Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / Joseph Campbell and the Strange Power of Myths
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone and hello minute. Hello Doc and you conversation
- 0:06about an interesting topic today which basically touches on myths
- 0:11and mythologies. And in order to cover that you
- 0:14suggested a popular video that was done a conversation with
- 0:21Joseph Campbell, he was probably one of the most popular
- 0:27comparative mythologist some of the 20th century.
- 0:31And comparative religion scholar.
- 0:35He passed away in 1987 and in the last two years of his life,
- 0:40that was very, very popular series of interviews made which
- 0:46was called The Power of myths, I think.
- 0:49Yeah, myth and mythology is with them at all.
- 0:52Yeah, let's this was a serious that was done by Bill Moyers
- 1:00that was Name the journalist. And interestingly, there is a
- 1:04website billmoyers.com. I will leave it in the comments
- 1:09and this website contains all the transcripts of this video
- 1:13series. So even if you're not able to
- 1:16find the videos on some sketchy places on the internet, you can
- 1:21find the transcripts of all the conversations of Moyers with
- 1:26Campbell on the site for people who don't know and Joseph Ample
- 1:31was famous for his concept of the hero's journey and probably
- 1:37he will be the most unforgettable for influencing
- 1:41George. Lucas for his followers Saga.
- 1:47Even if it's not as church will go down by.
- 1:49This contribution will never be forgotten.
- 1:52Yeah, by the way he's available on Amazon Prime if you have to
- 1:56pay for it but he has six series for two dollars each If anyone
- 2:01is interested. Yes.
- 2:02So I will leave the link and the link in the descriptions for all
- 2:06of this. Yes.
- 2:09So those conversations took place at the mid Ed end of the
- 2:1480s at the end of a life that covered basically the second
- 2:21half of the 20th century of Joseph Campbell and we will see
- 2:26how this is relevant because he speaks in a very specific way.
- 2:30Way that I think today would not be done anymore or to write it
- 2:38would. Maybe we find this kind of
- 2:40language from spiritual Seekers see teachers Advantage features
- 2:44or something like this. But not so much from Scholars.
- 2:47I think that would be very unusual today, right?
- 2:52Okay, so that's a basic introduction.
- 2:54We will of course not be able to cover everything.
- 2:57We focus on one specific episode.
- 2:59I think it's the last one. Yeah, serious called The Mask of
- 3:03Eternity. Yes, they are here.
- 3:06He talks about circles and, you know, how everything is a
- 3:11circle, how life is a circle? So, yeah, it's masks of
- 3:15Eternity. Okay.
- 3:16And we from that, we picked a few topics and this
- 3:21conversation, I can give my comments and I will also
- 3:24interested in your perspective on that and it perfect.
- 3:28Okay, so as you Doc's. I'm going to be going over some
- 3:34of the points I picked from this episode, right?
- 3:37And obviously, I have lot many points we can go over all of
- 3:40them. Some of them are two Phillips
- 3:43philosophical for us to debate on.
- 3:45So we we picked up our as we had discussed, we picked up three
- 3:51topics that we want to touch upon, right?
- 3:53One is his mention of Eternity and how he mentions the moments
- 3:59that we are spending right now. Now, with a loved ones are
- 4:03Eternal, right? So we wanted to discuss a little
- 4:05bit more into that. And maybe if you can take us
- 4:07into a deconstructed way of understanding it, the other one
- 4:11we want to talk about is perm on and how he mentions about
- 4:15Vermont and what Vermont actually means.
- 4:18And the third one is around purpose of life, right?
- 4:22So in discussion with my friends, they were more Curious
- 4:26to listen about purpose of life and then get into Eternity and
- 4:32then per month, I so I think we're going to go the reverse
- 4:36order if you are okay with it. So we'll start with the purpose
- 4:38of life. I'll ask you, some questions
- 4:42around purpose of life and then I'll let you tell me what you
- 4:47thought he meant by purpose of life.
- 4:50All right, in the episode, so we'll focus on that.
- 4:54Okay, so getting started with it.
- 4:57So the purpose of life, right? Or lack thereof, So with me,
- 5:02I've been working with you for three and a half four years.
- 5:05I don't even remember how long and for the good part of the
- 5:09first two to three years. I struggled with purpose of life
- 5:13and I read all kinds of books, young at Larry and stoicism,
- 5:19right to find out what my purpose of life false then I was
- 5:22unsuccessful in finding it to the time I came back and I said,
- 5:25okay, there is no purpose of life, right?
- 5:30But it Me a long time to get to it.
- 5:32Now mostly what happens is, if you pick up any book or you
- 5:35listen to any of the podcast to keep talking about purpose of
- 5:38life, you work with the purpose of life, you need to have a
- 5:41purpose to life. There is a purpose to life and
- 5:45it is really confusing for people to or maybe it is really
- 5:50tough for someone to understand that there is no purpose.
- 5:54And in this episode Campbell was talking about, there is no
- 5:59purpose to life. There is only there's only a way
- 6:04to find what your inner light is it is way of talking, Inner
- 6:11Light defines how you should live and if you are unhappy then
- 6:15you're most likely not living your life that way.
- 6:18And for you to be happy, you should live your life as per
- 6:22your definition. So my question to you is, what
- 6:27do you think of the sole purpose to life?
- 6:29I cannot have a clue. Let you explain.
- 6:31And the second question I have for you is, is it true that you
- 6:35can identify what your inner light or inner self or Guru or
- 6:41whatever people call it is telling you versus the voices in
- 6:46your head. Like how do you distinguish it?
- 6:48And in general, what you think about it as well?
- 6:51Okay, will be a little bit frustrating to you.
- 6:56I'm afraid because I will counter some questions.
- 6:59Why is it such an important? Don't question.
- 7:02Why is it such an important question?
- 7:04Why do purpose of life it? Why is it?
- 7:07Why is it a thing? The purpose of life?
- 7:11Okay, let me give you my spin on that, right?
- 7:13So I'm just thinking out loud when people are very happy,
- 7:18right? This is what I was listening to
- 7:20one of those sadguru's of whoever on YouTube, when people
- 7:23are really, really happy, no one questions, the purpose of life.
- 7:26They're really happy, they're enjoying.
- 7:28But the time people question, Was of life is when they have
- 7:32taken an alternative route, right?
- 7:34Like to give you an example, in my case, we decided not to have
- 7:37kids. So now the question is, okay,
- 7:41you follow the life principles, you went to school you worked,
- 7:45you got to a certain position. And now what now do you keep
- 7:51doing what you're doing? And if you continue doing what
- 7:53you're doing, where do you stop? What is the point where am I
- 7:57headed? Right.
- 7:59And that's when the question comes.
- 8:00That okay, maybe I was born for a certain purpose and that's
- 8:04when you get tripped on it and that this is one example for my
- 8:07case. But then there are other things
- 8:09where you watch videos all these, you know, life gurus and
- 8:13everyone and they keep talking about, you can discover the
- 8:15purpose of life live the purpose of your life.
- 8:18So a lot of people are fed that there is a purpose of life and
- 8:21they need to seek that purpose of life.
- 8:24And I think that's why it becomes important in my view.
- 8:26Okay, so I hear two components in your answer, one.
- 8:31Kind of fomo kind of fear of missing out.
- 8:34So yeah, you can say that. Yeah.
- 8:36And then I'm kind of astonished at what you have not found your
- 8:40purpose of life. What are you doing?
- 8:42And then it's like, oh, I'm sorry, I didn't know.
- 8:44I wasn't tell me about it. Apparently everyone has it.
- 8:48And I don't have this precious thing.
- 8:49Exactly. There is the fomo aspect there
- 8:52and the other one that you pointed out in the beginning of
- 8:56your answers, it's a kind of a symptom that I'm not feeling
- 9:00well. Well, that not everything is in
- 9:02place, basically, assuming that when I'm well, I don't, yeah,
- 9:08maybe I talk about the meaning of life and the purpose of life,
- 9:10but over a bottle of wine and kind of intuitive, very airy
- 9:16fairy philosophical way, but not really interested, not really
- 9:21desperate, the people are super interested in.
- 9:23It would be the implication there, they don't feel well,
- 9:26they're looking for something, and then the purpose of life,
- 9:30Becomes a shell, placeholder a significant empty signifier if
- 9:38you want to put it linguistically.
- 9:41So it's supposed to mean something.
- 9:43It's the, you know, in movie language, the MacGuffin.
- 9:46I don't know if you heard the term.
- 9:48Now I hand the MacGuffin and movies is kind of.
- 9:52We have to find the Three Stones, you know, the three
- 9:54stones. And in order to get there, we
- 9:56have to go to Africa, to find a clue.
- 9:58And then we have to go to South America to find.
- 10:00And a clue. And in the end, you know, to
- 10:03find the actual Three Stones is just the last minute and then
- 10:05the movies over, it's all just an empty thing to keep you going
- 10:09to have a story, right? Right.
- 10:12So, it could be that that the purpose of life is a MacGuffin,
- 10:18something that keeps us kind of keep me so.
- 10:21So but then is that, is that the same?
- 10:23Like let's say, people who follow the script of life,
- 10:26right? You, you are go to school, then
- 10:28you go to college, then you study for college.
- 10:30Then you get a job. Then you continue seeking to
- 10:33grow in your career, in the midst of it, you have kids, then
- 10:36you're worried about your kids, their college education.
- 10:39They go to college, they bring a lot of drama, you're busy with
- 10:41the drama and then you're like 65 70, you retire.
- 10:44And you're like, okay now I'm going to relax.
- 10:48If you follow that pattern, I don't think a lot of people
- 10:52would question the purpose of life.
- 10:54I mean, I don't know, I don't have kids, I don't know, but I
- 10:56see my friends who have kids, they don't sit around
- 10:58questioning it, they have no time.
- 11:00But if you do To deviate off of that route.
- 11:03Then these kind of questions come up because now you have a
- 11:05lot of time and you realize that I just working endlessly.
- 11:10It's not going to bring you too much happiness.
- 11:13Yes. So there is an interesting
- 11:17implication there. It's as if people who lead a
- 11:21normal life, don't like the notion so much but as if people
- 11:24will lead the normal life also follow a promise of fulfillment
- 11:29and purpose. It's if there is an unspoken
- 11:34kind of Dogma that I follow, as if someone told me, you know
- 11:39what, the purpose of life is to work, we felt family oriented to
- 11:45have children, have a career and retire in peace.
- 11:48This is the purpose of life. And as if people were following
- 11:53that and this is not too far off, I would say we find it
- 11:57basically in Old handbooks. An old hand books.
- 12:02For example, in Ancient India, we have the Dharma.
- 12:06Sutras Dharma is a very wide kind of idea, but one of the
- 12:13ways to understand Dharma is the law and the principle.
- 12:17And there is kind of the understanding.
- 12:20These are ideas around the turn of the first Millennium first
- 12:24century CE e, something like this as if each kind of major
- 12:28cast has its purpose. The way.
- 12:31Doing things the way of living standard trajectory, which you
- 12:36should abide obey to. And then basically you have
- 12:41fulfilled, your purpose, your Dharma so just to deconstruct
- 12:46that a little bit. So if I understand you
- 12:47correctly, what you're saying is like in India, when even your
- 12:50born, I shut 3i, that means you're a warrior class.
- 12:52So you're supposed to be a warrior, you born a prom and
- 12:56then you're supposed to be a priest or in the priesthood.
- 12:59And, and so on, is that what? You're saying.
- 13:01So, you follow that very roughly sad, some okay, Pathways laid
- 13:05out, right, right? You're supposed to become a
- 13:07student at which you use supposed to kind of finish the
- 13:11student hood. And when to enter the Family
- 13:13Life, at what time to retire, and then to become renunciate
- 13:18and you go into the forest. And so, you think our ancestors
- 13:21could have been questioning the same thing and then they got
- 13:24tired of it and then the defined that this is the purpose of
- 13:27life. Well, at least it's It
- 13:31accomplished. So until now we said well the
- 13:34purpose of life question is the unusual question.
- 13:38It's not the normal question. And yes, interesting
- 13:41Counterpoint to say that in the past or in certain cultures also
- 13:46normality was explicitly defined, it was not just the
- 13:51things that you perceive people did.
- 13:54They were actual manuals and handbooks and explicit
- 13:58knowledge. Like no this is what you're
- 13:59supposed to do. They didn't just rely on
- 14:03tradition. I caught it, okay, the purpose
- 14:07of life was basically both for, for example, the spiritual
- 14:12Seekers and a monastic life style.
- 14:14They had a very different idea of what their purposes as well
- 14:17as for the traditional householder, the normal worker
- 14:22working class. Ok.
- 14:24So going back to the beginning, there is already a complexity to
- 14:29the topic of purpose of life and we didn't even go into the
- 14:33possibilities of what this purpose.
- 14:34It could be there is a sandwich there.
- 14:37It's there was a context to the topic today.
- 14:42I would say, the biggest the most important framework is what
- 14:46we started with, which is one people who feel unhappy on
- 14:51certain they are looking for a purpose of life and it has
- 14:55become such a buzzword, such an expectation that I should find
- 15:01my vocation and live my life to the fullest and so on.
- 15:05That there is a certain pressure for me to know what my purpose
- 15:09is and to basically be able to put it on my CV that that one,
- 15:17two, three. Yeah, that's me.
- 15:21Okay. So it already means that we
- 15:25cannot approach the question without a bias.
- 15:28There is an expectation in a pressure, there's an outer
- 15:31pressure and certain kind of conditions to this question,
- 15:37right? It's supposed to fill a very
- 15:40specific hole. So if you ask me, what's your
- 15:43purpose of life, what's the purpose of life?
- 15:46And I say, well, the purpose of life is to go every Monday and
- 15:49to buy a can of beans that would not be a proper answer because
- 15:54we expect something more respect something.
- 15:58Cific from the sensor. I would have to be quite far out
- 16:04to, to understand the, the kind of beans as a proper answer.
- 16:09No, we won something. What something.
- 16:11Philosophical. Something.
- 16:13Deep. Something, existential something
- 16:16meaningful. So it's a placeholder that
- 16:18invites, certain constellation of topics.
- 16:24Well, don't we? So let's say if I asked you
- 16:28which, which I used to write, how do I find purpose of life?
- 16:31How do I find, what am I here for right?
- 16:35Because then that becomes what was that?
- 16:38Sorry, it's too fast because we first have to see.
- 16:41Okay, we have to understand that not everything is a plausible
- 16:46answer. Certain things fall into the
- 16:50basket of what a plausible answer could be.
- 16:52All so we are not entirely creative.
- 16:56This is what I mean. We already biased.
- 16:59When we approached the question without knowing it, we don't we
- 17:03pretend we are kind of completely open I look inside or
- 17:06look to a teacher or a look into the magazine to find the purpose
- 17:10of life. It's already extremely limited
- 17:12of what this could be at all. Okay, so some.
- 17:18So let's come back to the main question.
- 17:20So, first question was, is there a purpose of life, right?
- 17:24And, and I am assuming you're saying there could be right
- 17:28outside of the, okay, normal principles that some ancestors
- 17:34may have set to how life should be lived.
- 17:36You're saying there could be and then what you're saying is even
- 17:40though there could be a purpose to life when we look at it, we
- 17:44are biased. So we are not too.
- 17:46Open at looking at purpose of life.
- 17:50Yes. And our limitation might cause a
- 17:54situation that we miss it, assuming that there is one
- 17:58Because which we will get, we will miss because we have biased
- 18:02and we are not looking widely enough.
- 18:05Yes. Because the public discourse
- 18:07speaks about love and God and Eternity.
- 18:13And in reality, it could be that the meaning of life.
- 18:16Let's say, genetically hardwired is to eat until we die.
- 18:21We would already ruled that out because the way that we talk
- 18:26about it is focused on very specific themes, but this is
- 18:30very different than what kampl spoke about in this episode
- 18:35right where he's saying we're not there to okay.
- 18:38Okay, alright, so I'll let you continue.
- 18:40Okay, so was there, but not there yet.
- 18:42So if we assume that there is a purpose of life, it can be, it
- 18:47can be twofold one. It could be the same for others.
- 18:50For everyone. And the other is that it would
- 18:54be individual. If it's the same for everyone,
- 18:57it would mean a okay, we just have to crack the code of
- 18:59humanity and basically, it would go down to 22 Theory to an
- 19:05assumption that it's basically in the genes it's genetically
- 19:10transmitted we as humans are just bound to have a specific
- 19:14purpose of life. And some people would argue that
- 19:18right evolutionary, biologist might say It's clear like the
- 19:22purpose of life is to procreate. That's the whole deal with
- 19:26Evolution. So there is a possibility to to
- 19:30approach this question with the idea, okay, what is the purpose
- 19:33of life for everyone? And then increasingly.
- 19:37So, in recent, the most recent history and specifically from it
- 19:43started kind of the late 1900s, but increasingly, so, in the
- 19:491950s and 60s, and 70s. When the question it, got a
- 19:55spin-off know everyone has to find is her own purpose of life.
- 20:04Which kind of makes sense, right?
- 20:05Because it's not genetic. I mean, unless you follow her
- 20:09script right, like in certain cultures procreation is
- 20:15important and because of certain historical events that could
- 20:18have happened in certain cultures, right?
- 20:22So but in other cultures procreation is not that
- 20:25important, and then it becomes an individual choice.
- 20:29And now people are doing individual things, right?
- 20:31They are deciding not to get married there.
- 20:33Fighting not to have kids in many countries and many
- 20:36different cultures. So what do how do they then
- 20:40identify a purpose of life if there is one right?
- 20:44And this is. Yeah, but it's problematic
- 20:46right? It's just I have to acknowledge
- 20:48that the question was not approached and the same way all
- 20:51the time that there was a large period of time when it was
- 20:56approached in a more normative way for everyone and that now
- 21:01we'll live in a time where it's even difficult.
- 21:03Court to argue that. It's very individual.
- 21:07And this is where compl comes in.
- 21:10He falls in the way that he speaks in the way that he
- 21:12argues, he's very much in a new agey mindset, which which came
- 21:19to prominence in the 60s and then became quite popular in the
- 21:2270s. This is how people talked back
- 21:25then and he had in this series of interviews and the mid 70s
- 21:3180s. He Expressed something that fell
- 21:36onto very receptive ears. It was not nothing new.
- 21:39That he said, the hippies said it all the time.
- 21:42The guru's are the 60s and 70s. There were Growers before.
- 21:46But when the westerners kind of got hold of them, they said that
- 21:50all the time. You have to find your inner
- 21:53voice, your inner God. You're in a vocation and
- 21:58Campbell says, follow your own Bliss.
- 22:02Yeah, but how do you find your own Bliss?
- 22:05Well, that's a different thing then.
- 22:06Yes, but this is where it starts.
- 22:09This is the starting point and it it opens up possibilities and
- 22:14it opens up problems, right? We're not there yet of how to
- 22:18find it first. Have to see that by defining it
- 22:22as an individual problem, right? It's very much an
- 22:27anti-authoritarian approach. By saying everyone has to find
- 22:34their own Bliss. Their own vocation that one
- 22:36purpose. It automatically means that you
- 22:39cannot trust anyone with that question.
- 22:41Unless they can mind read or something.
- 22:45Your truth is not my truth General, but you can at least,
- 22:48let's say if these guys are going or let's say, if I ask you
- 22:52and you tell me how you identified what your inner voice
- 22:55is saying or how you identified your bliss, I think that's what
- 23:00the question is. The question is not For you to
- 23:02tell me what I should do. Right?
- 23:05Well, this is this is an older question, right?
- 23:07This is the authoritarian way. I asked my dad as my
- 23:11grandfather, the chief of the tribe, the artists the guru, and
- 23:18they tell me you should do that. Because I know I tell you right,
- 23:24so but then you're right if we move it into, okay?
- 23:27Everyone has their own but maybe there is an algorithm that is
- 23:33the same for everyone on the purpose, but maybe there's a way
- 23:38to get the that can be applied to everyone, which means I can
- 23:41write it in a book and sell it as a self-help classic.
- 23:45Maybe that works, right? Sure.
- 23:49Opens up the possibility. I think that Campbell falls into
- 23:54that category, right? But I'm just opening up the
- 23:58possibility that maybe it's so that even the algorithms are
- 24:03different for everyone. So that the in reality, not only
- 24:09false, and to, you know, everyone can have the needs to
- 24:13find their own purpose, but maybe everyone has to find their
- 24:16own way of how to find the purpose.
- 24:20That's a lot of work. It's now, it's kind of started
- 24:24sweating already. Yeah, it's too much was fun in
- 24:27the beginning and now it's serious.
- 24:29I might as well go back to the normal life.
- 24:31The predefined interest, and yes, which is one of one of the
- 24:36kind of explanations of the different directions that our
- 24:40society, go, right. And right now, we live in a way
- 24:44for people become more conservative with people.
- 24:46I mean, certain parts of society.
- 24:49We want To reduce complexity all those questions.
- 24:52All those decisions to be made all this uncertainty.
- 24:56No, let me go back to a way of life where answers were given
- 25:01and it didn't meet everything but I'm okay with 50%, who
- 25:05cares? Right.
- 25:08Because now you have to work to get anywhere, right?
- 25:11Like you have to, you have to start the and I agree with you
- 25:13because one of the sessions we had be, if those Adler or Marcus
- 25:18Aurelius, I don't know which one it was.
- 25:20But I did tell you, I said, okay.
- 25:21In this book it says, the purpose of life is to help other
- 25:24humans and love everyone. And my view was, I can't love
- 25:29everyone. It's not possible.
- 25:31I just can't, I judge everyone. That's what I do.
- 25:34So I try to fit into that category.
- 25:37And I was like, okay I'm failing miserably and then I felt even
- 25:40worse. So so you're right now, you have
- 25:43to identify Yeah, which is, which is a problem.
- 25:47So now you to identify what your algorithm is, to find your own
- 25:51Bliss, before you can find what your bliss is.
- 25:54And I think that this is where we are right now.
- 25:56I think we have kind of moved on basically in the complexity from
- 26:01the 70s and 80s where it was plausible to give everyone the
- 26:05same, the same kind of Handbook of how to do it, that was
- 26:10possible. So you could say meditate,
- 26:14right? You meditate A certain way, you
- 26:17create an inner light in your chest area, you let it grow and
- 26:21then you see what happens. And what happens is, kind of, it
- 26:24will tell you the purpose of life, or you go to a certain,
- 26:28you have to find your Guru. I, which was another answer
- 26:31back. Then, everyone finds the guru.
- 26:33The guru will tell you. Or in the, in the dynamic with
- 26:37the guru you will find it or you do therapy and you will find it
- 26:41psychoanalysis, for example, or you follow your bliss, which is
- 26:45A fancy way of saying, by finding out what is fun to you.
- 26:50You realize what you see, how your system is wired, right?
- 26:54And then by slowly applying it, the will become more distinct.
- 26:59They will some distinct figure come out of this, some patterns
- 27:04and you will realize do. Apparently, this is what I'm
- 27:06into and this is what I'm supposed to do.
- 27:09And I admit that sometimes this is what I recommend clients in
- 27:14truth. I think we are in a more complex
- 27:17situations. Why?
- 27:19Because Society has gone through those recommend standard
- 27:24recommendations and it has failed.
- 27:27Why am I saying it has failed. I'm not saying that nobody found
- 27:30any purpose, but the broad kind of application of this has not
- 27:36led to an end of the self-help. Books has not led to people not
- 27:43going to therapy therapy anymore.
- 27:45Or we divorces are as high as as economic issues are still there.
- 27:52Like, basically the issues are still there, which means the
- 27:57guidebooks and the helps of the past did not help on a systemic
- 28:02level. So I think that you know, if we
- 28:06look at it a little bit Zoom from the zoomed out position.
- 28:10We have to admit that probably if you want to pursue this
- 28:14question we also have to take into account that we don't know
- 28:19how to pursue to find the purpose of life.
- 28:24This is so let's say, okay. So basically what you're saying
- 28:28is, you know, when people do live, the pre-ordained like, you
- 28:34know, procedural life that has been defined.
- 28:38They're somewhat okay, there's somewhat happy.
- 28:41Maybe like, you know, if I take my sister, for example, at the
- 28:44age of 55, 60, the kids moving out.
- 28:49Now, she's questioning which is much later in her lifetime, then
- 28:53people who are The younger who don't have kids and they start
- 28:56questioning, okay, what am I supposed to do?
- 28:58So if you do that then there is it's a delayed questioning of
- 29:03purpose of life, maybe midlife crisis, whatever we call that
- 29:08people who are outside of the normal life who don't follow the
- 29:11prescription of life. Now are questioning it but what
- 29:16you're saying is those who are questioning it are mostly
- 29:20questioning it when they are probably not happy.
- 29:23So it should they Then try to find what makes them happy and
- 29:29try different things, and maybe then they'll fit into something
- 29:34for a few months or a year. And then they have to do it all
- 29:37over again. Is that how pointer?
- 29:39Yeah. Okay, if you pursue that there
- 29:42is failures guaranteed, I think the question is which kind of
- 29:47failure do I want to make your want to make the failure of not
- 29:51trying be satisfied with 40 or 50 percent?
- 29:54And To live with a fantasies of what could I have done?
- 29:57What should I have done and so on?
- 29:58So the failure of regret Do I want to pursue the thing knowing
- 30:03that the journey will be painful?
- 30:06Of searching and searching sometimes finding.
- 30:08And then the hopes are now found the thing playing cello that's
- 30:13apparently brings out the energies and me.
- 30:16And then I pursue that, and then as with most other things, the
- 30:21joy declines, and it becomes work, and then either drop it or
- 30:25I think, no, I have to go to the master cello Guru because they
- 30:29will teach me the real way of our to unleash my energies and
- 30:33my potential and so on. So it's struggle.
- 30:36Right. Do I want to hide strong?
- 30:39And again, I would say honestly, I cannot tell this is an
- 30:44individual choice where people have to come to a point where
- 30:50they are able to decide those questions, which meets a lot of
- 30:54maturity. That I'm facing the situation
- 30:58that I'm in. And I'm not, I'm not afraid.
- 31:04I'm not intimidated by the, by the kind of impact, of the
- 31:08question of what should I do? But I can I'm, I'm mature and
- 31:14responsible enough to say, you know what?
- 31:17I'm not interested in that struggle.
- 31:20Got it. Okay, so so let me let me Circle
- 31:23back in terms of how some of the people I observe, who don't
- 31:27believe in purpose of life are doing it.
- 31:29And I'm asking you this because then I can, I'm not trying to
- 31:32prescribe or anything, but I'm saying if this is the right way
- 31:35of doing it. So so one of my friends, he
- 31:38started doing yoga then he got so into yoga that he tried to
- 31:42become the best at yoga, and then after he got to a level
- 31:45where he was really good, then he decided that he likes to
- 31:48cook. So he started cooking now.
- 31:50He's, you know, into cooking a lot, right?
- 31:53So is this the right way of doing things?
- 31:57Because he liked something, he does it for a year, two years,
- 31:59then he moves on to something else, he does it for a year, two
- 32:02years and then he moves on to something else.
- 32:04Is that what you're saying? We should continue to do so
- 32:07until we find well, how I would say now personally it is the
- 32:11right way. If he made that choice, I would
- 32:15not have the right way in my kind of my standards.
- 32:20It would not be the right way if he fulfills something that some
- 32:23dude or a book or you know movie told him that this would be the
- 32:29right way for me. The best value is I made this
- 32:32decision and I hence I am taking the consequences.
- 32:37I'm not waking up in 20 years and thinking, why did I listen
- 32:40to this stupid movie? I feel I should have known as
- 32:44long as long as you feel like doing it.
- 32:46So that's what that's what you're saying.
- 32:47So it's not like someone comes to me and says, hey do this, and
- 32:52then I do that and then I'm like, okay, now I'm just keeping
- 32:55busy, I'm not enjoying it, but I'm keeping busy.
- 32:58So you're saying separated from being busy too.
- 33:01Are you having fun while you're doing it?
- 33:05Doesn't the journey fulfill you does.
- 33:07The journey fulfill you guys beat that leads to a purpose or
- 33:10not and it on it. It happened fulfillment and
- 33:13sense of you know there's enriching me I think I'm doing
- 33:16something meaningful and there is no result right.
- 33:19There is nothing it. So I don't want to, I don't know
- 33:22you know take off too much of your time but and I don't want
- 33:25to simplify this and it is not a very to me it does not a very
- 33:29satisfying answer either but tell me if I'm correct in saying
- 33:33this. So what you're telling me is or
- 33:35what what we are arriving at is that you don't have a purpose.
- 33:42To life, what you can do, however, is find what interests
- 33:46you continue to do that. And then if you get bored, find
- 33:50something else that interests you continue to do that and now
- 33:54fill your life in Sprint's of what makes you happy.
- 33:58So, Sprint's of six months to one year of what makes you
- 34:01happy? Keep doing it.
- 34:02Till it makes you happy, then jump onto something else.
- 34:04That makes you happy, jump onto something.
- 34:06So you just keep living these prints of year year and a half
- 34:09two years until you're done. Die.
- 34:12This is for thing interpretation.
- 34:14This is not what I mean what I mean is you can you know, after
- 34:176 month is good boring and then I would understand if someone
- 34:21says, you know what I will stick to the boring.
- 34:24Why would that be though? Because someone says I'm not
- 34:28interested in the jumping around life, I'm not interested to have
- 34:33six months of joy. For me, there is a value in
- 34:37doing something hard, which is to deal with my frustrations,
- 34:42which is to develop a skill in. You know, why not to apply to
- 34:47relationships every six months, I have another relationship.
- 34:50Another, every six months I have, I have a different job.
- 34:53I would understand and I would take it as something that
- 34:56resembles purpose, when someone says, you know, what this job is
- 35:00starting to bore me, but I'm in a stage of my life, where I'm
- 35:03interested of where this leads me.
- 35:08I can see that. Yeah, I mean and I you know, in
- 35:11my case also, I apply that right, like I get bored after a
- 35:15while but then I'm like, okay, let me see what else can I do to
- 35:18make it interesting. Yes, I instead of just jumping
- 35:21around because then you figure out that when you jump around
- 35:23especially in terms of career you end up in the same place
- 35:26another year and a half, so it's not the job, it's probably you,
- 35:31okay, okay. And to her kind of loop to the
- 35:34beginning, we started with Campbell, right?
- 35:36And his His formula follow your bliss, which is basically
- 35:40follow. What, what interests you.
- 35:42That would be the most purposeful thing.
- 35:46Looking back. Kind of on the complex, I would
- 35:48say there is a thing there. Regardless, if you want it or
- 35:52not, the seems to be something a fabric.
- 35:55And the human mind that produces the question of purpose.
- 36:01It's not that people that are up some people walk around, who are
- 36:04completely immune to this question in some way or another.
- 36:07I think it touches us when we look back.
- 36:11When we question, if we did something right or wrong, when
- 36:14life becomes more T and we ask yourself what to do.
- 36:17So this seems to be a kind of baked into our system.
- 36:22This question and as with so many things that are baked into
- 36:27our system, it makes us sometimes do very stupid things
- 36:32and the stupid find the purpose. You're saying, we do stupid
- 36:36things to find purpose, we do stupid things in applying this
- 36:41pressure that comes from within the pressure says okay okay
- 36:44let's find a purpose, right? Yeah, even kind of silly and
- 36:47applying this, for example, by just asking a random person or
- 36:52asking a teacher or asking a book that would be a silly thing
- 36:58to do because this doesn't apply to our kind of human mind,
- 37:04right? Right makes sense.
- 37:07Those formulas just don't work, if I'm happy with a 30% outcome,
- 37:11that's fine. But then again, I'm a
- 37:12responsible position then I have not delegated.
- 37:16My responsibility to another Authority.
- 37:18So this is one of the dangers that comes with the the question
- 37:22of finding a purpose that I'm delegating The Authority for
- 37:28what to search or how to search it to other agencies.
- 37:32And, you know, we see the effects of this in, for example,
- 37:36in the self-help and the self-development circuit.
- 37:42Okay, interesting. So to then enter wrap it up,
- 37:45right? Obviously, you're not going to
- 37:47prescribe anything because everyone has to find their find
- 37:51their own thing. But let's say if, in short
- 37:56responsibility, take responsibility for whatever you
- 37:59choose. If you go on a journey, if you
- 38:01jump back and forth, if you switch off the 20 years, if you
- 38:04don't switch anything, take responsibility for that, this
- 38:07would be my important thing. So what you're saying is for
- 38:11people, We're looking and you are saying, I need to find a
- 38:13purpose of life, and they are seeking, you know, some people
- 38:17will go on Journeys by foot some, people go to the Himalayas
- 38:23to sit and meditate and, you know, I tried to do this with
- 38:28Steve wolinski the one who recommended.
- 38:30He said that you need to imagine yourself as energy, vibrations
- 38:35and different portals. Maybe you'll open a portal.
- 38:37I try to do that. Probably didn't do it right, you
- 38:39know, I was like, okay, nothing's happening.
- 38:41So I Moved on. I try to love everyone but you
- 38:44know I ended up judging them more than I love them.
- 38:46So that didn't work either. So you know I'm still still
- 38:50going through what I'm going through what people have told me
- 38:52to do because I'm not open to saying I don't know what to do
- 38:57so maybe I'm missing something so if you were to summarize it
- 39:00basically what you're saying is open yourself up.
- 39:03Find what interests you keep doing it and then you know it's
- 39:06like you keep falling a path and then you follow another path and
- 39:09you follow another path until you get to a point.
- 39:11And video like, okay, I'm really enjoying it.
- 39:13And you forget that you're even looking for a purpose of life
- 39:16and you just keep enjoying what you're doing on a day-to-day
- 39:19basis. Yeah.
- 39:21Is that right? This, this is a nice end goal,
- 39:25it's but it's, that is much more complex.
- 39:27So I don't think that this end goal is the outcome of the
- 39:31purpose of life, kind of question.
- 39:34I think that that, that is the effect of maturity and a
- 39:39satisfaction that comes from many many sources.
- 39:41Has. Okay I apologize for being
- 39:46vague. Yeah that is that is a bit
- 39:49vague. I would have to listen to this
- 39:52whole conversation. Once more to see if I picked up
- 39:57the this purpose of Life theme or the mythology that is
- 40:02connected with that is something that is within us and is a
- 40:06pressure that wants to express itself.
- 40:09I don't think that it's by itself is sufficient to trigger
- 40:16path that really leads to its fulfillment.
- 40:18I think the question of the pressure is there.
- 40:20I don't think that it leads by itself to an actual
- 40:24satisfaction. The satisfaction will can buy
- 40:29many, many things and the purpose of life questions just
- 40:33one minor thing there. It's more.
- 40:36The expression of a problem than a part of this solution.
- 40:39All right, so you're saying the purpose of life question, is
- 40:42more of a pressure. We are applying to ourselves.
- 40:45There is no one purpose that you're.
- 40:47So there isn't. You shouldn't think that.
- 40:49You're born with a purpose. You're born to, I don't know.
- 40:53Do something like, you know. Invented electric car like, you
- 40:59know, yes, Elon Musk dead. So, you know, those are above
- 41:03average outliers but then for an average person there is no
- 41:08particular purpose. You just continue doing what
- 41:10you're doing and maybe you find something new.
- 41:12You don't find something, but try to not question everything
- 41:15that you're doing on a day-to-day basis.
- 41:17Thinking is this, my purpose is this?
- 41:20What I want to do that? Just produces dissatisfaction.
- 41:23Yes. Okay.
- 41:24Alright, so with that doc, do you want to go into the The
- 41:27other topics or I think the video is going to be too long if
- 41:30you can, let's choose a second one.
- 41:32And let's represent second one up and maybe we'll do another
- 41:36one after that, okay, got it? Alright, so the second one, I'm
- 41:39just looking back at my notes. Which one would you want to get
- 41:42into? Do you want to get into
- 41:43eternity, or do you want to get into Vermont?
- 41:48Yes, I would like to go into the Brahman topic because it's
- 41:51closely connected to give a little bit of a background.
- 41:56Brahmin Is philosophical term from ancient Indian literature
- 42:03and philosophy, very briefly. The oldest kind of layer of text
- 42:10philosophy. Are The Vedas and ancient India
- 42:15and after The Vedas, there were two other layers of text and
- 42:18philosophy, which were the brahmanas, the brahmanas dealt
- 42:21with rituals, mostly the detail details of rituals.
- 42:24And after the brahmanas, we have the upanishads With most which
- 42:28are mostly philosophical. The topic of Brahman and it's
- 42:34almost impossible to think of ramen in the Indian context
- 42:38without the artman, they are very often mentioned together
- 42:41the Atman and Brahman. They came to prominence in this
- 42:46latest phase of The Vedic texts on the upanishads.
- 42:51This is where it kind of we find those terms just again and again
- 42:55admin and Brahman in philosophical context.
- 42:59The, but the term of the Brahmin comes from the beta.
- 43:02So, it's much older than that, and originally, it means
- 43:06something like to form to expand to grow something like that, and
- 43:13it was connected with sacred ritualistic speech.
- 43:17So the way that I kind of summarize it for myself where
- 43:21the term comes from. It's basically transformative
- 43:25speech which The Vedas were supposed to be the Those were
- 43:29supposed to be the, the not magical but the the words that
- 43:37bring you satisfaction, because these are the words that the
- 43:43gods want to hear and they reward you for the poems of the
- 43:48data for the rituals that are connected with it.
- 43:51The reward you with longevity with children with cows,
- 43:55whatever, was in fashion back then.
- 43:58So this is the Root of web Roman comes from and the upanishads.
- 44:02It became a much more philosophical and Abstract term,
- 44:06it became again an empty vessel for the absolute for the
- 44:13everything for the cosmic, soul for the ultimate thing to
- 44:19achieve, or to identify with all those Purely meaningless
- 44:24becoming absolutes. This is the period of time when
- 44:30it started to be fair. It's not that kind of absurdly
- 44:34abstract on the upanishads yet. This is what later.
- 44:37Teachers made it to be where Brahman and you just throw
- 44:40everything inside. Everything is Brahman.
- 44:42I'm Brahma and you are Brahman. The cosmos is Brahman and the
- 44:45dog is also Brahma. Which means absolutely nothing.
- 44:49It is just a formula for something that sounds like a
- 44:53drug-induced state, where everything is everything but
- 44:57neither did the first one mean anything, right?
- 44:59Like the, you know, there's this talks about the words, you say
- 45:03to impress God, that makes no sense.
- 45:07Well, you know, there was a certain idea behind that does
- 45:10make sense, which is a very specific manipulation of
- 45:14reality. It was not random, you cannot
- 45:17just say a word. Then magic happens.
- 45:20No. The gods are susceptible to very
- 45:22specific words to very specific prayers to very specific
- 45:26rituals, which means you needed specialized people to do that.
- 45:30Not everyone could do that. So I see a scam coming, well,
- 45:35it's colors Cameo, maybe it's not that wrong, but it screamed
- 45:40for religious professionals. Okay, Lee Justified.
- 45:46The Brahmin caste or the profession of not every Brahman
- 45:50is a priest, but the profession of the priest to say, look you
- 45:53need us And we can do it. Okay, right.
- 45:58So it went from Advent from Brahman.
- 46:01Who is the educated professional?
- 46:05Who can talk to God on your behalf and do rituals to bring
- 46:10you luck money, happiness, whatever, that might be, then it
- 46:14went from there. To, as you said, philosophical
- 46:17in which sense, even I think from, when Campbell was talking
- 46:20about, he was saying we are all living in a man.
- 46:24And we are all Brahman and, you know, they were feeding with
- 46:30each other's energy and whatnot. I completely didn't understand
- 46:33that, but it sounded really good and he was talking about it.
- 46:36So we feeding with each other's energy, so on and so forth.
- 46:39And he distinguished, if I'm not mistaken, he distinguished, that
- 46:45God is going past God into your own Ramon, something like that,
- 46:54which Also sounded really good but it didn't make sense to me.
- 46:58And I would like to emphasize something like that, it doesn't.
- 47:01Okay, good, good. So to Let's it made sense to you
- 47:05or do you kind of get what he was saying?
- 47:07Well, you know, when you when you hear it, when you read to
- 47:09it, you get where it's heading. It's becoming again, you know,
- 47:15it sounds like he's high and he's high on these home with
- 47:20okay? And this kind of mindset and
- 47:23evoking. Breaking away of barriers,
- 47:26right? Where the Eternal is, and me, I
- 47:29don't project on some personal God who has their limitations,
- 47:35right? If it's the, if I'm talking
- 47:38about the God of the Old Testament, it's a very specific.
- 47:42God. It's not, I cannot project
- 47:44everything on it, the kabbalists did.
- 47:46But if you read through it, it's a jealous God.
- 47:49It's a punishing. God, this is Stern.
- 47:51God also, yes, I think kind of a selective.
- 47:54Ride punishing, everyone else punishing, the Sinners and so on
- 47:58is this specific thing. If you look into the Indian
- 48:00tradition krishna's very different, it's a very loving
- 48:03character. Shiva is very different.
- 48:05So what kind of Brahman signifies when we approach this?
- 48:08These kinds of methodologies, it's non distinct.
- 48:12It's not specific. It doesn't have specific
- 48:15qualities. It rather signifies that there
- 48:18is an absolute vastness behind that Beyond any particulars.
- 48:23The absolute Transcendence, right?
- 48:25And then the spiritual kind of teachers said, well, where's
- 48:32this thing? Of course you are part of it.
- 48:35Of course, it's part of you if it's that Transcendent, it's
- 48:39within us and to realize that Is one way of finding Liberation
- 48:45Moksha Nirvana whatever. When there is when you see that
- 48:49in essence nothing is distinct from each other and so on and
- 48:53everything is an illusion. There are certain consequences
- 48:55that come with this kind of thinking by saying this is the
- 48:59absolute this is kind of what we try to realize ultimately those
- 49:04consequences follow. Now, again, what is interesting
- 49:11to me is not so much if it's true or not.
- 49:13For me, it's like, okay. Who cares for me?
- 49:15What is interesting is that this kind of talking this kind of
- 49:18listening somehow feels good that from, yeah, why is that?
- 49:23Yeah, because it doesn't make full sensor, you said
- 49:25Transcendent, you said, transient and energy and it
- 49:30transcends. Yes.
- 49:31What does that even mean? It transcends, that it means
- 49:35nothing. I'm interested.
- 49:36Why did you feel good? Entered.
- 49:38I have no idea. It sounded like he was getting
- 49:41to something but I didn't know what he was getting to it.
- 49:45Sounded really good and after I was done listening to it, I was
- 49:47like what was he saying about the whole Brahman thing?
- 49:50So I had to listen to it. Again, it still didn't make
- 49:53sense to me so I don't know why did it feel good listening to
- 49:56it? Well, we would again kind of
- 49:58from from a point of Mythology or maybe jungian psychology we
- 50:03would say it's something that is within us.
- 50:07Is that is responding to such a lingo to such a talk.
- 50:12Okay, so once I don't go any further, so you're saying
- 50:15something within us so it's definitely not our mind.
- 50:19Or is it our mind? Because I don't understand the
- 50:22concept of a soul. I don't know where it is, but
- 50:24let's say the young Don conscious.
- 50:29So the unconscious is listening through our conscious.
- 50:33So, the conscious gets hit. The unconscious is.
- 50:36Yep. I like it.
- 50:37Keep listening to it and the unconscious probably understands
- 50:40it, but the conscience makes, Makes no sense of it, right?
- 50:45Which is alright, which is part of the whole deal because if you
- 50:50see how you can find YouTube videos where you have what is
- 50:55called satsangs, where gurus are talking to the followers or just
- 51:00sit there sometimes and the followers are blissed-out, right
- 51:05and they get sometimes one barded with this talk of
- 51:08everything, is everything and nothing is everything and the
- 51:11Eternal is the Thing, and all of the stuff that doesn't really
- 51:14make sense and the getting blitzed out by that.
- 51:16Okay? Now, there are certain
- 51:18possibilities of what it could be.
- 51:20It could be General spiritual kind of experience and it could
- 51:24be a trance. And if you go into your kind of
- 51:28hypnotherapy and LP, all those Traditions, the recent
- 51:32Traditions who cultivate hypnotic.
- 51:35Trances one way to bring people into and trans is to confuse the
- 51:41logical mind. End.
- 51:44Okay, I agree with that. So you are either bringing
- 51:49people into trans or you are undoing the transparent.
- 51:55By bringing them on the trans. Yes.
- 51:58Okay. By bringing them into a trance.
- 51:59So now what you're saying is you're talking, you're talking
- 52:01and now they are in a different phase in a different set of mind
- 52:05or they are outside of their regular mind, right?
- 52:08The understanding - like what everything is nothing and then
- 52:11blew it. I don't know what he's talking
- 52:13about capitulate. It sounds good.
- 52:16And then it's like, okay, rests, I don't know thinking just
- 52:21receptor so you're thinking stops.
- 52:23Yes, that's part of H. Then I think, but yes, what does
- 52:30it mean? So, okay, fine.
- 52:32The sounded good too. So the thinking stops, right?
- 52:35So I'm listening to Campbell and use talking about Brahman and
- 52:38the Transcendent energy and energy from the other person
- 52:41coming to him at cetera. Sounds really good.
- 52:45I'm completely into it, my thinking, possibly stops for 10
- 52:49seconds or 30 seconds, if at all.
- 52:53But then. All right, so my subconscious
- 52:56picked it up now. What one more?
- 53:00No. Yeah, let me read the book.
- 53:03Let me hear more about it. He refers to that, right.
- 53:05On to that, to that, the German writer.
- 53:09I forgot his name you did before too long.
- 53:11For example. Yeah, but and it's like, oh, I
- 53:14want I want more. I want more.
- 53:15I want more of that feeling. This is what I want.
- 53:18There's nothing to understand. What I'm craving for is this all
- 53:21this Blissful emptiness that I had?
- 53:23That feels great, the story is like, if I can't find my find
- 53:27out more, I will have more access to this emptiness but
- 53:31actually it's necessary. What I'm looking for is the
- 53:33state of mind is like great to just shower me more with empty
- 53:39talk so they can Bliss out. So wait one second.
- 53:43So what are you saying that when he's talking about it or when
- 53:47even you talk about it, sometimes?
- 53:50You are just relaxing the mind and bringing in emptiness.
- 53:55So the mind could be relaxed. Yes.
- 53:59Now, I'm not saying this is everything that is going on.
- 54:03There are certain additional things.
- 54:04I can not, you know, there's certain romantic ideal that
- 54:09comes with that. There is, I think a baked in
- 54:15wish, for unification of the mind for You know, it's
- 54:21something to put it very, simply, I get drunk.
- 54:26For certain reasons, right? It feels good.
- 54:29Yes, there's a slight of for you, but also, for God's sake, I
- 54:32stop thinking that much, that is enough to continue to drink or
- 54:37to pick up the drinking again. It's just easy, right?
- 54:41Stop thinking, right? It's not the same.
- 54:44There are kind of additional that the joy of narrative there
- 54:48is the joy of When I get drunk, I cannot cannot, you know,
- 54:53transport it that to you, right? When I hear something,
- 54:56fascinating about the Brahman and the Atman, and schopenhauer
- 55:00and Shuba and so on, I can tell my friends like oh, I heard
- 55:03this. Fantastic talk, do that go on
- 55:06this journey with me, let's hear that together.
- 55:08Let's listen to it and talk about it afterwards.
- 55:11So there are kind of social aspects that are there.
- 55:13It's kind of it's a nice package that I think it would be
- 55:16worthwhile to kind of dissemble. It and to put it together again
- 55:21to see what is the alluring package of these specific myths.
- 55:28But for the sake of Simplicity, I think it's enough to say that.
- 55:32Obviously, there is a satisfaction listening to it,
- 55:35and that we want to repeat this satisfaction.
- 55:42Let's say if you go on a hike or, you know, let's say the hike
- 55:46is very tough, right? Or, you know, one of the times,
- 55:49I was really, really into a difficult situation.
- 55:55And we went snowboarding and when we were snowboarding, we
- 55:58were really looking out and making sure we do it, right?
- 56:02Because if you slip and fall, you're going to get really,
- 56:05really hurt. So you were fully concentrated
- 56:07on that. So you couldn't think of
- 56:08anything else. And then at the end of it, your
- 56:10body is tired. So is the Is for hiking or
- 56:13biking and a tough Trail but your mind is fresh and you love
- 56:18it and you want to do it again. Am I is this the same as
- 56:21listening to these talks? Well, there's similarities the
- 56:25big difference is you don't worry doing the sportive
- 56:28exhaustion, you don't believe that you unlocked some secrets
- 56:33of humanity, right? Which is more the case.
- 56:36When you deal with philosophy and spirituality is like, oh
- 56:39this is, I understand the world now.
- 56:42Now and I can tell everyone, look, you make this mistake.
- 56:44You think that you're an individual but in reality your
- 56:47everything, so there is kind of a gray, don't know, but but what
- 56:51you're saying is, we don't know if that is true or not.
- 56:53Of course, we don't know if it's true, it's gibberish, but it has
- 56:57the component of a secret that is not just personal, but is
- 57:01universal. And that is again, a great
- 57:04fascinating myth. That kind of is looking through
- 57:10those cracks, it's like, oh, This is very depressing.
- 57:14I'm really depressed. I thought that I was on to
- 57:16something. And now what you're telling me
- 57:18is it was just a sample was just messing with our heads.
- 57:22He just kind of like calm does down made us stop thinking and
- 57:27we are like oh good I got something.
- 57:29I can't explain it but I got good something.
- 57:32I think I think it's It's well, he did not deceive you
- 57:37purposefully, I obviously, he believed what he was saying, but
- 57:42I think if, you know, you ask me, I'm not a mythologist and I
- 57:46don't know of these things that true.
- 57:48I'm basically, you know, I'm interested in the mind and
- 57:51interested in Psychology and these is for me was factual.
- 57:55I can see those mechanisms at place. you cannot ask me if
- 58:01beyond that, there is something, because I kind of tell you,
- 58:05Okay. So as a practicing Buddhist
- 58:07right or Buddhist that you are and as you followed a couple of
- 58:13teachings of as some of the guru's and in India, and in
- 58:17different religions they do, talk about.
- 58:22They do talk about individualism and individuality, which is my
- 58:26own conscience versus everything being together part of one
- 58:32energy and all you are saying that it is, although it sounds
- 58:37really good. We have no proof or evidence of
- 58:41that. It just sounds good.
- 58:42Makes you stop thinking makes you stop feeling bad for your
- 58:46own self and then you feel better?
- 58:48Because you think you're part of society.
- 58:51Well, Leave away the just maybe this is the necessary tool.
- 58:55The necessary story than necessary narrative in order to
- 58:59propel people into spiritual practice.
- 59:03And why would people be propelled into a spiritual
- 59:05practice just to feel better? This.
- 59:10Okay, that's a deeper question and which we cannot pursue right
- 59:13now because we have to, okay? All right, this might be an
- 59:17interesting question to pursue further and it connects of
- 59:20course to the purpose of life thing, but it's I think it
- 59:24stands on its own. Okay.
- 59:27I mean I do have to tell you I'm a little bit depressed, as we
- 59:31are ending this session because I thought I was onto something.
- 59:34And now you're telling me I wasn't and I was tricked.
- 59:37I don't want anything, I just thought.
- 59:39Okay, if there is there some things that can be said with
- 59:43Clarity and I hope that I contributed to that.
- 59:49Okay, so we can end I think the session today.
- 59:53Yes, I love that. The two components of our
- 59:56conversation today, what did you?
- 59:57Yes, what did you get? So are open questions that for
- 1:00:01yourself or with others who would like to pursue right?
- 1:00:04So on purpose of purpose of life, right?
- 1:00:07Or lack thereof. So I think we got somewhere and
- 1:00:11and the good part was, we were able to link this to the prom on
- 1:00:14question. I think there's a little bit
- 1:00:16more to be talked about, but we linked it very nicely because in
- 1:00:20terms of purpose, of life, or lack thereof, what we said was,
- 1:00:24we need You be open to saying I don't know and we need to not
- 1:00:29pressure ourselves by thinking oh crap.
- 1:00:31Am I doing what I'm doing and is this the purpose of my life?
- 1:00:35And I think this question comes more when you are in a live
- 1:00:37situation where there's death in the family, you get really sick,
- 1:00:42there is a there is an imminent mortality that you think of at
- 1:00:46that point this question comes in addition to when you are
- 1:00:48unhappy and all these things can contribute together.
- 1:00:51So at that point, how do you handle it?
- 1:00:53I think it's not a one session thing you Have to go through
- 1:00:55multiple different phases to understand it and then, coming
- 1:00:59to the prom on it was really interesting, what you just said,
- 1:01:03because I think I like the point where you said, why did you like
- 1:01:07it? And I think that's where it, it
- 1:01:12gave me a little bit of clarity because yes, for the 5 Seconds,
- 1:01:1510 seconds, maybe more. I don't know.
- 1:01:18I didn't think of anything else. I was fully concentrated on it
- 1:01:21and I was like, yes, this makes sense.
- 1:01:22Let me, let me get it. I wasn't thinking what bills I
- 1:01:24wasn't. About my code not compiling at
- 1:01:27work, you know, I wasn't thinking of any of that.
- 1:01:30And yeah, and then I would go in and read another book and read
- 1:01:33another book and try to see if I can bring that feeling back.
- 1:01:38And sometimes I can sometimes I cannot but then it was also sad
- 1:01:43to know that it is something that we can philosophically talk
- 1:01:48about and we don't know if the if the gurus and all likeness
- 1:01:53Agatha and all the books that That I have read of those.
- 1:01:57If they were factual or they were just saying it to make us
- 1:02:01feel outside of our mind, which is another way of relaxing, our
- 1:02:07mind. Well, same thing.
- 1:02:10It's not the words that have a, you know, it's not like the word
- 1:02:13Apple corresponds to Apple and that way, certainly, it's wrong
- 1:02:18because the word Brahman doesn't correlate to anything, you know,
- 1:02:22it's or the absolute or the Transcendent there is no.
- 1:02:25Equivalent object. So in that sense, those words
- 1:02:28are empty, maybe they are functional, and I would argue
- 1:02:31that they are functional. Right, but it's not in the
- 1:02:36conventional way that usually, we refer to something specific.
- 1:02:41It's a different way of referring to things when it
- 1:02:44comes to spirituality and this kind of language.
- 1:02:49Okay. Pretty interesting talk.
- 1:02:52All right so do you want to stop the recording now or yes?
- 1:02:57Alright, the outro. Thanks everyone for listening
- 1:03:00and we have since we didn't come to any answers, we Might pick
- 1:03:04that up. I don't know.
- 1:03:06Thank you, honey. Yeah, he thanks.