Latest / Eye Spy: The Intelligence History Podcast / The Spy and The State
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to EyeSpy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 0:08I'm your host, Krystel von Kumberg.
- 0:12Every few weeks, I'm going to be interviewing historians, practitioners and scholars in
- 0:16the field of intelligence to explore some aspect of the past and what it can tell us
- 0:21about the present and future of intelligence studies.
- 0:29Today we are going to be discussing some of the themes of Jeffrey Rogge's upcoming book,
- 0:35The Spy and the State, The History of American Intelligence.
- 0:40Dr. Jeffrey Rogg is Senior Research Fellow at the University of South Florida's Global
- 0:46and National Security Institute.
- 0:47Previously, he was an Assistant Professor at the Joint Special Operations University
- 0:52in the Citadel.
- 0:53He was also a Postdoctoral Fellow in the National Security Affairs Department at the U.S. Naval
- 0:58War College.
- 1:00He currently sits on the boards of the International Journal of Intelligence and Counterintelligence
- 1:04and the Society for Intelligence History.
- 1:08It's such an honor to have you here today.
- 1:11Welcome to iSpy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 1:15Without giving away too much about your new book, I'll ask you a few questions.
- 1:22I noticed that on your blog, The Spy and the State, The Unknown History of American Intelligence,
- 1:27you share some background information on your forthcoming book.
- 1:31Could you elaborate a little on how your research evolved from the content on your blog as well
- 1:36as your dissertation at Ohio State University entitled The Spy and the State, The History
- 1:42and Theory of American Civil Intelligence Relations?
- 1:45What initially drew you to this topic?
- 1:48And what if anything surprised you or changed the way you think of the intelligence realm?
- 1:54So like many historians, my research is shaped by contemporary events.
- 1:58You know, a lot of historians will say that we're supposed to look at the history, you
- 2:02know, only in the context of the day.
- 2:04And we can do our best.
- 2:06But what we learn in intelligence studies is you always bring your own biases and perceptions
- 2:10into your work.
- 2:12So I was looking at events and reading the news and I started my PhD in the fall of 2016.
- 2:19And what was in the news was intelligence ahead of the presidential election.
- 2:24And so, you know, I saw that we were experiencing some of the worst features of American civil
- 2:29intelligence relations.
- 2:30And I really wanted to understand more about that.
- 2:33And especially how people were saying at the time, you know, this element of intelligence
- 2:38is unprecedented or the way that intelligence was affecting the election was unprecedented.
- 2:43And I suspected that there was always going to be a deeper history there.
- 2:47So that's what I set out to find out.
- 2:50Before that, though, I should have given you a little bit more background.
- 2:52I first became interested in intelligence studies in my master's program at Georgetown.
- 2:57And when I was there, I decided to concentrate in intelligence.
- 3:01That was one of the concentrations in the security studies program.
- 3:05And so then after I looked at Intel studies more from the contemporary angle, I was interested
- 3:11in getting a PhD.
- 3:12Unfortunately, and you know, this is a problem for intelligence studies in general and intelligence
- 3:17history is it doesn't really receive enough attention.
- 3:21And so I did my PhD in military and diplomatic history because you don't really have an intelligence
- 3:27history concentration PhD programs.
- 3:30And so for my dissertation, I focused on American intelligence history.
- 3:34And to me, the idea of civil intelligence relations was really a no brainer because
- 3:40we have a very well established field of civil military relations that you see in security
- 3:46studies programs.
- 3:47It's in the news even the idea of civil and civil military relations.
- 3:52But no one was talking about civil intelligence relations.
- 3:56And considering all the intelligence controversies that we've faced as a country and that we
- 4:00continue to face, you know, I'd like to see more intelligence practitioners and academics
- 4:04pay attention to the idea of civil intelligence relations.
- 4:08And so the proof of concept is really in the book.
- 4:11And one of the biggest challenges I had when I started writing was how to structure a complete
- 4:17history of American intelligence from the Revolutionary War to the present.
- 4:21And not only did civil intelligence relations help me identify some of the core themes of
- 4:26American intelligence history, it also helped me create a chronology and a structure that
- 4:32helped me explain different eras and key events in this history.
- 4:36And so that's really like the origin story for the book and the relationship between
- 4:41civil intelligence relations and American intelligence history.
- 4:46So when analyzing civil intelligence relations, what methods and archival research did you
- 4:51undertake to really uncover this history?
- 4:55And did you encounter any specific challenges or surprises during this process?
- 5:02Great question.
- 5:03I think it's the first one that intelligence historians always have to address because
- 5:07it's one of the most common questions I hear when people find out I'm an intelligence historian
- 5:11is how can you write about it if it's secret?
- 5:14And so, you know, as part of this research, I've read documents going back to the very
- 5:18beginning of the United States, including letters that the authors and recipients at
- 5:23the time wanted to keep secret.
- 5:25And you know, I've also read, you know, more than I can count declassified files of different
- 5:32intelligence programs and operations and decisions that were once closely held secrets.
- 5:38And so, you know, yes, classification will always pose a challenge to intelligence historians,
- 5:43but there's also plenty of information already out there and more that's becoming available
- 5:48every day.
- 5:49And, you know, I'm constantly amazed at how intelligence historians are uncovering the
- 5:54role that intelligence has played in key moments in history.
- 5:58And so, you know, to echo my colleague and friend, Diana Bollinger, you know, I think
- 6:02we're really entering a golden age for intelligence history.
- 6:06You know, that said, the research for the spy in the state was daunting.
- 6:09It ranged from the exciting to the seriously boring.
- 6:13I would say among the greatest challenges was probably staying awake while trying to
- 6:19find intelligence sources in 19th century legislative history and congressional debates.
- 6:26Luckily, law school prepared me for that.
- 6:29Also, this is just always a challenge for historians trying to decipher old handwritten
- 6:34letters and especially ones that have been preserved on microfilm is pains taking work.
- 6:41A lot of my research though focused on how intelligence appeared in American civil society.
- 6:46And so, I think the area of research that surprised me the most is just how often we
- 6:51see intelligence in newspapers, literature, and pop culture throughout US history.
- 6:57This is ranging from a Federalist newspaper in 1802, book reviews from the 1820s, sketches
- 7:04in a newspaper during the Spanish-American War of what a Spanish spy supposedly looked
- 7:08like and carried as tools of the trade.
- 7:11Then there's, you know, political cartoons, movies.
- 7:15So really, intelligence has always been there in the shadows and shadowing American history,
- 7:21so to speak.
- 7:22And so, you know, on that note, I'd say one of my favorite parts of the research was finding
- 7:27some really cool pictures for the book that I think readers are going to enjoy.
- 7:32And these pictures are from all areas of American intelligence history.
- 7:36Yeah, and just echoing your thoughts, in your blog, you mentioned that people would be surprised
- 7:42by just how many of the current problems in the United States have their origins in American
- 7:47intelligence history.
- 7:49And I think every country has a very distinct approach to intelligence, and history can
- 7:53really shed light on those origins.
- 7:55So it's really important to unpack those.
- 8:00So what, in your view, is the historical significance of the so-called deep state in American intelligence?
- 8:09And how do conspiracy theories connect to the history of US intelligence?
- 8:14What role has disinformation, for instance, played in shaping American public opinion
- 8:19throughout history?
- 8:21So the idea of the deep state is one of the recent controversies that I think demonstrates
- 8:26why we need to talk about civil intelligence relations as a mainstream issue in American
- 8:31politics and government.
- 8:32You know, fears of conspiracy and collusion in government touch a nerve, a very raw and
- 8:39old nerve in American history that goes back to the earliest days of the American Revolution.
- 8:44And as I discussed in the book, the US is the product of conspiracy.
- 8:49First there is this belief among the founders that there is a conspiracy in the British
- 8:53government to undermine their rights in the American colonies.
- 8:57And second, the American Revolution itself began as a conspiracy against the crown by
- 9:01small groups of patriots like the Sons of Liberty and the Mechanics.
- 9:05So conspiracy is sort of baked into America's DNA.
- 9:09And it even continues in the early years of the United States.
- 9:12I recently spoke about this at a few conferences, but intelligence helped create the two party
- 9:17system because it generated a lot of the very bitter disputes, partisan disputes in which
- 9:24each of the two political parties accused the other of collusion with a foreign power
- 9:28and of conspiracies to undermine the US government and destroy the republic.
- 9:33When you combine that with the revolutionary war era fear of a strong central government,
- 9:40of intrusive intelligence and surveillance by the state, of conspiracy and politics that
- 9:45can undermine our liberty, these are themes of American history that never really left
- 9:50us.
- 9:51And throughout this history, intelligence periodically mixes with partisan politics.
- 9:57And so I try and highlight as many of these episodes as I could to show that the results
- 10:03are never good for civil intelligence relations, for the intelligence community, or really
- 10:07for the country at large.
- 10:08And that's regardless of the motivations or the intentions of the individuals or organizations
- 10:13that were involved.
- 10:16Moving on to the disinformation piece, you know, this is a really popular topic in intelligence
- 10:19studies these days.
- 10:21I still prefer the sort of old school term propaganda.
- 10:25Now I spent more time on what I'd say are actual intelligence controversies rather than
- 10:30alleged ones.
- 10:32But accompanying the conspiratorial side of American history, there's a related tendency
- 10:36to see the sinister hand of spies and saboteurs sort of everywhere.
- 10:40And so in the early years of the United States, the Federalists and the Democratic Republicans,
- 10:45the two political parties, would often accuse each other of different plots and make allegations
- 10:51about each other and prominent Americans, including George Washington.
- 10:55And in fact, Washington was so sick of it by the time he left office that he complained
- 11:00in a famous letter to Alexander Hamilton that he couldn't suffer any longer to be buffeted
- 11:04in the public prints by a set of infamous scribblers talking about the press.
- 11:08And so, you know, to answer your question, I take the long view of this history and I
- 11:14see that Americans are inclined to believe whatever excites their passions at any particular
- 11:20moment in time.
- 11:21And unfortunately, you know, ideas and allegations like these can cause Americans to be turned
- 11:28against each other.
- 11:30And so disinformation, propaganda, is yet another feature of American intelligence history that
- 11:37we need to study so we understand how it divides the country and harms civil intelligence relations.
- 11:45Another question I had was about your book title.
- 11:49And I'm wondering how you came to choose it and whether there's a reason you chose spy
- 11:55to come before the state.
- 11:59So book title is a fairly easy answer, actually.
- 12:03And I remember the first time I said it out loud.
- 12:06During my PhD, I did a directed reading with Colonel Pete Monsoor, who was on my committee,
- 12:11and it was on the history of American civil military relations, because I use civil military
- 12:16relations sort of the foreground and help with some of the ideas of what I would think
- 12:22American civil intelligence relations or the field of civil intelligence relations would
- 12:27look like.
- 12:28And so in this directed reading, the first book I read, and it's really the foundational
- 12:33book for civil military relations, was Samuel Huntington's The Soldier in the State.
- 12:38And so during one of the meetings with Colonel Monsoor, the directed reading, we were talking
- 12:45about my dissertation on civil intelligence relations, and he asked if I had a title,
- 12:48and I sort of just blurted out the spy in the state, and he said, there you go.
- 12:52And it's stuck ever since.
- 12:54I should also say, though, that the story goes a bit deeper than that.
- 12:59As an undergrad at Swarthmore College, I was fortunate to take classes with Jim Kurth,
- 13:04Professor Emeritus, now, and he's still been a friend and mentor for 20-something years
- 13:09now.
- 13:10And Professor Kurth's advisor, mentor, and friend of over 40 years was Samuel Huntington.
- 13:17And so the title, The Spy in the State, is also in tribute to Samuel Huntington and to
- 13:22Professor Kurth as well.
- 13:24It's a great story, very, very detailed.
- 13:27Thank you for sharing that.
- 13:30So turning a little bit more to the president and his relationship with intelligence, did
- 13:37George Washington's actions as the first spymaster-in-chief establish a distinctly American intelligence
- 13:44tradition?
- 13:45And how do you think the centralization of intelligence authority in the president compares
- 13:52to the democratic principles the founders sought to protect?
- 13:56So really, in what ways has the role of the president as this spymaster-in-chief evolved
- 14:01over time and how has this affected U.S. democracy?
- 14:07This general question is one of the first issues I tackled in the book.
- 14:11And so at the outset of the American Revolution, the Continental Congress tried to set up different
- 14:16committees to manage aspects of the war, and one of those was intelligence.
- 14:21But what you see over the course of the American Revolution is that control shifted from these
- 14:27committees, and in this case we're talking about the Committee of Secrecy and Correspondence,
- 14:31to really prominent individuals, and one of them was Washington.
- 14:35Washington himself followed earlier traditions in intelligence history where you see generals
- 14:40or leaders personally managing a network of spies.
- 14:43And so again, that's not necessarily anything that's inherently American.
- 14:47There's a longer history there.
- 14:49But what Washington did was he helped establish a distinctly American intelligence tradition
- 14:56in the sense of how his precedents shaped the U.S. constitutional system as it pertained
- 15:02to intelligence.
- 15:03And so some of the founders who helped draft the Constitution were personally involved
- 15:08in intelligence during the Revolutionary War.
- 15:11And for instance, they saw how politicized intelligence scandals blew up in the Continental
- 15:15Congress, and it risked the secrecy of their activities and disrupted the war effort.
- 15:20And they also saw how Washington deftly managed intelligence, personally managed intelligence.
- 15:26Moreover, in the early years of the United States, Washington was virtually the only
- 15:31unifying political figure.
- 15:33So it sort of makes some sense that he would have discretionary control over intelligence
- 15:38as president.
- 15:40So Congress quickly realizes after it legislates something called the Secret Service Fund,
- 15:47it was first called the Contingent Fund for Foreign Intercourse, later the Secret Service
- 15:50Fund, that it ceded considerable control to the president over intelligence.
- 15:56And so Congress starts debating its role in the first half of the 19th century.
- 16:02And it even evades its responsibility to exercise real congressional intelligence oversight for
- 16:09nearly two centuries, until the 1970s.
- 16:13And so intelligence evolves as another element of executive power in the United States that
- 16:20expansively is what Arthur Schlesinger called the Imperial Presidency.
- 16:23So intelligence really is a pillar of the Imperial Presidency insofar as the executive
- 16:30has control over this major area of national security, and a secret one at that.
- 16:36But beyond that, intelligence is really part of just the natural churn of democratic politics
- 16:41and the constitutional separation of powers.
- 16:44And so we've seen intelligence controversies involving the president and civil society
- 16:52become lightning rods in a polarized and partisan Congress.
- 16:56We've seen this especially in recent years.
- 16:58And so this is yet another reason that we need to study and understand civil intelligence
- 17:03relations.
- 17:04And it's arguably more important today than perhaps at any other point in our nation's
- 17:08history because, again, of its polarizing effects on the United States itself.
- 17:16In your work, you describe Nathan Hale as America's first intelligence hero, despite
- 17:22his lack of tradecraft.
- 17:25And so I was wondering in what ways did the tradition of amateur spies, as seen with Hale,
- 17:31impact the early history of American intelligence?
- 17:35And how does his story reflect broader American attitudes towards spies and intelligence work?
- 17:42I like beginning with Nathan Hale.
- 17:45And I do refer to him in the book as America's first intelligence hero in the sense, at least,
- 17:52that he's a hero to many Americans, whether he was a good spy or not.
- 17:56That said, I still personally count him as a hero.
- 17:59What he did was incredibly brave.
- 18:00And he stood up to his own friends and fellow soldiers who thought that spying was beneath
- 18:06the dignity of an officer and a gentleman.
- 18:09And so he's one of the foundational figures also in the sense of establishing this tradition
- 18:15of the amateur spy.
- 18:17And intelligence really did remain an amateur game throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries.
- 18:23It's also arguably the last profession of national security to develop in the United
- 18:28States when we compare it to, say, the law enforcement, diplomatic, or military professions.
- 18:33Because until the foundation of the CIA, which is an independent intelligence organization,
- 18:39these other professions of national security subordinated intelligence.
- 18:44And so it really was relegated to sort of an amateur role.
- 18:49Even military officers who functioned as intelligence officers in the capacity as attachés or diplomats
- 18:57who also gather intelligence, their first responsibility is to military or diplomatic
- 19:04imperatives.
- 19:05So they're not really professional intelligence officers.
- 19:09As far as public attitudes go, there's a similar issue that you see in American civil military
- 19:14relations where we have this militia tradition of the citizen soldier.
- 19:19Americans have been suspicious of national security institutions for most of US history.
- 19:25And the fear of a standing army, for instance, was at the forefront of debates over the Constitution
- 19:30and the powers of a central government.
- 19:33And espionage was even worse, by the way.
- 19:35So in some of these congressional debates and in pop culture pieces, you see how Americans
- 19:41regarded spies with mixed feelings of curiosity, fear, and even disgust.
- 19:48And so this ideological bias against intelligence was one of the major reasons for this stunted
- 19:54development of an American intelligence profession.
- 19:57And in terms of civil military relations, I also want to distinguish intelligence because
- 20:04it's different in that the military has a draft.
- 20:07And so the draft basically takes citizens and turns them into soldiers temporarily.
- 20:13But intelligence needs professionals because it takes too much time and training to do
- 20:18intelligence well versus the ability to just draft and quickly raise an army.
- 20:23And so there's a problem in civil intelligence relations that's distinct from civil military
- 20:28relations because it doesn't have democratizing features like the draft.
- 20:33And along with secrecy, you can create an elitism in these professional intelligence
- 20:40organizations that further separates them from civil society.
- 20:45And so this distance between secret insular intelligence organizations and professional
- 20:51intelligence officers on the one hand, and then American civil society and the American
- 20:56people on the other, nurtures mutual suspicions between them.
- 20:59And this periodically creates problems for civil intelligence relations throughout American
- 21:04history.
- 21:07So how have these civil intelligence relations really evolved throughout US history?
- 21:13Do you see a link between domestic intelligence during the Revolutionary War, Native American
- 21:19history, such as the Red Scare and McCarthyism?
- 21:23In what ways has the American public's sort of shifting support influenced intelligence
- 21:28policies and their implementation?
- 21:31Yeah, great question that again goes sort of to the heart of what historians do.
- 21:37As I mentioned, we're supposed to think about history in context, what was happening at
- 21:42any particular moment in time that could shape any particular decision or outcome.
- 21:48But what we also need to do is look for trends.
- 21:52And how often does a certain trend need to resurface before we can draw larger inferences
- 21:59from it about a country or a culture or people?
- 22:02And so that's one of the things I'm doing in the spy in the state.
- 22:04And domestic intelligence is a great example.
- 22:07I found a great quotation in a book where I was reading about, I think it was around
- 22:14the time of the First World War.
- 22:16And essentially paraphrasing it, what it says is, you know, the people who were Tories or
- 22:20domestic threats during the Revolutionary War later became the Copperheads in the Civil
- 22:25War, the Catholics in the Spanish American War, then the Germans in the First World War
- 22:29and the Socialists in the First Red Scare.
- 22:31Meaning, you know, in the U.S. we always have this internal enemy that we need intelligence
- 22:39to keep eyes on.
- 22:41And the spy mania that this creates among the American people has led to some of the
- 22:46worst domestic intelligence excesses and abuses that the American people tend to blame on
- 22:52the intelligence community when they either outright supported, you know, sometimes reporting
- 22:57neighbors, for instance, or at least implicitly supported in the sense of we need to feel
- 23:04safe.
- 23:05And so, you know, we need intelligence to do whatever it needs to do at this particular
- 23:09moment to keep us safe and we'll worry about it and moralize about it later.
- 23:14And so this is certainly a trend throughout American intelligence history and it certainly
- 23:21shaped civil intelligence relations because of this tendency where when the American people
- 23:27feel threatened, they just sort of forget about their, you know, quest for liberty and
- 23:34suspicion of national security institutions and then when the threat seems to be over,
- 23:40they expect the national security professions and institutions to just retrench almost automatically
- 23:47and there's this, you know, usually a period of friction following the end of a war or
- 23:51a threat where we try and re-institute retrenchment.
- 23:55And you know, for instance, the intelligence community sort of looks at you like, wait,
- 24:00you just want us to give up all the capabilities and systems and policies that we implemented
- 24:06now that you feel safe again.
- 24:09So again, it's one of those trends in American intelligence history that is formative to
- 24:16the book and the research and one that, you know, I try and raise awareness to because
- 24:21it just keeps repeating itself and always produces friction between the intelligence
- 24:27community and the American people.
- 24:29So stemming from this tendency that you mentioned, how have constitutional challenges arisen
- 24:35from the use of intelligence in American history and what are the implications of intelligence
- 24:41being a source of discomfort for Americans, yet also such a crucial tool for national
- 24:48security?
- 24:50So the question that you ask is basically the balancing act.
- 24:54The problem atique is what Peter Feaver terms it for, borrowing his term at least, for civil
- 25:01military relations to transfer it to civil intelligence relations is we need institutions
- 25:07of national security.
- 25:08We need intelligence.
- 25:10And yet it also causes social angst, not to mention that it can pose a very real threat
- 25:17to liberty.
- 25:18And so we've seen those threats when intelligence organizations, for instance, have unconstitutionally
- 25:24spied on the American people.
- 25:26The year of intelligence and the church committee hearings are a great example.
- 25:31So there's that fundamental tension that we never really seem to resolve.
- 25:38And again, I attribute it to partially, I want to be very clear that just as a matter
- 25:45of writing the spy in the state, there's, I've noticed sort of a tendency where you
- 25:55have people who are on one side or the other, meaning you tend to see practitioners, former
- 26:01practitioners, policymakers who defend the intelligence community.
- 26:06And then on the other side, you tend to get the journalists and the academics who tend
- 26:11to criticize the intelligence community.
- 26:13And I try and just be fair to both sides.
- 26:16And so yes, the intelligence community has unconstitutionally spied on Americans, done
- 26:23things that fundamentally are discordant with American principles.
- 26:30And yet on the other side, as I said, the American people themselves have sometimes
- 26:34been complicit in this.
- 26:36And so we have to be fair to both the intelligence community and the American people about our
- 26:43respective virtues and vices.
- 26:46And so part of the balancing act I'd say for civil intelligence relations is this realization
- 26:53that each side has areas of blame and areas that they can work on.
- 26:59I sort of think of it in terms of like a sine wave.
- 27:02If you see the peaks and troughs, how do we reduce, I know I'm using scientific terms
- 27:08that I myself as a historian wouldn't otherwise use, but it's just sort of a useful way to
- 27:12visualize it, but how do we reduce the amplification?
- 27:17How do we reduce the size or the height between those peaks and troughs where it just doesn't,
- 27:25these vacillations in civil intelligence relations don't produce so much angst and discomfort
- 27:31and mistrust between the intelligence community and the state and society that it serves.
- 27:37Absolutely.
- 27:38Very well put.
- 27:40My last question for you is what do you hope readers will take away from your book?
- 27:46Yeah, that's kind of the overarching question that I think authors are constantly considering
- 27:55when they're writing.
- 27:57And so, you know, I like starting at the beginning.
- 28:00I'm glad I started with the American Revolution.
- 28:03And I also, even before that, you know, I talk about in the introduction that the constitution
- 28:08begins with we the people.
- 28:10And it's fashionable these days to despair of democracy.
- 28:13You know, you hear people say that their vote doesn't count.
- 28:16It's probably even easier to think that you have no control over national security and
- 28:21especially not intelligence because after all it's secret or it's classified.
- 28:26But what I would want my readers to walk away with are probably two conclusions that I reached
- 28:35in writing the book.
- 28:36And first, it's that the American people have had a larger role in shaping the American
- 28:41intelligence system and U.S. intelligence history than more than they might realize.
- 28:48And second, we need to learn from this history and just the people need to assert their role
- 28:54in intelligence even more directly in the future than they have in the past because
- 29:00the challenges that the country faces today eclipse the abilities of the intelligence
- 29:04community or even the U.S. government to manage.
- 29:06You know, inside the U.S. government, there's something that you'll hear where people will
- 29:09talk about, you know, whole of government approaches to the challenges facing the country.
- 29:14Whole of government interagency.
- 29:16Basically, you know, how is the U.S. government going to deal with this problem?
- 29:21But I don't think there's really ever such a thing as a whole of government approach.
- 29:26It's always whole of nation, meaning that, you know, the society, the people are always
- 29:31involved.
- 29:32And so, you know, as I say in the book, it's really more than a history of the spy in the
- 29:36state, the title.
- 29:38It's a history of the spy, the state and the American people and how their ideas, ideals,
- 29:42even fears, suspicions, beliefs have shaped intelligence in the country along with it.
- 29:48And so ultimately, I hope that the spy in the state will inspire and empower the American
- 29:53people and, you know, even readers in other countries to have a more active role in their
- 30:00intelligence communities and in international intelligence policy and the governments along
- 30:04with it.
- 30:05Well, yeah, I'm very excited to read your book and I'm very much looking forward to
- 30:11learning more.
- 30:13So thank you so much for joining me on I Spy, the intelligence history podcast.
- 30:19Thank you.