Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Secondary Offerings to Manage Lockup Expirations
Transcript
- Lucas: Airbnb shares are up 8% this week, and the interesting part is that a chunk of that move happened right as a big lockup expiration was looming. That seems backwards — lockups usually create selling pressure — so what actually happened here is a textbook case of a company using a secondary offering to manage the exit. Luna: So Airbnb didn't just let the lockup expire and hope for the best. They proactively sold a block of shares through an underwritten secondary offering, right? Lucas: Exactly. And this is something a lot of post ipo companies are doing now. Instead of having a chaotic few weeks where every insider and early investor dumps shares whenever the lockup lifts, the company structures a single, coordinated secondary offering. It gives the market a clear supply number — say 10 million shares — and the underwriters place them with institutional buyers, often at a small discount to the market price. Luna: And the idea is that by concentrating the selling into one event, you avoid the drip drip drip of daily insider sales that can grind the stock down over months. Lucas: Right. And the market actually rewards that clarity. In Airbnb's case, the secondary was announced, priced, and executed cleanly. Then the lockup expired, and instead of a wave of selling, the stock rallied. Partly because the overhang was gone — everyone who wanted to sell had already sold in the offering. But also because the buyers in that offering were institutions, not day traders. That signals long-term confidence. Luna: Quick honest thing — a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many shows possible. No ads, no sponsors, just people who find these conversations useful. If you're one of them, thank you. If you've been thinking about it, no pressure — but that's how this stays independent. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small group that keeps the lights on, and it means we never have to tweak the content for anyone else. So — back to lockup management. The key variable is pricing. In a secondary offering, the underwriter typically prices the offering at a discount of 2% to 5% below the closing price. That discount is the cost of certainty. Luna: But doesn't that discount hurt the insiders who are selling? They're leaving money on the table. Lucas: They are, but they're trading that discount for execution risk reduction. If an insider tries to sell a million shares on the open market over two weeks, they might drive the price down 10% or 15% anyway — especially in a thinner-traded stock. The secondary offering front-loads the discount and gets it done in one day. For many early investors who have held for years, that's a trade they'll take. Luna: And the company itself sometimes participates, right? Not just insiders. Lucas: Yes. In a primary offering, the company issues new shares and raises capital. In a secondary, existing shareholders sell. But you can have a combination — a 'mixed' offering — where the company sells some new shares to raise money for the balance sheet, while insiders sell some of their stake. Palantir did that in their secondary back in 2021. They raised about a billion dollars for the company, and insiders cashed out around 500 million. Luna: That's a big liquidity event. But what about the signaling effect? If the company itself is selling shares, doesn't that look like management thinks the stock is fully valued? Lucas: It can, which is why the narrative around why the company is selling matters. If the company says 'we're raising money to invest in AI infrastructure' — which is a common story right now — that's different from 'we're selling because we need cash.' The market reads intent. And if the offering is coupled with a lockup agreement for the remaining insider shares — say, a 90-day lockup on shares not sold — that also signals commitment. Luna: So the lockup itself can be a negotiation tool. The underwriter might say 'we'll place this offering, but only if the remaining insiders agree not to sell for another three months'. Lucas: Exactly. That's standard practice. The lead underwriter — Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, these firms — they want to ensure the stock doesn't crater two weeks after they've placed the shares with their clients. So they extract lockup extensions from the remaining holders. The result is a staggered unlock, which is much healthier for the stock. Luna: And staggering makes sense. Let's talk numbers — Airbnb's lockup expiration was for something like 400 million shares. That's a huge overhang. A secondary offering of, say, 50 million shares doesn't even put a dent in that. Lucas: Right, but the secondary doesn't need to absorb all of it. It's about signaling. By having a large, credible seller step up and do a block trade, the company shows that there is institutional demand for the stock at current levels. Other insiders see that and think 'maybe I'll hold a bit longer.' The psychology matters. And in Airbnb's case, the stock is up 8% this week, so clearly the market liked what it saw. Luna: But not all secondaries go smoothly. I remember Coinbase had a lockup expiration in late 2021, and they didn't do a coordinated offering. Insiders sold on the open market, and the stock dropped something like 30% in a month. Lucas: Coinbase is a great cautionary tale. In October 2021, when the lockup expired on about 200 million shares, there was no secondary offering to concentrate the selling. Insiders just started filing Form 4s — these are the SEC filings that report insider transactions — and the market saw a steady stream of sales. The stock went from around 350 to 250 in a few weeks. The lack of coordination amplified the selling pressure. Luna: So the lesson is, if you're a post ipo company, you want to control the narrative and the timing. Don't let the market guess how many shares are coming. Lucas: Precisely. And that's why we're seeing more post ipo companies adopt this playbook. It's become almost standard for companies that went public in the 2020-2022 wave and are now hitting their lockup expirations. They've had time to see the mistakes of earlier cohorts — like Coinbase, like Robinhood — and they're choosing the structured path. Luna: What about the role of the underwriter? They're not doing this for free. The typical fee on a secondary offering is around 3% of the proceeds. On a billion-dollar offering, that's 30 million dollars. Lucas: It's a big payday, but the underwriter earns it. They're taking on the risk of placing a large block of shares in a short time. They have to line up buyers — often at a dinner or a roadshow the night before pricing. If they can't find enough demand, they might have to cut the price or reduce the size. The fee compensates for that risk. And for the company, it's worth it to avoid the chaos of an uncontrolled unlock. Luna: Last question — what's the signal for retail investors? If you see a company announcing a secondary offering around a lockup expiration, is that a buy signal or a sell? Lucas: It's nuanced. Typically, the stock dips on the announcement because the market anticipates dilution. But if the offering is well-structured and the proceeds are used for growth — not just to let insiders cash out — the stock often recovers within weeks. Look at Airbnb this week: the secondary was announced, the stock dipped a bit, then rallied 8%. The key is to watch what the company does with the money. If they're investing in the business, it's a positive. If it's all insider sales with no corporate reinvestment, be more cautious. Luna: So the playbook is: coordinate, communicate, and control the supply. Got it. Lucas: Exactly. And as more post ipo companies mature and their lockups come due, we'll keep seeing this dance between insiders wanting liquidity and companies wanting stability. The ones that manage it well will earn investor trust. The ones that leave it to chance — well, the market has a short memory, but the data shows it punishes disorganization. Luna: And that's a note for anyone watching the IPO calendar for the next wave. If you're investing in a recent IPO, check the lockup expiration date and whether the company has a secondary offering strategy. That'll tell you a lot about the near-term price action. Lucas: Absolutely. And we'll keep tracking how these play out. Next time, I want to look at how companies are using accelerated share buybacks to offset dilution from secondaries — that's another growing trend. But for now, thanks for listening. Luna: Yeah, thanks. And if you want to support the show, you know where to find us.