Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Report Card on Kentucky's Kids
Transcript
- 0:16Kentucky. Tonight I'm Renee
- 0:17Shaw. We thank you so much for
- 0:18joining us this evening.
- 0:20Tonight, an examination of the
- 0:22well-being of Kentucky kids. A
- 0:24recent annual report card on
- 0:26child well-being shows, strides
- 0:27and some challenges for
- 0:29Kentucky kids. The 2026 Kids
- 0:31Count data book ranks the
- 0:33Bluegrass State 36th overall.
- 0:35The 50 state report by the
- 0:37Annie E Casey Foundation takes
- 0:39a deep dive in how children are
- 0:41faring nationwide in areas like
- 0:44education, health, economic
- 0:45stability and other factors. A
- 0:47separate report, though an
- 0:49Education Recovery Scorecard
- 0:50from researchers at Harvard,
- 0:52Stanford and Dartmouth, puts
- 0:55Kentucky in the top performing
- 0:56states for education recovery
- 0:58after Covid. Area learning
- 1:01losses. So here to discuss this
- 1:02kind of mixed bag of results
- 1:04are state lawmakers and child
- 1:06advocates. We have two guests
- 1:07in our Lexington studio. Doctor
- 1:09Terry Brooks, the outgoing
- 1:11executive director of the
- 1:12Kentucky Youth Advocates and
- 1:14incoming executive vice
- 1:15president and ambassador for
- 1:17Sunrise Children's Services,
- 1:19and Christy Putnam, senior
- 1:21policy advisor in the Kentucky
- 1:22House speaker's office in our
- 1:24Louisville studio. We're glad
- 1:26to be joined by State
- 1:29Representative Samara Heavrin,
- 1:29a Republican from Litchfield
- 1:30and co-chair of the Interim
- 1:32Joint Committee on Families and
- 1:34Children and State
- 1:37Representative Tina Bojanowski,
- 1:38a Democrat from Louisville and
- 1:39member of the Interim Joint
- 1:41Committees on Education and
- 1:43Families and Children. And of
- 1:44course, we want to hear from
- 1:46you tonight. You can send us
- 1:47your questions and comments by
- 1:49X, formerly known as Twitter at
- 1:52Pub Affairs KET. Send an email
- 1:53to KY TONIGHT at ket.org or use
- 1:56the web form at ket.org/ky
- 2:00tonight, or you can simply give
- 2:01us a call at one (800) 494-7605.
- 2:06Welcome to our guests, both
- 2:07here in Lexington and in
- 2:08Louisville. We thank you all
- 2:09for being here on this summer
- 2:11night. Not too bad. So thank
- 2:13you for being here. Let's just
- 2:14jump right in. And I really
- 2:16want to start with
- 2:19Representative Samara Heavrin
- 2:19and Louisville, because right
- 2:21now the interim session, as we
- 2:22call it, where lawmakers are
- 2:25hearing a lot about the issues
- 2:27that they could be tackling.
- 2:28When you resume the Kentucky
- 2:30General Assembly in January,
- 2:31this is a good time to get a
- 2:33lot of background information
- 2:34and to know about the issues a
- 2:36little bit more in depth and
- 2:37some more dimension of issues
- 2:39that you're constantly dealing
- 2:40with and may not have found
- 2:42resolution to in the last
- 2:43legislative session. What are
- 2:44you really honing in on these
- 2:47next few months during this
- 2:49interim period?
- 2:53>> Thanks, Renee. Thanks for
- 2:54having me tonight. I'm so glad
- 2:55to be here with my friend Tina
- 2:57and our friends in Lexington as
- 2:59well. We started the interim
- 3:00Joint Committee on Families and
- 3:02Children last week, and we had
- 3:04an awesome committee hearing
- 3:06talking about autism from the
- 3:07from the very beginning, when
- 3:09kids are first diagnosed to
- 3:10what Kentucky families face is
- 3:12now. And we have a lot of work
- 3:14to do. But what I'm looking at
- 3:15this session during the interim
- 3:17session is to start looking at
- 3:19when kids get removed from home,
- 3:21really the child welfare
- 3:22continuum. And so when kids get
- 3:24removed from their homes all
- 3:25the way up to adoption, what
- 3:27are those conversations we need
- 3:28to be having from the from
- 3:30friends of the courts, from the
- 3:32family court system. And
- 3:34there's a lot of room for
- 3:35opportunity and just really
- 3:36focused on child welfare in the
- 3:38foster care system. Renee. We
- 3:40all since 2024, we filed bills
- 3:43to help child welfare, but
- 3:44we've got so much work to do.
- 3:45And I look forward to
- 3:47continuing on that.
- 3:47>> Yeah, thank you for that.
- 3:49And there is a little bit of a
- 3:51delay. So if you hear a little
- 3:53bit of pronounced silence,
- 3:54that's just because we have a
- 3:55little technical delay.
- 3:56Representative Bozinovski, I
- 3:57want to come to you and ask you
- 3:59the same. You serve both on the
- 4:00education committees and you
- 4:01serve on the families and
- 4:03children. And we know that if
- 4:04you did a Venn diagram, there'd
- 4:06be a lot of issues where
- 4:07there's some intersectionality
- 4:08there, right? What are you
- 4:09hoping can be discussed during
- 4:11this interim session?
- 4:11>> So. Well, so we started out
- 4:17the session with we've had one
- 4:19education meeting and we had a
- 4:20long discussion about workforce
- 4:22Pell grants. And so those are
- 4:25the ability now to use a Pell
- 4:26Grant to pay for a
- 4:29certification that isn't just
- 4:30community college hours or
- 4:34college hours. We also had a
- 4:36long discussion about our work
- 4:39in early literacy, which has
- 4:41just been amazing. We have
- 4:45actually you mentioned the
- 4:46Harvard study. You know, there
- 4:48were only seven states that
- 4:50have shown improvement and
- 4:51growth in their student
- 4:53literacy, and Kentucky was one
- 4:55of them. And I believe we
- 4:56ranked fifth. So a lot of work
- 5:00on literacy. I think we need to
- 5:04as far as over the interim, I
- 5:05think we need to have some
- 5:07conversations in regular
- 5:09session 25, we had House Bill
- 5:12240, and that was the
- 5:14kindergarten first grade
- 5:15retention bill. And I'm hearing
- 5:18kind of through the grapevine
- 5:19that some districts really
- 5:22absorbed it very, you know, had
- 5:24a lot of input in it. And a lot
- 5:26of children may have benefited
- 5:28and some districts aren't
- 5:30moving or aren't having quite
- 5:32so many kids retained who maybe
- 5:35need to be. And so I think in
- 5:37the interim, we need to have
- 5:38some discussions about how the
- 5:40language was written and how we
- 5:42need to tighten it up so that
- 5:44what the intent is and the
- 5:46intent is that a child goes
- 5:47into second grade ready for
- 5:50second grade, and they're not
- 5:51behind, behind, behind each
- 5:53year that the intent is what is
- 5:56actually happening. Also over
- 6:00the interim in this crosses
- 6:01between education and the
- 6:04families and children is, is
- 6:06the issues that we have for
- 6:07children with autism. And that
- 6:10rate has been growing so
- 6:12quickly. My son was diagnosed
- 6:14with autism in 1998, and at
- 6:17that time we had maybe 1 in 500
- 6:20children, and today it's 1 in
- 6:2331. So just imagine in a school
- 6:25building like the one I work in,
- 6:27it would either be one child in
- 6:29the whole building or where we
- 6:31are now is pretty much one
- 6:33child in each classroom. And so,
- 6:37you know, I could talk about
- 6:39this subject for an hour all by
- 6:40itself, but I've a lot of
- 6:42thoughts on areas that I think
- 6:44we need to address regarding
- 6:47children with autism.
- 6:48>> And I think even Tina, we
- 6:50heard in family and children
- 6:52last week, we heard how
- 6:54important it was for what
- 6:55happens when families have to.
- 6:57They can no longer care for
- 6:58their child. That's right. You
- 7:00know, they have to be sent to
- 7:01Kansas because they just can't
- 7:03be. They can't give them the
- 7:05the services they need. And so
- 7:07I think that's an even bigger
- 7:09conversation we've got to
- 7:10continue to work on.
- 7:11>> Yeah. And it's my
- 7:12understanding through talking
- 7:13to parents that sometimes the
- 7:16agencies are the, the
- 7:17facilities that can offer
- 7:20residential care for children
- 7:21with very involved autism who
- 7:24are no longer safe in their
- 7:26home or their family members.
- 7:28Aren't parents often are not.
- 7:33Their children are not accepted
- 7:34into the programs. I talked to
- 7:36a mom who had 349 agencies that
- 7:41she's tried across the nation,
- 7:42and they won't accept her child.
- 7:44But then sometimes in order to
- 7:47get the services, the parents
- 7:49are asked to give up basically
- 7:51custody and put them in
- 7:53dependency. So if you're a
- 7:54parent, when my son was little,
- 7:56I wouldn't have wanted, no
- 7:57matter what. His need is to not
- 8:00be his legal parent. And so
- 8:02there are some very concerning
- 8:05issues for our kids with autism.
- 8:07>> Yeah. You've really gotten
- 8:08us, both of you on a really
- 8:10good start on this conversation.
- 8:11Hopefully we can drill down a
- 8:13little bit more onto that
- 8:14discussion about autism and
- 8:15about having to go to Kansas to
- 8:17get care, which I know a lot of
- 8:19people are curious about. But I
- 8:21do want to back us up to that
- 8:23study that involved Harvard and
- 8:24Dartmouth, where and Stanford,
- 8:26where it showed that Kentucky
- 8:27ranks eighth out of 38 states
- 8:29nationally in math recovery and
- 8:31five out of 35 states in
- 8:33reading growth between 2022 and
- 8:362025. And that places the
- 8:38Commonwealth at those top
- 8:39performing states in the nation
- 8:40of recovering from those Covid
- 8:43era losses, from the disrupted
- 8:45learning. I want to ask Christy
- 8:46Putnam, when you hear that kind
- 8:48of ground being made up, are
- 8:50you encouraged by that? And
- 8:51then the next question is how
- 8:53do you sustain even build on
- 8:55that momentum?
- 8:57>> Absolutely. Encouraged by
- 8:58that. You know, I think any
- 9:00time you can show such
- 9:01significant gains in education,
- 9:03you know, what you want to
- 9:04focus on is maintaining that.
- 9:06So what has Kentucky been doing?
- 9:07What policies, what procedures,
- 9:09what what's working with
- 9:11parents involved in school and
- 9:13their children's education? So
- 9:15I'm very encouraged by that.
- 9:17You know, ten years ago when I
- 9:19was in the cabinet for Health
- 9:21and Family Services, Kentucky
- 9:22was at the bottom of a lot of
- 9:24things, and we have made a lot
- 9:25of progress. I think there's a
- 9:27reason to be hopeful across the
- 9:28board in child well-being in
- 9:30the state of Kentucky, not
- 9:31saying that the work is done.
- 9:32We're still in the bottom 10 to
- 9:3415 rankings of for a lot of
- 9:36indicators like child obesity
- 9:38and child poverty. But in the
- 9:40education gains, I think it's
- 9:42significant that Kentucky is
- 9:44one of the top. There's been a
- 9:45lot of focus on passing the
- 9:47right education policy, making
- 9:48sure that teachers have what
- 9:49they needed in the classroom.
- 9:51So I'm very encouraged by the
- 9:53progress that's been made.
- 9:54>> And Doctor Brooks, as
- 9:55someone who spent part of his
- 9:58career in the classroom and
- 9:59certainly 20 something years as
- 10:01a child advocate for the
- 10:02leading child advocacy
- 10:04organization, how encouraged by
- 10:05you from the educational gains.
- 10:07And then we'll drill down to
- 10:08the other areas.
- 10:09>> Sure. Absolutely. You first
- 10:11of all, Renee, I think it's so
- 10:12important given the narratives
- 10:13that are out there. I want to
- 10:14take just a second and say how
- 10:17appreciative I am of reps.
- 10:20Bujnowski and Heavrin and
- 10:22Christie, each of them, in
- 10:23their own way, really does
- 10:25deliver for kids. And I think
- 10:27sometimes it's easy to think of
- 10:29Frankfort as that place that
- 10:30doesn't get anything done.
- 10:32These three folks help things
- 10:33get done for kids. So as that
- 10:37you intimated as an old broken
- 10:39down principal.
- 10:40>> Now, I didn't say all of
- 10:42that.
- 10:42>> You know, when I think about
- 10:43that, there's absolutely lots
- 10:45of reasons to be optimistic. I
- 10:48think one of the things that I
- 10:49hope reenters the conversation
- 10:53is that pedagogy, curriculum
- 10:57methodologies, all those are
- 10:58really important. But I think
- 11:00one of the things that I'd like
- 11:01to see reinserted, and I, at
- 11:04the moment, I think the most
- 11:05articulate voice for this is
- 11:07Commissioner Fletcher. He does
- 11:08a great job of talking about
- 11:09this. That is the role of
- 11:12non-cognitive factors in
- 11:14student achievement.
- 11:15>> What do you mean by that?
- 11:17Define that for us.
- 11:18>> 200,000 kids woke up in
- 11:20poverty today in Kentucky. That
- 11:23has a dramatic impact on health
- 11:25outcomes and academic
- 11:27achievement. So we can't talk
- 11:29about reading scores without
- 11:31talking about economic
- 11:33well-being. When we think about
- 11:35kids in Health, I don't care
- 11:37how interesting the lesson is.
- 11:40If I've got a toothache that's
- 11:41not treated, I'm not going to
- 11:44learn about multiplication. If
- 11:47we think about schools and the
- 11:50number of young people we have
- 11:51living in kinship families, we
- 11:54have a lot of grandkids. And my
- 11:56wife and I collectively spent a
- 11:57lot of years in school. Yet the
- 11:59most frightening question I get
- 12:00is from our grandson saying,
- 12:02can you help me with my math?
- 12:04Schools have to think about
- 12:06what does that mean? That we
- 12:08have young people living with
- 12:10grandparents? And that's
- 12:11probably a crisis. So
- 12:13absolutely, we need to be
- 12:14talking about curriculum,
- 12:17helping teachers with their
- 12:18methods and pedagogy. Got to
- 12:20talk about discipline. We have
- 12:21to talk about funding, but we
- 12:23also have to talk about those
- 12:25factors that that are so
- 12:27important to kids. Because kids
- 12:28don't grow up in silos, they
- 12:30don't live their lives at home
- 12:32and then come to school as
- 12:33students. So what I hope
- 12:35happens, whether it's in
- 12:36juvenile justice or child
- 12:37welfare or education, is that
- 12:40we begin increasingly talking
- 12:42about the whole child and all
- 12:44of those needs. And I'm
- 12:45convinced that could be the
- 12:46secret sauce if we really want
- 12:49to move kids ahead in terms of
- 12:51reading, writing and arithmetic.
- 12:52>> So we recall that Doctor
- 12:54Steven Pruitt, when he was
- 12:56education commissioner, I think
- 12:57part of his platform was
- 12:59addressing the whole child. And
- 13:02Representative Bujnowski, I
- 13:03want to come to you for give
- 13:05our audience a working
- 13:06definition of what whole child
- 13:08means. I think Doctor Brooks
- 13:09just really laid it out for us.
- 13:11But is there anything you would
- 13:13add to that? And when you think
- 13:14about these educational gains
- 13:16and where they were made, you
- 13:17know, Anderson County, Perry
- 13:19County, Marion, Ohio, Corbin
- 13:21Independent and Pike are
- 13:23outperforming their peers in
- 13:24reading and math. And then
- 13:25other districts like Paducah
- 13:27Independent, Harlan County,
- 13:28Franklin County, Clay County
- 13:29and Davis County are
- 13:31demonstrating very strong
- 13:33subject specific growth. So
- 13:34sometimes we think in terms of
- 13:36everything as rural versus
- 13:37urban, but this is a really
- 13:39interesting mix of counties
- 13:40that are perhaps punching above
- 13:42their weight of what is
- 13:44normally expected of counties
- 13:45like that. Can you give us some
- 13:46insight there?
- 13:49>> Well, so I'll start because
- 13:51I'm also a special education
- 13:52teacher in addition to being a
- 13:54state rep. And what we believe
- 13:56in in our program is that
- 13:58children won't learn anything
- 13:59unless their basic needs are
- 14:00being met. If they're hungry,
- 14:02if they're tired, if they're
- 14:05they have needs, if they didn't
- 14:07sleep the night before, if
- 14:09there are issues at home. So
- 14:10those basic needs are so
- 14:12imperative. And if they're
- 14:14emotionally regulated, I mean,
- 14:15there's a lot of discussions.
- 14:17It's a major issue in education
- 14:19today of student behavior. And
- 14:22I don't think that that
- 14:23behavior is just related to
- 14:25school. It's oftentimes related
- 14:27to a trauma that may have
- 14:29happened or be happening, you
- 14:31know, outside of school. So
- 14:32we've got to have those basic
- 14:34needs. But then, you know, we
- 14:36also have to be teaching
- 14:38reading and math and writing in,
- 14:41in the best way. And I think
- 14:43that our state since the 2022
- 14:46Reed to succeed state has
- 14:48shifted the way that we've
- 14:49taught reading in a very
- 14:52monumental way. And not only,
- 14:55you know, I did the letters
- 14:56program. The letters program is
- 14:58a two year professional
- 15:00development to help teachers
- 15:02better understand how to teach
- 15:03reading, which is wonderful.
- 15:05But we also have a requirement
- 15:09that the Department of
- 15:11Education select curricula. And
- 15:13I was so fortunate last week to
- 15:16join more than 1500 teachers
- 15:18from across the state for the
- 15:21read statistic reads to succeed
- 15:23Summer conference and the
- 15:25keynote speaker there, he
- 15:27brought up an issue that has
- 15:29been corrected by needing to
- 15:32have our curricula decided, but
- 15:34I hadn't even really thought of
- 15:35it. And it's this having
- 15:38students in their reading
- 15:39groups read only what is
- 15:42supposedly on their level,
- 15:43which means that so many of our
- 15:45kids will not get exposed to
- 15:48grade level reading experiences.
- 15:50So we're making big changes in
- 15:54the state of Kentucky, and the
- 15:55fact that it's maybe showing up
- 15:58in the Harvard study, I can
- 16:01tell you 100% was showing up in
- 16:03the enthusiasm of the educators
- 16:07across the state at the
- 16:08conference where I was last
- 16:10week.
- 16:11>> And can you help us
- 16:13understand if if more and more
- 16:15teachers have have embraced the
- 16:17science of literacy, the
- 16:19science of reading, or is or is
- 16:22that slow to come online? Or
- 16:24does it depend on where you are?
- 16:26>> Well, I, I think that in
- 16:31that the superintendent,
- 16:33because it used to be that
- 16:34every building the the. Oh,
- 16:39I've forgotten the. The the
- 16:43what's it called? The building.
- 16:45>> Council, SVM.
- 16:46>> Yes. Thank you. I'm sorry.
- 16:48Yes. There we go. The SVM in
- 16:51every building used to be able
- 16:52to select the curriculum. And
- 16:55so with that happening, it was
- 16:58much harder to change how
- 17:01students, especially in
- 17:02Jefferson County, because we
- 17:03have so many schools we're
- 17:05learning to read. Now, the
- 17:07superintendent and the chief
- 17:09academic officer select a
- 17:11curriculum that embeds science
- 17:15of reading within the
- 17:17curriculum, because those are
- 17:18the curricula that are on the
- 17:20approved list. So I think
- 17:24teachers, you know, as time
- 17:25goes by, they're kind of
- 17:27they're still a little bit
- 17:29hesitant about like we had the
- 17:32no. Three cueing Bill. And
- 17:34there are still teachers who
- 17:36aren't, you know, three cueing
- 17:38is a way of teaching reading
- 17:40where you teach them, you know,
- 17:41do you look at the picture or
- 17:43the first letter of the word
- 17:44and try to figure out what it
- 17:46is? And it's an emphasis on
- 17:48more on whole language as
- 17:50opposed to what are the letters
- 17:52and phonics based teaching
- 17:54reading? And so there are still
- 17:55teachers who are hesitant to,
- 17:58to abandon some of the things
- 18:00that have worked for them in
- 18:01the past. However, every
- 18:04teacher is supposed to teach
- 18:06the curriculum that the
- 18:08superintendent selects, and
- 18:10those are by requirement of our
- 18:14legislation and selected by the
- 18:16Department of Education going
- 18:18to build in science of reading.
- 18:20So, you know, we're making a
- 18:22big shift in this state. And
- 18:23within the eight years that
- 18:25I've been in this General
- 18:26Assembly, it's a very big
- 18:28change. And I think that we are
- 18:31going to see. I think we are
- 18:33going to see children finish up
- 18:36stronger through their
- 18:38education path. I don't know
- 18:39how much of that. And what what
- 18:41concerns me is I don't know how
- 18:43much of that will actually show
- 18:45up in test scores, because the
- 18:48tests are designed to
- 18:49distinguish between kids, not
- 18:52necessarily to show that you
- 18:53are competent at grade level.
- 18:55So that could be a whole show.
- 18:58But I, I think we're really
- 19:01making good progress as far as
- 19:03what we need to do to ensure
- 19:06that our children are literate
- 19:09when they graduate from high
- 19:11school.
- 19:11>> Well, one of the things you
- 19:13mentioned earlier, and perhaps
- 19:14it was representative Heavrin
- 19:15to about emotional regulation.
- 19:17And we know that during Covid,
- 19:18we heard that the cohort of
- 19:20kids who were at home, Miss
- 19:22Putnam, who were entering
- 19:24kindergarten right at the peak,
- 19:25or the changes where Covid was
- 19:28its most kind of strident. They
- 19:30really had some socialization
- 19:33issues, right? Because they had
- 19:34not been in that atmosphere.
- 19:37And and when you think about
- 19:38the number of grandparents who
- 19:39are primary caregivers of, of
- 19:42their grandchildren, I think
- 19:43it's close to 100,000. I mean,
- 19:44we rank, I think, number one in
- 19:46the nation for grandparents who
- 19:48are caring for their
- 19:50grandchildren. So put all of
- 19:51that in a, in a, in a
- 19:53perspective for us about the
- 19:54challenges that that educators
- 19:55face in the classroom.
- 19:57>> Absolutely. And I'm not sure
- 19:59many people know that I started
- 20:00my career as a classroom
- 20:01teacher, and that bridged me
- 20:02quickly to human services and
- 20:04the intersection.
- 20:05Representative Bozinovski
- 20:06touched on it at the beginning,
- 20:07but the intersection of those
- 20:08two areas and child well-being
- 20:10and education was really
- 20:13emphasized during Covid. The
- 20:15ability for kids to be
- 20:16socialized and normalized, not
- 20:17just when they're entering
- 20:18kindergarten, but we had
- 20:19critical transitions that kids
- 20:21missed all throughout. You know,
- 20:22I had a daughter who was
- 20:24entering her freshman year in
- 20:25college, and it was a
- 20:26completely different experience
- 20:27than what she was expecting. So,
- 20:29you know, I think that the
- 20:31behavior challenges the
- 20:33substance use that happened
- 20:35when people were home and
- 20:36people were hopeless and people
- 20:37didn't know what was going to
- 20:38happen, turned into substance
- 20:40use issues, turned into parents
- 20:42with problems. And so we've
- 20:44ended up with a significant
- 20:46number of of grandparents
- 20:47raising children, aunts and
- 20:48uncles. The good thing is
- 20:51Kentucky does rank the highest
- 20:52for placement with relatives.
- 20:54And, you know, I think our
- 20:55state does an excellent job of,
- 20:56of seeking out the kinship care,
- 20:58making sure that there's a
- 21:00connected person with that
- 21:01child. But the issues that have
- 21:03have been exacerbated, the
- 21:05behavioral health issues that
- 21:06we're seeing, not just in our
- 21:08schools, but we're seeing kids
- 21:10enter juvenile justice at much
- 21:12higher rates. We're seeing kids
- 21:14enter the foster care system.
- 21:16Exactly the point that that was
- 21:17made earlier. Parents, they
- 21:19just don't know what to do with
- 21:21these, with their children. And
- 21:22the behaviors are so out of
- 21:24control that sometimes the last
- 21:26resort and the resort, the the
- 21:28option that's offered is put
- 21:30your child in custody because
- 21:31we have the services that can
- 21:33help your child with their
- 21:34behavioral issues and their
- 21:35regulation.
- 21:36>> That seems like a pretty
- 21:38stark option there. Drastic
- 21:41option, doctor Brooks, about.
- 21:43>> Yeah, one of the things when
- 21:44you think about where kids in
- 21:46crisis are, Renee, whether it's
- 21:49child welfare or juvenile
- 21:50justice, if you think about
- 21:52that continuum of care and link
- 21:55how kids do to the health care
- 21:58system, we have lots of
- 22:01immediate care and emergency
- 22:04rooms for kids, so to speak.
- 22:07We've got some intermediate
- 22:09areas, but kids in trouble,
- 22:12kids in crisis, like the child
- 22:14welfare equivalent of an
- 22:16intensive care unit. And I
- 22:18think that's so important that
- 22:20our legislators keep thinking
- 22:22about that. In fact, that whole
- 22:25notion of what has happened
- 22:26with kids emotional well-being,
- 22:29there's an important predicate
- 22:30that I don't think gets enough
- 22:32credit. In 2019, Senator Wise
- 22:35and the very noble late Bam
- 22:37Carney from the House passed a
- 22:40bicameral resiliency bill that
- 22:43kind of got lost with the
- 22:45pandemic. I'd love to see a 2.0
- 22:49version of that get looked at,
- 22:51because what Representative
- 22:53Carney and Senator Wise knew
- 22:55was that there are certain
- 22:57levers, certain supports, that
- 23:00young people need for their
- 23:02behavioral, emotional and
- 23:04mental health. Again, very
- 23:06common sense, very research
- 23:08based, very practical. So
- 23:11that's an area where I think
- 23:12that both the House and Senate
- 23:15calling on those historic
- 23:17commitments from the late
- 23:19Representative Carney and
- 23:20Senator Wise could reboot. We
- 23:22need that more now than we did
- 23:25in 2019. I think the other
- 23:27thing that I want to make sure
- 23:28we we at least allude to is
- 23:31Kristy mentioned, and I could
- 23:32not agree more. The number of
- 23:35grandmas and grandpas and aunts
- 23:36and uncles and godparents who
- 23:38are stepping up if they make
- 23:40that commitment, we as a state
- 23:43have to support them. I know
- 23:47Representative Heavrin is a
- 23:49champion on kinship. My premise
- 23:51is that as a state, we owe
- 23:55those caregivers, supports,
- 23:57respite care, adequate economic
- 24:00supports, and they are not
- 24:01getting them today. You
- 24:03actually get far more supports
- 24:05being a foster parent than you
- 24:08do a kinship caregiver. That is
- 24:10a broken system. We need to
- 24:13honor family as a first stop.
- 24:15So that's the other thing that
- 24:17folks embrace the concept of
- 24:19kinship care. We applaud those
- 24:21grandmas and grandpas. We got
- 24:23to do more than applaud. We've
- 24:25got to support.
- 24:26>> Yeah. Representative Heavrin,
- 24:27I want to come to you for a
- 24:29response about that. And this
- 24:30disparity between kinship care,
- 24:32the support, financial support
- 24:33and other supports and those
- 24:35who are foster parents talk
- 24:37about that. And if there will
- 24:39be possibly some legislation or
- 24:41ideas, policy ideas that could
- 24:42address that disparity.
- 24:47>> Yeah. You know, Terry hits
- 24:48the nail on the head. Renee,
- 24:50this has been such an issue for
- 24:52the last several years. And one
- 24:54thing I really want to commend
- 24:56my friend Norma Hatfield, she
- 24:58is the kinship caregiver to her
- 25:00grandchildren, and she's been a
- 25:01phenomenal advocate to them.
- 25:02She's in Hardin County, and we
- 25:04continue to work with her to
- 25:05try to get this right. In the
- 25:07state of Kentucky and the
- 25:08budget we funded more. We we
- 25:10gave more dollars to kinship
- 25:11care. And so we're looking to
- 25:12see how the executive branch
- 25:14plays that out. Now, we have
- 25:15been working with the federal
- 25:16government on this as well,
- 25:18trying to figure out what we
- 25:19can do to help families. You
- 25:21know, one of the biggest issues,
- 25:22Renee, is when you get that
- 25:24knock on the door at 2 a.m. and
- 25:26they say, hey, you know, you
- 25:27can be a foster care parent or
- 25:29you can be a kinship care
- 25:30parent to that grandma. You
- 25:32know, sometimes foster care has
- 25:33a negative connotation. And my
- 25:34world, it doesn't. And Tina's
- 25:35world it doesn't. But, you know,
- 25:37some people, they're like, oh,
- 25:38well, we don't need the
- 25:39government's help not
- 25:40recognizing the expenses it
- 25:41takes to raise a child in 2026.
- 25:44And so what we're trying to do
- 25:46first is being able to switch,
- 25:48you know, right now when Dcbs
- 25:49comes to you and says, okay,
- 25:52kinship care, foster care, then
- 25:53you have to stick with that.
- 25:55And it's not really fair for
- 25:56families who are having to make
- 25:58a decision in the early morning
- 25:59to figure out, well, what
- 26:01resources do we need? And I
- 26:02think families should be able
- 26:04to switch from that. That is
- 26:05something that we passed.
- 26:06Senator Julie Raque Adams
- 26:07actually passed that to be able
- 26:09to have flexibility, but then
- 26:10just offering, you know, what
- 26:11can we do to pull down those
- 26:13title $40 and better help
- 26:16Kentucky families? It's there.
- 26:17And I think that Kristi could
- 26:19probably share a little more
- 26:20information. But I think that's
- 26:21one of the most important
- 26:23things is, you know, when we
- 26:24know that kids do better when
- 26:25they're with family members.
- 26:27And so why aren't we making
- 26:28better strides to do that? And
- 26:30a lot of that lands on the
- 26:32executive branch right now. And
- 26:34seeing, you know, I'm going to
- 26:35say the ball's in their court.
- 26:37You know, we really feel like
- 26:38what we did, what we could in
- 26:40the budget and through policy.
- 26:42And so we're trying to to
- 26:44continue to be a partner on
- 26:45that and figure out what we do.
- 26:47Because at the end of the day,
- 26:48we want to help kinship care
- 26:50families, and we want to help
- 26:51grandparents and aunts and
- 26:52uncles that are stepping up to
- 26:54serve these kids because
- 26:55they're going to have a better
- 26:56outcome at the end of the day.
- 26:58>> So really quickly before I
- 27:00have Doctor Brooks weigh in
- 27:01there just so that the viewer
- 27:02at home understands. So the
- 27:04legislature allotted money to,
- 27:05I guess, the Department of
- 27:06Community Based Services, which
- 27:08would cover fictive kinship
- 27:10care, foster care, and then the.
- 27:13And then the executive branch
- 27:14can decide on how to
- 27:15disseminate those dollars. Or
- 27:16are they specific line items
- 27:18for each of those things that
- 27:20the General Assembly allocated?
- 27:25>> It was line item.
- 27:27>> Okay, Doctor Brooks.
- 27:29>> So it was line item in the
- 27:31budget. So the executive branch
- 27:32should. Oh, sorry, we've got a
- 27:33lag there. So there is a. It's
- 27:39a it was a line item in the
- 27:41budget including some policy
- 27:43language with that. And so
- 27:45we're looking you know, it it I
- 27:47don't know that it had an
- 27:49emergency clause on it. So it
- 27:50should start you know we should
- 27:52start seeing some movement
- 27:53hopefully July 1st.
- 27:54>> Okay. So we'll keep our eyes
- 27:55on that doctor.
- 27:56>> One of the things that I
- 27:58find so encouraging, Renee, and
- 27:59absolutely, we're counting on
- 28:01the House and Senate to stand
- 28:02up for kinship families as well
- 28:04as the Beshear administration.
- 28:06But every aspect of kinship
- 28:08care is not going to be solved
- 28:10in Frankfort and nationally.
- 28:12One of the phenomenon that we
- 28:14see is an increasing role of
- 28:17faith communities to support
- 28:19kinship care. There are
- 28:21churches, for instance, that
- 28:23have the magic of the ever
- 28:26present frozen casserole. If a
- 28:29grandma is just jammed, she can
- 28:31go to church and there is a
- 28:34frozen lasagna waiting for her.
- 28:36There are churches that are
- 28:39offering tutoring sessions a
- 28:41couple times a week. Bring your
- 28:43grandson or granddaughter in.
- 28:45We're going to have a retired
- 28:46teacher, a student teacher, a
- 28:47community member. But we need
- 28:49you to stay so you'll learn how
- 28:52to help your grandkid. Imagine
- 28:54that adult Sunday school class.
- 28:57Who says there's a kinship
- 28:59family down the street? We're
- 29:01going to provide a respite
- 29:03afternoon for that grandma. So
- 29:05as important as reps.
- 29:08Bogdanovsky and Heavrin and
- 29:09their colleagues in the Senate
- 29:11are, and they are absolutely
- 29:12vital to kinship care. The
- 29:14other thing that I hope happens
- 29:16is that community, folks,
- 29:18business, community, faith,
- 29:20community, civic clubs, they
- 29:22step up and think about what
- 29:24role we could play to help that
- 29:26grandma and that grandpa and
- 29:28that little boy and little girl
- 29:30go to a more prosperous,
- 29:31self-sufficient future.
- 29:33>> Miss Putnam. Yes.
- 29:35>> So, yes. And Terry and I
- 29:38have talked at length about
- 29:39about this prospect, as have
- 29:40the representatives, and I. So
- 29:42the idea that we have community
- 29:45partners, that we have civil
- 29:47society churches who are are
- 29:49ready and willing to step in,
- 29:50is more an idea about
- 29:51strengthening families and
- 29:53communities. And I think, I
- 29:55hope what what you will see
- 29:56coming out of both the interim
- 29:57and the next session are some
- 29:59additional ways and
- 30:01flexibilities where government
- 30:02is not the only answer.
- 30:04Government really should be
- 30:06further, much further down on
- 30:07the list. And we really should
- 30:08be looking at how do we
- 30:09strengthen the grandparents,
- 30:11aunts and uncles, those who
- 30:12raise their hands to say, we're
- 30:13going to help take care of this
- 30:15child because we have a
- 30:16connection with this child? And
- 30:18so what Representative Heavrin
- 30:20referenced in the budget
- 30:21language was that not just was
- 30:22there a line item for
- 30:23supporting kinship care, but
- 30:24there was also policy language
- 30:26that talks about provisional
- 30:28approval of a relative as a
- 30:30foster home, a different type
- 30:32of approval. You know,
- 30:33something that's very
- 30:34encouraging to me is we're
- 30:36seeing so much movement out of
- 30:37the administration for Children
- 30:39and families. Assistant
- 30:40Secretary Alex Adams and his
- 30:42team are doing a phenomenal job
- 30:44with a home for every child.
- 30:45And what a home for every child
- 30:47does at the national level is
- 30:49it does remove some of the
- 30:51barriers it they're doing a
- 30:53significant deregulation of of
- 30:55all these pages upon pages of,
- 30:57of bureaucratic barriers that
- 30:59are just in place because
- 31:00they've been there for so many
- 31:01years, they just get added to.
- 31:03So I'm very encouraged by the
- 31:05legislature's willingness to
- 31:07move in a direction that that
- 31:09removes some of these barriers
- 31:10and provides support for
- 31:11kinship caregivers through
- 31:13provisional approval and
- 31:13through some administrative
- 31:15changes. So I agree with
- 31:17Representative Heavrin. You
- 31:17know, the ball is in the court
- 31:19of the executive branch. And,
- 31:20you know, I'm very hopeful that
- 31:22this is an option for them that
- 31:24they will be able to pursue.
- 31:25>> Sometimes when viewers and
- 31:26listeners hear relaxing
- 31:29regulations, that translates to
- 31:30them that imperiling a child or
- 31:33endangering a child, can you
- 31:35just make a disconnection there
- 31:36between regulation and child
- 31:38safety?
- 31:39>> Absolutely. Child safety is
- 31:41imperative. The things that are
- 31:42not deregulated in the process
- 31:44of provisional approval are the
- 31:45the health and safety checks
- 31:47that have to be done. We have
- 31:48to do background checks. We
- 31:49have to make sure that the home
- 31:51environment is safe. And you
- 31:52know that there are not things
- 31:54that are harmful for children
- 31:55to get into in that environment,
- 31:56but the bureaucratic things are
- 31:58things like, you cannot be
- 31:59approved as a foster home until
- 32:00somebody comes in and inspects
- 32:02your refrigerator. I mean,
- 32:03there are just there are just
- 32:04some things that are put in
- 32:06place, well intentioned over
- 32:07the years. And what is it that
- 32:08we can remove while preserving
- 32:10the health and safety of that
- 32:11child and making sure that
- 32:12their needs are being met?
- 32:14>> And that's a tough balance.
- 32:15We absolutely want every kid to
- 32:17be safe. That's certainly what
- 32:18I hear Christie talking about.
- 32:20By the same token, what price
- 32:22is being paid when placement is
- 32:25delayed, when that young person
- 32:28is sleeping in an office or a
- 32:30state park because they have
- 32:32not had time to look at your
- 32:34refrigerator, there's a balance.
- 32:36And again, speed of placement
- 32:38and guaranteed quality don't
- 32:40have to be mutually exclusive.
- 32:42And I totally agree with what
- 32:44Christie is talking about in
- 32:45terms of that direction.
- 32:46>> And just to remind our
- 32:49viewers that your reference to
- 32:51out of home placement and kids
- 32:53staying in state office
- 32:55buildings, that's not just
- 32:56anecdotal. We know that the
- 32:57state auditor, Alison Ball, did
- 32:59an examination. I think that
- 33:02result of which came out in
- 33:04March of 9th of March. And she
- 33:07found that over a 22 month
- 33:08period, there were 304 children
- 33:10that were placed in what's
- 33:11called nontraditional placement
- 33:13settings, like cabinet for
- 33:14health and family services,
- 33:16office buildings, state parks,
- 33:17or other unlicensed settings.
- 33:19But sometimes you do the best
- 33:20you can with what you have.
- 33:23Right, Miss Putnam? I mean,
- 33:24were those the best available
- 33:26options at the time just to
- 33:27make sure those children
- 33:28weren't on the street?
- 33:31>> Absolutely. Something that I
- 33:33have said previously is when
- 33:35you're working in child welfare
- 33:37and in human services, but
- 33:38specifically child welfare, you
- 33:40are so often faced with making
- 33:41the best, worst decision in
- 33:42front of you. And, you know, I
- 33:45think, you know, one of the
- 33:47last things that that I would
- 33:48want to do is, is be critical
- 33:50of anybody who is in that role
- 33:52because there's no, there's no
- 33:54way to for people to actually
- 33:56understand all of the different
- 33:58complexities that go into
- 33:59making a decision for a child
- 34:01that you have taken into your
- 34:03custody. That being said, you
- 34:06know, one of the things that we
- 34:07see frequently is we see a
- 34:09pendulum swing in our country,
- 34:11and sometimes the pendulum
- 34:12swings to, we've got to leave
- 34:14kids in their families at all
- 34:16costs. And then other times it
- 34:18swings back to the we've got to
- 34:19remove kids because they're
- 34:21unsafe at the first sign of, of.
- 34:22There's an issue in the home
- 34:24and finding somewhere in the
- 34:25middle where we can both assess
- 34:28kids and make sure that they're
- 34:30in the right place, whether
- 34:31that's their home environment
- 34:32with appropriate safety in
- 34:34place or whether that's in a,
- 34:35an out-of-home care situation
- 34:36with a relative or with a
- 34:38foster home, you often don't
- 34:40have enough time to make that
- 34:42decision. You have to make a
- 34:43decision to put that child in a
- 34:45place where they're safe for
- 34:46the night. Again, one of its
- 34:48the best, worst decision that
- 34:49you can possibly make. But that
- 34:52being said, you know, I think
- 34:53it's important for us to
- 34:54remember too, that we are
- 34:57constantly questioning we, the
- 34:59general public. I'm going to
- 35:00put my general public hat on.
- 35:02Legislators, media, general
- 35:04public are constantly
- 35:05questioning the actions of the
- 35:06workers who are on the front
- 35:08line having to make these
- 35:09decisions instead of trying to
- 35:10understand perhaps why was that
- 35:12the best decision at the moment,
- 35:13and how do we keep that from
- 35:15happening? How do we provide
- 35:16more resources, meaning not
- 35:18necessarily funding, but
- 35:19supports and community
- 35:21environments that are more
- 35:22conducive to helping assess a
- 35:24child in a more meaningful way?
- 35:25>> And I think the the key,
- 35:27Renee, is if we know this
- 35:30phenomenon is happening in
- 35:31totally agree with with
- 35:33Christie that what tough jobs
- 35:37social workers have. So this is
- 35:39not about them. What what I
- 35:41hope happens is creative folks
- 35:43like Representative Heavrin
- 35:46Bogdanovsky and their
- 35:47colleagues take what's
- 35:49happening and think about what
- 35:50do we do about it as close as
- 35:53Tennessee. Tennessee has
- 35:55essentially solved the issue of
- 35:58temporary █placements.
- 36:00built regional assessment
- 36:02centers for kids with high
- 36:04acuity that are dangerous to
- 36:07themselves and others. One of
- 36:09the things that Auditor Ball
- 36:11reported was a stunning number
- 36:13of young people under the age
- 36:15of four who did not represent a
- 36:17threat for anybody, but it was
- 36:18their first time out of home
- 36:20and we didn't know what to do
- 36:21with them. Tennessee has built
- 36:23essentially stabilization
- 36:25centers. Think of it as a
- 36:27triage to do a quick assessment.
- 36:29Make sure there are bathed and
- 36:32have food and safe, and then
- 36:34let's get them placed. So when
- 36:37you look at other states, other
- 36:40states have had this problem.
- 36:41This is not unique to Kentucky,
- 36:44but they've begun to solve it.
- 36:45So it's not enough to talk
- 36:47about it as a problem. It's an
- 36:50obligation and an opportunity
- 36:52for our leaders in Frankfort to
- 36:53think about how to come
- 36:55together and come up with a
- 36:58palpable practical solutions.
- 37:00And I don't know how this can
- 37:02happen. I'll defer to our
- 37:03legislative colleagues. I, for
- 37:05one, am very impatient,
- 37:07thinking that we have to wait
- 37:08till July 1st, 2028 to say to
- 37:11those kids, good luck, kid.
- 37:13Just hang in. A new budget will
- 37:16be coming with a new governor.
- 37:18So I don't know if there's
- 37:19wiggle room, but boy, I hope
- 37:21that our General Assembly and
- 37:23the Beshear administration hear
- 37:25a call that we shouldn't have
- 37:27any kids in that situation.
- 37:30>> Representative Heavrin and
- 37:31co-chair, I mean, your co-chair
- 37:32of the joint committee, but
- 37:33your chairwoman of the House
- 37:34Families and Children Committee,
- 37:36when you I'm sure you've
- 37:37evaluated what Tennessee is
- 37:39doing and these regional
- 37:40assessment centers, do you
- 37:41think that's a valid idea worth
- 37:44pursuing? And have you even
- 37:45talked to colleagues in
- 37:47Tennessee about that idea and
- 37:48how they got it going and the
- 37:50success that they're having?
- 37:54>> You know, I haven't yet. One
- 37:57thing as Terri was talking, I
- 37:58was thinking about Tennessee is
- 38:00also we actually have our first
- 38:02set. Our first house in
- 38:04Kentucky is Isaiah 117. I'm
- 38:06hoping I have the numbers
- 38:07correct. They came and
- 38:08testified last year during the
- 38:10interim Joint Committee, and
- 38:11it's when it's a community,
- 38:12they build houses in a judicial
- 38:14center, judicial district, and
- 38:16then they allow for that house,
- 38:18for foster care kids to come
- 38:19while they're in that waiting
- 38:20period. And people from the
- 38:22faith community, people from,
- 38:23you know, neighbors and friends,
- 38:25they're background checked,
- 38:26they're very protected, and
- 38:28they're safe individuals. I'll
- 38:29say, come and help the kids as
- 38:32they come into the home. And so
- 38:34I am aware of that, that
- 38:36Tennessee has been doing. I
- 38:37have to learn a little more
- 38:38about what Doctor Brooks was
- 38:40talking about. But I think one
- 38:41thing what I've continued, you
- 38:42know, I said, we're talking
- 38:44about the child welfare
- 38:45continuum. And, you know, it's
- 38:46really a big picture
- 38:48conversation. And that's the
- 38:48importance of us talking about
- 38:49it during the session, because
- 38:52we've got to figure out what we
- 38:53can do from the very beginning
- 38:55when the child is removed from
- 38:56the home all the way to the
- 38:58adoption, you know, are we
- 38:59talking about through that?
- 39:00We're talking about friends of
- 39:02the court, termination of
- 39:03parental rights. What are the
- 39:04grandparents rights? What are
- 39:05foster parents rights? What
- 39:07about adoption and adoption
- 39:09disruption? What about foster
- 39:10care review boards, the child
- 39:11fatality and near fatality
- 39:14review review panel. You know,
- 39:15there's so much to it. And you
- 39:17know, we've really worked hard.
- 39:19You know, I think one of the
- 39:20biggest things that happened in
- 39:222024 to me was Baby Maya from
- 39:24Ohio County. You know, there
- 39:26were a lot of ways that we
- 39:27could have done better as a
- 39:29state. And what does that look
- 39:30like? And that's when I started
- 39:32a working group outside of the
- 39:33Kentucky General Assembly. Of
- 39:34course, there were
- 39:35representatives and senators
- 39:36involved, but also bringing in
- 39:37the law enforcement community,
- 39:39the hospitals, county attorneys,
- 39:41the AOC, and saying, hey, we've
- 39:43we've got to do better for kids.
- 39:44What does that look like? And
- 39:46we've passed some really good
- 39:48legislation on, you know, when
- 39:49two people call, say, a doctor
- 39:51calls and a teacher calls,
- 39:53those are two professional
- 39:54reporting sources. Those cases
- 39:56get automatically investigated.
- 39:58And I think that's really
- 39:59important because we were
- 40:00hearing that big concern that
- 40:01teachers would call and call,
- 40:03and there was no investigation
- 40:05when they knew the child was in
- 40:06harm. What we also did this
- 40:08past session, and that was
- 40:11Senator Carroll and
- 40:12Representative Nick Wilson, my
- 40:13vice chair in the House. They
- 40:15added ingestion to the
- 40:17definition of abuse and neglect.
- 40:19And, you know, sitting on the
- 40:21child fatality and near
- 40:22fatality panel. Renee, what
- 40:24that means is we are a panel
- 40:26that looks at every child who
- 40:28dies under the age of 18 and
- 40:30seeing what we could have done
- 40:31better. Are there policies that
- 40:33we can learn from this? Was
- 40:34this on purpose? Was it was on
- 40:36accident? And we learned from
- 40:37that report that the number one,
- 40:40the death was neglect. The
- 40:42number two was overdose and
- 40:44ingestion. And so we are we are
- 40:45learning information and taking
- 40:47that and putting it into law in
- 40:49hopes that we can start
- 40:50preventing that and that
- 40:52parents are held accountable. I
- 40:54was at my my best friend's
- 40:56kiddos, they play tennis and I
- 40:57was at tennis camp last week
- 41:00watching them because I think
- 41:01it's important for us if we're
- 41:02going to talk about community,
- 41:04we got to support our own
- 41:05community. And they were
- 41:06talking about how people just
- 41:07aren't held accountable anymore.
- 41:08And I think that's, you know,
- 41:10especially with parents that
- 41:11aren't being good to their kids,
- 41:12we've got to hold them
- 41:14accountable to what they're
- 41:15doing. And of course, the
- 41:16number three reason that kids
- 41:19had fatality or near fatality
- 41:22expenses, experiences were
- 41:24physical abuse. And so from
- 41:25those we look at that, you know,
- 41:27with baby Maya, there was no
- 41:29contact made. And so making
- 41:31sure that if you're a child
- 41:32under four, because I don't
- 41:33know if you know this, but
- 41:35children from 0 to 4 years old
- 41:37is 68% of the cases are the
- 41:38most vulnerable kids, which
- 41:41makes sense as aren't always on
- 41:42them. They might not be in
- 41:44schools, they might not be in
- 41:45child care. And so I think that
- 41:47we we try to learn from
- 41:49experiences, but we also have
- 41:50to remember child welfare is
- 41:51not a one size fits all topic.
- 41:53It's something we really have
- 41:54to think about because we're
- 41:56affecting lives of people. And
- 41:58sometimes we forget that in
- 41:59government.
- 42:00>> Yeah. Representative
- 42:01Bogdanovski, if you'll follow
- 42:03up on that, when you think
- 42:04about I mean, you have
- 42:05education experience as well
- 42:06and all of this, you know, if
- 42:08you're if you're in an abusive
- 42:10situation or you're exposed to
- 42:11the trauma of domestic violence
- 42:13or substance abuse because your
- 42:14caregivers are doing that, I
- 42:16mean, that really impedes your
- 42:18ability to, to listen and to
- 42:20learn and to concentrate when
- 42:22you're in a school environment.
- 42:23And we know that there has been
- 42:24legislation that even addresses
- 42:26disruptive students, right? And
- 42:27so you think, oh, well, do you
- 42:29do you punish the kids because
- 42:30they come from environments
- 42:32that are less than healthy and
- 42:33they just act out because they
- 42:34don't know any different? I
- 42:36mean, what is the balancing act
- 42:37of helping correct a child who
- 42:39has just been exposed to so
- 42:40much they can emotionally
- 42:42regulate, and also holding the
- 42:43parent accountable for the
- 42:45behavior that's contributing to
- 42:46that.
- 42:47>> Right? I mean, the hardest
- 42:51thing is we can't change what's
- 42:52happening at home, but what we
- 42:54can do. And, and I've had
- 42:56extensive training in trauma
- 42:58informed education. And so you
- 43:01might look at a child's
- 43:03behavior. I mean, every
- 43:04behavior is an attempt to
- 43:06communicate. But that behavior
- 43:08may have been triggered by
- 43:10something that has absolutely
- 43:12nothing to do with what's
- 43:13happening in the classroom. So
- 43:14if you limit your analysis,
- 43:16okay, so the child is screaming
- 43:20after another child's corrected.
- 43:23Well, it has nothing to do with
- 43:25what might have happened here.
- 43:26It might be what happened at
- 43:28home. Or, you know, there are
- 43:31situations where a teacher
- 43:32might wear a certain Cologne or
- 43:34hairspray that triggers a
- 43:37memory of something that
- 43:39happened outside of school and
- 43:40the child's having a meltdown.
- 43:42So you want to look at a
- 43:44child's behavior through the
- 43:46lens. And especially if you if
- 43:49you, you know, communicate with
- 43:50the family and maybe have some
- 43:52understanding of what kind of
- 43:54experiences may have happened.
- 43:55But through that lens of this
- 43:58might be a trauma trigger. So
- 44:00then as a teacher, you're not
- 44:02saying, okay, it's less of a
- 44:05judgment about the child and
- 44:07more of an understanding of
- 44:10what may have created that
- 44:12situation and that behavior.
- 44:14And then that leads you, you
- 44:16know, I can be much more calm
- 44:18if I know a child has been
- 44:19exposed to domestic violence
- 44:22and that they have a reaction
- 44:24when another child appears to
- 44:27be in trouble. So there's
- 44:30screaming, you know, they're
- 44:31not screaming, but the child
- 44:32might be screaming and the
- 44:34teacher might just be calming
- 44:35them down. And this other child
- 44:36is having a total meltdown over
- 44:38here. You know, I, I can look
- 44:40at that child and I can think,
- 44:42okay, so through a trauma lens,
- 44:45here's why he's reacting.
- 44:47Here's what he needs. He
- 44:48doesn't need me to correct him
- 44:51or to fuss at him. He needs a
- 44:54space to de-escalate until we
- 44:57can communicate a little bit
- 44:58about what was happening, how
- 45:00it wasn't even a situation
- 45:02involving him. And then, you
- 45:04know, have some conversations
- 45:08after after the child's
- 45:10de-escalated. But having that
- 45:11trauma lens is so essential. I
- 45:14did want to I think one thing
- 45:16we haven't talked about yet
- 45:17this evening is cell phones and
- 45:20the impact of social media on
- 45:22our youth. And we did in 2025
- 45:26in House Bill 208, we had a
- 45:29cell phone ban in schools. And
- 45:31the feedback. I just read an
- 45:32article today that had some
- 45:35discussions about, you know,
- 45:37consequences for children
- 45:38having their phones out. But
- 45:41the the principal at Fern Creek,
- 45:42when they did it a year before,
- 45:44she said that the number of
- 45:46books that were checked out of
- 45:47the library increased
- 45:49exponentially. I actually did
- 45:52an observation at a high school
- 45:53in Louisville before the cell
- 45:56phone ban, and the number of
- 45:57kids who were doing like a
- 45:59hands on it was one of the
- 46:02academies where they learned to
- 46:03take care of patients. And all
- 46:05these kids had their headphones
- 46:08on, and they were listening to
- 46:09something on their cell phones.
- 46:10And I was like, this is
- 46:12absolutely ridiculous. And so I
- 46:16think that the educators across
- 46:18the state are very appreciative
- 46:20of the cell phone ban. I would
- 46:21be very interested, as we go
- 46:24through the interim, to hear
- 46:25from some some buildings, some
- 46:29districts, you know, at at how
- 46:31that operationalized. Did they
- 46:33have pouches? Did they have to
- 46:34put their phones away? You know,
- 46:36how are the the biggest
- 46:38pushback was from parents who
- 46:39want to be able to contact
- 46:41their children at all times.
- 46:42But, you know, one district,
- 46:45and I don't recall the name,
- 46:46but one district already won a
- 46:49lawsuit with the social media
- 46:51company about the damage that
- 46:54that this social media and apps
- 46:58that the kids are in are having
- 47:00for our youth. So this, this is
- 47:02a really big part of, you know,
- 47:05that change from 2013 as we got
- 47:08the iPhones and the increase
- 47:10we've, we've discussed before
- 47:11on the show, you know, the
- 47:14anxiety that children have
- 47:16that's built from a world
- 47:18that's full of likes. You know,
- 47:20how many likes did I get from
- 47:21my post? And, and the way that
- 47:25cell phones in our schools, you
- 47:26know, some buildings or some
- 47:29districts have decided that
- 47:30kids can have it between
- 47:31classes, but how much of that
- 47:33cell phone kind of bullying
- 47:35happens where all the kids get
- 47:36together and have chats in
- 47:38Jefferson County, it's from
- 47:40morning to Bell to Bell.
- 47:42They're not supposed to have
- 47:43their cell phones. So I would
- 47:46like to really understand how
- 47:49that, you know, maybe some
- 47:52consequence of it that we might
- 47:53need to address. But I think
- 47:56overall, as an educator, it was
- 47:58a fantastic legislation.
- 48:00>> Yeah. I'm glad you brought
- 48:01that up. Representative
- 48:02Borowski, I know Doctor Brooks,
- 48:03you really want to chime in
- 48:05here because. I remember the
- 48:06resistance that we heard during
- 48:07the testimony.
- 48:08>> I just had to laugh because
- 48:10I conducted a really extensive
- 48:13research project that is I
- 48:15interviewed Renner, Kendall and
- 48:18Carson Brooks, three.
- 48:21>> Grandchildren.
- 48:21>> Public school children. This
- 48:24time last year. All three of
- 48:25them believed that life on
- 48:28earth had ended, that
- 48:30Armageddon had come because
- 48:32their cell phones would not be
- 48:35accompanying them in school.
- 48:37All of them. And I say that
- 48:39about the three, but we've
- 48:40heard this anecdotally. It's a
- 48:43game changer for discipline,
- 48:46for atmosphere at their
- 48:48respective high schools.
- 48:49Teachers are so cool. It's not
- 48:51punitive. It's like, hey, put
- 48:52it away, keep it away. And what
- 48:54they.
- 48:54>> Do, they don't collect them.
- 48:56Maybe. Well, I've often
- 48:57wondered, like, I.
- 48:58>> Think in some cases very
- 49:00Tina can weigh in. I think it
- 49:01varies significantly from
- 49:02school to school. But as you
- 49:04may guess, cell phone use
- 49:05during school generally was not
- 49:07about academic matters. It was
- 49:08about who was doing this and
- 49:10saying that. So they talked
- 49:11about just such a change in
- 49:13atmosphere, less disruption. So
- 49:17shout out to the General
- 49:18Assembly for really setting a
- 49:20stage to make schools calmer,
- 49:23more focused places. A big win
- 49:26for teachers and a big win for
- 49:28kids.
- 49:28>> And it's not like it hadn't
- 49:29happened before us Gen Xers.
- 49:31You know, you can take your
- 49:32princess phone. Absolutely,
- 49:33absolutely, absolutely. So yeah,
- 49:35Miss Putnam, how do how do you
- 49:37view that? I mean, some people
- 49:38may think, well, that's such a
- 49:40small action, but look at the
- 49:42compounding consequences in the
- 49:44positive direction that it's
- 49:45having. With book checkout
- 49:47increasing and kids seemingly
- 49:49more engaged in their learning,
- 49:50that's a real win win, right.
- 49:51>> And more engaged in each
- 49:53other. Right. And I think
- 49:54that's, that's the most
- 49:55important connection we can
- 49:56have. And I, you know, I
- 49:58believe that the, the
- 49:59connectivity, you know, we're
- 50:00always connected to these. I'm
- 50:01guilty a lot of the time, but
- 50:03the, the need for children to
- 50:06be able to connect to each
- 50:07other and to build those human
- 50:08connections before they learn
- 50:09anything else, before their
- 50:10brains are wired a different
- 50:12way. Jonathan Haidt wrote The
- 50:14Anxious Generation. And, you
- 50:16know, that was when I spent
- 50:18some time in Arkansas. When I
- 50:19was there, Governor Sanders had
- 50:21him come in and really, you
- 50:23know, led the way with some of
- 50:25these changes. And so did
- 50:26Kentucky. As far as ruling out
- 50:27cell phones in school, we have
- 50:29we are resource rich, but
- 50:31connection poor. And what I
- 50:32mean by that is we have all of
- 50:34these things at our fingertips,
- 50:36but we're still so disconnected.
- 50:38And removing that technology
- 50:40and being able to spend that
- 50:42time and being able to have
- 50:43their brains develop normally
- 50:45and not have these rapid fire
- 50:47games and lights and sounds and
- 50:48everything coming, that really
- 50:49disrupts the brain function.
- 50:52And to representative point it,
- 50:54it dysregulates a lot of kids
- 50:56to the point that they are
- 50:57really struggling behaviorally
- 50:59and academically and socially
- 51:01across the board in school. So
- 51:02I'm very encouraged. I, you
- 51:04know, we survived without it.
- 51:05Yes. You know, my corded phone
- 51:07couldn't leave the wall. So but,
- 51:11you know, I would encourage
- 51:12more school districts and more
- 51:14states to really take a hard
- 51:16look at, can we get these out
- 51:17of our classrooms and have our
- 51:19kids have really quality time
- 51:20together?
- 51:20>> Well, and we have done a
- 51:22program for our Education
- 51:23Matters series about artificial
- 51:24intelligence, AI in the
- 51:25classroom. Right. And we're not
- 51:27going to try to get that in in
- 51:29five minutes, but we know that
- 51:30that is a whole nother issue to
- 51:32deal with in our expanding
- 51:34digital landscape of how you
- 51:36deal with that kind of
- 51:38technology and good and bad
- 51:40ways. Representative Heavrin, I
- 51:41want to come to you in about
- 51:434.5 minutes. We have remaining
- 51:45to just kind of talk us through,
- 51:47as you and you've mentioned
- 51:48this at the outset, about the
- 51:50kind of issues that you would
- 51:51be taking on autism. And I'm
- 51:53also questioning about dealing
- 51:56with the mental health issues
- 51:57of children. We know that
- 51:58that's increased exponentially
- 52:00since the advent of Covid. And
- 52:02we representative Bozinovski
- 52:03kind of alluded to that earlier.
- 52:04And trauma informed care. There
- 52:06seems to be some concerns about
- 52:09trauma informed care in schools
- 52:11and whether or not that should
- 52:12be continued, or just a
- 52:13discussion about the validity
- 52:14of that. Where are those
- 52:16discussions now, particularly
- 52:17in that mental health space for
- 52:19our young people?
- 52:23>> You know, I think they're
- 52:25still being had and they're
- 52:26being had in a lot of different
- 52:28ways because no one knows the
- 52:29fix to it. And I think what you
- 52:31all alluded to is social media.
- 52:33You know, social media is such
- 52:34a fake world and kids don't
- 52:36recognize that that is a fake
- 52:37world. And, you know, I think
- 52:39that that that is a reality.
- 52:40And so then you take that to
- 52:42mental health. Like I think
- 52:43Covid exacerbated all of our
- 52:44mental health and maybe issues,
- 52:46you know, trying to figure that
- 52:48out. And it's going to be a
- 52:49continuous conversation because
- 52:50it's a generational
- 52:52conversation. You know,
- 52:53probably some of the older
- 52:54generations are like, rub some
- 52:55mud on it, get over it, you're
- 52:57going to be fine. Whereas I
- 52:59think my generation and, and
- 53:03coming up, you know, my
- 53:04generation after, they're more
- 53:07of like, well, let's, let's
- 53:08talk it out. Let's, let's talk
- 53:09about therapy. Let's figure out
- 53:12really what, what the need is.
- 53:14And I think that the middle
- 53:15ground there is, it's the
- 53:17community part. And, you know,
- 53:19trying to figure out, you know,
- 53:20I think it was Mother Theresa
- 53:22that says, if you want to see
- 53:24change in the world, start at
- 53:25your own kitchen table. And I
- 53:27think that's something, you
- 53:28know, we've got to we've lost
- 53:29empathy is as a state sometimes
- 53:31and even as humanity and, you
- 53:33know, being able to empathize
- 53:34with people and recognize we
- 53:35all have different life
- 53:36experiences and how do we help
- 53:38kids get through that? You know,
- 53:39if we expect them to, to be
- 53:43good citizens when they grow up
- 53:44and they start voting and they
- 53:45become a community member, what
- 53:47does that look like? And I
- 53:49think I really, I kind of want
- 53:50to pivot, Renee. And I want to
- 53:52bring up a conversation I want
- 53:53to have is about a six schools,
- 53:56which there are schools that
- 53:57house at risk students from DJ,
- 54:00J. Department of Juvenile
- 54:02Justice and DCBS and you know,
- 54:04I have a group through Kentucky
- 54:06Youth Advocates come to visit
- 54:07me once a year. It's a very
- 54:10emotional day and it's foster
- 54:11care. Kids are called true up
- 54:12and they come and tell me
- 54:14policy issues that need to be
- 54:16changed. And one of those is
- 54:17with six schools. And I think
- 54:19this is a great intersection to
- 54:20the conversation of education
- 54:21and foster care and child
- 54:23welfare we've been having,
- 54:24because what we found out
- 54:25through these kids is that the
- 54:26standards are not equal. You
- 54:28know, you could be an eighth
- 54:30grader and you're learning at a
- 54:3110th grade level because that's,
- 54:33you know, that's what's being
- 54:35taught right then. And so how
- 54:37can we create a level playing
- 54:39field for students? Because if
- 54:41we expect them to go, you know,
- 54:43to college or trade school or
- 54:45be a good human after high
- 54:47school, what does that look
- 54:48like? And so are we already
- 54:50giving them a place that they
- 54:51don't have an equal playing
- 54:53field because they, they don't
- 54:54have the opportunity, and they
- 54:56don't have parents that are
- 54:57going to step up or
- 54:59grandparents maybe if they're
- 54:59at a facility that says, hey,
- 55:01this my kid deserves better.
- 55:04And so it's upon us to step up
- 55:05and say, these kids deserve
- 55:08better. And I always say, you
- 55:09know, I don't have kids of my
- 55:10own yet, but the foster care
- 55:12kids are mine. And so I'm going
- 55:13to continuously advocate for
- 55:15them and see what we can do
- 55:17better. And so I do. That's,
- 55:19that's one thing, you know,
- 55:20along with mental health,
- 55:21that's a conversation we have a
- 55:23lot. But I also want to figure
- 55:24out about these, the
- 55:27alternative education and
- 55:28making sure that we're helping
- 55:30set kids up for success in
- 55:32Kentucky to have a good life.
- 55:33And so there's a lot that we
- 55:34can do with that. But, you know,
- 55:36I think one thing we start with
- 55:38empathy and move on from there.
- 55:39>> Yeah. Well, thank you for
- 55:41that chair. Heavrin. I think
- 55:42that's a good way to kind of
- 55:44end our conversation, and we'll
- 55:45need to break down individually
- 55:46some of those components that
- 55:48you mentioned, because there's
- 55:49a lot there to really tease out.
- 55:50Thank you all, doctor Brooks,
- 55:52Miss Putnam and Representative
- 55:54Renee and Bozinovski, we thank
- 55:55you for being here for this
- 55:57discussion. And thank you for
- 55:58joining us at home this evening.
- 56:00Make sure you join us each
- 56:01weeknight for Kentucky edition
- 56:02at 630 eastern, 530 central,
- 56:04where we inform, connect and
- 56:06inspire and connect you to the
- 56:07issues that really matter. And
- 56:08of course, Bill, Bryant and a
- 56:09panel of Kentucky reporters
- 56:11will be here on Friday night
- 56:12for comment on Kentucky at 8:00
- 56:13eastern seven central to
- 56:15dissect the news of the week.
- 56:16Thanks so much for being with
- 56:17us. I'm Renee Shaw, and until I
- 56:19see you again, have a great
- 56:21week ahead.
- 56:21[MUSIC]
- 56:31>> Good, because you're very
- 56:33good. Oh, no. No, you really
- 56:34are. That's art form.
- 56:36>> Just lean in. You know, you
- 56:37just learn to just lean in.