Latest / Politics with Paul / A New Way to Nominate Congressional Candidates? w/ Tom Joseph | Politics with Paul #89
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08It's another guest episode, and for such episodes, add a disclaimer that I do not take a
- 0:13stance for or against any guests' political views, but this is not a partisan or
- 0:17ideological discussion anyway.
- 0:19And unfortunately, many congressional elections have become quite predictable.
- 0:24Republicans and Democrats each have a significant number of districts that are all
- 0:28but guaranteed to be won by their respective party.
- 0:31And more than that, primary elections are often heavily geared towards the most well funded and
- 0:36most extreme candidates.
- 0:38And it's led to many voters of different partisan persuasions to feel like the
- 0:43nominating process isn't fair or representative.
- 0:46But what if it could become fairer or more representative?
- 0:51What if it could become more localized and grassroots oriented?
- 0:56Enter today's guest, Tom Joseph, founder and treasurer of America's Main Street Party.
- 1:02AMSP proposes a people's primary, which seeks to create a moneyless nominating system that
- 1:08relies on local committees rather than party insiders or big donors.
- 1:13Tom is also the founder and owner of BookMinders, a bookkeeping bookkeeping service
- 1:18specializing in complex accounting applications, as well as the producer of
- 1:22Wilson's Fountain, an LLC, which is also engaged in reforming the nominating process for
- 1:28congress.
- 1:29So let's talk to Tom and get more insight on the AMSP and discuss his vision for revamping
- 1:35the congressional nominating system.
- 1:37Please welcome Tom Joseph to the show.
- 1:39Tom, thanks for coming on.
- 1:40How are you?
- 1:42Thanks for having me on.
- 1:43Great intro.
- 1:44Really appreciate it.
- 1:45Yeah.
- 1:45No.
- 1:45Absolutely.
- 1:46I when you when you when you reached out about this topic, I was very intrigued because I
- 1:50hadn't really gotten to dive as much into nominating system.
- 1:55So really interested to see where this discussion goes.
- 1:58But before we get to America's main street party, like to always get back to the genesis
- 2:03of why people do what they do on my show.
- 2:06So what ultimately got you interested in trying to reform nominating processes in Congress in
- 2:12the first place?
- 2:13Well, going way back, it was really following Russ Perrault.
- 2:17When I started my company, I lost my job and I spent the summer watching the conventions and
- 2:22really following that, that process.
- 2:24And I was really torn on who to vote for.
- 2:27But I always thought, you know, Ross was really pointing out how messed up congress was and
- 2:32that we really needed to fix congress.
- 2:34And my takeaway is that Ross should have probably never run for president.
- 2:38He should just focused on launching a party that would change Congress.
- 2:42And that was the seed of my thought.
- 2:45I stood on this for literally three decades, this idea of trying to figure out how to reform
- 2:51Congress.
- 2:52Really, the thing that really upset me was the idea of these uncompetitive districts and
- 2:56gerrymandering and that people got reelected without competing, you know, that it seemed
- 3:02like this really low bar for a really high office.
- 3:05And, that bugged me that uncompetitive districts existed at all.
- 3:11You know, business would go in there and say, the product's bad.
- 3:14How do you fix it?
- 3:14And I that's the genesis of really me trying to wrap my thought around it, going from
- 3:21engineering to accounting to now this.
- 3:23You know?
- 3:24Yeah.
- 3:24The competitive competitiveness of elections is a big thing for me, and and it's really that's
- 3:30not a you know, I put that disclaimer at the top, but it's really not a political opinion
- 3:34one way or another.
- 3:35It's we have a very serious issue with competitiveness, and it's something that I
- 3:39think people of different political persuasions can agree on.
- 3:43That's something I've tried to work towards, figuring out myself actually led me to write a
- 3:49book, my first book about why independence struggle so much in elections and how they
- 3:55could potentially become more competitive, not arguing that I want more independence.
- 3:59I just want more competition.
- 4:01So I I can definitely appreciate that.
- 4:03So now let's go ahead and get to amsp the America's main street party.
- 4:07So how did you establish a s or a m s p a m s p, excuse me.
- 4:13And why did you feel it was necessary to create this initiative instead of, for example, get
- 4:18involved in other efforts towards reforming nominating systems?
- 4:21And, also, is AMSP an actual third party, or is it just the name of the movement?
- 4:26No.
- 4:27It is an actual five twenty seven political committee.
- 4:29It's what you need to do.
- 4:31It's the first step of becoming a national party.
- 4:35You know, people confuse this as what you need to do to get on the ballot to be president.
- 4:40That's a very different thing.
- 4:41You know, we are not at all interested in the presidency.
- 4:44This is about the Congress and specifically the US House.
- 4:48I'm looking at this like not a political scientist, but like a business person.
- 4:52And these are markets.
- 4:53And how do you penetrate the markets given the existing laws?
- 4:57Whereas a political scientist is saying, how do we change the laws to make the system better?
- 5:02And we've got to negotiate with lawmakers so that we can only ask for so much because
- 5:06they're only going to give so much.
- 5:08So if you look at all the election reform efforts, even if they all pass, you get rid of
- 5:12Citizens United, you get ranked choice voting, you get open primaries.
- 5:15Our system still sucks.
- 5:17We've taken a really bad system, made a little bit less worse.
- 5:22Still, the incumbents are hugely advantaged.
- 5:24So I wanted to be like, how do you rethink this completely?
- 5:27And I wanted to come up with a way to break the system without changing it.
- 5:32And I stumbled upon it.
- 5:34I like that.
- 5:36You know, you didn't say in these specific words, but you made that distinction between
- 5:40the practical and the philosophical because sometimes people get so wrapped up in the, I
- 5:46wanna change everything now, but you can't.
- 5:49Sometimes you have to work with what you've got right now and then work towards that point.
- 5:53And Especially when you start something and you're 65 years old.
- 5:57You know?
- 5:57If I was gonna have to drive past the law, I'd be dead by the time that happened.
- 6:01So, you know, I'm there like, hey.
- 6:02I only have so much time.
- 6:04I know I don't wanna run for office, and I know changing a law is impossible.
- 6:07So I started to come up with this idea of using a party to create a contest.
- 6:12It was a joke, actually.
- 6:13At first, I said, I'm just going to form an entity and do something.
- 6:17I didn't know what I was going to do, and I was frustrated.
- 6:19The original concept was more like the forward party, just kind of like better, more ethics.
- 6:25I don't know.
- 6:26That doesn't really work.
- 6:27Then one day I made a joke.
- 6:28Was like, we do a better job picking the next American Idol than we do the next
- 6:32representative of Congress.
- 6:34And it made me think, that's a moneyless system.
- 6:36You can't buy that contest.
- 6:39You can't, you know, they've created a portal.
- 6:42They made mobile voting work.
- 6:44They, you know, they figured it out.
- 6:46Now, we're not going to let everybody vote multiple times.
- 6:49But, know, you can now take technology that operates for banking and all these things that
- 6:54guarantee our security.
- 6:55Almost everybody has a FA and face identification in the mobile device.
- 6:59So if you go to purely mobile, not an election system, nominating system, we can do some
- 7:05better than what we have.
- 7:05And you can throw stones at it, but what we have is really bad.
- 7:08So give us a shot.
- 7:10It's a sandbox.
- 7:11You know, we can play with it.
- 7:12We're using a political party, not as an ideological entity, but as a tech company.
- 7:17That's really masquerading inside this entity as a political and it has, and what's really
- 7:22neat about it is that we can't sell the IT.
- 7:25We can't sell the information.
- 7:26Certain information has to be public.
- 7:28So we're by being a political community, we have to follow the laws.
- 7:32And the other thing that was interesting is that the loophole I discovered is that if the
- 7:37contestants don't spend money, the party can do whatever it wants.
- 7:41So it opens the door for us to do whatever we want, create whatever contest we want, because
- 7:45we don't fall under the purview of the FTC.
- 7:48This is what parties do in back rooms with their super donors.
- 7:52They just don't use a computer to do it.
- 7:53They use checks.
- 7:54You know, we're going to use technology to make our backroom the entire district, and they're
- 7:59all going to weigh in over five rounds and whittle the field down to their top nominee.
- 8:04And so at that point, who do you vote for?
- 8:06The one that the people chose or the one that the rich people from outside the district
- 8:10chose?
- 8:11I mean, I think if we get this in place, it's gonna win consistently.
- 8:15Well, I think that's a good segue into this next part because I wanna get more into the
- 8:19process of AMSP.
- 8:21So people just get a more concrete sense of what you guys are going for.
- 8:26They hear, oh, this is another third party, but this is a more unique way of going about
- 8:31things.
- 8:31So what is the basic step by step process of how a m s AMSP works and how they how exactly
- 8:37does it reform how we nominate candidates for congress?
- 8:41I wanna take you one step back.
- 8:43As you mentioned, Wilson's Fountain.
- 8:45Wilson's Fountain is really the big picture.
- 8:47It is defining how we use a national party, a super PAC, local committees, and candidate
- 8:53committees in a very different way.
- 8:55So to look at this as just a party is not a big enough view.
- 8:58What I did is say that, hey, how do we use the entire system differently?
- 9:03The super PAC becomes a marketing department and the prize money for the contest winner.
- 9:08The national party is this tech company.
- 9:10The local committees are like the Olympic trials committee that's gonna officiate the
- 9:14contest in the red and blue districts.
- 9:17And then the candidate committees, we can now put rules around them and say, you know what?
- 9:20When you win the contest, your treasure is gonna be one of our guys.
- 9:24And when the when the general election's over, we're gonna empty the account, and you're not
- 9:28gonna have war chests.
- 9:29So in exchange for getting promoted and getting the nomination, getting the super PAC backing,
- 9:34the candidate has to agree that they're not gonna accumulate war chest from election cycle
- 9:39to election cycle.
- 9:41Now this is a system of accountability because now they have to go back through the system and
- 9:46win it.
- 9:46And so if they aren't representing, they're not gonna win.
- 9:49Now unaffiliated from party whips.
- 9:52Okay.
- 9:52Interesting.
- 9:53It's a complete election reform without changing the law.
- 9:57Hey.
- 9:57That that that hey.
- 9:58Sometimes that's the way you need to go about it because sometimes it's too difficult to
- 10:01change the law because you gotta change laws.
- 10:03You gotta get people behind it.
- 10:05And I don't think the two major parties are necessarily interested in changing these laws
- 10:11specifically.
- 10:12We have a handful of different ways that we nominate candidates for congress.
- 10:15It might be a closed primary, open primary, semi closed, top two, the unique way that
- 10:21Louisiana does it, whatever the case may be.
- 10:24So how does AMSP choose which districts to get involved in?
- 10:28Does the calculus change for AMSP based on the type of primary it's operating in, or is it
- 10:34more about the competitiveness or lack thereof of the district?
- 10:38Well, we're not plan is not to run-in their primary.
- 10:42We run our own primary and go right to the general election.
- 10:46But there are rules in each state in terms of what it takes to get on the general election
- 10:51ballot before you're a national party.
- 10:53So at this stage, once we get our contest winner, we then have to, either get signatures,
- 10:59pay a fee.
- 11:00Most states, the bar to get on the ballot is low.
- 11:03It's like 500, 1,000, or 2% of the previous general election.
- 11:08It's not a big number, especially if we think we've marketed this, you know, correctly.
- 11:13There are certain states like Georgia or that either require so much money, so many
- 11:19signatures, or, so much time that I just roll them out.
- 11:23But we're not trying to get all of them.
- 11:25The the plan is to do, like, 10 blue, 10 red, 20 blue, 20 red.
- 11:29Enough that if you whittle through the you know, that you're not gonna win all of them,
- 11:32you still win enough races that neither party is a majority.
- 11:36I think people would get behind the idea that they're not being a majority party and that's
- 11:41moving away from majority party rule to have forced coalitions to pass legislation and not
- 11:47be in this really divisive, situation.
- 11:49It'd still be conservative and liberal, but you'd have a moneyless two moneyless caucuses,
- 11:54one pink, one baby blue, and then you'd have the two parties.
- 11:57Gotcha.
- 11:58I guess more when I was thinking of with the primaries is more like maybe more so the top
- 12:03two.
- 12:04Obviously, this you're not running in any other party's particular primary, but if there was,
- 12:09you know, top two or top four, I wasn't sure if anything about the strategy.
- 12:15Oh, you mean as far as the general election goes?
- 12:17Yeah.
- 12:18I I didn't know if there was a any particular change in the tweak in the strategy, but it is
- 12:24it is much more about the competitiveness of the districts then.
- 12:27And, Paul, it's really about the numbers.
- 12:29So we're we're looking at a district that is not naturally uncompetitive districts where
- 12:33nobody you know, it's 90% blue or 90 some percent red.
- 12:38It's a it's a gerrymandered district is typically the winner has two thirds to 80% of
- 12:44the vote.
- 12:44And in a district like that, the plan is that even if it let's say, a heavily blue district,
- 12:49it got split, that the conservative would still not be able to win if there's two strong blue
- 12:55candidates splitting the vote and vice versa.
- 12:58So that would be the number.
- 12:59It's over if you're over two thirds, you can split it and the opposition party still likely
- 13:04can't compete.
- 13:05So we want to go into districts where the opposition party has a lot of votes, but they
- 13:10know they can't win.
- 13:11So they're more likely to push for a, in a red district, a pink non Republican, and a blue
- 13:17district, a baby blue non Democrat, because that's how much the parties hate each other.
- 13:23So you're kind of, like, leveraging to say that that, hey.
- 13:25First, we're gonna attract, disaffected Democrats and Republicans to, you know,
- 13:30participate in this, and we're gonna attract people in the opposition party and show that
- 13:34through this process, you can elevate, you know, center left and center right candidates
- 13:40that can win in the general election.
- 13:42Gotcha.
- 13:43And and the other point that you had was, you know, you're talking about how people get on
- 13:47the ballot, and that's that's one of the big things I talked about in in my book too, and
- 13:50I've talked about it other times on this podcast is, you know, yes, there's the either
- 13:56you pay to get on the ballot or you get a certain number of petition signatures, but in a
- 14:00lot of places, independents don't even have the chance to or third parties, no parties,
- 14:06whichever whatever your definition of independent is.
- 14:08But they, a lot of times, have to get more petition signatures a lot more, and they don't
- 14:13even have the option to pay the filing fees.
- 14:15It can make things a lot more difficult for a lot of these independent candidates, but I
- 14:20would be interested to see if having much
- 14:22more on all 50 states for ballot pedia.
- 14:25We have a chronologically organized.
- 14:27And we technically, if we found a super PAC person this year, we're not completely ruling
- 14:32out this.
- 14:32I don't want to do a bad effort.
- 14:35I'd rather wait and actually, I'm a project manager business.
- 14:39You know, I don't want to do some flailing plan.
- 14:42Know, if you're running, trying to win an election, whether you're ready financially, or
- 14:46you you know, we don't need to do that.
- 14:49We can just wait.
- 14:50And our goal is to just get to the next step of the business plan.
- 14:53And if that takes two months, two years, whatever, we're just going to keep marching
- 14:57down the path to eventually market this.
- 15:01Gotcha.
- 15:01And shout outs about PD, former employer of mine.
- 15:04But now one particular question I really wanted to get your take on.
- 15:09Obviously, I wanted to get your takes on all of these, but this is something that I've done
- 15:13several episodes about and something that's particularly important to me is a common
- 15:20problem that we have with politics is voter apathy.
- 15:23You see in a lot of primary elections as well with very low rates of voter turnout, whether
- 15:27people can't vote in the primaries because it it's a closed primary and they're an
- 15:31independent or they just are like, I'll just let all the other people who are more in tune
- 15:36with these candidates just pick the candidates, whatever the case may be.
- 15:39So the lack of of voter turnouts for various reasons, but how does this plan for America's
- 15:45main street party getting all the ballot?
- 15:47How do you how does that address that?
- 15:48How will people be more incentivized to participate in the process of filtering,
- 15:54sorting, and reviewing the field of potential nominee?
- 15:58Well, the apathy is that the why engage?
- 16:03I mean, it is so our primary system is so bad, so uncompetitive.
- 16:07I mean, it's terrible advertising.
- 16:10And, you know, people are so sick of the way politics work today.
- 16:14And so to me, that they create a compelling event.
- 16:18I mean, think about the Olympics.
- 16:20People watch curling and, you know, there's really nothing magical about curling, but then
- 16:26NBC makes it compelling, you know, and I think this is really about producing the contest
- 16:32that's compelling.
- 16:33And so what we're doing is we're saying, hey, the local committee will identify seven issues
- 16:38that are coming before Congress in the next cycle.
- 16:41To get on through into the contest, you gotta take positions on that.
- 16:45So imagine you got 75, a 100 candidates.
- 16:48It's free.
- 16:49You're gonna get a lot of people.
- 16:50There's gonna be a bar.
- 16:51You're gonna have to get a 100 people of your friends to endorse you to get into the contest.
- 16:55So you fill out this stuff.
- 16:57You answer these questions.
- 16:59The local committee, like an HR department kind of screens, you know, make sure that you
- 17:04actually did serve in that branch of the military.
- 17:06And, then you're out in the field.
- 17:08And at this point, as a constituent, you can download the app, play this like Wordle, you
- 17:13know, and say, Hey, these four issues are important to me.
- 17:15There's 30 people that match me.
- 17:17I'm going to endorse them.
- 17:18You could do it with one button.
- 17:19It's called approval voting where you're going to prove, send forth all the people you
- 17:23approve.
- 17:24And so we'll use approval voting for the first three rounds.
- 17:28So it's gonna go from the field to a top 20 to a top 10 to a top four.
- 17:32And then at this point, we're gonna introduce new content in, a virtual town hall format
- 17:38where the local committee will have more questions, and the final four will be able to,
- 17:44you know, post additional video content responding to that so that constituents have
- 17:48more to weigh in on.
- 17:50And at this point, you know, we have the ability to change.
- 17:53We can do ranked choice voting to advance the top two or pick two, and then have a final
- 17:58debate between the top two in another round.
- 18:00But I would see, like in a reality contest, you have more people voting as it goes through.
- 18:05In an election system, if you ask people to go back out for another to leave, the turnout goes
- 18:10down.
- 18:11This means bowling is a hassle.
- 18:13If we make this that it's like, you know, playing your daily Wordle, I think people will
- 18:19do it.
- 18:20That's an interesting way to put it.
- 18:21And I've had several guests on here with various different apps for for the what they're
- 18:27trying to do, and I think that is, you know, one of probably the most accessible way for
- 18:31people to, you know, get involved in whatever the reform effort is at hand.
- 18:36So I I can I can definitely understand that?
- 18:38And then that's another thing too is this, you know, not just the ballot information gap, but
- 18:45this you know, for a lot of people, they think voting is just simple.
- 18:48You just go to a polling place.
- 18:51You just catch your vote, and you're on your way.
- 18:52But a lot of people find it much more difficult.
- 18:55They might have, they might not know all the specific rules for when they can register the
- 18:59vote, or they they have trouble getting to a place where they can go and get themselves
- 19:04registered because they're out in the boonies or or some other place that makes it hard for
- 19:10them to register or there's a whole bunch of other things that could potentially make things
- 19:15more difficult for them.
- 19:16And sometimes it's hard for people to appreciate that getting registered to vote and
- 19:21going to vote are not as easy easy as some people think.
- 19:25Now they're much easier than they were obviously, like, forty, fifty years ago.
- 19:29But at the same time, a lot of this these reform efforts, yours is is just one example
- 19:36is, you know, you have to make things as accessible as possible for people to get
- 19:41involved.
- 19:41So I can appreciate, you know, the the breakdown that you had there.
- 19:46But no matter what reforms you propose, no matter what it is that you're you're arguing
- 19:51for, you're trying to change, there's always gonna be somebody that's ready to push back
- 19:55against your idea for whatever reason.
- 19:57Maybe it's for a maybe it's an honest reason.
- 20:01Maybe it's dishonest because they just don't like what you have to say, and they're trying
- 20:04to tank your proposal.
- 20:06But I wanted to get your take on a few potential pushbacks whether or not you've heard
- 20:11these criticisms before.
- 20:12And it's always good to always, you know Fire away.
- 20:15Be, yeah, be ready for whatever somebody is is gonna try to throw back at you.
- 20:19So what would you say to somebody who just looks at this and says, nah.
- 20:23This is impractical.
- 20:24The power of the parties and their money, and this is just too strong to overcome.
- 20:27What do you say to people who are still not convinced that this is doable?
- 20:31Well, there's a lot.
- 20:32I mean, we're really looking to find early adopters.
- 20:35And our first step is to really instead of try this in election is to actually get the app to
- 20:40simulate the contest.
- 20:41So it's like, hey.
- 20:43Why don't you try it out?
- 20:44We don't have to wait for November or May.
- 20:46You know, you can just play with it and we're going to have the app.
- 20:50There'll be a field of a 100 candidates who have taken their positions.
- 20:53We're going to have two, two districts are Philadelphia 1 And 2 or PA 1 And 2.
- 20:59One's red, one's blue.
- 21:00And we're putting this simulation together.
- 21:02And so try it out.
- 21:04Okay.
- 21:04So so not not even the actual election.
- 21:07You're just making a or you're not actually necessarily getting involved in the the real
- 21:13election itself.
- 21:13It's more of just, like, the actual concept.
- 21:16Like, hey.
- 21:16If we were actually doing this, here's how you can vote kind of thing.
- 21:20Am I understanding that correctly?
- 21:21Right.
- 21:22Okay.
- 21:22Yeah.
- 21:22So don't don't knock it till you try it.
- 21:25Gotcha.
- 21:26And that, that, you know, that's, that's another thing too, is people try to, I find
- 21:31that really granular step by step process interesting because yes, it's, it's very, it
- 21:37can be very cumbersome and tedious to try to do every little step.
- 21:42And it's very easy to just try to jump to the end and try to, we need to just get this
- 21:47specific thing done now.
- 21:49It's now you, you have to have some buildup.
- 21:51And I think that's something that a lot of the independent movement has struggled with, and I
- 21:56talk about in the book is sometimes people just try to jump ahead and, like, we gotta get an
- 22:00independent president.
- 22:01Well, there's a million reasons why that's not gonna happen the very next election.
- 22:05You still have to build up.
- 22:07Look at your local level offices.
- 22:08Look at your state level offices.
- 22:10You see in a lot of state governments, for example.
- 22:12There's not a whole lot of them, but you definitely see a lot more third parties and no
- 22:16party people in states like Maine and Alaska and and several other states where that's a lot
- 22:23more viable.
- 22:24But in any case, just to bring that back to here, you know, that real step by step process,
- 22:29I can really understand that.
- 22:32Know, you'll be able to actually give the, build the data for that proof of concept to
- 22:37show, Hey, no, this thing can work.
- 22:39Then here's how.
- 22:40So on your website, another pushback that somebody might say.
- 22:44On your website, when it talks about your plan, it says, after the party nominee is chosen,
- 22:49immediate campaign will be funded by the super PAC.
- 22:51Now while people hear that, they might become a lot of times, they might become wary and start
- 22:57thinking, oh, super PAC.
- 22:58Oh, we're talking about big money.
- 22:59I don't know if I like this.
- 23:01They start thinking about the power of money in politics.
- 23:03So what would you say to these people?
- 23:05What misconceptions do you want to clear up when it comes to how these America's Main
- 23:10Street party campaigns are funded and run?
- 23:13This is really, you know, gets back to the Wilson's Fountain issue and and what how we're
- 23:18using a super PAC in a very different way.
- 23:20Yes.
- 23:20So and this is I had a really hard time myself wrapping my head around this, is that I think,
- 23:27you know, up until I came up with this idea, super PACs are evil.
- 23:30You know, they're backing either individuals or candidates or positions.
- 23:34And there's a lot of dark money.
- 23:36But what if we created a super PAC that was open and transparent and backed the people's
- 23:41choice?
- 23:42We've never had a super PAC that's done common good.
- 23:45I mean, and it would do it equally red and blue.
- 23:48So if the super PAC, say it raises $100,000,000 it's gonna say that, hey, we're gonna and
- 23:53there's we run 10 red and 10 blue winners.
- 23:56They're saying we're gonna apply that money across those 20 districts equally and try to
- 24:01win and try to create at the same time these pink and baby blue caucuses.
- 24:06And from that standpoint, this is what the election attorney, when I presented to him,
- 24:10he's like, wow.
- 24:12You know, he realized that I was kind of recreating the public election system within
- 24:16this little model that I've done.
- 24:17And now this would be like the government saying, you know what?
- 24:20We're going to apply this to make sure that the public can know equally about these candidates
- 24:24that you've chosen.
- 24:25And it's a completely common good use of the super PAC.
- 24:30So what I'm trying to do is find my Ross Perot.
- 24:32I'm not Ross Perot wealthy.
- 24:34I did okay to do this, but I need to find like a Marquette or somebody like that that would
- 24:39say, you know what?
- 24:39This is how I, you know, attach my I'm not putting my foot on the r's or the d's.
- 24:46I'm putting my foot on the public, and I'm giving them this money to elevate their restore
- 24:53their voice, really, and get their people in congress, not the party.
- 24:57Go on that small donor approach that you occasionally see big, you know, candidates go
- 25:03for.
- 25:04And and, yeah, campaigns have more small donor donations than than people think.
- 25:10But, obviously, yes, there's still just a significant amount of money through these super
- 25:15packs.
- 25:15And, you know, for for for people at home, you know, super packs, the main the main thing
- 25:20about them is, yes, they can spend unlimited amounts of money, but they can't coordinate
- 25:25with the campaign.
- 25:26If you do, you're gonna go to jail, but you can spend unlimited amounts of money as long as
- 25:31you're not coordinating with the campaign.
- 25:32So that's a really interesting way to do that.
- 25:35Go ahead.
- 25:35We have the interns.
- 25:37I had one of these law interns research that there's only been one case and it wasn't favor
- 25:42the super PACs.
- 25:43It's like this coordination, it's really yes, I cannot be CEO of the party and you can't do
- 25:52that.
- 25:52There's timing issues, but we can lay out an overall game plan.
- 25:56Then once the election comes, as long as we're not coordinating, it's fine.
- 26:00But they could run this marketing campaign, the general marketing command for all 20 or 40 of
- 26:05these folks, and then use the local committees to run the ground campaign and the, you know,
- 26:11the grassroots part of this.
- 26:12And through that, you've got like an advertising strategy and a way to do it.
- 26:17Tell you, this could be a really efficient way to turn the tables on the parties.
- 26:22Gotcha.
- 26:23Are are there any before we move on to the next Sure.
- 26:27Sort of subtopic, are there any other potential misunderstandings about the America's main
- 26:32street party system in particular that you often encounter, and how would you clear up
- 26:36those misconceptions?
- 26:38Well, then it's a party.
- 26:39I mean, it is a party.
- 26:41It's really kind of a tech it's an app.
- 26:43And, you know, I think people the the the misperception is that the perception when you
- 26:48hear America's Main Street Party, you think, oh, they're looking for candidates.
- 26:52No.
- 26:52We're looking for districts that are ripe for disruption, you know, and that we'll have a
- 26:57strategy that's 10 black 10 blue, 10 red.
- 27:01You know, we'll always do an equal number.
- 27:03So the the party itself will distribute these contests equally, so that we're not putting our
- 27:09foot on the scale to say, hey.
- 27:10We wanna push congress more red or more blue.
- 27:13It'll be up to the districts, you know, to figure out.
- 27:16But, you know, the first cycle, might do five and five, the next ten and ten, you know, and
- 27:20then maybe a couple senate.
- 27:22Gotcha.
- 27:23You know, this just occurred to me now.
- 27:25I don't think we quite touched on it at the beginning.
- 27:27What why choose Main Street Party for the name of this movement and this party?
- 27:33Well, every place has a Main Street.
- 27:35It could be a big one, small one, a conservative one, liberal one, but we all have
- 27:39to meet on Main Street and do business.
- 27:42And at the end of the day, this is all about jobs and paying the bills and having a nice,
- 27:48you know, way of living.
- 27:49And that's we're not it's not working these days, you know.
- 27:53And if you talk about that apathy, if you give people the toll to say, hey, we actually might
- 27:59be able to change the system for the better, and they can't stop us.
- 28:03You know, there's really operating within the existing system, just using it in a very
- 28:08different way.
- 28:09Gotcha.
- 28:10That makes sense.
- 28:11And I know a lot of this context has been or actually, before we get to outside of Congress,
- 28:16there is something I came across on your website.
- 28:19I haven't had a chance to really read it, but it says, how does free and equal candidate
- 28:23selection impact congress in two party, multiparty, and no party systems?
- 28:28So, obviously, America's a two party system, but you'll see other countries that are
- 28:33multiparty and no party.
- 28:34I've actually talked a little bit about this with my guest from last week.
- 28:39But could you give us a a sort of a basic breakdown of what this is about, this free and
- 28:46equal candidate selection and these different kinds of party systems and how it differs, how
- 28:51it's the same?
- 28:52Well, the thing about it, the parties exist for money to win elections.
- 28:57That's that's really their only purpose.
- 28:59Caucuses exist within Congress to bind people ideologically in subgroups.
- 29:05And there's more caucuses than there are parties.
- 29:07The caucuses get married by the money.
- 29:10So we break that marriage.
- 29:13There's no factions within the public.
- 29:16The factions exist within congress.
- 29:18And now we we would then identify with your poll.
- 29:21You're in this faction.
- 29:22I'll vote for you because I'm with that faction.
- 29:25So there's a political scientist called Lee Drutman who and Jesse, they put something in
- 29:30time.
- 29:31They're saying that, hey.
- 29:31If we eventually got to a multiparty system, what would the caucuses look like?
- 29:36And what what this paper that Cece Duncan wrote, she was a senior political science major
- 29:42at at Pennsylvania.
- 29:44She explored this idea that as we you know, we first had this system, then as soon as you have
- 29:50a system where neither party is a majority, things change.
- 29:52And she quickly kind of does a synopsis of how things change.
- 29:56Then once you get the bigger factions, you know, how Congress changed them, then at some
- 30:01point, the political parties could evaporate because Madison says we need the necessary
- 30:06factions.
- 30:08He didn't say necessary political parties, and the word political party existed in the time
- 30:12that he wrote that.
- 30:13The word that didn't exist?
- 30:15Caucus.
- 30:16So he may have actually been describing that the factions that were necessary were within
- 30:21the congress, not necessarily within the public.
- 30:24We've created this division ourselves.
- 30:26This is not a united state.
- 30:28You know?
- 30:29It it could be that the faction just need to be there.
- 30:32That's the moneyless.
- 30:33That's that's the evolution that we would see is that they would eventually the parties
- 30:37become powerless.
- 30:38You have a moneyless system, but you still need people to otherwise, you have chaos in
- 30:43congress.
- 30:43You need caucuses that would advance legislation, negotiate, and eventually pass it
- 30:49and go to president.
- 30:50That's an interesting point you make about how caucuses were, you know, not not a thing
- 30:55however many years ago.
- 30:57And but it the the whole factional discussion still applies to them.
- 31:03And, you know, you go back to James Madison and, you know, what he wrote about in
- 31:07Federalist paper number 10 and and just how Relevant what he said about factions is to
- 31:13today.
- 31:14And and that that's one of the things I always, you know, think about whenever I'm doing what
- 31:18I'm doing because, obviously, try to keep this stuff as nonpartisan, nonideological as
- 31:23possible.
- 31:24And, you know, obviously, there's a lot of factualism going around, which can sometimes,
- 31:29you know, make that challenging, but it's work that's worth doing.
- 31:33So now let me go ahead and move to away from congress because I always try to emphasize how
- 31:38it's not just federal government.
- 31:41And, you know, a lot of people focus on the federal government, not as not enough on the
- 31:45state and certainly not enough on the local.
- 31:47But at the same time, obviously, whenever you're involved in reform efforts, it's hard to
- 31:52get involved in all those levels of government.
- 31:54So this discussion has been entirely in the context of congress.
- 31:58Are there plans at some point to extend this to the state and local levels of government, or
- 32:04can AMSP be implemented in the same way at the state and local level that it is for congress?
- 32:10Well, in terms of the nominating tools that we're working on, we're looking at developing
- 32:14this in a way that's configurable and that can be used in different types of formats.
- 32:20The format that we have that works at the congressional level would work at a state
- 32:24legislative level, I believe, without any change.
- 32:27It's a smaller district.
- 32:29The concept though, is really about breaking gerrymandering.
- 32:32So putting this kind of contest into like a mayoral race, it may improve it, But we need
- 32:37improvement in other areas.
- 32:38People say, hey, why don't you try this out in a borough?
- 32:40I said, no.
- 32:41I mean, I get you want a smaller population, but we have to break gerrymandering.
- 32:46This is you know, if you guys want to do ranked choice voting in a mayor's race, great.
- 32:50Have at it.
- 32:51But to me, I'm working on a different problem.
- 32:54It involves representatives, legislative representatives, either the state or US level.
- 33:01The reason we pick The US is really just about raising money.
- 33:03I think if I just said, hey, I'm going to do this in Pennsylvania, fifty, forty nine other
- 33:07states to say, hey.
- 33:08Let us know when you come up with something.
- 33:10You know?
- 33:11So with this plan where we can go out, we might be in your state, we may not.
- 33:14But if the overall plan could make the whole congress better, then everybody has a reason to
- 33:18donate.
- 33:19Gotcha.
- 33:20That and and and, you know, that that that that makes sense.
- 33:23And, also, not not to mention the fact that a lot of local races, not all of them, but a lot
- 33:26of local races are nonpartisan.
- 33:29So there's the the gerrymandering isn't really at all that relevant to to that level either.
- 33:36So I'm that that I I I can understand, you know, that
- 33:41that makes away from swing ditch or if it gets ugly.
- 33:45Right.
- 33:46So if we go into a solidly conservative, solid liberal district, we know what the questions
- 33:51are.
- 33:51We know a conservative isn't going to win in a liberal district and vice versa.
- 33:55So it's really going to be about, hey, what shade of blue are you?
- 34:00And we think when you take money away from it, it's gonna move at center.
- 34:04And that's another thing too is, you know, I've know talking to different independent
- 34:08operatives before about how they determine where to run candidates in, and there is a
- 34:14little bit of debate amongst themselves as to whether to go into a competitive district that
- 34:18is both that has both viable republican and democratic candidates.
- 34:22And then or should you just take one that's heavily one way or another or if it, you know,
- 34:28goes too heavily?
- 34:29And that kinda goes back to what you were talking about there with, you know, picking
- 34:32decidedly red and blue districts, but not ones that are, like, so 90% plus that you can't
- 34:38possibly have somebody else, winning them either.
- 34:42So
- 34:42if I were running today as an independent, I'd want to run-in a swing district that's, you
- 34:46know, highly competitive because you could create the situation that people were sick with
- 34:50both parties.
- 34:51So if I was, you know, somebody that was just running on my own without, to me, the secret of
- 34:57what we're doing is that it elevates somebody that people, they come to a consensus on them
- 35:01over a four or five week period.
- 35:03So they feel like, just like when somebody wins the 100 yard dash, you really, the Olympics,
- 35:09you really know that is the fastest person in the world.
- 35:11You're buying their Wheaties.
- 35:12So that's, you know, it's really the same kind of thing.
- 35:15You're as they compete through, there's this brand identity that people will get with them
- 35:19as they survive each round.
- 35:21And it happens in American Idol as a survivor.
- 35:23It happens in all these things.
- 35:25The reason why somebody can't win in a primary, it's the first time people are hearing about
- 35:29it.
- 35:29Know, you know, people are just lazy.
- 35:32So if you create a vehicle where you can actually elevate them, they're going be the
- 35:36favor, you know, coming into that general election because people say, hey.
- 35:40They earned it.
- 35:42And not to mention that in the primary, a lot of times, it's who has that local level name
- 35:47recognition and people in the district backing them already.
- 35:52And America's Main Street Party is kind of emulating that already.
- 35:56And and and it kind of made me think when you're talking about how in order to get even
- 36:02considered for a nomination, you have to have, I believe you said, a 100 friends and family
- 36:06nominate them.
- 36:07So it's it's almost like there's a primary before the primary in some ways.
- 36:12It's I've tried to actually emulate the general election.
- 36:15Like, just to get on the general election ballot, you'd have to have a thousand
- 36:18signatures.
- 36:19So, you know, we had to have some bar.
- 36:21We you know, there's gonna be some work required to build out and submit certain
- 36:25information, all the information you'd have to submit for to run for the actual election.
- 36:29We wanna get that up front.
- 36:30So if you have tax returns, finance, whatever the disclosures are for congress, you're gonna
- 36:34have to submit those before you enter the contest.
- 36:36We only wanna find out later that you're not gonna do this or that you decide that you don't
- 36:40wanna give your financial disclosure.
- 36:42That is ridiculous that the candidates are setting their own rules.
- 36:45They work for us.
- 36:46Yeah.
- 36:46And I I get that you don't wanna necessarily have all of your private stuff put out there
- 36:53for people to know, but also people need to know if you've got any sort of baggage.
- 36:58If you win, it's required.
- 37:00You know?
- 37:00What are you gonna do?
- 37:01What's it?
- 37:01Get up to the time they're gonna put you in congress, say, oh, no.
- 37:05I can give you my financials, Scott.
- 37:07Of course not.
- 37:08So, you know, if you need to submit that information to take the job, then you submit it
- 37:12up front.
- 37:13Yeah.
- 37:13Right.
- 37:15Right.
- 37:16So, obviously, we touched on this a little bit, and, obviously, people hear about this whole
- 37:21concept and think, okay.
- 37:23Well, maybe it is practical to to do this.
- 37:25May and and let's say that they have been convinced of that.
- 37:28I like to always have at least one question specifically dedicated to actionable info for
- 37:34listeners.
- 37:34So maybe now people are sold on what you what's what you're trying to sell them on.
- 37:39Say, okay.
- 37:40You know what?
- 37:40America's main street party.
- 37:41I wanna know how I can get involved.
- 37:42So what are some practical takeaways you can give for how people can get involved in
- 37:48changing how this nominating process works and how they can get involved with AMSP?
- 37:54Well, you know, eventually, I want them to be able to download the app and play with it.
- 37:58I think we're probably still weeks away from, them being able play with it on the website.
- 38:03It can take a little bit longer to get it into the, app store.
- 38:08But engaging with it, telling other people about it, having hope.
- 38:11You know, I think right now when people look at it in 2024, I think $100,000,000 is spent on
- 38:16election reform efforts.
- 38:17The statewide efforts went zero for eight.
- 38:20You know, so it's hard to have a lot of hope when, you know, people are trying to make the
- 38:24election systems better.
- 38:25And the only thing that the parties agree on is stopping those initiatives.
- 38:31So going to the website, there's a page called A Brand New Way, and there's a one minute video
- 38:36that kind of explains the contest in a really quick way that you can really wrap your head
- 38:41around what we're trying to do.
- 38:43And it also explains that.
- 38:45And what I really like to do is get people to ultimately want donations.
- 38:49But even if you just go on our change.org, we have a change.org petition signing that,
- 38:53showing that there's traction, you know, because ultimately we want, a super donor to
- 38:58back us.
- 38:59And they'll really only do that if we can show that we are getting people to engage with the
- 39:03idea and like it.
- 39:04And right now, you know, the traction, we only started marketing this really in January.
- 39:09We've been on 30 podcasts in like two months.
- 39:12So there's at least podcasters like it.
- 39:15But there is, you know, I think people are saying, hey, this is interesting.
- 39:18I want my audience to hear about it.
- 39:20There's frustration with the system as it exists.
- 39:23So, yeah, I think educating yourself, becoming an early adopter, telling your friends, Like,
- 39:29share, follow.
- 39:30Gotcha.
- 39:31Well, I'll I'll I'll also give you a chance at the end of this to promote any specific links
- 39:36you wanna share, and then you can just say those specific ones, and then I'll put those in
- 39:39the show notes.
- 39:40But before we get to that, one more question about this actual topic on hand.
- 39:45Any final thoughts you'd like to leave us with when it comes to reforming candidate nominating
- 39:50systems, free and equal representation, or America's made street party, or anything else
- 39:55related to those concepts?
- 39:57Yeah.
- 39:57I mean, the last question on our FAQs that I put on there, could this work for a presidency?
- 40:02And imagine this at some point down the road where we've implemented a lot of districts and
- 40:06everybody has this cell phone on and say, hey, here's 30 people.
- 40:10Let's say they have the nation weigh in on them.
- 40:12Okay, now we got top 10, then top four, not this ridiculous system we have where what
- 40:19people in Iowa or New Hampshire set the course of who's going to be the president.
- 40:23We should all weigh in at the same time and whittle the field like we're gonna do in for
- 40:28congress.
- 40:29So that would be my long term goal is to, you know, come up with a way to come up with their
- 40:34original slate and to whittle a field for president down and then put that person up
- 40:39against this crappy candidates that these parties are coming up with.
- 40:44Yeah.
- 40:45That's an inter interesting point too, especially, you know, you talk about I think
- 40:48it's New Hampshire that they have it in law that they are supposed to be one of the first,
- 40:53if not the the first primary in the in the nation, like, it actually is in their laws.
- 40:59And it made me think of back at my undergraduate days.
- 41:05There was a book we read.
- 41:07It was I forget which edition it is, but I have it up here on my shelf somewhere.
- 41:11But it's called debating the presidency, and it's about all these various debates
- 41:16surrounding presidential power and how we select them.
- 41:18And one of the things was making regional primaries instead of state by state.
- 41:25So it might be, like, Northeast, for example, then Pacific or, you know, whatever the case
- 41:30may be.
- 41:30But I don't I don't as often hear the idea of just make everybody vote at the same time, and
- 41:36then there's gonna be several rounds.
- 41:38So that's an that's an interesting way to to go about it.
- 41:41But maybe that'll be a good topic for a podcast is is is thinking about ways that the
- 41:48presidential nominating or, yeah, the system could be changed.
- 41:51So thank you for that idea.
- 41:52I'll I'll have to
- 41:53The people's primary president.
- 41:55But, you know, I think we take this we're gonna knock this down like the constitution.
- 41:59Start with the house, then the senate, president.
- 42:01Well, there you go.
- 42:02Thank you so much for going so in-depth with America's Main Street party.
- 42:06And, obviously, like I said, I'll give you a chance to share some links that that you want
- 42:10people to see.
- 42:11But before we get to that, why don't you just go up a little bit of a lighter topic?
- 42:16So at the end of interviews and for those of you who are new to the show, whenever I
- 42:21interview somebody, I like to have a random question of the day.
- 42:24It's just something that's more fun and and light and gives a different oh, don't don't
- 42:30worry.
- 42:30It's not gonna be anything Okay.
- 42:31Crazy.
- 42:32But I try to give a different side to the guest as well because variety is the spice of life.
- 42:39So, Tom, today's random question of the day for you is, what is a weird pet peeve you have that
- 42:48you're not sure many or any other people have?
- 42:51Many or other people pet peeves.
- 42:53Well, you know, people stand when they should be moving, you know?
- 42:58So I don't know if it's a Pittsburgh thing, but people stand on our moving sidewalks here at
- 43:02the airport.
- 43:03That drives me nuts.
- 43:05Or people that get off a plane and they're right there at the end and they stand.
- 43:09I wanna blow up when that happens.
- 43:11That is my pet peeve.
- 43:12People that don't realize are blocking people getting by.
- 43:17And
- 43:18You no.
- 43:19I I I I'm sure a lot of people would would agree with you there.
- 43:22I I I don't go on moving sidewalks enough to to encounter that, but just thinking about it
- 43:28makes me mad.
- 43:30So I I can definitely agree with that.
- 43:33We have a new airport now, so those side I'm not gonna get air as irritated because they
- 43:37they phased out a lot of that.
- 43:39Gotcha.
- 43:41So for me, a pet peeve that I I don't know if and there's there's probably some people, but
- 43:47this is just a really weird one that's that started cropping up for me more and more.
- 43:52On these social media ads, these people are holding very, very tiny microphones.
- 43:58These, like, little ones with, like, three fingers and holding up like this.
- 44:02I can't tell you why.
- 44:03It just looks so stupid, and I hate it.
- 44:06It it it's one of these innocuous things that really does not matter, but it's just drives me
- 44:12crazy.
- 44:12Hold up an actual sized microphone.
- 44:15Stop this nonsense with this.
- 44:17Like, they're holding it with three fingers.
- 44:18Just looks goofy.
- 44:21You're right.
- 44:21This is a recent thing that I've noticed.
- 44:23Yeah.
- 44:25Good one.
- 44:26Okay.
- 44:26Good.
- 44:27So I I I I'm not I'm not totally crazy.
- 44:29Somebody else is with me on this.
- 44:31Yeah.
- 44:31I sometimes I've said this before, but sometimes I try to find things that really
- 44:35don't matter to get mad about so I don't, you know, blow up against things that actually do
- 44:40matter that are that that are, you know, more serious.
- 44:43So sometimes the catharsis is is a little yeah.
- 44:47Usually, the people holding those microphones look so good that you're willing to forgive
- 44:50that.
- 44:52I mean, I guess.
- 44:53I I don't I don't care.
- 44:54I don't care what they look like.
- 44:55They just I I I I'm I'm
- 44:56just models.
- 44:57I'm just, yeah, I'm just looking at the microphone, so I'm not even paying attention to
- 45:01what they look like.
- 45:02And they're selling something.
- 45:03Yeah.
- 45:03Yeah.
- 45:04Give me a regular sized microphone.
- 45:06Just stop it.
- 45:08But in any case, Tom, thank you very much for being on here for yeah.
- 45:12See, the random question wasn't bad.
- 45:14I was I don't I don't throw any, like, real curveballs or anything like that.
- 45:18It's just usually just something just Yeah.
- 45:21So but before we officially wrap up, what links do you wanna share specifically?
- 45:26Sure.
- 45:26To to, learn about America's Main Street Party, go to mainstreetparty.org.
- 45:31Like I said, there's a page called A Brand New Way, which talks about the contest.
- 45:35Another one, the proof of concept page is the work that the interns did.
- 45:39We had college students working on a shoestring here to get where we've got.
- 45:43Another website is wilsonsfountain.us.
- 45:46Wilson's Fountain is a LLC of mine.
- 45:49It's kind of like a sandbox where we can do things that don't need to be associated with
- 45:53the party, really research around free and equal elections.
- 45:56I call it my undergraduate think tank because I've got, you know, students from Penn, Drexel,
- 46:02Haverford.
- 46:03Try to hire interns around the Philadelphia area because this idea has its roots.
- 46:07And James Wilson, who was the first law professor at University of Pennsylvania, wrote
- 46:11the US constitution and the Pennsylvania constitution.
- 46:14I mean, the person who drafted it was James Wilson.
- 46:17He's a constitutional nerd.
- 46:19Never gets any never gets any credit for what he did.
- 46:22One of the first, first class of supreme court justice.
- 46:25Oh, there you go.
- 46:26I yeah.
- 46:26I can I can always appreciate when somebody shouts out a founding father or a framer who
- 46:32doesn't get their their due?
- 46:35He has no statue to tear down.
- 46:38Yeah.
- 46:39Alright.
- 46:39Well, I'll share those links in the show notes below, and that's gonna wrap things up for
- 46:46here.
- 46:46So Okay.
- 46:47My notes or my links is my LinkedIn, my Facebook, my five day educational email course
- 46:54about how we can more effectively decrease and mitigate polarization in this country because a
- 47:01lot of the ways we do it is actually ineffective or has the opposite effect.
- 47:05My my book on Amazon ebook and paperback format, the one I mentioned about independence
- 47:10and their, how they could potentially become more competitive.
- 47:13My medium.com profile, where I ride on from time to time and website and Paul Raider dot
- 47:20org and my email, PaulRaiderwrites@Gmail.com.
- 47:24So we are gonna wrap things up here.
- 47:26Please like, comment, share, and subscribe.
- 47:28And you always find this on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcast.
- 47:32Thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.