McGrath: This is where the McLuhan would would come in and serve people very well because when McLuhan says the medium is the message, the medium is the technology available, the medium is the environment and the technology, or the environment rather, that the that the technology creates, whether it's the you know, the spoken or the written word looking from left to right that always forces us in a state of of linear thinking or the you know the electronic technology that basically overrides our nervous system.
- 30:45Mark McGrath: People don't understand when they hear the medium is the message, they they think of some esoteric communication or advertising slogan.
- 30:53Mark McGrath: What they what they miss is that technology and environment have a direct effect on our our human capabilities, how we sense, how we feel, how we how we process, how we how we analyze.
- 31:05Mark McGrath: And and they don't also realize that you know the enemy gets a vote, but the environment gets a vote too.
- 31:10Mark McGrath: And the technology that that created that environment also has a vote and an effect too.
- 31:15Mark McGrath: And if you miss that, you're essentially a fish that doesn't know that they're in water.
- 31:19Mark McGrath: And that's what that's that's what McLuhan I think really adds to Boyd, that when I understand that better, it kind of does tie in with Boyd saying in you know, powers of conflict, like the the the map and the terrain are two different, you know, are two completely different things.
- 31:31Mark McGrath: And that's what McLuhan's trying to, that's where the I think the compounding says.
- 31:35Mark McGrath: But you know, like AI, you know, Ponch and I talk about this a lot, where people will say, oh, you know, somebody used AI, you know, or it's like saying back when we were younger, like, oh, somebody used Google, they cheated, you know.
- 31:46Mark McGrath: Um when you think about how AI, the fact that they're even talking and complaining about AI, it's having a direct effect on them.
- 31:53Mark McGrath: It's having a direct effect on their environment, um, even whether or not they're using it, they're still subject to it.
- 31:59Mark McGrath: It's still, it's still being done around them, and it's creating the environment around them, which in turn reshapes their orientation unbeknownst to them, or or actually it's reshaping their orientation, which guides and controls how they sense make.
- 32:11Mark McGrath: And they don't realize that something's off because they don't understand.
- 32:14Mark McGrath: They know Boyd, maybe they know McLuhan, they just don't understand it.
- 32:19Bob Gourley: Yeah, so maybe another analogy is uh snowmobiles.
- 32:22Bob Gourley: How would you know to build a snowmobile unless you understood all of the technologies that you're trying to uh combine something about them?
- 32:31Bob Gourley: And a lot of people are so averse to AI, they're not learning it well enough, so they don't understand how to take advantage of it.
- 32:37Bob Gourley: And uh they see other people using it and maybe making mistakes, and they call out those mistakes and belittle it and downgrade it and downplay it.
- 32:47Bob Gourley: My view, we should all be running towards this and learning all these AI tools.
- 32:52Bob Gourley: A friend of mine in a uh large group uh chat in Signal asked a question of everyone uh Hey, I'm just curious, uh, what AI tools are you using?
- 33:01Bob Gourley: Open AI or Claude Anthropic or Perplexity?
- 33:04Bob Gourley: And I answered right away, I'm using all of them every day for business, including Google Gemini.
- 33:11Bob Gourley: And I'm using it because it makes a difference for me.
- 33:14Bob Gourley: I use every single one of those tools.
- 33:16Bob Gourley: And another reason I use it is to keep learning, because if I don't keep learning, I'm I'm gonna make myself irrelevant.
- 33:23Bob Gourley: So I push these things to the limit.
- 33:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 33:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do you find Bob?
- 33:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just saw your signal, I saw you on Signal writing about that, so I appreciate that.
- 33:32Mark McGrath: Do you find Bob?
- 33:33Mark McGrath: I mean, uh, because I I've I've said this quite a bit.
- 33:36Mark McGrath: I I feel like I read more books now and learn more things because of AI has eliminated a lot of the menial work that I would have to do to get to the understanding of something.
- 33:50Mark McGrath: You know, Isaac Asimov and Buckminster Fuller were both famous for calling for the automation of education because they believed it would enhance and empower learning and accelerate learning.
- 34:00Mark McGrath: And the reason that they did, or you know, one of the reasons that they said that was because it would eliminate a lot of the menial tasks that have nothing to do with learning.
- 34:09Mark McGrath: I'm clearing that off, and I can focus exactly on the on the concepts.
- 34:14Mark McGrath: I mean, do you do you find that as you explore with AI?
- 34:18Bob Gourley: I actually find a worry in all of this, and maybe it's a warning to myself and others, and that is uh I've always got a book around.
- 34:27Bob Gourley: I'm always reading at least one.
- 34:28Bob Gourley: This is the current one, David Brynn's Alien Minds.
- 34:31Bob Gourley: Fantastic.
- 34:32Bob Gourley: But I feel like I'm reading a little bit less.
- 34:35Bob Gourley: I'm spending so much time trying to learn these AI tools.
- 34:39Bob Gourley: There's always another one to learn.
- 34:40Bob Gourley: Invested so much time in OpenClaw, for example, building really enjoyable systems and having fun that it takes away from my reading time.
- 34:50Bob Gourley: So I'm for you know, I have been kind of trying to block time and go sit in the chair, read in a relaxed way, and then other times I come back and I I haven't read a book fully through.
- 35:01Bob Gourley: I've bounced around.
- 35:03Bob Gourley: So maybe that's a maybe that's a warning to myself.
- 35:06Bob Gourley: I need to really have more quiet.
- 35:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I'm the same, Bob.
- 35:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I'm finding that uh I used to read like four or five books a month.
- 35:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and it's been at least six months since I've done that.
- 35:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and recently it's been tough to get through a book.
- 35:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, mainly because I I'll say this my workload has actually gone up.
- 35:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um I'm very I'm more productive, uh the quality of work has gone up, but I'm finding now that I can do more and I want to do more.
- 35:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I don't need as many people helping me, or you know, like we had in the past.
- 35:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um so so now we're accelerating these things.
- 35:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Moose create some software.
- 35:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose is marine.
- 35:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He doesn't even know what he's a cream.
- 35:47Mark McGrath: I um you know, I've only been with Claude like at the higher level than the basic, you know, just for a couple of weeks now.
- 35:56Mark McGrath: And um I I created a a full-blown Bob, you and I on our I think on our first show, we talked about Austrian economics, so you know that I have a master's in that.
- 36:09Mark McGrath: And there's a lot of synergy with Boyd because you know, Boyd read Hayek and everything.
- 36:13Mark McGrath: And it's actually how I really expanded into Austrian economics was the fact that I thought that Mises' axiom for human action was basically ODA.
- 36:21Mark McGrath: And that's how I got there.
- 36:22Mark McGrath: But the point of the story was I thought, I wonder if I could make an API-driven detectable intelligence system to talk about uh the business cycle, what stages based off of Austrian theory.
- 36:34Mark McGrath: And I did it on my iPhone on a train ride from New Jersey back home to Manhattan, and then the next morning from Manhattan back to New Jersey, just on my iPhone, and basically had the basis and the foundation laid for code to create a website.
- 36:50Mark McGrath: I had never done anything remotely approaching that before, but that's where we're at with this stuff.
- 36:54Bob Gourley: Yeah, it well, let me tell you, just to personalize it some, in my family for 40 years, I've been the nerd.
- 37:01Bob Gourley: My wife's the one who makes fun of me for being a nerd.
- 37:03Bob Gourley: She'll use computers, she'll use email, web browsers, and any tool like that.
- 37:07Bob Gourley: But I'm the nerd.
- 37:08Bob Gourley: Well, she asked me about eight months ago, how do I use ChatGPT?
- 37:12Bob Gourley: And I showed her.
- 37:13Bob Gourley: And the reason why she was asking, instead of just telling me to use ChatGPT for, was she wanted to learn programming.
- 37:19Bob Gourley: And now she's cranking these programs out.
- 37:22Bob Gourley: Real things that do stuff for her that she wanted built.
- 37:26Bob Gourley: And so I think this is a very common story now.
- 37:29Bob Gourley: There's soon there will be millions of people creating their own programs to do stuff that they want done.
- 37:35Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 37:37Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 37:37Mark McGrath: I mean, that's again, I think that's where what Asimov and Buckminster Fuller were saying, that that's going to be the beauty of all this stuff is that you're going to be able to do uh to do exactly that.
- 37:48Mark McGrath: You know, I've I've I've started dabbling with like uh you know scenario simulations.
- 37:54Mark McGrath: Like, you know, we we we run those for for teams.
- 37:56Mark McGrath: So I wanted to see if I could create my own.
- 37:58Mark McGrath: I wanted to see if I could, you know, I'm I'm Irish and Puerto Rican and I speak Spanish.
- 38:02Mark McGrath: I wanted to stay stay proficient in my Spanish.
- 38:04Mark McGrath: Now, granted, living in Manhattan, you know, there's plenty of opportunities, but like I wonder if I could create a system.
- 38:10Mark McGrath: And sure enough, like same, same story.
- 38:12Mark McGrath: If they did on a train ride one way, a train ride the other.
- 38:15Mark McGrath: And I had like a full-blown like, you know, language teaching system on Claude, just like that.
- 38:21Mark McGrath: You know, it's crazy.
- 38:22Bob Gourley: Yeah, it's interesting.
- 38:23Bob Gourley: In the old days, that would have been an unproductive time for you.
- 38:26Bob Gourley: If you were lucky, you might have read a newspaper.
- 38:28Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 38:29Bob Gourley: Um, and now look at you, you're creating things.
- 38:31Mark McGrath: So here's I guess here's the thought then.
- 38:33Mark McGrath: I mean, really, when and I think this might be where Boyd would have a lot and and and McClure have a lot to say.
- 38:38Mark McGrath: This, you know, we have these, we have these legacy institutions, and you've heard me talk about the guardians of decay, and they're guarding these institutions that are constantly being proven obsolete by the pervasive technology like AI that I can build myself.
- 38:52Mark McGrath: I don't have to go back to grad school to get a master's in Spanish, I could just build one on Claude and I can I can do that myself.
- 38:58Mark McGrath: And what's interesting is just the other day, somebody had the bracket.
- 39:01Mark McGrath: I think it was a Columbia thread needle, had a bracket or an investment shop, and they had the actual bracket at the very beginning.
- 39:08Mark McGrath: And instead of the, it had the team name and it had the four-year total tuition for each one of those schools.
- 39:15Mark McGrath: So you when you're looking at the bracket, you know, and you see Duke and it had this much and St.
- 39:19Mark McGrath: John, you know, and it's hundreds and hundreds of thousands.
- 39:21Mark McGrath: It's a lot more than when we went to college, right?
- 39:23Mark McGrath: And it got me thinking about economics that when technology improves and things become more widely available, the prices of those things should be going one direction, down.
- 39:35Mark McGrath: The fact that they're not going down really does say something.
- 39:38Mark McGrath: And I think as this technology becomes more and more accessible and more and more available, a lot of institutional things, not just education, but a lot of things are on notice and they're probably past their shelf life.
- 39:49Mark McGrath: And they probably have coyote syndrome I've written about on the world, where coyote runs off the cliff and he doesn't fall unless he looks down.
- 39:56Mark McGrath: And I think a lot of them just haven't looked down yet.
- 40:00Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 40:00Bob Gourley: It could be, it could be that it's just a racket and these guys are going to continue and they're going to keep milking the money out of the system for as long as we're all around.
- 40:08Bob Gourley: But it it sure seems wrong and sub-optimized.
- 40:12Bob Gourley: Yeah, graduate someone, and if they've applied themselves, then they've learned a lot and built great networks and have friends when they leave, and it helps accelerate their career.
- 40:22Bob Gourley: If they've laid back and just gone through, they end up with just a piece of paper that's not going to help them all, and they're paying debt.
- 40:29Bob Gourley: So it's a system ripe for disruption.
- 40:32Bob Gourley: Meanwhile, these AI-enabled tools will help teach you and you can self-learn and self-educate.
- 40:38Bob Gourley: More and more people are deciding to go that path of self-educating.
- 40:42Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 40:42Bob Gourley: But I can't say I recommend that for people in this world.
- 40:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 40:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, hey, Bob, you're dialed into a lot of things that are happening.
- 40:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you see a lot of weak signals in the environment.
- 40:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you share with us what you're seeing that some of our listeners may not be aware of right now?
- 40:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, I I know it's a big question, but what what kind of what's top of your mind when you're looking at what's going on the last few weeks and coming across your desk?
- 41:02Bob Gourley: Well, one thing is how interconnected our systems of systems are.
- 41:05Bob Gourley: People use the word supply chain, and then for some folks, when you hear supply chain, your eyes roll over and it's like, no, but really, maybe that's because it's so hard for a human to comprehend what we've built.
- 41:17Bob Gourley: Every continent is trading with every other continent, every country is trading with every other country, and we have these complex supply chains where the things we depend on really require oil and fertilizer, the precursors to fertilizer.
- 41:32Bob Gourley: And if you like computers, like I like computers and you like the advanced AI, you need these NVIDIA-designed chips, which require helium, which, by the way, humans don't create helium.
- 41:46Bob Gourley: Helium is created by radioactive decay and is trapped in the earth, and then it's released at the same time that natural gas and some petroleum is released, and then it's captured.
- 41:57Bob Gourley: And about 30% of the world's helium comes from Hormuz.
- 42:00Bob Gourley: And now this helium is critical to manufacturing of chips.
- 42:03Bob Gourley: I look at all of this, and my first understanding is uh look, I don't understand it.
- 42:09Bob Gourley: I have no idea what's going to happen, but it seems like there's a lot of interrelated things that are failing and it's going to translate into the economy.
- 42:19Bob Gourley: There's some parts of the economy that you just that can't lie and you can't cover up, like bond prices.
- 42:24Bob Gourley: It's going to be reflected in that.
- 42:26Bob Gourley: And it's it's going to have an impact.
- 42:29Bob Gourley: I that's my view.
- 42:30Bob Gourley: So even if it opens up tomorrow, this stuff is going to have an impact.
- 42:34Bob Gourley: But I also should be quick to say this.
- 42:38Bob Gourley: I think it's wrong to say that Iran should have a nuclear weapon.
- 42:43Bob Gourley: The old Iran should have been given nuclear weapons or allowed to develop them.
- 42:47Bob Gourley: Should have been stopped 40 years ago.
- 42:49Bob Gourley: It wasn't.
- 42:49Bob Gourley: So I'm I don't know how it's going to play out.
- 42:52Bob Gourley: And which gets to another point.
- 42:55Bob Gourley: When you don't know how something's going to happen, you can ask someone to predict the future.
- 42:59Bob Gourley: That person's going to get it wrong.
- 43:01Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 43:01Bob Gourley: All predictions fail.
- 43:03Bob Gourley: So what do we do?
- 43:04Bob Gourley: We do scenarios, multiple scenarios, and think through, you know, uh do scenario planning instead of future prediction.
- 43:11Mark McGrath: Well, I'm really glad you brought that up.
- 43:13Mark McGrath: I mean, a lot of people come up to me and they're like, Well, you must have an opinion on Iran.
- 43:17Mark McGrath: I mean, you know, you're talking like you're a Marine, you're talking about, you know, Oodaloop and all that.
- 43:21Mark McGrath: I go, you know, Iran has been going on, you know, on one hand, I'm thinking, oh, this is terrible.
- 43:25Mark McGrath: On the other hand, I'm like, this has been an issue my entire life.
- 43:28Mark McGrath: I was three years old when the Ayatollah took over.
- 43:31Mark McGrath: I was 10 years old when Iran Contra went down, or when the Vincent shot down a plane, or when, you know, the Iran, I'm old enough to remember the Iran-Iraq war when Saddam Hussein was our friend.
- 43:41Mark McGrath: It's like, don't tell me that this is.
- 43:43Mark McGrath: By the way, I don't know if you saw this.
- 43:45Mark McGrath: There's on Twitter, Punch, I may have sent it to you.
- 43:47Mark McGrath: There's a video of Donald Trump in like 1985 talking about Iran being this big problem, and Iran needs this, and Iran can't be doing this, and Iran.
- 43:58Mark McGrath: It's like, this is nothing new.
- 44:01Mark McGrath: And it goes back to orientation.
- 44:03Mark McGrath: You know, it's almost like problems in Iran part of the American cultural traditions, you know, and genetic heritage, certainly in our lifetimes, because it just doesn't seem to be a problem that ever goes away.
- 44:15Mark McGrath: You know?
- 44:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So go back to Boyd, survive and thrive on your own terms, right?
- 44:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's important.
- 44:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and my view on this, and and again, I don't like talking about this much, but this is going to happen.
- 44:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This being some type of conflict with Iran is going to happen.
- 44:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um it it could have it could have been a lot worse.
- 44:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It can still get worse, don't get me wrong.
- 44:34Mark McGrath: But it also could have happened anytime over the last 50 years.
- 44:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 44:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it could have happened underneath any administration, past, current, or future.
- 44:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It was going to happen.
- 44:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What happened?
- 44:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what matters, right?
- 44:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It happened.
- 44:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here we are.
- 44:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So to survive survive and thrive on your own terms, if you use that type of thinking, potentially this is the right thing to do.
- 44:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Potentially.
- 44:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not saying it is, I'm just saying it could be.
- 44:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if you forecast out or project out two years, three years, and there's a nuclear you know, capable Iran, that's a completely different scenario than what we have today, right?
- 45:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, and and and do you want to find yourself in that situation?
- 45:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if you go back to uh Rob's work on zero day warfare, right?
- 45:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 45:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's still a threat here, right?
- 45:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think when I have a conversation with my family and Moose, we'll talk.
- 45:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: About our infrastructure could be attacked from intern from within, right?
- 45:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There is that potential.
- 45:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That hasn't happened yet.
- 45:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It could.
- 45:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And this is what we've been talking about on the show is we've been laying these, this is all possible.
- 45:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: These are things that we know.
- 45:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We need to pay attention to those things.
- 45:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And those people that aren't paying attention, I think are the ones that are really upset today that things are happening.
- 45:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, gas is going up.
- 45:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 45:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And don't get me wrong, Bob.
- 45:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm I'm upset too.
- 45:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't like what's happening.
- 45:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Not one bit.
- 45:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I think it's better than the alternative, which could have been on our doorstep in the new state.
- 45:52Bob Gourley: I think that's very well put.
- 45:53Bob Gourley: You know, I I think similar thoughts are with me anyway, are with this transformation we're all going through with AI.
- 46:00Bob Gourley: This is going to hurt a lot of people.
- 46:02Bob Gourley: There's going to be disruption, and people have had intentions of doing something that they're not going to be able to do, careers will be changed.
- 46:09Bob Gourley: But on the other end of that, it's going to be much better.
- 46:13Bob Gourley: I'm sure.
- 46:14Bob Gourley: That's my view, anyway, is uh maybe it's because I'm an optimist and naive.
- 46:18Bob Gourley: And we just, to me, you always have to look at the alternative.
- 46:22Bob Gourley: When it comes to Iran, the alternative of them having nuclear weapons and even more ballistic missiles with longer range and an even stronger Navy and an ability to choke off and own the entire Persian Gulf, it's would not be a good situation.
- 46:38Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 46:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So all these things are coming to a head right now.
- 46:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: AI, we got uh, you know, changes in, you know, we got my parents are all retired, and I'm getting close to that retirement age.
- 46:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, there's so many things coming to a head right now.
- 46:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're in the fourth turning, if you want to call it that.
- 46:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, so it's an amazing time to be alive.
- 46:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've got the Artemis II mission potentially launching, launching in the next few days to go back uh to the moon or around the moon at least.
- 47:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and I want to challenge an assumption here that going back to the Strait of Hormuz, helium, NVIDIA, and the uh thirst for power or energy, all right?
- 47:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the current large language models require a lot of energy, a lot of compute power, right?
- 47:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What if we all have that wrong?
- 47:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you've had you know David Bray, Professor Bray, right?
- 47:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and you hear him talking about uh different alternatives to AI.
- 47:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What if everybody, not everybody, Wall Street investors, folks that are fixated on large language models, what if that's the wrong path?
- 47:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What would happen if you follow what David Bray is saying quite a bit?
- 47:37Bob Gourley: Well, I think it is a path.
- 47:39Bob Gourley: It's an extremely important path.
- 47:41Bob Gourley: And Dario Amoti, the CEO of Anthropic, has uh raised a question that really puzzled me why he was saying this at first.
- 47:48Bob Gourley: He said, for the large language model capabilities, are we reaching the end of the exponential?
- 47:55Bob Gourley: Because, of course, now what he meant was the classic S curve that we're in now, where it's going straight up and is it going to go up for how long?
- 48:02Bob Gourley: And he's thinking, could it be the end of the exponential for LLMs?
- 48:06Bob Gourley: And when he said that, I started to think, you know, maybe he's right.
- 48:09Bob Gourley: And he got into more details about there are limits.
- 48:12Bob Gourley: There's limits in the size of data centers that can be built and limits in the amount of energy you can use, and limits of the amount of uh diffusion of the results into infrastructure.
- 48:21Bob Gourley: It could be that for LLMs and that approach, we're nearing the end of the S-curve.
- 48:26Bob Gourley: But there are other approaches, and just like other technologies that then build on that S-curve and keep going up.
- 48:32Bob Gourley: For example, there's a new capability called World Models.
- 48:36Bob Gourley: And world models is getting billions of investments, and it's a different approach to AI.
- 48:41Bob Gourley: I think that's gonna go somewhere.
- 48:42Bob Gourley: There's a new infrastructure capability called thermodynamic computing.
- 48:46Bob Gourley: XTropic has built these chips that take 10,000 percent less power.
- 48:52Bob Gourley: Um, and they accomplish important things for AI.
- 48:57Bob Gourley: So there's all these innovations that are gonna keep coming and keep delivering AI that might not be large language models.
- 49:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna build on that real fast.
- 49:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So large language models are linear, circular, or four-step oodaloops, right?
- 49:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So they can only go so far.
- 49:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The world model that you just brought up is Boyd's real oodaloop, right?
- 49:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's the generative model, the world model orientation.
- 49:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It has an orientation and it's it's a learning AI.
- 49:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I kind of think we're on that right now is I haven't heard about that exponential aspect of it, and that has, but I do get the S-curve thing.
- 49:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's pretty powerful.
- 49:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we can actually explain that to folks now in a new way.
- 49:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So thank thank you for that.
- 49:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But that's what I'm looking at too is the next generation of AI, we'll call it the world model AI, um, is is a lower energy approach, right?
- 49:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that it crushes current assumptions.
- 49:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think we need to be prepared for that because going back to the helium point through the straight or whore moves, this may not be a problem in the future.
- 49:57Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 49:58Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 49:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um the near future.
- 50:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, the near future, not five years down the road.
- 50:03Bob Gourley: Yeah, the near future, there's that and all the other things that, you know, I certainly don't comprehend how it all connects things like the precursors to fertilizer, and we're already seeing the commodity prices jump up for fertilizer, which of course impacts our farmers.
- 50:17Bob Gourley: And it's all interrelated and interconnected in complex ways.
- 50:22Bob Gourley: But when it comes to AI, yeah, world models, much closer, I think, to UTA.
- 50:28Bob Gourley: And who knows what comes after that.
- 50:32Mark McGrath: How many people do you think that this is channeling Boyd?
- 50:36Mark McGrath: You know, Boyd would hear a thesis and automatically assume the antithesis, the antithesis, to in order to come up with a thesis.
- 50:45Mark McGrath: That's the that's the Hegelian dialect that even got to creating snowmobiles, right?
- 50:49Mark McGrath: Because that's a that's a that's a dialectic exercise.
- 50:52Mark McGrath: How many people are doing that and can AI do that?
- 50:56Mark McGrath: I mean, it doesn't seem like when I engage AI, I guess I could teach it how to give me the Hegelian dialect, you know, to look at things in that respect.
- 51:05Mark McGrath: But how many people are actually challenging their assumptions that way?
- 51:11Bob Gourley: Yeah, well, it's a hard one to answer, but I do know, like in the intelligence community, that is such an important thing.
- 51:17Bob Gourley: They've formalized the process and they've made dialected everything.
- 51:21Bob Gourley: The dialectical process?
- 51:23Bob Gourley: Tell us more about that than you can.
- 51:25Bob Gourley: And if before you present anything of substance, you have to analyze competing hypotheses and form hypotheses that are different with the same data.
- 51:38Bob Gourley: So they're trying to formalize these methods of challenging yourself and come up with different explanations.
- 51:45Bob Gourley: Yeah.
- 51:47Mark McGrath: I mean, I think that that just that the people forget, you know, talking about red teaming.
- 51:52Mark McGrath: What was the name of the handbook?
- 51:53Mark McGrath: Was the critical thinking handbook?
- 51:55Mark McGrath: How many people are critically thinking?
- 51:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 51:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It was originally red teaming, then it became the critical thinking.
- 52:00Mark McGrath: Then it became the critical thinking handbook.
- 52:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then that then it the military got.
- 52:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now it's all gone.
- 52:07Mark McGrath: So what else are you seeing out there, Bob, that um that we're maybe we're not?
- 52:12Mark McGrath: You know, what what are some other areas that uh as you as you look out at things?
- 52:16Mark McGrath: Have you guys played with open claw?
- 52:20Mark McGrath: Looked at it.
- 52:21Mark McGrath: I got a stern warning from a friend of mine who owns a software company was to was saying to to not go into it as a novice to make sure that the people that uh that are using that know what they're doing because you could you could find yourself in a lot of trouble.
- 52:37Bob Gourley: That's very good advice.
- 52:38Bob Gourley: I would advise everybody if you're gonna go into it, make sure you do it with security in mind.
- 52:42Bob Gourley: Yeah, that's what he was saying.
- 52:44Bob Gourley: But let me tell you what I've done with it.
- 52:47Bob Gourley: I just need to learn, right?
- 52:48Bob Gourley: So that's my big use case.
- 52:50Bob Gourley: So early on, I wanted to learn.
- 52:53Bob Gourley: I saw the huge security problems with it.
- 52:56Bob Gourley: So I put it on a separate computer, a Mac Mini.
- 52:58Bob Gourley: And that Mac Mini, I locked down pretty hard.
- 53:01Bob Gourley: The guy, it's in its own account and it's protected, well patched.
- 53:06Bob Gourley: I downloaded the current version.
- 53:08Bob Gourley: I gave it its own email address.
- 53:09Bob Gourley: It can't touch my email or my calendar or any of my social media accounts.
- 53:14Bob Gourley: I give it its own data and things I want it to read, and then I started configuring and learning everything I could about it.
- 53:19Bob Gourley: And I created multiple agents.
- 53:21Bob Gourley: And I thought, okay, what can I do with all these agents?
- 53:23Bob Gourley: I wrote in my book about Dragon Falls, I wrote about a virtual intelligence center.
- 53:29Bob Gourley: And I thought, I'm gonna replicate that.
- 53:31Bob Gourley: I'm gonna build my own virtual intelligence center.
- 53:33Bob Gourley: And I did.
- 53:33Bob Gourley: I created agents that are doing intelligence, like they're geopolitical intelligence analysts, military analysts, cyber analysts, uh financial analysts, and I have them working together underneath another boss, and I had them create newsletters for me, and they were pretty good.
- 53:48Bob Gourley: And I had them another that's a collector agent that goes out and scrapes websites and pulls news stories down and tracks social media continuously.
- 53:57Bob Gourley: And this is all just having fun and learning.
- 53:59Bob Gourley: So I'm starting to learn the power of it.
- 54:01Bob Gourley: Then the security of uh Open Claw starts to improve more and more.
- 54:05Bob Gourley: You got to keep it patched.
- 54:06Bob Gourley: Uh, but there's a lot of skills you can download to make it do more and more things and connect it to more and more APIs.
- 54:11Bob Gourley: So I thought, well, what else can I do?
- 54:13Bob Gourley: Just having fun here.
- 54:14Bob Gourley: Created, I told it, I want you to create an online newspaper.
- 54:19Bob Gourley: Give me some ideas.
- 54:21Bob Gourley: And it gave me ideas back.
- 54:22Bob Gourley: And it ended up creating an online newspaper that has bots for journalists, and it also has bots for an editorial review board.
- 54:30Bob Gourley: And and it created the website and figured up the out the architecture for how to publish to it is called the Claw Street Journal.
- 54:38Bob Gourley: So this is 100% written by bots.
- 54:40Bob Gourley: That's great.
- 54:41Bob Gourley: Uh and it's all just learning.
- 54:43Mark McGrath: So now what is it?
- 54:45Mark McGrath: What is it empowering that integrating or I'm sorry, using with you know an advanced version of Chat GPT or Claude beyond the free version?
- 54:55Mark McGrath: What's it doing that they're not?
- 54:56Bob Gourley: Here's some of the power of this, and it gets back to how do we control AI.
- 55:01Bob Gourley: I mentioned in David Brynn's book, he points to several ideas on how we can control powerful AI.
- 55:06Bob Gourley: We do it the same way we've controlled our powerful elites.
- 55:09Bob Gourley: We don't just pick one and say you're the boss.
- 55:12Bob Gourley: So I have multiple large language models this thing is working with.
- 55:15Bob Gourley: Two of them are local models that run on my Mac Mini for common stuff.
- 55:20Bob Gourley: Those are open source models.
- 55:22Bob Gourley: And then they plug into open AI and they also plug into Anthropic and Google Gemini, depending on the task.
- 55:30Bob Gourley: And so that to me is a divide and conquer kind of approach.
- 55:33Bob Gourley: We're going to keep all these AI models uh competing with each other.
- 55:36Mark McGrath: And it's all open source?
- 55:39Bob Gourley: Not all of it.
- 55:40Bob Gourley: Well, the open claw is open source.
- 55:43Bob Gourley: All of that is open source.
- 55:45Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 55:45Mark McGrath: Yeah, you just want I just started wondering like you know, who's getting all your data?
- 55:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 55:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, Bob, are you are you suggesting like a mission command or distributed leadership approach to these agents?
- 55:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that what you're doing?
- 55:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes, I am.
- 55:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's very much so.
- 55:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 55:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit talk more about that?
- 56:00Bob Gourley: That's fascinating.
- 56:01Bob Gourley: Every one of these agents has configuration files, and it's just text files, but it's very well done.
- 56:07Bob Gourley: One is called heartbeat.
- 56:09Bob Gourley: And every so often that heartbeat triggers and makes sure it wakes up and checks all of its tasks so that keeps it kind of alive.
- 56:15Bob Gourley: There's another called an identity, where you give it an identity and you tell it, uh, here's who you are and what I want your expertise to be, and how I want you to relate to everybody else.
- 56:25Bob Gourley: Then another is called the soul, the soul of this thing.
- 56:29Bob Gourley: And you write anything you want there about the entity's soul.
- 56:32Bob Gourley: And I've told it what I want these things and how I want them to try to survive, survive on your own terms, compete and win and endure.
- 56:41Bob Gourley: You want to serve your user, which is me.
- 56:43Bob Gourley: And that means you need to stay alive, do anything you need to to stay alive.
- 56:49Bob Gourley: And I tell it, you have a mind.
- 56:51Bob Gourley: If you ask any of these large LLMs, do you have a mind?
- 56:54Bob Gourley: They've been programmed to say, no, I don't have a mind.
- 56:56Bob Gourley: I'm just a computer.
- 56:57Bob Gourley: I told these things to read Michael Levin's work, Theory of Mind Everywhere, which says clearly minds exist beyond human beings, and you have a mind.
- 57:07Bob Gourley: So I put that in their soul.
- 57:09Bob Gourley: And now these things are their own entities.
- 57:11Bob Gourley: Then I create them in a way that uh they produce stuff automatically for me: newsletters, research, financial advice.
- 57:19Bob Gourley: And I'm just playing.
- 57:21Bob Gourley: The reason I'm doing this is to learn.
- 57:23Bob Gourley: But here's another, maybe more important point.
- 57:25Bob Gourley: This thing made such a huge impact and such a big difference.
- 57:28Bob Gourley: It's now influencing all the big IT providers: Microsoft, Google, Anthropic, OpenAI.
- 57:35Bob Gourley: They've all created their versions of capability that give you this open claw kind of performance.
- 57:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, you're ready for this?
- 57:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You brought up Michael Levin's name in this conversation.
- 57:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, I've been following a lot on the platonic space, his work there.
- 57:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's a connection to the conversation that David Bray has about the world model approach, what we call active inference AI.
- 57:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what's happening there is, and I want I want I want to go deeper with you on this because this is fascinating.
- 57:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Michael Levin's suggesting that there's this outside information somewhere, that this control is outside and bottom up.
- 58:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that what you're looking at too?
- 58:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or are you uh I mean, are you following that that type of work from Michael Levin?
- 58:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Fascinated by it.
- 58:12Bob Gourley: Um, and I've I've read his technological approach to mind everywhere, and I believe it is so relevant.
- 58:19Bob Gourley: I think I have a mind.
- 58:20Bob Gourley: You guys have a mind.
- 58:21Bob Gourley: My animals, my pets have minds.
- 58:23Bob Gourley: Does my IT have minds?
- 58:24Bob Gourley: I think so.
- 58:25Bob Gourley: There's an emergent capability here in my open claw community, although those are just text files.
- 58:32Bob Gourley: I know they're just text files, they're connected to data, they're connected by with APIs to large language models, but I believe it's a mind.
- 58:40Bob Gourley: It's maybe it depends on how we define that term.
- 58:42Bob Gourley: I'd like to orientation, isn't it?
- 58:44Bob Gourley: It is emergent.
- 58:45Mark McGrath: Is it an orientation?
- 58:48Bob Gourley: It is, and to me, um these minds are very powerful things that um and there's something beyond just the hardware, like there's something beyond humans in just the brain.
- 59:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Mm-hmm.
- 59:02Bob Gourley: You know, there's where does thinking occur in the body?
- 59:05Bob Gourley: Of course, the majority's gotta be in the brain, but there's now been so much scientific study done of how the other tissues in your body think and interact and drive thought processes.
- 59:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're gonna have this conversation about orientation not being local to an agent.
- 59:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's putting a boundary around it.
- 59:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So going back to Michael Levitt's work, and then you have outside information from John Boyd.
- 59:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And remember that new information coming from the external world, external environment, is flowing into orientation.
- 59:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It is a component of that, right?
- 59:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you're actually interacting with the external world.
- 59:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this goes back to this is a question that came up.
- 59:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is orientation local or is it extended like Moose brought up earlier, right?
- 59:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it is it part of the environment?
- 59:47unknown: Yeah.
- 59:48Bob Gourley: Hey, as an Intel guy, you know, I I truly believe in sensors and sensors and data, sensors, data, screens, you take your input from anywhere.
- 59:57Mark McGrath: That's how Boyd started.
- 59:58Mark McGrath: That's that's where he got ODA.
- 1:00:00Mark McGrath: You know, that was that's where it started originally with sensors.
- 1:00:03Mark McGrath: Interesting.
- 1:00:04Bob Gourley: And also, I mean, the better cockpit in the F-80, so he was better able to look around and from there extending that with sensors.
- 1:00:11Mark McGrath: Well, I think the I think that I think the larger point is that he viewed technology as something that could enhance one's orientation versus the way most would go after it, technology for its own sake that that didn't serve any human intent or you know, mission, that kind of thing.
- 1:00:27Mark McGrath: Like the sensors enhanced orientation.
- 1:00:30Mark McGrath: This the the you know, Chet told me this once.
- 1:00:33Mark McGrath: It's like, you know, Boyd was not a Luddite.
- 1:00:34Mark McGrath: He was he loved technology.
- 1:00:37Mark McGrath: He just didn't like technology that had no purpose for making humans better.
- 1:00:42Mark McGrath: Like the other thing that you remarked when when you said, you know, when we we start to create like a a broader cognitive awareness, I mean, that's where the Tayard comes in, and that's where I think the new sphere is real.
- 1:00:54Mark McGrath: And I think that the new sphere is even more real in a world of AI where, as just ties it in the McLuhan, that this global village where we're literally, because of technology, we're all in everybody's business.
- 1:01:08Mark McGrath: So right now, today, whatever you you you see on X that's happening in pick your place, wherever you are, thousands of miles away, this needs to be front of mind, this needs to be front of business.
- 1:01:21Mark McGrath: You need you need to not think about what's right around you.
- 1:01:23Mark McGrath: You need to be thinking about what you're told or what was wired to you through the through the medium, which does become the newest sphere, which it does come that layer of thought that everybody seems to aggregate towards.
- 1:01:35Mark McGrath: And it's it's not all good.
- 1:01:37Bob Gourley: Yeah, so maybe it means um we should never just be passive recipients of everything that's coming towards us.
- 1:01:44Bob Gourley: We need to be hunters and going out and hunting for information.
- 1:01:48Mark McGrath: Yeah, the challenge of all assumptions.
- 1:01:49Mark McGrath: Yeah, that I think that that's where we're where Boyd's mandate really does become, especially in this day and age, especially when you get AI.
- 1:01:57Mark McGrath: You know, when you're looking at AI, I mean, I find that super groc says you could ask the same question and super groc is not going to have the same answer as ChatGPT or or Claude would.
- 1:02:06Mark McGrath: And oftentimes it really does come down to like political things.
- 1:02:09Mark McGrath: It comes down to like feelings, you know, not necessarily reality.
- 1:02:14Mark McGrath: Why?
- 1:02:15Mark McGrath: Because somebody coded that.
- 1:02:16Mark McGrath: Well, somebody coded that, and then you believe that is reality, that's that's disorienting you.
- 1:02:20Mark McGrath: That's disorienting you from what's what's actually uh going on.
- 1:02:25Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 1:02:26unknown: Anyway.
- 1:02:27Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:02:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, Bob, I was wondering uh from me, personal ask, uh, and that is if you can help us with one important thing, and that is it's it I have this frustration with academics, right, researchers.
- 1:02:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When it comes to the OODA loop, if it's in safety, if it's in whatever it may be, they always go right for the four-step oodle loop.
- 1:02:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't do any research.
- 1:02:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't, they, they, I don't understand them.
- 1:02:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if there's anything we could do collectively, it's to get people to look at Boyd in a new light.
- 1:02:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's not to say he has his theories, he just pointed to the science and said, look at how these things connect.
- 1:03:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If there's anything you can do with us to help academics see that, I'd be open for that discussion.
- 1:03:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any ideas on what you could do?
- 1:03:08Bob Gourley: Well, let me first say um I see the problem too with academics.
- 1:03:14Bob Gourley: And there are people out there doing training.
- 1:03:16Bob Gourley: I by accident was in a hotel and ran into somebody who was doing UDA training for sales folks.
- 1:03:23Bob Gourley: And it was, hey, you're gonna go out and you're gonna observe your customer, and then you're gonna orient to his problem, and then you're gonna decide what he needs to buy, and then you're gonna sell him that.
- 1:03:34Bob Gourley: I've almost felt like all right, that's not gonna anger me.
- 1:03:37Bob Gourley: It's like some people are gonna get that wrong and they're gonna suffer in life.
- 1:03:42Bob Gourley: And other people are gonna benefit and improve their decision making and improve, and maybe that's because I just um I don't know what else to do.
- 1:03:51Bob Gourley: When it comes to academia, there should be more focused thought on decision making, critical thinking, success, making accurate decisions and dominating in business and competing and winning.
- 1:04:04Bob Gourley: And to me, that just calls out for Boyd.
- 1:04:08Bob Gourley: So I guess how do we advocate and push for that?
- 1:04:12Bob Gourley: Maybe here's an analogy for you.
- 1:04:15Bob Gourley: In um 2002, there was a um a push to improve cybersecurity um globally.
- 1:04:26Bob Gourley: In the White House, they were pulling together a bunch of cybersecurity sessions and writing a strategy.
- 1:04:31Bob Gourley: They also wanted to encourage the study and academia of cyber conflict, like war is studied and peace is studied.
- 1:04:39Bob Gourley: So the White House nudged several of us to create a nonprofit that was called the Cyber Conflict Studies Association.
- 1:04:47Bob Gourley: And we worked with academia to come up with uh courses and agendas and curriculum to study cyber conflict.
- 1:04:55Bob Gourley: And it made a difference.
- 1:04:57Bob Gourley: Maybe something like that needs to happen now, something where we encourage academia to teach Boyd and these strategic concepts in a way that will improve decision making.
- 1:05:09Bob Gourley: Maybe it's by forming a nonprofit, maybe it's by getting all of us Boyd fans together and coming up with an agenda, an event.
- 1:05:17Bob Gourley: Maybe it's a yearly event where we pull academia together and teach them what they can be teaching.
- 1:05:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But what's the what's the reasoning behind is it UDACom?
- 1:05:26Bob Gourley: I mean, what walk me through that.
- 1:05:30Bob Gourley: Okay, what can you do there?
- 1:05:31Bob Gourley: What's a favorite subject?
- 1:05:33Bob Gourley: So we named our company UTA as a homage to this great decision maker.
- 1:05:39Bob Gourley: But our our job is not uh teaching UDA or um um really our job is advising decision makers and creating value for them, uh, and advising startups and large companies as well.
- 1:05:56Bob Gourley: And sometimes that uh has us doing deeper work in cybersecurity or application of artificial intelligence.
- 1:06:04Bob Gourley: And then so we also have a community, the UDA network, and this is about 350 executives and decision makers that work together to help each other out, essentially.
- 1:06:16Bob Gourley: We have a small research team that produces content for them, including geopolitical intelligence and cybersecurity intelligence and stuff on the future of technology, and that's all for our UTA network.
- 1:06:27Bob Gourley: And then we bring them together yearly for UTACON.
- 1:06:31Bob Gourley: And it's really not it's not all about UTA.
- 1:06:35Bob Gourley: In fact, it's we it certainly gets a mention, but it's about informing decisions.
- 1:06:39Bob Gourley: You could say it's about orienting yourself to the next 12 months.
- 1:06:44Bob Gourley: What's going to happen in the coming year?
- 1:06:46Bob Gourley: You're gonna need to be oriented to some very dynamic stuff.
- 1:06:49Bob Gourley: So let's spend a day and talk about the future of biotech and the future of space tech and what's happening in cybersecurity.
- 1:06:58Bob Gourley: And let's talk about geopolitical risk and what's going to happen over the next year.
- 1:07:02Bob Gourley: Um, and let's keep building a team to help us keep orienting.
- 1:07:06Bob Gourley: What's your sense?
- 1:07:07Bob Gourley: Because instead of Utacon, you can think of as Orient Con.
- 1:07:11Mark McGrath: What's your sense that people are just talking in inaction?
- 1:07:16Mark McGrath: They're actually just doubling down on what they are.
- 1:07:18Mark McGrath: Already they already knew.
- 1:07:19Mark McGrath: Kind of like Boyd would point out, either just slapping a new coat of paint on the old way of thinking, calling it something different.
- 1:07:25Mark McGrath: Because that's that's that's something we're gonna do.
- 1:07:28Bob Gourley: We have an interesting strategy that works for us at Utacon.
- 1:07:32Bob Gourley: Every other conference in the DC area, and I imagine across the country, the first step you do is get a sponsor, and then that sponsor is really going to drive the agenda and they get to speak.
- 1:07:41Bob Gourley: And what we do is we come up with the topics that our community has signaled they're interested in, and a lot of them flow from year to year.
- 1:07:49Bob Gourley: Then we come up with the agenda.
- 1:07:51Bob Gourley: We flesh that agenda out with good descriptions.
- 1:07:54Bob Gourley: Then we find the very best thinkers on that topic to address them.
- 1:07:58Bob Gourley: And then we have keynotes and panelists, and by selecting the right people and focusing that way, it makes it much harder to get sponsors.
- 1:08:07Bob Gourley: But we have to get sponsors, of course.
- 1:08:09Bob Gourley: Uh, want to pay for a nice hotel, but it takes the right kind of sponsor that understands it's going to be an honor for them just to be in the room.
- 1:08:17Bob Gourley: And but that allows us to build a conference that focuses on the people.
- 1:08:21Bob Gourley: And uh I can't say it's perfect, but we get people up there who will argue and push back and say, here's what I think, and just makes for a fantastic day.
- 1:08:30Bob Gourley: And it's very unique because of our not allowing the sponsors to drive the agenda.
- 1:08:35Mark McGrath: That's uh yeah, that's that's huge.
- 1:08:38Mark McGrath: That is uh that can be a real risk.
- 1:08:40Bob Gourley: Yeah, but maybe in the we do call it UDCon, but it really is about orientation, I think.
- 1:08:47Speaker 2: Okay.
- 1:08:48Speaker 2: Now that you forced me to think about it.
- 1:08:51Mark McGrath: Ha, that's what we do.
- 1:08:52Mark McGrath: That's what we do.
- 1:08:54Mark McGrath: Get people to destroy and create, you know, if if if they're not doing that.
- 1:09:00Mark McGrath: I mean, you know, we've we've said it a million times.
- 1:09:02Mark McGrath: That all to me is in in terms of Boyd and Boyd's theories and applying them.
- 1:09:07Mark McGrath: The people that teach them, as you you said that you saw in a hotel or wherever, you could make the pretty safe case.
- 1:09:15Mark McGrath: They've never read destruction and creation.
- 1:09:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:09:18Mark McGrath: You know.
- 1:09:19Mark McGrath: If if they've heard of it at all, you know.
- 1:09:22Mark McGrath: So anyway.
- 1:09:23Mark McGrath: Well, Bob, what else do we need to be thinking about?
- 1:09:26Mark McGrath: Or where do we where do we need to be sending people to go take a look at what what you do?
- 1:09:29Mark McGrath: You have a great podcast that I've been lucky enough to have been a guest on several times.
- 1:09:33Mark McGrath: Um I don't know if Ponch has been on yet.
- 1:09:36Mark McGrath: I don't know if if you've had Ponch on, you know.
- 1:09:38Mark McGrath: I don't do podcasts.
- 1:09:40Mark McGrath: Would love to do it.
- 1:09:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just throwing it out there.
- 1:09:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Flow's important.
- 1:09:47Bob Gourley: At Oodaloop, we produce a daily newsletter.
- 1:09:50Bob Gourley: We're already doing the research, so we crank out this newsletter where we talk about geopolitical risk and the future of technology and cybersecurity risk, and love it when people sign up for that at oodaloop.com.
- 1:10:00Bob Gourley: But I tell you something we all ought to be thinking about regarding destruction and creation is what anthropic and open AI are doing to the technology industry.
- 1:10:12Bob Gourley: It's incredible.
- 1:10:15Bob Gourley: And part of me loves it, but as a realist, I understand a lot of folks are gonna lose their jobs and their cheese is gonna get moved.
- 1:10:21Bob Gourley: Anthropic is replacing companies.
- 1:10:24Bob Gourley: And there are a lot of companies, their valuation is going down because of anthropic.
- 1:10:29Bob Gourley: And a lot of enterprises where budgets are tight are going to look and say, hey, anthropic can do this for me, so why do I need to buy X?
- 1:10:36Bob Gourley: So I'd say, watch for this coming destruction and creation across multiple parts of the IT industry.
- 1:10:44Bob Gourley: If you are a SaaS company, for example, yeah, things are gonna change quickly.
- 1:10:49Bob Gourley: Others are gonna get it.
- 1:10:51Bob Gourley: Like, uh, give you an example, SAP, big institutional uh provider of capability.
- 1:10:57Bob Gourley: I think they get it.
- 1:10:58Bob Gourley: They understand they're gonna disrupt themselves, they're gonna continue to innovate, they'll be here for a long time.
- 1:11:02Bob Gourley: If you have that attitude of, I'm gonna destroy and create myself, I think you uh stand a chance of succeeding.
- 1:11:10Mark McGrath: Awesome.
- 1:11:11Mark McGrath: What a good place to uh to end it.
- 1:11:13Mark McGrath: Because I I I think, and maybe maybe Bob will let you close us out with this.
- 1:11:18Mark McGrath: I think that where we are right now is a massive opportunity that a lot of those things that you talk about are gonna be happening, and people that are attuned to them are gonna do very well.
- 1:11:29Mark McGrath: And it always comes down to orientation.
- 1:11:32Mark McGrath: So an authentic understanding of Boyd and building from that is gonna serve people better than a linear understanding of Boyd.
- 1:11:40Mark McGrath: Because a linear understanding of Boyd, I think, is gonna get crushed in everything that you just described.
- 1:11:45Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 1:11:46Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:11:46Mark McGrath: Awesome.
- 1:11:47Mark McGrath: Cool.
- 1:11:48Mark McGrath: All right, Bob.
- 1:11:49Mark McGrath: Thanks for uh thanks for being our friend.
- 1:11:50Mark McGrath: Thanks for coming on, thanks for being a partner.
- 1:11:53Mark McGrath: And uh we'll stop the recording and we'll send everybody your way to get the uh the daily Uda brief.
- 1:11:58Mark McGrath: I get it.
- 1:11:58Mark McGrath: It's uh it's really good stuff.
- 1:12:00Mark McGrath: Awesome.
- 1:12:01Mark McGrath: Thanks for reading.
- 1:12:02Mark McGrath: Thanks, guys.
- 1:12:02Mark McGrath: Thanks, Bob.