Latest / The Vegan Report / Debunking Christspiracy. With Daniel Mascarenhas, S.J. | Ep. 63
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan and today we are taking a close look at the documentary
- 0:06Christ-Piercy. There's a strong impactful and clear Christian argument for veganism and my hope
- 0:17was for Christ-Piercy to successfully make that argument to the Christian community.
- 0:22But I discovered that this is not what the documentary is about. What I watched was
- 0:30a patchwork of extraordinary claims that deserved some review. And who better to deliver that review
- 0:38than today's guest Daniel Mascarenhas. Daniel is a Jesuit seminarian currently studying to become
- 0:45a priest. He's also the activist behind vegancatholic.org, the resource for anyone
- 0:53interested in understanding why Christianity and veganism go hand in hand. You will find in the
- 1:00episode notes a link to vegancatholic.org and also a link to watch Christ-Piercy for free.
- 1:08It goes without saying that this episode contains major spoilers.
- 1:12I watched the documentary and I wrote down some comments and questions because I knew I was going
- 1:21to talk with you and I kept thinking about you while watching the documentary. And first of all,
- 1:30sorry, I think I forced you to watch the documentary. And also I want to start with something that is
- 1:40prevalent in that film. And it's the sense that the life of the documentary makers is in danger
- 1:53and that the church is going against them or will retaliate in some way. And I have to say,
- 2:03I was very skeptical of those claims, starting with the fact that I know you and I know how
- 2:12outspoken you are about veganism and animal ethics. And I was thinking, but Daniel never had his life
- 2:19threatened by the church for speaking up. So can you tell us about that? Is there some conspiracy
- 2:27out there, censoring Christians who speak about animal ethics?
- 2:35The short answer is no. I have never felt threatened. I did not pay much attention to that
- 2:42aspect of it. Now that you bring it up, I just thought it was a side show. No, if any of your
- 2:48listeners are listening here, there is no such conspiracy as far as I'm aware. Nobody has ever
- 2:55said anything to me as a priest in training. I have not seen any drones outside my window
- 3:03anytime. I think it's a little bit of a, first of all, it's hard to say when you say what is
- 3:08the church, right? I'm Catholic. There are many other Christians who are not Catholic.
- 3:14So when the church goes after somebody, what do you mean by the church? Is it a Catholic church?
- 3:19Is it a Presbyterian? Is it a Methodist? So in the documentary, it's unclear
- 3:27who exactly is angry with the producers, right? I have heard not from a church, but from
- 3:36more like a corporate executive, corporate America, they don't want their profits to be
- 3:43harmed by any movement towards veganism. And so activists who go undercover and try to take
- 3:49videos and things like that, they are gone after by corporate America, because
- 4:00usually money is the main driver for these kinds of things. I don't think the church,
- 4:04as far as I know at the Catholic church, doesn't stand to make or lose money in this fight of
- 4:11whether we should eat meat or not. On the other hand, companies that own factory farms and sell
- 4:17products in the market obviously have a lot to lose if people stop eating meat. And so they would
- 4:23have an incentive to do something like that. But I found that to be a little overdramatic and
- 4:30tangential to the topic at hand. And let me add that in our last podcast, you talked about how
- 4:38Pope Francis took a very friendly position to animal advocates and animals. He mentioned,
- 4:51I think, in one of his messages to the church that we should interpret dominion over animals as
- 4:58stewardship, basically, with the makers of the movies we're talking about. And I kept thinking,
- 5:09I don't think Pope Francis would be shocked or would feel like sending the army Swiss guards
- 5:19after the makers of that documentary if we're talking about the Catholic church. Because yes,
- 5:29I did find that they were using all sorts of labels in the most confusing way. Church is one
- 5:38of them. Religion is another. I feel like they were confusing religion and spirituality, but also
- 5:47religion and ethics and morality. All of that was very confusing. Yes. I think it's hard to put a
- 5:58clear label on who is in charge. First of all, you have so many different religions. And then
- 6:04in Christianity, you have so many different denominations. And even as a Catholic,
- 6:12people think that whatever the pope says is final. If I don't listen to the pope, the pope will send
- 6:17his army. Not really. First of all, the Vatican city is so small. And secondly, that's not how
- 6:23our fate works. We have different levels of authority. The scripture is the highest authority,
- 6:28and that's probably what I would want to discuss the most. But even if the pope says something,
- 6:33it is not binding on Catholics. It is the way he says it. Is he speaking from his office
- 6:39of the chair of Peter, or did he just say something while giving an interview? And those are two very
- 6:45different things. If the pope is speaking from authority, he says so, and then he gives a
- 6:50statement. If he's merely talking to a journalist at a different level of authority, and I'm
- 6:56completely free to disagree with the pope if he's not speaking from authority. You mentioned how
- 7:03the ultimate authority is the scripture. So let's talk about the scripture and something that is
- 7:08core to Christ's piracy, which is this new interpretation of what happened at the temple.
- 7:17Now, they find, I think they found a translator to present under a new light, what might have
- 7:25happened between Jesus and the temple people. So there were many claims mixed up with that.
- 7:36First of all, that the temple was basically a big slaughterhouse, and that what Jesus was reacting to
- 7:47in there was not so much the financial part, the money, but the animal sacrifices.
- 7:57So what do you make of that interpretation of the scripture in that episode?
- 8:04So one of the critiques I heard of that section was the producers go to a Hebrew scholar and not
- 8:13a Greek scholar. The New Testament, the gospels are part of the New Testament, were written in
- 8:21Greek, not in Hebrew. So in the Christian Bible, you have the Old Testament and the New Testament.
- 8:27The Old Testament, large parts, almost all of it, was written in Hebrew and then translated to
- 8:34Greek, and that's called a Septuagint. It was translated officially, if you may, and there's
- 8:39some talk about divine intervention because 70 different scholars translated the Hebrew to the
- 8:46Greek in exactly the same way, and hence it was considered to be a divinely inspired translation.
- 8:53The New Testament, on the other hand, was written in Greek from the start. Of course,
- 8:59there could be Hebrew translations made after that. I don't know. There should be. The New
- 9:05Testament has been translated into every language possible, so I'm sure there's a Hebrew translation
- 9:09of the New Testament. So if they were looking for what the original says, it would make sense to go
- 9:15to the Greek, not to Hebrew, because Hebrew would be one step removed. In the Greek, it does mean,
- 9:23and I'm not a Greek scholar, so I asked somebody else, and the word does mean robber or thief.
- 9:30Now when we think of robber, we can have all sorts of ideas about robbers. We can think of pirates.
- 9:37We can think of pickpocketers. We can think of burglars. We can think of people who mug.
- 9:42Now those who mug people are a little more violent than pickpocketers, right? So there's a whole
- 9:50level of what a robber or thief is in any context. But what would be common to all of that would be
- 10:01taking something that is not yours. And so if you apply that in the temple situation,
- 10:09it seems like there might have been some sort of conspiracy as to how much money they would take
- 10:16from people to conduct a sacrifice, both from a ritual standpoint to offer a sacrifice,
- 10:24but also from meat consumption, because they could only eat.
- 10:28There are different interpretations of this or different ideas of what kind of meat could
- 10:33be slaughtered, but even today we have kosher meat, for instance. And so the idea was that you could
- 10:39only eat meat that was slaughtered in certain places, which also kind of connects with what
- 10:43St. Paul talks about later. And so sometimes my understanding of it is how you have in today's
- 10:53world, when you have no competition, they can start charging more and more prices. That's why
- 10:57we have antitrust laws, right? And so if there's only one place where you can get your meat,
- 11:03then they have full control over the pricing. And then they would take a lot of money or take
- 11:07a large amount of the animal flesh for themselves. And so you would think of them as robbers.
- 11:13Or thieves, because they are price gouging. And in that sense, yeah, they are robbers and thieves.
- 11:19They are taking money from people and kind of gatekeeping religious practice, but also
- 11:27a food source. And so Jesus is angry because now the temple is no longer about living the law,
- 11:36the Torah, which is very important for people, but it became more about how much money I can
- 11:41get out of people. And so Jesus is angry, which kind of makes sense. So for me, that is a bit
- 11:51of a stretch, the way the producers talk about it as the translation is wrong. Well, the translation
- 11:57is probably correct, at least because it's from Greek, not from Hebrew. And as far as we know,
- 12:04that was the reality of the temple, that it was used to kill animals, both for ritual purposes,
- 12:12to offer sacrifice to God, and also as a source of meat, because the animal had to be killed in a
- 12:18certain way, according to Jewish customs. Because remember, at this time, Jerusalem, the Holy Land,
- 12:25was part of the Roman Empire. And so not everybody was Jewish. There were also a lot of Roman
- 12:32people and other people in the area. And they had their own sources of food, which, because they
- 12:38did not care about these rituals, but the Jews, those who were trying to follow the Torah,
- 12:45were trying to keep these laws. And so I think, I don't think we can establish clearly that
- 12:53Jesus was angry because of the meat trade, or he was just angry because of the way the money was
- 13:00being overcharged. And I just want to make this point before I forget it. Like I had mentioned to
- 13:05you that a lot of these conversations about whether Jesus ate meat or not is sometimes problematic,
- 13:13because we cannot know for sure, because it's not directly said anywhere in the Scripture. And so
- 13:19people say, oh, because we cannot know something, it doesn't matter. No, I mean, we cannot know many
- 13:27things about Jesus. We cannot know, for instance, what he said about slavery, because it's not
- 13:31mentioned in the Bible. Did he own slaves? Probably not, because he was too poor. Would he have
- 13:38owned slaves if he had more money? Who knows? But that doesn't mean that we should have slaves today,
- 13:47just because it's not clear in the Bible. And so I think we have to be careful when we try to do
- 13:52this historical analysis, that there's a common tendency that if we cannot know something,
- 13:58there's no point in trying to think about it anymore. And so people will say, oh, there's no
- 14:03way to know that Jesus ate meat or not. He probably ate meat. So it's a free for all now, 2000 years
- 14:10later. And so I just want to be careful when we do these historical analysis to keep in mind that
- 14:16there's going to be uncertainty and how do we deal with uncertainty is an important aspect of this.
- 14:23That's a really great point. Let's go back quickly to that interpretation of that episode of the
- 14:31temple. My first question, from what you said, is it convincing or does it matter for everyday
- 14:42Christians, the nuances of what happened at the temple? I feel like they make it a big deal in the
- 14:54documentary, but I feel like everyday Christians would not care that much about that, because it's
- 15:04really in the details and it's about technicalities of translation. I feel like this is something
- 15:11that would go way above the head of your average Christian. And also, I feel like there are more
- 15:19convincing arguments based on scripture to influence or convince someone of considering veganism,
- 15:32considering protecting animals. And you do make on your website, vegancatholic.org,
- 15:42those arguments. For instance, you talk about the Garden of Eden and how it's the ideal
- 15:50place and how there was no animal consumption. So can you address those two points?
- 15:57Yeah, since a lot of the arguments depend on a translation of one word, for me, that is
- 16:04putting a lot of pressure on one word. And as I said, they are using Hebrew for some reason,
- 16:11which doesn't make sense. Also, if Jesus was really against animal sacrifices or the temple
- 16:20situation, why did he not say anything elsewhere? And then eating fish and fishermen and so on.
- 16:33Sometimes the argument used is that, well, Jesus did not write the Bible, other people wrote the
- 16:38Bible, so maybe Jesus said he was vegan, but the gospel writers are not writing down. Well,
- 16:45that's where the element of faith comes in. We believe that the writers of the books of the
- 16:50Bible were human, but they were inspired by God and God's Spirit was working within them.
- 16:57And for 2000 years, God's Spirit works in all of us who are believers and kind of keep the faith
- 17:07alive. So it would seem like either God or God's Spirit was deceiving us or incompetent
- 17:17in misleading us for 2000 years. So a big thing for the Catholic faith is that we have a continuity
- 17:23of our faith. And so the idea that it is not there in the Bible or we mistranslated one word,
- 17:34or we mistranslated one word for 2000 years and we've been misled for so long, it kind of goes
- 17:41against the basic ideas of our faith that the Spirit would have prompted us about something
- 17:47that is so important. Now, that's why I always talk about a bigger picture of reading the Bible
- 17:57and understanding our faith. As you pointed out, the Garden of Eden. So from Jesus, the discipleship
- 18:07standpoint, I've always maintained, I'm a vegan, but I always maintain that if there's no other
- 18:12option, one can eat animals as a human, because in our tradition, humans are like the highest
- 18:22creature among, well, not really, angels are supposed to be higher than them. So humans are
- 18:28the highest in this world, okay, on planet earth. And so we have dominion over other creatures. And
- 18:35so we can use animals as far as needed. Okay. And that has to be balanced with the general call for
- 18:46kindness and compassion, right? Jesus always talks about loving your neighbor, about serving those in
- 18:55need, helping the poor, helping the widow, helping the orphan. That idea is to help those who are
- 19:04oppressed, who are on the margins. And so I talk about it in terms of that, like obviously a dog
- 19:12is not a human, but a dog has a capacity to receive kindness. As far as I know, an oak tree
- 19:21doesn't have a capacity to receive kindness in the same way, right? And so if a dog can receive
- 19:27kindness, I ought to show a dog kindness. And if a plant doesn't receive kindness in the same way,
- 19:34and so I can use a plant for my sustenance instead of a dog or a cow, because showing kindness to a
- 19:42dog or a cow would involve not killing it. So to take a step back from what is in the Bible,
- 19:52that is more explicit and not about mistranslations, is the book of Genesis. So in the book of Genesis,
- 19:59which is the first book in the Bible, but it was not written as the first book, it was written much
- 20:03later when the Israelites were in exile in Babylon. But since it's the first book of the Bible,
- 20:12it talks about creation. So this is how the Israelites, God's chosen people, saw their role
- 20:20in the universe. And so that's the way they felt inspired that this is how God created the world
- 20:27and where they stood in it. And so that is like a foundational text of where do we see ourselves
- 20:33in God's creation. And in chapter one, it's God says that we should eat seeds and plants.
- 20:40And then in chapter two, God says he creates animals as companions because the first human
- 20:47was feeling alone. And so the idea that even these people who lived in a land that was quite dry
- 20:58and they needed animals to use the hilly terrain for grazing and obviously have to slaughter or
- 21:04milk them, also realized that maybe the idea that originally this good and compassionate God would
- 21:13have intended something that is free from violence. But then violence came into the world through our
- 21:20own sin, that is the fall, right? When Adam eats from the tree, the forbidden fruit. So they sensed
- 21:27that, okay, God intended something good. We messed things up through our sin. And in the end,
- 21:38we will go back to perfection, to Eden. God will unite all of creation to God's self,
- 21:48peace and harmony when God comes to judge at the end of time. And that is also revisited in the
- 21:55book of Isaiah, where Isaiah the prophet, he's probably the most famous prophet from the old
- 22:00Testament who says like on God's holy mountain, so in God's reign, there will be no more violence.
- 22:09All these animals, the snake and the child and the lamb and the lion will all be together and
- 22:15they will not harm each other. So they envisioned that at the end of time, there will be no more
- 22:21violence. So God's original intent and God's final intent are both without violence. We are in this
- 22:29in-between time of God's original intent and before we believe in Jesus comes a second time,
- 22:36that's when God will judge the world and then that will be the end times.
- 22:41Now, when do we start eating meat in the Bible? Well, it's also in the book of Genesis, chapter
- 22:46nine. So there's a lot of sin, lots of things are happening and then God is angry and then God
- 22:55wants to flood the earth. So this is a great flood. Noah makes a boat,
- 23:00takes all the animals with him in the boat, the flood ends. And then God allows humans to eat
- 23:07animals because of the hardness of their hearts. Okay, that's how we live in the Bible. God allows
- 23:13humans to eat animals because of the hardness of their hearts. Now, there are two important things
- 23:18to remember in that context. One is allows. The word allows doesn't mean you have to, right?
- 23:26We can be allowed certain things, but we can avoid doing it if it is not the best idea.
- 23:34And secondly, it's also only because of the hardness of our hearts. Okay, so the best analogy
- 23:40I like to give is a two-year-old or say like a five-year-old and her mother. Okay, so mother
- 23:49and daughter. It is 5.30 in the evening and the daughter, a five-year-old really wants to eat
- 23:57ice cream. And the mom says, no, do not eat ice cream. And this goes on for a while. The daughter
- 24:04is throwing a tantrum, she's crying and she's saying all sorts of things. And so eventually
- 24:10the mother says, okay, go ahead, eat ice cream. All right, so the mother said to eat ice cream
- 24:16or the mother says, you can eat ice cream. All right, I will allow you to eat ice cream.
- 24:21She's not ordering the daughter. She's saying, I'm allowing you to eat ice cream because of
- 24:26the hardness of your heart. Now, the daughter, the five-year-old, if she knows her mother well,
- 24:31will understand that the mother is not telling her to eat, like it's not forcing her,
- 24:35it's not commanding her, she's allowing her. And the daughter also knows that the mother has just
- 24:40like given up, the mother is tired. And if she has some sense of her mother's tiredness or fatigue,
- 24:50she would probably not eat the ice cream even though she got permission, right? Because she
- 24:54loves her mother and she wants to be true to her original intent of not allowing the ice cream.
- 25:02And so that's how I like to see like our faith life in general. And when we talk about these laws,
- 25:10you know, that are in the Bible or there are laws in Christianity as well, all of these rules,
- 25:16it's not because like God wants us to be, you know, like in a straight jacket without freedom
- 25:23or that God likes troubling us. No, it's a sense of relationship. Like we show that we are in
- 25:29relationship with God by acting in a certain way. And so all of these laws that what God allows and
- 25:36God doesn't allow is about relationship with God. And so I think a way to read the Bible is always
- 25:44to say, what will enhance my relationship with God? And what takes me away from God? And so one of the
- 25:52ways we relate to God is through what God has created, right? So like me and you and all other
- 26:01people listening, and then we have non-human animals and then we have trees and we have the
- 26:06earth. Well, all of it belongs to God because God created all of this. And so how we relate to
- 26:13our fellow creatures kind of shows how we relate to God. You know, I mean, God is infinite, but God
- 26:21has allowed us to interact with fellow creatures as a way of relating with God. And so
- 26:28treating animals is different from treating plants is different from treating rocks.
- 26:33And we have to show love and kindness to each of these creatures in the level that they're able to
- 26:41receive. And at a better minimum, we shouldn't harm them as far as possible. I mean, for me,
- 26:47that is the way to read the Bible. It's not about all the laws. The laws are important,
- 26:52but it is important to know why they are there. And I think sometimes that is lost in the way
- 27:00we read the Bible. So to get to the other one that they talk about briefly, and I may have talked
- 27:07about this when we talked over email, I think St. Paul talks about people eating meat and those who
- 27:13don't eat meat are weak. The cause and effect there is a bit of a misleading way that they have
- 27:23portrayed in the movie. So what St. Paul is saying is that, okay, so connected with the temple,
- 27:33because it was a Roman Empire, not everything was Jewish. There were a lot of people who were not
- 27:38Jewish. They were either called pagans or gentiles. And so the Jewish people, so not just Jerusalem,
- 27:44so now St. Paul is talking to different parts of, this is in the letter to the Romans, so they are
- 27:49in Rome. There are different parts of Greece, modern day Turkey, and all of that. So people
- 27:54are spread out. Jews are living among other people, and Jews are in the minority in most places,
- 28:01except maybe in Jerusalem itself. And so a lot of times they had trouble keeping the law,
- 28:09because they were such a small minority. But an important part of keeping the law for them
- 28:16was to not eat meat that was sacrificed to the idols. Okay, so now imagine you're living in,
- 28:23I'm living in Boston, and this is a place where everything is religious. We cannot think of like
- 28:32star market or Safeway, or just separate. Here everything is connected with God. So a butcher
- 28:38down the street will have his God, and when he's working, he will offer the meat that he's
- 28:44slaughtering to his God. The Romans had lots of different gods. And so a Jewish person who
- 28:50would go to that butcher now is buying meat that has been sacrificed to the idol. Okay,
- 28:58and so that is a problem, because according to Jewish law, you shouldn't eat meat that has been
- 29:03sacrificed to an idol, because you don't want to honor other gods. Jews and Christians now
- 29:09also believe that there's only one God. And so it would be really hard sometimes to find
- 29:15things not offered to idols, meat especially. And so St. Paul is trying to find this balance here of
- 29:22allowing people to be more like liberal, if you may, and saying that what is important is our faith
- 29:30in Jesus. Sometimes these other smaller things might not matter as much. So if you're going to
- 29:39be strong in our faith in Jesus, St. Paul says, we don't have to worry about these smaller things
- 29:45about meat to the idols and so on. But some of us might not be strong in our faith. And so we need
- 29:54to take more precautions as weak people to not eat meat sacrificed to idols, just in case we don't
- 30:03think of these supernatural things. But I mean, as a person of faith, I do believe that there are
- 30:08evil, there's evil out there. And I should avoid bringing evil into myself. If I think that I'm
- 30:16strong, maybe my body or my spirit can fight the evil. And so I'm fine. But if I'm weak, I'm fine.
- 30:25But if I think that I'm weak, out of humility, I will think that I am weak. And so I will try my best
- 30:35to avoid possibility of getting evil into myself, in this case meat from idols. So he says,
- 30:43one person believes that one may eat anything. So strong people can eat anything, while the weak
- 30:50person eats only vegetables. Well, he's a weak person. And that is why he's eating vegetables.
- 30:57It's not that he has become weak because he's eating vegetables. Okay, so this is very important
- 31:03here. So if you know that you are weak spiritually, you should avoid eating meat sacrificed to idols.
- 31:12Okay, just eat vegetables, be safe. And that's what he's saying. So he's saying,
- 31:18I think that idea of like strong and weak, I think it's helpful to be humble and say,
- 31:24no matter how strong you are, I hope you be as a person of faith, I will be humble to say,
- 31:31my faith is not perfect. There are weaknesses to my faith. And I will do my best to avoid things
- 31:38that might cause me to stumble, to sin. Other things that might cause me to sin, I try to avoid
- 31:49as much as I can and not tempt myself. There's a famous, I think, Greek story about those people
- 31:55on the boat, the sirens. There are these sailors who are going to fight some war, but there are
- 32:02these really beautiful mermaids or something in the water. And I will try to avoid that.
- 32:07So they're going to fight some war, but they're not going to die. So they're going to die.
- 32:10So they're going to die. And so there are different ways of avoiding like one of them ties himself
- 32:14to the mast, one of them like covers his ears or something. So you don't want to tempt fate,
- 32:21if you may. And that's what Saint Paul is saying. So it's not that vegetables make you weak. It is
- 32:28that if you think that you are weak in your faith, you should avoid meat because it's coming from
- 32:33a pagan source that has been offered to the idols. That's what he's getting at.
- 32:39Yeah. So it is unfortunate because at least with a lot of men, meat is associated with strength
- 32:45and manliness. And then they use this passage and say, look, even Saint Paul knew it. And that's
- 32:50not how it is written. So beautifully said. I wish they hired you to advise them making this
- 33:00documentary. I really do. Because the editing and the way they filmed the thing was just
- 33:09beautiful from a visual perspective. It was stunning. But the content itself, I felt like
- 33:18it lacked substance really. And I'm not sure how much, because that's the thing. I heard lots of
- 33:30praises coming from people praising this documentary, but it always came from atheists or pagans or
- 33:40who are vegans who I know who are not really religious or belong to different religious
- 33:46traditions. And I kept thinking, where are the Christians? Is any Christian watching this movie?
- 33:52I felt like this missed the target audience and that a Christian audience would be more receptive
- 34:04to the case you've just made, clearly made that relates to their faith, relates to important
- 34:12episodes of the Bible, fundamental beliefs, and not to episodes and conspiracies and certain
- 34:23details and making those details into a whole situation. Like honestly, watching the documentary
- 34:33felt like watching that movie, The Da Vinci Code. I think it's based on a book. That's what it felt
- 34:41like. And yeah, I just wonder, you know, how much of the content is being made by the Christian
- 34:51community? And I wonder, you know, how much does that documentary appeal to the target audience
- 35:03and will make an impact, a positive impact among Christian communities? Yeah, you know, as I said,
- 35:12like the idea that we were wrong for 2000 years really goes against our teaching. And also, I
- 35:19think that people will feel attacked. And so, I think a more positive way of using the passages
- 35:24that I talked about Genesis chapter one, chapter nine, the book of Isaiah, you know, and then in
- 35:31Jesus's time, you know, there are certain places that could be helpful to think about. Like for
- 35:37example, I like to think there's a parable in the Bible where Jesus tells a story. There's a king
- 35:45who says, okay, let's call him high servant and low servant. There are different levels of servant.
- 35:49So, the high servant who directly reports to the king has some debts and he's not able to pay them.
- 35:55So, he goes to the king and asks the king for forgiveness. And then the king says, you know,
- 36:02okay, I will forgive you, you know, out of the mercy and so on. So, the high, the top servant
- 36:09is happy that he's been forgiven. But when the top servant goes home, he realizes that a low servant
- 36:19is indebted to him. Okay. So, the top servant starts abusing the lower servant until he pays
- 36:26him back. And the lower servant says, please forgive me. I will pay you as soon as I can.
- 36:30Have mercy on me. But the top servant says, no, I will not forgive you. And he throws the lower
- 36:36servant into jail. The king hears about this and so he summons the top servant and says,
- 36:42why did you do this? When I showed you mercy, why couldn't you show me mercy?
- 36:46Why couldn't you show your lower servant mercy? And so, he throws, the king throws the top
- 36:51servant into jail. That's the relationship we have in creation. So, God is the king.
- 36:59We humans are the top servants. As a Catholic, I have no problem saying that humans are more
- 37:05important than animals. Okay. That's just the way it is. And the lower servant are the animals.
- 37:11Now, notice we are in debt to God in the sense that God created us. And secondly, we have sinned
- 37:20and we're offending God. God can rightly punish us for our offenses. But we ask God to show us
- 37:26mercy. God is merciful and God shows us mercy. So, yeah, we are happy. Then we turn around and now
- 37:34we have these lower servants, dogs, cats, pigs, and cows. Now, they have not borrowed anything
- 37:41from us, but for the sake of the argument, let's imagine that, you know, they belong to us. They
- 37:47owe us something just because they are there. But even then, we have to show them mercy.
- 37:55I mean, that's what the story is about. Because if we do not show them mercy, those who are lower to
- 38:01us, that God, who is higher than us, will not show us mercy as well. Because Jesus says explicitly
- 38:08elsewhere, a blessed of the merciful, for they shall be shown mercy. All humans will be in need
- 38:17of mercy when the time of judgment comes, because none of us is perfect and we have all sinned.
- 38:23And so, because we want to be shown mercy by God, we have to be merciful, because that's what Jesus
- 38:31said, blessed are the merciful, for they shall be shown mercy. And so, anybody or anything
- 38:41that can be shown mercy, that can receive mercy, should be shown mercy. And that's why I say
- 38:46mercy and compassion and kindness is shown to each creature based on its ability to receive.
- 38:53As far as we know, like sometimes people say, oh, you know, trees are alive. What if they have
- 38:59brains that we don't know about? Well, we may not know about it. I don't know. As far as we know
- 39:05right now, like it's clear that a dog or a cow can receive mercy, because it can be hurt in some way,
- 39:13we immediately know if I kick a dog, it starts yelping and I know that I have been unkind to
- 39:18the dog with immediate feedback, right? We know from scientific studies that there's a central
- 39:24nervous system that when a dog is in distress, it lights up certain parts of its brain. So,
- 39:30it is receiving the unkindness, but it also can receive kindness. Anybody who has been near a dog
- 39:38knows the difference between petting a dog and kicking a dog. And so, it's a very important
- 39:43kicking a dog and how the dog responds. So, if a dog can receive mercy, we should show mercy.
- 39:50A very simple way of showing mercy is to not kill them, right? With a tree on the other hand,
- 39:58like, well, human substance is important, so I'm not going to starve to death. I have to eat
- 40:02something. And so, if I eat something from a tree or if I cut grass and, you know, eat grain,
- 40:10yeah, maybe there is some distress in the tree, if you may, in the plant, but it's not the same
- 40:15level as a dog. You know, if I walk over grass, I don't apologize to the grass, right? We have this
- 40:24ingrained within us that if I stamp on my cat's tail, I will say sorry to the cat. Most of us
- 40:31will do that because the cat will be angry and then we will feel bad for hurting the cat. We don't
- 40:38have that same sense of feeling when we walk across the grass or a tree branch breaks, right? So,
- 40:45from both an emotional response and from a scientific standpoint, a tree or a grass doesn't
- 40:52have the same level or same capacity to receive mercy, right? It doesn't mean I should do whatever
- 41:00I want with it. Like, I shouldn't just go around cutting trees because that would be bad for the
- 41:06environment and that would be bad for other animals and that would just be a misuse of what
- 41:10God has given us, right? We use things that will enhance our life but also realize that this is
- 41:18part of God's creation. But showing mercy to a tree or a rock is quite different from showing
- 41:24mercy to a dog or a cow. I completely agree with that. There are many environmentalists talking
- 41:31about such species of vegetation and how it's important to keep them, protect them. And then
- 41:42you think, but why are they so important? Is it just because they are exceptional, unique?
- 41:51In what way are they helping, supporting, sustaining sentient beings, which is, in my book,
- 42:00the most important factor in determining what subspecies of bush should be protected.
- 42:08Yeah, in the Bible, for instance, they said, God does tell us to eat seeds, but elsewhere,
- 42:19I forget off the top of my head, I think in the book of Exodus, God talks about giving the Sabbath
- 42:26rest to animals. The Sabbath, the seventh day is an important aspect of Jewish tradition.
- 42:33And God talks about giving rest to the animals. Now, you could be cynical and say, well, that's
- 42:39just good practice because if the animals rest, it will be able to work better, you know, for
- 42:44utility arguments. But the fact that God says that the animals deserve rest, shows that the animals
- 42:52can receive rest. God doesn't say that a tree should receive rest in the same way.
- 42:59And so I think there is a sense that sometimes we just have this idea, it's all or nothing.
- 43:05Oh, you know, plants also have feelings, so we should just do whatever we want. Oh, no,
- 43:10there's a gradient here, right? I mean, cows and pigs or dogs receive, as far as we know,
- 43:17and can experience, receive love and mercy differently from insects and then from plants
- 43:24or grass and then rocks, right? There's a gradient. And the highest kindness would be
- 43:30to reduce the amount of harm that we cause to creatures that can experience harm. So we
- 43:36should go with plants to eat.
- 43:41For the remaining time, I had, I noted two questions I heard. One from a state of
- 43:50that I think an evangelist makes. He says, animals do not have spiritual rights. And,
- 43:59you know, that felt like a stunning thing to say. And then the second one is a question
- 44:08they keep repeating, which is, is there a Christian or spiritual way, I think, of killing
- 44:15an animal or, yeah, killing an animal. And I wanted to just, you know, share those with
- 44:24you and have you comment on them.
- 44:27Yeah, the idea that animals don't have a spiritual life. Yeah, that is a, that is a,
- 44:35an important question. You know, do, do dogs go to heaven? You know, and Pope Francis
- 44:39created a bit of stir once by saying that the dogs will be in heaven. And so then we have to ask,
- 44:44what does it mean? And so on. It's a great question. So there are two ways of looking
- 44:49at this. One is that in the Catholic tradition, St. Thomas Aquinas, the most famous philosopher
- 44:56of our tradition, would say that if we harm animals, like, you know, by being a monster,
- 45:05we are harming ourselves. You know, it stains the soul. Okay. Now this may seem a little
- 45:11self-serving here that, oh, I should be kind to animals just because I want to keep my
- 45:15soul safe. It's a good, it's a good starting point. Like, I don't want to harm animals
- 45:21because my soul gets harmed. So, hey, I'll just keep away. So good starting point. So
- 45:27that would be a pretty standard way of seeing it. And then the third one is, is there a
- 45:32standard way of seeing it? So that would be a pretty standard way of seeing it. Now,
- 45:38whether animals go to heaven or not, you know, it's not, it's never said that animals don't
- 45:44go to heaven. So then we have to ask, what is heaven? And, you know, in our tradition,
- 45:53we are all about relationships. So God is Trinity, God the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
- 45:59So the relationship within God is important. Our faith is always about relationship with
- 46:07God. In the Bible, it's about covenant, which is again, relationship. Love your neighbor
- 46:13is about relationships. Everything is about relationships. And so the idea is that, for
- 46:21me, is what kind of relationships we have here on earth, and do these relationships
- 46:27in heaven. You know, like, we can start with a human level and say, you know, I love my
- 46:33parents very much. I mean, I have my brothers, my friends. Yeah, I will be with heaven in
- 46:39heaven with God. But it seems for me a little incomplete to say that, that even though my
- 46:46mom will be in heaven, I will have no relationship with her. For me, it seems unsatisfying. Yes,
- 46:52I'll be with God. But I don't want these relationships, this beautiful existence that
- 46:59I have here on earth, to just not matter. You know, like the people I connect with,
- 47:05the people who I truly care. So same thing you could think about with pets. A lot of
- 47:11people grieve when their pets die, you know. Having pets in this world is part of what
- 47:18made them human. The fact that they were able to love and receive love from another creature
- 47:25was part of their humanity. And so when we are in heaven, the idea is that it is not a break
- 47:31from this to the next. It's not like a test that once you go on the other side, nothing else from
- 47:36the previous life matters. It is a continuity. The idea that we will be resurrected, body and soul,
- 47:43is a sense of continuity. That this world is going to continue with the next and not going to be a
- 47:49break. And so I believe that animals can be in heaven for the same reason, because of relationships.
- 47:57Now a dog or a cat or a cow will suddenly not become like human in heaven. They will still be
- 48:04a dog or a cat or a cow, but in a glorified sense. So whatever relationship I had with
- 48:11animals here will continue in heaven and those animals will have to be present there for the
- 48:17relationship to continue. Otherwise it will be kind of awkward, like, oh I have a relationship
- 48:20with a cat, but there are no cats in heaven. So I wouldn't say like animals that go to heaven,
- 48:26but we can think of it in terms of relationships and how would they continue in heaven.
- 48:33So there is no part of our tradition that explicitly says animals don't go to heaven.
- 48:40It's just silent on the topic. And so we can try and think about what does heaven mean
- 48:45and what would a loving God want in the future. What is the second point?
- 48:53So that's the recurring question of is there a spiritual way to kill animals?
- 49:01Yes, I would say it really comes down to necessity, right? I've already said this,
- 49:08if a human being is starving for whatever reason, you are on a desert island and there's nothing
- 49:15else to eat, or you're really hungry and the only food that is offered to you, you are homeless,
- 49:21you are poor and you don't have your own capacity of purchasing food and somebody offers you meat
- 49:27to eat, like you have no other option. So if you have no other option and your life is important,
- 49:38it is at stake, then a Christian way of killing would be to recognize the necessity,
- 49:45to recognize that this is an imperfect world that occasionally does need violence.
- 49:54And to truly honor the life of the animal in some way and almost kind of apologize for saying,
- 50:01killing the animal to say, I'm sorry, we are in this situation. This is an imperfect situation,
- 50:06but I believe that God would want me to be alive by consuming your flesh
- 50:13and kind of ask for forgiveness. And I'm not making a sentimental call here, but a real sense that
- 50:20this is a necessity in an imperfect world and to recognize that. Not the idea the way we have it
- 50:30today where we don't even know the animals we've killed. The animals are just like leading horrible
- 50:36lives. We don't have to eat them. I mean, it's so removed from any sense of understanding that they
- 50:45are fellow creatures of God's creation. And so I think, yeah, I think there's a Christian way of
- 50:51killing, which would be strongly based on necessity and almost asking for forgiveness and saying that
- 51:01this is an imperfect world and here we are. And to kind of use that as a way of recognizing the
- 51:08value and the dignity of the animal that you are going to slaughter.
- 51:12Beautiful. We have the answer in a few minutes only. We did not need an hour long documentary.
- 51:18Thank you so much, Daniel, for having stopped by and answered my questions and gave your review
- 51:24of Christ Piercy. Thank you so much.
- 51:28You're very welcome. And thanks for your work.
- 51:30Thank you everyone for listening. I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the
- 51:36vegans you know. Let's encourage more people to take action. Again, thank you so much for caring
- 51:43and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.